Latest / Following Leads / Six Months Later: Inside the Nancy Guthrie Investigation with Raya Torres
Transcript
- Untitled - August 25, 2026 00:00:00 Raya Torres: But I think that this is still a very active and ongoing investigation, and they have to be very careful about what they give, because anything that is publicly given through the sheriff's department or the FBI, the person who did this is most likely listening. 00:00:21 Laura Hettiger: For most of this year, our entire country has been gripped by one question Where is Nancy? The abduction of today show host Savannah Guthrie's mom, Nancy Guthrie, not only shocked the nation and devastated the Guthrie family, it had a huge impact on the Tucson community. So many people now looking over their shoulders, neighbors questioning neighbors, and everyone asking, how did this happen and how did this happen here? Raya Torrez was one of the local reporters in Tucson who has covered this story from the very beginning. And today, six months after that initial report that Nancy was missing, she is with us to talk through what maybe didn't make the headlines and we are so grateful for her time. Reya, thank you for being here. 00:01:13 Raya Torres: Yeah. Thank you so much. I really appreciate it. 00:01:16 Laura Hettiger: February first, twenty twenty six. Many of us start getting alerts sent to our phone all over the country, saying that the mother of Today show host Savannah Guthrie was missing. What do you remember about those initial reports? 00:01:33 Raya Torres: Yes, I was a reporter producer in Tucson, Arizona, and I had produced the weekend shows. February first was a Sunday, and I was producing our five thirty and ten p m shows that day. And I remember getting the email and really quickly, people in our newsroom started catching on that the last name was Guthrie, and we started doing a little digging of our own, and we found out that this could have been the mother of Today show host Savannah Guthrie. Our weekend team consisted of the producers and anchor, a photographer, a very bare bones newsroom for a weekend show, and we knew that we had a responsibility in order to report this, and at the time we didn't get it confirmed that it was Savannah's mother. But once a press conference was called later that evening, fifteen or so minutes before one of our shows at nine p m, we knew that we had the responsibility to make sure we did this as as ethically as possible. There are a lot of there was a lot of stress surrounding that. We had a show that was about to be on air, and I remember listening to the press conference live while our photographer was out on the scene. And as soon as Sheriff Nanos had mentioned that there was there were homicide detectives at the home that had immediately started ringing alarm bells for for me and for all of us. And we had to do our best in order to stay calm and report this as accurately as we could and get the information out there so that police can do their job and people can know what was happening in their community. 00:03:19 Laura Hettiger: And also you do your job because, as you mentioned, you can't go out there and speculate that the last names are the same. Many people knew that Savannah was from Arizona. We had seen so many pieces of her going back to Tucson and bragging on her mom and loving her mom, one of the best relationships you could imagine. But you can't go out there and say it without that confirmation. 00:03:48 Raya Torres: Absolutely. What we had to do was when we were told that there was going to be a press conference on a Sunday afternoon, and the sheriff was going to be out in front of this home in the Catalina foothills, one of us had reached out. I don't remember if it was me or another person in our newsroom at the time who had reached out and said, can we get any confirmation as to whether this is the mother of Savannah Guthrie? And shortly before the press conference, if memory serves me right, we got that confirmation from the sheriff's department that it was. And going into it and seeing the camera set up and obviously I'm in the newsroom. So it's a, um, it was a very nerve wracking experience not knowing what the sheriff was going to say. Um, we definitely felt a big responsibility in order to get this out there as accurately and as sensitively as possible. 00:04:42 Laura Hettiger: Because with the sheriff saying this is now a homicide investigation with the blood out the front door, not only does this have a huge impact on the Guthrie's, and you think the worst of what's going to happen for them, you now potentially have a killer on the run, and no one has a clue what this person looks like. 00:05:04 Raya Torres: Yeah, absolutely. There was a lot within the first couple of days, a lot of unknowns that we had to make sure that we were reporting as accurately as we could. I think in the earlier days when, when Sheriff Nanos had announced that night that there were homicide detectives on scene and this was being treated as a missing persons kidnapping case, there was so there were so much questions. There are still so much questions that as reporters, we have to make sure that we are being as sensitive as possible to the investigation that is currently ongoing, but also keeping in mind that there is a family that is wondering where their mother is. And that was always something that we were taught to keep in the back of our minds that when it comes to reporting, of course, there is adrenaline in getting information and trying to make sure that you're getting it out there first. But there is a very real situation happening beyond the headlines, and we needed to make sure that we were being as sensitive as we possibly could. 00:06:04 Laura Hettiger: And let's get into that because when we talk about true crime and the Nancy Guthrie case, this becomes a worldwide story within hours. But when you have international and national journalists flock to an area, they don't often know that area. You and your team did. In fact, you lived ten minutes from Nancy's home, where this investigation is all unfolding. What was the overall sense in the Tucson community in early February? 00:06:41 Raya Torres: I think everyone knew that this was where everything was happening. The community of Tucson, the Catalina Foothills community, knew that they were going to be under a microscope, so to speak, in the days after it was announced that she had disappeared. I don't think that many people within that community were expecting the amount of media attention to flock into this quiet Catalina Foothills neighborhood. And I think that that had a very big impact on a lot of people living there. It had definitely had an impact on on us, you know, these streets that we had so freely driven through. A lot of media was parked on one side, and it became a one way street. There were a lot of people who a lot of neighbors who were really frustrated with the amount of media that would surround it, a lot of their homes. And unfortunately, some people who had wanted to cover these, these instances, whether that be other members of the media or even other streamers and other true crime enthusiasts, I would argue, didn't cover it with as much of a sense of sensitivity as they probably should. I understand that this is such a big story. We all knew that this was something that the entire world had had their eyes on. But at the same time, journalists have this ethical responsibility in order to cover something as remarkable as this, as crazy as this, with such sensitivity. And sometimes that got lost and it was hard. I think seeing our neighbors, seeing my neighbors come out and express how frustrated they were that people were stepping on their saguaro cactuses, their, um, their prickly pears outside of their home, things like that. As a local reporter, it hurt to see our neighbors struggling through this in terms of seeing a neighbor go missing, but also not being prepared and not knowing just how, how much interest it would that community would receive. 00:08:53 Laura Hettiger: And I'm sure that frustration came from a basis of fear because truly people were looking over their shoulders as I was sitting here in Saint Louis and listening to every update in those early days, I found myself looking around as anything suspicious, and I think that's part of what gripped the country. Because if it could happen to Nancy Guthrie, then could it happen to my family? 00:09:24 Raya Torres: Yes, we knew that there were a lot of people around the country and also around the world that had their eyes focused on this story, and there's still a lot of unknown questions to this day. I think even my former colleagues in Tucson were also hoping for more information to come out, and also for more progress to be made in this investigation. And it still feels so heavy for a lot of people in that area and a lot of journalists who still work there. We know the responsibility that we have to be there for the family and also be there for the community. And until we find out what truly happened, I don't think that that's ever going to go away. 00:10:11 Laura Hettiger: With the thirst for true crime and living in a twenty four hour news cycle. We do crave information, and I think sometimes it's easy for people to be an armchair quarterback and say, well, this should have been done. I would have done it differently. Let's talk about the information, but also misinformation that got out there. You referenced that very first press conference on day one, Sunday, February first with Sheriff Nanos. From what I understand, he had another one just a little later that week and then no more. Yeah. Should he have been giving more information to the public to tamp down some of the misinformation that was out there? 00:10:57 Raya Torres: I think that especially in an investigation, as sensitive and as pressing as something like this, I believe that the Sheriff's Department gave what they could at the time. And I believe that with everything that they have given us, we tried to recover that as much as we possibly could. Sometimes the tough part with misinformation is that people tend to speculate, as you had mentioned, when they don't receive as much information as they possibly could. And so I think as members of the media, we can try to give as much as we can. But it's hard whenever people try to put their spin on this, or they try to give tidbits that they think are going to be useful. And so I think that as someone who has covered this very extensively, I believe that the sheriff's department has given as much as they could with the information that they can provide. But I think that this is still a very active and ongoing investigation, and they have to be very careful about what they give, because anything that is publicly given through the sheriff's department or the FBI, the person who did this is most likely listening. 00:12:10 Laura Hettiger: And let's bring up that aspect of it, because this case has had some notes go out. Some in the early days were completely fabricated. And I know at least one person in California was arrested for that. Yes, it sounds like there are two very credible ransom notes. What do you remember working at cold at the time and the ransom notes coming out? 00:12:39 Raya Torres: Well, we have a system, I believe. Let me try to phrase this correctly. We have a pitch form on our website where it goes any single time that someone has sent over a pitch to us, it goes to members of our newsroom. So anyone in the newsroom can make sure that they have their eyes on it. It is received, and those particular notes were sent through that pitch form. And that was something that a lot of people in our newsroom had eyes on. As soon as they were received, we made sure to forward that to law enforcement. They were very concerning notes, and we didn't know if they were credible by any means. And we made sure to forward them to the proper authorities, while also making sure that we were that we were as sensitive as possible with what we chose to disclose about them. 00:13:43 Laura Hettiger: Let's make sure our listeners and viewers understand this aspect, and I will try to recite it to you through the lens of how it works here. If someone has a news tip, it could be anything. They can send it anonymously to a TV station or a newspaper. Most, uh, journalistic entities have that available. It goes out potentially to all the reporters, maybe all the photographers, if they are on this listserv. To all of the heads of the departments. Um, everyone who works on the desk, we call the assignment desk. They are the people who are usually in charge of the website, but also listening to the scanners to send people to breaking news situations. This is a big list of people usually. So twenty potentially people all of a sudden receive this ransom note. It is incredible that no one screenshotted it and blasted it out. 00:14:51 Raya Torres: Absolutely. I think that everyone in our newsroom from day one, that small group of people within the weekend team who got that first, um, that first note about Nancy Guthrie going missing. I think we all knew from the beginning that we had a huge responsibility to make sure that we were doing this with as much reporting this with as much integrity as possible. And I feel so grateful to come from a newsroom that made sure that we were doing that, because there is a real family that is wondering where their mother is, and we wanted to make sure that we were complying with everything that the FBI had asked us to. And we were, um, reporting this with the information that was provided to us by law enforcement. And I think that that just goes to show that our newsroom truly tried to be as sensitive as responsible and do this with as much integrity as we possibly could. It, I feel very grateful to come from, um, to come from a newsroom that reported this with as much care as we, we definitely tried to. 00:16:00 Laura Hettiger: From what I understand, that first ransom note laid out a deadline with a request for Bitcoin receive the money by this point. You get this information. By this point, it's more money. This is all in the first week. What do you remember about that timeline? And even probably checking the Bitcoin address that was included? 00:16:25 Raya Torres: Yeah. So what I can confirm was that yes, our newsroom did receive that first note within the first week of this happening. And I'm going to check my notes to make sure um, there was a deadline that was on there. There was a dollar amount that was on there. Um, but there were also details that were not made public in that note that someone who might have done something like this might have known if they've committed the, the crime. And so that week inside of the newsroom, again, we all knew that there was a responsibility that we had to forward this to law enforcement, but it brought us back down to earth a lot to make sure that we had at the back of our minds that there was a family here. There was there were children that were wondering where their mom was. And we made sure to forward this as much as we could to law enforcement. Anything that we had received, we sent it over to them so that they could do their job in order to investigate and hopefully bring her home. And I know that that is what we still try to do. Or my old newsroom they're continuing to do. Um, had we had gotten anything else from anyone used. 00:17:46 Laura Hettiger: The phrase bring her home, that almost became not just a plea from the Guthrie family, but it seems as an outsider, a rallying cry for the Tucson community, for everyone to get involved and bring her home. Something that broke about ten days after Nancy first disappeared was the haunting Nest doorbell images I remember standing at my computer as they came out and screamed, and there was a collective scream in the newsroom. How oh my gosh, terrifying. That was. 00:18:23 Raya Torres: Absolutely. 00:18:24 Laura Hettiger: What? Do you remember that about that time, but also about people in Tucson now having an image and being like, oh my gosh, is is that my son's friend? Is that a kid I know from down the street? 00:18:38 Raya Torres: I think when those suspect images came out, it had come out the week after she was first announced missing. And I remember that specifically because that was my first report on the Guthrie case, my first reporting report, so to speak. I had produced most of the the shows in the week following her disappearance. And when those suspect images came out a week after, they were chilling, they were just anyone who saw those images were very concerned that someone who looked like this, someone who was a possible suspect in this case, this was captured on doorbell camera footage. And I think that that's the photo that has been plastered on so many people's minds. I mean, my heart beats really fast thinking about it now because it has been printed in my mind, hoping that someone will be able to recognize it. And you could tell there were people who were very, very concerned that this this had happened. And they were very surprised that something like this could have been captured on doorbell camera footage. And it took a while for, for those images to come out as well. 00:19:54 Laura Hettiger: You mentioned you were hoping that this was going to lead to something, and that's what I envision for the Tucson community. There was so much fear, so much fear. But now we had hope that maybe someone recognized something. But still, six months later, there has not been an arrest of who this person was on the porch. They are still so many questions. Is there going to be closure? How does closure start to happen when we really don't know what happened to this beautiful soul? 00:20:32 Raya Torres: I think that we're all hoping for her to be brought home. And I think a lot of people in the Tucson community really want to know what happened, but not just for their own interests, but they also just want the Guthrie family to get that closure. It's tough. Six months following the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, and we're still hoping for more information to come out. And we're hoping for more progress to be made in something like this. But if there's anything that this coverage has taught me, it's that we need to be patient as much as we can, and we need to be as kind and as sensitive as we possibly can. Um.