Latest / BREAK/FIX the Motorsports & Vehicle Enthusiast Variety Show / Literature Review on Women in Motorsports (Mike Stocz)
Transcript
- 0:00BreakFix's History of Motorsports series is brought to you in part
- 0:04by the International Motor Racing Research Center, as well as the
- 0:07Society of Automotive Historians, the Watkins Glen Area Chamber of
- 0:11Commerce, and the Argettsinger family.
- 0:16A literature review on women in motorsport.
- 0:18By Michael Stokes.
- 0:20While men have taken the lion's share of media attention across
- 0:23motorsport, there have been women who had gained substantial coverages.
- 0:26From Britney Forrest to Hayley Deegan, women in motorsport
- 0:28have hit sport headlines on various networks and modalities.
- 0:31While coverage of women in motorsport may be more positive in terms of quantity and
- 0:35perception, driver talent versus overt sexism, et cetera, Has academia had any
- 0:41sort of focus on women in motorsport?
- 0:43The purpose of the current literature review is to summarize the current
- 0:46academic literature across two repositories, EBSCOhost and Google
- 0:50Scholar, to gain a broader understanding of this academic realm of inquiry.
- 0:54Various search terms, including women in racing and variants,
- 0:58were included in the search.
- 0:59Initial results suggest that women in motorsport are often a part of academic
- 1:03research, but are less so the main focus.
- 1:05Using the PRISMA methodology, articles were selected from relevant criteria
- 1:10and reduced from a larger sample.
- 1:11Methods and themes from articles will be discussed.
- 1:14Mike Stokes is an Assistant Director for the Department of
- 1:17Kinesiology and Senior Lecturer of Sport Management and Leadership at
- 1:20the University of New Hampshire.
- 1:22He is one of the founding members and Editor in Chief of the Journal
- 1:25of Motorsport Culture and History.
- 1:27Mike's recent works have included a co authored book chapter about the
- 1:30future of Formula One, as well as work surrounding big game hunting
- 1:33legislation on land preserves, an economic funding model for college
- 1:37athletics, and critiques on K 12 coaching certifications surrounding sexual assault.
- 1:42All right.
- 1:42Good afternoon, everybody.
- 1:43My name is Mike Stoats.
- 1:46There's another name on there, so I definitely want to acknowledge him.
- 1:50His name is Caleb McChesney.
- 1:51He just recently graduated and helped me out with this project.
- 1:55Earlier, during Lynn's keynote, there was kind of a paraphrased quote that
- 2:00she said that I quickly wrote down because I thought, this is somewhat
- 2:05related to how, up until this point, this research project has gone.
- 2:11And the quote was there aren't enough women drivers to portray the depth within
- 2:16the sport, which also kind of went on to mean, you know, the administrators and
- 2:20such across the sport, but here and how it really comes into this presentation.
- 2:26Is there's a lot more opportunity for not just historical research,
- 2:33but academic research across various disciplines that really isn't
- 2:38being harnessed at this point.
- 2:40And I think throughout the rest of this presentation, you'll get an idea
- 2:44of the opportunity that really exists.
- 2:48So, kind of an introduction to this, a couple of years ago, Dan Simone mentioned
- 2:54that he put on a panel on women in motor sports, and this is one of the ideas
- 2:59that came from that, for me anyways.
- 3:02There was another idea I had last year about women in motor sports podcasts.
- 3:07After completing that, I thought, we need to take a step back and actually
- 3:11analyze from an academic sense.
- 3:13What is actually out there?
- 3:15So some previous research to has suggested that motorsport, not just
- 3:20NASCAR, but motorsport in general, is a male dominated, sometimes
- 3:25referred to as a form of a fraternity type of situation and atmosphere.
- 3:30Although, according to the Women in Motorsports North America organization, as
- 3:35mentioned earlier, There are roughly over 400, 000 racers that are women across 250
- 3:42sanctioning bodies, which host over 15, 000 motorsports events at 1, 200 tracks.
- 3:48Layman's terms, there's a lot of interest.
- 3:50There's a lot of participation that generally isn't being captured.
- 3:55Moving more into the academic y side of things, what this research is effectively
- 4:00about is using a systematic method for reviewing academic literature.
- 4:08And here, academic literature is defined more as peer reviewed articles.
- 4:14So, we can think if we were in college, sometimes a professor
- 4:18would hand out this article from the Journal of Sport History or similar.
- 4:23Those are the types of things that were included in this analysis.
- 4:27It was not necessarily popular press articles.
- 4:31Such as those you would see across various media entities, not
- 4:34necessarily textbooks, nor books for recreation such as faster or similar.
- 4:40So here we're talking about purely peer reviewed academic articles were the
- 4:45only things that were included in this.
- 4:47Mentioned before that this was a systematic review.
- 4:50The term Prisma encapsulates the process for doing one of these systematic reviews.
- 4:57It's a 27 step process that at 445 on a Friday we're not going to go through.
- 5:03Just know that there were a lot of different steps to get down to the
- 5:07final sample and then the actual review.
- 5:10Where we got all of the academic articles from were two giant databases.
- 5:15Maybe most of us haven't heard of either of these, but essentially think of
- 5:19them as an internet repository for what you would find at a massive library.
- 5:25The first one in particular, EBSCOhost.
- 5:27EBSCOhost has a number of different databases, in which almost any topic
- 5:33you can think of, there's probably some academic literature out there.
- 5:37Gambling, horse racing, you name it, there's probably a database associated
- 5:42and has academic literature therein.
- 5:44And then we decided to use another one that was a little bit more public.
- 5:48So most of us know what Google is.
- 5:50Google has a scholar website.
- 5:52Which is effectively a giant repository for academic articles.
- 5:57So we figured, because previous literature reviews haven't looked at Google Scholar,
- 6:02that let's take a look at them and compare them with the various EBSCOhost databases.
- 6:08So when we're using these databases, we have to basically
- 6:11tell them, what are we looking for?
- 6:13First, like, indented some point are the general search terms
- 6:17that we used for each database.
- 6:20And we'll go over a little bit later how many results came up,
- 6:24but as you can see, we're trying to encapsulate women in sport and women
- 6:28in motorsport being the prime focus of the article in some form or fashions.
- 6:34For this, there were a number of exclusions from our results list,
- 6:38which included horse racing, drones, planes, boats, cycling, skiing,
- 6:43foot racing, and baby formula, as it would relate to Formula One.
- 6:47That was one we had to exclude.
- 6:49For the eligibility status of the articles, they had to be complete,
- 6:53obviously, and one of the languages shown on the screen, English or German.
- 6:59I am NOT the German speaker in here.
- 7:01That one went more towards my student.
- 7:04For the selection of the articles, broadly speaking, we first looked
- 7:09at the title of whatever the article was, as well as the abstract.
- 7:15Think of the abstract, if you haven't done academic research or
- 7:18haven't read one of these things in a while, as kind of the preview.
- 7:21You open up that book, that first little sleeve that gives you a little
- 7:25taster of what the book is about.
- 7:27We can think of that as the abstract.
- 7:29So those were the two at least first points that we would look at, followed
- 7:33by a full manuscript review to ensure that the manuscript was mostly, in
- 7:39quotes, mostly related to women in motorsports in some form or fashion.
- 7:44We also had to come together on one or two articles where it was kind of iffy on
- 7:49whether or not they should be included.
- 7:51We did come to full consensus for.
- 7:53Both of them.
- 7:54So as I said, there are 27 steps, and these are three of them.
- 7:57Once we got the general database results, so think of when you do a general
- 8:02Google search for something, it'll say displaying 10 of blank amount of results.
- 8:09Kind of a similar thing would come up.
- 8:11The first round was a general screening, generally look, title, abstract, does
- 8:16it include our search terms, or is it primarily about our search terms?
- 8:19If yes, even vaguely yes, we would keep it around.
- 8:22The second one was, we took all of the articles that got through the first
- 8:27round, and did a little bit more of an independent deep dive on them.
- 8:31At this point there were a couple of articles that For some reason,
- 8:34it would come up blank, meaning there was no text available to them.
- 8:37Or they would come up and not English or German, so we threw them out.
- 8:42And then the third round was really compiling everything or
- 8:47all of the manuscripts themselves into one form so we could dive
- 8:52in and see what they were saying.
- 8:55Like I said earlier, there was a lot of results, which is
- 8:58why this took quite a while.
- 9:01I should also mention that this is really phase one of this.
- 9:05We're going to go back and do some other things that I'll
- 9:08talk about a little bit later.
- 9:09But the first bullet point is identification of the articles.
- 9:13How many search results came up after we put in all of the
- 9:17different search criteria?
- 9:19Women in motorsports, women in NASCAR, women in Formula One, etc, etc. Of that,
- 9:23within the generally academic private databases, about 600 results came forward.
- 9:29Through Google Scholar, the public site, over 6 million.
- 9:32Like I said, this took a while.
- 9:33The next step was the screening step, in which We took all of
- 9:38those and reduced them down to what could possibly be a winning
- 9:43match for what we were looking for.
- 9:46The next part, we looked at the full text articles and excluded those that, for
- 9:51whatever reason, wouldn't make the cut, and finally ended up with a final sample
- 9:57base for women in motorsport academic peer reviewed research articles of 12.
- 10:03Starting with over six million, that number may seem a little bit low.
- 10:07Across other forms of academic research, there are similar literature
- 10:12reviews that have only nine articles.
- 10:15This was actually somewhat of an encouraging sign for us.
- 10:19Here's where the articles came up and the frequency of the year that they came up.
- 10:25A lot of the Prisma related literature review searches
- 10:29specify a general time frame.
- 10:31We decided to keep ours very open and going back to 1950 until present.
- 10:37A lot more of them are constrained.
- 10:39Most of the results, as you can see, happened 2002 and later,
- 10:43with a couple of years having two articles published in that year.
- 10:48Where they ended up, they were Humanities Research, International Journal of Sport
- 10:53History, Journal of Sport and Social Issues, International Journal of Sports
- 10:57Marketing and Sponsorship, Professional Engineering, European Journal of
- 11:01Women's Studies, Women's History Review, Mathematics Teaching in the Middle School.
- 11:06The German one.
- 11:06We're just going to go with that.
- 11:07I'm not going to butcher it.
- 11:08Journal of Popular Culture, Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,
- 11:13and Accident Analysis and Prevention.
- 11:17Each of the journals really only had one.
- 11:19Submission from here.
- 11:20When we're talking about the different subjects that we see, one thing that
- 11:25was surprising was we were able to find some exercise science based articles.
- 11:30Generally, exercise science or kinesiology researchers will look at how
- 11:35the body reacts to different exercise regiments or different stressors.
- 11:40So, it was very nice to see that women were included in
- 11:43some of these studies as well.
- 11:45Some of my previous, I think actually every single time I've
- 11:48presented here, I've included what's called results from Lexamancer.
- 11:52What we did for all of the articles that made the cut was we did
- 11:57something called a content analysis.
- 11:59So we would go through and find themes from within each
- 12:03of the articles and build.
- 12:05Bigger, bigger, bigger themes.
- 12:06Lexamancer is a computer program that does something similar,
- 12:11just it being independent.
- 12:13A lot of times, Lexamancer will throw out something weird, or call it
- 12:17something weird, in which we kind of corrected it, made sure that it was
- 12:21more related to what we wanted instead.
- 12:24The main themes that came from Our sample base were gendered motor sports in which
- 12:31Lexa Mansur came up with drivers, academic work environment, which Lexa Mansur came
- 12:36up with article, research and development, as well as exertion in which the computer
- 12:42came up with vehicle and stress, and exclusion in which the majority of the
- 12:47results that Lexa Mansur came up with had the tag of women included in them.
- 12:51For gendered motor sports, this theme was shown basically of women
- 12:56navigating the motorsports world.
- 12:58So for example, it is hypothesized that women's bodies in motorsport
- 13:02are seen in three ways.
- 13:04Beyond vehicles, navigating the space filled with other bodies
- 13:07and their respective vehicles.
- 13:09With vehicles, coordinating the technology of the vehicle itself.
- 13:12And inside vehicles, which is operating in the space of the technology,
- 13:17interacting with the technology, but situated by the gender's discursively
- 13:22constructed characteristics.
- 13:23This is from Plugfelder 2009.
- 13:27So some of those that fell into this general theme, either gender neutral
- 13:32or men, as seen instead of pretending that some sports are gender neutral.
- 13:38And we need to try and understand how the discourses that surround different
- 13:41sports help create driver identity because of the technology that may
- 13:46overwhelm any gender distinctions.
- 13:47That was another one from Plug Felder that was a couple pages later.
- 13:51Academic work environment, again, this was kind of how academic works surrounding
- 13:57gender studies and how they interacted with in the context of motorsport.
- 14:01An example from one of the articles, indeed following Alfred Adler's
- 14:06groundbreaking recent scholarship, substantiates that tend to overcompensate
- 14:11in a sense of overdoing gender and in so doing inadvertently reveal
- 14:16themselves to be sensitive to threats.
- 14:19The R. N. D. And exertion.
- 14:20The exertion ones in particular were studies of how either injuries or actual
- 14:27physical exertion like loss of sweat changes and glucose levels and similar
- 14:33would occur for both male and female drivers and on track simulation or an
- 14:38actual measurement after It's worth mentioning here is that there were many
- 14:43studies across the potential sample that did not include any representatives
- 14:48that were women, meaning in the ones that were not included in this part,
- 14:53but there were a lot of studies that just looked at male drivers from
- 14:58an exercise science perspective.
- 15:00And exclusion.
- 15:01Exclusion referred to instances across the data set where women were
- 15:04being excluded from racing or were being pressured not to participate.
- 15:08For example, after dispelling some very early prejudice in the 1930s
- 15:13domesticization of women coupled with the rapid professionalism of the sport
- 15:17has Limited participatory opportunities and continue to fuel mediated stereotypes
- 15:22about women drivers and in motor sports women have had to fight prejudice and
- 15:27bias in a sport dominated by men as men made the rules to suit themselves and
- 15:32the Women were expected to accept them.
- 15:35That's from Matthews and Pike in 2016 and their article titled what on earth
- 15:41are they doing in a race car towards an understanding of women in motor sports?
- 15:45so some of the titles Definitely show a negative side to that power dynamic.
- 15:50So after looking at these results, one of the things we wanted to see was how
- 15:55different would this be if we basically didn't use those 27 criteria that I
- 16:01talked about, but reduce that list down to basically say if an article mentions
- 16:07women in any form or fashion through the full text, how would those results differ?
- 16:13So we basically did the same thing over again.
- 16:16So the postdoc results and postdoc here means we didn't experiment.
- 16:20We thought of something funny afterwards.
- 16:21So we're going to chase that rabbit down that rabbit hole and see what happens.
- 16:25So we had three general themes for this one, which included competition
- 16:30and fandom, which Lexa Mancer said was racing and NASCAR gendered motor sports.
- 16:35Which Lex and Lancer pumped out with women and Faye Taylor.
- 16:39Faye Taylor was one of the subjects for one of the manuscripts and
- 16:43it was interesting to see that the computer analysis pumped
- 16:47that out as a separate theme.
- 16:50And then measurements, which is basically how did the original authors, what
- 16:56did they do with their experiment, which Lexamancer came up with, used.
- 17:01So for these, the differences were pretty stunning.
- 17:06In that there was a little bit of crossover, but for whatever reason, an
- 17:12independent computer pumped out one of the articles itself as its own theme.
- 17:17So we kind of found that interesting there.
- 17:20And most of the results were geared towards.
- 17:23Men in that portion, male drivers.
- 17:26So some of the discussion bits, to start to wrap up.
- 17:29When we started this, I told my student I would be surprised if
- 17:33there were six or seven articles.
- 17:34Thinking that, that might be the high end of things.
- 17:37We were pleasantly surprised on that front.
- 17:40But there's definitely a lot more work that can be done from an academic sense.
- 17:44We obviously need to look for different ways to analyze women in
- 17:48motorsports from different perspectives.
- 17:51We need to keep doing the history stuff.
- 17:53We need to get the history stuff out there a little bit more.
- 17:56But some of the speculation as to why we're not able to do that is, in many
- 18:01of the history articles themselves, we found that yes, the The article
- 18:07included a substantial amount of racing overview of the women driver
- 18:12from a biographical sense, but it was usually tied to something else.
- 18:16So we mentioned Faye Taylor earlier, and in the article that was basically
- 18:20a biopic of Faye Taylor, it starts off mostly describing her as a
- 18:25racer, some of the public renown that she had, but eventually goes into
- 18:30her life, her political feelings.
- 18:33Which were overwhelmingly fascist, and her interactions with MI5 and the
- 18:39CIA because of those fascist leanings.
- 18:41So, one of the things that we thought is, it's weird that we're not really talking
- 18:46about the drivers in some sense, and we got another sense too, that many of
- 18:51these peer reviewers may say, well it's just racing, we need a little bit more.
- 18:56And we argue that you don't really need that.
- 18:58Now there's obviously a crowd of folks who have an interest in this.
- 19:03I think we can get a lot of things going, particularly through SAH and a
- 19:08shameless plug for my journal, JMCH.
- 19:10So to end with.
- 19:12One of the articles actually had some cool photos about the Red X around
- 19:18Australia trials around the 1950s.
- 19:22So picture one was a women's weekly magazine crew that entered
- 19:26the Red X around Australia and featured an all women's team
- 19:30which included military members.
- 19:32Picture 2 features Winifred Conway, who when trying to find sponsorships for the
- 19:37Reddix around Australia races in 1953, had to call over 100 businesses to secure
- 19:43minor sponsorships for her vehicle.
- 19:45Sydney Australian Austin dealership was approached to sponsor Conway's
- 19:49Austin A40, in which they told her that they already sponsored two teams
- 19:53and would not sponsor her vehicle.
- 19:55In response, Conway said that she was driving a Monarch from
- 19:58Germany, totally fictitious vehicle.
- 20:00And other than the experience of the drive itself, Conway said that she was
- 20:04really only in the race to compete for a prize of an automatic pop up toaster in
- 20:09which Women's Weekly, Red X Organizers, and the owner of the previously mentioned
- 20:14dealership would supply her with one each.
- 20:18So she tripled what her expected winnings were.
- 20:21But at the end of the day, and the point of this whole article is, we have
- 20:25a base of where women in motorsports is from an academic sense, and I think
- 20:30we can do a hell of a lot better.
- 20:31Thank you for your time.
- 20:37Thanks, Mike.
- 20:38I was hoping you could condense that down to two or three articles
- 20:40I could pick up on my way home tonight, but I got a list here.
- 20:44That was pretty fascinating.
- 20:47very much for your presentation.
- 20:49I do have one scholarly critique.
- 20:52Sure.
- 20:52When you use search terms that you're limiting the title and abstract to women.
- 20:58I think you are very much presenting a narrow perspective.
- 21:02It's articles that are focusing on women as other.
- 21:06It's harping on the fact that they're women.
- 21:07Versus the numerous articles that are out there discussing, you
- 21:12know, racing drivers who are quite successful who, oh, happen to be women.
- 21:17And And I just think that that perhaps colors some of the results that you
- 21:22wind up with and how narrow they are.
- 21:23Yes.
- 21:24As I mentioned in the beginning, this is part one.
- 21:26Part two was getting more at that.
- 21:28Of looking at successful drivers who happen to be women and
- 21:32including them in the search terms.
- 21:34After five million, we needed a break.
- 21:36Six million, whatever it was.
- 21:37So like I said, this is part one.
- 21:39I expect there to be a little bit more, but yeah Thank you for your comment
- 21:42Francis the Baconator says is there an increase in the frequency of literature
- 21:47as we are starting to focus more on the history of women in motorsports and
- 21:52are pushing for more participation Hmm.
- 21:55The only, I wouldn't even call it hardcore great evidence to back up Francis the
- 22:00Baconator's comment would be this slide of the frequency of publications per
- 22:06year, in which, yeah, there were two in 2023, and kind of suggests that
- 22:12there's more of a positively going trend post 2015, but There's really not
- 22:17enough data points to even make that point for sure, but subjectively, yeah,
- 22:21you might be on onto something there.
- 22:23Great name, for instance, the Baconator follow up to that.
- 22:26You show 11 out of the 12 in there.
- 22:28Do you remember where the 12th one was?
- 22:31What year was in?
- 22:32Wow.
- 22:32So I do.
- 22:33That tells you there is a trend.
- 22:34Yes.
- 22:35Since 2000, let's say that there is an increase in it.
- 22:39And certainly, I think everybody's awareness of People that are working
- 22:45outside of the normal standards of jobs.
- 22:50So I think the same thing would apply to male nurses, for instance.
- 22:54You would find out that there's more written on those types of things
- 22:58since the years 2000 or some place.
- 23:01And up because we're putting more focus in our world today on.
- 23:06It's acceptable.
- 23:07It's okay for people to do the non standard, if you will, occupations.
- 23:13I mean, my wife is an engineer.
- 23:15She graduated in 79.
- 23:17I think I can count on both hands the number of female engineers.
- 23:21She graduated with, you know, thanks for pointing that out 2016.
- 23:24It's 2016, so add one to 2016.
- 23:27Elizabeth Blackstock writes, We've talked about Faye Taylor's fascism
- 23:32and touched on Helen Nice's potential Nazi ties in to Lin's keynote.
- 23:37Is there a larger trend of tying women in motorsport to politics as opposed to men?
- 23:43Um, maybe for academic research, another one of the articles to give
- 23:47an example from the expanded search.
- 23:50It occurred during the Bush versus Gore presidential race, and it was about
- 23:56NASCAR dads and protective mothers.
- 24:01I forget the exact term that was used there, but it did seem that there was
- 24:06Maybe not to the extent of it being substantial, but there was evidence of
- 24:11some politicalization there, for sure.
- 24:13Um, she was, um, a very good female racer.
- 24:22It was post, like, World War II, about the time frame that most of
- 24:26the article was written about her.
- 24:28Let's just leave it at that.
- 24:29Do you consider women in the publishing industry, like Denise McCluggage, or
- 24:34Alana Sher, who writes for Car and Driver, etc., or Beverly Rae Kimes,
- 24:39I think her name was, the historian?
- 24:42Those publications are great, but they were not included in this
- 24:45sample, mostly because they weren't academic, peer reviewed in one
- 24:50of our more academic journals.
- 24:51So that's why they weren't considered for this.
- 24:54Essays and books.
- 24:55Yes, so there was one, the mathematics teaching in middle school, but
- 25:01really that was the only one that we found through this search process.
- 25:06I'm sure there's more, which kind of speaks to redefining
- 25:10the search terms as well.
- 25:11And how many grad students do you go through on this project?
- 25:14One undergraduate student.
- 25:17We were both men, admittedly.
- 25:19Well, thanks Mike.
- 25:20That was fascinating.
- 25:21Thank you all.
- 25:28This episode is brought to you in part by the International
- 25:31Motor Racing Research Center.
- 25:34Its charter is to collect, share, and preserve the history
- 25:37of motor sports spanning continence, eras, and race series.
- 25:43The Center's collection embodies the speed, drama and camaraderie
- 25:48of amateur and professional motor racing throughout the world.
- 25:52The Center welcomes serious researchers and casual fans alike to share stories of
- 25:57race drivers, race series, and race cars captured on their shelves and walls and
- 26:04brought to life through a regular calendar of public lectures and special events.
- 26:09To learn more about the Center, visit www.
- 26:13racingarchives.
- 26:15org.
- 26:16This episode is also brought to you by the Society of Automotive Historians.
- 26:21They encourage research into any aspect of automotive history.
- 26:26The SAH actively supports the compilation and preservation of papers, organizational
- 26:32records, print ephemera, and images to safeguard, as well as to broaden and
- 26:37deepen the understanding of motorized wheeled land transportation through
- 26:42the modern age and into the future.
- 26:45For more information about the SAH, visit www.
- 26:52autohistory.
- 26:52org.
- 26:57We hope you enjoyed another awesome episode of Brake Fix Podcast, brought
- 27:01to you by Grand Touring Motorsports.
- 27:04If you'd like to be a guest on the show or get involved, be sure
- 27:06to follow us on all social media platforms at GrandTouringMotorsports.
- 27:11And if you'd like to learn more about the content of this episode,
- 27:14be sure to check out the follow on article at GTMotorsports.
- 27:19org.
- 27:19We remain a commercial free and no annual fees organization through
- 27:23our sponsors, but also through the generous support of our fans,
- 27:27families, and friends through Patreon.
- 27:29For as little as 2.
- 27:3150 a month, you can get access to more behind the scenes action, additional
- 27:36Pit Stop minisodes, and other VIP goodies, as well as keeping our team
- 27:40of creators fed on their strict diet of Fig Newtons, Gumby Bears, and Monster.
- 27:45So consider signing up for Patreon today at www.
- 27:48patreon.
- 27:49com forward slash gtmotorsports.
- 27:52And remember, without you, None of this would be possible.