Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 103
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder True crime cases five four, three, two one one. Welcome
- 0:28back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are all ready
- 0:31to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get started. Murder
- 0:40while Asleep the case of Albert Terrell. There have been a number of reasons
- 0:47lawyers have used to try and justify the actions of their clients, insanity,
- 0:51self defense, et cetera. Every once in a while, defense attorneys will
- 0:56make the claim that the accused isn't responsible because they were asleep at the time
- 1:00the crime was committed and thus cannot be held responsible for their actions. This
- 1:04defense was first used in Massachusetts in eighteen forty five, and the jury's decision
- 1:10in the case would lead to uses of this same argument in the future.
- 1:15During the middle part of the eighteen hundreds, Albert Terrell found himself, at
- 1:19twenty five years of age, the head of a prosperous shoe manufacturing company after
- 1:23his father unexpectedly passed away. For all intents and purposes, Albert was a
- 1:30good man and husband to his wife, Prudence and his two children. For
- 1:34the first year, Albert excelled at the shoe game, and the entire Terrell
- 1:38family found themselves prospering for it. Hoping to continue this streak of good luck,
- 1:45al took a trip to the city of New Bedford looking for a good
- 1:48deal on a supply of leather. Instead, what he found was an attractive
- 1:52young woman by the name of Maria Pickford. You see, Maria was tired
- 1:57of the rough and tumble crowd she become accustomed to around town, and in
- 2:01Albert, she found a man more in line with the type of life she
- 2:05wanted. Al was so infatuated with Maria that he all but forgot about his
- 2:10previous life, including his wife, children, and shoe business. Things got
- 2:15so bad that he even put up his new fleeing in an apartment in Boston,
- 2:20and only returned to his original home to pick up his pay. Hearing
- 2:24this, you might believe the two were perfect for one another. The truth
- 2:29was they fought a lot and they were quite heated. Despite this, they
- 2:32always ended up forgiving one another, usually in the bedroom. The Tyrelles didn't
- 2:39take kindly Al's behavior and told him that he needed to come back to where
- 2:44he belonged. The person chosen to have this talk with Albert was his brother
- 2:47in law, Nathaniel Bailey. He laid out to al that he had a
- 2:53responsibility to take care of the company and the people who worked for him.
- 2:57He also had a wife and two children to support home. Albert agreed with
- 3:01everything Nathaniel told him, but the pool of beautiful Maria was powerful. In
- 3:07September eighteen forty five, Maria and Albert had maybe too much of a good
- 3:12time and were told they had to leave the Hanover house. When getting word
- 3:16of this, the Tyrells attempted to correct his behavior by having him arrested for
- 3:21adultery. It seems they had a change of heart, though, and they
- 3:25came to his defense once the trials started. In the end, he was
- 3:30forced to pay a fine, not commit any further crimes for six months,
- 3:34and most importantly, stay away from Maria. The two managed to remain separated
- 3:39from one another for only a single day, most of which Albert spent whining.
- 3:46When they finally did reconvene, al wouldn't be seen leaving the Beacon Hill
- 3:50residence for almost a week. Near the end of October eighteen forty five,
- 3:54a fire was reported to have broken out in the apartment where Maria was staying.
- 4:00When the fire department arrived and put out the small blaze. They found
- 4:02her dead on the mattress. Her throat had been savagely cut with a straight
- 4:08razor that was on a table a few feet away. There were also several
- 4:12pieces of men's clothing scattered about the floor, leaving them to believe someone had
- 4:16left in a hurry. The police in the area knew Albert was staying with
- 4:20Maria, so they started asking around town if anyone had seen him. Their
- 4:27inquiries led them to speak with Timothy Fullham, who ran a livery stable.
- 4:30He told investigators that someone had tried to kill him and that he was in
- 4:34trouble. While having the conversation, Fulham believed al to be slightly drunk at
- 4:40the time. From there, he drove back to Weymouth, where he spoke
- 4:45to his brother in law, Nat Bailey. All he told him was he'd
- 4:48spent the night with Maria, which violated the conditions of his bail. He
- 4:53was given some money so he could leave town. When the police showed up,
- 4:58he was told Albert was wanted from me. During this conversation, he
- 5:02told police that al appeared somewhat confused and out of sorts. Al managed to
- 5:08leave town and boarded the freighter Sultana. It would be four months before he
- 5:13would be arrested when the ship made port in New York. His trial began
- 5:17on March twenty fourth, eighteen forty six, in Boston. To everyone involved,
- 5:24it seemed a pretty simple case of murder and only a matter of time
- 5:27before Albert would find himself led to the gallows to hang. But his lawyer
- 5:31had another plan in mind. When he spoke to the witnesses that had seen
- 5:35him after the killing and learned of his strange behavior, he started digging into
- 5:41Owl's past. What he discovered was a number of instances where he had exhibited
- 5:46a propensity for sleep walking. At the age of three, he had managed
- 5:50to climb out of a window in his bedroom and make his way to the
- 5:54edge of the roof before his father managed to restrain the boy and get him
- 5:58safely inside. The next morning, he was asked why he had done such
- 6:01a thing, but he had no memory of the incident. This only seemed
- 6:06to get worse as he got older, going so far as requiring his parents
- 6:11to lock him in his room at night. They eventually stopped this practice after
- 6:15many a fight about it. Then at age sixteen, Albert managed to harness
- 6:20and ride a horse to his uncle's house, which was quite a ways away,
- 6:25dressed only in his night shirt. Again, he had no memory of
- 6:29doing such a thing. Even Prudence went to the stand to describe a situation
- 6:33where she awoke to find her husband attempting to strangle her while she slept.
- 6:39She screamed, which brought al awake. He didn't remember trying to choke her.
- 6:45In his closing argument Therell's attorney stated simply that if he did in fact
- 6:49kill Maria while he was asleep, then he could not be held responsible for
- 6:54the crime since he wasn't aware of what he was doing. The jury must
- 6:59have bought the sleep walking defense, since they only took two hours to return
- 7:02a not guilty verdict. He walked out of court that day a free man.