Latest / Secrets of the Centuries / The Oregon Trail Death Toll and Realities
Transcript
- 0:00Usually when we talk about a major historical
- 0:02event, there's this expectation of absolute clarity.
- 0:07It's almost like walking into a carefully curated
- 0:09museum exhibit. Right. Everything has a nice
- 0:11little plaque. Exactly. You look at this massive
- 0:13oil painting of westward expansion, and you see
- 0:16the brave stoic pioneers, the iconic covered
- 0:19wagons glowing in the sunset, the dramatic clashes
- 0:22with wild nature. And that little bronze plaque
- 0:25on the wall just points to it and says, yep.
- 0:27That's how the West was won. It's a very comforting
- 0:29binary, honestly. The museum gives you this super
- 0:33clean linear narrative. You get clear protagonists.
- 0:37You get to find obstacles and this inevitable
- 0:40triumph over adversity because, well, we inherently
- 0:43want our history to be visible and neatly categorized
- 0:46into heroic struggles. Yeah, but then you step
- 0:49out of that museum. You pull back the curtain
- 0:52on the actual historical reality of the Oregon
- 0:54Trail. And that pristine painting just shatters
- 0:57into a million pieces. Because the landscape
- 0:59we're looking at today is, uh, it's terrifyingly
- 1:04murky. Oh, absolutely. The reality is incredibly
- 1:08dark. So, okay, let's unpack this. Because I
- 1:11want to start with the most staggering physical
- 1:13reality of this migration for you, the listener,
- 1:16right out of the gate. When you drive across
- 1:18the American West today on the interstate, you
- 1:21know, you might see a historical marker here
- 1:23or there. But the truth... The truth buried in
- 1:27the diaries and the records is that somewhere
- 1:29between 20 ,000 and 30 ,000 people are buried
- 1:32along that 2 ,000 -mile road from Missouri to
- 1:34Oregon. That's just a massive number to wrap
- 1:37your head around. It is. If you break down that
- 1:39math, you are looking at 10 to 20 graves for
- 1:43every single mile of trail. Which means, and
- 1:46this is crucial, those graves aren't often some
- 1:49peaceful shaded roadside cemetery. The vast majority
- 1:52of them were dug directly into the middle of
- 1:55the dirt track. Right into the road. Right into
- 1:58the road. By design. So the wagons essentially
- 2:01rolled over a massive unmarked 2 ,000 mile cemetery.
- 2:07And what's fascinating here is that the core
- 2:10thesis we have to understand right out of the
- 2:12gate is that Almost nobody died the way the movies
- 2:15or those dramatic paintings portray. No dramatic
- 2:17shootouts. Exactly. These pioneers, they spent
- 2:20their entire life savings guarding against a
- 2:23threat that barely even existed. Meanwhile, the
- 2:26real killers were the very things they brought
- 2:28with them. It just gives me chills visualizing
- 2:31that, like 10 to 20 graves every single mile.
- 2:34To understand why so many people died on this
- 2:36road, I feel like we first have to figure out
- 2:38why they were on it at all, you know, and the
- 2:41actual mechanics of how they left. Because nobody
- 2:43just wakes up and decides to walk 2 ,000 miles
- 2:46through a hostile wilderness just for a change
- 2:48of scenery. No, absolutely not. They went for
- 2:52land. I mean, the underlying engine for almost
- 2:54all human migration is resource acquisition.
- 2:57And in this case, it was the soil of the Oregon
- 3:00Territory. Right, the farming potential. Yeah,
- 3:02it was famously fertile. It was deep. And most
- 3:05importantly, it was practically free. Under the
- 3:09Donation Land Claim Act of 1850, a married couple
- 3:12could file on 640 acres of land. See, I always
- 3:15hear 640 acres, and my modern brain just glazes
- 3:19over the number. It just sounds like a lot of
- 3:20dirt. But to put that into perspective for you,
- 3:24640 acres is exactly one square mile. That is
- 3:29the equivalent of 480 American football fields
- 3:33stitched together. It's massive. It really is.
- 3:36Imagine standing in the middle of an area the
- 3:38size of a major downtown metropolitan district
- 3:40and someone just handing you the deed to all
- 3:43of it for free. And all for the simple price
- 3:46of just getting there and living on it for four
- 3:48years. If you consider the economic reality of
- 3:51a farmer in, say, Illinois or Missouri at that
- 3:54time, a man who owned 160 acres of worked land
- 3:58was considered wealthy. Right. A man with 80
- 4:01acres was doing just fine. So being handed 640
- 4:05acres, it wasn't merely a step up in social class.
- 4:08It was a completely different universe. It was
- 4:10guaranteed generational wealth. But getting to
- 4:13that free land wasn't free at all. The pop culture
- 4:17image we've all been fed is usually of these
- 4:19poor drifters looking for a second chance, tossing
- 4:22a few cast iron pans into a rickety cart and
- 4:25just whistling westward. Right, the whole romantic
- 4:28drifter myth. Yeah, exactly. When you look at
- 4:31the actual economics, the cost of entry was astronomical.
- 4:34Outfitting a family properly in 1850 ran somewhere
- 4:37between $800 and $1200. Which is wild when you
- 4:42translate that to today's purchasing power. We're
- 4:44talking about a capital investment of somewhere
- 4:46between $30 ,000 and $50 ,000. That's an entire
- 4:49down payment on a modern house. Easily. So these
- 4:53were not destitute drifters. These were established,
- 4:56firmly middle -class farmers and merchants. Which
- 4:58means they had to literally liquidate everything
- 5:01they owned just to afford the journey. Everything.
- 5:04They sold the family farm, the heavy plows, the
- 5:07heirloom furniture, any livestock they couldn't
- 5:09take with them. And this financial reality, it
- 5:12created an inescapable psychological trap. Because
- 5:15there's no going back. Exactly. By converting
- 5:17all their worldly equity into a wooden wagon,
- 5:20a half ton of flour, and a team of oxen, they
- 5:23eliminated any possibility of a retreat. It was
- 5:25a one -way financial commitment. If a family
- 5:28got 500 miles out onto the plains and decided,
- 5:31you know, the journey was too brutal, turning
- 5:33around just wasn't an option. They had no home
- 5:35to return to. Their entire net worth was rolling
- 5:38on four wooden wheels. I keep picturing this
- 5:41as the ultimate terrifying bottleneck. It's like
- 5:45imagining the entire population of a midsize
- 5:47city. trying to merge onto a single one -lane
- 5:50dirt highway at the exact same hour. But this
- 5:53highway has no gas stations, no grocery stores,
- 5:56no mechanics. And if you pull your car over to
- 5:58the shoulder and stop moving, your family starves.
- 6:01And the timing of that bottleneck was dictated
- 6:03entirely by biology and weather. The pioneers
- 6:06departed from a very short list of river towns
- 6:09on the Missouri River, places like Independence,
- 6:12Westport, St. Joseph, and later Council Bluffs.
- 6:15Right. And they had to leave inside an incredibly
- 6:18narrow window, usually about four weeks wide,
- 6:21typically starting in late April or early May.
- 6:24Because if you leave too early, the spring grass
- 6:26hasn't grown on the prairie yet. And if there's
- 6:29no grass, your oxen have nothing to eat. They
- 6:31starve, the wagon stops, and you die. Exactly.
- 6:35And on the other end of the spectrum, if you
- 6:38leave too late, you get caught in the high passes
- 6:40of the Blue Mountains or the Sierra Nevadas when
- 6:42the October blizzards hit and... You freeze to
- 6:45death. So the environmental parameters forced
- 6:48everyone in America who intended to go west that
- 6:51year to start within a few days of everybody
- 6:53else. It funneled everyone out of the same few
- 6:56river landings, creating this massive, slowly
- 6:59rolling city. The logistics of packing for that
- 7:02rolling city honestly just boggled my mind. Like,
- 7:06look at Joseph Weir's 1849 guidebook, which was
- 7:09basically the Bible for these pioneers. Oh yeah,
- 7:12everybody had a copy. For just three people traveling
- 7:14together, where calculated you needed to carry
- 7:171 ,080 pounds of flour plus 600 pounds of bacon,
- 7:23100 pounds of coffee, 150 pounds of sugar. And
- 7:27this massive payload isn't going into a modern
- 7:29semi -truck with a combustion engine. It's being
- 7:31hauled by animals that have to fuel themselves
- 7:34by eating the very grass that thousands of animals
- 7:37ahead of them have already chewed down to the
- 7:39dirt. And you know, the physical labor required
- 7:41just to prepare those supplies is staggering
- 7:44to consider. The primary diaries from the era,
- 7:47they're filled with these quiet, monumental domestic
- 7:50efforts. Yeah, the invisible work behind the
- 7:52scenes. Exactly. Take Ketra Belknap. She was
- 7:56a farmwife in Iowa. She spent the entire winter
- 7:59of 1847 manufacturing her family's wagon cover.
- 8:03And she didn't just sew it. She spun the thread
- 8:05herself. She stitched every single heavy canvas
- 8:08seam by hand. She designed this little clear
- 8:11corner in the wagon bed specifically for her
- 8:14young boy Jesse. No. Yeah. And Jesse had spent
- 8:18that exact same winter sitting in her work basket
- 8:20playing Going to Oregon. It's so heartbreakingly
- 8:24normal. Like a kid playing make -believe in a
- 8:26basket while his mom sows. But what they're actually
- 8:30doing is preparing to step off the edge of the
- 8:33known world. And because they were heading into
- 8:35this absolute unknown, carrying literally everything
- 8:39they owned, they armed themselves to the teeth.
- 8:43They were bracing for a war that wasn't actually
- 8:45happening. That fear of constant native attacks
- 8:48is arguably the most persistent myth of the trail.
- 8:52And it was entirely manufactured by the media
- 8:54of the time. The pioneers bought rifles, shotguns,
- 8:58kegs of black powder, and these heavy bars of
- 9:00lead, largely based on sensationalized guidebooks
- 9:03and penny dreadfuls written by men selling the
- 9:06romance of manifest destiny. Right. Guys who
- 9:09had never even been out there. Often, yes. But
- 9:12the statistical reality, which was meticulously
- 9:15proven by historian John David Unruh Jr. after
- 9:18reading thousands of diaries, is that in the
- 9:2130 peak years of the migration, Native arrows
- 9:25and guns killed a total of 362 pioneers. I mean,
- 9:29362 people out of roughly 400 ,000 who made the
- 9:33crossing. Statistically, that's barely a rounding
- 9:35error. It's a fraction of a fraction of a percent.
- 9:39Yet almost every single family bought at least
- 9:41one firearm. And many bought three or four. And
- 9:45the critical detail here is the demographic of
- 9:47the buyers. Most were farmers from places like
- 9:50Illinois, Ohio, and Iowa who had never owned
- 9:53a weapon, much less fired one under stress or
- 9:55in combat. Just everyday farmers. Right. They
- 9:59went to outfitters and bought cheap heavy trade
- 10:01rifles. They loaded them, arranged their wagons
- 10:04in defensive circles every single night, and
- 10:06stood watch in the pitch black, staring out into
- 10:09the prairie grass waiting for a phantom threat
- 10:10to materialize. And the bitter irony is that
- 10:13the guns absolutely did kill people. The violence
- 10:16was just entirely self -inflicted and accidental.
- 10:20Imagine the environment. You have loaded, primed
- 10:23weapons riding inside wooden boxes that are violently
- 10:25bucking and slamming over rocks all day long.
- 10:28And they're constantly within arm's reach of
- 10:30children and exhausted adults. The story of George
- 10:34Shotwell. perfectly encapsulates this grim reality.
- 10:37Oh, George Shotwell. Mm -hmm. Yeah. He was a
- 10:39member of the Bartleson Bidwell Company in 1841,
- 10:43which was the very first organized American wagon
- 10:45train to attempt to drive over land to the Pacific.
- 10:48They were the trailblazers. And his death totally
- 10:51sets the tone for the next three decades. So
- 10:53he reaches into a wagon box to retrieve his rifle.
- 10:56But instead of grabbing the stock, he grabs it
- 10:58by the muzzle and pulls it toward himself. The
- 11:01hammer catches on something, the gun discharges
- 11:04directly into his chest. He lives for a few agonizing
- 11:07minutes, they dig a hole beside the trail, and
- 11:10the wagons keep moving. The very first pioneer
- 11:12in the very first wagon train is killed by his
- 11:15own preparation for a non -existent war. The
- 11:19sheer volume of similar accidents in the ensuing
- 11:22decades just shows a profound failure to adapt
- 11:25to the reality of the technology. I mean, people
- 11:28shot themselves climbing over the tailgates of
- 11:30wagons. They shot each other while hunting rabbits
- 11:33in the tall grass. And they routinely shot each
- 11:36other while on Night Watch, reacting to shadows,
- 11:39which is the ultimate tragic irony given that
- 11:42the Night Watch itself was a defense against
- 11:44a threat the historical record doesn't even support.
- 11:47I am honestly still reeling from the story of
- 11:49Martin Ringo. That one is unbelievable. It really
- 11:51is. It's July 1864 near Deer Creek in Wyoming.
- 11:56a massive train of 70 wagons camps for the night.
- 12:00There'd been a false alarm earlier that day.
- 12:02Some native riders had attempted to take some
- 12:04horses, so the entire camp is on edge. They stay
- 12:07up all night, heavily armed, watching the darkness,
- 12:11following the guidebooks to the letter. At first
- 12:14light, Martin Ringo, a 45 -year -old father from
- 12:17Missouri, climbs up onto his wagon wheel to get
- 12:19a better view over the camp. And his shotgun
- 12:22just charges directly into his own face. He died
- 12:25instantly. And his wife, Mary, she had been keeping
- 12:29a very plain methodical diary up to that point,
- 12:32just documenting the weather, the miles traveled,
- 12:34the quality of the grass. And suddenly her entry
- 12:37just shatters. She writes, And now, oh, God,
- 12:41comes the saddest day of my life. For this day,
- 12:44my husband accidentally shot himself and was
- 12:47buried by the wayside. And oh, my heart is breaking.
- 12:50She was instantly transformed into a widow left
- 12:53to take five children. all the way to California
- 12:56alone. And this is where the history bleeds into
- 12:59American mythology in a way that feels almost
- 13:02too cinematic to be real. Because the oldest
- 13:06of Mary's five children, the 14 year old boy
- 13:09who had to stand by the trail that morning and
- 13:11help shovel dirt over his father's body, his
- 13:14name was John Ringo. The boy who grew up to become
- 13:18Johnny Ringo. Exactly. Johnny Ringo. He makes
- 13:22it to the southwest and becomes one of the most
- 13:24feared legendary gunfighters in Tombstone, Arizona.
- 13:27He was a central figure in the Cochise County
- 13:30Cowboys, the sworn enemy of Wyatt Earp and Doc
- 13:33Holliday. Popular history remembers the Ringo
- 13:37family entirely for outlaws, fast draws, and
- 13:40gunfighting. But the actual gunshot that shaped
- 13:43their family's destiny, the one that left him
- 13:45fatherless on the plains, wasn't fired in a dramatic
- 13:48high noon duel. It was a clumsy accident at dawn
- 13:52caused by paranoia. It's wild. When you zoom
- 13:55out, it demonstrates how the tools intended for
- 13:57their survival constantly morphed into the instruments
- 14:00of their destruction. The firearms were a sudden
- 14:04explosive hazard. But the vehicles they relied
- 14:06on for transport, the covered wagons themselves,
- 14:09were a constant, slow moving mechanical threat
- 14:12that was impossible to escape. I think we have
- 14:15a fundamentally flawed image of the unrelenting
- 14:19grind of the trail. Like, we picture these wagons
- 14:22moving at a brisk, bouncing trot with horses
- 14:24galloping across the prairie. Not at all. The
- 14:27reality is that these wagons were almost exclusively
- 14:30pulled by oxen. And oxen move at a crawling,
- 14:33deliberate pace of about two miles per hour.
- 14:35That is significantly slower than a casual human
- 14:38walk. And the choice of oxen over horses was
- 14:41purely economic and biological. Oxen could survive
- 14:44on the sparse prairie grass much better than
- 14:46horses. They were cheaper to buy and they were
- 14:49less likely to be stolen. But because they moved
- 14:52so slowly and because the heavy freight wagons
- 14:54had absolutely zero suspension, riding inside
- 14:57the wagon box for 12 hours a day would literally
- 15:00rattle your teeth out of your skull. Just brutal.
- 15:03So consequently, almost everyone walked. Children
- 15:06walked alongside the trail all day. They climbed
- 15:08on and off the moving wagons out of sheer boredom.
- 15:11They rode on the wooden tongue between the massive
- 15:14oxen. And the wheels on these wagons, we are
- 15:17talking about 2 ,000 pounds of dead freight plus
- 15:20the weight of the heavy oak wagon itself, all
- 15:23sitting on a single iron tire that is only about
- 15:26one inch wide. The engineering rationale for
- 15:28that narrow one -inch tire was to allow it to
- 15:31cut through mud and reduce surface friction,
- 15:33but physics dictates that a narrow surface area
- 15:36concentrates the weight. You essentially have
- 15:38an industrial crushing machine creeping silently
- 15:41across the landscape. If a child slips in the
- 15:43dirt or a skirt catches on a brake lever, the
- 15:46momentum of that wagon cannot be stopped by the
- 15:48oxen in time. Which brings us to the horrific
- 15:52reality of Catherine Sager. Yes. 1844. The year
- 15:57is 1844. Catherine is nine years old. She is
- 16:01doing what pioneer children did a hundred times
- 16:03a day, jumping down from a moving wagon. But
- 16:07the hem of her dress catches on an axe handle
- 16:09protruding from the wagon bed. She swings under
- 16:12the vehicle and that narrow iron wheel carrying
- 16:15over a ton of weight passes directly over her
- 16:18left leg, shattering the bone in several places.
- 16:21And understanding the medical context of the
- 16:231840s makes this even more grim. A compound fracture
- 16:27on the planes was frequently a delayed death
- 16:29sentence. It wasn't just the trauma of the break.
- 16:32It was the inevitable bone infection that followed.
- 16:34long before the advent of antibiotics. Her father
- 16:37had to physically set the shattered bone right
- 16:40there in the dirt without anesthesia while the
- 16:43entire wagon train waited. I can't even imagine
- 16:45the pain. She spent the next 1500 miles lying
- 16:49flat on her back in that unsprung wooden box,
- 16:53feeling the violent jolt of every single rock
- 16:55and rut in the road radiate through her broken
- 16:57leg. And the only reason Catherine kept her leg
- 17:00and Honestly likely the only reason she survived
- 17:02the fever that followed was just an absurd stroke
- 17:06of luck. A German doctor named Theophilus Dionne
- 17:10had randomly decided to attach himself to their
- 17:12specific company. He stayed close to the Sager
- 17:15family and meticulously managed the leg's healing
- 17:18process. Without him, she likely would have died
- 17:20of sepsis within a week. Reading through the
- 17:23primary source diaries, what emerges is a profound
- 17:26psychological numbness to these mechanical tragedies.
- 17:30There were simply so many of them. You read an
- 17:33entry and it describes a perfectly ordinary Tuesday
- 17:36afternoon. A family is walking beside their worldly
- 17:39possessions. A child is running ahead in the
- 17:42dust. They trip into a badger hole in the road.
- 17:45In an instant, before anyone can even shout a
- 17:47warning, the wheel rolls over them and the child
- 17:49is dead. There's no dramatic music swelling.
- 17:52There's no grand narrative arc. It's just blunt
- 17:55force trauma interrupting a Tuesday. And then
- 17:58they have to keep walking. You see this necessary
- 18:01stoicism perfectly encapsulated in the diary
- 18:04of Amelia Stewart Knight in 1853. Her journal
- 18:08is one of the most stark, unflinching documents
- 18:10of the migration. She walked the entire 2 ,000
- 18:14miles while heavily pregnant with her eighth
- 18:16child. Though she never actually writes the word
- 18:18pregnant in the entire diary, right? Because
- 18:21Victorian propriety forbade it? Precisely. The
- 18:24omission speaks volumes about the culture. Every
- 18:27single mile she covered, she was watching her
- 18:29toddler, Chatfield, playing near those lethal
- 18:32moving wheels. She was managing an outbreak of
- 18:35scarlet fever within the camp. She was looking
- 18:38at the bloated carcasses of dead cattle strewing
- 18:41the desert, noting that the alkaline dust was
- 18:43two or three inches deep and as fine as milled
- 18:46flour choking them with every breath. Just a
- 18:49nightmare. And then, one day after finally finishing
- 18:52the journey and arriving at a crude log cabin
- 18:55in Oregon Territory, She casually notes that
- 18:57she gave birth. It is an astonishing, almost
- 19:02incomprehensible display of human endurance.
- 19:05So we have the guns constantly going off by accident,
- 19:08right, blowing people's limbs off. We have the
- 19:11crushing, relentless weight of the of the wagon
- 19:13wheels. But it's visible and noisy and visceral
- 19:17as those physical dangers were. The absolute
- 19:20worst threat on the trail was completely invisible.
- 19:24Absolutely. And here's where it gets like incredibly
- 19:28dark. This invisible killer was manufactured
- 19:31by that exact same four -week departure bottleneck
- 19:34that we talked about earlier. Cholera. Cholera.
- 19:38It was the undisputed apex predator of the westward
- 19:41expansion. I didn't fully appreciate how brutal
- 19:44cholera is until reading the medical breakdown
- 19:46for this deep dive. It's a bacterium, Vibrio
- 19:49cholerae, that attacks the small intestine. and
- 19:53essentially hijacks the body's ability to retain
- 19:55fluid. It forces the body to expel water at a
- 19:59catastrophic rate. The diaries note that a perfectly
- 20:01healthy muscular adult could feel a slight stomach
- 20:04cramp at breakfast and be dead by nightfall,
- 20:07having lost up to a quarter of their entire body
- 20:10weight in fluids. The speed is terrifying. There
- 20:13is no prolonged fever to wait out, no visible
- 20:17wound to bandage. And the medical kits these
- 20:20families brought were entirely useless against
- 20:22a bacterial infection of that magnitude. They
- 20:25carried laudanum, which is a tincture of opium,
- 20:28and camphor oil. Which does nothing for cholera.
- 20:30Neither does a single thing to combat the cholera
- 20:33bacteria or rehydrate the patient. They simply
- 20:36sedate the victim, making their final agonizing
- 20:39hours slightly quieter for the rest of the family.
- 20:41And you, the listener, are probably thinking,
- 20:43well, why didn't they just boil the water? But
- 20:45we have to remember, Germ theory didn't exist
- 20:48for these farmers in the mid -19th century. They
- 20:50didn't know bacteria existed. Furthermore, they
- 20:53were traveling through a landscape largely devoid
- 20:55of trees. Fuel was incredibly scarce. Gathering
- 20:59enough dried buffalo dung to create a fire hot
- 21:01enough to sustain a rolling boil for large quantities
- 21:03of water was a massive expenditure of time and
- 21:06energy they didn't have. So they drank the water
- 21:09cold, straight from the source. Which brings
- 21:11us back to the geography of the bottleneck. You
- 21:13have 50 ,000 human beings and roughly 250 ,000
- 21:17animals, all utilizing the exact same shallow
- 21:19water source, primarily the Platte River, and
- 21:22the exact same dozen reliable springs, all within
- 21:25the exact same eight -week window, moving in
- 21:28the exact same sequence. I was looking at maps
- 21:30of the Platte River. It is famously shallow,
- 21:34heavily braided, and slow moving. It is geographically
- 21:37the absolute worst possible river to share with
- 21:4050 ,000 other mammals, because the water moves
- 21:43so slowly. bacteria doesn't wash away. Every
- 21:46single wagon train camped, drank, and relieved
- 21:49themselves in the fouled water of the vamp that
- 21:51had slept in that exact spot the night before.
- 21:54The human and animal waste from thousands of
- 21:57sick people ran directly back into the primary
- 21:59drinking supply. It was a perfect, self -sustaining
- 22:03biological loop. There is a detail from the diaries
- 22:06that absolutely blew my mind regarding this.
- 22:09There was a family traveling in 1852, the Scott
- 22:11family, and the father makes fascinating decision.
- 22:15He excuses his 17 -year -old daughter Abigail
- 22:18Scott from all her grueling trail chores, so
- 22:21she conserves the official diarist for the family.
- 22:24A really rare privilege on the trail. Huge privilege.
- 22:27So while everyone else is driving the oxen and
- 22:29gathering buffalo dung, Abigail is watching and
- 22:33she is writing. And on June 8th, 1852, this 17
- 22:36-year -old girl correctly observes deduces and
- 22:40writes down that the cause of the deadly diarrhea
- 22:42wiping out the wagon camps is the drinking water
- 22:45they are pulling from shallow holes dug in the
- 22:48riverbanks. It is a staggering moment of epidemiological
- 22:52brilliance. She recognized the pattern that doctors
- 22:54of her era were entirely blind to. She figured
- 22:58out the transmission vector for cholera. Two
- 23:00full years before Dr. John Snow famously removed
- 23:03the handle from the Broad Street water pump in
- 23:05London, which is widely considered the birth
- 23:07of modern epidemiology, a teenage girl on the
- 23:10American plains got there first just by watching
- 23:13her neighbors die. But of course, she had no
- 23:16scientific journal to publish in and no authority
- 23:19to stop 50 ,000 strangers from drinking the contaminated
- 23:22water. And the deepest tragedy of her brilliance
- 23:25is that her realization couldn't save her own
- 23:27family. 12 days after she wrote that entry, deducing
- 23:30the cause, her mother, Anne, died of cholera.
- 23:34Later that summer, they buried her three -year
- 23:36-old brother, Willie, in the dirt. And if we
- 23:39look at the macro level origin of this outbreak,
- 23:41the cholera wasn't out there in the wilderness
- 23:44waiting to ambush them. The American planes were
- 23:46largely pristine before this migration. Right.
- 23:49They brought it with them. they packed it right
- 23:51in their wagons. Exactly. Colorado was already
- 23:53raging in the crowded cities of the East and
- 23:55Midwest. In 1849, it killed over 4 ,000 people
- 23:59in St. Louis, which was roughly a tenth of the
- 24:01entire city's population. In Sandusky, Ohio,
- 24:04the outbreak was so severe, it killed 2 ,300
- 24:07people, roughly two thirds of the town, in a
- 24:09matter of weeks. The pioneers packed up their
- 24:12wagons in these highly infected river towns.
- 24:15drank the local water, contracted the bacteria,
- 24:17and literally dragged it west at the exact speed
- 24:20of a walking ox, infecting the entire continent
- 24:23behind them. It's basically a 2 ,000 -mile conveyor
- 24:26belt of disease. And while the rivers were carrying
- 24:29the invisible killer of cholera, the physical
- 24:32act of crossing those same rivers presented the
- 24:34next great physical and, honestly, financial
- 24:37hurdle of the journey. The geography of profit.
- 24:40There are over 20 major river crossings between
- 24:42Missouri and Oregon. The Kansas, the Platte,
- 24:45the Green, the Snake. And because of that critical
- 24:48departure window we keep coming back to, the
- 24:51wagons arrived at almost all of these rivers
- 24:53at the absolute worst possible time of year,
- 24:56late May and June. Which is exactly when the
- 24:58Rocky Mountain snowpack is melting, sending massive
- 25:01surges of freezing, violent brown water down
- 25:03the channels. You arrive at a raging river with
- 25:06your family and everything you own in a wooden
- 25:08box. and you have to get to the other side. And
- 25:11this creates a massive capitalistic opportunity
- 25:13for anyone willing to monetize desperation. It's
- 25:16the purest distillation of supply and demand.
- 25:19Brigham Young, the Mormon leader, realized this
- 25:21incredibly early. In June 1847, he was meeting
- 25:24his people to the Salt Lake Valley. They painstakingly
- 25:27built a sturdy wooden raft across the North Platte.
- 25:31Once across, Young looked back and saw the massive,
- 25:34endless queue of Oregon -bound wagons stacking
- 25:36up behind him. he immediately left nine men behind
- 25:39with strict instructions to run that raft as
- 25:41a commercial business. Brilliant, honestly. Oh,
- 25:43yeah. They charged up to $3 in cash per wagon.
- 25:47It was the first ferry on the upper Platte, founded
- 25:49on the very shrewd observation that a river that
- 25:52terrifies people is a highly lucrative asset.
- 25:55And the economics of those river crossings just
- 25:57explode from there. By 1850, a Missourian named
- 26:01David Hickman had set up a ferry running on the
- 26:03Platte charging $5 a wagon. Other diarists on
- 26:07the trail noted he was doing a smashing business.
- 26:10The historical estimates suggest Hickman's personal
- 26:12share for just 10 weeks of pulling a rope across
- 26:14a river was around $20 ,000. In today's money,
- 26:19that is the modern equivalent of making $600
- 26:21,000 in a single summer tax -free in the middle
- 26:25of the wilderness. And the entrepreneurs didn't
- 26:27stop at ferries. They moved on to massive infrastructure
- 26:30projects. In 1860, a man named Louis Gennard
- 26:34spent somewhere between $40 ,000 and $60 ,000
- 26:37to construct a thousand -foot tall bridge supported
- 26:40by 26 massive wooden piers over the North Platte.
- 26:44In an era when an entire fully functioning farm
- 26:47back east cost only a few thousand dollars, this
- 26:50man spent an absolute fortune building a bridge
- 26:53in the middle of absolutely nowhere. Why? Because
- 26:57his financial projections were sound. The tolls
- 27:00from ferries and bridges combined added roughly
- 27:02$30 to the total cost of every single wagon heading
- 27:06west. Which raises such a dark microeconomic
- 27:10question for me. Let's say you're a pioneer.
- 27:12You've already liquidated your life savings.
- 27:14You're exhausted. You arrive at the Green River
- 27:16and the ferry operator demands a $16 toll to
- 27:19cross. $16 was literally the cost of replacing
- 27:23one of your oxen. At what point do you look at
- 27:26your dwindling cash reserves and decide that
- 27:29you simply can't afford it? At what point do
- 27:31you look at that toll and decide instead to risk
- 27:34your family's lives in a raging river? The trail
- 27:36forced these impossible, brutal financial choices
- 27:39upon them constantly. If you refuse to pay the
- 27:42$16, the manual alternative is terrifying. You
- 27:45have to take the heavy wheels off your wagon.
- 27:48You then have to use boiling tar or resin to
- 27:51caulk the seams of the wooden wagon box, hoping
- 27:53to make it temporarily watertight. Then, you
- 27:56physically push this ungainly heavy wooden box
- 27:59into the violent current, hoping it floats, while
- 28:01simultaneously trying to force your panicked
- 28:04oxen to swim alongside it to pull it across.
- 28:07And the physics of floating a top -heavy wooden
- 28:10box filled with cast -iron stoves and flower
- 28:13barrels in a snow -melt river are incredibly
- 28:16unforgiving. The results were frequently catastrophic.
- 28:19In 1850 alone, 37 people drowned trying to get
- 28:23across the Green River because they wouldn't
- 28:25or couldn't pay the exorbitant ferry fees. One
- 28:29diary from June 1850 mentions a staggering 19
- 28:32people drowning at a single crossing on the Platte
- 28:35in a span of just 11 days. The trail was merciless.
- 28:40Whether the cause of death was the rivers, the
- 28:42cholera, or the iron wheels, the sheer unrelenting
- 28:46volume of death fundamentally broke down mid
- 28:4919th century American societal norms. This breakdown
- 28:52of ritual is perhaps the most profound psychological
- 28:55shift the pioneers underwent. The devastation
- 28:58of ritual. I think to really grasp the horror
- 29:02of what happened to these people, we have to
- 29:04remember what death looked like in 1850s America.
- 29:07A good death was deeply codified. It was a communal,
- 29:11highly structured event. Absolutely. The extended
- 29:14family, the neighbors, the local clergy would
- 29:16gather at the bedside. The dying person was supposed
- 29:19to be conscious, to accept their fate with grace,
- 29:22and to speak profound last words that would be
- 29:25meticulously written down, preserved, and mailed
- 29:28to distant relatives as a testament to their
- 29:30character. Then there was the physical ritual,
- 29:33a properly constructed wooden coffin, a defined
- 29:36family plot in a consecrated churchyard, a carved
- 29:39stone monument. These rituals were essential.
- 29:42They were what separated human dignity from the
- 29:45unceremonious death of a farm animal. And the
- 29:49Oregon Trail obliterated every single piece of
- 29:52that ritual architecture. Primarily because of
- 29:54the environment. There was simply no wood on
- 29:56the plains. For 600 miles along the Platte River
- 29:59Valley, they cooked their daily meals over dried
- 30:02buffalo dung because there wasn't a single tree
- 30:05in sight. So if a family member died, constructing
- 30:08a coffin meant destroying your own survival equipment.
- 30:11The only sawn lumber within 100 miles was the
- 30:14wagon itself. The diaries detail this agonizing
- 30:17calculus. Willis and Marianne Boatman literally
- 30:20ripped up the floorboards of their own wagon
- 30:22to fashion a crude coffin for a family member,
- 30:25and then later tore off the sideboards to make
- 30:27another. You have accounts of small children
- 30:30being buried in the wooden crates that originally
- 30:32held the family's supply of crackers. There's
- 30:35an entry about a woman wrapped in peeled tree
- 30:37bark. which the rest of the company considered
- 30:39a mass of luxury and a huge relief simply because
- 30:42it was wood. But often they couldn't spare the
- 30:46wood or there was none to be found. They had
- 30:48to use the family's bedding. Willis Boatman eventually
- 30:51had to roll his deceased brother -in -law in
- 30:54a feather mattress. Others used the very sheets,
- 30:58blankets, and quilts that the surviving family
- 31:00members would desperately need to sleep under
- 31:02for the freezing months ahead in the mountains.
- 31:05But the most brutal necessity of all, and this
- 31:08brings us full circle to the image we started
- 31:10with, is where they were forced to put the bodies.
- 31:14They didn't look for a quiet peaceful spot on
- 31:17a hill under a lone cottonwood tree. They buried
- 31:20their dead directly in the deep wheel ruts of
- 31:23the trail itself. And it is crucial to understand
- 31:26that this was not an act of disrespect, haste,
- 31:29or callousness. It was an act of profound desperate
- 31:33protection. If they buried a body off to the
- 31:36side of the road and left a traditional mound
- 31:38of soft dirt, the prairie wolves and coyotes
- 31:41would find the scent instantly. Amelia Hadley
- 31:44wrote a chilling entry in her 1851 diary about
- 31:47walking past a grave that wolves had dug out
- 31:50entirely, turning the burial shaft into a den.
- 31:53She observed that the scavengers dig up nearly
- 31:56everyone buried on the plains the moment the
- 31:59wagon train moves out of sight. So the pioneers
- 32:01adapted by doing the most emotionally devastating
- 32:04thing imaginable. They dug the grave directly
- 32:07in the deep, hardened ruts of the road. They
- 32:10lowered their child or their spouse into the
- 32:12earth, filled the dirt back in, and then intentionally
- 32:15drove every single 2 ,000 -pound wagon in the
- 32:18train and herds of heavy oxen straight over the
- 32:21top of the grave. They let the iron tires and
- 32:24the hooves pound the earth completely flat, compressing
- 32:27the soil until it perfectly matched the hard
- 32:30-packed ground around it. So the wolves and human
- 32:33grave hoppers couldn't detect that the earth
- 32:36had ever been disturbed. It is an almost unbearably
- 32:40heavy image. In order to protect your child's
- 32:43body from being desecrated, you have to physically
- 32:45trample their grave into the dirt until it completely
- 32:48vanishes. You have to participate in the erasure
- 32:51of their existence. So what does this all mean
- 32:55for the geography of the trail? It means the
- 32:58Oregon Trail is essentially a continuous 2 ,000
- 33:01mile intentionally unmarked tomb. If you were
- 33:05driving a wagon in August, your oxen were walking
- 33:08over the hidden, flattened graves of the people
- 33:11who left in May. Every single pioneer who made
- 33:14it to Oregon did so by walking over the dead.
- 33:18And because they were forced to erase the graves
- 33:20to protect them, there grew an incredible desperate
- 33:23hunger among the pioneers to leave some kind
- 33:25of lasting physical mark on the landscape. They
- 33:28needed proof that they had survived this far.
- 33:31This psychological need is exactly why places
- 33:34like Independence Rock in Wyoming became such
- 33:36monumental fixtures of the journey. They called
- 33:38it the great register of the desert. Right. It's
- 33:42a massive smooth granite whale back rising out
- 33:45of the sagebrush and immigrants would use whatever
- 33:48they had, hot tar, axle grease, buffalo fat,
- 33:51or iron chisels. to carve or paint their names,
- 33:54their hometowns and the date into the stone.
- 33:57It was one of the only places on a 2000 mile
- 33:59journey where a family could proclaim we were
- 34:02here. We existed. We survived in a medium that
- 34:05wouldn't be washed away by the rain or dug up
- 34:08by wolves. It's the profound human need to be
- 34:11remembered when every element of the environment
- 34:14around you is actively trying to erase you. And
- 34:17speaking of the environment and the inhabitants
- 34:19of that landscape. We need to address the actual
- 34:22encounters along the trail, because if you had
- 34:25interviewed any of those pioneers back in Missouri
- 34:27before they departed and asked what they were
- 34:30most afraid of, they would have universally said
- 34:32Native American attacks. They believed they were
- 34:35marching into a hostile war zone. The irony is
- 34:38that the reality of their daily interaction with
- 34:40the Native tribes was entirely the reverse of
- 34:43the violent myth. John David Unruh Jr., the historian
- 34:46who spent years doing the exhaustive quantitative
- 34:48work of reading thousands of diaries, proved
- 34:52conclusively that the day -to -day encounters
- 34:53on the plains were overwhelmingly commercial,
- 34:57transactional, and friendly. They were essentially
- 35:00running a massive moving flea market. Native
- 35:03families were constantly approaching the wagons
- 35:05to sell fresh fish. wild berries and durable
- 35:08moccasins to pioneers who were absolutely desperate
- 35:10for fresh food to stave off scurvy and new shoes
- 35:14because theirs had disintegrated on the sharp
- 35:16rocks. The commerce was vital for the pioneer
- 35:18survival. They traded tired horses for fresh
- 35:21ones. Native crews ran some of the more complex
- 35:24ferries and safely navigated immigrant families
- 35:27down the treacherous rapids of the Columbia River
- 35:29in Canoes for a fee. Native trackers were frequently
- 35:32hired by wagon trains to recover stray cattle.
- 35:35Which was an existential service because a heavy
- 35:38freight wagon without oxen is essentially a wooden
- 35:40coffin on the trail. The vast majority of the
- 35:43time, the wagons were passing through other people's
- 35:46sovereign country. And those indigenous populations
- 35:49were treating the migration as an economic opportunity,
- 35:52not a military engagement. But there was an immense
- 35:55catastrophic horror in these encounters. It just
- 35:58wasn't the pioneers being slaughtered. The true
- 36:00horror was that those rolling wagons were essentially
- 36:03biological time bombs. The cholera, the measles,
- 36:06the smallpox that the pioneers carried, the diseases
- 36:09that were already wiping out their own wagon
- 36:11trains, did not stay confined to the road. The
- 36:15bacteria and viruses spilled off the trail into
- 36:18the camps, the wintering grounds, and the villages
- 36:20of the Plains tribes. And we have to understand
- 36:23the epidemiology here. These were indigenous
- 36:26populations with absolutely zero prior exposure,
- 36:30meaning they had zero generational immunity to
- 36:33European diseases. The devastation was apocalyptic.
- 36:37The historical sources estimate that between
- 36:391849 and 1852, half of the entire Pawnee nation
- 36:44may have died from cholera. They lost roughly
- 36:47one thousand people in a single season. Roughly
- 36:50two thirds of the southern Cheyenne died in a
- 36:52similar time frame. The Comanche leaders reported
- 36:55to government agents that their people were too
- 36:57few, too weak, and too grief -stricken to even
- 37:01bury their own dead. The tragic irony is profound.
- 37:05The pioneers were terrified of being killed by
- 37:07native arrows, when, in reality, they were being
- 37:10killed by the fouled water they drank. Meanwhile,
- 37:13the native people the pioneers feared so deeply
- 37:15were being decimated by the invisible pathogens
- 37:18the pioneers carried in their own bodies. And
- 37:21it was precisely this biological collision, this
- 37:24profound lack of medical understanding on both
- 37:27sides that sparked the few genuine tragedies
- 37:30and massacres that did occur. The Whitman Massacre
- 37:33in 1847 is the most poignant example of this
- 37:35dynamic. The layers of tragedy in the Whitman
- 37:38story are just incredible. Walk us through how
- 37:40that unfolded. So in the autumn of 1847, a heavy
- 37:44late -season wave of immigration came down the
- 37:46Columbia River and brought a virulent strain
- 37:49of measles directly into the Walla Walla Valley.
- 37:52To a white pioneer family, measles meant a miserable
- 37:55few weeks of fever and rash, but generally they
- 37:57survived. To the Caius tribe living around the
- 38:00Presbyterian mission run by Dr. Marcus Whitman,
- 38:03it was an extinction -level event. The virus
- 38:06tore through their population that winter, killing
- 38:08close to half the tribe, with the mortality rate
- 38:11highest among their children. And Dr. Whitman,
- 38:14acting as the local physician, is treating both
- 38:17communities simultaneously. But the results are
- 38:20starkly different. The pioneer children he treats
- 38:23mostly recover, because they possess generational
- 38:26genetic immunity. The Caius children he treats
- 38:29mostly die, because their immune systems are
- 38:32completely naive to the virus. And you have to
- 38:35analyze this through the strict lens of Caillou's
- 38:38law and cultural justice. The Caillou's didn't
- 38:40understand the microbiology of viral immunity
- 38:42and frankly neither did Dr. Whitman. What the
- 38:45Caillou's leadership saw was a stark undeniable
- 38:48pattern. A white doctor administering medicine
- 38:51that saved white children but killed Caillou's
- 38:54children. Under their traditional law, a medicine
- 38:57man who acts with malice or whose patients continually
- 39:00die is answerable with his own life to balance
- 39:03the scales. So in November 1847, seeking justice
- 39:07under their own legal framework, a group of Caius
- 39:10warriors attacked the mission. They killed Marcus
- 39:12and Narcissa Whitman and 11 other settlers. But
- 39:16the detail that really highlights the interconnected
- 39:19tragedy of the trail is the identity of one of
- 39:21the other victims. A teenage boy named John Sager
- 39:25was among the dead. And his presence there ties
- 39:28the entire narrative together. This is the exact
- 39:31same boy who, three years earlier, had painstakingly
- 39:35carved the wooden board for his mother's grave
- 39:36on the trail, after his father died of typhus
- 39:40and his sister Catherine's leg was crushed by
- 39:42the wagon wheel. Those orphans miraculously survived
- 39:45the horrors of the trail, were adopted by the
- 39:47Whitmans, and found sanctuary at the mission.
- 39:51And then John is killed in a massacre that was
- 39:53ultimately sparked by a virus brought by a completely
- 39:56different wagon train years later. It's an incredibly
- 40:00dark, inescapable web of biological cause and
- 40:04effect. That fundamental biological and cultural
- 40:07misunderstanding is what manufactured the violence.
- 40:10And you see the same pattern of manufactured
- 40:12conflict igniting the later Plains Wars, which
- 40:15ran for 35 years and cost tens of thousands of
- 40:18lives. They were often sparked by almost unfathomably
- 40:21trivial incidents. The Grattan Massacre of 1854
- 40:24is the prime example. A 35 year war that essentially
- 40:28started over a single cow. A single wandering
- 40:31lame cow belonging to a Mormon immigrant traveling
- 40:35near Fort Laramie. The cow strayed into a massive
- 40:38Lakota camp and was killed for food by a visiting
- 40:41mini -conjuman. The Lakota leader, Chief Conquering
- 40:44Bear, understood the diplomatic situation. He
- 40:47went directly to the fort and offered a healthy
- 40:48horse from his own personal herd as compensation
- 40:52for the cow. The pioneer refused the horse. He
- 40:55demanded $25 in cash. which was an absurd exorbitant
- 40:59demand for a lame cowl on the plains. It was
- 41:02pure extortion. The fort commander, instead of
- 41:06defusing the situation, sent a 24 -year -old
- 41:09inexperienced West Point graduate named Lieutenant
- 41:11John Gratton. Gratton marched into a peaceful
- 41:14Lakota camp of thousands of people with 29 soldiers,
- 41:18two artillery cannons, and a violently drunk
- 41:20interpreter attempting to make an arrest he had
- 41:23zero treaty right to make. Tensions escalated.
- 41:26Someone fired a shot. Chief Conquering Bear was
- 41:29killed. And within a matter of minutes, the Lakota
- 41:32warriors wiped out Grattan and all 29 of his
- 41:34men. That single afternoon of arrogance and misunderstanding
- 41:38essentially ignited 35 years of bloody, retaliatory
- 41:42war across the plains. A generational conflict
- 41:45started over a stray cow and a demand for $25.
- 41:49You know, when we look at all these realities,
- 41:52the cholera, the drownings, the commerce, the
- 41:55Accidental gunshots. It's incredible to me how
- 41:58much of the real danger has been totally obscured
- 42:01by Hollywood. But there is one specific piece
- 42:05of pop culture that actually got the history
- 42:07right. If you were an American kid in the 80s
- 42:10or 90s, you almost certainly played the classic
- 42:13text -based computer game The Oregon Trail. Sitting
- 42:16in the school computer lab, staring at a green
- 42:19screen. Exactly. And think about what you actually
- 42:22remember about playing that game. You don't remember
- 42:26dying in massive, cinematic Indian attacks. You
- 42:29remember the screen telling you that you died
- 42:32of dysentery. You remember your oxen drowning
- 42:34while trying to ford the river. You remember
- 42:37losing three days because you broke a wagon axle.
- 42:40And the reason for that accuracy is fascinating.
- 42:43The game's creator in 1971, Don Rawich, didn't
- 42:47watch Westerns to make the game. He went to the
- 42:50archives. He used the Pioneer's actual diaries
- 42:54to calculate the statistical odds of every single
- 42:57event in the game's code. So a whole generation
- 43:00of American kids actually absorbed the historical
- 43:03truth from an Apple II computer, simply because
- 43:07the game's algorithm reflected the mundane, brutal
- 43:10data of the diaries rather than the dramatic
- 43:13narrative of the movies. Brilliant rare example
- 43:16of raw historical data overcoming a culturally
- 43:19entrenched narrative, at least within that one
- 43:21specific digital medium. But it raises a really
- 43:24important psychological question for us to analyze.
- 43:27If the statistical reality of the trail was dysentery,
- 43:31drownings, and friendly commerce, why is the
- 43:33broader cultural memory outside of that game
- 43:35so heavily skewed towards starvation, cannibalism,
- 43:39and constant native attacks? Because human memory
- 43:42is hijacked by the extreme. It's the myth of
- 43:45the cutoff. Our collective memory of the trail
- 43:47is entirely dominated by a tiny fraction of catastrophic,
- 43:52statistically anomalous events. The human brain
- 43:55latches onto extreme disaster and extrapolates
- 43:58it as the norm. The most famous example, the
- 44:00one story everyone knows, is the Donner Party.
- 44:04They decided to take a shortcut suggested by
- 44:06a man named Lansford Hastings in his 1845 guidebook.
- 44:10Hastings had never even traveled the route he
- 44:11was recommending. He just looked at a map and
- 44:14reasoned it out theoretically, which is a perfectly
- 44:16fine intellectual exercise to do in your comfortable
- 44:19living room back east. But it is a terrifically
- 44:22bad idea when you are leading actual families
- 44:24with heavy wagons into an unknown desert. The
- 44:28results were horrific. The Donner Party gets
- 44:30delayed. They get trapped by early snows at a
- 44:33lake in the Sierra Nevadas in October. They exhaust
- 44:36their food supplies by December, and the survivors
- 44:38ultimately resorted to eating the dead to stay
- 44:41alive. The historical analysis we are looking
- 44:43at argues something really profound. The Donner
- 44:46Party deserves exactly one sentence in the broader
- 44:48history of the organ trail because their experience
- 44:51is so incredibly unrepresentative of what the
- 44:54other 400 ,000 people experienced. But because
- 44:57the details are so macabre, it's the only story
- 45:00that's stuck in the national consciousness. It's
- 45:03exactly like the modern airplane crash effect.
- 45:06Millions of commercial flights take off and land
- 45:08perfectly safely every single year. The system
- 45:11works. But we don't remember or talk about the
- 45:13safe landings. We remember the one plane that
- 45:16goes down in a horrific fireball in the evening
- 45:19news. And we let that one extreme, horrifying
- 45:22exception define our baseline fear of the entire
- 45:25aviation system. The pioneers did the exact same
- 45:28thing with their perception of the trail. They
- 45:30absolutely did. You see this dynamic clearly
- 45:32with the Stephen Meek cutoff in 1845. Meek led
- 45:35roughly 1 ,000 people off the established main
- 45:38road, promising a faster route into the eastern
- 45:40Oregon desert. They wandered for weeks, ran critically
- 45:43low on water, and became infamous as the lost
- 45:46wagon train. Ultimately, 14 people died on that
- 45:49cutoff. Four drowned, and 10 died of camp illnesses.
- 45:53Mathematically, that's a death rate of under
- 45:552%, which was actually lower than the average
- 45:57mortality rate on the main trail. But because
- 46:00a woman named Anna Maria King was on that cutoff
- 46:03and physically saw people she knew die, she wrote
- 46:06letters back east describing the cutoff as an
- 46:09apocalyptic catastrophe. Your entire perception
- 46:11of the trail's danger was based strictly on the
- 46:13radius of your own wagon wheels. If a stranger
- 46:16died 10 miles behind you, the trail was fine.
- 46:19If your cousin died in your wagon, the trail
- 46:22was a nightmare. And we also have to remember
- 46:24that sometimes these disastrous cutoffs and new
- 46:27routes weren't forged out of a desire for speed
- 46:30or efficiency. Sometimes they were forged out
- 46:33of sheer blinding trauma. The Applegate Trail
- 46:36is a perfect example. It wasn't pioneered to
- 46:38save time. It was pioneered out of grief. In
- 46:421843, the Applegate brothers lost their children,
- 46:45a nine -year -old and a 10 -year -old who tragically
- 46:47drowned in a whirlpool while floating down the
- 46:49treacherous Columbia River at the very end of
- 46:51the journey. The brothers were so devastated
- 46:54that they spent the next three years swearing
- 46:56they would find a southern route into Oregon
- 46:57that entirely bypassed that river. They hacked
- 47:00a new trail through the wilderness simply to
- 47:03avoid looking at the water that took their sons.
- 47:05So you have this monumental human struggle, this
- 47:09relentless river of people flowing across the
- 47:11continent for 30 years, suffering, dying, adapting,
- 47:15and burying their children in the dirt. But this
- 47:18massive era of migration didn't end with a dramatic
- 47:21finale. It didn't end because they finally conquered
- 47:24the wilderness or defeated an enemy. No. The
- 47:27Oregon Trail didn't get safer. The mud didn't
- 47:29dry up. The cholera didn't vanish. The trail
- 47:32just became technologically obsolete. The turning
- 47:34point is May 10th, 1869, Promontory Summit, Utah.
- 47:39They drive the Golden Spike, connecting the Union
- 47:41Pacific and Central Pacific Lines, completing
- 47:44the Transcontinental Railroad. And practically
- 47:47overnight, the entire calculus of Westward expansion
- 47:50fundamentally changes. The shift in human experience
- 47:54is staggering. You go from a journey that costs
- 47:57a thousand dollars, requires liquidating everything
- 47:59you own, takes five agonizing months of walking,
- 48:03and carries a very real risk of burying your
- 48:05children in the road bed, to a completely different
- 48:08paradigm. Suddenly, a family in 1870 could buy
- 48:11a train ticket for the price of one good ox,
- 48:14about $65. They could sit in a cushioned seat,
- 48:18eat hot meals, and read a newspaper as they rolled
- 48:21smoothly across the exact same Wyoming desert
- 48:24that had killed so many just a few years earlier,
- 48:27completing the journey in just one week. It's
- 48:30an incredible technological whiplash. But the
- 48:32people who survived the walking era of the trail,
- 48:35they didn't just fade into the background when
- 48:37the trains arrived. They were still there. And
- 48:40they actively shaped the political and social
- 48:42future of the West. The historical records give
- 48:45this incredible epilogue about Abigail Scott,
- 48:49the 17 -year -old girl who brilliantly figured
- 48:51out the cholera transmission vector on the banks
- 48:53of the Platte River. Abigail Scott Dunneway.
- 48:57Her post -trail life is truly remarkable. She
- 49:00grew up in Oregon, married, worked as a schoolteacher,
- 49:03and in 1871 she founded her own newspaper in
- 49:06Portland called The New Northwest. She spent
- 49:09the next several decades using her platform to
- 49:12fiercely, relentlessly argue for women's suffrage
- 49:14and organ. And the detail that makes this feel
- 49:17like a novel is her primary opponent. The loudest,
- 49:21most powerful voice fighting against her in the
- 49:23press was the conservative editor of The Oregonian,
- 49:27the biggest paper on the coast. And the editor
- 49:29of that paper was her own younger brother, Harvey
- 49:32Scott, the exact same boy who had walked right
- 49:35beside her on the dusty trail in 1852. the same
- 49:38boy who stood next to her when they buried their
- 49:40mother and their three -year -old brother in
- 49:43the dirt. They engaged in a bitter public political
- 49:46war for decades. Oregon voters rejected women's
- 49:50suffrage multiple times under Harvey's influence.
- 49:53But Abigail never stopped fighting. Finally,
- 49:55in November of 1912, Oregon passed the suffrage
- 49:59amendment. Abigail was 78 years old. The state
- 50:02recognized her lifetime of effort by asking her
- 50:05to write the official proclamation. The governor
- 50:07signed it and he handed her the pen so she could
- 50:09sign it too. The young girl who had watched everyone
- 50:12around her dying on the plains, whose brilliant
- 50:14medical deduction had been entirely ignored by
- 50:16the men in charge, finally forced the world to
- 50:19listen to her. And on the other end of the spectrum
- 50:21of memory, you have the deeply haunting story
- 50:23of Ezra Meeker. In 1906, Ezra is 76 years old.
- 50:29He had crossed the trail way back in 1852, which
- 50:31was statistically the deadliest year on record
- 50:34for cholera. traveling with his young wife and
- 50:36a seven -week -old baby. He reaches his old age
- 50:40and he realizes that the physical reality of
- 50:42the road he had walked, the profound struggle
- 50:45of his generation, is disappearing. The ruts
- 50:48are being plowed under for modern wheat fields,
- 50:51fenced off by barbed wire and forgotten by a
- 50:53country moving on by train. He recognizes that
- 50:56the physical tether to his past and the graves
- 50:59of his contemporaries are slipping away. So at
- 51:0176 years old, he refuses to let it go. He hitches
- 51:05up a covered wagon to a team of oxen and decides
- 51:08to travel the entire trail backwards from west
- 51:11to east. He stops in every single town along
- 51:14the way, standing on a literal soapbox in town
- 51:16squares, begging for pennies and dollars to commission
- 51:19granite monuments to mark where the trail used
- 51:21to be. He spends the entire rest of his long
- 51:24life fiercely chasing the memory of the trail.
- 51:27He does it in an aux cart first. Then in 1916,
- 51:31adapting to the times, he does it in a Pathfinder
- 51:34touring car that he had customized with a canvas
- 51:37wagon shell bolted to the roof. In 1924, at the
- 51:41astonishing age of 93, he climbs into the passenger
- 51:44seat of an open cockpit Army biplane and flies
- 51:47over the exact same ruts he had walked, cruising
- 51:50at 100 miles an hour. He died in 1928, just before
- 51:55his 98th birthday. actively planning yet another
- 51:58cross -country trip in a Ford automobile. He
- 52:01was desperately, obsessively trying to find and
- 52:04mark the graves of the people they left behind.
- 52:07But the tragic reality of his quest is that he
- 52:09couldn't find them. Because as we discussed earlier,
- 52:13the roadbed burials had worked far too well.
- 52:16The cracker boxes and the floorboards they used
- 52:18for coffins had rotted away into soil decades
- 52:20earlier. The stones were scattered. The pioneers
- 52:24had put their loved ones in the deep ruts and
- 52:26driven their 2 ,000 pound wagons straight over
- 52:28the top to flatten the earth and hide them from
- 52:31the wolves. The erasure worked exactly as they
- 52:34had designed it to. The graves were completely
- 52:37irretrievably gone. So to synthesize this entire
- 52:43massive journey we've been on, we started today's
- 52:46deep dive by trying to strip away the pristine
- 52:49pop culture myth. of The Covered Wagon and The
- 52:52Noble Pioneer. And what we found beneath it is
- 52:55that The Oregon Trail wasn't an action movie
- 52:58full of dramatic shootouts with Native Americans.
- 53:00It was essentially the ordinary, grim, mid -19th
- 53:04century American death rate, which was already
- 53:07appalling in cholera -ridden cities like St.
- 53:09Louis, but uprooted and moved outdoors into a
- 53:13brutal environment. It was death stripped of
- 53:16community support, stripped of medical care,
- 53:19and violently stripped of all the comforting
- 53:22ritual that makes grief bearable. The pioneers
- 53:24ultimately achieved their primary goal. They
- 53:27succeeded in crossing a hostile continent, securing
- 53:30free land, and establishing a future for their
- 53:32descendants. But the ultimate cost of that success
- 53:35was that they had to literally trample their
- 53:37own grief into the dirt to keep it safe from
- 53:40scavengers. In the desperate act of protecting
- 53:43their dead, they inadvertently erased their personal,
- 53:47immense tragedies from the physical landscape
- 53:49of America forever. It is a profound and deeply
- 53:52unsettling truth to sit with. The pioneers literally
- 53:56drove their heavy freight wagons over the freshly
- 53:59dug graves of their own loved ones to hide them,
- 54:02smoothing the earth so perfectly, so seamlessly,
- 54:05that the very next wagon in the train wouldn't
- 54:08even know they were passing over a tragedy. Yeah.
- 54:12It makes you wonder, in our relentless modern
- 54:15drive forward, what collective traumas are we
- 54:18currently paving over? What deep historical grief
- 54:21are you driving past every single day on your
- 54:25morning commute, completely unaware that it is
- 54:28buried right beneath your wheels? Thank you for
- 54:31joining us on this deep dive. Until next time.