Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use At-The-Market Offerings
Transcript
- Luna: Lucas, I keep seeing this term 'ATM offering' in filings — not the cash machine, the capital markets kind. And it feels like every other tech company that went public in the last few years has one on file. What's the deal? Lucas: Yeah, at the market offerings — or ATMs — have become the default capital-raising tool for a lot of post ipo companies. The concept is simple: instead of pricing a big secondary offering all at once, the company sells shares gradually into the open market at prevailing prices. They file a shelf registration with the SEC, then dribble out equity over weeks or months. Lucas: The beauty is the flexibility. If the stock is up, they sell more. If it's down, they pause. No roadshow, no underwriting discount, no single-day price crunch. Just a steady trickle of shares through a broker like Goldman or Morgan Stanley. Luna: Right, so it's like a dripper for capital. And I've noticed Palantir has been particularly active. Their stock surged 15 percent in the last five days — closed at $134.54 today. That's got to be tempting for an ATM program. Lucas: Exactly the kind of moment ATMs are built for. Palantir has had an ATM shelf since late 2020, and they've used it opportunistically. When the stock runs up, they can sell shares into that strength and raise capital with less dilution than if they sold at a lower price. Lucas: In their most recent 10-Q, they disclosed having sold about $1.2 billion worth of stock through their ATM program since inception. That's serious money, and it didn't require a single press release or secondary offering announcement. Luna: So the market doesn't even know they're selling? That seems almost too good to be true. Doesn't the SEC require disclosure? Lucas: They do, but not in real time. Companies disclose ATM sales in their quarterly filings, often weeks after the trades happen. By then, the selling is done. That's actually one of the criticisms — investors can be buying stock while the company is quietly selling into the same demand. Lucas: But the SEC is okay with it because the shelf registration is public, and the company files a prospectus supplement within a day of each sale. It's just that the actual volume is low enough per day that it rarely moves the stock. Luna: So the company is basically acting like a whale that doesn't splash. Compare that to a traditional secondary — where the company announces a $500 million offering, the stock drops 5 percent that day, and everyone feels the pain. Lucas: Right. A secondary offering is a big event. You hire banks, you price after close, you announce the size. The market reacts immediately. With an ATM, you can sell $500 million over three months with barely a ripple. Lucas: And the cost difference is real. A typical secondary might cost 3 to 5 percent in underwriting fees. ATMs usually run 1 to 2 percent. For a company raising $500 million, that's $10 to $20 million saved. Luna: Okay, so who's doing this besides Palantir? I know Coinbase has had one for a while. And Shopify, maybe? Lucas: Yeah, Coinbase filed a $1 billion ATM shelf back in 2021 and has used it periodically. Shopify has one too, though they've been more focused on buybacks lately. Even companies like Rivian — which has been under pressure — have ATMs on file as a backstop. Lucas: Rivian's stock is down over 5 percent in the last five days to $16.41, so they're probably not selling right now. But the option is there if they need liquidity. Luna: That's the thing — it's an option. A lot of companies file the shelf almost like insurance. They might never draw on it, but it's there if a window opens. Or if they suddenly need cash for an acquisition. Lucas: Exactly. And the filing itself is cheap — legal fees, maybe $50,000 to $100,000. Then you have an ATM ready for three years. It's almost irresponsible for a public company not to have one. Lucas: But there's a nuance. ATMs work best for companies with high trading volume and tight spreads. If your stock trades $5 million a day, selling $2 million a day through an ATM would swamp the order book. So it's really a tool for liquid names. Luna: Which brings us back to Palantir, Coinbase, Shopify — these are high-volume tech stocks. Not a biotech micro-cap that trades 50,000 shares a day. Lucas: Right. For small caps, a block trade or a registered direct offering makes more sense. ATMs are for companies that can absorb consistent selling pressure without tanking the stock. Luna: And if today's conversation was useful for understanding how public companies actually manage their capital structure — and especially if you're building or running a business that might go public someday — these episodes stay ad-free thanks to listener support. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small gesture that keeps the podcast independent. No ads, no sponsors, just the real conversation. Appreciate anyone who chips in. Luna: Alright, back to ATMs. One thing I want to dig into — how do investors actually monitor this? If the company is selling shares quietly, what's the early warning sign? Lucas: The best signal is the daily trading volume. If you see unexplained selling pressure — especially on days with no news — it could be an ATM. But the real tell is the company's share count in the next quarterly filing. If the diluted share count jumps 2 percent with no secondary announcement, that's likely ATM activity. Lucas: Some companies even disclose ATM sales in their 8-Ks, but that's voluntary. Most just report it in the 10-Q. Luna: So the investor has to wait up to three months to know. That's a long time to be in the dark. Lucas: It is. And that's why some institutional investors push back. They'd prefer a clean secondary where they know the exact dilution upfront. But for the company, the stealth is the whole point. Luna: Let's talk about an alternative — convertible notes. Some companies choose that over ATMs. How do you decide? Lucas: Convertibles are great when you want to raise capital without immediate dilution, and when interest rates are low enough that the coupon is attractive. But they add debt to the balance sheet and can force dilution later if the stock appreciates. Lucas: ATMs are pure equity. No debt, no interest, no conversion. But the dilution is immediate and permanent. So it's a trade-off between balance sheet flexibility and shareholder dilution. Luna: And timing matters. In a rising rate environment like we've had the last couple years, convertibles become less attractive because the coupon has to be higher. ATMs become relatively more appealing. Lucas: Exactly. And that's part of why we've seen so many ATM filings in 2025 and 2026. Companies want to lock in equity capital while their stock prices are elevated — or at least not crashing. Lucas: Look at Meta. They've done huge buybacks, but they also have an ATM shelf. They haven't used it, but it's there. Same with Alphabet and Amazon. Luna: Interesting that the mega-caps have them too, even though they don't need the cash. It's really just a strategic option. Lucas: It's financial hygiene. You never know when you'll need to raise capital quickly — for an acquisition, a special dividend, or a crisis. Having an ATM ready means you can act in days, not weeks. Luna: So the takeaway for our listeners: if you're investing in a post ipo tech company, check whether they have an ATM shelf. It's a red flag? Not necessarily. But it's something to monitor. Lucas: Yeah, it's not a red flag at all. It's standard practice. But it does mean the company has a tool that can dilute you without warning. As an investor, you should know about it and watch the share count. Lucas: And if you're a founder thinking about going public, get an ATM shelf filed soon after your IPO. It's cheap, it's fast, and it gives you one more lever when you need capital. Luna: Alright, next episode we'll look at something I've been curious about — how companies use pre-arranged trading plans, the so-called 10b5-1 plans, for insider selling. That's another tool that's more nuanced than it sounds. Lucas: Good call. There's been a lot of evolution on that front with the SEC's 2023 amendments. We'll break down what changed and why it matters. Luna: Until then, thanks for listening — and if you found this useful, you know where to find us.