Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA in Limbo: What the Board Shakeup Means for Credit Unions
Transcript
- 0:03Hey everyone, this is Mark Kel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:07It is.
- 0:08The last Monday of July and last week, there was some interesting
- 0:13news in the press as it relates to President Trump's firing of board
- 0:19members, Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka.
- 0:22Let me see if I can get my days right.
- 0:24Last Wednesday there was.
- 0:26Uh, decision made at some level of the courts.
- 0:29I'm not gonna go into the nuances of what levels there are, but there
- 0:32was a decision made saying that Trump violated the Federal Credit
- 0:37Union Act and that Harper and Otsuka would be reinstated that same day.
- 0:43The government, uh, representing Trump scent Kyle Halman and Larry fao, who were
- 0:48also, uh, sued by, uh, interestingly by.
- 0:52Harper and Ska.
- 0:53But they filed a motion saying We need to stay this on Wednesday, uh, because it
- 0:59would be problematic to bring them back.
- 1:01While this has not worked its way all the way through the courts, uh, that
- 1:06did not get acted on in time for the NCA board meeting on Wednesday, which
- 1:11was, excuse me, on Thursday, last Thursday, which was three briefings.
- 1:16A briefing on artificial intelligence, a briefing on the CLF and a briefing by
- 1:21NCOs Ombudsman, a new office that has been created under Harper and or Halman, uh,
- 1:28as opposed to it just being one person who reported to the executive director.
- 1:31Uh, by the way, I predict that when new Republicans come in, that that
- 1:36office may be wound back into the office of the executive director.
- 1:39Anyway, I digress.
- 1:41So Thursday they had the board meeting.
- 1:44Uh, it was interesting to, I was interested to see how that went.
- 1:48Tanya Ska was in purpose.
- 1:50Todd Har Harper was on video, appeared to be elsewhere probably because he
- 1:55had things going on that prevented him from getting there in person
- 1:59on Thursday with the short notice.
- 2:02But the stay was not was not put in place.
- 2:05So they did have the board meeting.
- 2:07Harper cracked a joke on the front end, but hey, what's been
- 2:09going on the last three months?
- 2:11And the 500 pound elephant in the room relative to the whole
- 2:15issue, all three sides avoided.
- 2:17It, didn't bring it up.
- 2:18It was essentially business as usual from that perspective.
- 2:23Uh, the three briefings really didn't have anything of substance.
- 2:29The CLF briefing they do on occasion saying, Hey, they need more, uh, borrowing
- 2:33capacity for credit unions and the the.
- 2:38Briefing on the Ombudsman.
- 2:40Uh, it was interesting.
- 2:41They asked, uh, board member Harper asked if they were going to
- 2:45be doing some initiatives coming up, uh, relative to the program.
- 2:49And the individual said they didn't have enough staff.
- 2:52Uh, well, when I was there, we staffed the ombudsman with.
- 2:56One person and, uh, there were enough other structures at the agency to
- 3:00handle any complaints or appeals.
- 3:02So, uh, I found it ironic that new office was complaining about resources while NCO
- 3:08a's submission, uh, is losing about 20 to 22% of their staff and really having
- 3:13a hard time getting their mission done.
- 3:16They're having to do a lot of triage, which we've talked about here.
- 3:18But you know, no, nobody ever has enough resources and the ombudsman.
- 3:24Is, in my opinion, more of a, of a make believe position.
- 3:28That really doesn't do much of anything, but I will leave it at that.
- 3:32Okay, so they had those three briefings.
- 3:35Uh, you know, this puts staff in a weird position.
- 3:38Are they coming back?
- 3:39Are they not coming back?
- 3:42You obviously want to treat everybody with respect and it was a respectful
- 3:46board meeting, so that was all great.
- 3:48Uh, the AI briefing really I didn't glean anything from that other than an
- 3:54interesting dialogue and fact pattern Question from Todd Harper saying perhaps
- 3:59we can provide opinions that certain AI vendors are doing things right, uh, and.
- 4:07Talked about it as it relates to small credit unions, and, uh, while
- 4:12I was watching or listening I did the little head nod, like, when your dog
- 4:16doesn't understand what's going on.
- 4:18'Cause Todd's a smart guy.
- 4:20Clearly he doesn't think NCA can sanction those.
- 4:23So what was the purpose of asking that question?
- 4:26I don't know.
- 4:27Uh, but no, NCA cannot give opinions that, say vendor A, B, C that does X, Y,
- 4:33Z is blessed by NCA and he knows that.
- 4:36So I don't know, uh, what the purpose of that was, but I'm sure there was one.
- 4:42And maybe we'll find out in the future.
- 4:44Maybe we won't because the reality is, over the weekend, a stay was put
- 4:49in place and it said, you know, we're not, we're not commenting on the merits
- 4:53of the case, but we, but what we are doing, uh, is agreeing that the, with
- 4:58the government, that we should have a stay until this could be seen further.
- 5:01And I believe the next step will be the Supreme Court.
- 5:03Now, if you're listening to this, you can't see the shirt I
- 5:06have on, which is very colorful.
- 5:09It's the jockeys.
- 5:10Uh, silks of the numbers.
- 5:12And it's, uh, by the way, it's old smoke who makes some really
- 5:15cool horse racing t-shirts.
- 5:18Uh, but what are the odds that Harper notes could come back?
- 5:21I would say ultimately if I was a batting man, and I'm not, unless it has something
- 5:25to do with horse racing, uh, I would say 80% chance that they do not come back and
- 5:31that the places will be filled, before the end of the year, before the budget
- 5:36probably with the possibility of two board members, one Republican and one Democrat
- 5:42or Kyle Huffman's term is up next month.
- 5:44This is July, last Monday of July, next month his term is up.
- 5:47You could see president Trump reward three board members, put two Republicans
- 5:52in and one Democrat and have a brand new group, which, it is chaotic, right?
- 5:59Uh, the care and feeding of a board member at the executive level, when
- 6:02they come in the first year, uh, they believe that that they hear a
- 6:07lot of things negative about NCUA.
- 6:09They believe all them, and then staff spends time.
- 6:12Showing their professionalism and showing that things are done well and
- 6:16showing that they, what they might have not heard isn't all factual.
- 6:20You know, I I, I praise NCA when I think they need to be praised.
- 6:23I criticize them when I think they need to be criticized, but
- 6:26the professionalism of staff.
- 6:28Is well above average.
- 6:30And while they're going through all these things, it's chaotic.
- 6:33But imagine it's chaotic with two board members coming in and
- 6:37having to get brought up to speed.
- 6:39It's possible there will be three B brought on by the end of the year,
- 6:43and it's possible that, uh, I don't think the odds are long back to
- 6:46the, uh, to the silks on the shirt.
- 6:49Uh, but I don't think the odds are long.
- 6:50But it's possible that oats and Harper could come back.
- 6:53Now, as I've talked about elsewhere.
- 6:55On, on LinkedIn, on my blog posts here on video and on the podcast.
- 7:01Uh, NCUA does have a two year budget.
- 7:03The biggest thing coming up is the budget, and I think a Republican
- 7:08board of two would do some things relative to the budget, uh, and take
- 7:14some actions that would reduce cost to credit unions in the short term.
- 7:17And you can debate whether it would reduce.
- 7:20Cost to credit unions in the long term, uh, since AI was brought up, uh,
- 7:25I'm gonna pivot into, uh, one item.
- 7:28The inspector general at NCUA at all agencies has to report to Congress
- 7:35every six months, and there's certain things that they must do.
- 7:39And as it relates to senior government employees, if there are investigations
- 7:43that are done, whether they're they provide fruit, uh, or, or provide
- 7:48wrongdoing or exonerate, the senior government employee, they have to tell
- 7:53Congress that those actions were taken.
- 7:55And it's based on pay.
- 7:56It's not based on grade.
- 7:57And because the banking agencies pay higher, they tend to have to have
- 8:02a bigger percentage of their staff.
- 8:04Fall into the category of senior government official.
- 8:07So they did an audit, uh, that I'm going to read from the March report.
- 8:13Uh, I'm not sure exactly when this went up.
- 8:15It covered October to March.
- 8:17Takes 'em a couple months to do it.
- 8:19Probably submitted this in May.
- 8:21But anyway, false statement, misuse of government property during the reporting.
- 8:27Period.
- 8:27Uh, oi, the Office of Investigation closed an investigation that was opened during
- 8:32the prior reporting period regarding n NCAA's critical Infrastructure Division
- 8:36Director who was a grade 15 and an information system officer grade 14,
- 8:41who reported to him the investigation, substantiated allegations that direct the.
- 8:46The director sent non-public supervisory information, personally
- 8:50identifiable information and law enforcement sensitive documents to his
- 8:54personal email account in violation of the NCAA's acceptable use policy.
- 9:00The investigation also also found that the director provided false
- 9:04statements during the process for his background investigation.
- 9:07Including OMI omitting numerous outside employment positions he held while working
- 9:12at the NCA and that he violated the N C's acceptable use policy by routinely
- 9:17using his NCA email account to conduct business for the outside employment.
- 9:22The investigation substantiated allegations that the information
- 9:25system officer sent NA work to his personal email.
- 9:29And provided false information in the application process to the NCA that
- 9:34overstated his cybersecurity experience.
- 9:37On October 15th, the US Attorney's office of the Eastern District of Virginia
- 9:41declined the case for prosecution.
- 9:43By the way.
- 9:43They always decline 'cause it.
- 9:46Historically, what's pointed out here is not something, uh, that is, uh,
- 9:50the US attorney feels that they need to prosecute The information System
- 9:54officer resigned from NCA on September 19th, and the critical infrastructure
- 10:00division director retired from NCA on October 19th, because if you're
- 10:04eligible to retire, what do you do?
- 10:05You say, we're gonna fire you.
- 10:06They, you say, no, I'm gonna, I'm gonna retire.
- 10:09This situation is interesting.
- 10:12You've got people lying about their resume.
- 10:14You've got people sending stuff to their personal, the computer peop using
- 10:19NCA government, uh, for other work.
- 10:22And by the way, there's a regulation, uh, if, if A NCA employee has outside
- 10:26work it needs to be approved if you're going to continue doing that.
- 10:29So, look, sounds like they were double dipping.
- 10:32Maybe triple dipping sounds like they.
- 10:34We're sending information to their lap, their personal computers, using
- 10:41their business computers for personal work which probably in and of itself
- 10:45wouldn't have triggered all this.
- 10:47Having some personal documents, for example, on their, their NCA
- 10:51government employ, uh, laptop isn't gonna trigger this, but it's
- 10:54all that other noise around it.
- 10:56And I.
- 10:59I understand from the AI briefing that there's, that, you know, they want,
- 11:04they want credit unions to be able to use ai, but use it appropriately
- 11:08and follow third party due diligence that NCOA is using it in some.
- 11:12Minor ways.
- 11:13I've also heard that NCOA says they are not authorized to, to use it, and
- 11:18I also heard rumor that perhaps some people were involved in this case
- 11:23were sending information to their.
- 11:26Personal laptop and using their personal laptop to get information
- 11:30back into the NCA system, uh, so that they could use AI perhaps so that they
- 11:35could enhance their presentations.
- 11:37That's a little bit of conjecture on my part.
- 11:39A lot of rumor tied to what they may or may not have done.
- 11:43But I will be watching these IG reports going forward a little bit
- 11:47more closely to see if there's anything worthy of talking about they do.
- 11:53Audits, uh, they have an audit plan, just like they expect you to have an audit
- 11:57plan for your supervisory committee.
- 11:58And they did do an audit that caught my eye about the examiner rotation policy,
- 12:04which depending on what year it is uh, NCA has had a a three year rotation and
- 12:10they've had a four year rotation where examiner can only be an examiner charge
- 12:14for three years, if that's a policy, or four years, if that's the current policy.
- 12:17And quite frankly, I don't know which one the current policy is.
- 12:20But, uh, they made a, a pretty generic statement saying they
- 12:24need to improve their policies and make sure they're following that.
- 12:27That didn't go into great detail, but of the long report to Congress, those
- 12:32were the two items that caught my eye.
- 12:35Uh, lastly I had a longer podcast a couple weeks back with three members of
- 12:40my team, Dennis, who's new to the team.
- 12:43Steve and Todd, and it was longer than most of our podcasts.
- 12:48It was about the OCC risk report which there's a lot of
- 12:53corollaries to credit unions.
- 12:55What that means to credit unions and what you can look at, at the ramifications
- 13:00of how that might impact your exam.
- 13:02Uh, it was so long that I broke it down into shorter podcasts
- 13:05that we'll run on Thursdays.
- 13:07Uh, and that will also appear on YouTube on Thursdays running
- 13:11here through the summer.
- 13:12The summer months are a little slower as far as listeners.
- 13:15A little slower as far as me.
- 13:17Having much to talk about.
- 13:19'cause the NCA board kind of typically shuts down, and right
- 13:21now there really is no board.
- 13:23And, and as evidenced by the fact that all they did was these tame briefings,
- 13:28by the way, they could have done and usually have done historically, have done.
- 13:32Have acted on a mid-year budget or had a budget briefing.
- 13:35They didn't do that.
- 13:36And it's probably because of the chaos around all the numbers as it relates
- 13:40to the reorg that they probably just didn't wanna touch that as a reminder.
- 13:44NCOA takes August off as a board.
- 13:46They don't have a board meeting.
- 13:48They could, but they don't historically.
- 13:50'Cause that's when DC kind of shuts down and, uh, they'll be back up in September.
- 13:54Then they've got four months, September, October, November,
- 13:57December to theoretically.
- 13:58Get new board members in place to theoretically have a budget
- 14:02to theoretically have a budget briefing, which is, uh, required
- 14:06by the Federal Credit Union Act.
- 14:08Due to the good lobbying by Mark Warner, uh, the Senator from Virginia to get
- 14:13that act placed back several years ago.
- 14:15Alright, that's it.
- 14:16This is, uh, mark TriCal.
- 14:18As always, I appreciate you listening.
- 14:20I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 14:22Signing off with flying colors.