Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Ghost Stories 2023
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Don't Alcatraz
- 2:07sell fourteen D. The cell, of course, is empty today. This
- 2:12island prison was closed back in nineteen sixty three. Fourteen D was known as
- 2:19the whole Isolation solitary Confinement. It was one of the loneliest places on earth,
- 2:28except for the unfortunate view those who were not alone, who were locked
- 2:35in that cage with a visitor unwelcome. Just imagine you are an inmate inside
- 2:51those concrete walls. It's Alcatraz. After lights out. The guards have already
- 2:59gone to sell or bed check the cold bars inclosing the increasingly cold isolation self
- 3:07fourteen D. You are just another inmate trying to sleep somewhere down the row,
- 3:17and then you hear this. As the story goes, one inmate was
- 3:42given three years in the hole after trying to escape Rufus McCain. He begged
- 3:47and pleaded to be housed elsewhere, anywhere but fourteen D. He pleaded and
- 3:54petitioned the guards every day, please move me to another cell. And yet
- 4:00this isolation chamber would be his prison within the prison for three years, over
- 4:08one hundred and fifty weeks, one thousand days, roughly eight thousand hours of
- 4:15night, with barely a wink of sleep. His only companion beyond the guards
- 4:26was his unwelcome guest. After those three interminable years, he was finally released
- 4:40from solitary, and the inmates would say Rufus McCain had become a shell of
- 4:46a man. It was as if he had vacated his mind of everything,
- 4:50just so we wouldn't have to think about what he had seen and heard and
- 4:56felt, he wouldn't have to endure the horror any And yet horror would continue
- 5:02to follow McCain. He would soon be killed by another inmate with a painter's
- 5:09blade on the third of December nineteen forty Another monster in the halls of Alcatraz.
- 5:24Why this place, Why this prison? Many believe that it's simply the
- 5:30nature of human nature. If you're going to house some of the world's most
- 5:35dangerous people, and, according to some reports, further punish all troublemakers with
- 5:43no heat, no running water, no mattresses, and only holes in the
- 5:47concrete for toilets, there is going to be unrest. The spirit of that
- 5:54place will never be at peace, the physical and the extra natural world bleeding
- 6:00into each other. Perhaps this explains the unwonted guest, the ghost, the
- 6:09creature of fourteen D. Alcatraz today is for tourism, Yet even those who
- 6:17visit say that they hear cell doors close when none are closing. They hear
- 6:25laughing in empty halls, They feel unnatural chills in warm cells, and some
- 6:31say they have heard disembodied screams, torment in isolation, the taunting of demons,
- 6:42the open mouths and burning eyes of monsters, unknown echoes of those with
- 6:50a life sentence which had become a death sentence within the tiny walls of fourteen
- 7:00ind it's a long, long road trip through the state of Nevada. You've
- 8:03been staring at the highway's white line for hours and hours until the car begins
- 8:09to drift. You can't even keep your eyes open. It's been too long,
- 8:13too late. It's time to pull over. You scan the horizon for
- 8:18a motel sign anywhere of the head, and then finally there. It is
- 8:26an oasis in a tiny town called Tonopah, almost halfway between Las Vegas and
- 8:33Reno. But something is different about the motel sign out front. Filling the
- 8:41top half of that sign is a painting, the painting of a clown.
- 8:52Now it's at this moment that you consider sleeping in your car, but a
- 8:58hidden force, maybe just curiosity, pushes you toward the entry door and into
- 9:05the lobby. You are greeted by a life sized clown sitting in a chair.
- 9:11All around it are dozens of other tiny figures in makeup and wigs.
- 9:18The office is filled with painted eyes staring you down. Welcome vacancy. Your
- 9:26room is waiting. This Jestures of horror House was inspired by a man and
- 9:37collector named Clarence Davis. She had accumulated in his life no fewer than one
- 9:43hundred and fifty clown dolls and statues, and after his death, his children,
- 9:50Leona and Leroy Davis, wanted to preserve his memory, and so they
- 9:54built their monuments in that twenty four hundred person town in Nevana. Back in
- 10:01nineteen eighty five, they built the Clown Motel and oh yes, your room
- 10:11has clowns, so many clowns. All thirty one rooms feature at least two
- 10:18custom clown art pieces. Rooms one oh eight, one eleven, two ten,
- 10:24and two fourteen. These rooms are said to be haunted. Many believe
- 10:31that these are spirits who have walked to those rooms from the nearby old Tonopas
- 10:37Cemetery, a grave site populated by so many silver mine workers who burned to
- 10:43death in the Belmont mine fire of nineteen eleven. They died underground, they
- 10:50were buried underground. But in those white painted, red nosed, big toothed,
- 10:56long fingered statues, the dead can, for just a few moments and
- 11:01the darkness of night, remember what it was like to be alive. And
- 11:09there you are. You are tucked into bed with lights off, and only
- 11:15the faint glow of the street sign grazing your curtain. That glow faintly reveals
- 11:20the mural on the wall to your left, only three feet separating your bed
- 11:26from the figure. A clown painted almost to the top of the ceiling,
- 11:31taller than you, red hair, white shirt, yellow suspenders, squinting slits
- 11:39for eyes resting deep within, a narrow head, and a smile that feels
- 11:46like a threat. This clown is holding a red balloon. You turn your
- 11:56head away. Was that a sound? You cover your eyes and the red
- 12:01and white pillows. Did something just touch you? You turn on the television
- 12:09to mask the loud silence. Are the eyes of the painted clown now pointed
- 12:15there? Or there? Or back here? You get up and wash your
- 12:20face in the sink. What was that in the mirror? You wander back
- 12:26and click off the lamp. The shadows seem different, And then finally you
- 12:33acknowledge your unwelcome guest with words spoken out loud. We're in this together.
- 12:41I won't move if you won't. Good night until light. Let me rest
- 12:46without fright, smile, but don't bite. Be my angel in white.
- 12:54You know it's interesting to hear from those who stay at the clown Motel.
- 13:00Some can't and won't remain in their rooms. Others are filled with wonder and
- 13:07delight and a feeling of welcome. Many ask for one of the themed rooms,
- 13:13the Friday, the Thirteenth Room, the Halloween Room, the Exorcist Room,
- 13:18the It Room, and in all of the thirty one rooms, guests
- 13:24have reported strange things, knocks on the door, voices in adjacent rooms not
- 13:31occupied at the time, waking up to see newly carved scratches upon the wall,
- 13:39laughing sounds from a spouse or partner, or child or friend still fast
- 13:45asleep in their bed. Would you could you stay all night at the Cloud
- 14:00Motel with the dolls and mannequins and signs and paintings, and a lobby filled
- 14:07with over two thousand clown figures to greet you. It's not expensive if you
- 14:13would like to find out. The cheapest room is eighty five dollars. The
- 14:18most expensive is one hundred and fifty. Just remember when you log the number
- 14:24of guests for your stay, expect one or two more or three or four,
- 14:33and try not to run if you see a frown on your clown and
- 14:54tike Anish by William Hughes Marns. Yesterday upon the stair, I met a
- 15:07man who wasn't there. He wasn't there again today. I wish I wish
- 15:13he'd go away. When I came home last night at three, the man
- 15:20was waiting there for me, but when I looked around the hall, I
- 15:26couldn't see him there at all. Go away, Go away. Don't you
- 15:31come back anymore? Go away, go away, and please don't slam the
- 15:37door. Last night I saw upon the stair a little man who wasn't there.
- 15:46He wasn't there again today. Oh, how I wish he'd go away.
- 16:12What I'm about to recount for you is absolutely true, And I'm not
- 16:18saying that to try to build credibility or tension like this is a true story.
- 16:22I mean, this actually happened, but I found it so chilling and
- 16:27so compelling I wanted to include it here. It is the story of nineteen
- 16:33year old Brandon Swanson. The date was May thirteenth, two thousand and eight.
- 16:38Brandon was now with some friends at a party. They were celebrating the
- 16:42end of the spring semester at Minnesota West Community and Technical College, and Brandon
- 16:49had had a few drinks, but his buddy said he was not visibly intoxicated
- 16:55by the time the party was winding down. This is just before midnight and
- 17:00hopped in his car and began the thirty mile drive home. He still lived
- 17:04with his parents, so that's thirty miles driving on rural Minnesota roads. Call
- 17:10that forty five minutes or an hour long drive to arrive home at one am.
- 17:17But it was two am when his parents, Brian and Annette Swanson,
- 17:21at home asleep in their beds, received a phone call from Brandon. He
- 17:26said he'd driven his Chevy Lumina off the road and into a ditch. He
- 17:32couldn't get the car out, it was absolutely stuck. He was not injured,
- 17:36but he was going to need his mom and dad to come pick him
- 17:38up. And so Brian and Annette got in their pick up and they drove
- 17:42in the middle of the night toward that spot where they estimated Brandon to be.
- 17:48They kept their son on the phone. From time to time, the
- 17:52call would drop out and he would call them or they would call him to
- 17:56reconnect. Brandon flashed the headlight trying to signal them to bring them in.
- 18:03They drove road after road, turn after turn, yet they never saw any
- 18:07flashing headlights, and finally, after about forty minutes, Brandon got frustrated.
- 18:14He looked off in the distance and saw some tiny lights and he thought those
- 18:18might be the lights from a town called lynd l y in the lind And
- 18:23he said, I'm going to walk toward Lynde. There's a bar on the
- 18:27outside of town. I'm going to wait for you in the parking lot of
- 18:32that bar. Picked me up there. Brandon kept mom and dad on the
- 18:37cell phone as he walked toward what he thought was the town of lynd And.
- 18:42It was between two thirty and three in the morning. As he had
- 18:47been on the phone with his parents for forty seven minutes, she was saying
- 18:52something. He all of a sudden interrupted himself with the words, oh shit,
- 18:59and then went silence. There was no sound of a click or disconnect,
- 19:04only silence, and his parents were saying, Brandon, Brandon, are
- 19:10you there? Can you hear us say something? But no one said anything.
- 19:15They disconnected that call and dialed him back immediately went to voicemail. His
- 19:22father proceeded to the parking lot of that bar at lynd Brandon was not there.
- 19:27They drove for miles on the roads all around Lynde. Brandon was not
- 19:33there. They eventually did find the car. The Chevy was lodged in a
- 19:37ditch just off of a road between the towns of Porter and Taunton, but
- 19:41Brandon was not found. Brandon was never found. He was never seen again.
- 19:53Had he mistaken some other kind of distant light for the town of Lynde
- 19:59and somehow wandered into calamity. There was no sign of foul play at the
- 20:03vehicle. Air surveillance teams eventually brought in. They found nothing. Search dogs
- 20:10led officers roughly three miles away from the ditch to Yellow Medicine River. The
- 20:15river was flowing fast and high after some heavy rains, and it was there
- 20:21that the dogs lost the scent and teams walked up and down the river banks
- 20:26four miles no sign. Cadaver dogs brought to the region. They searched for
- 20:32three weeks. Nothing. Brandon Swanson had simply vanished into the rural farmlands and
- 20:38back roads of Minnesota, and it's possible that his remains are out there somewhere.
- 20:47Officials designated a one hundred and forty square mile grid for the search,
- 20:52but there were some farmers who didn't want outsiders trampling onto their land during planting
- 20:57and harvesting season, and for that reason, there are places that remain unchecked
- 21:04to this day. It was not, and is not suspected that Brandon,
- 21:10for some reason orchestrated his own disappearance, perhaps faking his own death. His
- 21:17parents, extended family, and friends reported no signs of cognitive impairment, mental
- 21:22illness, or even unhappiness at home. One night, he was simply there,
- 21:30and then he was gone. It has been a decade and a half
- 21:36and search teams working with the County Sheriff's Office will still go out today and
- 21:41comb through the fields when harvesting season allows. Every once in a long while,
- 21:47the tip line will ring. Those tips have not produced anything so far,
- 21:52and to date, no physical evidence of Brandon has ever been found.
- 21:57His cell phone, his car keys, remnants of clothing, nothing, absolutely
- 22:03no trace at all. How and why did Brandon Swanson just vanish in the
- 22:11middle of the night on the fourteenth of May two thousand and eight. This
- 22:17remains a mystery unsolved, a tragedy unexplained, and a baffling true story.
- 22:37For just a few minutes here, I want to talk a little bit about
- 22:41fear. Fear has a name, it has many names, and it's possible
- 22:48that one of these fears lurks behind your wide eyes and quivering lips. I
- 22:55used to have this recurring dream when I was a teenager. Back then,
- 22:59I was a night owl, so everybody else, mom and dad and my
- 23:03sisters would go to bed well before me, and I would stay up.
- 23:06I was watching television, or on the phone with my girlfriend or whatever,
- 23:11and finally, when I got tired enough to go to sleep, it was
- 23:14my job to make sure that the front and the back doors were locked.
- 23:19Now do you ever have a strange dream and realize in the dream that you
- 23:26are dreaming? Very often, I think it's this surreal stuff that tips you
- 23:32off. Oh look, there is Taylor Swift and she's singing the Oscar Meyer
- 23:37hot Dog jingle and she's sitting on a luck dragon that has the head of
- 23:41al Pacino. That kind of thing you realize, Okay, I know I'm
- 23:45in a dream. I realize that this is not real. But that was
- 23:51not the case with my recurring dream. It felt absolutely authentic. Everything looked
- 23:59and fell like real life. And so there I was, late at night,
- 24:07my eyes getting so very heavy, and finally after midnight, I decided
- 24:11it was time to call it a day, and so I got up,
- 24:15and I did my routine. I went to the front door, and I
- 24:19tugged on the door to make sure it was latched, and then I turned
- 24:23the doorknob lock and the dead bolt. And after the front door, I
- 24:30walked to the back of the house. But when I tugged on the back
- 24:33door, it had not been latched, and that door swung in toward me
- 24:40so quickly that it made me jump. And standing in that doorway was a
- 24:45tall, looming figure cloaked in black. In the dream, I couldn't tell
- 24:51if it was black fabric or just a person made of shadow. It was
- 24:56so bizarre. His face was not covered. I I couldn't see a face,
- 25:00though I couldn't see anything other than darkness. I couldn't even see his
- 25:04eyes. He just stood there, filling that doorframe with his massive size.
- 25:11And in that moment, I already knew he was coming inside my house.
- 25:15He was coming after me. And it all happened so fast. It happened
- 25:22in just a second, surprise and shock and panic, and I would wake
- 25:26up in that same surprise and shock and panic, and often I couldn't get
- 25:33back to sleep for a very long time. Did I have a condition called
- 25:38celeerophobia, the irrational fear of a stranger in my house. I don't think
- 25:45so. The idea hadn't really occurred to me during the day. It wasn't
- 25:51something I thought about. But I will tell you this, After the first
- 25:53two times I had that dream, locking the house in real life caused real
- 26:00anxiety. Every time I walk toward that back door and tugged on it to
- 26:06ensure that it was latched, I had a moment where I thought, there's
- 26:11something on the other side. There are so many phobias in this world.
- 26:17There is cholera phobia, the fear of clowns. I did an entire ghost
- 26:22story about a clown on the podcast and in my ghost Stories audiobook. Today's
- 26:27show has already featured the Clown Motel, and it's interesting to note how clowns
- 26:34have become personal nightmares for so many. I always feel a little bit sad
- 26:41for legitimate clown characters who only want to bring joy to parties and people,
- 26:47you know, the party clown people who may not always feel the welcome they
- 26:52deserve when they show up in a clown costume. Psychology Today says that chulaphobia
- 27:00is the result of our brains fearing the unpredictable make up on the face,
- 27:06strange paints on the smiles and cheeks and eyes. These make it difficult for
- 27:11us to perceive true emotion sincere intent, the silly antics of the clowns seem
- 27:18so unnatural to us, and so our brains trigger and we become suspicious.
- 27:25It's all a facade. This is an act. There is another agenda.
- 27:30For twelve percent of the population. Clowns are no laughing matter. Fear of
- 27:38the dark nicktophobia. That's another common one. You ever walk upstairs after turning
- 27:45off all the downstairs lights, and you'll walk those stairs really quickly to make
- 27:52sure the boogeyman can't catch you. There is a terrifying Ryan Reynolds film released
- 28:00back in twenty ten. The movie is called Buried. It is a survival
- 28:06thriller that is very much not the usual comedy fair that we're used to seeing
- 28:11from Ryan Reynolds. The entire movie takes place inside a coffin. Now Natalie
- 28:19and I rented this movie shortly after it released. I am astounded that she
- 28:26even made it through. After the first ten minutes, she was looking at
- 28:29me going, I don't think I can do this. I don't think I
- 28:32can do this, and yet somehow she persevered. Scientists know how the human
- 28:38brain resists notions of prolonged suffering and dying alone. Skelephobia types would hate my
- 28:48Halloween yard display, which is filled with plastic skeletons, Many people recoiling at
- 28:56the very idea of anything looking dead or dying things. In fact, our
- 29:02fears of death has a name thanatophobia. I recently found out that there is
- 29:08a clinical name for the fear of Halloween, the October thirty first holiday,
- 29:17Sowen of phobia. Now, remember that the Celtic New Year was long ago
- 29:23marked by the festival of Sowen, at the celebration of the Harvest. The
- 29:30Celts believed that this was a time when the supernatural plane and the physical world
- 29:36almost merged together. There was a veil, a very thin veil, between
- 29:41the living and the ghostly. That veil so thin that the dead could actually
- 29:48slip into the physical world to walk among the living. Many people would anticipate
- 29:56this, sometimes fearing this, they would leave gifts or treats for these spirits,
- 30:02and, as some were mischievous and quite frightening, the goodies might distract
- 30:07them or appease them and make them go away. Other people disguise themselves in
- 30:12costumes so that dead relatives might simply walk gone by. Perhaps sauenophobia reflects that
- 30:22aversion to anything death, or maybe as part of a highly Christian culture,
- 30:27they're nervous about any ancient ritual involving spirits that does not exist in Christian doctrine
- 30:36or tradition. Halloween has long been warned about by the Puritans, steeped in
- 30:41Satanic panic. My own childhood was filled with horror stories about evil people out
- 30:48there poisoning Halloween candy and putting razor blades inside apples, and stealing black cats
- 30:56for the purpose of sacrifice, and even steep killing people, often children,
- 31:02for the very same reason. It's ironic, then, that the word Halloween
- 31:07is actually a Catholic invention. About twelve hundred years ago, after the Romans
- 31:12had conquered the Celts, the Catholic Church was not pleased that so many of
- 31:18the common people were enjoying these pagan festivals. Around six hundred CE, Pope
- 31:26Gregory the First decided that rather than try to outlaw these godless traditions, the
- 31:33Catholic Church would simply adopt them and modify them to religify them. Pagan ritual
- 31:41would transform into Catholic ritual, Pagan temples could become Catholic temples. And three
- 31:48hundred years after that, the Church moved its All Saints Day ritual from earlier
- 31:56in the year to the first of November All Saints' Day, all Souls Day,
- 32:01all Hallows Day, and as such, the day before November one,
- 32:07which was of course October thirty first, well, that would become All Souls
- 32:14Eve, All Hallows Eve. Halloween. One theory held by some historians says
- 32:22that the Middle Ages saw the Church version of trick or treating. It was
- 32:28called souling, where poor people would collect food and money from neighboring homes in
- 32:34return for prayers for the dead, and yet the true spirits of Halloween would
- 32:39simply not die. Those pumpkins with candles inside still echoed today that celt symbolism
- 32:49of the magic of the sun over the harvest. In Ireland and Scotland,
- 32:54carved vegetables were made to scare off a trickster named Stingy Jack, and thus
- 33:01we got the jack O lantern. The colors of black and orange trace way
- 33:07back to that ancient Sowin festival, black representing the death of summer, orange
- 33:15representing the autumn harvest season. Oh, how could anyone be afraid of this
- 33:22wonderful holiday? Today, the second most popular and profitable holiday after Christmas.
- 33:30Apparently many people still are. Perhaps all they need is a smile and a
- 33:37costume and a candle and a delicious treat to change their petrified perceptions. I
- 34:00hope you feel the spirit of the season on our annual ghost Stories podcast as
- 34:06we head toward the Halloween holiday. There are more stories to come next.
- 34:37Halloween is upon us. It's ghost Stories twenty twenty three, and we're just
- 34:51having some fun this week. Thank you so much for listening. And I
- 34:54hear a lot of people. They send me emails and they're like, when's
- 34:58ghost stories? We can't wait? And other people are like, Eh,
- 35:06I'll see you later. Whatever, whatever, float your boat. But it's
- 35:08fun for me. It's fun to be a storyteller in this way. And
- 35:10Halloween's always blast. I've set a high bar in my neighborhood. It's either
- 35:16a high bar or a low bar for Halloween decorations. And everybody else they've
- 35:22got the little skull sitting on the porch, and they've got a couple of
- 35:24hanging bats in the window, and maybe there's an inflatable something a pumpkin in
- 35:30the front yard. Me I go down to Lowe's hardware store and I buy
- 35:38some cheap lumber and silver spray paint, and I make another worldly prison.
- 35:45Friend of mine bills an electric chair out of old pallide wood, and then
- 35:51I enhanced it. So he brought me the chair. We brought it over
- 35:53in his pickup truck and we put it in the yard and I'm like,
- 35:57well, how can I make this look more elect And so I got these
- 36:01what do you call the things that go on the end of the curtain rods,
- 36:07finnyl finish, something like finyl or finil, maybe finial, I think,
- 36:13And it was like six dollars finials, and you just screw them into
- 36:15the top of the chair. And then I got a little piece of electrical
- 36:20wire that comes out of a salad bowl. It's a salad bowl that is
- 36:23the hat for my skeleton. And he's kind of charred looking and he's sitting
- 36:28in there, but he's waving, so it's kind of a happy electric chair
- 36:30scene. And then the rest of my crap, all my skeletons and lights.
- 36:35I just sort of showered around it. But I mean it's pretty gaudy.
- 36:38You can see my house from a block away, so I can't maybe
- 36:44I'm bringing property values down. I don't really know, but you know,
- 36:47it's just awesome. And of course we get ready for tons of trick or
- 36:51treaters in this neighborhood, and a couple of friends of mine came up with
- 36:57an interesting trick or treat tradition. They use the October thirty first holiday to
- 37:07clear out the pantry in their kitchen. So they go through those shelves and
- 37:15it's like, oh, this has been in here for two years or whatever.
- 37:19I mean, nothing past the expiration, I guess. But oh look
- 37:22it's Campbell's Cream of Mushroom soup. We're not going to use that. Here's
- 37:27some gravy packets, here's some spaghetti noodles, here's all this stuff, and
- 37:31they grab they literally go through and sort of clear out the pantry. And
- 37:36then for the trigger treaters, they give them a choice. The kids in
- 37:40costumes come up, they romp up to the front door, ding dong trigg
- 37:45or treat and everybody comes out and they have two piles and they say,
- 37:51would you like a candy? Right, M and m's kitcat, snickers,
- 37:53whatever, milky way, what's your favorite candy? Mine's peanut M and ms?
- 37:58Okay, have peanut M and M, skit kats whatever, or you
- 38:02can have something from our pantry pile. And according to my friends, more
- 38:09kids get stuff out of the pantry pile, skipping the sweets. It's like,
- 38:15oh, here's a box of maltomeal. Mom. They just put they
- 38:22put regular food in the bags. Mom, I got a tiny plastic bottle
- 38:29of garlic and onion powder. Kraft macaroni and cheese. Who could say no
- 38:34to that? I actually think Kraft mac and cheese would be a great Halloween
- 38:38trick or treat candy because it's almost, you know, it's kind of a
- 38:42guilty pleasure. Some child walks up and it's like a bottle of olive oil.
- 38:52Wow, thank you. They say the pantry pile is a big I
- 38:58just think it's funny. I can't imagine, you know, gravy packets over
- 39:02a KitKat. I can't imagine that, but I just found that a funny
- 39:07story. Anyway, The rest of our actual ghost stories continue right now.
- 39:21A Girl of Nails and Teeth by Hannah Yang. The girl trims her fingernails,
- 39:31carefully, dropping each pale crescent into the glass jar in front of her.
- 39:37Her mother stands next to her, watching, waiting. It's the middle
- 39:43of summer, and the girl steams and the heat, anxious to finish her
- 39:47task so she can go outside and play with the other girls in the neighborhood.
- 39:53She can see them through the window, their shiny bikes prompt up against
- 39:59the telephone pole, their laughter writing the wind like bird's song. Half her
- 40:06mind is on the nail scissors, the other half on the laughing girls.
- 40:10On the third finger of her left hand, she rushes cuts too close to
- 40:15the quick blood beads up under her nail. The clipping falls to the hardwood
- 40:22floor with a muted clink and scuttles under the couch. Sorry, she says,
- 40:30sorry, sorry. Her mother gets down to her hands and knees to
- 40:35look for it. She is no longer young, and the movement takes visible
- 40:39effort. You're always so careless, she says, as she crawls. You're
- 40:45old enough to know better. The girl sits on her chair enduring her mother's
- 40:51quiet scolding, which ceases only when the lost nail clipping is recovered and dropped
- 40:58safely in with the other. They have glass jars all around the house of
- 41:05all different sizes, carefully labeled than stored. Jars of the girl's hair,
- 41:12collected each time her mother gives her a haircut over the kitchen sink. Jars
- 41:16of her blood from the phlebotomies her mother conducts once every six weeks, which
- 41:23are followed by a carton of apple juice to restore the girl's blood sugar level.
- 41:30Jars of shed skin she's peeled away from the pads of her thumbs that
- 41:36callouses on her toes, the chapped layers of her lips. A jar of
- 41:40all her baby teeth except for the one she accidentally swallowed while eating an ear
- 41:47of corn, after which her mother pulled out the rest with pliers. Her
- 41:55mother leaves the jars and plane sight to reassure herself of their progress. The
- 42:02only occasion for which she puts the jars away is when someone comes to visit.
- 42:08On those days, the girl and her mother pack everything into the pantry,
- 42:14teeth buried inside sacks of rice, blood concealed behind cans of condensed soup.
- 42:22Only after the jars are safely tucked away do they unlock the front door
- 42:28and greet their neighbors with close lipped smiles, holding in all the things they
- 42:34cannot say. Sometimes the other mothers burst into tears in the living room,
- 42:40mourning what they have not yet lost. The girl stands in the hallway and
- 42:47watches her mother comfort the other woman with sugar spun lies. Yes, I
- 42:53feel you, I know what you're going through. We can and to tell
- 43:00them the truth. Her mother reminds her afterwards, it won't work if someone
- 43:05else tries the same trick. The girl is too young to understand. She
- 43:12waves through the window as the other mothers walk away. The simulacrum sits waiting
- 43:24in the back of the mother's wardrobe, hidden under a spare bedsheet, a
- 43:30life sized doll made of wood and linen and desperation. Faceless and unfinished.
- 43:38It's been sitting there for longer than the girl has been alive. The mother
- 43:44started building it the day the doctor first told her she was expecting a female
- 43:49child. The same day she first put her hand on her swollen belly and
- 43:54felt the baby squirming inside her, a wild thing desperate to live. The
- 44:02girl has not yet seen the simulacrum. She has only caught glimpses of the
- 44:08blueprints, which her mother takes out once a year to update the necessary measurements
- 44:15the size of her feet, the circumference of her skull, the length of
- 44:21each arm. When the time comes, the mother will finish the simulacrum alone.
- 44:28It will have a perfectly painted face that mirrors the girl's own. It
- 44:34will have the girl's real blood pumping through its limbs, her real hair stitched
- 44:39into the pale cloth of its scalp, her real teeth drilled into its gums,
- 44:47her real fingernail clippings glued onto its fingers, and toes lined up like
- 44:53the tiles of a mosaic. The mother will leave the simulacrum outside their front
- 45:02door and wait. Even now, after all her planning, she does not
- 45:08know for sure if it will work. She will spend the whole night waiting,
- 45:15her arms wrapped around the girl, her pulse hot and fever quick,
- 45:21listening to the weeping and wailing of the other mothers in the neighborhood who were
- 45:28not clever enough to save their daughters. This way the mouth Man. Point
- 46:01Pleasant, West Virginia, nineteen sixty six, two grave diggers working their cemetery
- 46:08job heard something overhead. They looked up to the sky and saw the black
- 46:14figure flying ghostly and unnatural. It was ten feet long, with large wings
- 46:21and red eyes. These men didn't realize it at the moment, but they
- 46:25were the first people to ever report a sighting of the moth Man. From
- 46:32that day forward, Point Pleasant would see more encounters. Drivers spotting the creature
- 46:38at night, hikers reporting a large winged thing sitting high in the trees.
- 46:45Residents on sidewalks driven back to their homes after being followed by a pair of
- 46:50red eyes attached to a shadowy outline. The most famous sighting of the Mothman
- 46:58happened on the fifteenth of December nineteen sixty seven. Locals reported seeing a giant
- 47:04winged creature flying over the Silver Bridge, a suspension bridge over the Ohio River,
- 47:10the bridge connecting Point Pleasant to Gallip Police, Ohio. Moments later,
- 47:19the bridge collapsed. Forty six people died. Investigators found a fracture in the
- 47:31suspension chain, but many still insist the tragedy was the will of the Mothmaan.
- 47:39In the decades after nineteen sixty seven, witnesses far beyond Virginia have come
- 47:45forward to say they saw the Mothmaan moments before other terrible events accidents, fires,
- 47:52massacres, natural disasters, as if this visitor brought calamity in the wake
- 47:59of a its giant wings. Yet strangely, many see those catastrophes as merely
- 48:06coincidental to them. The Mothman is merely a visitor from another plane, a
- 48:12spectator, even a friend. Every third weekend in September, point Pleasant hosts
- 48:22the Mothman Festival, a celebration of the other worldly cryptid. There are museums
- 48:28and costumes, music and guided tours, a festival for a thing few people
- 48:35have seen, but so many embrace to be safe, just in case.
- 48:43If you ever see two red eyes in a shadow beyond, stop where you
- 48:49are, turn and run the other way. Within seconds, you may see
- 48:54a horror upon humans. Is he an agent of destruction or is he just
- 49:01watching? We do not yet know. We only know that so many say
- 49:08they've seen the Mothman and witnessed cruel happenings under the span of his wings.
- 49:47Very often the most terrifying ghostly creatures don't just haunt us. They consume the
- 49:55things around us. Maybe they eat soul, or animals or our children.
- 50:02They devour what is vulnerable and precious. The people of Thailand have a ghost
- 50:12they called the Hungry Ghost. These other worldly creatures were once human beings,
- 50:19people who took advantage of other people in life. They lied and stole,
- 50:24and cheated and harmed. They were agents of inhumanity that preyed upon their human
- 50:30brothers and sisters in this world. In a way, they were charging up
- 50:36a kind of karma, prospering in the living world, with the after life
- 50:42oh waiting to make them pay for every misdeed, every lie, every abuse,
- 50:49every grift. No, they were not going to get away with it.
- 50:52After all, real world cretans waking up in the spirit world after death
- 51:00no longer themselves, at least in form. They have become the Hungry Ghost.
- 51:07If you had lived as one of these terrible people, your after life
- 51:13form would be specific to the types of wrongs you had committed. If you
- 51:17were stingy and greedy, you might have one form. If you had physically
- 51:22harmed as someone, you'd have a different form. And so on. But
- 51:28the forms all have certain things in common. Long necks, lean bodies with
- 51:35protruding bellies, gray green or blackened skin, huge hands with spindly fingers.
- 51:43You're as tall as a palm tree, with a head proportional to that body,
- 51:49but your mouth would be as tiny as the eye of a needle.
- 51:53Your inability to eat more than a speck at a time compounds your misery,
- 52:00as your large stomach simply cannot be filled. You are tortured with hunger,
- 52:08and as you walk among the trees and the darkness of night, you make
- 52:14a high pitched wine of a scream, an outward expression of inner pain.
- 52:23Your roam as a phantom, a monster. You are slithering in the land
- 52:30of the living, desperate to feed. You are the hungry ghost. It's
- 52:37interesting that, according to legend, human beings are rarely attacked by these spirits,
- 52:44the famished phantoms often invisible to the human eye. The hungry ghosts instead
- 52:51feed on other things as best they can. Of course, they are never
- 52:54satisfied, and they also hunt offerings, offerings to give to the gods.
- 53:01They must appease the gods. They must atone for their misdeeds in life by
- 53:08gathering valuable things wherever they can find them, bringing those items to Buddhist temples,
- 53:15and then laying down their findings at the feet of the good and the
- 53:20hopes that they will encounter a merciful priest who will forgive and free them from
- 53:25their prison. The story of the Hungry Ghost is often told to children to
- 53:34keep them from misbehaving. Don't be cruel, don't lie, don't cheat,
- 53:38don't steal, don't harm, because if you do, when you die,
- 53:45you will be cursed to Rome as a hideous thing, as tall as a
- 53:50building, with only a constant, horrible hunger at your side. You will
- 53:58become the hung ghost. You know myself. I find a kind of magic
- 54:06to this story. Wouldn't it be nice if karma was real? As we
- 54:10live in a world where so many terrible people get away with it while so
- 54:15many very good people suffer at their hands. So yes, I fantasize that
- 54:22these people would be made to pay after death for all the bad things they
- 54:28had done in life, creatures in their hearts. As living people, they
- 54:34would become actual creatures, monsters, beasts, tormented spirits after death. Oh
- 54:40yes, I'm guilty. I would love to see the agents of suffering get
- 54:46a taste of suffering themselves, until finally they bring themselves before the altar of
- 54:53the good in humility and penitence, regrets and change. Oh, we can
- 55:02certainly imagine still to come. Two great ghost stories to climax the broadcast.
- 55:25I've got a Noose and a Witch coming up next. It is the season
- 55:47of the Witch and the Ghost, and the Jack o Lantern and the Black
- 55:52Cats and the Big bad Spider and the vampire. So much good stuff going
- 55:59on here in the month of October. As we continue with the final segment
- 56:04of ghost Stories twenty twenty three, as so many ghostly legends come from stories
- 56:40about real people in real places, allow me to tell you the story of
- 56:45Alice Riley, which is also the story of the Hanging Square. January of
- 56:53seventeen thirty four. There was a poor immigrant named Alice Riley. She arrived
- 56:59in the American colonies, and she found herself in what would one day become
- 57:04the town of Savannah, Georgia. Alice had had no money to pay for
- 57:08the trip overseas, and so she sold herself into indentured servitude and became a
- 57:15debt slave. She willingly sold her labor to a man named William Wise,
- 57:22and to pay off her debt, she would work for him for five years.
- 57:29Yet her master was not a good man. William Wise was oppressive and
- 57:34petty and cruel. He abused her every day. He insisted that he be
- 57:39personally groomed, washed and cleaned, and shaved and combed. He enjoyed the
- 57:45attention that Alice was forced to shower upon him. He enjoyed the master's chair.
- 57:52He enjoyed his slave, an attendant to his every whim, the object
- 57:59of his con tempt, the target of his horrible temper. William was a
- 58:05weak man. He was weak in character and weak in body. Perhaps his
- 58:10abuse of other people made him feel big and strong. I suppose it was
- 58:16inevitable that Alice had finally had enough. She reached the end of her tether,
- 58:22and so she and a fellow servant, a butler named Richard White,
- 58:28decided that they were going to end their misery. They decided they would end
- 58:34William Wise. The date was March the first, seventeen thirty four. It
- 58:40was time for the master's bath. William again stood at the tub with expectation.
- 58:47Alice filled it with water, but before he could get inside the bath,
- 58:53Alice and Richard grabbed him by the shoulders and they thrust his head under
- 58:59the water. William thrashed and splashed, but in his weakness he was helpless.
- 59:06He could not find the air to breathe. It was a terrible,
- 59:09violent, cacophonous moment, until all became quiet and the Master lay slumped all
- 59:17the way down, literally dead in the water. Alison Richard placed his body
- 59:25upon the bed with a handkerchief around his neck to hide the trauma to his
- 59:31body. What would happen now? Alice and Richard knew they would have to
- 59:37flee for their very lives, but soon they were captured and arrested. They
- 59:43were tried and both were sentenced to death by hanging. When Richard was dropped
- 59:51from the rope and executed, Alice screamed out, I'm pregnant. I'm pregnant.
- 59:58The colony doctor was brought in to verify, and he did. Alice
- 1:00:02had been impregnated by the man she had just murdered. The father would be
- 1:00:08her dead master, William Wise. Well, the town wasn't going to kill
- 1:00:15a woman with William's child inside of her. She was dragged back to the
- 1:00:21jail, and she was allowed to live there for another eight months until when
- 1:00:27the baby was finally delivered. Alice Riley again faced the gallows in the middle
- 1:00:34of Right Square in pre Savannah, Georgia, with a rope around her throat
- 1:00:39and the platform about to fall beneath her feet. Alice shouted curses at the
- 1:00:45townspeople who had come to gawk at her. She cursed them, and she
- 1:00:51cursed them until this immigrant slave who rose up against her rebuser, was dropped
- 1:00:58to the end of the hangar man's rope to send a message to the rest
- 1:01:02of the town. Her dead body was left there for three days, hanging
- 1:01:08in the breeze. At the end of the third day, Alice's body mysteriously
- 1:01:15disappeared. It is said that the newborn baby died mysteriously just a few days
- 1:01:22after that. This happened three hundred years ago. Today, Right Square is
- 1:01:30known as the Hanging Square, a place where so many others would come to
- 1:01:35die with broken necks at the gallows, the place where Alice Riley had died,
- 1:01:42the place where she had disappeared, and she has reportedly reappeared from time
- 1:01:49to time. People say they have been approached by a distraught woman asking where
- 1:01:53is my baby? Have you seen my baby? I've got to find my
- 1:01:58baby. Some of these people were so eager to help that they called the
- 1:02:02Savannah Police Department. This has apparently happened so very often that veteran officers immediately
- 1:02:10know it's Alice. She is said to be dressed in the clothing of her
- 1:02:15time, but few people even look twice because of all the popular guided tours
- 1:02:22in Savannah, where old and attire is common with tour guides and re enactors.
- 1:02:29Alice is both anomaly and anonymous. The red band's scar at the neck
- 1:02:36where the rope had once been walking and asking and pleading and crying and wailing.
- 1:02:43New mothers are very protective of their own babies when walking right square.
- 1:02:50They're nervous that Alice Riley might see their child, and somehow see her own.
- 1:02:57She might strip the baby out of their arms disappear the way she disappeared
- 1:03:02from that hanging noose three centuries ago. She had drowned her oppressor in the
- 1:03:09bathwater. She had paid with her life, and in death she roams those
- 1:03:15Savannah streets. Legend says that her ghost has been seen and reported more than
- 1:03:22any other ghost in the history of the state of Georgia. Perhaps you can
- 1:03:29visit right Squares someday and you can find out for yourself. The old woman's
- 1:04:11house was different than the others, older worn down, the paint long gone,
- 1:04:17the wood a gray blue, the door midnight black, with no windows.
- 1:04:27No one ever arrived or left. No one was ever seen except for
- 1:04:31the shadow of the witch in the window. That's what everyone said. She
- 1:04:38was the witch in the window. It didn't take much for the neighbors to
- 1:04:43whisper about her. Who is she? Why doesn't she ever go outside?
- 1:04:48What goes on inside the house? Be careful, something's wrong there, not
- 1:04:56natural, not safe, of course, what better place for a children's dare
- 1:05:04than the house of a mysterious witch. Samuel, Tim and Michael were all
- 1:05:11thirteen classmates in middle school, the best of friends. They'd been worned to
- 1:05:17stay clear of the rotting old house. But these were young teenagers, frash
- 1:05:23boys, invincible in their youth. One night, from their bikes, they
- 1:05:30passed by to see something tied to the door, a string. Above that
- 1:05:35string was a large orange balloon, just tethered to the doorknob and drifting in
- 1:05:41the light breeze. If not an invitation, it was certainly a temptation and
- 1:05:46the perfect opportunity to test one's courage. It was Tim who said it out
- 1:05:54loud, go get that balloon, Just take it. Go ahead, I
- 1:05:59dare you, Sam and Michael just looked back at him. It was easy
- 1:06:04to be bowled on this side of the small picket fence surrounding the weeds and
- 1:06:09thorns. Tim persisted, My dad gave me ten dollars. He pulled the
- 1:06:15money out of his pocket like a rich man flashing a thousand. I will
- 1:06:19give you ten dollars to get that balloon. His friends weren't smiling, they
- 1:06:28weren't frowning. Their faces were neutral and blank and a little bit stunned.
- 1:06:34Turning toward the balloon. They were obviously wrestling with the dare do it and
- 1:06:41you're in the shadow of the witch. Refused to do it, and everyone
- 1:06:46will find out that you're a coward. Tim dangled the money like a fisherman
- 1:06:53dangling his line, praying that one of them would take the bait, and
- 1:06:58after a few uncomfortable minds, his prayer was answered. Michael spoke up.
- 1:07:04I'll do it, but I want the money right now. No way you're
- 1:07:08going to cheat me if I do it. Tim hadn't been bluffing. He
- 1:07:14grinned and paid. Nobody rushed to Michael even as he stood there gathering himself
- 1:07:21for the mission. His buddies didn't goad him or push him. They were
- 1:07:26happy to wait until he felt ready. And if they were to speak honestly,
- 1:07:31even from a distance, they were a little bit afraid. The orange
- 1:07:36balloon was no longer moving. The curtain of the upstairs window slowly opened.
- 1:07:44The interior room flickered with candles. The shape of a woman filled the square
- 1:07:50glass. The boys were hidden behind the shrubs, invisible, invisible thirty seconds,
- 1:08:01and then she was gone. All was dark, All was still.
- 1:08:08Michael had wrinkled the bill in his hand smashed into a ball. Before he
- 1:08:12saw what he'd done, all eyes were on him. Go get the balloon.
- 1:08:20Michael wouldn't use the gate. Too rusty, too risky, It would
- 1:08:26certainly creak. He climbed the short fence and knelt down in the tall grass.
- 1:08:31He gathered himself. Then he slowly moved forward, like a soldier in
- 1:08:38battle, crawling enemy territory. He made himself small. He felt himself crawl
- 1:08:47forward and forward, an inch at a time. The house loomed larger,
- 1:08:55the door crept closer, the balloon got larger. The front left corner of
- 1:09:04the house was covered in brush. This was Michael's hiding place before the final
- 1:09:10act. Get the balloon, Get the balloon. He set his jaw and
- 1:09:16tensed his body and coiled like a spring. The sprint to the door had
- 1:09:21to be fast, lightning fast. Get the prize and get away. Breathe,
- 1:09:30breathe, breathe, here we go. Five four, three two one.
- 1:09:39Michael jolted from his hiding place and screamed toward the porch steps five short
- 1:09:44steps that he leapt in one motion. He lunged at the door and grabbed
- 1:09:48at the string. It popped into his hand without any resistance at all.
- 1:09:54Michael fixed his grasp and boomeranged as fast as a boy could. Run away,
- 1:09:59away, away. In the chaos of his retreat, the balloon grazed
- 1:10:05his cheek. There was a flash of bright light, then blackness. Michael's
- 1:10:18body was frozen in place, paralyzed. He couldn't even feel breath in his
- 1:10:26lungs. He was a small statue suspended between worlds slowly all around him.
- 1:10:34The black became gray, the gray became green, the green became red,
- 1:10:43the red became orange. His muscles and movement returned to him. As he
- 1:10:49began to reach out to touch the sinister shade of gold and saffron that enveloped
- 1:10:55him. His fingers touched something like rubber, or later plastic or nylon.
- 1:11:01It was meshy, elastic, sticky, and thick. He clawed with his
- 1:11:08finger nails to hear the sound of hands on a party balloon, but it
- 1:11:13would not tear. The more he tried to knife his round prison, the
- 1:11:18thicker the sticky orange walls became. Watching all this from outside the fence,
- 1:11:26where Samuel and Tim helpless and petrified. They cheered as their friend dashed from
- 1:11:32the brush to the door, then screamed as he was immediately swallowed by an
- 1:11:38orange floating quicksand the now large balloon, with the shadow of a boy barely
- 1:11:45visible inside muffled yells barely audible. Beneath this glowing orb was the tiniest string,
- 1:11:56dangling and drifting again in the breeze. The giant balloon just hung there,
- 1:12:04still as a grave. The only movement was the flailing shadow of Michael
- 1:12:10inside, scraping and clawing and climbing for nothing. Four eyes from two faces
- 1:12:24were unable to blink. And then they looked up to that second floor window.
- 1:12:30As the curtain again opened, the candles again flickered, and the shadow
- 1:12:35of the woman reappeared in the frame. Slowly, her body began to sway
- 1:12:44as she moved, The giant orange balloon began to sway left and right,
- 1:12:51left and right, back and forth and back and forth. It was an
- 1:13:00otherworldly dance until the figure reached forward to unlock the window latch. She raised
- 1:13:11the glass. She leaned forward into the warm evening air. She pointed her
- 1:13:17long dead corpse of a face at Sam and Tim. Her eyes weren't there
- 1:13:26only black sockets of decay. They could see hair like filthy straw, hands
- 1:13:32with unnatural fingers. The mythical witch wasn't a myth after all. With the
- 1:13:42slightest of motion, the creature in the window held out her open palms.
- 1:13:47She paused for a second, then she lifted them up. As she did.
- 1:13:54The floating round prison lifted as well. It rose upward and upward,
- 1:14:00above the house, over all houses higher and higher, smaller, and smaller.
- 1:14:08The boys shaped shadow inside, climbing and clamoring to escape the balloon,
- 1:14:14and the shadow rising far out of view, vanishing, vanishing. But wait,
- 1:14:30was it? There was it returning, tiny, then bigger, then
- 1:14:40bigger. The boys on the ground held their eyes to the horizon as the
- 1:14:45round orange things slowed and stopped in the far away sky. It was the
- 1:14:53boy, It was the balloon, It was the harvest moon. Samuel and
- 1:15:02Tim turned towards the high house window. The shadow pointed toward them until the
- 1:15:09boys could see teeth, blunt teeth revealed from separating lips and a wide open
- 1:15:17mouth. The face stretched back, as if pulled by some strange gravity,
- 1:15:24the Witch's teeth in a hideous grin. The breeze became still, the air
- 1:15:32became chilled. The witch raised her hand, and the crone in the frame
- 1:15:39spoke aloud. For the first and only time. She said, in a
- 1:15:45satisfied voice, enjoy the moonlight, boys, And then she was gone.
- 1:15:56Little Michael was gone, in a prison of both light and darkness, of
- 1:16:01stretching in symmetry, a balloon with a string that could never be stolen.
- 1:16:10No one would find him, no search would reveal him, nobody would see
- 1:16:15or know him ever again, except for two teenagers that nobody believed no one
- 1:16:25will ever know that their affectionate gaze at the Harvest Moon sees the boy locked
- 1:16:32for life in that orange balloon. A masterful telling of that story by one
- 1:17:06of three special guest narrators for this project. A huge thanks out to Sarah
- 1:17:12Gray, to Grace Bellaston and Connor Brannigan, great storytellers and welcome additions to
- 1:17:19Ghost Stories twenty twenty three. Thank you for listening, Happy Halloween, and
- 1:17:26we'll do it again next year.