Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #232 - Frances Haugen / Amanda Wawryk / Dino Archie
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Moameir and this is Van Collor,
- 0:13British Columbia's bona fide culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight, let's
- 0:18talk social media. Just how private are your private direct messages on social media
- 0:24sites? Is Facebook selling your private dms as a way to generate ad revenue?
- 0:30Here to discuss is a very special guest. She's an American engineer and
- 0:34scientist informally known as the Facebook whistleblower. Her revelations included how Facebook was seemingly
- 0:41aware of the damage that its products were doing to the mental health of teenagers,
- 0:46how the platform fanned ethnic violence around the world while failing to curb misinformation,
- 0:52disinformation, and threats to election security. You've seen her on Real Time
- 0:56with Bill Maher and The Daily Show. She's testified in front of the US
- 1:00Congress here via Internet Magic. She is Francis Hougan. Francis, thank you
- 1:06so much for beaming in tonight. Happy to be here, My pleasure now.
- 1:11There was a recent allegation that Meta, which includes Facebook, Instagram,
- 1:15and WhatsApp, was basically selling its users' private direct messages to Netflix. Meta
- 1:21denied this allegation, but is there any indication that Meta shares or sells private
- 1:26messages from Facebook, Instagram, or I guess even WhatsApp to advertisers or other
- 1:32companies. One of the things that I think is important to note about this
- 1:36lawsuit is that it is a class action lawsuit in the United States, but
- 1:40it refers to behavior that was taking place in the past. And one of
- 1:45the things that most people are not aware of is that Facebook has a history
- 1:49of engaging with data sharing practices with other companies. So going back all the
- 1:53way to this was around twenty ten twenty eleven with their Beacon project, so
- 1:57they had huge amounts of data transfer between other advertisers and the platform. You
- 2:05know, they have a history of doing these kinds of data sharing agreements.
- 2:07But there's a difference between sending safe stats to Netflix on how many people are
- 2:13talking about a TV show and sending the direct messages themselves. It's also important
- 2:17to note that over the course of the last year's Meta has made a big
- 2:22push to go towards end to end encrypted messaging, and so it is very
- 2:25unlikely that these practices are continuing today and as a general pattern in the past,
- 2:31when Meta has been sued about data privacy issues. They generally have changed
- 2:37their behavior afterwards. It would be nice to see them do it more proactively,
- 2:39but is unlikely they are selling your messages today. Okay, fair enough,
- 2:44Now, I know that there are some distinctions in the law depending on
- 2:49the country. But if you are a user of a social media platform,
- 2:53whether it's Facebook, Instagram, Twitter or snapchat, whatever, is there a
- 2:57fair expectation that your private messages are kept private or does the social media platform
- 3:04own those messages and can do whatever they want with them. One of the
- 3:07things that people are usually shocked by is so you actually go read your terms
- 3:13of service. The agreements that each platform you engage with make with you are
- 3:16very different. You know. They can range from thousands of words or which
- 3:22is an open source encrypted form messaging, you know, hundreds of word agreement
- 3:25on like what behavior is acceptable to fifteen thousand words if good to things like
- 3:30Microsoft products. Inside those agreements you can have very very different conditions. So
- 3:36to generalize across all products it's very difficult too. But the last thing I
- 3:39would leave you with is I you know, this is why having national regulations
- 3:45matter. Canada is right now considering something called the online harmspill, which would
- 3:50give us the right to ask questions like this. You know, right now,
- 3:53we don't really have exhausted rice to say, hey, what data do
- 3:55you have on us? How are you using it? How might that data
- 3:59be misused? With something like an online harms built, Canadians could have that
- 4:02right. Oh wow, okay, so that's even a surprise to me.
- 4:06I didn't realize that the government can't even find this out from these tech giants,
- 4:12which seems like a big glaring hole in the ecosystem. Yeah. And
- 4:18I suppose that the terms of service and those conditions that we all just kind
- 4:21of click through, I feel like they're probably complicated by design so that no
- 4:26one actually reads them. Right. They're written at an eleventh or twelfth grade
- 4:30level with lots of legal ease, and scholars have hypothesized that part of the
- 4:35reasons why they do make them so obtuse, so that people don't read through
- 4:40them. One of the things to remember is that these products are built out
- 4:44of the United States, and while Canadians have a higher expectation of privacy than
- 4:47people in the United States, the products aren't necessarily designed such that those expectations
- 4:54are universal. Even in the US things like the FTC or the FCC,
- 4:59which overseas things like Facebook, they usually can't act until a whistleblower comes forward.
- 5:03And so remember we need to have systems in place the give the public
- 5:09the right to ask for information and get it and not just have to rely
- 5:13on effectively marketing messages from these companies. Interesting now, in the meantime,
- 5:17if you are a user of social media, as most of us are,
- 5:21is there anything you can do to protect your privacy aside from not being on
- 5:27social media? Well, remember you don't have to do messaging on the same
- 5:31platforms that you do, say, consume videos. One of the things that
- 5:35I always encourage people for is I've mentioned before before, even in this interview.
- 5:40This platform called Signal. So signal like the signal on the Internet,
- 5:44signal for your phone. Signal is an open source that means anyone can go
- 5:48and look at the code peer to peer encrypto chat and it's one of the
- 5:54only things to say, like the State Department in the United States uses or
- 5:57like people in the US military often use it. And that's because when you
- 6:00have code that everyone can look at, people can know, oh, this
- 6:03product actually says what it means we don't have that same level of transparency for
- 6:09any of the major social media platforms. Wow. Okay, so basically what
- 6:13I'm hearing is don't expect privacy in terms of your DMS from those social media
- 6:17platforms. There are some alternatives, like, remember we were relying on effectively
- 6:25marketing messages. We haven't been given the code base for these platforms. They're
- 6:29not. They have a history of making big claims that later our proof should
- 6:32not be true when we rely on open source softwares. This is your bots.
- 6:36It comes from a nonprofit. They're not there to make sure you stay
- 6:40on as long as possible, show you as many ads as possible. It's
- 6:43something that is built for the public, by the public, paid for by
- 6:46donations from people in the public. Well, thank you so much for this.
- 6:50I think this is definitely illuminating for a lot of us, especially if
- 6:54we haven't thought about it and certainly had that expectation of privacy, but then
- 6:58finding out that we don't even really know. So, Francis, I appreciate
- 7:01your time tonight. Thank you so much. My pleasure. Folks you know
- 7:06her as the Facebook whistleblower. She is Francis Hogan. Be sure to pick
- 7:12up her memoir, The Power of One wherever you get your books. Now
- 7:15after some business, how is Meta's news band in Canada where Canadians can't even
- 7:19share news links on Facebook or Instagram affected newsrooms across the country. We'll talk
- 7:26about it up next. Welcome back to this as van color. It's been
- 7:35a full year since Meta has blocked news for Canadian users. Whereby you in
- 7:41Canada can't share or view news links on Facebook or Instagram. This was Meta's
- 7:46response to the Trudeau Government's Online News Act Bill C eighteen, which intends to
- 7:51compel tech giants to pay Canadian media anytime their news content is used or shared
- 8:00with newsrooms across the country already in crisis. How badly has this impacted Canadian
- 8:05news media outlets? Here to explain is the managing editor of The Daily Hive,
- 8:11which is Canada's fastest growing digital publication. She is Amanda Warwick and this
- 8:16conversation is brought to you by Pacific Sands Beach Resort and Tofino laid back luxury
- 8:22as beachfront as it gets. So, Amanda, what is the status of
- 8:31Meta's news ban here in Canada? Is there any progress on removing the band.
- 8:37No, it doesn't seem that way. So yeah, as you mentioned,
- 8:41you know, this bill received royal assent last June, and we started
- 8:46noticing the impacts probably in late July, early August. So you know,
- 8:52at Daily Hive, all of our news stories went up on Facebook, that
- 8:56sort of thing, and we started to notice, okay, fewer likes,
- 9:01no engagement, and you know that's when it really took effect. And you
- 9:07know, Facebook was a significant part of our traffic, you know Instagram as
- 9:13well. So right now there really isn't much update and Meta has basically it
- 9:20seems to be that they basically said, no, we have no interest in
- 9:22negotiating wow, with the federal government. They like, I will say,
- 9:26there is a bit of a silver lining you mentioned tech giants, the silver
- 9:30linings with Google. Google has negotiated, you know, with the government.
- 9:33They have agreed to pay one hundred million dollars to media organizations in Canada so
- 9:39that their news can still be hosted in Google Search. So if you search
- 9:43for something on Google, it's on Google. Thanks. Okay, so that
- 9:46is a little bit of a silver lining, and you know that's kind of
- 9:50forced Daily Hive to do more research into search engine optimization. You know,
- 9:56these days, if you're on LinkedIn, you see SEO all over and that
- 10:00is search engine optimization. So what Daily Hive had to do. You know,
- 10:03we're a really agile company. We're a young company with you know,
- 10:07really hard working reporters, and we've worked with them to improve SEO. You
- 10:13know, we've worked with the experts. We've gotten advice from outside sources about
- 10:16how we can really build up our presence on Google. And so you'll see
- 10:20Daily Hive hire and search results. Interesting, Now, I had heard that
- 10:24for the last two years before the ban, news traffic on Facebook in particular
- 10:28had already been on the decline. And I know that Daily Hive is has
- 10:33been historically quite reliant on Facebook in particular, right because that's where you're generating
- 10:39all the traffic. So did you already see a decline in terms of traffic
- 10:43from Facebook even before the ban? Slightly? It's hard for me to kind
- 10:48of gauge necessarily. I joined Daily Hive in September twenty twenty one. Okay,
- 10:52I came from a radio background, and so you know when I started,
- 10:56Facebook was bread and butter for us. For our traffic sources you know,
- 11:00it was huge and so you know, some posts would just absolutely take
- 11:05off. And as we were you know, growing and hiring more reporters and
- 11:11writers, we had more and more stories to get out there. So you
- 11:15know, I would work with our director of audience at the time to you
- 11:18know, look at algorithm changes that sort of thing. You know, we
- 11:20were posting every twenty minutes. Oh wow, So it was a lot.
- 11:24It was a big job. And that's in all cities across the country that
- 11:26we operate in, so that was a huge thing. So then you know,
- 11:31if we had a ton of news one day, it's can we go
- 11:33to fifteen minutes? Will that make a difference on the algorithm? And you
- 11:37know sometimes some stories wouldn't get a lot of traffic, but then other stories
- 11:41where you're still seeing huge numbers from them. So it wasn't you know,
- 11:46it definitely wasn't a significant or dramatic kind of fall off the cliff. Okay,
- 11:52that's until July August last summer, use when the band came into a
- 11:56fact. Now, I look at Facebook as a bit of a digital you
- 12:00stand where it is delivering a lot of links, news articles to people because
- 12:05people are sharing things it shows up in your feed, and so I'm just
- 12:09wondering, like, for Canadian media companies, has this bill, the C
- 12:13eighteen, the Online News Act? I mean, it seems to have been
- 12:16doing more harm, right, because why should the why should these big tech
- 12:22giants compensate companies like yours? What am I missing here? You know?
- 12:26In a way, you know, it's stung. It stung media organizations big
- 12:30and small right across the country who you know, relied on Facebook on Instagram
- 12:35to tell these stories. And it's it's been hard, but you you know,
- 12:39you have to be agile, you have to adapt. That's just you
- 12:41know the world. But is there a rationale to have those companies like Google
- 12:46pay Canadian news media organizations or is it just their existence is actually already helping
- 12:50you out? I would say their existence is already helping us out, you
- 12:54know it. It would be hard to say, you know, necessarily or
- 13:01the money could be great. But at the same time, we just want
- 13:03to get our news out to Canadian consumers. We want to tell them the
- 13:07stories that matter. We want them to be able to you know, find
- 13:09Daily Hive, a trusted source of news and information right across the country and
- 13:15now it's way harder for consumers. They have to you know, go out
- 13:18and search out this news. Right. Ultimately, I feel like the Internet
- 13:22has basically become like six sites and those sites then like filter to other sites.
- 13:28And so in the case of Daily Hive, like how has this affected
- 13:33your your newsroom or how's it affected just Canadian media in general? When I
- 13:37guess everyone is so reliant. You know, one thing we've done at Daily
- 13:41Hive, as I've said, you know, we're agile, we adapt,
- 13:43We've really gone after you know, short form video, we've gone after TikTok.
- 13:48We found other ways of getting our information out. Another one is our
- 13:52daily newsletters right across the country, where we can curate news that we think
- 13:56is important for Canadians to know and get it sent directly to your inbox of
- 14:01signed up a daily havef dot com if you have it, And you know,
- 14:03we're also focusing on verticals like our dish which is our food coverage,
- 14:07our sports, and our lifestyle and you know, those verticals aren't blocked,
- 14:13so we're really putting you know, big efforts again into video, into food,
- 14:16into sports, into lifestyle, and Canadians can still get that news as
- 14:22well and just expanding and growing and you know, finding new ways to share
- 14:26that information. Sounds like you're definitely ahead of the curve because I think that's
- 14:30where it's headed for media organizations, is newsletters and you can develop lists and
- 14:35things like that really quickly. Is it strange that Meta has banned Canadian news
- 14:41sites or I should say new sites for Canadians while at the same time misinformation
- 14:46disinformation is still being spread quite openly. You know, I don't think it
- 14:50is. It's you know, Canadians really have to think with a critical eye.
- 14:54You notice, you know, on Instagram, on Facebook, all these
- 14:58brands are popping up delivering news. But you know, for Daily Hive and
- 15:03you know, other news sites were staffed by experience journalism or journalists with newsroom
- 15:09experience, and many of the sites or you know, brands you see on
- 15:13Instagram, they don't have that background. So you know, when you look
- 15:18at your news, you you know, you have to think critically has it
- 15:22been sourced properly? You're putting a lot of trust in the consumer here,
- 15:24and you know, but that's kind of the you know, way we live,
- 15:26and that's unfortunate. Yeah, you know, you know, I read
- 15:31tons of different news sites, and it's it's really a shame because so many
- 15:35journalists right across the country are telling incredibly powerful stories, stories that I wish
- 15:41all Canadians could see. But with the band, it's hard and it's not
- 15:46getting shared as widely as it could have, which is really does a disservice
- 15:50to Canadians in general, it really does. Amanda, thank you so much
- 15:54for your time to night, Thanks for breaking this down for us. Absolutely,
- 15:56Thank you, folks. That was the Daily Hives Managing editor, Amanda
- 16:00Warwick. Bookmark the Daily Hive and visit their site directly, just like you
- 16:04do with check News. Daily Hive just expanded to Victoria back in February to
- 16:10deliver interesting news stories to keep you connected to Victoria and Vancouver Islands, so
- 16:14be sure to check them out. You can also follow them on x and
- 16:17TikTok. Thank you so much to Pacific Sands Beach Resort and to Fino for
- 16:22supporting local conversations. Now stick around because in an episode about social media,
- 16:26we have to talk about the trolls. Comedian Dino Archie will walk us down
- 16:32the social media low road. Up next, Welcome back to This is Van
- 16:41Color. Why are people so terrible and so gross online? Here to shed
- 16:48some light or at least make light of it. As a Vancouver based comedian
- 16:52by the way of Fresno, California, fresh off the Netflix is a joke
- 16:56festival, he is Dino Archie and this is the Road Report. So do
- 17:07you know the Internet is a cesspool? There's a lot of goons on there.
- 17:11What is it about social media and the Internet that just brings out the
- 17:15worst of us to take the low road and interact with each other in pretty
- 17:19gross ways. Well, you know, to begin this conversation that we're gonna
- 17:26have, we have to begin with trolls. Yes, we all know,
- 17:30we're familiar with trolls, but we just throw that term around. I did
- 17:34a little bit of research, we did, put my research team on it,
- 17:38and we got to give the Norwegians credit for trolls. Trolls were around
- 17:45before the Internet, Okay, right, so we think, you know all
- 17:49they just came out of nowhere. People always been trolls. The first troll
- 17:55was in Norwegian lived under bridge and k now okay like that? Yeah,
- 18:02yeah, they meant to That's where the lower comes from. That's where the
- 18:03lower comes from like the cave, ugly and unpleasant to look at, but
- 18:10that's that's the cartoonist thing. But now the Internet, what the Internet did
- 18:14was make us all trolls. And the internet's our cave, you know,
- 18:18and we could walk portably. No basements. Now with the phone is,
- 18:22we're all in the basement. So why do we do it? Though?
- 18:26It just seems like such unpleasant behavior? When why would anyone want to be
- 18:30one of those folks? See troll? Well, because there's something in a
- 18:33human being that feels good to kick someone when they're down right, sometimes not
- 18:38even when they're down apparently Yeah, yeah, they're standing straight up, you
- 18:41can get you could get kicked, but especially if they're going down. That's
- 18:45that's there's a human nature to it, you know. So right now,
- 18:49like the newtrol the best, the best trolling is happening in the comment section.
- 18:55Yeah, you know, I see it all the time. This is
- 18:57the comment section. That's where you get your premium troll because you can't regulate
- 19:03that. That's the bottom barrel of that world. There's no hate speech is
- 19:07celebrated. That's you say, sadly, someone has to say it, and
- 19:14all the trolls so they serve a purpose. I don't fully what is that
- 19:18purpose? What purpose does that serve? It gets out the evil in you?
- 19:23Okay, it gets out to eat. Like if everybody subpoena, if
- 19:26everyone got their d M subpoena, you wouldn't have a job row the stuff
- 19:32that you send me. In fact, you trolled me. I troll you
- 19:34with this episode. How did that troll your Yes, you text me out
- 19:40of It was probably late too, way too late for it was or it
- 19:45was early then it was early. Yeah, so it was so it was
- 19:48early, Yeah, way too early. That's what the problem was. It
- 19:51was way too early. You're up to five Internet goal, you know,
- 19:56you just sa let's talk about the inn, the low road, the internet
- 20:00say something. I'm like, that's that's not a trolling me. That wasn't
- 20:06enough. But then then you know, but you I know what you want
- 20:11though. You asked me here for a reason. Yeah, I mean it's
- 20:12called the low road. Reports everybody likes the low road. That's true.
- 20:17That's what I'm saying. There's a part of everyone that you know they had
- 20:21that saying Michelle Obama, the first lady, awesome first lady, but she
- 20:26had this saying she was like, when they go low, we go high.
- 20:32Like for some that's no man, like when you sometimes when someone goes
- 20:37low, you got to go lower. Right Sometimes have you ever taken the
- 20:41high road and regretted it? Like you hold the door just in a little
- 20:47you hold the door open for someone just you know they're walking behind you,
- 20:51and then they just walk by and don't say thank you. I have to
- 20:53convince myself that I'm a good person when that happens, because I don't get
- 20:57validated. I see it happens, but you think about that person sometimes wake
- 21:03up in the middle of the night cold sweats really quickly. I've seen that
- 21:07social media actually affects offline behavior too, Like at a recent show of Yours,
- 21:11there were some ladies that were taking selfies of themselves. I mean,
- 21:15you're trying to perform and they're taking selfies for social media. So it's not
- 21:18even just like bad behavior online, they're like taking it to reality as well.
- 21:25Yeah. Yeah, we're at this point, we're half of avatar and
- 21:32half human, you know what I mean. So yeah, every if the
- 21:36moment isn't recorded and put digitally, it didn't happen. We're there the genies
- 21:42out of the bottle man, there's no That's why I was like, I'm
- 21:45not gonna even come out here and complain about it, Like, because have
- 21:48you ever been locked into a bad conversation and all you could think about is
- 21:53your phone? Yeah, all you could think about it. I'm guilty of
- 21:56looking at you know, the DM, seeing what you're buddies, what crashes
- 22:00they sent you. You know, that's all my dms are. It's just
- 22:06slammis well, okay, slams It's madness, Stino. We got to cut
- 22:11it off there, But I appreciate your time. Thanks for shedding light on
- 22:15this and well on making the light is dark. You're shedding dark on it.
- 22:19I appreciate it nonetheless. Thank you so much, folks, Thank you
- 22:23so much for watching, and thank you to Francis Hougan, the Daily Hives,
- 22:27Amanda Warwick, and your resident low Road Larry Dino Archie. If you
- 22:33have any thoughts about tonight's show, shoot me an email mo at. This
- 22:36isvancolor dot com and since tonight was all about social media, follow me on
- 22:41x or TikTok at van Color. Please validate me with your likes, but
- 22:45be aware that our dms are not private. Apparently, they're probably being collected
- 22:48and sold in order to sell you stuff at ideas that you don't need.
- 22:52And on that dire note, we will be back next week, but for
- 22:56now, this is Van color and I'm moamir telling you that in a province
- 23:00where you can be anything, be colorful. Peace