Latest / Film And Whiskey / Moneyball (2011) / Bardstown Bourbon Company Distillery Reserve Cathedral French Oak Bourbon (NSFW)
Transcript
- 0:00In 2011, director Bennett Miller and star Brad Pitt gave the
- 0:05world a quiet look at the stunning revolution in the world
- 0:09of baseball. In 2025, we try a bourbon fit
- 0:13for royalty. The film is Moneyball.
- 0:16The whiskey is Bardstown Bourbon Company Distillery Reserve
- 0:19Cathedral French oak barrel finish are.
- 0:23You done yet, Bob? A one word movie title and a 78
- 0:27word bourbon title. And we will review both of those
- 0:32things today. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:36podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:57podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 1:00glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:03I'm Brad G. And Brad G It is almost opening
- 1:06day in the world of Major League Baseball.
- 1:10We've officially arrived in spring, it seems.
- 1:12I as I get older I find myself loving baseball more and more
- 1:18and more. What a great sport.
- 1:21I was gonna let's you know what, let's do this.
- 1:23Let's have the baseball conversation right now.
- 1:24Folks, welcome into film and whiskey.
- 1:26If this is your first episode joining us, we don't usually go
- 1:29deep on sports. We usually go deep on films and
- 1:32whiskey. But because this is opening
- 1:34week, we figured, hey, let's talk about Moneyball.
- 1:37And in order to talk about Moneyball, we got to talk about
- 1:39the state of things in the world of baseball.
- 1:42Brad, it seems that both viewership and attendance have
- 1:45been in the steady decline for baseball for years and years
- 1:48now. The young people are just not
- 1:50attaching themselves to the world of baseball as they once
- 1:52did. And I'm not here to interrogate
- 1:55why that is. But I will say I watch less
- 1:58baseball than I ever have. But I'm kind of with you in that
- 2:03like there is no sport that I feel nostalgia for or like a
- 2:07deep sense of like magic like I do with a good baseball game.
- 2:12So I don't know how to reconcile those two things.
- 2:14I never watch it, but every time I watch a great baseball game
- 2:18it's like this is. America, you know, yeah.
- 2:22Now I will say from what I have heard the last few years,
- 2:26baseball is actually kind of boosting in the ratings again.
- 2:29Oh, that's good. Around 2019, it started going
- 2:33up. 2020 I think helped as people wanted something to watch
- 2:38and since I I believe viewership is up the last few years as well
- 2:43as ticket sales. So baseball surprisingly doing
- 2:48well, whereas I think it's coming out of the NB as
- 2:50viewership a little bit. Yeah, for sure.
- 2:52Because I know that the NBA has been down, I will say football
- 2:57is the black hole of American sports viewership that seems to
- 3:02suck up a lot of viewers who are shed from other sports.
- 3:07But I will say, man, living in Cleveland over the last decade
- 3:12plus has been a huge blessing in the world of baseball because
- 3:18I've had a good baseball team to watch year in and year out.
- 3:22I do love me some Guardians baseball, and it makes sense
- 3:25that baseball viewership would rebound it.
- 3:28Honestly, it should be the dominant sport in America still.
- 3:31When you just think about like the sports calendar, it's the
- 3:34longest season of the year and it's got essentially like 6-7
- 3:39months of the year to itself. There's really nothing competing
- 3:42with it in those summer months. So, like, it's crazy how much
- 3:46people love the NFL because baseball's, like, right there
- 3:48for the taking. And Brad, I don't think we could
- 3:50have picked a better movie to talk about when it comes to the
- 3:53world of baseball than Moneyball.
- 3:56Folks, if you are joining us for the first time or if this is,
- 3:59you know, one of your first episodes, what we've been doing
- 4:02this season is we've been looking at films from the last
- 4:0520 years and we've been asking the question, does this movie
- 4:08deserve to be considered a modern masterpiece?
- 4:12Now, Brad, I don't want to spoil our answer to that question too
- 4:15much, but I will say based on the few sports movies we've done
- 4:19this season, we've already said there's not a lot of great
- 4:23Alzheimer sports movies in the 21st century.
- 4:27And so I think just on that criteria, it's kind of an
- 4:30automatic yes in terms of being a classic.
- 4:32Is that fair to say? I mean, I personally would judge
- 4:37it more just across all films. Like I, I don't think just
- 4:41because it's a baseball movie means that it's a classic,
- 4:44because it's really good. I will say if you are just
- 4:47limiting it to baseball films over the last 30 years, like,
- 4:52yeah, this is a classic. And and again, like, people need
- 4:56sports movies to watch. And so maybe kind of by default,
- 4:59it's like, well, this is the closest thing we've had for the
- 5:01last 20 years, you know? So we'll get into talking about
- 5:04all this, but let's kind of cast some vision for our Moneyball
- 5:08episode. Brad, I've seen this movie, I
- 5:12don't know, six or seven times all the way through.
- 5:14I've seen bits and pieces on TVA lot.
- 5:16It's really funny. My kids will lock in on this
- 5:19movie when I am like, flipping through channels.
- 5:22And it doesn't seem like the kind of movie that anyone under
- 5:25the age of 35 would be interested in because it's just
- 5:28a guy sitting in decaying office office rooms on telephones
- 5:32talking about dollars and cents. But like, you know, my five year
- 5:36old looked at me today and he's like, I get it.
- 5:38I get why it's called Moneyball. And I said, yeah, buddy, why is
- 5:42that? He said because they need money
- 5:44so they can play baseball. And I was like, this kid gets
- 5:47it. He he has solved it.
- 5:50So, yeah, I, I there's something about this movie.
- 5:53Maybe they're just preparing for their own dad phases down the
- 5:56road. But it is like I'm sucked into
- 5:58this thing every time I watch it.
- 5:59Brad. Just make sure the kids have
- 6:01like Doritos sprinkled onto their bellies while while
- 6:05they're watching the movie. I think my favorite part of this
- 6:08film that that I really want your kids to like, pick up on
- 6:11and start quoting is when the scout is talking about how they
- 6:15don't want the 1 prospect because he has an ugly
- 6:18girlfriend. Yeah, he doesn't got good
- 6:21vision. Nothing better exemplifies like
- 6:24the old way of scouting baseball players than like he is not Joe
- 6:29DiMaggio or Mickey Mantle or whoever it was that dated
- 6:32Marilyn Monroe for a while. You know what I mean, right?
- 6:34Yeah. DiMaggio, DiMaggio.
- 6:36Yeah. All right, Brad, on that note,
- 6:39let's get into our first segment of the day, which we call Brad
- 6:42Explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 6:44movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock.
- 6:47So let's go ahead and do your take with this little segment
- 6:51that we call Brad Explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 6:54show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 6:57just seen often for the first time.
- 7:00Brad, I just revealed that I've seen this a number of times.
- 7:03How many watches is this for you of Moneyball?
- 7:06I'm pretty sure that this is my second watch of Moneyball.
- 7:09I, I, I know I saw it 5 or 6 years ago.
- 7:13I don't think I've seen it since, but yeah, enough that I
- 7:17would say we're going to have a just ultra compelling 60 seconds
- 7:22here. Now, Brad, I don't know how how
- 7:26often you go down the rabbit hole of just kind of scrolling
- 7:28through YouTube clips, but this is a A fixture, a staple of the
- 7:33YouTube short, at least in my algorithm.
- 7:37Have you seen bits and pieces of it anywhere in between your two
- 7:40watches, or are you coming into this completely separated from
- 7:44any viewing experience? I don't feel like I've seen much
- 7:49of this movie. The the one thing that I saw
- 7:52that I was like, oh, I forgot that that was from Moneyball, is
- 7:56the meme when Brad Pitt is looking at the camera and he
- 8:00goes, listen, it's not that hard.
- 8:02Tell him it's incredibly, it's incredibly hard as anything
- 8:07worth trying to do. Is all right, man.
- 8:11So with that in mind, you have 60 seconds breakdown the plot of
- 8:15this movie with full spoilers and go.
- 8:18The film Moneyball follows Billy Beane, played by Brad Pitt, who
- 8:23is the general manager of the Oakland Athletics, a Major
- 8:27League Baseball club. They don't have much money, and
- 8:31they're losing some of their best players, and so they need a
- 8:34way to field a great team that can make the playoffs without
- 8:40much money, as your son put it. So he follows a few trails,
- 8:49realizes that there's a way to find value from lower costing
- 8:54players. He hires, what's his name,
- 8:58Jonah. We'll just call him Jonah Hill.
- 8:59He hires Jonah Hill, real life Jonah Hill, to be his baseball
- 9:05analyst who believes in this different way of thinking.
- 9:08He pisses off a bunch of people on the way, and they have a
- 9:11really cool winning streak and they lose in the ALDS going
- 9:15nowhere. The end.
- 9:18I want to kick off today talking about the team behind the camera
- 9:23of the movie, which I feel like we've been doing frankly, a a
- 9:26poor job of lately. Brad, we've got we've gone into
- 9:29performances a lot, but I don't feel like we've really spent
- 9:31much time talking about directing or writing with a lot
- 9:34of our movies lately. But this is a film that features
- 9:37a writing team of Aaron Sorkin and Steven Zalian.
- 9:41Now, Steven Zalian is a, I don't even want to call him a
- 9:45journeyman. He is one of the best
- 9:47screenwriters in Hollywood, and he kind of falls into a more
- 9:51traditional mold when it comes to the way he tells his stories.
- 9:54It's a classic Hollywood storytelling technique.
- 9:58So Brad, I'm going to read a couple of the movies that
- 10:00Steve's Alien has written, many of which we've done on this
- 10:04podcast. So even going back to the 90s,
- 10:06he wrote the movie Awakenings with Robin Williams and Robert
- 10:09De Niro. He wrote Schindler's List.
- 10:13Oh, wow. He wrote, he's credited for the
- 10:15story of the original Mission Impossible film.
- 10:18He wrote Gangs of New York. He wrote American Gangster.
- 10:22He helped with the screenplay for The Girl with the Dragon
- 10:24Tattoo. He wrote The Irishman for Martin
- 10:27Scorsese. The guy is a big deal in
- 10:29Hollywood. And so you pair him up with, you
- 10:31know, perhaps the preeminent dialogue guy in Aaron Sorkin.
- 10:36And I think what we have here is a script that is really
- 10:39fascinating to me to dissect because you I don't think you
- 10:43would immediately peg this as an Aaron Sorkin script.
- 10:48There is very little dialogue at times in this movie.
- 10:51And I find that it actually ends up being one of my favorite
- 10:54scripts that Sorkin has ever worked on because there's a lot
- 10:57of like economy to the dialogue. It's really crisp.
- 11:01It's really pointed, but it doesn't ramble.
- 11:04And I feel like especially late era Sorkin really tends to
- 11:07ramble. I I really love this script man.
- 11:11Yeah, It absolutely winds itself tightly around what you're
- 11:17seeing on the screen. And you always feel this sense
- 11:21of unease, like every single time Brad Pitt reassures Jonah
- 11:27Hill that their jobs are safe and then immediately, like,
- 11:31flips things on his head. He goes.
- 11:33And besides, what's the worst that could happen?
- 11:35Like, we're going to be fine. Everything's going to be good.
- 11:38And you're like, yeah, the worst thing that could happen is you
- 11:41get fired and you can't find a job.
- 11:42And, and you know, it's just has a way of pacing itself that you
- 11:49have a lot of these little funny moments kind of interspersed
- 11:53throughout the film. But what I love most about the
- 11:56script is that it allows each scene to just be what it's going
- 12:01to be. And it doesn't expect anything
- 12:04out of the viewer to like, I don't know, force it in any
- 12:09specific direction there. There's just a a natural smooth
- 12:13movement to the way that this script flows.
- 12:17So apparently Xalian had done a first draft of it, and then Amy
- 12:20Pascal, the head of the studio, specifically sought out Aaron
- 12:23Sorkin to come do a rewrite. And Sorkin had enough respect
- 12:27for Xalian that he said, like, I'm not going to work on this
- 12:30movie unless I get Steve Zalian's blessing.
- 12:33And so they both kind of crafted new drafts of it independently
- 12:37of each other. So they really weren't working
- 12:39together on this. I'd be interested, you know, if
- 12:41there's articles out there that talk about which scenes were
- 12:43written by which person, because there are definitely scenes in
- 12:47this movie where I'm like, oh, I think that's a Sorkin scene.
- 12:49And then there's other scenes where it's like, oh, that feels
- 12:52like the sort of pulling at the heartstrings thing that Steve's
- 12:55aliens really good at. In any case, I think that it
- 12:58adds up to a movie that I struggle to understand why this
- 13:05movie isn't a 10 out of 10 for me, Brad like it is.
- 13:11It's really good. And it's like the more I watch
- 13:15it, the more I realize that like, it's actually very
- 13:18understated in the way that it tries to pull off its themes
- 13:21that like, there's some grand overarching character arc thing
- 13:24going on with Brad Pitt and everything that is set up is
- 13:28paid off. There's like a ton of Chekhov's
- 13:29guns in this movie, but they're they don't really call attention
- 13:32to themselves. And I think because of that, the
- 13:35first four or five times I saw this movie, I was like, very
- 13:38good movie, 8 1/2 out of 10. This time around, I felt like it
- 13:42it worked even better for me, but I still just it almost has
- 13:46that like spotlight ceiling that we talked about where the way
- 13:50they made this movie I think is really appropriate for the kind
- 13:53of story they're telling. But it also kind of puts a cap
- 13:57on my overall enjoyment factor of the movie.
- 14:01I'm I'm kind of with you here, Bob.
- 14:02I found myself this time through feeling like this is a better
- 14:09movie than what I actually am seeing on the screen that
- 14:12there's, and maybe it's just because I've, I've listened to
- 14:17you talk about it and how much you love it.
- 14:19But this time through, I was struck by the beauty of the
- 14:24small moments of the film. But there's nothing that it ever
- 14:28really builds toward in my mind. Like like, yes, there's the 22
- 14:32wow, sorry, 20 game win streak. I I got a little tripped up
- 14:37there, Bob, seeing as as my Indians, you know, had a 22 game
- 14:42win streak to break this record. No big deal.
- 14:45I just thought I should throw that in there.
- 14:48It doesn't feel like this movie builds anywhere.
- 14:51And I think that's my frustration with the movie is
- 14:53like, it's at the end of the day, he started something that
- 14:59was already somewhat in the works around the league, and he
- 15:03kind of gets credit for it. And yes, like, it helped make a
- 15:07way better team than he would have built the traditional way.
- 15:11But at the end of the day, like, he's never been to the World
- 15:13Series. He's never won a World Series it
- 15:17it ends with a really cool win streak that gets them into the
- 15:20playoffs and they lose at the exact same place of the playoffs
- 15:23that they did the year before it.
- 15:26It makes me wonder if this sports story was even worth
- 15:32translating into a film. So I think that this is where I
- 15:37want to talk about the way the screenplay develops the Billy
- 15:40Bean character and Brad Pitt is so good in this movie, but also
- 15:45he's doing the understated thing so much that at times you're
- 15:48like, is he acting or is he just like really tired on set today?
- 15:52You know what I mean? Like it's a very.
- 15:54I don't understate it is the nice way of saying.
- 15:56It it reminds me of Bruce Willis in 6th sense.
- 15:59Yes, understated is the nice way of saying it.
- 16:02And I think Sleepy is like, it's like the mean, like he's got the
- 16:06old Sleepy Joe going on a little bit at times.
- 16:08And I think that like, because of that, it can be kind of easy
- 16:12to get distracted from the overall story they're trying to
- 16:15tell. And they do a great job of
- 16:17intercutting young Billy Beane being essentially like
- 16:22railroaded by the old way of gauging baseball players of
- 16:27scouting. They find him in high school.
- 16:29He has a full ride to Stanford. He chooses to chase the money
- 16:33and chase his dream. And it doesn't pan out for him.
- 16:36And he gets chewed up and spat out.
- 16:37And that has always stuck with him as a person that like, he is
- 16:42a victim of what he deems to be a, a, a failure of a system.
- 16:46It's not even just that like he thinks he got screwed, but he
- 16:50starts recognizing that like I should never have been as hyped
- 16:53up as I was as a player and like this is a fundamental flaw in
- 16:57the system. And so his embrace of the
- 16:59Moneyball system is really like him starting his own journey of
- 17:05discovery and healing. And I think for me, the the
- 17:08scene that really clicked it for me that I guess I just never put
- 17:11two and two together, is right after the 21 game or 20 game win
- 17:16streak. And it cuts to a scene of Jonah
- 17:19Hill and Brad Pitt in like a video room somewhere.
- 17:23And Brad Pitt's basically saying like, it doesn't matter, none of
- 17:27this matters. It sells hot dogs.
- 17:29But like, I know these guys. I know they don't care.
- 17:33The second we lose a game, they're going to be on our ass
- 17:36again. And what he's saying is correct
- 17:39about the way that the system sucks in baseball.
- 17:43But also, like, it's such an insight into the fact that,
- 17:46like, his character is still so deeply distrustful and haunted
- 17:51and scarred by what has happened to him that he still can't let
- 17:56himself take a step back and see that like he's already changed
- 18:00the course of baseball history by just by what he's done.
- 18:03I think it's a brilliant scene. And they do pay it off, you
- 18:05know, 20 minutes later in the movie.
- 18:07But the insights into the character are really small and
- 18:12really understated, and I think they're easy to miss if you're
- 18:15not asking yourself at every point of the movie, like, what
- 18:18does this say? Like, what's the larger picture
- 18:21here? And perhaps that's a flaw the
- 18:23movie. I'm curious like what you think
- 18:25about that? I think that, like you said,
- 18:28it's a really quiet movie and the more you sit with it, the
- 18:32more you let it simmer. I think that it makes an
- 18:35incredible experience. The, the, the beauty of Bean's
- 18:40character really is that he is distrustful of the MLB as a
- 18:45whole and he's deeply in love with like the art of the game of
- 18:50baseball. And you see that in those
- 18:53moments of contrast between who he is as a general manager and
- 18:58who he was as a player. I I think the hard part is you
- 19:02don't get enough insight, you know, you know, I don't even
- 19:05know if you ever hear his younger self speak it.
- 19:09It seems like there would be something to dive into there.
- 19:14But on another hand, like they do a good job of treating it
- 19:17like they are, you know, their memories.
- 19:19It's him remembering what it was like to be playing in the major
- 19:24leagues and how difficult it is. And you have to wonder, like is
- 19:28being being the type of general manager that he wishes he had as
- 19:33a player? Well, and I think that's like,
- 19:36so you get to the point at the end of the movie where their
- 19:37season's over and he gets this astronomical offer from the Red
- 19:41Sox to come be their GM. It's the, it would be making the
- 19:43highest paid GM in all of sports.
- 19:46And Jonah Hill has this moment where he looks at Brad Pitt and
- 19:50and, you know, get told Brad Pitt's like mulling it over.
- 19:53And he's like, what does this say about me?
- 19:55If I take the money at this point, he's like, it says what
- 19:58it says about every great player who goes for the money that
- 20:01they're worth it. And you can tell it doesn't sit
- 20:04well with Brad Pitt because the entire movie, what they've been
- 20:07saying is like these players that are commanding all this
- 20:10money aren't worth it. You can actually replace them
- 20:13for like, it's it's a perfect mirror image of him being on the
- 20:16other side of the equation now. But I think, Brad, that what I'm
- 20:22struggling with is. Do I actually want this movie to
- 20:28talk down to its audience more? And I think what I mean by that
- 20:32is like, it doesn't have the big showy Oscari speeches.
- 20:36It doesn't have, at least not very much.
- 20:38It doesn't have people like looking directly at Billy Beane
- 20:42the way they look at J Robert Oppenheimer and say, like, you
- 20:45are important. You need to realize how
- 20:47important you are. And I, I almost wish that it did
- 20:51a better job of underscoring the point it's trying to make about
- 20:56Billy Beane, because it relies on the audience to put two and
- 21:00two together. And I think obviously, like, we
- 21:03can do that, but it makes for a less dynamic, compelling,
- 21:08entertaining way of telling the story.
- 21:11And for me, I, I think that that all gets summed up with the
- 21:15final like big thing that happens in the film, the the big
- 21:19speech that he gives at the end when he goes, how can you not be
- 21:23romantic about baseball? I think it's a huge missed
- 21:26opportunity, Bob. Oh, that's my favorite part of
- 21:29the movie. I think that's the one place
- 21:31they nail it. See, that's the one place where
- 21:34they completely like with like. It is the best opening line for
- 21:41an absolutely terrible speech because he literally doesn't say
- 21:45anything about the beauty of baseball as a sport.
- 21:48He literally goes straight into like specifics about the Oakland
- 21:52A's. And I just was sitting there
- 21:54going, huh, I thought that this this was like an actual
- 21:59beautiful summary of what the sport of baseball is.
- 22:03But it's not. It's just him talking about like
- 22:08the Oakland A's for another few minutes.
- 22:10And I was so let down by that because the movie should be
- 22:17about more than just sabermetrics.
- 22:20Like, it should be more than just about the way that they've
- 22:24selected their players. And at the end of the day,
- 22:26that's all it's about. And so I, I found myself at the
- 22:30end of it kind of disappointed, like, oh, I was expecting this
- 22:33more to be about like the beauty of baseball as a whole and what
- 22:38it can mean to a person. And, and it just kind of fell
- 22:40short of that. It fell shallow.
- 22:42Yeah, and I think that's what I'm saying.
- 22:43I wish they made more explicit the way that he actually helped
- 22:47the players themselves too. And you you get a couple guys
- 22:50like there's the the jokey scene where the guy's like, I'm going
- 22:53to pray for you. And he's like, no problem.
- 22:55He just like walks away. But what he did is he
- 23:00implemented a system that actually values undervalued
- 23:04players and it doesn't overvalue people that don't deserve it.
- 23:08And like, so he's he's solving a system that victimized him and
- 23:13that kept so many guys from ever getting their chance.
- 23:16And I think that's the beauty of what he did.
- 23:18It's not just the dollars and cents.
- 23:19And you're right that the only thing they make explicit is the
- 23:22dollars and cents and the like, secondary benefit of like you,
- 23:26you made this better for players too.
- 23:29That needed to be made a little bit more explicit to me.
- 23:32Now, what I will say, though, is like, so you have the scene
- 23:35where Brad Pitt says it's really hard not to be romantic about
- 23:39baseball, but here's why you can't.
- 23:41And that's what I was referring to, the one where he's like, it
- 23:44doesn't matter that we had this streak.
- 23:45It doesn't matter. All these guys don't care.
- 23:47But then by the end of the movie, you get the inversion of
- 23:49that with Jonah Hill presenting the guy who fell down rounding
- 23:54first and didn't realize he hit a home run.
- 23:56And I think that scene is like, it is so perfectly scripted
- 24:02because even at the point where I'm like, I'm sitting there with
- 24:04tears in my eyes about it, and and even at the point where I'm
- 24:08like, that's a little on the nose, but I still love it.
- 24:11You get the great line where Jonah Hill acknowledges that
- 24:14it's on the nose because he's like, it's a metaphor.
- 24:18And Brett's, I guess I understand that this is a
- 24:20metaphor. I just man, that part of the
- 24:22movie for me is just perfection, man.
- 24:26Oh, that. That's the line about it being a
- 24:28metaphor. I'm like, it felt like an
- 24:32intrusion of humor from eight years later.
- 24:36Like it like it felt like an intrusion of Guardians of the
- 24:39Galaxy kind of humor. And I was just kind of was like.
- 24:44Oh man. That felt icky to me.
- 24:47Now what I will say is so this movie is nominated for I believe
- 24:516 Oscars at the 2012 Academy Awards, a historically crappy
- 24:56year for movies as I look through 2011 just not not a
- 24:59great year and says even more about this movie that it
- 25:03couldn't get the momentum needed to win any of these awards.
- 25:06The one that really stands out to me though, Brad is in editing
- 25:10because I think that the editing in this movie is unbelievably
- 25:14good so much so that like you almost don't notice it.
- 25:18But when I say that this movie is like a perfect YouTube clip
- 25:21movie, it's one of those things where like you, you have to have
- 25:26almost perfect editing to make a conversation between two people
- 25:30in an office building compelling.
- 25:32And even more so when it's like Brad Pitt on the phone with
- 25:34somebody that you don't hear the voice of on the other end.
- 25:37And even more so when it's like 2 guys watching a video replay
- 25:41on a screen. But where it really got me is is
- 25:44the the montage of the streak happening before, you know, the
- 25:49final game that Billy Bean goes back to when it's all just like
- 25:53archive footage and they're intercutting it with stuff from
- 25:56100 years ago and playing radio interviews over top of it.
- 25:59It is like a brilliantly constructed historical montage.
- 26:05And this movie does stuff like that so, so well that I think
- 26:09that again, you almost don't notice it, but it is like it's a
- 26:13feat of editing for me. Yeah, it's so seamlessly weaves
- 26:18between the narrative and the history of baseball that you
- 26:23almost feel like the movie is a documentary at points.
- 26:27And it and it does it in such a beautiful way that you, the
- 26:30viewer, don't feel like you're shifting between genres from
- 26:35drama to documentary and back it.
- 26:37It just has a really beautiful movement to it, flow to it that
- 26:43I I really enjoyed that. Did you say that it won editing
- 26:46or did it not come on Oscars? I know, man.
- 26:51I don't think it won any Oscars. I'm looking through the list.
- 26:53I Yeah, The Artist dominated this Oscars season, so here's.
- 26:58Let me let me read you that the the silent.
- 27:01Movie. Yeah, let me.
- 27:02Read you the best picture line up here.
- 27:04The Artist, The Descendants, which is a movie by Alexander
- 27:07Payne. Extremely loud and incredibly
- 27:10close, which is wow, that's a bad movie.
- 27:13The Help, a movie we liked. Hugo, the Scorsese movie, Pretty
- 27:17good. Midnight in Paris, a movie that
- 27:20you notoriously hate. Moneyball, The Tree of Life and
- 27:26then War Horse, the Spielberg movie.
- 27:28Hold up. Yeah.
- 27:30Midnight in Paris. Brad, you're the only person on
- 27:33earth who does not think that's at least a good movie.
- 27:35Like I I don't want to spend any money.
- 27:37Couldn't. I literally couldn't get past
- 27:40like 40 minutes. Like I gave it a shot.
- 27:42Well allowed. Acting was so horrifically bad
- 27:46in that film. Allow that to cast a pole over.
- 27:50That's how bad of a year this was.
- 27:52If you think that movie is bad, I, I can guarantee you at least
- 27:545 movies in the best picture line up or worse than that.
- 27:57So I look at this and I'm like, for me, this is Moneyball and
- 28:00The Tree of Life. And I don't know how those two
- 28:03movies didn't win everything at the Oscars.
- 28:05Yeah, that, that's what I was thinking as well.
- 28:08I've those are the two movies I've seen.
- 28:11I've seen 1/3 of Midnight in Paris.
- 28:13You saw the help. That's true.
- 28:15The help, I apologize. So yeah, I I would say Moneyball
- 28:19is better than the help. I would say the Tree of Life is
- 28:22cooler than Moneyball, but it would have made sense.
- 28:25If Moneyball wins over Tree of Life, that's that's a crappy
- 28:30year for movies. I yeah, man, I agree.
- 28:32I agree. I I thought I would look up the
- 28:34animated film to see if that was any good.
- 28:37The animated feature film of that year was Rango.
- 28:42Narrowly beating out Kung Fu Panda 2.
- 28:45Yes, and Puss in Boots. So Brad, on that note, why don't
- 28:51we hit pause here? I want to come back and talk a
- 28:53little bit about like what we think really works about the
- 28:56movie and then specifically dive into the two main performances
- 28:59here in Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill.
- 29:01But first, we've got to drink some whiskey.
- 29:03So what do you say we try this extremely long titled Bardstown
- 29:07Bourbon Company Bourbon? Let's drink some whiskey, Bob.
- 29:16All right, so today we are checking out Bardstown Bourbon
- 29:19Company Distillery Reserve. Now this is a new line of
- 29:23whiskeys from Bardstown that they are launching with this
- 29:27inaugural blend called the Cathedral French Oak Barrel
- 29:31finish. This is a blend of Kentucky
- 29:33straight bourbon whiskeys that are finished for 14 months in
- 29:36what they refer to as 300 year old French oak barrels.
- 29:42Now Brad, this is. That sounds listen expensive.
- 29:46It does. I I'm a marketing guy.
- 29:48I do a lot with copywriting. This is where language is very
- 29:52important, Brad, because there are times where a barrel or the
- 29:56wood used in a cooperage to make a barrel has been aged after the
- 30:01tree has been cut down like they age the wood.
- 30:04I don't believe that's what's going on here.
- 30:06Now, the trees that were chopped down to make these barrels were
- 30:09at least 300 years of age. I don't know if we can actually
- 30:12call that 300 year old oak the way that they're intending it to
- 30:16be interpreted, but I maybe I'm reading it wrong.
- 30:19I will just say first strike against this whiskey for me is
- 30:23like you guys got to you got to be clear about what we're doing
- 30:26with the wood here. Bob, I personally, this is just
- 30:30me. I remember living in Boston and
- 30:36we went to a ice cream shop called, I think it was called
- 30:39Richardson's Creamery. And on their logo it was like
- 30:44ice cream since 1685. And whether or not like they've
- 30:51been making the modern version of ice cream since then or like
- 30:55some ancient, you know, Puritan version of ice cream, I don't
- 30:59really care. Because when you say something
- 31:01is 300 years old, I don't, it doesn't bother me if it's a 300
- 31:07year old tree or a 300 year old aged piece of wood that was cut
- 31:12down to a tree. I I think either is impressive.
- 31:15It is very impressive. They also used trees that were
- 31:20harvested to help with the repairs on the Notre Dame
- 31:23Cathedral. So it's, it seems like these are
- 31:27the the pieces of wood that didn't make it into the
- 31:29cathedral. But that's why this is called
- 31:30like holy wood. It well, it seems like it was
- 31:34destined to become holy wood, but then it was intercepted by
- 31:37the Bourbon makers and they were like, no, you, you will not make
- 31:41it into the cathedral. We're just going to call this
- 31:44cathedral French oak instead. So I love that they not only
- 31:48didn't allow it to get used in the cathedral, but that they
- 31:51then took it and called it cathedral oak just as a big
- 31:55middle finger. Like, forget you gigantic.
- 31:58I don't know, Bob. Gigantic Duomo.
- 32:02I don't know Bob, knowing how much the Catholics like to
- 32:04drink, it would not surprise me if they like set up side some of
- 32:08the wood to be used in such a manner.
- 32:11They actually said we don't need that beam after all.
- 32:13RIP that out, let's make whiskey with.
- 32:15It bro, I know that who's still Gonzales might not have talked
- 32:18about it, but you better believe that almost every innovation of
- 32:22in the world of beer from like 500 till now happened because of
- 32:28monasteries all. Right, so this is a blend of at
- 32:31least 5 of different whiskeys. They are all Kentucky bourbons.
- 32:34They're ranging from 9 years to 18 years in age.
- 32:38Let's dive into this Brad. It's clocking in at 110.1 proof.
- 32:42Thank you to Bardstown for sending us this sample and thank
- 32:45you for what I am picking up on the nose of this bad boy.
- 32:48Brad, this is just I mean, it was an immediate well aged
- 32:53bourbon bomb. When I poured it out, it didn't
- 32:56it didn't like it didn't sense over oaked, but it was like, oh
- 33:00man, every time we've had a really good like 1415 or plus
- 33:04bourbon, it has this distinct, I guess I would just call it
- 33:09mature character to the nose. And then when that settled down
- 33:13a little bit, I got notes of like, Coca-Cola, but it really
- 33:16tipped into almost like a flat root beer for me.
- 33:19There's like this kind of syrupy sarsaparilla kind of note going
- 33:23on underneath it all. It's really decadent, really
- 33:27rich. The color on this is absurdly
- 33:29dark. Brad, I'm going to give this a
- 33:30nine out of 10 on the nose. Yeah, I'm, I'm with you, man.
- 33:34For me, it's it was almost like a really heavy cherry licorice
- 33:39vibe. There's some black pepper.
- 33:41It's a bit little bit of an orange zest.
- 33:44It kind of reminded me of like hot chocolate powder and all of
- 33:49that going along with some really nice mature caramel
- 33:53vanilla vibes of the classic bourbon.
- 33:56This is one of the best noses I think I've had on bourbon in a
- 34:00while. Bob, I'm not going to lie to
- 34:01you, I feel like I've almost given up on bourbon.
- 34:07Even you were teasing this last week, weren't you?
- 34:10Or the week before you were like, oh, this Scotch is just
- 34:12OK, but I'd still drink it over every other bourbon.
- 34:16Yeah. I this is the first bourbon I've
- 34:18had in a while that the nose makes me really excited, so 9
- 34:22out of 10 for me here. The palette Robert this is
- 34:29stunningly good. It is Okie, but in the most like
- 34:33smooth and mellow way I can describe.
- 34:37There is brown sugar, there is cinnamon.
- 34:39It's got that orange zest coming through.
- 34:42It reminds me of like a really nice creamy Creme brulee.
- 34:45Just little piece of deliciousness.
- 34:50This is the and I mean this in the best way possible.
- 34:53This is the closest thing I think I've ever had from
- 34:55Bardstown. That reminds me of some of the
- 34:57higher end versions of the Bourbons we get from like the
- 35:00big boy players in the industry like this.
- 35:04You could set this down next to Wild Turkey Rare Breed and I
- 35:07think it's right in that flavor wheelhouse.
- 35:09I actually I think it's right there with Four Roses Small
- 35:12Batch Select as well. It's just a a really nice down
- 35:16the middle, well aged, super sweet bourbon.
- 35:20It is like syrupy sweet in terms of like natural Maple syrup on
- 35:25the tip of my tongue. There's waves of cherry as well.
- 35:29I don't think this is very viscous like and I don't know if
- 35:32that makes a huge difference. I did expect it to be a little
- 35:35bit more viscous with how well aged it is, but it it just kind
- 35:39of dances across your tongue. It's a really easy to drink
- 35:42bourbon. It shoots like an electric wave
- 35:45back up your tongue in terms of how prickly it is on the palate.
- 35:49But it's, I already said down the middle, because I think this
- 35:52is a really crowd pleasing bourbon.
- 35:54There's nothing super complex going on here, Brad, but it's
- 35:58just like, this is everything I want in a bourbon.
- 36:01I'm going to give it a 9.5 on the palate.
- 36:04Yeah, I, I, I don't know if I set my score.
- 36:06I'm at a nine and a half on the pallet as well.
- 36:08I think I disagree with you a little bit though.
- 36:10I think that this is a relatively complex bourbon.
- 36:13It like it has some really nice, almost like cigar notes going
- 36:18on, which for me, the Finnish has a decent amount of oak.
- 36:22It's got black pepper. It lands in a really nice cigar
- 36:26area. There's some almonds, almost
- 36:29like an almond extract. I think that this is a 10 out of
- 36:3310 finish Bob and and I think it's a relatively complex
- 36:38bourbon compared to something that is unfinished and
- 36:42unblended. Every year at ALDI, I'm a big
- 36:45ALDI guy, by the way, they, they do twice a year, it's called
- 36:48German Week and they bring in a bunch of their foods from, you
- 36:51know, because ALDI is a German company.
- 36:52And so they sell like a lot of the stuff that they would
- 36:54normally sell in Germany for like a week in ALDI.
- 36:57And they have all these incredible desserts and they're
- 37:00always in like the frozen section, but there's these super
- 37:03decadent, like German cakes and pastries.
- 37:07And almost all of them have some amount of almond in them.
- 37:10And I'm, I'm with you, dude. There's there's a ton of almond
- 37:12on this, but I get quite a bit of almost like a raisiny or
- 37:15pruny character as well. It's like a really nice German
- 37:19cake. And I'm sure the French people
- 37:21that that, you know, offered up these wonderful barrels don't
- 37:25want to be compared to the Germans, but that's what it
- 37:28reminds me of. Like it has a distinctly
- 37:30European tart or pastry feel to it on the finish.
- 37:35I am going to give it a 10 out of 10.
- 37:37This the best thing I've had from Bardstown in years and we
- 37:41had one I think a couple seasons ago that was among our highest
- 37:44rated of the season that was a wine finish from them.
- 37:48I, I can't even remember the name of it now because I am so
- 37:51enthralled with the one we're drinking at the moment.
- 37:53Brad, this is fantastic. Yeah, I we have not had
- 37:56something from Bardstown this impressive in a while.
- 38:00And that's not saying that Bardstown isn't putting out
- 38:02great product because they are. This one is just a step above
- 38:07like an A into a plus territory. I, I think balance wise this is
- 38:12a 10 out of 10 that there there is everything you want here.
- 38:16It is rich and complex. It has a great balance of
- 38:21flavors. I I'm gave it a 10 out of 10 on
- 38:23the finish. I'm going to give it a 10 out of
- 38:2410 on the balance. I'm going to give it a 9.5.
- 38:27The only knock I think against this is that I wish it did have
- 38:30a little bit more viscosity to it, and I wish that it lingered
- 38:34just a little bit longer on the finish.
- 38:36But everything that it offers is so good that I can't go any
- 38:40lower than a 9.5 here. So even before we get into
- 38:43value, I'm at a 38 out of 40 when it comes to just the actual
- 38:49tasting experience. Brad, where are you?
- 38:52I am at a 38.5. Yeah.
- 38:56So I mean, like we're sitting like, you know, if you
- 38:58extrapolated that out, we're at like a 95 out of 100 on this.
- 39:01This is one of the best whiskeys, I mean, just by the
- 39:04numbers that we've ever had on this podcast, yeah.
- 39:08I'm curious, Bob, this has an MSRP, which I would say in
- 39:13general you can find products from Bardstown for their MSRP.
- 39:19This is $100. Oh yeah, that's a 10 out of 10.
- 39:23How? Do you feel about that?
- 39:24That is a 10 out of 10. I thought it was going to be.
- 39:26Everything they've been putting out lately has been like 160.
- 39:29So I was prepared to go into this like, oh, it's either going
- 39:31to be 160 or slightly more than that.
- 39:34And Bardstown always kind of straddles the line between like
- 39:38a luxury brand and like a middle class fancy when it when it
- 39:42comes to their price points, which I really appreciate.
- 39:45I'm glad that they don't price things at 2:50 or whatever at
- 39:48$100. I don't know that there is a
- 39:51better value in bourbon right now at that particular price
- 39:56point. This is unbelievably good dude.
- 39:59That's a 10 out of 10. Yeah, 10 out of 10 for me.
- 40:02I was expecting 180. Yeah, like tell me that.
- 40:07Let's let's do this, this thought exercise.
- 40:09If it was 180, what score would you give it?
- 40:13Probably like an. 8 So it's so good folks, that we would give
- 40:17it an 8 out of 10 or higher. At 180 dollars.
- 40:22It only costs $100. This is such a no brainer.
- 40:24It's like, unbelievable. Yeah.
- 40:26I mean 80% higher the cost and you only use lose 20% of our
- 40:32value score like like that. I mean would you also give it an
- 40:368 if it was at 180 bucks? Probably like at least a seven,
- 40:40I would say. Like, yeah, luckily I don't have
- 40:43to do that thought experiment because they priced it so low
- 40:46comparatively. Brad, I'm coming out to what has
- 40:50to be and, and this is a shock to me because I literally came
- 40:54into this blind tonight. I hadn't tried this.
- 40:55I had no, you know, thoughts coming in.
- 40:58This has to be my highest score I've ever given.
- 41:01I'm at a 48 out of 50. Wow, I'm at a 48.5 Bob.
- 41:08Like Brad this. Is one of the best whiskeys
- 41:11we've ever had. Yeah, I mean, and if you just
- 41:14like ask me, hey, is that one of the best whiskeys you've ever
- 41:17tasted? I probably wouldn't say yes, but
- 41:20it's just such a crowd pleaser that I think it's almost
- 41:24punching above its weight. It feels weird to say that about
- 41:27a whiskey finished in 300 year old barrels here.
- 41:31There is part of me that is like questioning how this can be
- 41:34$100. Yes.
- 41:36Because look at the blend man, 85% of this whiskey is 14 years
- 41:43old or older. Folks, this is coming out at
- 41:46$100. Listen, this is coming out to a
- 41:4848.25 out of 50 or a 96 1/2 out of 100.
- 41:55This is the highest rated whiskey we have ever had in our
- 42:00440 episode history of film and whiskey.
- 42:05This is incredible. Yeah, I I'm like, I might go buy
- 42:08another full bottle of this when it comes out.
- 42:10This is this. This is the most excited I've
- 42:12been about a new whiskey in a long time dude.
- 42:15Want to make a trip down to Kentucky?
- 42:17Let's freaking do it, man. Dude, we that's what we need to
- 42:20do. Just have a organized film and
- 42:23whiskey gathering at Bardstown just to buy this whiskey.
- 42:27All right, tying it back into our movie for the day.
- 42:29What? What better way to go than the
- 42:33Moneyball route? Dude, yeah.
- 42:37I mean, dude, Bardstown basically is like the Moneyball.
- 42:41Like they are grabbing whiskies from all over, they're helping
- 42:45other people out, they're Wheeling, Wheeling and dealing.
- 42:48And they're coming out with a product that punches way above
- 42:52its weight class. This is the Jeremy Giambi of
- 42:55Bourbons. That's what we're saying here.
- 42:58I don't know if that's a compliment or not.
- 43:01Bob, that man was dancing the whitest dance I've ever seen in
- 43:06a locker room. He deserved to get cut from the
- 43:09team. All I'm going to say is this.
- 43:11How can you not be romantic about Bardstown?
- 43:14Brad? Let's get back into talking
- 43:15about Moneyball. What do you say?
- 43:17Let's get to it. All right, everybody.
- 43:24That was Bardstown Bourbon Company.
- 43:26Something, something, something. Cathedral Whiskey.
- 43:29A whiskey. The best whiskey we've ever had.
- 43:32Yeah, I was going to say that deserves a lot more than sarcasm
- 43:35for me, because by golly, Bob, that was incredible.
- 43:41I'm I'm on cloud nine, man. Oh man, I I love drinking good
- 43:46whiskey. There's nothing like it.
- 43:48You know what is like it Brad is my freaking dominance this
- 43:51season at 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 43:55I dude, I love it man. You are doing great this year,
- 43:57Brad. Is going to try to stump your
- 44:00ball and what is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 44:08and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 44:11with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 44:16which is actually a complete lie and I have to figure out which
- 44:18one that is. Now, Brad, we're on an
- 44:21interesting streak here because we've had a couple guests on the
- 44:24show. And then before that we had the
- 44:26episode with Spotlight where you were like, I don't feel
- 44:29comfortable making up facts or fictions about this subject
- 44:32matter. So it feels like this is kind of
- 44:34our return to normalcy. I'm interested to see how I do
- 44:38without anyone here to help me this week.
- 44:40So hit me with your two Facts and a falsehood.
- 44:43In fact #1 Billy Bean is portrayed as a lonely divorcee
- 44:48in real life. He had remarried by the time
- 44:50that the streak happened. Scenes were shot with Katherine
- 44:54Morris as his second wife, Tara. They didn't make the final cut
- 44:58though, but they are included as a Blu-ray extra.
- 45:02However, Brad Pitt's character is still shown as wearing a
- 45:06wedding ring throughout the film.
- 45:09Fact #2 Director Bennett Miller was so impressed by Caris Dorsey
- 45:14when she sang the show by Lenka during her audition that he not
- 45:18only cast her as the protagonist's daughter, but let
- 45:20her sing the 2008 song twice in the movie, which was actually
- 45:24set in 2002, sacrificing some of the historical authenticity.
- 45:30Fact #3 Sony had originally allocated a much larger budget
- 45:35for the film, but after director Steven Soderbergh's departure
- 45:39over creative differences, the studio cut cost forcing rewrites
- 45:43and fewer game sequences. Interesting #3 immediately
- 45:50stands out to me because I do think that, like, I've always
- 45:53wondered if it was simply a creative choice to film the
- 45:56baseball scenes that way, as if they're like on an empty stage
- 45:59almost, or if it was like truly budgetary.
- 46:03So that could be, you know, if #3 is true, that would make a
- 46:07lot of sense #2 also sounds true to me.
- 46:09Can you just quickly remind me of what number one was?
- 46:13He was portrayed as a divorcee, but he was actually remarried at
- 46:16the time. Huh.
- 46:19It would have been funny if you were like, he's portrayed as a
- 46:20lonely divorcee. Actually, he was a super happy
- 46:23divorcee. He was just.
- 46:26Just out there tearing it up. That's the one, Swift.
- 46:30It's like Urban Meyer out there. Yeah.
- 46:31Oh gosh, although he is married. Let's see.
- 46:36You know. I have no idea.
- 46:39I I think it's probably either one or three.
- 46:42I'm going to say #1 is the falsehood just because if #3 is
- 46:47the falsehood. I think you did a really good
- 46:48job writing it, Brad. So I want to give credit.
- 46:50I'm on a good, rewarding, good writing streak here today.
- 46:53So I'll say 1 is the falsehood. Well, Bob, you have rewarded me
- 46:58properly because #3 was the falsehood and you?
- 47:01Are incorrect man, darn it. So OK, it sounds like even
- 47:07though that was a falsehood, it sounds like you also made note
- 47:13of the way that the action of the sport is filmed in this
- 47:17movie. Yeah, it's not great, Bob.
- 47:19Yeah, it's not good. It looks a little cheap, I'm not
- 47:22going to lie. Yeah, that, that.
- 47:24Was one of the roughest parts for me was the the moments where
- 47:28they are trying to show what's happening in the game.
- 47:32I think that they were going for like a let's get rid of all the
- 47:37noise, let's get rid of all the extras and just show the beauty
- 47:42of the game. It it didn't work, it wasn't my
- 47:45favorite. No, and I think that you can
- 47:47accomplish that. You know, and the sound design
- 47:50in this movie I think is really well done because there's a lot
- 47:52of times where it could like completely fades out and they
- 47:54isolate different things. And so I think you can
- 47:56accomplish most of what they tried to do visually, you know,
- 48:01orally instead. And yeah, I just a a UR hourly.
- 48:11Yeah, yeah, sure. So yeah, I'm with you, man.
- 48:16I don't think it works very well.
- 48:17And like the a lot of the stuff with the actual team I think is
- 48:22part of the weaker elements of this movie.
- 48:25Chris Pratt is really really good in this movie and it's cool
- 48:28to see him before his big breakout on Parks and Rec cause.
- 48:32Is it crazy that I freaking love him and oh.
- 48:34He's so good because he again, like I think this is where the
- 48:39understated thing works because his comic timing is really,
- 48:41really good in this movie. But they also use his comic
- 48:44timing for like non comedic moments where it's like not
- 48:48necessarily designed to make you laugh, but it's designed to
- 48:52under score how unsure of himself he is.
- 48:55And I think it like he takes that up to the extreme with Andy
- 48:59Dwyer and then with Star Lord. And here it's just like, here's
- 49:03a guy who's really struggling to like find self worth.
- 49:07And I think he plays it beautifully.
- 49:09I don't know who it is, but whoever plays the brother to
- 49:15Giambi is it. What's Jeremy?
- 49:19Jeremy, Jeremy, thank you is like terrible and perfect.
- 49:25And the image of him dancing in the clubhouse is like everything
- 49:30I wanted out of this movie. It was that just killed me.
- 49:35And the moment when Jonah Hill is like, like, no, no, don't
- 49:38trade him. Like we we we like went to bat
- 49:41for this guy and Brad Pitt looks at him like trust me, we don't
- 49:46want this guy anymore. Is the most well deserved scorn
- 49:50I think I've ever seen in a movie.
- 49:52Philip Seymour Hoffman shows up in this movie as Art Howe, the
- 49:55manager. He.
- 49:56He's got some eyebrows in this movie, man.
- 49:58Dude, here's why Philip Seymour Hoffman is like among the goats.
- 50:04He was never above taking a part that you almost forget he's in.
- 50:10And I think he does it as a favor to Bennett Miller.
- 50:12So Bennett Miller, this is only, I believe, his second film ever.
- 50:16And his first, or at least his first big one was the movie
- 50:19Capote in 2005, which wins Philip Seymour Hoffman the
- 50:22Oscar. Bennett Miller does not direct
- 50:24another movie until Moneyball six years later, but he asked
- 50:28Philip Seymour Hoffman to come on board and he does.
- 50:30And I think that like, again, it, it's the spotlight thing.
- 50:34It's he's like the the Marty Baron of this movie.
- 50:37It's so understated. But then you get these little
- 50:40moments, like the moment that Chris Pratt's character had a
- 50:44Berg hits that Homer to win the 20th game.
- 50:49Even before the music kicks in, you get a shot where you see the
- 50:53like the launch angle of the ball.
- 50:55And then the first cut is to Philip Seymour Hoffman in the
- 50:58dugout. And it's his immediate reaction
- 51:01as his eyes raise up and he realizes this guy's going to hit
- 51:04a Homer. And it is the most believable
- 51:08facial acting I've ever seen in a It's just, I just threw my
- 51:13hands up. I was like, this dude's the
- 51:14freaking goat. It's so good, man.
- 51:16Yeah. I have two thoughts.
- 51:18My first thought is of all the ways to win a sporting event,
- 51:24whether it's like a shot from outside the box and soccer, a
- 51:29Hail Mary, a three pointer to win it all, I think a home run
- 51:34is the best way to walk off of a field of battle victorious.
- 51:40Home runs are just incredible. It's.
- 51:44Secondly, oh, it's absolutely perfect.
- 51:47Secondly, Philip Seymour Hoffman is perfect in every single way.
- 51:53And I almost expected when he and Brad Pitt are like fighting
- 51:58about the line up, I expected to like see it cut to black and
- 52:03then like come up with like Brad Pitt chained to a chair and you
- 52:08just have Mission Impossible 3, Philip Seymour Hoffman looking
- 52:12at him being like, listen, it's it's not about the line up.
- 52:16All right, just. Counting to 10 with a gun on
- 52:19Hatteberg. It's about 7 control you see.
- 52:26He's so good, man. I'm, I'm, I'm glad to have him
- 52:28in this movie. Every time I see him in a movie,
- 52:29it you know, it makes me sad that we lost him so young, but
- 52:32like just so good. And then you've got Jonah Hill,
- 52:35who we just talked about a couple weeks ago in the Wolf of
- 52:38Wall Street. And this is this could not be
- 52:40more polar opposite of a character.
- 52:42This is Jonah Hill at his most insecure.
- 52:46And again, I think I've used the word understated 58 times on
- 52:51this episode so far. But like, that is clearly the
- 52:54direction that Bennett Miller is giving everyone in this film
- 52:57because it enhances the believability.
- 52:59It enhances the the idea that these could be real people.
- 53:02And his character, spoiler alert, is not a real person.
- 53:05He is a he's a mash up of a couple other different people
- 53:09and one guy in particular that apparently did not allow his
- 53:11name to be used for this film. And I just, I think he's so
- 53:15good, man. I don't know if I like him as
- 53:17much as I do in The Wolf of Wall Street, but I think that's just
- 53:21because he's so much showier in The Wolf of Wall Street that you
- 53:24remember it more, you know? It's interesting, I I feel like
- 53:29the Wolf of Wall Street character is actually more
- 53:31similar to this one in certain ways as far as like his ability
- 53:38to play a super awkward character that doesn't always
- 53:41know if he fits into a space. Like like that describes both
- 53:46characters in both worlds. The the direction that he takes
- 53:50his Moneyball character feels and ought to feel so much more
- 53:54realistic and honest that I I really love him in this movie.
- 53:59I think he is my favorite performance in this film.
- 54:02Well, that's a good segue into talking a little more about Brad
- 54:04Pitt. I, I don't know what to make of
- 54:06this Brad Pitt performance. Like, he's nominated for best
- 54:09actor. And I think that Brad Pitt is
- 54:11just he's a great actor, but he is so constantly this century,
- 54:16especially trying to find roles like this where he can play like
- 54:21he's almost toying with the idea of like, how laid back can my
- 54:24performance be? And I think it there's varying
- 54:28levels of success for me with that.
- 54:30I actually, I just took a trip to Las Vegas and I was on the
- 54:33flight out and I was like, you know, what I'm gonna watch on
- 54:35this airplane is Ocean's 11. And I, you know, you watch a
- 54:39little bit showier of a performance there.
- 54:41He's still not the most over the top in that movie.
- 54:43But I think what strikes me about watching multiple Brad
- 54:46Pitt performances kind of back-to-back is that he is like,
- 54:52I think that like mentally he tries to find like weird tics to
- 54:56give his character or, or I don't know, do something
- 55:00unexpected. And sometimes that's like an
- 55:03outburst and sometimes that's like a weird facial expression.
- 55:07And I think in that way, he's actually more similar to like,
- 55:10he, he has the same MO. I feel like as a guy like
- 55:13Nicolas Cage, but the way that manifests with Nicolas Cage is
- 55:15always like, what's the craziest thing I can do right now?
- 55:19Whereas with Pitt, it's like, you know, people always talk
- 55:21about how he's eating all the time, like he's always chewing
- 55:24something In the movie. He does that a lot.
- 55:26But I, I wonder, I don't actually know what his success
- 55:30rate is when he's making these weird choices.
- 55:33But the overall effect, I think works 90% of the time with Brad
- 55:37Pitt. And I think it works here in
- 55:40Moneyball. He is very, very determined and
- 55:47focused when it comes to his work.
- 55:49I think what makes the character work for me is his interactions
- 55:53with his daughter and the scene where he's with his ex-wife and
- 55:58her new husband. Dude the way that he cuts that
- 56:02guy down the size and he just looks at it and goes her mother
- 56:06and I will make that decision. Oh man it is like so laced with
- 56:13disgust and like I know who I am.
- 56:18I am her father. I am self assured.
- 56:21I was like blown away at that moment and it had nothing to do
- 56:24with the main thrust of the movie but it was perfect and I
- 56:27loved it. Also, can I just say, is this
- 56:32the most beautiful Brad Pitt we've seen in a movie?
- 56:37I don't know, Brad Pitt as Achilles in Troy is pretty
- 56:41pretty. Beautiful, sure.
- 56:43I the the slightly shorter hair I think does it.
- 56:46For me, OK, I like it. I like it.
- 56:48He is a beautiful man. There's no getting around it.
- 56:50The, the actor in the scene that you were talking about is the
- 56:53actor and director Spike Jones, who we will be watching one of
- 56:57his films here in a couple weeks, the movie Her with
- 56:59Joaquin Phoenix. He also was in The Wolf of Wall
- 57:02Street a couple weeks ago. Brad, he's the guy in the penny
- 57:06stock place when DiCaprio first goes in and he's like, if you
- 57:10sell $10,000 of this stock, I will personally give you a
- 57:12blowjob. That's it's the same guy.
- 57:14So, you know, just show it up here again.
- 57:18Hold on a second. What?
- 57:19What is it with directors that make random like cameos in other
- 57:24people's movies? I don't know, but I love it
- 57:26because I think he knows exactly what kind of character he plays.
- 57:30Well, because it's the same character in both of these
- 57:32movies. Yeah.
- 57:33Beta. Yeah, Exactly.
- 57:35Exactly. All right, man.
- 57:37So we've gone through the cast list.
- 57:39I guess he only. Go ahead.
- 57:41He plays betas and then he makes a movie about a guy who can't
- 57:46get laid in real life. So.
- 57:48So he's focused on an AI. The man.
- 57:53Oh, sorry, that's just funny to. Me, I think what we call that is
- 57:55self aware, you know? Sure, yeah.
- 57:58Totally. All right, so we've gone through
- 58:02the cast list. The only other major actor in
- 58:04this movie is Robin Wright, who shows up for like 3 seconds as
- 58:07his ex-wife. I honestly, I understand what
- 58:11they're trying to do with the presence of the daughter and
- 58:13telling him, you know, singing, literally singing to him.
- 58:16Just enjoy the show. I think that like, including his
- 58:20personal life in this movie is probably the movie's biggest
- 58:22mistake because he's clearly not a very good dad and he was a
- 58:25worse husband. And you can accomplish, like you
- 58:28can accomplish that by just having someone mention that to
- 58:31the audience once. Like just have one phone call
- 58:34with Robin Wright where she's like, you're a shitty dad and a
- 58:36shitty husband and then that's it.
- 58:37You know? I don't know that we need 10
- 58:39minutes of screen time with his wife or her new husband or the
- 58:43daughter. Absolutely this.
- 58:46Actually watching Moneyball marks one of the rarest feats in
- 58:52the film and Whiskey podcast history.
- 58:55Haley watched this movie with me.
- 58:58Oh wow. It's it's a very rare thing.
- 59:01And as we got to, she liked it. She was a little sad at the end
- 59:06and she said I feel like he should have taken the Boston job
- 59:11because his main like reason not to was that he didn't want to
- 59:15leave his daughter. But she already had to fly to
- 59:18see him anyways, so why not just have her fly to Boston?
- 59:22Also is there a more like 2001 thing than like sending a child
- 59:27unaccompanied on an airplane? I can't wait to do that someday.
- 59:30Dude I am 100% going to send my 13 year old on an airplane by
- 59:35herself and it's going to be so good for her.
- 59:37Yeah, you're going to learn a lot.
- 59:39Get out of here, kid. Go on.
- 59:42Get well on that note, Brad, I think it's time for us to get
- 59:45into our last segment of the day, which we call Let's Make it
- 59:48a Double. We're near the end of the
- 59:50episodes of Things listening to the film and Whiskey Show.
- 59:53Let's pair another film with this one.
- 59:55Even if it's struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 59:57day. Now let's make it a Double.
- 59:59Let's make it a Double is presented by Blackwood
- 1:00:01Distilling Company. This is the part of the show
- 1:00:04where we pick a movie to pair up with this one to make the
- 1:00:07perfect double feature. Brad, I'm really curious which
- 1:00:09direction you went. With your let's make it a double
- 1:00:12today because I think there's a couple different ways we could
- 1:00:14go. The floor is yours, Sir.
- 1:00:17I think I am going to pair this with another film that feels
- 1:00:23kind of like a documentary of realizing of historical events
- 1:00:29where they are under the gun to make something beautiful happen
- 1:00:34without any sense that it's actually going to go right.
- 1:00:38I'm going to pair this with Apollo 13.
- 1:00:41Oh, nice. Thanks, man.
- 1:00:44Yeah, I think it would be a really fun evening.
- 1:00:47I don't think I'm going to. I'm just going to spoil.
- 1:00:50If you already do, Bob, I don't think you should pair this with
- 1:00:52a baseball movie because I don't know if Moneyball at its core is
- 1:00:59a baseball movie. Yeah, even though we did an
- 1:01:02episode a couple years ago that was top five baseball movies and
- 1:01:05I'm pretty sure Muddy Ball was our winner.
- 1:01:07So yeah, it feels like we're we're doing some revisionist
- 1:01:10history here now. Easily.
- 1:01:12I will gladly revise my personal history, Bob.
- 1:01:16I'm kind of with you in that like I don't know if it's
- 1:01:19fundamentally a baseball movie, but I do want to pair it with a
- 1:01:22baseball movie. And I think that if that's the
- 1:01:24case, then there's only a few you can really pair it with
- 1:01:27because I want to essentially focus on baseball action.
- 1:01:31And I think for that I will pair this week with A League of Their
- 1:01:34Own. I think you get both sides
- 1:01:36obviously of like front office and the team with that.
- 1:01:39You also round out like what makes the baseball action so
- 1:01:44special in that movie? But I actually think Moneyball
- 1:01:48might do a better job of capturing or contextualizing why
- 1:01:53we love baseball so much. You know, it's it's, it's almost
- 1:01:56as good as the James Earl Jones speech in Field of Dreams.
- 1:02:00But we've also talked on this podcast, like I don't think
- 1:02:04Field of Dreams is really a baseball movie.
- 1:02:05Like Field of Dreams is a freaking weird movie that people
- 1:02:08remember like 2 scenes from. And so I think you can kind of
- 1:02:11capture that with Brad Pitt saying, how can you not be
- 1:02:15romantic about baseball? And then watching, you know, the
- 1:02:19the members of the the ladies of the All American League doing
- 1:02:23their Rockford Peaches thing. I'm going to pair it with a
- 1:02:25league of their own. Dude, any chance I have to tell
- 1:02:29the public about how funny watching Tom Hanks with a
- 1:02:34baseball club at like a nine year old kid is, I will
- 1:02:39absolutely take it and say you need to go watch A League of
- 1:02:42Their Own, if only for that singular scene.
- 1:02:47Listen, I don't really buy into the like, you know, we've gone
- 1:02:50soft theory, but I don't think you get away with that scene in
- 1:02:542025. We no, you have to bring back
- 1:02:57hitting children in the face with baseball gloves, right?
- 1:03:03Dude, it's fascinating to think that like I feel like we've kind
- 1:03:07of hit on a theme in our in our season, because when I think
- 1:03:12about Moneyball, it's this idea of like an underdog who has a
- 1:03:19lot of insight into an industry that comes out on top.
- 1:03:23Like, tell me that couldn't describe The Big Short.
- 1:03:27Tell me it couldn't describe Ford V Ferrari.
- 1:03:31Tell me it couldn't describe Spotlight Whiplash.
- 1:03:36Like I I feel like a lot of the movies we have highlighted from
- 1:03:40the last 25 years kind of fall into this vein of outsiders or
- 1:03:46underdogs that want to prove their greatness.
- 1:03:50I I don't know if I'm like grasping for straws here, but it
- 1:03:54it seems interesting to me. Absolutely.
- 1:03:57And I think that's like that's a major theme of what has made the
- 1:03:59great movies great over the years.
- 1:04:01Like that's a that's a Mr. Smith Goes to Washington kind of
- 1:04:05movie. That's a 12 Angry Men kind of a
- 1:04:07movie. It like, yeah, it it makes a lot
- 1:04:10of sense when you frame it that way.
- 1:04:11Speaking Speaking of 12 angry men, I watched juror #2 the
- 1:04:16other day. What'd you think, man?
- 1:04:19Oh, I was good. It's a good movie.
- 1:04:22Here's. The problem?
- 1:04:23It's Clint Eastwood trying to make a 12 Angry Men.
- 1:04:28And Clint Eastwood does not have a nuanced bone in his body,
- 1:04:33especially at like 93. Well, first of all, I don't know
- 1:04:36that I would call 12 Angry Men especially nuanced in the
- 1:04:38arguments it's trying to make. But I think what Eastwood's
- 1:04:41doing there is he's like, I'm going to make kind of ACD 90s
- 1:04:44thriller. And it was marketed as like one
- 1:04:48man stands for justice. Like, that's not even remotely
- 1:04:51what that movie's about, you know?
- 1:04:52Sure. So yeah, I'm glad you watched
- 1:04:55it, though, man. And and.
- 1:04:56With that, I liked it. It's like a 7 1/2 out of 10.
- 1:05:00Oh, for sure, but I but like it's a good 7 1/2.
- 1:05:04So with that, let's say that Let's Make it a Double was
- 1:05:07brought to you by Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 1:05:10No matter what movie you choose to pair this film up with, you
- 1:05:13can always make it a double with Blackwood Distilling Company and
- 1:05:17our friend Zach Johnston. Thanks again, Zach, for joining
- 1:05:20us. I'm super excited to continue
- 1:05:23drinking all of these whiskeys that Zach continues to give us.
- 1:05:25Brad and. Folks, in a few weeks he will be
- 1:05:29joining us to review JoJo Rabbit.
- 1:05:31That's what I'm talking about, man.
- 1:05:33He's about to be here with some more whiskey.
- 1:05:35I'm so excited, man. If you have not tried Blackwood
- 1:05:38yet, you can get 5% off of your bottle by going to
- 1:05:41bourbonoutfitter.com and using our code Film Whiskey at
- 1:05:45checkout. That's Bourbon
- 1:05:46outfitter.com/film Whiskey. Use the code Film Whiskey at
- 1:05:50checkout. Thanks again, Blackwood Brad,
- 1:05:53it's time for final scores. I think I already said that I've
- 1:05:56been in an 8 1/2 on this movie for a really long time.
- 1:05:59It's starting to click into place why I think this movie is
- 1:06:03so quote UN quote, perfectly structured.
- 1:06:07I'm just having the spotlight problem again here, and I think
- 1:06:10that I'm going to give it a nine out of 10, but I don't know if
- 1:06:14my actual enjoyment level or entertainment level will ever
- 1:06:18let me go higher than that. Yeah, I Bob, I'm sitting at an 8
- 1:06:23out of 10. I think this is a really fun,
- 1:06:26interesting, solid movie. There's just not enough oomph to
- 1:06:31it to make me want to give it a higher score.
- 1:06:34And then, and there's more than enough like average elements to
- 1:06:38the film, like 6 1/2, seven out of 10 elements to the film that
- 1:06:42I'm like, yeah, it has some great pieces, some great acting.
- 1:06:47Like if you take Philip Seymour Hoffman out of this movie, it's
- 1:06:50like a 7 out of 10 for me, 7 1/2 maybe.
- 1:06:54So like that there's elements that raise it beyond where it
- 1:06:58ought to be. I, I, I don't think it's
- 1:07:01actually a truly great film, but it's really enjoyable and really
- 1:07:07fun and an easy way to pass. I, I think it's like an hour and
- 1:07:1050 minutes, I want to say so. Yeah, Great.
- 1:07:13Like, great movie, not overbearing, really fun to
- 1:07:17watch. And truly the the scene when
- 1:07:21Pitt and his assistant are at Hatteberg's house and they're
- 1:07:25talking about how hard it is to play for a space is incredible.
- 1:07:30So I yeah, there's a lot to love here. 8 out of 10 for me.
- 1:07:34All right, Brad, so let's answer the question.
- 1:07:36Is this a modern classic for you?
- 1:07:38No. Yeah, once again, I'm gonna give
- 1:07:41my sports movie caveat. You got mad at me when I did
- 1:07:43this for Creed, but I think it applies here too.
- 1:07:45Like, there are not a lot of good sports movies in the 21st
- 1:07:48century. So on that criteria, it kind of
- 1:07:52automatically qualifies. I think if we're just talking
- 1:07:54like, let's pick the 30 or 40 best movies of the 21st century,
- 1:08:00then that's a no really good movie.
- 1:08:03But it, you know, it's just not quite there for me.
- 1:08:05So folks, that's where we're at on Moneyball.
- 1:08:07We're coming to an 8.5 out of 10 on average.
- 1:08:10But we'd like to hear what you think.
- 1:08:12You can find us on any of our social media accounts, Facebook,
- 1:08:16Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at Film.
- 1:08:19Whiskey. Or if you want to join the
- 1:08:22conversation, you can join our Discord server.
- 1:08:25We're on there every single day talking about movies, whiskey,
- 1:08:28and all sorts of other things. You can find a link to the
- 1:08:31server at the end of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:08:35Next week we'll be back talking with our friend Zach Johnston
- 1:08:39about the movie JoJo Rabbit, a film that Brad and I really
- 1:08:42enjoyed and it seems like the entire Internet hates at this
- 1:08:45point. Should be a fun conversation,
- 1:08:47Brad. I'm looking forward to that one.
- 1:08:49So join us for JoJo Rabbit next week, but until then, I'm Bob
- 1:08:52Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:08:54And we'll see you next time.