Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Mini: Rich people and their sandy em-oceans
Transcript
- 0:00Chelsea, this article that I am going to read is kind of a continuation of our subcategory of rich people dealing with the impending loss of their oceanfront property.
- 0:11Okay.
- 0:12Which apparently there is a vast degree of directions you can go with your emotions when you're a rich person losing your...
- 0:18Gonna say is there a category or have we just been following up on the same people?
- 0:24You would think.
- 0:25Is it why this is broad enough?
- 0:27This is different people.
- 0:28And they are facing this issue and dealing with their emotions in a different way than our Bostonian friends or Massachusetts friends.
- 0:38Can we just establish what the category is called?
- 0:42I think...
- 0:43Emotional React.
- 0:44I...
- 0:45Rich people getting a little too beachfront?
- 0:48Hmm...
- 0:50Maybe something along the lines of rich people and their emotions.
- 0:54I think that's just the category.
- 0:56And the ocean.
- 0:57They're sandy emotions.
- 0:59They're sandy emotions.
- 1:00Rich people and their emotions and the ocean.
- 1:04So, Chelsea, this article comes from grist.org, written on June 4th, 2024 by Jake Bittle.
- 1:14Article title, The Homeowner Mutiny Leaving Florida City's Defenseless Against Hurricanes.
- 1:18The government is refusing to restore eroded beaches in coastal Florida counties unless homeowners agree to one condition, public access.
- 1:26Lisa Hendrickson is almost out of sand.
- 1:29Hendrickson is the mayor of Reddington Shores, Florida, a well-heeled beach town in Pinellas County.
- 1:34Her town occupies a small section of Razor Thin Barrier Island that stretches down the west side of the sprawling Tampa Bay metro area,
- 1:41dividing cities like Tampa and St. Petersburg from the Gulf of Mexico.
- 1:44Many of her constituents have an uninterrupted view of the ocean.
- 1:48The town's only protection from the Gulf of Mexico's increasingly erratic storms is a pristine beach that draws millions of tourists every year.
- 1:55But that beach is disappearing fast.
- 1:57A series of storms culminating in last fall's Hurricane Idalia have eroded most of the sand that protects Reddington Shores and the town around it,
- 2:05leaving residents just one big wave away from water overtaking their homes.
- 2:09This perilous situation is the result of a standoff between local residents and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers,
- 2:15the federal agency that handles flood prevention and protects many of the nation's beaches.
- 2:20The corp often rebuilds eroded beaches by hauling in thousands of tons of sand,
- 2:25but the agency is refusing to deliver $42 million worth of new sand to Pinellas County,
- 2:31unless the area's coastal property owners grant public access to the slivers of beach behind their homes.
- 2:38Hundreds of property owners, however, are in turn refusing to sign documents that grant these points of access, which are known as easements.
- 2:45The face-off has brought the area's storm recovery to a near-standstill.
- 2:49Is that not blackmail?
- 2:51Well, what do you mean by blackmail?
- 2:52Well, like, maybe blackmail's not the word I'm looking for, but they're not...
- 2:57Yeah, strong-arming.
- 2:58I'm into making a decision of something because, I mean, they bought the property, like, thinking they had private beach, right?
- 3:05I mean, technically, but let's... Is that the part you're hung up on?
- 3:09No, I'm not hung up on the golf.
- 3:11Okay.
- 3:12Just making observations.
- 3:13Well, we'll talk about it at the end.
- 3:15The standoff highlights growing tensions between the federal government and homeowners in coastal areas that are threatened by climate change.
- 3:21As sea levels have risen and strong storms have caused greater damage than ever before,
- 3:26the costs of protecting and ensuring beach fronts in Florida and other states have increased rapidly.
- 3:31Agencies like the Corp have had to weigh these costs against the interests of property owners in places like the Tampa Bay region.
- 3:37When those interests come into conflict, populated coastal areas can be left exposed or uninsured,
- 3:42making them sitting ducks for the next climate-fueled storms.
- 3:44Quote, our coastlines are the first line of defense against storms, and our golf beaches are just eroding away. I don't know where we go with it now,
- 3:52or how we come together to work through it.
- 3:55Hendrickson told Grist.
- 3:56The Corp's put the easement policy in place decades ago to ensure that it didn't spend public money to restore private beaches,
- 4:03but the agency didn't begin enforcing the rule in earnest until Superstorm Sandy in 2012,
- 4:08when the Corp tried to replace disintegrated beaches in New Jersey.
- 4:11It discovered that it didn't have all the easements that needed.
- 4:14Local government spent years trying to obtain them, and the state government had to use eminent domain to seize the portions of the beach in order to satisfy the agency.
- 4:23In the years since, the agency has warned Pinellas County and other local governments that they won't get any more sand,
- 4:29unless they get easements from all the property owners on their beaches.
- 4:32The Corp say it first raised the issue with Pinellas back in 2017,
- 4:36but tensions started rising last year after Adalia eroded the area's beaches to a dangerous degree,
- 4:42creating a desperate need for new protective sand.
- 4:45The Corp requires that easement be perpetual, which means that the public will always be able to access the beach area behind an owner's property.
- 4:52The agency says this is only so that it has the ability to help out after future storms.
- 4:57When a hurricane wipes out a beach, the Corp's often swoops in to pay for an emergency beach,
- 5:02replenishment just weeks later, ensuring homes don't wash away.
- 5:05The agency says that it can't commit to doing this emergency work unless it can be sure that the beach access will remain public for good.
- 5:11It also says that it needs easements from all property owners in a given area,
- 5:15because nourishment projects don't work unless they're continuous along an entire stretch of sand.
- 5:21Pinellas County officials tried their best to obtain these easements,
- 5:24even going from door to door and pleading with residents to sign for sand.
- 5:27Nevertheless, around half of the 461 property owners along the barrier islands has refused to grant this.
- 5:35County officials are still urging residents to submit, but they have obtained few new easements since last year.
- 5:40The strange thing about the easement controversy is that these waterfront residents don't fully own the beaches behind their houses anyways.
- 5:47In fact, most of the county's beaches are already public.
- 5:50State law provides that all Florida beaches with artificial sand are public to the erosion control line,
- 5:55which is about the same as that which marks the high tide.
- 5:58In other words, everything from the water to the high tide line is open for anyone to walk, tan, or spread a blanket.
- 6:04The land in dispute between the corpse and the owner is only the section of sand between the backside of a beach house and the high tide line,
- 6:12which in many cases is just about a few dozen feet.
- 6:15Quote, for most of the project, the beach is wide open to the public.
- 6:18A lot of the easement areas aren't even on the beach. They're in the dune behind the beach,
- 6:23said John Bishop Pinellas County's coastal management coordinator.
- 6:27End quote.
- 6:28Owners' reasons for refusing easements are numerous, but most cite fear that granting public access to the sand behind their property
- 6:35will encourage tourists to venture up on their dunes or sit on the seawalls behind their homes.
- 6:40Sure, they can't stop tourists and beachgoers from using the beach that sits between the erosion line and the water,
- 6:45but they don't want them coming any closer.
- 6:47I think that's far enough for us to kind of have an idea of what's going on in this story.
- 6:52Chelsea, do you want to give any opinions on this?
- 6:56You plan to opine?
- 6:57I don't... I don't... I just go. I don't plan. I just talk.
- 7:01I'm just trying to picture how this would be, so their house is in the middle of the beach?
- 7:06Well, it's on beach. It's just like...
- 7:09It is on beach. That doesn't sound smart in the first place.
- 7:12No, it sounds awful. And in fact, let's look at a picture of Pinellas County.
- 7:15Yeah, can we?
- 7:16So, I mean, eventually, if they wait long enough, the whole front of their house is going to be public beach anyway.
- 7:22Yeah, pretty much.
- 7:23And if they're lucky, to the back of their house as well.
- 7:26And yeah, that's... I find it hilarious that they would rather their houses be swept away by the ocean
- 7:34than have common folk come nearer their property.
- 7:37Probably just a sunbathe and not bother anybody.
- 7:40Yeah, because let's face it, if they were going to do anything anyways,
- 7:43they're probably going to do it and it would be illegal either way.
- 7:46True.
- 7:47But I find that hilarious.
- 7:48They only got half of the people to sign off on saving their property.
- 7:52The government putting $47 million towards saving your property.
- 7:56I don't think it's unreasonable to say if we're going to put public money into it,
- 8:01the public needs to be able to access it.
- 8:03Well, the reasoning was there. I will say that much.
- 8:06And more probably.
- 8:07Waiting for this picture, though. I'm trying to picture it.
- 8:09And I don't know if this is what the place we're talking about, Chelsea,
- 8:14but I'll share my screen here really quick.
- 8:16Yeah, please. I need to know what we're dealing with.
- 8:18So, we're talking about where the people are in that photo would be the public beach already.
- 8:23You would just be talking about those sand dunes behind them.
- 8:26Behind the public beach?
- 8:29Yes.
- 8:30Okay.
- 8:32I think, of course, this might not be where they're talking about it.
- 8:35They could be in different locations.
- 8:36I thought we were talking about there's beach, then house, then sand dunes.
- 8:42The way it was said.
- 8:43Oh, okay.
- 8:44Okay, I mean...
- 8:46But, yeah.
- 8:48I don't see the problem, to be honest.
- 8:50It's overreach, apparently, to save your fucking house.
- 8:55I mean...
- 8:56Who dare they?
- 8:57I mean, to each their own...
- 8:59Let's keep that private.
- 9:02I really think this is going to be an ongoing...
- 9:07Yeah, it's going to be one of these ongoing follow-ups that we're going to see,
- 9:10with different rich people reacting in different ways across the coasts of the world,
- 9:15with their lost property.
- 9:17Because for some reason, rich people really like building in the shit...
- 9:20Nice looking, but shittiest areas to actually build.
- 9:23Well, yeah.
- 9:24I mean, they got the money.
- 9:26Well, they don't always have the money.
- 9:29They don't want to spend the money, though.
- 9:32No, they don't.
- 9:33Because that's not how they got rich.
- 9:35They got rich by bleeding the rest of us dry.
- 9:37Okay, the category will be...
- 9:40I don't know.
- 9:41We need more time.
- 9:42Rich people's emotions about the ocean.
- 9:46I still feel like rich people's sandy emotions is good.
- 9:49We got some good contenders, but I feel like it doesn't do it enough.
- 9:53There's something that's good out there.
- 9:56But I'm quite enjoying whatever this category is.
- 10:00Oh, yeah.
- 10:00This is like watching Real Housewives.
- 10:03This feels like Real Housewives, and I'm sure that we'll actually cover them at some point,
- 10:07because I guarantee you some of them won't be from properties.
- 10:10Anyhow, people look into that, see if that's something we should be covering.
- 10:13You've got 48 hours to get back to us.
- 10:15Yeah, do it.
- 10:16Okay, bye.
- 10:17Bye.