Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When Solar Deals Go Dark: Arbitration Strategies for Energy Disputes
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07When Solar Deals Go Dark, Arbitration Strategies
- 0:11for Energy Disputes. I'm Alapoli Castro, Director
- 0:15of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:17Beverly Hills Bar Association. And I'm delighted
- 0:19to introduce our speaker today, Zee Claiborne.
- 0:22Zee is a mediator and arbitrator with Jams in
- 0:26San Francisco, where she has served as a full
- 0:28-time neutral since 1998. She focuses on complex
- 0:32domestic and international business disputes
- 0:34and has handled a wide range of energy matters,
- 0:37including power purchase agreement disputes involving
- 0:40solar and wind projects, investor and joint venture
- 0:44conflicts over utility scale solar developments,
- 0:47and construction claims arising from solar power
- 0:50plants. She regularly serves as sole arbitrator
- 0:53and as chair of three member panels. Zee is a
- 0:57distinguished fellow and board member of the
- 0:59College of Commercial Arbitrators, a member of
- 1:02the Executive Advisory Committee of the International
- 1:04Institute for Conflict Prevention and Resolution,
- 1:06and a past chair of the ABA Arbitration Institute.
- 1:10She also serves as Judge Pro Tem for the San
- 1:12Francisco Superior Court. Joining Zee today will
- 1:16be Erica Plotz, who's an Associate Director of
- 1:18Practice Development at Jams. She'll be assisting
- 1:21with shepherding your questions for Zee today,
- 1:23so please submit those to the Q &A box on your
- 1:25screen. your screen. We're so excited to hear
- 1:27what Z has to share with us today. So I'm now
- 1:29going to turn it over to her. Thank you, Alla.
- 1:32I appreciate the nice introduction and I'm very
- 1:35happy to be here. I plan to talk about some of
- 1:40the energy disputes that I've dealt with and
- 1:43talk about the growth of these energy disputes.
- 1:47I will also then move on to talking about arbitration.
- 1:51Some of this may be basic to some of you, but
- 1:55some of you may need the information because
- 2:00a lot of these disputes now are going to arbitration.
- 2:04And after that, I will give some tips about handling
- 2:10these cases in addition to what I talk about
- 2:13on the way. The cases, these energy cases are
- 2:17complicated often. They involve technical complexity,
- 2:22they're high litigation costs. They need special
- 2:29handling. And so what I'm going to try to cover
- 2:32for you is kind of a flexible framework for handling
- 2:37sophisticated energy disputes and ways to kind
- 2:41of streamline the process so that it's more manageable.
- 2:46So I made a few notes about some of the kinds
- 2:51of cases Specific cases that I've handled and
- 2:55I thought I'd give you a few examples here just
- 2:58to give you an idea about this field. I have
- 3:02handled cases involving utility scale solar companies
- 3:08in disputes with their investors. These can be
- 3:12very complicated as you can imagine, because
- 3:15they are high dollar matters. There are maybe
- 3:17many sources of investors, many kinds of investors
- 3:21involved, and many different kinds of disputes
- 3:25about perhaps breaches of contract or other matters.
- 3:30Another kind of case that I've handled, construction
- 3:34defects and delay cases where a general contractor
- 3:38say and an owner are in a dispute. One of the
- 3:42biggest ones I had had to do with a very large
- 3:45ground mounted photovoltaic panel solar project
- 3:50where allegedly many things have gone wrong and
- 3:54we had to hear all about it. Another kind of
- 4:00case would be a solar company. Or a win company
- 4:04versus a utility where there is a, a utility
- 4:08like. PG &E, let's say, where there have been
- 4:12alleged breaches of PPAs. And PPAs are power
- 4:16purchase agreements. And generally speaking,
- 4:21the solar company is providing a certain amount
- 4:24of electricity to the utility company at certain
- 4:28timeframes. And so that situation often involves
- 4:33a dispute as well. And there are even cases called
- 4:37virtual PPAs where a company is investing, say,
- 4:42in a wind power project, but not actually taking
- 4:47the electricity. Instead, what they want are
- 4:50the environmental credits that they can apply
- 4:55to their company. And then, let's see, of course,
- 5:00there are disputes over intellectual property
- 5:03and other kind of technological issues. And recently
- 5:09I was asked to participate in kind of an interesting
- 5:12podcast that had to do with delays in delivery
- 5:18of oil and gas due to the closing of the Strait
- 5:22of Hormuz. And we were talking about how arbitration
- 5:28and mediation could be used to help handle those
- 5:31issues that would involve things like, of course,
- 5:35breach of contract, insurance issues, force majeure
- 5:39would be certainly a focus of attention. And
- 5:44it reminded me of times during the pandemic when
- 5:48certain certain equipment from Asia was delayed
- 5:54because of the pandemic. And we had to work on
- 5:59how to handle those issues. Who had liability?
- 6:04How long were the delays? What was the cost?
- 6:06That kind of thing. So when I talk about... energy
- 6:13types, I'm talking about a lot of things, oil
- 6:17and gas, of course, alternative energy, and that
- 6:21would include solar and wind and something like
- 6:24geothermal. I currently have a case that I'm
- 6:29handling that involves biomass electric generation
- 6:32where they're using, say, wood that's taken out
- 6:39of the forest and brought in and chopped up and
- 6:41used as a source of electricity. So it's kind
- 6:44of an interesting area. I would say that these
- 6:50cases are challenging for a lot of reasons because
- 6:54it's high financial exposure. They're complex
- 6:59technically and a lot of testimony covers those
- 7:03kinds of issues. There are a lot of parties involved
- 7:07often and they have different contractual obligations.
- 7:14There's engineering and construction evidence
- 7:16maybe and a lot of focus as I've said on supply
- 7:20chain interruptions and maybe issues of force
- 7:24majeure. And finally, preserving these ongoing
- 7:29commercial relationships. A lot of these companies
- 7:32are in dispute, but they depend on each other.
- 7:36They work together, and they have a history of
- 7:39doing that. And so some of what we're doing,
- 7:42particularly in mediation, is trying to preserve
- 7:45that business relationship. So I wanted to talk.
- 7:53Besides now about types of cases and why we're
- 7:59trying to handle them in some unusual or different
- 8:02ways, I wanted to talk about the dispute resolution
- 8:06process a bit. These disputes often go to mediation
- 8:12and then to arbitration if they're not resolved.
- 8:16And in fact, I think that there's a three -tier
- 8:19approach to a lot of disputes, commercial disputes,
- 8:24not just energy disputes, but other kinds of
- 8:27disputes where there are three steps involved.
- 8:32The first one is the higher ups, the executives
- 8:36and the companies are to try to negotiate on
- 8:40their own and try to reach some sort of resolution.
- 8:43And if that is unsuccessful, the case goes to
- 8:46mediation. And if mediation is unsuccessful,
- 8:50then they move on to arbitration. A lot of times,
- 8:54though, a mediator can work with the parties
- 8:56to resolve part of the case and then help the
- 8:59parties kind of structure the case for arbitration
- 9:02so that it can move forward relatively smoothly.
- 9:09This kind of arbitration is not forced arbitration.
- 9:14The companies have considered this when they
- 9:16went into their contracts in the first place.
- 9:20And so all those contracts have dispute resolution
- 9:23provisions that outline the approach that I just
- 9:28described, the three -step approach or something
- 9:31close to that. also set forth ideas for arbitration
- 9:37if it goes that far. So other commercial cases,
- 9:41as I say, could follow this same kind of pattern.
- 9:45For example, I've handled cryptocurrency cases,
- 9:51breaches of contract involving an AI company,
- 9:55licensing disputes, all kinds of things have
- 9:58this sort of framework, and we use this approach.
- 10:03I would say that the benefit of the arbitration
- 10:08process really is in its flexibility. That is,
- 10:12when you go into arbitration, you can structure
- 10:17the case, you can work with counsel and work
- 10:21with the arbitrators to structure the matter
- 10:24to fit your case and design the process to be
- 10:29both fair and efficient. So it's been my experience,
- 10:33of course, that council always disagree on the
- 10:36merits of the case. I mean, that's that I expect.
- 10:40But they will work with the arbitrator or the
- 10:43panel of three arbitrators in order to structure
- 10:47a case appropriately. And I wanted to talk about
- 10:50how you do that. I'm going to mention JAMS rules.
- 10:57A lot of the rules are very similar at the American
- 11:00Arbitration Association or CPR or the ICC, but
- 11:04I'm just for simplicity sake going to refer to
- 11:07the JAMS rules. So the preliminary conference
- 11:11rule is rule 16, and at some point you might
- 11:14want to take a look at that. There is in the
- 11:18materials for this case, a copy of the agenda
- 11:20that I used before the preliminary conference.
- 11:23So I asked the lawyers to take a look at the
- 11:27agenda and the applicable arbitration rules,
- 11:31which ordinarily would be the jams, commercial
- 11:33rules and procedures before the conference. And
- 11:41then be prepared to talk about how we're going
- 11:44to structure this case so that, or structure
- 11:47this arbitration so that it fits the case at
- 11:51hand. Another thing to review, of course, in
- 11:54advance would be your arbitration agreement because
- 11:58they're sometimes just kind of plain vanilla
- 12:01agreements and everything is. pretty clear and
- 12:05pretty ordinary, but sometimes there are some
- 12:08unusual provisions in the arbitration agreement
- 12:11and we need to pay attention to those in order
- 12:15to go forward under that particular agreement
- 12:18because the arbitration agreement controls how
- 12:22we go ahead. So I would say not to underestimate
- 12:28the importance of the preliminary conference,
- 12:31participate in it. After the lawyers and the
- 12:36parties get together with me and my fellow arbitrators
- 12:40during the preliminary conference, I will issue
- 12:45a scheduling order, which basically is a reflection
- 12:48of everything that we've discussed during the
- 12:51conference. And it lays out the dates and the
- 12:53processes that are going to happen between conference
- 12:57and the hearing date, the first hearing date,
- 13:00and I call that scheduling order the blueprint
- 13:03for the case. It's always a little bit different
- 13:06as the cases are different. And as the case goes
- 13:12forward, the lawyers will generally look back
- 13:15at that order. OK, here's the next step. Here's
- 13:19what we're going to do. So there's a lot that
- 13:24we discuss. in the preliminary conference that
- 13:28is important in thinking about in order to fit
- 13:32the process to the case. So we take a look at
- 13:36the requirements of the arbitration provision.
- 13:40Think about things like which law applies. Usually
- 13:43the provision will say that and the parties agree
- 13:46on it. But sometimes there's a disagreement about
- 13:49which law applies and we have to have some motion
- 13:52work in order to get that issue settled as we
- 13:54get started. Which rules apply? Usually the arbitration
- 14:00agreement will say that, you know, the case is
- 14:04going to go to jams and we're going to go forward
- 14:06under the jams. the JAMS commercial arbitration
- 14:11rules and procedures. Sometimes the parties stipulate
- 14:16to different rules. For example, maybe a case
- 14:20comes in and it says we're going to use the rules
- 14:23of the American Arbitration Association, but
- 14:26the lawyers get together and agree that they're
- 14:29going to use the JAMS rules or it could be vice
- 14:32versa. So those things can be changed. Another
- 14:36thing that is important to consider is whether
- 14:40or not the parties want to use the expedited
- 14:43rules. And I would say that in the case of jams
- 14:47anyway, the expedited rules are for smaller cases
- 14:49than most of these cases. But as part of the
- 14:54general commercial rules, there are provisions
- 14:5816 .1 and 16 .2 that provide for expedited procedures
- 15:04and the parties can agree on those or not, or
- 15:08some of them or not. So that's really something
- 15:10that we talk about in the course of the preliminary
- 15:14conference, our first meeting with the parties
- 15:17and the lawyers. So other questions during that
- 15:22meeting? Are the pleadings complete? And if they're
- 15:26not, we often set a date. And, you know, in arbitration,
- 15:30the pleadings don't necessarily look like the
- 15:32ones that get filed in court. They're often in
- 15:35arbitration a little more fact intensive. And
- 15:43so more of the facts will be laid out and often
- 15:45more of the facts in the defense side will be
- 15:48laid out as well from the respondents. So if
- 15:52the pleadings are not complete when we meet,
- 15:55then we set a date for that to happen. And then,
- 15:58oh, and there could be arbitrability issues.
- 16:02Is there any party that insists that the case
- 16:05is not suitable for arbitration and we have to
- 16:08deal with that? Sometimes the arbitration agreement
- 16:11will leave all that up to the arbitrators. And
- 16:15sometimes the parties have to go to court to
- 16:17get something like that settled. So in addition
- 16:23to all that, one of the big subjects that we
- 16:27talk about during the preliminary conference
- 16:30is discovery. And that discussion always involves
- 16:35some kind of compromise and some discussion of
- 16:41different points of view. Because in arbitration,
- 16:45we don't have discovery that's complete, as complete
- 16:49as discovery would be for trial. But we want
- 16:51to make sure that there's enough discovery so
- 16:54that the parties have the information that they
- 16:57need. The job really is how do we get enough
- 17:04information without going overboard and breaking
- 17:08the bank? We don't really have to look under
- 17:11every single stone, but we need to focus on the
- 17:13important areas. And so experienced arbitrators
- 17:17would help you do that. So at JAMS, rule 17 is
- 17:23a really important rule about discovery. And
- 17:27it has to do with things like document exchange.
- 17:31And all relevant nonprivileged documents, including,
- 17:36of course, electronically stored material, has
- 17:40to be produced by a certain date. And we talk
- 17:43about that. And we set the date during the course
- 17:47of the preliminary conference. And that date
- 17:49goes into my scheduling order so that everybody
- 17:52knows when that should be due. The discovery
- 17:57includes things like chat conversations. It didn't
- 18:02used to be true that that kind of information
- 18:06was used as evidence in the course of a hearing,
- 18:09but now we have it all the time. And a lot of
- 18:12times there's a dispute about what was the company's
- 18:17attitude toward this particular. contract and
- 18:23in the chat it's obvious that that the company
- 18:28was trying to get out of the contract so I never
- 18:32know what to expect in that regard. So what I
- 18:35do in my scheduling order is put in a time for
- 18:40exchange of documents and then I put in a backup
- 18:43date too so that if either party feels that some
- 18:47important documents have not been produced We
- 18:51set a date for that and and that is a more formal
- 18:55process and the party wanting more documents
- 18:58would do a request for reduction. We have response
- 19:01to that and move forward ahead on that basis.
- 19:07Rule 17 is very important because the parties
- 19:11are continued under that rule. They're continued
- 19:14to be obligated to exchange documents. And of
- 19:20course, if documents are not exchanged, they
- 19:22can't be offered at the hearings and there could
- 19:23be penalties involved. And so it's important
- 19:28to keep up with that particular requirement.
- 19:35Then there's the discussion of written discovery,
- 19:37by which I mean interrogatories and requests
- 19:42for admission. And it's interesting to me because
- 19:45I've been arbitrating for a long time. I've been
- 19:48at Jams a while, as you heard earlier. Parties
- 19:53always used to have written discovery and they
- 19:56still, some of them do and they want it and that's
- 19:58fine. But a lot of lawyers are saying to me these
- 20:01days, no, we don't need written discovery. We
- 20:06want document exchange and we want a few depositions,
- 20:10but we do not need interrogatories and requests
- 20:12for admission for a couple of reasons. First
- 20:16of all, they don't necessarily give rise to a
- 20:21lot of useful information, or that anyway is
- 20:24the opinion that I'm hearing, and I can agree
- 20:26with that. And also they give rise to all kinds
- 20:29of disputes. And so there'd be a lot of motion
- 20:34work, wanting additional information under a
- 20:37certain interrogatory, that kind of thing, requests
- 20:41for admission too. So think about that as you're
- 20:48making a plan for arbitration. Do you want written
- 20:53discovery or not? Is it important? Or if maybe
- 20:56you want to have a limited amount of written
- 20:58discovery, and that is part of the conversation
- 21:01during the preliminary conference. So on depositions,
- 21:07there's always a discussion about what's appropriate
- 21:09for a particular case. The rules just say there's
- 21:14one deposition per side. I don't handle very
- 21:18many cases where everybody agrees to one deposition
- 21:21per side, but it is not unusual for the parties
- 21:25to agree to three depositions per side, maybe
- 21:28a little more than that. So that goes into my
- 21:33scheduling order as well. And I always say that,
- 21:39okay, we've agreed on three depositions per side.
- 21:43If there's good cause to take another deposition,
- 21:46then send me a note about that and we'll discuss
- 21:50it and make a decision about whether another
- 21:54deposition is warranted or not. And of course,
- 21:58the whole goal of this is that we want to get
- 22:01enough discovery, but we don't want it to be
- 22:04so expensive and so complex that it's prohibitive
- 22:08as we move forward. Of course, most parties want
- 22:13a protective order these days. That wasn't always
- 22:15true, but now it's true. I think partly because
- 22:18of the technical matters that we often handle.
- 22:23So I asked the lawyers to submit a protective
- 22:27order. If they can't agree on the form, then
- 22:29I help with that, make a ruling about it. And
- 22:33of course, we set hearing dates and location
- 22:36and It's not uncommon now, of course, for all
- 22:42or part of the hearing to take place on Zoom.
- 22:45I'm perfectly happy to meet in person, but sometimes
- 22:50the parties want everything on Zoom. And sometimes,
- 22:54especially in the international cases that I've
- 22:56handled, The case we will meet in person, but
- 23:00we'll put certain witnesses on on zoom just because
- 23:03they happen to be in a different time zone in
- 23:06a different country and we want to have a chance
- 23:09to hear from them. So that is common too. In
- 23:15addition, of course, we we said besides the hearing
- 23:22dates and location, we set witness list. dates
- 23:26for witness lists, arbitration exhibit exchange.
- 23:30I describe what should happen about the arbitration
- 23:35exhibits in my order and also when pre -hearing
- 23:39briefs are due. Generally speaking, I request
- 23:41a pre -hearing brief about a week before the
- 23:44first day of the hearings. There may be motions.
- 23:49We may be talking about motions that one of the
- 23:52other parties want to bring. And so we agree
- 23:56on a date by which the motions must be heard,
- 24:00be complete before the hearing. So we aren't
- 24:02running into the hearings. Experts are important
- 24:08in these cases for several reasons. I mean, we
- 24:13need experts sometimes to explain the solar infrastructure,
- 24:17the equipment specs, the specifications for equipment.
- 24:21They may be looking at engineering, manufacturing
- 24:25and construction issues. They may be evaluating
- 24:30why a system is underperforming, that kind of
- 24:33thing. I've even had experts who were determining
- 24:39how the output of electricity from a particular
- 24:43wind plant ought to be measured. There was a
- 24:47dispute about that. And also then, of course,
- 24:52experts may be helpful in considering how government
- 24:55action gets involved here, like maybe the BLM,
- 25:01the Bureau of Land Management is involved, and
- 25:05how does that fit? So there's often room for
- 25:10experts. And of course, So, it might have to
- 25:14do with agency -specific knowledge, but of course,
- 25:18it often has to do with damages. So, in a big
- 25:23solar or wind case, for example, there would
- 25:26be experts on each side arguing about particular
- 25:29damages, and it's not always a simple subject
- 25:34to discuss. So, we've talked about written discovery,
- 25:44request for admission. So, let me see. Generally
- 25:49speaking, I require a court reporter because
- 25:52I want a transcript and so do my fellow arbitrators
- 25:57if maybe I'm the chair of a panel of three because
- 26:01there's lots of money at stake and we may want
- 26:04to go back over certain things and the court
- 26:06reporters are very helpful about that. In addition
- 26:13to all of this, at the end of a preliminary conference,
- 26:17we generally talk about the award. What's the
- 26:20form of the award? And the arbitration agreement
- 26:24may say what that form should be or not. And
- 26:30so the general rule is the award is due in 30
- 26:35days. That sometimes gets changed for various
- 26:38reasons, but we do work that out. And I always
- 26:43write a reasoned award. So that reasoned award
- 26:48would cover all the issues, the main issues,
- 26:51and would refer to what my decision is, but also
- 26:56would refer to the evidence, the pieces of evidence
- 26:59or testimony, whatever it was, that support that
- 27:03particular decision. So the parties would know
- 27:07at the end of the day what the... what my decision
- 27:10is, but also why it is that particular decision.
- 27:15And sometimes, of course, we're dealing with
- 27:18a question of whether there should be fees and
- 27:20costs for the prevailing party. And so the way
- 27:24we handle that is we issue an interim award that
- 27:28has to do with all the matters of liability and
- 27:30says which party is the prevailing party. And
- 27:33then after that, there's briefing about fees
- 27:35and costs and those those matters are wrapped
- 27:40into a final award. So I had besides, that's
- 27:48sort of my outline of what the process is in
- 27:54arbitration. But I had a few tips now that I
- 28:01wanted to, a few points that I wanted to make
- 28:04to you. to maybe help with some of the questions
- 28:07that are running through your mind as you're
- 28:09thinking about how to respond to what's happening
- 28:13in the preliminary conference. I think, excuse
- 28:18me for a sec here. I have a quick question. You've
- 28:26talked a little bit about three arbitrator panels
- 28:29first. And I was wondering, can you talk about
- 28:32the benefits of using a three arbitrator panel
- 28:35versus a single arbitrator, particularly in these
- 28:37complex energy disputes? Good question. Well,
- 28:43a lot of times, I mean, it's really the parties
- 28:45that decide whether they want one person or three
- 28:50on the arbitrator panel. And my own, although
- 28:55I do handle a lot of arbitrations on my own,
- 28:58and that's fine. I really like a three person
- 29:01panel if it's a large case, large dollar claims
- 29:06and a lot of complicated technical issues, because
- 29:10it's really good for all of us, I think, to talk
- 29:14about the matters and come up with some kind
- 29:18of agreement on what the right result is in the
- 29:21case. And I should say, too, that I've chaired
- 29:27or been part of many three -person panels, and
- 29:30it's very rare that the members of the panel
- 29:34disagree, which is kind of interesting to me,
- 29:36because I always thought there would always be
- 29:39one side that was arguing a lot with the others,
- 29:42but not necessarily so. Great. One more question.
- 29:48You talked about the importance of the preliminary
- 29:50conference, and you kind of talked about what
- 29:53you hoped that meeting would be or what you think
- 29:56is the most productive way of handling that.
- 29:58But what is one thing you wish more attorneys
- 30:00would address during that initial meeting? Well,
- 30:04I really like it if they were conscious of this
- 30:08fact that the case can be designed the process
- 30:12can be designed to fit the case. So I'm hoping
- 30:16that they're thinking along those lines and also
- 30:20giving me their thoughts about that, what exactly
- 30:23the goal is here. Was there more of that question?
- 30:33No, that's perfect. Thank you. I'll let you get
- 30:35back to the best. I mean, a lot of times it's
- 30:38really a difference of opinion about how much
- 30:42discovery there ought to be. And my thought about
- 30:47that is, well, okay, we'll try to narrow things
- 30:50down. And then if it becomes obvious that more
- 30:54is necessary, we talk about that. It's not an
- 30:57inflexible kind of process. In fact, it's very
- 31:00flexible. Okay. Well, so one of the things that
- 31:06we do at this preliminary conference is set a
- 31:09schedule for the hearings. And my advice to you
- 31:14folks out there would be try to stick to that
- 31:17schedule. Continuances can be very expensive,
- 31:22especially if there are three panelists. They're
- 31:26difficult to reschedule. And also, if the case
- 31:31is delayed, I mean, it may be necessary. But
- 31:34if it's possible to avoid that, that saves a
- 31:39lot of time and money because as the case goes
- 31:41on that expenses just increase. So think about
- 31:45that. And also I would say pay attention to the
- 31:50arbitrator's cancellation periods so that if
- 31:53you're going to get things resolved, get it done
- 31:55before the cancellation period begins so that
- 31:59you don't have to pay fees for unnecessary work.
- 32:05The second tip that I wanted to talk about has
- 32:10to do with limiting motion practice. And I think
- 32:13it's widely understood that motions can be difficult
- 32:17to grant in arbitration. In part, that's just
- 32:21because the discovery is not as thorough as it
- 32:25might be ahead of a trial. And so there may be
- 32:28a lot of questions of fact that arise. So the
- 32:32motions that are that are most successful have
- 32:38to do with the legal argument, a legal point,
- 32:41like something like the statute of limitations.
- 32:43It's a little more cut and dried. Because again,
- 32:50if discovery is limited, so there may be a lot
- 32:53of questions of facts. So the question to ask
- 32:56about motion work is, will the motion meaningfully
- 33:02advance the case? In other words, If the motion
- 33:07is granted, will it eliminate a need for part
- 33:10of the hearings? Will it cut things down? Sometimes
- 33:14I advise counsel, but what I do is ask counsel
- 33:18to send me a note. Here's my motion. This is
- 33:22the kind of motion that I want to bring. This
- 33:26is the topic. Here's why I want to bring it,
- 33:30why it would be successful. And they also tell
- 33:33me it will cut down on hearing time. And that
- 33:37may be the case, but the worst situation is if
- 33:41the lawyers bring a pretty big motion and it
- 33:45has to be denied because of questions of fact,
- 33:48then the issues have to be heard again during
- 33:51the hearing. And that doesn't make any sense.
- 33:54So sometimes I think whatever the issues are
- 33:58that would have been in the motion, those are
- 34:01better reserved for the hearings and they can
- 34:04be wrapped. into the hearings relatively easily,
- 34:08I think. Another thing to be considering, I think,
- 34:14during the preliminary conference is should the
- 34:18case be bifurcated? Maybe there should be a hearing
- 34:23on liability, and then if there is liability,
- 34:28a hearing on damages, and sometimes the case
- 34:30can get structured that way. And even more important,
- 34:35I have had cases that were complicated enough
- 34:38so that they moved ahead in phases. So there'd
- 34:42be a phase having to do with part of the case
- 34:46and the panel of three would make a decision
- 34:49and write a decision. And then there'd be the
- 34:52next phase and so on. So there are many different
- 34:55ways in which these cases could be shaped. and
- 35:02organized that benefit everybody. So we can talk
- 35:06about that. On the number of hearing days, I
- 35:13always talk to the lawyers about make sure you
- 35:17have enough days so that we don't have to end
- 35:21the first set of hearing days and not reschedule
- 35:24for three months later. That doesn't make any
- 35:27kind of sense. And so we talk a little bit about
- 35:30how to cut down the time of the hearings. And
- 35:33there are a few ways to do that. I'll just mention
- 35:36a couple of them. One would be use the chest
- 35:39clock approach so that each side has 50 % of
- 35:44the hearing time, or we might say 40 % for one
- 35:48side, 60 % for the other. It can be done in different
- 35:52ways. But the chest clock approach is good in
- 35:55that it keeps everybody on target, I think. And
- 35:59there's a push to focus only on important witnesses
- 36:03and important documents and leave out whatever
- 36:06is really unnecessary. So that's one way to shorten
- 36:11the hearing time. And another way is for expert
- 36:15testimony. Sometimes council want to use the
- 36:20expert report as the direct testimony. And the
- 36:23way that works is that the expert comes on the
- 36:26stand and there's some kind of introductory questions,
- 36:30little background material. And that lasts for
- 36:3315 or 20 minutes. And then the process goes into
- 36:39full cross -examination. And that also can save
- 36:44a lot of time, assuming that there is a good
- 36:48report from each expert. OK, my fifth tip is,
- 36:56remember that in arbitration, Strict conformity
- 37:02to the rules of evidence are not required. So
- 37:05the jams rule is rule 22 and basically says,
- 37:10well, there's no need to stick to the rules of
- 37:16evidence except for the privileges and work product
- 37:20and other things can come in. And so I always
- 37:26encourage the lawyers to Limit their objections.
- 37:31It's not a deposition when you're in the hearing.
- 37:33It's a different process. And of course, if there's
- 37:37something really important, you can raise an
- 37:40objection, but I encourage everybody to just
- 37:44save those save those objections because for
- 37:49very important matters so that there are not
- 37:53repeated objections that interrupt the flow of
- 37:58the hearings. So we wanna avoid that, also avoid,
- 38:01of course, cumulative evidence. But if something
- 38:05comes in like hearsay, it's okay to remind the
- 38:10arbitrator that this is hearsay. We wouldn't
- 38:14keep it out of the hearings, but we'll give it
- 38:17the weight that it's entitled to. And hearsay
- 38:19evidence is not entitled to much weight. So that
- 38:23ought to... solve that problem, at least to some
- 38:30extent. So there may be some questions about
- 38:37some of this at this point. I don't know if any.
- 38:41I have some questions. So in your written material,
- 38:45Z, you included your article about writing closing
- 38:49briefs. So I was wondering, what are some of
- 38:52the most important things attorneys should keep
- 38:54in mind when preparing their closing briefs?
- 38:57OK. I have written an article about that and
- 39:02so there are several tips in there, but I think
- 39:05that the main thing I would say is focus on the
- 39:10big issues and refer to the evidence that was
- 39:14presented at the hearing that relate to those
- 39:17particular issues. Maybe divide your brief up
- 39:21so that it's clear you're handling issue one,
- 39:24now you're handling issue two. that the brief
- 39:28is organized and helpful to the panel. Basically,
- 39:34I think when you're writing your final brief,
- 39:41what you should be doing is kind of help the
- 39:43panel come to the right conclusion, if I could
- 39:45say it that way, from your client's point of
- 39:49view. And so make it clear. And the rest of that
- 39:55you may be able to find in the article that's
- 40:00available online. Anything else? Yes, I have
- 40:06another question. So what are, you know, you
- 40:10discussed the importance of selecting the right
- 40:12arbitrator for your case. So what are qualities,
- 40:15obviously you're an arbitrator as well, but what
- 40:17are qualities that you think are most important
- 40:19when handling these technically complex disputes?
- 40:24Thank you. Yeah. I mean, you really do need some
- 40:30experience to arbitrators to handle these matters.
- 40:35And if there's a panel of three, make sure you
- 40:39have at least one who's had this kind of case
- 40:42before, I think. So it calls for experience with
- 40:47complicated and technical matters, commercial
- 40:54matters. Some arbitrator who is decisive and
- 41:01timely on ruling on various procedural issues,
- 41:05what I try to do is make myself available as
- 41:09the parties are preparing for the hearings so
- 41:12that if an issue comes up, they can put a question
- 41:15online to me using our Jams Access approach,
- 41:19which is a private communication. And then I
- 41:21can hear from both sides and make a ruling fairly
- 41:25promptly, more so than in court, because we don't
- 41:28really make everybody follow the delay times
- 41:34in order to have a motion. You know, we just
- 41:37set dates according to what works for everybody.
- 41:41So I think it's important that an arbitrator
- 41:44is available to make prompt decisions about discovery,
- 41:47say, going forward. And also somebody who is
- 41:52actively managing the hearings, paying attention
- 41:56and responding as the lawyers ask questions or
- 41:59raise issues. I think that arbitrators want to
- 42:06prevent gamesmanship. That's pretty obvious when
- 42:09it happens and it can be prevented. And so I
- 42:13guess the summary for me would be you want an
- 42:17arbitrator who's firm. but fair, and just things
- 42:23that way. That's great. And then another question.
- 42:27How can parties balance resolving a dispute,
- 42:30and you talked about this in the beginning, while
- 42:32maintaining an ongoing business relationship?
- 42:35Well, that has a lot to do with how we handle
- 42:43the arbitration. You know, I mean, arbitration
- 42:46is definitely an adversary process, but there
- 42:50are ways to handle it so that everybody feels
- 42:54fairly treated and the lawyers, it's particularly
- 42:57good when the lawyers are very professional and
- 43:00can talk to each other in a very professional
- 43:03way and there won't be, you know, insults or
- 43:08anything done to demean one side. So it's...
- 43:11basically kind of the process, how we handle
- 43:15the process. And during the preliminary conference,
- 43:18one of the things that I am doing, I'm thinking
- 43:21about how the lawyers are related. I'm hearing
- 43:25how the lawyers are relating to each other. And
- 43:27I'm also trying to provide a model for them of
- 43:30here's how we're going to do this. We're not
- 43:33shouting at each other. We're going to make good,
- 43:36strong legal arguments. We're going to be civil
- 43:40here. I don't usually even have to say that.
- 43:44It's just a matter of how I run things. At the
- 43:48preliminary conference, they get the idea. Are
- 43:55there situations where mediation can be helpful
- 43:58even after an arbitration has begun? For example,
- 44:01maybe resolving certain issues through mediation
- 44:04and then leaving others for the arbitration.
- 44:07Yeah, that could happen. That's really up to
- 44:11the lawyers during the course of the hearing
- 44:15because I know that there are some arbitrators
- 44:18who also kind of mediate a case and then arbitrate,
- 44:21but I don't like to do that because I feel as
- 44:24if when I mediate, I learn too much to be a really
- 44:29fair arbitrator. So that would have to be kind
- 44:33of done on the side. handled by the lawyers,
- 44:36not by the arbitrator. Yeah. And then one more
- 44:41question for me. Do you anticipate arbitration
- 44:43becoming more common as renewable energy projects
- 44:46continue to expand? Absolutely. Yeah. I mean,
- 44:49that's what I'm seeing in the course of my career
- 44:52that it used to be that the Energy cases had
- 44:59more to do with the construction of the project.
- 45:03Were the panels put in properly? Did they really
- 45:06work? But now it's all kinds of things and it's
- 45:10all different kinds of energy. And so I think
- 45:12there will be more of these cases and a continuation
- 45:17of complicated cases that need to get resolved.
- 45:21Yeah. And then a question from from us, what
- 45:28do you think the best way the lawyers can prepare
- 45:30their clients for arbitration? Well, I think
- 45:36that talking about the kinds of things that I've
- 45:39just been discussing, I mean, they wouldn't want
- 45:41to go into that much detail, but explaining to
- 45:45the clients, sorry about that. explaining to
- 45:54the clients how the case is going to go forward
- 45:57and doing that step by step as the case moves
- 46:00ahead, I think we'll make it clear to the clients
- 46:04what's happening and why. And the key clients,
- 46:11maybe the CEO of the company or whomever, those
- 46:14are the people who are going to be deposed probably.
- 46:19And so there'll be a lot of lawyer discussion
- 46:21with those clients about what a deposition is,
- 46:25how do people behave in a deposition, and so
- 46:28forth. Given how technical these disputes can
- 46:32be, you mentioned experts in depositions, how
- 46:35important is it to have the right experts involved
- 46:38early? Really important. I think it's really
- 46:41important. A lot of times, if law firms are handling
- 46:47these cases regularly, they have a list of who
- 46:51are qualified and would be good experts. And
- 46:55I think also that's just a matter of kind of
- 46:58calling around and hearing reports of different
- 47:01experts. And so the technical experts are important,
- 47:06but the damages experts are really important
- 47:10too. And I have had cases where it was really
- 47:17clear to me that one set of experts on one side
- 47:21was far more prepared and gave a lot of a lot
- 47:24more information about damages than the other
- 47:27side. And so that is that it's a make or break
- 47:31issue. Yeah. And based on your experience, what
- 47:37guidance would you give attorneys about presenting
- 47:39complex technical information clearly to an arbitrator?
- 47:44Well, sometimes it's interesting. I mean sometimes
- 47:49they prepare us by having a class in advance
- 47:53where the experts will meet with the arbitrators
- 47:57and explain certain things and That can be it's
- 48:02like being tutored. It's that can be a very helpful
- 48:05Approach it. It takes some time and it costs
- 48:08some money for the parties, but it's It's a common
- 48:13practice and really can be very helpful. I mean,
- 48:20some of the technical things we'll know based
- 48:22on experience, but getting good guidance is helpful.
- 48:28And even if there's not like a tutorial of the
- 48:31sort that I just mentioned, a good expert report
- 48:34can lay things out in a way that will educate
- 48:37the arbitrator panel. Yes, well, thank you for
- 48:41answering our questions and that's all for us.
- 48:44Okay, I think we're kind of are there any questions
- 48:48that have been brought by anybody who's observing
- 48:52online? Anybody in the audience? No, I think
- 48:56we don't have any current questions. If anyone
- 48:58would like to ask, please put them in the Q and
- 49:00a, but not at this moment. Any final pieces of
- 49:07advice as we close out the program, Z? Oh, we
- 49:10actually have one question. Can we get to it?
- 49:24Just kidding. So, yes. Do you have any pieces
- 49:27of advice as we close out the program to leave
- 49:31attorneys with? No, I think that the point is
- 49:39that energy arbitrations present unique procedural
- 49:43and substantive questions. And it's important
- 49:47to design an efficient and fair process and employ
- 49:52practical strategies to streamline discovery
- 49:55and motion practice, hearing management to control
- 49:59costs. We've talked about evaluating the role
- 50:05of experts for help with technical evidence and
- 50:10also regulatory agencies, their activities are
- 50:14important too. And it's so important to have
- 50:18active case management by the arbitrator or the
- 50:21arbitration panel for a fair and efficient resolution.
- 50:26We do have one question. So how early should
- 50:28council evaluate the dispute resolution clause
- 50:31in their contracts? Right away. Right away. I
- 50:35mean, that is really important because that those
- 50:42Provisions are what the parties agreed to at
- 50:45the time of entering into a contract. And so
- 50:49they may want to come to negotiate with the other
- 50:55side and change part of it or something, but
- 50:58usually not. Usually the arbitration provision
- 51:01controls. Yeah. We talked about that when we
- 51:07were talking about the straight of her moves,
- 51:09you know, what would the. Very big energy companies
- 51:12that are very sophisticated. You know, they've
- 51:15got their arbitration provisions. They know what
- 51:17they are. And so how are they going to use mediation
- 51:22and arbitration to make things work during this
- 51:26time when the straight seems to be open? Sometimes
- 51:28enclosed, sometimes delaying everything. Yeah,
- 51:34and then how can cancel? council distinguish
- 51:37a contractual breach from a delay or failure
- 51:40caused by maybe delays in production or regulatory
- 51:43action? Well, see, that's the discussion that
- 51:47has to be had in a particular case, you know,
- 51:50which is it. And so, and sometimes that comes
- 51:54down to, you know, what caused this? I mean,
- 52:00was this Was this war? What was it that caused
- 52:06the war? It could be a pandemic, as I mentioned
- 52:09earlier. And the lawyers may be arguing about
- 52:14whether it's force majeure or not. And so I had
- 52:18that during the pandemic when there were delays
- 52:22in materials, delivery of materials. All right.
- 52:30Well, those are our questions from the audience.
- 52:33Thank you for presenting today, Zee. It was a
- 52:35wonderful presentation. Thank you, Beverly Hills
- 52:38Bar. I appreciate that, too. All right. Thank
- 52:42you.