Latest / Automotive State of The Union / EV Credit Cliffs Notes, Big Companies Investing Big, Is the Nordstrom Tire Story True?
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Yo, welcome to Thursday, back half of the week. We're already laughing because the show's gonna be awesome today. We're talking about the EV tax credit.
- 0:07We're gonna break it down for you, and we're talking about that legendary Nordstrom tire return story. Legendary. Straight up. So good. The people really wanna know who I is and who I be.
- 0:17They stop and stare when they see me. If you are sensing- They perceive the one, no need to fear... some level- Run up on me with the cold stare...
- 0:21of competitive anxiety in this morning's show- They back up when they see it really clear... you, my friend, are astute I think you better consider me I'm the real one feeling it, just as a note.
- 0:28Yeah, that's why Kyle's face is a little red, because he had game face- [laughs]...
- 0:31during the countdown because we are, we decided that we're gonna have a little on-air competition today, um, because I just found out moments ago that Kyle knows how to solve a Rubik's Cube relatively quickly.
- 0:43There's the messed up one. And so [laughs] when we go through the first story of us breaking down the EV tax credit, Kyle's gonna try to solve the Rubik's Cube before I can get through the story.
- 0:51[laughs] Which means two things: number one, if you're watching the story, you won't hear anything I say about EV tax credits, but if you're listening you'll be fine; and number two,
- 1:01um, I think we're gonna f- I, I'm not, I'm not even betting on myself. Kyle, see, if you know Kyle- We'll see. We'll see... I, I think it's gonna be pretty fast.
- 1:08But first, we have a few things to talk about before we get into the fun and games. Um, we started yesterday streaming our Auto Collabs podcast at noon. How about that? Yeah.
- 1:19Yeah, that's gonna be- I think that's gonna be a good, if you're, you know, noon Eastern, 11:00 Central. You know, for the Pacific people, you gotta do it during the morning meeting. Mor- [laughs] Uh, but [laughs]
- 1:30it'll be a great time. Sorry about that.
- 1:31But most everybody else can kinda catch it around lunch, and, and you've got like a half an hour, 40, 40 minutes of, uh, just listening in on some really, really cool conversations.
- 1:40We launched, uh, the Jim McElwee podcast yesterday.
- 1:43And today, uh, we're, we're gonna be talking with Damon Lester, uh, president of Namad and owner of Nissan Abu Dhabi, and talking a little bit about his origin story as well as breaking this barrier of trust that he sees, uh, across the automotive industry between partners and OEMs and dealers and even customers.
- 2:02Uh, so just getting his perspective on, on how that's playing into the automotive retail landscape. So you won't wanna miss that. That's right. So you can get the podcast.
- 2:10It is live now if you want it, autocollabs.com, or just search Auto Collabs on your favorite podcast platform. Or just check out the ASOTU page on LinkedIn, Facebook, or YouTube at noon.
- 2:21LinkedIn preferred, because that's kinda where we spend most of our time, so we like to engage with the community there. Um, what else? Hey, we just wanna say, ASOTU CON is shaping up to be a blizzard of fun.
- 2:34People are calling and texting nonstop being like, "Hey, can I get there? How can I get there?" Industry partner tickets are this close to being sold out. So- 11. Oh, we're down to 11. 11. 11. Woo!
- 2:45Which really means if you're going, usually it's gonna be two people buying at the same time, so we're probably somewhere between five and six purchases away from- Oh... you not being able to go.
- 2:54And we want you to go, especially if you listen to this podcast or watch the show. We wanna make sure you get there. So go to a- asotucon.com, get your tickets. Dealers- Let's go...
- 3:02uh, we still have some tickets available for dealers, so, um, $299, all the meals, all the entertainment, easy and easy out. $399. It's $399. I just gave everyone a discount. [laughs] False advertising.
- 3:15[laughs] It's okay. It's okay. Thanks. Thanks, Kyle. We're good. We're good. But, but we're, we're delivering $1,000 of value. Actually, even more than that. Easily. Easily. Check out the site.
- 3:24Uh, we w- do wanna thank so much, uh, our presenting sponsor, cars.com, for making it possible. We also wanna- Woo... like, we have some cool activations going on. We said- We do...
- 3:33look, there's g- not g- no trade show booths allowed. We put, put the smackdown. No exhibit floor, no trade show booths. You have to think about active, uh, engagements.
- 3:41And speaking of active engagements, I'm not gonna do the segue button, but- Can't segue that. That's- Little company called- That's not fair... it was...
- 3:47[laughs] An aptly named company called Active Engage actually sponsored the VIP lounge. So this is gonna be an elevated VIP lounge where 100 people only are gonna be able to be up there. It's got its own bar.
- 3:59It's got relaxing seating. Uh, maybe they'll be nice enough to get you a pass to it. But, uh- Ooh... they really stepped up to have some fun with the VIP lounge.
- 4:06And if you haven't checked out their TikTok, you need to check out Active Engage's TikTok. Without a doubt.
- 4:11It's one of the reasons we said yes to them as the VIP lounge sponsor, because- We're like, "They can have some fun with this probably," right? [laughs] Can't have boring people hosting the VIP lounge.
- 4:20[laughs] Like, rule number one. Not a chance. So, um, just wanna thank them for doing that. We have some other people we're gonna talk about.
- 4:24But, um, we should, if you're Active Engage and you're listening, we need to make you a, we need you to make a pre-ASOTU CON, uh, TikTok. Like, your team- Please... preparing to go to ASOTU CON.
- 4:35Make that video for us, and we'll get it up here for everyone to enjoy and laugh out 'cause y'all do an awesome job. Okay, let's get into the news. We have three stories to talk about today.
- 4:43But this first one is gonna be all the sizzle. Kyle, shake the hands out. I just found out this morning that Kyle can actually solve a Rubik's Cube like one of those super nerds that he is, um, quickly.
- 4:54Now, he's not like one of those, like, competitive, like, ten-second kids who can do it blindfolded, backwards, behind the back. Yeah, I'm not, yeah, can't do the blindfold, backwards.
- 5:00I saw someone yesterday, uh, or a couple days ago. They were juggling three of them- No, stop it... and solved them all in four and a half minutes. Not a joke. Ridiculous. That, that is next level. That's next level.
- 5:11Yeah. And you taught me something. You said that most people, like, who are that level look at the whole cube and really know they can solve it in 18 moves. Yes. That's crazy. Exactly. That's crazy. It's unbelievable.
- 5:22Oh, man, I just realized something. Okay, so here's the deal. The EV tax credit proposal in the news is, like, a little confusing. It's a little different.
- 5:31So I'm gonna give you the bullet points and break it down and confuse it. And while Kyle is going to attempt to solve the Rubik's Cube, and the rule is I can't just, like, read bullet points.
- 5:42I have to actually go through it like I usually would go through it.
- 5:45And Kyle- And then I'll try and re- I, I'm also gonna be trying, uh, to obtain and retain the information, 'cause I haven't read every bullet point that you put in. And then I'm gonna quiz him at the end.
- 5:53[laughs] It's gonna be amazing. All right, all right. This'll be great. All right, here we go. Best segment ever on the Automotive Podcast. Hold on. Do we, I, do we need theme music? I think- Uh, you know what?
- 6:01L- let's not do the music. Let him have a click clack, and if, if- Yeah, don't do music... if we do the theme music, we won't be able to make the social media posts we need to of this- [laughs]... when we're done.
- 6:08All right, so- All right... here we go. Ready? All right. It's truly messed up, just so everyone knows. All right. Yeah, yeah. Mess it up a little more. Mess it up a little more.There you go. I got it.
- 6:16You got to get the sound. Get it near the mic. The podcast people need to hear you messing it up. There we go. Okay. It's messed up. Okay. The Rubik's cube is messed up, and here we go.
- 6:24So currently the EV tax credit is $7,500 for the first 200,000 units that an OEM sells.
- 6:31It's being proposed, and likely will pass, is lifting the cap on the EV tax credit so now there is no more, but there are also a lot of things in this bill that require regulation on where materials are sourced, the sticker price of the actual vehicle, and the income level of the purchaser.
- 6:48So basically 50% of all the minerals sourced for the battery, uh, creation have to be extracted or processed in the US or a country that has a free trade agreement with the US.
- 7:01In 2024, it's got to be 60% of battery components need to be made or assembled in North America. That increas- increases to 80% in 2026, and by 2029, 100% of the battery has to be assembled in the United States.
- 7:16So really the point of this is to influence manufacturing to get into the US. So that's the, the sourcing component. The other component, the credit cap.
- 7:27The MSRP is capped at $80,000 for pickups and SUVs, and $55,000 for all other vehicles. Meaning if the vehicle is over that amount, then it's not eligible for the credit.
- 7:38So that includes a lot of EVs that are now currently overpriced or priced out of that market, but it also includes a lot of EVs that, the majority of them, that are priced within that price point, and it, again, incentivizes affordability.
- 7:52Um, the next thing, the credit cap for income. So if you have a joint income of over $300,000 a year in your family, you are not eligible for the credit.
- 8:02If you're single and you make over $150,000 a year, you also are not eligible for the credit. An interesting one, too, is that there's a $4,000 tax credit on the table for consumers buying certain EVs that are used.
- 8:15So a used EV tax credit or commercial vehicle.
- 8:18So Manchin, uh, Joe Manchin, that we're hearing so much about him, the swing vote in the Senate, um, he pushed back on people that were saying the credit is unstable or it's, like, too aggressive, and here's what he said.
- 8:29I'm gonna read his quote. Um, he said- Where is it? Where is it? Um, he says, "I want to make sure we're extracting in North America, that we're processing in North America, and we quit relying on China."
- 8:42He was very adamant that, "I don't believe we should be building transportation modes on the backs of a foreign supply chain, and I'm not going to do it. We've never done that in America. We build our own cars.
- 8:53We build our own combustible engines. We've done everything. Now, all of a sudden, we can't?"
- 8:59So Manchin is really saying he wants this bill to believe in America's, you know, ability to provide the transportation needs of itself and not rely on other countries.
- 9:10And he says with this big shift to battery technology, he's all for it. He wants to move it forward, but he says we have to do it in a responsible way.
- 9:17So the Alliance for Automotive Innovation, which includes the Detroit Three, Volkswagen, and Toyota, they did express concern that the EV credits, uh, limit will in- uh, the income limit- Ah. He got it. He got it.
- 9:32I didn't get it. I didn't get it. [laughs] I missed one move. Brian Ortega says- I, I'm not done yet. All right. All right. All right, all right. I'm not- Oh.
- 9:40[laughs] Brian Ortega says he's not hearing one word that I'm saying. [laughs] I'm not either- [laughs]... 'cause I'm trying not to concentrate on Kyle. That's why we haven't had a boat. Okay, so almost. I'm almost done.
- 9:51So maybe Kyle's not almost done. So, so back to the Alliance for Automotive Innovation, which includes the Detroit Three. So it's Detroit Three, Volkswagen, and Toyota.
- 10:00They expressed concern that the, the income limit, meaning, like, certain families or households that make over the certain income level, that $300,000 for joint filers or $150,000 for single, that it's going to sideline a lot of potential buyers when in the beginning early adoption phase of EVs is going to be more essential than ever, more critical than ever.
- 10:21So I think if you take these three considerations, number one, that it's going to require, um, batteries to be sourced, materials to be sourced, or I, I skipped this part, or recycled and produced in the US.
- 10:35It's gonna be, uh, cause them to have to be assembled and manufactured in the US over time, number one in the bill. Number two in the bill, uh, number two, this is number two.
- 10:45Number two in the bill, um, the vehicle can only be- costs a certain amount of money, so $80,000 for trucks and SUVs, $55,000 for sedans, and the household income level of $300,000 for joint filing or $150,000 for single.
- 11:01Those are the three components of the new proposed EV tax bill. Here's the takeaway. This EV transition is a game of chess. It's moves setting up for other moves. It's not checkers, right? It's all these things at play.
- 11:15So we would say to you still, control the things that you can control, right? Pay attention to as much as you can, and that really is gonna be the continued prescription for success in this EV future.
- 11:26But now hopefully you understand the credit bill a little bit more, and hopefully Kyle isn't done with his Rubik's cube so that, um, I can win this one. I don't think I won. I'm not done. He's not done. What happened?
- 11:40[laughs] Uh, so on the top layer- The comments, the comments in, in LinkedIn, people are like, "I don't hear a word that Paul's saying." People are talking about the suspense is real.
- 11:49Um, so, and then Charles McCann comes in with actually he's paying attention to the story. Thank you, Charles.
- 11:54He says, "Very unlikely as long as we're using lithium as far as-" I think he's talking about mining and extracting, uh, from the earth, 'cause we don't have a lot of lithium here in the US. So how far did you get, Kyle?
- 12:03Hold it up. Uh, I'm very close. Uh, th- yeah, I'm, I'm really excited about, uh, how close I was able to get. Mm-hmm. And, uh, yeah, it's, uh, it's not very easy to do this when you're not, like, a professional-
- 12:18And you're under pressure... uh, you're, you're- And I'm, I'm barking in your earJust barking- This is-... just like a mess... this is real life Yeah. No, no movie magic here.
- 12:27We're gonna try this again on a less important story in the future. [laughs] All right. All right. See, now he's stuck on it. He can't pick his head up until- Done... the ru- Done. Okay. [clapping] Got it.
- 12:41I wish I had the applause track. Got it. Got it. Got it. We're moving on. [laughs] I think that, uh, uh, that educating people on this particular, uh, thing is very, very important. It's a generic statement.
- 12:49And I will have to say- [laughs]...
- 12:51that the credit caps, locking out l- high-income, uh, high-income people from these tax credits, who are the primary purchasers and, of early adoption new technology, and locking down, uh, the total cap, the, the cap on the MSRP, are the most poignant pieces of this, uh, because we're seeing higher MSRPs on these EV vehicles, and your, uh, and, and people that are, um, uh, high-income earner- earners are the early adopters.
- 13:18So there's my recap. We're way too long into this. Well done. I did finish the Rubik's Cube. I had to do it twice, 'cause I missed one move on the first time, and we're rolling. Oh, that's how life is.
- 13:27There's a, there's a life, there's a life lesson in there. It's so a life lesson in there. All right, we're gonna move on, speaking on to moving on. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Let me break it up for a second. Mm.
- 13:38All right. Yeah, I gotta get those jitters out. Yeah, you gotta.
- 13:40[laughs] So GM, Google, and Pepsi, as well as a lot of other, um, high market cap companies, are boosting their investments in fixed things, capital expenditures as they cost, which signals a confidence in the future of their business.
- 13:55It's giving the markets confidence, because in times when companies are hesitant to spend and they hoard their cash, it sends the wrong signals to the market and people get scared.
- 14:04But GM, Google, and Pepsi are just three examples of companies who are actually spending money to invest in the future, because they really believe that business is going to continue to be strong and pick up.
- 14:15Um, you know, GM CFO Paul Jacobson talked about expanding the electric fleet, and obviously we know in the industry there have been tons of investments in, uh, EV manufacturing and infrastructure.
- 14:27So the spending actually rose from 1.5 billion to 2.1 year over year. Um, couple other- Yeah... companies doing that too, Kyle.
- 14:35Yeah, no, so Alphabet is, uh, who, who if you know is Google's parent company, um, owns things like YouTube and, and a lot of different infrastructures in a big, uh...
- 14:46And they, and they do a lot of investment as well in other startups.
- 14:48And tech startups are leaning into, uh, things like servers and tech infrastructure, noting that, uh, with the current global outlook, uh, global economic outlook, the strategies to invest deep in technology and computer science allows to build products into the future.
- 15:04So it's just another look at, like, capital expenditures, going to things that support future builds.
- 15:09And it's interesting, because what we're seeing in, in across industries, including the retail automotive space, is that people recognize that, you know, this, this kind of, like, fix the roof while the sun is shi- shining, is also invest the capital while it's there.
- 15:24Yeah. Uh, because when you have that capital to invest and, and not just, like, set aside a nest egg, you actually get the opportunity to go quicker.
- 15:32You know, I've talked, uh, about this to a lot of people, um, is that, is that what happens typically out of any turn- any sort of economic downturn, or particularly a recession, is the people that press in during the recession and have the staying power to come out of it actually accelerate quicker a- uh, quicker.
- 15:49So when you look at, like, 2009, 2010, and some of the companies that were really able to get their things in line in '07 and '08, they actually were some of the highest accelerants in technology and retail.
- 16:02Um, so these companies I think understand that. They have the staying power to make it through, and they're making the investments right now to see themselves on the other side of any economic downturn.
- 16:12Yeah, I mean, that, that principle works in brand marketing as well. When, you know, we see- Period...
- 16:15study after study after study, com- companies who don't like diminish or obliterate their ad spend in downturns are the ones that disproportionately are ahead, coming out ahead.
- 16:25Because during all that time, they're just scooping up market share, right?
- 16:28Sales might not reflect it as far as sales records and year over years, but when they come out of it, you just see that they're two and three times further ahead.
- 16:36Another one of these companies is Pepsi, where they are investing in digital technology that makes sure that machines are stocked properly, um, and that they're stocked. So they're- Mm...
- 16:45really, and if you think about it, this technology, like, lets them know when vending machines are empty, when short- store shelves are empty.
- 16:51So it just cuts out a lot of labor needed to check on things, and allows them to make sure their products are ready when a consumer's ready to purchase it, without all the labor of having to take inventory physically and kind of pass messages back and forth.
- 17:04So, um, really- Luckily for Pepsi, because they're not Coke, they only have to check those things every eight weeks, so the server costs aren't that high. Oh. [laughs] That's a- I mean, that- I got 'em.
- 17:15[laughs] That's because you live in the South. I mean, I'm... Are you- It's true. I'm assuming you're a Coke guy. It's true. Right? You're in the South, right? Well, I mean, I, I'm kind of either, but definitely Coke.
- 17:23And in the South, like, you're like, "What kind of Coke products do you have?" Yeah, right. And you just expect if someone says Pepsi to look at them sideways. [laughs] Exactly. That's my point. That's my point.
- 17:31[laughs] Northeast is a little different. I personally, um, I'm a Coke drinker, but my kids like Pepsi. I don't know what went wrong. But, um, you know, I mean, I guess it makes sense.
- 17:39Pepsi's target market really is, like, Pepsi doesn't have a brand. Their brand is whatever pop- whatever's popular in culture at the moment. That's Pepsi's brand. Yes, exactly. All right. Yep.
- 17:47This last story I'm so excited for. When I came across this this morning, it triggered all these feelings of just, like, business and customer service and nostalgia all at one time.
- 18:01So the, as the story goes, and if you're in the industry, you're listening to this, you've probably heard the infamous, legendary story of Nordstrom's customer service being so great that one time a consumer came in to return tires to a Nordstrom, and they gave him his money back, even though obviously they don't sell tires, and he didn't buy them there.
- 18:21Right. But they're so obsessed with making a good customer experience that they actually refunded this guy for tires. And I was like, "Oh, that, that's good."
- 18:27And I, I think I always assumed it was probably, like, urban legend.Well, yeah, you thi-- like, you're like, somehow the Chick-fil-A story, right, and, and, or the Nordstrom story or the Apple story started as like, "Yeah, you know, the, you know, the guy came in with a tire shirt and they, you know, with a tire on the shirt, and they refunded it."
- 18:47Tire shirt. And all of a sudden- It's a tire shirt... like five years later, it's like- It's a tire... he had four tires that were 18 years old, and they, you know, [laughs] it's like- Right. Yeah [laughs]...
- 18:53a big fish story. It was really old. But this one was actually true, because the president of Pe- uh, of Nordstrom, Pete Nordstrom, recently ho- hosted an episode of the Nordy Pod, which- I love that.
- 19:04[laughs] Talk about brand build. All right, here we go. Next, um, he interviewed a gentleman named Craig Trouts, the sales associate that wa- was behind the story. Now, Craig is no longer with Nordstrom.
- 19:16He's the manager of, um, the Phoenix Contact Centers for Alaska Airlines. And by the way, uh- And by the way- Yeah... he is on LinkedIn, and he does have 30 followers, and I may be 31. [laughs] He's got 30 followers?
- 19:31[laughs] Oh, no, he's got about to have, like, 29 more right now. So he's gonna be up to 60 by the end of the day. Uh, but the interview came out, and, uh, the, the, the story goes like this.
- 19:43Um, uh, and we should probably read his- Okay... actual commentary on it, right? Paul? You, you, you, you wanna be Craig? You wanna be Craig? [laughs] I'll be the customer, and I'll be the customer and the manager.
- 19:52This is a three-character story. So go ahead. You be Craig. Here we go. So, uh, yeah, so Craig, uh, said, "I, I, I came up, I asked him, 'Hey, Mr. Customer, is there anything that I can help you out with?'"
- 20:04And the customer said- [laughs] He said... Oh, actually, I don't think- We can't do it. We can't do it. We have to rehearse this. Can't do it. We're not good. He said, "Help you out with?" [laughs] And so- [laughs]
- 20:17Okay, okay, so- Oh, man... he came up and he said to the customer, like, "Hey, I think you're in the wrong place." And this is the texture to the story that I didn't realize. And Mr.
- 20:25Trouts says, "I did try him to tell him that, you know, Northern Commercial, who was the previous tenant of the building, doesn't exist anymore, and, like, as you can see, we're a clothing retailer."
- 20:35So- Clothing, yeah... the guy did actually buy the tires in the building. It used to be a place that sold tires. And so- Right...
- 20:42he came out, and he said, the guy said, "This is, this is really typical, kinda like old, old, I don't..."
- 20:48"This is the building I bought them in," and they said, [laughs] "if there's anything ever wrong with them, I could bring them back, so here they are."
- 20:55[laughs] The, the, like, irony in two-year-old tires trying to be returned is just, there's one layer there. There's a thing there anyway.
- 21:04And then they're at a Nordstrom, and then some guy has the guts to say, "Yeah, and I bought them at the store that used to be here, and I recognize this is a new store," is quite wild. Uh, so, uh, Mr.
- 21:15Trouts says that his manager the whole time was kind of watching him from the wings, uh, looking out and, uh, from the back stock for the men's shoes.
- 21:23And he realized really quickly, like, "My manager should be coming out here to help me," but he's just kinda nodding in empowerment, like, "You're headed in the right direction." So he keep, and Ms- Mr.
- 21:33Trouts keeps going and, uh, and, and takes the refund.
- 21:37He actually, interestingly enough, called a local Fire- Firestone dealer, so kinda did his research, like similar to a car dealer would call, like, the Harley store, calls them and said, "Hey, what would these tires be worth a couple years later?"
- 21:50Gave them all the radius and that type of stuff. They said 25 bucks, and so, uh, because it was without a receipt, and so the man got his refund that day. And, uh, so it actually happened.
- 22:03The story goes down in infamy, but talk about a consistent brand vision that Nordstrom has, like, laid the groundwork for over y- years and years and years, that an employee then became empowered by his manager, who didn't come in and try and take over the situation, turn the customer away, and boom, like, a legendary story that attributes a legend...
- 22:23and something to a legendary brand that allows others to focus their employees and their, and, and their customer experience on, on what they did. You think they- In- incredible...
- 22:31you think they got their 100 bucks back over time? I think they did. You think they- [laughs] I think they, I think they earned that. 100 bucks it cost them to do that thing? [laughs] Yes.
- 22:39Which, I mean, adjusted for inflation- They're smart... it was probably, like, 400 bucks. [laughs] So, um, [laughs]
- 22:45one, one little cool thing that was in the article, um, by the employee entrance in a lot of Nordstrom stores is a tire. And, you know, uh, some of them- Oh, nice...
- 22:54have signs that say, like, "Create your tire story today," right? And it just is a reminder.
- 22:59So, you know, truth or myth, that story is true, and, um, that is something that we all have the ability to set in motion today across the automotive industry, and it doesn't take a lot.
- 23:12But empower your people as much as you can. Think outside the box. And I know when this happens, like, it can really change the dynamic of the automotive industry and the perception of it, right?
- 23:23If 1,000 of these instances happen every year, how many people are actually gonna hear about it, right? Millions, probably. Come on. Millions, probably. Come on. It's, it's like a brand build lesson. Yeah.
- 23:33So we have to build the brand of retail automotive together. We're trying to do that from our end. We need you to do it from your end. So whatever it is today, think of one person you can just make an incredible fan.
- 23:43Kyle's gonna get back to solving that Rubik's Cube, and maybe I'll learn how to do it, too. No, I'm not gonna learn that. [upbeat music]