Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / One Hour With You (1932) ft. Danny Reid
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And today's episode will
- 0:23involve exactly one hour with you. Will it? You
- 0:26think it's going to... And some change. An hour
- 0:28and some change. One hour and some change with
- 0:30you. I will say the movie One Hour With You,
- 0:32about an hour and some change. Yeah. It's like
- 0:34an hour and 20. It felt like maybe... two hours
- 0:37with you. Yeah. Roughly. Which might be what
- 0:39our episode ends up being today. We'll see. I
- 0:42don't know. We'll see. We'll dive right into
- 0:44it. One hour with you is, of course, the return
- 0:46of one of our boys, Ernst Lubitsch, and his constant
- 0:50partnering with Maurice Chevrolet. We've got
- 0:54to figure this out. Let's iron this out right
- 0:55now. Chevrolet? Chevrolier? Chevrolier, I think
- 0:59is how I would say it. Maurice Chevrolier. We'll
- 1:02go ahead and say we're at the top. This episode
- 1:04does feature an interview with Danny of Precode
- 1:08Essentials. Really excited to talk about this
- 1:10one specifically, as this is the movie that he
- 1:13requested to cover with us. Absolutely. If you
- 1:16were a fan of the five -star final interview
- 1:18we did with Kim Luperi, they are two halves of
- 1:23the authors of Precode Essentials, as you said.
- 1:27Yeah, I can't wait. I do want to preface by saying
- 1:29they both picked Bad Girl. And I was like, nah.
- 1:32We just released Bad Girl at that point. I feel
- 1:35so bad. That's okay. We'll still talk about Bad
- 1:37Girl. Yeah. I'm not worried about it. So this
- 1:39is a film that features one nomination. We talked
- 1:43last week about how we're not seeing a ton of
- 1:46movies with, or a ton of Best Picture nominees
- 1:48with a ton of nominations. And at that point,
- 1:51we're talking about like three nominations total.
- 1:53Yeah. Here's one. It's only outstanding production.
- 1:55Also Paramount Publix returning back to back
- 1:57with Shanghai. Wow. This recording day is really
- 2:01the Paramount Publix day. It is. Look at that.
- 2:03It is. Do you want to run through the cast? Sure.
- 2:05We have really just four major players in this
- 2:08film. Mostly. Maurice Chevalier as Dr. Andre
- 2:11Boutier. Jeanette McDonald, the return of her
- 2:14as well, and her duo partnership with Maurice
- 2:17Chevalier. I don't want to say trio, but we'll
- 2:19get there. Yeah. As Colette Boutier. They're
- 2:22married in this. Genevieve Tobin? Tobin, yes.
- 2:26I'll work on that. Genevieve Tobin as Mitzi Olivier
- 2:30and Charles Ruggles as Adolph. Olivier, right?
- 2:35Are they married? Yeah. Okay, Olivier. You're
- 2:38right, you're right, cool. So, yeah, you've got
- 2:40two married couples, but four... major players
- 2:44and you know one of them is maurice chevalier
- 2:46so you know where this is going let's be real
- 2:48yeah and the thing that i really liked about
- 2:50this was from the very beginning maurice actually
- 2:52looks at the camera and kind of addresses like
- 2:55don't worry we really are married yeah like not
- 2:58a joke Because at the beginning, we see them
- 3:01making out in a park. And the cops kind of stop
- 3:04them. And this is the park where everyone comes
- 3:06to make out and have infidelity or just at least
- 3:10not be married. And he's like, no, no, we are.
- 3:13We just enjoy the thrill. And I like this because
- 3:16this is not the first time we've seen him break
- 3:18the fourth wall. We talked about this on the
- 3:20Smiling Lieutenant episode. But this is the first
- 3:24time where we've kind of not expected him to
- 3:27be a scamp. Right? Right. Like we expect him
- 3:30to kind of be like sleeping around and like not
- 3:32be tied down. But no, he's found his person.
- 3:35He's found his other half, specifically in Jeanette
- 3:39MacDonald Collette. So I thought that was a really
- 3:41funny opening for him to be like, this one's
- 3:43different. Right. Until it's not. So a couple
- 3:49things about this. I mentioned that this was
- 3:51kind of, you mentioned this was the return of
- 3:54Jeanette MacDonald and Maurice Chevalier together.
- 3:57Yeah, actually, technically, it would be the
- 4:00trio with Ernst Lubitsch because this is the
- 4:02return of the love parade. But then again, we're
- 4:05seeing the return of multiple people. Charles
- 4:07Ruggles has been in Ernst Lubitsch films with
- 4:10Chevalier before. So I will say this. I don't
- 4:14know what Chevalier did to Ruggles. for every
- 4:17film to now be like, hey, man, gotcha, girl.
- 4:19But that's two movies in a row now, man. What
- 4:22are we doing? So I have some questions about
- 4:25that. A couple things about this. So this was
- 4:27written by Lothar Schmidt, Samson, Raphaelson,
- 4:31and Leopold Marchand. This is actually a remake
- 4:35of a film from 1924, The Marriage Circle. Sorry,
- 4:40which was also based on a play. Based on a play,
- 4:43and it was the second film that Lubitsch directed.
- 4:46The second film that Lubitsch... Oh, okay. What
- 4:49was it called? The Marriage Circle? The Marriage
- 4:50Circle in 1924. Okay. Now, it's a musical remake.
- 4:54Not a surprise for anyone who's heard our Love
- 4:57Parade and Smiling Lieutenant episode. Lubitsch
- 4:59is known for musicals. This is a continuation
- 5:01of that. This one's a little different, though.
- 5:03I don't know if you caught this. The dialogue.
- 5:06It rhymes off and on at times. Right. Not throughout,
- 5:09but there's a lot of like, what do you mean he's
- 5:12coming tonight? This just doesn't feel all right.
- 5:14Like there's a little bit of that. Yes. Through
- 5:16some of the movie, but not all of it. And it
- 5:18almost feels like a song light. Like we're not
- 5:21going to have a song in this, but we are going
- 5:23to have a little bit of a sing -songy rhythm
- 5:25in the way we do this. Yeah. I thought that was
- 5:27interesting. I don't know if I'd say I love it
- 5:29because I thought that was... we've talked a
- 5:31lot about like Les Mis, how that's like a, they
- 5:34sing song throughout the movie. Right. This does
- 5:36feel kind of like adding this in, but not having
- 5:38it be throughout feels kind of like, like you're
- 5:41picking your spots. Yeah. The way I kind of interpreted
- 5:44it is kind of Mother Goosey, almost like with
- 5:49Maurice Chevalier breaking the fourth wall so
- 5:51often and kind of narrating the story, it almost
- 5:54feels like he's telling this very scandalous
- 5:57story as kind of a nursery rhyme. And I don't
- 6:00know if that is to add like a lighthearted nature
- 6:03to it and make it, you know, listen, we're all
- 6:06having affairs, but tee hee. Ha ha. Yeah. Like
- 6:10to me, it was a little Dr. Seuss. Yeah. It was
- 6:13a little bit of like, I don't like that Sam.
- 6:15I am. Yeah. Just a little bit too much. Colette
- 6:18was a star bellied snitch. Yeah. Mitzi had no
- 6:22star. It felt a little like, I don't want to
- 6:25say childish because that's not the right word,
- 6:27but it just did feel like. Oh, that's what we're
- 6:30doing? Yeah. And I think that's kind of what
- 6:32I'm talking about. It like made it something
- 6:35fun to digest rather than like, I don't know,
- 6:37chicken wings and pizza at 3 a .m. That's, yep.
- 6:42I exactly know what you're talking about. Which,
- 6:44you know, is good. It's fun. It kind of messes
- 6:47with you. It's not nutritious. Exactly. That's
- 6:49okay. But delicious. You know, I just realized
- 6:51we haven't really gone through the synopsis of
- 6:53this. No, we've just alluded to it, which is
- 6:55kind of what pre -code does, right? That's so
- 6:57true. And here we are. We'll dive right into
- 6:59it. So this film depicts the faithful relationship
- 7:02between, faithful marriage even, between Andre
- 7:05and Colette. And Colette has a really good friend,
- 7:08Mitzi, that she wants to come by. And through
- 7:12a series of events, Andre and Mitzi have met
- 7:15and kind of have like a little bit of a flirtation,
- 7:17but not really. After all, he's a committed man,
- 7:20so he pulls away. But it isn't until we find
- 7:22that Mitzi is having a troubled marriage on her
- 7:25own that she then wants to kind of create some
- 7:28chaos with some other people, and specifically
- 7:30her good friend, Colette. I gotta tell you, I
- 7:33don't have any friends in my life that I'm like,
- 7:35can I ruin your marriage? Is that chill? Is that
- 7:38a chill thing for me to do right now? Right.
- 7:40So there's a lot of villainy in Mitzi for just
- 7:44kind of being bored at home and just wanting
- 7:45to, you know, if I'm not miserable at home or
- 7:47if I'm miserable at home, why aren't you? Yeah.
- 7:50And she pulls a lot of that. She's definitely
- 7:52like the definition of a homewrecker. Correct.
- 7:55And she gets between Andre and Colette. And then
- 7:58Adolf does the same here, too. I want to go ahead
- 8:01and stop right here and ask you something. You
- 8:03kind of alluded to this earlier when you mentioned
- 8:04Charles Ruggles playing Adolf. Olivier, whether
- 8:08they're married or not. I don't think they are.
- 8:10I think that Adolf is the fifth character in
- 8:13this. Well, rather, he's the fourth character.
- 8:15I think the fifth character is Mitzi's husband.
- 8:19And he's just kind of like, I think he's the
- 8:20professor. Isn't that who Adolf is? No. Professor
- 8:24Olivier is Roland Young and Charles Ruggles is
- 8:26Adolf. Adolf is just Andre's friend. They are
- 8:32the same person to me. You know what I absolutely
- 8:35love about this? This is what I love. We just
- 8:37last episode talked about how I missed such important
- 8:41context with Shanghai Express that now we're
- 8:47flipped. And I feel this is vindication. This
- 8:49is great. No. So Roland Young was the fifth character
- 8:54in this. And he really is just kind of like,
- 8:56I'm miserable. I don't like being here. He actually
- 8:59has one of my favorite lines in this. This is
- 9:01another great one with lines. He says, and I'm
- 9:04paraphrasing here. There's this really strange
- 9:06law in the world that you can't shoot your wife
- 9:09and kill her. And I was like, what is going on
- 9:12in this movie? Because if you do, you'll be arrested,
- 9:15I think is what he says. A little lighter and
- 9:17brighter of a line, but this is something that
- 9:19Andre says. Madam, you may think I am a coward.
- 9:22I am. Yeah. And he runs off. Great line. But
- 9:26my reason to bring up those two lines is that
- 9:28first line, the former, that is from The Professor.
- 9:31mitzi's husband because he just hates being married
- 9:34to mitzi and he's pretty much like solidified
- 9:37the idea with his lawyer hey man she's leaving
- 9:39at like 2 a .m this is a lock don't worry about
- 9:42it divorce easy you got everything coming to
- 9:44you and yet still later in the movie he's like
- 9:47hey man you're complicating my marriage this
- 9:50doesn't work for me i'm like doc just we all
- 9:52just need to get a divorce we need to make divorce
- 9:54much easier but something that we don't think
- 9:57about now In the 1930s, divorce was one of the
- 10:01hardest things to do. There's so many laws around
- 10:03it. And there were not really lawyers that were
- 10:05specializing in this at the time to where this
- 10:08was the easy, I mean, not that easy process,
- 10:10but it was much harder back then. Sure. So it
- 10:14was kind of hard to navigate through this of
- 10:16like, okay, if you guys aren't happy, just don't
- 10:18be together. But instead, let's ruin some people's
- 10:21lives. Yeah. And that's what ends up happening
- 10:23in this movie. Absolutely. And I think the way
- 10:26that we... we talked about Shanghai Express last
- 10:28episode and how the plot, it's not one of those
- 10:31movies where you're like, well, why are they
- 10:32doing this? That doesn't make any sense. You
- 10:34have to just throw that away and just be like,
- 10:36okay, this is kind of a fantasy world we live
- 10:39in, even though everything is based on really.
- 10:41real experiences and things right it's just it's
- 10:44silly goofy is what we're doing here it's very
- 10:46silly goofy to a point where i mean i guess i'll
- 10:49spoil this a little bit i didn't connect with
- 10:51this yeah as much as i did with love parade or
- 10:54smiling lieutenant i thought smiling lieutenant
- 10:56was like fantastic yeah so then getting to one
- 10:59hour with you this is clearly a continuation
- 11:01of the sex comedy and It has everything you're
- 11:05looking for. I don't think it necessarily has
- 11:07the direction that I loved about it. And there's
- 11:09a couple reasons for that. I think I want to
- 11:11say that for our conversation with Danny. But
- 11:13there's a couple of reasons why that might be.
- 11:16So this is kind of like a troubled production
- 11:19a little bit. And I think that bleeds into the
- 11:22movie. I think that there's some things that
- 11:24stop me from really enjoying it. A big part of
- 11:26it is the reason that... and I guess mild spoiler
- 11:30alert for everyone for about halfway through
- 11:32the movie, a lot of this is kind of like the
- 11:34confusion behind, is Andre actually cheating
- 11:37on me? Is there something going on with Andre
- 11:39at one point moves the place cards of like he
- 11:41knows Mitzi's trying to flirt with him. So he
- 11:43doesn't want Mitzi sitting next to him. So he
- 11:45moves the place cards. But by doing that, he
- 11:47actually ends up moving the place card of Mademoiselle
- 11:50Martel next to him. So Colette's now like, well,
- 11:54hey, Mitzi, I think there's something wrong with
- 11:56him and Martel because he wants to sit next to
- 11:58her. Why is that? And now there's this confusion.
- 12:01And you think, hey, here's the movie. It's like
- 12:03his life is complicated because of Mitzi. But
- 12:06then about halfway through the movie, there's
- 12:08an actual interaction between him and Mitzi,
- 12:10maybe a little more than halfway. A little more
- 12:12than an interaction, too. That's true, yeah.
- 12:14I mean, what we see is, like, we went to the
- 12:16garden together. And, like, you know, you assume.
- 12:20But even the incident of how he ends up going
- 12:21to the garden with her is like, ah, man, she
- 12:24untied my tie and I don't know how to tie my
- 12:26tie. And if I walk in here with my wife and she
- 12:28sees my tie untied, she's going to know that
- 12:30something happened, but it didn't happen. But
- 12:32now I'm going to go into the garden to get my
- 12:33tie tied and something's going to happen. But
- 12:35my tie will be tied. But my tie will be tied.
- 12:37And that's ultimately what gets him to go into
- 12:39the garden. It's like, well, I guess I'm going
- 12:41to get my tie tied. I got to point out, too,
- 12:43he makes that decision by doing the old rose
- 12:45petal. Yes. And that's a very funny scene because
- 12:49he is like, I go inside and pretend nothing happened.
- 12:52I go to the garden and I get my tide tied by
- 12:54Mitzi. And like he says that over and over and
- 12:56over and over. It's at least like five or six
- 12:58times that he says this over and over. And I
- 13:00did really like it. And the manic nature of Andre
- 13:03in this, I actually liked that version of Chevalier.
- 13:06Yes. I think that him playing just like the rascal
- 13:09of like, yeah, I'm just going to do it and it's
- 13:10going to be fine. No problem. He kind of slips
- 13:12into that towards the end of the movie, but it
- 13:14really is the first half that he's like faithful
- 13:16and trying not to like have that and put that
- 13:19all behind him. And then the manic nature of
- 13:22him just being like, Mitzi, leave me alone. I
- 13:24really liked. Yeah. So then when he kind of slips
- 13:26into like, ah, whatever, cool, we'll do it. And
- 13:29then it's like the old Chevalier. For me, it's
- 13:33just kind of like, ah, man, I really liked what
- 13:34we were doing before. That kind of sucks. It's
- 13:36so interesting when you look at the progression
- 13:38of his performances, where we started with Love
- 13:42Parade through Smiling Lieutenant to this. He's
- 13:44been less tied down starting with Love Parade.
- 13:48but somehow more charming and faithful as well.
- 13:52And now as he goes from like a very serious relationship
- 13:56in The Smiling Lieutenant to now married, he's
- 13:59been more of a scamp as time goes on. And in
- 14:02this movie, he's like the absolute worst. And
- 14:04I think to your point, like I also did not connect
- 14:07with this movie very well. And I did have to
- 14:09watch it a second time because the first time
- 14:11I was like, I hated this. I must be missing something.
- 14:14And it did help. But the weird thing about this
- 14:17is the fourth wall breaking that occurs throughout
- 14:20the entire movie. Yeah. And not just like a fun,
- 14:23like, what do you guys think? Should I cheat
- 14:27or should I not cheat? It's the point where he
- 14:29goes, don't judge me. You would have done it
- 14:32too. And I'm like, who are you? How dare you?
- 14:37What I love about the fourth wall breaking this
- 14:38movie specifically is, and this reference is
- 14:40mostly for my parents, my wife, and my in -laws,
- 14:44but it's, I kind of expected John Quincinones
- 14:46to come out of What Would You Do? Have you ever
- 14:49seen that show? I think so. It's on like ABC
- 14:51and it's like a, it's like kind of like 2020,
- 14:54but it's a 2020 extension of like, we put real
- 14:56people in situations with actors and saw what
- 14:58they would do. It's like a candid camera. Exactly.
- 15:00But it's always like a very like, you know, what
- 15:02would you do if you heard this conversation?
- 15:04Yeah. Less pranks and more. You know what? It
- 15:06is pranks. That sucks. Anyways, point is, the
- 15:09way that, like, Chevalier handles the scene,
- 15:12Andre specifically, it seems like John Quintanilla
- 15:14is just kind of coming off screen, just being
- 15:16like, hi, what would you do in this scenario?
- 15:18And it's like, not this. Like, I'm with you.
- 15:21I'm like, don't associate me with this. I wouldn't
- 15:23have done this. There's a scene at the end of
- 15:25the movie, it's the actual closing scene, where
- 15:27the musical number is not just Andre anymore,
- 15:30but now it's Andre and Colette. And they're both
- 15:33like, well, look, I was put in this situation.
- 15:36You were put in this situation. What would you
- 15:39have done? The same thing. I'm like, no, I wouldn't
- 15:41have. Stop this. Chill out. Chill out with the
- 15:44accusations. Yeah, this was, I didn't hate it.
- 15:48I want to clarify that. I didn't hate it. It
- 15:50was my least favorite of the three that we've
- 15:52seen with Lubitsch for this run so far. Right.
- 15:55But I did appreciate where I know where it went.
- 15:58This did feel the most like a sex comedy that
- 16:00we would see like today. But definitely like
- 16:02the whole how he actually does end up like sleeping
- 16:05with Mitzi and like being involved with Mitzi.
- 16:08And then Colette and how she ends up with like.
- 16:11Adolf like that. It just felt kind of rushed.
- 16:14Like this just happened to happen and it didn't
- 16:16feel like an organic part of the story. Yeah.
- 16:18So for me, I was kind of like pulled away by
- 16:20that. It wasn't as interested. One thing I did
- 16:23like, and this is like, I'm, I'm asking, asking
- 16:26for, I want cake and to eat it too. Right. Okay.
- 16:29Is the scene where Colette is so convinced that
- 16:32Andre is having an affair and she thinks it's
- 16:35with Martel and she's crying in the bed. after
- 16:38their party and he's like look what can i can
- 16:40do to convince you that i'm faithful to you and
- 16:43he looks at his watch and realizes that he has
- 16:46like i think exactly two minutes for the car
- 16:49he's like what can i do in the next two minutes
- 16:51to convince you that i'm faithful and i think
- 16:55that little line is very cute and like i get
- 16:57it and There's something about that whole infidelity
- 17:00thing that to me was just like, ah, I can't rock
- 17:02with that. Yeah. It doesn't feel right for your
- 17:04character. Well, because there's the other part
- 17:06of that scene where she thinks that he has had
- 17:09an affair with Miss Martell. Right. When he,
- 17:11in fact, has had an affair with Mitzi. And when
- 17:14she accuses him of being with Miss Martell, he
- 17:17starts laughing at her. And he's like, no, that's
- 17:19ridiculous. Unbeknownst to her that it's Mitzi.
- 17:22Yeah. So it's almost like, ha, I would never
- 17:25do that. With her. And it's just like, damn,
- 17:28dude, chill out. You're laughing in her face.
- 17:31He's kind of a really despicable character. And
- 17:34while everybody does kind of, you know, nobody
- 17:37is faithful in this movie at all. I think that
- 17:39he is the worst offender by far in this. And
- 17:42the fact that he is also the one that stands
- 17:44in front of the screen and is like, yeah, we're
- 17:47all unfaithful and so are you. Okay. Sure. It
- 17:52just kind of ends up being like a wash situation
- 17:54where they're like, ah, you made some mistakes.
- 17:56I made some mistakes. What I did like is how
- 17:58this ends up in the conversation. I mean, it
- 18:01doesn't feel good, but I did see like the cute
- 18:03like rom -com nature of it where he tells her
- 18:07everything he did with like Mitzi and like, you
- 18:09know, I've been unfaithful. And she's like, this
- 18:11is so funny because I have been too. And it's
- 18:13with Adolf. And he's like, that's hysterical.
- 18:15Like, that's so cute that you would try and do
- 18:17that. She's like, no, for real, look. And, like,
- 18:19Adolph, who just happens to be there, she's like,
- 18:22okay, come in here. Like, her back is to Andre,
- 18:25and she's facing Adolph. And she's like, did
- 18:28we not, like, embrace in the dark after the party?
- 18:31And Adolph kind of looks over her shoulder at
- 18:33Maurice, and Maurice is like, yeah, say yes,
- 18:36man. Make her feel better. Like, lie to her.
- 18:38That's fine. And you have that, like. He gets
- 18:41to admit it out loud, but like make Andre feel
- 18:44like he's doing a favor for him. Yes. I thought
- 18:46that was really funny. Especially the thing that
- 18:49sold it for me is Maurice's like exaggerated
- 18:51like hands of like, yes. And I know, sorry, audience,
- 18:55you can't see me doing this. But watch the movie
- 18:57because his gestures here are so funny to me.
- 19:00I talked about how in Smiling Lieutenant, that
- 19:02line of him having, you know, this is my limit.
- 19:05That's it. Like his hand signals. I think Maurice
- 19:08is an incredible like physical actor. So I really
- 19:11like that portion. So there's things like that
- 19:13that stand out to me of like, I really like portions
- 19:16of this. But overall, this just feels like the
- 19:18least cohesive of the three. Yeah, I think that's
- 19:22a big thing. What with just the theme and kind
- 19:26of how kind of dirty the whole thing feels. Yeah.
- 19:29And how much it's promoting it in a way. I don't
- 19:33like that. But even if you remove that, the story
- 19:36itself feels kind of convoluted with the... I'm
- 19:40not having an affair with this person, but I
- 19:42am with that person. And the fact that there
- 19:45are two guys in this that I thought were the
- 19:46same person, maybe that's just me. But it just,
- 19:50I don't know, it gets a little confusing at times.
- 19:53But as far as the comedy goes, I think there
- 19:56are some solid moments in this. I adore when
- 20:00Maurice does his first fourth wall breaking.
- 20:03And I think he's just kind of setting up. the
- 20:06the story itself and he's like yeah i'm faithful
- 20:08to my wife mitzi's about to show up and i don't
- 20:12know how i feel about that whatever but as he
- 20:14finishes that that monologue and goes to turn
- 20:16and walk away he turns back and he's like people
- 20:18of france and just disappears And that killed
- 20:21me. I just thought that was so funny. And it
- 20:22really is based on like his delivery of his lines.
- 20:25He's so funny. He really is always, when he's
- 20:28on screen, he's the one everyone's looking at.
- 20:30Yeah. I do want to give credit to Jeanette McDonald.
- 20:32I think she's fantastic in this. It seems like
- 20:35she's trying to have as much fun as Maurice does.
- 20:38I don't know if the camera follows her near as
- 20:39much as it does Andre. So then Maurice gets a
- 20:43little bit more of a chance to kind of like,
- 20:44you know. ham it up but i thought she was i really
- 20:47liked her in this a little bit more than love
- 20:48parade because in love parade i think she has
- 20:51a different role to play and in this she really
- 20:52is kind of like in the trenches with him yeah
- 20:54for most of it which i i think she's really great
- 20:57at one thing i do want to mention is while jeanette
- 20:59mcdonald is having a lot of fun with it i think
- 21:01she is kind of the setup to the the story or
- 21:04the punchline and then the punchline itself is
- 21:06generally ends up being Maurice and Andre's character.
- 21:10There's a scene and we'll talk about this with
- 21:12Danny towards the beginning where they're in
- 21:13their bed together and the lights turning off
- 21:16or like he's trying to go to sleep or like trying
- 21:18to make something happen, turning the light off
- 21:19and on. And she turns it back on and she's trying
- 21:23to talk about Mitzi. Yeah. And he says this thing
- 21:25that just like son of a gun, there's always like
- 21:27one recurring theme or ta ta ta ta ta ta ta that
- 21:30kind of comes through the one in this movie.
- 21:32is the Mitzi, Itzy, Bitsy, Gritsy or something
- 21:35like that. Like Mitzi, Itzy, Bitsy. I think it's
- 21:38Mitzi, Bitsy, Itzy, either way. He says that
- 21:40a lot. And the reason that this stuck with me
- 21:43was the first time that he says it, he's trying
- 21:45to turn off the light and she turns it back on
- 21:47to have the conversation. And while she's talking,
- 21:49he has this look like, yes, please go on while
- 21:51he's unscrewing the light bulb. And then he just
- 21:54like smashes it. And he's like, good night, Mitzi,
- 21:56Itzy, Bitsy. And like goes to sleep. And then
- 21:59he continues that as she's like, hey, Mitzi's
- 22:01coming over. God, Mitzi, Bitsy, Itzy. He's really
- 22:05funny. And like, I kind of almost feel like,
- 22:07tell me if you think this is true. It feels like
- 22:10he's on set and he just makes something up. And
- 22:13like the crew loves it. And he's like, yeah,
- 22:15I'm going to use that. It does kind of feel that
- 22:17way. And I wonder if any of that is true. It
- 22:21can't be with the ratatatatata because it's in
- 22:23the score. Yeah. But like specifically the son
- 22:25of a gun, there's something in the love parade
- 22:28that's like that too. I'm forgetting now. But
- 22:30then the Mitzi thing here, it definitely feels
- 22:32like he just kind of riffs. And the minute that
- 22:34like Ernst laughs, he's like, there it is. Yeah.
- 22:37I'm going to say this as many times as I can
- 22:38in this movie, but it feels like the formula
- 22:41is there. It feels like a Lubitsch film. It feels
- 22:44like Chevalier is doing what he needs to do in
- 22:47this. And he is firing. But again, there's something
- 22:50disconnected about the movie itself. And I think
- 22:53there's a reason for that. And that seems like
- 22:55a really good cliffhanger to lead into our interview
- 22:57with Danny here. Yeah. I'm going to leave that
- 23:00as a cliffhanger. Yeah, I think that's a good
- 23:02call. Most of the stuff that I think I want to
- 23:05talk about now involves the pre -code nature
- 23:07of the film and how heavy this is on the sexual
- 23:11innuendos and it being a sex comedy. So I think
- 23:14that is a good moment to swap over. And I think
- 23:16that Lubitsch as a director knows his way around
- 23:21how he wants to do that, but some other directors
- 23:23may not. And I think that lends to the conversation.
- 23:25So I'm excited to talk with Danny about that.
- 23:28So do you want to get to our ratings on this?
- 23:31Or do you have anything else you'd like to mention?
- 23:32Yeah, I think we can get into ratings. Cool.
- 23:34I had mine pulled up. And then I just, I don't
- 23:37know if you've done this before. You're like,
- 23:38cool, I got my app pulled up. No problem. But
- 23:39then you open five other apps. So now when you
- 23:42open your phone, you're like, scroll, scroll,
- 23:43scroll. You're doing it anyways. Anyways, you
- 23:45dirty rat. What happened? You just changed your
- 23:49score. That's because I rewatched it. So that's
- 23:51legal. I just saw. This is legal. Okay. All right.
- 23:55So my rating is two stars. I gave this two stars.
- 23:59It feels a little dirty. Not the movie, my rating.
- 24:02It feels dirty to give it two stars because I've
- 24:05seen some movies that I was like, ah, man, I
- 24:07did not care for that at all. Two stars. And
- 24:09with this, I have more appreciation for it. But
- 24:12in terms of an enjoyment factor, it was not there.
- 24:16Maybe this is having enjoyed the Lubitsch films
- 24:19as much as I have, that this was kind of like
- 24:21a down moment for that. And that's why I rated
- 24:24it two. Yeah, it feels weird rating it that low,
- 24:27but I do stand by that at this point. It did
- 24:29not feel connected as a story. I wasn't as interested.
- 24:32It didn't feel like, while the performances are
- 24:35there, it just didn't feel like a Lubitsch film
- 24:38like we've seen previously. Yeah. Maybe I just
- 24:39want a more smiling lieutenant. I don't know.
- 24:41Yeah, that might be it. I really don't know what
- 24:43was lacking, and hopefully our conversation with
- 24:46Danny opens or opened, depending on when this
- 24:49gets placed in the episode. Kind of reveals that
- 24:52a little bit more for me. I had to watch it twice,
- 24:55like I said. Your first rating was two. It was.
- 24:59It was two. And I think I paid, like once I realized,
- 25:03okay, this story is going to be something that
- 25:05is just morally, what are we doing? Once I got
- 25:08past that and I just kind of enjoyed the music
- 25:10and the jokes and things, I found a little bit
- 25:13more enjoyment. Exactly half a star more. So
- 25:16I gave it two and a half stars. Kudos to you
- 25:18for seeing a movie that you hated. And you're
- 25:20like, I got to rewatch that. Because that's not
- 25:23always my first thought when I hate a movie too.
- 25:25And I will say, I think a big reason is because
- 25:28I knew Danny was going to be talking with us.
- 25:31And I didn't want to go into that interview and
- 25:32be like, so Danny, tell me why this movie is
- 25:34awful. You know? So tell me why you like this
- 25:36movie that sucks so much, Danny. Yeah. But yeah,
- 25:40two and a half stars is what I gave it. I think
- 25:42this is definitely the lowest of the Lubitsch
- 25:44and the Chevalier. collaborations we've seen.
- 25:46But I do think it's very funny. I do wonder if
- 25:50I hadn't done some research on what happened
- 25:53behind the scenes here, if that would change
- 25:54my rating of it. But I feel like even having
- 25:58a slight explanation of why that might be, it's
- 26:00again, sorry for the cliffhanger, everybody,
- 26:02but we'll get there in a second. Even with that
- 26:05explanation, I feel like my rating is still a
- 26:07two. So I feel like it's pretty confident. I'm
- 26:10confident in my two. Yeah. Let's get to double
- 26:12features. Totally. For double features, I was
- 26:15thinking about the idea of Mitzi just wanting
- 26:17to come in and just completely destroy this relationship.
- 26:20And while Mitzi and Adolf are not together, I
- 26:24can't confirm that for you now, it does feel
- 26:26like kind of an agreed partnership of like...
- 26:29Let's get into this relationship and ruin this.
- 26:31And to me, that kind of reminded me of Cruel
- 26:33Intentions from 1999, the Roger Cumble movie
- 26:35starring Sarah Michelle Gellar, Ryan Phillippe,
- 26:38and Reese Witherspoon as two siblings who both
- 26:43try to romance an individual. It felt not so
- 26:46much like the comedy of that. It's obviously
- 26:48a pretty dramatic film. But the idea of how to
- 26:51use sex and how to use romance, both from the
- 26:55male and female perspective, it reminded me a
- 26:58little bit of Cruel Intentions. Tone, pretty
- 27:00different. But just in subject matter, I felt
- 27:03like those were two very united films in the
- 27:05way that they looked at how you can seduce and...
- 27:10darkly romanticize someone. So I thought that
- 27:13was an interesting pairing. So Cruel Intentions,
- 27:151999. No, I like that a lot. Similar to what
- 27:18I did with Shanghai Express, mine's kind of more
- 27:21of, oh, here's an opportunity to explore something
- 27:24similar from the same director. Sure. So I went
- 27:28with, yet again, another movie I've not seen
- 27:30yet, but I've heard so much about. We've now
- 27:33seen three Lubitsch films with Maurice Chevalier.
- 27:36I want to know what a solid... Lubitsch film
- 27:39is that doesn't have the opportunity to utilize
- 27:43Chevalier's zany, offbeat French performance.
- 27:47Right. So I went with 1932's Trouble in Paradise.
- 27:50Oh. Yeah, which actually, I believe it was the
- 27:53Plaza just last month screened, and I'm sad that
- 27:58I didn't go and see it. But this stars Herbert
- 28:00Marshall, Kay Francis, and Miriam Hopkins, Return
- 28:03of Her. Also, Charles Ruggles is in that movie.
- 28:06What is this guy not doing? I feel like whenever
- 28:08Chevalier has always mentioned Ruggles, I thought
- 28:12Chevalier was this guy. I think Ruggles might
- 28:13be his guy, too. I think so, yeah. But, yeah,
- 28:16honestly, I don't know anything about this movie,
- 28:18but I love the idea of sitting down to watch
- 28:20a Lubitsch film that is held in such high regard
- 28:22that doesn't have Chevalier. Yeah. Because the
- 28:26only other Lubitsch movie I've seen is the one
- 28:30with Jimmy Stewart, Shop Around the Corner. I've
- 28:33seen a Lubitsch film then before this. Because
- 28:35The Shop Around the Corner is the film that You've
- 28:37Got Mail is based on. Yeah, yeah. And I saw that
- 28:40because my You've Got Mail Blu -ray collection
- 28:43comes with the Blu -ray for Shop Around the Corner.
- 28:45There you go. Oh, interesting. Yeah. That's cool.
- 28:47Not a musical. Not a musical. No. So very good
- 28:51though. So great to know that he still balances
- 28:53that pretty well. Yeah. So yeah, that's ratings
- 28:55and reviews. I think what we'll do now is we'll
- 28:59cut over to the interview with Danny and we'll
- 29:01talk all pre -code and all of the sexcapades
- 29:04that take place in this movie. And it should
- 29:07be a blast. So stay tuned for that. Well, not
- 29:10stay tuned. It's like right now. So as long as
- 29:12you don't turn it off right now. How about let's
- 29:14instead say we'll cut now to our interview with
- 29:17Danny on Pre -Code Essentials to talk a little
- 29:20bit more about One Hour With You and some behind
- 29:23the scenes stuff. Enjoy. All right. So we are
- 29:26here with Danny Reed, co -author of the book
- 29:29Precode Essentials. We spoke last week with Kim,
- 29:34and now we have you here, Danny. Welcome. Thank
- 29:36you so much for joining us. Thanks for having
- 29:38me. Yeah, I'm really excited. I know both you
- 29:41and Kim originally picked Bad Girl to cover,
- 29:45and we had just finished that episode. So I want
- 29:48to start off with what... drew you to One Hour
- 29:51With You to be your movie? It is one of my favorite
- 29:54films. So I'm looking forward to finding out
- 29:56what your guys' ratings were for it because on
- 29:58Letterboxd, it's pretty decisive or divisive.
- 30:01I really appreciate it. I think I love a lot
- 30:04of Lubitsch's. He's one of my favorite directors.
- 30:07I think One Hour With You is kind of like this
- 30:08hidden little gem where there's so many little
- 30:10interesting things being done throughout it.
- 30:12And it's still very, very funny. It's like the
- 30:15hardest I think I'll ever laugh in my life is
- 30:17someone just standing up. But it's played so
- 30:19perfectly that it's just, you know, I just bust
- 30:22up every time. So I really enjoy it. It has one
- 30:25of my favorite pre -code stars in it, which is
- 30:27Genevieve Tobin. She played Mitzi in the film.
- 30:29And she has a fascinating career that's not talked
- 30:32about a whole lot because she kind of jumped
- 30:33between studios. So I just love her and I love
- 30:36that film. And I think it's probably one of the
- 30:38funniest movies from the early 30s, in my opinion.
- 30:41Yeah. It's funny because what we talked about
- 30:44in the episode was exactly that, where I think
- 30:47that this movie more so than the other two films
- 30:50that we've watched of Lubitsch with Maurice Chevalier
- 30:52is his physical comedy. And this is like so on
- 30:56display. I'm thinking specifically of when he's
- 30:58having that like secret conversation with Adolph
- 31:00over Colette's back where he's like emphatically
- 31:04moving his hands to be like, yes, say yes. And
- 31:08that physical comedy of Maurice is so good in
- 31:11this. And I think he's kind of had a little bit
- 31:13of that, but we talked about his like, not maturity,
- 31:15but his growth as like a physical comedian in
- 31:18this. So is that for you, like your favorite
- 31:20of the Maurice and Lubitsch films? Is it one
- 31:25hour with you? Yeah, I think it's, this is the
- 31:27second to last one. I think Mary Widow comes
- 31:28out in 34, which is kind of a mixed bag because
- 31:31that's at MGM. And so they go all in on being
- 31:34glossy and glitzy, which is, it's fine. Like
- 31:36it's still pretty funny, but. In terms of Chevalier
- 31:39and Lubitsch, I think this is probably my favorite
- 31:41of theirs. I do think, and this is one of the
- 31:44movies in our book, Love Me Tonight, which is
- 31:47another Jeanette MacDonald, Marie Chevalier movie,
- 31:50but it was Ruben Mamoulian who did it. He was
- 31:52just given the directions you have these two
- 31:54stars go, and he just tried to outdo Lubitsch
- 31:56at every turn. And I think that's my favorite
- 31:59of their pairings, but this one's solid too.
- 32:01Like, I'm not complaining. Yeah, so far we've
- 32:05covered The Love Parade and The Smiling Lieutenant.
- 32:07So this is our third one. And you mentioned this
- 32:10being kind of divisive on Letterboxd. And I think
- 32:13that for both of us, we would agree that this
- 32:15is probably our least favorite of the three that
- 32:18we've covered. Do you think that kind of the
- 32:21morality of the film has like a negative effect
- 32:25to most viewers, the way it kind of promotes
- 32:27the infidelity plotline? Well, that's kind of
- 32:31the thing about it, and I'm not going to dismiss
- 32:33the average Letterboxd viewer. First of all,
- 32:36this is Lubitsch Paris. This is not real Paris.
- 32:39This is a fantasy world. This is his idea of
- 32:42Europe. This is paramount Europe. I think, like
- 32:44Billy Wilder said, that they're very different
- 32:45things. And so you kind of have to take morality
- 32:48with a grain of salt. Obviously, the main plot
- 32:51line of this film is Chevalier cheating on Jeanette
- 32:54McDonald with Genevieve Tobin. But in reality,
- 32:57the whole movie is just about like miscommunication
- 32:59and just. misunderstandings and just how love
- 33:04could be misdirected and misguided uh at the
- 33:06end i don't think anybody has a clear idea of
- 33:08what happened actually like you kind of all just
- 33:11get these implications and inferences from both
- 33:13sides where chevalier doesn't know that jeanette
- 33:16mcdonald really did have kind of a moment with
- 33:17um charles ruggles and you know she doesn't quite
- 33:20understand what was going on with madame mattel
- 33:22there's just all these little complications and
- 33:25switcheroos I think the main thing that I disagree
- 33:28with a lot of the Letterboxd viewers is if you
- 33:30watch this movie and you think that at the end,
- 33:33Chevalier was absolutely right and that cheating
- 33:35on your wife looks great, I think that's weird
- 33:37and insane because really it's about relationships
- 33:41and how at the beginning of the movie, they're
- 33:43in year three of their marriage and they're still
- 33:45going to the park to make out. And by the end
- 33:47of the movie, they're still together and they're
- 33:48still very much in love. And it's just learning
- 33:50more about each other, learning more about each
- 33:52other's desires and their foibles. And they become
- 33:55more human to each other in a way, which is weird
- 33:57to say in a movie that's like half musical, half
- 33:59like rhyming couplets. And, you know, it's a
- 34:02very fantastical tale to say that. But that's
- 34:06just my opinion. I know one of those things is
- 34:09I've watched a lot of movies from the early 1930s,
- 34:12like somewhere around 800 of them at this point.
- 34:14And there's a lot of movies about infidelity
- 34:18and just... the way infidelity was handled back
- 34:20then was a lot different than the way people
- 34:22would handle it today. Especially here where
- 34:25it's clearly in like a joking manner, it's trying
- 34:27to say stuff about the relationship. And I don't
- 34:30know if that's one of those things that I see
- 34:32it through that lens, or if I'm just seeing it
- 34:35differently than a lot of other people. I don't
- 34:37think this movie is coming out and saying like,
- 34:39you know, Chevalier, his character, the doctor
- 34:42was doing the right thing whenever he did what
- 34:45he did. But I think it's more of a, uh avenues
- 34:49used to explore his weaknesses because you know
- 34:53you're paying 50 cents a nickel a dime whatever
- 34:56to go see a marie chevalier movie you know every
- 34:58woman in that movie is at risk um and they set
- 35:01that up early on too with the pictures of him
- 35:03at his wedding and he shows him and it's just
- 35:05him surrounded by all the bridesmaids drinking
- 35:07out of their shoes and while he might be in love
- 35:09with his wife it's not like this guy is on the
- 35:12straight and narrow you don't think this guy
- 35:13got through medical school on skill alone i mean
- 35:15he uh There's probably a Dean's wife somewhere
- 35:18who's very happy. So that's just kind of my take
- 35:21on it. But I get where other people are coming
- 35:23from. No, I think you're 100 % right. Fantastical
- 35:26Paris, or as you coined it. Lubitsch's Paris,
- 35:30that makes plenty of sense. And I did enjoy the
- 35:34comedy of that a lot. We talked a lot about that
- 35:36on the episode too, is the comedy of this is
- 35:39just, it's perfect, Lubitsch. And it feels great
- 35:41with that. One thing I wanted to talk about is
- 35:43that this was kind of the pioneer in what it
- 35:47did, because one of the first scenes in this,
- 35:49you talked about that scene in the park, but
- 35:51then it cuts to their bedroom. And it's one of
- 35:53the first films pre -code that actually showed
- 35:55like a married couple in bed together. So can
- 35:58you talk to us a little bit about like when it
- 35:59comes to pre -code, like how this fit into that
- 36:03journey into code in 19, was it 35 or 34? Yeah,
- 36:08July of 34. Yeah. So this film, the way that
- 36:12there's different ways to understand pre -code
- 36:14Hollywood, and some of them are just on a pure
- 36:16timeline basis. Some of them are technical basis.
- 36:18Some of them are on. the reaction basis right
- 36:21so in 1929 1930 talkies get adopted and as that's
- 36:25happening all these studios are leveraging so
- 36:27much money uh and when that happens in the great
- 36:30depression hits suddenly every studio is bleeding
- 36:32cash right left and right during 1930 and 1934
- 36:36we're talking about third biggest industry in
- 36:38the entire country is filmmaking at this point
- 36:40only company that's actually making money is
- 36:42mgm everyone else is in the red um there's Companies
- 36:46trying to merge, trying to decouple, trying to
- 36:48recouple. They've spent all this money wiring
- 36:50their theaters for sound, and it's going terribly.
- 36:53And during this time, they try different things.
- 36:56They're trying to ride trends. There's no TV.
- 36:58Radio is super expensive, so your only competition
- 37:01is newspapers. So they try different trends to
- 37:04bring people into the theater. And a lot of times,
- 37:08as they progress through the early 1930s, it
- 37:10becomes more and more desperate. In 1930, they
- 37:13make so many musicals. And by they, I mean like
- 37:16the five major studios, MGM, Warner Brothers,
- 37:18Paramount. Oh, I shouldn't have tried to list
- 37:21them all. But they're all making musicals hand
- 37:24over foot because that's what's making money.
- 37:26But they're making so many musicals, it completely
- 37:28collapses the entire musical industry. Like people
- 37:30will just refuse to go see musicals and suddenly
- 37:32have these very expensive productions no one's
- 37:34going to see. So what's interesting with One
- 37:36Hour With You is it is a musical. It comes out
- 37:38in 1932. Musicals don't... really come back in
- 37:41terms of box office appeal until 42nd Street,
- 37:45which I believe you guys will cover in the next
- 37:47year. But this is an interesting moment where
- 37:52you see the power and appeal of Lubitsch. Now,
- 37:55Lubitsch was at Paramount, which was a very loosey
- 37:57-goosey studio. You just had producers going
- 37:59off and doing whatever, which is why it was a
- 38:00great comedian studio, because the Marx Brothers
- 38:02would just go off and make a movie and come back
- 38:04and be like, okay, I guess we're going to release
- 38:05this. And Lubitsch really... excelled at having
- 38:10that kind of freedom and so he made a lot of
- 38:12movies they're very risque and very daring but
- 38:14even the censors admired him because they're
- 38:16so well made and so tight and so uh you know
- 38:21a lot of what censorship comes down to is what
- 38:24you're saying versus what you're implying versus
- 38:26what you can say what you can't imply and so
- 38:28one hour with you even though it is very clearly
- 38:30about um infidelity and it's about you know there's
- 38:34moments where They just like seeing Charles Ruggles
- 38:37in his tights, you know? Lubitsch puts it all
- 38:40with such class and grace that even the censors
- 38:42were kind of charmed by it and let a lot of this
- 38:44stuff get by. Now, there's going to be a lot
- 38:47of movies from Warner Brothers and other studios
- 38:48that keep getting crasser and crasser as you
- 38:50kind of lose that appeal. But Lubitsch really
- 38:53was at the height of his game. His next two movies
- 38:55are Trouble in Paradise and Design for Living,
- 38:57which are the two we picked for our book because
- 38:59they are iconic for a reason. Trouble in Paradise
- 39:02is probably one of the few perfect films ever
- 39:04made. But in terms of when this came out, this
- 39:08was really like this early 1930s. Lubitsch can
- 39:11do this. Not many other people have the skill
- 39:14or ability to make a movie like this. And so
- 39:16he kind of has this talent, has this ability
- 39:19to make a movie. And that's why it was so acclaimed
- 39:22and so loved, is because really there are so
- 39:24few other people who are able to have the technical
- 39:26ability and the sophistication to make something
- 39:29this sophisticated at that point. It's really
- 39:33interesting. Like you say how he was kind of
- 39:36able to get away with so much because he was
- 39:38so good at what he did. And like he was able
- 39:40to put a charm on it, even to persuade like the
- 39:43production code office and all of that. We think
- 39:46we both agree that like this movie really ups
- 39:50the like sexual innuendos and just the level
- 39:53of spice altogether from what we've seen for
- 39:56the Lubitsch films we've covered on the show
- 39:58so far. Is that really what it is? Like he's
- 40:01just reached a comfort level where he's like,
- 40:03I can do this and probably nobody's going to
- 40:06say much. Well, I know the movie, it is a remake
- 40:08of The Marriage Circle, which I believe he did
- 40:10in 22. So there's familiar territory. There's
- 40:13an argument he can make, like people have seen
- 40:16this movie before. I can kind of go in that same
- 40:18direction and you can't be offended by it because
- 40:20obviously this movie made a lot of money 20 or
- 40:2210 years ago. And so I feel like he felt at the
- 40:25time, and I don't know if you talked about this
- 40:28already or not. whenever he put this movie into
- 40:30production, he felt like he had the ability to
- 40:32make something with this sort of sophisticated
- 40:34nature without running into too much pushback.
- 40:36But then again, there's also behind the scenes
- 40:38drama with this that might lead you to believe
- 40:40whether or not like, was this something that
- 40:42he thought, or was this something about the other
- 40:44director thought? So it's a really like, I wouldn't
- 40:48say like, this is the most explicit sexually
- 40:51explicit pre -code from this time. I mean, this
- 40:52is around the era of like Call Her Savage and
- 40:55some other very dirty movies that just don't
- 40:59have the sophistication that Lubitsch uses. But
- 41:01I would say that as you progress from 30 to 34,
- 41:05I don't know if you guys will see this as much
- 41:07based on what's nominated for Best Picture, but
- 41:09as the movies are being made, you get to a lot
- 41:11more wild things. For example, in 1934, I know
- 41:16there's no way in hell this is going to be on
- 41:17your podcast, there's a movie called Murder of
- 41:19the Vanities, which we cover in our book, where
- 41:21there's this whole song and dance number where
- 41:23Kitty Carlyle's grinning about sweet marijuana.
- 41:26And while she's singing the song, which is very
- 41:28like honest, like half the censors don't know
- 41:31what marijuana is at this point. And while she's
- 41:33singing this, there's a bunch of women in cactuses,
- 41:35but they're all half naked and they're just kind
- 41:37of covering themselves with their hands. And
- 41:40that is just shot after shot of these beautiful,
- 41:42almost bare -breasted women. You're just waiting
- 41:44for one of them to sneeze. Eventually, what happens
- 41:47is that it's a murder at the Vanities. Blood
- 41:49starts dripping at one, and she screams. And
- 41:51it's a very evocative image. But even then, there's
- 41:54so many movies around that time where they're
- 41:57getting so close. Tarzan and his mate, where
- 41:59there's full nudity, depending on which version
- 42:01of the movie you see. So it really is kind of
- 42:04a progression. And the production code kind of
- 42:06just... comes down and says, no, slow down, start
- 42:09over again. We'll figure it out from here. And
- 42:11that changes a lot of things for Hollywood. Yeah,
- 42:14I definitely want to lean into a bit of what
- 42:16you kind of alluded to there with the behind
- 42:18the scenes is that I think that's something that's
- 42:20really interesting with this movie specifically
- 42:22is that there feels like there's like a Lubitsch
- 42:24touch, right? Specifically to this kind of story.
- 42:28And that's surprising because a lot of what was
- 42:30directed, or at least some of what was directed
- 42:33with this, wasn't really Lubitsch specifically.
- 42:36From what I read, Wildly was off schedule because
- 42:39he was filming Broken Lullaby, which came out
- 42:41in 1932 as well. And then was it George Cukor
- 42:44who took over and filmed some of those scenes?
- 42:46Can you speak a bit to what that looked like
- 42:49behind the scenes? I don't have a lot of detailed
- 42:52information. And to this day, it's very controversial.
- 42:54Some people say that... Lubitsch just came in
- 42:57and slapped his name on the end credits that
- 43:00it was all him. I don't think that's true. Some
- 43:02people say it was two weeks. Some people say
- 43:04that because of contracts, they're both on set.
- 43:07It could go either way. Cukor, I think this is
- 43:10his first movie as a director. It's pretty close,
- 43:12if not. He goes on to be a very prolific director,
- 43:15obviously. You're going to see a lot of him.
- 43:17And it really comes down to whose style you feel
- 43:20you see more of. In terms of the creation, again,
- 43:25this was going to be Lubitsch's production until
- 43:27Kukor took over. In terms of script and everything,
- 43:30you definitely see Lubitsch. In terms of direction,
- 43:33it feels like Lubitsch, but Kukor also had that
- 43:36sophisticated look as well. He went to MGM. He
- 43:38made The Women. So I don't know. It's one of
- 43:41those big things where it could go either way.
- 43:44It feels so much like Lubitsch. I don't see why
- 43:47it wouldn't be included in a Lubitsch collection.
- 43:49Obviously, his name's on there. But I would just,
- 43:53it's up for grabs. And I don't know if there's
- 43:56anybody who's a big fan of George Cukor who'd
- 43:58be like, yeah, that should be ours too in terms
- 44:00of film authorship. But it's an interesting,
- 44:03you know, idea. I just, everything I've read
- 44:06about Lubitsch, I don't see him having that kind
- 44:07of ego, but. You know, it's 90 years ago. What
- 44:10the hell do I know about some of this stuff?
- 44:12Well, and for what it's worth, I agree with you.
- 44:15I think Kyle does as well that this feels so
- 44:17Lubitsch that it's hard to imagine that this
- 44:19is like he came in and slapped his name on it,
- 44:21right? Also, I read some reports that Chevalier
- 44:25and Cougar did not get along extremely well.
- 44:29And that's interesting because I think the performance
- 44:31that we see from him in the movie, it just feels
- 44:33like every... if not at his peak in terms of
- 44:37his performance, it feels very much like that
- 44:39Lubitsch film. So I was interested to read that.
- 44:42I think that may be a little bit of what the
- 44:43hesitation that I had towards the film was it
- 44:46didn't feel... Coherent isn't really the right
- 44:48word, but something felt a little strange. So
- 44:50I wasn't sure if that was some of my research,
- 44:52but I'm glad to hear you speak on that a bit
- 44:54because I was wondering about that too. But I
- 44:57agree. I mean, it feels so Lubitsch that I think
- 45:00he was involved at least halfway through. Yeah.
- 45:03Yeah, there's definitely, it's one of those things
- 45:05where both, like Lubitsch has such a specific
- 45:08style that you see so much of it there. Cukor
- 45:11also has a similar style, but just because the
- 45:13nature of the material, you can't suss out as
- 45:15well. So that's one of those things. I've read
- 45:18a, I was working, I've been writing an essay
- 45:21about the nature of film authorship, just as
- 45:25an academic work. And I bought a book that was
- 45:27just like, is there really film authorship? And
- 45:30it goes through and like take apart every single
- 45:32idea of a theory of like the writer's the author,
- 45:34the producer's the author, the director's the
- 45:36author. And they're, you know, it's really interesting
- 45:38when you try and like break it down to the brass
- 45:40tacks of whose film is this. I think for film
- 45:42nerds like us, it's easiest just to say, well,
- 45:44it's a Lubitsch movie or it's a Kukor movie.
- 45:46And sometimes I don't think, I think this film
- 45:48is very muddy, but it's muddied by a lot of geniuses,
- 45:51a lot of great people. So it's not the worst.
- 45:54Worst thing you have to worry about. You can't
- 45:55just say, well, this is a great movie except
- 45:57for that one piece, which must have wanted this
- 45:59one guy, which ruined everything, you know? Yeah.
- 46:01I think I got lost a little bit when I was trying
- 46:04to determine what is it about this one that I
- 46:07don't like as much as Smiling Lieutenant and
- 46:09all of that. And I started to blame Cukor. And
- 46:13then I was like, no, because I like him, too.
- 46:15I love the Philadelphia story. So the only thing
- 46:18that I could really pick out is that. The way
- 46:21that music was handled in this movie was a little
- 46:24bit different than Smiling Lieutenant, where
- 46:26I feel like a lot of the physical actions that
- 46:28take place on screen in the Smiling Lieutenant
- 46:31early in the movie, there's someone running up
- 46:34the stairs and there's kind of that the music
- 46:37is playing like the sound of footsteps in a way.
- 46:39And there's not a lot of that here. A lot of
- 46:42the action is a little more stagnant on the screen,
- 46:45I feel. I could see that. Yeah. Yeah. And I don't
- 46:48know if maybe that's what it is that. I like
- 46:50less. I'm not able to pinpoint what it is. No,
- 46:54that's fair. I could see the aesthetics being
- 46:56different. It's one thing I always keep in mind
- 47:00in the early 30s is just how bulky camera equipment
- 47:02and sound equipment was. And that's why you guys
- 47:05went through 29 through 31. You know, a lot of
- 47:07those movies were just single shots. uh very
- 47:09can be very theatrical very staged yeah um and
- 47:1332 is when they really start emerging from that
- 47:15um but a lot of directors it's the same with
- 47:17sound as people are still learning how to be
- 47:19able to use that sort of thing um i think you're
- 47:22talking about in that episode uh something about
- 47:25when they use sound and when they didn't like
- 47:27for when doors were being knocked on or people
- 47:29were entering rooms and i think that's a really
- 47:31interesting moment to understand how how new
- 47:34of a category sound design was and how they're
- 47:37figuring out like, we should emphasize this,
- 47:39we should do that. I think the first movie with
- 47:41like a dedicated score is King Kong, which comes
- 47:43out in 33. So there's just, everything is very
- 47:47new, very raw. And we have, you know, almost
- 47:50a century of experience of understanding and
- 47:52watching these things and, and working with them.
- 47:54So it's, it's difficult to go back and try and
- 47:57process some of that stuff. Just how raw and
- 48:00different that could be. But I see what you're
- 48:02saying there for sure. One thing I want to mention
- 48:05is kind of coming back to the comedy of One Hour
- 48:07With You. And we both really liked the fourth
- 48:10wall break. I think that kind of existed in all
- 48:12of them, but especially in The Smiling Lieutenant.
- 48:14That is fully on display in One Hour With You
- 48:17where he's addressing the audience. But one thing
- 48:19that I really liked was not only is he addressing
- 48:21the audience and kind of doing the fourth wall
- 48:23break that way, he's also kind of acknowledging,
- 48:25like, welcome to another Chevalier -led... Lubitsch
- 48:29film because in the very beginning he's like
- 48:31hey yeah don't worry we're married and looks
- 48:33directly at the camera he's like I'm serious
- 48:35like can you believe I'm married so I yeah we
- 48:39both thought that was a hilarious like introduction
- 48:42to kind of be like it almost kind of felt like
- 48:44it was very personal of like hey I know you you
- 48:46and Kyle have been working on watching these
- 48:49movies so closely it's weird that in this one
- 48:51I'm married right yeah it was very meta even
- 48:53beyond the fourth wall break it was it was very
- 48:55like I know you've seen my movies. Let me clarify.
- 49:00So to your knowledge, have you seen anything
- 49:02like this, Lubitsch or otherwise, where they
- 49:04kind of, not just the fourth wall break, but
- 49:06acknowledge the work that they've done in something
- 49:09like this? Yeah, there's a lot of... I mean,
- 49:12the movies are being made so fast. There's a
- 49:14lot of times where the fourth wall kind of gets
- 49:16broken or there's references to other movies.
- 49:19Paramount was pretty bad with it because, I mean,
- 49:20obviously they did the Marx Brothers movies as
- 49:22well. The movie I mentioned before, Love Me Tonight,
- 49:25is another Chevalier movie and it opens with
- 49:27a picture. of his famous hat on the wall. There's
- 49:30a famous silhouette of him, and it just opens
- 49:32with that. And so that's how you get to him.
- 49:34And then later on, his hat gets crushed by a
- 49:37car or a horse. It gets stepped on by a horse.
- 49:39And his chauffeur comes over and says, ha ha,
- 49:41what are you going to do now? You lost your famous
- 49:42hat. And he pulls another one out. He's like,
- 49:45nah. And so there's, like, obviously Chevalier
- 49:48has that. There's Monkey Business, which is the
- 49:51Marx Brothers movie, where they all impersonate
- 49:53Chevalier. They all come through and pretend
- 49:54to sing as him. because they all have their passports,
- 49:57say, the Chevalier when they're entering the
- 49:58States. And Harpo does, has like a little recorder
- 50:01on his back. One of the more famous ones is there's
- 50:04a movie called Red Dust, which I don't think
- 50:06got nominated. But it's Jean Harlow. It's really
- 50:08famous. She's in a rain barrel taking a bath.
- 50:11And so Clark Gable's like, hey, you can't just
- 50:13walk around here buck naked in front of everybody.
- 50:15She's like, try and stop me. And then the very
- 50:17next year, they made a movie called Bombshell,
- 50:19where Harlow's kind of parodying her image because
- 50:22she always got stuck in these movies where she's
- 50:24talking about her own life somehow. And they
- 50:26do the rain barrel scene again. It's just her
- 50:28behind the scenes, like arguing with people about
- 50:30it. So it's interesting because there are these
- 50:33little nuggets of continuity or references to
- 50:35other movies that nowadays we can pick up on
- 50:38pretty quickly. But back then you're like, there
- 50:40is no way anyone was paying this close attention
- 50:42to these movies to notice this coming up from
- 50:45this movie into this movie and stuff. It's so
- 50:48fun to pick up now, though, especially with how
- 50:50frequent or close together we're able to watch
- 50:54all the movies. We don't have to wait a year
- 50:55for them to be released. True. Do you have like...
- 50:58a favorite moment in this movie that really stuck
- 51:00out to you? You mentioned earlier, there was
- 51:02a scene that made you laugh out loud. Yeah. The
- 51:05scene where at the very end, where Chevalier
- 51:08is convinced that Ruggles, that McDonald's is
- 51:11trying to convince Chevalier that Ruggles and
- 51:13her had an affair as well. And Chevalier doesn't
- 51:16believe it, but there was something and Ruggles
- 51:18is being forced to tell the truth, but he doesn't
- 51:20think that's what he wants to hear. But his friend
- 51:22is telling him to laugh. It's very complicated,
- 51:24but it's very funny. That scene is great. I will
- 51:26say my favorite moment in the entire movie is
- 51:28that Mitzi basically gets the doctor to come
- 51:31visit her at her home. And they sing this song.
- 51:33It's a very cute little like three times a day.
- 51:35And it's very suggestive. And it's really like
- 51:37flirty. And then the very end of the song, it
- 51:40ends with her grabbing his wrist. And it's this
- 51:42very sudden moment where you realize this has
- 51:45been fun and flirty, but this is going to happen,
- 51:47man. Like you can't escape. And then her husband
- 51:50walks in and he very quickly like tries to play
- 51:52it where he's holding her wrist. And it's just
- 51:55like completely obvious what was going on. I
- 51:58just love that moment because you talk about
- 52:00like this film is very light and frothy. It doesn't
- 52:03take things seriously. But there are moments
- 52:05where Tobin and Chevalier, there really is like
- 52:09a seriousness and they realize what's going on,
- 52:11how bad this is underneath. and their whole you
- 52:13know this like many of the scenes between um
- 52:15roland young and chevalier where he is very clearly
- 52:18knows what chevalier is doing is like no uh that
- 52:22never happened oh okay that could have happened
- 52:24yes um there's this like very like as light and
- 52:28comedic as the movie is there's still a lot of
- 52:30interesting and uh potent emotions underneath
- 52:33it so yeah yeah i also uh we're gonna thank you
- 52:37a couple times here moving forward but i want
- 52:39to thank you especially for saying uh chevalier's
- 52:43name so many times because one thing that kyle
- 52:45and i have been talking about pretty much since
- 52:47we've covered lubitsch is like we want to make
- 52:49sure we're getting his name correct so thank
- 52:51you for doing that because we've definitely been
- 52:53butchering it multiple times um i will say i
- 52:55uh i listened to your smiling lieutenant episode
- 52:57and like halfway through i'm like am i thinking
- 52:59it right no i trust your judgment way more than
- 53:03ours so i'm going on off that forever something
- 53:05i've really thought was interesting about lubitsch
- 53:07from the get -go and this is the case for love
- 53:09parade and smiling lieutenant and continues to
- 53:11be with one hour with you is you know we we talk
- 53:14a lot about how movies now there'll be dubs and
- 53:17everything and that didn't exist back then so
- 53:19the way to do the french version of the movie
- 53:21is to film the french version of the movie and
- 53:24they do that at the same time, simultaneously
- 53:26from like filming the American version. And I
- 53:29love that in this one, it's not just Chevalier
- 53:32and his female co -star, but also now it's three
- 53:36people. It was specifically Maryse, Jeanette,
- 53:39and Genevieve that starred in the French version.
- 53:42So my question, have you watched the French version
- 53:45as well, or just the English? I've only seen
- 53:47the English. I don't know if the French version
- 53:49is available, but that's just because... Rights
- 53:52issues are weird. Sure. That was done a lot.
- 53:55Like I know Buster Keaton's free and easy, which
- 53:57was his first big sound film or archive released
- 54:00it with the Spanish version and the French version.
- 54:03And then the English language version. So you
- 54:04can watch all three of those on DVD. Obviously
- 54:07to some people, the Spanish Dracula is more,
- 54:09they like it more than the Bela Lugosi version.
- 54:13It was a very interesting time. It's just, you
- 54:15imagine how much that must have cost to shoot
- 54:16the same movie three times. I'm sure they felt
- 54:19pretty lucky they could just force three of their
- 54:21stars to stay a little later and do it in French.
- 54:24But yeah, it was just an interesting time. As
- 54:25soon as they figured out sound dubbing, I think
- 54:27around that time, they were probably very happy
- 54:29monetarily. I do wonder what that looks like.
- 54:32Kyle, having worked on set, provides a lot of
- 54:36context that I don't have. I just wonder what
- 54:38it looks like. They're like, cool, we shot that
- 54:39scene. So now let's switch all the cast but the
- 54:43three leads and now bring the rest of the cast
- 54:45in that can provide. Let me tell you, as someone
- 54:47that does background acting, I would be miserable
- 54:50if they were like, yeah, now we're going to do
- 54:52the whole day again, but in French. French, yeah.
- 54:56I know that for Spanish Dracula, it was shot
- 54:58at night on the same sets, but I don't know how
- 55:00it was handled for other films. That was obviously
- 55:03a completely different cast, too. Yeah, I'm not
- 55:05sure. So if I can interrupt your thought on that,
- 55:08I appreciate you saying us film nerds, because
- 55:10I felt like, yes, we're accepted. But so what
- 55:14was your what did your journey look like, like
- 55:15getting into film specifically and like movies?
- 55:18And what do you think like the first Do you remember
- 55:20the first movie that you watched? I was first
- 55:23movie I watched like was I was addicted to Back
- 55:26to the Future when I was a kid. I would just
- 55:28watch that and the trilogy over and over again
- 55:29on VHS. I worked at a video store in my teens.
- 55:33So that's how I got into the Marks Brothers.
- 55:36My dad would come up and hang out with me at
- 55:37the video store. I was 16. And he'd be like,
- 55:39these guys, nobody ever watches these. And so
- 55:41one thing you do when you're stuck at a video
- 55:43store for a long time is you're just like, I'm
- 55:45just going to watch all the classics. I'm going
- 55:46to watch all the sci -fi section. And at the
- 55:49time, that was feasible. So I watched all the
- 55:51sci -fi. I watched all the classics. I worked
- 55:54at a different video store in college, which
- 55:56was a lot more of a liberal, commie, sort of
- 55:58homosexual, crazy video store, which is a lot
- 56:01of fun. That introduced me to a lot more stuff.
- 56:04And then in college, I also started, I saw Kurosawa
- 56:06for the first time on DVD when those were coming
- 56:08out. That really got me further in. I used to
- 56:12review movies for my high school newspaper. Those
- 56:13reviews were really bad. And then I moved away.
- 56:18My wife is military, so we moved away from my
- 56:21friends. And one of them said, hey, we should
- 56:22start a movie blog. and that way we can we'll
- 56:25still keep in touch and so we did that for a
- 56:26while and as i was doing that um i started reviewing
- 56:29just dvds i found that i had not heard stuff
- 56:31about um and so one of those was the first forbidden
- 56:33hollywood collection from warner archive or yeah
- 56:36i think it was still them back then And that
- 56:38has like the divorcee and redheaded woman. So
- 56:41some really classic pre -codes. And I was watching
- 56:44that. I was like, this is really interesting.
- 56:45Is there anyone out there writing about this?
- 56:47And there really wasn't. There was no dedicated
- 56:49people just writing about pre -code film. So
- 56:52I spun off my blog for my friend's blog, turned
- 56:55it into pre -code .com like 15 years ago now.
- 56:58And then I was just like reviewing, doing reviews
- 57:00twice a week. And that was before I had kids.
- 57:03And now I have kids, so I don't do any reviews
- 57:04at all. But it was just one of those things where,
- 57:08I obviously you guys understand this feeling
- 57:10as well, where you, you say, okay, I want to
- 57:12complete something. I like lists. I have, I like
- 57:14having challenges to complete. It keeps me focused.
- 57:17Like I know I've seen 871 of the 1001 movies
- 57:20I must see before I die. So I'm not in a hurry
- 57:23to finish that because I might die. And it was
- 57:24like, oh, I did it. um but obviously like saying
- 57:28okay i'm gonna try and watch every movie i can
- 57:30from 30 to 34 because i think this is interesting
- 57:32and if i learn a lot about this i can help share
- 57:34it and find some cool stuff and over the last
- 57:38decade and a half it's been really interesting
- 57:39because um what pre -code was i remember doing
- 57:42my first like google search back in 2010 2011
- 57:45or whatever it was and um the only things that
- 57:48came up for pre -code were like three articles
- 57:50like total on the internet they were actually
- 57:52about pre -code films And since then, obviously,
- 57:55it's exploded. Kim's done great work with the
- 57:57Instagram, has thousands, tens of thousands of
- 57:59followers. I had a really big, I had a good go
- 58:02on Twitter for a while back when that was tenable,
- 58:05enjoyable. But it's one of those things where
- 58:09it's become a lot more popular, which makes me
- 58:12really happy. And I really am glad because it's
- 58:15such an interesting era of movies. And there's
- 58:17so much you can still get out of it and learn
- 58:19about. And there's so much that still relates
- 58:21to today. When I first started watching it, it
- 58:24was right after the Great Recession, which obviously
- 58:27you're watching movies from the Great Depression.
- 58:28You're like, OK, I can see. I understand this.
- 58:30I understand that. And then you go through political
- 58:32issues. You say, oh, I see this in this movie
- 58:35or this in this movie. Women's rights, you know,
- 58:39racial animosity. This is all written in these
- 58:42films. And you see them from 90 years ago. And
- 58:45you kind of can feel that kindred spirits, these
- 58:47people trying to make these movies, you know,
- 58:49at the time they're just making them make a couple
- 58:50bucks, but some of them really say things and
- 58:53mean things in ways that movies can't really
- 58:55do anymore. So it's just been a fascination since
- 58:58then. I love that. Like what started as kind
- 59:02of, Oh, nobody's talking about this. Like it
- 59:04just exploded into like, is this like one of
- 59:08those things? Like this is a defining characteristic
- 59:10of your personality. Like you are the pre -code
- 59:13guy. When I go to classic film places, yes. They're
- 59:16like, oh, you're the precode .com guy or you're
- 59:18the precode guy, which is nice. I don't like
- 59:21take credit for it or anything by any imagination,
- 59:23by any source of imagination. But I do. I love
- 59:27talking about pre -code. I love trying to get,
- 59:29like, the book is the labor of, like, I want
- 59:31more people to watch these movies. How can I,
- 59:34because I grew up in the 90s and, you know, 80s,
- 59:37and I have all those books with checklists of,
- 59:38like, 50 this, 100 that. That was one movie you
- 59:41see before you die. And I was like, well, pre
- 59:43-code deserves that, too, because it's such an
- 59:45interesting era. There's so much you can get
- 59:46out of it. So this book really kind of came from
- 59:48that impulse of, I want more people to watch
- 59:51these movies so they can find other movies that
- 59:53tell me to watch those as well. This whole kind
- 59:55of atmosphere. Yeah, I brought this up to Kim
- 59:59as well. One thing I really love about the book
- 1:00:01that I'm enjoying so much is the way you make
- 1:00:05it accessible for people. It doesn't feel like
- 1:00:09gatekeepy or stuffy or anything. It feels like
- 1:00:13anybody could pick this up and enjoy it because
- 1:00:15you add a good bit of comedy. I call that a specific
- 1:00:18moment where in Night Nurse, there's a photo
- 1:00:21of them standing around the skeleton in bed,
- 1:00:24and there's the caption of... the skeleton blew
- 1:00:27off Barbara Stanwyck and Joan Blondel's clothes
- 1:00:29or something like that. And it was so simple,
- 1:00:32but it made me laugh. And I just love that it
- 1:00:34does feel like welcoming to anybody that's able
- 1:00:38to pick up the book. So I appreciate it. Yeah,
- 1:00:40we really, um, obviously we wrote the book, we
- 1:00:43did a ton of research. There's been some other
- 1:00:44great pre -code books before us, but we really
- 1:00:47wanted to make something that was very easy that
- 1:00:49anyone interested in the area could just pick
- 1:00:50up and you wouldn't have to worry about what
- 1:00:52chapter you're flipping to, or trying to understand
- 1:00:54the timelines or any of that, where you can just
- 1:00:57pick it up and go, I have no idea who Wallace
- 1:00:58Berry is, what's going on in grand hotel. And
- 1:01:00you read about it and you're like, Oh, Wallace
- 1:01:01Berry, um, you know, stuff like that. Yeah, we
- 1:01:05actually just covered him in The Champ, and we
- 1:01:08felt the same way of like, oh, Wallace Beery.
- 1:01:10What's going on here, man? You never read any
- 1:01:13good behind -the -scenes stories about Wallace
- 1:01:15Beery. No. Which is funny, because I think that
- 1:01:18we talked about Lewis Wolheim and Wallace Beery
- 1:01:21being some of our favorites that we've covered
- 1:01:23so far on the episodes. And then we do research,
- 1:01:25and we're like, oh, you're our on -screen favorite.
- 1:01:29Louis Woolheim, man, I wish he hadn't died young
- 1:01:31because he had such a great presence. Like he
- 1:01:33was in All Quiet and then he made like a gangster
- 1:01:36movie with John Gilbert that he was also just
- 1:01:38great in. He was, yeah, he was a shit. There's
- 1:01:40a couple actors in that era and that's what's
- 1:01:42interesting about just taking a chunk of time,
- 1:01:44kind of like what you guys are doing, but like
- 1:01:45for me specifically is you see these cul -de
- 1:01:48-sacs where there's like something really interesting
- 1:01:50that could happen but fate intervenes and this
- 1:01:53person dies or this person... moves or this director
- 1:01:56goes away um i always think about like when i
- 1:01:59was growing up my teens uh like Freddie Prince
- 1:02:02Jr. and Rachel Lee Cook were the biggest movie
- 1:02:04stars for my high school years, and they were
- 1:02:07so fascinating and everywhere, and you couldn't
- 1:02:09go anywhere without girls swooning over them.
- 1:02:10And if you mention that to anyone who wasn't
- 1:02:13a teenager for that specific five -year period,
- 1:02:16they have no idea what you're talking about.
- 1:02:18Yeah, I immediately pegged you as a she's -all
- 1:02:20-that guy when we hopped on. 100%. I'm glad I
- 1:02:24was right about that. I agree with you completely.
- 1:02:26Okay, you and I are going to have a conversation
- 1:02:29about Josie and the Pussycats off. because i'm
- 1:02:32all about that du jour du jour all the day or
- 1:02:34all the time so uh i complete with you i completely
- 1:02:38agree with you when you talked about like how
- 1:02:39fate like the cul -de -sac of like just how these
- 1:02:41things happen lewis wolheim is a perfect example
- 1:02:44of that we talked about the front page uh last
- 1:02:47year or last month and that specifically i loved
- 1:02:50the idea of seeing lewis wolheim play uh the
- 1:02:53role that he was i mean he was going to play
- 1:02:55um specifically walter burns in that And like
- 1:02:59six or seven days into rehearsing, like he just
- 1:03:01he passed. uh, of cancer. So then that introduced,
- 1:03:06uh, Adolph Menjoo to come in and take over the
- 1:03:08role. And then of course he's nominated and wins
- 1:03:10and wins. So it's absolutely crazy seeing like
- 1:03:13just how fate intervened in that. And unfortunately
- 1:03:16in the case of Lewis Mulheim, but it's so fun
- 1:03:19covering it, doing this to talk about those things.
- 1:03:21And I think one hour with you is a perfect example
- 1:03:23of just the behind the scenes and how that lends
- 1:03:25itself to the movie and just the comedy overall.
- 1:03:28So I was really excited that you picked this
- 1:03:30episode to talk about. Yeah. And that's another
- 1:03:33thing about those cul -de -sacs, where you think
- 1:03:34about this film, and you've seen Chevalier and
- 1:03:37Jeanette MacDonald before in Love Parade, and
- 1:03:39they make two more films together, which is Love
- 1:03:41Me Tonight and Merry Widow. And as the 30s progress
- 1:03:46and European film markets close up, Chevalier
- 1:03:48kind of goes away. Like, at this time, he's the
- 1:03:50biggest star in Paramount Stable. But when you
- 1:03:53lose those foreign audiences, I think he goes
- 1:03:55back to France, works the nightclubs, has some
- 1:03:57issues with the Nazis. And his career just kind
- 1:04:00of falters until the 50s. They bring him back
- 1:04:03and you guys see him again and like Gigi. Meanwhile,
- 1:04:06Jeanette McDonald goes to MGM and she makes these
- 1:04:08series of operettas that are huge successes with
- 1:04:10Nelson Eddy. Basically unwatchable in my book,
- 1:04:13but whatever. But you're really seeing like this
- 1:04:16moment of, you know, where everything is kind
- 1:04:18of coming together and they're just going to
- 1:04:20go in radically different directions after this.
- 1:04:22So this is very interesting. Obviously, the studios
- 1:04:26were. In control of pretty much everything that
- 1:04:29happened in Hollywood at this time. And it's
- 1:04:32like you and Kim both mentioned when Warner Brothers
- 1:04:36puts out a movie, like you expect certain things
- 1:04:38from that studio and Paramount being kind of
- 1:04:41like the fast and loose studio and MGM being
- 1:04:43glitz and glamour. Like that's something I really
- 1:04:45want to dive more into as we move forward. Because
- 1:04:50I think it is cool to not only pop on an Ernst
- 1:04:53Lubitsch film and be like, oh, I know what I'm
- 1:04:54going to get out of this to a certain degree.
- 1:04:56But to just see the studio logo pop up and be
- 1:04:59like, oh, I kind of know based off of that. Do
- 1:05:02you have like a favorite studio from this time
- 1:05:04period? I mean, it depends. I think Paramount
- 1:05:07and Warner Brothers were the two that were really
- 1:05:09kind of pushing the boundaries. Warner's was
- 1:05:11making very socially conscious films. You saw
- 1:05:13a five -star final. Camino talked about that.
- 1:05:16And they're going to make one of my favorite
- 1:05:17movies in 33, which is I'm a Fugitive from a
- 1:05:20Chain Gang, which really caused a lot of problems.
- 1:05:24We write about it in our book. I won't spoil
- 1:05:26any of that for you. But they make a lot of really
- 1:05:28dynamic and exciting pictures where they're trying
- 1:05:31to kind of push things as far as they can go.
- 1:05:34Meanwhile, Paramount is making these very, like,
- 1:05:36MGM's kind of idea of glamour and glitz is similar
- 1:05:40to Paramount's, but Paramount isn't afraid to
- 1:05:42kind of go low when they could go high. And then,
- 1:05:46like I said, MGM was very controlled, top -down.
- 1:05:49Irving Thalberg was picking out every movie that
- 1:05:51was being made and reshooting stuff and doing
- 1:05:53what he thought was best. And Paramount was just
- 1:05:55putting out things left and right and doing crazy
- 1:05:57stuff. And so you never 100 % know what you're
- 1:06:00going to get with a Paramount movie. It's going
- 1:06:03to be well -made, which is better than, like,
- 1:06:04Fox. But there's always going to be something
- 1:06:07interesting and exciting in one of them. So,
- 1:06:09yeah. You talked about the 1001 movies that you
- 1:06:13need to see before you die. And I agree with
- 1:06:15you. I feel like if I ever watched the 1001st,
- 1:06:18I'm like, oh, God, I'm dead. It's like the ring.
- 1:06:21Exactly. So in that search that you've done,
- 1:06:25obviously you've covered a lot of movies that
- 1:06:27haven't fallen under that list. I'm curious,
- 1:06:30what have you seen that you think belongs on
- 1:06:32that 1002 movies that you think we should all
- 1:06:36see before that happens? Oh, I don't know. I
- 1:06:39couldn't tell you all the movies because it's
- 1:06:40changed so much on that list. And it's very,
- 1:06:43you know, everybody, as you watch more movies,
- 1:06:45you develop more of a refinement in your taste,
- 1:06:49right? Like you decide like, oh, I like when
- 1:06:51Kurosawa does this. I don't really care about
- 1:06:53what he does this. I like it when this director
- 1:06:56kind of does this. Like, for example, I was looking
- 1:06:58at my top 10. I have a top 100 on my letterbox
- 1:07:00the other day. And I'm realizing like several
- 1:07:02of the movies. I have my top 10 are the only
- 1:07:05films of that director that I like at all, which
- 1:07:07is just funny because you're like, like one of
- 1:07:10my favorite films is beyond the Valley of the
- 1:07:12Dolls, which is a very weird and crazy movie.
- 1:07:15I saw it in the theater. It's gorgeous. It's
- 1:07:17just really lunatic and written by Roger Ebert.
- 1:07:22But it's, it's so funny and so wild that all
- 1:07:25of the directors, other films, his name escapes
- 1:07:26me right now are very much more of a, not quite
- 1:07:30on that same level. So in terms of just in general,
- 1:07:34adding to the 1001 movies, if Heather's isn't
- 1:07:38there, it should be like, I think everybody needs
- 1:07:40to see Heather's at least once in their lives.
- 1:07:42But I don't know. It's, it's hard to, it's hard
- 1:07:46to come up with your own canon. I try not to
- 1:07:49be, I wrote a book with my own canon, but I try
- 1:07:53not to be that definitive because there's different
- 1:07:56strokes for different folks. Yeah. Stuff I love
- 1:07:59isn't what everybody else loves. I watch with
- 1:08:01my kids. I make them watch Buster Keaton movies
- 1:08:03and my daughter loves it. My son hates it. And
- 1:08:06it's just one of the, he hates it until he actually
- 1:08:07watches it. And then he's laughing, pulling off
- 1:08:09the couch. But, you know, I. i just i like listening
- 1:08:15to other people's opinions a lot just because
- 1:08:17i know so much about pre -code and i've done
- 1:08:19so much with it i felt like this book was something
- 1:08:21i could put out there and obviously i've gotten
- 1:08:22feedback from people like oh you picked some
- 1:08:25very obvious movies like i've seen already seen
- 1:08:27like 40 of them like great that's 10 more for
- 1:08:28you to see um i've gotten feedback where people
- 1:08:31like i haven't heard of any of these movies what
- 1:08:32on earth are you talking about i'm like well
- 1:08:34then you got a lot more to see you know um so
- 1:08:37i just feel like i don't feel like gatekeeping
- 1:08:39is necessary at an entry level. Like when you're
- 1:08:43trying to get people interested in things and
- 1:08:45you want more people, the more people you have
- 1:08:46talking about pre -code, the more books and DVDs
- 1:08:49are going to sell, the more screenings they're
- 1:08:51going to do. There's more, the more people can
- 1:08:54see this, understand this and enjoy this. And
- 1:08:56I think right now in the attention economy, it's
- 1:08:58just so difficult to try and connect with people
- 1:09:01and get them into old movies, which is very different
- 1:09:04than how it was for like my parents' generation.
- 1:09:07It's just a very, interesting situation to put
- 1:09:10yourself into and to try and to do something
- 1:09:13with so yeah i mean it's it's awesome to hear
- 1:09:16you say that and i i think we both completely
- 1:09:17agree you know with the double features that
- 1:09:20we do i think the intention behind it at least
- 1:09:23from my perspective, is that there's a lot of
- 1:09:25people who haven't seen these movies. And if
- 1:09:28they're like, yeah, but you know, am I really
- 1:09:30going to like it? Then the way you can do that
- 1:09:32outside of explaining, hey, here's why I think
- 1:09:34you'd like it is at the end, like, look, if you
- 1:09:35like this, like, it doesn't make sense why you
- 1:09:37wouldn't enjoy this, because this is kind of
- 1:09:39what paved the way for that. So that level of
- 1:09:42inclusivity and like, you know, getting rid of
- 1:09:44gatekeeping, I think that's the whole. perspective
- 1:09:46that we want to have on this is we want to share
- 1:09:48it with everyone because why aren't we talking
- 1:09:51more about preserving these films and everything
- 1:09:53so very big fan of your writing that you and
- 1:09:56kim put into this because it does to kyle's point
- 1:09:59that he mentioned earlier it feels very inclusive
- 1:10:01and welcoming and to include not just the the
- 1:10:04humor in it but like the levity of the conversation
- 1:10:06because it does feel like you can pick up oh
- 1:10:09hey i'm talking about this movie let me skip
- 1:10:10to page 78 and talk about that specifically so
- 1:10:13again just incredible work that you've done on
- 1:10:15this you and kim thank you i appreciate it it
- 1:10:17was a it was very much a labor of love you guys
- 1:10:21are doing is it turner classic movie fest is
- 1:10:24that is that what it's called yeah the 17th annual
- 1:10:27turner classic movies film festival um i think
- 1:10:30it's the actual title is more cumbersome than
- 1:10:32that because tv channel is called turner classic
- 1:10:34movies i think it's like the turner classic movies
- 1:10:36classic movie film fest doesn't matter um we're
- 1:10:40gonna be there it's in los angeles at the end
- 1:10:41of the month Uh, we're going to sign books on
- 1:10:44Sunday, which is exciting. Um, very much a dream.
- 1:10:46Uh, again, this book, I don't, I don't remember
- 1:10:49if Kim mentioned in our interview, we started
- 1:10:50talking about it in like 2015, 2016. Um, and
- 1:10:54we, uh, I written most of it at one point and
- 1:10:58that's, turns out that's not what you're supposed
- 1:10:59to do with nonfiction books. Cause then we go
- 1:11:01to publish and say like, we have this a hundred
- 1:11:03thousand word nonfiction book for you. And they're
- 1:11:06like, no, what are you talking about? Um, So
- 1:11:10it was really like, we really, you know, like
- 1:11:13I never thought this would actually happen. So
- 1:11:14I'm so excited the book is here. I'm really proud
- 1:11:16of it. I'm so thankful all the help we got from
- 1:11:18TCM and Running Press. Kim, like in terms of,
- 1:11:22I've worked with a lot of other writers before
- 1:11:24and Kim's been like one of the easiest. She's
- 1:11:26got such a great eye for research. I think you
- 1:11:28can tell between the difference between our conversations
- 1:11:30where Kim was like in the production code files,
- 1:11:32they said this, they did that. And I'm like,
- 1:11:34yeah, Lubitsch is. Terms and evolution, if you
- 1:11:37go from here to here, and so we just have very
- 1:11:39different perspectives. I think that really kind
- 1:11:42of works well together. So it's been a lot of
- 1:11:45fun. Absolutely. Yeah. Completely agreed. So
- 1:11:48do you guys, I know based off what Kim said,
- 1:11:52but do you have any plans to make your way down
- 1:11:54to Atlanta anytime in the future? So I live in
- 1:11:58Germany right now. So getting back to the States
- 1:12:01has been difficult. But I am moving to Colorado
- 1:12:04in the summer. And part of that will hopefully
- 1:12:08be more travel around the states. I know Kim
- 1:12:11talked to me. I used to live near San Francisco.
- 1:12:14I've lived a lot of places. I used to live near
- 1:12:16San Francisco. We went to a couple of pre -code
- 1:12:17showings at the Roxy, and they came to us and
- 1:12:19said, would you like to help introduce some of
- 1:12:20those? Yeah, that'd be great. So we'll see. She
- 1:12:25can name theaters in Atlanta. I cannot. I've
- 1:12:28been to them before. It was a long time ago.
- 1:12:31That's okay. We won't really answer you. We'll
- 1:12:33see. But yeah, I mean, I would really like, you
- 1:12:36know, there's so many opportunities. And I think
- 1:12:38the way theatrical distribution is evolving and
- 1:12:42the way these megaplexes have to evolve, you
- 1:12:44know, I'm watching, I live in Germany. There's
- 1:12:46like four movies in English that come out a week
- 1:12:48that I can go see. But I look at like the listings
- 1:12:50in Colorado Springs and you see like, oh, this
- 1:12:52week the AMC is showing Ferris Bueller's Day
- 1:12:55Off or they're showing, you know, they're doing
- 1:12:57a lot of retro films. And I think that smaller
- 1:12:59theaters in specific, when you have, people who
- 1:13:02can introduce the movies and help introduce because
- 1:13:05i i mean i've been to sorry it's a little digression
- 1:13:07but i've been to a lot of screenings classic
- 1:13:09film screenings and i really think the context
- 1:13:12for how you present the screening matters especially
- 1:13:14nowadays um i know when i saw double identity
- 1:13:17in the theater 2005 um there was uh there's the
- 1:13:22scene where he goes to the bowling alley and
- 1:13:24drinks a beer in front like in his car like they
- 1:13:27bring the beer to his car he's just drinking
- 1:13:28it behind the wheel and everybody's just laughing
- 1:13:30And you're like, ah, it wasn't really supposed
- 1:13:32to be a laugh. I think having someone there and
- 1:13:35adding context and adding, having this wealth
- 1:13:38of knowledge, I'm not just like blowing smoke
- 1:13:40up my own, but being able to do this at the theatrical
- 1:13:43level really helps make a difference in how these
- 1:13:46movies are remembered and received nowadays,
- 1:13:47which is why I like going to the TCM Film Festival
- 1:13:49and, you know, having these people get up and
- 1:13:52talk about films and, you know, sometimes even
- 1:13:54people who worked on the film. I was... I went
- 1:13:57a few years ago and Cora Sue Collins was there
- 1:14:00and she, you probably never heard of her, but
- 1:14:02she was a child actress in the early 1930s to
- 1:14:05early 1940s. And so she played like young, you'll
- 1:14:09actually see her. She's in Smiling Through. She
- 1:14:12plays young, oh my God, I can't remember her
- 1:14:15name, Norma Shear. She plays young Norma Shear
- 1:14:17in Smiling Through. And she plays young Greta
- 1:14:20Garbo in Queen Christina. And so she has these
- 1:14:22roles where she's just basically every young
- 1:14:24actress version of themselves at MGM for a while.
- 1:14:26And so I got to meet her cause she was like 95
- 1:14:29and she kissed me on the cheek and she says,
- 1:14:31Oh, you're so sweet young man. I was just like,
- 1:14:33that's cool. I got kissed on the cheek by somebody
- 1:14:35who met Garbo. Like, what are you, what are you
- 1:14:37going to do? Um, yeah, but just finding those
- 1:14:40connections and learning about this history and,
- 1:14:42you know, realizing the human side of it while
- 1:14:44also understanding the statements that were being
- 1:14:46made and the way they're being made. Uh, it's
- 1:14:49just very interesting and I think very much worthy
- 1:14:51of effort. Yeah, 100%. Absolutely. I want to
- 1:14:57shout out, too, like you mentioned, context and
- 1:14:59having somebody present these classic films being
- 1:15:02so important. I totally agree. The best example
- 1:15:05I have of that is... Two hours ago? Yeah, exactly.
- 1:15:09Francis Ford Coppola, his most recent film, Megalopolis,
- 1:15:12which is just shrouded in controversy and so
- 1:15:16much stuff. That was the very first movie I had
- 1:15:22the opportunity to work as a background actor
- 1:15:23on, so I was really excited to see it. And then
- 1:15:26the more I heard about it, the less excited I
- 1:15:28was to see it. But I went to a screening where
- 1:15:30he presented it, and him being there and being
- 1:15:33able to talk about what the movie meant for him
- 1:15:35and all of that, and having that context, did
- 1:15:38make it a more enjoyable experience, even if
- 1:15:42ultimately I still do not like that movie. It's
- 1:15:45not a good movie. Yeah, well. But, you know,
- 1:15:49to your point, like, I do think that is so important.
- 1:15:52And that's usually a driving force to get me
- 1:15:54to go see an older movie in theaters is, well,
- 1:15:56who's presenting it? Because that really matters
- 1:15:59to me as well. Yeah, it does. I'd be remiss when
- 1:16:02we talk about context and everything if we didn't
- 1:16:04give you the opportunity that we gave Kim. You
- 1:16:06both picked Bad Girl that you wanted to cover.
- 1:16:09Sure. Is there anything you'd like to say about
- 1:16:11Bad Girl? Why that was your first thought when
- 1:16:13you wanted to cover that? Honestly, like I listened
- 1:16:16to you guys' episode. I know you were kind of
- 1:16:17mixed on it. Honestly, it's, I hadn't seen it
- 1:16:21in a long time and I remember really liking it.
- 1:16:23So it was, it wasn't like, this is like with
- 1:16:25one hour with you, I'm very enthusiastic and
- 1:16:27I really do enjoy it. I'd love to say, I thought
- 1:16:30it was fun to pick both of those as well. Cause
- 1:16:32they're about relationships and this communication
- 1:16:33and they have very similar themes and obviously
- 1:16:36are very different movies. And they kind of speak
- 1:16:39to this. level of sophistication the movies were
- 1:16:42at at the time and i think you guys are kind
- 1:16:45of getting to the cusp of that in the pre -code
- 1:16:47era because after in the late 30s and i'm you
- 1:16:50know not someone in love with late 30s movies
- 1:16:52um they seem to go in a different direction uh
- 1:16:551933 little women comes out which i do believe
- 1:16:57is the best picture nominee it's a good movie
- 1:16:59um but as studios are trying to do something
- 1:17:03different that's not going to get them as much
- 1:17:04trouble with the sensors uh they start making
- 1:17:07a lot more literary movies where they're very
- 1:17:09solid and well -meaning and very dramatic but
- 1:17:13they get they have a very different kind of tone
- 1:17:15and a very different kind of message um and that's
- 1:17:18obviously by design um but i think it's interesting
- 1:17:21at this point what you can say what you can't
- 1:17:24say Going back to Genevieve Tobin, who I mentioned
- 1:17:26before, was one of my favorite actresses. She
- 1:17:28made a movie in 1938 called Yes, My Darling Daughter,
- 1:17:31where she's not the lead. She's the fun, wacky
- 1:17:33aunt of this girl who's trying to decide whether
- 1:17:36or not to go spend the weekend sleeping with
- 1:17:38her boyfriend. And her mom has to decide whether
- 1:17:40or not to let her go. And this is for 1938. This
- 1:17:43caused a lot of problems like this was, you know,
- 1:17:4634, 32, 33. It might it probably would cause
- 1:17:49some controversy, but it would not have caused
- 1:17:51as much controversy as it's going to cause in
- 1:17:5338. And so you really lose a lot of these stories
- 1:17:56about dealing with relationships, dealing with
- 1:17:58how people treat each other. And so that evolution
- 1:18:02is interesting. Yeah. We were talking earlier
- 1:18:05how that's my biggest fear is once the production
- 1:18:08code really kicks in, our enjoyment of these
- 1:18:12movies, like, is that going to completely flip?
- 1:18:14Are we going to have to really search for what's
- 1:18:17good? I think it's going to be. uh not as much
- 1:18:21fun for you is my opinion but you're gonna get
- 1:18:23to 1939 there's a lot of great movies in 39 during
- 1:18:25the war years they let they loosen things up
- 1:18:28a bit obviously you're gonna get to a year with
- 1:18:30casablanca so you know there's something to look
- 1:18:32forward to at the very least sure um and they
- 1:18:35it's one of those things where uh One of my favorite
- 1:18:39directors who really got me into film was Billy
- 1:18:40Wilder. And the reason I really got into Lubitsch
- 1:18:43is because Wilder absolutely loved Lubitsch.
- 1:18:45So you're going to get to the Billy Wilder films.
- 1:18:48And there's always this tension about whether
- 1:18:50or not the Hays Code forced filmmakers to make
- 1:18:53better movies. This idea that saying specifically
- 1:18:56what you are and aren't allowed to do forces
- 1:18:58you to be creative. And I don't know if I necessarily
- 1:19:02agree with that. i do think that there's movies
- 1:19:05that are very crass movies that are being made
- 1:19:07in the early 30s there's but there's also like
- 1:19:09movies that say nothing a lot more in the late
- 1:19:1130s um and it really kind of comes down to how
- 1:19:15people can bend these rules what interest they
- 1:19:17can find um and just how human you can make your
- 1:19:21story within this this set of principles and
- 1:19:24ideas. Some people get away with it. Wilder is
- 1:19:27really good at like skirting the line and finding
- 1:19:30interesting ways to get around it. Lubitsch manages
- 1:19:32to, he makes some great films in the forties.
- 1:19:35But I mean, everything changes and you'll get
- 1:19:38to this 50, I mean, God willing, you guys get
- 1:19:40to the fifties and sixties and there's going
- 1:19:43to be a lot of really interesting stuff as things
- 1:19:44kind of unravel as the post -war, you know, maturity
- 1:19:47kind of kicks in. um so it's a journey i think
- 1:19:50you'll i think you'll definitely hit some years
- 1:19:52i'm sorry um we're anticipating it but you know
- 1:19:57i think in terms of completion like in terms
- 1:20:00of like like i've seen every best picture winner
- 1:20:01i've not seen every best picture nominee um but
- 1:20:04in terms of completion it's still you know even
- 1:20:06the bad movies are worth being able to say okay
- 1:20:08you know this year they made like flirtation
- 1:20:10walk i think it's nominee in 34 which is pretty
- 1:20:13lousy um it's another dick powell musical with
- 1:20:16ruby keeler but you know you see you can see
- 1:20:18the evolution you see the changes you see people
- 1:20:20come back and disappear and you'll get to experience
- 1:20:23film history which i think is super cool and
- 1:20:25i think it's a worthy cause it's a worthy journey
- 1:20:28to go on so yeah well you know when we started
- 1:20:31this podcast we we don't really pride ourselves
- 1:20:33on being like experts of of any of this and it
- 1:20:36really is a journey not only to to be a completionist
- 1:20:40and go through all the best picture nominees,
- 1:20:41but also just to offer information for others,
- 1:20:45but also to learn ourselves. And I think that
- 1:20:47having people like you and Kim as guests has
- 1:20:50really helped us do that. Um, just in this conversation
- 1:20:53alone, I've learned more about pre -code than
- 1:20:55I knew, you know, an hour and a half ago. Yeah.
- 1:20:58My, my ratings on whatever they were very different.
- 1:21:00So the, I mean the. The big thing that Kyle and
- 1:21:04I are very we're very adamant about is the conversation
- 1:21:08of like these movies should not just be for us.
- 1:21:11This should not just be in a vacuum of us talking
- 1:21:14about it. It should be a conversation with other
- 1:21:15people. And I think your writing style, clearly
- 1:21:18your communication style in this interview, it
- 1:21:20is indicative of. We need to be a community.
- 1:21:24And I'm thrilled to see like in theaters in 2026,
- 1:21:27like there are more audiences coming out and
- 1:21:29it feels like movies are important again. And
- 1:21:30that's amazing because they have always been.
- 1:21:33And I'm glad there's an audience for it more
- 1:21:35so than ever. But the main thing about this is
- 1:21:38being able to talk about these movies and provide
- 1:21:39context that we don't have. And like Kyle said,
- 1:21:42like we aren't experts and we want to learn this
- 1:21:44in real time. So the long way around that is.
- 1:21:48Thank you. Thank you and Kim for making this
- 1:21:49book, but also for making time with us to talk
- 1:21:51about these movies and fill in the gaps. Cause
- 1:21:53I think I'm looking at one hour with you very
- 1:21:55differently than I was before having that conversation
- 1:21:58with you and having that context. So I appreciate
- 1:22:00you doing that. No, no. Thank you for having
- 1:22:02me. If you ever need me to come back and ramble
- 1:22:04on about other films, I'm more than happy to.
- 1:22:06I love talking about movies. And I do not get
- 1:22:09to talk about, like I live in Germany. I don't
- 1:22:11have any other film loving friends. So when I,
- 1:22:13when I do talk to people, it's just. It's a fountain.
- 1:22:15It's not going to stop. Yeah, unfortunately,
- 1:22:17in 90 years from now, I don't think we're going
- 1:22:19to be talking about one hour. Sorry, can't hardly
- 1:22:21wait or Josie and the Pussycats. But if I ever
- 1:22:24have an opportunity to talk about those very
- 1:22:26easily, you're going to be on that episode. But
- 1:22:27I look forward to you being on future episodes
- 1:22:29with us because I think what you and Kim have
- 1:22:31provided for us, not just in the book, but in
- 1:22:33our conversations, has been invaluable. Thank
- 1:22:34you. I appreciate it. And thanks for having me.
- 1:22:36And I've really enjoyed listening to you guys'
- 1:22:38podcast. doing the research for this. So thanks
- 1:22:40for making what you make. Thank you for that.
- 1:22:42Thank you. Thank you very much. Was there anything
- 1:22:44at the end here that you'd like to plug? Obviously,
- 1:22:47the book we've mentioned a dozen times now. Precode
- 1:22:50.com, right? Yeah, it's pre -code .com. I don't
- 1:22:55update super often. I just usually put out stuff
- 1:22:57that's coming up on TCM. I try to do reviews.
- 1:23:00It's just difficult. I have two kids, and so
- 1:23:03I'm the stay -at -home dad who works all around
- 1:23:04all their stuff. I have the blue sky. It's precode
- 1:23:08.com spelled out for the other crazy lefties
- 1:23:11out there. Kim has the Instagram, which is much
- 1:23:14better. And that's the precode .com. And she
- 1:23:18does fantastic work with that. But yeah, I mean,
- 1:23:21if this gets somebody to pick up the book or
- 1:23:23even get it from your library, I'm a librarian
- 1:23:25by trade. Obviously I want people to use their
- 1:23:27libraries. Check it out. I think it's fun. I
- 1:23:29think it's amazing that it exists. And I hope
- 1:23:33it gets more people to check out some of these
- 1:23:35films. Yeah, 100%. Well, good luck in Los Angeles.
- 1:23:38We wish you could be there. But congratulations
- 1:23:41on the signing, on the book, all the success.
- 1:23:43And we look forward to speaking with you more
- 1:23:45in the future. Yeah, just drop me a line, guys.
- 1:23:46Thank you. Thanks so much, Danny. Our thanks
- 1:23:49again to Danny Reed to join us here to talk about
- 1:23:51his Pre -Code Essentials book that he co -wrote
- 1:23:53with Kumlu Perry. Our huge thanks to Kim as well
- 1:23:56for joining us to previously talk about Five
- 1:23:57Star Final. It was a blast to be able to talk
- 1:23:59one hour with you, with Danny, and you. So I'm
- 1:24:04glad we were able to do that. Also, just a side
- 1:24:06thing, very excited about the interviews that
- 1:24:09we've been able to do so far, both having Jordan
- 1:24:13on to talk about one hour. Not when I'm with
- 1:24:16you. To talk about All Quiet on the Western Front.
- 1:24:19Rachel on to talk about specifically like the
- 1:24:21cinema archives, the work that she's doing on
- 1:24:24YouTube. And then to have both Kim and Danny
- 1:24:26talk about Precode Essentials. Really excited
- 1:24:28to kind of have these experts come in and speak
- 1:24:31a little bit about some areas that we're not
- 1:24:33as keen on. So love the ability to be able to
- 1:24:36do this. Yeah, yeah. And if you're enjoying these
- 1:24:38interviews too, like that's something that I'm
- 1:24:41trying to... strive for at least once a month.
- 1:24:44So if there's somebody you want to see us speak
- 1:24:47to, you know, send us an email, OUTAOPodcast
- 1:24:50at gmail .com and just steer us in the right
- 1:24:54direction because I'm looking for experts and
- 1:24:56people that are kind of an authority on these
- 1:24:58movies. I actually have someone who I think we
- 1:25:00should include on the Citizen Kane episode when
- 1:25:03we talk about that. I'm really interested because
- 1:25:05I think she's listening and she doesn't know
- 1:25:07that I'm about to ask her, but I think we should.
- 1:25:09All right. So I'm interested. I like that. Maybe
- 1:25:12I shouldn't tell her until we get closer. So
- 1:25:14she hears it and she's like, is it me? We'll
- 1:25:16see. But either way, very excited about the interviews
- 1:25:18that we can get for this and have gotten so far
- 1:25:20and will continue to get. Absolutely. Appreciate
- 1:25:22everyone joining us on that journey. Thank you
- 1:25:24so much. As far as next episode, we will be covering
- 1:25:28Grand Hotel. A big one. Yeah. Massive one. And
- 1:25:33that's going to be the last film of the fifth
- 1:25:35Academy year. And then we'll be moving into our
- 1:25:38ceremony episode, which also means that the...
- 1:25:41Best Picture poll available on our Patreon will
- 1:25:44be coming to a close. So if you want to be a
- 1:25:46part of that and vote for which film you think
- 1:25:49truly deserved to win Best Picture at the Fifth
- 1:25:51Academy Awards, check out patreon .com slash
- 1:25:53O -U -T -A -O podcast and send in your votes.
- 1:25:57Also join the Discord. Stay tuned for a watch
- 1:26:00party that we will be hosting on April 29th.
- 1:26:04And... Look forward to more stuff on the Patreon.
- 1:26:07Beyond that, leave us a review, leave us a rating,
- 1:26:10and stay tuned for next episode. And make sure
- 1:26:13to check out on the Discord when we are voting
- 1:26:16on what film or what kind of film we'd like to
- 1:26:18watch for the watch party because sometimes it
- 1:26:20is a film from that year, sometimes it's a film
- 1:26:23that was nominated in that year, and sometimes
- 1:26:24it's something more modern. So make sure that
- 1:26:27if you want to stay in that, you're joining the
- 1:26:28Discord and voting appropriately. Absolutely.
- 1:26:31That's going to do it for this episode. As always,
- 1:26:33I'm your host, Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see
- 1:26:36you at the movies.