Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 294:7-9. Orlah: Outside of Israel, For a Non-Jew, Safek, Doubts

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 294:7-9. Orlah: Outside of Israel, For a Non-Jew, Safek, Doubts · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Good morning. We are in some rich Saudi Dalit
• 0:06
  Siv Zion din. We're in the middle of, you
• 0:09
  know, Palafos from Neta Revai din.
• 0:11
  Neta Revai no egg after kutzar. So this the neta revai is also
• 0:18
  no egg in kutzar. It's Aquaponim whether it's
• 0:24
  whatever it's the HP show image in annoying Ella Baaret.
• 0:28
  Some say no, it's all annoying and it's so of a Bajutsa aaretz
• 0:32
  Paris abbaim akasha avar shani Orla mutara envelope Pedro and
• 0:38
  and therefore and the Hutzar. It's after the after three
• 0:41
  years. Then it's there's the Mutarian
• 0:47
  straight so that right no egg Bahutsa are it's wrapped the
• 0:52
  carrier envelope with Shari Lanos.
• 0:54
  This is bahogas in the gummar beds and Brahos.
• 0:57
  Some say it's only no egg, only it's net.
• 1:00
  It's not that's wherever it's Caramavai.
• 1:02
  It's mahogas in the Gummara and therefore we're only have to be
• 1:06
  Makhmir for Caramavai only by grapes and not by Shari Lanos.
• 1:11
  That one the first shita who holds that didn't net the
• 1:14
  revised noegar or the revolt is Karamvai and the is that means
• 1:21
  that it needs pigeon. Even in fozar it's you have to
• 1:25
  be poled poled than net the revai on a pruta Shah says that
• 1:32
  that we should be mahmir for both karamvai and net the revai.
• 1:36
  You should leave this with hozar.
• 1:37
  It's below bracha. So what it what does that mean?
• 1:41
  What's what does that mean in Kutsar?
• 1:42
  It's something which people aren't really, you know, so
• 1:44
  familiar with. In Kutsar it's, you know, so the
• 1:48
  emphasis is that apruta, OK, I mentioned yesterday Apruta
• 1:52
  nowadays I looked it up on the website here and there, it sells
• 1:55
  around 25 agarot. According to Rifati's husband,
• 2:03
  there's about 25 agarot. This translates into in US for
• 2:09
  idle dollar, for pounds and U.S. dollars, it comes out to be
• 2:13
  around between like around $0.10, maybe a bit more.
• 2:17
  I don't know, about around $0.10 a dime.
• 2:22
  And, and so therefore someone who has three outside trees in
• 2:26
  their backyard and things, whatever and there's and, and
• 2:29
  there's, and there's, and it actually grows within the first
• 2:32
  four years, which is not always, doesn't always happen.
• 2:35
  You know, sort of depends on your, on your, on your muscle
• 2:37
  and, and how well you take care of it and everything like that.
• 2:40
  So then whatever the so then those fruits, they have to, you
• 2:46
  know, they, they should be picked and they should be lifted
• 2:49
  on, I'd say a dime. I I don't, I didn't see anyone
• 2:53
  talk about what do you do with that dime.
• 2:56
  But Lahore, it was the Yamamella.
• 2:58
  And if you're OK, if you're by the coast, Chuck it in the sea.
• 3:01
  But but if you're you know, but if you're what's it called?
• 3:06
  But if you're you have to be sure that it's maybe you can
• 3:10
  flush it down the toilet. That might be good enough.
• 3:12
  I'm not sure. That's just yeah, maybe.
• 3:17
  Yeah, you can smash the coin. I mean, if you want the feds
• 3:20
  after you, but OK, fine. But yeah, you can grind it up.
• 3:26
  Yeah, however, but it should be it should be destroyed.
• 3:31
  Whether you have to get rid of the you know, whether you have
• 3:36
  to get rid of the the what's it called?
• 3:39
  The Paris? The resident of the Vai is also,
• 3:44
  I don't know if it yet it has to be Bavaria, just like but we'll
• 3:48
  see about Oregon. Sorry, in a minute.
• 3:54
  Sorry. Once you pothe it, right, Sorry,
• 3:57
  you're confused, right? I mean the so there so therefore
• 4:05
  right, So therefore, Even so, if you have so basically so the way
• 4:09
  it's going to work with cold sores is you have Orla of three
• 4:11
  years. The 4th year you pothe it and
• 4:14
  then you can use those fruits and then the fifth year
• 4:17
  everything is 100 percent, 100% motor.
• 4:21
  Sif has Orla, no haggis Paho Malcolm Orla is knowing every
• 4:26
  place in Israel and Kotarz. The Holzman doesn't make it even
• 4:33
  in even in Shmita. It's knowing baby shall go, baby
• 4:37
  shall you swell whether it's a go is the non Jews or you swell
• 4:41
  or some There's a discussion about is that mean that goy
• 4:46
  meaning? Does that mean that he is it in
• 4:49
  the land of he swells land or he owns the land?
• 4:53
  Some say if he owns the land, there's there's less of an
• 4:56
  issue. The differences in there to sell
• 5:02
  Orla is Minotauri. It's it is Nash of only, but
• 5:12
  also the Locket le goye. OK, so one second there are even
• 5:17
  those who tie who who tie that There are those who who who even
• 5:25
  say that that in there it's a swell.
• 5:28
  There's a mashmalls, there's a Maharanian say there's a
• 5:31
  mashmallah. So you've been there.
• 5:32
  It's a swell nowadays, you know Ashfalls and Naramba.
• 5:35
  Maybe that it's only that that it's also not Minotaura just
• 5:41
  like we have by the other Shah Allah has submits his trulis
• 5:45
  bar. It's that he needs Rove BS to
• 5:48
  thrill needs most of clay cell to be to to be here in order to
• 5:53
  machi Minotaura. There are there is a there are
• 5:55
  some Maharanian and some. We're we're right at.
• 6:00
  That point I'm not honestly I don't know, but we'll have to
• 6:04
  get to well I'll something I'll have to look at the other place
• 6:07
  can say now that you know nowadays about that but upon him
• 6:11
  as the real BSSL of arts in order to behind it me and I'll
• 6:16
  tell you the core of this is interesting enough.
• 6:19
  It's it was like in the Rambam, because the Rambam says that the
• 6:24
  Borla that was there before Kibush for the kibush of sure as
• 6:32
  whatever. So he just he just he he he says
• 6:36
  that that's that that was that was not really used.
• 6:39
  So if it's a dinner to sell, so why why does he say that?
• 6:42
  Like what's he pointing out? You know, it's also he only
• 6:46
  speaks Halacha. He only speaks Halacha Lamaisse.
• 6:48
  How would they OK, that's a different.
• 6:52
  However, they knew they knew. I don't know.
• 6:54
  Hey, that's that's hey, I don't know.
• 6:56
  That's a good question. I know how they knew, but Uncle
• 6:58
  Punny discussion is is around saying her office and machine
• 7:02
  What's he what's he bringing in? So some say says because it's
• 7:09
  telling you that without robe is not mean Naf Kamina could be
• 7:17
  from a chef Naf Kamina then you could understand differently in
• 7:21
  the round bombers. I think it's interesting is that
• 7:24
  you know La Mesa, you know now I can say nowadays if you I don't
• 7:28
  know what yeah, get into a lot of cleavage.
• 7:31
  I don't know these, I'm not Bucky in them, but someone let's
• 7:35
  say goes on to Arab lands and takes over some, you know, some
• 7:39
  Arab land here and there's Orlaus according to the there
• 7:42
  would be law for La Mesa about whether you would have to be
• 7:44
  knowing Orla on those on those trees or not.
• 7:48
  If you took over, you know, if, if you would capture, you know,
• 7:51
  some Arab land around here, then there would be actually Halakhla
• 7:54
  Maisa. But let's not saw that the clock
• 7:56
  would. Start again.
• 7:58
  Found the key Bush of the of. The it's the Rambo who mentions
• 8:02
  it. It's it.
• 8:03
  No one else talks about it. So it's not hulking.
• 8:06
  So I assume that's, you know that that's just the question is
• 8:09
  what the what what the condition the Rambo is.
• 8:11
  But the. You would have to wait another
• 8:16
  year or two, right? But you wouldn't have to wait
• 8:22
  three more years. From one keyword, it's
• 8:25
  definitely not Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, no Hagar, but also the
• 8:29
  lacquette lagoi Paris, the Elon Chilo even in the in the Hutzar.
• 8:35
  It's also to pick Paris of a guy from his tree shoe Orla.
• 8:41
  You know he knows it's Orla Mishum Shenan and Mashima
• 8:45
  tovals. He the even if he does it, even
• 8:50
  if he does it as a favour Koshikin, if he gets money for
• 8:53
  it, it's Nakshavv even in Hutzar.
• 8:55
  It's a Nakshavv getting Honda from Orla, which is also even in
• 8:59
  Hutzar. It's so even if the goy's
• 9:02
  Maxiklotova, it will be it, it, it's, it's an issue.
• 9:06
  Some seifer, the pesky chubatop brings a some seifer talks about
• 9:10
  someone who who used to, you know, he, he used to, you know,
• 9:14
  run someone's farm, run someone's orchard and go, you
• 9:17
  know, and the goy's orchard, non Jew's orchard.
• 9:20
  And the question is, and he knows there's a hundreds of
• 9:23
  trees and he knows that there is Orla in there.
• 9:25
  He knows there's definitely Orla in there.
• 9:28
  The question is, what should he, what should he do?
• 9:31
  So basically the you know, the, you know the so he interested,
• 9:36
  he says he brings the translation says you can't rely
• 9:40
  on, even though there are, you know, experts who say they know
• 9:44
  that although these trees are all they could tell these trees
• 9:47
  are all these trees are not. He says he can't rely on that
• 9:50
  because he says that since they don't know exactly, we don't see
• 9:55
  under the ground. We don't know exactly when the
• 9:57
  tree was Nishrash before. Was it before tuba, after tuba?
• 10:05
  No, but you don't know. He doesn't know.
• 10:06
  He comes into the orchard, he knows for sure there's there's a
• 10:11
  body or here. It's not something.
• 10:13
  But we don't know exactly. Even if, even if someone comes
• 10:15
  and even if the experts come and say look at this tree, it's
• 10:19
  three, it's less than three years old.
• 10:21
  They can test it, they can check their rings, they can do
• 10:23
  whatever they want. But the devices, they don't
• 10:25
  know. You know if this tree was
• 10:27
  Nishash before tuba or after tuba, that's all though 'cause
• 10:32
  that's gonna be a different issue cancel that's
• 10:33
  transplantation right that's a that's a completely different
• 10:36
  issue. So he says he can't be Sonic on
• 10:37
  the experts when it comes to this.
• 10:39
  But but he says, however, if you could, you know, if you could
• 10:43
  tell that the fruits are Khalil like they're not, they're not
• 10:48
  good fruits. Usually lower.
• 10:49
  The fruits are not are schwack fruit.
• 10:51
  They're not good fruits, They're small, they're not and they
• 10:54
  usually don't market these things.
• 10:56
  And nowadays I don't know with genetics, with genetic and
• 10:59
  grafting, I don't know. There's we'll get to the those.
• 11:02
  You know, the the there might be more more it might be more
• 11:05
  issues, but I'll component in general.
• 11:07
  There's a Hazaca that lower the fruits look schwack and he says
• 11:09
  if you can tell which ones are schwack, so he shouldn't then he
• 11:13
  shouldn't be market then. But since it's there is a
• 11:16
  Suffolk here and we'll get through it in a second.
• 11:17
  So he says it's OK since since you could you can tell which
• 11:22
  fruits by sight are probably Orla.
• 11:25
  So it's next. You have a sulfate and therefore
• 11:27
  it's it would be OK siftest Suffolk Orla bear.
• 11:35
  It's a soil awesome. This is something early there to
• 11:38
  swell is also 'cause it's something there isa the
• 11:40
  hallmark. It's something for me Notaria
• 11:44
  and therefore we don't know it would be AUSAR.
• 11:48
  It's motor. And this is the general din and
• 11:51
  the halacha Machini Sinai was set up was the way it came down
• 11:56
  and it's it's ulcer if you know about it.
• 12:00
  If you don't know about it, then it's motor Kaitza
• 12:04
  karamishiation, the tea of Shah Orlo, a Karen that has a tea has
• 12:08
  has, you know, you know, things of Orla, but Novi Ninkarim
• 12:13
  Putzalo outside the the Karen. There's, you know, a fan
• 12:17
  selling, you know, selling grapes or marketing.
• 12:21
  They marketed there to sell also and there to sell and it's also
• 12:25
  to go ahead and buy these grapes over Surya.
• 12:28
  If you know there if there's a sulfate, there might be Oreo
• 12:32
  there. So then it's a problem if
• 12:34
  there's a Hatcher on on the Carim if there's So let's get
• 12:39
  into a bit. I looked up, you know, according
• 12:42
  to of a Frati based on the Sacovilios that unless it,
• 12:46
  that's sort of a hydrant Hatcher on the on the field, then
• 12:52
  there's then then there's a sulfate, because they're going
• 12:56
  to be mapped with the check for, you know, transplantation or
• 13:00
  there's a lot of all these, there's a lot of different
• 13:02
  things that they can do, which might be Shiloh's Avorla and
• 13:05
  they'll they're going to check into it since they, they they're
• 13:08
  not next of, of the, you know, lesser Hecheri.
• 13:12
  If you know that they check fine, but you have to, you said
• 13:16
  things that things might be that depends on what the hash Kaha
• 13:19
  is. You don't know you have to, you
• 13:20
  have to investigate into it. The question is also how much he
• 13:26
  is Also every year they put out a a list of how much Paris or
• 13:33
  the different fruits are in the shook.
• 13:35
  So therefore, if you go to a if you decide to go to a roadside
• 13:38
  stand or a store that does not have a, a decent Hatcher on it
• 13:44
  or you just go to a roadside roadside stand, you know you
• 13:47
  want to buy fruits. So probably take too much some
• 13:49
  ISIS. It's very good.
• 13:50
  Question is, is there a problem of oral?
• 13:52
  So you have to look at this your list and see how much you know
• 13:56
  is there. You know, if it's Rove, you have
• 13:58
  you have an issue. If it's less than Rove, then
• 14:02
  then then it's it's less of an issue.
• 14:05
  I think you have to look look at it in the you have to spend time
• 14:08
  looking through what their cash bonus are, how they how they
• 14:11
  view it, how the you know, there's other could be there's
• 14:14
  other ways of seeing the the percentages of Orla in the in in
• 14:18
  in the shook of a Surya motor in Surya.
• 14:23
  It's mutter. But who Shiloh.
• 14:25
  You know, nowadays you can even maybe you can go to Surya.
• 14:27
  I don't know. But who Shiloh Yoda, Shihu
• 14:30
  Shihuva Mayosa Karim, as long as you don't know it came from that
• 14:35
  Karim over Hutsar. It's mutter.
• 14:39
  It remains a it remains a Safi right then yeah.
• 14:45
  For PK, it's it's a bit of a middle 0 because it's it's it's
• 14:50
  no, that's fake sake. It's a next chef.
• 14:52
  You know for sure there's Orla on this Karim.
• 14:55
  Not all the vines in the world, right, But not all the vines are
• 14:59
  Orla. So it's a Suffolk in this
• 15:00
  Malcolm. So in Syria, they they they
• 15:04
  answered it. The Hutar.
• 15:05
  It's mutter. In that case, it's mutter
• 15:08
  Ophelio de Eshoova mealsa Karim. Even if you know that in that
• 15:12
  Karim there is Orla, it's OK rock show here at she needs the
• 15:17
  room in a Tia show Orla. You just can't know that it was
• 15:21
  cut from an Orla tree. The close chicane she came.
• 15:26
  She was Suffolk Orla Shu mutter and it and the Ramada sandwich
• 15:29
  is much, much more than cover anyway that any caram which it
• 15:33
  was Suffolk Orla. You don't even know that there's
• 15:36
  real Orla there. It's possible it's also motor.
• 15:40
  There's an interesting ran which the place can bring down.
• 15:43
  The Ran says Khutzar is eaten based on the Gemara that even if
• 15:47
  I know that this fruit came from Orla, I am allowed to give it to
• 15:51
  another Jew and not tell him that it's Orla.
• 15:56
  And that's it's not the thing either.
• 15:58
  It's not because it it's not a beer because you're.
• 16:03
  Having an option. Give me yeah no no whatever I
• 16:08
  saw I saw a husband like I said it's a bit of a Finnish.
• 16:12
  I thought that maybe it's only there were only goes there Orla
• 16:15
  if a person knows about it OK it's a Finnish I you know I try
• 16:19
  to I have to look into them. I'm sure there's other
• 16:21
  explanations about how in this round but this round is is
• 16:26
  there's a whole is to be shining.
• 16:27
  But Occupani, it is brought down by the person on the daft, but
• 16:33
  outside the daft that that as long as you don't know, you
• 16:36
  don't have to worry about it. So therefore, and this and this
• 16:42
  is generally how they know the the Sharon and and Huzzar.
• 16:46
  It's they don't they don't look into a bachelors.
• 16:48
  Don't you have to look into if, if this tree is if you haven't
• 16:51
  your this tree is Orla. If you have something in your
• 16:53
  backyard that you planted and you know it's Orla, don't you
• 16:57
  know, don't touch it. Now included in this in this in
• 17:00
  this thing and the place you can bring is also any Suffolk Orla,
• 17:06
  even if it's a Mahoka suppose game in whether this thing is
• 17:09
  oral or not is also is also mutter and Cultsol.
• 17:14
  So I just want to mention a few. For example, the passionfruit.
• 17:19
  Passionfruit is a Mahoka suppose game.
• 17:21
  We all should another. Whether it is it's a tree or
• 17:25
  it's it's a tree or it's a it's a yarek.
• 17:28
  It depends on the because it most trees don't you know, they
• 17:32
  you know, they, it keeps from year to year, but most trees
• 17:35
  don't grow, only grow fruits after a while.
• 17:38
  So there's a there's a mafocus here, I think, but that's I
• 17:41
  think something else. They don't give share in on on
• 17:45
  passion fruit because here's the salt.
• 17:46
  They hold it to Suffolk gorilla and therefore and therefore
• 17:51
  there will be ulcer to eat here from wholesaler.
• 17:54
  It's and that's why you see passion fruit and all the great
• 17:56
  sharing juices and stuff. They come from wholesaler.
• 17:59
  It's just a soft fake it's melter other other medium, other
• 18:04
  other fruits which are have have big issues.
• 18:08
  The papaya is the big Shiloh and here here a lot of a lot a lot
• 18:13
  of places can hold that is that there are there.
• 18:17
  It is it's it is Taco. There are reasons to be matted
• 18:21
  the papaya, the way the tree, the tree, the tree grow because
• 18:24
  the tree stays, but but then the only, the only the food only
• 18:31
  grows from one part of it. And, and you know, so then it's
• 18:35
  sort of like for, for example, the banana is also a Shiloh, you
• 18:39
  know, and that's also Shiloh's hiatus or Adama.
• 18:41
  But since generally wheat, plastic and bananas are Adama
• 18:45
  because the tree dies every year, so therefore it's not
• 18:48
  there's no problem Orela by bananas, Haya somewhere in the
• 18:52
  middle because it it doesn't die, but it doesn't, but it the
• 18:57
  way it produces fruit is not is a little bit a little bit
• 19:01
  different and it's not exactly like a tree.
• 19:04
  It's like a bullshit. It's a whole discussion.
• 19:08
  So Alco Pani and there it's getting getting papayas and
• 19:13
  there it's a swell is a Shalwa getting you know, if you come
• 19:16
  from Hutzaritz, then her it's OK.
• 19:22
  And the there are other Shilohs about Orla.
• 19:27
  What about the berries? Berries They produce fruit in
• 19:30
  the first year. There are and then like
• 19:32
  raspberries and things are Taco that it is or other person say
• 19:36
  it is Orla. So hotzar it's also a person has
• 19:39
  to be, you know, it's still a mahoga.
• 19:43
  So it could be it's fine here. Raspberry Raspberry is growing
• 19:47
  here. You have to know, you know, a
• 19:49
  person has to be far whether it's whether it's going to be
• 19:52
  whether it's Orla with shy with, with pineapple as well, since
• 20:00
  depends on how it's grown. Pineapple friends do grow from
• 20:04
  year to year, but here they they, they cut them down and
• 20:06
  regrow them. So therefore it is it, you know,
• 20:11
  therefore it's it's, it's lots of a shy.
• 20:14
  I don't know that I don't know. Yeah, but it's again, these
• 20:22
  things are these things are questions.
• 20:24
  So look right here, I think I hear, I do think the many gets
• 20:27
  the I don't. I don't know about many many, I
• 20:30
  don't know the many. I guess the hash sharing do.
• 20:33
  Look, you know those are relatively insane, right, Right.
• 20:41
  So it really sort of depends on how they grow it, but they they
• 20:45
  call it Ryan Kanyeski Paskin that it's it's since I see
• 20:49
  money, Eric, you can be knowing that it's a Eric.
• 20:51
  You don't have to be closer so much.
• 20:55
  But but yeah, so that's, you know, the the the question of
• 20:59
  also picking. So picking a passion fruit from
• 21:01
  a tree here. It could be it's OK, it could be
• 21:05
  it's not a person has to ask a person in the shine how to be
• 21:08
  you know how to be know how to be knowing because people do
• 21:10
  grow them and it could be, you know, so his Mahalo kids.
• 21:15
  It's what? There's what to.
• 21:17
  There's what to ask.