Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / San Francisco (1936)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:18every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. You ever get hit with the
- 0:23old switcheroo, Ryan? I do. Yeah? I do. Sometimes
- 0:28people ask for favors at work, and I'm like,
- 0:30yeah, that was easy, and then I'm like, oh, wait
- 0:31a minute. Mm -hmm. And then it all happened.
- 0:33What about you? Yeah, all the time. You know,
- 0:35I think that movies do it quite a bit. You think
- 0:41you're going to see one movie and then what just
- 0:43happened? Big example. I haven't seen it yet,
- 0:46but I've heard someone recently talk about how
- 0:48the Masters of the Universe movie was presented
- 0:51in the trailer as kind of a serious movie. You
- 0:54know, a lot of action, a lot of adventure. And
- 0:57it is an over -the -top comedy film. You get
- 1:01that a lot. You do. I haven't seen it yet either.
- 1:05I have heard that and I'm excited to see it as
- 1:06well. Along with the subversion and the switcheroos,
- 1:11let me ask you this. How do you feel about a
- 1:12disaster film? I love a disaster. I loved a disaster
- 1:17film. Do you think something stopped you from
- 1:21loving it? I love a disaster film with practical
- 1:24effects. And I think the modern disaster film
- 1:26is so heavily CGI that it doesn't capture me
- 1:31the way movies that I watched a lot in my childhood
- 1:34did. You know how sometimes I like to create
- 1:36awards on this show and name it something? I'm
- 1:39going to give you the Look What You Took Away
- 1:43From Us Roland Emmerich Award of loving disaster
- 1:47films with practical effects. I will say, big
- 1:50fan of The Day After Tomorrow, Roland Emmerich.
- 1:52But are you then a fan of the 2012 and everything
- 1:57afterwards, Roland Emmerich? Yeah, it gets rough
- 2:00for me. Yeah, that's when I think he's like,
- 2:02yeah, it's all CG anyways, who cares? But I agree,
- 2:05day after tomorrow, there's wolves in a frozen
- 2:09tundra of a ship in New York City. How do I turn
- 2:14that down? Is it a sub? That's cool, man. It
- 2:16is pretty cool. That is cool. It's pretty sick.
- 2:19Is that Anne Hathaway in that movie? No. Who
- 2:22is that? Jake Gyllenhaal, Dennis Quaid. Who is
- 2:24the female lead in that? Oh, that's a good question.
- 2:28I don't believe it's Anne Hathaway. Why don't
- 2:30I say... Oh, you know... Emmy Rossum. Emmy Rossum.
- 2:34Rossum. From Shameless. Oh, okay. Oh, interesting.
- 2:37She's in The Furious right now on Hulu. Just
- 2:39a connection to stuff later on. Uh -oh. We'll
- 2:44see how that goes. We will. Some people might
- 2:46be wondering, hey, you guys are talking about
- 2:47a movie called San Francisco today starring Clark
- 2:50Gable and Jeanette MacDonald. Why are you talking
- 2:52about disaster films? You'll see. We'll see why.
- 2:57I will say that on my side, I also... I think
- 3:00you said it right. I have enjoyed disaster films.
- 3:03I think disaster films, unfortunately, with the
- 3:07development of CGI, got very hackneyed, I guess
- 3:11is the best way to put it. Yeah. They've just
- 3:13been too reliant on CGI, and they can kind of
- 3:16phone in everything else. I like a movie that
- 3:19can harken back to the days of the... Was it
- 3:24earthquake sequence or ride at Universal? Oh,
- 3:27yeah. Where they put you in a subway train tunnel
- 3:32and then everything around you starts collapsing.
- 3:34They have a similar one actually at the tram,
- 3:38the Hollywood tram in Universal in Hollywood.
- 3:42Yeah, yeah, they still have that sequence. Yes,
- 3:44which is very effective. And I had a really good
- 3:47time a couple years ago when I went there. So
- 3:49anything that can make me feel like that again
- 3:51and see practical effects factored into it, I'm
- 3:54way more interested. And I'm excited to get into
- 3:56that to talk about San Francisco. The movie that
- 3:59we are talking about today, our final movie of
- 4:02the 1936 9th Academy Awards. Now, in this, there
- 4:07were six nominations for San Francisco. San Francisco.
- 4:11which we're continuing the watch out now. Just
- 4:14figured that out. Give me a break. The first
- 4:17of which is sound recording, and you're never
- 4:20going to believe it, Kyle. MGM Sound Department
- 4:22showed up with none other than Douglas Shearer.
- 4:26Yeah. This man can't stop being nominated for
- 4:28some sound. Gotta be one of the most nominated
- 4:30figures up to this point. And you know, if this
- 4:33was any other movie, I'd probably be like, all
- 4:35right, we get it, Douglas Shearer. Chill out.
- 4:36But I would say this movie earns it. And we'll
- 4:39talk about that too. Assistant director was Joseph
- 4:42M. Newman. Wonder what went wrong on this set.
- 4:45Original story was Robert Hopkins. Actor, and
- 4:49this was lead actor. Spencer Tracy as Father
- 4:53Tim Mullen. Fascinating choice. We'll get there.
- 4:55Director was W .S. Van Dyke, our, well, my guy,
- 5:00from Thin Man. Yeah. Liked him from that a bit
- 5:06better than his other film he did. His other
- 5:09two films, Naughty Marietta and Traitor Horn.
- 5:11Well, maybe not my guy. Thanks for Thin Man.
- 5:15Half of your guy. But otherwise, half of my guy.
- 5:18Yeah, there you go. I'll take Thin. And leave
- 5:21man. Sounds good, man. Outstanding production,
- 5:24MGM Metro -Goldwyn -Mayer was the final nomination.
- 5:27Yes. As you just said, W .S. Van Dyke directed
- 5:30this film, and we have the return of Clark Gable
- 5:34and Jeanette MacDonald. Blackie Norton, the notorious
- 5:38gangster really is what he is in this movie,
- 5:40trying to go politician, probably crooked politician.
- 5:45Mary Blake is an up -and -coming singer. moving
- 5:50to San Francisco to make it big. And Spencer
- 5:53Tracy plays Father Tim Mullen, who is Blackie's
- 5:57best friend and kind of the guiding figure in
- 6:02his life, trying to put him on a good path. I
- 6:05would also say he's the moral compass of San
- 6:06Francisco. Yes, as the whole city itself. The
- 6:11history of San Francisco is something I am not
- 6:14familiar with. And there's a lot of that in this
- 6:17movie that I've... Wouldn't have been surprised
- 6:19with what happens in this movie had I known the
- 6:21history. But San Francisco is presented as a
- 6:25high, wretched, high, scum and villainry. Is
- 6:30that what it is? Is that the line? Yeah, I know.
- 6:32You got it. Yeah. Did not sound like Alec Guinness
- 6:36there. You know what's so funny? It sounded a
- 6:38little more like Ian McKellen's Gandalf. Oh,
- 6:41yeah, yeah, yeah. Just a little bit. Who is also
- 6:43a wizard. Just not a space wizard. But if he
- 6:46was launched into space, I feel like he could
- 6:48have done well. I think Ian McKellen would have
- 6:51played Obi -Wan Kenobi. Oh, yeah. Yeah, he could
- 6:54have. The force is strong with you, young Bilbo.
- 7:00I don't want to see him die. No, me neither.
- 7:02In Doomsday. I mean, in Doomsday. I don't want
- 7:05to see him die anywhere. But anyway, yeah, San
- 7:07Francisco is presented as like this very risque,
- 7:11seedy city. Spencer Tracy's character, Father
- 7:16Tim Mullen, really is kind of like the one pure
- 7:19thing in the world. He's trying to—well, the
- 7:24fun thing about him is obviously he's a man of
- 7:26faith, and there's a lot of religion presented
- 7:29in this movie. Blackie himself is very much an
- 7:33atheist, and his best friend, Father Tim Mullen,
- 7:38is so cool with that, but also tries to offer
- 7:41advice and things. through that faith -based
- 7:44lifestyle without being overbearing. And he also
- 7:48does it like in the boxing ring, which I love.
- 7:51Yeah, it's interesting. I really like his introduction
- 7:54here because he's in the boxing ring fighting
- 7:55him. Yeah. And then at first it's like, is that
- 7:58Spencer Tracy? Interesting. And then he leaves
- 8:01out of the scene for maybe like 90 seconds at
- 8:04most and comes back in the full father garb.
- 8:06Yeah. And everyone's like, oh, father, yes, I'm
- 8:08so sorry, father. You're like, yeah, the father
- 8:10just knocked out. Clark Gable. It's so good.
- 8:14It is really good. I love the introduction of
- 8:17his character. I love his character a lot. And
- 8:19we'll get into him, but I want to get you the
- 8:21chance to kind of talk through what happens in
- 8:24this. Yeah. I mean, it's a really interesting
- 8:27story. We talked about the bait and switch or
- 8:31the, what was the word I used initially? Switcheroo.
- 8:36Get hit with the old switcheroo. Yeah. Because
- 8:38this is like. Part gangster movie, part musical
- 8:43in a way. Part romance. Yeah, big part romance.
- 8:47Part like philosophical faith -based movie. And
- 8:53then ultimately a disaster film in the final
- 8:56act. So Clark Gable is running this nightclub
- 8:59and he's introduced to Jeanette MacDonald and
- 9:02kind of starts to fall in love, but ultimately
- 9:06is like using her to better his club. Yes. It's
- 9:11worth noting that this is all, we see a title
- 9:13card up front that says that everyone remembers
- 9:16where they were on, is it April 17th, 1906? I
- 9:20think so. But then it immediately burns. And
- 9:24then we see instead that the title card of where
- 9:26we are right now is New Year's Eve or New Year's
- 9:28Day, 1905. I forgot that the title screen burned.
- 9:32And when I watched it, I was just like. That's
- 9:35an interesting choice. That's dramatic. And then
- 9:37instead shows us right at midnight of 1905 in
- 9:41San Francisco, and it is now officially 1906
- 9:44in San Francisco. Everyone is celebrating, drinking
- 9:47wine out of the fountain, and we see Blackie
- 9:50Norton, kind of like the king of the city, really,
- 9:52walking around. There was one sequence that makes
- 9:57a little bit more sense later on now, but at
- 10:00the time I was just laughing so hard. And Clark
- 10:04Gable, and I'm stopping just to kind of tell
- 10:06this little anecdote, Clark Gable stops and all
- 10:09of a sudden he sees that there are fire trucks
- 10:11and emergency systems running. And he hops on
- 10:15the back of one as if he's just a fireman. He's
- 10:17like, what's going on? And they're like, oh,
- 10:19hey, Blackie, here's what's happening. And they
- 10:21talk him through it. And they're like, there's
- 10:23a fire. He's like, hope it's not my place. And
- 10:25then you get there and there's children jumping
- 10:28out of a burning building. And everyone's watching
- 10:31in awe. including Blackie. Like, we gotta get
- 10:34those kids out of here. But he still makes the
- 10:36time where they're like, yeah, it doesn't look
- 10:38like it's your place, Blackie. He's like, yeah,
- 10:40it's not hot enough for mine. Like, there's children
- 10:43jumping out of a building. Maybe we don't joke.
- 10:46And he watches, and they all kind of watch in,
- 10:48like, amazement. And they land, and I think that
- 10:51this sequence is great. Like, you see the kids,
- 10:54like, actually jumping, or at least figures.
- 10:55Maybe it's, like, smaller people. I don't know.
- 10:57Stunt doubles. But they land. And as soon as
- 11:01they land, Blackie's like, is everyone out? And
- 11:03they're like, yeah, Blackie, they're out. As
- 11:05if he's the chief. And then he's like, great,
- 11:07see ya. And just leaves. And then you hear the
- 11:10fireman say, wait, there's one more person inside.
- 11:12And Spider -Man shows up. And he's like, I'm
- 11:16going in. And he's like, we'll be here when you
- 11:17get back. And he goes, not coming back, chief.
- 11:20Except Spider -Man would be so far off on the
- 11:23other coast. Right, yeah. Well, you know, he's
- 11:25traveling. Clark Gable runs behind a building
- 11:27real quick. Yeah, puts on the robe. He's Spider
- 11:33-Man. He's Green Goblin. That is what I was going
- 11:36for. Oh, he's much more Green Goblin in this
- 11:38movie. That's a good point. Although I would
- 11:41say maybe Harry Osborn is... Here you go. Here's
- 11:45a double feature for you. I think that Harry
- 11:47Osborn is Father Tim Mullen, Spencer Tracy. And
- 11:51I think that Clark Gable is the Green Goblin
- 11:53mask. Ah, yeah. That's what I think. Yeah, yeah.
- 11:57Or maybe money is the Green Goblin Mask and Clark
- 11:59Gable. Misery, misery, misery. I thought this
- 12:04was just really interesting, where I was like,
- 12:06oh man, he's really invested in the people, isn't
- 12:08he? And he's like, are they out? All right, see
- 12:10ya. And just goes to his club. Yeah. And then
- 12:12he has probably the worst line, maybe, in the
- 12:15movie for him. First off, not a big fan of his
- 12:18name. Just gonna go ahead and say that right
- 12:19off the bat. But then the second thing is when
- 12:21he talks with one of the women at his... his
- 12:25establishment the paradise and he's like what
- 12:27are you wearing and she's like oh i thought it
- 12:29was really cute and go with this right and he's
- 12:30like i told you not to wear it she's like yeah
- 12:32but you know what's the big deal i thought it
- 12:34was this and he's like take it off blackie doesn't
- 12:37like when you wear that and i was like oh no
- 12:39he does so much of that in this movie yeah he
- 12:43like clark gable is known for being like suave
- 12:48and Kind of like smarmy at times, I think. We
- 12:53get a little bit of that and it happened one
- 12:55night. Like he's sarcastic and he's snarky. But
- 12:57in this, he's sleazy. He is. He picks his spots.
- 13:03He's not sleazy all the time. No. He picks his
- 13:05spots and he tries to still be like a good person
- 13:07when it benefits himself. Yeah. But like he will
- 13:10still tout like, oh, look at this great thing
- 13:11that I'm doing for that person. It just happens
- 13:13to also benefit me. So he's not like 100 % committed
- 13:16to the sleaze, but that's the character. Yeah.
- 13:19There is the moment where I can't remember if
- 13:21it's Jeanette McDonald's character or just another
- 13:23girl shows up at his club kind of auditioning.
- 13:26She's like, would you like to hear me sing? And
- 13:28he's like, no, but I'd like to see your legs.
- 13:30This is Jeanette McDonald. Okay. Yeah. And you're
- 13:32like, yeah. Okay. Here we go. But then he brings
- 13:36up a good point. He's like, great. That's awesome
- 13:37that you can sing, but you got to be able to
- 13:39dance too. And in order to dance, you need to
- 13:41see your legs. So he kind of explains it, but
- 13:43he's way too forward. Yeah. So you're right.
- 13:46He's a creep. But it's really off and on for
- 13:49me that he is. Interesting. I think he's detestable
- 13:52in this movie. See, here's what's tough. I think
- 13:56he's detestable off screen. So I'm almost like
- 13:59yearning for an opportunity to not see him detestable
- 14:02and be like, oh, that's where he's likable. Right.
- 14:04So I think maybe that's why. OK. But I mean,
- 14:06no, he says these things 100 percent. But then
- 14:10in the act of hiring her, he, of course, introduces
- 14:14this. this bright light into the seedy underbelly
- 14:18of San Francisco. Yeah. And Father Tim Mullen
- 14:22sees the opportunity to either save this girl
- 14:27from getting involved in the dark nature of San
- 14:29Francisco or potentially pierce the black heart
- 14:33of Blackie Norton to then save his soul, which
- 14:36is something he's been trying to do for 20 years.
- 14:38Yeah. So this kind of blends in, I would almost
- 14:42say seamlessly. The themes that you talked about
- 14:45of corruption, of love, of faith and religion,
- 14:50of redemption. Like, all of these themes are
- 14:53covered so well in just these three people. And
- 14:56it is a story that I was really interested in.
- 14:58Yeah. I thought that it was hitting all of the
- 15:01milestones so well. It's like, yep, this is where
- 15:04she gets really popular, but she chooses the
- 15:06club. And then this is where they choose their
- 15:09love, but then they don't. And she ends up singing
- 15:11at the Tivoli, somewhere where she's always destined
- 15:13to be with the voice that she has. And then she's
- 15:15not sure if he wants to be this person. So she
- 15:17does this. And all of these things happen. And
- 15:20I was like, this movie is like hitting all the
- 15:22milestones without feeling like it's wasting
- 15:24any time. And I'm a really big fan. This movie
- 15:27is an hour and 55 minutes, I think. I think that's
- 15:31right. Yeah. And by the time that I think that
- 15:35she and. She stops working at the Tivoli. I was
- 15:39like, is it Tivoli or Tivoli? I think it's Tivoli.
- 15:42I'm just trying not to think of Nirvana, the
- 15:43band, the show, the movie. Which, by the way,
- 15:45I want to say, in our previous episode where
- 15:47we talked about A Tale of Two Cities, the fact
- 15:49that we talked about both A Tale of Two Cities
- 15:51and Nirvana, the band, the show, the movie, in
- 15:53that one episode, I'm a very big fan. I just
- 15:56wanted to say that out loud. I didn't mean, I
- 15:58forgot to not, I forgot I didn't say it before.
- 16:00But we got to the scene where she chooses to
- 16:03instead return to the Paradise instead of the
- 16:05Tivoli. Right. and I had to let Murph out or
- 16:09something, so I paused the movie. And I saw that
- 16:11I was an hour and 20 minutes into this movie.
- 16:14Yeah. And I said, what? How is this not hour
- 16:17three of this movie? So this is where I need
- 16:21you to kind of talk me through some stuff. I
- 16:23feel like the movie expertly navigated its way
- 16:27through these plot points and didn't feel like
- 16:29it was stalling at any point. And yet, an hour
- 16:34and 20 minutes feels like three hours. This movie
- 16:37is about 10 to 15 minutes, maybe 20 minutes shorter
- 16:41than A Tale of Two Cities, but felt significantly
- 16:44longer than A Tale of Two Cities to me. Yeah.
- 16:47The movie doesn't feel like it's meandering or
- 16:52stumbling through its plot points. Not at all.
- 16:54I don't know that I was in love with the plot.
- 16:57I like a lot of the theming is what it is. I
- 17:00agree. I think Blackie... While he is kind of
- 17:05an obnoxious character, I think he is interesting,
- 17:07especially when it comes to his faith. And like
- 17:10I was I was interested in that element of this
- 17:12movie because we're in the production code era.
- 17:16It's it's interesting to tackle like lack of
- 17:19faith, I think. But the the romance and everything
- 17:22with Clark Gable and Jeanette McDonald, that
- 17:25that really wasn't catching my interest at all.
- 17:28So I don't know. I was kind of lukewarm. through
- 17:31a good portion of this movie. And similar to
- 17:35Three Smart Girls, the way we talked about Deanna...
- 17:40Durbin. Durbin, and how the movie was rewritten
- 17:43so that it could highlight her singing skills.
- 17:47This movie feels like, hey, we know you like
- 17:51music, we know you like singing, we know you
- 17:53like musicals, so Jeanette McDonald's here. Obviously,
- 17:55one of the most famous voices of the time. We
- 17:58talked about her not only in the Love Parade,
- 18:02but her return in Naughty Marietta. Yes. Operatic
- 18:07movie. So like a whole other version of singing
- 18:09from the Love Parade. That all kind of like it
- 18:12made sense as far as the plot goes. But every
- 18:15time there was a singing. moment i'm like yeah
- 18:17she sounds great but like what what are we doing
- 18:19here really it's interesting i think i can defend
- 18:22this a bit better than i can three smart girls
- 18:25in terms of why they're singing in this right
- 18:28sure the plot is just like it's so woven into
- 18:30it of like the paradise the tivoli like the mafia
- 18:34or the gangsters in san francisco all have an
- 18:39area in which earns them money and then they
- 18:41operate out of that and for Clark Gable's Blackie
- 18:46Norton, that's the Paradise. And for Jack Holt's
- 18:50Jack Burley, that is not just the Tivoli, but
- 18:54more like being associated with individuals like,
- 18:58I forget his name, but I think it's Bedini, actually.
- 19:01Senior Bedini. Being involved with those individuals
- 19:03of higher class. So he's able to kind of like,
- 19:05you know, get them that way. So the singing aspect
- 19:08made a lot more sense to me. Here's what's interesting.
- 19:11I don't know if you read this. Jeanette MacDonald
- 19:13actually made this movie happen. She brought
- 19:15this to MGM and wanted it to happen. She actually
- 19:19requested Clark Gable, too, which makes some
- 19:22things a little interesting that we'll get into
- 19:24a little later here. But she wanted this to happen.
- 19:28So I would say the movie actually started with
- 19:30her singing and then evolved outside of that.
- 19:32Clark Gable being involved in a movie that's
- 19:35heavily as much of a musical as this one is or
- 19:39can be is interesting because it really doesn't
- 19:41belong there. Right. You mentioned that this
- 19:44is similar to Three Smart Girls. I would say
- 19:46it's more similar to like Broadway Melody in
- 19:48which we are watching a Broadway show or an opera.
- 19:52So you're just hearing that performance. No one
- 19:55else is breaking into song with her. I agree.
- 19:58I agree with the first like hour and 35 minutes,
- 20:02hour and 40 minutes. Yes. Where I'm like, yes,
- 20:04I understand that. This is kind of the. Part
- 20:08of the course of the musicals that we cover on
- 20:10the show, there is a story about performers.
- 20:14There is a story about a venue or a club or a
- 20:18director or something like that and its actors
- 20:21who will perform in the movie. Yes. And that
- 20:24is completely what's happening here. It's the
- 20:28fact that this movie takes such a dramatic shift
- 20:30in its final act that I'm like, what a weird
- 20:33choice to follow these people specifically. During
- 20:38this historic event. I think that's what's odd
- 20:41to me. But I guess it makes sense. It's the 30s.
- 20:43Of course, we're going to add music anywhere
- 20:45we can. Yeah. I mean, it's going to happen. And
- 20:48I think that Jeanette McDonald is a good beacon
- 20:52for that. It makes sense to see her in this.
- 20:56The other thing I want to mention before we get
- 20:59too far from the story is, I mean, let's go and
- 21:02talk about Spencer Tracy. Yeah. Spencer Tracy,
- 21:05as I mentioned, received a lead actor nomination
- 21:08for this. Interesting, because we're just coming
- 21:11off of the heels of Mutiny on the Bounty, a movie
- 21:15of Clark Gable's that also saw some, I'm going
- 21:18to say hashtag or like hashtag quote, controversy
- 21:21around lead actor nominations. So it's interesting
- 21:27that in this one, we're seeing Clark Gable as
- 21:30clearly the lead of this movie. He and Janet
- 21:32McDonald are sharing the lead. in this. His name,
- 21:35of course, first. But then after the two of them,
- 21:38some spaces, and then Spencer Tracy. But Spencer
- 21:41Tracy got the nomination for this, and he also
- 21:44won this award, I believe. No, he didn't. He
- 21:47did not win the award for this. My bad. But I
- 21:50will say that this man earned this nomination.
- 21:53I love Spencer Tracy in this movie. I think he
- 21:56is on something that is very interesting. He
- 21:59is obviously known for some different things,
- 22:02being a heavy hitter or like a thug type in some
- 22:05movies, even though we just saw him in Liable
- 22:07Lady a bit differently. This movie changes that.
- 22:10This changes things for him. He goes on next
- 22:12month, next year, but next month for you and
- 22:15I, to do Captain's Courageous. And he's nominated
- 22:19for that role as well. We'll get to what happens
- 22:21with him. But this opens doors for him that he
- 22:23didn't have previously. And I think the idea
- 22:26of him playing this beacon of hope in a city
- 22:30that otherwise doesn't have that serves him extremely
- 22:33well. And I really like him. I think the moment
- 22:35that I fell in love with his character in this,
- 22:37or his performance, was when he has a conversation
- 22:41with Jeanette MacDonald, with Mary Blake. And
- 22:45he invites her into his office because he's going
- 22:47to make coffee, and he's talking with her. And
- 22:50while he's talking, he's talking about, like,
- 22:52you know, this, I can't remember exactly what's
- 22:54in the story, but he mentions, like, a duck.
- 22:57And he says, like, yeah, there was a, and then
- 23:00there was this duck that came along. And then
- 23:01he grabs a pen and says, almost to himself, that
- 23:05reminds me, that Mickey kid ducked mass this
- 23:08morning. And he, like, writes something down
- 23:10on a piece of paper, puts it down, and then keeps
- 23:12talking. So this was ad -libbed. Spencer Tracy
- 23:15just threw this in. He previously worked with
- 23:17Mickey Rooney. on a movie called riffraff yeah
- 23:21and he was just shouting out and like acknowledging
- 23:24mickey rooney by saying like that rooney guy
- 23:26or rooney kid but he uses this to kind of say
- 23:29like he ducked him and he just puts that in the
- 23:31movie this is genius on multiple levels for him
- 23:34one he wants to shout at mickey rooney he finds
- 23:36a way to do it two he knows spencer tracy knows
- 23:40that ws van dyke as we know from thin man really
- 23:44doesn't like to do multiple takes yeah so he's
- 23:46going to do one take and keep it in So if he
- 23:49puts this in here and just expertly kind of puts
- 23:51it in, he knows that W .S. Van Dyke is likely
- 23:53going to continue rolling on this so he can get
- 23:56away with it. And this is something where he
- 23:59can put a little bit more of himself into the
- 24:00role and not just play this character. Yeah.
- 24:03And if you look at this scene again and you watch
- 24:06Jeanette McDonald's reaction, you can see where
- 24:08she actually is like kind of taken by surprise.
- 24:10And she's like. what's going on in this moment
- 24:13which kind of works out she's like i don't know
- 24:15who that is and like what you're telling me this
- 24:16for but that would be organic in that scene so
- 24:19it's such a like perfect opportunity for him
- 24:22to put this in here and not be the star and not
- 24:25be like all eyes are on me with this one line
- 24:27that i do and i'm so dramatic and i'm throwing
- 24:29my hand on the table it's subtle but it feels
- 24:31lived in and it makes this character feel authentic
- 24:34And I was just like not even reading on this.
- 24:37I was like, man, that's a really cool thing.
- 24:39That was a great idea on the writer to put that
- 24:41in. And I'm like, oh, he came up with it. Right.
- 24:43That's even better. Man, I think we're starting
- 24:45to see that style of acting show up more and
- 24:49more in these movies, which is, again, my favorite
- 24:51part of the podcast is seeing the evolution of
- 24:54all of these different crafts. We talked about
- 24:56in Doddsworth how there's a similar moment, which
- 25:00I can't remember specifics now. But I love all
- 25:03of that. When people truly bring these characters
- 25:06to life, it doesn't just feel like you're reading
- 25:08the lines or performing the lines even. You are
- 25:11building a person from the ground up. Was it
- 25:15the decision of him hearing that they got a noise
- 25:18complaint, but instead of stopping the conversation,
- 25:21it's continuing? No, I think it was him looking
- 25:23for a lighter or cigarettes or something. Oh,
- 25:27yes. But then he found the cigarettes on the
- 25:29couch. Yes. Yeah, it was that. I love that. I
- 25:33love Spencer Tracy in this role more so than
- 25:37I did in Libeled Lady. And they're completely
- 25:39different characters, but I think that shows
- 25:40his range as well. And I think if we're talking
- 25:43about range, you have to give some praise to
- 25:46Jeanette McDonald as well. Oh, yeah. Because
- 25:48she has been known, at least on this show, for
- 25:51being kind of like a pre -code sex symbol. And
- 25:57in this, she is kind of the tame, timid star
- 26:00who follows faith. much more closely than Blackie
- 26:06does. And she's much closer with the father,
- 26:09with Spencer Tracy's character. And I love that
- 26:13range for her as well. You're getting to see
- 26:16some showcases of these actors, these performers.
- 26:20That's very exciting to me. This is not an example
- 26:23of that for Clark Gable, though. I have some
- 26:27qualm with that. But I think I would be fighting
- 26:30both you and Clark Gable in what I have to say.
- 26:33Because I think Clark Gable would be like, no,
- 26:34no, stop. Don't talk about that. Without getting
- 26:37into too many specifics, there's a scene at the
- 26:39very end of the movie where he is meant to be
- 26:42groveling. He is meant to be very emotional and
- 26:44almost like accepting God into his life. And
- 26:47this scene is mostly shot from behind. I read
- 26:51that this was because he requested that all of
- 26:54his like... I think his words, sappy lines were
- 26:57all filmed from behind. So it wasn't shown like
- 26:59his face and you can make the plausible deniability.
- 27:01It wasn't him. Um, and I think that's really
- 27:04where it starts to show his range and like him
- 27:07walking through San Francisco. Again, I'm admitting
- 27:09a very large part of this cause we'll get there.
- 27:11Yeah. But him walking through San Francisco for
- 27:13like days and then, uh, seeing, um, or being
- 27:18reunited with father Tim Mullen. And deciding
- 27:21to, like, then accept God into his life and,
- 27:23like, grovel at that is something that Clark
- 27:25Gable was like, I would never do that. But, okay,
- 27:28sure. He also didn't want to make this movie.
- 27:31That's another thing to kind of point out. He
- 27:32didn't want to make this, but he was kind of
- 27:34at the whim of MGM. And he decided to anyways.
- 27:37I mean, he did. I don't think he decided to.
- 27:39They're just like, you do it. You work for me.
- 27:41But it's always funny when I hear things like
- 27:43that with these movies of, like, yeah, you're
- 27:44under a contract, so you have to do this even
- 27:46though you don't want to. And then you watch
- 27:48it and you're like, you're so good. Like, you're
- 27:50so good in this movie. Even when you're like,
- 27:52I don't want to be here. It's like, wow, you're
- 27:53such a good actor. Why are you such a terrible
- 27:55person? So, at least in everything we're reading.
- 28:00That's where I think it's like, man, you're unlocking
- 28:02something. Like, you're unlocking something where
- 28:04I think you really could truly be great. Because
- 28:06you are charming. You know, I think people always
- 28:09kind of compare Clooney to Gable. And they're
- 28:12like, you have that charisma. I will say, though,
- 28:15I think Clooney has out -surpassed. uh gable
- 28:18for me in his humility lack of humility he is
- 28:22willing to like be the butt of it i mean look
- 28:24at him in the coen brothers movies like he is
- 28:26willing to be laughed at he is willing to be
- 28:29the fool and to go the extra mile i i don't think
- 28:32gable is allowing himself to do that because
- 28:35of his own pride at least what i've seen so far
- 28:37but i mean we have the biggest hitter of any
- 28:40for him to come with gone with the wind that's
- 28:43so There's still some time for that to be true.
- 28:46But from what we've seen, I agree with what you're
- 28:49saying in part. And I think just the brief, brief
- 28:53semblance of him having a lack of humility in
- 28:56this makes him a better actor to me. No, he's
- 28:59great at the end of this movie. He's great throughout
- 29:01the whole movie. Yes. I think that he's playing
- 29:03a very similar character. to It Happened One
- 29:05Night. Oh, totally. Just with the snarkiness
- 29:07of the performance. And I think that's what he's
- 29:09well known for. Yes. But he is not an unskilled
- 29:14actor by any means. No. The end of this movie
- 29:17moved me emotionally in a way that I did not
- 29:20expect. Yes. Especially with all of the lead
- 29:22up to what's happening. Because it ties just
- 29:25about everything. There was a part of this where
- 29:28he runs for supervisor? Uh, yes, he, he, it's
- 29:33some political role and, uh, Spencer Tracy, the
- 29:37father is kind of pushing for this because he
- 29:39thinks you can enact real change if you're in
- 29:43a position of political power. Yeah. Uh, and
- 29:45that doesn't end up panning out very much at
- 29:47all. That's the only thing that I think in this
- 29:49movie doesn't like super tied into the ending.
- 29:52Yeah. I mean, granted, there's a reason that
- 29:54no one's like. hey, who's in charge of San Francisco
- 29:56right now by the end of this movie? Yeah. Which
- 29:58we'll get into. But it feels like that's kind
- 30:00of like bypassed a bit. Everything else though,
- 30:02I think that ending just ties everything together
- 30:04so nicely. I think it does too. I think it does
- 30:06too. Blackie as well, like his snarkiness is
- 30:10one thing and his relationship with Faith is
- 30:14the most interesting part about his character.
- 30:16And I think that one of the best visual representations
- 30:19of this is He is known for throwing hands. And
- 30:24I think he knocks out like three or four people
- 30:26in this movie total. But the most memorable one
- 30:29is when Mary Blake shows up deciding like she
- 30:33is going to work at his club. And he's like,
- 30:36perfect. We'll get you on stage in just a moment.
- 30:38And Father, is it Father Tim, his name? Spencer
- 30:41Tracy, yes. Father Tim shows up and he's like,
- 30:44wait a minute, what are we doing? You're a good
- 30:46woman. Like you shouldn't be here. There's no
- 30:49way you're going to go on stage. And Blackie,
- 30:52of course, is like, this is the deal, man. This
- 30:55is what we're doing. And they get into a little
- 30:56scuffle and Blackie punches Father Tim in the
- 30:59face. And I think that's the biggest visual representation
- 31:03of how little connection Blackie has to Faith
- 31:07at all. Because not only has he just swung on
- 31:10his best friend, but he swung on a priest. Yes.
- 31:15And that was the first moment in the movie I
- 31:18was like, oh, wow. They're showing violence for
- 31:21one, but also like during the production code
- 31:23era, we now have a priest who has a bloody nose
- 31:27after being hit in the face. And that was just
- 31:30really striking, a really striking visual that
- 31:33I didn't expect. Well, there's a almost haunting
- 31:37image of once he punches Father Tim Mullins,
- 31:41Spencer Tracy looks back up and his nose is bleeding
- 31:44and he doesn't have anger in his face or anything.
- 31:46It's just more like. I want you to see what you've
- 31:48done. And that sells that image so well. Of course,
- 31:52it's the exact realization that Mary Blake needs
- 31:56to realize that she can't be with Blackie because
- 31:59of how dark his heart is at this time. And I
- 32:04thought that was done extremely well. I really
- 32:06liked Clark Gable and Janet McDonald together.
- 32:09I don't think they're my favorite couple by any
- 32:11means, but I like them a lot, which makes it
- 32:13interesting to know that they did not. talk to
- 32:16each other on set. Really? They really did not
- 32:18like each other. I mentioned that Janet McDonald
- 32:19recommended Clark Gable for this, but she and
- 32:24Gable did not get along. They actually avoided
- 32:26each other on set in between takes. I did read
- 32:30a bit more about how in between their love scenes,
- 32:33like whenever they would kiss, Clark Gable would
- 32:35eat a plate of spaghetti with a lot of garlic
- 32:37in it. Oh, no. To kind of deter her. and there's
- 32:43a couple scenes where they're kissing where you
- 32:44can kind of see it a little bit, where she's
- 32:45like, oh, it's just so much garlic. That's unfortunate.
- 32:49A lot of this just kind of continues to paint
- 32:51Clark Gable in a little stinker way of, if I
- 32:53don't like someone, I'm just going to make it
- 32:55really difficult for them to be on set, which
- 32:57sucks. No one likes to see that. But again, great
- 33:01acting on both sides because you can see where...
- 33:04Jeanette McDonald's Mary Blake is in love with
- 33:06Blackie at times. Like, you believe that. And
- 33:09with Clark Gable, you believe a lot of his character,
- 33:11too, even though he's wrestling with those, like,
- 33:12inner demons. Yeah. I also like that they don't
- 33:16really go into a lot of, well, this is what Blackie
- 33:18went through as a child, and this is why he's
- 33:19so tormented now. It's just more, no, he's just,
- 33:22he's like that. Yeah, this just is who he is.
- 33:25And he's wrestling with it. There's no trauma
- 33:26or anything like that. It's just, it's who he
- 33:28is. He's a really interesting character. He is.
- 33:32I think this is a good time for us to get into
- 33:34what happens. Yes. Boy, what a shocker. If you're
- 33:38a fan of history, like maybe the opening title
- 33:40sequence would have been enough for you to be
- 33:42like, that's what this movie is about. Yeah.
- 33:44I had no idea. No idea at all. And that opening
- 33:49sequence that's like everybody remembers where
- 33:52they were on the night of blank blank 1906. I
- 33:55believe it's April 17th, 1906. Might be April
- 33:5914th. Yeah. So that alone should have been enough
- 34:02to be like, OK, well, we are leading up to that
- 34:05date. Clearly, I didn't even pay any attention
- 34:09to that. I was just like, all right, let's see
- 34:11what this movie is about. Then the title screen
- 34:13catches on fire and I'm like, let's see what
- 34:15the movie is about. Like, what a dope. But Mary
- 34:19Blake shows up at a contest. that all of these
- 34:23clubs are entering to try and win a cash prize.
- 34:27And she decides she's going to enter this competition
- 34:30on behalf of the Paradise. That's the name of
- 34:32the club, right? Yes, because her fiance at the
- 34:35time, Jack Burley, has trapped all of his employees
- 34:40of the Paradise in the building and had it locked
- 34:43up. And they're all not up for bail, so he can't
- 34:46bail them out. and he did this intentionally
- 34:48to keep them from performing at the benefit.
- 34:51Yes. So she takes it upon herself to perform
- 34:53in the name of the paradise, and she performs,
- 34:56and of course she wins. And Blackie shows up,
- 34:59and he sees what she's done, and he's like, look,
- 35:00I don't need your pity. I don't need any of this.
- 35:03And he storms out. And all of this feels like,
- 35:07you know, wow, what a climax. It's an interesting
- 35:10story. Not something that I'm super invested
- 35:13in, but it's fine. And then as they're walking
- 35:16out the door, There is a rumbling that occurs.
- 35:19And everybody's like, what is that noise? In
- 35:22your mind in this moment, were you like, oh,
- 35:24I get it. No. Well, actually, no, that's not
- 35:28true. I was. But the reason why is always about
- 35:32halfway through a movie, I start taking notes
- 35:34on the trivia and stuff. Because I'm like, oh,
- 35:36I've got an idea of the story. I'm following
- 35:37along. I'm not missing a lot of the setup. So
- 35:39I'm OK. I'll start writing it. And I got to something,
- 35:42and it said, sets were built on hydraulic lifts
- 35:44and shakers. raising and rocking violently i
- 35:49was like what yeah but but why but why would
- 35:53they yeah and then when this started happening
- 35:55i was like oh that's why and uh there's a couple
- 35:59other details we'll get into here but there's
- 36:01an earthquake um an earthquake is just completely
- 36:04devastating san francisco yeah and this is Real
- 36:08life historical earthquake. Yes. And then it's
- 36:11just fictional events in between there. Now,
- 36:13in the beginning, it says that, you know, this
- 36:15is all based on fictional events. Any characters
- 36:18that are in stuff that we see now all the time.
- 36:20Yeah. Right. Any characters or moments. Yeah.
- 36:23Are completely incidental, not based on anyone
- 36:28in real life. And that's because these events
- 36:30really did happen. But then they made stories
- 36:32around it. So. An earthquake just devastates
- 36:36San Francisco, and Clark Gable finds himself
- 36:39separated from Mary Blake in this. Yeah. And
- 36:44we then see for the next 25, 30 minutes him trying
- 36:48to survive this rubble, because there's two separate
- 36:51earthquakes that happen, him trying to survive
- 36:53this incident and then find her. And he then
- 36:56walks through all of San Francisco and sees how
- 36:58devastated everything is. And they have to actually
- 37:00destroy the majority of the buildings and almost
- 37:03burn down all of San Francisco or destroy San
- 37:06Francisco to allow for water to wash away all
- 37:10the fire. right from what's erupted they the
- 37:12plan is to use tnt to blow up buildings to clear
- 37:16the path for the water correct yeah so then all
- 37:19these people who have you know there's not much
- 37:22damage to my building and this is my entire life
- 37:24savings this is building and you can't do this
- 37:27to me well they have to be safe san francisco
- 37:29yeah and i you know we'll keep that separate
- 37:32for now but the actual scene of the earthquakes
- 37:35itself the first one That shows really just,
- 37:38I can't remember the name of the venue they're
- 37:39in, but where they're performing is really impressive.
- 37:42Like the sets are like tearing apart, like the
- 37:45entire upstairs area is like split in half and
- 37:47falls over. And I was like, oh, that was it.
- 37:50It's still really good, but like that's it. Great.
- 37:52And then he goes outside. And when he goes outside,
- 37:55everything else falls apart. There are scenes
- 37:59of the concrete street. the gravel street, where
- 38:03it is cracking in half. There is a man who falls
- 38:06in the crack down. And you can see a pipe burst
- 38:10underneath the ground coming out. I'm sure there's
- 38:14a mat or something underneath. But part of me
- 38:16was like, was he meant to fall down there? Because
- 38:18that doesn't look very safe down there completely.
- 38:20There's another guy hanging on and someone else
- 38:22saves him. this is where the hydraulic lifts
- 38:25and the shakers and everything like this is just
- 38:27absolutely unlike anything we've seen in the
- 38:30academy yes and not just the academy movies in
- 38:33general up into this point and this is the last
- 38:3730 minutes of this movie that they put all this
- 38:39in here and this is all practical effects yeah
- 38:43all of this was done through building these sets
- 38:45and building them on these like shakers and hydraulic
- 38:48lifts to make this happen And to see buildings
- 38:51crumble and fall on top of people and the rubble
- 38:54afterwards. And the thing that I'm most impressed
- 38:57with with this is, like, I think there's a statement
- 39:00that I read on this that said that this did not
- 39:04receive a nomination for Best Production Design
- 39:07because, and then it said after this, because
- 39:09that didn't exist. Like, that's why they didn't
- 39:12win it. But, much like we talked about with Mutiny
- 39:14on the Bounty of, like, well, why didn't Frank
- 39:17O'Tone get a... supporting actor nomination on
- 39:20this because that didn't exist. But pretty immediately,
- 39:23they're like, well, we see the benefit of having
- 39:24to do that. So let's go ahead and create it next
- 39:26year. Here's the best supporting actor category.
- 39:29Yeah. Same thing here. People saw this movie
- 39:32and they're like, we need to be able to give
- 39:34an award for when you do crazy stuff like this.
- 39:37So let's just create the production design award
- 39:40after this. Is that? Or no, special effects.
- 39:42I'm so sorry. A special effects award comes in?
- 39:44That's where the special effects award comes
- 39:46into play. This is introduced in 1938. Gotcha.
- 39:51So pretty immediately after, they're like, we
- 39:53need to reckon with this. And they do. So it
- 39:56is so cool to see these movies that not only
- 39:59say, hey, maybe we need to talk about this, but
- 40:01beg the question, why aren't we doing this? Yeah.
- 40:04If we're capable of doing this on screen, why
- 40:07is this not happening? And it really does usher
- 40:10in that idea of disaster movies. And there are
- 40:13so many disaster movies that come from something
- 40:15like this. You wouldn't have Armageddon without
- 40:18this movie. You wouldn't have Airport without
- 40:21this movie, and we'll talk about that. You wouldn't
- 40:23have, I mean, Roland Emmerich wouldn't exist
- 40:26without something like this. Right, yeah. There
- 40:28are, I think one of Taylor's favorite movies
- 40:30is Day After Tomorrow, so she agrees with you
- 40:32on that. There are a plethora, Titanic. Yeah.
- 40:37Yeah. Which, by the way, I'm sure we were both
- 40:38like double feature. We're like Titanic. Like
- 40:40until we're like, God damn nominated. It's pretty
- 40:43solid. Yeah. Yeah. But I think that's the one.
- 40:46Like this really does feel like Titanic in that
- 40:48sense of a love story that is tied around a historical
- 40:51tragedy of epic proportions. Absolutely. Yeah.
- 40:55I think that this whole sequence of the earthquake
- 40:59is so impressive and it's such a perfect. acknowledgement
- 41:03of like the the ensemble of departments that
- 41:07have to come together and make everything work
- 41:09because you do have the the special effects and
- 41:11the and the practical effects but i i don't believe
- 41:15there's any music playing during this whole sequence
- 41:17which i think is a stellar choice i love that
- 41:21but the special uh not the special the the stunt
- 41:25performers here again we talked about this in
- 41:28a tale of two cities but stunt actors i feel
- 41:31after King Kong have really taken off because
- 41:34you have people falling out of windows. You have
- 41:37people falling into the cracks in the streets
- 41:39that are opening up, like you mentioned. And
- 41:42then just the actors themselves. This is probably
- 41:46the most haunting a film has been since we covered
- 41:50All Quiet on the Western Front to me. That's
- 41:52true. There is a moment where when Blackie Norton
- 41:57goes outside, there is a... I still don't know
- 42:00how they did this. Miniatures are used in this
- 42:02pretty heavily. There's a sequence later on where
- 42:06he goes to try and find Mary Blake at Burley's
- 42:10house, and instead he finds Mrs. Burley, his
- 42:12mother. And there's a whole scene where it shows
- 42:16a lot of people walking. They look a little weird,
- 42:19but they're walking in the foreground, and the
- 42:22background is the mansion that the Burleys live
- 42:24in. And I was like, that's an interesting shot.
- 42:29And then we see where Norton helps Mrs. Burleigh
- 42:33walk away from the house as they're about to
- 42:35devastate it with TNT, blow it up. And then they
- 42:39cut back to that same shot we saw, and then it
- 42:42just completely erupts. And you're like, oh,
- 42:44it was a miniature. And those people that were
- 42:46shown were either photo, I'm not sure what I'm
- 42:50trying to say, but overlaid later, or they're
- 42:52little miniatures that they moved around. I really
- 42:55like that use. But the thing that I can't figure
- 42:57out how they did, an entire wall of a building
- 43:01or two slides off. And we see it separate and
- 43:04it just slides off. And we see a woman holding
- 43:07a baby. It's like the shadow of a woman holding
- 43:09a baby. God. And it cuts back to Norton. And
- 43:13then it cuts back to the woman and the baby,
- 43:14like the shadow. And she jumps off. Thinking
- 43:18she's safer on the ground than she is in the
- 43:19building and jumps off with her baby. She clearly
- 43:22dies. Yeah. But then this is extra haunting because
- 43:26the effect in the way they did this was, I guess
- 43:29she jumped off a much shorter distance. Yeah.
- 43:32And they just overlaid this later. So she's very
- 43:34like, you can see through her. And she's almost
- 43:37like an apparition, which makes this even more
- 43:39haunting. Yeah. And just this whole thing. You
- 43:43stop thinking less how do they film this and
- 43:45just more like the devastation and the humanity
- 43:48that you feel in watching that, which is the
- 43:50whole point. Well, there's so many sequences
- 43:52in this that feel so heavy. When Blackie first
- 43:57comes outside and he sees a man that is buried
- 43:59under the rubble and he's calling out, he's like,
- 44:01please help. I'm trapped. I'm stuck. And Blackie
- 44:03goes and he starts to uncover him from the rubble.
- 44:05And that's when the after, what is it called?
- 44:08After? Afterquake? Afterquake. I can't remember.
- 44:11Aftershock. Aftershock. Thank you. That happens.
- 44:14And someone else runs up and they're like, Blackie,
- 44:17we got to go. It's not safe here. And he's like,
- 44:19I have to help this man. But then more debris
- 44:22falls on him. And you just watch as this man
- 44:25gets covered with more and more debris. And the
- 44:27look on this is where Gable really is just something
- 44:30else. The look on his face and the devastation
- 44:33he feels watching all of these tragedies happen
- 44:35right before his eyes is incredible. And then
- 44:38when he's looking for Mary. He's calling out
- 44:41to her and you hear somebody else calling Irene
- 44:43or for Irene. And I if I remember correctly,
- 44:48they're they're both calling out Mary and Irene.
- 44:50He asks where she is to this man. And he's like,
- 44:53I'm looking for Irene. And he kind of wanders
- 44:56off out of frame. And then you hear him discover
- 45:00Irene. And he just starts sobbing because clearly
- 45:04she's she's been caught in the rubble or she's
- 45:06passed away. And Clark Gable is just like turning
- 45:09back and looking and coming to terms with like
- 45:12we were both looking for a woman. He has found
- 45:15the woman he was looking for and it is not good.
- 45:18It's so emotionally devastating. It's wild. And
- 45:22you mentioned when – what is the woman's name
- 45:26whose home was blown up? Miss Burley? Miss Burley.
- 45:30Miss Burley. Mrs. Burley. Mrs. Burley. Her son
- 45:34is Mary Blake's fiance. Jack. And he has passed
- 45:37away in the earthquake as well. So when Blackie
- 45:41finds Mrs. Burleigh, she basically says, like,
- 45:44hey, he's gone, isn't he? He died. And he's like,
- 45:47yeah, I'm sorry. And, like, he hugs her and gives
- 45:49her comfort. And she's like, again, her character
- 45:52leans very heavily into faith. And she's like,
- 45:54this is God's will. Like, this is what is supposed
- 45:57to happen. And when he does lead her away from
- 46:01their home. Just as it is detonated and she turns
- 46:06back, she says, he was born in that house. And
- 46:10it's so heavy because, like, she's just lost
- 46:13her son. And now the one thing that she can use
- 46:16as, like, a memorial for him, knowing that she
- 46:18has that home, is gone. And I don't know. It
- 46:22just felt like moment after moment just gut -punching
- 46:25you. Yeah. And it's by design. And it's so effective.
- 46:29Every time it hits harder and harder. we do see
- 46:34where uh norton after like having this it is
- 46:38almost like a christmas carol thing yeah where
- 46:40it's like he is reckoning with now other people
- 46:43finding the fate that he has narrowly avoided
- 46:46in surviving and in doing so he gets reunited
- 46:50with uh with father tim mullins or mullen and
- 46:54he is now kind of like devoting his life to like
- 46:58hey i gotta find mary but at the same time she
- 47:01might be gone so what do i do and we see him
- 47:05like right on the cusp of like accepting god
- 47:08of like you know could you bring her back to
- 47:11me like i'm sorry for everything that i've done
- 47:13and in that moment he finds mary and she is alive
- 47:17and she is helping uh other people with the power
- 47:20of her voice and music in like grieving the ones
- 47:24they've lost yeah And he finds her. And when
- 47:27he finds her, it's less, I found you great, let's
- 47:30start anew. And it's more like he's still just
- 47:34kind of in shock. And he and everyone else, along
- 47:37with Mary, go to the side of a hill. And they
- 47:41oversee all of San Francisco because the fires
- 47:43have stopped. And they overlook it. And the final
- 47:46shot is the devastation of San Francisco, but
- 47:49then also what San Francisco was previously.
- 47:51Or what it could become. I think it's the future
- 47:53of San Francisco. So here's what's interesting.
- 47:55There is an alternate ending on the DVD. And
- 47:58I was like, oh, does everyone live? What happened
- 48:00to the alternate ending? The alternate ending
- 48:02is exactly the same, but the shot that overlays
- 48:05the devastation of San Francisco is multiple
- 48:09shots of what it becomes. Golden Gate Bridge,
- 48:12cities, cars in the 20s and 30s. So it's a little
- 48:19bit more. I wasn't sure if the shot in the canon
- 48:23ending, the theatrical ending, if that was indeed
- 48:28the future. But then the alternate ending solidifies
- 48:31that that is what they're trying to communicate
- 48:33there. It's still not clear to me if that means,
- 48:36well, instead of showing what it was, we're going
- 48:38to show what it became. Or if they're just being
- 48:40a little more clear that it's what it becomes.
- 48:43Right. Yeah, I don't know. But I think either
- 48:46way, it still has the same... Yes. I want to
- 48:51point out another comparison to Titanic as well.
- 48:53When Blackie finds Mary and she's singing with
- 48:57the people, she is singing near thee to God,
- 48:59which is, of course, the song that the orchestra
- 49:01plays on the sinking Titanic. But again, even
- 49:04that is like an element of Blackie finding faith.
- 49:08He is himself near thee to God after this traumatic
- 49:11event. But it does end with with the people basically
- 49:15saying. Okay, it's up to us now to go rebuild
- 49:18San Francisco. And it has kind of that hopeful
- 49:20American kind of ending that we see in Ruggles
- 49:24of Red Gap and things like that. Absolutely.
- 49:26It's interesting, too. We didn't talk about it,
- 49:29but there are original songs made for this movie,
- 49:32including San Francisco. And it's sang throughout
- 49:35the movie, mostly slow and fast by Jeanette MacDonald.
- 49:40Yeah. San Francisco is actually an anthem of
- 49:43the city now. So they have embraced that, specifically
- 49:46performed and sung on earthquake memorial days.
- 49:50So not only did they take the song from the movie
- 49:54and make it part of their culture, but they took
- 49:56the meaning of the movie and put it behind what
- 49:59has really happened in San Francisco as well.
- 50:01So it's very cool to see how much this movie
- 50:04has meant to the city of San Francisco. I also
- 50:07had no idea the history of this. I had heard
- 50:10of earthquakes, but never really that specific
- 50:12earthquake in 1906. How that has affected things.
- 50:16It makes for a really interesting experience.
- 50:19And ultimately, I think a very fitting final
- 50:23movie for us to talk about in this year. In that
- 50:25it is close to the best thing that I've seen
- 50:30this year. Yeah. But it is so long. It does run
- 50:35a little long. Rather, let me take that back.
- 50:37It feels so long. It's under two hours. I was
- 50:41enjoying... I shouldn't say I was. I think I
- 50:43enjoyed pretty much every aspect of this movie.
- 50:46But when you get to the end runtime, you're like,
- 50:48how is this not three hours? It feels so lived
- 50:52in. And it's not that it slogs. It is truly an
- 50:55enigma of a movie. Because I enjoyed so much
- 50:58of it, it's so hard for me to find aspects that
- 51:01I didn't really like. And then that breathtaking
- 51:03last 30 minutes is just like, that doesn't go
- 51:07on too long at all. But yet the movie feels too
- 51:09long. And I don't understand how that is. The
- 51:12acting, the singing, the sound. How is this movie
- 51:16not nominated for sound? Yeah. Something we haven't
- 51:18talked about with three smart girls being nominated
- 51:20and not San Francisco. It was nominated. Douglas
- 51:23Shearer got the nomination. Oh my God, you're
- 51:24so right. Yeah. But like, that's something where
- 51:27it's... It won for sound. Oh, thank God. Nevermind.
- 51:29Scratch that completely then. But this is a movie
- 51:32that like earns all those things. And you look
- 51:34across the board and you see everything that's
- 51:35nominated for and you're like, yup, yup, yup,
- 51:37nailed it. All these things were not just present,
- 51:40but like essential. to the movie and it being
- 51:42successful so it's so close to being like absolutely
- 51:46great and that's not something like that's a
- 51:49mark against it it's just it's so good and it's
- 51:53very nice to end these years when we're like
- 51:56yeah there's a couple okays and like pretty goods
- 51:59to see something like this it just comes out
- 52:02of nowhere yeah right like clark gable and jeanette
- 52:04mcdonald you're like that's a guy who's charm
- 52:07and a girl who's like really good into like singing
- 52:10And she's a good actress. I just don't know how
- 52:12this is going to go well together. And Spencer
- 52:13Tracy plays a priest in it. We'll see. And it
- 52:16just knocks you out. Yeah. So I thought this
- 52:19was great. I think there's something about that.
- 52:22I don't know. It feeling long to me. Did that
- 52:25bother you at all? So I think what it is, is
- 52:28without the earthquake, this plot is just fine.
- 52:31It's just okay. And in most disaster movies,
- 52:36the disaster occurs. I would say within the first
- 52:3920 minutes of the movie, or at least you have
- 52:42some semblance like that there will be a disaster.
- 52:45Titanic's the exception, but you know what you're
- 52:47getting into. It really is almost like split
- 52:49in half. Yes. Which, unfortunate phrasing. Yeah.
- 52:54So I think that's what it is. It's that without
- 52:57the earthquake element of this, it's kind of
- 53:00just a mediocre movie, the plot itself. I think
- 53:03the most interesting thing is the relationship
- 53:06with Faith. That it tries to play with. Absolutely.
- 53:08That really, really is fascinating for me in
- 53:11a film from 1936. So I think that's it. When
- 53:16you get to the disaster, it completely changes
- 53:18everything about this movie. And it elevates
- 53:21it. Because it does, it serves its purpose at
- 53:25tying in all of these themes that you've dealt
- 53:27with up to this point. So with all that being
- 53:30said, for me, I gave this three and a half stars.
- 53:32I also give this three and a half stars. Yeah.
- 53:34I think when I revisit this, this has a possibility
- 53:37of being four. Yeah. But four for me is like
- 53:40pretty great. But what stopped me from like really
- 53:42connecting with it, with this, it is really good.
- 53:46It's probably great, but... a pretty damning
- 53:51thing is to say that it feels like it's three
- 53:52hours. Yeah. And yet I do feel that way. Sure.
- 53:56And again, I watched this after like, I got a
- 53:58full night's rest after Tale of Two Cities. I
- 54:01told you that I watched the audioscopics short
- 54:03attached to the DVD of Tale of Two Cities. Thought
- 54:06I fever dreamed. That short and me being like
- 54:09simulated to be shot in there, which, you know,
- 54:12okay. And got a full night's rest. I think I
- 54:15actually got nine to ten hours. Not trying to
- 54:17brag. Congrats. Doesn't happen. So I was like
- 54:20well rested and everything. So it's not like
- 54:22I was tired. I was watching it. It was just like,
- 54:24man, this just feels so long. Are we sure it's
- 54:28an hour and 55 minutes? And it was. And at no
- 54:31point am I like, yeah, you cut this scene. This
- 54:33is just too long. I just don't understand it.
- 54:35I'll go on forever about it. That's where I think
- 54:38it lands me at three and a half stars. I will
- 54:41say if this was the quarter thing that we're
- 54:43talking about, this would be a 3 .75 easy. Gotcha.
- 54:46So I'm probably going to be closer to four once
- 54:49I like maybe pick up the Blu -ray. I have the
- 54:51DVD I'll let you borrow for like shorts and stuff,
- 54:53but really good special features too. So a very
- 54:58excited 3 .5 is where I would put my vote. And
- 55:02props to this movie for like dawning the genre.
- 55:06of disaster movies because we both, as we said,
- 55:08if not love them, we loved them. And that's a
- 55:13good lead -in to my double feature. Go for it.
- 55:16When I was a kid, I watched a particular disaster
- 55:19movie all the time, and it's probably my favorite
- 55:22disaster film of all time. It stars Gene Hackman,
- 55:26and it is The Poseidon Adventure. I love that
- 55:30movie. I think it's such a cool setup to have
- 55:33to navigate a ship that is capsized, a cruise
- 55:36ship. It's a New Year's Eve movie, so look forward
- 55:40to that this year if you're looking for something
- 55:42new. But not only is it a disaster film, but
- 55:46it also heavily deals with a man's relationship
- 55:50with faith. And not just a man, a priest as well.
- 55:53Gene Hackman plays a priest who is kind of losing
- 55:57his connection with God in this movie. And it
- 56:01all culminates in this really, really intense
- 56:04scene at the end of the movie where he has to
- 56:07perform kind of a feat of strength and heroism
- 56:11while he is directly shouting at God and asking
- 56:16why this has happened. So I think it is it becomes
- 56:21a common theme. to question faith in a disaster
- 56:25movie because, of course, you are up against
- 56:27the elements or an act of God, if you will, that
- 56:31really does kind of bring that into question.
- 56:34And I think Poseidon Adventure is just like a
- 56:36perfect disaster film. I haven't seen that yet.
- 56:41Really? No, I haven't. I'm really excited to,
- 56:43though. That was obviously very much on my short
- 56:46list when I was looking at double features here.
- 56:48But I felt like... I've recently talked about
- 56:51a movie that I haven't seen. I kind of wanted
- 56:52to, of all the disaster movies and romances of
- 56:55that involved in it, I've seen, I felt like I
- 56:58should call that out. So I'm very excited for
- 57:00that. I think Keaton Lorber has an edition of
- 57:03that Blu -ray that I'm really interested in.
- 57:05Yeah. I'll pick it up and I'll let you know.
- 57:08So I changed mine. Okay. I originally, I know
- 57:11I just said like, there's so many disaster films
- 57:13that I like that have like romances and everything.
- 57:16And then I just picked one that wasn't. and I
- 57:18think I can hold on to it for something better
- 57:20later down the road. So instead, I'm just going
- 57:23to lean into what you said, and that's your favorite
- 57:25disaster movie. And what is my favorite disaster
- 57:28movie? And I'm pretty confident that I will not
- 57:30be able to talk about this in most other movies
- 57:32that we cover on the podcast, so I'm picking
- 57:34the 2008 Matt Reeves film Cloverfield. Oh, yeah.
- 57:38I was in the trenches, man. I was in Valdosta
- 57:42State University in 2007, 2008, and I was on
- 57:46the computer. I was on the internet and I was
- 57:49going through the ARG, the alternate reality
- 57:51gaming. I don't think that's what it stands for.
- 57:54But I was going through the alternate reality
- 57:55game and everything. And I was solving the clues.
- 57:58I was going through it. Hey, this website is
- 58:00like, what's Slusho? What's their involvement
- 58:03in this and everything? Well, here's where Clover
- 58:05popped up. And then this guy used to work for
- 58:07Slusho. Now he's friends with this guy and blah,
- 58:10blah, blah. I was putting all the pieces together
- 58:12waiting for the movie. And then I see the movie
- 58:14and I'm just blown away. And I'm like, my God,
- 58:17what can we do? Like, what can we do with found
- 58:19footage in disaster movies? This is the future.
- 58:22There's a whole monster in this movie. This is
- 58:25incredible, what we're doing. The destruction
- 58:27of it, so much of it is like CG, so it's not
- 58:30a lot of practical effects. There are practical
- 58:32effects in it, and they just filmed around that.
- 58:35Love the, I mean, still to this day, seeing Transformers
- 58:39in theaters, and then seeing... the statue of
- 58:42liberty head just rolled down the street with
- 58:44claw marks on the face terrifying what on earth
- 58:47is this movie i don't think it drops the name
- 58:48it just says the date yep i think it's january
- 58:5118th 08 i cannot believe that's in my head but
- 58:54like that's that's how much that movie meant
- 58:56to me so cloverfield is so important And to think
- 59:00that San Francisco has a hand in playing of like
- 59:03what can happen to destruction movies like, or
- 59:05disaster movies like this. It's a lion. Like
- 59:09just that. Did they say it's alive or did they
- 59:11say it's a lion? Like trying to figure out what
- 59:13was going on. Well, it's so good. Oh my God,
- 59:15dude. There's, um, there's a moment at the end
- 59:18of the movie. spoilers for cloverfield i assume
- 59:20i mean 20 almost 20 years old um there's a scene
- 59:23at the end of the movie where uh it's a flashback
- 59:26it's the final scene of uh the two leads on a
- 59:29ferris wheel yeah and you can see like a little
- 59:32pod like falling from the sky if you look really
- 59:34closely and splash into the ocean and there's
- 59:38just so many little clues and like it just feels
- 59:41so lived in and then you have 10 cloverfield
- 59:43lane that has almost nothing to do With Cloverfield.
- 59:47And Cloverfield Paradox, which is not really
- 59:49worth mentioning very much. But it's so cool.
- 59:53I love a Twilight Zone movie. It feels very Twilight
- 59:55Zone. It's a disaster movie. It's got to be my
- 59:57favorite. And then, of course, the romance between
- 59:59the two leads. It's just easy to ride into San
- 1:00:02Francisco. Yeah. Not the best romance, I think,
- 1:00:05in that movie. No. It's fine. Would you say Hud
- 1:00:08and Lizzie Kaplan? Oh, man. No, I don't know
- 1:00:13that there's really a whole big... Would you
- 1:00:15say The Parasites and Clover themselves is the
- 1:00:18best romance? Maybe The Parasites and Lizzie
- 1:00:21Kaplan. Boy, there is some saliva swapped there.
- 1:00:26Yeah. Man, I love Cloverfield. Great movie. It's
- 1:00:29so good. Great movie. Remind me to show you some
- 1:00:31of the stuff that I got from buying a t -shirt
- 1:00:34for it. Oh, yeah? Yeah. Sounds good. Guys, let
- 1:00:37us know what your favorite disaster film is.
- 1:00:39We double featured. disasters for both of our
- 1:00:42picks. I want to know, shoot us an email at O
- 1:00:45U T A O podcast at gmail .com. Uh, and we'll
- 1:00:49read all of these responses on next episode of
- 1:00:52the podcast, which is going to be the final episode
- 1:00:54of 1936 ceremony, the ninth Academy award ceremony.
- 1:00:59We're about to start the 10th number 10. Can't
- 1:01:02believe it. It's unreal. 1937 from 1927. So cool.
- 1:01:07Wild. So cool. Yeah, shoot us those emails because
- 1:01:10I'd really like to talk leading up to this new
- 1:01:13year. And I just like to talk. Yeah, there's
- 1:01:16that too. So stay tuned for the ceremony. And
- 1:01:19I think that's going to do it for this episode.
- 1:01:22As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see
- 1:01:25you at the movies.