Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 91: On France's War on Woke with Cole Stangler
Transcript
- 0:08Listen to the New Paris, I'm your host Levitra muta with less
- 0:14than three months, to the French presidential election. 74 days
- 0:17actually, to the first round, there are a number of worrying
- 0:21discussions taking place online. And in the media that risk
- 0:24distracting from the most pressing issues for French
- 0:27citizens, they've taken up Herbal are time in 2020.
- 0:32That was the controversial idea of East Longmeadow go.
- 0:34She smoked or is Lama leftism since the buzzword in heavy
- 0:38rotation, trotted out by Talking Heads and politicians has become
- 0:42woke ISM. A term that has become
- 0:44completely bastardized and distorted from its original
- 0:47meaning, weaponized and political discourse, and used
- 0:50pejoratively. To condemn, both political
- 0:52correctness and perceived excesses of Social and racial
- 0:56Justice movements all across Europe, the anti woke Brigade.
- 1:00It has been in full force and of course that includes France to
- 1:04talk about this term. How we got here?
- 1:06How it has been weaponized and what it means.
- 1:08Moving forward, particularly as we anticipate election debates,
- 1:12I'm joined by Cole stangler. A French American journalist who
- 1:15regularly covers labor and politics Cole.
- 1:19Thanks for being here. Thanks so much for having me on.
- 1:24You know, you you have done a number of pieces somewhat
- 1:28recently that look Woke and woke yzma and you know a variety of
- 1:33related terms and how their fostering a new kind of cultural
- 1:37world war in France. Can you talk a little bit about
- 1:41the way woke and other buzzwords are playing into this?
- 1:45Yeah, I mean, you know, just just before we were speaking
- 1:48here I was, I was a little bit late because I was curious to
- 1:51look at lift, you got a whole newspaper, which is the sort of
- 1:58mainstream conservative newspaper.
- 2:00And transfer of your listeners. And the calm is that the Fig all
- 2:05have a real. I think obsession with, with the
- 2:09word woke, I went to go check on their website and I guess in the
- 2:14last year so this is over, going back to January 2021, if you go
- 2:21and if you got a little website so not the print paper.
- 2:23But the print, I guess, and the website there have been four
- 2:26hundred and thirty-nine articles that have the world.
- 2:29Whoa. Over 365 days.
- 2:32So if when you're counting I guess the blog, the blog posts
- 2:37stuff that doesn't make it into the print paper were at what
- 2:39iterated like more than once a day.
- 2:41You're on the Figo. You're going to have an article
- 2:44assuming this thing on their website is correct.
- 2:46That's going to mention the word woke so it's become this real?
- 2:53Yeah, sort of obsession for the French right, that is becoming
- 2:59more and more. Mainstream because, you know, if
- 3:02you get 0, which is the example, I just gave is not necessarily,
- 3:05you know, a far-right paper. It's sort of the mainstream
- 3:08conservative newspaper in France, and so, okay, what?
- 3:11Why is there this obsession with, with woky smell, which is,
- 3:16I guess, a rough translation of woke - but even the way that
- 3:20it's used, I guess in the u.s. we wouldn't say woken us,
- 3:23they're sort of talk about whooping friends, there is this,
- 3:25real obsession with woken will keys.
- 3:28So you know, He comes from a variety of factors, I guess I'll
- 3:33just give two explanations one, being the sort of official
- 3:37explanation, why people say they're interested in.
- 3:40And then, and then the second explanation, which I think's are
- 3:43really kind of explains why people are so obsessed with.
- 3:46This is so the official line I guess, when you look at,
- 3:49probably most of these articles in the thing, going other
- 3:52outlets as well across. You know, the French right-wing,
- 3:55press and TV stations, but also in the mainstream media woke
- 3:59refers to this Idea, is similar to the US where you have a bunch
- 4:03of sort of politically correct people in politics and media.
- 4:12And also, you know, with big platforms that are producing
- 4:16culture, whether it's athletes, musicians Etc.
- 4:21You have these people that are really interested in showing how
- 4:27much better they are than everyone else.
- 4:30Else but also precisely by talking about people's different
- 4:36ethnic differences, religious differences, sexual differences
- 4:42and differences in sexual identity and that you know by
- 4:46highlighting these differences you know, these these people
- 4:52think that they're you know, basically better better than
- 4:54everyone else. And so the idea is that you have
- 4:59this breed Of thought that sort of creeping into France.
- 5:02That is really, really obsessed with pointing out people's
- 5:06ethnic religious racial or sexual differences which is anti
- 5:12universalism. And that's the whole protective
- 5:15force is like at all costs. Let's protect.
- 5:18You know, these values of the Republic except that, you know,
- 5:22that's not working either. Yeah.
- 5:24And so sort of the official line and thanks for getting to get to
- 5:28the point Lindsay but I mean the big difference the way that is
- 5:34often talked about is that on the one hand you have this sort
- 5:36of woke way of looking at things right?
- 5:37Where everyone's obsessed with pointing out people's
- 5:39differences and it's often opposed to as you point out the
- 5:42universal French model which does not see ethnic difference
- 5:49at least legally speaking and does not see religious
- 5:54difference at least in theory. And so the idea is you have this
- 5:59sort of In influenced often, anglo-american the word that
- 6:04gets thrown a lot. Also around in France, a lot is
- 6:06Anglo-Saxon framework and looking as well.
- 6:08I don't know why people talk about Anglo-Saxons, I don't know
- 6:11what the tribe of Missouri, like medieval to me but okay, so
- 6:17we'll talk a lot about Anglo-Saxon ways of thought and
- 6:20woke. You know, this sort of woke way
- 6:22of viewing. The world is seen as being this
- 6:24kind of foreign yet an anglo-american way of viewing
- 6:27difference whereas in France, you know.
- 6:29And again this is just a That sort of surface level cliches
- 6:31but in France you know the Republic doesn't see people's
- 6:35difference. It doesn't collect statistics on
- 6:37people's racial or ethnic backgrounds and of course you
- 6:41know the Republic respects this vision of like a seat, a where
- 6:45people's religious people's religious affiliations don't
- 6:49matter. And that's what it is in theory,
- 6:50of course, in practice. It's very different.
- 6:52You know, we could talk about that as well, but that's sort of
- 6:54where you get the official, you know, that's the official Clash
- 6:58according to A lot of the people that throw this word around and
- 7:02say that it's important to defend, you know, Frances
- 7:04Universal model from these people who don't understand
- 7:09really what their public is about.
- 7:10But in my estimation, you know, I think it's a lot more
- 7:14complicated than that and we have, you know, this is part of
- 7:16a political battle that the French right is waging as well.
- 7:20So I mean you brought up a lot of interesting points there.
- 7:23One is also that the there's this idea that it's a u.s.
- 7:26import, right? And that it's also importing
- 7:29theories. He's American theories on race
- 7:32and post colonialism and gender. And they say that poses a risk
- 7:35for sort of national identity. I found it interesting that
- 7:38Rebecca solnit commented somewhat recently that the term
- 7:43has basically been kidnapped by old white conservatives.
- 7:47But as we've seen in France it's not actually just conservatism
- 7:50is primarily from the right but even on had that ago who's
- 7:53currently you know a candidate for president said, you know she
- 7:57respects sort of these The values, but she's not going to
- 8:01be campaigning on them. And I think, probably one of the
- 8:04themes is like, inclusive writing inclusive references for
- 8:09four different people. So, like, what is this, is this
- 8:12a real debate? Like, can everything be called
- 8:14an American Import? Yeah, I know, I think, you know,
- 8:17this is something, you know, as you're alluding to that that's
- 8:20been going on quite a while in France.
- 8:22So, I think that's important to point out as well.
- 8:24You know, if you look at the debate, you know, the woke the
- 8:27debate around the Lord woke. If you watch some of these news
- 8:31channels and thinking of like bfm TV or even more,
- 8:35particularly, you know, the C News Channel, which is sort of
- 8:38the French Fox News bought by transformed by this billionaire
- 8:42of Ensemble. Do hey, you know, if you watch
- 8:44these channels, you can sort of have the impression that, wow,
- 8:47there is this kind of new threat, that that's coming in
- 8:49from, from the United States. But the fact is, you know, this
- 8:54is actually been something that an accusation that's been made
- 8:57quite a lot. In France.
- 9:01And I just interviewed for peace, that that should be
- 9:04coming out soon for for Jack and them as political scientists.
- 9:08I've had leaked my 20 who has a book in French and the English
- 9:13translation is, how did we all, how did we become reactionaries
- 9:16as English translation? She's a political scientist who
- 9:19studies French intellectuals. And in this book, you know, she
- 9:24should have traces. How actually this idea that
- 9:26there's this sort of pernicious dangerous, American influence.
- 9:29That's Undermining, the French way of viewing the world is
- 9:33actually something that, you know, dates back to at least,
- 9:35you know, she's looking at the modern era like at least the
- 9:381980s and 90s, you know, where you start to see this.
- 9:44These sort of accusation being thrown around on a more regular
- 9:46basis. And if you look at, you know,
- 9:48Publications like blue dibba and come on Taff, which was the old
- 9:55the publication of lame-o alone, you know, with authors like I
- 10:00think I'll quote they've been talking about American influence
- 10:03for for a long time and back then you know, the buzzword was
- 10:06political correctness. It was all right.
- 10:09You know all these you know well-to-do liberals that want to
- 10:14police the way we think and there's this classic phrase that
- 10:17kind of gets that you hear a lot which is a fuel then deal.
- 10:22You know, we can't say any God, anything anymore, right?
- 10:24Because the the politically correct police are.
- 10:27Are limiting your ability to express yourself and This came
- 10:30up a lot in France again on the in the 80s and 90s and I'm sort
- 10:33of paraphrasing my 20, the professor.
- 10:36I interviewed it comes up a lot around sort of Campus politics
- 10:41in in French are really interested in and what's
- 10:44happening and, you know, American college campuses about
- 10:49sort of the curriculum that are being proposed and that are
- 10:52being studied in these universities.
- 10:54And then also the fact that an College campuses.
- 11:01The there seemed to be a lot of rules around here.
- 11:05Seems to be backlash around around sexual harassment and who
- 11:09write and basically sexual conduct in general.
- 11:12And so the idea is, you know, this American way of policing.
- 11:19Yes. Induction, you know, if you
- 11:21think'll Kraut way of thinking, you know, this is this is
- 11:24something that's sort of a threat to the French model.
- 11:25And so I say all this just to give some more context because
- 11:28it's, it's a help. A reminder that, you know, this
- 11:31idea that there's this like pernicious American cultural
- 11:34influence, led by liberals, who want to police your lives and
- 11:38undermine the French model is not something that's, you know,
- 11:41it's totally you. This is that's been part of the
- 11:44French, right? For four decades.
- 11:48And, you know, given where we are right now politically in
- 11:50France. It's it's, you know, it's
- 11:52surfacing more and more well, and you bring up something else.
- 11:57That's quite interesting. Even just as recently, As 2020,
- 12:01you know what came before this obsession with woke is emits
- 12:04Aslam ago. She smell.
- 12:06So it almost seems like there's this this ability to just
- 12:09transfer attention to another. Another buzzword, and actually a
- 12:13poll by the express found that only 14% of French people who
- 12:16were asked even had heard of the term broke and then only six
- 12:20percent of those people even knew what it referred to.
- 12:22So I mean do you think this is sort of a smokescreen to draw
- 12:25attention away from? You know, the things that are
- 12:27actually concerning people like The economy, their purchasing
- 12:31power, you know, the Healthcare System, the environment, you
- 12:34know, these are things that I know, even just recently, you
- 12:37you tweeted about, you're tweeting a French piece and
- 12:41explaining that those are sort of, like, the key issues that
- 12:44voters are most concerned about. And yet sort of policing
- 12:47people's way of referring to others and an inclusive writing
- 12:52is probably not even in the top 10.
- 12:55Yeah, I know. Absolutely.
- 12:56I mean, you mentioned Islam, oguchi smell?
- 12:59Which You know, the worth is recalling briefly, you know,
- 13:02this was, you know, it's translates as Islam.
- 13:05Oh, leftism. And this, according to the
- 13:08higher, the minister of higher education who's in charge of the
- 13:10University system in France. This is a supposed threat on
- 13:14academic freedom. The irony being that if you
- 13:17know, she wants to crack down on it.
- 13:19Meaning that I think the government saying they want to
- 13:21control what professors can and can't teach him to be much more
- 13:25of a threat to academic freedom, at least a lot of professors you
- 13:28at that point in any case. So you had this Big talk about
- 13:31Islam. Oh leftism.
- 13:32We were talking about woke ISM. There's also been a lot of talk
- 13:35about cancel culture. And these are, these are these
- 13:38kind of buzz words that get thrown around that occupy a lot
- 13:43of space in the debate and I guess before answering getting
- 13:47to the question of. Why do people care about?
- 13:50I don't think they do care about it that much.
- 13:52But before, you know, going to that point, I think it's I think
- 13:58it's, you know, worth asking why.
- 14:00Why are these Place? Why are these debates occupying
- 14:03so much space? And and for that, you know,
- 14:05there's a lot of things going on.
- 14:07One is the you know, just the fact that you know politically
- 14:12and I think there's some of the left who want to downplay this
- 14:16or out, ready, sometimes even deny it.
- 14:19You know, there is a there is a large share of the French
- 14:22population that, you know, that is pretty that is pretty right
- 14:26wing and more and more, you know?
- 14:30We could disagree with that or be upset by it.
- 14:33But you know, you do have you have a, you know, a small but
- 14:36significant share of the population.
- 14:38That basically, you know, is into these issues about French
- 14:45identity is into protecting French culture.
- 14:50And so these are various debates.
- 14:53You know, are meant Are Meant to satisfy this this part of the
- 14:56electorate. You also have a media landscape
- 15:00That is, that is Shifting as well.
- 15:04You know, I wrote a piece as well about as others have as
- 15:07well about about the, you know, the rise of this network.
- 15:10That's called c-- news in France, which is sort of the,
- 15:14the Fox News equivalent both in terms of the style.
- 15:18And meaning, you know, they'll have these debates that the
- 15:21debate itself is so far to the right.
- 15:23That, you know, even by having the debate, you're making a Sort
- 15:30of political intervention just by having the date in the first
- 15:32place. Sure.
- 15:34And then, you know, and then to the form of it as well where you
- 15:36have, you know, the chi rounds that immediately show up in the
- 15:39bottom of the screen. When someone has said something,
- 15:41you know, provocative and ridiculous, you get that you get
- 15:44the kind right in the bottom. It's very Fox News like and see
- 15:47news has sort of had a lot of success in the last few years.
- 15:51I think one point even last year, I don't know if it's the
- 15:54case, the more recent monthly figures, but for a moment it
- 15:57became the most widely watched news.
- 16:00Is Network, new specific Network.
- 16:05So, you know, c-- news and other and other media Outlets that,
- 16:10you know, like to both push things to the right.
- 16:14And also just incentive, I, you know, and also just have debates
- 16:18for the sake of having a base because they get clicks, they
- 16:20get eyeballs on the page and viewers.
- 16:23You know, I think, I think that has played a role as well, you
- 16:28know? And I think finally, Lee, you
- 16:30know, the government, the, the microns party, you know?
- 16:35Well, obviously there's, there's, there's meaningful
- 16:37differences between someone like my: le pendens and more, you
- 16:41know, the government has decided it's in their immediate
- 16:44political interest to play up these sort of culture War issues
- 16:48and to drive the political discourse to the right, because
- 16:51because it not only is divides. The left.
- 16:57As you were talking about the left, You know, how to respond.
- 17:02You have people like I need that go.
- 17:03Who, you know who say? Yes.
- 17:06I'm against, you know, I have I'm Against Racism, obviously,
- 17:12but I also don't think we should go too far when we're talking
- 17:14about about people's ethnic religious differences, right?
- 17:21Other people in left disagree. So it divides the left and it's
- 17:23also showing, you know, it's meant as a signal this
- 17:26government strategy to show to the right wing.
- 17:30Electorate in France that micro Lino takes their concerns
- 17:34seriously. Because you know, he sees the
- 17:39political discourse being being driven to the right and wants to
- 17:41make sure that you know he has a, you know, that he's seen as
- 17:45legitimate in the eyes of a lot of these voters.
- 17:47I think for all those reasons, the media, the government
- 17:49short-term political interest, in the fact that, you know,
- 17:52there is a significant base for the sort of politics.
- 17:54I think all that explains why, you know, we've seen these sort
- 17:59of You know, hot-button culture or issued the loved by the
- 18:05right, you know, play such a dominant role in our in the
- 18:08French political discourse. But did you also write recently?
- 18:12I think it was for the nation where you were trying to you.
- 18:15You're sort of talking about Mac home's, current, I guess current
- 18:21status, you know, who is he playing to wear?
- 18:23What are his leanings? And I think you argued that, you
- 18:26know, macklowe has always had more of an authority.
- 18:30Therrien streak than his supporters have cared to admit.
- 18:33So, you know, do you think they are also, I mean, do you think
- 18:37this is just pure politicking and you know, it's a, it's a
- 18:41strategy or do you think there's some real ideological Foundation
- 18:47to this backlash and and like, what are the risks of this
- 18:50moving forward? Because whether it's him and his
- 18:52party who continue on in leading the country in the next election
- 18:57which is, you know, around the corner.
- 19:00We're at someone on the, on the left or the far, right?
- 19:02I mean, it just feels like this is going to continue in some
- 19:05form to be an issue. But like how dangerous is this?
- 19:10Yeah, you know, it's always an interesting question to think,
- 19:14you know what our politicians really thinking are they just
- 19:18doing things because they think it's in their political
- 19:20interests. Do they?
- 19:21You know, do they really believe it?
- 19:22And I guess you can't. You can ever really answer,
- 19:24answer that question. But yeah, if you look, I mean,
- 19:29if you just Judge, you know my Crohn's, you know, microns
- 19:32actions. You know, there is this sort of
- 19:35authoritarian leaning Edge again, I want to be careful.
- 19:39You know, it's not the same. I don't think he's as
- 19:42fundamental of a threat to democracy as someone like
- 19:45someone like the movies, but he didn't have this sort of
- 19:48authoritarian vent, which you can see, in a few different
- 19:50ways. So, you know, passing laws
- 19:52trying to get through laws by executive order in order to
- 19:56bypass sort of messy parliamentary debate.
- 19:59We saw that with the Reforms, that beginning of his
- 20:01presidency, we saw the attempt from the government to do the,
- 20:05the security law, which included.
- 20:11For a time before it was struck down by the French
- 20:13constitutional Court. Included a measure that would
- 20:15have effectively criminalized, the filming of police officers
- 20:19if the person filming them wanted to quote harm harm them.
- 20:24So this was something that microns government, you know,
- 20:27wanted to wanted to get across including a bunch of other
- 20:30measures to sort of beef up police surveillance, you know?
- 20:37So we saw also government has been was criticized for this.
- 20:42A lot. The law around, which ultimately
- 20:45was renamed to the law. I think reinforcing Republican
- 20:49principles originally called the sensor disc law, really going
- 20:52after going after the threat of radical Islam, A lot of critics
- 21:02and people concerned about civil liberties thought that if the
- 21:04law was too broad you know the government outlawed, the biggest
- 21:08Association in France fighting islamophobia, the collective
- 21:12against islamophobia. I'm so I think if you look at
- 21:15all these measures you can say. Yeah you know there is this sort
- 21:17of yeah this sort of authoritarian Edge to to to my
- 21:22call, you know. So I'm not sure if it's a really
- 21:28satisfying answer to And I mean, we're gonna mean you're right?
- 21:31We can't. And, you know, it could be a bit
- 21:35of both. I mean obviously you know,
- 21:36ideologically he would have trouble defending all of this if
- 21:39he didn't somehow, you know, believe it.
- 21:43But I guess the bigger question is, you know, you take this term
- 21:46that has been so distorted and weaponized.
- 21:49How, how could this continue to affect education?
- 21:53You know, bronchial who's the who's the minister of Education?
- 21:58Who is just Lately, you know, who takes a hard line stance on
- 22:03on what he sees, as you know, anything to Progressive, how
- 22:08might this affect you know, individuals who are you know,
- 22:13like the feminist organizations who believe that there's an
- 22:16importance in inclusive language and you know everything becomes
- 22:20then. You know as a source of being
- 22:24able to say we can't say or do anything anymore and yet
- 22:28ultimately what they want to do is control what can be said and
- 22:31done because you know if they are going to impact what kinds
- 22:34of academic research can be pursued that is in effect, you
- 22:39know stopping on some Liberties right there.
- 22:41Hmm. Yeah I mean you know I should
- 22:43have mentioned at the very beginning you were talking about
- 22:46malankov the education Minister and it's pretty unbelievable if
- 22:50you think about the the Aang but earlier this month so the same
- 22:55time as you know he's having to announce you know new
- 23:01restrictions and changing the the different rules for the
- 23:04education system in France for schools with the with the
- 23:07Omicron wave and covid. The same time as he's doing
- 23:11this. Not only was I guess there is a
- 23:13scandal that the broken France about he was I guess he was in
- 23:16Ibiza in Spain and England, but I think what I was going to say
- 23:20was this month, he was Was also excuse me, in January.
- 23:23He he was also, he was also speaking at a conference that
- 23:31was, that was sort of dubbed, the, the antiguo conference at
- 23:35the sorbonne where he brought together researchers to talk
- 23:38about, you know, basically, you know, problems and their view in
- 23:44the social sciences. I think the official name was
- 23:46the conference against over deconstruction, I think was
- 23:50something like that, improve the Name of it, something having to
- 23:53do with deconstruction. So you have these experts
- 23:55talking about that. Any case, I think it's pretty
- 23:57unbelievable that were in the middle of this Health crisis and
- 24:01yet the education minister is choosing to devote.
- 24:04His time to speak at conferences at the, at the sorbonne about
- 24:09what deconstruction and the problems in the social sciences
- 24:12that it poses. So yeah, I think, you know, he's
- 24:14a real, you know, Blanca ideologically is really
- 24:18committed to This sort of anti woke offencive to be clear.
- 24:28All so this is not just happening in France.
- 24:30The same thing is happening in Britain.
- 24:33There are other countries that have, you know, even if they're
- 24:35not using that term, that's effectively what they're going
- 24:38after. You know, the sort of ultra
- 24:39Progressive ideology which may or may not be ultra Progressive.
- 24:44But, you know, just the way that the way that it's viewed and and
- 24:47so, but the way that it plays out in France, I think is very
- 24:50particular and I'm so glad you mentioned Shouldn't sort of this
- 24:52long history of, you know, rising up against anything
- 24:58that's considered, you know, almost like a nun American style
- 25:05form of identity politics. Yeah, I mean, and to just to
- 25:09yeah, it's I guess to talk more about the parallels, you know,
- 25:12the the, you know, somebody like belong.
- 25:16Kevin. It's sort of ironic.
- 25:17I I wrote a piece about this as well, but you know, we hear so
- 25:20much about this supposed, you know, Americanization of the
- 25:24left in France where they're what they're there in theory
- 25:26importing. All these ideas from the US, the
- 25:28obsession with the race. The I had this sort of identity
- 25:31politics, you know, multiculturalism which again
- 25:35according to these people is against the French model of And
- 25:38viewing ethnic and religious difference.
- 25:40It gets talked a lot about on the left but I think you know
- 25:42the the French Ray is becoming you know, a quote-unquote
- 25:47Americanized and you know and it's only as well but don't have
- 25:49is a great example of that. You know, if you look at Blancas
- 25:55and for that matter as well, the higher education minister video
- 25:58talking about, you know the threats posed to the the French
- 26:01system by these, you know dangerous.
- 26:06Basically dangerous ways to teach students.
- 26:09You know it looks a lot again. It's different.
- 26:11I know it's different but it looks a lot like what we're
- 26:13seeing in the US with this backlash from Republicans
- 26:16against, you know, CRT against critical race theory.
- 26:19Yes. And that you know this desire
- 26:22among a lot of people on the right to to basically police
- 26:25what teachers can can teach in which they can't teach.
- 26:29I think that's, you know, seems pretty American to me, you know,
- 26:32as well. And there's a lot of
- 26:34fascination. You know with with you know, the
- 26:40Trump Administration there was there was a lot, you know, among
- 26:43you know people like Zim will and people in his and his inner
- 26:46circle and they you know, there's there's a certain form
- 26:50of politics. I think you know in the u.s.
- 26:53that interest a lot of people a lot of people in the French,
- 26:57right? Well, you're absolutely right
- 27:00and the piece that you're talking about, you don't need to
- 27:02be modest about, it was an excellent op-ed in the New York
- 27:05Times, which I will link to in the show notes because that's,
- 27:08you know, one of the one of the moments where I was like, yes, I
- 27:12wish I was reading and I was like, yes, this is exactly how
- 27:16to analyze what's going on here because I too don't always
- 27:19believe that we can say that this is, you know, like the like
- 27:22the anti-racist movement is necessarily an extension and
- 27:27only an extension of black lives matter.
- 27:29So there are moments where I'm like, you know, not everything
- 27:32can be compared to the US, but there are certain moments where
- 27:35it can and and I wanted to end just with one one point you
- 27:38were, I believe this was earlier in the month or maybe it was the
- 27:41end of December. You were on a show on a I guess
- 27:45was like a Roundtable show talking about the Insurrection
- 27:47at the Capitol and that was in France.
- 27:51So I'm presumably people want to know whether that sort of
- 27:54nationalistic uprising. Is an inevitability in France.
- 28:00Do you think something like? I mean, if we're talking about
- 28:02parallels, like, are we at the same risk?
- 28:05This is the country that that did have a revolution like is
- 28:09that in our in our future, do you think?
- 28:12Yeah, I mean, I it's so it's I mean it's interesting question,
- 28:16it's hard to it's difficult to compare but yeah, I know it's
- 28:20interesting to compare as well. I mean I think you know you do
- 28:24have this this far, right. That's increasingly Powerful in
- 28:28France, if you look just at the polls for the presidential race,
- 28:31which is coming up in April right now, you have two
- 28:33candidates in the far, right? Le pendens immobile that both
- 28:36are like, 30 percent combined. I think something like that
- 28:39maybe more than 30 percent combined, which would have been
- 28:41unheard of, you know, even even in 2017, you know, Le Pen at
- 28:48this point in the campaign, you know, was not at 30%.
- 28:52So you have the far right? I having a big chunk of the of
- 28:56the electorate, You know, I think the the and we have
- 29:00obviously we're talking about right now and sometimes, you
- 29:04know, it's even hard to follow because they're all these
- 29:06different sort of buzzwords that kind of coalesce into this
- 29:10giant, you know, just like mess of of, you know, words that
- 29:15that's sort of hard to make sense of or its Islamic ushi
- 29:17somewhat cancel culture woke -. But, you know, I guess I hope to
- 29:21some set. You know, this would be helpful
- 29:22to your listeners in some sense because this is what a lot of
- 29:25The French Press can look like But anyway so you have this big
- 29:29ol, you have this far right? Electorate that's pretty
- 29:31significant you have this discourse in the media that
- 29:36that's that's occupying. A lot of space, these gripes
- 29:39about what's happening in French culture.
- 29:41All that is alarming. I think one of the big
- 29:44differences with with the u.s. is just has to do with the
- 29:47political system. You know, the fact that you have
- 29:50this you know to round grounds for determining the president,
- 29:55it's hard to imagine. Situation in which and maybe,
- 29:59you know what? We can go back and play this
- 30:02podcast when I when I turned out to be horribly wrong, but it's
- 30:04hard to imagine a scenario still in which he'd have, you know,
- 30:08Zamora or Le Pen winning the presidential election in April.
- 30:12Just because you have these two rounds where even if one of them
- 30:14were to get into the second round.
- 30:17You know, the consensus and polls also show at the consensus
- 30:21is that, you know, they would lose in the second round against
- 30:25against their opponent. Trump, you know, became
- 30:28president essentially because you won the Republican Party.
- 30:31Primary, you don't quite have this.
- 30:33This you don't have this by pardons partisan system in
- 30:36France, you do have this, you know, there's two rounds system,
- 30:39which makes it very difficult to imagine the far-right winning
- 30:42power, you know, certainly, you don't have the same
- 30:45gerrymandering issues and all of the other, you know, attempts at
- 30:48voter suppression that, you know, I think complicate the
- 30:52issue in the u.s., in a huge way.
- 30:57Yeah, yeah I think. Yeah, absolutely.
- 30:59And I think, I think also the, I mean what's interesting in
- 31:02France, you know, the, the danger I suppose would be, you
- 31:08know, not only to some degree having another, you know, having
- 31:12another five-year term for from Mike.
- 31:15Holland goes to goes until 2027 which over the course of those
- 31:18five years you can imagine my concert of giving little crumbs
- 31:24to the right-wing culture Warrior as well.
- 31:26Also. You know, pursuing a, you know,
- 31:31a policy agenda that involves some sort of cracking down on
- 31:38civil liberties, to some extent and sort of aggressive, economic
- 31:42reforms. We could imagine that and that
- 31:44would be, you know, not not so positive for a lot of us.
- 31:48But we could also, you know, I think imagine the more dangerous
- 31:50scenario is in which the far-right could really have more
- 31:54of a say, in governing Frances. Is something in which you know,
- 32:00would be having the right Wing's, different, the right
- 32:02wing parties, unite in France, and forming, you know, one, you
- 32:06know, you know, one one campaign it's something that is a more
- 32:10supporters have talked a lot about.
- 32:11It doesn't look like it's going to happen this time.
- 32:13But you know what happens when I don't know the, you know, Zim
- 32:18War Camp. The Le Pen camp and the right
- 32:20wing that would be can't Camp decide to join forces.
- 32:24And then you have, you know, more robust.
- 32:27Right-wing political force. We're really far away from that,
- 32:29but I think that's the more for thinking of like you know,
- 32:33immediate scenarios in which the quote-unquote far I could arrive
- 32:36in power in France. That would be, it would be by
- 32:38joining together and making alliances.
- 32:41We're not there yet. But, you know, we're sort of
- 32:43trucking long in this kind of dreary climate for the next few
- 32:50months and, you know, I guess we'll see what happened.
- 32:51Then we'll see. And until then we will still
- 32:53continue talking about Wilkie smart and now I'm going to pay
- 32:56extra Attention to how many times it's used in reference in
- 33:00in various Publications. I'm sure it's not just the few
- 33:02yellow Cole. Thank you so much for joining to
- 33:04talk about this. I am sure people have more
- 33:07questions and and if they do you know they can reach out to you.
- 33:11I'm sure on Twitter where you you share your work and I look
- 33:13forward to reading your next story.
- 33:15Great. Yeah.
- 33:15Thanks so much for having me. Lindsay that's the show for
- 33:18today. As always.
- 33:20Thank you for listening subscribing and sharing with
- 33:23Friends you can find all previous episodes of The New
- 33:26Parish. Cast wherever you stream your
- 33:28podcasts and on world radio Paris.
- 33:30If you're enjoying these conversations, please consider
- 33:32picking up a copy of the New Paris book for my recent release
- 33:36their new Keynesian from your local book sellers.
- 33:39Until next time, identical,