Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #27: CFB Week 10 recap, a new CSR Top, auditing the Committee and AP Poll, and a Week 11 Preview
Transcript
- 0:12Hello and welcome to episode number 27 of the Common Sense Rankings podcast, where we rank the resume.
- 0:19In this episode, I'll recap the biggest games from week 10.
- 0:22We have a change in the conference hierarchy in the CSR that I'll need to discuss.
- 0:26We'll do some blind resume tests before I reveal my top 25 this week.
- 0:30I'll audit the CFP committee and the AP poll voters, and we'll finish by looking ahead to week number 11.
- 0:37125 college football teams had a game scheduled in week 10.
- 0:40There were 62 games between FBS programs, with Wake Forest playing an FCS school and the remaining 13 teams going through their bye week.
- 0:49Three of last week's top 25 resumes were on bye in week 10: Indiana, who dropped four spots week over week in the CSR, USC, who dropped two spots, and Memphis dropping 11 spots since last week.
- 1:02Only six teams have a bye remaining on their schedule, so the benefit teams were experiencing in the CSR from playing more games earlier in the season is disappearing here with just three weeks left.
- 1:13There was one non-conference matchup that could and did have an impact on the CSR conference strength rankings.
- 1:19The American had a two to one lead over the Mountain West going into the week, but the fourth and final matchup between the two conferences was Air Force against Army in West Point, New York.
- 1:28Air Force escaped with a three-point win, evening the series between the two conferences where it will finish two-two this season.
- 1:35As a result, the American Conference has just two winning records against other conferences, lowering them from being tied with the Sun Belt and Pac-12 atop the group of six to the same level as the Mountain West, a step below where they were last week.
- 1:47Now, any team that beat an American Conference school will receive less credit for that win, and any school that lost to a team from the American will suffer more harm.
- 1:57With so many amazing games that will have postseason implications, let's take a chronological look at the week that was.
- 2:03While Boise State is the top group of 16 in both the CSR and human polls, James Madison is sitting there waiting if the Broncos were to stumble.
- 2:11The Dukes played their third straight Thursday night game, and after losing their first two, I'm sure it was a sigh of relief to get a dub last Thursday.
- 2:18The win moves the Dukes to eight and two on the season and just outside the CSR top 25.
- 2:24CSR number 19 UTSA had a chance at the CFP until last Thursday.
- 2:30The Roadrunners got straight flattened by Florida Atlantic, losing to the Owls 60 to 29 and dropping to seven and two this season.
- 2:37Friday night, SMU righted the ship after a surprise loss to Syracuse two weekends ago and kept their slim CFP hopes alive.
- 2:45They took down Virginia Tech at home Friday night 51 to 28.
- 2:49Arizona was in a similar boat to SMU, needing to win out and get help to have a shot at the 12-team bracket this year.
- 2:56In an absolutely wild finish, the Wildcats picked up a one-point win over TCU in the late game on Friday.
- 3:03In the early game Saturday, the Holy War took center stage.
- 3:06CSR number two, Utah, took on number 12, BYU, in the highest-ranked matchup in series history.
- 3:11After the Cougars scored 17 in the second quarter, they didn't score again as the Utes finished with an eight-point win to continue their undefeated season.
- 3:20On ESPN, it was a battle of two-loss SEC teams when CSR number six, Texas, traveled up to play number 20, Missouri.
- 3:26A tie game going into the fourth quarter, Texas scored the last 14 points to head home with a dub and stay in the top ten.
- 3:34Over on Fox in that early time slot was CSR number one, UCLA, facing the Golden Gophers of Minnesota.
- 3:40Minnesota kept it close throughout, but the Bruins escaped with a 14-point win to start nine and oh, the first time they've won their first nine games since 1998.
- 3:49In the mid-afternoon time slot, CSR number eight, Alabama, headed down to Baton Rouge to take on Lane Kiffin and number 14, LSU.
- 3:56Two late touchdowns likely made the winning margin more than the game warranted, but Alabama continued to roll.
- 4:02CSR number 16, Ohio State, hosted Oregon on CBS Saturday.
- 4:07The Buckeyes were still without their star quarterback, Julian Sayin, and it's easy to say that they missed their play caller.
- 4:12Ohio State suffered their second consecutive loss, giving them a third L, and many OSU fans are considering twenty twenty-six a lost season.
- 4:21CSR number 17, Boise State, played Colorado State on USA Network Saturday afternoon.
- 4:26As has been the case in most of CSU's games, a bunch of points were scored.
- 4:30A hundred and two points in this one, with the Broncos scoring sixty-four in their win to retain their spot among the top teams in the group of six.
- 4:38CSR number 18, Tennessee, played host to CSR number six, Kentucky, in primetime on ESPN.
- 4:44It was all Vols from the get-go as the Wildcats scored just six points in the loss to fall into a tie for second in the SEC.
- 4:52In the game of the week and home of college game day, CSR number three, Miami, was in South Bend to play number 13, Notre Dame.
- 4:58Malachi Toney, the Hurricanes' star receiver, suffered an injury in practice during the week and was unable to play.
- 5:04After the Irish jumped out to an early lead, Darian Mensah led the Hurricanes back to make it close late.
- 5:09A controversial catch ruling in the end zone ended with an incomplete ruling against the Hurricanes, and Notre Dame held on for a signature win this season.
- 5:17Over on ABC, CSR number seven, Georgia, took down number nine, Ole Miss, in Oxford in a rematch of last year's Sugar Bowl.
- 5:23Georgia got their revenge and then some, defeating the Rebels forty-two to seven.
- 5:28In the late-night ESPN game, Texas Tech and West Virginia scored over a hundred points.
- 5:32The Red Raiders emerged victorious, keeping their CFP hopes alive and well.
- 5:38Due to Air Force's win over Army, we have to level set on the conference strength rankings.
- 5:43In the CSR, conference strength is determined by the number of leagues a conference has a winning record against.
- 5:48It doesn't matter if conference A is twelve and O against conference B or two and one, a winning record is a winning record.
- 5:54The formula is designed to reward twice the points for a win over the best conference compared to a team from the worst conference.
- 6:00The SEC is the conference at the top playing each of the other nine conferences throughout the year and winning more than they lost against each other league.
- 6:07Second with seven winning head-to-heads is the Big Ten.
- 6:10Third is the Big 12 with six winning head-to-head records, and the fourth conference is the ACC, which is just one step below the Big 12.
- 6:17There's now just a two-way tie for fifth among all FBS conferences with the Sun Belt and Pac-12 owning that spot.
- 6:24After the American lost their winning record against the Mountain West, courtesy of Air Force's win, they find themselves tied with that very conference at seventh with two winning head-to-heads each.
- 6:33Conference USA sits ninth and the MAC in tenth.
- 6:37A few things to note here, a team that beats an SEC squad will get twice the number of win points as a win over a team from the MAC.
- 6:44Also, the ACC in the CSR formulas is four conference head-to-heads behind the SEC and only two ahead of the best group of six, meaning a win over the ACC is closer to the value of a win over the Sun Belt than it is to a value of the win over an SEC team.
- 6:59The Big 12 is the same distance from the SEC as it is from the Pac-12 Next up, let's take a look at a couple of resumes, taking team names and opponent names out of it, and see how some of the CFP hopefuls are stacking up.
- 7:12Blind resume test number one.
- 7:14Team A is six and three with a four and three record in the SEC.
- 7:18Their one out-of-conference win over the FBS is over a MAC team.
- 7:22The teams they've beaten have 11 SEC wins, 13 total Power Four dubs, and 20 total FBS victories.
- 7:29The losses are to teams with nine cumulative Ls.
- 7:32Team B is seven and two.
- 7:34They are four and two in the Big Ten.
- 7:36They have additional FBS wins over the Sun Belt, the Pac-12, and the Mountain West.
- 7:40The seven FBS opponents they've defeated have nine Big Ten and 30 total FBS wins, and their losses are to teams with six cumulative losses.
- 7:49Recapping the differences, Team B has two additional FBS wins and the opponents they've defeated have an additional 10 FBS wins, but four fewer Power Four wins.
- 7:58And the teams they've lost to have suffered fewer total losses.
- 8:02This blind resume was a battle of the USCs.
- 8:05Team B was Southern Cal, who sits number 12 in the CSR, but number 18 in the CFP.
- 8:10Team A was South Carolina, 23rd in the CSR and 17th in the College Football Playoff rankings.
- 8:18Blind resume test number two.
- 8:20Team A is seven and two with a five and two record in their conference, the SEC.
- 8:24They have additional wins over the ACC and American conferences.
- 8:27The seven FBS teams they've defeated have 15 SEC wins, 20 total Power Four wins, and a total of 30 FBS wins.
- 8:35The teams that have beaten Team A have a cumulative three losses.
- 8:40Team B is eight and one with a five and one record in the Big Ten.
- 8:43Their additional three wins were over the American, C-USA, and an FCS program.
- 8:47The teams DB has defeated have 11 Big Ten wins, 13 total Power Four wins, and 27 total FBS wins.
- 8:55The teams to which they lost has three losses, all to Power Four schools.
- 8:59Team A may have an additional loss, which is what everybody is harping on, but they have a larger, more impressive stable of wins.
- 9:05The teams they've beat have been significantly more impressive, and their conference statistically has been better on the field this season.
- 9:13Team A is Alabama, who sit at number three in the CFP Committee rankings released Tuesday and fifth in the CSR.
- 9:19Indiana is Team B, who sit eighth in the CSR, but ninth according to the committee.
- 9:25One more blind resume test.
- 9:27Team A is seven and two.
- 9:28They are four and two in the ACC.
- 9:31Their out-of-conference wins are over a Big Ten team, an American team, and an FCS team.
- 9:35The teams they've defeated have eight ACC wins, 13 Power Four wins, and 21 FBS victories.
- 9:41Their two losses are to teams with a cumulative 11 Ls, 10 of which were to Power Four.
- 9:47Team B sits six and three.
- 9:48They are four and two in the Big 12.
- 9:50They also have a win over the Big Ten and an FCS squad, and their third loss was to a team from the American Conference.
- 9:56Their six wins are over opponents with seven Big 12 wins, 13 Power Four wins, and 18 total FBS victories.
- 10:03Their three losses are to teams with a total of 11 Ls, eight of which were Power Four.
- 10:07The Big 12 sits a little ahead of the ACC in the conference strength, lending more credit to those conference victories, but the value of wins and opponent wins both actually favor Team A, while Team B is getting hurt more because of their losses.
- 10:21Team A is Duke, who sits 25th in the CSR but is unranked by the committee, and Team B is the committee's 25th-ranked team, Oklahoma State, who sits down at number 40 in the CSR.
- 10:32Now that you have a little more insight into the CSR and how it compares to the playoff committee, let me show you the top 10 in the Common Sense rankings this week.
- 10:40UCLA remains atop the rankings, continuing to lead the country in the value of their on-the-field wins.
- 10:46Without an FCS team on their schedule, they have nine wins over FBS programs, and they'll continue to gain points for each of those wins and each of those nine opponents' wins.
- 10:55The value of their opponents' wins right now is up to fourth in the CSR formula, putting them comfortably at the top of this week's rankings.
- 11:02I can't predict how the rest of the season will go, but if the Bruins do go twelve and O, I can all but guarantee they'd finish atop the CSR after Thanksgiving.
- 11:11The number two spot is the same as last week as well, the Utah Utes.
- 11:14Similar to the Bruins, being undefeated not only saves you from any negative points, it also allows the Utes to get points for eight different teams' FBS victories.
- 11:22Utah sits second behind UCLA in the direct wins portion of the CSR, while the strength of their opponents' wins ranks fifth, a combination that keeps them at number two another week.
- 11:31The number three spot will change after Miami's loss to Notre Dame, and Georgia slides up into that third spot this week.
- 11:37Playing in, statistically, the best conference this season will only help them, and continuing to beat SEC teams will boost each win by the Dogs and by the teams they've defeated.
- 11:46I explained earlier the strength of the SEC's out-of-conference results and why the best teams in that conference will rise to the top.
- 11:52The four spot this week is a good example of that, as it belongs to the Texas Longhorns.
- 11:57Like UCLA above them, no FCS win allows for an extra data point for themselves, as well as 11 more for the teams they play, and all those extra wins are paying dividends for the Longhorns.
- 12:06The teams who have fallen to Texas this season have picked up the most impressive allotment of wins so far in the CSR.
- 12:13Number five is a further example of the SEC status in college football this season, the Alabama Crimson Tide.
- 12:19Alabama only has two FBS opponents remaining, and both are in the lower half of the conference, so the majority of their remaining points will come from opponent wins.
- 12:27Number six was the winner of the game day game last week, the Notre Dame Fighting Irish.
- 12:31Picking up a win over the otherwise undefeated Miami Hurricanes obviously helps, but their opponent win component of the CSR is 15th in the country, meaning the Irish are doing their job, but the teams they've beaten aren't picking up wins.
- 12:44Number seven is the Miami Hurricanes, who, by playing in the ACC, don't have the value of wins, but the teams they've beaten are performing well, allowing Miami to stay in the top 10 after the loss.
- 12:54Number eight is Indiana, who dropped four spots after taking their bye week in week 10.
- 12:59Kentucky drops to number nine following their second loss of the season, this time to Tennessee.
- 13:03Another team benefiting from playing an SEC schedule, the Wildcats are right in the middle of a tight seven through 12 range in the CSR.
- 13:11Rounding out the top 10 is another Big 12 team, the Texas Tech Red Raiders.
- 13:15Texas Tech will need to keep winning, as all the SEC teams around them will continue to pick up more points for a win and suffer less decrease for a loss.
- 13:21So Texas Tech has no wiggle room.
- 13:24Continuing down the top 25, number 11 is Tennessee, a fifth SEC team.
- 13:2912 is Southern Cal, who dropped two spots after their bye.
- 13:3213 is Ole Miss, the top three loss team.
- 13:3414 is Wake Forest, who drops after playing an FCS program.
- 13:3815th, BYU, the third Big 12 squad.
- 13:4116, Houston.
- 13:4217, Boise State, the top group of six school.
- 13:4418 is Iowa.
- 13:4619, LSU.
- 13:4720, Oregon.
- 13:4821, New Mexico from the Mountain West.
- 13:5022, Ohio State after suffering their third loss.
- 13:5323 is South Carolina.
- 13:5524, Arizona, and 25, Duke.
- 13:58Five three-loss teams make up the top 25 this week, all from the SEC and Big Ten.
- 14:02The only two-loss power conference school to be outside the CSR top 25 is SMU, who sits at number 27.
- 14:10In the CSR top 25 this week, we have eight SEC teams, six Big Ten, five Big 12, three ACC, then Notre Dame, New Mexico from the Mountain West, and Boise State from the Pac-12.
- 14:22In comparison with the CFP rankings released Tuesday, we have one fewer SEC squad.
- 14:26Missouri is beyond the top 25 in the CSR.
- 14:30The correct number of Big Ten teams with half over ranked and half under ranked.
- 14:34One fewer Big 12 team in the top 25 of the CSR, the aforementioned Oklahoma State being the culprit.
- 14:40We have Duke in the top 25 in addition to Miami and Wake from the ACC.
- 14:44And amongst the group of six, we included New Mexico.
- 14:48Putting together a 12-team playoff based on the CSR this week would provide UCLA, Utah, Georgia, and Texas with a first-round bye.
- 14:55In the first round, number five Alabama would face number 17 Boise State as the Group of Six rep.
- 15:00Number six Notre Dame hosting number 11 Tennessee.
- 15:03Number seven Miami playing Texas Tech.
- 15:05And number eight Indiana playing host to number nine Kentucky.
- 15:09The three teams just on the outside of the playoff are numbers 12 through 14 who are USC, Ole Miss, and Wake Forest this week We have the second release of the CFP committee's rankings, and I have some thoughts.
- 15:22First, they got 23 of the top 25 resumes correctly pinned.
- 15:25Eight of the top 10 were also correct, just in a slightly different order.
- 15:29Boise State is correctly identified as the best Group of 16, and the ACC's top two teams were ranked almost precisely where they were in the CSR.
- 15:37I thought the committee could have improved upon their diversification.
- 15:40Still just one pity spot given to Group of 16 when more should have been considered.
- 15:44The top of the SEC is being overvalued, and they seem to be valuing one or two big wins over the totality of the resume.
- 15:53We don't know who voted for what in the committee room, but we do have the ballots of AP voters, so let's see how they did this week.
- 15:59UCLA continues to lead in the CSR, and four voters like their resume enough to put them second: Alex Taylor, Brian Fonseca, Kirk Bowles, and Matt McGavock.
- 16:08Duke snuck into the top 25 of the CSR this week but were just outside the top 25 in the AP.
- 16:1419 voters included the Blue Devils in their ballot.
- 16:16I won't name them all, but they know what they did.
- 16:19Among the bad ballots, the Louisville Cardinals are the lowest team in the CSR to receive votes in the AP poll this week.
- 16:25They're number 43 in the resume-based Common Sense rankings, but David Jablonsky thought they were the 22nd best team in the country.
- 16:32I loved your college basketball ballot, David, but I disagree with your college football ballot.
- 16:38SMU was one of two teams in the AP Top 25 that was outside the top 25 in the CSR.
- 16:43Two voters had SMU all the way up at number 17, Andy Yamashita and Randy Johnson.
- 16:50Looking forward to Week 11, there are four matchups between top 25 teams in the Common Sense rankings.
- 16:55CSR number seven takes on number 25 Duke at noon on ABC.
- 16:59Those two teams were front and center during the drama surrounding the college football playoff last season, and they will play in Week 11.
- 17:05Miami is still very much in control of their destiny as far as the postseason is concerned, but Duke is having a sneaky good season.
- 17:12The Blue Devils have five Power Conference victories, but they are one of the teams that suffer from the Americans demotion in the conference strength rankings.
- 17:19Their win over Tulane in week one now looks slightly less impressive than it did a week ago.
- 17:24CSR number eight Indiana will hold down the midday time slot, playing Southern Cal on CBS at 3:30 Eastern.
- 17:30Both teams had a bye last week and will be entering the showdown in Bloomington fresh.
- 17:34Both schools have a path to the playoff, and a win would mean big things for both teams as the season starts winding down.
- 17:41CSR number four Texas will face number 19 LSU under the lights at 7:30 Eastern on ABC.
- 17:47Texas finishes its season against two teams from the bottom half of the SEC, so this is their last real opportunity to pick up a statement win that could impact decisions in the committee room.
- 17:56LSU, meanwhile, will need to win out in order to even sniff the top 12 on selection day in a few weeks.
- 18:02The final CSR ranked matchup will also be in prime time when Utah visits Arizona on Fox.
- 18:07Utah will have a hard time chasing down UCLA at the top of the CSR without a Bruins loss, and Arizona is eyeballing all of the Utes wins and wondering what a win over the formerly undefeated team could do for their resume in both the CSR and CFP committee polls.
- 18:23As for the rest of the top 10 teams in the CSR, number one UCLA plays Illinois at home at 9:00 p.m.
- 18:29Friday night.
- 18:29They sit a hefty amount ahead of number two this week.
- 18:32CSR number three and CFP number one Georgia will host Missouri on ABC at 3:30 Eastern.
- 18:39Alabama will visit Vanderbilt as the Tide begin their easy three-game stretch to finish the season.
- 18:43They'll play on SEC Network at 12:45.
- 18:46Notre Dame gets another ACC foe, this time Boston College.
- 18:50The Irish will host the Eagles at 3:30 Eastern on NBC.
- 18:53CSR number nine Kentucky plays the Florida Gators at 6:15 Eastern on ESPN.
- 18:59And CSR number 10 Texas Tech will play on ESPN at 9:30 p.m.
- 19:02Eastern again, this time against Oklahoma State.
- 19:07That'll be the end of this episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 19:10I hope you enjoyed it.
- 19:11I'll plug my social media handle again at ComSenseRanking and point you toward the website where all this information lives.
- 19:17That URL is commonsenserankings.com.
- 19:21I'm always open to feedback, so let me know if there's anything you want to hear more of or something you'd like me to change.
- 19:26I'll see you again next time, and as you go about your day-to-day, please use some common sense