Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump Found Liable for Sex Abuse and Defamation
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:11Speaker 1: Donald Trump did it. Donald Trump did it, and all
- 0:17Speaker 1: his saying no, no, no is not true.
- 0:23Speaker 2: For the first time, a former president has been found
- 0:26Speaker 2: libel for sexual abuse and defamation. Donald Trump has been
- 0:30Speaker 2: accused by more than a dozen women of sexual misconduct,
- 0:34Speaker 2: but never before had a jury weighed those claims. And
- 0:37Speaker 2: after deliberating for less than three hours, that New York
- 0:40Speaker 2: jury of six men and three women found that Trump
- 0:44Speaker 2: had sexually abused and defamed Egene Carroll, a writer who
- 0:49Speaker 2: accused him of raping her in a department store in
- 0:51Speaker 2: the mid nineties. Carol said getting that verdict was probably
- 0:55Speaker 2: the happiest day of her life.
- 0:57Speaker 1: I'm overwhelmed, overwhelmed with joe, happiness and delight for the
- 1:03Speaker 1: women in this country.
- 1:04Speaker 2: The jury awarded Carol five million dollars in combined damages.
- 1:08Speaker 2: Trump's attorney, Joe Takapina, said they would appeal, apparently taking
- 1:12Speaker 2: some solace in the fact that the jury found that
- 1:15Speaker 2: Trump had not raped Carol.
- 1:17Speaker 3: For me, it's just about the results.
- 1:19Speaker 1: And at the end of the day, while you know
- 1:22Speaker 1: who's strange, Harby was.
- 1:24Speaker 3: Obviously very happy that Donald Trump was not granted a rapist.
- 1:28Speaker 3: I didn't think this should be any liability findings, so.
- 1:31Speaker 1: We'll pursue it.
- 1:32Speaker 2: And on his truth social platform, the former president called
- 1:36Speaker 2: a verdict a political hit job. I have absolutely no
- 1:39Speaker 2: idea who this woman is, he said, this verdict is
- 1:42Speaker 2: a disgrace, a continuation of the greatest witch hunt of
- 1:46Speaker 2: all time. Joining me is former federal prosecutor Jessica Roth,
- 1:50Speaker 2: a professor at Cardozo Law School. Jessica, what does this
- 1:54Speaker 2: verdict stand for?
- 1:55Speaker 4: Well, I think it was a resounding vindication of Future Carroll.
- 1:59Speaker 4: The jury took less than three hours to return a
- 2:02Speaker 4: unanimous verdict in her favor after a trial that was
- 2:05Speaker 4: about two weeks. It found that Donald Trump committed battery
- 2:08Speaker 4: when he sexually abused Miss Carroll in the mid nineteen
- 2:11Speaker 4: nineties at a Bergdorf Goodman's dressing room, and that he
- 2:14Speaker 4: defamed her in twenty twenty two when he denied publicly
- 2:17Speaker 4: her allegation after she had gone public with them. And
- 2:20Speaker 4: the jury's award of five million dollars to Miss Carroll,
- 2:24Speaker 4: mostly for compensatory rather than punitive damages, demonstrates not only
- 2:28Speaker 4: that the jury credited miss Carroll's account about the attack,
- 2:32Speaker 4: but also her testimony about how Trump's actions had harmed her.
- 2:36Speaker 2: The jury found that Trump did not rape Carol, they
- 2:39Speaker 2: found sexual abuse. Her testimony was that she was raped.
- 2:44Speaker 2: So does that mean they didn't fully buy her testimony
- 2:48Speaker 2: or was this a compromise verdict.
- 2:50Speaker 4: I don't think I would characterize it as a compromise verdict.
- 2:53Speaker 4: My sense of the case is that it was a
- 2:56Speaker 4: very important through line that there was pattern of how
- 3:01Speaker 4: Trump attacked women sexually. It was the account that was
- 3:06Speaker 4: given by the two other women who had come forward
- 3:08Speaker 4: and who were permitted to testify at the trial about
- 3:11Speaker 4: how Trump had assaulted them, and also the account that
- 3:14Speaker 4: Trump himself gave in that now infamous Access Hollywood video
- 3:19Speaker 4: where he talked about how when he would see a woman,
- 3:22Speaker 4: he would just move on her, as he said, and
- 3:25Speaker 4: start kissing her and touching her and grab her by
- 3:27Speaker 4: the genitals without asking for permission. In a sense, that
- 3:30Speaker 4: was the narrative that was just repeated over and over
- 3:34Speaker 4: again throughout the trial, and that narrative is most consistent
- 3:38Speaker 4: with sexual abuse, which doesn't involve an element of penetration
- 3:42Speaker 4: by his genitals and so to the extent that that
- 3:46Speaker 4: consistent narrative was important to the jury's quick verdict, it
- 3:50Speaker 4: makes sense that they would essentially check the box for
- 3:53Speaker 4: sexual abuse because that's most consistent with the account that
- 3:57Speaker 4: they heard over and over again.
- 3:59Speaker 2: So the standard on that count was preponderance of the
- 4:03Speaker 2: evidence that the claims were more likely to be true
- 4:06Speaker 2: than false. But as far as the defamation claim, the
- 4:09Speaker 2: standard was higher, although not as high as a criminal case.
- 4:13Speaker 2: Can you explain the standard and the defamation claim.
- 4:16Speaker 4: The standard for the defamation claim was clear and convincing evidence,
- 4:20Speaker 4: which is higher than the normal civil liability standard of
- 4:23Speaker 4: a preponderance more likely than not, but lower than the
- 4:27Speaker 4: burden of proof and a criminal case of proof beyond
- 4:29Speaker 4: a reasonable doubt. The jury found that that standard of
- 4:33Speaker 4: clear and convincing was established for her defamation claim, and
- 4:37Speaker 4: they awarded damages for the battery claim and damages for
- 4:43Speaker 4: the defamation claim separately.
- 4:45Speaker 2: You mentioned the short deliberations under three hours. Do you
- 4:50Speaker 2: think that's a result of the fact that Trump didn't put.
- 4:53Speaker 5: On a case.
- 4:55Speaker 4: It may have been. In part. It was probably a
- 4:57Speaker 4: reaction to the fact that there wasn't all that much
- 4:59Speaker 4: evidence for them to sort through, and if the Trump
- 5:03Speaker 4: side had put on a defense, there would have been
- 5:05Speaker 4: simply perhaps more evidence for them to go through. Instead,
- 5:08Speaker 4: they had to evaluate the witnesses and the evidence that
- 5:13Speaker 4: was presented to them, which was all from the plaintiff's side.
- 5:16Speaker 4: The plaintiff put on Miss Carroll's testimony, which was quite
- 5:21Speaker 4: vivid and detailed, and then the testimony of the two
- 5:25Speaker 4: friends whom she had called very soon after the attack,
- 5:29Speaker 4: one immediately afterward, that same night and the other one
- 5:33Speaker 4: within a day or two afterward. And those witnesses I
- 5:36Speaker 4: think were very important to rehabilitate Miss Carroll's credibility after
- 5:41Speaker 4: it was attacked on cross examination by Trump's lawyers, who
- 5:44Speaker 4: essentially suggested that she had fabricated her claim in twenty
- 5:48Speaker 4: nineteen when she wrote her book in order to gain
- 5:51Speaker 4: same and fortune by selling her book, and also because
- 5:55Speaker 4: of some kind of political bias against Trump once he
- 5:58Speaker 4: had already become president, and so to rehabilitate Miss Carroll's
- 6:03Speaker 4: credibility from that line of attack, the plaintiff was permitted
- 6:07Speaker 4: to put on those two friends to whom Carol had
- 6:09Speaker 4: given prior consistent statements about the attack, to show that
- 6:13Speaker 4: she had been making the same claim that she had
- 6:15Speaker 4: told the same story long before Trump was running for
- 6:19Speaker 4: president or was president, long before she was writing or
- 6:23Speaker 4: trying to sell a book, or had any motive of
- 6:26Speaker 4: the kind that the defense alleged to be telling this story.
- 6:29Speaker 4: So I think those two friends testimony was very important.
- 6:33Speaker 4: And then, of course the testimony of the two other
- 6:35Speaker 4: women who I mentioned a moment ago, who testified about
- 6:38Speaker 4: sexual assaults by Trump that were very consistent with the
- 6:41Speaker 4: kind of attack that Miss Carroll described, and that also
- 6:45Speaker 4: mister Trump, in his own words discussed on the Access
- 6:49Speaker 4: Hollywood tape.
- 6:50Speaker 2: Trump didn't appear in the courtroom at all during the trial,
- 6:55Speaker 2: and instead the jury saw bits of his videotaped deposition
- 6:59Speaker 2: that were select the plaintiff. Did that hurt his case?
- 7:02Speaker 2: I mean, does the jury say he doesn't even care
- 7:05Speaker 2: enough to show up.
- 7:07Speaker 4: It's hard to know exactly what the jury thought as
- 7:10Speaker 4: a consequence of Trump not showing up. I do think
- 7:13Speaker 4: that there is a risk that they thought that Trump
- 7:15Speaker 4: was not showing respect for the forum or for the
- 7:18Speaker 4: claim by not showing up. At the same time, he
- 7:22Speaker 4: may have done himself no favors had he been in
- 7:25Speaker 4: the courtroom if he exhibited certain behaviors or a demeanor
- 7:29Speaker 4: that communicated a similar message. So it's hard to say
- 7:33Speaker 4: exactly how that all shook out. I will say that
- 7:37Speaker 4: the deposition that was admitted it to evidence where Trump was,
- 7:41Speaker 4: for example, shown a photograph of Egene Carroll. He was
- 7:44Speaker 4: shaking her hand essentially on a receiving line, and he
- 7:48Speaker 4: misidentified her as his former wife, Marla Maples. I thought
- 7:51Speaker 4: was a devastating moment because he had been saying, oh,
- 7:54Speaker 4: she's not my type, as though that were a reason
- 7:56Speaker 4: why he wouldn't sexually assault her. But it certainly lied
- 8:00Speaker 4: the claim that she wasn't his type when he misidentified
- 8:02Speaker 4: her in a photographic as his former wife. And then
- 8:05Speaker 4: there was a devastating moment in the deposition as well,
- 8:08Speaker 4: where he's asked about the Access Hollywood tape and he
- 8:12Speaker 4: essentially said that what he had claimed on that tape
- 8:15Speaker 4: that stars could assault women and essentially get away with it,
- 8:19Speaker 4: and women would let you do that to them.
- 8:21Speaker 3: They would let you grab.
- 8:22Speaker 4: Them without consent. He said that that had been true historically,
- 8:25Speaker 4: and then he added on fortunately or unfortunately, and that
- 8:29Speaker 4: was just an extraordinary moment. The idea that he would
- 8:32Speaker 4: affirm that he thought that that was true, that stars
- 8:34Speaker 4: could do it, and that there was a way to
- 8:37Speaker 4: look at that as fortunate in some circumstances. I think
- 8:41Speaker 4: that that was just a terrible moment for the defense.
- 8:44Speaker 2: The plaintiff didn't ask for a specific sum. Do you
- 8:48Speaker 2: know where the jury got those numbers from?
- 8:52Speaker 4: There was an expert who testified for the plaintiff about
- 8:55Speaker 4: the amount of money it would take to repair her reputation,
- 8:59Speaker 4: and that I believe a professor of marketing who testified
- 9:03Speaker 4: that there was a range that she had calculated of
- 9:06Speaker 4: what it would cost to do essentially reputational repair, and
- 9:09Speaker 4: she estimated it would be on the low end, in
- 9:11Speaker 4: the high three hundred thousands of dollars, on the high
- 9:15Speaker 4: end two point seven million dollars. And so if you
- 9:17Speaker 4: look at what the jury awarded for damages, at least
- 9:20Speaker 4: for the defamation claim, I believe they gave one million
- 9:25Speaker 4: for compensatory damages not having to do with repairing her reputation,
- 9:30Speaker 4: and then one point seven million for reputational repair. And
- 9:34Speaker 4: then where they came up with the two million in
- 9:36Speaker 4: compensatory damages for the battery claim, I'm not sure They
- 9:40Speaker 4: also added on punitive damages of twenty thousand dollars for
- 9:45Speaker 4: the battery claim and two hundred and eighty thousand dollars
- 9:48Speaker 4: in punitive damages for the defamation claim, which is how
- 9:51Speaker 4: we get all together to five million dollars. But I
- 9:54Speaker 4: thought it was interesting that they chose the numbers that
- 9:58Speaker 4: they did, frankly, and that the punitive damages were relatively
- 10:02Speaker 4: insignificant given the overall total of the damages award. To me,
- 10:08Speaker 4: that suggested that they really did credit Miss Carroll's testimony
- 10:12Speaker 4: about how she had been harmed by the battery and
- 10:14Speaker 4: the consequences it had had on her life, and that
- 10:18Speaker 4: they didn't award an extraordinary amount in punitive damages. When
- 10:22Speaker 4: you think about it, it's really quite restrained. Twenty thousand
- 10:25Speaker 4: dollars in punitives on the battery charge and two hundred
- 10:29Speaker 4: and eighty thousand on the defamation charge suggests that this
- 10:32Speaker 4: was not a political verdict on Trump, but really about
- 10:35Speaker 4: compensating Miss Carroll for the harm she had suffered.
- 10:39Speaker 2: That struck me too that the punitives were quite low.
- 10:42Speaker 2: I want to go through some of the appellate issues
- 10:45Speaker 2: that Trump's lawyer, Joe Tekapina mentioned, so one was that
- 10:50Speaker 2: Egene Carroll should not have been allowed to play that
- 10:53Speaker 2: Access Hollywood recording for the jury. I'm wondering if you
- 10:56Speaker 2: think that's a strong point on appeal, don't.
- 11:00Speaker 4: I mean, in general, evidentiary rulings are subject to an
- 11:03Speaker 4: abusive discretion standard of review on appeal, and Judge Kaplan
- 11:08Speaker 4: wrote an opinion about why he was admitting the Access
- 11:11Speaker 4: Hollywood tape as well as the testimony of the two
- 11:14Speaker 4: other women about other assaults by Trump against them, and
- 11:19Speaker 4: so it's a well written, reasoned opinion, and he cites
- 11:23Speaker 4: the particular federal rule of evidence that permits evidence of
- 11:27Speaker 4: other sexual offenses by a defendant who's been charged in
- 11:33Speaker 4: a case, including in a civil case with offensive sexual conduct.
- 11:37Speaker 4: These are rules of evidence that are not frequently utilized
- 11:41Speaker 4: because very few cases involving sexual offenses are actually litigated
- 11:45Speaker 4: in federal courts. Those are overwhelmingly cases tried in state courts.
- 11:49Speaker 4: Most states do not have analogous rules of evidence that
- 11:52Speaker 4: are so permissive about admitting in other acts of a
- 11:56Speaker 4: sexual nature committed by a defendant, But the federal system
- 12:00Speaker 4: does have these special rules for cases involving sexual offenses,
- 12:04Speaker 4: and they are explicitly permissive in terms of allowing in
- 12:08Speaker 4: evidence of other sexual conduct and permitting a jury to
- 12:12Speaker 4: make inferences about a defendant's propensity to engage in such
- 12:15Speaker 4: conduct based on that prior conduct. So it's diametrically opposed
- 12:20Speaker 4: to how lawyers normally think about other act evidence and
- 12:24Speaker 4: the uses to which it can and can't be put
- 12:26Speaker 4: in litigation. So these are rules that apply only in
- 12:30Speaker 4: federal court and in very few staate jurisdictions that have
- 12:32Speaker 4: adopted similar rules, But they applied here, and I think
- 12:35Speaker 4: that really worked to Trump's disadvantage. But it also means
- 12:39Speaker 4: because the rules are so explicit and Judge Catherlin was
- 12:42Speaker 4: very clear and relying upon them, that it's hard for
- 12:45Speaker 4: me to see how in appellate court would overrule his decision.
- 12:49Speaker 5: There are also some others.
- 12:50Speaker 2: He raises the fact that Trump couldn't get a fair
- 12:53Speaker 2: trial from a Manhattan jury, and the decision to keep
- 12:57Speaker 2: the names of the jurors anonymous and barring the mention
- 13:02Speaker 2: of Carol's litigation financing from a major Democratic Party donor.
- 13:08Speaker 5: Do any of those strike you?
- 13:10Speaker 4: The anonymous jury question is I think an interesting one
- 13:13Speaker 4: in its novel, and my understanding is that Judge Kaplan
- 13:17Speaker 4: raised the issue and it was his idea to have
- 13:19Speaker 4: an anonymous DURYA don't believe that was something requested by
- 13:22Speaker 4: either party. So I mentioned it's interesting because it's novel.
- 13:26Speaker 4: I don't see that as being a particularly strong issue
- 13:29Speaker 4: on appeal. I think the defense would have to spell
- 13:31Speaker 4: out how they were prejudiced by the jury having been anonymized.
- 13:36Speaker 4: But that's the one that I think would potentially be
- 13:37Speaker 4: of most interest to the Circuit Court, although as I said,
- 13:40Speaker 4: I'm not sure that I see that it's particularly meritorious
- 13:43Speaker 4: on the issue of not being able to cross Jean
- 13:46Speaker 4: Carroll about the donor and bias. Again, I think that
- 13:50Speaker 4: ruling is going to be subject to abusive discretion, and
- 13:53Speaker 4: the defense really was permitted to probe bias, including political
- 13:57Speaker 4: bias of Missus Carroll aswell as the other one witness
- 14:00Speaker 4: is the plaintiff called. So even if the Napella Court
- 14:03Speaker 4: were to find their were error there, they would likely
- 14:05Speaker 4: find it to be harmless error, I think because that
- 14:08Speaker 4: issue was so thoroughly explored.
- 14:10Speaker 2: So it sounds like winning an appeal would be an
- 14:12Speaker 2: uphill battle.
- 14:13Speaker 4: I think so mentioning.
- 14:15Speaker 5: The secrecy of the jurors.
- 14:17Speaker 2: So, now that the trials concluded, obviously the jurors are
- 14:20Speaker 2: free to identify themselves publicly, but the judge encouraged them
- 14:24Speaker 2: not to do so. Quote, my advice to you is
- 14:27Speaker 2: not to identify yourselves, not now and not for a
- 14:31Speaker 2: long time, he said after the verdict. That's pretty unusual,
- 14:35Speaker 2: Isn't it very unusual for a.
- 14:36Speaker 5: Judge to say?
- 14:37Speaker 4: It is very unusual? And, as I said a moment ago,
- 14:40Speaker 4: swearing in a jury, using an anonymous jury in a
- 14:43Speaker 4: civil case is extremely unusual as well. So I see
- 14:47Speaker 4: his instructions to the jurors once they were discharged about
- 14:51Speaker 4: maintaining the privacy of their identities. I think it's consistent
- 14:54Speaker 4: with that decision on the front end to use an
- 14:57Speaker 4: anonymous jury. I think that there were very good reasons
- 15:01Speaker 4: for Judge Kaplan to do what he did here and
- 15:04Speaker 4: to give that instruction to the jury at the end,
- 15:06Speaker 4: given the social media postings by President Trump in this
- 15:10Speaker 4: case and in other cases where he's essentially urged his
- 15:14Speaker 4: supporters to take action and defend him in a way
- 15:18Speaker 4: that can prove dangerous to those who he's identified as
- 15:21Speaker 4: his enemies as political enemies. So I think that there
- 15:24Speaker 4: is a very good record upon which the judge was
- 15:28Speaker 4: drawing when he chose to make the jury anonymous, and
- 15:31Speaker 4: when he encouraged the jurors to maintain that anonymity going forward.
- 15:36Speaker 2: Egene Carol said that through this trial they demolished the
- 15:40Speaker 2: concept of the perfect victim who always screams, always reports
- 15:44Speaker 2: to police, always makes notes of when it happened. But
- 15:48Speaker 2: you know, a juryvert has no precedential value. Do you
- 15:51Speaker 2: think that this will really make a difference in future
- 15:55Speaker 2: rape cases.
- 15:56Speaker 4: It's hard to say. I think that the fact that
- 15:59Speaker 4: this case got so much publicity may have an impact
- 16:03Speaker 4: in terms of affecting the public consciousness, so that future
- 16:07Speaker 4: jurors who are impaneled in future cases involving allegations of
- 16:12Speaker 4: sexual assault may remember this case and may remember that
- 16:17Speaker 4: the plaintiffs prevailed, And it may be part of a
- 16:20Speaker 4: much larger cultural conversation that may take years to percolate
- 16:26Speaker 4: and for there to be significant impacts in courtrooms. But
- 16:30Speaker 4: I do think that it is a significant event in
- 16:33Speaker 4: terms of potentially shaping people's consciousness about how survivors of
- 16:38Speaker 4: sexual assault behave in the moment of the assault, right
- 16:42Speaker 4: the allegation, you know, widen new scream, in the moments afterward,
- 16:46Speaker 4: like why she didn't go to police, and then in
- 16:48Speaker 4: the years afterwards, because of course, part of what mister
- 16:51Speaker 4: Trump's lawyers suggested was that she had essentially been too
- 16:54Speaker 4: happy in the years afterward. So I think that this
- 16:57Speaker 4: case does perhaps mark a significant and turning point in
- 17:01Speaker 4: public understanding about the different ways in which somebody who
- 17:05Speaker 4: has experienced sexual assault might behave at all those points
- 17:09Speaker 4: in time, in the moment, immediately afterward, and in the
- 17:13Speaker 4: years to come.
- 17:14Speaker 2: Thanks so much for your insights, Jessica. That's Professor Jessica
- 17:17Speaker 2: Roth of Cardozo Law School. Massachusetts attorneys are advising businesses
- 17:23Speaker 2: to rethink the way they pay and fire employees in
- 17:27Speaker 2: the wake of a state top court decision that puts
- 17:30Speaker 2: them on the hook for triple damages when they're late
- 17:33Speaker 2: on a paycheck. Compliance trainings for managers and monitoring payroll
- 17:37Speaker 2: providers are just some of the things companies are doing
- 17:41Speaker 2: to mitigate legal risk after the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial courts
- 17:45Speaker 2: game changing twenty twenty two ruling. Companies are still grappling
- 17:50Speaker 2: with that ruling one year later joining me is Michelle
- 17:53Speaker 2: Dia Lavera, a director for Kenny and Sam's that represents
- 17:57Speaker 2: businesses in employment disputes.
- 17:59Speaker 5: So us about this decision?
- 18:01Speaker 3: Sure, I'd be happy to So this was a decision
- 18:04Speaker 3: that was issued by the Massachusetts highest Court, the SJC.
- 18:09Speaker 3: It was a decision that would It was issued in
- 18:11Speaker 3: April of twenty twenty two. It's Ruder versus City of
- 18:15Speaker 3: Misuins And basically, this decision held that an employer that
- 18:21Speaker 3: is late on wages that an employee earns is automatically
- 18:27Speaker 3: liable for treble damages plus attorneys fees and costs. It
- 18:33Speaker 3: is a groundbreaking decision because before this decision was issued,
- 18:39Speaker 3: an employer arguably could avoid being hit with treble damages,
- 18:44Speaker 3: attorney's fees and costs if it paid the employee in
- 18:48Speaker 3: full for all wages earned before the employee filed a complaint.
- 18:54Speaker 3: And therefore there was some wiggle room and an employer
- 18:57Speaker 3: could avoid being hit with signialificant liqu data damages via
- 19:03Speaker 3: trouble damages attorney's season costs. So this decision changed that dramatically.
- 19:08Speaker 3: And now if an employer is lated, and it could
- 19:11Speaker 3: be a day, it could be two days. It doesn't
- 19:14Speaker 3: really matter how long the employer is late. If the
- 19:17Speaker 3: wages are paid late, the employers automatically on the hook
- 19:20Speaker 3: for treble damages attorney's season costs.
- 19:23Speaker 2: So was this the court interpreting a statute or was
- 19:26Speaker 2: there another reason behind the decision?
- 19:29Speaker 5: You know the why of the triple damages.
- 19:32Speaker 3: This was the court interpreting a statute that has been
- 19:36Speaker 3: in the books for a while. But, like I mentioned earlier,
- 19:40Speaker 3: even though the statute provides for attorney fees and treble
- 19:45Speaker 3: damages and the event of late paid wages, employers could
- 19:50Speaker 3: do away with that by making the employee whole before
- 19:53Speaker 3: an action was filed and before a complaint was filed.
- 19:57Speaker 3: So it was the court interpreting a pre existing statute.
- 20:01Speaker 2: Does the reason for the non payment of wages matter?
- 20:05Speaker 2: Say it's something beyond the control of the employer, like
- 20:08Speaker 2: a paycheck that's lost in the mail.
- 20:11Speaker 3: Great question. It does not matter. It is a no
- 20:14Speaker 3: mercy statute. It is strict liability for the employer, and
- 20:20Speaker 3: the reason does not matter. It could be a situation
- 20:23Speaker 3: in which the employer has no idea that the payroll
- 20:27Speaker 3: provider made an error, or as you mentioned, a check
- 20:30Speaker 3: gets lost in the mail, or could be you know,
- 20:33Speaker 3: a clerical mistake that happens and for whatever reason, there's
- 20:36Speaker 3: an error made on a paycheck that is issued to
- 20:39Speaker 3: an employee and the employee is short a certain amount
- 20:42Speaker 3: of wages on that check. Regardless of the reason, it
- 20:46Speaker 3: does not matter because it really is a no mercy statute.
- 20:50Speaker 3: It's a no mercy decision that employers are stuck with
- 20:55Speaker 3: and trying to, you know, implement best practices and protocols
- 21:01Speaker 3: to avoid potential liability under the wayeck because you know,
- 21:05Speaker 3: depending on how much money an employee makes, depending on
- 21:09Speaker 3: you know, how many employees are paid late, the damages
- 21:12Speaker 3: and the monetary amount and issue can quickly skyrocket and
- 21:17Speaker 3: create massive exposure for an employer.
- 21:20Speaker 2: So what was the general reaction from management when this
- 21:25Speaker 2: decision came out?
- 21:26Speaker 5: I mean, was there panic?
- 21:28Speaker 2: Was it okay, we can do that, no problem.
- 21:30Speaker 3: The reaction is shocked, and the reaction is dismay, And
- 21:35Speaker 3: the reaction is, you know, how can we make the
- 21:38Speaker 3: things work and what can we do to avoid human error?
- 21:43Speaker 3: Because we're human, right, So the people who are entering
- 21:47Speaker 3: the time, sure, maybe they're relying on software to enter
- 21:50Speaker 3: time but there there often is a human element involved
- 21:55Speaker 3: when somebody is being paid and people make mistakes. So
- 21:59Speaker 3: the fact that employers now are stuck with this no
- 22:02Speaker 3: mercy decision, no mercy statute. It is talking and employers
- 22:09Speaker 3: still struggle with it when issues arise and there are
- 22:12Speaker 3: a very good reasons why there was a mistake. There's
- 22:15Speaker 3: a very good reason why. You know, somebody misread something
- 22:19Speaker 3: that was on a timesheet that was handwritten and misinterpreted it,
- 22:24Speaker 3: and it really it really doesn't matter. So this is
- 22:27Speaker 3: a decision. It's really difficult for employers to deal with it,
- 22:31Speaker 3: understand it, and they're trying to work really hard to
- 22:35Speaker 3: again avoid liability under the statue.
- 22:38Speaker 2: So, say an employer wants to fire someone, something comes up,
- 22:42Speaker 2: they found out that the employee did something egregious and
- 22:45Speaker 2: they want the employee off the premises that moment, do
- 22:50Speaker 2: they have to hand them a paycheck at the same time.
- 22:53Speaker 3: So if there is something that happens and an employee
- 22:56Speaker 3: needs to be off the premise asap, what needs to
- 23:00Speaker 3: happen is one of two things. One the employer would
- 23:03Speaker 3: need to have a check in hand to pay that
- 23:05Speaker 3: person on the day of termination, or two if that's
- 23:10Speaker 3: not doable for whatever reason, and there could be, you know,
- 23:13Speaker 3: legitimate reasons why an employer just can't have a check
- 23:17Speaker 3: available on that day, what the employer would need to
- 23:20Speaker 3: do to avoid liability under this statute would be to
- 23:24Speaker 3: suspend that employee, and it could be without pay. You
- 23:28Speaker 3: can suspend thout pay through the effective date of the termination,
- 23:32Speaker 3: and then the effective date of determination needs to be
- 23:37Speaker 3: the day on which the employer can ensure that they
- 23:40Speaker 3: will have a check in their hands available to pay
- 23:43Speaker 3: that employee, or payment can be made via direct deposit.
- 23:47Speaker 3: It doesn't really matter. It could be either or. But
- 23:50Speaker 3: the ability to just terminate somebody on the spot and
- 23:53Speaker 3: not be able to pay them in full on the
- 23:56Speaker 3: date of determination, regardless of the reason for the termination,
- 24:01Speaker 3: that ability nowadays has sort of been depleted if an
- 24:04Speaker 3: employer wants to avoid liability under this decision and under
- 24:08Speaker 3: the Massachusetts WAGA.
- 24:10Speaker 2: So I don't know if there are any stats about this,
- 24:12Speaker 2: but have you seen less on the spot firings then.
- 24:16Speaker 3: Yes, I have seen less on the spot firings. And
- 24:19Speaker 3: what I have been advising and encouraging and recommending that
- 24:22Speaker 3: my clients do is have management be adequately trained. So
- 24:28Speaker 3: have your managers undergo management training so that they understand
- 24:33Speaker 3: the importance of following this protocol of a suspension without
- 24:37Speaker 3: pay or an administrative leave without pay pending the effective
- 24:41Speaker 3: state of termination. And companies are being more careful with
- 24:47Speaker 3: that in order to avoid liability under this statute.
- 24:51Speaker 2: And I know you've said that some employers are more
- 24:55Speaker 2: closely overseeing the payroll providers.
- 25:00Speaker 3: That's exactly right, because oftentimes what happens is an employer
- 25:05Speaker 3: will submit the payroll information to the payroll provider and
- 25:09Speaker 3: then will just rely on the payroll provider to do
- 25:12Speaker 3: the right thing and pay the employees the way that
- 25:15Speaker 3: they need to be paid. But there have been mistakes
- 25:18Speaker 3: that have happened on the payroll providers, and really through
- 25:22Speaker 3: no fault of the payrolld provider. What I mean is
- 25:25Speaker 3: they're not intentionally trying to make the mistake, but human
- 25:29Speaker 3: error occurs, clerical error occurs, and therefore employers are now
- 25:35Speaker 3: encouraged and are developing practice of overseeing the payroll provider
- 25:40Speaker 3: the way in which these wages are paid to be
- 25:42Speaker 3: sure that the wages are being paid correctly and that
- 25:46Speaker 3: there are no mistakes and that wage payments aren't canceled
- 25:50Speaker 3: or made, you know, in a way that isn't consistent
- 25:54Speaker 3: with what the employees should be paid for the wages
- 25:56Speaker 3: earned in that pay period.
- 25:58Speaker 2: So I was reading about this businesses speed up the
- 26:01Speaker 2: whole payroll process.
- 26:04Speaker 3: I think they can, and it's something that each company
- 26:08Speaker 3: would have to work out with the payroll provider. In
- 26:10Speaker 3: other words, a payroll provider typically will have a date
- 26:14Speaker 3: by which the information needs to be submitted so that
- 26:16Speaker 3: payroll can be made via X day, and so businesses
- 26:20Speaker 3: need to work closely with the payroll providers to ensure
- 26:23Speaker 3: that not only that all wages are being paid, but
- 26:26Speaker 3: that the wages are being paid to employees within six
- 26:29Speaker 3: days of the conclusion of the pay period within which
- 26:32Speaker 3: the wages are earned. Because this is also an issue
- 26:35Speaker 3: for your current active employees, because a statute for the
- 26:39Speaker 3: most part, with a few exceptions, requires that employees be
- 26:43Speaker 3: paid within six days of the conclusion of the pay period,
- 26:46Speaker 3: and it is imperative that all companies are ensuring that
- 26:51Speaker 3: that happens on a timely manner.
- 26:54Speaker 2: Have more employees been suing since this decision?
- 26:58Speaker 3: Yes, more employers at least for in our practice. And
- 27:02Speaker 3: what I have seen here in my practice in my firm. Yes,
- 27:05Speaker 3: we are seeing our clients be sued for non payment
- 27:09Speaker 3: of wages and sometimes for minimal amounts of the late payments.
- 27:14Speaker 3: And when I mean minimal, I'm talking about you know,
- 27:16Speaker 3: a few thousands of dollars, not hundreds of thousands of dollars.
- 27:20Speaker 3: We're seeing more lawsuits, We're seeing more litigation, We're seeing
- 27:23Speaker 3: more demand letters because there's plaintive lawyers, you know, who
- 27:29Speaker 3: are we're sending demand letters or who are filing these
- 27:32Speaker 3: complaints assuming that the late payment is clear, you know
- 27:37Speaker 3: that there's there's clear evidence that that the wages were
- 27:40Speaker 3: paid late. The fact that a plaintiff side lawyer will
- 27:43Speaker 3: be able to be to recover attorneys fees, I think
- 27:46Speaker 3: has played a role in this as well, and they're
- 27:49Speaker 3: just alleging, you know, trouble damages plus payment of attorneys fees.
- 27:53Speaker 2: In the opinion, was there any talk of like why
- 27:56Speaker 2: it's important to protect employees in this way.
- 28:02Speaker 3: Yes, there is a discussion in the opinion about that,
- 28:05Speaker 3: and basically the discussion centers on the fact that employees
- 28:10Speaker 3: are relying on their wages to make a living and
- 28:14Speaker 3: when you're dealing with employees who live pay paycheck by paycheck,
- 28:18Speaker 3: it is important that those employees be paid timely, and
- 28:22Speaker 3: there's there's really no excuse for an employer to withhold
- 28:26Speaker 3: wages that an employee earns unnecessarily so or beyond the
- 28:31Speaker 3: time within which you know, the employees should have been paid.
- 28:35Speaker 3: So the discussion centers on, you know, protecting employees, protecting
- 28:38Speaker 3: employees well being, and ensure that they're timely paid for
- 28:41Speaker 3: wages that they're earned, because again, employees for the most part,
- 28:45Speaker 3: are relying on payment of their wages to make a
- 28:48Speaker 3: living and provide for their for their families, and the
- 28:51Speaker 3: case talks about, you know, the need for the employee
- 28:54Speaker 3: to pay for housing, transportation, food, clothing, tuition, medical expenses,
- 29:00Speaker 3: et cetera. So employees can really be harmed if they
- 29:03Speaker 3: are paid late.
- 29:05Speaker 5: Any final thoughts.
- 29:07Speaker 3: I think the only final thought that I'll throw in
- 29:08Speaker 3: there is that given the decision and the implications that
- 29:12Speaker 3: stem from the decision, the time is ripe for employers
- 29:16Speaker 3: to be reviewing bonus plans, commission plans, and any type
- 29:21Speaker 3: of compensation that an employee receives that could be construed
- 29:25Speaker 3: as a wage under the Massachusetts Wage Act to ensure
- 29:29Speaker 3: that not only are those plans legally compliant, but to
- 29:34Speaker 3: ensure that to the extent a form of compensation constitution
- 29:39Speaker 3: could constitute a wage under the statues, that they have
- 29:42Speaker 3: processes and protocols in place to ensure timely payment, and
- 29:46Speaker 3: like I said, you know, to ensure that those plans
- 29:48Speaker 3: are compliant with the statue.
- 29:51Speaker 2: Thanks so much for being on the show, Michelle. That's
- 29:53Speaker 2: Michelle di'ela vera, a director for Kenny and Sam's. And
- 29:57Speaker 2: that's it for this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show.
- 30:00Speaker 2: Remember you can always get the latest legal news on
- 30:02Speaker 2: our Bloomberg Law podcasts. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 30:06Speaker 2: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law,
- 30:12Speaker 2: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 30:14Speaker 2: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso,
- 30:18Speaker 2: and you're listening to Bloomberg