Latest / Bloomberg Law / States Sue Meta Over Addictive Features Targeting Youth
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: So today we're announcing a federal lawsuit against Meta. Met
- 0:14Speaker 2: of course, is the parent company of Instagram and Facebook,
- 0:18Speaker 2: for knowingly harming the mental health of young social media users.
- 0:23Speaker 1: Meta Platforms is being sued by forty one states who
- 0:27Speaker 1: claimed that social media platforms Instagram and Facebook exploit young
- 0:32Speaker 1: people for profit by building an addictive features that are
- 0:36Speaker 1: harming their mental health. At a press conference of the
- 0:38Speaker 1: Attorney General of Washington State, Bob Ferguson, two teenagers described
- 0:43Speaker 1: their struggles coping with social media sites like Instagram.
- 0:47Speaker 3: The worst part was these pictures and videos were never ending.
- 0:52Speaker 3: The addictive algorithm and the constant flood of new content
- 0:55Speaker 3: kept me glued to my phone, and before I knew it,
- 0:58Speaker 3: I began to hate myself and.
- 1:00Speaker 4: The way I looked.
- 1:02Speaker 3: This all happened before I.
- 1:04Speaker 4: Turned thirteen, as I would go on my phone intending
- 1:09Speaker 4: to do other things and then instinctively start opening up Instagram,
- 1:12Speaker 4: opening up different social media platforms without even meaning to,
- 1:17Speaker 4: and then getting stuck in the cycle of scrolling seeing
- 1:20Speaker 4: other people's lives and interactions.
- 1:23Speaker 1: Ferguson said, Meta knowingly misled users and hooked youngsters with
- 1:28Speaker 1: psychologically manipulative product features.
- 1:31Speaker 2: They tap into their so called fear of missing out,
- 1:34Speaker 2: discouraging them from leaving the apps once they are logged on.
- 1:38Speaker 2: Meta is aware of the addictive nature of these features
- 1:42Speaker 2: for young people and the risks that they pose. The
- 1:45Speaker 2: original developer of the infinite scroll concept Liken the feature too,
- 1:50Speaker 2: and I'm quoting now behavioral cocaine.
- 1:53Speaker 1: Thirty three states are filing a joint lawsuit in federal
- 1:56Speaker 1: court in California, while attorneys general for d and eight
- 2:00Speaker 1: other states are filing separate complaints in federal, state or
- 2:04Speaker 1: local courts. Joining me is Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Matthew Shettenhelm.
- 2:09Speaker 1: Matt tell us about the federal lawsuit.
- 2:12Speaker 5: So yesterday over thirty states filed in federal court in California,
- 2:19Speaker 5: basically using their consumer protection laws under each states and
- 2:25Speaker 5: accompanying that with one claim under federal law under the
- 2:30Speaker 5: Children Online Privacy Protection Act, which is known as KAPPA.
- 2:35Speaker 5: And basically the allegation here is that Meta acted in
- 2:40Speaker 5: an unfair and deceptive manner because it knew that its
- 2:46Speaker 5: social media service was harmful to teens, but it withheld
- 2:53Speaker 5: that knowledge and misled users and proceeded to deliver its
- 2:58Speaker 5: product to teens anyway. So it's seeking damages, civil penalties
- 3:04Speaker 5: as well as injunctive relief, basically forcing the company to
- 3:08Speaker 5: change how it serves teams. That's the goal of the lawsuit.
- 3:13Speaker 1: And so what they're alleging is that Meta designed algorithms.
- 3:19Speaker 1: It says Meta did not disclose that its algorithms were
- 3:22Speaker 1: designed to capitalize on young users, dopamine responses, and create
- 3:27Speaker 1: an addictive cycle of engagement. So the allegation is that
- 3:31Speaker 1: Meta specifically designed an algorithm for this.
- 3:34Speaker 5: That's exactly right. So the lawsuit takes aim at a
- 3:38Speaker 5: number of features that are sort of fundamental to how
- 3:42Speaker 5: Meta designed its social media platforms, using data about the
- 3:47Speaker 5: teams to send them content that keeps them scrolling and
- 3:51Speaker 5: keeps them reading, sending them notifications that keep them coming
- 3:56Speaker 5: back to the service as soon as they look away
- 3:58Speaker 5: from it, using the law like system that entices them
- 4:02Speaker 5: and draws them in and pushes them to put more
- 4:04Speaker 5: content out there. And the allegation here is that Meta
- 4:09Speaker 5: knew that all of these features were harmful to teams.
- 4:14Speaker 5: There's a separate lawsuit actually in this same federal court
- 4:17Speaker 5: that goes to the design of the product itself and
- 4:21Speaker 5: whether that violates product liability law or whether Facebook was
- 4:25Speaker 5: negligent in designing it. Actually, this Friday, that's going to
- 4:29Speaker 5: be go for emotion to dismiss hearing. This suit's a
- 4:32Speaker 5: little bit different. It's not about the design itself. It's
- 4:36Speaker 5: about did Meta lie? Did it mislead users about that?
- 4:41Speaker 5: And so it takes same It uses these existing consumer
- 4:45Speaker 5: protection laws about what is unfair and what is deceptive
- 4:49Speaker 5: to ask did Facebook mislead the public about what it knew?
- 4:53Speaker 1: And a lot of this is based on the whistleblower
- 4:58Speaker 1: who released internal Dyes documents in twenty twenty one.
- 5:02Speaker 5: Yeah, I think that's the real start of this, when
- 5:04Speaker 5: Francis Hoggin came out with her release of the internal
- 5:08Speaker 5: documents suggesting that that Facebook knew more about the risk
- 5:14Speaker 5: to children than it was letting on. And so this
- 5:18Speaker 5: is really you been playing out ever since that moment. Now,
- 5:22Speaker 5: Facebook disputes her allegations and says that they're overblown and
- 5:27Speaker 5: that the evidence isn't clearly as one sided as it
- 5:31Speaker 5: might seem or as she might suggest. So that's the
- 5:34Speaker 5: sort of allegation that would be tested in this case
- 5:37Speaker 5: if it gets past a motion to dismiss.
- 5:40Speaker 1: Metta said, we share the Attorney General's commitment to providing
- 5:43Speaker 1: teens with safe, positive experiences online and have already introduced
- 5:48Speaker 1: over thirty tools to support teens and their families. Do
- 5:52Speaker 1: you know what kind of tools they're talking about.
- 5:54Speaker 5: I think these are features like there are settings that
- 5:57Speaker 5: teens can put on the product to turn off after
- 6:01Speaker 5: so many minutes on the product. I think there are
- 6:04Speaker 5: a handful of features like that that they have added.
- 6:07Speaker 5: You can turn off if you go into the settings,
- 6:10Speaker 5: you can turn off the data that is used about
- 6:12Speaker 5: you for ads. I think as a practical matter, these
- 6:16Speaker 5: features may not be used all that frequently. I know
- 6:19Speaker 5: my teenager doesn't jump to find those features, and I
- 6:24Speaker 5: suspect that's true of many many other teams as well.
- 6:27Speaker 5: So I think the negotiation here before this lawsuit was filed,
- 6:32Speaker 5: was trying to push the states, likely trying to push
- 6:35Speaker 5: Meta to find more features and more effective features. And
- 6:39Speaker 5: I think eventually, if you saw this lawsuit settle, you
- 6:42Speaker 5: might see a push for even more in that direction,
- 6:46Speaker 5: more effective features to discourage the use of the network
- 6:50Speaker 5: so frequently by young users.
- 6:52Speaker 1: Would they have to actually change the algorithm? Would Meta
- 6:55Speaker 1: have to change its algorithm?
- 6:57Speaker 5: That's the question. It starts to become maybe a difficult
- 7:01Speaker 5: solution because, as we've talked about, this is really focused
- 7:04Speaker 5: on young users. And is there even a way for
- 7:07Speaker 5: the company to tailor a fix that changes the algorithm
- 7:11Speaker 5: just for teens. I don't know. That's probably part of
- 7:15Speaker 5: the conversation, and it has a technical component that probably
- 7:19Speaker 5: makes it tricky as well.
- 7:20Speaker 1: Yeah, because I was listening at the press conference by
- 7:24Speaker 1: the Washington a G he had two teenagers talk about this,
- 7:29Speaker 1: and they were so self aware of what was happening,
- 7:34Speaker 1: and yet they still couldn't get away from it. Listen
- 7:37Speaker 1: to the things that one of the teenagers tried.
- 7:41Speaker 4: I've done a lot of different methods to try to
- 7:44Speaker 4: prevent engagement with Instagram. I've created time limits, I've created
- 7:48Speaker 4: like an app that you have to open first to
- 7:51Speaker 4: breathe and then to engage with Instagram. But all of
- 7:55Speaker 4: these methods eventually fail because I understand that it's up
- 7:58Speaker 4: to my own discretion and the promise of gaining connection
- 8:03Speaker 4: with my peers owas seems to be more important.
- 8:09Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean, I think that's the allegation that it's
- 8:12Speaker 5: so inviting and so difficult for young users to look away,
- 8:17Speaker 5: that the companies need to make changes here. Now, it's
- 8:21Speaker 5: sort of a tricky First Amendment problem here. I mean,
- 8:24Speaker 5: in the media, there's always been allegations about, you know,
- 8:28Speaker 5: the next form of media and the harm that it's
- 8:30Speaker 5: causing to you. So you can go back to the
- 8:32Speaker 5: nineteen seventies and the Federal Trade Commission was going to
- 8:35Speaker 5: go after advertising to kids that made them eat onhealthy things,
- 8:41Speaker 5: and there was a big to do over that, and
- 8:44Speaker 5: ultimately that sort of fizzled as well. And so you wonder,
- 8:48Speaker 5: especially in light of the serious First Amendment arguments that
- 8:51Speaker 5: Meta is going to make to say, look, we have
- 8:54Speaker 5: the right to organize speech on our platform and to
- 8:58Speaker 5: make it enticing, to make it, you know, so useful
- 9:01Speaker 5: and engaging for our users. That's sort of a fundamental
- 9:04Speaker 5: First Amendment right. What they can't do is mislead about it.
- 9:08Speaker 5: So that's what if we get right back down to
- 9:10Speaker 5: the key legal element here is did they mislead? Did
- 9:13Speaker 5: they know something and then tell the world the opposite.
- 9:17Speaker 1: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, I'll continue
- 9:19Speaker 1: this conversation with Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Matthew Shettenhelm, and we'll
- 9:23Speaker 1: talk about emotion for summary judgment that's coming up this week.
- 9:28Speaker 1: In some other lawsuits against social media platforms, I'm June
- 9:32Speaker 1: Grosso and this is Bloomberg. The Attorney General for Washington State,
- 9:36Speaker 1: Bob Ferguson, is one of the forty one state ags
- 9:41Speaker 1: suing Meta platforms, claiming Instagram and Facebook exploit young people
- 9:46Speaker 1: for profit by building an addictive features that are harming
- 9:50Speaker 1: their mental health.
- 9:51Speaker 2: Not only did Meta know the risks these features posed
- 9:54Speaker 2: to children and teens, the company's own research demonstrate the
- 9:57Speaker 2: potential for psychological and physical.
- 10:00Speaker 1: I've been talking to Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Matthew Shettenhelm, and
- 10:05Speaker 1: our children or teenagers particularly attractive demographic for businesses and advertisers.
- 10:13Speaker 5: Yeah, I think it's it's important for the company to
- 10:16Speaker 5: facilitate engagement in young users because young users look at
- 10:21Speaker 5: they are important a source for advertisers to go after,
- 10:26Speaker 5: and young users grow up to be older users, and
- 10:29Speaker 5: so that the more you can engage them at a
- 10:33Speaker 5: young age, that only makes them, you know, use the
- 10:36Speaker 5: product more in later years. So I do think it's
- 10:39Speaker 5: an important demographic now. Metas pushed back on that a
- 10:42Speaker 5: little bit and said, it really maybe isn't a large
- 10:46Speaker 5: goal to keep youthful users on the service for you know,
- 10:50Speaker 5: extended amounts of times. I think that's going to be
- 10:52Speaker 5: an issue in this case is how much has Meta
- 10:55Speaker 5: said that that is or is not a goal to
- 10:57Speaker 5: keep young users spending time the platform.
- 11:01Speaker 1: The suit also accuses Meta of violating the Children's Online
- 11:05Speaker 1: Privacy Protection.
- 11:06Speaker 5: Act right so that you know, I almost read it
- 11:08Speaker 5: like a throw in. They kind of throw that in
- 11:10Speaker 5: at the back of the suit maybe to get this
- 11:12Speaker 5: into federal courts, because all these other things are state
- 11:15Speaker 5: law claims that you would think maybe would be brought
- 11:19Speaker 5: state by state in their own courts. By having a
- 11:21Speaker 5: federal claim in there, then you say, all these other
- 11:25Speaker 5: state claims are sort of supplemental to it, and so
- 11:27Speaker 5: one federal court should take the whole thing at one time.
- 11:30Speaker 5: But the federal claim focuses on the idea that for
- 11:33Speaker 5: the youngest users, those under thirteen, this federal law says
- 11:36Speaker 5: you have to have the parents make the decision about
- 11:40Speaker 5: whether the kids' data can be used for ad targeting
- 11:43Speaker 5: and have to get their consent and the allegation here
- 11:45Speaker 5: is that Facebook knew that some of these users were
- 11:49Speaker 5: under thirteen years old, and it nevertheless let them use
- 11:54Speaker 5: the system without getting proper parental approval.
- 11:58Speaker 1: My daughter is well paid the teenage years. So let
- 12:01Speaker 1: me ask you this. When there are these rules that
- 12:03Speaker 1: you have to get parental permission, how is that implemented
- 12:07Speaker 1: when you're online.
- 12:10Speaker 5: I mean, it's a problem with this law too in
- 12:14Speaker 5: one other sense as well, that it only applies. Facebook
- 12:17Speaker 5: only is vulnerable to the law if it knows it
- 12:22Speaker 5: knowingly allows users under thirteen to go on the site.
- 12:27Speaker 5: And so that's the first problem that a lot of
- 12:29Speaker 5: times kids are going on and filling this in. And
- 12:32Speaker 5: as long as Facebook doesn't know that the kids are
- 12:35Speaker 5: going on below age thirteen without getting parental approval, then
- 12:39Speaker 5: it's at least theoretically protected from liability. But otherwise I
- 12:44Speaker 5: think there's sort of a notification process where once you
- 12:47Speaker 5: fill in that hey, I'm younger than thirteen years old,
- 12:51Speaker 5: then there's going to be pop up screens that require
- 12:54Speaker 5: a second level of approvals and sign off from a parent.
- 12:58Speaker 5: But if the kid misleads in that first answer to
- 13:01Speaker 5: the question, that's where it gets kind of tricky.
- 13:04Speaker 1: When I first heard about this lawsuit, I thought, well,
- 13:07Speaker 1: there have been other lawsuits like this, right, I keep
- 13:10Speaker 1: hearing about lawsuits against platforms. What happens to them?
- 13:14Speaker 5: Yeah, So this is just one piece of a much
- 13:18Speaker 5: larger sort of legal puzzle I think here on exactly
- 13:21Speaker 5: this issue. So you know, as I said, there's this
- 13:24Speaker 5: other lawsuits that is going ahead Friday of this week
- 13:28Speaker 5: in the Northern District of California that says, look, social
- 13:31Speaker 5: media itself is a defective product and the companies are
- 13:35Speaker 5: negligent just by putting it out there exactly for these
- 13:38Speaker 5: features we talked about, you know, in facilitating engagement of
- 13:41Speaker 5: youth and the harm it and inflicts on you know,
- 13:45Speaker 5: mental health for youth across the country. Is that itself
- 13:49Speaker 5: defective And so that suit's going to play out. As
- 13:52Speaker 5: we've talked about before, there's this liability shield Section two
- 13:56Speaker 5: thirty liability shield. Usually Facebook didn't face lawsuit for bad
- 14:01Speaker 5: stuff on its system because of the liability shield. Increasingly
- 14:04Speaker 5: courts are reading that real narrowly and so these cases
- 14:08Speaker 5: can move ahead in a way that they hadn't before.
- 14:11Speaker 5: The Federal Trade Commission is going after Meta on its
- 14:15Speaker 5: targeting of youth. So it's really it's a storm here
- 14:18Speaker 5: on multiple levels. And the real elephant in the room
- 14:21Speaker 5: is what's Congress going to do about it. Congress hasn't
- 14:24Speaker 5: been able to pass a law restricting the use of
- 14:28Speaker 5: data from kids or advertising to kids, and so the
- 14:32Speaker 5: real question is is Congress going to be able to
- 14:35Speaker 5: step in with something here? In the meantime, this is
- 14:39Speaker 5: an effort to use existing old law to try to
- 14:42Speaker 5: go after these companies, and that's often not easy. So
- 14:45Speaker 5: I think the companies can win these cases, fight this
- 14:48Speaker 5: stuff off, although I mean it's not easy. It can
- 14:50Speaker 5: be difficult. In a lot of cases.
- 14:52Speaker 1: It seems like meta it's part of the cost of
- 14:55Speaker 1: doing business. It's been fighting with the Federal Trade Commission for.
- 14:59Speaker 5: How long exactly right. It did a five million dollars
- 15:02Speaker 5: settlement on its data issues is part of the Cambridge
- 15:06Speaker 5: Analytica matter, and that hasn't been the end of the story.
- 15:10Speaker 5: Now under Lena Khan, the Federal Trade Commission is trying
- 15:12Speaker 5: to reopen that settlement and ban exactly what we're talking
- 15:16Speaker 5: about here, the use of data to advertise to kids.
- 15:20Speaker 5: There was a court hearing I went to in Washington,
- 15:23Speaker 5: I think just last week on exactly that question, can
- 15:26Speaker 5: the FTC ban that just by reopening the twenty twenty settlement.
- 15:30Speaker 5: So this is part of life for a company like
- 15:34Speaker 5: Meta these days. And these are lawsuits that are difficult,
- 15:37Speaker 5: but there are lawsuits that you know, you're applying old
- 15:40Speaker 5: law to new technology, and their lawsuits that often I
- 15:43Speaker 5: think the companies can win, but it's not always going
- 15:46Speaker 5: to be easy.
- 15:47Speaker 1: You know, I'm surprised that Congress hasn't been well. I'm
- 15:49Speaker 1: not surprised surprised that Congress hasn't been able to do
- 15:54Speaker 1: something about, you know, the young users, because you know,
- 15:57Speaker 1: with this lawsuit, you have bipartisan attorneys general from blue
- 16:02Speaker 1: states and red states and purple states joining together to
- 16:05Speaker 1: sue Meta. So it's surprising that Congress can't get together.
- 16:09Speaker 5: That's a great point. And there is a law piece
- 16:12Speaker 5: of legislation that has advanced in Congress known as the
- 16:15Speaker 5: Kids Online Safety Act, and it has over forty co
- 16:19Speaker 5: sponsors in the Senate. Right now, it's just so difficult
- 16:24Speaker 5: for Congress to agree on anything. I mean, right now
- 16:27Speaker 5: they're struggling just to agree on who their leaders will be.
- 16:31Speaker 5: And you know, all of these proposed laws have just
- 16:35Speaker 5: struggled to advance very far. But you're exactly right. This
- 16:39Speaker 5: has bipartisan support, and as I said that Kids Online
- 16:42Speaker 5: Safety Act, you know, it probably has a better chance
- 16:46Speaker 5: than most pieces of legislation. So you could see some
- 16:49Speaker 5: movement there if Congress can get attacked together.
- 16:52Speaker 1: Also, I mean TikTok I always thought was the most
- 16:57Speaker 1: addictive of these platforms for.
- 17:00Speaker 5: Kids, right right, I think that's that's right, and it's
- 17:04Speaker 5: very popular with the kids. Some of the lawsuits have
- 17:07Speaker 5: targeted TikTok as well, as I said that the one
- 17:10Speaker 5: that's pending in the Northern District of California that will
- 17:13Speaker 5: be heard on Friday, that targets TikTok as well as Meta,
- 17:16Speaker 5: as well as a couple of the other social media networks.
- 17:20Speaker 5: This new one doesn't target TikTok, but we could see
- 17:23Speaker 5: follow on actions from the states I think going after
- 17:26Speaker 5: TikTok as well.
- 17:27Speaker 1: Well, we'll have to check back with you to find
- 17:30Speaker 1: out what happens on Friday at that hearing. Thanks so much, Matt.
- 17:34Speaker 1: That's Matthew Shechttenhelm, Bloomberg intelligence analyst. Coming up next on
- 17:38Speaker 1: The Bloomberg Law Show. Instagram promoters test the limits of
- 17:42Speaker 1: a ninety year old securities law. This is Bloomberg.
- 17:47Speaker 6: Welcome back to real estate investing made simple. Grant Cardone
- 17:50Speaker 6: here in the car Doon Zone. Every Monday, I said, Steve,
- 17:53Speaker 6: what I hey you?
- 17:54Speaker 3: Last month?
- 17:54Speaker 6: Steve was paid thirty one twenty dollars last month because
- 18:00Speaker 6: the invested at Cardoncapital dot Com, Cardoncapital dot Com, Cardoncapital
- 18:05Speaker 6: dot Com.
- 18:06Speaker 1: This month, the Supreme Court declined to hear a case
- 18:09Speaker 1: involving a lawsuit against real estate management company cardone Capital
- 18:15Speaker 1: and its CEO, Grant Cardone, for misleading statements in YouTube
- 18:19Speaker 1: and Instagram videos. The lawsuit was dismissed on other grounds
- 18:24Speaker 1: days after the justices refused the case, But the core
- 18:27Speaker 1: issue remains, what does it mean to sell securities in
- 18:31Speaker 1: the age of YouTube and Instagram? As venture capital firms
- 18:35Speaker 1: and others hyping investment projects online are facing lawsuits from
- 18:40Speaker 1: disgruntled buyers. Joining me is Anne Lipton, a business law
- 18:44Speaker 1: professor at Tulane University. Start with the real basics, which
- 18:49Speaker 1: is tell us about the provision in the thirty three
- 18:53Speaker 1: Securities Act that allows sellers to sue over unregistered securities.
- 19:00Speaker 7: Okay, so Section twelve is from the nineteen thirty three
- 19:02Speaker 7: Securities Act, and it basically has two separate provisions. The
- 19:06Speaker 7: first is that a purchaser of a security that was
- 19:09Speaker 7: sold unregistered when it should have been registered has a
- 19:13Speaker 7: right to sue the seller. Basically, it's a right of recision.
- 19:16Speaker 7: They can give the security back and ask for their
- 19:19Speaker 7: money back minus any income they've earned on it, so
- 19:23Speaker 7: they can sue whoever sold it to them if it
- 19:25Speaker 7: was sold in violation of the registration provisions. And then secondly,
- 19:29Speaker 7: they can sue anyone who sold it to them or
- 19:32Speaker 7: who solicited the purchase if the prospectus or sales documents
- 19:38Speaker 7: contained false statements. Now, sometimes there's a bit of a
- 19:42Speaker 7: debate about what counts as a prospectus, but what it
- 19:44Speaker 7: comes down to is that this is sometimes a more
- 19:47Speaker 7: attractive option than say, more traditional ways of suing for
- 19:50Speaker 7: false statements, like Section ten B, which is the anti
- 19:53Speaker 7: fraud statute, because if you sue for false statements in
- 19:56Speaker 7: connection with essentially these unregistered ccurity sales under section twelve,
- 20:02Speaker 7: you don't have to a show that you relied on
- 20:05Speaker 7: the false statement, and you don't have to show that
- 20:06Speaker 7: there was any intent to make a false statement, and so.
- 20:09Speaker 1: How did the Supreme Court define a seller in nineteen eighty.
- 20:15Speaker 7: Eight, So in the case of Pitter versus Doll, there
- 20:17Speaker 7: was a question of who counts as a statutory seller.
- 20:20Speaker 7: In other words, Section twelve speaks of people who sell securities.
- 20:24Speaker 7: So the question was, do you have to be actually
- 20:26Speaker 7: the person who transfer the title me to you or
- 20:28Speaker 7: could it be other people who are somewhat involved with
- 20:31Speaker 7: the sale. And the court first said it has to
- 20:34Speaker 7: be either a direct transfer of title or it has
- 20:38Speaker 7: to be someone who solicited the purchase. But they drew
- 20:41Speaker 7: a distinction between someone who is somehow involved and had
- 20:46Speaker 7: something to do with the buyer actively going out and
- 20:49Speaker 7: purchasing the security, and instead they said they have to
- 20:52Speaker 7: have actually solicited and had some kind of relationship with
- 20:56Speaker 7: the buyer. They rejected a test that would be somehow
- 20:59Speaker 7: like people who are just substantially participate in the sale.
- 21:03Speaker 7: So that was interpreted by courts to mean that you
- 21:06Speaker 7: could only be liable under section twelve if you literally
- 21:09Speaker 7: transferred title it was your security and you sold it
- 21:12Speaker 7: to someone else, or if you had some kind of
- 21:16Speaker 7: direct contact with a relationship with the buyer so that
- 21:19Speaker 7: you induced the purchase that way.
- 21:21Speaker 1: So in our world of social media, where venture capital
- 21:25Speaker 1: firms and others are hyping investment projects online, are courts
- 21:31Speaker 1: having a difficult time determining whether they're sellers or not.
- 21:36Speaker 7: Yeah. So the issue here is that after Pinter versus Doll,
- 21:39Speaker 7: there were a bunch of cases involving what were basically
- 21:43Speaker 7: registered offerings. They were registered offerings, they were IPOs where
- 21:47Speaker 7: people sued for false statements in the IPO documents. Now
- 21:50Speaker 7: there's a cause of action specifically for that false statements
- 21:53Speaker 7: in a registration statement under section eleven, and they would
- 21:56Speaker 7: also sue under section twelve because Section twelve has liability
- 22:00Speaker 7: both for unregistered offerings, which these weren't, or for false
- 22:03Speaker 7: statements and a perspective, and courts rejected the Section twelve
- 22:07Speaker 7: liability looking at Pinter in a lot of cases where
- 22:11Speaker 7: there was no direct contact with the buyer. So for example,
- 22:15Speaker 7: issuing companies, it was their security, but they sold in
- 22:19Speaker 7: a firm commitment underwriting, meaning the underwriters bought the securities
- 22:22Speaker 7: from the issuer. The underwriters then sold to the public.
- 22:25Speaker 7: The producer would try to sue the issuer under section
- 22:27Speaker 7: twelve because the issuer's name is all over the perspectives.
- 22:30Speaker 7: It's like their company, it's their securities being sold, and
- 22:34Speaker 7: the courts would say the issuer did not have enough
- 22:37Speaker 7: direct involvement with this particular sale to this buyer to
- 22:41Speaker 7: justify imposing Section twelve viability. Now, you could still have
- 22:45Speaker 7: other forms of liability because these were registered offerings, but
- 22:48Speaker 7: you couldn't have liability under section twelve. So the court
- 22:51Speaker 7: reading pincher vicious now very narrowly to mean you have
- 22:53Speaker 7: to have had some kind of contact with a relationship
- 22:56Speaker 7: with the buyer. So now we fast forward to crypto,
- 22:58Speaker 7: and the problem is there is an alternative scheme because crypto,
- 23:02Speaker 7: assuming it's a security, which is a whole everything, but
- 23:04Speaker 7: let's assume is a security. If crypto is a security,
- 23:08Speaker 7: it's not registered. So the liability regime that was available
- 23:12Speaker 7: in those IPO cases for registered offerings is not available
- 23:16Speaker 7: to these shareholders. So for these shareholders, Section twelve is
- 23:21Speaker 7: sort of the main potential avenue of liability other than
- 23:25Speaker 7: the anti fraud laws, which are hard. There's much harder.
- 23:28Speaker 7: So they're suing under section twelve because that's it. And
- 23:32Speaker 7: what we've seen now is too Appellate Court said, direct contact,
- 23:35Speaker 7: we never said that. We are you talking about known
- 23:38Speaker 7: as it's talent is a solicitation. As long as you
- 23:41Speaker 7: make these public statements in advertising urging people to buy,
- 23:45Speaker 7: that's a solicitation, even if there's no personal relationship. Meanwhile,
- 23:48Speaker 7: there are at least a couple of other decisions that say, no,
- 23:51Speaker 7: we're sticking to the old interpretations of pinter that there
- 23:54Speaker 7: have to be this kind of direct relationship. And then
- 23:57Speaker 7: you have courts that are sort of like saying, like
- 24:00Speaker 7: in a case against Coinbase, that Coinbase with air drops
- 24:04Speaker 7: and materials about particular securities, that wasn't a solicitation. But
- 24:07Speaker 7: it's not exactly clear why, you know, the court just
- 24:11Speaker 7: says that's not enough. So we don't know exactly what's
- 24:14Speaker 7: enough or what exactly the regime is going to be.
- 24:17Speaker 1: The Supreme Court decided not to take a case involving
- 24:20Speaker 1: cardone Capital. Tell us a little about the issues there, Well,
- 24:25Speaker 1: that was the.
- 24:25Speaker 7: Case that was Actually it wasn't a registered offering. I
- 24:27Speaker 7: believe it was under Regulation A. So Regulation A is
- 24:31Speaker 7: an exemption from a full on registered offerings, but it
- 24:35Speaker 7: does require some degree of filing and disclosure. With the SEC,
- 24:39Speaker 7: so it wasn't an unregistered offering. But because it's not
- 24:44Speaker 7: registered offerings, the standard protections available in registered offerings are
- 24:47Speaker 7: not available to purchasers. Instead, the only liability available would be,
- 24:51Speaker 7: you know, just straight up fraud, which is again very
- 24:53Speaker 7: hard to prove, or Section twelve liability. That's what's available.
- 24:57Speaker 7: And so this real estate company, they use social media
- 25:01Speaker 7: to advertise the offering that was filed with the SEC.
- 25:05Speaker 7: They had documents with the SEC and so forth, and
- 25:06Speaker 7: shareholders claimed that these advertisements were solicitations. In the Ninth
- 25:11Speaker 7: Circuit agreed and repudiated. I mean, you know, some of
- 25:14Speaker 7: the case law that had held there must be direct
- 25:16Speaker 7: contact hadn't come out of the Ninth Circuit, so at
- 25:18Speaker 7: very least it was disagreeing with you know, the other
- 25:21Speaker 7: courts that had imposed something like a direct contact requirement.
- 25:25Speaker 7: But the Supreme Court denied sort you know, I mean,
- 25:28Speaker 7: there are any number of reasons why they could have
- 25:30Speaker 7: denied CIRT. But one possibility is that the social media
- 25:33Speaker 7: cases are new. They're you know, looking to this old
- 25:37Speaker 7: precedent that was generated under IPO situations, and you know,
- 25:40Speaker 7: it may take some time to work through the court
- 25:43Speaker 7: you know, if you ask.
- 25:43Speaker 1: An average person, it doesn't seem like the difficult question.
- 25:47Speaker 1: They're online, they're soliciting. Yeah, they're selling. What makes you difficult?
- 25:53Speaker 7: Well, because the interesting thing is that the word solicit
- 25:56Speaker 7: it doesn't actually appear in the statute. Nothing in the
- 25:59Speaker 7: statutes as imposing liability for solicitation. What the statute says
- 26:04Speaker 7: is imposing liability for selling. The Supreme Court's interpretation of
- 26:08Speaker 7: selling in Printer versus Doll, this case from nineteen eighty
- 26:11Speaker 7: eight is the one that imposed this concept of solicitation
- 26:15Speaker 7: with this very specific kind of definition. And to be honest,
- 26:18Speaker 7: Printer doesn't seem to really understand how security sales work.
- 26:22Speaker 7: There are parts of it that display a kind of
- 26:24Speaker 7: lack of understanding. For instance, there's a line in it
- 26:28Speaker 7: that says you can't have liability for a seller seller
- 26:31Speaker 7: that if you sell to somebody and that person sells
- 26:33Speaker 7: to someone else, the original seller isn't going to be liable.
- 26:36Speaker 7: But that's a firm commitment underwriting, and courts are struggling
- 26:39Speaker 7: with that. The sec has been struggling with that ever
- 26:41Speaker 7: since Pinter versus Doll held it. So, you know, this
- 26:44Speaker 7: concept of solicitation and exactly how we're defining it is
- 26:47Speaker 7: not in the statute. It comes from the Supreme Court
- 26:49Speaker 7: case launch. So now we're all trying to figure out
- 26:51Speaker 7: what the Supreme Court meant and how you translate a
- 26:53Speaker 7: case in nineteen eighty eight to today.
- 26:56Speaker 1: So the Ninth and the Eleventh Circuits are they in
- 26:59Speaker 1: sync ruling?
- 27:01Speaker 7: Yeah, it's they seem to be following the same path
- 27:03Speaker 7: that you know, at least, at the very least, these
- 27:05Speaker 7: sort of widespread social media campaigns are sufficient. But what's
- 27:09Speaker 7: really unclear is like what would be like, I mean, like,
- 27:11Speaker 7: once you take away the requirement of direct contact, which
- 27:14Speaker 7: is how courts seem to be reading it before, then
- 27:17Speaker 7: there's the question of well, how much urging is enough?
- 27:21Speaker 7: And that was exactly what happened with coinbase, where you know,
- 27:24Speaker 7: Coinbase technically it did have direct contact. It was talking
- 27:27Speaker 7: to its customers and it you know, it does whatever
- 27:29Speaker 7: it does to say, you know, here's an airdrop of
- 27:31Speaker 7: a new security or whatever, and a court said, well,
- 27:32Speaker 7: that's just not enough. So now we have all kinds
- 27:35Speaker 7: of questions like if social media is permissible, if you
- 27:37Speaker 7: don't have the restriction of direct contact, then how much
- 27:41Speaker 7: urging is enough to qualify solicitation, given that in Pinter,
- 27:46Speaker 7: the Supreme Court's concern was, we don't want just substantial
- 27:50Speaker 7: participation to be enough. And the reason we don't was
- 27:52Speaker 7: because we want people to have certainty as to when
- 27:54Speaker 7: they are potentially liable or not. It's important that we
- 27:56Speaker 7: have certainty. Direct contact at least, that's that's a rule
- 28:00Speaker 7: be the best rule. It may not be the most
- 28:01Speaker 7: functional rule, but we know what it means. We know
- 28:04Speaker 7: when we see in. Now we're in this space where
- 28:07Speaker 7: it's not clear what's going to be enough and.
- 28:09Speaker 1: Which circuits have a different take on this than the
- 28:12Speaker 1: ninth and the eleventh.
- 28:14Speaker 7: There are several circuits that implied anyway, especially in these
- 28:17Speaker 7: IPO cases, that you needed something like direct contact. The
- 28:20Speaker 7: third circuit, the first circuit, the fifth circuit. I know,
- 28:23Speaker 7: there's definitely a district Core case involving crypto that followed
- 28:28Speaker 7: in the second circuit that followed these cases to say no,
- 28:31Speaker 7: you need something like direct contact, although sometimes the phrasing
- 28:35Speaker 7: they use is sort of unclear because they say direct
- 28:37Speaker 7: contact or active solicitation, and it's not exactly clear what
- 28:40Speaker 7: they mean by active.
- 28:41Speaker 1: Why don't these quote sellers want to register just to
- 28:46Speaker 1: be safe.
- 28:47Speaker 7: So first of all, the crypto people all say that
- 28:49Speaker 7: these aren't securities anyway. But the whole point is that
- 28:51Speaker 7: like registration, if you register them that there's a terrific
- 28:56Speaker 7: amount of disclosure you have to make and there's very
- 29:00Speaker 7: strict liability if those disclosures are false. That's why courts
- 29:03Speaker 7: could get away for so long saying well, we won't
- 29:05Speaker 7: have Section twelve liability for these IPO situations because there
- 29:09Speaker 7: were alternatives. There's some very strict liability for false statements.
- 29:12Speaker 7: If you register, you have to do a terrific amount
- 29:14Speaker 7: of disclosure. It's very expensive and you're risking this liability.
- 29:18Speaker 7: And a lot of crypto people say that the registration requirements,
- 29:22Speaker 7: like the disclosure requirements that attach, are simply not suitable
- 29:27Speaker 7: for crypto, like they ask for things that don't make
- 29:29Speaker 7: sense in the crypto context, like principles of an organization
- 29:32Speaker 7: when it's a decentralized autonomous organization, or addresses when there
- 29:36Speaker 7: is no address. So the crypto people will say that
- 29:39Speaker 7: not only is disclosure expensive and opens us up to
- 29:42Speaker 7: all this liability, but the SEC hasn't updated the registration
- 29:46Speaker 7: requirements to really make sense in a crypto world.
- 29:50Speaker 1: So then will it be up to the Supreme Court
- 29:52Speaker 1: to clarify this so that there is clearer guidance?
- 29:56Speaker 7: Very possibly. I mean, you know, there's a lot that
- 29:58Speaker 7: could happen in between. And then, I mean, first of all,
- 30:01Speaker 7: if all the circuits come to settle on something, I mean,
- 30:04Speaker 7: the Supreme Court doesn't have the kind of passion for
- 30:07Speaker 7: securities cases that say I do. So if the circuits
- 30:12Speaker 7: coalesce around a principle that's coherent, then the Supreme Court
- 30:16Speaker 7: may not step in at all. And you know, we
- 30:19Speaker 7: can all argue about it. But you know, I'm not
- 30:21Speaker 7: convinced that crypto is, you know, the wave of the future.
- 30:25Speaker 7: So at some point, if crypto has becomes less popular,
- 30:28Speaker 7: then we may just see less of these cases. I mean,
- 30:31Speaker 7: Regulation A was how this came up in the Ninth Circuit,
- 30:35Speaker 7: and that will still exist because that's sort of a
- 30:37Speaker 7: formal disclosure space for securities that you don't want to
- 30:40Speaker 7: do full registration for. But reggae isn't really that popular
- 30:43Speaker 7: to begin with. So I mean, if crypto becomes less
- 30:47Speaker 7: of a thing, it may simply be that this kind
- 30:50Speaker 7: of settles down by itself.
- 30:52Speaker 1: Well, it's been great to talk to you, Anne. I
- 30:55Speaker 1: love your enthusiasm about securities law. That's Anne Lipton, a
- 30:59Speaker 1: business professor at Tulane University. And that's it for this
- 31:03Speaker 1: edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always
- 31:06Speaker 1: get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law podcasts.
- 31:09Speaker 1: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 31:12Speaker 1: www dot Bloomberg dot com slash podcast Slash Law, And
- 31:17Speaker 1: remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight
- 31:21Speaker 1: at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and
- 31:24Speaker 1: you're listening to Bloomberg