Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Premises-Liability Cases Involving Third-Party Criminal Conduct with Robert Glassman & Nadine Khedry
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to Premises, Liability Cases Involving
- 0:09Third Party Criminal Conduct. I'm Philip Vonder
- 0:12and I'm delighted to introduce today's speakers,
- 0:14Robert Glassman and Nadine Kadri. Robert Glassman
- 0:17is a partner at Panache Raviputi, where he represents
- 0:22plaintiffs in large and complex personal injury
- 0:25cases and is a recognized leader in the Los Angeles
- 0:29legal community. Recognized by the Daily Journal
- 0:32as among the 2023 top 40 lawyers under 40 in
- 0:37California. Mr. Glassman has also been named
- 0:40a rising star in personal injury litigation by
- 0:44law 360 and recognized as a rising star by the
- 0:48Super Lawyers publication since 2013, where he
- 0:51has been consistently selected as one of the
- 0:54up and coming 100 Southern California rising
- 0:57stars. The list of lawyers who rank at the top
- 1:01of Super Lawyer Rising Stars list. Nadine Kadri
- 1:06is an attorney with Panache Revaputi and focuses
- 1:10her practice on catastrophic personal injury,
- 1:13sexual abuse, wrongful death, dangerous condition,
- 1:16and product liability cases throughout California
- 1:19and Nevada. Since joining the firm, Ms. Kadri
- 1:22has worked on a variety of personal injury cases.
- 1:26Ms. Kadri is a member of the State Bar of California
- 1:29and Nevada. and an active member of Consumer
- 1:32Attorneys Association of Los Angeles, CALA. She
- 1:35also sits on the Consumer Attorneys of California's
- 1:38new law division board and is a member of the
- 1:41Los Angeles chapter of the Assyrian Aid Society,
- 1:45which helps Assyrians in need and focuses on
- 1:48humanitarian concerns on the Assyrian people.
- 1:52And now let's get started. Thank you so much,
- 1:57Philip. Thank you so much, Phillip. Thank you
- 1:59for the kind introduction. Welcome, everyone,
- 2:03to today's session. We're excited to be here.
- 2:07So we're here to talk to you about premises liability
- 2:11cases and third party criminal conduct that causes
- 2:16damages to people on the third party premises.
- 2:22premise and a third party comes, commits a crime.
- 2:25In our case, you know, it's focused against the
- 2:28property owner, but the property owner is going
- 2:31to obviously deflect and blame everything on
- 2:33the third party assailant. We're going to highlight
- 2:37one case that Nadine and I handled recently that
- 2:41illustrates a lot of these principles really
- 2:43well. And the case for purposes of today, we're
- 2:50going to call it Jamie Smith Sarah Alexander
- 2:53versus Bullseye Corporation. So about a couple
- 2:57of years ago, two families called our office
- 3:00and told us about a horrible set of circumstances
- 3:04that happened on the evening of November 15th,
- 3:082022 in downtown Los Angeles at a big department
- 3:11store. One family unfortunately had their son,
- 3:17whose name is Jamie Smith, We can go to the next
- 3:20slide, Nadine. Jamie was this cute little boy
- 3:23who was born and raised in Los Angeles, lived
- 3:27with his family here, was in the sixth grade,
- 3:30happy and healthy little boy, loved sports, loved
- 3:33playing with his friends. And unfortunately,
- 3:38he was in a department store in LA on that evening
- 3:43with his mom and all of a sudden was brutally
- 3:47attacked. by someone who had taken a knife from
- 3:52the shelf in the store and stabbed him multiple
- 3:56times up and down his body. Miraculously, he
- 4:00survived the attack, but he suffered tremendous
- 4:05injuries and will unfortunately have to live
- 4:10with those injuries for the rest of his life.
- 4:12He does have a form of paralysis now and When
- 4:17you look at what happened to him you just have
- 4:19to Be thankful that he survived it because it
- 4:22was it was a pretty bad attack unfortunately
- 4:27Jamie wasn't the only victim of this attack on
- 4:31that evening. There was another Young woman named
- 4:35Sarah Alexander who was in a different part of
- 4:40the department store after Jamie was attacked
- 4:43and she was also brutally stabbed by the same
- 4:48guy who took the knife from the shelf in the
- 4:52store. And she too survived somehow. It's a miracle
- 4:57that she did. But stabbed multiple times in her
- 5:01back and through her hand. Also has former paralysis
- 5:05now. She was an amazing young woman. Was in LA
- 5:11just because of work really. She was a flight
- 5:14attendant for Korean Air. She was visiting this
- 5:19department store to get something to eat for
- 5:23the night because she was in a nearby hotel put
- 5:26up by the airline that she was working for. And
- 5:29it was just wrong place at the wrong time. She
- 5:33was the second victim to be attacked that evening,
- 5:37was rushed to USC hospital, was there for about
- 5:41a month. had multiple surgeries, somehow survived.
- 5:46And her life is going to be forever changed as
- 5:48well. So we heard these stories from both of
- 5:53these families. And we, of course, did some investigation
- 5:59into the case. And the case was also on the news.
- 6:04So we learned some information about the case
- 6:06from various news stories. But, you know, we
- 6:10started focusing on the department store itself.
- 6:15So it was a large department store in downtown
- 6:20LA. There's an aerial view of it right there.
- 6:25Obviously, it's a heavily trafficked area. A
- 6:29lot of people go. It's probably a place that
- 6:32people on this Zoom have been to before too.
- 6:39We knew basic facts. I mean, we knew these two
- 6:43people were in the store. They were customers
- 6:45in the store. And they were both attacked by
- 6:49the same man using a knife that he got from the
- 6:53store. So that was really it as far as what we
- 7:00knew before kind of filing the case. Nadine,
- 7:06if you want to go down and just show. Just a
- 7:09couple more images of the store. I mean, you
- 7:12know Yeah, so we so that that's really it we
- 7:16knew customers in a store stabbed by a guy who
- 7:20took a knife from the store Whatever else we
- 7:23got we got from the news You know our clients
- 7:26weren't the best historians at that time just
- 7:29because they were still very traumatized about
- 7:32what happened and You know, you're dealing with
- 7:35a little kid on one hand and a young woman who
- 7:39couldn't speak English that well on the other
- 7:41hand. So we had to rely a lot on what we could
- 7:45gather from the news. So we were able to file
- 7:50the complaint a few months after the incident
- 7:53with the limited information that we did have
- 7:55in hopes that we would find a better theory of
- 7:59liability throughout the course of discovery.
- 8:01All we knew at the time of filing was really
- 8:03that a knife was taken off the shelf. and used
- 8:07by a homeless man in the store to stab these
- 8:10two individuals. So the claims that we ultimately
- 8:14ended up alleging were a negligence claim that
- 8:17the store failed to properly secure the knives,
- 8:21store properly failed to have proper security,
- 8:25and then we alleged a premises liability claim.
- 8:29But it was a dangerous condition allowing the
- 8:32knives to be accessible to the public in the
- 8:35store. And then lastly, we had a negligent infliction
- 8:38of emotional distress claim for the mother who
- 8:41had witnessed her son be stabbed in the storm.
- 8:45And I think it's just important to note that
- 8:48sometimes you are in those situations where you
- 8:50file a complaint with limited information in
- 8:53hopes that you'll fine tune your theory of liability
- 8:56throughout the course of discovery. Sometimes
- 8:58it just pans out that way where you're limited
- 9:00in the information that you can obtain without
- 9:02a subpoena. As Rob said, we were able to get
- 9:04some information from the news, but we still
- 9:07didn't have the final police report. We didn't
- 9:09have final police investigation, the photographs
- 9:11that were taken, the video from the inside of
- 9:14the store. We didn't have any of that. And so,
- 9:19you know, upon filing the complaint, we went
- 9:21through and compiled what our discovery strategy
- 9:24was going to be. We had a few different angles
- 9:27that we thought would be viable avenues of liability,
- 9:31one being that the store didn't lock up the knives.
- 9:34Two being that the store failed to have proper
- 9:37security for being in downtown Los Angeles. That's
- 9:41a high crime area and an area that had a number
- 9:44of previous incidents inside that shopping center
- 9:47in particular. And so the main two things that
- 9:50we were focused on in discovery were prior knife
- 9:54instances that had happened at that store and
- 9:57or nationwide stores of that department store.
- 10:02and two prior security instances that had happened
- 10:06in the store, that specific store or the shopping
- 10:09area. Those are the main two things that we were
- 10:12looking for throughout the course of discovery.
- 10:15And in gathering more information, we added additional
- 10:19theories of liability, but at the time that was
- 10:21the focus. And one thing that became evident
- 10:25to us early on in the litigation is that the
- 10:28store was trying to frame the case in a very
- 10:38limited way. They took a very narrow approach
- 10:42to what the case was about, which was this exact
- 10:47type of attack has never happened before at this
- 10:51particular location. Remember, we're dealing
- 10:55with a nationwide change. So they were saying
- 10:58this attack that happened on November 15 2022
- 11:03never happened here. And so it wasn't foreseeable
- 11:08that it was going to happen on this evening.
- 11:11And our job was to kind of expand the scope of
- 11:15the relevant, you know, kind of kind of facts
- 11:23of, well, it's not it's not necessarily about
- 11:28whether this exact type of attack happened at
- 11:32this exact store, it's about whether people in
- 11:37general were able to also obtain danger, knives
- 11:44or other weapons from the shelves at any of the
- 11:47stores across the country and use them in some
- 11:50kind of dangerous way in the store on either
- 11:54themselves or others. And the defendant really
- 11:57took the position that that wasn't relevant.
- 11:59What was relevant is what happened at this place
- 12:02only. And so that was a big early on that that
- 12:07was going to be a big fight. They were saying,
- 12:09let's limit it to this store only and what happened
- 12:13exactly. And we just kept pushing back and saying,
- 12:17no, no, no. This is about where other people,
- 12:21you know, at your company, whether it was in
- 12:24Los Angeles or San Francisco or Oakland, where
- 12:27other people able to walk into one of your stores,
- 12:31take a knife from the shelf, and use it in some
- 12:33kind of dangerous way. It doesn't need to be
- 12:35precisely the manner in which it occurred here,
- 12:39but just that kind of broader definition. Take
- 12:42a knife from the shelf, using it in some kind
- 12:44of dangerous way. So we did our initial request
- 12:48for production, which is the standard reports,
- 12:51videos, surveillance of the incident, any witness
- 12:55statements, things of that sort. And if anybody
- 12:57needs any type of discovery samples, I'm happy
- 12:59to share anything that we talk about today that
- 13:02isn't subject to a protective order, including
- 13:04any type of motions that were filed throughout
- 13:06the course of the case. So after obtaining the
- 13:09video, we were able to go through it. Initially,
- 13:13we weren't able to get the entirety of the video.
- 13:16um after a lot of meet and confer and additional
- 13:19depositions in which their employees testified
- 13:23that there was different video angles we were
- 13:25able to get the rest of the video and when we
- 13:28were able to get the video it was determined
- 13:31that the homeless man that committed these acts
- 13:35walked into the store at around 6 16 p .m you
- 13:40can tell there's a there's a person right here
- 13:42standing here um who is a security for the shopping
- 13:47center. And she actually noticed him prior to
- 13:51walking in to the store to the point of where
- 13:54she made an announcement over her handheld radio
- 13:58saying that he was essentially acting bizarre
- 14:01walking into the store. He was spitting profusely
- 14:04or sweating, sweating profusely and then spitting
- 14:07on the ground. And so she alerted the security
- 14:11in the shopping center that this gentleman was
- 14:14walking into the store. I think it's also important
- 14:17to note, Nadine, that when you first watch this
- 14:20video, and just play it for a second here. So
- 14:24this is the assailant walking into the store.
- 14:28Okay, you stop it for a second. If you back up
- 14:31to the second, the slide before this. Yeah, yeah,
- 14:37this one. I think it's important to know, when
- 14:39you watch this video, when we watched this video
- 14:41for the first time, we didn't know that this
- 14:43person, on the left side of the screen was a
- 14:47security guard who made an observation of this
- 14:51guy walking into the store. Because when you
- 14:53watch the video, it's not really that apparent
- 14:59from just watching it that that's what's going
- 15:01on. It wasn't until we got this security report
- 15:06from the security company that works at this
- 15:09shopping mall that we found out that This woman
- 15:13was, in fact, a guard who did make an observation
- 15:16of this guy, radioed it in and said, you know,
- 15:20she was concerned enough or had enough, you know.
- 15:27You know. Suspicion that this guy wasn't acting
- 15:31that normally, he was sweating profusely, as
- 15:34Nadine said, it says it right here and spinning
- 15:36on the ground as he entered the store. It's not
- 15:38really normal behavior. And so. once we were
- 15:42able to see that report and kind of juxtapose
- 15:46it with the video uh it made it made more sense
- 15:49to us and that was actually really good evidence
- 15:51for us that this guy was already acting strangely
- 15:56before he even walked into the store there was
- 15:59a radio broadcast look you know just be on the
- 16:04lookout there's a guy who's not acting right
- 16:07now of course the defendant was like everything
- 16:09he's doing is fine There wasn't anything abnormal
- 16:12or unusual about him sweating profusely or spitting
- 16:16on the ground. In fact, they were trying to push
- 16:19this narrative like, hey, there's a Gold's gym
- 16:22at this shopping center and maybe this is the
- 16:26guy who had just walked out of the gym from working
- 16:29out and he was sweating and he came up to the
- 16:32store to go get some stuff. That was one of the
- 16:37arguments that they advanced in this case. turned
- 16:42out that was completely ridiculous and false.
- 16:45Not true. But nonetheless, this is how we kind
- 16:49of like piece the discovery together. Because
- 16:52sometimes you're going to get some discovery,
- 16:54and it may not be that relevant seeming or important
- 16:59seeming at first blush. But it's not until you
- 17:01get another piece of evidence you're like, OK,
- 17:04now what I looked at before is actually very
- 17:07helpful for our case. Initially we saw the video,
- 17:11we saw him kind of walking quickly into the store,
- 17:13but then once we got the security incident report
- 17:16from the shopping center security company, it
- 17:20kind of all came together and they were also
- 17:23a defendant in the case, which helped in getting
- 17:26this type of discovery. So I'll go ahead and
- 17:28play the video of him walking into the store.
- 17:34And we had an expert that put this together for
- 17:36us with the map. On the left hand side up here.
- 18:03Yeah, it was actually see visual evidence who's
- 18:08a great. company that we use to put together
- 18:11trial graphics and mediation videos and Help
- 18:18us, you know organize exhibits and show them
- 18:20at trial see visual evidence are really good
- 18:23so they put together this little pac -man video
- 18:25on the left hand corner of his movements in the
- 18:29store Yeah, no, no go ahead maybe at this point
- 18:36he's grabbing the knife off the shelf and then
- 18:41you're gonna see a target employee, I'm sorry,
- 18:44a department store employee approach him. And
- 18:48this was also connected. Right, right. Like you
- 18:53don't really know what he's doing here watching
- 18:56the video at first blush. It's kind of hard to
- 19:00tell, but it wasn't until we got this woman's
- 19:07deposition testimony, And we went into the store
- 19:13to look at that area of the store to see what
- 19:16was on the shelves to kind of know what exactly
- 19:20he was doing at that kind of critical moment
- 19:23in time. So this is when he starts the spree
- 19:28essentially throughout the store. So that's the
- 19:49young lady that he just stabbed. And we had to
- 20:04piece this together from like hours of surveillance
- 20:07footage because the defendant produced hours,
- 20:11hours of footage from that evening from different
- 20:15camera angles and it took some time to kind of
- 20:19put it together in a chronological way. This
- 20:24is when the assailant confronts the armed security
- 20:28guard who was at the front of the store. Security
- 20:31guard shoots him and the assailant was killed
- 20:37by the guard and that kind of concludes the end
- 20:44of the incident. from the evening. So initially,
- 20:52looking at this, like Rob was saying, this kind
- 20:55of took hours of piecing together. And it wasn't
- 20:57until we completed all the depositions of the
- 21:02employees that were at the store that night that
- 21:03we got a clearer idea. That woman that confronted
- 21:07him at the time when he was grabbing the knife
- 21:09off the shelf testified at the course of her
- 21:12deposition that she walked away from the time
- 21:16that he was grabbing the knife off the shelf
- 21:18because she thought to herself well that was
- 21:20AP asset protections problem and she didn't want
- 21:24to deal with it essentially and so it wasn't
- 21:26until we got that testimony that we went back
- 21:28realized okay this woman was the same woman who
- 21:31confronted him and ended up walking away and
- 21:33I think you guys saw it she was walking to the
- 21:35back room with the bucket in her hand very uh
- 21:38lackadaisical with no sense of urgency that this
- 21:42man was about to go on a stabbing spree, opening
- 21:45up a knife off the shelf and acting in a very
- 21:48neurotic and, you know, really just unpredictable
- 21:53way. So these were the knives that were on the
- 21:59shelf at the time of the incident. You can tell
- 22:02there is no type of security measures that were
- 22:07placed. Sometimes the stores will have those
- 22:10knobs that prevent you from grabbing it off these
- 22:12pegs here. Other times, there'll be an acrylic
- 22:15casing. But in this case, it was just free to
- 22:19grab. And the theory of the case was that the
- 22:22store failed to secure these knives, but they
- 22:27chose to only lock up high theft items. So throughout
- 22:31the store and throughout the depositions, we
- 22:34were able to figure out which items were under
- 22:38lock and key. and that was detergent and that
- 22:41was beauty products and that was men's underwear
- 22:44and men's t -shirts, a variety of things. And
- 22:49throughout every deposition, every employee confirmed
- 22:53that the reason the department store locked up
- 22:55certain items was solely for theft reasons. They
- 22:58would crack theft trends religiously and determine
- 23:02which products were high theft items and depending
- 23:06on the metrics, would change which products were
- 23:09locked up or not. Every single employee testified
- 23:11that there was never a product that was ever
- 23:15locked up for safety purposes. So this was shortly
- 23:21after the stabbing. These were photographs that
- 23:24the police took. So I want to jump into some
- 23:29of the discovery. Discovery was very difficult
- 23:34when you're dealing with a big box retailer like
- 23:36this, the MO really is that they won't turn over
- 23:41the discovery because they rather you spend the
- 23:45time to go get the motion to compel presented
- 23:49in front of the court. And unfortunately, the
- 23:51sanctions that are even awarded in those types
- 23:54of situations just aren't enough to deter them
- 23:58from their behavior. I mean, we got a number
- 24:01of different sanctions throughout the course
- 24:02of this case, but unfortunately $2 ,000, $3 ,000,
- 24:05$4 ,000, $5 ,000 worth of sanctions just isn't
- 24:09worth it for them. They'd rather take the risk
- 24:11and get sanctioned than provide the information
- 24:13over to you and force you to file motion to compel
- 24:17after motion to compel. Robert and I filed a
- 24:22preference motion in this case. And so we were
- 24:24on a shortened timeline, which added to the prector
- 24:28because obviously, as most of you know, LA courts
- 24:31are really backed up. You come to reserve a motion.
- 24:34It's likely after your trial date. And so every
- 24:37time we wanted to file a motion to compel, it
- 24:38would be an ex parte to advance the motion. The
- 24:42ex parte would have to get granted and the court
- 24:44would have to do a shortened timeline for the
- 24:47motion. to be heard, and then the motion would
- 24:49be heard. I mean, this was a reoccurring process,
- 24:52probably at least once a week throughout the
- 24:54course of the case. I think we had probably about
- 24:5712 motions to compel by the end of the case.
- 25:00And the judge was very upset with the behavior
- 25:04and awarded sanctions. But unfortunately, like
- 25:07I said, just not to a degree that was severe
- 25:09enough for them to change their behavior. So
- 25:13this was one of the requests for productions
- 25:15that we did. which was relating to past incidents
- 25:19of stabbing, shootings, assaults, or any other
- 25:22types of violent occasions at the subject store.
- 25:25This was after they produced initial responses
- 25:29for basically just objections only. After meeting
- 25:32and conferring, they provided further responses.
- 25:37And as you can tell, it was a two -page incident
- 25:40report. which involved somebody hitting someone
- 25:44with an electronic scooter inside the store.
- 25:47So that required further meaning and conferring
- 25:52to figure out what other instances had occurred
- 25:54at the subject store. We also requested a number
- 25:57of different documents pertaining to incidents
- 26:00like this at nationwide stores. I would say that
- 26:03that was probably the biggest discovery dispute
- 26:06that we had in the case, which was what was the
- 26:09scope? of what was discoverable, as it pertains
- 26:13to geographically, what was discoverable, whether
- 26:16it was nationwide, California, Southern California,
- 26:19the district where the store was, or the other
- 26:23thing was what types of incidents were we allowed
- 26:27to get into? Was it every type of shooting, every
- 26:29type of stabbing, any type of incident with a
- 26:31knife? I think we took nearly 60 depositions
- 26:35in this case. which was the lower level employees
- 26:39that were there at the time of the incident.
- 26:41Then the regional people that were supervising
- 26:44at the time came out to the store and did further
- 26:47investigation. And then, you know, more senior
- 26:50management up until the corporate level. And
- 26:54throughout the course of those depositions, we
- 26:56discovered that big box retailers like this have
- 26:58a lot of different databases. They have databases
- 27:01that store this type of information, these types
- 27:04of incident reports. And so once we were able
- 27:07to figure that out, we did further discovery
- 27:10as to what exactly would be in those databases
- 27:12and how we could obtain it. Eventually, we got
- 27:16a court order that the scope of the discovery
- 27:19was five years prior to the incident, any and
- 27:23all incidents involving knives nationwide. And
- 27:26they had to turn over the results within the
- 27:31database that search terms that we agreed to
- 27:36within the database and the results of those
- 27:37search terms, which ultimately had thousands
- 27:40and thousands of results, some of which, not
- 27:44even some, most of which were not relevant to
- 27:47our analysis. A lot of them were, you know, somebody
- 27:50walking in with their own knife. Some of them
- 27:53were, you know, using a knife to open up a package
- 27:56that they were trying to steal, things of that
- 27:59sort. But we really had to dig through and find
- 28:01the ones that were relevant to our theory of
- 28:04liability, which was, as Robert mentioned, framing
- 28:08the bigger issue, which was taking a knife off
- 28:12the shelf and using it in any type of dangerous
- 28:14way. The defendant knew that the narrower the
- 28:23scope was, the better it was for them. And that's
- 28:25why they kept kind of trying to hold us to this
- 28:29unrealistic and improper standard, which is we're
- 28:33not on notice of this type of thing happening
- 28:35unless you can provide us with some evidence
- 28:38that this exact thing happened at this exact
- 28:41store before this incident. Well, of course,
- 28:45this exact thing, more likely than not, is not
- 28:50going to have happened at this exact store before.
- 28:54I mean, this is the first time that this exact
- 28:57thing happened. But what Nadine found out through
- 29:01going through scores, thousands of incident reports
- 29:05is that what has happened before a lot was people
- 29:10walking into stores nationwide, taking knives
- 29:13off the shelves and using them in some kind of
- 29:15dangerous way. That's it. Then ultimately the
- 29:18judge agreed. that that should be the proper
- 29:21scope of the inquiry and allowed us to get this
- 29:25discovery after pretty aggressive motion practice
- 29:29seeking this information because you know we
- 29:38knew that at this particular location you know
- 29:44this exact thing just didn't happen before but
- 29:49But when it comes to a big box retailer, you
- 29:52know, the you know, an incident that happens
- 29:57in New York is imputed on the corporation period.
- 30:04And in here, they were trying to act like, well,
- 30:06this little store is its own little fiefdom.
- 30:09It's its own little entity. And it wasn't it
- 30:12wasn't like it's it's its own franchisee. It's
- 30:15not like it was owned and operated by a separate
- 30:19LLC or corporation, no. The company didn't do
- 30:25business that way. The company owned and operated
- 30:28each of its stores nationwide. So something that
- 30:31happened in Florida is imputed on the central
- 30:35nervous system in its headquarters. And so, you
- 30:40know, that took a lot of wrangling and fighting
- 30:43over and the judge, like I said, ultimately said,
- 30:46no, no, this is it's one defendant with multiple
- 30:48locations. It's not, you know, multiple little
- 30:52entities. And if something happens in one place,
- 30:54you know, it's not like that doesn't count. It
- 30:57does count. It certainly counts. And we found
- 31:00how many was it? I mean, like it was over 30.
- 31:07Yeah. Over 30 prior incidents of people going
- 31:10into stores, taking knives off shelves and using
- 31:12them in a dangerous way. And yet, as Nadine pointed
- 31:16out, the store continued to not make any changes
- 31:19to the merchandise protection. They locked up
- 31:23laundry detergent, they locked up cell phone
- 31:25accessories, they locked up batteries because
- 31:27people stole those things a lot. But the one
- 31:30thing that people were, you know, criminals were
- 31:33using to go in to, you know, cause carnage and
- 31:38wreak havoc were knives and those weren't being
- 31:41protected in any kind of reasonable way. A lot
- 31:45of objections throughout the course of discovery.
- 31:48And these were the multiple prior knife instances.
- 31:51I mean, like I mentioned, there was over 30.
- 31:53And so I kind of just want to talk about how
- 31:55we were able to get some of those prior knife
- 31:57instances. There was a lot of creativity and
- 32:01a lot of motion work, as I was mentioning. A
- 32:03lot of them came from the... Database that I
- 32:07was talking about earlier going through the search
- 32:09terms after we went through the search terms
- 32:12in the database We asked that target produced
- 32:14the I'm sorry the departments to produce the
- 32:17incident reports related to the results that
- 32:21came out from the database also just being creative
- 32:25and trying to find other incidents, whether that
- 32:29was through Google, searching Facebook, looking
- 32:32through court records, trying to find any prior
- 32:35lawsuits. There was a number of instances that
- 32:38I found through just news articles. And a lot
- 32:42of times the news articles, the issue, the biggest
- 32:44issue was sometimes we couldn't confirm whether
- 32:46it was a store knife or not. And we would have
- 32:48an issue where it seemed like it was the assailant
- 32:51bringing in their own knife into the store. And
- 32:54there was one instance that I had found the news
- 32:57articles weren't able to confirm whether it was
- 32:59a store knife or not. I figured out that there
- 33:02was a criminal case related to that incident.
- 33:05And I ordered the preliminary hearing transcript
- 33:07from the criminal case. And the preliminary hearing
- 33:10transcript confirmed that it was, in fact, a
- 33:12store knife. Target didn't produce, obviously,
- 33:14any of that kind of stuff to me. But if you're
- 33:17able to do the grunt work and get the public
- 33:20records, you're able to find out a lot of great
- 33:24information that way. As I mentioned, these were
- 33:30a number of different motions that we had to
- 33:33bring. It was compelling prior instances, the
- 33:36time, the locations, the inspections of the databases.
- 33:40I hope that I can one day get to do this again
- 33:43because they had been so evasive throughout the
- 33:48course of discovery and the judge had caught
- 33:50on to that. you know, you can't come out swinging
- 33:53really. You've got to build it up with the judge
- 33:55and build the credibility to come in and ask
- 33:57for something to this degree because they had
- 34:00been so, you know, deceptive with their discovery
- 34:06throughout the course of the case. And so I basically
- 34:10pled to the judge and said, look, they can't
- 34:11be trusted to produce what they need to produce.
- 34:15We want to have a forensic expert go in and inspect
- 34:18their databases ourselves. And the tentative
- 34:21was to grant that, which I was kind of surprised,
- 34:25but I was thankful. And then we went in that
- 34:29week for the hearing. And I don't know if you
- 34:30all remember that week where the courts were
- 34:33hacked and there was a data breach. And so they
- 34:36used that to their advantage. And the judge ultimately
- 34:39ended up flipping and said, you know what, you
- 34:41just need to produce the results. I think it's
- 34:44a tool to keep in your back pocket that you can
- 34:46have a forensic expert go in and they can have
- 34:48their own forensic expert go in and download
- 34:51the information from the database so you have
- 34:54that raw data. And then the last was just motions
- 34:58to compel employees who were involved in the
- 35:00prior instances. That was also good information
- 35:03that we were able to get. I mean, of the ones
- 35:05that we were able to track down, a lot of the
- 35:07employees didn't work at the stores anymore,
- 35:09but some of them did and the depositions we took
- 35:12were really helpful because they would testify
- 35:14that, for example, there was one instance in
- 35:17Seattle where the assailant took the knife off
- 35:21the shelf and began threatening hostages. That
- 35:25was pretty much all the information I had. And
- 35:27then once I took the deposition, the employee
- 35:29testified that the incident went on for hours.
- 35:31He was attempting to hold a number of different
- 35:34customers hostage. The police came. There was
- 35:36a standoff. And then the kill question was, well,
- 35:40did the store lock up the knives after that incident?
- 35:43And it was no. So that's the information that
- 35:46you're able to get in the deposition versus just
- 35:50a concise incident report. So this was the court
- 35:58order that we got regarding the database. It
- 36:01was called Origami. It's a risk management database,
- 36:06basically. And like I said, we got the instances
- 36:10for the past five years within the United States.
- 36:18Rob, you want to talk about the MSJ a little
- 36:20bit or? Yeah, sure. So. So, you know, we knew
- 36:28the we knew the defendant was going to was going
- 36:31to file a motion for summary judgment. In any
- 36:33you can anticipate in any premises liability
- 36:37case involving third party criminal conduct,
- 36:40the premises owner is likely going to file a
- 36:43motion for summary judgment. And look, I mean
- 36:47this goes without saying we haven't. We haven't
- 36:49said it yet, but it does go without saying in
- 36:52these types of cases, a lot of the focus and
- 36:55emphasis is going to be on the third party criminal.
- 36:57What he or she did to your client, and that's
- 37:01a big. That's going to be a big hurdle to overcome
- 37:04in a lot of these cases because when a jury hears
- 37:08about someone taking a knife from a shelf and
- 37:11stabbing your client with it, their natural inclination
- 37:15is going to be to blame the person who did that.
- 37:18So these cases are very difficult to prosecute.
- 37:25Our job is to shift the focus from the third
- 37:28party criminal onto the premises property owner
- 37:32and what they could have done to have prevented
- 37:35this type of foreseeable attack. So when the
- 37:41motion was filed, they advanced arguments that
- 37:46we knew were coming. One, we didn't have a duty
- 37:49to prevent this type of thing from happening.
- 37:54It was completely unforeseeable that a crazy
- 37:58guy was going to come in and take merchandise
- 38:03from us and use it as a deadly weapon on other
- 38:07people. It's never happened before here. It wasn't
- 38:12anticipated. None of our people were on notice
- 38:17that he was going to do something like that.
- 38:21And once he did do that, the security company
- 38:24who we hired immediately dismantled the situation.
- 38:31I mean, they, they, they, they, you know, as
- 38:33you saw in the video, security guard went up
- 38:35to the guy and took out his gun and shot him
- 38:40and he is killed. Threat is abated. No more issue.
- 38:44So that's what the defendant was arguing that,
- 38:46you know, we didn't know it was going to happen.
- 38:49It's so unfortunate. It was a crime. A crime
- 38:51happened in our store. We didn't know that was
- 38:53going to happen. Once it did, Nadine, what was
- 38:58it, like three minutes? The time was again, from
- 39:01the time that from the time the guy walked into
- 39:03the time he was shot and killed, it was like
- 39:06three minutes. It was tough. So, you know, they're
- 39:09like, he walked in, he was, you know, acting
- 39:12pretty normal. He could have been working out.
- 39:15That's why he was sweating. There's no crime
- 39:17against sweating and spitting. And, you know,
- 39:20by the time He took the knife, did all that.
- 39:22Our guy came to apprehend him. He tried to de
- 39:26-escalate the situation without shooting and
- 39:28killing him. But the guy lunged at him with the
- 39:30knife because he was crazy. So our guy shot and
- 39:33killed him. Threat is eliminated. The end. It
- 39:38all happened in three minutes. How are we negligent?
- 39:41This is all the criminals' fault. I mean, so
- 39:50notice was obviously such a big issue in the
- 39:53case, and that's why Nate Dean spent just the
- 39:56last few minutes talking to you about how critical
- 39:58and important the discovery is to get the evidence
- 40:04of prior instances of this type of thing happening
- 40:07before. We needed that in order to succeed on
- 40:11the motion. We also knew that you know, a business
- 40:18establishment owes a duty, in fact, has a special
- 40:23relationship with people like our clients, with
- 40:26their customers, to keep them safe in their store.
- 40:31And, you know, the defendant here was arguing
- 40:33that they had no duty. They failed to mention
- 40:36the special relationship doctrine at all in its
- 40:39moving papers. We brought it up really for the
- 40:43first time in the case in our opposition. And
- 40:50the judge ultimately, I mean, we're going to
- 40:52get to it, but the judge ultimately sided with
- 40:55us and said, no, no, you as a business owe a
- 41:00special relationship. You're in a special relationship
- 41:03with your customers, with your invitees. And
- 41:05so you owe them a duty. So now the question is
- 41:08like, was this foreseeable? Could you have done
- 41:11more? And Thankfully, because of the evidence
- 41:15we uncovered about the prior instances of attacks
- 41:18and using knives in dangerous ways, we had enough
- 41:22evidence to create, you know, I think numerous
- 41:26tribal issues of material fact. And so, you know,
- 41:31obviously it's always a scary thing when you're
- 41:33hit with a motion for summary judgment, especially
- 41:35in a premises case involving a third party criminal
- 41:39act. it's risky, because you always think about,
- 41:45well, was this thing truly preventable? What's
- 41:51the jury going to think? Are they going to put
- 41:52like 90 % on the perpetrator and 10 % on the
- 41:56property owner? Those are all things that were
- 41:59swirling around in our heads. But I think we
- 42:01were comfortable with the evidence that we had
- 42:05uncovered to date by the time it was to oppose
- 42:08this motion. And obviously, Rowland is an important
- 42:14case that we're going to talk about that discusses
- 42:16numerous factors that you can use to hold property
- 42:23owner liable even in the face of an egregious
- 42:26third party criminal act like we had in this
- 42:28case. This slide here is actually from the court's
- 42:34tentative ruling to deny the defendant's motion
- 42:38for summary judgment. And as you can see, it's
- 42:40kind of small, but what you can see, the judge
- 42:43said, as an initial matter, as discussed above,
- 42:46there exists a special relationship between the
- 42:49defendant and plaintiffs who are customers of
- 42:52the defendant, which gives rise to an affirmative
- 42:55duty by the defendant. The question then becomes,
- 42:59what specific duties do the plaintiffs claim
- 43:02the defendant had and do relevant policy considerations?
- 43:05counsel limiting those duties and those policy
- 43:08considerations is where the role in factors come
- 43:11into play. But this was like an important, very
- 43:14important finding because the defendant was saying
- 43:16they didn't owe, they didn't owe an affirmative
- 43:18duty to our clients, to their customers, to do
- 43:22anything beyond what they did, which was we had
- 43:25a security guard with a gun and that was it.
- 43:31you know what what more could we have done to
- 43:34prevent this and turns out they could have done
- 43:37a lot more they could have locked up the knives
- 43:39the the video we showed you of the assailant
- 43:44taking the knife off the shelf i mean just to
- 43:47kind of give you a little bit more color as to
- 43:49like what went down during that critical period
- 43:52of time this was all information we obtained
- 43:56during the discovery. We didn't know this before
- 43:58we filed the case, but what we found out is that
- 44:01that guy was, you know, took a knife off the
- 44:04shelf, used his teeth to try to open up the package
- 44:09while he's sweating profusely using tons of profanity
- 44:15as he's trying to rip open the knife package
- 44:18with his teeth all in front of an employee working
- 44:23for the defendant. as you saw in the video and
- 44:26again the video doesn't you can't really understand
- 44:29that by watching the video because there's no
- 44:31sound and it's from far away and you don't really
- 44:34know what's happening but when we took that employee's
- 44:37deposition she tells us yeah this guy was ripping
- 44:41open the knife package with his teeth sweating
- 44:44and saying go fuck yourself to me and acting
- 44:48like a madman So the next logical question we
- 44:52asked in the deposition was, and what'd you do
- 44:56after that? And she said, well, I thought to
- 45:00myself, this is someone else's problem. And I
- 45:02walked away. I mean, when that happens, like,
- 45:07it's like, you know, the case stopped for a second
- 45:11and it was like, oh my God, you know, that is
- 45:14such a horrible. mistake. That is probably the
- 45:19most pivotal mistake that you made in the entire
- 45:23case. You were there watching this guy opening
- 45:28up a knife package with his teeth sweating, cussing,
- 45:33saying go fuck yourself, fuck you, blah, blah,
- 45:35blah, all this stuff. He wasn't ultimately successful.
- 45:39She witnessed this too. He ultimately wasn't
- 45:41successful ripping opening the package with his
- 45:44teeth. So he took his backpack. Put it on the
- 45:47ground unzipped it took out a scissors from his
- 45:51backpack and started cutting open the knife package
- 45:54like this in front of her and She walked away.
- 45:59She put up her hands and said this isn't my problem.
- 46:04I'm Del you know, and probably I'm not paid enough
- 46:08to deal with this shit and she walked away She
- 46:10didn't tell anyone she didn't alert any customers.
- 46:13She didn't you know Sound the alarms which by
- 46:18the way is against the defendant's policies because
- 46:20we also got their policies and procedures and
- 46:22it clearly stated as it should that if you see
- 46:26something suspicious Say something alert the
- 46:29customers alert people to like clear the area
- 46:31She didn't do that. And what happens after she
- 46:34walks away? He takes the knife from aisle J Finds
- 46:38the little boy stabs a multiple times goes to
- 46:41a different part of the store finds the flight
- 46:43attendant stabs her multiple times and then thankfully
- 46:47he was fatally shot but the damage was already
- 46:50done too little too late right so um so that
- 46:55was like a really that was a bad thing that happened
- 46:59and of course the defendant you know they tried
- 47:01to spin it as best as they could and they said
- 47:04well she didn't know it wasn't reasonable for
- 47:09her to know that he was going to take that knife
- 47:12and go and do what he did with it she thought
- 47:17she thought that he was just simply trying to
- 47:20steal the knife so there is no real reason to
- 47:23sound the alarms because he was simply going
- 47:26to just steal the knife well we know that that's
- 47:29not true we know when you look at the evidence
- 47:32it's obvious that that's not what he was doing
- 47:35if he was going to steal the knife take the knife
- 47:38off the shelf put it in the bag walk away That's
- 47:42what you do when you steal a knife. What he was
- 47:45doing is he was You know prying it open with
- 47:48his teeth with a pair of scissors Sweating cussing
- 47:53at store employees telling them to get away from
- 47:56him That's what you do when you're gonna use
- 48:01that knife in some kind of dangerous way and
- 48:04I think ultimately they knew that and they knew
- 48:06they were screwed but So that's all important
- 48:11because that all goes to what more they could
- 48:14have done. So once we found out what their employee
- 48:19did, which is basically walk away from the threat
- 48:23as it was unfolding, we were like, okay, now
- 48:27there's multiple things that you could have done
- 48:31to have prevented this. Number one, and this
- 48:33is something you could have done prior to the
- 48:37subject incident, You could have locked up the
- 48:40knives. And you should have locked up the knives
- 48:43because this happened over 30 times before. How
- 48:48many more times is it going to take for you to
- 48:49learn? Lock up the knives. You lock up the laundry
- 48:54detergent. You lock up the batteries. You lock
- 48:56up the cell phone accessories. Lock up the things
- 48:59that could actually kill your customers in your
- 49:02stores. That's number one. And you failed. Number
- 49:07two. and this is something admittedly that you
- 49:10couldn't have done before the event but you knew
- 49:14about the event unfolding when it was happening
- 49:18your own person saw this guy getting ready to
- 49:24carry out this attack your defense to that that
- 49:27he was simply just trying to steal it is complete
- 49:29bullshit everyone knows it He was clearly in
- 49:35a menacing way trying to take this knife out
- 49:39of the package to use it in some kind of dangerous
- 49:42horrible way and You didn't do anything. You
- 49:46didn't intervene. You didn't alert our clients
- 49:48your customers. You didn't alert anyone It wasn't
- 49:52until this guy unfortunately stabbed two people
- 49:55that the security guard at the front of the store
- 49:57was finally made aware of what was happening
- 50:00inside of the store and came to to try to deescalate
- 50:07the situation. So, you know, that was like, I
- 50:12think that was just so important. It's such an
- 50:16important foundation to like understanding why
- 50:19the defendant bear responsibility in this case,
- 50:23not just the third party criminal. And so we
- 50:27actually started our motion. I'm sorry, our opposition
- 50:32to the motion for summary judgment. With those
- 50:35details, I have it printed out here and I'll
- 50:37just read it. This is how our opposition starts
- 50:40to the, to the MSJ. A visibly deranged man was
- 50:48sweating profusely and shouting obscenities while
- 50:52feverishly using his teeth and a pair of scissors
- 50:54to rip open the packaging of an eight inch carving
- 50:57knife he took off the rack in aisle. Jay at the
- 51:01department store at Fig and Seventh. When the
- 51:03store's executive team leader confronted him,
- 51:05he mumbled, quote, fuck you, leave me alone.
- 51:09The employee thought to herself, quote, this
- 51:11is someone else's problem, and walked away. The
- 51:14man, later identified as a transient, then took
- 51:17the knife out of the aisle, walked to another
- 51:19part of the store, and violently stabbed a nine
- 51:22-year -old boy in his spine, causing life -threatening
- 51:24injuries. And so I think we set the We set the
- 51:31scene up nicely for the judge to think, all right,
- 51:34obviously we know the guy is a bad seed, and
- 51:38maybe a jury's gonna allocate some fault on him.
- 51:41Not maybe, probably. I mean, we were contemplating
- 51:45that. We didn't know how much fault would ultimately
- 51:48be put on him. The more we were working up the
- 51:52case and prosecuting the case, I think the worse
- 51:54it got for the defendant. the more bad stuff
- 51:58came out. You had the 30 prior incidents, you
- 52:01had the confrontation of the perpetrator getting
- 52:06ready to carry out the attack and what did they
- 52:08do? Nothing. They just tried to spin the facts
- 52:11and make it seem like it wasn't as bad as it
- 52:14actually was. And so I think it started to get
- 52:17really bad for them. And so we had a lot of good
- 52:22evidence to use in the opposition. All right.
- 52:29So judge found, which is great in the tentative
- 52:33that they ordered an affirmative duty. Awesome.
- 52:42So, yeah, yeah. Why don't you talk about this
- 52:44great case that you found? Yeah, this was a great,
- 52:46this was a great case. So, I mean, throughout
- 52:48the course of discovery and a lot of the motion
- 52:51work, the issue was the defendant was using the
- 52:54admissibility at trial standard versus the discover
- 52:57ability standard. And I was able to find some
- 53:00case law that. Helped us. The case law talked
- 53:06about even admissibility at trial being broader
- 53:08than what the defendant thought was discoverable.
- 53:11And so this was a case that if you have a third
- 53:15party criminal conduct case, keep this case in
- 53:18your arsenal. This is a case involving a someone
- 53:24coming into a 711 store and attempting to rob.
- 53:28the 7 -Eleven. The Court of Appeal found that
- 53:32just with one prior incident not involving a
- 53:35weapon and coupled with the fact that there had
- 53:38been other robberies at other 7 -Eleven locations
- 53:42generally, this was a foreseeable issue and it
- 53:47was something that was a tribal issue of fact
- 53:49for the jury. And so that language, those four
- 53:52words, other 7 -Eleven locations generally, is
- 53:56enough for you to convince your judge that you're
- 54:00entitled to discovery of nationwide instances
- 54:03in any type of big box retailer, any type of
- 54:08store like a 7 -Eleven with multiple, multiple
- 54:11locations. And that way, you can cast your net
- 54:14into a wider you know, array of instances and
- 54:20to see what you can find and to show that the
- 54:22corporation should have been on notice. So these
- 54:28are the role and factors, also a case to keep
- 54:30in your arsenal. And this basically are the factors
- 54:35that decide whether a duty is owed by the defendant
- 54:42in protecting individuals invitees to their store
- 54:47and so there's other case law too that says that
- 54:52duty of foreseeability is a question of fact
- 54:55for the jury and I think because of that we were
- 54:58able to get past motion for summary judgment.
- 55:00I think even without the prior instances we likely
- 55:03would have gotten past motion for summary judgment
- 55:06just because of the evidence that came out about
- 55:10what the employee did at the time of the incident
- 55:15and confronting the gentleman. And so, you know,
- 55:18B was really what we focused on. Well, A, you
- 55:21know, the special relationship that the court
- 55:23found, and then B, the foreseeability of the
- 55:26harm. That's where we were able to stick in all
- 55:28the prior instances. And the rest are kind of
- 55:32more policy considerations. This was a, this
- 55:39is a really important case that talks about what
- 55:41type of defendants have a special relationship
- 55:44with their invitees at shopping centers, restaurants,
- 55:47and bars. You know, and yeah, I mean, so like
- 55:51the Cohen case that Nadine just talked about,
- 55:54Roland, obviously in Delgado, I think these were
- 55:56the three most important cases we used to defeat
- 55:59the summary judgment in the case because I mean,
- 56:12on the Delgado case, I mean, again, like, you
- 56:15gotta think, this is a case that we focus grouped.
- 56:18I mean, it settled, I think, one day before jury
- 56:21selection was set to begin. And, you know, we
- 56:25tried out a couple different theories, and one
- 56:31thing that just kept resonating with, perspective
- 56:36jurors in the focus group and with us is like,
- 56:39look, if you open up a business and you invite
- 56:44people to come there, you gotta keep them safe.
- 56:49It's as simple as that. When you run a business
- 56:51in this town, when you run a business in this
- 56:54city, you have to keep them safe. You are in
- 56:58the law. The law even intervenes and says, You
- 57:04owe them a special, you're in a special relationship
- 57:06with them to keep them safe. And the law even
- 57:09contemplates that sometimes bad things are going
- 57:12to happen that seemingly on the surface might
- 57:15be outside of your control. Like a criminal might
- 57:18walk into your place of business and do bad things
- 57:21to other people inside your store. But that doesn't
- 57:24mean you get a get out of jail free card just
- 57:28because a third party comes in and does bad stuff.
- 57:32The law contemplates that because it's happened
- 57:34before and there's policy reasons why the law
- 57:39is the way it is. And so like this would have
- 57:41been a special jury instruction. And this is
- 57:45something that we did propose in our trial documents.
- 57:48Like the jury needs understand that you know,
- 57:52a defendant owes an affirmative duty to protect
- 57:54another from the conduct of a third party if
- 57:57it has a special relationship with that other
- 57:59person. So, you know, I think that was a really
- 58:02important concept for everyone, whether this
- 58:05case, you know, whether you're trying to get
- 58:09past summary judgment or you do and then you
- 58:12try it, it's an important concept for everyone
- 58:15to understand is that these types of big box
- 58:19companies like Nadine's talking about, They have
- 58:21this special relationship with their customers
- 58:24to keep them safe. And that means that they have
- 58:28to take precautions before the event happens
- 58:31and take precautions at the time the event happens.
- 58:39And here, because of the discovery we found and
- 58:44pursued, we had evidence of both. Things that
- 58:48the defendant could have done before, and things
- 58:51that they should have and could have done during
- 58:54to minimize the severity and extent of the attack.
- 59:00So again, it was kind of like two phases of evidence,
- 59:03the stuff before and the stuff during. And again,
- 59:09I think the evidence was kind of overwhelming
- 59:11that they really dropped the ball in both phases,
- 59:15both things they could have done before and things
- 59:17they could have done at the time. So as you can
- 59:23imagine, we got past summary judgment. Judge
- 59:25denied the motion. And like I said, it resolved
- 59:29one day before jury selection was set to begin.
- 59:39These slides kind of just go through the incident.
- 59:42Yeah, if you go back, Nadine, to the arrows with
- 59:46the employee. in the assailant. Yeah, I mean,
- 59:54this was a big slide we made from the surveillance
- 59:59footage. We actually, at the motion for summary
- 1:00:02judgment, we had a big styrofoam board with this
- 1:00:10image printed on it. And we brought it to the
- 1:00:14hearing and put it on an easel to kind of just
- 1:00:18underscore the importance of this critical event
- 1:00:20at the time of the incident. I mean, because
- 1:00:28again, when you watch the video, you don't really
- 1:00:29know what's happening. You have to kind of take
- 1:00:31all the evidence together to know the import
- 1:00:35of it. But this was just such a visually such
- 1:00:39an important part of our evidence that the guys
- 1:00:43reaching down to get a pair of scissors from
- 1:00:45his backpack. to open up this knife that he just
- 1:00:49took from the shelf freely. You know, there was
- 1:00:53no case, there was nothing. He just took it off
- 1:00:55the shelf, reaching into his bag to get a pair
- 1:00:59of scissors to open it up after he couldn't open
- 1:01:02it up with his teeth. And this employee is just
- 1:01:06standing there watching him do this, watching
- 1:01:09this whole thing unfold and does absolutely nothing
- 1:01:14with what she observes. walks away and sure enough
- 1:01:19within 10 seconds after she leaves he walks out
- 1:01:24of this aisle with that knife that he opened
- 1:01:26up in front of her and brutally attacked and
- 1:01:30stabbed two innocent people. I think we've got
- 1:01:37a couple more slides we're running low on time
- 1:01:39um we just wanted to see if there was any questions
- 1:01:42that anyone had if anyone needs um or opposition
- 1:01:48to summary judgment, just let us know. As Nadine
- 1:01:54said, there was a ton of motion work in the case.
- 1:01:56So, you know, there's probably a half a dozen
- 1:02:01to a dozen motions to compel multiple rounds
- 1:02:05of written discovery. There was a protective
- 1:02:08order in the case. So some of it we can't give
- 1:02:13out, some of it we can. But obviously our opposition
- 1:02:16to the motion for summary judgment is available
- 1:02:18for everyone who wants it. I think it's a good
- 1:02:21one. It outlines all the important cases. And
- 1:02:24I think it's structured in a way to really successfully
- 1:02:28overcome these tough liability cases involving
- 1:02:32third party criminal conduct on someone else's
- 1:02:37property. I think there was a question about
- 1:02:39That in hindsight, it seems like this case is
- 1:02:41a slam dunk, but it's establishing liability
- 1:02:45wasn't so clear. And I think that's right. I
- 1:02:46mean, looking back, you're probably thinking,
- 1:02:48yeah, this seemed like an easy case and something
- 1:02:51that the store should have been made aware of.
- 1:02:53But on day one, that was definitely not the case.
- 1:02:56And so what keeps us confident in cases like
- 1:02:58that is just to keep pushing. Honestly, I think
- 1:03:01it's really important to take every deposition
- 1:03:04that you possibly can of every employee. every
- 1:03:07regional employee, every high level employee,
- 1:03:10you're eventually going to find some theory of
- 1:03:13liability that the store did something wrong.
- 1:03:18And I think also to the fact that it was a national
- 1:03:21corporation also kept us confident because there
- 1:03:24was going to be something that the corporation
- 1:03:26had done prior that would have put them on notice.
- 1:03:29And I think sometimes to the theory you have
- 1:03:31to frame is, well, not that they necessarily
- 1:03:36should have done something. Which was the case,
- 1:03:39but also to they didn't do anything with the
- 1:03:42information that was presented. There had been
- 1:03:4430 prior instances and Rob took the deposition
- 1:03:48of one of their national corporate representatives
- 1:03:50who was the head of their risk management and
- 1:03:53just went through every instance and was like
- 1:03:55this was in your database, correct? That's a
- 1:03:57database that's accessible to you. That's a national
- 1:04:00database and you fail to do anything with that
- 1:04:02information. You never. did a study to ensure
- 1:04:06that stores locked up their knives, right? So
- 1:04:09it's also the lack of action. Yeah, I mean, that's
- 1:04:13a really important point, Nadine. Like, you can't
- 1:04:16let the defendant hijack the narrative of your
- 1:04:22case. You can't let them dictate the scope and
- 1:04:26what's relevant and what's not. You have to be
- 1:04:29the one to define the scope and to define the
- 1:04:33narrative. like case in point in this case we
- 1:04:39had like 30 prior instances of people taking
- 1:04:45knives off shelves and using them right and the
- 1:04:49defendant in our case was saying so what that
- 1:04:52didn't happen at this store and it didn't happen
- 1:04:55in the exact same way it's irrelevant and they
- 1:05:00just kind of acted like it was no big deal and
- 1:05:03you know they were good lawyers very formidable
- 1:05:05and they knew what they were doing and like you
- 1:05:08know if you're kind of on the weaker side they
- 1:05:11could push you around and make you believe that
- 1:05:14what they're saying is true but once you like
- 1:05:17looked at the information uh i'm trying i'm looking
- 1:05:22at like some of uh i'm trying to look at uh some
- 1:05:28of the prior instances like for example um Just
- 1:05:32one second, like, you know, a couple years before
- 1:05:37the incident, there is an incident report that
- 1:05:41documents a man walking into one of the stores,
- 1:05:43went to the kitchen department, grabbed a knife
- 1:05:46off the peg hook, took the knife out of the package,
- 1:05:50and ultimately stabbed and killed himself. He
- 1:05:53used it to commit suicide inside of the store.
- 1:05:57The defendant said, That's not relevant, so different
- 1:06:01from our case. We disagreed. And so, again, because
- 1:06:07our theory was, how many times are you going
- 1:06:09to let someone take a knife off your shelves
- 1:06:11and use it in some kind of dangerous way? Using
- 1:06:14it in some kind of dangerous way includes killing
- 1:06:16yourself with it. It's one of your people, one
- 1:06:19of your customers. a wealth of information, like
- 1:06:26Nadine just said, with the PMQ for the company,
- 1:06:29you don't need to really even need to get them
- 1:06:34to make any kind of crazy concessions or admissions.
- 1:06:37You can just simply walk through each of the
- 1:06:40prior incidents and say, as she just said, this
- 1:06:43is in your database. This happened before the
- 1:06:45incident. And the database is available to every
- 1:06:49store in the nation? Yes. And the database is
- 1:06:52accessible. to anyone if they just want to search
- 1:06:55the word knife yes it was there to be seen if
- 1:06:59you wanted to look for it right yes okay i mean
- 1:07:03they can't dispute what's in their own documents
- 1:07:07and that that's why in this basic stuff but it's
- 1:07:11important to remind ourselves of it You got to
- 1:07:16get the documents before you take the depositions
- 1:07:19so you can simply just get the confirming oral
- 1:07:22Testimony of what's in the actual document itself
- 1:07:25and that that's really all it was I mean it took
- 1:07:28a lot for us to get the information to get the
- 1:07:31documents But once we had all the information
- 1:07:33in the documents they thought they were being
- 1:07:37Smoothed by saying all this doesn't count. It's
- 1:07:39not relevant. But as soon as they authenticated
- 1:07:43the document and said that the information in
- 1:07:45it was in their own database prior to the incident,
- 1:07:51that really screwed them. That notice, whether
- 1:07:55it was constructive or actual, was imputed on
- 1:07:59the entire company. I think we are over on our
- 1:08:05time, but we really appreciate everybody jumping
- 1:08:08in. You can contact myself or Rob for any other
- 1:08:11questions that you have. Like we said, we have
- 1:08:13an open door policy about sharing anything that
- 1:08:16we can, anything that's not subject to a protective
- 1:08:18order. We're happy to share it with you all.
- 1:08:21Really appreciate everybody jumping on. I don't
- 1:08:23know if Rob had anything else. Not at all, no.
- 1:08:26It was good to be with you all this morning and
- 1:08:28please reach out to us if you have any questions
- 1:08:30or. one, anything. I saw a question about the
- 1:08:34opposition to MSJ, if that was included in the
- 1:08:37course materials. I don't know if it was, Nadine,
- 1:08:41do you know? If it wasn't - I don't think it
- 1:08:43was, and you can email myself or Robin, we'll
- 1:08:47send it over to you. And Rob's email is rglassman
- 1:08:50at panish .law, mine is nkedri at panish .law.
- 1:08:59I see a question that says, what is Rob? That's
- 1:09:02a question for the ages. We just, we don't know.
- 1:09:05We're still trying to figure out what Rob is,
- 1:09:07but no. I think it was, what is Rob Siebel? I
- 1:09:10answered it. I know. I'm kidding. All right.
- 1:09:13It was good to be with everyone. Have a good
- 1:09:15rest of your week. Thank you everyone. Take care.
- 1:09:17Have a good one. Take care. You may be eligible
- 1:09:19for CLE credit in your state. Visit bhba .org
- 1:09:24slash podcasts for more information.