Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration: Construction Arbitration
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration, Construction
- 0:05Arbitration. I'm Belinda McCauley, Executive
- 0:08Director and CEO of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:12I'm delighted to be here today to introduce our
- 0:14speakers, Michael Powell and Jason Adams. Michael
- 0:17Powell is Vice President for the Construction
- 0:19Division of the American Arbitration Association.
- 0:21AAA, and manages the Los Angeles Regional Office.
- 0:25A 29 -year veteran of the company, he leads the
- 0:27expansion of construction and commercial ADR
- 0:29services throughout the Pacific West and oversees
- 0:33national initiatives to grow the organization's
- 0:35construction caseload. An experienced author,
- 0:38presenter, and industry leader, he works closely
- 0:40with the NCDRC and numerous other ADR organizations
- 0:44to educate stakeholders, design dispute resolution
- 0:47systems, and advance best practices in the field.
- 0:50Jason Adams is a partner of Cox Castle and Nicholson
- 0:53LLP. He's a leading litigator whose practice
- 0:56centers on insurance recovery and risk management,
- 0:58construction law, and complex business and civil
- 1:01litigation. A licensed insurance broker and certified
- 1:04construction risk and insurance specialist. He
- 1:07regularly secures significant results for policyholders
- 1:10and construction industry clients, including
- 1:12multi -million dollar recoveries through trial
- 1:14and arbitration. And now let's get started. Thank
- 1:17you for joining us today. Together, we bring
- 1:20both the institutional and practitioner viewpoints,
- 1:23which makes this discussion especially valuable.
- 1:27So let's get started with the nuts and bolts
- 1:29of arbitration, construction arbitration. Now,
- 1:32if you practice construction law in California,
- 1:34you already know this. Arbitration isn't an alternative
- 1:38anymore. It's the default forum for most construction
- 1:41disputes, whether you're dealing with a complex
- 1:44defect case, a delay claim on a public works
- 1:47project, or a multi -party high -rise dispute
- 1:50in downtown LA, you're almost certainly going
- 1:53to end up in arbitration. So today isn't about
- 1:57theory, it's about execution. By the end of today,
- 2:01you should walk away with practical takeaways
- 2:04you can use in your current case or your next
- 2:07case, and you'll have a better understanding
- 2:09of where construction ADR is headed in California.
- 2:15We're going to walk through the life cycle of
- 2:17a construction arbitration from filing through
- 2:20a ward and talk about what actually moves the
- 2:22needle, including arbitrator selection strategy,
- 2:26managing discovery without letting it become
- 2:28litigation, coordinating experts effectively,
- 2:31using procedural tools intelligently, and making
- 2:34arbitration efficient rather than expensive.
- 2:37We'll also spend time discussing what AAA is
- 2:40doing differently, especially around AI and technology.
- 2:44Because whether we like it or not, technology
- 2:47is already reshaping how disputes are administered.
- 2:51The question isn't whether it's coming. It's
- 2:54whether it's governed properly. So today, we're
- 2:57focused on real world application. I like to
- 3:00think of it, arbitration in California construction
- 3:03is like playing procedural chess. And the earlier
- 3:07you make strategic decisions, the fewer fires
- 3:09you're putting out later. The goal is predictability.
- 3:13Many clients I have spoken to care about predictability
- 3:16as much as outcome. Many disputes that we see
- 3:22arise from AIA, consensus docs, or heavily negotiated
- 3:28custom forms. Arbitration clauses often include
- 3:31consolidation language, but sometimes not. Construction
- 3:35defect cases are documentation driven. RFIs,
- 3:39submittals, schedule updates, they win or lose
- 3:41cases. And unlike general commercial arbitration,
- 3:46construction disputes are expert -centric from
- 3:49day one. And think about this, arbitration doesn't
- 3:53remove complexity, it just changes how it's managed.
- 3:59Jason, tell us about the types of construction
- 4:01arbitration disputes that are out there. Yeah,
- 4:04so the breakdown on the arbitrator side is probably
- 4:06similar to what most practitioners see in their
- 4:10practices, right? So we kind of have two big
- 4:12buckets. We have your construction defect actions,
- 4:15which are going to be your SB 800 claims, usually
- 4:18large scale single family homes or HOAs, things
- 4:21like that. And then kind of the other bucket
- 4:23is going to be your owner GC, breach of contract
- 4:27disputes. large delay claims, a lot of subcontractors,
- 4:33mechanics liens with a pending action and superior
- 4:35court, etc. And then you can see all these different
- 4:38bullet points, these design defects, things of
- 4:40that nature. But the reality is that most of
- 4:44these cases have some components of all of these
- 4:47things, right? Like your defect cases are going
- 4:49to have design disputes. There's going to be
- 4:51multi -party issues with all of them. I mean,
- 4:53that's really This slide is where we start to
- 4:56see the difference between litigation and arbitration
- 5:00and how arbitration can kind of be beneficial
- 5:02because you have someone here in your case like
- 5:06me or there are anyone else on the construction
- 5:08panel who's been doing this for decades usually,
- 5:11right? So they have intimate familiarity with
- 5:13the subject matter in the issues that arise.
- 5:18That's a lot better than having your case heard
- 5:21by someone who doesn't know what a change order
- 5:23is, right? So arbitration can be hugely beneficial
- 5:26in that regard. Absolutely. And if you have a
- 5:32construction dispute and it's headed to arbitration,
- 5:36I'm going to walk us through the very initial
- 5:39stages. We are talking about the nuts and bolts
- 5:41of construction arbitration. So let's talk about
- 5:44filing a case, initiating the arbitration process.
- 5:50And think about this. A poorly drafted demand
- 5:53creates months of confusion. We see this all
- 5:55the time. So you want to be specific about your
- 6:00contracts. Identify related parties. early and
- 6:04think ahead about Joinder and consolidation.
- 6:10Upon filing, when you are thinking about the
- 6:14selection and appointment of your arbitrators,
- 6:16another critical point. We all know construction
- 6:20practitioners have strong preferences. Now, the
- 6:23traditional strike and rank system remains a
- 6:26powerful tool for selecting an arbitrator, but
- 6:30You might not know there's alternatives out there,
- 6:33and not just with AAA with all the providers.
- 6:37For example, AAA has an online search tool. It
- 6:41uses a semantic AI search. We call it AAAI panelist
- 6:45search, meaning you can search arbitrators based
- 6:48on actual experience narratives, not just keywords
- 6:52any longer. for your large mega projects or highly
- 6:56technical matters, specialized panels matter.
- 7:00So be thinking about, is this size of a claim,
- 7:05does it warrant a look at AAA's mega project
- 7:08panel? And just some background on our mega project
- 7:11panel, there's roughly about 75, 80 neutrals
- 7:15from around the country that make up this panel.
- 7:19panelists are not selected by the AAA to be a
- 7:22part of the mega project panel. We actually pull
- 7:26users who have filed cases with us over the past
- 7:30five years, and we ask them to rank a large number
- 7:33of arbitrators who fit our large complex case
- 7:36definition. Depending on the ranking, the higher
- 7:39the ranking sets you up for inclusion on the
- 7:43mega project panel. So the key word here is our
- 7:46mega project panel is is driven by client interface.
- 7:52It is not just simply the AAA staff thinking
- 7:57these are the best of the best. We have our users
- 8:00decide who the best of the best are, and that's
- 8:03our mega project panel. The key takeaway here
- 8:07is arbitrator selection is the most important
- 8:10early decision you'll make. Along those lines,
- 8:20this is one of the threshold decisions, right?
- 8:23And a lot of times it's governed by the contract,
- 8:25but it can be waived if everyone stipulates.
- 8:28It's do you want one arbitrator or a panel of
- 8:31three? So it always goes back and forth, right?
- 8:36One arbitrator is a lot cheaper, but three arbitrators,
- 8:40the argument you always hear is, oh, it prevents
- 8:41one rogue arbitrator from going sideways on you.
- 8:45And it keeps everyone in check. This slide is
- 8:51fantastic. Mike pulled these stats because these
- 8:53are things I've always wondered, but I never
- 8:55knew. So everyone knows one arbitrator is cheaper,
- 8:59but how much cheaper? So it reduces cost by 81%.
- 9:05I was shocked to hear that. And again, part of
- 9:08that is it makes things a lot more streamlined
- 9:11when you have one arbitrator versus three. So
- 9:14that just makes sense. I've been on both. I've
- 9:17been a panelist on a three panel arbitrator.
- 9:19And just by nature of the process, every decision
- 9:23has to be discussed by all three of you. You
- 9:25have to set up a separate conference to discuss.
- 9:28You have to come to consensus. You have to circulate
- 9:30drafts of different orders. Everyone has to weigh
- 9:33in on. So just that process, it takes longer
- 9:36and is more expensive just by nature. So when
- 9:40I've seen three arbitrator panels be most effective
- 9:45or recommended is when there's some specific
- 9:49issue that may require subject matter expertise
- 9:52where it would help to have another arbitrator
- 9:55with that type of subject matter expertise be
- 9:59involved. So like I said at the outset, I have
- 10:02a kind of a subspecialty in insurance. So if
- 10:04there's a massive case that justifies the expense
- 10:07and there's going to be a lot of insurance issues
- 10:10like did Did party X breach the contract by failing
- 10:15to procure this particular insurance and these
- 10:17particular coverages? If that's going to be a
- 10:19critical issue, then you may want a three arbitrator
- 10:22panel, including someone with that type of subject
- 10:25matter expertise. So it's a real interesting
- 10:29decision at the outset. More and more so, as
- 10:32you can see from this stat here, people are opting
- 10:35for one versus three arbitrators unless it's
- 10:37just a massive case with a lot of unique issues.
- 10:40And one more thing just to close on this, even
- 10:43if you do opt for three arbitrators, then what
- 10:46a lot of people, a lot of parties do just to
- 10:48make it more cost effective is they allow the
- 10:51panel chair. to run point and to handle the day
- 10:55-to -day issues without involving all three arbitrators.
- 10:59So the panel chair can handle minor discovery
- 11:02disputes, maybe status conferences, et cetera,
- 11:05without having to loop in all three. So that's
- 11:07one kind of hybrid approach that can make it
- 11:10more cost effective and streamlined if you decide
- 11:12to go the three arbitrator route. Jason, thanks
- 11:15for bringing that up. The streamlined option
- 11:18for three arbitrator panels has really taken
- 11:21shape. It's something that we discuss as administrators
- 11:25prior to the... selection of an arbitrator, we
- 11:31talk about some of the options that are available
- 11:34to parties as they move through the process.
- 11:37And that's one of the areas that always gets
- 11:39a second look, is if you are thinking we need
- 11:42three, do you need three arbitrators from the
- 11:45very start of the preliminary hearing all the
- 11:50way through? the discovery phase and all of that,
- 11:53when typically there's a chair could handle many
- 11:56of the discovery issues and so forth, leaving
- 11:58the two wings on the sidelines, not billing,
- 12:02but still very much a part of the case, and then
- 12:05coming in towards the evidentiary hearing, saving
- 12:08a considerable amount of money as well. So thank
- 12:11you for bringing that up, Jason. Yep. Okay, so
- 12:17the next two slides are kind of related and we're
- 12:19starting to get into the actual meat of the process
- 12:22now. So after you file the form that Mike talked
- 12:26about previously, one of the first things that
- 12:28AAA does is they send you these discovery best
- 12:31practices. And Mike, if you want to go to the
- 12:33next slide too. And the e -discovery best practices,
- 12:38right? So it's a PDF that everyone gets as part
- 12:41of their intro packet, usually when discussing
- 12:43the preliminary hearing. And the parties are
- 12:46encouraged to review these prior to the preliminary
- 12:48hearing and to discuss the issues presented.
- 12:52I feel like I get a sense, you know, once we
- 12:54get to the preliminary hearing that everyone
- 12:56kind of ignores these, right? And I wish they
- 12:59wouldn't. I get it. They seem to like just introductory
- 13:02information, they're fairly dense information,
- 13:04but both of these guides are super helpful. And
- 13:08they talk about many of the things that we're
- 13:10going to talk about here today, some of which
- 13:13may seem obvious, but it's really not. Especially
- 13:16once you get into the nuts and bolts of the ESI
- 13:18and the specifics there, which it can be a complex
- 13:21top. So they're really good guides to help the
- 13:26parties meet and confer in advance of the preliminary
- 13:29hearing, which, as we're going to talk about
- 13:30in the next slide, is really the kickoff event
- 13:34that can make or break an arbitration in terms
- 13:36of efficiency and cost effectiveness. So everyone
- 13:40who's listening, when you get these, don't ignore
- 13:42them. I highly recommend that everyone read these.
- 13:45talk about them at your meet and confer, and
- 13:47be ready to address these issues at the preliminary
- 13:49hearing. And Mike, we were talking about this
- 13:52when we were practicing this presentation, and
- 13:55you mentioned kind of the history behind these
- 13:57two submissions. You want to talk just briefly
- 14:01about how these came about and where they came
- 14:03from? Oh, sure, sure, sure. So the AAA has...
- 14:09a national construction dispute resolution committee
- 14:12that serves as an advisory body with regard to
- 14:15construction dispute resolution services. It's
- 14:18composed of liaisons from a diverse group of
- 14:21leading construction industry and related organizations
- 14:24like AIA, AGC. The various trade groups are represented.
- 14:30and they provide industry guidance to the AAA
- 14:33on trends in alternative dispute resolution,
- 14:36including recommendations for AAA rules and procedures.
- 14:40This was born out of this particular committee
- 14:44and hearing from constituents across the country
- 14:49about discovery and e -discovery and not having
- 14:55a tool at their disposal where the parties and
- 15:00the arbitrators could all look to the same guides
- 15:03and say, you know, which of these sections is
- 15:06applicable? Which of these bullet points is applicable
- 15:08for our particular dispute? And what it does
- 15:13is it is it eases the tension between the parties.
- 15:16So one side is not saying, we want this, we want
- 15:19that. It's in the guide. So it's merely at that
- 15:22point, it's already presented to you what is
- 15:25going to work best. So you work with the arbitrators
- 15:28on deciding what the best discovery plan is,
- 15:31and especially when it comes to e -discovery.
- 15:33What is that e -discovery plan going to look
- 15:35like? Because that's where we see a lot of hangup
- 15:39in the back and forth on these principles of
- 15:44how we're going to dictate this arbitration hearing
- 15:48moving forward. So thanks for bringing that up.
- 15:50And that's how both of these guides, they were
- 15:55born out of our NCDRC, that committee. And again,
- 15:59we went out to the ADR community, the construction
- 16:03industry in particular. We visited with law firms.
- 16:06We visited with in -house counsel. We had focus
- 16:10groups in all the major cities that gave us input
- 16:13and guidance through the drafting process. Again,
- 16:21it's our user community that speaks to us and
- 16:23says, this is what we want to see in construction
- 16:26arbitration. And that's what we deliver. Always
- 16:31user driven to enable the parties to have a much
- 16:36better experience through arbitration. Next slide.
- 16:41Yep. Alright, so here we go. So everyone submitted
- 16:47their claim form. They reviewed the guidelines
- 16:49we just talked about. They've met and conferred
- 16:52in advance of the preliminary hearing and we're
- 16:54ready for the preliminary hearing, right? So
- 16:56this. You talk about the difference, again, between
- 16:59arbitration and litigation. So in litigation,
- 17:02your case management conference is almost just
- 17:05like a check the box type of process, just to
- 17:09kind of check in with the judge and give them
- 17:11some basic information. Whereas in arbitration,
- 17:15the preliminary hearing is hugely important,
- 17:17at least in my opinion and my practice. the parties
- 17:22are expected to meet and confer beforehand, and
- 17:24they're expected to come prepared, and they often
- 17:26take a significant amount of time to work through
- 17:29all the issues here on the screen and other issues
- 17:33such as site inspections, et cetera, right? Done
- 17:36properly, a preliminary hearing can set the tone
- 17:39for the rest of the case, right? So, absent extreme
- 17:42circumstances, I will always put an ultimate
- 17:46evidentiary hearing on calendar. even if it's
- 17:49a ways out, and we use that to back in the rest
- 17:52of the dates and we stick to that date in terms
- 17:56of making the case run efficiently and as expeditiously
- 18:00as possible toward the ultimate hearing date,
- 18:04right? So all of the issues in the guidelines
- 18:08we talked about, we hash out at the preliminary
- 18:11hearing and we do a deep dive if necessary, right?
- 18:14To join her. Do any subcontractors need to be
- 18:17added? What are we going to do about that? Do
- 18:19we need a Rule 7 hearing? Do you stipulate that
- 18:21I can handle some of those decisions? The scope
- 18:23of discovery, have you talked about discovery?
- 18:25Do you want to anticipate depositions? Does the
- 18:28case value warrant that? What do you want to
- 18:31do? What's the schedule, the deposition schedule?
- 18:33What's the document production schedule? Are
- 18:35there going to be any dispositive motions? We'll
- 18:37talk about that in a little more detail in the
- 18:39next slide. All of these issues, we want hashed
- 18:42out, we talk about substantively, and we lay
- 18:46out a roadmap for the case. So there's no surprises.
- 18:48So once the case is proceeding past a preliminary
- 18:51hearing, it's essentially on autopilot. And I
- 18:54don't even need to get involved unless there's
- 18:56significant issues that can't be figured out
- 18:58between the parties. So I mean, this is just
- 19:01the good part about arbitration, again, is it's
- 19:05generally all people who really know this area.
- 19:08And when you have a neutral and counsel, who
- 19:13are all sophisticated, all know what they're
- 19:15doing, have all been doing this forever. I mean,
- 19:18this process done well. with an eye toward efficiency
- 19:23can just really work well and do a service to
- 19:28everyone's clients in terms of hearing massively
- 19:30complex disputes as efficiently as possible.
- 19:33So I can't stress enough, do the work beforehand,
- 19:36get on the phone and talk to each other, come
- 19:39prepared, and you can do your client a real service
- 19:42by nailing the preliminary hearing. I can't stress
- 19:45it enough. You know, just a follow up, Jason,
- 19:48on that. you know, on a lot of the administrative
- 19:51conference calls that we have with the parties,
- 19:54sometimes they're not even aware that our rules
- 19:57have been updated. Our latest construction industry
- 20:01arbitration rules is dated March 1st, 2024. We
- 20:05still see parties showing up, you know, with
- 20:08outdated rules and expecting decisions from AAA
- 20:14that are no longer applicable. And one of the
- 20:17big ones, and you had talked about Joinder, is
- 20:20the Rule 7 change. It now reads that any party
- 20:26that another is seeking to join to an ongoing
- 20:28arbitration that fails to timely object to the
- 20:31Joinder request shall be deemed to have waived
- 20:35its objection. to the Joinder request. Now that's
- 20:38different than prior years, where if you had
- 20:41a party that simply ignored the Joinder request,
- 20:45we didn't add them to the case. And it was just
- 20:48a long and lengthy process trying to get them
- 20:51into the case. Now they're deemed to have waived
- 20:55their objection to the Joinder request. If they
- 20:57ignore us, it has made a world of difference
- 20:59in terms of responsiveness. uh and the timeliness
- 21:04of moving that case forward yeah i mean that's
- 21:07a huge change and this is a nuts and bolts so
- 21:09i don't want to get too far under the weeds i
- 21:11could talk about this forever But I mean, just
- 21:13on the arbitrators end as well, it's been a huge
- 21:17benefit because we would often get to the preliminary
- 21:20hearing and the parties would be so frustrated
- 21:21because they've already spent months trying to
- 21:24wade through the Joinder process, right? So they're
- 21:26like, you know, our clients are pounding the
- 21:28table. Arbitration is supposed to be more efficient
- 21:31and cheaper. And here we are months into the
- 21:33case and we haven't even started yet. So, yeah,
- 21:36I mean, that was a great change and it's paid
- 21:40dividends on the part. practical side. Very good.
- 21:44Let's talk a little bit about managing the case.
- 21:47Well, if everyone did the preliminary hearing,
- 21:50right, then there's not much to manage, right?
- 21:52So that's what I was kind of saying. My practice,
- 21:56we set the ultimate hearing date. We have a good
- 21:59preliminary hearing. We put together all of our
- 22:02roadmap. I issue an order following the hearing.
- 22:05And absent some dispute that the sophisticated
- 22:09council can't work out themselves, which is generally
- 22:12unlikely, then I pretty much just set status
- 22:17conferences and check in periodically. And unless
- 22:20the parties need to talk to me in advance of
- 22:22the hearing, it's smooth sailing, right? So that's
- 22:25the best case scenario. It doesn't always work
- 22:27out like that, right? But again, referring back
- 22:30to the guidelines and the preliminary hearing
- 22:32and the subsequent order, if issues do arise,
- 22:35then we've already talked about those issues.
- 22:36And everyone's kind of agreed about what the
- 22:38process is going to be, right? If there's a discovery
- 22:41dispute, then we kind of know we've laid the
- 22:43groundwork and we know how it's going to be handled,
- 22:45right? You got to meet and confer first, only
- 22:47in extreme circumstances. Did you bring motions?
- 22:49If you really can't figure it out, I'll help.
- 22:53Similarly, one of the issues that comes up a
- 22:55lot is dispositive motions, which we kind of
- 22:57touched on previously, right? So again, absent
- 23:01some clear cut issue with no disputed facts.
- 23:08that's really going to carve out a significant
- 23:11portion of the case or streamline a major issue
- 23:13or knock out a major component of damages, then,
- 23:16you know, dispositive motions are usually discouraged
- 23:19because it's just an issue that can be heard
- 23:20that's going to be kicked anyway and heard at
- 23:22the ultimate hearing, right? So think long and
- 23:25hard about bringing dispositive motions because
- 23:28they're typically more time and money than they're
- 23:30worth. Not always, like I said, they can be beneficial,
- 23:33but these are kind of the, if the process is
- 23:37running smoothly, managing the case isn't that
- 23:39difficult in the time between the preliminary
- 23:43hearing and the ultimate hearing. I know that
- 23:48we talk about in the training of new arbitrators,
- 23:53to make the hard calls. I think one of the issues
- 23:58that escalates to my attention is when an arbitrator
- 24:05is not responsive to... the particular needs
- 24:12of the parties. When they need a decision, it
- 24:15can be difficult, you know, to make that decision.
- 24:19And so we stress that, you know, you're going
- 24:21to have to make some hard calls. Have you had
- 24:24an opportunity to come across that situation
- 24:27with either yourself or while you're sitting
- 24:30on a panel? Oh yeah, I mean all the time. So
- 24:33at this level with the cases we see, right, and
- 24:36like I said, the level of sophistication from
- 24:38counsel, then usually the only issues that get
- 24:42to the arbitrators are the hard calls, right?
- 24:44Because they've figured out the non -hard issues
- 24:47themselves, right? So usually by the time it
- 24:49gets to us, it's some fairly nuanced, fairly
- 24:52high level issue that's kind of a fence sitter
- 24:56that requires the arbitrators to roll up their
- 24:59sleeves and do the work and make... the tough
- 25:00call. So in my mind, that's what we're here for,
- 25:04especially on these types of cases. And can we
- 25:06just go back a little bit to the hearing presentation
- 25:09of technical and expert evidence? What are you
- 25:12seeing in regards to how parties are presenting
- 25:14their cases? Have you seen any significant changes
- 25:17over the years? Yeah. And I think we'll talk
- 25:21about that. Oh, this is the hearing slide too,
- 25:23right? Oh, yeah. Yes, is the short answer. So
- 25:28this could be another 20 minute discussion, so
- 25:31let me try to streamline it, right? So construction
- 25:34cases, especially the bigger ones, involve. thousands,
- 25:39if not millions of documents, right? So when
- 25:42you talk about the technological component and
- 25:47organizing that volume of information, it's extremely
- 25:52difficult and has advanced significantly over
- 25:54the past. over the years, right? So the parties
- 25:58who can marshal that evidence and put it together
- 26:01in the most streamlined fashion definitely have
- 26:04a leg up. And that kind of dovetails into the
- 26:06expert discussions as well, right? The parties
- 26:10who can marshal that evidence in conjunction
- 26:13with their experts and put their best foot forward
- 26:16have a leg up there as well, right? In terms
- 26:20of developments, just not tech. I mean, the actual
- 26:24Hard. technology is becoming better too, which
- 26:28is a whole different issue we could talk about,
- 26:29right? The ability to summarize documents and
- 26:32the presentation capabilities, et cetera, is
- 26:35just light years beyond what it was 20 years
- 26:37ago, right? And then just there's been advances
- 26:40with experts and how we handle them as well,
- 26:42right? So, you know, there's the hot tubbing
- 26:46phenomenon, which people have talked about where
- 26:48all the experts kind of get up there at once
- 26:49and go back and forth and talk about their positions.
- 26:52I mean, there's a lot of creative ways. to streamline
- 26:56these issues and significant amounts of documents
- 27:01and information that have made this whole process
- 27:03easier for people who know how to do it. Yeah,
- 27:08you know, as an outsider peeking into the hearing
- 27:11room sometimes, I'm sometimes overwhelmed by
- 27:16the technology that's present in the hearing
- 27:18rooms. It almost looks like they're filming a
- 27:20Hollywood movie or something. Over the years,
- 27:24it's just incredible the amount of technology
- 27:28that's entered into the hearing rooms themselves.
- 27:31No, it's incredible. Just the project videos
- 27:34and cameras that people can wear on their heads
- 27:37now to capture every defect and everything. You're
- 27:43going to talk about this later just in terms
- 27:44of AI. Everything's getting exponentially better,
- 27:49extremely fast here. I can't wait to see what
- 27:52we're going to be looking at two years from now
- 27:54even. Well, hang on. Let's talk about the hearing
- 27:59to the award stage. All right. So we had our
- 28:03hearing. All right. Everyone did a good job and
- 28:06brought in their experts and did all our fancy
- 28:08presentations. So what are we going to do from
- 28:10the hearing to the award? Everyone's done, right?
- 28:12There's nothing else to talk about. That's not
- 28:16necessarily the case. I mean, there's a lot of
- 28:19considerations. But again, this is just a high
- 28:20level kind of flyover. So I mean, the biggest
- 28:24issue we the parties seem to wrestle with is
- 28:27whether they want a reasoned award or not, right?
- 28:30And sometimes the knee jerk is always, yes, we
- 28:32want a reasoned award, right? But I would encourage
- 28:34people to kind of take a pause and think about
- 28:36that, right? So especially. If you have a lower
- 28:39value case, do we need to expend the time and
- 28:42the resources for a full on reasoned award? So
- 28:46there's a financial component to it, right? Reasoned
- 28:49awards are more subject to scrutiny in terms
- 28:51of challenges, right? So if you think you won,
- 28:54do you want a reasoned award? That's one consideration
- 28:58we hear about. What rules are governing the dispute,
- 29:06the FAA, which makes it harder to challenge awards
- 29:09versus the California rules, which makes it,
- 29:13you know, gives you a little more potential to
- 29:16challenge awards. I mean, everyone wants finality
- 29:19when it comes to arbitrations, right? So that's
- 29:21what the party should be thinking about just
- 29:23all the way from the start. You know, do you
- 29:25want to? If you think you have a good case, do
- 29:27you want to pound the table and try to exclude
- 29:29massive categories of evidence? So the other
- 29:31side is going to say, the arbitrator didn't let
- 29:33us introduce this and try to challenge the award,
- 29:35right? There's all sorts of strategic considerations
- 29:38from the outset of a case that people should
- 29:40be thinking about leading up to and after the
- 29:45award or the hearing. Talk a little bit about
- 29:53some of the strategies that are effective in
- 29:56arbitration. Yeah, so, I mean, this is just kind
- 29:58of a summary of the things we've talked about,
- 30:01right? So you want to use your procedural tools,
- 30:03you know, starting at the preliminary hearing
- 30:05to kind of streamline the case, manage the complexity,
- 30:08make it as efficient and cost effective as possible,
- 30:11right? You want to coordinate your expert and
- 30:14technical testimony. That's what we talked about
- 30:17previously. Just putting your best foot forward
- 30:19presentation -wise and involving your experts
- 30:21so they can help you do that. And then just,
- 30:23again, what arbitration is supposed to be all
- 30:26about, right? Done right. It's supposed to promote
- 30:29efficiency and cost control. And that's kind
- 30:31of what the arbitrators are there for, to be
- 30:33the referee and to kind of to push the ship in
- 30:36that direction at all times, right? So that's
- 30:40the big picture takeaway is just in terms of
- 30:43the process itself, I think. So, you know, one
- 30:50of the The strategies that I have seen in construction
- 30:55arbitration is parties come to the arbitration
- 31:04process having already worked together more than
- 31:08I've seen in the past. I'll get on administrative
- 31:12conference calls and the parties have already
- 31:15discussed the case. They have already discussed,
- 31:17you know, how they want the case to proceed.
- 31:21I can't tell you how much time and money that
- 31:24saves. And I see it a lot. And naturally, the
- 31:29ADR industry and construction is a small community.
- 31:34So I see a lot of the same players. But it's
- 31:37really refreshing over the last few years how
- 31:40they have taken the saving of time and money.
- 31:47very seriously. And what that means is that,
- 31:52you know, everything from, you know, how we're
- 31:54going to select the arbitrator, how we're going
- 31:56to, you know, proceed with discovery, all of
- 31:59those, you know, they're having discussions about
- 32:02that. And I just see on the back end, when I
- 32:05look at the at the final compensation and total
- 32:09cost of the arbitration, I say that was a case
- 32:12that was very effective in their arbitration
- 32:14management. Yeah, no, 100%. It is a small world,
- 32:20right? Even though California is a big state,
- 32:23the construction industry is relatively small.
- 32:26So there is that, you know, a lot of people have
- 32:29been doing it for a long time, have seen a lot
- 32:30of the same people, right? So there's some camaraderie
- 32:34and collegiality, at least knowing you may see
- 32:36these people in the future. So there's that kind
- 32:38of high level, just everyone's interest to kind
- 32:42of get along for that purpose alone. construction
- 32:45industry is unique to in that, you know, the
- 32:48contracts will often require pre arbitration
- 32:51mediation or whatever. So the parties have often
- 32:53been dealing with each other for a long time
- 32:55and have gotten to know each other. So they've
- 32:57developed some sort of rapport. Right. And I
- 33:00think just it's a testament to the construction
- 33:02industry. that there's a time and a place for
- 33:06pounding the table and everyone is an advocate
- 33:10there for their client, a zealous advocate for
- 33:12their client, but there's something to be said
- 33:14about professionalism too, right? And I think
- 33:18that rings true. even more so in arbitration,
- 33:21where unreasonable requests, denials of extensions,
- 33:27and being unreasonable in general is generally
- 33:30more frowned upon. So I couldn't agree more.
- 33:33At the end of the day, I think getting along
- 33:35is in everyone's best interest, including the
- 33:38clients, which is obviously the most important
- 33:40consideration. Absolutely. Absolutely. Let's
- 33:45move on. This is something that I want to talk
- 33:53about a little bit about the process of mediation
- 33:57in an arbitration presentation because mediation
- 34:03is in every contract. If it's not in the contract,
- 34:09it's on the minds of the parties. If it's not
- 34:11on the minds of the parties, it's on the minds
- 34:14of council. California, in particular, is mediation
- 34:19-centric. I've been with the association for
- 34:22just over 30 years now, and I started out six
- 34:28months into my time with AAA, I was handling
- 34:33construction defect administration for just a
- 34:37couple of construction mediators. And our company
- 34:44was unfamiliar with the term construction defect.
- 34:47They had no idea what a multi -party was. You
- 34:49know, California brought that to the table. They
- 34:53literally flew a person out of our headquarters
- 34:58in New York to sit at my desk to understand what
- 35:02a construction defect case looked like. And they
- 35:06were so intrigued by the fact that I had drawers
- 35:12full of files, and every single one of those
- 35:16files was a multi -party construction defect
- 35:18case. They literally thought construction arbitration
- 35:22should be like commercial arbitration. There
- 35:24should only be two parties. And I said, no, these
- 35:28cases are, you know, this is what's going on
- 35:31in California. We literally had to rewrite the
- 35:34rules to adapt to this new process and procedure
- 35:41with these case management orders and special
- 35:44masters. It was all new to AAA. We literally
- 35:49wrote the book on mediation. And I can remember
- 35:53our East Coast folks saying, you know, this isn't
- 35:57a process that's coming, you know, our way. It's
- 36:01probably just a fad in California. I literally
- 36:04had AAA people telling me that from the East
- 36:06Coast. Every case that comes to arbitration,
- 36:12I'm asking the question, have you considered
- 36:15mediation? Have you been to mediation? You know,
- 36:18most of the cases have already attempted mediation.
- 36:22They're at impasse. This is why they're filing
- 36:23for arbitration. The very few that have not.
- 36:28are interested in mediation. So it's worth talking.
- 36:31It's part of the process because, you know, not
- 36:35everyone has large complex cases that comes to
- 36:38us. We have first time attorneys filing with
- 36:40us and they just don't know that mediation can
- 36:43run concurrently with the arbitration process.
- 36:46Especially in construction, you want to be thinking
- 36:49about mediation. I have cases that I look at
- 36:59during the award phase and I said, boy, you know,
- 37:03this is a case that really should have mediated
- 37:06its way into a settlement because it took, you
- 37:10know, took a little bit longer than we expected
- 37:12in arbitration. So, you know, it's not always
- 37:17a game where we tried mediation. and it failed.
- 37:23So we're going to go all the way to arbitration.
- 37:25I just want our users to know, our advocates
- 37:27to know that mediation can occur at any stage
- 37:31of the arbitration process. You could be two
- 37:36months out from your arbitration hearing and
- 37:39decide we want to try to, we're going to give
- 37:41it one more go with mediation. Do you see that
- 37:48as well, Jason? No, 100%. I mean, most of the
- 37:51time, actually. So that could fall into the slot
- 37:53of managing the case. oftentimes will be in arbitration,
- 37:57but the parties on the back end will be working
- 37:59toward mediation, right? So they'll come to me
- 38:03and say, look, can we kick out this deadline
- 38:05or that deadline because we're mediating with
- 38:07so -and -so on X date? And that's how I get involved,
- 38:11right? So yeah, highly encourage resolving the
- 38:15dispute if at all possible. Arbitration is...
- 38:20can be cheaper than litigation, but settling
- 38:23the case and ending everything is cheaper than
- 38:25both, right? So to the extent a compromise can
- 38:27be worked out, I think that's generally always
- 38:30in the best interest of the party. So yeah. Absolutely.
- 38:33And one of the things about mediation that over
- 38:37the years that I've seen is parties willing to
- 38:42go outside of a construction expert for mediation.
- 38:46We just want somebody who's very good at mediation.
- 38:50And sometimes that works and sometimes it doesn't.
- 38:53And the reason I say it like that is because
- 38:55construction cases are unique in the ADR field.
- 39:00There are so many variables. You could have a
- 39:04mediator that gets you all the way. to what you
- 39:08think is a closed deal, and they're not able
- 39:11to close that deal because they don't understand
- 39:14the dynamics of all of those parties that they've
- 39:17had to wrestle together. Our construction mediation
- 39:21panel. was developed specifically the same as
- 39:25our arbitration panel. You've got to come with
- 39:27subject matter expertise. So when you get into
- 39:29that room, you've got to know what you're talking
- 39:32about. You've got to know the situation inside
- 39:35and out. And you've got to bring that real expertise.
- 39:39One of the other things that we have started
- 39:41is streamlining our calendaring system. I hear
- 39:47time and time again from clients who are telling
- 39:49me that we can't find a mediator within the time
- 39:53frame that we're looking for. So we have dedicated
- 39:55mediators that are on call that can mediate those
- 40:00cases immediately. That's a game changer. I had
- 40:06a case that was three months out from the arbitration
- 40:11hearing. They had a mediation set. The mediation
- 40:16did not go for whatever reason. Now what? The
- 40:20mediator says, I don't have another date in the
- 40:24next three months. So I told the party, what
- 40:29do you want to do? Do you want to try another
- 40:31mediator? Or are you going to go to arbitration?
- 40:34They said, let's go to arbitration. That's the
- 40:38one mediator that we wanted. And so I wanted
- 40:40to impress upon our users, you've got to start
- 40:43finding mediators. who can mediate your cases
- 40:46when you want them to mediate your case. Whether
- 40:50that's looking outside the box or talking within
- 40:57the firm or something like that, you've got to
- 41:00expand your pool of mediators because your clients
- 41:03deserve it. they deserve to get these cases settled.
- 41:06And that's all I'm really going to say about
- 41:08that. I mean, you know, we encourage early mediation
- 41:11before arbitration because that's when the costs
- 41:14escalate. Yeah, no, I mean, I'm on that panel
- 41:18as well, so I'm biased, but I just echo your
- 41:20sentiments, right? just like I wouldn't go try
- 41:24to mediate some international M &A dispute or
- 41:27something I knew nothing about, right? I think
- 41:29subject matter expertise is so key in the construction
- 41:31mediations. There are just so many variables.
- 41:33It's almost like a different language, right?
- 41:35From the coverage components and the different
- 41:39parties involved to the lien issues to, I mean,
- 41:42especially if you're in a complex scheduling
- 41:43dispute. I mean, like I said, it's a different
- 41:45language that calls for subject matter expertise,
- 41:47in my opinion. Yeah, and here's the deal. I mean,
- 41:50you talked about our data. We have data as well
- 41:54for this area. You know, roughly two thirds of
- 41:58the cases that are filed for arbitration are
- 42:02settled before the first day of hearing. Yeah,
- 42:06that seems low, actually, based on what I see.
- 42:08It's a vast majority are resolved prior to the
- 42:11ultimate hearing. Yeah, and those are the cases
- 42:14that attempted mediation with AAA. There's a
- 42:18much higher percentage if you count those that
- 42:20had settled prior to even filing for arbitration.
- 42:24But those who decided to go all the way, two
- 42:26-thirds of those cases are going to eventually
- 42:28settle in mediation. So when I talk about the
- 42:31mediation process doesn't come to a standstill
- 42:34when you file for arbitration, that data is right
- 42:38on point, proving that parties are, you know,
- 42:41they are continuing the exercise of mediation
- 42:44all the way up to the hearing, trying to get
- 42:46those cases settled, which is good for California.
- 42:52All right, let's move, let's pivot and talk a
- 42:59little bit. I want to talk a little bit about
- 43:01some of the generative AI tools at AAA. And the
- 43:07reason I want to talk about this is because it's
- 43:12on everyone's mind. We've all experimented with
- 43:17ChatGPT. We've also seen its hallucinations.
- 43:22AAA's approach is different. We focus on governed
- 43:25AI, meaning secure, explainable, built on curated
- 43:32AAA data, not the internet's data. and auditable.
- 43:37An example is a tool that's used by many advocates
- 43:43is Clause Builder AI. When we're talking about
- 43:47drafting an arbitration clause, you can go to
- 43:50clausebuilder .com and you will find that you
- 43:56can create from a template your own construction
- 44:01contract. You can customize it. You can use the
- 44:06AI feature to further customize it. And here's
- 44:12the deal with the AI feature. Instead of answering
- 44:14from its training data alone like the Internet,
- 44:17the model first looks up relevant documents and
- 44:20then answers based on them. So you get a much
- 44:23more, you know, precise language. for the type
- 44:28of clause that you're drafting. And we mentioned
- 44:33already the AAAI panelist search. It's a semantic
- 44:37search that reads resumes intelligently. The
- 44:41semantic search is a search method that retrieves
- 44:44results based on meaning rather than exact keyword
- 44:47matches. We're all accustomed to putting in a
- 44:52keyword and getting the results from that keyword
- 44:55match. Instead, Does this document contain the
- 45:00same words as the query? The semantic search
- 45:03asks, does this document mean something similar
- 45:06to what the user is asking? So you're going to
- 45:08get a much different response using the type
- 45:12of search that we have put together in the panel
- 45:16of search tool. Interestingly, Our case managers
- 45:21use this when they're putting together lists.
- 45:23And since the time of introduction, they've reported
- 45:27at least 50 -55 % time savings in preparing the
- 45:34list based on what the parties have told them.
- 45:36This is the qualifications. This is the criteria.
- 45:40And the parties are telling us, wow, the list
- 45:43is a much better match now than what we've seen
- 45:45in previous years. So that's a good thing about
- 45:49generative. the AI assistant in a web file. This
- 45:54is the document that the parties in the arbitrator
- 45:58use to store their documents, to upload their
- 46:01documents. There is an AI component to that that
- 46:06allows you to document summarization and Q &A
- 46:14to assist you along the way. Everything we can
- 46:17do to assist the parties in understanding this
- 46:19process better is what we're trying to accomplish.
- 46:24Chatbots are something that we've seen with all
- 46:27of the retail online sites, all of the customer
- 46:31service, the retail, the customer service. Everyone
- 46:34has a chatbot. Well, we have a chatbot now to
- 46:37help people just in. filing a case. There are
- 46:39so many questions that people have just on, you
- 46:43know, how do I arrive at, you know, which rules
- 46:48to use? And you can ask the chat bot, you know,
- 46:51which rules should I be using? It makes a big
- 46:54difference. It's not theoretical efficiency.
- 46:58It's operational impact that we're trying to
- 47:00achieve. And then let's take a look at something
- 47:05that's been on a lot of people's minds. And that's
- 47:08the introduction of AAA's AI Arbitrator. And
- 47:15this is important for this discussion because
- 47:18we launched this late last year in 49 states,
- 47:25every state except California. And we only launched
- 47:32it for the construction cases. We've trained
- 47:37this AI arbitrator on thousands of construction
- 47:41awarded cases. But let's talk about what it is
- 47:47and what it is not because I have arbitrators
- 47:49are telling me Oh, they're gonna replace me.
- 47:51No, they're not gonna replace you Yeah, are you
- 47:53in this bot gonna be doing this presentation
- 47:55next year? No, but maybe by itself, I don't know
- 48:01if you're gone I'm gone So so let me just just
- 48:06very Frankly say upfront. This is not about replacing
- 48:10human judgment at all And I have talked to Jason
- 48:16about this. And I said, we might even want to
- 48:19call it a AAA AI Arbitrator Assistant. And I
- 48:23think that might even be a better name for this
- 48:26particular product. It's about augmenting dispute
- 48:29resolution. So public AI is exciting, but it's
- 48:33unpredictable. Governed AI that I mentioned before
- 48:36is controlled, audible, built for legal reliability.
- 48:43Designed with ethical guardrails. That's what
- 48:46you want. This is not a system that's exposed
- 48:48to the public. This is not an Internet based
- 48:51product. This is a system that we created in
- 48:54house. And it's designed to assist in dispute
- 48:58resolution by analyzing case materials, and that
- 49:02could be documents. It could be photographs.
- 49:04It could be video and generating structured explainable
- 49:08outputs grounded in AAA rules. and approve data
- 49:12sources without, let me be real clear here, without
- 49:15replacing human arbitrator judgment. So here's
- 49:18basically how it works. Parties can opt in to
- 49:23these AAA AI arbitrator and they have choices.
- 49:29Do they want a binding decision? Do they want
- 49:31a non -binding decision? There may be a time
- 49:35when this is used outside of the box for early
- 49:38neutral evaluation. We just want to see by entering
- 49:42our documents, what the AI arbitrator says about
- 49:46our case, multiple uses for it. What it is not
- 49:50going to do is give you a final and binding award.
- 49:54What it will do is access the data, analyze the
- 49:58data, and then it will put out an award that
- 50:04is then reviewed by the human arbitrator who
- 50:07has literally been involved in the process from
- 50:11the time of filing all the way to the award,
- 50:15the human arbitrator will do their own research,
- 50:21making sure there's no hallucinations or all
- 50:23of those things that we had talked about. They
- 50:25will place their signature on the award when
- 50:28they know that that award is the right award.
- 50:31So that's what the AI arbitrator is and what
- 50:35it is not. People ask why we put this out. This
- 50:39is coming, folks, whether AAA puts it out or
- 50:42not. There's think tanks that are already trying
- 50:46to outdo us on this. AAA is not observing AI
- 50:49from the sidelines. We are integrating it into
- 50:53ADR responsibly. And that means that as the leader
- 50:59of alternative dispute resolution, there's an
- 51:03expectation that when it comes to innovation,
- 51:07and thoughtful and responsible case management
- 51:11systems that the leader in ADR is going to be
- 51:14at the forefront of that. Interesting that we
- 51:20move into our next slide because what we're talking
- 51:23about is the AAA's 100th anniversary that we
- 51:28celebrated this month, 1926 to 2026. We've been
- 51:32doing this, folks, for a long time. And California
- 51:35practitioners should understand this. AAA is
- 51:40entering its second century by modernizing dispute
- 51:43resolution infrastructure with AI -powered solutions.
- 51:48ethical AI governance and leadership, blockchain
- 51:52tools to ensure document integrity, expansion
- 51:56of mediation offerings, collaboration with institutions
- 52:00like PLI, and continuous innovation in Webfile,
- 52:04the document repository system. We are looking
- 52:08at every stage of dispute resolution and asking,
- 52:12how can this be faster? How can this be more
- 52:15secure? How can this be more predictable? That
- 52:19is where construction arbitration is heading.
- 52:23And at that point here, I'm going to leave it
- 52:27to Jason to wrap us up. I think we're done, right?
- 52:30So what did we learn here today? Arbitration
- 52:34is supposed to be faster and more economical.
- 52:38uh alternative to litigation right so there's
- 52:42scrambling oftentimes that that's not the case
- 52:44and it's so expensive blah blah blah but i i
- 52:47would to challenge that kind of thinking by saying,
- 52:52kind of reiterating what we've said throughout
- 52:54this presentation, that if done properly and
- 52:59people get in front of the issues at the outset
- 53:01to try to streamline these cases, there's a lot
- 53:04higher likelihood that you're going to end up
- 53:06with a faster and more economical result, right?
- 53:10So that's kind of the big picture takeaway here.
- 53:13There's a lot of exciting things to come. All
- 53:15the tech issues that Mike talked about. It's
- 53:17happening so fast. I can barely get my brain
- 53:19around it. Again, this is just a super high level
- 53:2530 ,000 foot overview of all these topics. I
- 53:28think Mike and I could talk for an hour on each
- 53:31slide if we wanted to. So if anyone has questions
- 53:34or wants us to come back to talk about anything
- 53:37else, you have our contact information here.
- 53:40And Mike, unless you got anything else. Thanks
- 53:42for listening, everyone. I appreciate the opportunity.
- 53:46I just wanted to thank everyone also for joining
- 53:49us today. And thank you, Jason, for coming to
- 53:53this presentation with the skill set of an incredible
- 53:58arbitrator. Thanks, Mike. And mediator. Oh, thank
- 54:03you. And that's a wrap. Thank you.