Latest / The Team House / The Future of Human Intelligence w/ Senior CIA Officer Marc Polymeropoulos | EYES ON | Ep. 13
Transcript
- 0:00Hey guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today about
- 0:03a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:06we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple or
- 0:10Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get recognized,
- 0:16and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really appreciate
- 0:19your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is to
- 0:24become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five dollars
- 0:29a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all of
- 0:32our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is the
- 0:41biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if you'd
- 0:47like to, and we really appreciate that, So go and check us out
- 0:51at patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. Hello everyone, Welcome to another episode
- 0:58of iz On. Today we have a special create Aside from our usual lineup
- 1:03star host cast with both THEE and Jason, today we have Mark Polymeropolis and
- 1:10I am smiling a little bit because we were laying bets on who would mess
- 1:15up his name the most, but because it is for me being ingrained into
- 1:19my memory, it trips off my tongue. Delighted to have him. You
- 1:23will be pleased to hear that that we are going to give him a stream
- 1:29of consciousness today. Quick ait, quick bit about Mark in case you've been
- 1:34hiding under a rock and just don't know who he is. Mark's been twenty
- 1:38six years in the agency, has had a number of a When you look
- 1:42at his resume, it's a lot of hard billets in bad places. And
- 1:49yes, you know, Jason will tell you, of course that's the norm
- 1:53for the agency, but it looks like Mark has actually chosen these places out
- 1:59Marks. Mark also was the target of I think was suspecting, well he
- 2:06is suspected was an e W attack or a directed energy attack that that resulted
- 2:13in traumatic brain injury and he's been going through treatment for that. So if
- 2:19you have questions about please you know, do duping him. And since you
- 2:24know since leaving the agency, and by the way, you know Mark,
- 2:28Mark's name carries a lot of wister in the agency. When we even thought
- 2:34we were getting him on the show, Jason, I don't know how to
- 2:38say it of it and what I mean he was giddy. But anyway,
- 2:43since my point is, since Mark's got out, he has continued to do
- 2:46great work. For the course, some of you may have been following his
- 2:51writing and his commentary. He is one of those rare people who they rope
- 2:53in as an expert to Fox News, MNS, b C and in Well,
- 3:01anyway, thank you the spending the name. Okay, that's long enough.
- 3:07Intro Monk. We ought to like it to to have you on,
- 3:12and I'm gonna tone over to you to uh, to talk about your your
- 3:15favorite topic, which I think is soft agency integration. So so hey,
- 3:22thanks guys so much. You know, it's it's an honor beyond here.
- 3:24Congratulations on the show. I actually I'm I have. I have listened to
- 3:28it, I've watched it, love it, uh, And of course I've
- 3:30been a friend of the team house for for some time. I think,
- 3:34do you how many times I've been on? Five times? I don't know,
- 3:37I think there might be four, Okay, but it's been it's been
- 3:40a blast. Yeah, So you know, because again I love coming on
- 3:44because I'm talking to my old peeps. And there's a sense for me of
- 3:47comfort frankly, and doing that is you know, when we love when we
- 3:50leave the agency. You know, there's a lot of things I don't miss
- 3:53about it, but there's certainly the camaraderie and kind of the brotherhood and sisterhood.
- 3:55That's what I really really do miss. And so thanks for having me
- 3:59on great Or. I know it's early in the morning, but come on,
- 4:01I'm almost fifty five years old. I get up at like five,
- 4:03So you guys got to suck it up. It's not early. It's seven
- 4:06thirty there. Generation we got Generation Z and very early for me. I'm
- 4:14young enough to be Generation X, but he's not. I have grand kids.
- 4:17This is oh no. But you you mentioned something. I just did
- 4:24a talk to a DoD seminar, the Department of Defense seminar. I think
- 4:27there's fourteen hundred people on a zoom call and it was something that I actually
- 4:30believe in passionately. And that's you know, the future of the CIA Special
- 4:34operations, you know, forces soft relationship, but really how we do this
- 4:41kind of in the era of great power competition, which is kind of Russia
- 4:44China in some case, you know, maybe Iran, But you know almost
- 4:46kind of the crappy States or or where the Department of Defense sees kind of
- 4:50our greatest threats coming from. But how do we take those twenty years of
- 4:55the GYT in which the US, which is CI and SOFT were kind of
- 4:59you know, a line side by side. How do you translate that?
- 5:01And in particular, and I know I'm jumping into the weeds too much.
- 5:03You guys will shut me up, the start waving your hands if I'm talking
- 5:06too much, But but how do you do this in the era of what
- 5:10we call and Jason's going to notice really well, ubiquitous technical surveillance, which
- 5:15means a way different operational environment that I grew up in that Jason operated in,
- 5:19and that you know, how does the agency and SOFT run you know,
- 5:25in essence clandestine slash covert operations when you have sensors everywhere, really interesting
- 5:30stuff and so uh you know, that's that's my that's my stream of conscious
- 5:33this this morning along with you know, I I picked up I was reading
- 5:38the paper this morning. I was thinking about our colleagues, the US Embassy
- 5:41and import of Prance and Haiti. I mean, holy shit, talk about
- 5:44environments in which we all used to operate. That is crazy, crazy stuff
- 5:46going on now. So that's where I am this morning, jacked up on
- 5:49coffee and I've been up a while. So hey, mar come the on
- 5:55this your your discussions of Soft agency? Can you can you talk about I
- 6:00mean, I'm I'm all on when we look at our past experiences. When
- 6:04I was hosting the Irregular Warfare podcast, we had some really good episodes on
- 6:11this particular topic. And when we look back, yes, we eventually figured
- 6:16it out actually in Afghanistan right off the bat. But then but then we
- 6:20had some rocky times in that relationship and sometimes when it was two compountmentalized it
- 6:26always worked really well at the team level, you know, always always never
- 6:31and so if we can capture that, if you could maybe talk about some
- 6:36so I mean areas of times before what Colombia I'm thinking of, like things
- 6:44like Plan Colombia where or El salvad or where small you know, Soft and
- 6:49the agency worked together very well on an formal level. And the second thing,
- 6:55if you could just talk about and you can do this in a way
- 6:58that makes it otherwise dry subjects sound really exciting, but the you know,
- 7:02the title ten title fifty obstacles perception, they're all of et cetera, et
- 7:10cetera. Sure, So I mean, let's let's go back to World War
- 7:13Two, you know, so the creation of the Office, the OSS,
- 7:15the Office of Strategic Services, so kind of you know, the intelligence gathering,
- 7:19special operations, you know, in some sense always kind of had an
- 7:25entity, and that was the OSS. And in fact that the CIA and
- 7:28SOFT were born out of the same kind of you know thing, and so
- 7:32you know, and and but they are two different entities as you as you
- 7:36mentioned, and they operate under different titles, whether you know Title ten or
- 7:40Title fifty, which is intelligence operations versus military operations. But ultimately, I
- 7:45think that if I look back in my career, I whan I started the
- 7:48agency in ninety three, So really the Balkan conflict in Bosnia, you know,
- 7:53is where this this stuff kind of started, and where you know,
- 7:56members of my generation first got a got an inkling that we have to kind
- 8:00of integrate and work closely with with SOFT. And then of course nine to
- 8:03eleven occurred. But what what kind of bound us together was necessity and so
- 8:09and so, and that of course is the challenge now, you know,
- 8:13so what do we have. We have war zone operations, we had embassies
- 8:16and Bagdad and Cobble with a thousand personnel. That means there's a thousand CIA
- 8:20personnel who every day are side by side with their soft brothers and sisters,
- 8:24and so we kind of squashed together, forced to kind of learn about each
- 8:28other. Everyone has their own habits, everyone has their own preconceived notions.
- 8:31I mean, you know, what does it happen? So, you know,
- 8:33someone from fifth Group walks in and we say, hey, here come
- 8:35the knuckle draggers. Some of the agency comes in, they say, watch
- 8:39a while, they're going to steal our ship. And that was the first
- 8:41you know, that was the first kind of reaction. But then over time,
- 8:45because you had this U certainly a common enemy, but we're actually in
- 8:48proximity next to each other, we were forced to adapt and learn and I
- 8:52think that is absolutely key. But what does what does that really mean?
- 8:54It means personal relationships and that's you know, and the kind of the talk
- 8:58that I gave, I called it the three rs. It was relationships,
- 9:01Resources, and then Russia meaning meaning kind of you know, the the our
- 9:07conflicts for the future. I'm being really Russia China. But but when I
- 9:11say relationships, so you know, I talked to think about Chris Miller.
- 9:15I don't know if he's on your show or not. Chris Miller was the
- 9:18you know, acting Secretary of Defense in the Trump administration. I first met
- 9:20Chris on the border with with uh you know Kuwait on the board with the
- 9:24Rock in two thousand and two when he was with Fifth Group. And so
- 9:26you know, you have these personal relationships, same thing with you know,
- 9:30the the he was he was. I think he's now the commander Jay Sock.
- 9:33I don't even know if I'm supposed to say his name. He was
- 9:35the head of the Seal Team six of DEV Group. I first met him
- 9:39when he was just a you know, a regular seal officer, and so
- 9:41because just side by side year after year, and where in Afghanistan, in
- 9:48Iraq, in Syria, I'm gonna think of, you know, good buddy
- 9:50of mine, Rob Blively, he retired as the CSM, the command Sergeant
- 9:54major of he'll get mad if I say this of Delta. He doesn't say
- 9:56it, but I'll say it. Him and I spent six months to other
- 10:00kind of in Syria years ago and got to be great friends, and so
- 10:03when they kind of when everyone grows up together in their organizations, those relationships
- 10:07are key, so and andy. When you you know, I think about
- 10:11things that went wrong. Sometimes there's a there's a there's a strike in Yemen,
- 10:15the famous wedding strike. It was a bad, bad strike on a
- 10:18q AP, killed a lot of innocent people. Huge mess between the agency
- 10:22and UH and and Soft and Jaysck really and it was worked out in the
- 10:26end because the personal relationships that I and a whole bunch of other people had.
- 10:28And so think about that in relationships. You know, born in the
- 10:31oss kind of I think Bosnia was a was a big deal, but then
- 10:35Afghanistan a rock really kind of made that and kind of nurtured it. And
- 10:41so that you know, as you guys know this, everyone knows this.
- 10:43I mean, I can you know if you and I know each other and
- 10:46something bad happens, but you know, we have this personal relationship. We're
- 10:50going to figure it out, as bad as it might be, and and
- 10:54you can kind of overcome all those biases. One key point just to make
- 10:58on this stuff. And I think it started in Bosni as well, you
- 11:01know Columbia. I imagine same thing I'm not just not as familiar, but
- 11:05as a case officer, and Jason you'll understand this as a case officer.
- 11:07So if I'm sitting in Bagdad, or if I'm sitting in uh in Cobble,
- 11:13I have an agent meeting. You know, we have a penetration of
- 11:16ISIS or al Qaeda or something like that. Uh. And so, but
- 11:18our royal, our kind of our kind of piece in this pie, and
- 11:22the fine and fixed finish mission is the fine and fixed mission. And I
- 11:26got my soft colleagues to the right or left of me, and you know,
- 11:28they're they're doing the finish. Why would I not? And I did,
- 11:31and it was not the norm, But why would I not in the
- 11:35beginning of some of these conflicts take a soft operator with me to an agent
- 11:37meeting. I mean, do I not fucking trust them? Of course I
- 11:41do. Uh, They're they're in an America and they have their clearances.
- 11:43Now that was not the norm. But I would take someone, for example,
- 11:46from dev group with me to an agent meeting when we're trying to go
- 11:48after a high value target, and you know, and you know, perhaps
- 11:52CI headquarters would go bananas about this, But then slowly this gets kind of
- 11:56institutionalized, and we're like, you know what, you know, these guys
- 11:58get it. We can trust them, and they're in fact they're the consumer
- 12:03as we're doing these fine fixed finish My consumer is my soft colleagues right next
- 12:07to me, not the President of the United States. It's not Secretary of
- 12:09State. I'm not getting the talking points for the foreign minister. I'm getting
- 12:11a location of of a of a bad guy. And so you know,
- 12:16that kind of understanding and that change in mindset I think was really important.
- 12:22And you know, what does it do with builds trust? Uh and uh
- 12:24and ultimately successful and so you know, some of my fondest memories. I
- 12:28mean, you know, a great buddy of mine is mc mulroy. You
- 12:30guys pat him on the show. I mean, Mick and I have been
- 12:31in Iraq and Afghanistan together and and when we're up in the Nile teams in
- 12:35northern Iraq living with the Kurds, I mean, this is where you know,
- 12:39and he think I think he wrote a piece too that he got cleared
- 12:43by the Agency about this to the kind of the integration with Tenth Group and
- 12:46how how you know the our agency kind of element there along with UH Special
- 12:50Operations Forces really were critical in kind of in the battle against not only Saddam's
- 12:56Iraq but also terrorist groups. And so it's just the way to do it.
- 13:00And so the key thing on the relationships is, I guess the question
- 13:03is how do we continue that now when we have Russia China, when you
- 13:07don't have embassy Bagdad or embassy Cobble, how do those relationships we need to
- 13:13We need to nurture them, we need to sustain them. I mean,
- 13:15I'm retired, you know, Jason, You're out, and so so you
- 13:18know, so at the end of the day, we got it. We
- 13:22got to make sure that these relationships can flourish or we're going to go back
- 13:26to those old biases. Absolutely. I mean I came in during a time
- 13:28when EO one two triple three, which basically told us you will cooperate,
- 13:35but that was interagency was really hot and heavy. So I didn't you know,
- 13:41obviously, can you explain quickly what what that was? The Executive Executive
- 13:46Order one two triple three. It's the the I don't know the legal eads
- 13:50of it, but basically it's it was after nine to eleven when we saw
- 13:54the mistakes that had been made because of compartmentalization between US and mainly FBI.
- 14:00I uh, literally we sat or FBI sat in our spaces but didn't share
- 14:07the information. They would get information from their people, but literally within the
- 14:11same office wouldn't tell us. Now, I say us as in CIA,
- 14:13this is before me. So nine to eleven happens, and we figure,
- 14:18hey, you know, we can't have this. So EO one two Triple
- 14:20three was signed and disseminated saying you will cooperate with one another. And so
- 14:26I came in at a time when it was already being implemented, so I
- 14:31didn't have an issue of hey, I can't tell you that. You know,
- 14:35yes, there were certain things that I need to be read into,
- 14:37or someone had to get permission from their asaced or you know, or their
- 14:41special agent charge to be able to tell me. But it was pretty smooth.
- 14:45I had some you know, speaking to what Marc was talking about,
- 14:48some great relationships with FBI agents that I still have who are in some pretty
- 14:52senior positions today. But again they were a special agent, junior special agent.
- 14:56I'm a junior intelligence officer, and you know, we just we just
- 15:01clicked on a personal level, and because of that, I did a lot
- 15:05of work domestically. So when I would go out to these meetings, if
- 15:09that person, you know FBI, we would take FBI along with us,
- 15:13and they would be able to ask questions from a legal standpoint, you know,
- 15:18trying to make a case or whatever they're trying to do. That I
- 15:22might have been able to ask, but it won't cross a line, or
- 15:26it was something that I just didn't even think to ask because I'm not looking
- 15:28I'm looking at gathering the intel. You know, they're looking at it from
- 15:31a prosecution standpoint or a counter intelligence standpoint. So those relationships were pretty awesome.
- 15:37And sometimes in the beginning it was hey, let's sit down and and
- 15:43game this. Let's figure out you asked this, I'll ask that, blah
- 15:46blah blah. After a while it just became sympathic. It was just,
- 15:50you know, they knew to ask questions that I missed, or you know,
- 15:54things like that, or they would be able to even say something that
- 15:56would calm the person down because I'm getting them revved up trying to get the
- 16:00intel. They would be able to say something, or I would be able
- 16:03to say something to calm that person down reset and then they would be more
- 16:07comfortable telling us what we need to know. So I think that's a smaller
- 16:10scale of what Mark is talking about No One, and again it's but it's
- 16:15also based on necessity, you know, and so that's that's huge. By
- 16:18the way, I think I flipped title ten, title fifty when I was
- 16:22describing that. Sorry about that, because if you think back, title the
- 16:26Love of Operation was the title fifty operations. Sorry. So, so all
- 16:30of those were good things. But we have and when I say we,
- 16:34I mean we collectively US security establishment have a dreadful record about about holding on
- 16:42to lessons learned and reapplying them right off the band the next time we need
- 16:47to. And as you point out, Mark, now is the time to
- 16:49do this. And you know, while they're obstacles in the way, I
- 16:55mean, I can I just give you an example that I think, you
- 16:57know, I think you're right on target. So we are. You know,
- 17:00we've been talking about the Red Sea problem recently. Bottom line is this,
- 17:06there's really only two ways to solve that. One is to really really
- 17:08put pressure on Iran, but that might not even solve the problem. Who
- 17:12knows if the who these are now the teenagers ready to leave the house number
- 17:17two And Evan cringe is when I say this, but you do need to
- 17:19have someone on the ground because that terrain there. You can launch all the
- 17:25air strikes you want based on targeting data that looks really good and still not
- 17:30headed damn thing that you know of worth doing. You know how it is,
- 17:33it's very easy for them to move stuff. It's very easy to do
- 17:37it undercover, et cetera, et cetera. So the only way you can
- 17:40get in and obviously you don't want to put conventional forces there who are basically
- 17:44helmeted targets just walking around. You want to put guys who are working with
- 17:48Ian Ditch on the ground who does that best, you know agency. But
- 17:53you have to have DD reps there too because of the support that you're going
- 17:57to need, you know, you guys know, yes, of course,
- 18:03and principal d O D will I mean d O D will always support.
- 18:06But it really helps, really helps if you have self guys you know,
- 18:10represent on on the ground too. Yeah, and you should, I mean,
- 18:12you know it's so so, I mean, how do we how do
- 18:15we how do we how do we do that? Going ahead? You know,
- 18:17I mean, so I think there's okay. So there's there's a there's
- 18:21a couple of things on that. And if you take a look for example,
- 18:23you know Ukraine is is not great just because of the kind of the
- 18:27prohibition set by the White House on on no U S boots on the ground.
- 18:33So you know, ostensibly, you know, do you will smile?
- 18:36Now you know there's a there's a rather large intelligence community footprint in Ukraine,
- 18:40and and what there should be is a soft footprint as well. There's not
- 18:45because of prohibition from the White House, but but really that would be an
- 18:48ideal, you know, and that's just something that you know, you kind
- 18:51of have to ultimately live with. But you know, when you think about
- 18:53kind of the I call it, and it's not so it's it's the man
- 18:56hunting triad of human sigant and is SR, but it would apply to something
- 19:02like the houthis as well. So you know, you do need human and
- 19:04so that means you need people on the ground. And so so let me
- 19:07get let me go back to what I was talking about before. And one
- 19:11of the one of the evolutionary things that happened with SOFT is they also had
- 19:17the ability and were trained, and they went down to our schoolhouse down to
- 19:19the farm as well, so they had they had some you know, the
- 19:23special mission units of of SOFT have in some ways some of the same training
- 19:30as the agency does in terms of you know, surveillance detection. And I
- 19:33thought, union is human there's there's I gotta be careful in saying this.
- 19:37There's troops, there's there's units in these special mission units who are trained up
- 19:42to kind of the gold standard. So there's a way to kind of work
- 19:45together with the agency on this. I I kind of I agree completely,
- 19:48one hundred percent completely, but but let me kind of flip all of this
- 19:53to what's important is how to sustain these relationships, how to sustain this ability
- 19:59to work to together. And it has to do, I think, with
- 20:03training. And so one of the things what I still don't understand doesn't happen
- 20:07is why, for example, for the special Forces, the Q course,
- 20:11why for the agency, you know, tradecraft training down at the farm,
- 20:15Why are we not cross training? And so what you do is you take
- 20:18everyone this is gonna be a silly analogy, like you know, out of
- 20:21the womb at birth, when you're training someone to be in our kind of
- 20:26old weird world. Let's start from that. Let's start with the idea of
- 20:29we're going to have to work together from the beginning. So in the final
- 20:32problem, set down the farm or in the Q course, integrate what a
- 20:36station would be like, Integrate what an inter agency environment is like, Integrate
- 20:40what a war zone environment is like. Do it from the beginning, because
- 20:42what happens people learn, But then all of a sudden, I'm sitting there,
- 20:45twenty six years old, just graduated with the farm next to my you
- 20:48know, maybe someone of a similar age from Army, Navy, Marine Corps,
- 20:53you know, special operations. I'm going to know that person for the
- 20:56next twenty years because we trained together. Don't do that. I don't get
- 21:00that. It's because you know, and but it's gonna take you know,
- 21:03and and of course and Jason will remember this. There's there'll be a thousand
- 21:07reasons we can't do this, okay, because they're not cleared, or we're
- 21:11too busy or this or that you should do it, and you know,
- 21:14talk about what we do even domestically with the bureau. Same thing. Why
- 21:18down a quantico is there? You know, aren't there when they're training to
- 21:21be a special agent. Why are there not agency folks down there? This
- 21:23is what it was like to be I gotta be careful again, but in
- 21:26a perhaps a domestic environment, what a domestic station would look like. Here's
- 21:30how you work with your your intelligence community partners, just for missus special agent.
- 21:37So it's it's that you know, that kind of that training piece that
- 21:40I think we were not getting right and we're gonna fall back on our bad
- 21:42habits again. And all of a sudden when China moves on Taiwan and we
- 21:48have an embassy country team that's kind of in a panic on this in Taiwan,
- 21:52you know, and and and agency and soft and you know the bureau,
- 21:56they are all together. Well, if you know, if if they
- 21:59didn't experience into Rock and Afghanistan Assyria, and they might not, how are
- 22:03they going to work together? Well, they would be able to if they
- 22:04trained. So that's that's saying. That's a really interesting point. And you
- 22:10brought up kind of a couple of things said that I want to go back
- 22:12sure and touch on. So first of all, your point about integration with
- 22:18training, Yeah, it is. It is amazing that we haven't done that
- 22:22yet at the institutions. You know, we all know that it's happening.
- 22:26For instance, in Mars SOK, we would bring agency guys into our former
- 22:30agency guys into eight exercise. But it's still not quite the same as you
- 22:34know, having a one gray beard there is different than than setting it up,
- 22:40so you're actually integrating training and I and I think you know, the
- 22:45obstacle to that is just the fact that although there is a great kind of
- 22:52peacetime I'll use that to a peace time I hate it, but peace time
- 22:53relationship or in between the wars relationship between the agency and Tier one, that
- 23:00relationship tends to atrophy between the agency and you know, I hate using these
- 23:07terms, but soft right tier too or you know whatever we're calling them today,
- 23:12white soft, which is you know, which is which is all important?
- 23:17Which I think you're larger, way larger. Yeah, and the tentacles
- 23:21so farther and it is, but and it's really where you want to have
- 23:25that connection because it is where you're doing stuff day in, day out in
- 23:30an area with people who are regionally affiliated with that area. Lastly, I'm
- 23:36gonna say though, though on on that, I think you're on the right
- 23:40track because putting people when we're talking about forcing this or not forcing it,
- 23:47but you know, forming a task organized teams, it's going to take forever.
- 23:52You know that we're not even within d O D. But now you're
- 23:56talking about between d D and an outside agency, and you're looking about doctrine,
- 24:00and you're talking about you know, so many other things that it will
- 24:04take. We will talk about this forever before we do it. But if
- 24:08you set up within the school houses and the institutions, then you're building that
- 24:12relationship informal and you've got type A personalities in on both sides who are going
- 24:18to make this happen in a in a and and come up with really good
- 24:21ideas in each region. Let me let me throw in here's a here's a
- 24:25great hypothetical scenario that I that I use all the time because I have to
- 24:29say it's hypothetical just to get it by the Agency Publication Review Board. But
- 24:33it's not hypothetical because it's true. That's just super It's going to be like
- 24:37a Jason's hypothetical. Honeypot never happened. So so let's say so again a
- 24:44hypothetical. So you're at a US embassy in Eastern Europe. And your role
- 24:49is uh, you know, obviously it's not the same as as a war
- 24:52zone, but your role is to uh, to kind of uncover find out
- 24:56what Russian intelligence officers are doing. Right, it's a small CI station and
- 25:02so and you know we're working with the local liaison too, but in essence
- 25:07we're doing and just think about this compared to the g whatt we need to
- 25:10find pol pattern of life on the Russian io presence, right, So what
- 25:12does that mean a lot of time on the street, some kind of surveillance
- 25:15training, maybe you know, you know, recruiting folks who can assist on
- 25:19this. It's a fine fix mission. But the finish mission obviously is not
- 25:25you know, a health fire missile from m Q nine. The finish mission
- 25:27is going to be a recruitment attempt. A finish mission might be a disruption
- 25:30operation with with local liaison, but that's the that's the job. So all
- 25:34of a sudden you have a soft element that kind of rolls in, uh.
- 25:38And they're doing primarily again it's an Eastern Europe, so they're probably primarily
- 25:44training you know, local security services. So a station chief a smart one
- 25:48and this is where that this is the resources piece of my whole argument this,
- 25:51the smart one is going to be like, you know, hey,
- 25:52guys like or gals or whoever, it is like, you know, you
- 25:56know, I have a I have a manpower shortage because cee I always does
- 26:00overseas. People forget how small there's less. There's more FBI special agents in
- 26:03New York City than there are CI case officers globally, So that's how small
- 26:07CIA is. But the locals, the station chief would say to the soft
- 26:11commander, who's probably not an officer, probably you know, an E eight
- 26:15or nine or whatever, and and so so you would say, you know,
- 26:18what training do you guys have or galas have And they're like, well,
- 26:21you know what, you know, we did the equivalent of kind of
- 26:22what we call HETSI Hostile Environment trade course tradecraft course. In fact, there's
- 26:27and you know, and and there's lots of units that that have HETSY training.
- 26:30And they're like, the CS is gonna be like all right, hey,
- 26:33so when you're done with your training evolution with with the local security services,
- 26:37can I have some of your guys and gallus to go out in the
- 26:40street Because I got to find these Russian intel officers. We got to find
- 26:41their patternal life and give me two weeks. Uh. And so the local
- 26:47soft uh team, it would be like, well, goes back to you
- 26:49know, goes to his teammates, Hey, you want to help the agency
- 26:52out kind of chase in Russian assholes and they're like fuck yeah. And so
- 26:56it's all right, So now what do we have now, So there's there's
- 26:59some people train correctly, we have resource issues. Now what happens, of
- 27:03course, is this is wildly successful in the field and back in the rear
- 27:07in SAFT, the commanders, the officers hate it. Well, what are
- 27:11you doing. You're not supposed to be doing that. You're supposed to be
- 27:12doing your training mission. But but and and by the way, guess what's
- 27:18not there's no zero dark thirty moment, you know. So so because what
- 27:22the agency will do is thank you for this targeting study on the Russian io
- 27:26presence. And guess what's soft. You're never going to hear what happened.
- 27:29Fact, if it's successful and we recruit a Russian, you know, ninety
- 27:33nine percent of CI headquarters is not going to hear. It's going to get
- 27:36into a compartmented channel. And so all of a sudden this kind of you
- 27:38know what we got addicted to, including me very selfishly, the fine fix
- 27:44and finished portion taking bad guys off the battlefield. You don't have that anymore,
- 27:48and so that has to be a change in mindset of SAFF as well.
- 27:51But that scenario works and can work really well. And I remember I've
- 27:55retired in twentyeighteen. I had these discussions with Sokker Special Operations Can and your
- 28:00uh, you know, senior leadership, and they were a game at the
- 28:03time. I don't know what happened, but I was like, we need
- 28:04some help, and I can tell you to do. I can tell you
- 28:08that happens. I can give you an example of a really really savvy station
- 28:12chief in a country that well in the Middle East who did exactly that integrated
- 28:18Actually there were massac guys to generate it. It was to help the case
- 28:26officered help collection efforts. And I'm trying to remember, but I don't think
- 28:30we had to get a lot of clearance to do that. He was,
- 28:33you know what, because what he was having them do was already within the
- 28:37parameters of what they were allowed to do. But he had enough. Rather
- 28:41than that usual kind of there's always there's always courtesy. Uh, but but
- 28:48here there was there was real collaboration and it was based on his his initiative.
- 28:53I meant, there's always reship and then all of a sudden, like
- 28:56there's no you know, credit is shared. Yeah, exactly, the result
- 29:00is is unknown, like we're going to leave, yeah, collectively and maybe
- 29:03the c I station, Like we're never going to know the fruits of our
- 29:06labor if you're if you're sitting in the station there as well, and you
- 29:08leave that targeting study sitting there if it's successful. Down line, no one's
- 29:11gonna from Russia House or Operational Unit supercompartment, and no one's calling you and
- 29:15saying, hey, what you did a year ago? Yeah, and so
- 29:18you have to have that mentality that there's you know, there's a greater gain,
- 29:22greater greater purpose here and so and by the way, in these kinds
- 29:26the Marines involved in their careers as hasants and you know, or just reaking
- 29:30that is the that's the only time they got to do in a you know,
- 29:36kind of a totally non combat not even near combat environment, third country
- 29:42doing that kind of type of operation. And Andy, let me tell you
- 29:45something, I've never met a soft operator who didn't want to do it.
- 29:48That's what I was gonna say, Who wouldn't want to? You know,
- 29:51who wouldn't. They loved it, they said, this is great, and
- 29:53you can you know, it can be you know, uh, you know,
- 29:57hitting the bars or watching Armed Forces Network on TV, you know those
- 30:00stupid commercials that they still have, or you can go out and help you
- 30:03know, you know, help Team America. And I've never met anyone who
- 30:07didn't want to do it. But but again, is this institutional now?
- 30:11And so you know it's and I, you know, I in this in
- 30:15this paradigm I'm talking about I actually you know I call I don't ever reach
- 30:18back into the I retired in twenty nineteen. I'm very careful. I don't
- 30:22know what they're doing now. I don't reach back to the agency, but
- 30:25I do talk to my buddies like Mick and others who have some experience with
- 30:27this, and kind of all of us kind of collectively, you know,
- 30:30Doug Wise as well, another guy you should get on your show, a
- 30:33great friend of mine, former Deputy Director DIA and chief the station in Baghdad.
- 30:37I think another Teamhouse veteran too. But but you know, so as
- 30:41we're talking about this kind of premise of CIA SOFT, you know, into
- 30:45the future. I think a lot of us do think these problems still exist.
- 30:48Maybe I'm wrong, maybe they figured everything out in the last three or
- 30:51four years, but I don't think so. I I think culturally it's hard
- 30:56to imagine that they have figured to help, you know. I mean,
- 30:59we've tar about again. It's just when I was in Israel a couple of
- 31:03weeks ago. And yes, despite all the dreadful failures that they have done,
- 31:10they have one thing very strong on their side now that is unity of
- 31:12purpose, and all the barriers, any barriers that were there before to include
- 31:18between the services, seemed to have disappeared. I mean it's but we yeah,
- 31:25and that happened with us in the in the immediate aftermath of ninety eleven.
- 31:29But but when we don't need to, we tend to lose that touch
- 31:32point and we revert to our own, our own areas. But what you
- 31:37described integration with case officers work because we use SOFT is used to working with
- 31:41agency paramilitary, not working with them. But that's kind of their natural shaded
- 31:47air in the VENT diagram. But actually they can do arguably in these places
- 31:52a lot more constructive or strategically relevant stuff for cases of station cheap yep yep,
- 32:01free labor, sorry that I'm looking for it, Patriotic Americans, free
- 32:07labor, excited to go, kind of take the fight to the you know,
- 32:09it's where we are twenty twenty four and beyond. That's that's kind of
- 32:13Russia, China, Iran, uh and uh and and so I don't know,
- 32:16I mean, I hope this is done. One thing to note on
- 32:19this though, and that's this is this will be my next kind of soapbox.
- 32:22You know, d you gave me some okay to do stream of consciousness,
- 32:25So sorry, you know me. And that's what we call the ubiquitous
- 32:30technical surveillance environment. And so you know, the where we all kind of
- 32:32grew up, uh in terms of counterintelligence threats has changed dramatically and and you
- 32:38know and and so you know what does that mean? And so just kind
- 32:42of for the for the regular person, it's it's you know, it's your
- 32:45cell phone. Well, that's that's an incredible kind of collection device for any
- 32:49hostile service. It's it's biometrics. When you go into an airport, you
- 32:52get your picture taken at some place I would I would always laugh biometrics,
- 32:57how much, how hard it is for us. Some of these systems are
- 32:59actually systems of the agency gave to the host country. Yeah, there you
- 33:04go. Just don't use this on that. I don't know if that was
- 33:06all you already program program in oil, bio down the same one time.
- 33:13Smart cities are everywhere. There's the camera systems, and so the world now
- 33:16is a collection of sensors and and so and so that is a that has
- 33:21a huge effect on both the CIA and the soft community because you can't hide
- 33:27anymore. And so, you know, the perfect example is, you know,
- 33:30in the past, you know, I let's say I was I was
- 33:32in I don't know, through out a place Damascus, Syria. So I
- 33:36go off, you know, I I have my cell phone, I turn
- 33:38it off, leave it at my house. Uh, do my surveillance detection
- 33:43route meet an agent successfully? I know I'm black. There's you know,
- 33:46one hundred percent sure I'm black. Do a reverse surveillance detection route come back?
- 33:51Got some great gouge, you know, in terms of you know something
- 33:54that the president of the National Security Advisor is gonna love. Syria's was a
- 33:58hot button issue. Uh, pour myself a little jamison and you know that
- 34:01was that was a great day. That world doesn't exist anymore, not at
- 34:06all. And so let me if you dissect that and this is all you
- 34:07know, this, all this, everything I'm telling you now has been cleared
- 34:10it's okay for me to talk about by the agency. So so what does
- 34:14that mean? Well, first of all, your cell phone if it's if
- 34:15you turn it off, the hostile service is monitoring your cell phone all the
- 34:20time. That's a you know, so that's that's a flag. When you
- 34:22drive and you do your surveillance detection route, if you're running through things like
- 34:25such as smart cities or any kind of sensors. Uh, you know,
- 34:30that can be that's that's data that can be not only seen in real time,
- 34:34it can be recorded for the future. Uh uh. And so in
- 34:37all, so, when you go back and you're sitting in your house saying
- 34:39I was I was surveillance free. I did a successful agenty that doesn't exist
- 34:44anymore because we don't know because this data is collected and it can be stored.
- 34:49And then that's stored data, which means these sensors again, everything from
- 34:53your cell phone usage to the camera system of a city to your vehicle,
- 34:59which is just a role GPS to any casuals on the street. With with
- 35:02a smartphone, all of that you know, is stored forever, but then
- 35:07with AI can be accessed immediately, so hostile services can kind of go back
- 35:10years and take a look at data on a certain individual. And so you
- 35:15know my argument and all this, and I think that you know, in
- 35:17the HCI did put together what's called the Ubiquitous Technical Surveillance Center that Bill Burns's
- 35:22announced as publicly. There's a UTS center. So it's it's how do we
- 35:25do things? How do how do we kind of tackle this really this enormous
- 35:30problem of sensors which kind of control our lives. I'm going to sound like
- 35:34some crazy futurists, but I'm not. And the answer is probably the kind
- 35:37of go to do something called in pattern operations. And you know at Jason's
- 35:42nodding, but it's the notion of hiding and playing sight. So instead of
- 35:45doing a surveillance detection route, I'm going to go to you know, I'm
- 35:47going to Liverpool in England and go to a Liverpool game with fifty sixty seventy
- 35:52thousand fans and my agent meeting is going to be in that stadium somehow,
- 35:58because I've established a pattern of going all the time to Liverpool games, and
- 36:01so is my penetration in the Chinese embassy. They're doing the same thing,
- 36:06you know. And and so it's you know, so ultimately you kind of
- 36:08build things in pattern. And the challenge is, first of all, how
- 36:12does the agency do this? But then here's the other thing. There's seventy
- 36:15thousand members of SOFT. How do you do that with seventy thousand members who,
- 36:19by the way, everyone's addicted to what, you know, my fancy
- 36:21you know, my fancy watch or your phone more fitfit mark that I just
- 36:27jump in very quickly. Yes, seventy thousand for they you know this Severn
- 36:30here knows there's seventy thousand people in so calm that when you're talking about to
- 36:35the kind of the pointing end of the spear, actually us self is free
- 36:38tail heavy. I'm just but that's the scale. That's the challenge we have.
- 36:43Yeah, yeah, absolutely, Ultimately, so how do we run in
- 36:45pattern operations for CI but also CIA and SOFT together again an enormous challenge and
- 36:52uh, you know, and and so that's because because the whole kind of
- 36:57our trade has changed so dramatically. Uh, And you know, it's it's
- 37:01it's it's the kind of thing where you know, so I if I,
- 37:04if you have my if I have my phone, I can't I can't turn
- 37:07it off because a hostile service is going to see it. Well, I
- 37:09can't leave it on and leave it in my apartment or residence because that hostile
- 37:14service is also monitoring what Twitter sites I go to. So then this is
- 37:20just conceptually then I'd have to have my spouse or my kid be you know
- 37:23surfing, you know, Twitter and ESPN and all this stuff. You know
- 37:28that with the same pattern I do every single night, because you've got to
- 37:30you've got to be invisible, and that just gets super hard. And so
- 37:32it's the idea of kind of you know, in pattern operations, and I
- 37:36think that's where there's a lot of thought going into. Uh. But just
- 37:39these are these are just huge, huge challenges and uh, you know,
- 37:44at the end of the it's sad u. You pretty can't say we hope
- 37:47that that is being torn at the farm now right as part of that sure,
- 37:52sure, and and and again there's a UTS center. So in this
- 37:57talk I gave the other day to d O D when I challenge to the
- 37:59d D CAN unity is does SOFT have kind of a center doing this?
- 38:04And if they do? And I would imagine some of the special mission units
- 38:07are focused on this. I think they are, but they I guess,
- 38:09are they integrated with CIA's UTS center, because you have to have this gold
- 38:13standard of trade craft, and so that's the question, you know, in
- 38:17the respective schoolhouses is this being taught? I don't know, I would hope.
- 38:22So it is very interesting and just an example of how we in the
- 38:29US SOFT don't yet think this way. And I think, you know,
- 38:32I've got a theory on it that's not that interesting. But as an example,
- 38:37for instance, just talking to Israeli soldiers going into Gaza at least once
- 38:45with the two main divisions there, and this guy who's with the ninety eighth,
- 38:50who's with their reconnaissance unit, but he said this was standard across when
- 38:53they go into Gazaram and the conventional infintrum and they put everything in a box.
- 38:59Everything you know and there's familiar to you, but it's not to the
- 39:02you know, average marine or soldier, to include their cell phone. They
- 39:07won't see that cell phone until the end of the operation. There's no hey
- 39:10can I call my mom? They're writing letters like World War two, and
- 39:15the logistics officers picking them up, taking the bat scanning them into WhatsApp and
- 39:20sending them out and you know, it's it's it's so they they are reverting,
- 39:27you know. I mean that kind of approach is yet culturally not there
- 39:31within the US military. Within certain soft units, yes, but mainstreams of
- 39:39yeah, kind of awareness, but not that conventional units. No, forget
- 39:44it. Can you imagine, okay, hey, give me all your ship
- 39:47to include your cell phone, two months send you send your wife one last
- 39:51text. And you remember in Ukraine, you know, and this was like,
- 39:55I mean, this was some some commercial firms were doing this because you
- 39:59know, the russ military had their cell phones on everywhere. Uh. You
- 40:02know, there's there's a there's one hundred thousand Russian forces with with basically pinging
- 40:07their location. Yeah, I mean, this is a this is a godsend.
- 40:09And so yeah, you're right, it's very hard to stop what is
- 40:14kind of you know, normal behavior. Uh. And when the and when
- 40:16the Russians, by the way, collected up all their cell phones, you
- 40:21know, and of course soldiers didn't get them back. There were two units
- 40:24that were exempt. One was the Wagner group pregotion never imposed that on his
- 40:30own guys. And the other group with the Chechens, you know, two
- 40:32of the who were doing a lot of the serious fighting within the campaign.
- 40:37They all had their cell phones and their Chechans were were incredibly undisciplined, unbelievable
- 40:45experienced fighters taking selfies. I mean, it was. It was a godsend
- 40:51to the Ukrainians, as you know knows. That's why you don't hear about
- 40:55them so much now. But but again, you know, there's so many
- 41:00examples of these of tradecraft errors and the need to be really disciplined. And
- 41:04so I guess the question is, can CEI it soft as we talk about
- 41:07this, you know, move to great power competition as a target, can
- 41:09they actually both adapt together to that ubiquitous technical surveillance environment. It's a it's
- 41:15a it's I mean, this is an awesome conversation, like I've I've never
- 41:17had this before with anyone. So this is we're doing kind of like a
- 41:21graduate level seminar right now. You know, you know one reason why I
- 41:24think the US, uh, not just the military but and within our culture
- 41:29we find it harder to understand this in places of Europe. It, I
- 41:32mean, CCTV has been ubiquitous in Europe for a long long time. Yeah,
- 41:39and so there is nothing there is really very little you can do in
- 41:44public in Europe without it being recorded by a camera. And Europeans understand that,
- 41:50you know, even and but we in the United States that would be
- 41:54kind of abhurrent to us. But so if you grow up kind of being
- 41:59used to certain ask that of the surveillance state already being in place, it
- 42:01doesn't make a big difference if someone says, oh, now they can listen
- 42:05to your phone, all this on that. But for us, we hold
- 42:07on to this feeling of well, there's part of me that Sally's exempt from
- 42:12this one percent true, and and then you you know, there's there,
- 42:16But it's also in other places. I mean, so certainly in Europe.
- 42:19You're right, London is one of the one of the first smart cities.
- 42:22But do you remember that op I think it was back in it was a
- 42:23two thousand and ten I can't remember in Dubai when Masad got caught trying to
- 42:28kill this Amas dude. And yeah, there's the great there's the great uh
- 42:31CPB footage of an Israeli intelligence officer and it was it was a female with
- 42:37a tennis racket. Yeah, and that was that. It should have been
- 42:43awake up call. Yeah, it should have been a wake up call,
- 42:45like holy shit in the UAE technology. When did they that was in a
- 42:49hotel c CPV. Yeah, hit team with this woman with the tennis racket.
- 42:53Now a lot of us are gonna like, like serve him today.
- 42:57I know, no, but I think there was a lot of who's actually
- 43:00served the before. I think I recognized that officer. I think I knew
- 43:05her. But but anyhow so, but that was a wake up call,
- 43:07but it was twenty ten, so you know, again, I don't I'm
- 43:09not sure we have kind of evolved in a rapid fashion, but but our
- 43:15enemies have. And it's very interesting. Even Hamas, who is not regarded,
- 43:20you know, previously not regarded as by the Israelis as being particularly sophisticated,
- 43:24showed a very sophisticated approach to taking out the surveillance, all the surveillance
- 43:29assets along the fence line but also at the military basis that they then made
- 43:34a b line for to kill the soldiers, so they couldn't respond to the
- 43:37Kibbutz massacres. But that it was surveillance. It was those cameras that that
- 43:44was their primary target right off the bat. So you're right, and you
- 43:46know that's something that you know, and they knew where they were, they
- 43:49knew where all the cameras were. I mean, I told her first targets
- 43:52was an intelligence base in essence, Yeah, the servers were located that that
- 43:55that you know, that did control the kind of the camera system. So
- 43:58you're you're a thousand percent can also don't forget that Hamas And again this is
- 44:04this is hubris. It's what we did with you know, in terms of
- 44:06al Qaeda as well, uh, you know pre nine to eleven to some
- 44:08sense. But but there is this, Uh it turns out that Hamas was
- 44:15very you know, cognizant of Israeli sigant capabilities. And so what did they
- 44:19do in the tunnel system. They ran this incredible network of in essence,
- 44:22landlines, so they communicated in ways in which Israeli sigan could not pick it
- 44:27up. Pretty extraordinary and so and so that's that's the underestimating your adversary really
- 44:32interesting point on that mark. So during during operations in Gaza. Subsequently,
- 44:38so jump forward from seven October, at least five weeks and nine to eight
- 44:44Brigade has done a relief from place with the thirty six or whatever it was
- 44:47a division. I'm sorry at that point, at the at the you know,
- 44:54unit level, that's still not getting intelligence. They there is some exquisite
- 45:00there's a lot of exquisite signals intelligence allowing higher level targeting, But for the
- 45:06troops on the ground, they're gathering intelligence through drones. It's all tactical intelligence,
- 45:12and they're using drones, you know, obviously to great effect. But
- 45:15it's kind of interesting. So even now with all of those assets tech assets
- 45:20focused on her Maas, the amount of information that they're getting is very limited
- 45:25because her Mass is adapted, you know, and no one gave them credit
- 45:30for adapting, just like no one gave the Russians credit for adapting in Ukraine.
- 45:34We have this feeling of, you know, Organization X is effing and
- 45:38competent. We just can take our eye off the ball. And as you
- 45:42know, the US intelligence community trusted the Israelis to keep in their eye on
- 45:45her mask, which is a big mistake. And now I'm gathering I'm guessing
- 45:50that the agency is doing a very quick catch up we have that's exactly Sorry,
- 45:54No, I'm sorry. We just speaking to what you were just saying.
- 45:58Andy, We and I say we collectively as a as a, as
- 46:02agencies, and as nations, we have a mindset of they can't quote unquote
- 46:07they can't. We completely underestimate and just dismiss right off the bat the capabilities
- 46:14of certain certain organizations, you know, like a MOS. And again that's
- 46:21going right back to the beginning of our conversation where human comes into play.
- 46:24All this technology is great when it's you know, when it's it confirms our
- 46:29bias of they can't. But until you have that person standing across from that
- 46:32other human being saying yeah, well actually we can and we're going to you
- 46:37know, and this is how until we get back to that were it's just
- 46:40going to keep happening over and over it. Yeah, a man now one
- 46:44hundred percent. You know Tom Sylvester, who has now come out in public
- 46:47or it's been reported in public as the new deputy Director of Operations for CIA.
- 46:52He did the CIA actually has their podcast not as good as this one.
- 46:54Of course, that we're talking on today, but it's called the Langley
- 46:58Files, and so they really talk about it, like, let's be honest,
- 47:00it's interesting. But but he actually came on and you know, this
- 47:02was just kind of coming out, and he's a he's a great friend of
- 47:07mine, great American and he but he basically said exactly that, like,
- 47:09we still need a human source. So what is a human source? You
- 47:12know, it's not a snippet in time. It's someone you can talk to,
- 47:15it's someone you can debrief, it's someone you can task. Uh.
- 47:19And so so actually having that kind of that granularity is absolutely critical. And
- 47:22one of the questions after October seventh that I had was, you know what,
- 47:27how did Israeli military intelligence? How did shin Bet not recruit a single
- 47:31individual out of out of in essence of three thousand person terrorist army. I
- 47:37mean that's incredible, you know, you know, I think this a couple
- 47:40of reasons. Mark one was the withdrawal from Gaza made it more difficult for
- 47:44human and then when they built the wall, that gave them an excuse you
- 47:47know, with all that not the excuse, but with that huge surveillance paraphernalia
- 47:52of you know, two billion shekels it. You know, there is a
- 47:57scene back in twenty twenty one that you can't read implicate where the head of
- 48:00Shinbet had a Mossad and a Lavy who's the chief of staff for the army,
- 48:05meet at this wall and and do an interview with Heretz newspapers saying,
- 48:08hey, you know this is this means the communities can sleep in it.
- 48:12I mean, they were egretting that interview now, but to me that was
- 48:15just, you know, it was it was underestimating Hamas, thinking that they
- 48:21were just caring about administering Gaza and now total reliance on a wall. How
- 48:27many lessons do we have to learn before we realize, you know, you
- 48:30know, and I agree, I'm one of these kind of intel geeks that
- 48:32I actually am. I'm looking forward to the after action. You know,
- 48:36the Israelis are going to They're doing two of them. One is the military
- 48:37is doing their own, which is a little sketchy in the sense of who
- 48:43directed the military way, but they're try and get the right But when they're
- 48:47to be careful curious commission, you know, and it's for all of us
- 48:52on this show right now. I mean, it's going to be super interesting.
- 48:54I do think, you know, and to the credit of for example,
- 48:59Ronan bar the head of Shin, I mean he said, you know
- 49:00this is this is on me. I think you're going to see every you
- 49:02know, the Israeli military and intelligence chiefs all resigned after this, as they
- 49:07should. There has to be some kind of accountability. But ultimately it's going
- 49:10to be fascinating to see you know what Sigan was produced. There's all these
- 49:15kind of reports that that the Hamas you know battle plan has been floating around
- 49:17for several years, so you know, how did that not get to the
- 49:21right policymakers. But also I'm in my thousand and then since two thousand and
- 49:24eight, right the plan they showed me up in uh the IDEF. They
- 49:30had a plan captured from hamas Is around two It was off to the wall,
- 49:35it was off to the six wall, and it shows it shows five
- 49:39part in sirclement hitting kibbutz that were taking out the military basis clause. So
- 49:44you could superimpose that plan down in Conza. And it is why they didn't
- 49:47have was a human sourcing the plant. It's a go now exactly, So
- 49:52to me, that is that is going to be kind of the you know,
- 49:55just as a kind of geek out on this stuff that's going to be
- 49:58the critical intel failure. But as a three thousand person army like how and
- 50:04you know, with all the counterintelligence practice, I still think it's a it's
- 50:07a spectacular failure in our old kind of a you know, human world.
- 50:10One. Let me just one thing, a pet peeve of mine. It
- 50:14just came across because it was bugging me the other day. So the D
- 50:16and I put out their annual threat assessment, and they still assess that Iran
- 50:21had no kind of knowledge of this, of this operation, which I just
- 50:23think is a load of crap. I think it was. It's it's political
- 50:27because we don't want to deal with the Iran problem. But let me tell
- 50:29you why the idea is saying that he hear FOSSi or at least it's or
- 50:31at least say I mean, I mean, come on, so who trains
- 50:37who trains Hamas? That's the IRGC, right So, and and you know
- 50:40those of us in the intel world when we do training missions, guess what
- 50:45we also do We also recruit our host partners. That's that's fifty percent of
- 50:49my job. Sorry, it just is it not a secret? So if
- 50:52you're telling me the IRGC coulds for us with their training mission for Hamas,
- 50:57whether it's inside Gaza, whether it's an Iran, whether in Lebanon, you're
- 51:00telling me they didn't recruit anybody, you know, And so that's a load
- 51:04of crap. And so that kind of stuff drives me nuts too. Now
- 51:07you know, maybe maybe the Iranian intelligence services are having the same conversation we're
- 51:12having right now. Oh my god. We were surprised, but I doubt
- 51:15it. Yeah, so agreed, It's it's interesting though. Hey, so
- 51:20a couple of things I I what I didn't realize is the fact that Iran
- 51:25is the puppet master behind all of this is not commonly understood by the general
- 51:30public in the United States. And that was brought to my attention when someone
- 51:35sent me a note about one of our previous episodes, very kind. I
- 51:39forget what it was. I think it was a message on Facebook, very
- 51:43kind message saying, hey, that episode was total trash. All you guys
- 51:45did was trot out conspiracy theories about Iran. But but but it is truly
- 51:52concerning. Yes, indeed, will will it isl be obliterated by Iran.
- 51:59No, very un likely in the next decade or so or two decades.
- 52:02But that's not comforting. I'm not taking sides on this. I'm just saying
- 52:07from US perspective, very concerning and how it was set up. He is
- 52:12reelly so focused on his boller, the indications, and you know, there's
- 52:17a lot of discussion even these you know, the Shinbet doesn't know the level
- 52:23of coordination. But what they think happened was that Hamas definitely expected his bolla
- 52:31to step in all the signal traffic was that his bolla was about to step
- 52:37in right after it kicked off. They were ready, they'd been preparing,
- 52:40but for some reason they didn't. Where did that come from? You know,
- 52:44no one really knows. We can speculate, But the point is this
- 52:46whole thing was was balanced and set up, huge focus on his boller.
- 52:52The you know, IDF contingency plants are all about response to the northern border,
- 52:57not the south. You know, they had no off the shelf plants
- 53:00to pull off, you know, and so all of this was was It
- 53:07wasn't accidental, right, It wasn't a perfect storm. It was very carefully
- 53:10orchestrated. Yeah, I think we take our take our eyes off the ball
- 53:16or the balls that are in play. We did it with g Wat.
- 53:22I think we and I saw it when I was at you know, when
- 53:24I was at CIA, it was like I it went from when I first
- 53:30got there. I mean it was well into you know, g Watt.
- 53:32It was two thousand and eight. So I noticed an uptick based on surges
- 53:38things like that of like guys walking around with beards as opposed to clean cut
- 53:44suits, you know at headquarters, things like that. You know, if
- 53:47you wear it, if you have a bed, you look exactly like an
- 53:51f game exactly. Yeah, no one can tell the difference. Yeah,
- 53:53so I think everybody wanted to get in on the game that was the big
- 53:59game at the time, and so we kind of took our eyes. And
- 54:02I'm saying this from my you know, ten foot level, you know,
- 54:06inexperience there. It seemed like we took our eyes off of the traditional spying
- 54:10that I was trained in. But the point is in going back to what
- 54:15you were just saying about, you know how Hesbelah was the focus. We
- 54:23can do it all, the Israelis can do it all. You can you
- 54:27can focus on Hesbelah because you have people trained to do that, Let them
- 54:31do that, and say keep your eyes north while we have those who are
- 54:36trained to you know, to counter her Hamas. Let them focus. If
- 54:39we need you up north, or if you get indication that Hesbelah is going
- 54:44to step in, that's when you you know, you let us know.
- 54:46But I think everybody wants to get in on the big game or whatever the
- 54:52issue is that's going on. In the case of let's just say pre nine
- 54:55to eleven, the whole Cold War quote unquote, spying was was starting to
- 55:01what had slowed down with what you know, we believe was the fall of
- 55:06the the it was the fall of Soviet Union, but not the fall of
- 55:07Russia. So now we were like, okay, now we can turn our
- 55:12attention to terrorism. Everybody turned and look this way. But we didn't leave
- 55:15anybody in place to do the the traditional human And I think we need to
- 55:21get back to that. I think we're getting back to that. But what's
- 55:24the next thing that's going to happen that's going to take our eyes right back
- 55:27off of it again? And I think that people like Mark you know,
- 55:30who are you know screaming with what some people would say their hair on fire
- 55:36with the whole soft fig integration. And you know, I think that people
- 55:44like that need to keep keep screaming with their hair on fire because if not,
- 55:49when that near peer thing kicks off, you know, let's go back
- 55:52to the the on the ground level. It's it's gonna suck to be that
- 55:58CIA officer, that that paramilitary officer, or whoever who's standing next to that
- 56:02DEV group guy or you know, those those white side soft operators having to
- 56:07huddle up and say, okay, listen, this is what an SDR is,
- 56:12this is what this is. Having to explain the nomenclature and you know,
- 56:15ready break and get them out on the streets to help. Like those
- 56:19examples you guys gave were awesome, but there were one offs. But if
- 56:22we if we formally train each other side by side, you don't have to
- 56:28everybody knows the the the nomenclature. Everybody will know, Hey, in this
- 56:32situation, you know this is what we need to do. Because I went
- 56:37to the farm or I went to the Q course. You know, even
- 56:39though I'm CIA or SOFT, you can just huddle up and say, okay,
- 56:44this is the this is the op. Let's get it and everybody just
- 56:47goes and does their thing. It doesn't have to be on the fly.
- 56:50So I think people like you, Mark, and this is not me blowing
- 56:52smoke. I think that you're what we need. People like that are what
- 56:57we need to keep screaming. You know, great, this is great that
- 57:00this is what's happening over here. But can we focus over here as well?
- 57:04You know? So sorry, that was my rant. I think there
- 57:07are people thinking about this, you know. I am confident. Uh,
- 57:12it's just it's gonna take kind of the the you know, breaking bad habits
- 57:15that are kind of formed again to get that notion of okay, you know,
- 57:19we can't wait for the next conflict. We do have to do that
- 57:22across training. I mean, to me, this it shouldn't be that.
- 57:24You know. The excuse the agency always gives is there's so few case officers.
- 57:29There's you know, and so you know it's it's my other kind of
- 57:31rant, and we can do it in Another episode is about leadership training,
- 57:35which we suck at. We don't do leadership training. You know, to
- 57:37get through the senior Intelligence service level, you have to take basically three one
- 57:39week classes in your care Unlike in the military. Andy that you know where
- 57:43you're going to go for a year or to a staff college. You know,
- 57:46to make a colonel, don't you have to do two one year evolutions
- 57:50of training and lead. We never did that because we can't take people offline.
- 57:54And that's that's so. And I think it's also in the agency and
- 57:59that you know may have changed, but certainly within the State Department. What
- 58:01it is is just not an understanding of how leadership is really a hard skill,
- 58:07right, I mean it is. It is. It's the fundamental building
- 58:13block without which you you really can't do anything else effectively. This is me
- 58:17spouting leadership propaganda because you know, you might prefer brand is always toxic,
- 58:23but but you know it's you see this a lot, especially in non diodecument
- 58:30agencies. How you see it within d D that it's all too easy to
- 58:35slip into a management style and justify it on the basis of the new generation
- 58:39and forget about the tenets of what we've learned about, which are ultimately how
- 58:45you get people to do things regardless of the move on technology. That's one
- 58:49thing I've always was taught at the agency by a great mentor, and I
- 58:52use it still today. Is there's a huge difference between a manager and a
- 58:55leader, and we have too many managers and way not enough leaders. And
- 59:00it's it shows Mark, where can we find you? Tell us everything you're
- 59:07doing? Sure, so you can see me on TV. I work for
- 59:09MSNBC now, so I'm kind of one of their their national security analysts.
- 59:13So I I'll pop on and and and try to give you know, my
- 59:16a political perspective, which is very hard in these in these times, particularly
- 59:21on stuff like you know, Gaza uh and in Ukraine, I am prolific
- 59:25uh And I'm sad if anyone has to actually follows all my silliness. But
- 59:30on Twitter it's at M Polymer and I will tweet about you know, my
- 59:34favorite dive bar in Northern Virginia, the Red Sox, my love heavy metal,
- 59:37and of course uh kind of serious topics like national security and intelligence and
- 59:43so you know, I just I'm you know, I'm I'm one. One
- 59:45cool thing I'm doing next fall is I'm going to be an adjunct professor at
- 59:49the Citadel uh or Intelligence Study. That's awesome. People as before they go
- 59:54on before they go on to get that GEDs that's right. So I mean
- 59:59I I have. People have asked me why the Citadel, and I said,
- 1:00:01have you ever been to Charleston? Yeah, that's right. So so
- 1:00:07I'm doing some stuff, you know, here and there. It's been it's
- 1:00:09been fun. I'm trying to stay busy in retirement, but not too busy
- 1:00:14because I still we have a we have a house down the Outer Bank.
- 1:00:15So I spent a lot of time at the beach, which is that's my
- 1:00:17happy place. So it is every hey, before we before we sign off,
- 1:00:23first of all, and we've got to secure an on air agreement to
- 1:00:27come back on again. Sure, okay, all right, we've captured that.
- 1:00:30And secondly, I want to point out that this is it's kind of
- 1:00:35a riddle, but we've accomplished something here. There's only four of us.
- 1:00:37We have two Marines, two agency guys, and two Greeks. That's right.
- 1:00:45Yeah, somebody's BINGO card got punched. Yeah. Hey, you know,
- 1:00:52the Russians just tried to essentially kill the Greek prime minister the other day.
- 1:00:55I wanted to talk about that, like, imagine what the Greeks off.
- 1:00:59The Greeks now put together a nice aid package. I think they're they're
- 1:01:02sending all their entire inventory of Howarzer's to Ukraine, and so don't piss the
- 1:01:07The lesson is, don't piss off the Greeks. Yeah, we're not just
- 1:01:09sending sublak ya over the fucking you crazy. Yeah, it's not all about
- 1:01:15goats. Oh wow, hey, all right, all right, day on
- 1:01:20that note, when you sign us out, all right, check out check
- 1:01:22out Andy on substack on Twitter, buy his book, everything will be links
- 1:01:25will be in the description and the show notes for Andy and Mark. Don't
- 1:01:29forget to like and subscribe. If you're listening to us on audio rate and
- 1:01:31review at five stars, it's it's huge for us. And check out our
- 1:01:37Patreon, Patreon dot com, slash the team house. All the links will
- 1:01:39be in the description. Thank you, Tony, fine buck you can join
- 1:01:43third it's little as five bucks a yeah, oh no, five bucks a
- 1:01:46month. I was gonna say, and I'm doing to go fund me.
- 1:01:53I'm doing to go some month. I'm doing a GoFundMe to get you guys
- 1:01:58to bribe me to get back on Twitter her. Yeah that it's not happening,
- 1:02:05all right, Thank you bye everyone. Thanks