Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 3)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:05where we left off with alex Acosta's interview with the
- 0:09Inspector General. Question do you have any did you have
- 0:13any negative, you know, anything less than fully positive in
- 0:16your assessment of her? Answer? No question, okay, answer. I
- 0:21think she was a good, strong, dedicated a USA. Answer
- 0:25all right. Question wasn't managing USA at West Palm Beach Office?
- 0:32Answer correct question at least? And would redacted work there?
- 0:38How closely did you work with redacted? And again that's
- 0:41an assessment question. What was your assessment of him? Answer
- 0:45so less so only because of geographic distance question Uh huh. Answer.
- 0:49I would also say he was a respected professional. He
- 0:52had a good reputation. He went on to be chief
- 0:55of staff here at the Criminal Division, which I think
- 0:58speaks to how he was viewed within the department, And
- 1:02so I would say positive. Question okay, So turning to
- 1:05the Epstein case. Answer, yeah, question, now that your recall
- 1:09has been refreshed by virtue of the documents that we provided,
- 1:12before we get into the actual sort of documents and
- 1:15some of the details of the events, would you please
- 1:17give us a general overview of what you currently remember
- 1:20refreshed about how the case came into the US Attorney's office,
- 1:24how it was assessed for prosecution, and how and why
- 1:28the decision was made to resolve it with a two
- 1:30year stage plea that ultimately became an eighteen month sentence. Answer. Okay,
- 1:39and to that, mister Haran, who is the lawyer for
- 1:42alex Acosta, pipes up before you answer the question. Let
- 1:47me just jump in on the notion of refresher recollection,
- 1:50which is of course has a very specific legal meaning,
- 1:53and I think to assert that mister Acosta's recollection has
- 1:56been refreshed generally probably overstates it. It's really a document
- 2:01by document, issue by issue thing. So I push back
- 2:03on that. He gets interrupted, but he keeps going a
- 2:07little bit. But the question is fair and accurate, misredacted.
- 2:12If you're talking about handing him a document or refresh
- 2:15an exhausted recollection, that's not the process we're talking about.
- 2:19We're using it more in a lay term. That you know,
- 2:22if we ask you this before giving you all these documents,
- 2:25you'd probably would have not been able to be as
- 2:28full in your responses. So we're asking for your full response.
- 2:32Mister Haran, We appreciate the opportunity to review the documents
- 2:36and Alex in your answers, try to distinguish what you
- 2:39actually recall in your own head versus what you saw
- 2:43in the documents, and that would make for he gets
- 2:46interrupted the cleanest record. Acosta. Okay, So three parts. How
- 2:51did it come to my office? Question? How was had
- 2:55it come in? Answer? Right? Question? How is it assessed
- 2:59for prosecutution? Answer? Write question? And then how and how
- 3:05and why the decision was made to resolve it the
- 3:08way it was answer. So let's begin with how it
- 3:11came into the office. Putting all the documents aside, I
- 3:14can't say with certainty how it came in. I can
- 3:17speculate how it came in and the way it would
- 3:19have come into the office is I can speculate that
- 3:22the chief the chief writer from Palm Beach County would
- 3:25have brought it to either the FBI or the Palm
- 3:28Beach office. I'm not certain that I would have asked
- 3:31who brought this case to the office, as opposed to
- 3:34the case is now in the office. Let's discuss it right,
- 3:37the format or the mode in which it came in.
- 3:40I think is important because my recollection is it arrived
- 3:43to us in the position that the state attorney had
- 3:46negotiated a plea, and that the reason that we looked
- 3:48at it was that the plea was going to be
- 3:52that there had been an initial charge that wasn't pursued
- 3:55and that required jail time and registration, and that the
- 3:59plea was going to be taken was a charge that
- 4:02didn't require jail time and didn't require registration, and based
- 4:06on the preliminary assessment of the facts, that seemed that
- 4:09seems wrong. So that's how it arrived. The next question
- 4:13was question how was it assessed for federal prosecution? Answer?
- 4:19So it was assessed for federal prosecution. My recollection from
- 4:22very early on, and I'm sure we'll talk about this
- 4:25some more, is you have a case that while technically
- 4:28it wasn't final at the state level, but for a
- 4:30federal involvement would have been final. And so from the
- 4:33earliest point we were thinking federal versus state and petite
- 4:37and the contemporaneous record sort of shows at least the
- 4:40material that I got. The earliest communication was mister redacted
- 4:44telling me that redacted is preparing a petit policy waiver.
- 4:49That misredacted is preparing a petite policy waiver. And that's
- 4:52consistent with my recollection of how it was assessed and
- 4:56then brought in assessed. You know, doesn't make sense to
- 4:58go forward, yes and instigate and circle back and then
- 5:02and then the third part was question how and why
- 5:05the disposition answer, So, my general recollection is the view
- 5:10was that if the state had followed through on the
- 5:12original charge I don't recall which that call for jail
- 5:15time and that call for registration, that the local police
- 5:18or whoever brought it would not have seen the need
- 5:21to refer it. And so that was, in terms of
- 5:23pre indictment resolution, a logical and reasonable place given all
- 5:28the other sort of factors, both the petique concerns, the
- 5:31witness concerns, and the legal concerns. And to that I
- 5:34would add a fourth concern, which it had already been
- 5:37reviewed by a grand jury at the state level. Is
- 5:39my recollection, and so to some extent that's indicative of
- 5:44how some individuals may sort of view this matter. Question. Okay,
- 5:49we're going to pick that apart answer I figured question,
- 5:52but thank you for that answer. You ask for an overview.
- 5:57So I tried to be very he gets interrupted. Yeah,
- 6:00answer a general question. That doesn't. That doesn't. The second
- 6:03part of that last prong was why a two year
- 6:05state plea? In other words, you talked about you talked
- 6:09about assessing the case and why resolve it? But why
- 6:12with a two year state plea? Answer? So, my general
- 6:15recollection is my understanding if I was asked, what is
- 6:19the best understanding that I have of why two years?
- 6:22Is that is what would have been obtained in one
- 6:25of the original state charges. Question? How do you know that? Answer?
- 6:30We gets cut off, question how did you know that? Answer?
- 6:35That's why I say general recollection. I'm reconstructing memories of
- 6:39that twelve years ago. I can speculate that at some
- 6:42point the matter came up and I or someone else said,
- 6:45if you know what would the original what would the
- 6:47original plea have? You know, what would the original charges
- 6:51have likely brought? And someone said this amount question? Who
- 6:55would have said that answer? I'm speculating at this point,
- 6:58I don't have a recollection, but that's my general understanding. Question.
- 7:04All right, well, now unpack some of that question. And
- 7:08by the way, my colleague, we're all in this boat. Together,
- 7:11so they're going to feel free answer I know, question,
- 7:14to chime in as they see fit. So the first
- 7:17thing going going to the intake of the case. We
- 7:20know from the records that and by the way, we
- 7:23obviously have done a great deal of other investigation and
- 7:27spoken to many people. So Redacted briefed you and Redacted
- 7:30pretty much when the case first came in in the
- 7:33mid two thousand and six, after the FBI, and indeed
- 7:36the office the US Attorney's Office in West Palm Beach
- 7:39had opened the case, but before Epstein was indicted. So
- 7:42this first exhibit exhibit number one that you have in
- 7:45your binder before you or in your folder before you,
- 7:48is that email from redacted to you that you just
- 7:51referred to, dated July twenty fourth, two thousand and six,
- 7:54in which he sort of passing on the information that
- 7:56Epstein has by now been arrested, been in I did,
- 8:00arrested and indicted by the state. Do you recall anything
- 8:03about the original briefing from redacted? Answer I don't question,
- 8:08all right. Did you know at the time that the
- 8:10time she briefed you, which is prior to Exhibit one,
- 8:13did you know who Epstein was? Answer? I did not
- 8:16question never heard of them to your knowledge? Answer? To
- 8:19my knowledge, I don't recall having heard of them. Question,
- 8:23and what did you understand at that early point the
- 8:26case to be about. Answer, So I don't recall the briefing,
- 8:29and so I can't give an independent recollection. You know,
- 8:32based on this, I mean, he gets cut off. But
- 8:35you're talking about exhibit one. Answer based on Exhibit one,
- 8:39you know, I can infer that this would have been
- 8:41my general understanding of the case, and you know, and
- 8:44the key things that I point out here is pre
- 8:47trial diversion, which is code for an al jail time
- 8:50and petit policy. The question, but this what exhibit number
- 8:56one does not make it clear to you that this
- 8:59case involved allegations that Jeffrey Epstein had been enticing, coercing,
- 9:03whatever verb you want to use, young underage females. We
- 9:07will for the record call them girls here as opposed
- 9:09to women. And these underage females were being paid to
- 9:12provide him essentially with sex or sexual activity or conduct
- 9:16of a pretty salacious nature. Do you recall that as
- 9:20being essentially what you were briefed on from the beginning. Answer, again,
- 9:24I don't recall the initial briefing. I take it, based
- 9:26on your review, that there was an initial briefing. I
- 9:29can't say the degree of detail. I can't say what
- 9:32it was about. As a typical matter, I wouldn't be
- 9:36briefed when a case comes into the office other than
- 9:39being made aware this is the case, this is what
- 9:41we're looking at. Question. So then if you or your
- 9:45understanding you don't remember the briefing, is it fair to
- 9:49say you did not have some understanding of the case
- 9:51that was the West Palm Beach was pursuing as of
- 9:54mid two thousand and six. Answer. I certainly had an
- 9:58understanding of the general facts of the case early on.
- 10:00I can't speak to whether it was mid two thousand
- 10:03and six versus late two thousand and six versus two
- 10:06thousand and seven, but early on I certainly had an
- 10:09understanding that it was a case that involved, you know,
- 10:11a billionaire who was doing sordid things with young women
- 10:15or girls who were minors. Question redacted, And the records
- 10:19indicate that our concerned in bringing this all the way
- 10:21to you and her first at the time criminal chief
- 10:25but sort of acting first assistant redacted, was because she
- 10:28was afraid of political pressure that might be brought to
- 10:31bear against the US Attorney's office in the case. Do
- 10:34you have any recollection of that being a concern that
- 10:37was laid before you? Answer? I don't. Again, I don't
- 10:41recall the early that briefing. I've reviewed the email, and
- 10:44I can you know I'd take it It would have
- 10:46been natural for me to say should we approach the
- 10:49state attorney because we had lots of ongoing matters with
- 10:52the state attorney and it seems that redacted said no
- 10:56for fear it'll be leaked straight to Epstein, and I
- 10:59assumed i'd let it be at that point. Question and
- 11:02do you know do you know what he meant by
- 11:04it being leaked to Epstein by the state by Barry Krisher,
- 11:08the state attorney. Answer so, based on context, what I
- 11:12would assume is that if the state Attorney is cutting
- 11:14this kind of deal, and it appears that things have
- 11:16already leaked, because you know, there's clearly an article here
- 11:20with leaked, so something has already leaked. Question are you
- 11:24referring to Exhibit one? Answer? Exhibit one? Other things would leak?
- 11:28Question have you ever met Barry Krisher? Answer? Sure? Question
- 11:33what was your relationship with him. Answer, So there were
- 11:35multiple state attorneys within the district he was. It was
- 11:39a professional relationship question. It was an elected position. Correct answer,
- 11:43It was an elected position question. And what was your
- 11:46assessment of his aggressiveness as a prosecutor and his capabilities?
- 11:51Answer on the public My most of my assessment with
- 11:56him was on the public corruption front, and we had
- 11:59brought several cases, and I was a little disappointed that
- 12:02these were cases he could have brought that he chose
- 12:05not to bring. Question rights, So can I am I
- 12:08accurate in inferring from that you didn't regard him as
- 12:11a particularly hard charging prosecutor. Answer? So with any state attorney,
- 12:17I hesitate to sort of paint a broad brush stroke.
- 12:20I don't think that's always fairer. But my experience had
- 12:23been in the public corruption space, and in that space,
- 12:26I did not think whether it was him or whether
- 12:28it was his office, I can't speak, but I did
- 12:31not think they had done as much as they could
- 12:33have done. Question is there any area in which you
- 12:36thought he in his office did pursue aggressively? Answer? So,
- 12:40as I recall, we had emphasized gun crimes quite a
- 12:43bit and really had a lot of success moving the
- 12:47ball in the gun crime space in Palm Beach. But
- 12:51let me let me just say, it's also very difficult
- 12:53to reconstruct timeframes. And so I hesitate because I don't
- 12:56know if that was two thousand and six or two
- 12:59thousand and seven. But you asked in another area gets
- 13:02cut off question in this exhibit one, you ask whether
- 13:05it's appropriate appropriate to approach Barry Krisher and give him
- 13:09a heads up as to where the US Attorney's Office
- 13:11might go with the case. Answer correct question. Why would
- 13:15you want to extend that difference to him? Why would
- 13:17it matter? Answer a colleague and law enforcement. I thought
- 13:21it was important for the office to work with with
- 13:23state attorneys as a general matter, and I found that
- 13:27the office worked best when it had good working relationships
- 13:30with state attorneys and with you know, for that matter,
- 13:33the agency sacks and others. But again, you know, rather
- 13:37than my asserting, I'm asking redacted and redacted with saying no.
- 13:41And I don't know what the ultimate outcome was, but
- 13:43I would guess that we just defer and let it be.
- 13:47All right, folks, We're gonna wrap up right here, and
- 13:49in the next episode we're gonna pick up where we
- 13:51left off. All of the information that goes with this
- 13:54episode can be found in the description box.