Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #230 - Adam Zivo (National Post)
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Mohameir and this is Van Keller,
- 0:20British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show. If you watch this
- 0:24show regularly, you know that I am a proponent of safe supply programs,
- 0:29which is when drug users are prescribed pharmaceutical alternatives to elicit street drugs, street
- 0:35drugs whose unknown potency and composition has killed over fourteen thousand people in eight years
- 0:41here in BC. My support for safe supply has been expressed both in my
- 0:45commentary and by guests of this program. I've also expressed support for drug decriminalization.
- 0:52If you watch the show regularly, you also know that I'm more than
- 0:55willing to talk to people with whom I disagree, and tonight maybe that's what's
- 1:00going to happen, but I'm going to keep an open mind with our featured
- 1:03guest. A weekly columnist for the National Post, best known for his coverage
- 1:07of LGBTQ issues, the war in Ukraine, and his critical lens on safe
- 1:11supply and drug decriminalization. He's also the executive director of the Center for Responsible
- 1:18Drug Policy. He is Adam Zvo Adam, nice to see you. Thanks
- 1:23so much for being here tonight. Thanks for having me on the show.
- 1:25It's a pleasure to be here. So first things first, we know what
- 1:27safe supply is, and I know that you're somewhat critical of safe supply,
- 1:32but can you explain what safe supply diversion is? Okay? So, safe
- 1:36supply diversion essentially is when patients take their tax payer funded drugs and instead of
- 1:41consuming them as intended, they predominantly resell them on the street. Now,
- 1:46the main driver behind diversion is that the drugs that we distribute safe for supply
- 1:52is not really fit for the task. So most most serious opioid addicts in
- 1:57Vancouver and canad more generally are addicted to that. And fentanyl is about ten
- 2:01to fifty times stronger than the hydromorphone, which is the drug that we give
- 2:05out through safer Supply. The brand name is Delauded. It's Delauded, yeah,
- 2:08and you know hydromorphone Deluded. It's comparable in strength slash potency to heroin.
- 2:15But if you're on fentanyl, which is you know, ten to fifty
- 2:16times stronger, and you receive a jar of hydromorphone pills, it's going to
- 2:21do very little for you. So in that situation, the rational thing to
- 2:24do is to sell your free drugs to make money to buy fentanyl, which
- 2:29is your drug of choice, which has the potency to match your tolerance.
- 2:32And we tend to forget that. You know, drug addicts are reasonable people.
- 2:37Addiction has hijacked their brain, so they have unreasonable goals, but they
- 2:40know how to rationally pursue those goals. So I guess where I'm curious is
- 2:46the diversion of pharmaceutical drugs has always occurred. I mean, we could go
- 2:50to the downtown Ey Side and buy tail and all threes. We could buy
- 2:53morphine, We could buy methadone, even though methadone is supposed to be consumed
- 2:57under supervision. Right, we know that hydromorphone delauded has also been diverted for
- 3:02decades, pre dating the safe supply programs. So I'm curious, like,
- 3:07why does this matter? Now? Why are we talking about diversion in this
- 3:12context. No one's saying that pharmaceutical diversion is a new thing. Pharmaceutical diversion
- 3:15has been around forever. What is new here is this scale of diversion that
- 3:20is happening much in the same way how during the OxyContin crisis. You know,
- 3:23diversion of pharmaceuticals was not new there, but this scale was important in
- 3:27that scandal. So hydromorphone has always been a bit of a rare drug on
- 3:32the black market. It used to sell for about, let's say, twenty
- 3:37dollars for an eight milligram pill. Since safer supply programs have become accessible in
- 3:42Canada, the price of an eight milligram pill has collapsed to about one dollar
- 3:46a pill if you're buying it directly from a safer supply patient, to three
- 3:50to five dollars a pill if you're getting it from drug dealers who purchase from
- 3:53these patients and then resell in bulk, to five to seven dollars a pill
- 3:58if you're buying it from a street supplier who purchase from those drug dealers.
- 4:02The amount of supply that seems to be getting into communities as a result of
- 4:06this diversion seems unparallel to anything that we've seen before, and much of that
- 4:11comes down to the immense quantities of hydromorphone that we're giving to safer supply patients.
- 4:16So hydromorphone is used to treat pain, it's used to treat chronic pain
- 4:20and people who are in acute pain after for example, going through surgery.
- 4:25So if you're in a hospital and you're recovering from surgery, you're going to
- 4:28be given a two milligram pill every four to six hours, So let's say
- 4:31on average, that's about twelve milligrams every day. A safer supply patient in
- 4:35BC will receive fourteen eight milligram pills, so that's one hundred and twelve milligrams
- 4:42every single day indefinitely. If you're in Ontario, you can receive up to
- 4:46thirty which is two hundred and forty milligrams. So the average safer supply patient
- 4:50is going to be receiving about ten to twenty times the amount of hydromorphone of
- 4:55a comparable patient who is in chronic or acute pain. Going back to chronic
- 4:59pain, people are treated with about twelve milligrams or less of hydromorphone if they
- 5:03have arthritis. The only exception for that is people who are in late stage
- 5:09cancer, who receive maybe up to about one hundred milligrams. So only late
- 5:13stage cancer patients get a comparable dosage, and that's a relatively small population that
- 5:17is unlikely to divert because they really need that medication. Where I'm confused is
- 5:24the RCMP said that there is no widespread diversion of safe supply. We've also
- 5:29seen Stats Canada put out a report saying from twenty twelve to twenty twenty two,
- 5:34the rate of substance use disorder has stayed pretty stable and has actually dropped
- 5:39a little bit. So I don't deny or I don't you know, I
- 5:42think it's reasonable to assume that diversion is happening, But ultimately, what is
- 5:46the impact if it was going to happen and it has been happening for decades.
- 5:49Well, I think what's important to note here is that the rate of
- 5:53substance used diagnoses doesn't necessarily match the rate of actual substance abuse, right because
- 6:00in order for you to diagnose someone, you have to have a certain you
- 6:01have to have that capacity, And we have to be aware of the fact
- 6:04that we're currently going through a healthcare crisis where it's very difficult to get access
- 6:08to a family doctor, let alone to specialized addiction care. So, first
- 6:13of all, you know opio addiction like diagnosing that that's a lagging indicator.
- 6:16And second of all, our system is not really set up to capture all
- 6:19the new addiction that we're seeing on the streets today. So do we have
- 6:23any data to show that there are new people with substance abuse disorders or that
- 6:29that rate is going up, Well, it's hard to say. When it
- 6:32comes to the data that backs safer supply diversion. I'll give you a few
- 6:35different examples. So in July of last year, the BC Corner Service released
- 6:42a report that looked at youth drug debts between twenty seventeen and twenty twenty two,
- 6:46and they try to downplay safe supply diversion by saying that most tests came
- 6:50from fentanyl and that only seven percent of debts involved hydromorphone. However, safer
- 6:56spiling came out in twenty twenty, so the way they framed it using that
- 6:58average is misleading. It would be like saying we looked at the data between
- 7:01sixteen fifty and twenty twenty four and saw that on average, there were very
- 7:05few automobile debts. Therefore cars are safe, right, right, So when
- 7:10you look at the number year by year, you see the zero percent of
- 7:12deaths involved hydromorphone for youth in twenty seventeen zero percent in twenty eighteen zero percent.
- 7:16In twenty nineteen, safe supply becomes widely available. In twenty twenty,
- 7:19that number goes up to five point five percent twenty twenty one nine dot six
- 7:23percent, twenty twenty two, twenty two dot two percent. So since safer
- 7:28supply became available all of a sudden, you're seeing this very dramatic spike,
- 7:31and youth were dying. We have hydromorphone in their system. But as tragic
- 7:35as those debts are, hydromorphone was not the only thing found in their system.
- 7:41I mean, it was an intermingling between other substances as well, right,
- 7:44Like opioids and alcohol when mixed together can be quite fatal. But it's
- 7:47not necessarily one that's killing you, right of course, And here's a major
- 7:51piece of disinformation that is often shared around the safe supply diversion crisis. People
- 7:57believe that the main argument being made is that hydromorphone is directly killing youth or
- 8:01other drug users. That is not what we're saying. We're saying that hydromorphone
- 8:07is initiating addictions which then graduate on defensinal and then the fensanyl then kills people
- 8:13and so the data that we're seeing within that report is very consistent with that
- 8:16most people are dying from fensanyl a much, very very a large growing portion
- 8:22of them have hydromorphone in their systems. Now moving forward, in the autumn
- 8:26of last year, doctor Sharon Koivu from London, Ontario published a chart review
- 8:31of her patients in Victoria Hospital in London, Ontario, and so she reviewed
- 8:35two hundred patients of hers who had gone through her addiction service between January of
- 8:41twenty twenty three in July twenty twenty three, I believe, And so of
- 8:46those patients, the ones who were not enrolled in a safe supply program,
- 8:48thirty three percent of them approximately reported accessing diverted hydromorphone and the overwhelming majority of
- 8:56them very explicitly said that they were accessing safer supply. So we can see
- 9:01that in that city, one third of drug users who are not on safe
- 9:03supply are accessing diverted hydromorphim from safer supply according to what they're reporting, right,
- 9:09But it can still be unclear, can't it. I mean, in
- 9:13BC, less than five thousand people actually have access to safe supply, but
- 9:16there's tens of thousands of people that have access to hydromorphone because they're being prescribed
- 9:20that because of pain. Right, So again, how do we know that
- 9:24it's How do we know definitively that it's from safe supply and not a diverted
- 9:28prescription or a counterfeit. Well, well, so I'm going to answer the
- 9:31two different points that you brought up here. So, yes, the patient
- 9:33population for safer supply is relatively small. So on average there's about four thousand,
- 9:39five hundred patients in BC. The most recent data for the total number
- 9:43of hydromorphorm patients comes from twenty eighteen to twenty nineteen, of which there are
- 9:46approximately eighty thousand patients. So we can estimate that approximately five percent of the
- 9:50hydromorphim patient population are safer supply clients. However, as I mentioned earlier,
- 9:58they're receiving a significantly higher rates or sorry dose of hydromotionim compared to everyone else,
- 10:03which is how such a small population has been able to have such a
- 10:05large impact. On top of that, their diversion rate is unparalleled. So
- 10:11it's hard to quantify diversion rates for opioids in general, but the estimate of
- 10:15the upper bound estimate is about three percent. What I'm consistently hearing from former
- 10:20drug users and former drug dealers is that eighty to ninety percent of safe supply
- 10:24clients diverts. Right, So there's just a magnitude of difference here, which
- 10:28is again anecdotal evidence, right, Like, And I'm not saying you're necessarily
- 10:31wrong. I'm just saying we don't have hard data to prove that well.
- 10:37I mean, like, how else are you supposed to find out about,
- 10:39you know, rates of diversion if not querying the people who are directly involved
- 10:43in this. In this space, now, there is a lack of evidence,
- 10:46and unfortunately we do have to rely on anecdotes. And I don't think
- 10:50that's ideal. And I recognize the fact that my research is anecdotal. I'm
- 10:54an investigative journalists. I do the best I can given my limited resources.
- 10:58That's fair. If I had a multimillion dollar research grant, I do things
- 11:00differently. We have to wrap it up for this segment, but I just
- 11:03want one more yes or no question to be clear. We cannot attribute hydromorphone
- 11:09delauded safe supply to any of the drug debts here in BC directly. Is
- 11:13that correct? I think there are a few examples for it has been,
- 11:16but that's very complicated. Okay, well, when we're back, let's talk
- 11:20about drug decriminalization and what's happening here in BC. Welcome back to this as
- 11:31Van Color. Last week the government of British Columbia announced plans to ban drug
- 11:35use in public spaces, which would create new restrictions on BC's drug decriminalization pilot
- 11:41project. To discuss, we're back with one of the most outspoken and arguably
- 11:46influential critics of safe supply and drug decriminalization, a weekly columnist at the National
- 11:52Post. He is Adam Zvo, and this conversation is brought to you by
- 11:56Pacific Sands Beach Resort into Fino laid back luxury as beachfront as it gets.
- 12:05So, Adam, has decriminalization failed in British Columbia with this recent rollback from
- 12:09BC Premier David Ebe I think absolutely. I think the public disorder that we've
- 12:13seen is completely unacceptable and we've seen no real benefits to countervail its. Has
- 12:20there been a significant decrease in overdoses or debts? Absolutely not, And I
- 12:24think that the failure of decriminalization in BC was in many ways predictable, given
- 12:28that the model of decriminalization that BC pursued was almost uniquely irresponsible and lazy.
- 12:35Why uniquely well, okay, Oregon also really screwed this up. But let's
- 12:41talk about Portugal, because everyone is obsessed with Portugal and they often misunderstand it.
- 12:46Right. So, the Portuguese decriminalized drugs in the early two thousands,
- 12:50but they didn't just let people do whatever they wanted. So, first of
- 12:52all, in the years leading up to decriminalization, they invested significantly into treatment
- 12:58capacity to ensure that those who wanted treatment could easily access it. Then when
- 13:03they decriminalized, they essentially created an alternate system of justice where if you were
- 13:09caught openly using drugs or possessing a small quantity, you weren't just let go.
- 13:13You were essentially just sent to a dissuasion commission composed of a social worker,
- 13:18a psychologist, and a lawyer, and that commission could use fines and
- 13:24other punitive measures to coerce you into treatments, so they kept you out of
- 13:30the criminal justice system. You weren't automatically sent to jail, you weren't saddled
- 13:35with the criminal record, that could destroy your life, but there were accountability
- 13:39measures that ensured that you controlled your behavior and that there was a mechanism in
- 13:45place to divert you into the healthcare system. Right, which is the point
- 13:48of decriminalization, taking it out of the criminal justice system and putting drug use
- 13:52into the healthcare system. But is Portugal a fair comparison because they were dealing
- 13:58with in addictions chright, Whereas here in British Columbia, and I guess throughout
- 14:01North America, we're dealing with a toxic drug supply crisis where you know,
- 14:05people think they're taking something, but they're taking something else and they die instantly.
- 14:09And the drugs are so toxic that even the lock zone has started to
- 14:13not be as effective. So is it a fair comparison to say that we
- 14:16should set that up because treatment itself, you know, people are prone to
- 14:20chronic relapse. So should you really be at risk to die just because you
- 14:26are going through the treatment process? Well, I mean, look like,
- 14:28obviously the situations aren't exactly the same, but I don't think that there is
- 14:31different as people want to make them out to be. Right, Like,
- 14:35if you want an effective form of decriminalization, you have to have actual mechanisms
- 14:39in place to divert people into healthcare. The BC government just assumed that if
- 14:43you quote unquote destigmatized drug use, then somehow people would be less embarrassed to
- 14:48seek treatment and therefore they would you know, do so more often. But
- 14:54to my understanding, there's not a lot of strong evidence backing that, and
- 14:56oftentimes people you know, continue to use drugs because they're locked into addiction,
- 15:01right, They don't quit until there's a really strong reason for them to.
- 15:05And an embarrassment is not something that really dissuades many people. But if you
- 15:09fear police interaction, then aren't you going to go do those drugs alone or
- 15:13somewhere private? And that increases your risk of dying from a toxic dose,
- 15:18doesn't it. Well, so that's a different issue, right, Okay,
- 15:20So now we're talking about, you know, the benefits of decriminalization, not
- 15:24about whether or not we have mechanisms in place to divert people into healthcare.
- 15:28Like, sure, some people who use alone, like that's a bit more
- 15:31dangerous. I think that you have to balance that against the potential public harms
- 15:37of decriminalization. So if someone uses alone, that's more dangerous. So you
- 15:43want them to use in public, but at what cost? Right? And
- 15:46if your city becomes unlivable, and if people are unable to recover because public
- 15:50spaces are no longer drug free and they're constantly reminded of drug abuse, does
- 15:56that balance out? And I don't think that's really the case. I think
- 15:58there might be we might have some agreement here where I do think decriminalization was
- 16:03successful in terms of taking it out of the criminal justice system, or at
- 16:06least in terms of interactions with the police. But British Columbia failed to provide
- 16:11the wrap around services to keep people safe or to connect them into the healthcare
- 16:14system. Do you think that's a fair assessment. I'd say so, I
- 16:17think from my understanding, and you know, correct me if I'm wrong,
- 16:19But decriminalization works when there is a strong focus on recovery. And in the
- 16:25early years of Portugal we saw that. You know, we saw really great
- 16:29outcomes, We saw decreases in infectious disease rates, we saw decreases in overdoses
- 16:33and debts. But then starting around two thousand and eight, those successes started
- 16:37to disappear. And there's a reason for that is that you had the financial
- 16:40crisis, and so Portugal suddenly had to make some cuts because it no longer
- 16:45had the money it used to, and of course investments recovery oriented services began
- 16:48to disappear, and so recovery was no longer as available as it used to
- 16:53be. And then on top of that, the state was what they started
- 16:57to do is that the government started to outsource some addiction services to nonprofit groups
- 17:03rather than directly provide them, and these nonprofit groups no longer prioritized recovery.
- 17:08They essentially focused on quote unquote destigmatizing drug use and enabling it rather than pushing
- 17:14people into getting better. Now really quickly, we have about a minute left.
- 17:18Alberta has moved towards a recovery model, but we've seen their rate of
- 17:22drug debts also increase, and it doesn't seem to be effective there either in
- 17:27terms of bringing down drug debts. So it just feels like the key here
- 17:33is to link people into health services. So how do we do that?
- 17:36What is the alternative that we should be pursuing. Well, I mean,
- 17:38so the Alberta model is not perfect. The way that I see it is
- 17:41that it's akin to the Portuguese model in the years leading up to decriminalization.
- 17:45So they've invested a lot into recovery oriented services and those services have been online
- 17:51for about six months to a year now, but they haven't put in the
- 17:55mechanisms to coerce people into treatment like you saw in Portuguese in Portugal in the
- 17:59early two thousands, So I think you know they're looking at in voluntary treatments.
- 18:03They'll need to expand drug courts, but from my understanding, they're very
- 18:07reluctant to expand drug courts until they have the capacity to absorb all the people
- 18:11who are being diverted into healthcare system. You can't push people into healthcare into
- 18:17recovery if you don't have beds to hold them, right, Adam, thank
- 18:21you so much for your time tonight. I know this is a heavy subject
- 18:23and I do appreciate you coming here to talk about it with me. Oh
- 18:27thanks for having me. I love cross partisan discourse. Absolutely love to do
- 18:30it again, folks. That was freelance writer and National Post columnist Adam Zvo.
- 18:36Be sure to find his work in the National Post. It is thought
- 18:38provoking and I'm personally appreciative of both a diverse diet of local media and an
- 18:44openness to talk about these important issues. Thank you so much to Pacific Sands
- 18:48Beach Resort and to FINO for supporting local conversations even when the subject matter is
- 18:53not as laid back as their resort. Now, after some business, the
- 18:57big question in BC when it comes to who the toxic drug supply crisis is
- 19:02what now? I'm going to take a moment to ask Premier David eb that
- 19:07very question. Up next, Welcome back to this is Van Color. We've
- 19:18discussed some big themes tonight regarding British Columbia's toxic drug supply crisis, including the
- 19:22newly announced plan to ban public drug use. I suppose the next logical question
- 19:27is what now? Let's talk about it and let's take a moment. Last
- 19:41week, BC Premier David Ebe announced the plan to ban illicit drug use in
- 19:45public spaces, which would create new restrictions on BC's drug decriminalization pilot project.
- 19:52It's a sort of recriminalization, or, in mushy speak, the implementation of
- 19:56common sense safeguards and the interest of public safety. But what now? I
- 20:02mean, now that we've addressed the public safety issue, which was not a
- 20:06public health emergency, what are we doing now to focus on the eight year
- 20:10plus actual public health emergency that has killed over fourteen thousand human beings in BC.
- 20:15Are we investing in safe consumption sites so that vulnerable drug users, many
- 20:21of whom will have nowhere to consume their drugs, can do so in a
- 20:23setting that connects them to health care services. Are we expanding access to pharmaceutical
- 20:29alternatives safer supply, which is currently only accessed by less than five percent of
- 20:33drug users, so that drug users can reduce and replace the toxic street drugs
- 20:37they consume, you know, the thing that's actually killing seven British Columbians a
- 20:41day. How about treatment and recovery. If someone is ready to stop using
- 20:47drugs, they should have immediate access to free, low barrier addictions treatment.
- 20:52Now, you can't force people into treatment, if only because the success rate
- 20:56of mandatory treatment is proven to be very low. Also, in a province
- 21:02where over eight hundred thousand people don't have a family doctor and there's a shortage
- 21:06of nurses, how are we staffing these treatment facilities. That's not to say
- 21:11that we shouldn't try, but rather to refocus the toxic drug supply emergency on
- 21:17what can be done to keep people alive today, and whether drug users are
- 21:22using recreationally or because of addiction or through the treatment process where folks are prone
- 21:26to relapse. No one deserves to die because of a bad batch of drugs,
- 21:30a risk which is made worse when a drug user is pushed to dark,
- 21:34solitary corners to consume those drugs because there's no other option. So premier
- 21:40ebe. Since we've addressed the not an emergency of public drug use, What
- 21:45now, folks? That's our show? Thank you, of course, to
- 21:56our very special guest, National Post columnist Adam Zo for his time tonight.
- 22:00If you have any thoughts about tonight's show, shoot me an email Moat.
- 22:04This isvancolor dot com. I love hearing from you. Your thoughtful feedback always
- 22:10inspires the type of guests we host on the program, and not only what
- 22:14we talk about, but how we talk about those issues, So please don't
- 22:18hesitate to shoot me a line. Also follow me on x or TikTok at
- 22:22Van Color. We will be back next week, but for now, this
- 22:25is Van Color and I'm moamir telling you that in a province where you can
- 22:29be anything, be colorful. Peace