Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / International Family Law - Islamic Law in International Family Matters
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:03International Family Law series. I'm Alphonse
- 0:06Provenziano, a certified family law specialist
- 0:08and a fellow of the International Academy of
- 0:12Family Lawyers located here in Beverly Hills,
- 0:14California. In this episode, I have the distinct
- 0:18pleasure to be joined by Anna Kahn of Anna Kahn
- 0:21Law and Dr. Yousef Al -Amri. of Saudi Arabia.
- 0:27And we are here to discuss the role of Islamic
- 0:30law in international family law matters across
- 0:33the UK, United States, and Middle East. And a
- 0:36little bit about our guests. Anna Kahn is a well
- 0:41-known and well -respected London -based solicitor
- 0:44who's internationally recognized for her work
- 0:47in cross -border family law. With a particular
- 0:50focus on cases involving Islamic law, complex
- 0:53financial remedies and international child matters.
- 0:57She was honored with the prestigious member of
- 0:59the Order of the British Empire for the Register
- 1:03Our Marriage Act, which allows unofficial marriages,
- 1:07mostly Islamic marriages, to be registered in
- 1:10the United Kingdom, which had never happened
- 1:13before she initiated that initiative. And she
- 1:17is also an advisor to the UK government on family
- 1:21law issues. Dr. Yusuf Al -Amri is also a professor
- 1:25of law with over 30 years of experience teaching
- 1:28at King Abdulaziz University in Saudi Arabia.
- 1:32And he's a legal consultant who specializes in
- 1:35Saudi and Islamic law and advises on family law
- 1:39issues, including conflicts of law, cross -border
- 1:42enforcement throughout the Middle East. Together,
- 1:45they offer a nuanced, practitioner -focused perspective
- 1:48on navigating the intersection of religious and
- 1:51secular legal systems in international family
- 1:55law disputes. Let's get to it. Generally speaking,
- 2:01in California, we have a very large population
- 2:04of people from the Middle East, and we have a
- 2:07lot of... uh issues that arise uh but it's an
- 2:10area that not every practitioner knows generally
- 2:13and i think it would be really beneficial uh
- 2:16to for the for the audience of direct examination
- 2:20to understand a little bit about the applications
- 2:23of islamic law uh as it as applies generally
- 2:27because this is somewhat of an alien area for
- 2:29us but this comes into play both as a cultural
- 2:32background and also as we look at marriage contracts
- 2:35uh islamic marriage contracts Anna, can you tell
- 2:39us a little bit about the general principles
- 2:41of property ownership under Islamic law as you've
- 2:47seen them in the United Kingdom? The reason I
- 2:50got interested in Islamic law in the first place
- 2:53was because of the demand from the clients. It
- 2:56wasn't something I was planning to specialize
- 2:58in. Having worked with Muslim women who could
- 3:04see in Islamic law they had all these rights
- 3:06but in English law they didn't was an eye -opener
- 3:10for me so I started studying and specializing
- 3:14in it and my father had a very large library
- 3:16as a specialist in Islamic law as a lawyer so
- 3:19that helped me a lot. A few principles that I
- 3:22can put into place for you which I can apply
- 3:25under English law straight away are things that
- 3:27may surprise you that a woman has a right not
- 3:31to have any claim from the husband against her
- 3:35income or assets or businesses. The husband has
- 3:40the sole duty to bring up his children, so finance
- 3:45everything, housing, education, everything, and
- 3:49as well as look after his wife. If she does earn,
- 3:53that's considered what we call a satka or an
- 3:55extra offering that she gives, it is not his
- 4:00right to demand it. She can actually stop whenever
- 4:04she wants to. He can ask her to stop working
- 4:06if it's affecting family life and harming the
- 4:09family. He can have a discussion with her. So
- 4:12it's about collaboration and working together.
- 4:15Our prophet, Mohammed, 1400 years ago was married
- 4:19to a business woman. So his first wife Khadija
- 4:22was 15 years older than him when they got married
- 4:24and he was her employee and she proposed to him.
- 4:29So it's very interesting how the dynamics were
- 4:32then. Other rights that you may be interested
- 4:36in are Islamic financial settlements, which I
- 4:40enforce in English law and have been enforced
- 4:43under other civil jurisdictions. So the husband
- 4:46has, again, poor thing, the duty to pay his wife.
- 4:52either a lump sum or anything of value. It could
- 4:56be knowledge if he's got no assets. It could
- 4:59be stocks and shares in Apple or anything else
- 5:03that he's got of value or land or property. And
- 5:07that's given at the time of the marriage. So
- 5:09it's a nuptial contract. It's not a pre -nuptial
- 5:11or post -nuptial. It's written in a certificate
- 5:14and it's enforceable either by paying the same
- 5:18day or on the death or divorce by the husband.
- 5:22That's a contract we apply under English law.
- 5:25Very rare, but it's had success. Just two examples
- 5:28for you, but there's many more that have empowered
- 5:31women. And Dr. Youssef, we spend a lot of time
- 5:36in California law with the concept of community
- 5:39property, that everything that's acquired is
- 5:43a 50 -50 ownership rate during marriage. Everything
- 5:45before marriage is separate property. Is there
- 5:48anything in similar application. Okay, one of
- 5:53the main objectives when the man gets married,
- 5:56of course, when he marries, he has to ask her
- 6:02hand in marriage like you have in the old movies.
- 6:05He goes to the father and ask the daughter's
- 6:08hand in marriage. Once he does that, he is to
- 6:11provide housing, adequate housing, food, clothes.
- 6:18Money, everything. She's a millionaire. Nothing
- 6:22to do with it. I've had several cases. The wife
- 6:24is a billionaire and the husband is a plain employee.
- 6:31He is obliged to spend on her. She wants to give
- 6:35him something. It's a gift. But she's not obliged.
- 6:41She can give him a gift. You know, a push or
- 6:45something that he needs. hashed to whatever.
- 6:50So it's very much a different system than we're
- 6:54used to seeing in California. And I know, Anna,
- 6:56you mentioned that there's been some rare applications
- 6:59where you've actually enforced marriage certificates
- 7:03in the British courts. Can you tell us a little
- 7:07bit about that crossover and how you've been
- 7:10able to do that and what applications there were?
- 7:14So when I looked into this I found that there
- 7:17was case law going back to 1961 with Shanaaz
- 7:21and Ridwan where the English law judge was calling
- 7:25the couple Muhammadans. So this is how far back
- 7:29we're going 60 plus years ago, but the English
- 7:34law judge said this is a contract under English
- 7:37law To the wife. He said you're right to ask
- 7:40me to enforce it. It's enforceable You had witnesses,
- 7:45he accepts he signed it, he should give you the
- 7:47lump sum due. So we have case law. And as you
- 7:50know, our system is based on precedent. It's
- 7:53been revisited only a few times. So because it's
- 7:56been revisited in 71, and then again, in 2011,
- 8:00we have very rare revisits, primarily because
- 8:05women are usually not aware that they can get
- 8:08this help. Two, they're too scared. to actually
- 8:12enforce their rights. So when you find a feisty
- 8:15woman who's got the knowledge and the bravery
- 8:19to come forward and support from her family,
- 8:22then she has a major block of legal fees, because
- 8:25it's extremely expensive. It's rare. I'm the
- 8:27only one doing it. And it's not my fees you should
- 8:30worry about. It should be the court fees. Today's
- 8:33case, I'll give you an example. Meher is 20 kilos
- 8:37of gold, which is 92 ,000 pounds. at the moment
- 8:42per kilo. So we're talking about 1 .4 million
- 8:46pounds plus 100 ,000 lump sum for her to start
- 8:50off her married life. Now, it's very interesting.
- 8:53That's all written down, but they never got married
- 8:56under English law. So in English law, she's a
- 9:01cohabitee. She lived with him. Cohabitees have
- 9:03no legal rights in our system. So she walks away
- 9:08with absolutely nothing. In fact, her belongings,
- 9:10her design, her clothes, et cetera, were put
- 9:12in bags and thrown at her when she had been asked
- 9:16to leave. No children. So we have no law which
- 9:19will give a roof over the head for her while
- 9:21she brings up her child till the age of 18. So
- 9:24what do we do? I've got to enforce this under
- 9:28contract law. She's left it go too long. So the
- 9:32pain and suffering element, I would normally
- 9:34add to the lump sum. for what she suffered has
- 9:38a limitation. So you can't leave it too long
- 9:42either before you consult the lawyer. So all
- 9:44we can do is enforce. Luckily, he's very, very
- 9:48wealthy and he's got the assets. She now has
- 9:52to find 10 ,000 pounds just with a court fee.
- 9:55She needs to have backers who will support her.
- 9:59It's not an easy thing to do, but Islam, in a
- 10:03Muslim country would give this to her straight
- 10:05away, I believe. And that's the beauty of it,
- 10:09that she wouldn't have to go to the court system
- 10:11and beg for this money. And Dr. Youssef, just
- 10:15in sort of a comparison, you have a client that
- 10:17comes into you and says, you know, they could
- 10:21file in the UK, Saudi Arabia, with the similar
- 10:26circumstance that Anna's brought up. How do you
- 10:29advise them? I'll solve her case in Saudi Arabia.
- 10:32Now, they have a marriage contract between them.
- 10:36She has her dowry written down. She has not received
- 10:40it. If he has not consummated the marriage, she
- 10:46will get half. If they have consummated the marriage,
- 10:52full amount is due. Now, you go to court. Family
- 10:57court here is free. There are court costs for
- 11:02other kind of cases, individuals, et cetera,
- 11:06et cetera. Family court is free. There is no
- 11:09cost for it. The judge will, in the first setting,
- 11:15he sees the marriage contract, he sees the amount,
- 11:19he will put it under enforcement. That's it.
- 11:22It won't take any... It's a much more straightforward
- 11:24procedure. Yes, there's no... playing with that.
- 11:30It's just the idea of consummating and not consummating.
- 11:34The difference of the dowry. In your experience
- 11:37in international law in the Middle East, is it
- 11:39very similar throughout the Middle East in enforcing
- 11:42that type of marriage contract? Mostly. Because
- 11:44we don't go by common law here. There are no
- 11:47precedents. Every case is looked at individually.
- 11:51And therefore the result will differ. depending
- 11:55on the judge, depending on how it's presented
- 11:57to him, how it is actually, you know, what you
- 12:03have as merits for the case to give to the judge.
- 12:07That's why it will take a difference between,
- 12:09you know, case and case, there will be a difference.
- 12:13But the main key feature in the dowry, if it's
- 12:17being paid in full or in half, is closing a door
- 12:21or lowering a shade. There's a prophet saying
- 12:28and that if you close the door on the two in
- 12:31the room They're fighting they're wrestling and
- 12:35fighting and throwing whatever at each other
- 12:37that Considered is considered consummation Hmm
- 12:42because they were alone in one location If the
- 12:46car is too tinted you can't see what's going
- 12:48on inside that Has been their marriage has been
- 12:52consummated they don't have to copulate consummation
- 12:57is just opportunity yeah and see that's very
- 13:02interesting because i always look at an international
- 13:04case the first question is where do you, what's
- 13:08your form? And obviously, if a California practitioner
- 13:12encounters a marriage contract case, and there's
- 13:15a leg in the Middle East, and it sounds like
- 13:17if you're representing the woman who hasn't been
- 13:19paid their dowry, maybe the first step should
- 13:21be considering, is there a form in the Middle
- 13:24East where you can enforce that contract, because
- 13:26it'll be more readily available? Would you agree
- 13:29with that? Under Saudi law, The woman's location
- 13:36is where the court can be adjourned from city
- 13:41to city. He's in one city, she's in another,
- 13:44then it's her city because she's a woman and
- 13:47therefore he will travel to there. Before we
- 13:51were online, now we're through Teams, so it really
- 13:54doesn't matter that much. But before, he has
- 13:58to go to her city for court session. Does it
- 14:04cost him? He goes, she stays. And how long is
- 14:09it if they're both? One very important thing
- 14:12I need to ask, which worries me is if there's
- 14:15no talaq, Islamic divorce by the husband, because
- 14:20he knows he has to pay the Islamic financial
- 14:23settlement as the trigger is his death or divorce
- 14:26by him. And that trigger event he has to avoid
- 14:29at all costs. So if he doesn't give the divorce,
- 14:32And she doesn't want to get a no -fault -based
- 14:36divorce, which is called a khola, which means
- 14:38she has to give up the financial settlement to
- 14:42obtain release from a marriage without any basis
- 14:45whatsoever, no behavior cited, just walk out,
- 14:49she gives up meher. This lady obviously doesn't
- 14:51want to do that. So if he weren't going to divorce
- 14:54her, would she be able to apply like I'm doing
- 14:57in England for a tafrik, which is a judicial
- 15:00divorce? But we have to go to the Sharia Council
- 15:03here. It's by ijma, consensus, we have Sharia
- 15:06Council. Now the question is, did she leave or
- 15:11did he kick her out? He kicked her out. Then
- 15:15that is a non -direct divorce. Exactly. You don't
- 15:20have to say the words, if you could explain that
- 15:22a little bit more. You don't have to say the
- 15:23words, exactly. The new law that came into effect,
- 15:28what was it, 2022 June. The new law The divorce
- 15:35can happen in several ways now he kicked her
- 15:38out. She has had three periods Done. They're
- 15:41divorced. Yeah He has consummated no children.
- 15:45No problem. He has consummated done full maha
- 15:51So the words the lock don't need to be said They
- 15:56don't have to be said it can be it can be you
- 16:00can kick somebody out or tell somebody to go
- 16:03away. That also is considered talaq. So on the
- 16:07basis that's constructing a divorce, the situation
- 16:11is that she cannot continue in the marriage.
- 16:13So even if you don't say the words, you are constructing
- 16:17a divorce for her. However, sadly, yeah, but
- 16:21in England, we don't have that pleasure that
- 16:24you have of a great law in Saudi that does that
- 16:27logical position. In England, They leave everything
- 16:31up to the husband, whether he wants to divorce
- 16:33her or not. And if not, the first is not applicable,
- 16:37applicable because it's not nullity. They it
- 16:40was a valid marriage and she's not arguing. It's
- 16:43null and void. But here we have a concept of
- 16:46the freak, which is the judicial panel or that
- 16:50in your court, it would have been the Kadi, the
- 16:53Islamic judge gives a divorce. Can I ask you
- 16:56in Saudi, do you have the freak? Which is full
- 17:00-based divorce? No. Fasq, we have talaq. Fasq,
- 17:05talaq, the man goes and does it. Fasq, and...
- 17:10What was the other word? Because the fasq, there's
- 17:13fasq bi awad and bidun awad. She returns the
- 17:17mahar. She doesn't want him. She decided she
- 17:19wants to go and live on her own, whatever. That
- 17:22is called fasq bi awad. So she returns the dowry.
- 17:29But if he has kicked her out, he has mistaken
- 17:33care of her, there is damages that has happened
- 17:36to her, then it is... Therefore, she does not
- 17:41return the dowry. And the judge will divorce
- 17:45her from him. Well, the judge will actually yell
- 17:47at the man and tell him to say the words. But
- 17:50it's the same thing. If he doesn't want to say
- 17:52them, the judge will issue a court order that
- 17:54she's been divorced. I'd be very interested to
- 17:57know, Al, in California, what would happen? Would
- 18:00the judge say, you're being unreasonable, you
- 18:03need to give the Islamic divorce now, and I encourage
- 18:07you to do the right thing? Or would he just leave
- 18:10it up to her to be trapped in this marriage forever?
- 18:14I mean, that's such a great question. And I think
- 18:17in California, it's a completely secular based
- 18:19system. And so What we would really draw on is
- 18:23something similar to what you were doing, Anna,
- 18:26is, is there a contract -based enforcement for
- 18:29a marriage certificate? Because we will, under
- 18:32the marriage of Fernandez case, interpret foreign
- 18:35agreements if they're done in an appropriate
- 18:38manner as a binding prenuptial agreement. And
- 18:43so there's good precedent in our law to do that.
- 18:45And then also your contract analysis is another
- 18:50avenue that one could go into in filing a civil
- 18:53lawsuit. But very much like England, there is
- 18:57no, in fact, rights right now for cohabitees,
- 19:02except a very narrow exception for what we call
- 19:04Marvin actions, which goes back to a celebrity
- 19:07a long time ago, Lee Marvin, who was living with
- 19:11someone that made some promises, I'll take care
- 19:13of you for the rest of your life. but they're
- 19:16more of a rare case. We see those often here
- 19:18in Beverly Hills. So just for our listeners to
- 19:22understand, in terms of getting into a court
- 19:26in the UK, it's true that if both parties are
- 19:30nationals of the UK, even if they're living abroad,
- 19:33they could bring an action in the UK courts.
- 19:37Is that right? Well, under matrimonial law, it's
- 19:40a bit stricter. Even if you're a British national,
- 19:43you have to be in the country for at least six
- 19:45months. If you're not a national, be there at
- 19:49least one year. You have to show a connection
- 19:51to the UK. So there could be a property here.
- 19:55But if you really can't find any connection,
- 19:57we have a concept called domicile. So domicile
- 20:00of choice. You can get to England somehow. So
- 20:04if you suddenly find, you can say to the judge,
- 20:07the air only smells sweet in England and I can
- 20:10breathe again, that's enough to get you into
- 20:13English law. So, you know, we've had to do quite
- 20:16a few things. English law is usually a very generous
- 20:20jurisdiction for women. And I guess my question
- 20:24for you, Dr. Youssef, let's say the wife is residing
- 20:27in California, husband's in Saudi Arabia. but
- 20:30she would get a better, she would get a better
- 20:32enforcement in Saudi Arabia. Does she then have
- 20:35to go to Saudi Arabia to seek the divorce or
- 20:37does she, can she still pursue it? Power of attorney.
- 20:43Okay. Explain how that works because we don't
- 20:46make, we don't have the same concept here in
- 20:48the states. Because she's in the state, you don't
- 20:50have a power of attorney in the states? We do,
- 20:52but it's a different meaning I think than what
- 20:54you mean, Dr. Yusuf. When I do a piece of paper
- 20:59that says I give out the right to sell my house,
- 21:04to find me a bride to whatever in the States,
- 21:09for instance. Right. And it is stamped and signed
- 21:14by a notary public. So she could have someone
- 21:18with the power of attorney in Saudi Arabia act
- 21:20on her behalf to then seek the divorce. On her
- 21:22behalf and divorce to raise a case etc against
- 21:25my husband and have the name everything clear
- 21:28and then send it to the lawyer and then the lawyer
- 21:31has to translate it to Arabic. Oh she has to
- 21:35stamp it at the Saudi embassy or consulate in
- 21:38the states. and then send it all the way over
- 21:41to Saudi Arabia by DHL, whatever. The lawyer
- 21:45receives it. He has to take it to the ministry
- 21:48of the, what is it called, the external, the
- 21:54ministry, the one involved with all the passports,
- 21:57et cetera, et cetera. The, what is it called,
- 22:00ministry of exterior. Okay. And have it stamped
- 22:03there. Then take it to the ministry of justice
- 22:05and have it stamped there. Plus the translation.
- 22:10A certified translation. And then he has the
- 22:14power of attorney to represent her in the court
- 22:16here and go crazy. So she could live in LA and
- 22:21do that, right? She could live in LA and do that?
- 22:23How long does that process take? Is it a very
- 22:26difficult process? Well, it's just the stamps.
- 22:30It costs like 300 reals to do it at the Foreign
- 22:33Office. That's right, not Ministry of the Exterior,
- 22:35Foreign Office. It costs 300 reals, which is
- 22:40less than 50, 60 quid, to have it stamped there,
- 22:44authenticate the embassy's stamp or the consulate's
- 22:47stamp. And then both these stamps are taken to
- 22:51the Ministry of Justice, where they certify those
- 22:55stamps. That's just to make sure that that person
- 22:59has, because she has to represent herself in
- 23:02person at the embassy for them to stamp it and
- 23:05then when it arrives here. Once it's stamped
- 23:07by the Ministry of Justice here, it's done. So
- 23:11let's say that took two to three months. How
- 23:13long is the court process? No, it's the trip
- 23:16of the DHL and one week here maybe. One week.
- 23:20Okay, excellent. What's the court process? How
- 23:22long is that? The court process, he raises the
- 23:26case with her power of attorney. He goes through
- 23:29it. He keeps on going, you know, whenever they
- 23:32determine a court date. And that's it. It depends
- 23:36on, because are we speaking about the same past
- 23:40case that was represented? Any case? Well, you
- 23:47have untouchables, so, you know. Let's say there's
- 23:52a US -based or UK -based woman who wants to recover
- 23:56a very nice lump sum in Saudi. You think that
- 24:01she could get the court process over within three
- 24:04months? Well, usually these untouchables, high
- 24:07-class untouchables, once the case is raised,
- 24:11he goes and pays up, just shuts it down. He doesn't
- 24:14want it on his record, so he closes it. Especially
- 24:17if, you know, these people with this extra...
- 24:20Income, so they'll close it. Sometimes they will
- 24:23fight. He will have his own lawyer and his lawyer
- 24:25will say, she did this, she did that, she did
- 24:27this. Trying to annul the marriage because of
- 24:31cheating, whatever, trying to start, and it gets
- 24:36dirty. What I would be interested... That's fascinating.
- 24:39Yeah. If you had a client like this, and let's
- 24:41say I had a client, and we think it's quick and
- 24:44easy to get this in Saudi, would we think...
- 24:48um the Saudi courts need a connection to Saudi
- 24:51like one of them should have some kind of link
- 24:54to the country or would the courts be happy to
- 24:57waste their time with foreign nationals using
- 24:59their jurisdiction that they use that if you're
- 25:03a foreign national residing here in Saudi Arabia
- 25:05it's automatic for the Saudi courts that's no
- 25:07problem somebody outside you will need a power
- 25:10of attorney The teams does not work. The Ministry
- 25:15of Justice teams does not work over borders.
- 25:19It only works inside of Saudi Arabia. So the
- 25:22power of attorney person will have to do teams
- 25:26for instance on the mobile and represent it to
- 25:30the judge because he will actually want to question
- 25:32the woman to get information out of her and therefore
- 25:36she'll have proper attire. scarf, et cetera,
- 25:41she'll have her ID to show to him that this is
- 25:44her and the power of attorney is there. And then
- 25:47the judge will actually ask her questions over
- 25:51another way because his teams will not show up
- 25:55on, it will not connect internationally. It's
- 26:01really fascinating because the fact of the matter
- 26:05is you can't do that in the US. You can't have
- 26:07a power of attorney person representing you in
- 26:10court to get essentially to get jurisdiction.
- 26:14So that's a really important thing, I think,
- 26:16for US practitioners to understand is that if
- 26:20you do have a situation like this and you're
- 26:23concerned, for example, it may be a very long,
- 26:25arduous process. I know if you do a civil lawsuit
- 26:28in the United States, it can take up to five
- 26:30years to get through the system. And so you can
- 26:34go and if you have the connection, if you have
- 26:36the nexus, Now, I would say what someone might
- 26:39do is they might file a divorce case here and
- 26:42then argue that there's a jurisdictional battle
- 26:45over it. Anna, is it also a similar, a long period
- 26:49of time that it would take to go through the
- 26:51civil courts in England to enforce a, like in
- 26:53the case that you talked about where you're trying
- 26:55to enforce a 1 .4 million dowry, would it be
- 26:58a similar length of time or would it be less
- 27:01in the UK? Much less, thank goodness. So post
- 27:05-COVID, the courts have recovered. quite well
- 27:07and the listings are back to normal it's a civil
- 27:10court so it's actually quicker than the matrimonial
- 27:13court and the judges are really astute to commercial
- 27:19contracts and they're very keen on enforcing
- 27:21them so we feel very comfortable filing in a
- 27:24civil court they will be one stop usually they
- 27:29will stop it at the first hearing for mediation
- 27:32and they will order them even if there's been
- 27:34abuse, like there has been in a lot of cases,
- 27:37to do shuttle mediation. So they go between different
- 27:42rooms, the mediators, to try and reach a solution.
- 27:45But the judge will hold the trial probably for
- 27:47a couple of months to allow this to settle with
- 27:51non -court dispute resolution. If that doesn't
- 27:54work, then it's listed fairly quickly. Case management
- 27:57hearing is listed. to see how many witnesses
- 27:59would there be an expert in sharia law needed
- 28:03to be cross -examined because a husband is likely
- 28:06to contest it all the way okay and then there'll
- 28:09be a final trial with witnesses which can be
- 28:13two three days listing with the time estimate
- 28:16so probably within a year we hope to get somewhere
- 28:20it's not so bad at all Dr. Youssef, how long
- 28:24would it take your average case? We do have mediation,
- 28:28especially as it's divorce. They go straight
- 28:31to a person who calls up the husband, chats with
- 28:35him, calls up the wife, chats with them, try
- 28:37to bring them together. That's less than a week.
- 28:42He was unable to solve the situation automatically
- 28:48when it was unable to join them. to, you know,
- 28:53correct the situation, transfer to the judge.
- 28:56Next day there will be a court which will be
- 28:59next week. I have one who has now two days. The
- 29:05session has been left open on Teams because he
- 29:10requires a medical report where the husband was
- 29:13abusing her, beat her up, and she had to go to
- 29:16the hospital. And they made it secret because
- 29:19it's above 14 days of cure. So the police keep
- 29:23it secret because it's actually also a criminal
- 29:26offense where he will actually go to jail because
- 29:29it's over 14 days because it's, you know, it's
- 29:32a criminal matter as well, not just a family
- 29:36matter. So the police are keeping it as a secret
- 29:39report and they're trying to get the copy of
- 29:41the report to give to the judge because he says,
- 29:44bring me the report. I will finish the marriage.
- 29:48No return of dowry. Don't bring me the report.
- 29:51you will have to return the dowry. And they have
- 29:55four children and the latest is two months and
- 29:58the oldest is four years old. Wow. And so how
- 30:03long would that case take to go through the system
- 30:05to start to finish? It was one. You raise the
- 30:11case, they say, OK, next week we'll have a mediator.
- 30:16The mediator will call them up. unable to cure,
- 30:22the next week will be the court session. He will
- 30:26call them up once or twice at tops. So very expedient,
- 30:30very fast. Yes, yes. And Anna, in your experience,
- 30:35there is, for our audience in the States to understand,
- 30:40there's jurisdictions in the Middle East that
- 30:42go very fast in terms of their marriage, but
- 30:45do they also... Are the women able to recover
- 30:48the same types of rights as they might be in
- 30:50other contexts? So that's the problem because
- 30:54you have to look at what you're going to actually
- 30:57be able to recover and also enforce. It's no
- 31:00good having a piece of paper which doesn't mean
- 31:02anything. So if you have a big Meher financial
- 31:07settlement that's worth enforcing straight away.
- 31:10If you've had a nominal amount, which most women
- 31:13actually, because they don't know the significance,
- 31:16just let the Wali or the father or uncle who's
- 31:20the guardian at the time, just negotiate a nominal
- 31:23amount. I've seen 101 pounds quite regularly
- 31:26as the lump sum. So that's very sad when that
- 31:29happens. It's almost like a dismissive, oh, well,
- 31:32we know Islam gives you rights, but let's just...
- 31:35not ask for any shall we and let's just dismiss
- 31:37it in the contract so because she didn't have
- 31:40it put in the contract she's then relying on
- 31:44the Islamic law which is simply three months
- 31:49in that period which is three menstrual cycles
- 31:51to complete after the divorce notice is given
- 31:55by the husband is she pregnant if so the husband
- 31:59is responsible for the child fully if she's not
- 32:03pregnant he just has to maintain her for those
- 32:06three months after that there is no connection
- 32:09between them they both start with a clean break
- 32:12so it shows the critical importance of putting
- 32:16the meher in place discussing it well before
- 32:19the wedding don't do it on the day and announce
- 32:22it that this is how much i want and try and do
- 32:25it through mediators like an uncle or brother,
- 32:29rather than the woman trying to have this difficult
- 32:31conversation with her intended. So I would say
- 32:34put that in place. Otherwise, she's reliant completely
- 32:37on civil law, which becomes really difficult.
- 32:41In England, you may have matrimonial rights,
- 32:44which is great. Okay, but if you never registered
- 32:48your marriage, which about 80 % plus of Muslims
- 32:51in the UK were not doing, they were just having
- 32:54a religious marriage and not registering, then
- 32:59you're outside the courtroom trying to negotiate.
- 33:03And tell us a little bit about your registration
- 33:05of marriage initiative. And how does that affect
- 33:09if you can do a second go around of a divorce
- 33:11in the UK? So register on marriage campaign I
- 33:15launched because of the amount of calls I used
- 33:17to get saying that I found out after 30 years
- 33:21of marriage, I have no legal rights. He told
- 33:24me that we were married. for example, or he died.
- 33:28We were very happy. He died and the in -laws
- 33:31have taken over the houses that we had together
- 33:34saying, you're just a girlfriend. I have four
- 33:37children and I'm homeless. These stories are
- 33:39horrific. It could never happen in a Muslim country.
- 33:43In a Muslim country, you're forced to register
- 33:46your marriage. The state has to know you're legally
- 33:49married so that women and children are protected.
- 33:52So I couldn't believe in the UK in 21st century
- 33:56Britain we are having this happening to British
- 33:59born and raised women not foreign women by the
- 34:03way if a Saudi woman had a divorce in Saudi she
- 34:07would have all her legal rights under English
- 34:09law the judge would bend over backwards to give
- 34:12her all her rights under English law because
- 34:14she had a legal marriage in Saudi but the same
- 34:17woman sister who didn't register in England has
- 34:20zero rights. Imagine the frustration as a lawyer.
- 34:24So I launched this campaign which has been very
- 34:27popular in terms of awareness building. So all
- 34:31the faith leaders, including the Imams, have
- 34:33then understood their obligations to register
- 34:36marriages and they are becoming much more responsible.
- 34:41by telling the couple what they'll face if they
- 34:44don't but we're waiting for the government to
- 34:46actually recognize this appalling injustice and
- 34:49update the law because we only have three countries
- 34:52in the UK that have any obligation to register
- 34:56their marriages and everybody else has to just
- 34:59take their potluck according to their rights
- 35:03you know what those countries are those faiths
- 35:06are can you have a guess what no no tell us okay
- 35:10so it will be the church of england because that's
- 35:12the established church of course they have to
- 35:15register the Jewish community and something called
- 35:19Quakers society of friends hardly 10 000 of them
- 35:23but nobody knows about them but they've got complete
- 35:26rights they're known in the states oh they are
- 35:30yes yeah no not in England and you have the Quaker
- 35:33state oh you have the you have that of course
- 35:36you have much more than we do now uh amount of
- 35:41people here and 1949 that's when the law is stuck
- 35:46before mass migration brought over four million
- 35:50muslims hindus seeks all of them left unprotected
- 35:54do you know catholics are left unprotected so
- 35:56they have to be that's fascinating because in
- 35:58the states all all marriages have to you have
- 36:01to get a marriage license yeah and then the officiant
- 36:05has to submit the marriage license but even if
- 36:07that doesn't happen, you can be considered semi
- 36:12-spouses or quasi -spouses. So, you can still
- 36:14get all your rights even if you believed, if
- 36:17one party even believes they were married. Now,
- 36:20something that people are really going to want
- 36:21to understand, because I've seen many cases involving
- 36:23the Middle East with child custody, is the different
- 36:27ways in which Middle Eastern countries deal with
- 36:30a child custody. So, Dr. Yusuf, can you tell
- 36:32us a little bit about, in general, Saudi Arabia?
- 36:36Now, I'll go back to that. unregistered marriages
- 36:38first. Here, registered or unregistered, you
- 36:42need two witnesses to say, yes, they said they
- 36:46were husband and wife or they were living together
- 36:48or whatever. Done. They're married. For not registering,
- 36:53it is a, okay, to the exchange rate today, it
- 36:57is $13 .33 a fine to pay because you do not register
- 37:03the marriage certificate or do not register the
- 37:06match. Yeah. Wow. Wow. British pounds, that would
- 37:12be £9 .88. How lucky are you feeling today? Is
- 37:21that a daily fine, Dr. Youssef? No, that's a
- 37:26one -off fine. Oh, interesting. You were married
- 37:29for 40 years and you didn't register. Okay, give
- 37:32us the $13 and you're registered now. Oh, fascinating.
- 37:38My question was something that comes up a lot
- 37:40is that we see is child custody differences between
- 37:44the U .S. and the Mideast and Saudi Arabia. Can
- 37:47you tell us a little bit in what's the general
- 37:49framework in Saudi Arabia? And I know it's different
- 37:52by different countries in the Mideast, but tell
- 37:54us a little bit about that framework in Saudi
- 37:56Arabia as the Islamic way. Boy, seven to nine,
- 38:01the girl seven to nine, depending on the judge.
- 38:04He may talk with the children just to see if
- 38:07they understand what it is. But the general idea
- 38:11is the mother has custody. Father? When the child
- 38:19is old enough to say, I don't want mama, I want
- 38:22to go to daddy. which is past nine years old,
- 38:27seven years old, depending on what the child's,
- 38:31you know, how the child's brain is working. What
- 38:35about the woman, sorry, the girl child, if it's
- 38:38a daughter? The girl child should stay with their
- 38:41mother, they have a mediator in between. The
- 38:44mediator will try to actually convince the children
- 38:50to stay with their mother. you know, basically,
- 38:54but sometimes their mother doesn't have an interest
- 38:59or whatever or relinquishes her rights and says,
- 39:02I don't want them. They can go to their father.
- 39:05But as long as they're with their mother, the
- 39:07father will spend until the boy is about 18,
- 39:1119 years old. He finishes being a student. The
- 39:16girl until she gets married. He will pay child
- 39:21support. Is there any difference, Anna, based
- 39:24on religious community and child custody, or
- 39:26is it just the same across the board in the UK?
- 39:30For Muslim families? Yes, yeah. Yes. No, we do
- 39:34have different sects, like the Sunnis have four
- 39:37different schools of thought. Then the Shias
- 39:40will have their own school of thought. So when
- 39:42I have different Muslim clients, I have to go
- 39:46by each person's own laws. and regulations but
- 39:51generally it's the same as Dr Al Umbri has said
- 39:55that a woman keeps her daughter with her until
- 39:59she's married it's just considered more seemingly
- 40:02for a daughter not to have to go and live with
- 40:05her father she should stay with her mother and
- 40:08for a son generally over the age of understanding
- 40:11which is seven to nine depending on how advanced
- 40:15they are in their thinking, they can choose to
- 40:19go and live with their father. So English law
- 40:23doesn't go against this in any way. It's the
- 40:26same thing, but it's got to be a child -centered
- 40:29approach. Usually English law will appoint a
- 40:31court officer to listen to the wishes and feelings
- 40:34of the children and ask who they want to go to,
- 40:37as well as tell them who they should go to. And
- 40:41would they respect the preferences of the family
- 40:45if they want to follow a Muslim approach on child
- 40:49custody? Not in the past. Some judges have been
- 40:53very difficult and have ordered a two -year -old
- 40:56girl to go to the father, even though it was
- 41:02clear that he was going to put her in a nursery
- 41:04from 6 a .m. to 6 p .m. But because the mother
- 41:07came across so badly to the judge and was argumentative,
- 41:10and difficult, that its order was made. But it
- 41:13doesn't work in real life. That woman just kidnapped,
- 41:17abducted the child abroad and never brought her
- 41:19back. So people vote with their feet. Wow. Wow.
- 41:25That's fascinating. Keep in mind here in Saudi
- 41:29Arabia, he has to pay child support. The husband
- 41:32or the father has to pay child support. On the
- 41:35Ministry of Justice site, there's a calculator.
- 41:40which he enters his income, and how many children,
- 41:43etc. And that will come out with how many, or
- 41:46the amount of money that the judge has to stick
- 41:50around kind of for spending on the child. So
- 41:55there's a child support is not like, I don't
- 41:59know how it's done in the states, but here there's
- 42:01actually a an app for it. Yeah, we have. Yeah,
- 42:08yeah. And is it based on just income of the father?
- 42:13Do they factor in the mother's income as well?
- 42:15He's in debt. He's about to go to jail. It doesn't
- 42:19care. How much is his salary? Or how much is
- 42:24his income? And the mother's income does not
- 42:26matter? No, not at all. The mother may be a millionaire.
- 42:30The father is a taxi driver, for instance. His
- 42:35income. Nothing to do with the mother. And it's
- 42:39so different in the states because in California
- 42:43in particular, they have a presumption that both
- 42:47parents are gonna be significantly involved in
- 42:50the upbringing of the children. And the way that
- 42:52that's applied a lot of times is there's a presumption
- 42:55towards 50 -50. It's not written that way, but
- 42:58in application we see often with judicial officers
- 43:01that they'll impose a 50 -50. time share, but
- 43:05they still have to consider the best interest
- 43:06of the children. So you do often see they look
- 43:08at the primary care provider, which many times
- 43:11may be the mother and that the mother may have
- 43:14more time or the father if they're the primary
- 43:17care provider. Is there any analysis like that
- 43:21or is it more based off of what you've described?
- 43:25Okay, I have another thing. You mentioned prenuptial
- 43:28agreements earlier. Okay. inheritance law she's
- 43:36his wife she gets her share there's a prenuptial
- 43:40agreement there isn't same oh interesting so
- 43:44they wouldn't in Saudi they wouldn't look at
- 43:45it he dies he dies he can only will away a third
- 43:50of his fortune not more than a third to a non
- 43:56inheritance person inherited person gets their
- 44:00share They're not an inherited person and he
- 44:04wants to will all his money, for instance, to
- 44:07his driver. His driver gets a third and the two
- 44:13-thirds go to the people who are supposed to
- 44:16inherit him legally. Wife, son. He has a son,
- 44:21everybody else is kicked out. No uncle, no whatever.
- 44:26He only has a daughter. It's a difference between
- 44:28Sunni and Shia. Shia, yes his brother will go
- 44:33in or his father will come in, but they give
- 44:39it all to the daughter. Under Sunni, half will
- 44:43go to the daughter, for instance one daughter,
- 44:45half will go to the daughter and eighth to the
- 44:48mother and the rest goes to the uncle. The formula
- 44:53is in the Quran, so you have to be very brave
- 44:58to argue against it. You just cannot go there.
- 45:0211, 12, 13, and the last ayah. There's four verses
- 45:07in the Quran that put that all out there. And
- 45:12it's something to note. In family law, obviously
- 45:17in your jurisdictions, family law and succession
- 45:20and inheritance are intertwined. In California,
- 45:22we think of those as separate concepts. They're
- 45:24different. different court jurisdictions, same
- 45:27superior court, but different jurisdictions within
- 45:30the court. You have the family court and you
- 45:32have the probate court that handle things differently.
- 45:35But it's all based off of our community property
- 45:38system. So if you die and you die in testate,
- 45:41there's a presumption that similarly that it
- 45:43will go to your spouse. And if you don't have
- 45:45a spouse, it's divided up amongst your children.
- 45:47But minor children are always protected with
- 45:49a certain uh share so it's it's a similar statutory
- 45:53situation but with the will you can you can cut
- 45:56out certain uh people with your property but
- 45:59you can't cut out your minor children in general
- 46:02so it's very different in england we have something
- 46:06called testamentary disposition and the english
- 46:09are very proud of it they uphold it always and
- 46:14it means you can give everything to the dog's
- 46:16home and cut out your children cut out everyone.
- 46:20It's absolutely outrageous. And can you believe
- 46:24those people are then dependent on the welfare
- 46:26benefit system and the taxpayer has to support
- 46:30them while the will has made an unfair disposition
- 46:35as far as I can see? It seems like an injustice
- 46:40to the taxpayer. You do have a little bit of
- 46:46help if you can afford to go to court. If you
- 46:49were a dependent, like a minor child or a girlfriend
- 46:53who was paid for by this man, let's say it's
- 46:56a man, then you go under the Inheritance and
- 46:59Dependence Act. So there is a claim, but it's
- 47:03very hard to expect people to go to the law to
- 47:06claim things. It should just be done from the
- 47:09beginning. On a little bit of a different note,
- 47:12because I think this must come up quite a bit
- 47:15in the context of Saudi Arabian Middle Eastern
- 47:20divorces. You have a client that comes to you.
- 47:23They say, look, I have the divorce from the Middle
- 47:26East, but the assets are here in the UK. What's
- 47:30your ability in the UK to enforce a foreign asset
- 47:35division? Our judges love them. Judges love them.
- 47:39I send it to Anya. Yeah, you send it to me, Youssef.
- 47:43You too. is in England. It's under Part 3. We
- 47:49have something called a Part 3 jurisdiction.
- 47:52And I can gather in all the assets in the UK,
- 47:56bank accounts, yachts, whatever they have, and
- 48:01base it on the foreign divorce, which then allows
- 48:04the trigger to be pulled on the English claim
- 48:07and divide it according to English law. And do
- 48:10they have to, for example, take a look at you
- 48:14know, the other forum if there is due process
- 48:17or how they how the legal system operated if
- 48:19they're they were conformity or will they just
- 48:21take that foreign divorce and enforce it? They
- 48:25love seizing hold of things. So the English judges
- 48:27love, you know, having large asset divorces for
- 48:31sure. You could be in the Philippines and have
- 48:33no connection with England and suddenly develop
- 48:35a love of England and turn up and you enforce
- 48:39your divorce. and say, I'm domiciled here now,
- 48:42this is my domicile of choice. Of course, there'll
- 48:45be a fight on jurisdiction, but usually the judges
- 48:47get hold of everything. You've seen the Sheikh
- 48:50of Dubai. Sheikh of Dubai's wife, you heard about
- 48:53that? Yes. Sheikh Al Maktoum, his wife, came
- 48:56to England and decided because she liked having
- 49:00racing horses in England, that's where she'll
- 49:03have her divorce. And you could even get a second
- 49:06chance at a bite of the apple if you don't like
- 49:08your divorce and the other jurisdiction you can
- 49:10come to the UK? We call it second bite of the
- 49:15cherry. You call it apple, I think. Second bite
- 49:19of the apple in the States. How interesting.
- 49:22So we had usually say no second bite of the cherry.
- 49:26You're supposed to just make up your mind where
- 49:28you want to go, try once. So it's a bit like
- 49:31double jeopardy. You can't do the same thing
- 49:33twice. Dr. Yousef, how about enforcing foreign
- 49:37judgments in Saudi? Okay, enforcing foreign judgments
- 49:41in Saudi, they will be enforced. The judge will
- 49:44enforce them. You have to have them translated
- 49:46and stamped, just like the power of attorney.
- 49:50You know, that's just typical procedural because
- 49:53the judge does not read English. So he makes
- 49:56sure that this written in Arabic is actually
- 49:59what is written in English. The only thing he
- 50:02will not enforce is anything that is against
- 50:05Islam. Have you seen that in application? Okay,
- 50:11I had a case a while back which involved a court
- 50:15order from Harain. But it was the interest, he
- 50:23was a guy who took a loan, well he took a loan
- 50:26from half the banks in the world a while back.
- 50:32The interest was adding up. it was increasing
- 50:37interest on the loan that he had taken from the
- 50:41bank. It was something like $200 million. It's
- 50:44a very well -known thing, but I don't want to
- 50:47put the name out here. Anyway, that bit, it cannot
- 50:51be enforced. Whiten Case had written an article
- 50:57that, yes, it will be enforced because Saudi
- 50:59Arabia has signed this, this, this treaty. And
- 51:03Stevenson Howard had taken up the idea that,
- 51:06you know, they asked me for an expert opinion.
- 51:09So I gave them the extra opinion. It is not going
- 51:11to be enforced until that manipulate of interest
- 51:16is not removed. Because under Islam, interest
- 51:19is considered haram. It's not acceptable. It
- 51:23is taboo. So you don't do interest. And that
- 51:29was increasing interest, which is very, you know,
- 51:34so they actually, it won't work if it's against
- 51:39Islam. If it's not against Islam, the judge will
- 51:42enforce it. So there is some review based on
- 51:45local rules. And if you can, you can kind of
- 51:48defeat a foreign judgment if it goes contradictory
- 51:50to Islam, but otherwise in general. Otherwise
- 51:53it's enforced. Yes. Yes. And I'm kind of curious,
- 51:59Anna, you were talking about this a little bit,
- 52:01but what do you see as the future of Islamic
- 52:05family law in the UK and internationally? In
- 52:11a dream scenario, the law would be updated so
- 52:15that it's fit for purpose and that people are
- 52:17protected in legal marriages. So the whole world
- 52:25would be the same. Whichever country you went
- 52:27to, you would have your religious marriage registered
- 52:30and it would apply equally. It's not that you
- 52:33can go to Saudi and it's legal. You come back
- 52:35to England, it's not legal. Then you go to another
- 52:38country and it's suddenly legal again. It's it's
- 52:41ridiculous. We need clarity and we need there
- 52:44to be no conflict of laws. So that's one shopping.
- 52:48Yeah. Exactly. We can't have that. That's not
- 52:51justice. So English law really needs to get its
- 52:54act together. I strongly urge anyone who's watching
- 52:57who's got power over the government to urge them
- 53:00to change the law. It doesn't take long to say
- 53:03all faiths must register their marriages. Then
- 53:06you can go and have your religious ceremony and
- 53:09do whatever you want. But at the point of the
- 53:12marriage contract, it should be legal. OK, so
- 53:15that's the first thing I'd like to see happening.
- 53:17And then on top of that, that I think would take
- 53:21away a lot of the problems we have with women
- 53:24having to go to Sharia councils. Trump even went
- 53:27there and talked about Sharia taking over England.
- 53:31You must have seen that recently. So Donald Trump,
- 53:34President Trump says, we are succumbing to Sharia
- 53:38as we speak. It's an invasion. Hello, we've been
- 53:41having this discussion for 40 years. Sharia councils
- 53:45were set up in the early 80s in response to the
- 53:50demand from women to have a divorce because the
- 53:53men were keeping them chained. In England, where
- 53:55does she go to get a divorce? So for women's
- 53:59rights, Sharia councils grew up and they gave
- 54:02women their divorces and their Meher. So they
- 54:06did some great work. However, If you could have
- 54:09a legal marriage in the first place, then it's
- 54:11up to you not to go to a Sharia council. You
- 54:14could have your civil divorce. In most Muslim
- 54:18countries, Dr. Amri will correct me if I'm wrong,
- 54:22in most Muslim countries they actually accept
- 54:25the civil divorce of the foreign country rather
- 54:28than a Sharia council divorce from an organization
- 54:32that has no status, no impossibility. So a Sharia
- 54:36council divorce will not be accepted in Saudi,
- 54:38but an English divorce will. It's very interesting.
- 54:42I'd like clarity on that. I'd like a woman to
- 54:44know, a man to know when he's married. I'd like
- 54:48him to know when he's divorced and I'd like to
- 54:50know he's free to remarry. So let there be clarity.
- 54:54Most of my expert opinions that I have to give
- 54:56are for people who are thoroughly confused. It's
- 55:00understandable. Yeah, for sure. The judges don't
- 55:03know if they're legally married. And two judges
- 55:06will differ. So it will be a dream scenario for
- 55:10me to have to do no more expert reports and to
- 55:13have utter clarity. I've done myself out of a
- 55:16job. There we are. But it saved a lot of injustice
- 55:21in the doing. Dr. Al -Amri, what What do you
- 55:25see as the future of Islamic family law in an
- 55:29international context? Basically, it's been the
- 55:32same for the last 1400 years. It hasn't changed.
- 55:35It's the same. Right now, it's being printed,
- 55:39organized, fine -tuned. For instance, unregistered
- 55:44marriage, whatever, whatever. It's the same as
- 55:46it was a thousand years ago. It's the same. It
- 55:49hasn't changed. it's only being fine -tuned written
- 55:53down that yes you can do this no you cannot do
- 55:55that yes you can do this and so on there's about
- 55:59close to 300 articles in the new family law which
- 56:04actually are the same of you know i all i got
- 56:08to do is go over it because i know what's in
- 56:11it and it was just issued i don't have to read
- 56:14it because i know what's in it because it's the
- 56:17same as it was before but it's just written down
- 56:19now instead of leaving it to the whims of the
- 56:22judge as for instance a marriage is registered
- 56:27not registered they consummated there was some
- 56:31sort of dowry okay she was a virgin she was not
- 56:37that makes a difference under Hanbali and I think
- 56:40Hanafi as well if she was a virgin before her
- 56:45father has to give her away but in three of the
- 56:53four if she is not a virgin then she doesn't
- 56:57need her welly or her father or guardian to give
- 57:03her away what happens is all they need is a dowry
- 57:09which can be anything it can be a Coca -Cola
- 57:14cap you know those old ones that you lift up
- 57:17and she wears it as a ring and he gives it to
- 57:21her as a dowry that can be two witnesses okay
- 57:26which are also considered everybody knows because
- 57:29it's two people have witnessed it she accepts
- 57:33he accepts they're married the piece of paper
- 57:38will cost 13 but you have the two witnesses etc
- 57:42they're married they have a child he's not born
- 57:46out of wedlock He was born to a married couple
- 57:49because the framework for a marriage was already
- 57:56there. It just needed that guy to write on a
- 57:59piece of paper that, you know, the diary was
- 58:01this, the whatever was this. That's all it needed.
- 58:05But that was missing and that was just something
- 58:07extra. And I think, you know, I think in terms
- 58:12of for the for our listeners in Beverly Hills
- 58:16and abroad, The key takeaways from this to me
- 58:20seem to be that if you're facing an Islamic marriage,
- 58:26you really need to understand what the dowry
- 58:29is, where that would be best enforceable. If
- 58:33it's in your jurisdiction, if it's in Saudi or
- 58:36Middle Eastern jurisdiction, or if it's potentially
- 58:39in the UK, which you can still seek enforcement.
- 58:44It's also important to note that both forms,
- 58:47Saudi, UK, they're going to enforce foreign judgments.
- 58:51But if you don't like your foreign judgment,
- 58:54you can get a second bite of the apple or the
- 58:56second bite of the cherry in the UK. But also,
- 59:01if it's inconsistent with Islam, it might not
- 59:05get enforced in Saudi. A Saudi judge will reject
- 59:10a case. all the other side has to say is, it
- 59:14has already been judged. And he may reject and
- 59:17may not, considering if he accepts from a non
- 59:20-Islamic or not. Because as we said, the judgment
- 59:25has to be not against Islam or anything, you
- 59:29know, against any ruling, Islam rules. And therefore,
- 59:32if the judgment is not against any Islamic rules
- 59:35that was judged before in another country, you
- 59:38try, when you come here to take the... second
- 59:41bite out of the apple, it won't work if the judge
- 59:46accepts that judgment, which is the best defense
- 59:49for closing the matter basically. And I just
- 59:56want to thank you, Anna, for your time and your
- 1:00:00explanation. And I know that if anybody has a
- 1:00:03Islamic law issue involving the UK and the states
- 1:00:07or elsewhere, they should give you a call. And
- 1:00:09I also want to thank so much Dr. Youssef, who
- 1:00:13is an amazing scholar and legal mind. And if
- 1:00:16you have any issues related to Islamic law, he
- 1:00:19is a go -to person in Saudi law. with all of
- 1:00:23his experience in being a founding member of
- 1:00:25the faculty of the law school in Jeddah. So thank
- 1:00:30you both for your time and for bringing light
- 1:00:33to this. I think it's going to make such a big
- 1:00:36difference for so many practitioners here in
- 1:00:38the Los Angeles area.