Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 241. Team Spirit: How to Make Group Work Work
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: We are all members of multiple groups and teams, our
- 0:07families, our coworkers, our friends.
- 0:10The ability to communicate effectively in groups is critical.
- 0:15My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:18Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:20Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:25Today I am really excited to spend time with Colin Fisher.
- 0:28Colin is an associate professor of organizations and innovation at University
- 0:32College London School of Management.
- 0:35His research focuses on helping groups and teams in situations
- 0:38requiring creativity, improvisation, and complex decision making.
- 0:43His latest book is The Collective Edge: Unlocking The Secret Power of Groups.
- 0:48Welcome, Colin.
- 0:49I'm really excited for our conversation.
- 0:52Colin Fisher: Thanks so much for having me, Matt.
- 0:53Looking forward to it.
- 0:54Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:55Shall we get started?
- 0:56Colin Fisher: Yeah.
- 0:57Matt Abrahams: Like you, I have long been fascinated by groups and their impact.
- 1:01I used to teach classes on group communication, and I always
- 1:04start by talking to my students about the benefits and perils of
- 1:08groups, so I thought it would make sense for us to start there too.
- 1:11From your perspective, can you share what are the advantages
- 1:14and some of the disadvantages of groups and the work we do in them?
- 1:19Colin Fisher: The advantages of groups are, on some level, they're almost so
- 1:23obvious we don't even think about them, that we bring more minds to the problem.
- 1:28We bring more people's labor, that the idea that many hands make light
- 1:32the work, is why we come to groups.
- 1:35We can accomplish things that we could never do if we tried to go it alone.
- 1:41Groups can be, in my mind, the pinnacle of human accomplishment.
- 1:47But as your question implies, there's some downsides too.
- 1:51Groups can also be these engines to produce conformity, to really restrict
- 1:59people's individuality, that we have terms like group think or you know, that
- 2:04we call these groups, that have these extreme conformity pressures to be cults.
- 2:09And that groups have all these tendencies within them as well to restrict us to,
- 2:14to take away our individuality and to sometimes make us the worst versions of
- 2:19ourselves where they bring out of us this kind of tribalism that is at the root
- 2:24of war and intergroup conflict and all kinds of terrible things in the world.
- 2:29So, so groups really are this dichotomy.
- 2:31Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 2:32On one side we have this notion of creativity, which really
- 2:35can bring out the best in us.
- 2:37And then we have on the other side, extreme conformity, which can really
- 2:41lead to a lot of negative things.
- 2:42So the trick becomes how do we maximize for the benefits of groups
- 2:47and minimize for those negatives?
- 2:49So what are key ingredients for successful teams, teaming, and teamwork.
- 2:54I think about things like diversity of participation, psychological safety,
- 2:59having clear purpose, clear roles.
- 3:01What do you see as some of the most important aspects
- 3:04for successful group work?
- 3:06Colin Fisher: You got some of the really important ones right off the bat there.
- 3:09The benefits of groups come from having diverse knowledge,
- 3:14skills, and perspectives.
- 3:16The, the kind of synergy that we talk about in group work really only
- 3:20emerges when we don't all think the same thing, when we don't all have
- 3:24the same knowledge and skills, and that we share them with one another.
- 3:28So we need to compose groups carefully.
- 3:31But one of the things that we often make a mistake in when we compose them is that
- 3:36we don't think about how big those groups should be, and so we end up often with
- 3:42groups most commonly that are too big.
- 3:45Prototypical example of these are meetings.
- 3:48We can all imagine one of the worst things to be in is a meeting that's
- 3:53got twenty people in it, because we know we're not gonna be able to
- 3:56really hear everyone's perspective.
- 3:58We're not gonna be able to know what everyone knows, what everyone thinks.
- 4:02The only thing worse than this meeting of twenty people is a meeting with
- 4:06twenty-five people or thirty people.
- 4:08We have to be thoughtful about how big a group can really be to have
- 4:12this kind of synergistic interaction.
- 4:15Matt Abrahams: So I'm curious, what does the research say about group size?
- 4:18Is there an ideal group size?
- 4:19Does it depend on the task you're trying to complete?
- 4:22Colin Fisher: It does depend on the task you're trying to complete.
- 4:25I like to give a fairly definitive answer to this because it doesn't depend as
- 4:29much on the task as we'd like to think.
- 4:31One is a line of research that looks across different tasks at the effect
- 4:36of group size on team performance, and the there you get answers depending on
- 4:40the task, anywhere from three to seven.
- 4:43But then when you ask people, when do you feel like the groups
- 4:47you're in are too big or too small?
- 4:50You get the line of my group is too big and my group is too small, they
- 4:54cross, right about four point five.
- 4:57We feel that groups are the right size between four and five, and
- 5:02that we see performance measures be anywhere from three to seven.
- 5:06And so I think those are pretty good guidelines for thinking about
- 5:10how big your group should be.
- 5:11Matt Abrahams: I think having an anchor for group size is really important
- 5:14because there's a tendency to want to include more people, or perhaps because
- 5:18other communication challenges exist within an organization, meetings become
- 5:23the only way to convey information.
- 5:25So more is better, is often the mindset, but it sounds like that's not the case.
- 5:29I'd like to dig a little deeper into a couple of the other aspects.
- 5:33We had Amy Edmondson on, we talked a bit about psychological safety.
- 5:37Curious to get your perspective on how we go about building groups that can be
- 5:43more effective by making sure that those diverse points of view and perspectives
- 5:47feel comfortable being shared.
- 5:49Colin Fisher: If you've talked to Amy, you've really gotten the
- 5:51best advice that's out there.
- 5:53Psychological safety, as you were saying, it's so important because even if we get
- 5:58this diverse mix of knowledge, skills, and perspectives onto our team, we still
- 6:03aren't gonna take advantage of it unless people are comfortable sharing it.
- 6:07They're comfortable speaking up with different ideas.
- 6:09They're comfortable asking questions.
- 6:12They're comfortable admitting mistakes and trying experiments and failing.
- 6:16And the way that we build that psychological safety is that first
- 6:22we ask for it, that we say the work that we're gonna be doing is gonna
- 6:26require us to share our different knowledge, skills, and perspectives.
- 6:30It's gonna require us to take risks, that we're gonna have some things to learn.
- 6:34And that's always true because any new team has to figure out
- 6:38how to work together at a minimum.
- 6:40They've gotta figure out how to communicate, and they're going to need
- 6:43to do some of this learning and some of this experimentation to make it happen.
- 6:47Another way that you can build this kind of psychological safety is to model it.
- 6:53So especially if you're a leader for you to admit your own mistakes, for you to
- 6:58ask questions that you might worry are dumb questions, for you to do experiments
- 7:04and say, hey, I'm learning too.
- 7:06This is what I'm gonna try.
- 7:07Let's see how it goes.
- 7:08And to model those kinds of behaviors.
- 7:11And then of course, to not shoot the messenger and not to, when people do
- 7:16speak up, they do share their ideas, they do ask questions that are on their
- 7:19mind, that you reinforce that with positive reinforcement, you encourage it.
- 7:24You don't criticize people for doing those things.
- 7:27Matt Abrahams: So it's about setting expectations for this sharing of
- 7:32different viewpoints that mistakes are acceptable and actually needed
- 7:36for the group to be successful.
- 7:38And as a leader or somebody who has a leadership role, demonstrating this
- 7:42in your own actions, role modeling, I think those are great ways to
- 7:46help people understand that this is important and reinforce these values.
- 7:50Are there certain things we can do when a group forms that really
- 7:54helps set us on a path of success?
- 7:56You know, this notion of forming sometimes happens very quickly.
- 8:00There's a crisis and we have to pull people together.
- 8:02Other times it's more thoughtful.
- 8:04Can you give two or three best practices for group formation that
- 8:08can really set you on a good path?
- 8:11Colin Fisher: So group formation is such an important time in a group's life
- 8:16that the stuff that we do when we first get together tends to be really sticky.
- 8:21We all can imagine the first time we meet with a new group at work or a
- 8:25new class at school, people tend to sit in the same place the whole time.
- 8:30Where we sit, who talks first, who talks the most.
- 8:34These kinds of norms form really early, and so we wanna
- 8:38manage that really carefully.
- 8:40Now with group formation, some of the work should happen
- 8:44before we ever get in the room.
- 8:45The work of thinking about the task, thinking about composing that group
- 8:50well, the group size and diversity of knowledge, skills, and perspectives, all
- 8:53those things should be done ahead of time.
- 8:56But then once we're, what I would call launching the group,
- 8:59and there's three big tasks.
- 9:01One is we need to bring that goal to life and make sure we
- 9:04all understand it similarly.
- 9:06So we need to have a very clear and vivid communication of that goal.
- 9:11So the kind of classic business school examples of these are like
- 9:16when John F. Kennedy repurposed NASA, which had a very ambiguous goal,
- 9:22prior to his charge, for them to put a man on the moon within ten years.
- 9:27So that was a very clear, vivid goal that everyone can imagine.
- 9:31So even if we don't have a clear idea of what we need to do first, or what
- 9:36we need to do tomorrow, the fact that we can all imagine the future vividly,
- 9:41that we need to get to collectively, allowed people to stay coordinated
- 9:46and to synchronize their efforts.
- 9:48So we need these kinds of clear, vivid goals to, to get us together.
- 9:53And then second, we need to establish these initial norms.
- 9:56So the fact that norms are sticky and they form really fast, we can use
- 10:00that to our advantage by doing some of the things we talked about when we're
- 10:05establishing psychological safety.
- 10:07To say, I wanna have a team where we all share what we know, where we speak up when
- 10:12we have an idea, and how can we do that.
- 10:16We can have that conversation.
- 10:17But the most important things I think are close to your heart
- 10:20are norms about communication.
- 10:22How are we gonna communicate with one another?
- 10:25And that some of these are really basic things like, what communication
- 10:29channels are we even going to use?
- 10:31I can't tell you how many teams I've seen where some people are communicating
- 10:36through one channel, and a few people don't use that channel, don't know.
- 10:39So some people aren't signed up for Slack, they don't get notifications,
- 10:43they don't know what's being said there.
- 10:45So some of it's really basic about where are we gonna communicate, but
- 10:49then we also need norms for how quickly are we responding to each other.
- 10:54That, when do I think you haven't seen this email, is it one day, two
- 10:58days, a week, you know, and that different teams can have different
- 11:02norms, but as long as we're clear, we can communicate effectively.
- 11:06And then we need to have understanding of the individual responsibilities
- 11:12and work that we're gonna have between now and the next time we talk.
- 11:17And this could be the beginnings of roles, they could be really
- 11:20formal roles, but that needs to be clear what I need to do between now
- 11:25and the next time we're gonna be collectively accountable to one another.
- 11:28So if we do those three things, that we have clear vivid goals, we have
- 11:32norms, especially norms for how we're gonna communicate and that they're
- 11:35promoting psychological safety, and we know what our responsibilities are,
- 11:40and we know the deadline by which those responsibilities to the group are set,
- 11:45then we have a pretty darn good launch.
- 11:48Matt Abrahams: Vivid goals that people are aligned towards, norms, which are simply
- 11:51just expectations for what and how we will interact, and responsibilities for
- 11:57the actions that we'll follow up with.
- 11:59Very important.
- 11:59And, and the key thing you've said there is that work has to happen in advance.
- 12:03We have to think about these things before we pull people together.
- 12:06And in fact, thinking about these things might determine who
- 12:08we pull together and how many.
- 12:11I wanna switch now and talk about the way in which we do group work,
- 12:15which is primarily meetings and most people don't like meetings.
- 12:20What is your advice on how to make the group time in meetings more effective?
- 12:26What are things we can do to have better meetings?
- 12:28Colin Fisher: So that's a great question, and it's such a common one.
- 12:32Sometimes I ask myself the same thing in my organization.
- 12:35The number one tip is to not ask what can I do to have a better
- 12:40meeting, but to ask should we have this meeting in the first place.
- 12:44As we said, norms are really sticky.
- 12:48And so if we start having this norm that we're gonna have boring meetings, that
- 12:52people are gonna be disengaged and not speak in these meetings, not contribute
- 12:56what they know, that norm's likely to stick even if we go from a meeting
- 13:00that really wasn't necessary and that was one way communication, information
- 13:04sharing, and the next time we have a meeting where we do need people to
- 13:08speak up, they're less likely to do it.
- 13:10So eliminating those meetings that we didn't need has the added benefits of
- 13:16you're gonna start to develop better norms for how people contribute in the meetings,
- 13:21where you really need their contribution.
- 13:23So step one, eliminate unnecessary meetings, and that will make the
- 13:27meetings you do have much better.
- 13:29But then step two is likely you are inviting too many
- 13:34people to these meetings.
- 13:36So just like we said, when we wanna get real work done and we wanna
- 13:40have everyone's contributions, we wanna know what they think.
- 13:43We wanna have them participate in decision making, communicate well.
- 13:47We really need to have this kind of core group of three to
- 13:51seven people around the table.
- 13:53Once we've even got a group of ten, if I've got an hour long meeting and
- 13:58a group of ten, especially if they're ten academics like us, or it's in
- 14:01the university situation, the chances that we're gonna get through that and
- 14:05everyone's going to say everything that they have to say is really low.
- 14:10And if we're over ten, if we're fifteen, we're twenty, we're
- 14:13twenty-five, it's almost none.
- 14:15There's almost no way we're gonna have that meeting.
- 14:17So if we can have meetings that have very concrete outcomes, that we're
- 14:22there to make a decision, we're there to generate new ideas, we're there to
- 14:28develop a new strategy, that there's some reason that we're meeting, it's
- 14:32clear to all members, and then we invite people who have something
- 14:36really to contribute towards that goal, we're likely to have better meetings.
- 14:41One way communication, if it could have been an email, or if you prefer it
- 14:45could have been a video message or an audio message to the team, then do that.
- 14:49Don't have a meeting, but that when you do have meetings, they have
- 14:53clear purposes, they have agendas, and only the people who need to be
- 14:57there are invited to those meetings.
- 15:00That's gonna go a long way towards improving your meetings.
- 15:03Matt Abrahams: Amen.
- 15:04Do we need a meeting?
- 15:05Are there other ways to communicate?
- 15:07Super important first question.
- 15:09Then what are we meeting for?
- 15:11What's the purpose?
- 15:12Do we have a clear agenda?
- 15:14Does everybody understand it?
- 15:15Excellent.
- 15:16Then finally being willing to cancel a meeting or not hold a meeting if
- 15:21not necessary, really important.
- 15:23Thank you for sharing that.
- 15:24And may everybody adopt that and may meetings be what they truly can be, which
- 15:28is really productive opportunities to accomplish work and to feel connected.
- 15:33So thank you.
- 15:35Colin, this has been a fantastic conversation.
- 15:36Before we end, I like to ask three questions of my guests.
- 15:40One I create just for you, and the other two are similar across
- 15:43everybody I've interviewed.
- 15:44Are you up for that?
- 15:45Colin Fisher: Yeah, absolutely.
- 15:46Matt Abrahams: So there's so many things about you that
- 15:48are really interesting to me.
- 15:49One is you're a professional jazz trumpeter.
- 15:52I tried to play the trumpet early in my life and failed miserably, so I'm in awe
- 15:56of your ability to do it professionally.
- 15:58What is one thing that you've learned as a professional jazz trumpeter
- 16:01that has helped you in terms of how you interact with people in groups?
- 16:05Colin Fisher: The essence of all kinds of music really is listening.
- 16:08I had a really famous teacher, his name was Bob Brookmeyer, who said, when
- 16:13you're improvising, you have to keep one ear on your head and you have to take
- 16:17the other ear and put it over on the piano, oversee the whole interaction.
- 16:22And so I think it's made me listen in different ways.
- 16:26It's made me more open to both what somebody who's speaking is
- 16:30saying and the whole ensemble of the group of the communication.
- 16:34And just to really attune me to the importance of listening.
- 16:38Matt Abrahams: It always amazes me that people who study and teach communication
- 16:42come back to listening, and it's an important lesson for all of us.
- 16:46We think of communication as broadcasting, getting information out,
- 16:49but receiving it is really important.
- 16:50Thank you for sharing that.
- 16:51Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 16:56Colin Fisher: I have to continue to give credit to my mentor, Richard Hackman, who
- 17:02I owe so much of the book too as well, who took this complicated world of groups
- 17:09and really started to give order to it.
- 17:11I think what I respect about him as a communicator was finding
- 17:16terms that were really accurate.
- 17:19His famous theory is work design, right?
- 17:22And that's not like a fancy academic set of terms.
- 17:26I make fun of the term group entitativity in the book where it's like we come
- 17:30up with these like mouthfuls of things that are really hard to say.
- 17:34But just calling it work design theory already was such a powerful communication
- 17:40move to not only be clear within the academic community, but also to be
- 17:44clear to everyone else about what it is we should be paying attention to
- 17:49that we weren't paying attention to at the time, which was the tasks and
- 17:52the way that we are thinking about structuring the work that we do.
- 17:55So I think he would be one of the best communicators that I've encountered.
- 18:00Matt Abrahams: Thank you for sharing that, and thank you for reinforcing
- 18:02the idea of clarity, concision, accessibility, are really important.
- 18:07Final question for you, Colin.
- 18:08What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 18:13Colin Fisher: So I'm going to say listening again.
- 18:16When I first started studying teams, I thought I was gonna see these people who
- 18:22were these expert diagnosers of group dynamics, that they were gonna walk into
- 18:27a room and they'd look at a team and go, oh, I know what's wrong with you.
- 18:30Instead, when I started studying these great coaches of teams, what they
- 18:34did was they asked more questions.
- 18:37They said, oh, how are you doing?
- 18:39So they didn't magically diagnose people.
- 18:41They asked them what was going on.
- 18:43You ask questions, you listen to the answer, and then you respond in ways
- 18:51that both show you're concerned with that person's intent and wellbeing
- 18:56and emotional message that they had, but then you build on it and
- 18:59it's this kind of idea we find in theater improvisation of yes and-ing.
- 19:04That you say, yeah, I see what you're saying and now I'm
- 19:07gonna add something onto it.
- 19:09So I think if we ask good questions, we listen to the answer, and then we both
- 19:14respond and build on those responses, we're gonna have some great communication.
- 19:19Matt Abrahams: Excellent three ingredients.
- 19:21I echo that very much.
- 19:22I think those are really important.
- 19:24Ask questions, listen genuinely to the answers, and we've done a lot of episodes
- 19:29on the value of improv and this notion of responding and adding to what people say.
- 19:33Colin, thank you so much for bringing insight into a type of
- 19:37communication that we all do all day.
- 19:40We are parts of many different groups.
- 19:42Learning to be more effective in how we establish groups, how we make
- 19:46groups work better, and ultimately, how we feel more productive, really
- 19:51can be helpful for all of us.
- 19:53Thank you for your time.
- 19:54Colin Fisher: Thanks so much for having me, Matt.
- 19:57Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 19:59Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:02To learn more about setting groups up for success, please listen to
- 20:05episode 174 with Priya Parker.
- 20:08And to improve your meetings, check out both episodes, 125 and 125 with
- 20:12Joe Allen, Karin Reed, and Elise Keith.
- 20:16This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 20:21Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 20:23With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 20:26Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 20:29Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 20:32Also, follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 20:34And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 20:39learning content, and our newsletter.
- 20:41Please consider our premium offering before extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 20:45Ask Matt Anythings, and much more at fastersmarter.io/premium.