She Trusted the Neighbor: The Babysitter Who Never Came Home

Scary Paranormal Stories · Jul 24, 2026 · 20m

She Trusted the Neighbor: The Babysitter Who Never Came Home

A fifteen-year-old left her house on January 4, 2011 to babysit and never came home; three weeks later her remains were found fifteen miles northwest of Lubbock. A man who comforted the family had twelve years of prior convictions and appears on motel security footage escorting her out that night - why did he drive away and then return to the same parking lot?

In this episode, we tell the sequence of events from the evening Elisabeth Marlene left her mother to the surveillance timestamps that became central to the case, and we…