Latest / Play Therapy Parenting: Real Parenting Questions Answered by a Child Therapist / S4E7 - How Do I Handle Aggressive Behavior Without Punishment?
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Play Therapy Parenting Podcast
- 0:06with Dr. Brenna Hicks.
- 0:09Hi,
- 0:10I'm Dr. Brenna Hicks,
- 0:11The Kid Counselor.
- 0:11This is the Play Therapy Parenting Podcast where
- 0:14I answer real parenting questions
- 0:16about behavior,
- 0:17emotions,
- 0:17and the parent-child relationship.
- 0:19In today's episode,
- 0:20I'm answering a question from Stacy.
- 0:22Stacy,
- 0:22thank you for the email.
- 0:24And this is about her
- 0:27child,
- 0:28actually a twin,
- 0:28but one of the two we're talking about.
- 0:31And aggressive behaviors,
- 0:34big emotions,
- 0:35all kinds of things,
- 0:36but not specifically just about the behaviors,
- 0:39but actually about implementing child-centered play therapy,
- 0:42parenting approaches
- 0:44to help with those behaviors.
- 0:46Actively working with a play therapist,
- 0:48actually,
- 0:48in fact,
- 0:49one of the play therapists that I coached personally.
- 0:51So,
- 0:52shout out to,
- 0:53you know who you are
- 0:55and
- 0:56really excited
- 0:57for this opportunity because Stacy,
- 0:59as you're working,
- 1:01With a child-centered play therapist
- 1:02and then you're also implementing strategies at home,
- 1:05that is an ideal scenario
- 1:08for your daughter's ability to
- 1:10work through this in the most healthy and effective ways.
- 1:13We know that when parents are involved and invested,
- 1:16that we have more favorable outcomes.
- 1:18So,
- 1:19with the support of a play therapist as well as the work you're doing at home,
- 1:23this is going to equip your daughter with
- 1:26the ideal scenario to really heal through all of this stuff.
- 1:29So,
- 1:30thanks for the email.
- 1:31I'll read part of what was shared and then we'll dive in together.
- 1:35So this
- 1:36child has been adopted
- 1:38and is a twin.
- 1:40There were issues in utero,
- 1:42so,
- 1:43you know,
- 1:43obviously comes from
- 1:45a different kind of background
- 1:47and a background over which we have no control
- 1:50and that.
- 1:51Always plays a factor,
- 1:52you know,
- 1:53for foster families and adoptive families
- 1:55that plays a role in
- 1:58the process of healing for a child because
- 2:01we didn't have any governance over what
- 2:04happened before they were in our possession.
- 2:07And,
- 2:07you know,
- 2:08obviously this is a contributing factor,
- 2:09so that's important to note as well.
- 2:11We've been seeing aggressive behaviors,
- 2:13biting,
- 2:14hitting,
- 2:14scratching in response to big emotions.
- 2:16She was not sleeping well.
- 2:18Her OT was helping her with sensory issues.
- 2:21And has been helping her with the zones of regulation.
- 2:25She can articulate things after the fact,
- 2:27but cannot control her behavior during the situation.
- 2:30She seemed to be going from 0 to 100 in 0.005 seconds
- 2:34with very little warning.
- 2:35That is a very brief amount of time.
- 2:37All right,
- 2:37so let me pause on that note,
- 2:38Stacy.
- 2:39So,
- 2:40She could articulate things after the fact but
- 2:42not control her behavior during the situation.
- 2:45We know this.
- 2:46This is developmentally appropriate.
- 2:48This is age-appropriate,
- 2:50very known
- 2:52process.
- 2:53Emotions override the brain.
- 2:56So,
- 2:56as emotions escalate,
- 2:58they get bigger and bigger and bigger.
- 3:00It essentially trips a switch,
- 3:02if you like to think about it that way,
- 3:04and tells the brain,
- 3:05go have a little nap.
- 3:07So,
- 3:07the brain disappears.
- 3:09The child behaves exclusively out of emotions,
- 3:13trying to show you
- 3:15how she feels,
- 3:16trying to help you understand how big this is for her,
- 3:20and
- 3:21there's no cognitive component there whatsoever.
- 3:24Once the emotions start to de-escalate
- 3:27and they come back down a little bit,
- 3:29the switch gets tripped again.
- 3:31Brain comes back into the picture
- 3:34and says,
- 3:35What in the world were you doing?
- 3:37You didn't need to scream.
- 3:38You didn't need to yell.
- 3:39You didn't need to throw something.
- 3:41You didn't need to do whatever.
- 3:42But in the moment,
- 3:43there was no ability
- 3:45for the brain to weigh in.
- 3:46There's a hierarchy,
- 3:47and emotions are always going to trump the brain.
- 3:50That's true of adults.
- 3:51Please don't think that's isolated just to children.
- 3:53There are plenty of adults in this world
- 3:55that
- 3:56just do something.
- 3:58I mean,
- 3:58you ever heard the phrase
- 4:00they.
- 4:01You need to think before you act.
- 4:04There's a reason why we say that,
- 4:06because there's plenty of adults
- 4:08that just act
- 4:09in reaction.
- 4:11And if they were to think about it,
- 4:13they would probably not do
- 4:15said action
- 4:16in their reaction,
- 4:17but they don't.
- 4:18They just dive straight into,
- 4:20I feel this,
- 4:21so I'm gonna do this,
- 4:22and then after the,
- 4:23after the fact,
- 4:24there's a lot of regret.
- 4:26So,
- 4:26this is universal,
- 4:28but even more pronounced with children.
- 4:30So that in and of itself,
- 4:32she could
- 4:33share after the fact but not control the behavior during the situation.
- 4:37She's not going to be able to do that for quite a while.
- 4:39I mean,
- 4:3913 is the earliest
- 4:41development of abstract reasoning,
- 4:43and she's a long way from there.
- 4:45So,
- 4:45that is a maturity
- 4:48process
- 4:49and that's something that's going to have to be
- 4:51established a little bit over the course of childhood.
- 4:55OK,
- 4:55so let me continue.
- 4:56We've done 4 weeks of play therapy.
- 4:57I've been binge,
- 4:58binge listening to your podcasts.
- 5:00I'm thrilled to hear that you find them helpful,
- 5:02Stacy.
- 5:02Currently in the summer of 2022.
- 5:06The therapist
- 5:07has us trying choice giving.
- 5:09We saw some results right away.
- 5:10I'm not the best at it,
- 5:11but I'm continuing to try.
- 5:13I have a hard time giving choices before she doesn't do what we're asking her to do.
- 5:17For example,
- 5:18when we tell her it's time to come get inside for dinner,
- 5:20and she runs off before I remember to give her choices.
- 5:23I also sometimes have a hard time coming up with a choice that is not punishment.
- 5:27Any suggestions on how to do those better?
- 5:29All right,
- 5:30so,
- 5:30really helpful scenarios,
- 5:32we can certainly talk through that.
- 5:34One of the most important things that we do is recognize that
- 5:38we're giving empowerment choices as often as possible.
- 5:41We're giving enforcement choices to address a limit.
- 5:43They function differently.
- 5:45So,
- 5:45Stacy,
- 5:46in your scenario,
- 5:47She
- 5:48is outside playing
- 5:50and you know that it's time for dinner.
- 5:52That's a very easy empowerment choice.
- 5:55So,
- 5:56Daughter,
- 5:57do you choose to come in in 2 minutes or do you choose to come in in 3 minutes,
- 6:00which do you choose?
- 6:02See how now I'm not even going outside and saying,
- 6:05it's time for dinner,
- 6:06come inside.
- 6:08That takes away all of her power.
- 6:10She feels at the mercy of the circumstance and your authority.
- 6:15But if you lead with the choice of when she comes in,
- 6:18it's not a matter of whether she wants to or not.
- 6:20It's almost guarantee she's not gonna want to come in for dinner,
- 6:24especially if she's having fun outside.
- 6:26That's a pretty standard childhood
- 6:28norm.
- 6:28I don't wanna come in for dinner and stop what I'm doing.
- 6:31OK.
- 6:32So,
- 6:32we're not gonna focus on,
- 6:33do you wanna come in or not?
- 6:35It's when do you choose to come in.
- 6:38You don't really care whether she comes in in 2 minutes or 3 minutes,
- 6:41so that's why we would give that empowerment choice.
- 6:44So we're not even going to say it's time for dinner.
- 6:47We're going to just say.
- 6:49OK,
- 6:49daughter,
- 6:50you can choose to come in in 2 minutes for dinner or
- 6:52you can choose to come in in 3 minutes for dinner.
- 6:53Which do you choose?
- 6:55And then a hard time coming up with a choice that's not a punishment.
- 6:59I suspect you're talking about enforcement choices
- 7:02which are tied to the limit.
- 7:04And in that case,
- 7:06you're giving choices
- 7:08that are based on the child's currency.
- 7:12So,
- 7:12let's say she refuses to come in,
- 7:14you give another choice,
- 7:16set the limit,
- 7:17she refuses to come in,
- 7:18you give another choice,
- 7:19you set the limit,
- 7:20she refuses to come in.
- 7:21OK,
- 7:21by that point,
- 7:22you're moving to ultimate limit setting at that
- 7:24moment.
- 7:25So then it's an if then
- 7:28choice.
- 7:29So,
- 7:29daughter,
- 7:30you really want to stay outside and play,
- 7:31but it's time for dinner.
- 7:33If you choose to come in right now,
- 7:35you choose.
- 7:37Favorable
- 7:39outcome
- 7:40based on her currency.
- 7:41What does she really love?
- 7:43What's really important to her?
- 7:45What is motivating for her?
- 7:47Is it dessert?
- 7:49Is it?
- 7:50Books
- 7:51after dinner,
- 7:52is it?
- 7:54Getting to.
- 7:56Snuggle on the couch and.
- 8:00Play a game,
- 8:01whatever it is that's important to her,
- 8:03we're going to work that into the choice.
- 8:06So,
- 8:07if you choose to come in right now,
- 8:09you choose to have
- 8:11your book snuggle time on the couch after dinner.
- 8:13If you choose not to come in right now,
- 8:15you choose not to have your book snuggle time on the couch after dinner,
- 8:19which do you choose?
- 8:21There's no punishment in that choice.
- 8:24There is
- 8:24a more positive outcome,
- 8:26and there's a less positive outcome.
- 8:29But your only job is to enforce the choice that's made.
- 8:32And so whatever she chooses,
- 8:34she either chooses to come in right away,
- 8:36you validate that out loud.
- 8:38You chose to have your book and snuggle time on the
- 8:40couch because you chose to come in for dinner right now,
- 8:43or
- 8:44you chose not to have your snuggle book time tonight
- 8:47because you chose not to come in right away.
- 8:49That will over time condition her
- 8:52that she does not want to lose the things that are important to her.
- 8:57That is actually
- 8:58more painful
- 8:59than the pain of coming inside for dinner.
- 9:02Kids are always trying to avoid
- 9:05the outcomes that they don't want
- 9:07because they're emotional.
- 9:09So,
- 9:10which is the lesser of two evils?
- 9:12Is it coming in for dinner but getting to keep my book snuggle time?
- 9:14Yeah,
- 9:15that's probably better
- 9:16than staying out here for another two minutes,
- 9:18still having to come inside for dinner anyway,
- 9:20and then I lose my book and snuggle time on the couch.
- 9:23That's far worse.
- 9:24I'll just come inside.
- 9:26It's conditioned.
- 9:28OK,
- 9:28I'm also struggling with limits,
- 9:30especially when she's choosing to hit,
- 9:32kick,
- 9:32and attack us or her brother.
- 9:34I keep telling her people aren't for hitting,
- 9:36but struggle after that.
- 9:37I'm trying to reflect feelings too,
- 9:38but struggle,
- 9:39especially when it's not in an aggressive moment.
- 9:42OK.
- 9:43So,
- 9:44it needs to be established
- 9:47long before the behavior is taking place.
- 9:49We establish household rules
- 9:52as a part of our CCPT parenting approach.
- 9:55So it is set at a neutral,
- 9:56calm,
- 9:57emotionless time.
- 10:00And it's very clear,
- 10:02it's made very clear,
- 10:04this is an expectation universally in our home.
- 10:07It might be speaking kindly,
- 10:09it might be not yelling,
- 10:10it might be
- 10:12not hurting anyone else.
- 10:14It might be.
- 10:16Obeying immediately,
- 10:18it might be doing chores.
- 10:19What the household rules are,
- 10:20they're going to be different for everybody,
- 10:21obviously.
- 10:23But we establish those at a neutral,
- 10:25calm time.
- 10:26So,
- 10:27we have a family meeting,
- 10:28we do it before bed,
- 10:30we do it in the morning when everybody's fresh and bright-eyed,
- 10:33and we're essentially saying
- 10:35this is an important established expectation in our home.
- 10:39You know,
- 10:39the phrase that we often teach in
- 10:42the parent training that's related to child-centered play therapy
- 10:45is we're about to institute a new and
- 10:46significant policy within the confines of this household.
- 10:49The premise is it gets your kids' attention.
- 10:51You don't have to say those words exactly,
- 10:54but
- 10:54it's very clear,
- 10:55oh,
- 10:56OK,
- 10:56I don't even know what was just said,
- 10:57but it sounded important,
- 10:58and every time
- 11:00my life's about to change,
- 11:02mom or dad or whoever says this,
- 11:04so I think I should probably pay attention.
- 11:07You're making it very clear this is important.
- 11:09So once the expectation is established,
- 11:11so Stacy,
- 11:12you might say.
- 11:15The
- 11:16New and significant
- 11:18policy
- 11:19in our home.
- 11:20Is that no one in the house is ever for hurting.
- 11:26No matter what happens,
- 11:28no matter how upset we are,
- 11:29no matter how we feel.
- 11:32No one is ever for hurting.
- 11:35OK,
- 11:35we reiterate it several times,
- 11:37we move on.
- 11:39That's what you fall back on in the moment.
- 11:41So,
- 11:41if she starts to hit or kick or whatever,
- 11:44first of all,
- 11:44we recognize that's age-appropriate behavior.
- 11:47So we have to understand
- 11:48what's age appropriate versus what is extreme.
- 11:53But then we say,
- 11:54you know,
- 11:55your brother is never for hurting.
- 11:58OK,
- 11:59reiterate the expectation she may be able to calm down.
- 12:03She may be able to stop the behavior.
- 12:06If she can't,
- 12:07you go through the limit.
- 12:10You're really upset,
- 12:11you're really angry,
- 12:12you're really mad,
- 12:13you're really frustrated,
- 12:14you're really disappointed,
- 12:15you're really whatever,
- 12:16whatever she's feeling,
- 12:17you're really fill in the blank,
- 12:19but your brother is never for hurting.
- 12:21You can choose to tell me.
- 12:24How you feel,
- 12:25you can choose to tell me what he's doing.
- 12:27You can choose to tell me that you're angry.
- 12:29You can choose to tell me that you don't want to be with him right now.
- 12:33Or you can choose to,
- 12:35is,
- 12:35is the need a release
- 12:37because sometimes just saying,
- 12:38hey,
- 12:38my brother's ticking me off isn't enough.
- 12:40Maybe it's,
- 12:41I need to hit or kick or punch something.
- 12:43So you can choose to punch your stuffed animals in your room.
- 12:46You can choose to punch your pillow,
- 12:47you can choose to punch your bed.
- 12:49You can choose to punch the cushions on the couch.
- 12:51There are alternatives if the need is the release of the aggression.
- 12:55You're gonna have to feel that out,
- 12:56Stacy.
- 12:57You're gonna need to find out
- 12:59what is it exactly that she's trying to.
- 13:02have met in the way of a need.
- 13:04Is it just I need someone to understand how big these feelings are,
- 13:08or I need to release some of this emotion?
- 13:11Those are two very different things and therefore
- 13:13we would change the choices that we provide.
- 13:16So that's the way that you can handle
- 13:18the ultimate limits.
- 13:21And
- 13:22again,
- 13:22we go back to currency.
- 13:25If you choose to.
- 13:27Behavior,
- 13:28hit,
- 13:28kick,
- 13:28punch,
- 13:29whatever the scenarios,
- 13:30your brother.
- 13:32You're choosing to,
- 13:33what matters?
- 13:34Is it
- 13:35be in your room for
- 13:3710 minutes
- 13:39alone?
- 13:40If
- 13:40that would really bother her,
- 13:42that would be a helpful currency.
- 13:43Some kids would just play in their room for 10 minutes and they'd be happy as clams.
- 13:46So
- 13:47it would be kid by kid situationally specific,
- 13:49but
- 13:50you have to figure out what matters.
- 13:53If you choose not to hurt your brother,
- 13:54you choose
- 13:56not to have that outcome.
- 13:59That's all very clear and established before
- 14:02it actually happens.
- 14:03And then
- 14:04final question,
- 14:05how to handle when one spouse is further along
- 14:07in implementing the pillars and focusing on the relationship?
- 14:10Do you have suggestions on how to help the other along and help them to
- 14:13not do or say things that might
- 14:15damage the relationship without undermining their authority?
- 14:18All right,
- 14:18really helpful question because this is one of the
- 14:21most common scenarios that we see as CCPTs.
- 14:25One parent is
- 14:27more involved in the knowledge,
- 14:28the training,
- 14:29the acquisition of information,
- 14:31and so then they're trying to pass along the information to the other parent.
- 14:35But the one doing the research and doing the learning is usually more
- 14:38able to implement it than the one that's being told about it.
- 14:41So,
- 14:41very common dynamic.
- 14:43And
- 14:44the most helpful way to manage that is
- 14:47We don't address anything in the moment.
- 14:50So no matter what happens,
- 14:51even if you go,
- 14:52oh my gosh,
- 14:53that's going to damage the relationship,
- 14:55or like,
- 14:55oh my gosh,
- 14:56like the child feels so
- 14:57unheard right now,
- 14:58or oh my gosh,
- 14:59like this would have been such a helpful moment to give a choice,
- 15:02whatever we think,
- 15:03because we understand the skills more intentionally,
- 15:07we're not going to say anything in the moment.
- 15:09But we make a mental note
- 15:11and then later when,
- 15:12you know,
- 15:12it's just the two of you,
- 15:14you're able to sit down and say,
- 15:16hey,
- 15:17I noticed earlier
- 15:18that
- 15:18you said or did X,
- 15:20Y,
- 15:20Z when such and such happened.
- 15:23One of the things that I've been learning,
- 15:24one of the things that's been really helpful.
- 15:27is
- 15:28you can
- 15:29give choices.
- 15:29Let me show you what that looks like.
- 15:31You can reflect feelings.
- 15:32Let me tell you why that's helpful and what that looks like.
- 15:35So,
- 15:35you say,
- 15:36uh,
- 15:36it's actually the same concept as what we do with kids.
- 15:39We wait until it's a calm,
- 15:40neutral moment
- 15:42to have the important dialogue.
- 15:44So,
- 15:44make a mental note of when it's happening in real time.
- 15:48And then save it where there's receptivity
- 15:51and there's a willingness to actually hear and and take the information in.
- 15:56When it's actively happening,
- 15:57that would be when it would undermine the authority.
- 16:00So we're we're just going to recognize that as I would have handled it differently,
- 16:05but
- 16:06we'll just let this play out for now and then we'll talk about it later,
- 16:09kind of scenario.
- 16:10And then there was kind of like a postscript that was added in there.
- 16:13I got thinking about using this with our
- 16:15son who is not developmentally his chronological age.
- 16:18I'm assuming it works the same for him,
- 16:20but it has to be done at his developmental age,
- 16:22any adjustments.
- 16:23So,
- 16:24for a child that is not developmentally on target per se,
- 16:28in other words,
- 16:29like other peers
- 16:30would be in a different level,
- 16:32and that can be
- 16:34in all kinds of contexts.
- 16:35So,
- 16:36physically,
- 16:36mentally,
- 16:37emotionally,
- 16:37psychologically,
- 16:38so on and so forth.
- 16:39So if there's any kind of delay
- 16:41or anything that would cause the child to not be at the same level as peers,
- 16:46that's actually one of the most ideally
- 16:47suited scenarios for a child-centered play therapy
- 16:50because even with the delay,
- 16:52even with those scenarios,
- 16:54CCPT is appropriate because it doesn't require the cognitive ability,
- 16:59it doesn't require the verbal ability.
- 17:00So we actually don't make any adjustments
- 17:03to working with children that are maybe behind level.
- 17:08Because
- 17:08it meets them where they are developmentally.
- 17:10I mean,
- 17:10CCPT is appropriate for kids as young as 3.
- 17:14Kind of an older two will sometimes also work.
- 17:18So,
- 17:19if your son is at a 2.5 year old level or up,
- 17:23it's still going to be fully effective.
- 17:25If he's a little bit below that,
- 17:27maybe he's at like a 1.5 or a 2 year old level,
- 17:30all the skills can still be implemented.
- 17:33They can still be practiced.
- 17:35But it's going to take a little bit more
- 17:37before some of those things start to register,
- 17:39but you can certainly still engage with the child-centered approach
- 17:43with your son,
- 17:45and then as he continues to mature and develop,
- 17:48things will start to be a little bit easier for him to comprehend.
- 17:51But many of the parents with whom we
- 17:53work will actually start practicing on their infants
- 17:55because it gives them time to get used to the language
- 17:59and the engagement and the dialogue and things like that for
- 18:02when the child is old enough to understand the information.
- 18:05So,
- 18:05Stacy,
- 18:06thank you so much for the questions.
- 18:07I hope that all of you found that helpful.
- 18:09It's really important to practice the skills that we learn.
- 18:13And I'm really encouraged,
- 18:15Stacy,
- 18:15that you're actually trying to integrate these into your parenting approach.
- 18:19That's what this podcast is all about.
- 18:21It's giving you practical,
- 18:23effective tools.
- 18:26Founded in
- 18:27a model that we know is proven effective.
- 18:30So this is taking the guesswork
- 18:32out of a parenting approach.
- 18:33And so thank you so much for the email.
- 18:35If y'all want to reach out,
- 18:36I'd love to hear from you,
- 18:37brenna@thekidcounselor.com
- 18:40We'll talk again soon.
- 18:41I love you.
- 18:41Keep loving on your kids.
- 18:43Bye.
- 18:43Thank you for listening to
- 18:45the Play Therapy Parenting Podcast with Dr. Brenna Hicks.
- 18:49For more episodes and just subscribe to our newsletter,
- 18:52please go to www.playtherapyparenting.com.