Latest / Automotive State of The Union / John Bozzella Paints The Path For China to Bypass US OEMs
Transcript
- 0:00Well, good morning. It is Friday, March 20th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. It's Kyle Mountsier.
- 0:06Today we're joined in the studio with, by, uh, [laughs] joined by the one and only John Bozzella with the Alliance for Automotive Innovation.
- 0:14We're gonna talk about his op-ed that got released in Automotive News this week. It's got people talking. We'll get to that. And, uh, that's gonna be a great part of the show.
- 0:22This week I feel like has been, like, the, the juicy details of auto. Oh, good way to put it. Every, every day has felt like, ooh, we're get- we could- We're getting into it...
- 0:31we could lean on getting on trouble, you know? [laughs] I mean, we're, definitely this is a week of getting into it and, and, you know, sometimes, uh, things just culminate, right?
- 0:38Like, sometimes we're talking about little issues. This week I feel like we're talking about big issues all week long. Yeah. Yeah.
- 0:45You know, I, I don't know if you've noticed this or if you've even seen it, but do you see what's hanging up behind me? No. Hold on. Wait. Oh. [laughs] We got the scarf print. That's crazy, insane. Unbelievable.
- 0:58We got the sample. The, so behind me, it's, it's a scarf, a soccer scarf that says, "You're the human." It is the sample. We're about to get them bulk printed for ASOTU Con that's coming in hot- Yes...
- 1:06May 12th through 14th. The scarves have been a part of... I mean, it's like, this is a soccer fanatic level community that gets together.
- 1:13Um, hundreds of dealers and hundreds of industry partners gathering together in Hanover, Maryland, May 12th through 14th. Um, you know, we were talking about how do we talk about ASOTU Con.
- 1:22It's a place where we can say the hard things out loud, right? Not in a way- Yeah... that's, like, combative, but in a way that's challenging, in a way that actually moves us toward solutions.
- 1:33That's everything from tech, to policy, to marketing, to sales, and F&I- I hear-... company culture, all the things...
- 1:39I hear every single year someone, at, at least one person, but more like five to 10 will come up to me and say, "People are saying things here that they don't say at any other conferences." Every year.
- 1:50And so I think it's because of the community. The guard is down. It's like, all right, we're all in here to solve something. Mm-hmm. Let's actually say the thing instead of just sugarcoating it on the top. Yep.
- 2:00You should get your tickets at asotcon.com. Make sure you get them and book your hotel room at the main event hotel right away because that sucker's gonna sell out, and you can't say- These too...
- 2:10that we didn't tell you. We wanna thank our sponsors of today's show, our friends at Hey Greenlight. What if every salesperson on your team suddenly knew exactly what to say on every call? Relax.
- 2:21We're not cloning your top performer, by the way. It's Wingman from Hey Greenlight.
- 2:25Live prompts during calls that ask your, uh, that help your team ask better questions, handle objections, and confidently set the appointment. Yeah, so there's less guessing, more closing.
- 2:35You have to check out heygreenlight.com. Such a cool product. I wish I had a teleprompter for a lot of areas of my life. [laughs] Not sales calls. Not just sales calls. Yes. I'll put it that way. Not just sales calls.
- 2:45That's right. Okay. So, um, without further ado, uh, we're gonna bring John Bozzella on. He's arguing that Washington State has quietly handled EV-only manufacturers, uh, give- given them a direct pass.
- 2:56John, welcome to the show. Thank you for joining us this morning. Thanks to be with you guys. All right. So, uh, big op-ed in Automotive News, has a lot of people talking. Can you start at the beginning of this op-ed?
- 3:07Why did you feel like, um, you had to submit this and that this is such a pressing issue that we should all be paying attention to? Summarize the issue for us as well. Yeah.
- 3:15So look, it, it, it, this is, here, here, this is a, a series of big questions. You were talking about that a minute ago, right? We're talking at, about the big questions. Mm-hmm.
- 3:23This is a combination of two big questions. One, what should the automotive retail market look like, right? In other words, um, is it a multi-channel market?
- 3:34Um, we sell through dealers, we sell direct, we have an agency model. Is, is it all of the above? Or is there one model that every manufacturer has to work through, right?
- 3:47Our view is there should be one model, and it should be one consistent model, and it's a franchise model. We support the franchise system. Automotive manufacturers sell through dealers, period, paragraph.
- 3:59What we've seen, um, of late is this development where s- you know, the, uh, the kind of, um, you know, the newcomers, uh, you know, the Teslas, Rivians, Lucids of the world are like, "No, we wanna try this sell direct thing," right?
- 4:15And so, um, you know, our view is everybody, newcomer, legacy company, incumbent, no matter what the powertrain is, we should all sell through dealers. My view is I thought the dealers believe the same thing. Mm.
- 4:31And in fact, I get criticism every once in a while when I say, "Hey, whoa, I, I'm not sure this model's perfect.
- 4:36We gotta make sure it's competitive," and people say to me, "Oh, John, you're not supporting the franchise model." Heck yes, I am.
- 4:43My concern is in Washington State, they cut this sort of deal where they say, yes, some people have to sell through dealers, but others, Rivian, Lucid, can sell direct. Here's my question.
- 4:56The Chinese wanna come here to this market. How do I know? I was in Beijing recently, and I was in Shanghai recently. [laughs] They would love to, love to be in the US market.
- 5:05And so this thing just blows a hole in the franchise model, and it shows the Chinese how to come here. Because in Washington, we've now created a discriminatory system.
- 5:14For a certain type of manufacturer, you can only sell through dealers. But for a certain group, you can sell direct.
- 5:22Well, if I'm a Chinese manufacturer, I'm gonna come here and s- I'm, I want, I want what the Tesla got to have. Going right to that space. Yeah. Yeah. Right? And so that's the concern I have.
- 5:30Like, y- you know, like, do we support the franchise model or not? Yeah, and, and the clarity here- Like-... is that a, a state dealer association, Washington State backed the law, right? Yeah.
- 5:41So it wasn't just that the lawmakers kinda came through and came over the top. It was a dealer associa- d- dealer association backing. And, and this is where it goes down to the dealer.
- 5:51And I think this is your argument, is that if this is the position that as an industry, the manufacturer side, right, that's, that's, uh, your, your organization, and the dealer side, typically the ADAs and ADA are all combined in the effort, then we show a united front.
- 6:07But now there's a, there's kind of a bifurcated and there's a question mark, and it's the avenue in which this comes in.What's the, what's the risk that we have here if, for some reason, this is the entry point for these Chinese brands?
- 6:21We've gone over this a bit in the last six to nine months. It's been a heavy topic of conversation.
- 6:26But remind us what the risk is here for especially the US market, not just maybe the, the, the, the main big three in the US, because it's more than just the big three. 100%. Look, here's the risk.
- 6:38The risk is, is that in the case of China, we're not, these are not, uh, companies based in the US competing with companies based in China. This is companies in the US competing with China the nation. Mm.
- 6:55China that is engaged in anti-competitive, unfair economic behavior. It'd be one thing if trade between the countries were fair. Um, we'll compete with anyone.
- 7:09But what we're dealing with is a heavily subsidized, um, and a heavily over-capacitized industry that is pumping that overcapacity to countries around the world.
- 7:19And the risk here is that the whole lake that is filled with this retail business starts to drain as these, you know, meaning the profitability and the sustainability of dealers, uh, and manufacturers in the market if you allow below-market competition into this market.
- 7:39Mm. If it's fair competition, we're all for it. That's the issue. You know, and your point about Washington dealers is exactly right. You know, we face the same thing in New Hampshire.
- 7:48New Hampshire legislative put a bill together that said everybody should have the option to sell direct, everybody including the members I represent, the Toyotas and the GMs of the world. We opposed that.
- 7:59That's a huge point. We worked with the dealers, and we beat it. When we stand together and we're united, we win these things.
- 8:05And, and the, one of the great things I think about the franchise model is that there is vast competition within the model. So it's, it's not, you're not limiting competitive option.
- 8:15Actually, you're increasing a competitive environment where you have multiple people competing for price, competing to deliver a better customer experience, and if they don't get it in one place, they can go and there's someone competing for their business somewhere else.
- 8:28We have seen, uh, a similar model, we were talking about it earlier this week, with VinFast.
- 8:33Here you have, um, an, a, a foreign company coming in, manufacturing vehicles in the US, going through a dealer network, and we're seeing a situation where, like, you can establish and set up this way.
- 8:44Um, what, what are your thoughts on VinFast, the way they're doing things, and is, is that something that we can look to, to kind of maybe bridge the gap? Yeah, I think that's a great example.
- 8:52You know, and I, and I've had an opportunity to get to know the team at VinFast and, you know, look, I think, I think, uh, you know, Madame Thuy is a force of nature, the chairman of the board of that company.
- 9:01I mean, yeah, I think she totally gets it, right? And that's exactly what she wants to do. Her ambition is to put down roots here in the United States- Mm...
- 9:07both at the retail network, working with dealers, as well as ultimately manufacturing here in the United States, and that is, that is a great approach, right? And now look, it's challenging, right?
- 9:19Because it requires capital, and it requires partnerships, and it requires the types of work, you know, that, you know, it, it's hard work in the up, on the upfront side of it, but what you end up with is you end up with loyalty, and you end up with partners, and you end up with, you know, support for customers.
- 9:36And that's why, you know, taking the harder tack upfront makes more sense in the long run, in my view.
- 9:43W- whenever we talk about, uh, China or Trump or, or any, any of those, uh, considerations in this show, even though a lot of the times we're speaking to a dealer partner network, there's a lot of consumers that may, uh, see this and, and start to question, like, "Why the fight?
- 9:59Why is this, why is this an important battle, and how does it impact me as a consumer?"
- 10:04Under, uh, maybe even understanding, like, I see the business outcome for the, for the dealer and how that could be advantageous there.
- 10:10But as a consumer looking at some of these considerations and the way that maybe the dealer associations, the OEM associations are considering laws like this, what would you say to the consumer that might be happening upon some of this because it's coming into the public eye?
- 10:25Yeah. Yeah, well, f- like, it, this is a really important point, right?
- 10:28Because now it's been delayed, but, but President Trump and President Xi of China are looking to get together at some point very soon, and they're gonna have a discussion about sort of what the trade relationship could be.
- 10:39We've advised the president of the United States to tread very carefully in this space, to consider competition and to consider, you know, our system, um, carefully before they allow any Chinese manufacturers into the United States.
- 10:56What, well, so what does that mean from a customer perspective? Now, if you're a customer, you say, "Look, I want more choice. I want more opportunities. I want more value." Yes to all of that. But here's the thing.
- 11:07First of all, you know, the US policymakers are concerned that Chinese, uh, connected vehicle technology, um, is a potential national security threat. Security threat. Mm-hmm.
- 11:18And so, so, you know, I think we have to be very careful here, cybersecurity concerns, privacy concerns, um, as well as overall economic competitiveness concerns before we open that door.
- 11:32And that's really ultimately a concern, I think, for customers, uh, as well as for manufacturers and dealers.
- 11:38And so, you know, what we're saying is, let's make sure we get these questions answered, get the economic competitiveness question answered, make sure that the competition is fair, get the national security question answered.
- 11:49Is it a threat or is it not a threat? The US government right now thinks it's a threat, and so they've put this, they've put these rules in place.
- 11:55And so, you know, these are big questions, and I, and I do think, you know, not only as consumers, but as, as citizens, we ought to be paying attention to this. You know, I ha- we have you here.
- 12:05I'll, I'll, I was gonna wrap it, I, one more question came to mind. Just wondering what your perspective is on this.
- 12:09So Rivian obviously, uh, one of the beneficiaries of the Washington law, and obviously there's a lot of, uh, back and forth going between dealers and Rivian and, and you're kind of in this-Interesting place because VW is also, you know, one of your members and associations.
- 12:24But, um, the question was, Rivian has recently talked about the majority of their pre-orders and the, uh, majority of their initial vehicles are actually gonna be EREVs and have a gas-powered engine in them.
- 12:36Is the regulation with EVs just about powertrain? Is that not connected to a gas, or is that just a gray area that we haven't gotten to yet? Yeah.
- 12:44Yeah, this idea of, "We'll let EV manufacturers sell direct," is that the question? Like, look, that's a pretext, right? Uh, you know, this is just a, "I need to cut a deal." You know, Rivian's, uh, you know, threatened.
- 12:56They bluffed the Washington dealers. They bluffed them. They said, "We're gonna run a big referendum and we're gonna, we're gonna, we're gonna barge our way in-" Sorry... until we should cut a deal." I said Rivian.
- 13:04I said Rivian. Kyle's correcting me. I actually mean Scout. [laughs] Okay. Well, let me talk about Scout. Sorry about that. [laughs] Okay, so, so here's, like, here's the thing. I, just so we're clear- Yeah...
- 13:13we represent Volkswagen. We represent Honda. Our view is this: We should sell through dealers, period, paragraph.
- 13:21Whether you are Tesla, Rivian, Scout, Afela, we make no distinction between time in the marketplace or powertrain or anything else. We either have one system or we don't. That's back to your first point.
- 13:36I think that's a great way- Period, paragraph. That's right. I'm stealing that from John Bozzella. I think it go- By, by the way, like, you guys are way better than me at all the, like, the, the, the phrases.
- 13:43And by the way, I wore my "Love people more than cars" hoodie on a, on the plane recently. And man, it's such a great conversation starter. Isn't it, though? Immediately. Every single time. Yes. Doesn't matter. Yes.
- 13:55Oh, that's great. [laughs] Well, thanks for representing. John, uh, thank you for joining us today.
- 13:58I'm looking forward to the conversation you, me, and Mike Stanton are going to have, uh, on stage at the New York Auto Forum on the 31st in just about 10 days from now.
- 14:06Thanks for being such an advocate for everyone out there working hard to make this an industry that people fight to join. I hope you enjoy the rest of your Friday and get some work done. Paul, Kyle, thanks so much.
- 14:14Great to be with you to, as always. Man, I, [laughs] we, I'm always like, "Why don't we hang out more?" [laughs] Every time. We should hang out with John more and other people like him.
- 14:25I, I, I appreciate not just the sentiment, but the care for every party involved. And the consideration all the way down to the consumer is, I think, something that our industry has as its nature.
- 14:35Uh, and I would argue that the Washington state dealers, when they, when they went into this, were thinking in that direction. Mm-hmm.
- 14:41Uh, but the consideration of multiple parties understanding the global game and the national game is something that we have to have at the forefront. So thanks to John.
- 14:48Thanks for others that are, uh, keeping this conversation a- at the, at the forefront of our minds, dealers' minds, consumers' minds, OEM and the, and the political ecosystem. It's a big deal. That's, it, it really is.
- 14:59This, this, as we're closing here, it reminds me of something that the auto industry is contributing, I believe, to society and culture and the conversation in general.
- 15:09So many times people treat issues as black and white, and they get, they, they get aggressive at one another- Mm... and they start, like, demonizing one another.
- 15:18And I think auto is a great, uh, this conversation that's going on is like, "Hey, topics are complex." Yes. It's 3D chess. It's not this or that.
- 15:28We have to make considerations that in the end our obligation, like, the, the government's obligation is to protect the country and protect the people in there.
- 15:37The auto industry has stepped up to say, "Hey, we're also, we wanna protect the consumer by protecting income, by protecting the community involvement, and protecting us against something that could actually drain the whole pond and not just affect one little issue."
- 15:50So, uh, what a way to start a Friday, Kyle. Like, we get to- What a rip. So, uh, listen, if you're listening, watching, this is a great weekend.
- 15:58Before the weekend, a great time to go to asotucon.com so you can have more conversations like this in person.
- 16:04[upbeat music]