Latest / Buffalo Bred / Real or Not Real: The Bills After 2 Games
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Buffalo Bread podcast. I
- 0:02am your host, Dan Roberts, here to celebrate
- 0:04with you, Bills Mafia, our 2 -0 Buffalo Bills,
- 0:08headed into a mini -buy where they're set to
- 0:10take on the Los Angeles Chargers at the conclusion
- 0:13of week three of the NFL season. The Joe Brady
- 0:16era off to a good start. The new Highmark era
- 0:19off to a good start. And year 30 of Joshua Patrick
- 0:23Allen here in season nine, also off to a really
- 0:26good start as well. But folks, It's hard to crown
- 0:29a Super Bowl champion in September. The Bills
- 0:32have been here before, off to a hot start. Josh
- 0:36Allen looking like there is not a team he cannot
- 0:38conquer, a defense he cannot overcome, regardless
- 0:41of talent levels of this Buffalo Bills roster.
- 0:45September, folks, can be a time for panic. It
- 0:49can be a time for great excitement, when in reality...
- 0:52With about 16 weeks of NFL football left to play,
- 0:56things have a better shot of regressing a little
- 0:58bit more towards the average. Now, don't get
- 1:00me wrong. I'm stoked for these bills and where
- 1:02they are right now. But again, we've been here
- 1:05before. We've had those good September vibes.
- 1:08We've had that great four or five week start.
- 1:10Only see the Bills inexplicably lose to teams
- 1:13that they shouldn't be losing to. Do the Miami
- 1:16Dolphins of 2025 ring a bell? Do the early season
- 1:19struggles last year against New Orleans Saints
- 1:22ring a bell to anybody? Listen, I'm as excited
- 1:24as anybody about where these Bills are, and I've
- 1:26been thoroughly enjoying the brand of football,
- 1:29particularly on the offensive side, that this
- 1:31Buffalo squad is rolling out. But tougher tests
- 1:34are still to come. So it's worth doing a little
- 1:36bit of a heat check here for the Buffalo Bills
- 1:38to determine what is real two weeks in for the
- 1:41squad and maybe what is not real. Two games after
- 1:45all is not a trend. So tonight we're going to
- 1:48do something a little bit different before we
- 1:50get into our pregame later on in the week for
- 1:53the Los Angeles Chargers. We're going to play
- 1:55a little game. We're going to play real or not
- 1:57real. So two games in isn't enough to know exactly
- 2:01what the Buffalo Bills are. But it is enough
- 2:04to start asking whether or not some of the things
- 2:06we're seeing are completely random, early season
- 2:09September noise, maybe catching good teams at
- 2:12a bad time early on in the season, or whether
- 2:15or not we're actually looking at changes that
- 2:17matter. And listen, this is important because
- 2:19this has been an off season of change for the
- 2:21Buffalo Bills. New stadium, new head coach. Kind
- 2:26of the same offensive philosophy, but not really
- 2:28as we'll get into here in a little bit So I'm
- 2:32gonna tee up three topics for you We're gonna
- 2:34decide if they're real or not real first the
- 2:37Buffalo Bills defensive front Notably, in 2025,
- 2:41the Buffalo Bills struggled to get standard four
- 2:44-man pass rush pass pressure against opposing
- 2:46QBs. And when they did, they failed to bring
- 2:49the opposing QB down to finish the sack. JJ and
- 2:52I have argued for years what matters more, pressure
- 2:54or sacks? And this Buffalo Bill squad is good
- 2:58at getting one but not the other. Is this Buffalo
- 3:01front though, led by Greg Russo, Dion Walker,
- 3:05and Bradley Chubb? Is this truly a wrecking crew
- 3:07for the Buffalo Bills, and is it real? Second,
- 3:11and while it feels like a little bit past the
- 3:14time we should be talking about Sean McDermott,
- 3:16two weeks of this new Joe Brady offense has me
- 3:19wondering. Was the Shawn McDermott ceiling real
- 3:23and I'm not talking about getting over the hump
- 3:25and getting to the Super Bowl I'm talking about
- 3:27a lot of the compression artificial constraints
- 3:30that the Buffalo Bills seem to be operating with
- 3:33on the offensive side of the ball Allen's depth
- 3:36of target, average air yards per throw between
- 3:382025 and 2026 is a completely different beast.
- 3:42And it makes you wonder if some of the rumblings
- 3:44we heard out of Buffalo Bill's training camp
- 3:46about McDermott, maybe artificially trying to
- 3:50have a conservative offense to cover up for this
- 3:52defense was in fact real or not. But more importantly,
- 3:56are we seeing the ceiling removed from what Josh
- 3:59Allen can be? And then finally, third, Christian
- 4:03Benford. He has been one of the most reliable
- 4:06players on the Buffalo Bills, and I have gone
- 4:08on record saying I think he's maybe the best
- 4:10all around football player on the defensive side
- 4:13of the ball for the Buffalo Bills and has been.
- 4:16But with Jim Leonard's new new defense, asking
- 4:19him to play a lot more man coverage than he is
- 4:21used to. Do the Buffalo Bills suddenly have a
- 4:24Christian Benford problem two weeks into the
- 4:26season? That's it, folks. Let's just dive right
- 4:29into it and let's talk about the Buffalo Bills
- 4:31lead pass rush. Verdict on this real or not real
- 4:35do the Buffalo Bills finally? have an elite pass
- 4:38rush. And I'm gonna, got a little bit of Chris
- 4:41Collins worth there. Do they finally have an
- 4:43elite pass rush? And I'm gonna say not real,
- 4:46but not yet. And it sure is trending in the right
- 4:48direction. And listen, I get it. Greg Rousseau
- 4:51looks like Bruce Smith out there. He's got four
- 4:54sacks early on in the season. His pressure rate
- 4:57through the roof. And this is a guy whom we know
- 4:59was always able to get pressure. The question
- 5:02with Rousseau is how could he finish those pressures?
- 5:05Add to that, that he's also forced three fumbles
- 5:08this season, including the game closer against
- 5:10the Houston Texans in week one. All of a sudden,
- 5:14Greg Rousseau is looking like the guy we thought
- 5:17he would be. Brandon Thorne, Trench Warfare.
- 5:19He rolls out this composite kind of aggregate
- 5:22score called True Pressure Rate. And when you
- 5:25look at the True Pressure Rate, the TPR for Greg
- 5:28Rousseau through two weeks, his work along the
- 5:31defensive line seems even crazier. And it would
- 5:34be easy for us to rush this early in the season
- 5:37into thinking that Jim Leonard's scheme is all
- 5:40of a sudden unlocked. the full Rousseau. So through
- 5:43two weeks, Thorne has Rousseau with 12 non sack
- 5:47pressures, 12 so far. Now 11 of those were graded
- 5:51as high quality pressures and only one was considered
- 5:54a low quality pressure. So he's got a true pressure
- 5:57rate, according to Thorne, about 11 .5. It's
- 5:59the highest number by a good three or four other
- 6:03total pressures for any other player in the league.
- 6:06And he's not the only one popping up on this
- 6:08list. Bradley Chubb is in the top 20. and Deon
- 6:11Walker on the interior defensive line also in
- 6:14the top 25. I think he was in the top 12 when
- 6:17I looked. So if you're asking me right now is
- 6:20Gregor so playing awesome football the answer
- 6:22is absolutely unquestionably yes and Thorne has
- 6:25one of the best methodologies in the business
- 6:28and trying to separate pressures that are created.
- 6:32By the defender versus crusher paraded by the
- 6:35scheme versus quarterback movement free runners
- 6:38the whole nine this year He's just winning one
- 6:41-on -one But here is where I tend to hit the
- 6:44brakes a little bit because the opponent that
- 6:46you play matters and against Detroit Rousseau
- 6:48had eight pressures alone according to Thorne
- 6:51and a sack Eight of those pressure wins were
- 6:54coming up against a backup in Larry Morem. Now
- 6:57that's domination to dominate a dude and an opposing
- 7:00NFL player with one single move, one motion.
- 7:04That being said, though, all across the Detroit
- 7:06line, we know they were playing backups. They
- 7:08had three backups in for injured starters on
- 7:11that short week against the Bills. And Houston,
- 7:13as we know, while they have brought in a veteran
- 7:16squad with the exception of Keelan Rutledge,
- 7:18they're working the kinks out with yet another
- 7:21revamp along. offensive line. So here's the problem
- 7:24I have with declaring the entire defensive line,
- 7:27because we mentioned Chubb, Rousseau, and Walker.
- 7:29The entire defensive line is being elite. According
- 7:32to NFL next -gen stats, the Buffalo Bills overall
- 7:35pressure rate is only 27 .1 % through two games.
- 7:39That's the bottom quarter, the bottom 25 % in
- 7:42the NFL. What has changed, though, is the Buffalo
- 7:46Bills ability to finish those pressures. Their
- 7:49pressure to sack conversion rate, according to
- 7:52next gen stats, is 29 .1%. Third overall in the
- 7:55league. For context, last year, that number was
- 7:5819%. And then in 2024, that number was a poultry,
- 8:02almost half, 12 .8%, or more than half. So the
- 8:07Bills aren't creating... like this amazing tidal
- 8:11wave of pressure. They're not overwhelming opposing
- 8:13QBs with a really high pressure rate. But what
- 8:16they are really doing better at, and you can
- 8:19credit a lot on Leonard's scheme with this, is
- 8:20they're finishing at the point of attack. They
- 8:23are finishing the sack and getting the opposing
- 8:25QB to the ground on a higher clip than they ever
- 8:27have. But this is also, to me, feels like an
- 8:30unsustainable clip. For a team that gets this
- 8:32few overall pressures of the Buffalo Bills, I
- 8:35believe that that SAC ratio is very likely to
- 8:39regress. Now, what does it regress to? Right
- 8:42now, the pressure to SAC ratio is otherworldly.
- 8:47If it just regresses, it can still regress to
- 8:50above average and still be good. But 29 % of
- 8:54pressures becoming SACs is an absolute monster
- 8:56number that feels unsustainable for the Buffalo
- 8:59Bills. Now back on the Rousseau tip, because
- 9:02overall along the entire defensive line, I do
- 9:04believe there's regression to be seen here, but
- 9:07I'm much more willing to believe that Rousseau's
- 9:09numbers individually are a little bit more sticky
- 9:11than I'm willing to believe that all of a sudden
- 9:13the entire defensive line has figured out how
- 9:16to sack the QB. Now, and this is because Rousseau
- 9:19has always been a pressure machine. Even in 2024
- 9:22and 2025, FTM had him in the top 15 overall of
- 9:27edge pressure rate in each of the previous two
- 9:29seasons. The only question with Rousseau has
- 9:32always been, can he finish the QB? Can he finish
- 9:35and get the opposing QB on the ground? And we've
- 9:38seen frustratingly low numbers for a guy with
- 9:40his athletic profile and his ability to set to
- 9:44get pressure on the opposing QB. Maybe what we're
- 9:47watching as a player who is already good at creating
- 9:50pressure, finally turn the corner and take those
- 9:53pressures into higher impact plays, not just
- 9:56the sacks, the strip sacks, the cost fumbles
- 9:59here early on against professional QBs and CJ
- 10:02Stroud and Jared Goff. Maybe Leonard's front
- 10:05is helping. But the interesting thing about Greg
- 10:06Rousseau is that the quality of his wins is really
- 10:10spectacular, regardless of the opponent that
- 10:12you want to lay him out. And this is where we
- 10:14get to that high quality. versus rare high quality
- 10:17pressure rate that Thorne gets back to. And that's
- 10:20the category where you're really just starting
- 10:22to beat good blockers. So that's the test. I
- 10:25don't need Greg Russo to keep up an 11 .5 true
- 10:28pressure rate, because he's not going to. And
- 10:30I don't need the Buffalo Bills to convert 30
- 10:33% of its pressures into sacks, because that number
- 10:36is almost certainly going to regress back to
- 10:38the mean. If it doesn't, that'd be great. And
- 10:40I would love to sit here at the end of the season
- 10:42and tell you I'm wrong. But when the quality
- 10:44of the offensive line gets better. Do we see
- 10:48Rousseau still able to beat guys one -on -one
- 10:50with some of the moves that he's breaking out?
- 10:53What happens when he gets, albeit a recovering,
- 10:56Rashawn Slater and Joe Ault this week against
- 10:58Los Angeles Chargers? What about the Kansas City
- 11:00Chiefs, who have seemed to completely rebuild
- 11:03that offensive line around Patrick Mahomes and
- 11:06this new rugged style of offense they're trying
- 11:09to play around Kenneth Walker as well? If Rousseau
- 11:12is still generating high quality pressure in
- 11:15those games, then we're not just talking about
- 11:17him being a September, a September Bruce Smith
- 11:19anymore. We're talking about what we have been
- 11:22waiting for, which is the star turn that we have
- 11:25been waiting to see from Greg Rousseau since
- 11:27we drafted him. So overall, defensive line, elite
- 11:32sack unit, probably not real, probably going
- 11:35to regress. But Greg Rousseau in this scheme
- 11:38is outside linebacker with Jim Leonard at the
- 11:41helm. Only potentially getting better. I'm not
- 11:44ready to say it's real yet But this one folks
- 11:47has the highest potential for B to become real
- 11:50by the end of the season and Sunday against the
- 11:53Chargers again with Rashaun Slater and Joe Walt
- 11:55albeit recovering from last season's injuries
- 11:58and still not coalescing with that new interior
- 12:01offensive line in LA is going to be a very stout
- 12:04challenge for Gregor so All right take two The
- 12:08Sean McDermott ceiling around this offense and
- 12:11I know we have all debated these numbers on Bill's
- 12:14Twitter and Bill's reddit How could the Buffalo
- 12:17Bills offense under Sean McDermott be conservative
- 12:20yet? It put up 30 points a game and what seemed
- 12:24to be an effortless almost workman like fashion
- 12:26for the past two seasons But still I think this
- 12:30is real and here's why And it's probably not
- 12:33going to be the take that I'm most proud of tonight.
- 12:36And I want to be really precise in what I mean,
- 12:38because I'm not saying that Sean McDermott gave
- 12:40the Bills a bad offense. I mean, that's false
- 12:43by any metric or measure that you want to take.
- 12:46And I'm not saying Joe Brady is all of a sudden
- 12:48John Gruden and definitely taking this Buffalo
- 12:51Bills team to the to the Super Bowl. Two games
- 12:54into his head coaching career, that'd be a ridiculous
- 12:56thing to declare. I'm not even saying McDermott
- 13:00personally walked into Joe Brady's office every
- 13:02Tuesday in pregame when it was like, hey, don't
- 13:05throw the ball downfield. We want check down,
- 13:07check down, check down to protect the defense.
- 13:09Here's what I am saying. I think the McDermott
- 13:12era Bills became obsessed with protecting Josh
- 13:16Allen from himself. reducing the volatility that
- 13:20they saw in a supremely talented generational
- 13:23but somewhat mistake prone and not risk adverse
- 13:27young QB he wanted to protect against volatility
- 13:30because that would protect the defense it would
- 13:33protect field position and it would protect the
- 13:35football complementary football was the name
- 13:38of the game in the McDermott era and listen there's
- 13:41a logic behind that Josh's greatest gift as we
- 13:44know is that he thinks he can make every play,
- 13:46we would call it big game hunting, where you
- 13:49would see Josh openly not take what was in front
- 13:52of him and look for the bigger strike down field.
- 13:55The biggest difference in the McDermott era versus
- 13:58the Brady era, it seems like. Brady is no longer
- 14:02asking Josh to be ashamed for hunting the big
- 14:05play. He's actually creating infrastructure that's
- 14:08allowing Josh to do this. But in McDermott era,
- 14:12they wanted a different brand of football, a
- 14:14different holistic identity around this team.
- 14:17And as crazy as it is to think, they didn't want
- 14:20the identity of the way the Bills played football
- 14:22to solely be about Josh Allen. And some of that
- 14:25tension would come out McDermott interviews with
- 14:27Ty Dunn that I was able to revisit after McDermott
- 14:30was let go by the Bills in the off season. McDermott
- 14:33was always great about praising Josh, but also
- 14:35being very, very careful to be like, but it's
- 14:38not just Josh. We've got great players on both
- 14:40sides of the ball. We've got great coaches, right?
- 14:43And McDermott will almost have to stop himself.
- 14:46It wasn't a jealousy thing. It wasn't a, it wasn't
- 14:49a, hey. I'm part of this two thing, like McDermott
- 14:52doesn't operate with that kind of ego. It really
- 14:55was McDermott trying to create this holistic
- 14:58team identity while also trying to develop a
- 15:02young, generationally talented QB. So he deferred
- 15:05to what he knew, which is do your one 11th. How
- 15:08do you take the star and you make them fit as
- 15:11a piece of the whole? So Buffalo spent years
- 15:14investing in Josh Allen. But they spent years
- 15:17trying to coach out of him. The thing that a
- 15:20lot of times can make it great. Check it down.
- 15:23Stay on schedule. Don't turn every third and
- 15:26seven into needing a 12 point touchdown because
- 15:29they don't exist. Don't play backyard football
- 15:31all the time. And listen, some of that development
- 15:34was totally necessary. We saw the raw product
- 15:37that Josh was his first two years a starter and
- 15:40they didn't. turned Josh into a game manager.
- 15:43They wanted to build that philosophy around the
- 15:47moments where they needed him to be destructive.
- 15:49But unfortunately, they weren't always allowing
- 15:52that destructive part of Josh to come out in
- 15:54the best ways. I mean, look at twenty twenty
- 15:55five. Buffalo led the NFL in time of possession.
- 15:59Thirty three minutes and nine seconds per game.
- 16:01They ran an all ran a play and me and JJ would
- 16:04talk about this. We want tempo. We want the Jay
- 16:07gun, right? We want the Josh Allen gun. They
- 16:09ran an offensive play once every 30 seconds,
- 16:12basically milking that play clock. down to the
- 16:15absolute bone that they could. And according
- 16:17to FTN, that was the slowest overall pace of
- 16:20play by an NFL team since the 2007 Steelers.
- 16:25That's not an accident. That was an identity
- 16:28that the McDermott Bills were trying to play.
- 16:32Control the ball. Run James Cook. Stay ahead
- 16:35of the six control game script by reducing possessions
- 16:39for the opposing team and keep Josh out of chaos.
- 16:44And Joe Brady, listen, was a part of that. Like,
- 16:45I want to be fair. Joe Brady was brought in after
- 16:47Ken Dorsey, and he built this offense in the
- 16:52image that Sean McDermott wanted to. Right. So
- 16:55I'm not absolving Brady and trying to pin everything,
- 16:58every single conservative tendency on Sean McDermott.
- 17:02But what's changed has been the incentive structure.
- 17:05I think around this offense, Joe Brady isn't
- 17:07coordinating Sean McDermott's football team anymore.
- 17:10Joe Brady is finally building a Joe Brady football
- 17:13team and through two games. That philosophy looks
- 17:16completely different, even though it's the same
- 17:18guy calling plays as has been for Josh the past
- 17:21two years. Josh Allen's average depth of target
- 17:24through two games right now, 10 .5 yards, tied
- 17:28for third on football. Last year, 7 .8 yards,
- 17:31according to NFL Next Gen stats. That was the
- 17:3411th lowest among qualifying QBs. 16 .7 % of
- 17:40Allen's attempts this season have traveled, we're
- 17:43not talking about yak, we're talking about air
- 17:46travel, have traveled at least 20 yards downfield.
- 17:50Last year, that number was about half at 11%.
- 17:53And on those deep 10s, those 50 -50 balls, our
- 17:56boy Josh is at 50%. Five for 10, 198 yards of
- 18:01passing, and three touchdowns to zero interceptions
- 18:04on balls that are traveling 20 yards or more
- 18:08downfield. And Brady is also using, thank God,
- 18:12play action on about 47 % of Allen's drop backs.
- 18:16So this isn't just about turning Josh loose and
- 18:20hoping he doesn't screw things up. Brady is building
- 18:23a real infrastructure with heavy personnel. We've
- 18:27seen the 13 personnel usage with a healthy concave
- 18:30Dawson Knox and Jackson Hawes on the field. The
- 18:32Buffalo Bills are running heavy personnel at
- 18:35about 38 percent clip, which is good for third
- 18:38in the league right now. So they're running more
- 18:40heavy personnel to keep teams guessing on their
- 18:43run pass tendencies. They're running play action
- 18:46at more than double the clip they were last season.
- 18:49And they're doing it on early downs. extraordinarily
- 18:53effectively as well. They're keeping opposing
- 18:55defenses through two games guessing. This is
- 18:58the infrastructure, right? This is play action
- 19:01to make things easier for Josh. Dalton can Cade
- 19:04and pre snap motion to identify what's his best
- 19:07run blocking assignment or to handpick his matchup
- 19:10against a linebacker or a safety from the opposing
- 19:12team. All of it is feeding Josh meaningful data
- 19:16at the line of scribbage. So what does that allow
- 19:18you to do? You have Josh Allen. taking his God
- 19:21-given natural talent to hunt that big play,
- 19:25but you're building it with structure. And that's
- 19:27the piece that was missing. The structure that
- 19:29McDermott wanted is not the structure that Brady
- 19:32is building right now for Josh. And what I will
- 19:35say, I think we can all agree on and is very
- 19:38true. Brady understands better than McDermott
- 19:41the type of quarterback he has, right? He knows.
- 19:45What Josh brings to the table as far as negatives
- 19:48go and he's willing to ride that tiger and so
- 19:51far He's ridden that tiger to the tune of 582
- 19:55total passing yards five passing touchdowns zero
- 19:58interceptions zero turnovers add another 92 rushing
- 20:03yards and four rushing touchdowns to that and
- 20:06all of a sudden You've got nine total touchdowns,
- 20:08no turnovers, and the Buffalo Bills have scored
- 20:1177 points in two games. That is a different style
- 20:15altogether and a style that is needed because
- 20:18the Buffalo Bills defense right now needs protection
- 20:21in the form of a cushion and a pad so that the
- 20:24game script can flip in their favor. And we don't
- 20:27have to worry about seeing that putrid run defense
- 20:29that the Bills are running out there. And it's
- 20:31not happening in the same way that it did last
- 20:33year against Houston. The Buffalo Bills possessed
- 20:36the ball for about 23 minutes, 23 minutes in
- 20:39total. They still scored 36. That's not controlling
- 20:42the game through volume. It's just the change
- 20:45in mentality. The old question seemed to be under
- 20:47McDermott. How do we prevent Josh Allen from
- 20:50losing the game? And yes, at some point. Joe
- 20:53Brady's riding this tiger, the tiger is going
- 20:55to bite. Like Josh probably has a two to three
- 20:58turnover game sitting in him somewhere. And with
- 21:01our luck, it's going to come at the worst possible
- 21:02time against Baltimore, Kansas City, an AFC opponent
- 21:06that the Bills really need to win against, right?
- 21:08Josh is going to throw a pick. He still has that
- 21:10in him, right? That's part of the transaction.
- 21:13And if you want all the good that Josh Allen
- 21:15brings to the table without accepting any of
- 21:18the danger that's attached to good Josh Allen,
- 21:20You're trying to purchase something that doesn't
- 21:22exist. His aggression is not a bug that is separate
- 21:26from his greatness. It is a feature of the way
- 21:28he plays. It is built into his core operating
- 21:31system. You manage it. You give it structure.
- 21:34You give him answers. But eventually you've got
- 21:37to let Josh be Josh and McDermott wasn't ready
- 21:41to do that. So this is my reel two weeks into
- 21:44the season. The McDermott ceiling was real. Not
- 21:47because the Buffalo Bills weren't successful
- 21:49because we all know they were. But it's because
- 21:51I believe that the organizational priority became
- 21:54eliminating variance and eliminating volatility.
- 21:57And when you eliminate too much bad from Josh,
- 22:01you're eventually going to start eliminating
- 22:03some of the great that Josh brings to the table,
- 22:05like any antibiotic. A germ in a cell can kind
- 22:09of look like the same things. And that after
- 22:11almost nine years of Sean McDermott at the helm
- 22:15of the Buffalo Bills is what we were getting
- 22:17with Josh. You were eliminating too much of the
- 22:20bad. And in that effort, an altruistic and noble
- 22:23effort as it was, you were starting to eliminate
- 22:25a lot of the good. Joe Brady appears to be willing
- 22:28to make a different bargain. Understand the chaos
- 22:31embrace the cast but build structure around the
- 22:33cast and ride that tiger, baby Because that tiger
- 22:36might take you to a Super Bowl by the end of
- 22:38the season All right last real or not real here
- 22:41before we get out of here folks Christian Benford
- 22:45liability and man coverage And it pains me to
- 22:48say this because I love me some Christian Benford.
- 22:50I've been on the record saying he is probably,
- 22:52other than Matt Milano, maybe my favorite defensive
- 22:55buff Bills player of this era. That being said,
- 22:57though, this verdict has got to be real, even
- 23:00two games in. But there is an important distinction.
- 23:03Benford's not a bad cornerback. I want to start
- 23:05there. I'm not saying he is bad. PFF. Take it
- 23:09for what you will, though. has got some ugly
- 23:12numbers associated with Benford as a man coverage
- 23:15corner versus his adaptability as his own coverage
- 23:18corner. Right now, Benford has a coverage grade
- 23:21of 32 of 32 .7. according to PFF, that is 87th
- 23:27out of 92 qualifying corners. He has allowed
- 23:3011 total receptions on just under 100 coverage
- 23:33snaps, and QBs are targeting him in coverage
- 23:37actively. And those that do have a passer rating
- 23:41of 122 against him. For those of you at home
- 23:44wondering what is a good passer rating, Pretty
- 23:47much anything above 110 is considered highly
- 23:49above average, and all QBs when targeting Christian
- 23:52Benford and man coverage are becoming those QBs.
- 23:56Those are just bad numbers, right? But it doesn't
- 23:59mean that all of a sudden Christian Benford sucks
- 24:01or can't play cornerback. I think we're learning
- 24:03the wrong thing about him, because we have years
- 24:05of evidence telling us that he is a good cornerback,
- 24:09albeit in a different scheme. FTN, I was really
- 24:13big into their... their preseason guide this
- 24:15year, and I studied it, you know, cover to cover,
- 24:17and they described Benford as one of the league's
- 24:20better coverage players, right? Buffalo went
- 24:23from 31st to first in its CB1 to wide receiver
- 24:28one coverage DVO way as Benford began to travel
- 24:32last season with opposing teams wide receivers
- 24:35more often, and opponents actually targeted.
- 24:38those number one receivers at a league -high
- 24:4029 % of the time. And Bedford still finished
- 24:43as a top 20 cornerback by coverage DVOA in 2025.
- 24:47So we saw it last year where teams were just
- 24:49not afraid of him and they were targeting him
- 24:51more, but more often than not, he was holding
- 24:54his own. So what's the big change from last year
- 24:57to this year? It's the scheme, right? And this
- 25:01was the concern that I think... Many of us had,
- 25:03but didn't want to say out loud when we knew
- 25:05that Jim Leonard was going to be bringing in
- 25:07more of a man's game. Benford's career numbers
- 25:11entering into 2026 showed a pretty dramatic split
- 25:14in zone coverage. Quarterbacks produced only
- 25:17a 68 .5 pass rating when targeting him. This
- 25:20is all pre this season in man. Even before Leonard
- 25:23came about came about, it was 110 .7. That's
- 25:27not something that two games have invented, right?
- 25:30That's not Benford adjusting. to a new man -based
- 25:34scheme on the defense. This has always been the
- 25:37liability with Benford. He's amazing in his own.
- 25:39He's amazing as part of a system. But when you
- 25:43gotta leave him on an island against an opposing
- 25:45team's number one wide receiver, he's going to
- 25:48be a liability for you. And that's why I think
- 25:50this is real. Benford wins because of his anticipation,
- 25:54because of his instincts, because he can see
- 25:56things. He knows how to process the route. He
- 25:59understands pacing. He understands technique.
- 26:01He knows what opposing QBs are trying to take
- 26:04advantage of. He closes out passing windows really
- 26:07well. He plays, again, with a ton of anticipation.
- 26:09He knows how to play tight coverage. And again,
- 26:12he is still a lockdown zone cover corner. But
- 26:15as a man cover corner... It's a different proposition
- 26:19with him. Can he carry the vertical speed of
- 26:22an opposing wide receiver? I think we've seen
- 26:24that he can't in man coverage. Can you leave
- 26:27him alone without safety help over the top? I
- 26:30think Nico Collins showed us early on in week
- 26:32one that you can't do that. And can you mirror
- 26:35receivers one -on -one in man coverage across
- 26:38their entire route? I mean, listen, Benford was
- 26:41not a speed demon coming out of college. I think
- 26:43he ran like a four or five at the combine. So
- 26:46Leonard, if you're Leonard, you got an interesting
- 26:47problem, right? Because when you were Jim Leonard
- 26:50in Denver, those defenses played man and roughly
- 26:5334 % of their snaps and then 36, 34 % of their
- 26:57snaps in 2024 and 36 % in 2025. Highest rates
- 27:01in football. Leonard comes to Buffalo, wants
- 27:04an aggressive scheme and you can bat. that more
- 27:08man is coming down the pipeline. But aggression,
- 27:11aggression has a cost to it, especially when
- 27:14you don't have the guys or the dudes on that
- 27:16side of the ball to be able to fulfill that scheme
- 27:19to its fullest. And if you're manipulating fronts
- 27:21and you're bringing pressure, sometimes your
- 27:23corners just have to hold up. And this is where
- 27:27take one and take three, the Rousseau take and
- 27:30the take on Benford, they actually intersect
- 27:32a little bit. The same defensive philosophy.
- 27:34that may be helping Greg Rousseau attack offensive
- 27:37linemen in completely different ways is also
- 27:40putting Christian Benford in situations that
- 27:42don't maximize what he does best. But that's
- 27:45football. Scheme doesn't unlock everybody equally.
- 27:49And through two games, Buffalo's defense has
- 27:51given up 31 points twice. Jared Goff torched
- 27:55them for 327 yards and four touchdowns. Amanara
- 27:59St. Brown had nine catches for 142 yards and
- 28:03two touchdowns. So with Benford, elite cover
- 28:06zone corner, liability and man coverage. The
- 28:12progress that Rousseau is making is potentially
- 28:14coming to the expense of another stall war on
- 28:16this defense in Benford. But here's what I would
- 28:19do. Definitely wouldn't panic because again,
- 28:20it's week two and you can't bench Christian Benford
- 28:23because you already have a depth problem at the
- 28:25outside cornerback anyway. I would lean harder
- 28:28if I'm Leonard and what made him good in the
- 28:29first place. Let Harrison. And, um, Igmanosen,
- 28:34some of these more athletic corners take some
- 28:36of that isolated man work and, uh, when the personal
- 28:39allows for it. Use Ben for his intelligence.
- 28:41Let him read concepts. Let him drive downhill.
- 28:44He's still excellent as a run defender as well.
- 28:47Let him play with a little bit of vision on the
- 28:49QB. When you ask him to play man, be selective
- 28:53about the matchup. You can't, again, leave him
- 28:55on Nico Collins or a Garrett Wilson. or a Jamar
- 28:59chase without even a little bit of safety help
- 29:01over the top, right? You install the scheme because
- 29:06you think the scheme works. And when you start
- 29:08asking players to fit the scheme instead of the
- 29:11scheme to fit your players, this is where you
- 29:14get into trouble. Joe Brady, we just give a massive
- 29:17compliment to because he is fitting a scheme
- 29:19that fits his players. He's fitting. Josh Allen's
- 29:24tendencies and building structure around it.
- 29:26We need to be able to see the same thing from
- 29:28letter on the defensive side of the ball. We
- 29:30don't want Greg Rousseau's progress to come with
- 29:33the sacrifice of Christian Benford's process.
- 29:35So for me, Christian Benford being bad is not
- 29:38real, he's not bad. But Christian Benford being
- 29:41vulnerable if the Buffalo Bills ask him to take
- 29:44another step up in man reps in service to the
- 29:47scheme. I do think his liability then becomes
- 29:50real. And that's something I'm definitely going
- 29:52to be watching closely as the season goes on
- 29:54here from week two. So there you have it, Bill's
- 29:57Mafia. After two games, this is kind of where
- 30:00I land. The Bills are two and oh, they're scoring
- 30:02points left and right. I think they just scored
- 30:04another touchdown while I was recording this
- 30:06podcast. They got a quarterback playing like.
- 30:10Like he's free for the first time in a few years
- 30:14like he's unrestricted And that he's got the
- 30:16confidence of the head coach to do what he needs
- 30:19to do to get this team over the top You've got
- 30:21Greg Rousseau taking the right steps as well
- 30:24And you've got a new defensive system that is
- 30:26still kind of coming into form But it's only
- 30:29two weeks in two weeks is not a time To be answering
- 30:33a lot of questions if you're a fan or you're
- 30:36an analyst, but it's time to start identifying
- 30:38the questions so Does Buffalo suddenly have an
- 30:41elite defensive line? Probably not yet, but we
- 30:44might have an elite real one in Gregg or so.
- 30:47McDermott ceiling, that was probably real, right?
- 30:50And Joe Brady appears determined to find out
- 30:53just how fast things are going to move from here.
- 30:56Christian Benford struggling when Buffalo asked
- 30:58him to line up a man coverage Absolutely real
- 31:01and that's something that Jim Leonard needs to
- 31:02pay attention to But it's not real because it's
- 31:05only happening two weeks into a new scheme And
- 31:07it was real because this has been who Christian
- 31:09Benford is throughout hit the course of his career
- 31:12What I want to see better opposing caliber of
- 31:15opponent for Gregor so I want to see Brady particularly
- 31:19interested here heading into week three with
- 31:21after an emotional game I would say in Houston
- 31:24getting that monkey off your back and then basically
- 31:27doing the most emotional thing you can do which
- 31:29is open up a new stadium on a short week in one
- 31:32of the best football communities in the country.
- 31:352 -0 is fun, but I want to see if Brady takes
- 31:37his foot off the gas and if this mini -buy, this
- 31:40long break, has led to a little bit of malaise
- 31:42for the Bills or is Brady going to have this
- 31:44offense out and ready to go and step on the throats
- 31:47of a reeling opponent in the Los Angeles Chargers?
- 31:50More to come on that later this week. All I know
- 31:53right now is this is a sample, but the sample's
- 31:55been really fun so far. There's definitely concerns
- 31:58on the horizon, but being a Buffalo Bills fan,
- 32:00as they said here in 2 -0, is a very good thing,
- 32:02too. And it's also been a very good thing here
- 32:04to pod for you. Like, share, and subscribe wherever
- 32:06you get your podcasts. We are on YouTube, Spotify,
- 32:09and Apple. And as always, Bills Mafia, go Bills.