Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Par for the Course: Legal Issues Arising from the Game of Golf
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Par for the Course, Legal Issues Arising
- 0:08from the Game of Golf. I'm Laurie Critt -Martin,
- 0:11a Certified Family Law Specialist and a past
- 0:15Vice Chair of the Litigation Committee for the
- 0:18Beverly Hills Bar Association. I'm delighted
- 0:21to introduce our speakers today, the Honorable
- 0:23Judith Ashman Gerst and the Honorable Clifford
- 0:28Klein. Judge Clifford L. Klein is a mediator,
- 0:32arbitrator, and judicial referee as signature
- 0:35resolution. Judge Klein served as a Superior
- 0:38Court Judge in Los Angeles County from 2001 to
- 0:422021, presiding over probate cases involving
- 0:46states, trusts, guardianships, and conservatorships,
- 0:50including cases involving numerous public figures
- 0:53and entertainers. Judge Klein also presided over
- 0:56the nation's first full juvenile mental health
- 0:59court. Prior to the ban, she spent 25 years as
- 1:02a prosecutor in the Los Angeles County District
- 1:05Attorney's Office, specializing in complex business
- 1:09fraud cases. Judge Judith Ashman Gerst is a mediator,
- 1:14arbitrator, and appellate consultant at Signature
- 1:17Resolution with over 44 years of judicial expertise.
- 1:22Judge Justice Ashman Gerst served as an Associate
- 1:26Justice of the California Court of Appeal, Second
- 1:29District, from 2001 to 2024. Her notable cases
- 1:34include an entertainment royalty dispute involving
- 1:38the estate of Michael Jackson and producer Quincy
- 1:41Jones, and a breach of contract case that secured
- 1:44a $500 million verdict for the City of Hope.
- 1:48She previously served on the Los Angeles County
- 1:51Superior Court and Municipal Court and held positions
- 1:54as Executive Assistant U .S. Attorney, Deputy
- 1:58City Attorney, and Deputy Attorney General. And
- 2:01now let's get started with today's program. Thank
- 2:06you. I originally got into this unusually complicated
- 2:11field I found out. I was looking up one question
- 2:14on a legal issue involving golf and I was also
- 2:17doing more when I served on our country club
- 2:20board. A number of issues are not included because
- 2:24I have no idea how many there are. Perhaps the
- 2:27biggest potential case in golf right now is the
- 2:30antitrust case involving the LIL and the PGA.
- 2:33I did not include that for, among other reasons,
- 2:36I assume that's going to be resolved with a lot
- 2:38of backward negotiating over financial issues.
- 2:42There are also, believe it or not, environmental
- 2:43issues that are Prop 65, warnings about chemicals
- 2:48on golf clubs. Of course, there are issues about
- 2:50how courses are treated with certain substances.
- 2:56And there are cases that are really not unique
- 2:58to golf, even though they may occur on a golf
- 3:00course or in a country club, so it's riding drunk
- 3:02on a golf cart, fights, sexual harassment issues.
- 3:06The golf setting is not unique to those cases.
- 3:09All right, so we're not going to get into those.
- 3:11We have enough to do in maybe a little superficial
- 3:14at times with all the topics. Next slide, please.
- 3:18Question I'm often asked is, what happens if
- 3:20I hit someone with my golf shot? Or by the better
- 3:23golfers, what happens if I get hit? Probably
- 3:26assuming I would be the one to hit them with
- 3:28a wild shot. We've all seen spectators get struck
- 3:32by the pros, as with many legal questions. The
- 3:35answer is, it depends on the facts. And the answer
- 3:39to this question can begin at our local Rancho
- 3:42Park Golf Course. Next slide, please. Next slide.
- 3:47Yeah. And so we're going to talk about the doctrine
- 3:49of assumption of risk. Who is responsible if
- 3:53you're hit by a golf ball? Was the injury caused
- 3:56by a factor beyond ordinary play? And if I briefly
- 4:01use an analogy, you know when you go to a baseball
- 4:03game, you can get hit by a foul ball. You obviously
- 4:06know the risks of your skiing. or horseback riding.
- 4:10So those are examples where you assume the risk.
- 4:13I was surprised to hear when a pitcher throws,
- 4:15I'm getting off topic to another sport, when
- 4:17a pitcher's throwing a bean ball that actually
- 4:20comes within the doctrine of assumption of risk.
- 4:23They're not negligent. Good news for all of us
- 4:27old Dodger fans, because Don Drysdale was known
- 4:30to painfully throw bean balls. All right. Next
- 4:33slide, please. Next one, after this one, please.
- 4:45Next slide. All right. The leading case is the
- 4:49Shin case that occurred in Rancho Park. The facts
- 4:52are fairly simple for any of us golfers, and
- 4:55that is there was a threesome playing at Rancho
- 4:58Park, a plaintiff and a defendant. Defendants
- 5:01on the tee. The plaintiff goes up. about 30 feet
- 5:05in front at a 45 -degree angle. It almost sounds
- 5:08like that opening ceiling gun smoke. The defendant
- 5:10looks to his left, checks his phone, drinks some
- 5:13water. The defendant, that is the person hitting
- 5:15the drive, pulls out his drive. He pulls the
- 5:18driver, hits the plaintiff in the temple. And
- 5:21the question is, did the defendant know where
- 5:23the plaintiff was standing and did he actually
- 5:25stare at him? That's a factual question that
- 5:27was sent back to the court. And when I looked,
- 5:30I did not see results, so presumably it's 7.
- 5:33So the question is, was this a deliberate shot,
- 5:36not assumption of risk? That went back to the
- 5:38trial court. What the California Supreme Court
- 5:40held is there is a general duty of care on a
- 5:44golf course that is owed by a basic golfer. That's
- 5:50basically hitting the ball. That doesn't mean
- 5:52you can throw the club. You throw the club at
- 5:53someone, that's reckless conduct that would not
- 5:56be covered by assumption of risk. It is your
- 5:58duty not to increase the risk, not to... engaged
- 6:01in reckless conduct outside the range of a normal
- 6:05game of golf. But there's, there's no duty to
- 6:09avoid what is simple negligence that really doesn't
- 6:12apply in this case. Next slide. Next slide. So
- 6:20the question is who is liable for the injury
- 6:22and through and does a defendant person hit the
- 6:25golf ball get relief? Our expert in our club
- 6:30A rules official says, yes, the defendant gets
- 6:33relief in case you weren't, in case they get
- 6:35older. Again, all right, next slide, please.
- 6:40So the Supreme Court, California said, the assumption
- 6:43of risk doctrine applies. They leave open the
- 6:46question, as I mentioned before, was his conduct
- 6:49reckless, meaning did he intentionally hit the
- 6:51guy when he was looking right at him? And there
- 6:54was a factual dispute. Next slide, please. So
- 6:58you have various factors you look at if you get
- 7:01into contributory comparative negligence. If
- 7:05you have primary assumption of risk where the
- 7:08defendant, that is the golfer, did not owe any
- 7:11extra duty to protect the plaintiff from any
- 7:14particular risk, it's a complete defense. However,
- 7:18if that's not the case, and there was some actions
- 7:22by the golfer above and beyond just the normal
- 7:26play, Then you get into contributing or comparative
- 7:29negligence. Where was the person standing who
- 7:31got hit? In an earlier case, they made a distinction
- 7:34whether they were in the same threesome, foursome,
- 7:36or nine, not this court. Were they paying attention?
- 7:39You look at those facts. In a case that I don't
- 7:43have cited up here, as usual for California,
- 7:47the victim didn't know in the late afternoon
- 7:48where he was out in the yard that the golfers
- 7:51were playing and they… could hit into his yard
- 7:54from the third hole. And that's an older case,
- 7:57which took a different view. But in any event,
- 8:00if the golfer who hits someone goes beyond the
- 8:02typical game of golf, typical swing, then you
- 8:05look at contributory comparative negligence.
- 8:08So next slide, please. So we have, again, primary
- 8:14assumption of risk, no duty by the defendant
- 8:16to protect the plaintiff from a particular risk.
- 8:19It is a complete defense. anything can happen
- 8:22on a golf course. Secondary assumption of risk,
- 8:26the defendant still owes a duty of care, but
- 8:29the plaintiff knowingly engages in risky behavior.
- 8:33That's a breach of his duty. So he does have
- 8:35some responsibility. In other words, his conduct
- 8:39beyond just trying to hit the ball straight.
- 8:43So basically, it's a limited amount of duty.
- 8:47Secondary, For example, it could be considered
- 8:49negligence if the defendant hits where he can't
- 8:52see. That could be considered reckless conduct.
- 8:56So I have a hypothetical which cares about Justice
- 9:00Ashton's response, and I haven't found a case
- 9:04of that. I just ran an AI. When I say I ran an
- 9:06AI, I'm not preparing a brief, so I don't have
- 9:09the responsibilities to start reading all the
- 9:11cases. But I was playing one day, and it was
- 9:15very, very foggy, and I was up on the tee box
- 9:18hitting down onto the tee, onto the three. You
- 9:21couldn't see any. So the guys in my foursome,
- 9:25we sort of, you know, go down there, and one
- 9:26yells to the other one, it looks like it's clear,
- 9:29et cetera, to avoid hitting onto the green when
- 9:32someone was standing there, because I think that
- 9:34would be considered reckless behavior. Now let's
- 9:37add a fact. We have a strict fast play policy.
- 9:41So one of the marshals comes up and says, you
- 9:43guys are playing too slowly, said to several
- 9:45of us. We've said, we can't see where we're hitting.
- 9:48And so when you throw in that factor, you could
- 9:50argue that the club also was engaged in negligent
- 9:53behavior because notwithstanding, you couldn't
- 9:55see someone because of the fog, they didn't close
- 9:58the course. They didn't change the time limitations.
- 10:01In fact, they were encouraging us to hit quicker
- 10:04without trying to observe some safety factors.
- 10:10What do you think? I think that the problem is,
- 10:14of course, the golfer is going to head for the
- 10:17deep pockets. And who's that? That, of course,
- 10:20is the course. But it seems to me that in my
- 10:26mind, it's really one of the risks of playing
- 10:28golf. The weather changes. Fog comes in. It gets
- 10:33to be heavy rain. You've got to leave. I think
- 10:36that all comes within the assumption of the risk
- 10:40because you don't want to interfere with the
- 10:43purpose of the game and what's going on with
- 10:46the game. I don't know if you disagree with that.
- 10:51I thought the club was negligent for asking us
- 10:54to play more quickly and we get these nasty letters.
- 10:57Now, one of the fears you have whenever you do
- 10:59these classes is there's something that happened
- 11:01the last two or three days and you don't know
- 11:03about and someone's going to ask a question.
- 11:05So, there was a case of verdict in Long Beach,
- 11:09$1 .4 million, I think, within the last two or
- 11:12three days. And in that case, a lawnmower propelled
- 11:17a golf ball at 200 miles an hour and shattered
- 11:20a window where the plaintiff was in the clubhouse
- 11:26or somewhere ordering lunch. There, the trial
- 11:29court apparently found that it was not assumption
- 11:32of risk. that liability was based on negligent
- 11:35maintenance of a lawn mower. There were certain
- 11:37safety equipment they could put on to prevent
- 11:40balls and other things on a golf course from
- 11:43flying out. They didn't do that. So they did
- 11:45not find those primary assumption of risks. So
- 11:47if you saw that case, that's another application.
- 11:54And I wouldn't be surprised if we have a court
- 11:55of appeal decision on that. Next slide, please.
- 12:01So as As written in this case, I love this quote,
- 12:05if every ball behaved as a golfer wished, there
- 12:08would be little sport in the sport of golf. That
- 12:11shots go, hooray, is a risk that all golfers,
- 12:14even the professionals, assume when they play.
- 12:18There are a few other states who, you know, vary.
- 12:21Some find intentional reckless conduct. Some
- 12:23find it has to be reckless, like in California.
- 12:26But I think that's generally probably the same
- 12:28rule in other jurisdictions. All right, next
- 12:32slide, please. So we're going to go into a new
- 12:36topic now, and that is when you go see the lawyer
- 12:41because you got hit by a golf ball, next question
- 12:46by the lawyer is going to be, well, what about
- 12:47the design of the courts? In other words, deep
- 12:50pockets. Was it a bad golfer or a bad architect?
- 12:55And let me tell you an interesting point. It's
- 12:57not on the slide. If you go on one of these AI
- 13:01websites that I put in my course, not only do
- 13:05they list what they feel are faulty designs,
- 13:07but they actually have next slide. Not our next
- 13:10slide, but you could go to our next slide, yes.
- 13:12They said, do you want to go to the next question,
- 13:17which is, shall we fill out the civil complaint
- 13:19for you against your golf course? Interesting.
- 13:23All right, negligent design. I'm going to turn
- 13:25that over to Jessica Ashman. And it's very appropriate
- 13:29that she speak on this topic because one of the
- 13:32major cases in this area of negligent design
- 13:35was authored by Jessica Ashman. That was the
- 13:39Garcia case. Next slide, please. We will get
- 13:41to that. But the concept of assumption of the
- 13:46risk also applies to asserting that the course
- 13:49itself caused the injury. One example of that
- 13:53is that Wells Free case versus Ocean colony.
- 13:57That one there was a depressed drainage grate
- 14:00and someone fell on a wooden step and was injured.
- 14:05The courts are pretty liberal on what is assumption
- 14:09of the risk because the whole concept, as I mentioned
- 14:12before, is not to destroy the nature of the game.
- 14:18So a lot of examples even though it seems to
- 14:22me it could possibly be considered negligence
- 14:26on the part of the course is not treated that
- 14:29way. So where does a specifically negligent design
- 14:35come in? Well, it comes up when the golfer or
- 14:38spectator or someone on the course is injured.
- 14:41So the injured person, as we both have said,
- 14:44looks for the deep pockets. That's going to be
- 14:45the golf course. playing member. But under secondary
- 14:52assumption of the risk, the course might be liable.
- 14:55That's what we're going to talk about now. So
- 14:57in essence, the rule is that the owner of a sports
- 15:01facility has a duty to use due care to remove
- 15:04risks that are not inherent in the sport. Morgan
- 15:07versus Fuji case that really explains that further
- 15:12says the duty of the golf course towards golfers
- 15:16provide a reasonably safe golf course. Specifically,
- 15:21the design that must minimize the risk that a
- 15:24player will be hit by golf balls. So, for example,
- 15:27the way the various tees are placed, how the
- 15:30fairways and the greens are aligned or separated,
- 15:34certain areas of a golf course The golf course
- 15:37owner may also have a duty to provide special
- 15:40protections for players from being hit with golf
- 15:43balls. And the reason we have this picture up
- 15:45there is not for the Rose Bowl, but that's the
- 15:47scene of the Garcia case. That's Brookside. Right.
- 15:52Yeah, the Rose Bowl was really an interesting
- 15:55case that I'll get to in just a moment. So. The
- 16:03example of if the injury is designed by the course,
- 16:07but may not cause the course to incur liability.
- 16:11But there are always exceptions to that. For
- 16:15example, what about the duty to a spectator at
- 16:20a tournament? We all know, we've watched on TV,
- 16:23somebody gets hit. And is that assumption of
- 16:29the risk? It depends, and that depends on the
- 16:33facts of it. It depends on where the spectator
- 16:39decided to sit. Was there adequate protection
- 16:43provided for a spectator? Where were the stands
- 16:47placed? In those cases, there are tribal issues,
- 16:51so motions for summary judgment would probably
- 16:53be denied, depending on the facts of the case.
- 16:58So now we get to the concept of the duty of care.
- 17:03You can stay on that slide. Duty of care to non
- 17:07-golfers outside the course. So there's not really
- 17:11a good line of cases applicable to the liability
- 17:14of a golf course to non -golfers outside the
- 17:17course. But the law pertaining to landowner's
- 17:20duty not to cause harm to people outside the
- 17:23land would also apply. So, for example, this
- 17:26is a case, not a golf case, but it involves Spretcher
- 17:31versus Adamson, which involved a landslide on
- 17:34defendant's property that damaged a neighbor's
- 17:36house. The court explains that the duty analysis
- 17:40with respect to a landowner's duty goes back
- 17:44to our very, very favorite first -year tort class,
- 17:48Rowland versus Christian. So this means there
- 17:50are lots of considerations. Major of which are,
- 17:55first, the ability of harm to the plaintiff,
- 17:57degree of certainty that the plaintiff suffered
- 18:00injury, the closeness of the connection between
- 18:03the defendant's conduct and the injury. So we
- 18:06would then also look back to the moral blame
- 18:09attached to the defendant's contact and the policy
- 18:13of preventing future harm. So golf courses liability
- 18:17may be mitigated, of course, if a non -golfer
- 18:21outside the course acted unreasonably. For instance,
- 18:25ignoring obvious warning signs about walking
- 18:28in the area and you might be struck by a golf
- 18:32ball. If you ignore that, then the course is
- 18:35null events. It's not going to be liable. So
- 18:39when else would a property qualify for immunity?
- 18:45So the Garcia versus American golf case, which
- 18:48yes, in fact, I wrote, a boy was hit by a golf
- 18:52ball. while he was on a pathway between the road
- 18:56and Brookside Golf Course in Pasadena. He sued
- 18:59the city as well as the operator of the golf
- 19:02course. Trial court found that the pathway was
- 19:05a trail and granted summary judgment for the
- 19:08city based on the concept of trail immunity.
- 19:12Now, what is trail immunity? Let's see if we
- 19:15talking about or see if we can go past to Next
- 19:22slide, here comes Garcia. And my problem with
- 19:28this case, even when I was involved in writing
- 19:31it, was what's trail immunity? I had never heard
- 19:33of the concept before. So trail immunity, a trail,
- 19:38it's a pathway that's any trail that is used
- 19:43for access to hiking and recreational activities
- 19:46or scenic areas, which is not a city street.
- 19:50So whether the property qualifies for immunity
- 19:53depends on several of these considerations, including
- 19:57the accepted definition of the word trail. The
- 20:01purpose of the trail is designed and used to
- 20:06connect recreational areas from one to another.
- 20:11So the Garcia case is often called the major
- 20:15case on trail immunity. So, as in Garcia, the
- 20:20city moves for summary judgment on multiple grounds,
- 20:24including the absence of a dangerous condition
- 20:26on the trail, lack of notice, dangerous condition
- 20:31on the trail, and the applicability of trail
- 20:34immunity, which is within the government code.
- 20:38And I think it's section, it's not on here. It's
- 20:42section in case you're interested. is government
- 20:46code section 830. So the city argued assumption
- 20:52of the risk. The trial court granted summary
- 20:55judgment for the city based on the trail immunity
- 20:59statute. The trial court though found a trialable
- 21:04issue as to whether there was a dangerous condition,
- 21:08whether the city had actual notice of the dangerous
- 21:11condition. and whether the city took sufficient
- 21:15action to protect against the risk of injury.
- 21:20That's on the slide in front of you. And next
- 21:25slide, let's see. The next slide is a different
- 21:29case. Well, okay, then I'm not finished yet.
- 21:34So let's say in Garcia, we reversed the summary
- 21:39judgment. deciding that the city was not entitled
- 21:43to trail immunity. We found no trail immunity
- 21:47because Garcia actually assisted the development
- 21:51of the law on trail immunity by discussing the
- 21:55policy considerations at play. So there are several
- 21:59cases that have focused on trail immunity and
- 22:04when it applies. One of the main ones is Amberger.
- 22:08Warren versus City of Piedmont, which involved
- 22:11a woman on a trail with a walking her dog and
- 22:16slips and falls. And that was found to be trail
- 22:19immunity. I think we're a little behind. We should
- 22:23focus on the golf course. Well, of the three
- 22:27cases, only Leyva involved a golf course. In
- 22:30that matter, Miguel Leyva was walking on a public
- 22:33path adjacent to Benito Golf Course when he was
- 22:37struck in the eye by a golf ball. Court applied
- 22:41government code section 834 .1, the trail immunity,
- 22:46and extended this prosecution to private owners
- 22:49who provide property for public uses. So the
- 22:54trail provides immunity because it provides access
- 22:57to recreation. If there was no immunity, it would
- 23:00really discourage. private property owners from
- 23:05providing and opening up those kinds of trails.
- 23:09It's a question though, I'm there about this
- 23:11case is you found against the golf course because
- 23:14it was privately owned. Am I correct? And that
- 23:19they had the responsibilities to for ensuring
- 23:24safety. We found that the trail did not protect
- 23:27them. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Should we go on to the
- 23:31next one? All right, next one. That's where the
- 23:39plane has land next to the golf course. And do
- 23:45you want to handle this one or should I? Sierra
- 23:51products? Well, I can briefly talk about it if
- 23:58you want. Plane or plot land next to the golf
- 24:00course and I figured The use was permitted to
- 24:04have a golf course because they got permission
- 24:06from the city zoning laws. And the court found
- 24:09that there were two holes that really should
- 24:13have been redesigned. It was a continuing problem
- 24:16of the risk of golf shots going onto this property.
- 24:19And they did not find that the permitted use
- 24:22under the city zoning law was a defense. In that
- 24:26case, I believe it was under nuisance, they ordered
- 24:29a golf course to redesign both holes. just those
- 24:32two. So they can too do that. All right, next
- 24:36slide. I think this is yours. This involves just
- 24:44a survey as an example of a number of examples
- 24:48where people sue on various things that come
- 24:51up with the golf course. Right. Yeah. You can
- 24:54go through it. pretty much on yourselves. You
- 24:57know, the tripping on tree roots was foreseeable,
- 25:00there's no liability on the city path we talked
- 25:04about in Garcia. Well, one of them was just a
- 25:08little bit different where trees were removed,
- 25:10separate fairways. When I mean removed, they
- 25:12were taken out completely and someone was hit
- 25:16after that and that was held to be tribal on
- 25:21the duty of care by the golf course. Ones that
- 25:25don't, you know, don't cause liability, there's,
- 25:30you know, wouldn't yardage markers. Okay, so
- 25:32the ball ricochets and hits the plaintiff. There's
- 25:35no liability because that's one of the possible
- 25:39injuries that you might occur. So you assume
- 25:44the risk when you play golf for that kind of
- 25:50Also, there's a case that the Strand versus Connor,
- 25:53there are adjacent fairways, but there's no one
- 25:58that tells you you really should be yelling for
- 26:00to make sure that somebody knows that you're
- 26:03ready to hit your ball. And they said, no, no
- 26:06liability. That's one of the risks when you play
- 26:09golf. You know, it's interesting because there's
- 26:10another case which says that etiquette is irrelevant.
- 26:14That is golf etiquette. The sanctions of social
- 26:17disapproval, of course, etiquette says you do
- 26:20yell for, but you can't use that as a basis of
- 26:24a lawsuit. All right. Can we go to the next one?
- 26:30Yes. All right. Here's an entirely different
- 26:32topic. Virtually every club member, I will guess,
- 26:39would answer yes to the question, are country
- 26:41clubs private? Is this the correct question?
- 26:45Obviously, I'm implying no. Hotel lobbies are
- 26:48private, but they can't discriminate. Restaurants
- 26:51are private, but they can't discriminate. And
- 26:53the workforce is changing, and I think that's
- 26:55an important policy issue. How many of your business
- 26:58contacts with those of you in the clubs are club
- 27:00members? And if you're excluding certain groups,
- 27:04because we know historically they were only white
- 27:05males, there is a real detriment. I looked at
- 27:09my own situation. and how many of my business
- 27:13contacts are in my country club? Eye doctor,
- 27:16electrician, roofer, physical therapist, although
- 27:19we need those when we play golf, car dealer,
- 27:23air conditioning repairman, financial advisor,
- 27:25gate and fence guy, and don't need them yet,
- 27:28but my criminal defense attorney. So that's why
- 27:33it becomes an important question. And if we could
- 27:36go to next slide, next slide. Is the club private?
- 27:42Is it a business establishment or is it a public
- 27:44accommodation? And one of my surprises, many
- 27:48of us or some of us who are older remember the
- 27:51historic 1964 Civil Rights Act, which is the
- 27:54basis for public accommodations. They have that
- 27:58famous lunch counter from the South if you go
- 28:00to the Smithsonian. But actually, it specifically
- 28:04excluded athletic clubs. I have the language
- 28:09there. Can we go to the next slide, please? Next
- 28:13slide. Yeah. This doesn't apply to private club
- 28:18or establishment, not in fact open to the public
- 28:22unless they're part of a establishment within
- 28:26the scope of subsection B. Well, subsection B
- 28:29is actually now being used quite a bit because
- 28:31that refers to public accommodations. All right.
- 28:37That's not the most important law in California.
- 28:40I'll turn it over to the next slide, Justice
- 28:44Ashley. Yes, the California Unroll Civil Rights
- 28:47Act is actually the premier law dealing with
- 28:52discrimination and requires that all persons
- 28:57are entitled to full and equal accommodations,
- 28:59advantages, facilities, privileges, or services
- 29:02in a business establishment. That means you know,
- 29:09various categories such as sex discrimination
- 29:14comes up a lot in ADA issues as well. One of
- 29:21the important ones is learner versus American
- 29:23golf, where our club member with a disability
- 29:26asked for accommodation. Case involved not only
- 29:30Unruh, but the federal ADA. So the member, for
- 29:35example, the member wanted to bring a golf cart.
- 29:37closer to where the ball lands because of his
- 29:40disability. And he also wanted to get a special
- 29:44golf carton, a single -person golf carton. The
- 29:47club was really reluctant to do it. And actually,
- 29:51the case found of going to court before it was
- 29:54finally resolved. The gentleman was given what
- 29:57they call a blue flag. We call it a red flag.
- 30:01was able to go in areas where the other players
- 30:04weren't. The other players were getting upset
- 30:06with him at times and would make comments. So
- 30:11one of the things he did was have the club assure
- 30:13them that he was following the rules as required
- 30:17by the club. As it turns out, probably this guy
- 30:21had... had some issues with some of the other
- 30:25club members because they were making this, you
- 30:27know, a personal thing and he also at one point
- 30:31threatened to get in a fight with the other golfers.
- 30:36So, Ron O 'Hara overlaps with private club issue
- 30:39as mentioned by Cliff. So, is the club truly
- 30:44private or is it a business establishment? I
- 30:46think we should go to the next slide on that.
- 30:48Well, I had There it is. Well, you're going to
- 30:54talk about Vanessa. Well, I think I thought we
- 30:58were going to discuss. I can talk about it. I
- 31:01just want to make a couple of things quickly.
- 31:06You know, when I passed the bar in the early
- 31:10days of the common law, there were several private
- 31:14clubs in downtown L .A. that were out of bounds
- 31:16to women. And one, women were simply not allowed.
- 31:21Another, you could go to a meeting, but you had
- 31:23to travel the back elevator that the help used.
- 31:28So that was really prevalent in the early days
- 31:35and also employment. So we get back to private
- 31:38clubs, whether it's a business establishment
- 31:40or not. The most well -known is Warfield versus
- 31:44Peninsula Country Club. In a country club setting,
- 31:49potential violations of under civil acts generally
- 31:52arise when the club denies full and equal access
- 31:56services or privileges. Private golf clubs, country
- 32:01clubs, often sit right on that line between private
- 32:06club that's exempt and a business establishment
- 32:09that's covered. So liability frequently turns
- 32:11on how the exclusive club really is in practice.
- 32:18So there are a lot of ways of determining whether
- 32:21a club is private or not. It's denying membership
- 32:25based on race, religion, and national origin.
- 32:28You can get in only through an old boys' network
- 32:31by having a sponsor, local sponsor, unequal access
- 32:36to facilities or privileges. And it goes on.
- 32:41Having a men's grill. There used to be a men's
- 32:44grill in a lot of the clubs. I think there probably
- 32:46still are. And having restricted times for use
- 32:51of the golf course by women. Times, days of the
- 32:56week were fairly common when I started playing
- 33:01golf. But leading down to the threshold question.
- 33:09And I know the clip will have something more
- 33:11to say about this. The threshold question is,
- 33:15why is it important to be a private club versus
- 33:18being a business establishment? And it all goes
- 33:21back to money. Because if you become, if your
- 33:26private club starts bringing in outside income,
- 33:32you know, you're hosting a political discussion.
- 33:37You're having bar mitzvahs and weddings at the
- 33:43club, but you the member are not in fact paying.
- 33:49Using the club goes out into the public for these
- 33:53events. So clubs have become much more concerned
- 34:00about them, although I think some are. a little
- 34:04bit looser than they used to be. But the thing
- 34:07is, if they are deemed to be a business establishment
- 34:10because of the way they're conducting this outside
- 34:12business, they need to lose their liquor license.
- 34:15And that's a big thing. So as we look at other
- 34:21clubs, we see that there's a club in Palm Springs,
- 34:25in the Palm Springs area, I don't know exactly
- 34:27where, where no women may need members. No women
- 34:34can be guests. Women can't come on the property,
- 34:39can't step foot on the property other than on
- 34:43Christmas Day. And I know there was a time my
- 34:47husband was playing as some group and it was
- 34:50going to be at that club. I couldn't even drop
- 34:53him off at the club. I wasn't allowed to drive.
- 34:56That didn't last very long for us. It was. He
- 35:01laid down a lot. Yeah. I'll talk about Peninsula,
- 35:05I don't know. All right, so Peninsula is the
- 35:08big California Supreme Court case on this issue
- 35:11where they found that Peninsula didn't let in
- 35:14women and they found with the business establishment,
- 35:17it was not a private club. And they set up a
- 35:20bunch of criteria and I'm going to prepare, Justice
- 35:22Ashton, because I'm asking this question about
- 35:24how much precedent this really case will really
- 35:27receive now. So, they look at factors. Did they
- 35:30regularly receive income from fees? I want to
- 35:33go to the next slide, please. Next slide. Yeah.
- 35:37Did they regularly receive income from fees for
- 35:39the use of facilities, funds, or events? Did
- 35:41they get a financial benefit from non -members'
- 35:45use of the Pro Shop, which was open to the public?
- 35:47They let the high school team use it. Guests
- 35:49could pay cash for food or drinks. Next slide,
- 35:52please. Is that the next slide? Yeah, they looked
- 35:59at the factors in most cases as selective versus
- 36:03allowing the public in, which I always found
- 36:05interesting because if you let everybody in,
- 36:07you would think you'd be more diverse. Size of
- 36:10the club, if there's 700 members, it's more of
- 36:13a commercial establishment. How much do the members
- 36:16actually control? How much do non -members use
- 36:19the club? Is the primary purpose for business
- 36:21or social? And they found that Peninsula flunked
- 36:27this test. But my question for Justice Ashen
- 36:33and our appellate specialist is they didn't cite
- 36:36any specific numbers. How much of the income
- 36:39was received from the facility? These kinds of
- 36:43issues. And I think we both agree, being members
- 36:45of the club, they're bogus anyway, because I'm
- 36:48in a national network where people call, can
- 36:50I'm in town, can I play? They pay the guest fees.
- 36:53People are regular guest, pay guest fees. You
- 36:56host an event and people chip in if it's a baby
- 36:58shower. So the stats are misleading if they present
- 37:03them. So my question about the precedent value
- 37:07of this case, they didn't list any specific numbers.
- 37:11And the other one is, should have come up again.
- 37:17This California Supreme Court is very different
- 37:19from the one decided, the Peninsula case. There
- 37:21are currently six members. Everyone is a member
- 37:26of a class that was historically excluded from
- 37:29country clubs. There's one, a Jewish member,
- 37:32Justice Groden, Jewish, Jews didn't get in the
- 37:35clubs. The others are all the people of color.
- 37:37Do you think this case would stand? to come up
- 37:42together for the California Supreme Court. Yes.
- 37:44I think really going through the facts specifically
- 37:49as you did. I meant, would they change the criteria
- 37:52since they didn't give any specifics? No, no.
- 37:54I think it's very vague. The selectivity of admissions,
- 37:57how do you deal with that? The size of the club,
- 38:00700 to okay, but is a thousand too many. Degree
- 38:06of membership control, who's really controlling
- 38:09the club? And as you have mentioned, the use
- 38:13by non -members. So my question is suggesting
- 38:15that a lot of these clubs, if they get in front
- 38:18of the California Supreme Court, will be in trouble.
- 38:20They'll be in trouble. Yeah, it's going to be
- 38:22less than pathetic. All right, next slide. Other
- 38:24state laws. I'm going to summarize this very
- 38:28specifically because it shows some difference.
- 38:31Maryland, you don't get a property tax deduction.
- 38:34Remember that one. Connecticut's prohibited by
- 38:36statute. Michigan prohibited by statute. There's
- 38:39no you know, these are the words like you have
- 38:41in the Civil Rights Act. Florida, there you get
- 38:45into more looking at factors. Statutory, no,
- 38:48you cannot discriminate. New York is more like
- 38:51California. All right, next slide. I find this
- 38:57one very interesting because one club litigated
- 38:59this. All You Golf was in Oakland Valley, one
- 39:02of the most renowned clubs. But in New Jersey,
- 39:07they have an anti -discrimination law. The other
- 39:09difference in Pine Valley is it also included
- 39:12a lot of the members' own real estates, and then
- 39:14you get into housing issues, which we all know
- 39:18you can't discriminate on who you sell your house
- 39:20to. So I thought the settlement was very interesting.
- 39:22I bet the Pine Valley members are sorry they
- 39:25ever got into this. All right, no discrimination.
- 39:27They probably knew that was happening. No restricting
- 39:30lease of land based on gender or club members
- 39:32or status, so you can't. You know, not say that
- 39:35blacks or women or Asians can't buy houses, which
- 39:39historically was obviously the situation. California,
- 39:42other places. But now we get into must provide
- 39:45all persons, including women, transgender, whatever
- 39:48equal opportunities to obtain employment. OK,
- 39:50next slide. This is the one where I bet some
- 39:55of the members were going, oh, my goodness. Cannot
- 39:58bar any employee from wearing earrings at work
- 40:01on the basis of gender, gender identity, or gender
- 40:03expression. Any of you club members, you know,
- 40:06well, most club members feel about their very
- 40:09conservative undress. Cannot prohibit any employee
- 40:12from appearing, grooming, dressing consistent
- 40:15with their gender, gender identity, or gender
- 40:18expression. I can imagine my club would think
- 40:20of that. No, I don't know if that was my point,
- 40:23but you know, some would, you know, it's a coat
- 40:26and tie. And they have to go to anti -discrimination
- 40:29training, which, of course, we all have to be
- 40:31members of the bar. Next club. That's the next
- 40:34question. All right, a couple other sanctions.
- 40:38Some clubs say, we are not giving in. And there's
- 40:41a well -known club, Illinois. They can discriminate,
- 40:45but they lost the PGA Western Open. There's a
- 40:48club in Maryland. I'll name Burning Tree. They've
- 40:51had four presidents, Supreme Court justices,
- 40:54congressional representatives. I love this story.
- 40:57Edward Burrow reportedly learned of Pearl Harbor
- 41:00on the 10th T, but he finished his round. And
- 41:03they do not have a tax exemption, and it goes
- 41:07up every year, and it's up to 1 million. But
- 41:09they have, my understanding, is a policy, as
- 41:13the one that Justice Shirley mentioned, in Palm
- 41:16Desert. Next slide, please. There are other sanctions.
- 41:23Some occupations like judges, the judicial code
- 41:26of ethics says you cannot be in a club that discriminates,
- 41:29but they use the word invidious, meaning arbitrary.
- 41:34So if you're in a club that, let's say a Jewish
- 41:36organization, that's not going to be considered
- 41:39an illegal club under the violation of the code
- 41:44of ethics. Signature itself has a disclosure
- 41:46form similar to that. Uh, liquor license is actually
- 41:50an interesting one because I researched that
- 41:52in the California law, virtually every type of
- 41:56club, they must list 20 kinds of clubs. They
- 41:59say you lose your liquor license if you discriminate,
- 42:02not country clubs. For some reason, there was
- 42:05a bill to include them and that went nowhere,
- 42:07I believe, in the early 80s or late 90s. They
- 42:11do say if you have a liquor license and you serve
- 42:14liquor and you discriminate, you get something
- 42:16on your invoice that says it's not deductible,
- 42:20but I think it's not deductible anyway. So there
- 42:23are other sanctions out there. And what makes
- 42:27it difficult to enforce the membership ones is
- 42:30there is a conflicting statute or policy which
- 42:35says there's rights under the First Amendment
- 42:37for freedom of association. So you may not have
- 42:41to disclose your list should it be challenged.
- 42:44All right, other jurisdictions. Next slide. I'm
- 42:49going to skip that. That just shows that some
- 42:52of them had racist policies or were not allowed
- 42:58to continue discrimination when they had lawsuits.
- 43:02There are some federal cases. Again, you have
- 43:04that little small thing about public accommodation.
- 43:07And if I may summarize the criteria, if they
- 43:11look at... Selectivity based on protected categories,
- 43:15that's most important. Obviously, as we talked
- 43:18about certain store groups that have not been
- 43:21allowed, did they advertise or solicitate? If
- 43:24they do a lot of advertising, that's more of
- 43:26a public club. Internal governance of members,
- 43:29that's more of a private club. Use by non -members,
- 43:32that's a big one. That, of course, is a public
- 43:35club. All right, next slide. Yeah. Next slide,
- 43:43please. I will turn it over to you. I don't know
- 43:46if it's the perfect analogy. We have a designated
- 43:48hitter rule in baseball for our older players
- 43:52who can't field anymore. Should they be accommodated?
- 43:55Well, what about golfers who can barely walk?
- 43:58I'll turn it over to Justice Ashman. Disabilities.
- 44:03Next slide, please. Great case there. Disabilities,
- 44:06please, is the case of PGA Tour. versus Martin.
- 44:12So closely related to the other discrimination
- 44:15issues, the disability issues has come up very
- 44:19recently. And the Supreme Court was asked to
- 44:21decide whether professional golfers who could
- 44:24walk with difficulty should be accommodated.
- 44:27The decision came down in 2001 in the case of
- 44:31P. J. Cho versus Martin, and he sought the ability
- 44:34to drive in a golf court. The Supreme Court found
- 44:37that riding was not an advantage over walking
- 44:41and permitted Martin to drive. So the decision
- 44:45was based on the PGA being considered a commercial
- 44:48enterprise and that its tournaments were places
- 44:51of public accommodation under the ADA. And other
- 44:56other cases have really dealt with disabilities
- 44:58and not discrimination. So I previously mentioned
- 45:03the golf at a private club who was initially
- 45:05just denied the accommodation but subsequently
- 45:09was provided in the blue card and the use of
- 45:13a special golf cart. So any events that occur
- 45:15on golf course identified by the act as a public
- 45:19accommodation cannot discriminate against any
- 45:22individual in the full and equal enjoyment of
- 45:26the good services of the courses and that includes
- 45:30going as far as the Q schools which are for golfers
- 45:36trying to get on various tours. Yeah, I think
- 45:39they may have allowed riding in a few schools.
- 45:41Of course, in the senior tour and even in pro
- 45:44tours. Yep. Transportation from the ninth green
- 45:47to the tenth tee. But I love this quote. Can
- 45:49we go to walking versus riding? Go up a couple
- 45:51slides. There. So, court is screen court. It's
- 45:58the same energy level. Some of you, such as myself,
- 46:03may question that. I get tired when I walk instead
- 46:05of writing, but they found an expert to say otherwise.
- 46:09And so are US Supreme Court. All right. So they're
- 46:12right. Next slide. Very topical. All right. Skip
- 46:19that one. Skip that one. Duplicate. Skip that
- 46:23one. Transgender competition. All right. Just
- 46:27yesterday, the International Olympic Committee
- 46:29made a ruling on transgender competition. Next
- 46:33slide. All right. So a lot of agencies are getting
- 46:40involved in this. The California Coastal Commission
- 46:42ruled that a women's surfing competition had
- 46:44to permit transgender surfers. So what happens
- 46:48to Pebble Beach and Torrey Pines and the California
- 46:51Coastal Commission? The Coastal Commission has
- 46:57jurisdiction over equal access, not sports eligibility.
- 47:00But in ruling on equal access, they, of course,
- 47:02can make decisions about sports eligibility.
- 47:06So it's not, in their view, just fences and gates
- 47:09that prevent any beach access. Earlier, there
- 47:11was a controversy when they made a ruling on
- 47:14curfew on the Venice Beach, disagreeing with
- 47:17the city's efforts to enforce it. There was another
- 47:20controversy over Elon Musk shooting off rockets.
- 47:24And the LPGA, of course, is looking at competitive
- 47:26fairness and physiology. So the question is,
- 47:30is eligibility in sporting event a permissible
- 47:32classification? You get into sports governance,
- 47:36or is that a legal discrimination? We have the
- 47:39Olympics coming up here. We have international
- 47:42treaties, contracts. Please, no one ask me what's
- 47:45going to happen with beach volleyball. Next slide.
- 47:51So this is the LPGA rule. uh that after male
- 47:56puberty they can't complete anymore we're going
- 47:59to learn a lot about this next year that is the
- 48:02law next slide please because there are two cases
- 48:07going in front of the united states supreme court
- 48:10uh two different states i think the other one
- 48:13might be idaho in west virginia have passed statutes
- 48:17restricting participation in girls and women's
- 48:19sports to athletes who were born female the Court
- 48:23of Appeals, two different circuits, and join
- 48:25these laws, it's going up in front of the U .S.
- 48:27Supreme Court. Next slide, please. And the question
- 48:33will be, is discrimination substantially related
- 48:35to the stated goals of equal participation and
- 48:38opportunities for women athletes? And are the
- 48:42procedures to decide if they are trans athletes
- 48:44unnecessary and invasive requirements that they
- 48:47have to undergo? The invasive requirements were,
- 48:53I think, about 40, 50 years ago, much more invasive.
- 48:57So those are the two issues that will be coming
- 49:02up. Coincidentally, just to let you know how
- 49:05topical this is, there was a golfer, Haley Davidson,
- 49:11who I believe he's the one who actually got to
- 49:13the second round in Q School. She is now suing
- 49:17the USGA and the LPGA. I think it was filed.
- 49:20this week against discrimination. So we will
- 49:26see where this goes because it's really not the
- 49:29California Coastal Commission that's going to
- 49:31decide this issue. It's going to be the Under
- 49:35Civil Rights Act. That's going to be the one
- 49:38where it provides, it prohibits discrimination
- 49:42against people based on their central orientation
- 49:44and transgenders. And so you very likely will
- 49:49have a lawsuit like Haley Davidson's, I don't
- 49:51know if that's in California, that's probably
- 49:53a federal case, dealing with the conflict over,
- 49:57well, you all know, I've just been getting a
- 49:59lot of publicity. When you get to the Olympics,
- 50:01you have international treaties and international
- 50:03contracts. So I think we know, I'd be surprised
- 50:07if state agencies had any relevant say on that.
- 50:12But when we get to some of the other situations,
- 50:15I suspect there'll be some litigation. And it's
- 50:17hard to tell how the courts have come down on
- 50:19this, these competing interests. Next slide.
- 50:23Let's go to... This is a quick one. Those of
- 50:32you who are country club members. There are always
- 50:36disputes by members. And in my club, my president...
- 50:41past president who read this came up to me and
- 50:44said, this is interesting because guys are always
- 50:46saying, you know, I'm going to sue the club.
- 50:48We had a situation where there was a dispute
- 50:51over the calendaring in a match play tournament
- 50:54and he threatened to sue. So the question is,
- 51:01where are these lawsuits going to go? Just to
- 51:03ask what court? Next slide. The courts aren't
- 51:06really interested in us. The courts are really
- 51:09not eager to hear from clubs to hear disputes
- 51:14by the members of country clubs. But instead,
- 51:19many courts have the board of directors or rules
- 51:22committee to resolve disputes. Cobb versus Ironwood,
- 51:28which is a California case. Former and current
- 51:31members brought in action to seek declaratory
- 51:33judgments as to a club's obligation to repay
- 51:37land purchase assessments. This is something
- 51:39that's coming up more commonly for the clubs
- 51:43that are member on. The club filed a motion to
- 51:48compel arbitration. Trial court denied the motion
- 51:52and the club appealed. What had happened in that
- 51:55case is bylaws had been amended retroactively
- 51:58while the case was already in court. So the Court
- 52:00of Appeal affirmed the public policy facing arbitration
- 52:05did not favor retroactive application of the
- 52:09amendment. Another recent case, the disgruntled
- 52:12members of a club didn't seek arbitration. Arbitration
- 52:16was in the bylaws. It went to arbitration. The
- 52:19members lost based on the interpretation of the
- 52:23bylaws. The members were thereafter expelled
- 52:27from the club on the theory that because they
- 52:34sued because these disgruntled members also sued
- 52:37the individual members of the board in their
- 52:40individual capacity. Those those numbers were
- 52:46invited to leave the club, which they were, which
- 52:49they did because they. where their conduct was
- 52:55unbefitting of the club when the board members
- 53:00were sued in their individual capacity. All right.
- 53:04If we can move on now to intellectual property,
- 53:07let's go to that slide. I'm going to go very
- 53:09briefly over that. It's a complicated area, and
- 53:13I'm going to basically skip most of the slides.
- 53:16If you could, next slide. Yes, Carpenter to the
- 53:20Tools. You know, we all like to think, given
- 53:22the right club, maybe things will change. But
- 53:26anyway, I'll just say that the major case going
- 53:28on right now is Taylor made 790 irons used by
- 53:31some of the top pros versus Cotsville and Kirkland.
- 53:35And these are the various issues that come up,
- 53:36club heads, cleats, balls, practice mats, those
- 53:39initial golf balls, which I think would not turn
- 53:43out to be patented. There was a problem with
- 53:45how they were made. So that's the big case. There's
- 53:49a $900 difference in price. The Costco ones sold,
- 53:53I think, in a few hours when they first came
- 53:57out. Costco's famous. People love it for the
- 54:02wine, the batteries, the high -priced vodka,
- 54:05and the cheap Costco prices, the $1 .50 hot dog,
- 54:07et cetera. On the other hand, you've got... Taylor
- 54:11-Made, which has taken the historic pride in
- 54:14being very innovative in the golf business. They
- 54:16were the first to, I think, go to metal clubs
- 54:20versus the old Persimmon and their other ears
- 54:23also. Can we go to the next slide that shows
- 54:26a diagram of the two different slides? Just move
- 54:29through. All right. Next slide. I just thought
- 54:41it goes through all. All right, there we go.
- 54:42So back to that one. So there's a difference
- 54:46in the two. And you see in the red, it's the
- 54:48inserts. Next slide. All right. Taylor says there
- 54:55are hollow body designs, strategic weight placement,
- 54:58speed foam technology, et cetera. Next slide.
- 55:06They say also that, guess who went to work for
- 55:10the design company that Costco used? He used
- 55:13to work for TaylorMade on B79 irons. They have
- 55:16the secret design team. Next slide. All right,
- 55:20Costco has various defense. Older irons are similar.
- 55:25Some of these are required by the rules. The
- 55:26foam is different. The technology already existed.
- 55:30These were critical issues in patent law. Next
- 55:32slide, please. And then there's an issue of equivalence,
- 55:36does it perform the same function, in which case
- 55:39there would be a patent violation. Next slide.
- 55:45All right. And you can see how many times we
- 55:47have patent disputes. These are all the companies,
- 55:49all very well -known. Ashkenet, I think, makes
- 55:51a lot of some of the products. Maybe if you title
- 55:55this, I'm not sure. You know, as a retired judge,
- 55:59I was thinking about this, because you obviously
- 56:01have a lot of engineers who are going to be doing
- 56:02all of this research. It's a very expensive case
- 56:09to prepare. And right now it's on appeal. The
- 56:12issue is, I believe, Costco wants new arbitration.
- 56:16TaylorMade wants to have a jury trial. I will
- 56:18say this would be a tough case for a judge to
- 56:20try, because you have all this costly research.
- 56:23And how do you prevent You know, you go on the
- 56:25web and they got guys talking about, oh, I hit
- 56:27the 790, you know, hit the Kirkland, whether
- 56:31it's the same or not. Or what do you do? I don't
- 56:34know. You know, jurors are going to the driving
- 56:36range, trying it for themselves and saying, ah,
- 56:38so much for the experts. So who knows how that
- 56:41will turn out? Yeah. You know, Cliff, just to
- 56:44clarify, I know nothing about golf clubs, except
- 56:48I always want the newest and the best because
- 56:50that's going to change my golf game. Right. And
- 56:54boy, those clubs, there are a lot of people like
- 56:56that, and they go on and on about it, and then
- 56:58you get to get a new club. All right. I don't
- 57:02know how much more time we have. I think I'm
- 57:05going to have to really go to the conclusion,
- 57:07except for, I was going to talk about the PGA
- 57:11authority, the limit authority to limit. And
- 57:14outlaw golf equipment, the big case there was
- 57:16pain. Pain challenged it because they didn't
- 57:19like U -shaped grooves. golf people testifying
- 57:26on both sides. You had conflict of interest things,
- 57:29because all the pros on the committee had contracts
- 57:32with the companies. And it was very hard for
- 57:36the Pings to retool it. So they got a preliminary
- 57:40injunction saying it would be very difficult
- 57:43for Pings to change the contracts for the golfers
- 57:48to change production facilities. And then it
- 57:51kind of went away. But one of the interesting
- 57:55things on cross -examination, one of the experts,
- 57:58one of the pros, is the golf balls. Pros, they're
- 58:02not using the same tireless Pro V1s that all
- 58:05of us are using. It turns out they tweak them
- 58:07a little. So I found that one of the interesting
- 58:10facts. Property tax, Malcolm Gladwell, just a
- 58:15session. Well, that's pretty simple. We take
- 58:18just a minute to tell you that nonprofit golf
- 58:21courses, golf courses and clubs cannot be reassessed.
- 58:25Why is that? It's commonly known as the Bob Hope
- 58:29exception. So, clubs are non -profit and cannot
- 58:34be reassessed based on change of ownership with
- 58:38every new owner. Yeah, and you go to the next
- 58:39slide, that's what Bob Hope got enacted. Because
- 58:42I know there's always worry, you know, with clubs
- 58:44like Bel -Air, you know, etc., they're in pretty
- 58:47high -priced areas. What would happen if they
- 58:50had a property tax reassessment? And Malcolm
- 58:54Gladwell is always complaining about all the
- 58:56tax revenue that's lost simply to subsidize the
- 58:59wealthy. All right. I will conclude with an example
- 59:05of great legal scholarship. Next slide. Look
- 59:11at what a justice room. Fresh air, smell of pines
- 59:15and eucalyptus, recreation with friends, meeting
- 59:18other citizens. Oh, I wouldn't mind meeting Roy
- 59:21McIlroy. It can be a very social event. Neighbors
- 59:25benefit by seeing a green belt. Golf brings wildlife
- 59:29and joy. And that bit in the coyotes. So the
- 59:33law should not discourage participation in such
- 59:36an activity whose benefits to the individual
- 59:38player and to the community at large are so great.
- 59:41What beautiful... legal writing. So the final
- 59:44exam question for you to get your MC on credit
- 59:47is this. According to case law, when you leave
- 59:51your family to play golf, are you contributing
- 59:54to the public welfare? Yes or no? There's your
- 59:59case. Thank you. I think we finished our hour
- 1:00:06just under the gun. Do we have time for questions?
- 1:00:12Yes, we do have time for questions. It looks
- 1:00:14like we have one question from Laurel Starks.
- 1:00:19Let's see. I think this is in reference to an
- 1:00:22earlier portion of your program. Would this suggest
- 1:00:24that the existence of a quote unquote men's card
- 1:00:27room that is located in a prime location of the
- 1:00:30building and men's courtesy tee times would fall
- 1:00:34within discriminatory practices if it is classified
- 1:00:37as a business establishment? Well, I wondered
- 1:00:41about that because my club is certainly very
- 1:00:44diverse on its membership The men's card room
- 1:00:48is near the locker room. So we don't have that
- 1:00:50issue. Yeah, you have tee times but You know,
- 1:00:53they're bigger issues is my thought right now
- 1:00:56than that one I think membership is really where
- 1:00:59if we see anything that that's where the attacks
- 1:01:01will be right? I think a lot of the clubs are
- 1:01:04getting rid of men's card rooms women's card
- 1:01:08rooms and they're just all card rooms and the
- 1:01:10only place that there's any division there is
- 1:01:13up where we have a gym up there and so there's
- 1:01:19of course obviously the men's area and the women's
- 1:01:21but everyone can use the equipment everyone is
- 1:01:23invited to use the equipment everyone can use
- 1:01:25the private rooms for like pilates or whatever
- 1:01:28and there will there is a separate area for men
- 1:01:32as in the men's club area and another for women
- 1:01:36in their area obviously. So haven't been any
- 1:01:41complaints about it. I think in the case of mine,
- 1:01:45you know, the clubhouse is old and so you have
- 1:01:50certain things like the men's card was near the
- 1:01:51men's locker room. But I'd just be surprised
- 1:01:55if that's where the attacks would be on country
- 1:01:57clubs, considering what's out there. Yeah. In
- 1:02:01other areas. Yeah. Tax is going to be on general
- 1:02:03membership issues. Yeah. Because our women members,
- 1:02:07you don't usually see them there on Sunday morning,
- 1:02:10but you know, we have women members and they
- 1:02:12can play on Sunday morning. So it used to be
- 1:02:14that the women couldn't play on Saturdays. because
- 1:02:19of course the men are working and the women are
- 1:02:21not working so they can play during the week.
- 1:02:23But I think that that old concept has gone with
- 1:02:27the wind as well. At our club everybody can play
- 1:02:29on any day except that women do get Tuesday mornings
- 1:02:33and they have team and they have competitions
- 1:02:37and things but at 11 o 'clock it's then open
- 1:02:40to everybody. Yeah I was in membership committee
- 1:02:44for seven years and I felt very very comfortable
- 1:02:46and we just allowed you know hopefully gay couple
- 1:02:49to join. So there is progress. Yeah, there's
- 1:02:53nothing at most clubs that had anything to do
- 1:02:57with couples. They may have a requirement that
- 1:03:01the couple, the people, whether they're two men,
- 1:03:05two women, doesn't matter, are sharing the same
- 1:03:07residence, that they are in a relationship. That's
- 1:03:10the only little complex that we have. Yeah. For
- 1:03:17ours. A lot of clubs are going away, people living
- 1:03:19together. Anybody can come in, yeah. All right.
- 1:03:23There's one issue about the transgender when
- 1:03:28you're talking about the former. Oh, well, I
- 1:03:34don't know. But a very good, you know, athlete
- 1:03:38who's transgender, she does not play in a women's
- 1:03:42tournament. Correct. But that's my choice, I
- 1:03:46believe. Yeah, I think that's just by agreement
- 1:03:48with the club. Yeah, right. Anything else. Come
- 1:03:52up ready. Well, it looks like that's it for questions.
- 1:03:55This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:03:58so much. Judge Klein and Judge Ashman Gers and
- 1:04:02thank you so much to our audience. Have a great
- 1:04:05day. Everybody. Thank you. See you on the links.
- 1:04:08Bye.