Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Post-Acquisition Disputes - Basics & Strategy
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everyone welcome to today's program post
- 0:07acquisition disputes basics, and strategy. I'm
- 0:11Allapoli Castro, Director of Education and Professional
- 0:14Development at Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 0:17and today I'm delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:19Christina Fung and Peter Brown. Christina is
- 0:22a certified public accountant, accredited in
- 0:25business valuations, certified fraud examiner,
- 0:28and a certified anti -money laundering specialist.
- 0:31As a member of GHJ's Forensic Services Practice,
- 0:34she provides litigation support, including expert
- 0:36witness testimony, complete forensic investigations
- 0:40and supports clients with issues that may threaten
- 0:43their business. She was named Young Accountant
- 0:45of the Year at the International Accounting Awards
- 0:47in London, one of the top 100 CPAs in Los Angeles
- 0:51County by the Los Angeles Business Journal, and
- 0:54received the AICPA's Standing Ovation Award,
- 0:57which is awarded to professionals in forensic
- 0:59accounting or business valuations who exhibit
- 1:01exemplary professional achievement. Peter is
- 1:05also a certified public accountant, accredited
- 1:07in business valuations, a certified fraud examiner,
- 1:10and certified money laundering specialist. He
- 1:13is the Forensic Services Practice Leader at GHJ
- 1:16with extensive experience quantifying damages
- 1:19and commercial litigation. and conducting internal
- 1:22investigations. He has served as an expert witness
- 1:26and as a third -party neutral accountant in financial
- 1:28matters and purchase disputes. Prior to GHJ,
- 1:32Peter spent 30 years at Big Four accounting firms.
- 1:36He is an active AICPA member and currently serves
- 1:39as CalCPA's statewide counsel, having previously
- 1:42chaired CalCPA's forensic service section. We
- 1:46can't wait to hear what these experts have to
- 1:47share with us today, so I'm going to turn it
- 1:49over to them. Well, great. Thank you very much
- 1:54for that warm introduction and thank you to the
- 1:56Beverly Hills Bar Association for having us today.
- 1:59As mentioned, I'm Peter Brown. I'm a partner
- 2:02with GHJ. And GHJ Greenhouse and Jenks is an
- 2:06accounting firm, full service accounting firm
- 2:08located here in Los Angeles. And I'm going to
- 2:11be speaking today about post -acquisition disputes.
- 2:16So today's topic really is very interesting because
- 2:18it's really the intersection between accounting,
- 2:21deal making, and litigation. So many attorneys,
- 2:25and I assume those on the call, are involved
- 2:29in negotiating deals and buying and selling of
- 2:32companies, conducting diligence and closing transactions.
- 2:36But as many of you know, after the closing is
- 2:40when the disputes begin. The issues we're going
- 2:43to be discussing today can sometimes result in
- 2:46millions or tens of millions of dollars in damages.
- 2:50Those occur really after the transaction has
- 2:53already closed. We'll talk about the types of
- 2:56disputes that arise, the contractual language
- 3:00that is often more important than the accounting
- 3:02language in the agreements. and then how forensic
- 3:06accountants become involved. But before we do
- 3:09that, I'll just allow my colleague, esteemed
- 3:11colleague, Christina, to just give a brief introduction
- 3:14of herself as well. Yes, thank you, Peter. Hello,
- 3:17everyone. My name is Christina Fung. I'm the
- 3:19principal with GHJ. It is my pleasure to address
- 3:22the Beverly Hills Bar Association today. As Peter
- 3:25mentioned, we've worked on many, many post -acquisition
- 3:28disputes, and we're excited to bring this topic
- 3:30to you. Let's take a look at the agenda. This
- 3:33will be our roadmap for the next hour. We'll
- 3:35begin with the major categories of post acquisition
- 3:38disputes. Next, we'll discuss how contractual
- 3:40language often drives outcomes in these cases.
- 3:43We'll then examine the role forensic accountants
- 3:45play before and after closing. And then finally,
- 3:48we'll be walking through several case studies
- 3:50illustrating how these disputes unfold in practice.
- 3:53By the end of today's program, our goal is for
- 3:55you to be able to spot potential dispute areas
- 3:57earlier and understand where accounting experts
- 3:59can add value. So Peter, I'll throw it back to
- 4:02you. Let's get started. Well, thank you. Okay,
- 4:04so let's go to the next slide. Let's just introduce
- 4:09the topics. Typically, there's really three different
- 4:12types of disputes that we talk about when we
- 4:15have a post -acquisition dispute. The first is
- 4:18a networking capital true -up, and we'll define
- 4:20and explain what that is. The next is an earn
- 4:23-out dispute, and the last category would be
- 4:26representations and warranties disputes. The
- 4:30common drivers for those really are ambiguous,
- 4:33vague, or omitted contractual provisions. I bet
- 4:36if I was to do a poll, of the attorneys on the
- 4:39call. And I asked how many of you actually enjoyed
- 4:42taking accounting classes or actually taking
- 4:44accounting classes. I would suspect it's a pretty
- 4:46small number of people on the phone. And it's
- 4:49because lawyers typically don't do the accounting.
- 4:52They don't do accounting for a very specific
- 4:54reason, because they want to pursue other things.
- 4:57And when you have accounting provisions that
- 5:00are within a contractual document, sometimes
- 5:04it leads to problems. The other issue is sometimes
- 5:08there's accounting differences. So you have the
- 5:10difference between historical practices and what
- 5:13we call generally accepted accounting principles
- 5:15or GAP. And then the other issue, which is really
- 5:19sometimes at the core, is there's misaligned
- 5:22incentives between what the buyer expects and
- 5:25what the seller expects. So let's first talk
- 5:28about networking capital. And then next slide.
- 5:34So what is networking capital? What is working
- 5:37capital? And I suspect there's some folks on
- 5:40the phone that don't know what working capital
- 5:41is. Well, working capital from an accounting
- 5:44perspective is current assets minus current liabilities.
- 5:47And what's that, right? Well, I like to think
- 5:50of working capital as breathing room. So let's
- 5:53assume you have a small business and you need
- 5:56to make payroll this Friday, right? Do you have
- 6:00enough cash in the bank to make your payroll?
- 6:03Well, to me, if the answer is yes, let's say
- 6:06you have oodles of cash, that's great. That means
- 6:08you probably have sufficient working capital
- 6:11to pay your debts as they come due. But if no,
- 6:15then you are deficient in working capital. And
- 6:19so what we define current assets as is things
- 6:22that you own that will turn to cash within the
- 6:25current year. So think of things like cash, cash
- 6:27is cash, obviously. Accounts receivable, hopefully
- 6:30your customers will pay you within a year. Inventory.
- 6:35Let's assume you have inventory. Well, hopefully
- 6:36you will turn that to cash within a year. And
- 6:39then you subtract from that the liabilities,
- 6:41which typically would be things that you owe,
- 6:43such as accounts payable. Think of things like
- 6:47payroll, mortgage payments, rent, insurance that
- 6:52comes due. These are all things that you pay
- 6:54in the normal course. So the things you have
- 6:57available, the current assets minus your current
- 6:59liabilities is working capital. Now what happens
- 7:02when a company is sold typically is that's kind
- 7:05of a nebulous number and So companies typically
- 7:09will be sold based on a target or a peg So we
- 7:13think the working capital as of the date of the
- 7:15deal is going to be X but that's kind of a difficult
- 7:18number to get out to get out of to get out because
- 7:22You know the business is operating. I mean if
- 7:25you if you're an ongoing business your working
- 7:27capital is really changing every day So it's
- 7:31a difficult number to get at, particularly if
- 7:33you're operating. So they set a peg, and it can
- 7:36be a very specific number. I've got a number
- 7:38here. This is for a deal we're actually currently
- 7:40working on. The peg is $13 ,060 ,103 .48. That
- 7:47is actually the number that is in the agreement
- 7:49between the parties. And what happens is there's
- 7:52typically an initial target amount that's put
- 7:55in the deal. And then after the buyer takes control
- 7:58of the company, there will be a final audit or
- 8:01final true up of working capital. Typically financial
- 8:04advisors or auditors will come in and they will
- 8:07audit the balance sheet as of a very specific
- 8:09date, the date of the deal, and they will put
- 8:11the working capital at a certain number. And
- 8:14there's typically a dollar -for -dollar difference.
- 8:17So if the peg was $13 ,060 ,000 XXX and the actual
- 8:22working capital comes in as of that date, there
- 8:25will be a dollar -for -dollar difference between
- 8:27the purchase price and what the seller and the
- 8:29buyer agreed to. And that either results in the
- 8:32seller receiving more money or the seller returning
- 8:35funds back to the buyer. And a lot of times,
- 8:38it'll be like escrow of funds that are held aside
- 8:41in order to make sure that the true So disputes
- 8:46arise because what happens is, and a lot of times
- 8:49we see this, is that the contracts between the
- 8:52buyer and the seller, the deal document, is ambiguous.
- 8:56It's vague, or sometimes key definitions are
- 8:59missing. And again, these were agreements written
- 9:03by non -accountants, and it's difficult sometimes
- 9:06for the accountants to figure out what was actually
- 9:08going on, and disputes arise. There's also differences
- 9:12between how the company was operated. And just
- 9:15think of a company that was a small business.
- 9:18The founder of the company is getting to the
- 9:20point where they want to make a transaction maybe
- 9:23for estate planning purposes, et cetera. So they
- 9:25ran the company a certain way and they accounted
- 9:28for things a certain way. And then what happens
- 9:30is you have a buyer comes in and then the buyer
- 9:33runs the business differently. The buyer has
- 9:35different accounting policies, has different
- 9:37ways of looking at things. And those differences
- 9:40can give rise to differences in the working capital.
- 9:44Things such as the inventory. How do you value
- 9:47inventory? How do you determine what accounts
- 9:51receivable are collectible and what needs to
- 9:54be written off? Well, those require judgments.
- 9:56So there's a lot of judgments that are made by
- 9:59the buyer when they come in. And those judgments
- 10:01do impact working capital as well. And so sometimes
- 10:05you get disputes that arise as a part of that.
- 10:08And what happens is a lot of times in these agreements,
- 10:12If there's a dispute regarding the working capital,
- 10:15that dispute will not be heard by a lawyer or
- 10:19a judge. That dispute will typically be heard
- 10:22by a neutral accountant. I've actually served
- 10:24in this role dozens of times myself, and I also
- 10:27do a lot of party -appointed work where I represent
- 10:30either the buyer or the seller in a transaction.
- 10:33Let's go to the next slide. The next type of
- 10:38dispute that typically arises is what we call
- 10:40an earn out. Imagine a company that is sold.
- 10:43I have a company right now that we're working
- 10:44with where the company was sold for roughly $100
- 10:47million. But the seller thought that the company
- 10:51was worth more than that. Sellers think the company
- 10:53is worth more like $150 million. Well, in order
- 10:56to get the deal done, the sellers agreed to an
- 10:59earn out, which means that they'll get a certain
- 11:02amount of money up front. And then they may get
- 11:05some additional compensation contingent upon
- 11:09certain post -deal performance, which can be
- 11:12earnings. And we'll see there on the slide EBITDA.
- 11:14Let's define EBITDA. EBITDA is earnings before
- 11:17interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization.
- 11:20Some people think that that looks a lot like
- 11:22cash flow, but you could do a deal based on revenue
- 11:25or some other financial metrics as well. So typically
- 11:29there would be another PEG, another target. Let's
- 11:32assume the earnings of the company are supposed
- 11:34to be X. If the earnings come in higher than
- 11:37X, then the sellers would get some additional
- 11:39compensation. That's typically how it works.
- 11:42Earnouts are also used typically for when you
- 11:45want the seller to stick around. So let's assume
- 11:48you have a founder who has a lot of great relationships,
- 11:52has key customers that they handle, et cetera,
- 11:56a lot of business knowledge. And you want the
- 11:57sellers to actually stick around after you buy
- 11:59the company. Well, a way to incentivize them
- 12:02to stick around is to put in an earn out as well.
- 12:05And so we have issues that come up because we
- 12:08have conflicts that arise because what happens
- 12:10is The buyer takes control of the company after
- 12:13the company is sold, and the buyer runs the business
- 12:16the way the buyer wants to run the business.
- 12:19Sometimes that's to the detriment of the person
- 12:23who has the earn out, because the person with
- 12:25the earn out wants everything to be done in a
- 12:27way that's going to maximize their earn out,
- 12:29the buyer may have different ideas, and so that
- 12:32you can see where sometimes that could lead to
- 12:34disputes, and it's very common as well. Let's
- 12:37go to the next one. So the last area where we
- 12:40really get involved in these post -acquisition
- 12:42disputes is in representations and warranty disputes.
- 12:46And so this is a situation, if you guys have
- 12:48seen these deal documents, you'll see that there's
- 12:51a section of the document that says the seller's
- 12:53representation. So the seller represents a bunch
- 12:55of stuff. Financial statements were prepared
- 12:58in accordance with GAAP. We've disclosed all
- 13:01liabilities to you. We've represented, we comply
- 13:05with laws, environmental, et cetera. So they
- 13:08represent a bunch of stuff. And then the buyer
- 13:10actually represents a bunch of things as well.
- 13:13And there can be disagreements post -close involving
- 13:16those representations. A lot of times it has
- 13:19to do with the accounting. Because again if you
- 13:22had a business that was accounting for certain
- 13:24things a certain way before the deal and Now
- 13:28the buyer comes in and changes things and thinks
- 13:31the way that they are doing it is correct Well,
- 13:34then they say well wait a minute seller you you
- 13:36you violated your representations because you
- 13:38weren't doing it right And so these are the things
- 13:41that come up. There's tax issues that come up
- 13:43There's environmental, and I think we probably
- 13:45have some environmental lawyers on the line.
- 13:48I mean, that's a whole nother area of the law,
- 13:50environmental law, right? And then you have legal
- 13:51disputes. Hey, we just got a subpoena that showed
- 13:54up as seller. You didn't tell us about this lawsuit.
- 13:57Those types of things can lead to disputes regarding
- 14:01representations and warranties. And it's interesting
- 14:05because there are insurance carriers now that
- 14:08provide insurance for this. It's difficult for
- 14:14the parties to get a claim paid. I don't believe
- 14:17I've ever seen a situation where the carrier
- 14:21did not at least deny the claim initially, saying,
- 14:24no, we're not going to cover that. But if you
- 14:26continue to fight, sometimes you can get some
- 14:27coverage. So those are really the main areas
- 14:31that we talk about when we're talking about post
- 14:33-acquisition disputes that would be working capital,
- 14:36number one, earn out, and then represent warranties
- 14:39disputes. Let's go to the next slide. So now
- 14:44I'm going to turn it over to Christina, who's
- 14:45really going to talk to you about contractual
- 14:46language. Okay. Thank you, Peter. Great. Let's
- 14:50go to the next slide. Perfect. Okay. So let's
- 14:55talk a little bit about how contract language
- 14:57can drive the outcome in these matters. One of
- 15:00the most important themes we'll discuss today
- 15:02is that courts generally do not resolve these
- 15:04types of disputes by asking, what is the best
- 15:07accounting answer? Instead, they're going to
- 15:09ask, what did the parties agree to in the contract?
- 15:12And that's a critical distinction. Attorneys
- 15:14sometimes assume that if an accounting issue
- 15:17arises after closing, the answer will be found
- 15:19somewhere in GAAP. But in practice, GAAP is often
- 15:22secondary to the language that the parties negotiated.
- 15:26If a purchase agreement contains a defined term
- 15:28for EBITDA, working capital, revenue, or debt
- 15:31-like items, courts and arbitrators will typically
- 15:33start there and often end there. We've seen situations
- 15:37where both parties accounting experts agreed
- 15:39on the technical accounting treatment, but the
- 15:41outcome was still driven entirely by how a term
- 15:43was defined in the agreement. And when the agreement
- 15:46is silent or unclear or ambiguous, that's when
- 15:49things become more complicated. In those situations,
- 15:52judges, arbitrators, and mutual accountants will
- 15:55frequently turn to contemporaneous evidence to
- 15:57determine what was the intent. So that might
- 15:59include things like diligence materials, draft
- 16:01agreements, management presentations. emails,
- 16:05exchange, share negotiations, text messages,
- 16:07quality of earnings reports, or other board materials.
- 16:10In other words, accounting records stop being
- 16:12just financial information. They become evidence.
- 16:15And that's one of the reasons forensic accounts
- 16:17become so heavily involved in these disputes,
- 16:20because we're often helping reconstruct not only
- 16:22what happened financially, but also what the
- 16:24parties understood and intended at the time of
- 16:26the transaction. So let's go to the next slide,
- 16:29please. and we'll talk about some key areas where
- 16:35language matters. Okay, so looking at some specific
- 16:38areas where contractual language frequently determines
- 16:41outcome. The first is the definition of financial
- 16:44metrics. Most disputes involve terms that sound
- 16:47simple on the surface, right? Like Peter has
- 16:49already discussed some of them, working capital,
- 16:51EBITDA, net debt, cash, debt -like items. But
- 16:54then once you start unpacking those terms, dozens
- 16:57of questions can emerge like, should deferred
- 17:00revenue be included? How are customer deposits
- 17:02treated? What about accrued bonuses? What about
- 17:04reserves? The level of specificity in the definition
- 17:08can dramatically impact the dispute risk. The
- 17:12second area is one that we've already touched
- 17:13on a little bit, gap versus consistency with
- 17:16historical or past practice. This is probably
- 17:18one of the most common sources of post -acquisition
- 17:21disputes because the buyer often wants financial
- 17:24information prepared in accordance with gap.
- 17:26and the seller often wants calculations that
- 17:29were performed consistently with their historical
- 17:31practice. And those concepts may sound compatible,
- 17:34but they aren't always. Because what happens
- 17:39if the seller's historical practice wasn't technically
- 17:42GAP compliant? Which standard controls? Peter
- 17:45and I have seen agreements that say calculations
- 17:47must be prepared in accordance with GAP applied
- 17:50consistently with past practice. Because that
- 17:53sounds reasonable until a gap and past practice
- 17:55point in two different directions. Then you've
- 17:58essentially built a dispute into the agreement.
- 18:01Another critical area is dispute resolution provisions.
- 18:05Many attorneys focus heavily on substantive provisions
- 18:08and devote less attention to the dispute mechanics.
- 18:11But those provisions can significantly impact
- 18:13the outcome as well. For instance, will the disputes
- 18:15be resolved in court? Are we going to do it in
- 18:17arbitration by a neutral accountant? Who will
- 18:20the neutral accountant be? What issues can the
- 18:23neutral decide? Like, can the neutral interpret
- 18:26the contract or can they only perform accounting
- 18:28calculations? All of these distinctions matter
- 18:31enormously and they can have a significant impact
- 18:33on the outcome. The next area is earn out operational
- 18:37evidence. As Peter discussed earlier, once the
- 18:41transaction closes, the buyer typically controls
- 18:43the business. And if the seller's future compensation
- 18:46depends on performance metrics, The agreement
- 18:49should address how the business will be operated.
- 18:53Will the buyer be required to act in good faith?
- 18:56Do the operations have to be substantially consistent
- 18:58with the activity before the transaction closed?
- 19:01Can certain expenses be allocated differently?
- 19:04Can key employees be terminated? When those provisions
- 19:07are absent or they're vague, disputes can become
- 19:10much more likely. And then finally, we have indemnification
- 19:14provisions and reps and warranties. the structure
- 19:17of caps, baskets, survival periods, and fraud
- 19:20carveouts can completely change the economics
- 19:22of a dispute. Even where liability appears limited,
- 19:26allegations of fraud may allow the parties to
- 19:28bypass contractual protections entirely. For
- 19:32the litigators in the room, you've probably seen
- 19:34cases where the fraud allegations become just
- 19:36as important as the underlying accounting issues.
- 19:39And let's go ahead and go to the next slide,
- 19:41please. We'll talk a little bit about practical
- 19:43implications. Okay. So what does this all mean
- 19:47in practice? The good news is that many disputes
- 19:50are preventable with careful drafting. Clear
- 19:53drafting can eliminate ambiguity before it ever
- 19:56becomes a problem. One of the best tools available
- 19:58is the use of examples and sample calculations.
- 20:01If the agreement contains a sample working capital
- 20:04calculations, a sample EBITDA calculation, or
- 20:07illustrative schedules showing how certain items
- 20:10should be treated, it becomes much more difficult
- 20:12for the parties to argue later about intents.
- 20:14When agreements are vague, disputes tend to shift
- 20:17away from accounting and toward interpretation.
- 20:20And interpretation battles are expensive, right?
- 20:22Because now we're hiring attorneys, we're hiring
- 20:24experts, we're exchanging expert reports, we're
- 20:27conducting discovery, we're taking depositions,
- 20:29all because two parties have different understandings
- 20:32of a few sentences written years earlier. You
- 20:36know, there's this joke out there that forensic
- 20:39accountants are often beneficiaries of poor drafting.
- 20:42The more ambiguity exists, the more work there
- 20:45is for experts to do. And from the client's perspective,
- 20:49ambiguity can be expensive and also avoidable.
- 20:52So, the clearer the agreement, the lower the
- 20:55likelihood that experts like Peter and I will
- 20:56need to become involved later. Okay. And let's
- 21:00go to the next slide, please. Hold on, before
- 21:02we go to the next slide. Let me go back. I just
- 21:04want to spend a couple minutes here. You know,
- 21:07my experience working with these agreements is...
- 21:10It may have an arbitration provision in there
- 21:13where if there's a post -acquisition dispute
- 21:16involving, let's say, working capital, earn out,
- 21:20it will be heard by a neutral accountant. So
- 21:23that's where I come in sometimes and will serve
- 21:25as a neutral accountant or will serve as a party
- 21:27appointed. But one of the things that's never
- 21:29addressed in these agreements is discovery. So
- 21:32if you have a dispute that's going to be heard
- 21:34by a neutral accountant, what do you do about
- 21:37discovery? What do you do about depositions?
- 21:39What do you do about normal interrogatories or
- 21:42the normal process of going through discovery?
- 21:45What happens a lot of times is the business gets
- 21:48sold. The buyer is in control of the business.
- 21:52The seller is now the out party. They no longer
- 21:55have access to records to people, et cetera.
- 21:57And then there's a dispute. Well, the seller
- 22:00needs access to information in order to make
- 22:02their case, but the agreement is totally silent
- 22:06on discovery. And that's not unusual. That's
- 22:10pretty much the rule. And so a lot of times you'll
- 22:13see the neutral accountants be asked to essentially
- 22:18serve as discovery referees. And this happens
- 22:20all the time. And so I agree. The other thing
- 22:23I didn't want to pass over too much is the issue
- 22:27of putting an illustrative example into your
- 22:30deal document. So just put it as an exhibit that
- 22:33says, this is how we're going to... calculate
- 22:36working capital because, yeah, there's a standard
- 22:39definition out there for working capital. But
- 22:43guess what? I've seen so many different definitions
- 22:46of working capital throughout my career. Just
- 22:48put something in the agreement that talks about
- 22:51what things are in, and more importantly, what
- 22:53things are out and how things should be calculated.
- 22:56I think that really does go a long way in minimizing
- 22:59potential disputes later. So let's go to the
- 23:03next one. So let's really talk about the role
- 23:06of forensic accountants and go to the next slide,
- 23:08please. So early involvement. I'm going to talk
- 23:14about quality of earnings or getting financial
- 23:17advisors involved here in the next slide or two.
- 23:20But there's an opportunity to get involved pre
- 23:24-deal. And I really do encourage particularly
- 23:28the sellers to do that, to really spend some
- 23:30time getting their company ready for sale. And
- 23:34so you could bring in financial advisors before
- 23:37the deal to do things such as look at the financials,
- 23:41look at how your financial statements are being
- 23:43prepared. Do you see any red flags associated
- 23:46with that? Normally, where I come in would be,
- 23:50and Christina comes in, is in the post -acquisition
- 23:53dispute world, where we're really being asked
- 23:55at that point to analyze the financial information,
- 23:59provide really independent expert opinions. So
- 24:02we will actually be drafting, let's say, an expert
- 24:05report to support our client's position in an
- 24:07arbitration. We will assist if asked. We'll go
- 24:12to mediation. We'll help try to settle the case
- 24:15with parties. We'll be asked a lot of times to
- 24:18quantify damages that are associated. Sometimes
- 24:20there's out of pocket damages. Sometimes there's
- 24:23delay damages. Sometimes there's other damages
- 24:25that arise. And we really assist in the resolution.
- 24:28And also, as I said, a lot of times we are actually
- 24:31asked to serve as the neutral or the actual judge
- 24:35jury. And I like to say executioner in the matter.
- 24:38So let's go to the next slide and talk about
- 24:41quality of earnings. So quality of earnings,
- 24:44you may have heard this term. It's kind of an
- 24:46industry in and of itself, but it's really sort
- 24:49of the kick the tires before the deal is done.
- 24:53And so the seller gets the opportunity to do
- 24:56that and the buyer gets the opportunity to do
- 24:58that. If you take my advice, if you're a seller,
- 25:02you're looking to sell the company, get your
- 25:04quality of earnings people or your financial
- 25:07advisors in early because a lot of times they're
- 25:11going to make recommendations what you should
- 25:14do to clean the business up, let's say, get it
- 25:16ready for sale. And I'm talking really more in
- 25:18an accounting perspective as opposed to other
- 25:19things. How are the financial statements being
- 25:22prepared? How are you accounting for certain
- 25:24items? Make sure you're doing those in a way
- 25:27that's going to be attractive to potential buyers.
- 25:30If you're not doing things in accordance with
- 25:32GAAP, well, go ahead and make some accounting
- 25:34changes so you are in accordance with GAAP. But
- 25:37then it takes some time. right, to have those
- 25:40things flow through the business and to get things
- 25:43back up and running, get things normalized, let's
- 25:45say, before the buyer comes in or potential buyers
- 25:48come in. So I would say on QAV side for sell
- 25:51side, and our firm does a lot of sell side deals,
- 25:54get in early. I mean, two years is not. too early
- 25:57to get in and try to get a business ready for
- 25:59sale. A lot of times we get calls, hey, you know,
- 26:02we want to sell our company next month and you
- 26:04come in and help us. Well, that's really too
- 26:06late. You can't really do too much. You need
- 26:07to give yourself six months to a year at least
- 26:10to get the business ready for sale. But some
- 26:13of the things we do is, you know, normalize EBITDA.
- 26:16So EBITDA, again, would be earnings of the company.
- 26:18Remove non -recurring items, right? Or what we
- 26:21say, you know, owner compensation related things.
- 26:24If, you know, the business owns three delivery
- 26:26trucks, two forklifts, a Lamborghini, a Porsche,
- 26:30and a Mercedes. Well, wait a minute. Let's go
- 26:32back. What about the Lamborghini, the Porsche,
- 26:34and the Mercedes? Those things are really not
- 26:36business assets. Those are things that the owner
- 26:38is just kind of flowing through the business.
- 26:40So let's get those things off the books, right,
- 26:42before we sell the business. And there's a whole
- 26:44bunch of other stuff in there that relates to
- 26:46really owner comp that you want to take out,
- 26:48normalize the earnings of the company before
- 26:50you put the company up for sale. So that's Q
- 26:54of E. Let's go to the next slide. The next one
- 26:58would be valuation gap. So we're talking about
- 27:01a valuation gap is just how do you adjust for
- 27:04informal financial metrics? So the buyer is going
- 27:08to assume some. some risk here, right? And I
- 27:12think that forensic accountants can help in kind
- 27:15of identifying what those things are. So the
- 27:17buyer comes in and does their own Q of E, and
- 27:20then they're going to identify certain things.
- 27:22And it's like the seller doesn't account for
- 27:27inventory. properly, we recommend that the seller
- 27:30or the buyer do a full physical count of inventory
- 27:33before the deal happens, et cetera. So really,
- 27:36it's trying to get these valuation of certain
- 27:39key assets, make sure that there's commonality
- 27:42between the seller and the buyer on valuation
- 27:45type issues. Let's go to the next slide. And
- 27:50this is, I think, you're going to take this one,
- 27:52right, Christina? Yeah, exactly. OK. So let's
- 27:55talk a little bit about the data room and due
- 27:58diligence readiness, right? So I think when most
- 28:01people hear the phrase data room, there's like
- 28:04a mix between excitement, mild anxiety, fear,
- 28:07just depending on where you're at emotionally.
- 28:10Forensic accountants tend to feel the same way.
- 28:12Virtually these days, every transaction involves
- 28:15some form of a centralized electronic repository
- 28:18containing financial records, contracts, operational
- 28:21information, and diligence materials. So, a well
- 28:25-organized data room does more than just facilitate
- 28:28diligence. It also helps establish credibility
- 28:31and build trust. If the information is complete,
- 28:35it's reconciled, it's readily accessible, it's
- 28:38organized, the buyer gains confidence in the
- 28:40quality of management's financial reporting.
- 28:43On the flip side, disorganized records tend to
- 28:46raise more questions, like if there's missing
- 28:48schedules, unexplained adjustments. multiple
- 28:51versions of the same financial document or inconsistent
- 28:54reports, those issues don't necessarily indicate
- 28:57fraud or misconduct, but they often create additional
- 29:00diligence scrutiny. So one practical observation
- 29:04that Peter and I have seen repeatedly is that
- 29:06disputes often arise not because information
- 29:08was hidden, but because the information was poorly
- 29:11organized or difficult to understand. Because
- 29:15the seller may believe disclosure occurred and
- 29:18the buyer may believe it never received the information.
- 29:21And then years later, the parties are arguing
- 29:23about who knew what and when. Good documentation
- 29:27can prevent those arguments. And from a litigation
- 29:29perspective, a well -maintained data room often
- 29:32becomes an important source of evidence regarding
- 29:34disclosure and intent. So the point is, be organized,
- 29:39be prepared, be complete. Data rooms are important.
- 29:43Let's just stop there for one second. What about
- 29:47file names? I mean, how many times, I mean, if
- 29:49you guys have been involved in deals and you
- 29:50go into a data room and you get file names that
- 29:53make absolutely no sense, right? When you're
- 29:56talking about getting organized, name files that
- 29:58make sense. So when you're making a disclosure
- 30:01about certain things, if you're talking about
- 30:02working capital, maybe put working capital in
- 30:05the name of the file. You know what I'm saying?
- 30:06Do that. Make it organized in a sense that someone
- 30:10who's really not connected to the deal, let's
- 30:12say, could go into the data room and make sense
- 30:15of how things are organized. That would really
- 30:17go a long way, frankly, in minimizing disputes
- 30:20later as well. Amen, Peter. OK, let's go to the
- 30:25next slide. We'll talk a little bit about fraud
- 30:28and financial misstatement risks. OK. So another
- 30:32area where forensic accountants frequently become
- 30:34involved is evaluating allegations of fraud or
- 30:37financial misstatement. Many middle market businesses
- 30:40are founder led organizations, and that's not
- 30:43inherently problematic. In fact, many highly
- 30:45successful companies are run that way. However,
- 30:48founder led organizations sometimes have weaker
- 30:50internal controls than larger companies would.
- 30:53Responsibilities may be concentrated among a
- 30:56small group of individuals, or you might have
- 30:58a limited segregation of duties. documentation
- 31:00may be informal or it may not exist at all. Adjustments
- 31:04could be made outside of the formal accounting
- 31:06processes. And these circumstances can all create
- 31:09risk. Importantly, risk does not necessarily
- 31:13mean fraud. One challenge that we see in post
- 31:16-acquisition disputes is that buyers occasionally
- 31:19discover accounting issues and immediately assume
- 31:22misconduct. But the reality is often more nuanced,
- 31:26like a financial statement may contain errors
- 31:28without any fraudulent intent. A reserve may
- 31:31be understated because management was overly
- 31:34optimistic rather than being deceptive. Part
- 31:38of the forensic accountant's role is to distinguish
- 31:40between intentional manipulation, aggressive
- 31:42accounting, and simple mistakes. We use tools
- 31:45like analytical procedures, transaction testing,
- 31:48data analysis, and other techniques to evaluate
- 31:51whether the financial information appears reliable.
- 31:54And those analyses often become important evidence
- 31:56in both litigation and settlement discussions.
- 32:00And then, so with that, I will turn it back to
- 32:02Peter, and we'll talk about some case studies
- 32:04and real -world examples. Yep. So these are actual
- 32:07case studies that we've worked on. Go to the
- 32:09next slide. So the names have been changed or
- 32:13not here to protect the innocent. Here's one.
- 32:18Normally, I would put up here, these are all
- 32:21cases that we won. Well, the first one I'm presenting
- 32:24is a case that we lost. This is a situation where
- 32:28we represented the seller. OK. And this was a
- 32:32seller that had a he was a brilliant, brilliant
- 32:35guy. Him and his brother started a company, software
- 32:38company. They built a better mousetrap for a
- 32:42certain application. And then they sold it off
- 32:45to a much larger company. OK. And they had a
- 32:48huge payday. It was wonderful. But a lot of the
- 32:51a lot of the compensation for the sale of the
- 32:55company, in my opinion, way too much was contingent
- 32:59upon an earn out. And so it took a relatively
- 33:02small amount of money up front and then was hoping
- 33:06for a big payday on the back end. And what happened
- 33:09is this is a seller -led, founder -led company.
- 33:13They were not necessarily recognizing revenue
- 33:16in accordance with GAAP. So again, software company,
- 33:20if they got a software sale for $100 ,000, they
- 33:24would recognize $100 ,000 of revenue. If you
- 33:28go to the gap associated with revenue recognition,
- 33:33well, gap says you can only recognize revenue
- 33:35when you meet certain performance criteria, parameters
- 33:40within the pronouncement itself. So you don't
- 33:44get to recognize $100 ,000 right up front, right?
- 33:47And so we have this issue where we have consistency
- 33:49of practice. Because the seller was thinking,
- 33:53well, yeah, for purposes of my earn out, I realize
- 33:55it wasn't gap. But we're going to be consistent,
- 33:59because if we measure the performance of the
- 34:01company on an apples -to -apples basis, which
- 34:03would be before the deal and post -deal, you
- 34:06got to measure it based on the way we used to
- 34:07measure revenue. OK, so then there's a big dispute
- 34:09over that, right? So then a neutral accountant
- 34:13arbitrator gets appointed. And what happens?
- 34:16Well, the neutral accountant arbitrator says,
- 34:19well, wait a minute, your agreement says gap
- 34:22consistently applied. So I am going to say the
- 34:27gap controls and does not. And so the way you
- 34:31historically recognize revenue is not right.
- 34:35And so I'm going to rule against you with respect
- 34:38to your earn out. And that was worth millions
- 34:40of dollars in compensation to this person. We
- 34:44felt horrible about it. But it was a situation
- 34:47where it wasn't the work that we did that ended
- 34:50up in. causing the issue. The issue was the agreement.
- 34:54And the issue was there was some ambiguity with
- 34:57respect to the earn out and how it was going
- 34:59to be treated post -closing. And so that was
- 35:04the issue there. So that's really the first example
- 35:10that we have. So let's go to the next slide.
- 35:14And we'll talk about another case study, a real
- 35:18world example, which involves a networking capital
- 35:20dispute that Peter and I were involved in. So,
- 35:23as we discussed earlier, working capital true
- 35:26ups are intended to ensure that the buyer receives
- 35:28the business with a normalized level of working
- 35:31capital at closing. So, in theory, that sounds
- 35:34like it should be fairly mechanical, but in practice,
- 35:37these disputes can become surprisingly complex.
- 35:40In this particular matter, the purchase agreement
- 35:43provided for a post closing purchase price adjustment
- 35:46based on the difference between the balance sheet
- 35:48at closing. And then a final audited balance
- 35:51sheet that would be prepared after the transaction
- 35:53closed. The challenge was that the agreement
- 35:56did not clearly define several key working capital
- 35:59components. They were just vague and ambiguous
- 36:03language. Like many disputes, we see the problem
- 36:06wasn't that the parties. Forgot to address working
- 36:08capital. The problem was that they thought that
- 36:11they had addressed it, but they left enough ambiguity
- 36:13for reasonable people to differ in terms of the
- 36:16conclusions that they reach. So, after the acquisition
- 36:19closed, the buyer applied accounting policies
- 36:22that differed from the. The policies that the
- 36:25seller had used in historical practice. And so
- 36:28the disagreement centered around 3 primary areas
- 36:311st accounts receivable and bad debt reserves.
- 36:35The buyer believed that additional reserves should
- 36:37be recorded because certain receivables appeared
- 36:40less collectible than what had been historically
- 36:42reflected on the seller's books. The seller thought
- 36:45that, hey, the historical reserve methodology,
- 36:47we've been using it consistently for forever,
- 36:50for years, and it accurately reflected their
- 36:52collection experience in the past. The second
- 36:55issue was inventory valuation. So the buyer believed
- 36:59additional adjustments were necessary to account
- 37:01for slow moving or obsolete items. The seller
- 37:04maintained that its historical inventory practices
- 37:07were appropriate and consistent with how the
- 37:09business had always been run. And then 3rd, we
- 37:12have this issue of a reserve account accruals.
- 37:15The buyer argued that certain liabilities and
- 37:17reserves were understated at closing and they
- 37:19should be increased. So disagree. So, as a result,
- 37:23what began as a purchase price adjustment exercise
- 37:26evolved into a dispute involving competing interpretations
- 37:30of accounting policies. historical practices
- 37:32and contractual language. The matter was ultimately
- 37:35submitted to an arbitrator for resolution. And
- 37:39then in this case, the arbitrator focused on
- 37:41the specific accounting issues submitted by the
- 37:42parties and evaluated them within the framework
- 37:45established by the contract. And the results
- 37:48is essentially a split decision. The arbitrator
- 37:51agreed with the seller on certain issues, including
- 37:54aspects of the receivables and the inventory
- 37:57valuation disputes. but then the arbitrator agreed
- 37:59with the buyer on certain other issues, including
- 38:02the reserve account rules. So neither side won
- 38:06everything, neither side lost everything. And
- 38:09frankly, that's a fairly common outcome and working
- 38:12capital disputes. It's rarely just like a total
- 38:14and complete victory for one side. From a forensic
- 38:18accounting perspective, both parties retain financial
- 38:20advisors to support their positions. The experts
- 38:23analyze relevant accounts, they've reconstructed
- 38:26the working capital calculation, they evaluated
- 38:28the historical accounting practices, and prepared
- 38:31written submissions supporting their clients'
- 38:34views. I'd say for me the key lesson from this
- 38:36case is that working capital disputes are rarely
- 38:39just math exercises, like the numbers matter,
- 38:42but the outcome is often dependent on definitions,
- 38:45assumptions, and accounting methodologies that
- 38:47are embedded in that purchase agreement. And
- 38:51when those provisions are ambiguous, the Truett
- 38:52process can become really messy. And then we're
- 38:55dealing with this months or years after the deal
- 38:57is closed. Let's go to the next one. And before
- 39:03we go to this last case example, I want to spend
- 39:08just a few minutes, because it might be worthwhile
- 39:11to just discuss what's our approach when I serve
- 39:14as a neutral accountant. What do I really try
- 39:17to get at? Because you have a situation where
- 39:21the agreement may be ambiguous, right? The agreement
- 39:25may be, there may just be, there's not even there.
- 39:28The issue that you need to address is not even
- 39:29covered by the agreement, right? Or it's vague
- 39:32and it's not really well defined. And so what
- 39:35happens in those? situations. And what I tell
- 39:38the parties is, and these things are normally,
- 39:41when you arbitrate these things, they're normally
- 39:43done through 100 % written submissions. So each
- 39:46party will be able to submit their case to a
- 39:50neutral accountant, have an initial brief, and
- 39:54the brief will include basically anything you
- 39:57want to throw in there. I would say kitchen sink,
- 39:59anything you want. So it can be obviously a brief
- 40:02written by the lawyers. can be an expert report
- 40:05written by your financial advisors, can be witness
- 40:08statements, can be accounting records, can be
- 40:11anything you want, photographs, whatever you
- 40:12want to do, throw it all in there to make your
- 40:15case. And if you've got a vague agreement, what
- 40:18I really like to look for is what are the contemporaneous
- 40:22documents, information that was available as
- 40:25of the time of the deal that really kind of set
- 40:28forth the party's positions? What is the intent?
- 40:32What was the intent of the transaction? Now,
- 40:35the buyer's intent and the seller's intent may
- 40:37differ. But let's understand where each party
- 40:40was in the negotiation and what they were bargaining
- 40:43for. And that's really what I try to get at.
- 40:46And so if the parties don't produce the information
- 40:48I want to see, I will typically ask for that
- 40:51information. Typically, there'd be an initial
- 40:53submission, and then there typically is a reply
- 40:55or rebuttal submission. And then you'll get a
- 40:57decision that comes from the arbitrator. That's
- 41:00how these things typically work. But if you've
- 41:03got an agreement that's not great, the more contemporaneous
- 41:07information you can come up with to support your
- 41:11position goes a long way in these types of disputes.
- 41:17This last case example that we have is the reps
- 41:20and warranties case that we just worked on. And
- 41:24this is a situation where it appears that the
- 41:28buyer is trying to get two bites at the apple.
- 41:31So let's assume you have, in this case, you have
- 41:33a situation where you did have a working capital
- 41:36true up. And as a result of the working capital
- 41:41true up, The seller actually had to pay the buyer
- 41:44a certain amount of money, a couple million dollars,
- 41:46and post -closing working capital true up. So
- 41:49the working capital that the seller delivered
- 41:52was under what the target was, so they had to
- 41:56pay two million to the buyer. You would think
- 41:59that would be the end of the argument, but the
- 42:01buyer came back and said, no, no, no, no, no.
- 42:04We still have arguments regarding inventory.
- 42:07So the seller's position was, well, wait a minute.
- 42:09We already discussed inventory. We already did
- 42:12a true up of inventory things such as You know
- 42:15a book to physical adjustment or you know issues
- 42:18of obsolete Inventory or the level of the inventory
- 42:21reserve, etc. All these types of things related
- 42:23to inventory You had your bite at the apple because
- 42:26you had your work in capital. Why are you coming
- 42:28after us for for for reps and warranties violation?
- 42:32Well, they say, you know you you had a non -gap
- 42:35way of accounting for inventory. Well Yes, that's
- 42:39true. We told you about that. Your QAV that you
- 42:43did, that you engaged a big four accounting firm
- 42:47to do, told you that the inventory was accounted
- 42:50in a certain way that wasn't necessarily GAAP.
- 42:52So you had plenty of disclosure. This isn't fraud.
- 42:55And a lot of times, what you have to prove in
- 42:58these cases is you got to get over that hump
- 43:00of intent and get over that hump of fraud. And
- 43:03so the sellers are arguing, yeah, there were
- 43:05problems. But number one, you had your bite at
- 43:08the apple. You had a working capital trip. So
- 43:10why are you complaining now about reps and warranties?
- 43:13And the buyer is saying, no, no, no, no, no.
- 43:15If we would have known you had all these problems,
- 43:17we never would have bought the company. Result
- 43:21of that was that the outcome was that the court
- 43:25agreed with the sellers that there was sufficient
- 43:28disclosure regarding these non cap issues, et
- 43:31cetera. And so that defeated the fraud claims.
- 43:34And they also agreed with the seller that the
- 43:37accounting inventories involved, et cetera, inventory
- 43:39and other things, that should have been covered
- 43:42in networking capital. So this was a win for
- 43:44the seller in this case. Well, Peter, I'm sorry.
- 43:48I just noticed we had a question that came in
- 43:51through the Q &A function. It's actually a good
- 43:52timing because we're talking about reps and warranties.
- 43:54The question was, what is a basket? What is a
- 43:58basket in reps and warranties? What is a basket?
- 44:01Yes. Well, I mean, you're talking about a basket
- 44:04of either assets or liabilities. Is that what
- 44:07we're talking about? Exactly. So let's just explain
- 44:09to them what a basket might be in this context.
- 44:12Well, I mean, a basket would be a accumulation
- 44:17of, let's say, assets or accumulation of liabilities.
- 44:20That's what I would say a basket is. Yeah, exactly.
- 44:22So just within the contract, there might be specific
- 44:25thresholds that are set out for certain buckets
- 44:28or items that go together, and they're bundled
- 44:32together into a basket. So there might be a specific
- 44:35dollar amount target that is set for certain
- 44:38baskets of items. Yeah, so you might have, I
- 44:41mean, current assets may be a basket. So a basket
- 44:44would be cash, accounts receivable, and inventory.
- 44:48So that's a basket of current assets. Current
- 44:51liabilities might be accounts payable and other
- 44:53accruals. That could be a basket of current liabilities.
- 44:58And it's typically defined within the contract.
- 45:02Yes, typically defined, but sometimes not. I
- 45:04mean, you might have an agreement that says current
- 45:05assets like current liabilities. I don't really
- 45:08like those types of agreements. Most people know
- 45:13that current assets typically involve these things,
- 45:18current liabilities typically involve these things.
- 45:20But let's just write out specifically. I mean,
- 45:23if you've got You know, 10 current asset accounts
- 45:26in your books and records, right? Just list them
- 45:28out, all 10 accounts. Current assets include
- 45:30these 10 accounts. Current liabilities include
- 45:32all these 10 accounts, right? That's going to
- 45:34go a long way in defeating any disputes later.
- 45:38I agree. I think my number one piece of advice
- 45:42or my takeaway would be, when it comes to drafting
- 45:44the contract, take your time. Take your time.
- 45:48Be very specific. and include illustrative examples
- 45:51because it will potentially save you a lot of
- 45:53Arctic down the road if you're very clear on
- 45:55what is or is not included. Okay, do we have
- 46:02any other questions? No, I don't think we have
- 46:05any current questions in the Q &A, so we could
- 46:07go to the next slide, which is key takeaways.
- 46:11Okay, so key takeaways. Post -acquisition disputes
- 46:16are driven primarily by contractual language.
- 46:19When I say contractual language, again, it's
- 46:21ambiguous, vague, omitted language. It's not
- 46:24there. It's not accounting theory. So that's
- 46:28number one. And that's really what I think drives
- 46:30most of these things, because you have an agreement
- 46:32that's not perfect. So working capital disputes,
- 46:37they're typically mechanical, but they're highly
- 46:41sensitive to definitions and consistency requirements.
- 46:44Remember that There are judgments. Accounting
- 46:49is not black and white. That's what I tell people.
- 46:53There are so many judgments that go into every
- 46:56single account. So you talk about accounts receivable,
- 46:59right? Well, accounts receivable have a thing
- 47:01called bad debt reserve, have a bad debt reserve
- 47:03associated with accounts. Well, the bad debt
- 47:06reserve is based on management's judgment. How
- 47:11much should we set aside? for bad debts. Well,
- 47:15that requires some thought of, well, what do
- 47:18we think with respect to what receivables are
- 47:23collectible, which receivables are not collectible,
- 47:26what's our historic level. And there's all these
- 47:28different types of adjustments that go into that
- 47:30when you're determining. that actual account
- 47:34value. So it involves all these judgments. And
- 47:37so working capital, yes, it's a mechanical calculation,
- 47:40but there is so much judgment that goes into
- 47:44every one of these accounts. It's really helpful,
- 47:46again, to have an example of what you mean. Earnout
- 47:51disputes. really arise from misaligned incentives,
- 47:55and I would say lack of operational constraints
- 47:57on the buyer. Because what happens when the buyer
- 47:59takes over the company, I mean, they're incentivized,
- 48:02obviously, to not pay as much, you know, they
- 48:04don't want to pay any more for the company. And
- 48:07so they're sort of incentivized not to pay the
- 48:09earn out in some respects. It depends, again,
- 48:12is the seller still actively involved in the
- 48:14business or not. But Bottom line is the buyer
- 48:18still has and takes control of the company and
- 48:20still can make operational decisions of the company.
- 48:23And those operational decisions are necessarily
- 48:26going to impact the earn out. And reps and warranties
- 48:31disputes. They often turn on financial misstatements.
- 48:38So again, it's arguments that things were not
- 48:40prepared in accordance with gap, disclosure gaps,
- 48:44or fraud considerations. If you had a situation
- 48:46where the seller repped, let's say that they
- 48:52didn't have with respect to certain contracts,
- 48:57or let's even assume legal dispute or they were
- 48:59being sued for something, and that was not properly
- 49:02disclosed as part of the deal, then you really
- 49:05do, I think, have a serious reps and warranties
- 49:07issue. But if you're using reps and warranties
- 49:09as just another mechanism to get a purchase price
- 49:12adjustment, I don't find that those things succeed
- 49:15very often. The next one is, you know, forensic
- 49:18accountants may assist with various types of
- 49:20disputes. Well, we've talked about it. Forensic
- 49:23accountants can assist before the deal. Forensic
- 49:26accountants certainly assist post -deal where
- 49:30they're either representing the party or assisting
- 49:32the party in resolving the dispute or actually
- 49:34serving as a neutral arbitrator themselves. And
- 49:39then ambiguity and omissions in the purchase
- 49:41agreement really do kind of fall to the experts
- 49:44because if you, you know, it says Financial statements
- 49:48are going to be prepared in accordance with GAAP.
- 49:50Well, what is GAAP? Well, we better get an expert
- 49:52in here and explain what it is and how you're
- 49:53supposed to do that. That's how they help. Then
- 49:56the last key, which I think we've been harping
- 49:59on this whole time, is this well -drafted agreements
- 50:02can prevent disputes. Again, if you really want
- 50:06to have an agreement that is you know, bulletproof
- 50:10and at least as bulletproof as you can make it
- 50:13to not have a dispute. Put an example in the
- 50:17back of the agreement as to how you're doing
- 50:19the calculation with respect to working capital
- 50:21and earn out and use real numbers. So take numbers.
- 50:25from the company's financial statements, plug
- 50:28them into an example and show this is how we're
- 50:30going to do the working capital true up. This
- 50:33is how we're going to calculate the earn out.
- 50:35And if you have that amount of specificity there,
- 50:37you're probably not going to have a dispute that
- 50:40goes to litigation. We're happy to take questions
- 50:49from the audience. If there are any, please feel
- 50:51free to use the Q &A function. We will be happy
- 50:54to. Assist. You know, Peter, let's let's just
- 51:02talk for a minute about gap because for the attorneys
- 51:05in the room, they may not be familiar with what
- 51:07gap is and it may come as a surprise to them
- 51:10that it often is not. Yeah, that can often be
- 51:13principles based. It's more conceptual as opposed
- 51:15to providing mechanical definitions for how you
- 51:19calculate something. So, for instance, Peter
- 51:21gave a great example a minute ago when he was
- 51:23talking about. An allowance for uncollectible
- 51:27accounts, right? So there's many gap basically
- 51:30says that it's a best practice to establish an
- 51:33allowance for uncollectible accounts for people
- 51:35that you think aren't that you're not going to.
- 51:37People that aren't going to pay basically right?
- 51:39And there is. A spectrum of different ways to
- 51:44calculate that, and it can vary based on judgment
- 51:47based on past practice. So, for instance, there
- 51:49could be a scenario where the company says. If
- 51:52anything's over 120 days old, we're gonna reserve
- 51:55all of that. Other people might say, no, I'm
- 51:57gonna do 180 days. Other people might go on literally
- 52:01like a customer by customer basis and assess
- 52:03the likelihood that that customer is going to
- 52:05pay. So as you can imagine, and I just gave three
- 52:08different examples, you can get very different
- 52:10results depending on which you think is appropriate.
- 52:14Gap does not tell you. anything over 180 days
- 52:18you have to reserve for. It doesn't say anything
- 52:20over 120. It basically says, using management's
- 52:25best evidence, what do you think is a reasonable
- 52:28amount to reserve for? And so this is a perfect
- 52:31example where, including an illustrative example
- 52:33saying, well, historically, we've done anything
- 52:36over 120, could put 120 days, could really help
- 52:40to mitigate some of the risk that it will pop
- 52:44up later in a dispute. Peter, I mean, so there
- 52:48are quite a few things that are actually subject
- 52:50to estimates. Reserves, inventory evaluation,
- 52:56the list goes on and on. Honestly, actually,
- 52:57if you were to look at a company's balance sheet,
- 53:00aside from maybe cash, you'd be surprised. There
- 53:03are very few items on there that are really not
- 53:05subject to some degree of uncertainty and estimates.
- 53:10Yeah, I agree. So we have another one in the
- 53:12case that we're working on. It's a company that
- 53:16manufactures fairly simple products. And the
- 53:20issue is the inventory reserve. So you're supposed
- 53:23to have a reserve for excess and obsolete inventory.
- 53:26Question becomes, how much? And so the buyer's
- 53:32position is we're going to write off 100 % of
- 53:36everything that hasn't moved for six months.
- 53:38Seller's position is, wait a minute, this stuff's
- 53:41not perishable. and they continue to have value.
- 53:45So this is a company that makes customized products
- 53:47for customers. And so when they make customized
- 53:49products, they have to have a certain amount
- 53:52of excess, certain amount of leftover inventory
- 53:55when they do a custom run, because that customer
- 53:58is typically going to call up and ask for additional
- 54:00units. Hey, we need some replacements. Hey, we
- 54:03need some new stuff. And they need to keep stuff
- 54:05on the shelf. Now, if you just have some arbitrary
- 54:09way of coming up with an inventory reserve that
- 54:13says anything that hasn't sold in six months,
- 54:16you're writing off inventory, in my view, there
- 54:19that still has some net realizable value. And
- 54:22this is an issue that's causing a $30 million
- 54:24dispute between the parties. And again, could
- 54:28have been avoided if during the deal, the parties
- 54:32had more definition around how things were going
- 54:35to be accounted and what's the policy for establishing
- 54:38an inventory reserve. Yeah, here and we've had
- 54:42a couple items come in through the Q and a, so
- 54:45I will I'll read off the 1st 1. Okay, can you
- 54:48speak to indebtedness and working capital definitions?
- 54:51How to distinguish between short term payables
- 54:54versus longer term debt. And let's just stop
- 54:57and answer that 1. there's a 2nd part to it as
- 54:59well. Well, you want to take it or want me to
- 55:01take it. Do any define it carefully and include
- 55:05examples would be okay. Yeah, so indebtedness.
- 55:10So typically, let's talk about indebtedness.
- 55:12So we've got loans, right? And let's assume we've
- 55:16got a mortgage, and then we have a credit line
- 55:18at the bank, OK? So the credit line, a lot of
- 55:22times, I'm going to say that this credit line
- 55:24needs to be brought to zero every year. So you
- 55:27need to pay it off, bring it to zero every year.
- 55:30So that is going to meet the definition of a
- 55:33current liability. So a current liability is
- 55:37What obligations do I have coming up that are
- 55:40going to be due and payable in the next year?
- 55:44So the total balance on a credit line that has
- 55:48to be brought to zero is going to be the total
- 55:50amount of whatever's outstanding. That's the
- 55:52current liability. But now let's take a 30 -year
- 55:55mortgage. 30 -year mortgage, in the next year,
- 55:59I only have to make, let's say, 12 payments.
- 56:02monthly payments on my mortgage. So what you
- 56:05do is you take the current portion of long -term
- 56:08debt as current, as a current liability. So it's
- 56:11only those 12 payments that you would include
- 56:15as a current liability. So 30 -year mortgage,
- 56:17let's just say, is year one. My first -year payments
- 56:20are going to be current liability. 29 additional,
- 56:23the 29 years that I owe coming up down the line,
- 56:27that is long -term debt. That is not a current
- 56:29liability. So hopefully that Makes it makes sense
- 56:33there. Yeah, and then as Peter, so that's a good
- 56:37example, right? Because that's an interesting
- 56:39point where so that in that 30 year mortgage.
- 56:41If you were to look at the company's balance
- 56:43sheet, you'll actually there'll be 2 different
- 56:45entries for it. There'll be the current portion
- 56:47of the mortgage, which is what's due and payable
- 56:49in the next 12 months. And then there's the long
- 56:52term portion of that debt, which is years. 2
- 56:55through 30, right? Okay. And then Peter, there
- 56:58was a 2nd part to this question as well. How
- 57:00to address prepaid amounts from services or deposits
- 57:04made for future performance? Yep. So prepaid,
- 57:08so let's... Like a retainer, perhaps? Yeah, a
- 57:14retainer or, you know, another prepaid most businesses
- 57:17have, let's say insurance. So I'm going to put,
- 57:21you know, get my insurance bill. It's good for
- 57:23a whole year. I'm going to pay that whole year
- 57:28upfront. I'm going to pay my insurance upfront.
- 57:30But it's good for a whole year. So essentially,
- 57:32what happens is that current portion, so today,
- 57:36this month's expense for insurance, you're going
- 57:39to recommend, let's just make it easy. It's $1
- 57:42,200. So initially, I'm going to put $1 ,200
- 57:47as a prepaid asset. That's a current asset on
- 57:51the balance sheets for $1 ,200 because I paid
- 57:53my insurance. Now, after month one, I'm going
- 57:57to essentially amortize that prepaid. So it's
- 58:00$100 a month. What happens is I'm going to expense
- 58:02$100, and hopefully I'm not... I'm losing you
- 58:05guys, but I'm going to spend $100 after month
- 58:08one. So my prepaid balance after month one is
- 58:11going to be $1 ,100. It's not going to be $1
- 58:13,200, OK? So I've got 11 months remaining. And
- 58:16so you're going to do that every month until
- 58:18you whittle down that prepaid balance to zero
- 58:20over the course of a year. And hopefully that
- 58:23makes sense to the person who asked the question.
- 58:27And then, Peter, we have another question as
- 58:29well. Do you have experience with disputes arising
- 58:31under reps and warranties insurance policies?
- 58:34that you could share. So I think the short answer
- 58:37would be, yes, we've seen it. In fact, I think
- 58:39we've actually seen an uptick recently and probably
- 58:41claims being submitted. Whether or not the claim
- 58:45is accepted is a different question entirely.
- 58:50Well, I apologize to anybody who sells this insurance
- 58:53out there who may be on the line, but I think
- 58:57that there's an uptick in the amount of reps
- 59:00and warranties insurance that's being sold. Okay.
- 59:03But in my experience, I have never seen, and
- 59:07I'm just a sample of one, okay? So, but I've
- 59:10talked to people on this field as well. It's
- 59:12very difficult to get the carriers to pay on
- 59:14this, okay? It just is. So maybe if you have
- 59:17a clear situation where, again, let's assume
- 59:20as seller rep that they didn't have any lawsuits
- 59:23and all of a sudden a lawsuit turned up and it
- 59:27was filed way before the deal closed and everything
- 59:31else. So you got really good facts. Yeah, I think
- 59:33maybe there's some insurance that can be collected
- 59:35there. But a lot of times there's shades of gray.
- 59:37We've got a case right now where parties are
- 59:41trying to collect, unwrap some warranties, insurance.
- 59:43It involves inventory. And the carrier has all
- 59:47kinds of arguments to say, and they're using
- 59:49the same arguments that we heard before. Well,
- 59:51wait a minute. You had a working capital true
- 59:52up. Should have been covered there. This isn't
- 59:55fraud. This isn't reps and warranties. This should
- 59:57have happened in the normal course with the working
- 1:00:01capital true up. And so I haven't seen, I mean,
- 1:00:04I've never seen it. Every deal I've ever seen,
- 1:00:07there's always a denial letter. In the file,
- 1:00:09OK, so first thing you make a claim against the
- 1:00:11carrier and there's going to be a denial letter,
- 1:00:13at least initially that they were not covering
- 1:00:15this claim. That's my experience. I think that
- 1:00:20that's I think that that's probably many people's
- 1:00:24experience with this matter, right? And then
- 1:00:26it's just, you know, try, try again and see if
- 1:00:29you get a different result next time. Maybe down
- 1:00:32the line you get some negotiation and you get
- 1:00:34some coverage, but it's not. I don't think it's
- 1:00:38a safe harbor for these deals in any way. That's
- 1:00:42just my own opinion. So, Peter, we are at time.
- 1:00:45We're at 130, which I believe means that many
- 1:00:48people probably need to get to the next appointment,
- 1:00:49but there are still 2 questions left in the Q
- 1:00:52and a. I'm game if you are. Yeah, let's finish.
- 1:00:55Okay. All right. So there's 1 question, which
- 1:00:58is this kind of interesting 1, what is the pre
- 1:01:01closing consulting work that a firm like yours
- 1:01:03can help. with a limited budget and a small deal
- 1:01:07of under $500 ,000 sale of assets, or is that
- 1:01:11just too small to care about? Well, I mean, it's
- 1:01:17tough, right? Because when you deal with professional
- 1:01:20rates and you're dealing with a deal that's a
- 1:01:23$500 ,000 deal, your consultants can cost a lot
- 1:01:27of money. And really, you should probably save
- 1:01:32your money and and not hire them. But if you're
- 1:01:36talking about a really shoestring budget, what
- 1:01:40I would recommend is you would always say, take
- 1:01:45a walk down the balance sheet. So what's on the
- 1:01:48balance sheet? And what do those amounts look
- 1:01:51like? What do those assets look like? What do
- 1:01:53those liabilities look like? And then go and
- 1:01:57see, well, what are the policies and procedures
- 1:01:59with respect to how you've been accounting? for
- 1:02:02revenue, for instance. And then look at things
- 1:02:05that are easy to clean up, like adjustments to
- 1:02:09earnings that are non -recurring. So let's say
- 1:02:15you had some major repairs that you had to do
- 1:02:17to. building or something like that. That's going
- 1:02:20to be non recurring. You're going to want to
- 1:02:22make sure that that's not reflected in your go
- 1:02:24forward earnings. If you have a bunch of stuff
- 1:02:26in there related to owner compensation, I would
- 1:02:29try to take those out. That's going to boost
- 1:02:31your earnings and make the business more attractive
- 1:02:34and those types of things. But I would say bottom
- 1:02:36line for a $500 ,000 deal, you are not going
- 1:02:40to get a lot of firms such as ours to want to
- 1:02:42sign up for that just because it doesn't pencil
- 1:02:44out from a cost benefit perspective. And I agree.
- 1:02:49Okay. And then so Peter last question. Could
- 1:02:52you share some of your experience with price
- 1:02:54allocation, goodwill and intangible assets valuations?
- 1:02:59Oh, those are potentially some of the more complex
- 1:03:02items to that. So price allocation. Goodwill
- 1:03:06and intangible assets valuations. Yeah, well,
- 1:03:10I mean, listen, we deal with those things. But
- 1:03:14typically, those things are not in the context
- 1:03:17of post -acquisition dispute. So we're not dealing
- 1:03:19with things such as Goodwill. It's not a current
- 1:03:23item on the balance sheet. So we're not dealing
- 1:03:25with that as part of post -acquisition. But we
- 1:03:27do deal with that as part of our commercial dispute
- 1:03:30practice, right? And so we do have to deal with
- 1:03:33things such as that. When company A is suing
- 1:03:37company B over IP related issues or anything
- 1:03:41like that. I mean, that's the normal course.
- 1:03:43And when we're doing valuation, we typically
- 1:03:45use the three primary steps, which would be we
- 1:03:48usually look at cash, right? So discounted cash
- 1:03:50flow, we look at costs, look at the market, and
- 1:03:53then we look at asset approach. So those are
- 1:03:55the three methods that we use when we're doing
- 1:03:58that. Is there another piece of that question
- 1:03:59that I missed, Christina? I don't believe it's
- 1:04:02just, could you share some of your experience
- 1:04:03with price allocation, goodwill, and intangible
- 1:04:06assets valuations? Well, let me deal with price
- 1:04:09allocation. We've got another case where we're
- 1:04:10dealing with price allocation. Price allocation
- 1:04:13or purchase price allocation is an art and it's
- 1:04:19a science. It's a situation where you've got
- 1:04:22different stakeholders at the table, and there's
- 1:04:26different motivations for those stakeholders
- 1:04:28at the table. The buyer of the company needs
- 1:04:32to take the purchase price that they paid for
- 1:04:34the company and then assign it based on fair
- 1:04:36value to the assets and the liabilities of the
- 1:04:39company. And if there's excess value there, they
- 1:04:41create something called goodwill. But there are
- 1:04:44all kinds of tax implications associated with
- 1:04:48that. There are depreciation and amortization
- 1:04:53issues associated with what values you assign
- 1:04:55to certain assets, equipment, any type of asset.
- 1:04:59How you depreciate that is going to determine
- 1:05:01your earnings of the company going forward. Usually
- 1:05:05the other person that's in the room or lurking
- 1:05:07thereabouts is going to be the external auditor,
- 1:05:09and they're going to have to come in and they're
- 1:05:10going to audit those price allocations. They're
- 1:05:13going to have to get satisfied that those price
- 1:05:16allocations were done in accordance with GAP.
- 1:05:18okay so you got all these sort of competing motivations
- 1:05:21there and i can tell you someone who's been a
- 1:05:23fly on the wall and he's in these and then the
- 1:05:25room when they're doing this it's kind of some
- 1:05:28horse trading to be honest with you it's not
- 1:05:30a exact science it's you know how much can we
- 1:05:35do here to get everybody assigned to these assets
- 1:05:40and these liabilities because we've got tax motivations
- 1:05:43and all these other things I just described.
- 1:05:47It's not black and white. There are shades of
- 1:05:50gray all over the place when you're doing price
- 1:05:52allocations. Okay. Well, I believe that was the
- 1:05:57last question from the Q &A. So, Peter, I think
- 1:06:00we could go ahead and wrap up. Well, thank you
- 1:06:03very much, everybody. Really appreciated your
- 1:06:05time. I hope you learned something here. We certainly
- 1:06:07have enjoyed the opportunity to speak to you
- 1:06:09today. Thank you very much. Thank you.