Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 068 – Jan 2020 Questions – Nudists, exhibitionism, male lingerie, pet play, ANR and more
Transcript
- 0:43Hello and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. My name is JD and I blog over at UncoveringIntimacy.com and today we're going to be answering some questions about nudism, exhibitionism, male lingerie, pet play, Romans 13, 14, adult nursing relationships, and a few other things from our anonymous Have a Question page.
- 1:01Special thanks to all of our supporters who share their thoughts, opinions, and experiences in our forum. I absolutely love all the discussion that we have about these kinds of topics.
- 1:10So, without further ado, here are the questions from last month.
- 1:14Question one is, is nudism a sin? If you're a Christian, is it inappropriate to be naked outside of one's intimacy? Are naked hiking and or swimming okay?
- 1:24So, I've been struggling with the idea of Christian nudists for a while, and to be honest, I don't have a hard stance on it. But here's where I am right now.
- 1:31First, I don't believe nudism is a sin. Adam and Eve were created naked before sin entered the world, so being naked clearly isn't sinful.
- 1:41However, I believe there is a time and a place for everything, and the problem is that not everyone agrees on what those times and places are.
- 1:47And if everyone agreed that nudity wasn't inappropriate at any time, and everyone went naked any time that the weather or their activities permitted, then we wouldn't likely have an issue.
- 1:59Likewise, if everyone agreed that nudity was inappropriate, except for in the privacy of your own bedroom and bathroom, then we'd not have any issues either.
- 2:07However, the problem is that you have some people who have no issues with nudity, and others who have serious issues with them, and a whole bunch of people in the middle.
- 2:14Sorry, middle. And that causes a conflict.
- 2:19So, some will argue that it's immoral to offend someone else. So, even if nudity isn't immoral itself, offending someone else with your nudity is.
- 2:28I don't particularly like that answer, because that's kind of the direction our entire society is going, to outlaw being offensive.
- 2:36And I think it's making us stupid in the process.
- 2:39You know, intelligent debate requires being willing to both offend and be offended, because you can't even discuss critical issues without potentially offending someone.
- 2:49For example, I'm fairly certain that just about every post and podcast that I ever released, or will ever release, will offend somebody.
- 2:58It's nearly guaranteed.
- 2:59But I'm not about to stop, because I think it's important that we discuss these issues.
- 3:05And, frankly, I take my example from Jesus, who clearly wasn't worried about offending people either.
- 3:11He was much more interested in the truth than whether or not he was offending someone.
- 3:16At least, that's how I see it.
- 3:17And then there's the argument about whether it will incite lust in others or not.
- 3:24And, however, this is a bit cyclical of an argument, because the reason it incites lust is because it's taboo and uncommon to see naked people walking around.
- 3:34If it was commonplace, then we likely wouldn't have the same impact.
- 3:37So, that's not a great argument either.
- 3:39However, here in Canada, and I believe most other countries, there are laws prohibiting nudity when out in public.
- 3:48And what we see in the Bible is Jesus telling us to respect our authorities.
- 3:53So, hiking and swimming naked then become problematic, because unless you can be assured of your privacy due to the legality and because it's a legal issue,
- 4:01then it becomes a moral issue, since it's moral to follow the laws.
- 4:05And don't get me wrong, I think there's a time for your rights and freedoms.
- 4:09When governmental law goes contrary to it, but personally, the right to be naked is not a hill I'm willing to die on or even get a ticket for.
- 4:17Especially since nowhere does the Bible seem to even suggest that nudity in public spaces is something that we should be striving for.
- 4:25So, I'm going to say that it's probably not above the submit to authority's direct commandment that we do have in the Bible.
- 4:31So, yeah, if it's legal where you live, then I don't see an inherent problem with it.
- 4:37So, for example, I don't see an issue that I can find with being naked in the privacy of your own home.
- 4:43Having people over who would also be of the same mind about nudity and being naked together, by that same logic, I think would also be okay.
- 4:52I would say be careful about open windows, because in some jurisdictions, if the windows are open, then that could also be considered public and thus fall under public indecency laws.
- 5:00So, then things like hiking in your own backyard, if you have acreage, for example, likely not a problem.
- 5:07Hiking naked on public trails, however, check your laws.
- 5:11Likewise with swimming, if it's in your own pool, maybe not an issue, so long as you have fences and your neighbors don't have a second floor on their house.
- 5:20Skinny dipping in the quarry, again, check your own laws.
- 5:23All right, and question two kind of builds on this.
- 5:27This person writes,
- 5:28Hey, Jay, my wife and I are followers of Jesus and pretty conservative.
- 5:32We were virgins when we married, and I never slept on our wedding night when we had glorious and awkward sex for the first time.
- 5:40On our honeymoon, my wife went topless on a public beach.
- 5:43She was inspired by other topless women around, and no one seemed to care about it and took the plunge.
- 5:49Her topless beach experience led to our hottest round of sex afterwards.
- 5:52Thirteen years later, my wife discreetly goes topless on beaches when others are doing the same.
- 5:57She has probably been topless on the beach for 15 to 20 times now, and because of my job, we travel a lot and end up on beaches all around the world.
- 6:06In the bedroom, topless fantasies are one of our favorite role plays.
- 6:11When I come to the bedroom, she's often in a little thong bikini getting warmed up for me with her vibrator.
- 6:16She says the vibrator feels great over her bikini bottoms.
- 6:19And yes, she has worn thongs on public beaches, although less often than being topless.
- 6:24Like with being topless, she will not wear a thong on a busy beach and does her best to remain discreet.
- 6:30Clearly, my wife and I enjoy some exhibition together.
- 6:33So here's my question.
- 6:34Is it okay for a Christian couple to engage in mild exhibition like I described?
- 6:40All right.
- 6:41So like I said, this question kind of builds on the previous one.
- 6:44But in this case, we still have nudity, which I still stand by isn't a problem if it's legal, such as when you describe when topless speeches are legal.
- 6:53For example, here in Ontario, Canada is perfectly legal for women to walk around topless in public.
- 6:58That law came into effect when I was a teenager, so it hasn't quite become the norm in our culture by any means yet.
- 7:05I believe I've only ever seen one woman exercise that right, and it was at an outdoor concert, and I have a feeling she would have done it regardless of whether or not it was legal.
- 7:15However, with this question, now it's not just nudity, but the requirement for other people to see you naked.
- 7:21And here's where I think you start to enter a more dangerous gray area, because for some, it might be the fact that they're finally free to be nude that's exhilarating the focus on being free and the nudity itself.
- 7:34And that, I don't think, is a problem.
- 7:37But for this couple, it seems to be specifically about other people being witness to that nudity.
- 7:42So now you're using other people's foreplay, and that trips across the line for me, because now you're using someone else in your sex life, basically using them as a sex toy.
- 7:52And for me, that's problematic.
- 7:55That's how I see it anyways.
- 7:58But I'd love to know what other people's opinions are.
- 8:00So, if you've got a thought, head over to the blog and put it in the comment section.
- 8:05You can find the link to the show notes in the podcast episode description.
- 8:09Question 3 states,
- 8:13With reference to Romans 13, verse 14, how much thinking or planning about sex with my wife is too much thinking?
- 8:20So, Romans 13, verse 14 says,
- 8:23But put on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make no provision for the flesh to fulfill its lusts.
- 8:30Alright, so here's the problem when you take a verse out of context.
- 8:34Reading this as a standalone verse, you may conclude that planning for sex is sinful because it's a provision for the flesh.
- 8:41However, in the verses immediately surrounding this verse, Paul makes it clear that he's talking about works of darkness, that is sin.
- 8:49Sex with your wife is not sin, so you can't apply this verse to sex within marriage in general.
- 8:53As well, if you read more of Paul's writings, he often talks about the dichotomy between, you know, the flesh and the spirit.
- 9:01And he uses these as metaphors, not to talk about physical things and spiritual things, but rather the life you live apart from Christ, and the life that you live as part of Christ.
- 9:11That is, the unbeliever's life versus the believer's life, the unsaved versus the saved.
- 9:17And this is important because people, many people, mistakenly believe that Paul is talking about flesh versus soul literally, and make up a lot of contradictory doctrine because of it.
- 9:28But he's not.
- 9:28He's talking about your life acknowledging Christ as Lord versus your life believing yourself to be Lord.
- 9:34And given that larger context, this verse isn't about sex at all, but rather about all those sinful temptations that come up.
- 9:42Paul is saying not to give them any thought.
- 9:46Don't entertain them.
- 9:47Don't try to make plans for how you're going to fulfill them.
- 9:50And don't work towards satisfying them.
- 9:52Because otherwise, if this text is actually about physical desires, well, then you shouldn't plan for meals or sleep or anything else that we need to survive as physical beings.
- 10:02And that doesn't really make much sense.
- 10:06So, with reference to Romans 13 verse 14, how much thinking or planning about sex with my wife is too much thinking?
- 10:12Unless you're planning to do something immoral with your wife, I don't think this comes into context.
- 10:17Rather, I'd go check out Song of Solomon and read that whole thing and see how much planning and thinking about sex that Solomon does.
- 10:25It doesn't seem to be an issue there.
- 10:28All right.
- 10:29Question four writes,
- 10:31Hello, Jay.
- 10:32I'm a 48-year-old male and married to a 50-year-old.
- 10:35We lost our first child, stillborn, back in 2005, and my wife hemorrhaged and lost a lot of blood.
- 10:41She received a blood transfusion and doctors said no long-term damage because of the amount of blood lost.
- 10:48We had a daughter in 2007 and a miscarriage a year later.
- 10:52My wife has never been the same since the day we lost our first baby.
- 10:55She has gotten worse over the years, always irritable, and most of the time angry, upset at the kids for the smallest things and yelling at them.
- 11:03She has not dealt with the losses and tries to fill the void with stuff, always buying things.
- 11:08I've tried to get her to go to counseling, which she refuses, and she won't open up and talk about it.
- 11:13I'm at my wit's end and the kids are always walking on eggshells around her.
- 11:16She also had a rough upbringing in her childhood, which has caused issues as well as physical abuse and, I believe, sexual.
- 11:26Divorce is a really tough option as a believer, but I can't keep going on like this.
- 11:32Any suggestions, Rob?
- 11:38For me, I would say don't take no as an option for counseling.
- 11:42There's a time and a place for counseling, and I believe this is one of those times.
- 11:46If it's as you describe it, you know, she's experienced trauma and never dealt with it and now is passing on that trauma to others.
- 11:54You know, there's an old saying, you know, hurt people, hurt people.
- 11:59And that's not okay.
- 12:00It's not okay for her or for you nor for your kids.
- 12:04You know, they shouldn't have to grow up in a home where they have to walk on eggshells.
- 12:07That's going to negatively affect their future relationships as well.
- 12:11So, if it was me, I would tell my wife all of that.
- 12:16Maybe something like, dear, I believe you're hurting and you need someone to help you.
- 12:22What's going on right now isn't okay for me or for you or our children.
- 12:26You know, they need stable parents and I need a stable wife.
- 12:29Are you willing to come with me to counseling so that we can get help?
- 12:32And if she won't go, then I'd probably say something like, all right, well, I'm going to be going to counseling then and I'm going to be taking the kids so that we can learn how to not have our lives damaged by your pain.
- 12:43I'd much rather you be part of that discussion so we can plan our futures together.
- 12:47But if you're unwilling, then I understand.
- 12:50And this is a bit of a warning shot and some may call it manipulative or an ultimatum.
- 12:55But the fact is that you're already thinking about leaving.
- 12:57If you didn't do this, then she'd be blindsided by it.
- 13:00So this is telling her clearly out in the open that this is intolerable, not in a mean way, but literally we cannot tolerate it and we're not willing to live like this anymore.
- 13:12So I would consider this extending an opportunity to fix things.
- 13:16To me, that's setting a healthy boundary and then standing by it for the sake of your health, that of your children and for your wife as well, because ultimately you have promised to love her and leaving her like this is not loving.
- 13:27So that's what I do in my marriage with my wife.
- 13:33I don't know enough about your marriage to tell you what you should do.
- 13:36You'll have to make that decision for yourself, but maybe that gives you something to work with as an idea.
- 13:42And what you could always do is reach out to a therapist and go yourself and say, hey, this is my situation.
- 13:48You know, what can I do?
- 13:49And then the therapist can spend time asking you questions and build a plan with you that fits your situation better.
- 13:57All right.
- 13:58Question number five is my husband wants to start an ANR, which I'm excited about.
- 14:02I did not breastfeed my children and have gone through menopause.
- 14:05What steps do I need to start lactating again?
- 14:07I hope you can help me.
- 14:08So for those who don't know, an ANR is an adult nursing relationship.
- 14:12I've written about them before.
- 14:14I'll link to the post in the show notes.
- 14:16Um, it also has some information that this person is looking for.
- 14:20I believe, um, you can also check out the comments on the post too, because some Christian
- 14:24pro ANR websites left some comments that might be helpful as well.
- 14:28And that's about all I'm going to say about it.
- 14:30Cause I am not an expert on this, but hopefully that'll point you towards some people who are.
- 14:37All right.
- 14:38And question six is quite long.
- 14:41It's multiple paragraphs.
- 14:42So, so if you want to read the whole thing, you can go check it out on the website.
- 14:45Uh, links in the show notes as always.
- 14:47Um, but the short version of it is, uh, this wife's husband has started masturbating and
- 14:53watching porn.
- 14:54And this is making sex less pleasurable for her because he doesn't last long enough for
- 14:58her to have an orgasm.
- 14:59Plus she's hurt by it because he's cheating on her with porn.
- 15:02So how does she deal with this and still remain biblically respectful as a wife?
- 15:08So in the longer version, uh, you mentioned that you already talked to him and he got angry.
- 15:12And I'm curious exactly what you said, uh, because often when people say, oh, I talked
- 15:18about it, but they got angry, the conversation starts very combative.
- 15:21So if I had to make a guess, I would, I would guess that you were on the attack from the
- 15:27beginning.
- 15:27And then he got defensive.
- 15:29Um, I'm not saying that you don't have every right to be angry, but often what we have the
- 15:34right to do isn't what's more effective or the productive thing to do.
- 15:37Um, but that's not a guarantee.
- 15:39Some people just get defensive because it's easier than feeling convicted.
- 15:43So let's say you approached it lovingly and you expressed how it made you feel and made
- 15:49it appeal for him to protect your feelings and gave him hope that devoting his sexual
- 15:54energy to you would yield an even more erotic sex life than what porn could give him.
- 15:59Now what?
- 16:02Well, then I go back to my rule about divorce.
- 16:04Is this something that you can bear for some?
- 16:07They have the strength to continue like this for the rest of their life.
- 16:10And if you have the strength, there are verses that talk about such things.
- 16:14Uh, one Corinthians seven verse 13 says, and a woman who has a husband who does not believe
- 16:18if he is willing to live with her, let her not divorce him.
- 16:22Uh, in cases like this, I would say your husband is acting like a non-believer, whether
- 16:26he claims to be or not.
- 16:28One Peter three verses one to four has a similar message about staying in a marriage.
- 16:33Um, even if your husband is not a believer or doesn't obey God, uh, because you might
- 16:40convert them.
- 16:41And if you look at the book of Hosea, you see this huge, shining example of a husband
- 16:46who stayed with his wife, despite public adultery and humiliation.
- 16:50And so there is a chance that your message of love might reach him.
- 16:54It's not a guarantee that he'll listen to it though.
- 16:58For others, this situation is unbearable.
- 17:00In which case I would consider this adultery as you do, uh, which the Bible says is permissible,
- 17:06is a permissible reason for divorce.
- 17:08Um, I should note, it doesn't say divorce is mandatory, merely permissible.
- 17:13So then the question falls to, uh, which is stronger your love for your spouse or your
- 17:18hate for what he's doing.
- 17:19And I'm not making a judgment here.
- 17:21I think that calculation is different for everyone and you have to decide for yourself
- 17:25which one wins.
- 17:27All right.
- 17:27Question seven.
- 17:29This person asks, is male lingerie okay within the confines of a straight Christian marriage?
- 17:34Some quote unquote male lingerie ranges from pretty mild to very effeminate, but are clearly
- 17:39made with a male figure in mind.
- 17:41For example, if something is made for the male figure, but it is lace or fill on it, is that
- 17:46considered women's clothing, even though it's labeled as male lingerie stuff that I'd strictly
- 17:50want to wear for my wife confined only to our intimate moments occasionally.
- 17:55Also is pet play.
- 17:56Okay.
- 17:57Nothing too extreme, but accessories like cat ears or painted on nose and whiskers stuff
- 18:01that is cute, but distinctly male and human just made to be a cute and submissive role
- 18:06play while still being distinctly male and masculine.
- 18:09All right.
- 18:11So we have two questions here, really.
- 18:12So we'll tackle them in order.
- 18:14The first is male lingerie.
- 18:17Okay.
- 18:18So my stance has always been that God made two genders distinct and separate and what
- 18:23constitutes male and female clothing changes from culture to culture and from age to age.
- 18:28So you can't say that X clothing is for women and Y clothing is for men.
- 18:32Um, if you look back in old pictures, uh, and paintings, we can see radically how dressing
- 18:39style is different, uh, even in today's age styles differ.
- 18:43Um, so I think it comes down to the why, why is it that you want to wear this, you know,
- 18:50lace and fill used to be commonly included in male clothing, so they're not inherently female,
- 18:55but if your goal is to look or feel more feminine, that's where I think you begin to cross
- 19:00the line.
- 19:01And it's not to say that men can't have interests that some would consider feminine.
- 19:05I don't want people to be confused here.
- 19:07If a man wants to take up knitting, go right ahead.
- 19:09Uh, if you like frill on clothes, that's fine.
- 19:13Um, but if you're doing it to feel more feminine, then I think we're drifting again.
- 19:21So that's my thought about the clothing.
- 19:23Now for the pet play thing, here's my issue with pet play.
- 19:26You're basically acting out bestiality, which is abhorrent in the Bible.
- 19:32Uh, Exodus 22 verse 19 says, whoever lies with an animal shall surely be put to death.
- 19:37Um, I believe they actually killed the animal as well.
- 19:41So that's strong language.
- 19:42And I'm not suggesting that having sex with someone who is dressed like a cat is bestiality,
- 19:47but it's mimicking bestiality, which I think violates the verse in Philippians 4 verse
- 19:53eight, um, which is the one that says finally, brethren, whichever, whatever things are true,
- 19:58whatever things are noble, whatever things are just, whatever things are pure, whatever
- 20:02things are lovely, whatever things are good report, if there is any virtue and if anything
- 20:06is praiseworthy, meditate on these things.
- 20:08So in other words, we should focus on the things that are good, not be mimicking things that
- 20:13are evil.
- 20:14And so I have some concerns about it because what, again, what is it that makes you want
- 20:19to, uh, have sex with an animal or act as an animal when you're having sex?
- 20:25Uh, furthermore, why does it seem acceptable to feed that desire by play acting it?
- 20:31You know, if we have a child that seems to be enamored with murder, starts buying knives
- 20:36and play acting, killing their siblings and friends, well, we'd be bringing that child to
- 20:41the therapist and it doesn't matter that they've never killed anyone before.
- 20:44The point is something's not right.
- 20:47And I'm not saying that pet play is akin to being a psychopath.
- 20:50I'm just using extreme case to try and make a subtle point, less subtle.
- 20:55Um, basically don't feel feed unnatural and unhealthy desires.
- 21:01Question eight is when I have sex doggy position, my husband is too rough bottoms out.
- 21:07Any suggestion for this situation?
- 21:09So having just read that, I said this about pet play and this, this, uh, position is called
- 21:16doggy's position.
- 21:17Um, someone's going to make the connection and go, well, they're having sex in doggy's
- 21:21position.
- 21:21That's like pet play.
- 21:22And if I think if you're doing it to act out two dogs having sex, then yes, it is.
- 21:28But if you're not, then they're unrelated.
- 21:30It's just what it's called.
- 21:32Um, anyways, to answer the question, yes, they actually make, uh, something for this.
- 21:39There is on Mary dance, uh, a toy or accessory or whatever you want to call it, um, called
- 21:47the bumper deep thrust cushion.
- 21:49I'll put a link to it in the show notes and there's a coupon code to, I think, get 10%
- 21:55off from your first order.
- 21:57So give that a try.
- 21:59If it works, leave a review over on their site.
- 22:03All right.
- 22:04And lastly, question number nine, this person writes some quick background.
- 22:09I'm a morning person.
- 22:10My wife is a night owl.
- 22:12I go to bed around 10 to 10 30.
- 22:14She goes to bed around one to 3 AM.
- 22:17And I get up at five between five and 6 AM.
- 22:21And she'll stay in bed until 9 AM when she works at 10 or noon.
- 22:24If she doesn't, we never in the morning.
- 22:27I would love to, but to live with it.
- 22:30We have an arrangement where she'll wake me up and comes to bed for sex.
- 22:34It messes with my sleep because I anticipate it and don't really sleep well, but for sex,
- 22:39I'll deal with it.
- 22:40This week has been a problem.
- 22:41Sunday, she had on her sexy panties.
- 22:43I ate too much and didn't want to.
- 22:45Monday and Thursday, she stayed up until 3 AM working on some craft.
- 22:49Wednesday, too tired, went to bed at 10 with me.
- 22:52Um, Thursday, she said she'd wake me up and didn't.
- 22:55So I was mad and couldn't sleep at all from 1 to 3 30 AM after she came to bed.
- 23:01Friday, she watched a movie until 1 AM.
- 23:04Saturday, we went to a party.
- 23:05She again had on the lacy panties, but just went to bed when we got home.
- 23:10Sunday night.
- 23:11Now she'll read a book until late.
- 23:14This has not been a good week.
- 23:15Help.
- 23:17All right.
- 23:17So sleep schedules are more of a preference than anything.
- 23:21When we first got married, I was a night owl.
- 23:24My wife would go to bed early and I would stay up late.
- 23:27At the time, I was going to college and I had no morning courses.
- 23:31So it was easy to sleep until late in the morning where she went off to work and then
- 23:36work late into the evening on projects and assignments.
- 23:39It wasn't good for our marriage, though.
- 23:41Um, similar to what you're experiencing.
- 23:43Uh, about five years ago, I took a job where I had to get up before 6 AM to commute to work.
- 23:49Since last year, when COVID hit, I no longer have to commute, but I'm still getting up at
- 23:536 30 AM to work out and then start work at 7 30.
- 23:56That's not a requirement of my job.
- 23:58I picked my ship, uh, shift hours.
- 24:00The point is sleep schedules are modifiable.
- 24:05Now you didn't mention whether or not you're getting up early for work or simply because
- 24:09that's a preference.
- 24:10So barring some commitment like work, what's stopping either of you from shifting your
- 24:14schedules?
- 24:15I mean, this is clearly not working for you and putting up with marital issues simply
- 24:20because of preferences is not productive in the least.
- 24:23Now that said, I would say that there's plenty of evidence to suggest that going to bed prior
- 24:27to midnight results in better rest.
- 24:29So as such, I would lean towards an earlier bedtime and an earlier rise, but I'm not a
- 24:34medical professional, so I can't say what would be better for you.
- 24:38Alternatively, what's to stop her from coming to bed when you go to bed, you know, have sex
- 24:43and then she can get up again, or you wake her up in the morning, have sex, and then she
- 24:48can go back to sleep if she doesn't feel that interrupted sleep is a problem because apparently
- 24:53she doesn't think your interrupted sleep is a problem.
- 24:55Um, but you already said that morning sex never happens, so maybe that needs to change.
- 25:01Why not trade off on the timing?
- 25:03Sometimes have sex when she comes to bed and sometimes when you get up, that way you're
- 25:08both equally affected.
- 25:10Um, so there are some ideas.
- 25:14Um, ultimately it sounds like you guys have to have a serious adult discussion about this,
- 25:20not where one of you is blaming the other one, but where you both come to this and say,
- 25:24Hey, this is a problem that we have.
- 25:26How do we solve it together?
- 25:29And that's all the questions I got in January.
- 25:32Uh, as always, if you have a question of your own, you can either email me at j at
- 25:35uncovering intimacy.com or submit it on our, have a question page.
- 25:40Uh, if you want to participate in the discussions yourself, consider joining our support forum.
- 25:44Uh, all the links are in the show notes and that's it for now.
- 25:48See ya.