Latest / Deconstructing Horror / BRIGHTBURN (2019) | Evil Superman: What Superhero Horror Reveals About Power
Transcript
- Ryan Does: Supergirl is hitting theaters very, very soon. And that got me thinking about superpowered beings and what we often do with Superman-esque figures fiction, specifically horror fiction. ⁓ Big fan of James Gunn, what he's done over at Marvel, what he's doing at DC. I really enjoyed Superman last summer. I enjoyed Creature Commandos, a lot of what's going on over at DC, both in comics and movies. I'm a big fan of. since we Have this obsession with Superman and twisted versions of Superman. I thought that's something worth investigating on the eve of Supergirl. So am out here ⁓ my porch, I'm just having a delicious cup of coffee, ⁓ ⁓ wanted to try a different kind of video episode ⁓ because. Sometimes there's a movie that pops up in my head, and I can't can't line up ⁓ friend to talk about that specific movie ⁓ time, ⁓ I just like I've I've got to talk about it now. ⁓ this such a ⁓ ripe season ⁓ for superhero movies, I wanted to look the specific subgenre ⁓ horror of ⁓ horror. So since it's James Gunn, I back ⁓ and Brightburn from 2019, ⁓ a that I had heard about, ⁓ I seen the trailer of, ⁓ and I had ⁓ convinced that horror movies weren't ⁓ scary me, ⁓ I didn't if I wanted to watch Brightburn. ⁓ Well, ⁓ watched ⁓ and I'm super glad I did. ⁓ just wanted to share a few ⁓ thoughts on the ⁓ Superman trope, ⁓ ⁓ superpowered being, what happens with powers of Superman if they to be so altruistic. And Brightburn really is it's good origin story version ⁓ of would happen. And obviously in ⁓ book fiction, there been alternate Supermans for a while now. ⁓ Right now, you people probably think most commonly of Homelander, ⁓ of Omniman from my personal favorite, ⁓ that I ⁓ really would to come back around to because I find him especially interesting. And that's not even to mention the Superman. variants within DC comics. Superman from Injustice is another good example as well of what happens ⁓ when ⁓ ultimate power ⁓ is ⁓ ⁓ in the direction of ⁓ evil ⁓ and of or good. So Brightburn, 2019 film. It's got James Gunn ⁓ influence, it's got gun family in influence all over, especially in the screenplay. I attracted to this movie ⁓ for few different reasons. One, the concept of a ⁓ being a villain, essentially a slasher villain, is intriguing to ⁓ I had not that idea on ⁓ film yet. I the the the the cast Elizabeth Banks leading this cast was perfect. I think she is the heart and soul of this movie. She's the tension, she's the the person that hopes it's not true and ⁓ realizes my goodness, ⁓ this true. And ⁓ ⁓ maybe this not as simple as I it was going to be. The story really Flips the script ⁓ Superman origin ⁓ ⁓ alien child from another planet being found by a family ⁓ being raised well, being raised to be kind, being raised to be loving, ⁓ all that. the movie subverts by Brandon, ⁓ the Clark stand-in, having Brandon When he reaches puberty and maturity and he starts growing, has him activated by ship that brought him to Earth ⁓ to take the world. And I that is it's a simple ⁓ and I think someone an ultimate power, a Superman-esque power. ⁓ for a young for a young man in the of confusion ⁓ that of life where everything up in the air, giving them such vague a vague command right terrible things happening because reacts so ⁓ To all these different triggers, ⁓ being told no, being confronted, ⁓ wanting to know, hey, girl looked at me a certain way. What does that mean? having those kind of ⁓ physical tensions. And I this movie plays out in a really sick but ⁓ also way. ⁓ it ⁓ I think of the things it does well is it to really help you understand Brandon. But things he does are so monstrous. And things ⁓ he are so unfeeling un un un emotive even though they're being triggered by very very emotional things so the ⁓ the mirror superman this ⁓ became really really clear and ⁓ one because the iconography the the red cape ⁓ the spaceship the farmhouse ⁓ but then some of the Things they take from action comics number one. ⁓ his uncle ⁓ ⁓ car, being him being smashed into the front of the car. ⁓ That ⁓ a really well done scene. And I'm sure the gun the gun family, James and ⁓ his brother and his cousin that were involved in this ⁓ film, I'm sure were just ⁓ eating that up a spoon, like the idea of like, ⁓ my gosh, we can do our own version of that. So I like I like the homages, also Everything that Clark Kent is is what I love about Superman. The the the hope, the empathy, being strong for people that are weak standing the gap for oppressed people. Early on in action comics, this is such a ⁓ an overt, obvious theme. I think carried over really well into Gunn's Superman movie in the summer of 2025. it it it subverts all of the core and themes ⁓ Superman ⁓ I think makes too sense. And I don't mean in a bad way, but I think ⁓ the reason why super superhero horror and Edgier, darker versions of superheroes that don't have as clear-cut moral compasses. I think why that has become so prevalent because we at someone, something with a sense ultimate power, of superior power, and the question to be raised, how could you not that? ⁓ How could someone with so much power not be at least tempted, let alone tempted and then convinced, to use it in a ⁓ in honestly in a hateful motive. Brandon in Brightburn, he uses it in a hateful way when it's revealed that is who he truly is. ⁓ lashes out ⁓ these parents who have loved him his entire life ⁓ who are struggling themselves with what do we do? What we do with this this child ⁓ we've we that not from here. They know they're not his biological parents, ⁓ but they ⁓ an adoptive ⁓ they have taken that emotional mental role of provider of parent and then twisted how could how someone not use ⁓ power ⁓ and it such a a ⁓ great like I said mirror ⁓ to it because ⁓ main iteration Superman we get ⁓ for a of his is He does things for others. in Brightburn Brandon does things for himself. ⁓ part of the horror of that ⁓ ⁓ does not care for others. And is That was watching the movie, that the thing that stood out to me ⁓ the profoundly. Because it everything I love about Superman. ⁓ completely inverted. It speaks to a of something, ⁓ that is good, that is hopeful, that youthful in case. ⁓ Someone that so much ahead of them, someone who has ⁓ so much provided for ⁓ but ⁓ matter that person can still Make decisions in their own interest, ignore the needs of others. And go off on a different path. I I think you you see that sometimes when there's news reports of who does horrific thing. ⁓ Well keep it vague. Someone who does a horrific thing, ⁓ and of the comments is ⁓ they a loving mom, they had a loving dad, they were a straight A student, they were star athlete, they were what whatever you want to say, all these ⁓ exterior To ask the question, well, they were they they were so good. They were doing so well. then this thing happened and it sent them off ⁓ on a different The horror of ⁓ is, yes, the that goes ⁓ throughout the town and he taking his ⁓ confusion, his anger, ⁓ experimenting these powers. He's it out ⁓ on people who have ⁓ either told him no, d actually that's probably the most basic thing, the the the rejection, the ostrization, the feel the othering of him, the the shutting off of him. You see it, of the scenes that was most profound along those lines was when his uncle gives him the gun for his birthday. ⁓ his dad ⁓ says, ⁓ he's young. Brandon instantly that. ⁓ And then they he ruins a birthday party that moment. That feeling of rejection sends him off on a different ⁓ ⁓ ⁓ that he has then he realizes, ⁓ I don't have to be told no anymore. I I don't have to be told no. And ⁓ it is ⁓ it is ⁓ powerful ⁓ ⁓ growing young men specifically. Y this movie a second viewing I I really do need to rewatch it again. And I and I know, it's it's not it's some Stanley Kubrick piece where you're just like I I don't I don't know the real meaning of Brightburn is. But I I do maybe revisiting it and looking at at it back a voice speaking to young men and young masculinity, I think that would be a powerful reviewing. And to of bring this morning coffee of Brightburn leading into Supergirl and continuation of James ⁓ DC ⁓ films. ⁓ I think how movie acts as a dark mirror ⁓ Superman as a concept is worth because are obsessed with evil versions, dramatic retellings of how goes ⁓ And you can see that in the real world when people have power, the the the the common phrase is that absolute power corrupts absolutely. And see that in ⁓ in real world, and it is reflected into our fiction. ⁓ And is a greater example ⁓ of power, Superman, being corrupted Like I said we have these ⁓ examples of homelander, man. There are a tens of other third publishers outside of Marvel and DC who have done their own versions of it. La last year we got a version of a evil Superman in Century during the Thunderbolts film. DC Comics has done so many different alternate versions of Superman, and let's just say most of them are not, you know, you know that good guy? He got better. He got greater. He became more of a nice guy. that not the story that is told. It's what go wrong in Clark's life ⁓ for him not not feed best him. ⁓ And ⁓ I said wanted revisit Omniman, My I think what find interesting about Omni Man is Omni Man a plan. He knew why he was there and he actively lied to everybody. ⁓ And when ⁓ his secret comes out ⁓ that he kills guardians of globe in the episode of Invincible, very on in the Invincible comic. His lack of remorse, his lack of ⁓ he puts on ⁓ beings, specifically Mark, his son Mark's mom. The the remorselessness a being with unchecked power. Not even really giving a thought to the insignificance to the humans on in the first season of Invincible, which if you haven't seen, ⁓ Invincible is a great, a great TV show. it's it's fun, it's great action, and it proposes questions ⁓ centered power. And that important. ⁓ At the end of the season, Omni Man to convince Mark that fighting him is useless because everyone around him is going to die. ⁓ fact that they will not last as long as he is, the fact that they're not as powerful as he is, ⁓ that they are insignificant and not worth his effort to protect. Well, Man at that. And he is doing his version of the logical thing. Like Brandon does in the beginning of Brightburn. I have a feeling that Brandon's story, if it had continued, if it ever continues in any kind of medium, it would play out similar to an Omni-man, where the insignificance of human life ⁓ not able to tell him no leads to horrors. that this this he this potential superhero becomes a menace to the entire world because after all he's been given the mo the motivation of take the world. if he feels no remorse ⁓ what he's doing, the conclusion would be he would just he would keep doing it ⁓ until ⁓ a is made. Like o the thing that gets through to Omni Man is ⁓ the of son. ⁓ The thing that gets through to him is that fragility doesn't mean something not worth something. If if if ⁓ humanity is destined die, it doesn't that there's ⁓ value in living. ⁓ And this comes back to my favorite thing about Superman. favorite thing about Supergirl. ⁓ favorite thing that I ⁓ learned in opposite way from Brightburn. ⁓ And that is that humanity matters. matter how powerful you are, humanity It is it is the that connects us. It is the thing drives us. ⁓ Your regard for others, rem your feeling of remorse over in the hurt of others, the treatment of others, your sense of for fellow man, for your fellow woman, ⁓ for your fellow person. is what separates you being a esque figure. ⁓ from being a in kind of figure. ⁓ I hope, perhaps if you're checking this out, ⁓ I hope that maybe you've benefited from ⁓ me just ⁓ being out here on the porch. drinking my coffee and sharing this ⁓ little journal entry about Brightburn right before super girl hits theaters and James Gunn continues us off on his DC DC universe but yeah if want to check out another video I'm sure there are suggestions around you right now. ⁓ but yeah we'll see in the next one.