Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #25: Consequential Presidential Elections in US History
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:06Today, we're gonna talk about consequential presidential elections in US history.
- 0:12Now every time there is a presidential election, the media, politicians and political
- 0:19observers in general often touted as the biggest store, the most important election for
- 0:24the office yet, the most important one we've ever had in our history.
- 0:28It's somewhat of a cheap way to hype people up and get them to engage with campaigns and news
- 0:35stories and so on.
- 0:36But, sure, each subsequent election is probably the most important one because it's the one
- 0:41that's happening right now or at least at the time.
- 0:46Now every US presidential election is, of course, significant.
- 0:50It's for the highest office in the country and one of the most prominent in the world.
- 0:55But when you look back on history, some presidential elections stand out more than
- 1:00others do.
- 1:01Most impactful ones establish precedents, no pun intended, enact long term policies and
- 1:08programs, reshape government structure and function for years to come, or fundamentally
- 1:14change the political landscape for years years years.
- 1:19And it's not always because of who won.
- 1:21In a few cases, the bigger impact comes from a losing candidate in the election, or at least a
- 1:28pretty monumental change comes from the losing candidate in the election.
- 1:33And that impact can also take many years to fully recognize.
- 1:37You don't necessarily realize it when you're in a thick of things, how impactful something can
- 1:42be.
- 1:43Now there's no objective way to rank the most impactful presidential elections of all time.
- 1:50Historians and political scientists don't even come close to a consensus on that.
- 1:56Today, we're going to talk about some of those presidential elections that you should know
- 2:01about.
- 2:02However, don't treat this list as the only significantly consequential elections we've
- 2:07ever had.
- 2:08We'd be here for weeks weeks to fully cover all those.
- 2:14There isn't enough time to cover all of them.
- 2:16And even before the ones we do cover, we can't exhaust everything.
- 2:20So these are just some of the biggest impacts in those terms I talked about earlier.
- 2:26So let's take a trip into the past to look at presidential elections from long ago and not so
- 2:34long ago.
- 2:35We'll look at the year of the election, how long the winner of the election served as
- 2:41president, the context of the election, and what are some of the most notable long term
- 2:47impacts as a result of that election and some programs that and policies that lasted for many
- 2:54years after that.
- 2:55So let's begin.
- 2:571st up on the list is Thomas Jefferson, more particularly his 1800 election.
- 3:03He served from 1801 to 18 o nine, and his 1800 election is sometimes dubbed the revolution of
- 3:131800.
- 3:14So some context here.
- 3:16John Adams, the second president of the United States, was in office at the time.
- 3:20He was the first and only official federalist federalist president that we had.
- 3:29Technically, George Washington was also a federalist.
- 3:31He tended to side more with them, but he'd never officially called himself 1.
- 3:36And political parties had only just formed a few years before Adams' term had begun.
- 3:44And there was a lot of political differences between John Adams as president and Thomas
- 3:49Jefferson as vice president, and it would get so heated that it would sever their friendship
- 3:54for some time, though they would fortunately reconcile later on in life.
- 3:59You have to remember, though, at the time, presidential elections didn't quite work the
- 4:05way that they do now.
- 4:06The top vote getter would become president, and then the 2nd place vote getter would be vice
- 4:13president.
- 4:14So very it was very likely to have a president as one party and then a vice president as
- 4:21another party.
- 4:22And that's what happened in in John Adams's term as president.
- 4:27He being a federalist, Jefferson being a Democratic Republican.
- 4:33And John Adams was starting to become pretty unpopular.
- 4:36And one of those reasons was the passage of the Alien and Sedition Acts, the latter which
- 4:41greatly curbed criticism of the ability to, quote, unquote, print, utter, or publish any
- 4:49false, scandalous and malicious writing conveniently aimed at Democratic Republicans
- 4:55who were very critical of John Adams and his policies.
- 5:00And so the 2 had gone after each other in 17 96, or they they competed in the presidential
- 5:10election of 17 96, hence why John Adams was president and Thomas Jefferson was vice
- 5:15president.
- 5:15So they rematch in 1800, and this time, Jefferson wins.
- 5:21And it becomes it's called the revolution of 1800 because it was the first time that a
- 5:28transfer of power in the presidency was between people of 2 different parties.
- 5:36So it was a real test there for the still infant nation of the United States to see if
- 5:45Parties could actually transfer power peacefully when it came to the presidency, and
- 5:50it did.
- 5:51John Adams is a federalist, and then it became Thomas Jefferson as a Democratic Republican.
- 5:59So some of the real big long term impacts of Thomas Jefferson's election in 1800, you had
- 6:07one of the biggest things was the Louisiana Purchase, which doubled the size of the country
- 6:12for a paltry $15,000,000.
- 6:16Trying to think of the exact boundaries of the Louisiana Purchase.
- 6:20You hear Louisiana Purchase, you might think, oh, just Louisiana?
- 6:23No.
- 6:24It also was present day Indiana, Ohio, Illinois, Missouri, lots of states, but it
- 6:33doubled the size of the population or, excuse me, of the geographical size of the United
- 6:42States.
- 6:42So it was back then, it was about $15,000,000.
- 6:45It was around $340,000,000 today bought from France, and it was an early test of implied
- 6:52powers of the constitution as the constitution did not specifically mention how to acquire new
- 6:58lands.
- 6:59And this was somewhat ironic given that Thomas Jefferson was and Democratic Republicans were
- 7:07very skeptical of implied powers of the constitution.
- 7:12They were very much, only what the constitution can actually say because they thought implied
- 7:17powers would lead to a federal government overstepping its bows.
- 7:22And this geographic expansion would later on fuel the belief in manifest destiny, which
- 7:27we'll talk about in a little bit.
- 7:29But it's basically the idea that the US was destined by God to stretch coast to coast on
- 7:36the continent.
- 7:38And in terms of political landscape, again, it's the first instance when control of the
- 7:42presidency changed between parties.
- 7:45Election of 1800 inspires the 12th Amendment, the chief provision of which provides for
- 7:51separate elections for president and vice president.
- 7:53So you distinctly vote for president and distinctly vote for vice president instead of
- 7:58being first place as president, 2nd place as vice president.
- 8:02Now today, obviously, they're they're on the same ticket, but that's how we started to get
- 8:08to more of how the presidential election functions today.
- 8:13And because of this election, the federalist party becomes severely weakened at the federal
- 8:19level, and they don't come close to retaking a majority in either the US senate or US house.
- 8:25I think they might have kept the US senate majority for the first couple of years of
- 8:31Thomas Jefferson's, trying to tenure, but in any case, they really don't come close to being
- 8:38a, serious threat to retake power throughout the rest of their existence, and the party
- 8:45eventually folds in the 18 twenties.
- 8:48And the Democratic Republican Party of Jefferson later becomes the only party during
- 8:53the loan period of a one party system in US national politics, and that party is the
- 8:59Democratic Party of today.
- 9:00Obviously, it's gone undergone a lot of changes, but it's still technically the same
- 9:04party of Thomas Jefferson's day.
- 9:07So that does it for Thomas Jefferson.
- 9:10Now let's move on to Andrew Jackson, particularly his election in 18/28, and he
- 9:16served from 18/29 to 18/37.
- 9:20So some context here.
- 9:21This was another case of a presidential rematch because in 18/24, John Quincy Adams and Andrew
- 9:28Jackson and a couple of other candidates went up against each other.
- 9:33And it was a very controversial election because, initially, Andrew Jackson was in the
- 9:38lead with, in terms of the electoral votes.
- 9:41I think he had 99 and John Quincy Adams had 84, but neither one of them was even close to a
- 9:47majority, so it became a contingent election.
- 9:50I had an episode of this podcast on contingent elections, but basically, if nobody wins a
- 9:56majority of the popular vote, then the election gets thrown to the U.
- 10:01S.
- 10:01House.
- 10:03So John Quincy Adams and Andrew Jackson are the top 2 vote getters in 18/24, but in what is
- 10:08termed the corrupt bargain of 18/24.
- 10:13They never admitted that this was actually the case, but 4th place finisher, Henry Clay, who
- 10:19pops up quite often in early American history.
- 10:24He was a speaker of the house at the time, and he used his influence in the US House to push
- 10:31supporting colleagues of his part that were, allied with him toward John Quincy Adams in
- 10:38exchange for John Quincy Adams naming Henry Clay to the secretary of state position.
- 10:44Back then, secretary of state was considered the stepping stone to the presidency or at
- 10:50least a major one.
- 10:53So John Quincy Adams wins that election and.
- 10:58They he's accused of.
- 11:00Of engineering a corrupt bargain with Henry Clay 18/28.
- 11:05They go back at each other again.
- 11:07Jackson flips the script and uses his populist commoner image to propel himself to a decisive
- 11:13victory in a rematch against John Quincy Adams, beat him pretty badly in both the electoral and
- 11:19popular votes.
- 11:21So impacts of Andrew Jackson's election, several of his policies and programs.
- 11:29One big thing from him is he really tested the separation of powers.
- 11:34He defied the Supreme Court following the I'm hoping I'm saying this right.
- 11:39Worchester versus Georgia verdict in 18 32.
- 11:44So at the time, Georgia had a state law that that said that they could forcibly move
- 11:51Cherokee Nation members from the lands that they were on if they were within that part of
- 11:58the land that Georgia claimed was within Georgia's jurisdiction.
- 12:04But the Supreme Court ruled that the Cherokee nation on lands that Georgia claimed were a
- 12:08sovereign nation, and thus Georgia state laws to try to forcibly move them were
- 12:14unconstitutional because the US had already had several treaties with the Cherokees, which the
- 12:20fact that they had treaties with them inherently acknowledged that the Cherokees had
- 12:24sovereignty.
- 12:25And so Georgia as a state could not actually move them.
- 12:29But Andrew Jackson, as his, anti native sentiment would dictate, refused to enforce
- 12:39that SCOTUS decision, and so he allowed Georgia to force the Cherokees to relocate or fall
- 12:46under Georgia jurisdiction if they didn't move.
- 12:50And although this was after Jackson led or left office, this would eventually lead to the Trail
- 12:56of Tears in, I believe it's 1838, where Native Americans were forcibly moved westward.
- 13:04Now when it comes to political landscape, that was where Andrew Jackson's impact was probably
- 13:10most felt.
- 13:111st populist to be elected president, so kind of set a tone, I guess you could say, for
- 13:19future populist presidential candidates.
- 13:23Early test of separation of powers again because of that Worcester versus Georgia
- 13:28verdict.
- 13:29Judiciary depends on the other two branches of government for its rulings, but Jackson
- 13:35dismissed the SCOTUS ruling, decided he was not gonna enforce it.
- 13:40And that kinda harkens back to what Alexander Hamilton talked about in Federalist Paper
- 13:45number 78, which basically said the judiciary is inherently the weakest branch of government
- 13:52because it doesn't have any actual power to enforce its laws.
- 13:58Congress legislative branch rights laws, executive branch executes and forces laws.
- 14:04Judiciary, the judiciary just interprets laws, and they can't really actually do anything to
- 14:10make sure it's being upheld on their own.
- 14:15He also shaped the Democratic Party in his image for years to come.
- 14:19In fact, he was so polarizing that the Whig Party formed in response to his policies, and
- 14:27it was a collection of disparate sectional interests that really didn't have, they didn't
- 14:34really have a whole lot in common, but They were all united in hating Andrew Jackson.
- 14:44But while within only a couple of decades, they would dissolve and their their the vacuum that
- 14:50was created from the wake party's dissolution would lead to the formation of the Republican
- 14:55Party.
- 14:56And he's often considered the first example of a president truly establishing the power of a
- 15:03presidency.
- 15:04The presidency took on a much greater role in domestic and foreign affairs during his term.
- 15:10He also vetoed more bills than his predecessors altogether.
- 15:15I believe he had 12 in to enter over the course of his total, years in office as president, and
- 15:24he inaugurated the spoils system and whereby he replaced government officials on partisan
- 15:32grounds quite often, and that spoils system would last for decades until civil service
- 15:38reform, which we'll also talk about in, a little bit.
- 15:42But he also reshuffled his cabinet frequently if they dissatisfied him in some way.
- 15:49So real example of a president really exerting its power or influence, whether it was within
- 15:59the bounds of what the constitution said.
- 16:02Obviously, that was a big debate at the time and still a debate for some historians even
- 16:09today.
- 16:10Now we shift from Andrew Jackson to not too many years after he left office to James Polk.
- 16:18He was a one term president.
- 16:19He won in 1844, served from 18/45 to 18/49.
- 16:25So some context here.
- 16:27Many Americans had expansion fever.
- 16:30They wanted to expand westward back to that idea I brought up earlier of manifest destiny,
- 16:36which was the idea that the US was ordained by God to stretch coast to coast on the continent.
- 16:43And in large part because of James Polk's support of westward expansion, which other
- 16:49major presidential candidates didn't necessarily support, he practically came out of
- 16:56nowhere to win his party's nomination.
- 16:58Now back then, we did not have the primary system where voters actually chose through
- 17:03primaries who was going to be the democratic nominee, the Republican nominee, these third
- 17:09party nominees.
- 17:11Back then, the parties themselves actually chose their nominees.
- 17:17And because of his support of westward expansion, he jumped over several other
- 17:24candidates and is con often considered the 1st dog horse candidate to actually become
- 17:29president.
- 17:30So in terms of impact, going back to that westward expansion, areas of California, New
- 17:37Mexico, Texas, Oregon, and James Polk's eyes and in the eyes of many other people thought
- 17:43that they should belong to the US.
- 17:44Now the attempts at Oregon risked war with Britain, but the two countries eventually
- 17:50agreed to settle along the 49th parallel, in terms of latitude, except for the southern tip
- 17:57of Vancouver Island.
- 17:59So that got kind of, taken out of the way somewhat early on.
- 18:05But because of the desire to expansion westward, the Mexican American war was waged,
- 18:12in large part because Mexico was angered at Texas seceding, becoming their own country for
- 18:20only about 8 or 9 years.
- 18:22And then later on, Texas wanted to be annexed into the US, and northern interests were
- 18:28initially against adding Texas because it supported slavery.
- 18:33And becoming a southern state, it would continue to support slavery.
- 18:39The war lasts from 1846 to 1848.
- 18:42The US wins an incisive victory and in the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, Mexico recognized
- 18:48Texas as part of the US and sold California and the rest of its territory north of the Rio
- 18:54Grande for $15,000,000 plus assumption of certain damage claims.
- 19:01Not as big an expansion as the Louisiana purchase was, but still a considerable amount,
- 19:07something like 525,000 square miles.
- 19:11And I think the Louisiana purchase was something like 808 or something along those
- 19:16lines.
- 19:16But it was almost the rest of the contiguous United States of today, save for the Gadsden
- 19:23purchase, which was a small sliver of Arizona and a little bit of New Mexico in the 18
- 19:29fifties.
- 19:29But just about the rest of what we see of the contiguous US today Was part of that Mexican
- 19:37session.
- 19:39And then in terms of political landscape, he again, he was the first example of a dark horse
- 19:44candidate eventually winning the election.
- 19:47The Mexican session in Texas annexation added another huge portion of land that would become
- 19:52several states like California, Nevada, or Nevada, depending on who you ask, Utah, New
- 19:58Mexico, Arizona, and then parts of several other states like Colorado.
- 20:03And then unfortunately further fueling the slavery debate because giant swath of land that
- 20:09Texas was gave a lot more power to slaveholders and slaveholding supporters in Congress.
- 20:15And debate over slavery raged in other states that were added by the new land as well,
- 20:21including in California.
- 20:23And so it added fuel to the fire that would eventually become the civil war, which really
- 20:29was going to be inevitable anyways.
- 20:33But speaking of that Civil War, we now move on to Abraham Lincoln, often nicknamed the great
- 20:40emancipator.
- 20:41So his election in 18/60, and he served from 18/61 to 18/65.
- 20:46He did win a second term but was assassinated shortly into that term.
- 20:52So some context here.
- 20:53Again, North and South's tensions were building up more and more over over multiple issues, and
- 21:00chief among them was slavery.
- 21:03Presidents before Lincoln had either only temporarily ceased increases in hostility or
- 21:09had contributed to its fomentation.
- 21:12For example, James Buchanan, who a lot of historians consider the worst or at least one
- 21:18of the worst presidents we have ever had, he supported what was called the Lecompton
- 21:22Constitution.
- 21:22Lecompton is a town in Kansas, and that that constitution would have allowed slavery in pre
- 21:29statehood Kansas.
- 21:31Now Kansas voters voted against the Lecompton constitution and slavery in our referendum, and
- 21:38fellow democrats or James Buchanan's fellow Democrat and a US senator, Stephen Douglas,
- 21:44called for respecting popular sovereignty, although Stephen Douglas was still a racist.
- 21:49He just believed that whatever the people voted for, that that should be what goes.
- 21:56And this friction between James Buchanan supporting the Lecompton Constitution and
- 22:01Stephen Douglas opposing the Lecompton Constitution only really though because Kansas
- 22:06voters had voted against it, It fractured the Democratic party, and it helped lead to the
- 22:11election of Republican Abraham Lincoln, who was a former Whig.
- 22:17And the election of Abraham Lincoln was really the final straw for these seceding southern
- 22:23states, and the Civil War begins in 18/61.
- 22:27So impact probably the most well known impact that he had was the Emancipation Proclamation,
- 22:34which ruled that slavery in the southern states was illegal.
- 22:39Technically, it was not what ultimately ended slavery because it didn't really have the legal
- 22:47teeth to actually end slavery.
- 22:50That was the 13th amendment, which actually outlawed slavery and was.
- 22:57Ratified, I believe, a little bit after Abraham Lincoln's assassination, but he also oversaw
- 23:04the start of the reconstruction era, which was basically rebuilding the south following the
- 23:09Civil War.
- 23:10More on that in a little bit.
- 23:11And he also authorized a major expansion of the US military to combat the Confederacy.
- 23:20And in terms of political landscape, he really galvanized the North during the Civil War and
- 23:25post Civil War years, and that North and South divide would last still long after the Civil
- 23:31War.
- 23:31And he really cemented Republican power that continued through Reconstruction.
- 23:38And in terms of general history, he was also the 1st assassinated US president, not the 1st
- 23:42to die in office, but he was the first one that was assassinated, that was murdered.
- 23:46And he is also one of, if not the most iconic presidents in US history.
- 23:52I mean, he's on he's one of the 4 that's on Mount Rushmore.
- 23:56Doesn't get much more iconic than that.
- 23:58Now we move on to Rutherford b Hayes, was elected in 18/76, served from 18/77 to 18/81.
- 24:09So context here, again, Reconstruction follows the Civil War with the north occupying the
- 24:16south and make sure making sure that they abide by post war terms.
- 24:21Reconstruction of course was highly unpopular in the south, but for the most part, they went
- 24:27along with it because they kind of had to.
- 24:30But post civil war, tensions were rising as Democrats were starting to gain traction again
- 24:35in the South, which was a stronghold for them before that and became a stronghold for them
- 24:41for many, many years following Reconstruction.
- 24:45The 18/76 election itself was very controversial, though, because it had 2
- 24:51different counts, of votes for the presidency.
- 24:57And conveniently, one count was Democratic and one count was Republican, and both sides
- 25:03claimed that they had won the presidency.
- 25:06It was Democrat Samuel J.
- 25:08Tilden versus Republican Rutherford B.
- 25:10Hayes.
- 25:11And so to resolve the issue, ultimately, Democrats agreed to declare Hayes the winner,
- 25:17but Republicans agreed to end Reconstruction.
- 25:21This became the compromise of 1877.
- 25:26So not so much because of Hayes himself, but because of the election itself, the end of
- 25:32reconstruction as part of the compromise of 1877.
- 25:37And with the and with that, the political landscape changes dramatically The Democratic
- 25:42Party began begins reclaiming their strongholds in the South.
- 25:46They were starting to already do that, but then they really became that force that they used to
- 25:50be and would continue to be for many decades afterwards.
- 25:55Southern states then get to institute Jim Crow laws to suppress freedoms of black people while
- 26:02technically not making them slaves.
- 26:04The basic idea was to recreate the conditions of slavery without actually making them slaves
- 26:11because that was now illegal.
- 26:14So North coming out of the South didn't have the ability to enforce such laws against the
- 26:22South.
- 26:23So the South basically got to act with impunity against racial minorities.
- 26:28But Rutherford b Hayes was also an advocate of civil service reform.
- 26:34Go back to that spoil system we talked about with Andrew Jackson.
- 26:38Civil service reform appointments are based on past performance in government and civil
- 26:44service as opposed to that dominant patronage system, which was born out of that spoil
- 26:49system.
- 26:49And this led to a schism in the Republican party between stalwarts that opposed civil
- 26:55service reform and the half breeds as stalwarts derisively called them that supported it.
- 27:02So that schism in the Republican party really, they actually still won the 18/81 election, but
- 27:13later on, Democrat Grover Cleveland would become president.
- 27:17But the the movement toward civil service reform picked up steam not long after Hayes'
- 27:22presidency, and so you really saw civil service reform take shape and and and sort of set the,
- 27:29I guess you could say, tone for civil service laws much further down the road.
- 27:36Now let's fast forward a couple more decades to the election of William McKinley in 18 96.
- 27:42He served from 18 97 to 19 o 1.
- 27:45He would win a second term, but, like, Abraham Lincoln would be assassinated shortly into that
- 27:51second term.
- 27:51But back to the 18 96 election.
- 27:55At the time, US has mired in a severe economic downturn, one of the worst that it's had in its
- 28:01history from the panic of 18 93 that saw gold reserves plummet because the US was on the gold
- 28:07standard at the time and runs on banks to withdraw money, which made things worse.
- 28:14Whether right or wrong, then president Grover Cleveland and the Democratic Party were blamed
- 28:19for the economic issues, And that led his party to dump him and pick William Jennings, Brian
- 28:26for his nominee in 18 96.
- 28:29Again, at the time, presidential candidates were not picked through primaries.
- 28:34But before the 18 96 election, the 8 in 18 94, republicans had made enormous gains.
- 28:41They gained a 130 seats in the US house, and democrats lost a 125.
- 28:47In the US Senate, Republicans have gained 4 seats, and Democrats have lost 4 seats.
- 28:53In terms of impact of the election, a lot of it actually came from the losing candidate,
- 28:57William Jennings Bryan, in terms of campaigning.
- 29:01William Jennings Bryan had traveled around the country to campaign and traveled extensively.
- 29:06That was basically unheard of then.
- 29:08McKinley took the traditional route of campaigning from his front porch while others
- 29:13traveled around the country on his behalf.
- 29:16Today, everybody travels all around the country that's trying to run for president, or at least
- 29:21serious candidates travel around the country to run for president and to campaign for
- 29:26themselves.
- 29:27So it's also an early instance of that rural and urban divide that you still see today,
- 29:34rural voters being much more on William Jennings Bryan's side, particularly farmers.
- 29:41Urban divide was more with William McKinley, in terms of other terms of political landscape,
- 29:48changes.
- 29:49It was the it was an early but not earliest instance of populism in America from losing
- 29:56candidate William Jennings Bryan.
- 29:57Remember, Andrew Jackson was also, populist, but populism and its anti elite sentiment had a
- 30:05major influence on progressive era reforms in the early 20th century.
- 30:10And it really cemented an era of Republican dominance.
- 30:14The the Mick McKinley's election 18 96 cemented an era of Republican dominance that started
- 30:20with sweeping Republican gains in 18 94.
- 30:24Now 18 96, they actually lost some seats.
- 30:26But from 18 96 to 1928, Republicans won 7 of 9 presidential elections.
- 30:33And from 18 94 to 1928, they either won or kept the US house majority in 14 of 18 elections and
- 30:42won or kept the US senate majority in 15 of 18 elections.
- 30:47So that era of republican dominance began at very end of 19th century and was there for,
- 30:59they continued to be dominant for a lot of the beginning of 20th century.
- 31:05That was until the next president on our list, Franklin d Roosevelt or FDR for short.
- 31:12His first election was 1932, and he served from 1933 to 1945.
- 31:18So context here.
- 31:21With the exception of most of Woodrow Wilson's presidency, Republicans had been dominating
- 31:26both the presidency and control of Congress, and the roaring twenties had seen considerable
- 31:34economic growth, some of the biggest economic growth that the country had experienced up to
- 31:38that point.
- 31:39But this came crashing down with the Great Depression starting in 1929.
- 31:45And the throes of the Great Depression then and this was caused by a lot of factors, mostly the
- 31:51stock market crash of 1929, Black Tuesday gets covered, or it kind of gets, the way it's
- 32:00covered.
- 32:01A lot of times it's considered like the cause of the Great Depression.
- 32:05But I mean, it was a big reason, but there was also overproduction of products, bank failures,
- 32:12high income inequality, reciprocal tariffs between the US and other countries that really
- 32:18did not work out for the US at all or these other countries.
- 32:23But whether right or wrong.
- 32:26Just like Americans had blamed Grover Cleveland and the Democratic Party for the issues in the
- 32:3318 nineties, in the early 18 nineties, they also blamed Herbert Hoover and congressional
- 32:39Republicans for the economic plummet at the end of the 19 twenties going into the 19 thirties.
- 32:46And so they punish them in the 1930 and 1932 elections at the ballot box.
- 32:52In 1932, Democrats gained 97 seats in the US House, and Republicans lose a 101 seats there.
- 33:00And in the US Senate, Democrats gained 12 seats from Republicans.
- 33:05So just like with 1894 and through throughout when it was Republicans dominating, this
- 33:14ushered in an era of Democratic dominance.
- 33:16So impact of FDR's election in 1932 and several more elections afterward, but particularly with
- 33:26the 19 32 election, policies and programs.
- 33:30These programs were based on what's called Keynesian Economics, and the basic idea behind
- 33:36Keynesian Economics is that government intervention and spending stimulates demand,
- 33:40and that's what stabilizes the economy.
- 33:43Now, whether it worked and whether it helps the country get out of the Great Depression, that's
- 33:49for you to decide not getting into that.
- 33:52But many of these New Deal programs back there, his his whole collection of programs was called
- 33:59the New Deal.
- 34:00Many of his New Deal programs installed back then are still in existence.
- 34:05There's Social Security.
- 34:06There's the Securities and Exchange Commission, which or SEC for short, and that's meant to
- 34:11enforce laws against market manipulation.
- 34:14The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, FDIC, They insure banks' deposits and examines
- 34:21financial institutions for soundness of their finances.
- 34:25And then, of course, he was the chief executive throughout all of World War 2.
- 34:29We didn't enter World War 2 immediately.
- 34:32That was not until 1941 following Pearl Harbor, and he was one of the guys who really led the
- 34:41charge for the founding of the United Nations.
- 34:44Woodrow Wilson, when he was in office, he tried to bring the US into what was called the League
- 34:50of Nations, and congressional Republicans were against that.
- 34:54So we did not enter the League of Nations, and the League of Nations did not last for very
- 34:59long.
- 34:59But United Nations, we still have today, and FDR was a real big reason why we why the United
- 35:06Nations formed and why we entered the United Nations.
- 35:10And in terms of political landscape, FDR is still held up as a liberal icon today.
- 35:17If you're if you're a liberal, he's the greatest thing ever since sliced bread.
- 35:21If you're a conservative, you think that he's one of the worst people to walk the face of the
- 35:26earth.
- 35:26Obviously, slight exaggerations, but still a liberal icon today, ushered in that era of
- 35:33Democratic dominance for many, many years to come.
- 35:37From the 1932 to the 1992 elections, Democrats gained or held the US house majority in 29 of
- 35:4531 elections.
- 35:47And in that same span, they gained or held the US mid senate majority in 26 of 31 elections.
- 35:55And there was also a point where there was 40, yes, 40 years straight where Democrats held the
- 36:03US House majority.
- 36:05And Keynesian economics, while the original form isn't really in existence anymore, it
- 36:12still has greatly influenced more liberal economists such as Neo Keynesians who have
- 36:16taken some of the Keynesian economic philosophy and applied it to their own philosophy just
- 36:26with some more tweaks to it.
- 36:29Next up on the list is Lyndon b Johnson, LBJ for short.
- 36:34His election was 1964, but he had actually served from 1963 to 1969.
- 36:42Context here, John f Kennedy was assassinated in 1963.
- 36:46LBJ takes over the presidency, and he had had a quite high approval rating following his
- 36:53ascension to the presidency.
- 36:57And then 1964, he runs again or or well, not runs again, but he he runs in 1964 to try to
- 37:04stay in office.
- 37:06Helping LBJ's campaign besides the approval rating following his takeover after JFK's
- 37:12assassination was that there was a schism within the Republican Party.
- 37:16There was an insurgent campaign by U.
- 37:19S.
- 37:20Senator Barry Goldwater of Arizona, and that really split the ranks of the party between
- 37:26moderates and the more conservative wing, because Barry Goldwater was a very conservative
- 37:30guy.
- 37:30And that conservative ethos of his was put front and center in the campaign, and he would
- 37:37eventually actually win the party nomination.
- 37:40And LBJ was successful in painting Goldwater as an extremist.
- 37:46Now whether that's right or wrong to call him, that is not the point.
- 37:50That's that's for you to decide.
- 37:51But.
- 37:53Barry Goldwater also didn't do himself much of favor in that regard, kind of actually did say
- 37:58that he I forget extreme extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice, I believe, was
- 38:05the quote by him.
- 38:07So but, again, that's that's for you to decide.
- 38:11In terms of impact from the 1964 election, in terms of campaigning, really opened a new front
- 38:19for campaign ads because you saw what was called it's it's it's called it's nicknamed the
- 38:25Daisy ad, but it's officially called Peace Little Girl.
- 38:29It only appeared once on TV, but you it shows a an unnamed little girl.
- 38:34She's plucking a daisies petals, and suddenly an atomic bomb hits, which didn't actually name
- 38:42Goldwater by name, but it implied that a vote for Goldwater was a vote for nuclear war.
- 38:49And was arguably the biggest catalyst for ushering in a new era in negative political
- 38:55advertising that centered on voters' fears and other visceral emotions That you still see a
- 39:02lot of today.
- 39:04Policies and programs, his programs were collectively called the Great Society, and that
- 39:09included the formation of Medicare and Medicaid, which we still have today.
- 39:15The Voter Rights Act of 1965, which enforced the 15th Amendment, and that was what granted
- 39:21the right to vote to racial minorities.
- 39:23And it outlawed literacy tests, which were one of the ways that southern states had.
- 39:30We're able to prevent black people from voting, try to say, well, you have to have a certain
- 39:35level of literacy to be able to vote.
- 39:39And also during his tenure was an escalation of the Vietnam War, which would still continue for
- 39:46several years after LBJ left office, especially with the Tet offensive in 1968, which was a
- 39:53surprise attack by the North Vietnamese against the US and the South Vietnamese military
- 40:01forces.
- 40:02In terms of political landscape, the impacts arguably comes more from Barry Goldwater, and
- 40:09I've mentioned this in a couple of other podcast episodes.
- 40:12He arguably shaped the political landscape more than Lyndon Johnson did.
- 40:18Goldwater, again, he put that conservative philosophy of his front and center, and this
- 40:24sort of began.
- 40:25You didn't really didn't really see it until decades down the road when you can actually
- 40:29look back at it.
- 40:30What is sometimes called the great sorting out, and that was the the trend where conservatives
- 40:39more and more moved towards the Republican Party, and Liberals moved more and more toward
- 40:43the Democratic Party.
- 40:44At the time, there's a lot more ideological difference within the parties.
- 40:51There were Liberals and moderates, and even some conservatives in the Democratic Party.
- 40:56There are moderates, liberals, and conservatives in the Republican Party, and
- 41:00that's still the case today, but a lot less.
- 41:02There's a lot more conservatives that make up the Republican Party and a lot more liberals
- 41:08that make up the Democratic Party, and you can still see the effects of this sorting out even
- 41:13today.
- 41:14But you especially saw it really start to come to fruition right around in the in the nineties
- 41:20and and 2 thousands.
- 41:23So one of the most influential candidates in presidential election history was actually one
- 41:32who lost his election.
- 41:34And for our last example, before we start to wrap things up, is Ronald Reagan in 1980, and
- 41:43he served from 1981 to 1989.
- 41:47Context here.
- 41:47This was towards the end of Jimmy Carter's one term, and the economy had taken a dip.
- 41:52There is a lot of what was called stagflation, which was high unemployment and high inflation
- 41:57at the same time.
- 41:57Usually, you get one or the other.
- 42:00Ronald Reagan, who had actually been a liberal early on in his life and at least and said that
- 42:05he voted for FDR for all four times that FDR had run for president.
- 42:12He had been shifting towards conservatism some years before, and then he won a landslide
- 42:19victory in 1980 against Jimmy Carter.
- 42:23And in that buildup to Ronald Reagan's election, the religious rights, which was a
- 42:29collection, basically a collection of organizations such as the moral majority that
- 42:34were both conservative and, infuse their politics with their religious faith, They
- 42:42increased their influence and power and they helped to fuel Reagan's victories in the 1980s.
- 42:48So some of the impacts that Ronald Reagan had so similar to how FDR and Keynesian economics
- 42:55had a major impact on 1930s.
- 42:59What was often called Reaganomics, sometimes derisively, was based largely on supply side
- 43:05economics, and that has influenced economic conservatism for decades now.
- 43:11The idea there is that if you cut taxes on the wealthy, it actually increases tax revenue
- 43:16because it stimulates the economy.
- 43:18And through government expansion, there is more activity to tax.
- 43:22And so it actually focuses on increasing the goods and services available, whereas for
- 43:27Keynesian economics, it was much more on the demand side.
- 43:30Now, again, just like with Keynesian economics, whether supply side economics works, that's for
- 43:35you to decide.
- 43:36Not getting into that.
- 43:38You also saw an increase in military spending during Ronald Reagan's tenure, some of which
- 43:43still exists today, and he also signed the Intermediate Nuclear Force or INF Treaty with
- 43:50Mikhail Gorbachev, who was the head of the Soviet Union in its in the Soviet Union's
- 43:56waning days.
- 43:58And in terms of political landscape, just like with FDR, except on the other side of the
- 44:03aisle, Ronald Reagan is held up as a conservative icon today.
- 44:07So if you're a conservative, Ronald Reagan's probably the greatest thing since sliced bread
- 44:11if you're a liberal.
- 44:12Ronald Reagan is one of the worst presidents we've ever had.
- 44:15Again, that's for you to decide.
- 44:18But supply side economics has influenced economic conservatism for decades now and still
- 44:24has some influence.
- 44:26And also Ronald Reagan's elections in the 19 eighties were a prelude to the gains that
- 44:31Republicans would make in the 19 nineties, particularly in the 1994 election when, for the
- 44:37first time in decades, that the Republican Party had won a majority of the US House.
- 44:47So that does it for the previous consequential elections that we've had in US history.
- 44:54Again, not the only consequential ones, of course, but just some of the really big ones to
- 44:59really cover.
- 44:59Now let's bring it to the present day.
- 45:02Donald Trump.
- 45:04Are his elections among the most consequential we've had?
- 45:08Now it's easy to say whenever you're in the middle of something.
- 45:12It's easy to say that it's the most important thing that's going on ever because you're in
- 45:16the midst of it.
- 45:17So you're going to say.
- 45:19Something might be the worst thing ever or the best thing ever nor.
- 45:23Whatever's going on.
- 45:24It's the most important thing because you're in the middle of it and you're in the present.
- 45:29But.
- 45:31It is also hard to say in terms of historical significance, whether it's going to be one of
- 45:38the most consequential ever.
- 45:39But nonetheless, let's compare what Donald Trump has done so far to previous presidents to
- 45:45see how he could potentially be one of the most consequential presidents that we've ever had.
- 45:52Whether we agree with his policies or not, that's not the point.
- 45:55It's about just how wide ranging his his, impacts are gonna be.
- 46:03We can look at, for example, possible geographic expansion talking about buying
- 46:09Greenland from Denmark.
- 46:10We'll think back to the Louisiana purchase by Thomas Jefferson or the Mexican session for
- 46:18James Polk.
- 46:20Could an expansion into Greenland or other places be Donald Trump's impact similar to
- 46:31those presidents from before with Greenland in particular?
- 46:35Maybe we'll see something similar to what Thomas Jefferson and James Polk did.
- 46:42Will he have a particular impact on economic philosophy similar to FDR did with Keynesian
- 46:48economics or Ronald Reagan with supply side economics?
- 46:53Have has Donald Trump's election?
- 46:57Did his elections in 2016 2024 have an impact on the political landscape akin to Andrew
- 47:07Jackson indirectly leading to the creation of the Whig Party because the Whig Party was made
- 47:13of people just hated Andrew Jackson and his policies or Barry Goldwater in his 1964 lost.
- 47:20Will Donald Trump and his victories have a similar impact on the political landscape?
- 47:26Some people say that has already happened, but we'll have to see if his effects on where voter
- 47:35demographics have divided to see if they're long lasting.
- 47:39It's easy to say that, you know, he's changed the makeup of the Democratic or Republican
- 47:44parties now, but we'll have to see if it's just because of him or if it's going to be longer
- 47:50lasting for the parties such as the white non college educated voters moving towards them?
- 47:57Is it going to continue to stay that way?
- 47:59Can't really say for certain.
- 48:01And then establishing the power of the presidency, is it going to be something similar
- 48:05to what Andrew Jackson did?
- 48:08Donald Trump in his 2nd term has already been very active in his 1st couple of weeks with
- 48:13executive orders and some debate as to whether he has overstepped his bounds, but And not
- 48:20saying he has already hasn't just that that is a debate.
- 48:24And so will he have a similar impact on the powers of the presidency similar to a president
- 48:31like Andrew Jackson?
- 48:34In any case, we'll again have to wait years down the road to see how long term some of
- 48:40Donald Trump's impacts are.
- 48:44We can't say for certain if those impacts are Going to be around for decades to come, but
- 48:51they could be.
- 48:53But anyways, that's going to do it for today's podcast episode since this one was a bit
- 48:57longer.
- 48:57We'll wrap things up here now.
- 49:00So once again, as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 49:04Please like comment, subscribe, share the podcast with your networks, your friends,
- 49:10anybody you know, my book.
- 49:14I have the links in the show notes, my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my book, why
- 49:20independence rarely win elections and how they can become more competitive on Amazon and ebook
- 49:25and paperback format.
- 49:27And, any other links that, you need to know are gonna be in the show notes as well.
- 49:35So, anyways, thank you so much for listening.
- 49:37Until next time.
- 49:39Take care.