Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep18: GRD018: To Convert or Not To Convert Pt. 2
Transcript
- 0:00Intro: Hi, I'm Ed Slott.
- 0:01And I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we are two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the savers, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic with the.
- 0:23Helping you keep more of your hard-earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip
- 0:29a coin winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want
- 0:33to argue, and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respect positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner you, a more
- 0:45informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate to your
- 0:49own personal situation to decide what's.
- 0:51For you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:02Ed Slott: Hi everyone, I'm Ed Slott along with Jeff Levine and welcome
- 1:05back to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:07Now, if you remember last time we really got into it whether to convert
- 1:12to a Roth or not, and I would have to say I probably lost, I did lose the
- 1:16to the coin toss and I had to take an argument that I might not agree with.
- 1:22But as usual, Jeff, we wanna give people both sides of the coin, and I
- 1:26took the side for reasons when it might not be favorable to convert to a Roth.
- 1:30And it got so, uh, it, we got so into it that we had to make two episodes.
- 1:35So this is the beginning of part two.
- 1:37So Jeff, continuing from last week, here are even more reasons or situations
- 1:42where it may be more favorable.
- 1:44Not to convert to a Roth ira.
- 1:47It's all about the tax rates and that's what this Roth conversation is
- 1:50about, to convert or not to convert.
- 1:52It's a big giant bet on where you think where, uh, where tax rates
- 1:57are today versus what they might be in the future at distribution time.
- 2:02If you think tax rates will be higher later on, as Jeff just said,
- 2:05than, uh, the Roth is a good deal.
- 2:08If you think tax, your own tax rates might be lower.
- 2:12But you have to look beyond too.
- 2:14Uh, you might even look towards beneficiaries.
- 2:17I remember one guy, uh, telling me years ago, and I, I told him
- 2:20all about converting and I talked about the tax rate argument and he
- 2:24said, well, I don't mind it for me.
- 2:26Uh, but, uh, to put it nicer than he put it, he says, I got three
- 2:30kids and they're all losers.
- 2:32Uh, they'll never be in a house
- 2:34Jeffrey Levine: That was nicer than he put huh?
- 2:36Ed Slott: What's that?
- 2:36Jeffrey Levine: That was nicer than he put it?
- 2:38Ed Slott: Oh, that was way nicer.
- 2:39. Jeffrey Levine: Okay.
- 2:42. Ed Slott: He said they will never be in a high bracket, but granted that was
- 2:45back in the days of the stretch IRA, and he said they're gonna always be a
- 2:49low bracket, so that might be a little different now with the 10 year rule.
- 2:52But you have to look beyond the tax rates.
- 2:55You know, if you leave an IRA to beneficiaries, remember the more
- 3:00tax returns, you could spread that income over, and that is
- 3:03totally about the beneficiaries.
- 3:04Let's, for example, even under the 10 year rule, if you have three kids
- 3:09and they wanted to spread out, uh, the distributions on the IRA that you
- 3:14didn't convert, that you left to them, and they wanted to do it over 10 years,
- 3:19they could spread that income over 30 different tax returns, 10 years times,
- 3:24uh, for each of the three of them and get that money out at almost nothing.
- 3:29Now that's on the backend.
- 3:30That may be a concern for you too.
- 3:32Another reason.
- 3:33So that may be a reason to hold on.
- 3:35Not convert and let them get that money out at bargain basement
- 3:39rates, especially if they themselves may be in lower brackets.
- 3:42Again, it's all about the brackets, the marginal rates now versus
- 3:46when the money has to come out.
- 3:47Another reason.
- 3:49Okay, go ahead.
- 3:49Jeffrey Levine: Good.
- 3:49Yeah.
- 3:49Lemme pause you there, Ed, because you know you're talking about the brackets
- 3:53and the rates and when people get stuff, but you know, one of the things that makes
- 3:56IRAs different from just about every other type of asset is that you can't get it
- 4:00to someone else until you are dead right?
- 4:03There's no way to gift an IRA to, to other heirs during lifetime.
- 4:08And most of the time, married couples, uh, will end up leaving their IRA
- 4:11to each other first, and then when the second one passes away, that's
- 4:15when it goes down to the kids.
- 4:16Well, you talk about that and you said spreading, you know, spreading
- 4:21the tax bills over lots of different returns, which sounds great, but while
- 4:25you're alive, there's just one return.
- 4:27You could spread it over yours, and if you are married and one of you passes
- 4:31away and the survivor lives for some sort of extended period of time, you
- 4:36go from using the nice joint brackets down to the single brackets, which
- 4:41get you to much higher tax rates at much lower income levels and so that
- 4:48can end up being a significant impact.
- 4:50Sometimes people refer to as the widow or widowers penalty, and effectively what
- 4:55happens is someone who's surviving can end up with slightly less income cuz you
- 5:00lose the lower social security check.
- 5:02and you sometimes lose pensions, etc.
- 5:04Uh, there's that word again, Ed.
- 5:05Uh, but you can sometimes lose some income, but still end up with a
- 5:10significantly higher tax bill because you're paying a higher rate, because now
- 5:15you're filing as a single individual.
- 5:16So converting while both members of a couple are alive is almost like
- 5:21buying, uh, tax bracket insurance.
- 5:25You're ensuring that you can use those joint brackets as
- 5:28opposed to the single brackets.
- 5:29Ed Slott: But again, it all comes down to if you think you'll be
- 5:31in a lower rate in retirement, some people believe they will be.
- 5:35Another reason you may not wanna convert, at least everything is if you're
- 5:39anticipating, and a lot of people are, large medical bills, as you get older.
- 5:45You wanna have, if the only money, if that's where most of your money
- 5:48is, is an taxable IRA, you're not gonna wanna convert that because if
- 5:53medical bills go really high, and I have to tell you the last 10 years, it
- 5:58hasn't been unusual to see tax returns where people claim over a hundred
- 6:03thousand dollars of medical expenses.
- 6:05I had this, you know, with my own, uh, mother recently, uh, nurses age, uh,
- 6:10uh, nursing homes, uh, all, all kinds of uh, medical home improvements, ramps
- 6:15and railings and chair lifts and stair lifts and widening doorways and hallways.
- 6:21Bathroom and kitchen modifications.
- 6:22These are big ticket items.
- 6:24If the only money available to pay for that is in an IRA, don't convert it.
- 6:29Use that IRA.
- 6:31If you convert it to a Roth, now you paid tax on money you could have
- 6:35got a deduction for that would be a reason to keep some of that IRA money
- 6:40use it to pay these medical bills.
- 6:42At least you'll get somewhat of an offsetting deduction.
- 6:45I know there's a threshold amount, but I'm talking about big ticket items.
- 6:49Uh, you'll get some type of big tax benefit by using regular IRA money.
- 6:55And there's another reason you have to be careful and you
- 6:58should always do a projection.
- 6:59One thing with Roth conversions, you better be careful what you
- 7:03do because they are permanent.
- 7:05There's no backies, there's no getting your money back.
- 7:07There's no do overs.
- 7:09That stopped a few years back.
- 7:11We used to call them Roth re-characterization, so I
- 7:14wouldn't be so quick to convert.
- 7:16I, I'm not saying that should deter you, but you have to have
- 7:19an accurate tax, pro projection.
- 7:21You have to know what it's going to cost before you buy in because
- 7:24you can't get your money back.
- 7:26So those are some other reasons.
- 7:28I'll throw in one more reason.
- 7:29This may not affect a lot of people, but right now we have this, uh,
- 7:33oddball deduction, which does help a lot of self-employed people.
- 7:37The qualified business income deduction.
- 7:41If you convert to a Roth and you have a, uh, maybe you have a small business
- 7:45that has passed through income or your Schedule C, self-employed, or you have
- 7:49an S Corp or an L L C or a partnership, we have passed through income.
- 7:53You may or may not be always run this by your tax advisors.
- 7:58Uh, you may qualify for a huge 20% deduction.
- 8:03If you are under certain income limits for certain groups, without getting into
- 8:07the weeds on this, a Roth conversion can actually kill that and cost in
- 8:12the wrong year, uh, cost you a big tax deduction on your business income.
- 8:16So those are other things, not to mention if maybe your younger or you're
- 8:20paying for a, a college and uh, uh, you, the income from a Roth conversion
- 8:25could throw you out for financial aid.
- 8:27So there are, uh, reasons on both sides of this debate.
- 8:31Jeffrey Levine: You know, Ed, you, you hit on something there that, uh, it's not
- 8:34an argument for my side nor an argument against my side, but just a point that
- 8:38I think that we should really hit on.
- 8:40You talked about the phasing out of this Q B I deduction, and that's just
- 8:44one example, this business deduction that Ed was just talking about, that,
- 8:48you know, that's just one example.
- 8:49There are credits that phase out as income goes up, there are other deductions
- 8:54that phase out as income goes up.
- 8:55Ed Slott: IRMAA charges, or what we call sur taxes.
- 8:57Jeffrey Levine: Exactly.
- 8:58Sur taxes, right.
- 8:59The 3.8% investment, surtax, all the good things basically that
- 9:03are on a tax return that go away.
- 9:04Yeah.
- 9:04Where the bad things that come in are somehow keyed to income and, and so
- 9:09when we talk about rates, so oftentimes people associate rates with brackets.
- 9:15The brackets help to inform what the rate is, but they don't
- 9:19determine what the rate is.
- 9:21There are times when you might be in a lower bracket but be paying a
- 9:24higher tax rate because you're phasing yourself out of some sort of credit or
- 9:28deduction you may not get in the future because of circumstances changing.
- 9:32For instance, you know, if you phase yourself out of an education, uh, credit.
- 9:36Right.
- 9:36Well, you only get that credit maybe while you or your kids are in school.
- 9:40Once they're outta school, you don't have to worry about phasing
- 9:41yourself out of the credit anymore cause you don't get it to begin with.
- 9:44So, and whenever you're doing this and talking with your financial
- 9:48professionals, either a tax advisor or your financial advisor, it's important
- 9:52not to fall into the bracket trap of just looking at what bracket you're in.
- 9:56You have to look at the, uh, the full picture.
- 9:59Now, ed, I wanna bring up, one maybe last argument here from my
- 10:02side and I think it is my, my Trump card, and that is peace of mind.
- 10:08You know, peace of mind.
- 10:09Uh, when we talk about retirement, there are so many unknowns.
- 10:12How long will I live?
- 10:14What will interest rates be?
- 10:15What will markets do?
- 10:17What, you know, what will my health be like?
- 10:19What will inflation be?
- 10:21All of these are unknown.
- 10:23So is what will my future tax rate?
- 10:25Will, uh, what will my future tax rate be?
- 10:27Unless that money is sitting in a nice, beautiful tax free account
- 10:32like the Roth IRA and there, even if I've overpaid a little bit.
- 10:37Now, I certainly wouldn't suggest people make foolish decisions and dramatically
- 10:42overpay, but if you're not sure.
- 10:44There are some times when people will just do things because it gives
- 10:47them peace of mind and security.
- 10:49The same thing goes for, for people who maybe, you know,
- 10:53like Ed, I know you drive a car.
- 10:56Thankfully, you are in a position where if, God forbid something happened,
- 10:59if you, if there was an accident and someone hit your car, uh, you
- 11:02would be able to pay to fix your car.
- 11:04You don't need insurance on your car.
- 11:06You don't need collision insurance, but you own it because
- 11:09it gives you peace of mind.
- 11:10And the same thing comes with the Roth.
- 11:12And by the way, Anytime you buy insurance, theoretically on the whole, it should
- 11:17be a losing proposition, otherwise the insurance companies would be out.
- 11:20Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 11:20Damn, my house didn't burn down and I had all that fire insurance.
- 11:24Jeffrey Levine: That's right.
- 11:24Exactly.
- 11:25No one gets upset about that.
- 11:26No one goes and drives to work and says, ah, can't believe I
- 11:29didn't get into an accident today.
- 11:30Driving to work.
- 11:31What a waste of money.
- 11:32No.
- 11:32Sometimes you do things just cuz it gives you peace of mind and the
- 11:35Roth conversion can do just that.
- 11:38I rest my case with that argument.
- 11:40Good, sir.
- 11:41Ed Slott: All right.
- 11:41I think you rested your case to do a Roth conversion by handing me off
- 11:45the biggest softball in this debate.
- 11:48On reasons maybe not to convert, you said, well, at least I have insurance.
- 11:53My Roth will be tax free forever.
- 11:56I never have to worry about it.
- 11:58Well, CPAs have an old saying, tax laws are written in pencil, and
- 12:02the number one question, and you probably know what it is, I get in
- 12:06every program I do for consumers.
- 12:09Especially after I talk all about the great things which I love
- 12:12Roth IRAs, cause I love tax free.
- 12:14They say, yeah, but can I trust the government to keep its word that
- 12:18Roth IRAs will always be tax free.
- 12:22What if they need money?
- 12:23Can they change the laws, I guess anything's possible, but
- 12:27that sits in people's minds.
- 12:29They don't wanna be played for suckers paying a tax.
- 12:31And then the Congress can find some way around the fringes maybe.
- 12:36Personally, I don't think they'll do it because if they kill the golden
- 12:39goose, which is the Roth IRA for them, that produces a lot of revenue.
- 12:43But it's what people are thinking about.
- 12:44And if that keeps you up at night, that may be a reason not to convert.
- 12:51Jeffrey Levine: Well said.
- 12:52Well, you know, Ed, this one, perhaps more than any other that
- 12:55we've talked about so far, truly has two very, very compelling sides.
- 13:02Uh, there's lots of reasons to convert, lots of reasons not to convert.
- 13:06As you pointed out, Ed, for many people, this is not an all
- 13:09or a nothing decision, right?
- 13:11It's ultimately, uh, you know, most people who do conversions.
- 13:16Probably should not do a giant conversion one time.
- 13:19It's usually done over many years, uh, in a limited fashion each year, so as
- 13:25not to raise the rate too high, obviously the more you convert, the more income
- 13:29you're gonna have, the higher your income tax rate will be, you know, save for
- 13:33maybe those at the highest tax rates already where it can't get much worse.
- 13:37Uh, and we look at someone who might be paying more tax down the road when things
- 13:40expire, going from 37% back up to 39.6.
- 13:45With the exception of those who are already at that highest tax rate, uh,
- 13:49it's likely that this is a multi-year process to shift money over, and for
- 13:55many folks it will ultimately be a combination of traditional IRAs, Roth
- 14:00IRAs, and taxable accounts like joint accounts, individual accounts, revocable
- 14:04trust accounts that ultimately produces the greatest, uh, tax efficiency
- 14:10in terms of, uh, and, and, and...
- 14:13Ed Slott: What we call tax risk diversification.
- 14:15Jeffrey Levine: Tax risk diversification.
- 14:16Indeed.
- 14:17Now, I, I will say Ed at, uh, you know, at the risk of arguing against
- 14:21something I just said, I think too many people aim to have that diversification.
- 14:26The goal, as we talked about earlier, is pay your taxes
- 14:29when your rate is the lowest.
- 14:30Ed Slott: Right
- 14:31Jeffrey Levine: But oftentimes that results in having tax diversification,
- 14:35which you can then use to your advantage.
- 14:37Ed Slott: Right.
- 14:37That was a good point.
- 14:39Jeffrey Levine: Alright, well Ed on that note, when you say it's a good
- 14:42point, that's where I wanna end.
- 14:43So I'm gonna end there and call it a day.
- 14:45You know, Ed..
- 14:45Ed Slott: Like that Seinfeld episode where George, uh, makes an argument.
- 14:49I'm outta here!
- 14:50Jeffrey Levine: That's it.
- 14:50I'm out.
- 14:50I'm done.
- 14:52The summer of George.
- 14:53All right.
- 14:53I've been watching old Seinfeld episodes lately.
- 14:55I got to that one the other night.
- 14:57Alright, well on that note, uh, you know, there are two sides to every coin.
- 15:00We covered them today, but your life and your retirement decisions are too
- 15:05important to leave up to that coin flip.
- 15:06And that is why the one thing that.
- 15:08And I will always agree on is making sure that you talk through any big
- 15:13decision like should I convert to a Roth or not with a knowledgeable
- 15:18financial advisor or tax professional, so that you can weigh the pros and
- 15:22cons of these decisions against your specific goals and objectives.
- 15:27If you'd like to continue to discussion with Ed and I, we
- 15:29would love to hear from you.
- 15:30Let us know what you think.
- 15:31Do you have your money in a Roth, in a traditional IRA?
- 15:34Are you in the process of converting?
- 15:36Do you believe the government when they say it's gonna be tax
- 15:38free in the future, let us know.
- 15:40Reach out to us on Twitter using the handle @TheSlottReport that's
- 15:45@TheSlottReport for Ed, or @CPAPlanner.
- 15:49Once again, that's @CPAPlanner for myself.
- 15:52We'd love to hear from you, Ed, this one was a lot of fun.
- 15:55I can't wait for our next debate.
- 15:57Ed Slott: Oh yeah, on the Great Retirement Debate, this was a big one to Roth or not.
- 16:01Listen back a few times.
- 16:03There were a lot of points in this one, so you may wanna play it back.
- 16:06And we also talk fast.
- 16:08See you next time on the Great Retirement Debate.
- 16:11Outro: Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 16:14This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 16:18not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 16:21Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 16:24which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 16:27Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 16:30completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 16:31The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 16:35and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.