Latest / Statecraft / How to Fix a Department's Funding Tools
Transcript
- 0:04SPEAKER_00: Hi, I'm Santi Ruiz and this is Statecraft.
- 0:07SPEAKER_00: Today's guest is Narayan Subramanian.
- 0:10SPEAKER_00: Under the Biden administration,
- 0:11he worked in a few different roles at the Department of Energy
- 0:14and later at the
- 0:15SPEAKER_00: White House National Security Council.
- 0:17SPEAKER_00: At the DOE,
- 0:18Subramanian helped ensure that a big influx of money could best
- 0:21be used to support
- 0:22SPEAKER_00: innovative energy projects.
- 0:23SPEAKER_00: If you've followed Statecraft for a while,
- 0:25you know we're really interested in this question of how to
- 0:28actually deploy
- 0:28SPEAKER_00: taxpayer dollars most effectively.
- 0:31SPEAKER_00: Narayan played a key role in making sure that the DOE could do just that.
- 0:34SPEAKER_00: One editor's note.
- 0:36SPEAKER_00: Well, really a couple editor's notes here.
- 0:38SPEAKER_00: One,
- 0:38SPEAKER_00: we discussed the DOE's Loan Programs Office,
- 0:40SPEAKER_00: or LPO,
- 0:41which plays a key role in financing infrastructure that enables
- 0:44new technologies
- 0:45SPEAKER_00: like nuclear power development and domestic mineral production.
- 0:49SPEAKER_00: As of this recording,
- 0:50DOGE is reportedly pushing for a more than 50% reduction in
- 0:53headcount at LPO,
- 0:55SPEAKER_00: which would kneecap its ability to manage existing loans,
- 0:57SPEAKER_00: let alone to underwrite new ones.
- 0:59Without technical staff capacity at LPO of the kind that
- 1:02Narayan discusses in our conversation,
- 1:05the federal government risks stalling energy projects that
- 1:07serve national priorities,
- 1:09SPEAKER_00: like nuclear energy development for powering AI.
- 1:12SPEAKER_00: In the audio version of this conversation,
- 1:14we spend a little bit of time at the beginning talking about
- 1:16Narayan's work
- 1:17SPEAKER_00: clearing Oppenheimer's name in federal records.
- 1:21SPEAKER_00: I've left that part out of the transcript for reasons of space.
- 1:24SPEAKER_00: Without further ado, Narayan Subramanian.
- 1:26SPEAKER_00: Narayan, thank you for joining Statecraft.
- 1:29SPEAKER_01: Thank you for having me on.
- 1:30Will you give listeners a little introduction to what you've
- 1:33been up to the last four years?
- 1:34SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so I was a political appointee in the Biden administration.
- 1:38SPEAKER_01: I started on day one.
- 1:40SPEAKER_01: In fact,
- 1:41SPEAKER_01: just minutes after inauguration,
- 1:43SPEAKER_01: I was sworn in to be a legal advisor in the Office of General Counsel.
- 1:47And I was in that role for about the first two and a half years
- 1:50of the administration.
- 1:51SPEAKER_01: And then I moved to the secretary's office,
- 1:54SPEAKER_01: became an advisor to the secretary,
- 1:56working on implementation for the bipartisan infrastructure law
- 1:59and the Inflation
- 1:59SPEAKER_01: Reduction Act.
- 2:00SPEAKER_01: And then the last six months or so of the administration,
- 2:03I was the director for energy transition at the White House
- 2:06National Security Council.
- 2:08SPEAKER_00: One of the,
- 2:09SPEAKER_00: this isn't really the focus of what we're going to talk about,
- 2:11SPEAKER_00: but I think one of the fun things you did,
- 2:12the most interesting things you did was Oppenheimer security
- 2:15clearance decision.
- 2:16SPEAKER_00: Will you talk a little bit about that?
- 2:18SPEAKER_01: Sure thing.
- 2:18SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:18SPEAKER_01: So,
- 2:20SPEAKER_01: and it actually relates a lot,
- 2:22SPEAKER_01: believe it or not,
- 2:23to even the implementation of the bipartisan infrastructure law
- 2:25and the Inflation
- 2:26SPEAKER_01: Reduction Act,
- 2:27SPEAKER_01: which I'm sure we'll get to.
- 2:28SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:51SPEAKER_01: Half the movie is this.
- 2:52SPEAKER_01: It truly is, right?
- 2:54SPEAKER_01: And what's amazing about the movie is it quite literally,
- 2:57large parts of it follow the script of the Atomic Energy
- 2:59Commission's security
- 3:00SPEAKER_01: clearance hearings.
- 3:02SPEAKER_01: And at the end of the security clearance hearings,
- 3:04the Atomic Energy Commission made an extraordinary decision to
- 3:07strip Robert
- 3:08SPEAKER_01: Oppenheimer of his security clearance.
- 3:11SPEAKER_01: For decades since then,
- 3:12SPEAKER_01: the pop culture understanding of this,
- 3:15SPEAKER_01: people even then knew this was kind of a sham proceeding.
- 3:19Everyone knew that Robert Oppenheimer was likely being
- 3:22persecuted for taking
- 3:23SPEAKER_01: positions that were at odds with the administration at the time.
- 3:27Nothing was done really explicitly about that 1954 decision by
- 3:31the Atomic Energy Commission.
- 3:33Granted,
- 3:33years later,
- 3:341963,
- 3:35the Fermi Award was given to Robert Oppenheimer.
- 3:38SPEAKER_01: It was one of the last official acts of John F.
- 3:41SPEAKER_01: Kennedy to select Robert Oppenheimer for the Fermi Award.
- 3:44It was one of the first official acts of Lyndon Johnson as
- 3:47president to award him
- 3:49SPEAKER_01: the Fermi Award.
- 3:50At the end of the movie,
- 3:50you'll see that scene where they're getting the award.
- 3:53SPEAKER_01: Robert Oppenheimer is getting the award.
- 3:55SPEAKER_01: It's at the White House.
- 3:56SPEAKER_01: So that's kind of how the movie ends.
- 3:58SPEAKER_01: But for decades since,
- 3:59SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 4:00it has indeed had a chilling effect on the scientific
- 4:03enterprise where scientists
- 4:05genuinely felt in the years following that if they spoke up and
- 4:09were at odds with
- 4:10SPEAKER_01: the administration or government in general,
- 4:12SPEAKER_01: they very well could be persecuted.
- 4:14And many scientists and associations of scientists like FAS
- 4:17have come out over the
- 4:19SPEAKER_01: years continuing to call for some kind of
- 4:22SPEAKER_01: Yeah, like a rectification of that decision.
- 4:25SPEAKER_01: So Secretary Granholm actually had read American Prometheus,
- 4:29SPEAKER_01: the book on which the Christopher Nolan movie is based on.
- 4:32SPEAKER_01: By that point,
- 4:33there was also a letter from every living and former director
- 4:38of the Los Alamos
- 4:38SPEAKER_01: National Laboratory and the Idaho National Laboratory.
- 4:41SPEAKER_01: There was also a letter from 43 U.S.
- 4:44senators,
- 4:44a bipartisan group,
- 4:45calling for the secretary to take another look at this.
- 4:48This is not to say that the department hadn't tried to do this
- 4:51in the past.
- 4:51SPEAKER_01: Past secretaries of energy had, in fact, tried.
- 4:54But they ran into a pretty big barrier with the general
- 4:57counsel's office and the
- 4:58general apparatus at DOE of why are you looking at a security
- 5:02clearance for someone
- 5:04SPEAKER_01: that's not alive anymore?
- 5:05SPEAKER_01: You can't posthumously reinstate a security clearance.
- 5:08SPEAKER_01: You can't give a dead person a security clearance.
- 5:10SPEAKER_01: Exactly, right.
- 5:11you know,
- 5:11that ended up being a significant barrier to anyone even
- 5:15revisiting this.
- 5:17What I did in the general counsel's office,
- 5:19so I led the effort to take a second look at this.
- 5:22SPEAKER_01: I came at this from two perspectives.
- 5:24One is this was something that was conducted by the Atomic
- 5:27Energy Commission.
- 5:28The Department of Energy is not the Atomic Energy Commission
- 5:31today in a strict sense.
- 5:33SPEAKER_01: The Department of Energy, of
- 5:35SPEAKER_01: course, has security clearance holders.
- 5:37It has a process for people to re-adjudicate security clearance decisions.
- 5:41SPEAKER_01: So you don't want to mess with that for contemporary purposes.
- 5:45SPEAKER_00: Because people work on nuclear issues today.
- 5:47SPEAKER_00: The security clearance stuff is real today.
- 5:50SPEAKER_00: It's quite real.
- 5:50SPEAKER_01: And that was also a significant barrier,
- 5:52that there were legitimate institutional concerns about taking
- 5:56another look at that.
- 5:57What I did was I went back to the Atomic Energy Commission's
- 6:00regulations and looked
- 6:01particularly at what was different in the security clearance
- 6:04regulations then that
- 6:06SPEAKER_01: are not in DOE's regulations now,
- 6:08so that it was very specific to how the Atomic Energy
- 6:11Commission carried out that
- 6:12SPEAKER_01: security clearance hearing.
- 6:13Then went through the fact pattern of how the hearing was
- 6:16actually conducted.
- 6:17SPEAKER_01: So I went up to the archives quite a few times,
- 6:20SPEAKER_01: going through all the different stages of the proceedings.
- 6:24What was really interesting is the proceedings were carried out
- 6:27in the spring of 1954.
- 6:29SPEAKER_01: But in January 1954,
- 6:31SPEAKER_01: there was actually this memo,
- 6:32SPEAKER_01: internal memo within the Atomic Energy Commission,
- 6:35SPEAKER_01: laying out the whole framework for how they were going to,
- 6:38SPEAKER_01: quote-unquote,
- 6:38SPEAKER_01: get Robert Oppenheimer.
- 6:39And there's this explicit quote that says,
- 6:41"...the element of surprise must be maintained."
- 6:43SPEAKER_01: This isn't an official.
- 6:44SPEAKER_00: It's on paper.
- 6:45SPEAKER_01: It's on paper.
- 6:46SPEAKER_01: It's at the archives.
- 6:47SPEAKER_01: And cc'd at the bottom was Louis Strauss,
- 6:50SPEAKER_01: the then chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission,
- 6:52SPEAKER_01: who's Robert Downey Jr.
- 6:54SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that was an incredible thing to find for one.
- 6:57Then one of the things that I found that was not covered in
- 7:01American Prometheus was
- 7:02this 50 plus page memo written by an Atomic Energy Commission
- 7:06lawyer just a few
- 7:07SPEAKER_01: years later,
- 7:08SPEAKER_01: just listing out what a sham.
- 7:10SPEAKER_01: this process was,
- 7:10how it had deviated significantly from the Atomic Energy
- 7:14Commission's procedures.
- 7:15SPEAKER_01: So I actually was able to get on the phone with Kybert,
- 7:18SPEAKER_01: one of the co-authors of American Prometheus,
- 7:20SPEAKER_01: spoke to him a few times.
- 7:21SPEAKER_01: He was very, very helpful in pointing me to a few other books as well.
- 7:24SPEAKER_01: We put together the fact pattern,
- 7:26and you'll see there was a secretarial order that came out in
- 7:29December of 2022,
- 7:30SPEAKER_01: well before the movie came out.
- 7:32SPEAKER_01: Quite honestly, the decision had nothing to do with the movie itself.
- 7:35SPEAKER_01: It was purely
- 7:36SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 7:37there was this chorus of voices asking for the secretary to
- 7:39take another look at this,
- 7:40but I really have to commend the secretary because she was very
- 7:44dogged in wanting
- 7:45SPEAKER_01: to take another look at this.
- 7:46SPEAKER_01: As she puts it,
- 7:47everyone involved and every historian that's looked at it since
- 7:51knew that this was
- 7:52SPEAKER_01: a kangaroo court.
- 7:53And I had the privilege of getting to go to Los Alamos with the
- 7:57secretary the
- 7:58SPEAKER_01: summer of 2020,
- 7:59SPEAKER_01: right after the movie had come out,
- 8:00SPEAKER_01: in which she talked directly to the scientists at Los Alamos,
- 8:03SPEAKER_01: saying,
- 8:03SPEAKER_01: this decision really was for you guys.
- 8:05I want you all,
- 8:06as scientists,
- 8:07to hold us as public leaders accountable and speak out.
- 8:10SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 8:11SPEAKER_01: the beauty of the scientific enterprise,
- 8:12SPEAKER_01: especially in the United States,
- 8:14SPEAKER_01: is we really want our scientists to be able to register dissent.
- 8:17SPEAKER_01: This is ultimately good.
- 8:18SPEAKER_01: I mean, even think about the energy transition, climate science...
- 8:22There's been a lot of persecution of scientists and the
- 8:25secretary felt very,
- 8:27very strongly that this decision should send a signal to
- 8:30scientists all across the
- 8:31SPEAKER_01: country that we've got your back.
- 8:33One of the things you mentioned before we started recording was
- 8:36that this kind of
- 8:37archival work and you digging into the history of the
- 8:39Department of Energy ended up
- 8:41SPEAKER_00: not just being helpful for this particular project that you were put on,
- 8:44SPEAKER_00: but also for much broader implications.
- 8:46SPEAKER_00: Do you want to talk about that?
- 8:48SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 8:48SPEAKER_01: The secretarial order,
- 8:50SPEAKER_01: which anyone can find online,
- 8:52SPEAKER_01: the last sentence of that says something along the lines of,
- 8:55pursuant to the authorities vested in me as the Secretary of
- 8:57Energy to carry out
- 8:58SPEAKER_01: the functions of the Atomic Energy Commission,
- 9:01SPEAKER_01: I hereby vacate this 1954 decision.
- 9:02SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 9:04SPEAKER_01: A sentence like that sounds kind of like a throwaway sentence,
- 9:06SPEAKER_01: but actually from a legal standpoint,
- 9:08I had to go through every delegation of authority going back
- 9:12from the Atomic Energy
- 9:13SPEAKER_01: Commission to the Energy Research and Development Administration,
- 9:15SPEAKER_01: which was an interim body before DOE was created,
- 9:18SPEAKER_01: and then down to DOE to see,
- 9:20SPEAKER_01: you have to actually cite where that authority is coming from.
- 9:23SPEAKER_01: And in the process of doing that,
- 9:24SPEAKER_01: that actually got me thinking,
- 9:26SPEAKER_01: well,
- 9:26what other authorities or functions are vested in the Secretary
- 9:30of Energy that were
- 9:31SPEAKER_01: given to the Atomic Energy Commission?
- 9:32SPEAKER_01: And
- 9:32SPEAKER_00: Before you get into that,
- 9:33I guess I'm just realizing I don't have a great picture in my
- 9:35head of how we went
- 9:36SPEAKER_00: from the Atomic Energy Commission to today's Department of Energy.
- 9:39SPEAKER_00: Will you give us that pocket history of... Yeah.
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: The DOE wasn't always this entity.
- 9:44SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 9:45SPEAKER_01: A bunch of... And this is like fascinating history.
- 9:48SPEAKER_01: So everyone...
- 9:50as a result of the Oppenheimer movie or otherwise,
- 9:52knows what the Manhattan Project was.
- 9:55SPEAKER_01: Wartime mobilization,
- 9:56the whole kind of nuclear enterprise in this country was stood
- 9:59up from scratch
- 10:00SPEAKER_01: within a couple of years.
- 10:02SPEAKER_01: The war ends in 1945.
- 10:04SPEAKER_01: And by the spring of 1946,
- 10:06Robert Oppenheimer and others that were involved with the
- 10:08Manhattan Project started
- 10:10calling for a new apparatus to explore the peaceful uses of
- 10:14atomic energy.
- 10:15SPEAKER_00: Because the Manhattan Project is entirely oriented around the bomb.
- 10:18SPEAKER_01: Around the bomb, correct.
- 10:19But everyone involved with the project knew that one day this
- 10:23could have spillover
- 10:24effects for a lot of other scientific research that could be
- 10:27used for civilian purposes.
- 10:29SPEAKER_01: The Atomic Energy Act was passed in the summer of 1946,
- 10:33SPEAKER_01: and it established the Atomic Energy Commission,
- 10:35SPEAKER_01: a five-member commission,
- 10:36SPEAKER_01: which Louis Strauss of Robert Downey Jr.
- 10:39SPEAKER_01: fame becomes the chairman of later on.
- 10:40Robert Oppenheimer was one of the scientific advisors to the
- 10:44Atomic Energy Commission.
- 10:46And so the Atomic Energy Commission is not only entrusted with
- 10:50continuing to do the
- 10:51SPEAKER_01: weapons research,
- 10:52but also setting up a whole new function to harness the
- 10:56peaceful purposes for
- 10:58SPEAKER_01: atomic energy,
- 10:59SPEAKER_01: figure out ways to better process uranium and fuel supply,
- 11:03SPEAKER_01: all that stuff.
- 11:04SPEAKER_00: That's interesting.
- 11:04SPEAKER_00: So it's a little use commission.
- 11:06SPEAKER_00: It's still the military applications and nuclear power, whatever else.
- 11:11SPEAKER_01: What's fascinating is in the decades after World War II,
- 11:15SPEAKER_01: that's when American consumerism really takes off,
- 11:18SPEAKER_01: right?
- 11:19SPEAKER_01: So you have shows like Mad Men that portray that.
- 11:21But really what Mad Men is getting at in terms of a cultural
- 11:24moment is Americans
- 11:26SPEAKER_01: are starting to drive more cars,
- 11:28SPEAKER_01: buy household appliances,
- 11:30SPEAKER_01: dishwashers,
- 11:31SPEAKER_01: toaster ovens,
- 11:32SPEAKER_01: you name it.
- 11:33And so energy use is exploding and the Atomic Energy Commission
- 11:36exists at a time
- 11:37SPEAKER_01: when that's happening.
- 11:38SPEAKER_01: So we're also in parallel.
- 11:40The government is backing,
- 11:42putting a lot of money into building nuclear reactors.
- 11:44So a lot of the nuclear reactor build out happens in those
- 11:47decades after the
- 11:49SPEAKER_01: creation of the Atomic Energy Commission.
- 11:51SPEAKER_01: And we pretty much kind of take all that for granted up until 1973.
- 11:56SPEAKER_01: And in 73 in the fall is when the Arab oil embargo happens.
- 12:00SPEAKER_01: And so that's around, I believe, late September, October of 1973.
- 12:06And President Nixon at that time immediately jumps in and gives
- 12:09an Oval Office
- 12:10SPEAKER_01: address pretty much saying,
- 12:12SPEAKER_01: this is serious and we need to treat this like we're almost at war.
- 12:18SPEAKER_01: You have all these images from that period of time,
- 12:21SPEAKER_01: the long gas lines and all that kind of stuff.
- 12:24And what President Nixon does is he calls immediately for a
- 12:28quote-unquote project independence.
- 12:30He starts talking about how we really need to figure out a way
- 12:33to address our
- 12:34SPEAKER_01: dependence on foreign oil.
- 12:35SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 12:36And in that Oval Office address invokes the Manhattan Project
- 12:42and the Apollo
- 12:42SPEAKER_01: mission saying,
- 12:43SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 12:43we've done big things before and we have to treat this crisis
- 12:47with the same
- 12:48seriousness we did when we undertook the Manhattan Project and
- 12:51the Apollo mission.
- 12:51SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 12:52SPEAKER_01: It's a really incredible speech.
- 12:54And so within a month,
- 12:55there is a new executive order establishing a federal energy office.
- 12:59SPEAKER_01: Within a few months after that,
- 13:01Congress formally establishes that federal energy office under
- 13:04the Federal Energy Act.
- 13:05SPEAKER_01: So that's the spring of 1974.
- 13:06SPEAKER_01: And at that point, Congress knows...
- 13:10SPEAKER_01: We really need to set up a new apparatus that's not just doing R&D,
- 13:15but has the ability to scale up new energy technologies and do
- 13:18it very quickly.
- 13:19What's interesting is even when you go back to the statute that
- 13:22established the
- 13:23SPEAKER_01: Atomic Energy Commission,
- 13:24you'll see a lot of references to the need to bring in private
- 13:28enterprise and the
- 13:29SPEAKER_01: need for the government to collaborate with private enterprise.
- 13:32SPEAKER_01: So this idea in the last few years,
- 13:33you've probably heard a lot of folks at the Department of
- 13:36Energy from Secretary
- 13:37Granholm to Jigar Shah to David Crane use phrases like the
- 13:41energy transition must
- 13:42SPEAKER_01: be private sector led,
- 13:44SPEAKER_01: government enabled.
- 13:45That's very much been at the core of energy policy in this
- 13:49country for decades,
- 13:50I would say.
- 13:51SPEAKER_01: Industrial policy and energy policy have been intertwined,
- 13:53SPEAKER_01: I would say,
- 13:54SPEAKER_01: for the last even 100 years,
- 13:55SPEAKER_01: even going back before the war,
- 13:57SPEAKER_01: going back to the Federal Power Commission days.
- 13:59SPEAKER_01: But just focusing on the 1970s for a second,
- 14:03SPEAKER_01: by the fall of 1974,
- 14:04SPEAKER_01: so now we're a year out from the Arab oil embargo,
- 14:08SPEAKER_01: President Nixon resigns,
- 14:09SPEAKER_01: President Ford takes over.
- 14:11And one of his first speeches is to the World Energy Conference
- 14:15in Detroit.
- 14:16And he addresses them and once again invokes this concept of
- 14:20project independence.
- 14:21SPEAKER_01: He talks about the Apollo mission.
- 14:23SPEAKER_01: He talks about the Manhattan Project.
- 14:24He says,
- 14:25you know,
- 14:25we really need a new agency to be able to deal with this crisis.
- 14:29SPEAKER_00: At that point a year on, are gas prices still through the roof?
- 14:34SPEAKER_01: Gas prices are so high.
- 14:35SPEAKER_01: I mean, the supply shortage is still real.
- 14:37SPEAKER_01: Americans are still hurting.
- 14:39There was a really good book called Panic at the Pump that
- 14:42chronicles this.
- 14:43SPEAKER_01: It's by Meg Jacobs, a Princeton historian.
- 14:46SPEAKER_01: She has quotes about how,
- 14:47SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 14:47SPEAKER_01: when the Arab oil embargo took effect,
- 14:49SPEAKER_01: it wasn't like bombs were dropped or anything like that.
- 14:53SPEAKER_01: But the feeling that Americans had was as if bombs had dropped.
- 14:57SPEAKER_01: Like there was almost this like...
- 14:59metaphoric silence across the country because we had become so
- 15:02dependent on oil and
- 15:04so you know when you talk to people that live through those
- 15:07times they'll tell you
- 15:07like yeah i remember you know waiting hours in a gas line and
- 15:10so this is very
- 15:11palpable so this had fully taken up all of the political space
- 15:16at that time so it's
- 15:17not a coincidence that president ford felt the need to focus on
- 15:21energy pretty
- 15:21SPEAKER_01: quickly
- 15:22SPEAKER_01: And so within a few months of him taking office,
- 15:26SPEAKER_01: President Ford signs the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974 into law.
- 15:31And so that establishes the Energy Research and Development Administration.
- 15:34And what they do there is they consolidate all of the
- 15:38non-nuclear energy R&D
- 15:40functions that are scattered across the National Science
- 15:42Foundation and the
- 15:44SPEAKER_01: Department of Interior,
- 15:45SPEAKER_01: and they pull it all together under IRTA.
- 15:48SPEAKER_01: as it was known.
- 15:49And even then they knew that ERDA was not going to immediately
- 15:52serve all the needs,
- 15:53SPEAKER_01: but it was a significant step to consolidate energy functions.
- 15:57SPEAKER_01: So you're not just doing atomic energy, you're doing everything now.
- 16:01SPEAKER_01: That clearly...
- 16:03SPEAKER_01: was not enough.
- 16:04And a couple of years later,
- 16:06President Carter,
- 16:07Jimmy Carter wins election.
- 16:09SPEAKER_01: And his famous,
- 16:10SPEAKER_01: we're in the moral equivalent of war speech,
- 16:13he gives that speech and he quickly lays out a vision for a new
- 16:17Department of Energy.
- 16:18SPEAKER_01: And he pushes that into motion pretty quickly.
- 16:21SPEAKER_01: So there's many...
- 16:22SPEAKER_01: Plans drafted.
- 16:22SPEAKER_01: A lot of this is very well chronicled also by Jay Hakes,
- 16:26a presidential historian and was also an energy advisor to
- 16:29President Carter.
- 16:30SPEAKER_01: So these are books.
- 16:31SPEAKER_01: I'm just telling you books that I read along the way.
- 16:33SPEAKER_00: You did a lot of reading.
- 16:34People that have worked with me at DOE have probably heard me
- 16:37recommend these books
- 16:38ad nauseum just because I think it's really important to know
- 16:40this history.
- 16:41So how do we get from there to the place we're at now to paint
- 16:44with a really broad brush?
- 16:45My picture of the Department of Energy is this weird creature
- 16:48that has a bunch of
- 16:49SPEAKER_00: nuclear energy...
- 16:51SPEAKER_00: research and security work,
- 16:53SPEAKER_00: the national labs are in there,
- 16:55SPEAKER_00: and you've got all this other infrastructure and energy stuff going on.
- 16:59SPEAKER_00: Finish that loop,
- 16:59SPEAKER_00: but where do we...
- 16:59SPEAKER_00: The Department of Energy is built,
- 17:01SPEAKER_00: and why does it end up being this kind of three-legged stool?
- 17:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 17:05SPEAKER_01: actually,
- 17:05SPEAKER_01: three-legged stool is an excellent way to put it,
- 17:08SPEAKER_01: and maybe I would add a fourth leg in the last...
- 17:10SPEAKER_01: A couple of years or so.
- 17:11SPEAKER_01: So the three-legged stool as of October 1977,
- 17:14SPEAKER_01: when the DOE Organization Act was passed,
- 17:17SPEAKER_01: was,
- 17:18SPEAKER_01: OK,
- 17:18SPEAKER_01: this enterprise is going to continue working on nuclear weapons.
- 17:21SPEAKER_01: There's also this whole nuclear cleanup mission, which continues today.
- 17:24SPEAKER_01: It's a significant part of the department's budget.
- 17:27SPEAKER_01: And then, gosh, we really got to expand our R&D enterprise.
- 17:32SPEAKER_01: And actually,
- 17:33SPEAKER_01: I would say,
- 17:33SPEAKER_01: even back then,
- 17:34SPEAKER_01: there was a fourth leg to the stool,
- 17:35SPEAKER_01: which was the R&D enterprise is really,
- 17:37SPEAKER_01: really important.
- 17:38But we also have to figure out how to scale up these
- 17:41technologies and commercialize them.
- 17:42SPEAKER_01: And so you'll see,
- 17:44SPEAKER_01: sprinkled throughout the DOE Organization Act,
- 17:46all these references to this department is meant to have broad
- 17:50authority to address
- 17:52SPEAKER_01: the energy needs of the country.
- 17:54SPEAKER_01: You'll see also the reference to private enterprise.
- 17:56SPEAKER_01: You'll see the reference,
- 17:58SPEAKER_01: I don't think they use the word commercialization per se,
- 18:00but they pretty much say this department is entrusted with the
- 18:04duty to figure out
- 18:04SPEAKER_01: how to get things essentially out of the lab and out into the real world.
- 18:08So that was very much at the core of the department when it was
- 18:12founded in 1977.
- 18:14SPEAKER_01: And so then you have two bills that passed pretty quickly after that.
- 18:17SPEAKER_01: The first is the National Energy Act of 1978.
- 18:20SPEAKER_01: My favorite one is the Energy Security Act of 1980,
- 18:23SPEAKER_01: which was passed in June,
- 18:24SPEAKER_01: of an election year.
- 18:25SPEAKER_01: And that, I mean, if one could do an alternative history
- 18:29SPEAKER_01: of U.S.
- 18:30SPEAKER_01: energy policy,
- 18:30SPEAKER_01: I would really focus on the Energy Security Act of 1980,
- 18:33SPEAKER_01: because in those days,
- 18:34SPEAKER_01: it set up an $88 billion,
- 18:36SPEAKER_01: or authorized an $88 billion synthetic fuels corporation.
- 18:40SPEAKER_01: It also set up a solar bank,
- 18:42SPEAKER_01: geothermal research,
- 18:43SPEAKER_01: a Renewable Energy Resources Act sat within it.
- 18:46SPEAKER_01: So it had all this stuff in there.
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: And one of the first things that
- 18:51came out during the Reagan transition after Jimmy Carter lost
- 18:54the election in 1980
- 18:56was to dismantle the Department of Energy and pretty much
- 18:59dismantle the Energy
- 19:00SPEAKER_01: Security Act of 1980.
- 19:01SPEAKER_01: So the Synthetic Fuels Corporation,
- 19:03SPEAKER_01: they tried to implement it for a few years,
- 19:05SPEAKER_01: but they pretty much folded it down pretty quickly.
- 19:07They weren't very serious about implementing the Energy
- 19:09Security Act of 1980.
- 19:11SPEAKER_01: So it ends up being a bill that goes unfulfilled.
- 19:14And the reason this has importance for our conversation today
- 19:18and where DOE is at
- 19:19SPEAKER_01: is because DOE essentially in the 1980s,
- 19:22SPEAKER_01: as there were multiple attempts to shut it down as an agency,
- 19:26DOE essentially ends up in this kind of defensive crouch where
- 19:29it goes back to
- 19:29SPEAKER_01: doing R&D,
- 19:31SPEAKER_01: the nuclear weapons work,
- 19:32SPEAKER_01: and nuclear cleanup.
- 19:33SPEAKER_01: And that's pretty much what DOE largely ends up doing through the 80s,
- 19:37SPEAKER_01: the 90s,
- 19:38SPEAKER_01: all the way until the early 2000s.
- 19:40SPEAKER_01: And so until the Energy Policy Act of 2005,
- 19:43there weren't very serious efforts to get DOE to going back to
- 19:47trying to scale up
- 19:48SPEAKER_01: energy technologies,
- 19:49SPEAKER_01: commercialize energy technologies.
- 19:51The Energy Policy Act of 2005 is when the DOE Loan Programs
- 19:55Office first gets authorized.
- 19:56Within that same year is when ARPA-E,
- 19:58the DOE version of DARPA,
- 20:00gets set up.
- 20:01And as you may recall,
- 20:02the 2000s,
- 20:03this is before the fracking revolution really took hold.
- 20:07We were starting to get nervous again about our dependence on
- 20:09foreign oil.
- 20:10SPEAKER_01: So you have the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007.
- 20:13SPEAKER_01: So we've got all these things leading up to the financial crisis.
- 20:17SPEAKER_01: And then the Obama administration in 2009 passed the Recovery Act,
- 20:22SPEAKER_01: and that plunges a lot of money into energy,
- 20:26SPEAKER_01: trying to deploy energy,
- 20:27SPEAKER_01: trying to put more money into R&D work.
- 20:30And one of the things that's very interesting there is the
- 20:34whole mission at that
- 20:35SPEAKER_01: time was to get money out the door to shovel-ready projects.
- 20:39And the ability for the department to really think creatively
- 20:42or look at its
- 20:43SPEAKER_01: authorities and put money out the door in innovative ways,
- 20:46SPEAKER_01: there wasn't much time.
- 20:47SPEAKER_01: It was like, we got to get money out the door yesterday.
- 20:50SPEAKER_01: Fast forward to 2021 and 2022 when
- 20:54The bipartisan infrastructure law passes in November 21 and the
- 20:57Inflation Reduction
- 20:58SPEAKER_01: Act passed in the summer of 22.
- 20:59That's really the first time the DOE then gets a huge influx of
- 21:03money and the
- 21:04ability to kind of deliberately think about how to put this
- 21:07money out in the most innovative,
- 21:09SPEAKER_01: catalytic way.
- 21:10So you end up in the Biden administration at the Department of
- 21:13Energy as the DOE is
- 21:16SPEAKER_00: trying to move a ton of money for Biden admin priorities.
- 21:20SPEAKER_00: Will you just say a little bit about
- 21:22how the DOE is structured at that point because you're trying
- 21:25to do a whole lot,
- 21:26SPEAKER_00: a huge amount of money,
- 21:27SPEAKER_00: relatively and just actually.
- 21:29SPEAKER_00: It's billions, billions of dollars that the DOE is trying to move.
- 21:33SPEAKER_00: What tools do you have at that point to move that money out the door?
- 21:37SPEAKER_01: Yeah, great question.
- 21:38SPEAKER_01: This was a very live conversation at the time.
- 21:41So DOE was still organizationally set up to largely be an R&D
- 21:47enterprise at the
- 21:48SPEAKER_01: time that we came in,
- 21:49SPEAKER_01: in January of 2021.
- 21:51SPEAKER_01: But in anticipation of one or both of these bills being passed,
- 21:56there was a lot of work done during transition and before on
- 21:59trying to reorganize
- 22:01DOE to exercise more of a demonstration and deployment function
- 22:05and not just an R&D function.
- 22:07SPEAKER_00: And just for laypeople,
- 22:08SPEAKER_00: the difference between an R&D function and a deployment function is what?
- 22:12So put simply,
- 22:13R&D,
- 22:14largely the government is paying you potentially to even fail.
- 22:17SPEAKER_01: The government is fine with you taking risks with your projects.
- 22:21SPEAKER_00: On a new technology, on a new kind of project.
- 22:23SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so it can be like an innovative sodium ion battery, right?
- 22:28SPEAKER_01: Maybe it hasn't been proven at scale yet,
- 22:30SPEAKER_01: but it's still being tested out in the lab,
- 22:32and the government is giving out a couple million dollars of
- 22:35grant money for that,
- 22:36SPEAKER_01: right?
- 22:36SPEAKER_00: So you can run some trials in the lab.
- 22:38SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 22:39SPEAKER_01: And you're ultimately...
- 22:40SPEAKER_01: being paid under a cost reimbursement structure.
- 22:43Regardless of what the outcomes of your research are,
- 22:46you're getting paid essentially to try.
- 22:48SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 22:48SPEAKER_00: And you basically, you submit a receipt.
- 22:51SPEAKER_00: You're like, here are the costs for the project.
- 22:53SPEAKER_00: And if they're within scope, DOE pays them back and that's it.
- 22:56SPEAKER_01: More or less, yeah.
- 22:56SPEAKER_01: But that's essentially what it is.
- 22:59SPEAKER_01: And so then when you think about demonstration and deployment scale,
- 23:03SPEAKER_01: a demonstration project could run upwards of billion,
- 23:06SPEAKER_01: billion plus dollars.
- 23:07SPEAKER_01: So at that stage, government's not...
- 23:10SPEAKER_01: just trying to pay you to fill.
- 23:11SPEAKER_01: They really want to make sure that your technology is proven.
- 23:15They really want to ensure that your project has a higher
- 23:18chance of success.
- 23:19SPEAKER_01: They're not just throwing grant money at a highly risky project.
- 23:24Obviously,
- 23:24the government is going to still take risks that the private
- 23:27sector isn't.
- 23:27SPEAKER_01: That's the whole reason why the government is giving that grant money.
- 23:30SPEAKER_01: And so by the time actually President Biden was even sworn into office,
- 23:34the Energy Act of 2020 had been passed was a bipartisan bill in
- 23:38the waning days of
- 23:39SPEAKER_01: the Trump administration.
- 23:40SPEAKER_01: And that bill had authorized the Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations.
- 23:44So there was already this vision that government needs to be
- 23:46putting more money
- 23:47SPEAKER_01: into scaling up technologies at the demonstration level.
- 23:51SPEAKER_01: Now,
- 23:51deployment is once you've scaled up that technology and it's
- 23:54been demonstrated,
- 23:55SPEAKER_01: then you want to deploy the second,
- 23:57SPEAKER_01: third,
- 23:58SPEAKER_01: fourth,
- 23:58SPEAKER_01: fifth,
- 23:59SPEAKER_01: nth of a kind of that project.
- 24:01And so at that point,
- 24:02you've reached commercialization essentially for that technology.
- 24:07The demonstration and deployment function,
- 24:09it requires a very different skill set.
- 24:11SPEAKER_01: It requires not just technical experts.
- 24:15SPEAKER_00: It requires prototyping or...
- 24:17People that have worked in finance that actually know a lot of
- 24:20these projects.
- 24:21You've really reached success for energy technology when you
- 24:23can project finance that project.
- 24:25SPEAKER_01: So that means you have an offtaker.
- 24:27SPEAKER_00: Offtaker, will you just define that?
- 24:29SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 24:29SPEAKER_00: That's a word I learned at IFP.
- 24:31SPEAKER_00: I did not know it.
- 24:32SPEAKER_00: Offtake agreement was before this job.
- 24:33SPEAKER_01: So an offtake agreement is quite literally what it sounds like.
- 24:37SPEAKER_01: I'm selling this thing.
- 24:38SPEAKER_01: Let's say it could be batteries or it could be electricity itself.
- 24:43Someone is literally saying,
- 24:44I will buy X amount of those things for Y price.
- 24:48SPEAKER_01: Got it.
- 24:48SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 24:48SPEAKER_01: And so that offtake agreement allows one to go to a bank and say,
- 24:53SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 24:53SPEAKER_01: over the next 10 years,
- 24:54SPEAKER_01: if I build this thing and I produce these widgets or electricity,
- 24:59SPEAKER_01: I'm getting paid this much.
- 25:00SPEAKER_00: You literally take that to the bank.
- 25:01SPEAKER_01: You literally take that to the bank.
- 25:03SPEAKER_01: And the bank is very, very conservative.
- 25:05SPEAKER_01: And that's why at the point where you're getting debt for a project,
- 25:09SPEAKER_01: that project has to be technically de-risked by that point.
- 25:13SPEAKER_01: There might still be some financial risk,
- 25:15SPEAKER_01: and that's why you're signing these offtake agreements.
- 25:17SPEAKER_01: A bank is only going to give you a loan at that point.
- 25:20SPEAKER_01: So that's how you reach final investment decision for a project.
- 25:23SPEAKER_01: And then the project eventually gets built and voila, right?
- 25:26SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 25:27SPEAKER_00: So you come into the DOE where there's increasing,
- 25:30SPEAKER_00: it's just the mandate has just come from Congress,
- 25:32SPEAKER_00: do more demonstrations.
- 25:34SPEAKER_00: And then a year or two later,
- 25:36SPEAKER_00: you get this push from the Biden admin,
- 25:38the infrastructure law to do a whole bunch more of the
- 25:40deployment side stuff.
- 25:41Did you need to bring a lot of talent in or what did the rework
- 25:44look like?
- 25:45SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 25:45SPEAKER_01: Well, so actually, even before the rear, a couple of things I'll note.
- 25:49SPEAKER_01: The Loan Programs Office existed for a good decade plus by that point,
- 25:53SPEAKER_01: but they hadn't executed any new loans in years.
- 25:56SPEAKER_00: Was that a consequence of the Solyndra blow up largely that-
- 26:00SPEAKER_00: There was hesitation to try again?
- 26:02SPEAKER_01: One can say so.
- 26:03SPEAKER_01: There's many,
- 26:04SPEAKER_01: many reasons,
- 26:05but the Energy Act of 2020 started already laying the
- 26:09groundwork for LPO to be
- 26:11SPEAKER_01: reinvigorated as an enterprise within the department.
- 26:14The bipartisan infrastructure law further amended some of the authorities,
- 26:17and then eventually the Inflation Reduction Act gave LPO
- 26:22significantly more loan authority,
- 26:23SPEAKER_01: upwards of $400 billion of loan authority.
- 26:26SPEAKER_01: which Jigar Shah has spoken a lot about.
- 26:29SPEAKER_01: And so, you know, you've got the Energy Act of 2020.
- 26:33SPEAKER_01: Biden takes office in January 2021.
- 26:35SPEAKER_01: And pretty much as soon as the new administration gets in place,
- 26:39SPEAKER_01: negotiations have started for the,
- 26:40SPEAKER_01: quote unquote,
- 26:41SPEAKER_01: Build Back Better agenda,
- 26:43SPEAKER_01: which eventually gets broken up,
- 26:45SPEAKER_01: at least on the energy side,
- 26:46SPEAKER_01: into the bipartisan infrastructure law in the Inflation Reduction Act.
- 26:50SPEAKER_01: And so there is a recognition that,
- 26:52SPEAKER_01: well,
- 26:52SPEAKER_01: if one or both of these bills get passed,
- 26:54we're going to need a lot more expertise on the demonstration
- 26:57and deployment side.
- 26:58When you say that,
- 26:58you mean the financing side to not just the supporting R&D research?
- 27:02SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 27:03SPEAKER_01: To give you a very concrete example of how the department was not set up
- 27:07SPEAKER_01: immediately to take this on,
- 27:09there's a little quirk in how the grant structure works at the
- 27:13Department of Energy,
- 27:14SPEAKER_01: where if the department gives you a grant for a project,
- 27:19The department essentially has a property interest in that
- 27:22project pretty much in
- 27:24perpetuity until the property or the equipment in that project
- 27:27basically diminishes
- 27:29SPEAKER_01: in value under $7,500 at some point.
- 27:31SPEAKER_01: Until the end of the project.
- 27:33SPEAKER_01: Well, pretty much, yeah.
- 27:34SPEAKER_01: Yeah, right.
- 27:36SPEAKER_01: Which is not a big deal for microscopes in a lab or a small lab project.
- 27:42But if you're trying to build something big and you're trying
- 27:44to go to a bank and say,
- 27:45SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 27:45trying to build this thing and the government might have a
- 27:47running interest.
- 27:48SPEAKER_01: The first question a bank is going to ask is,
- 27:50am I going to be fighting DOE and bankruptcy court for pennies
- 27:53on the dollar if
- 27:53SPEAKER_01: this project fails?
- 27:54You're pretty much scaring a bank away from wanting to invest
- 27:57in one of those
- 27:58SPEAKER_01: projects or provide a loan for one of those projects.
- 27:59Because they know there'll be rival risks in a bunch of
- 28:02situations with the federal government.
- 28:03SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 28:03SPEAKER_01: And so this had actually been corrected,
- 28:05particularly for nuclear projects and for fossil energy
- 28:08projects along the way.
- 28:10A lot of the way federal agencies are set up is there's a lot
- 28:13of gum and tape along
- 28:14the way that Congress plugs a hole in a leaking ship or adds a
- 28:19little thing to the top.
- 28:21When we were getting ready to seriously implement the
- 28:25bipartisan infrastructure law
- 28:26SPEAKER_01: in the Inflation Reduction Act,
- 28:27SPEAKER_01: it became very,
- 28:28SPEAKER_01: very clear that this is going to be a huge problem.
- 28:31SPEAKER_01: If you actually look at the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023,
- 28:34SPEAKER_01: which passed in December of 2022,
- 28:36SPEAKER_01: just a couple months after the Inflation Reduction Act,
- 28:38there is now authority for the Secretary of Energy to best
- 28:41title in any projects
- 28:43SPEAKER_01: undertaken for demonstration or deployment purposes.
- 28:47SPEAKER_01: That means the Secretary of Energy can essentially say,
- 28:51SPEAKER_01: at the end of this project,
- 28:52SPEAKER_01: there's no running government property interest in this project.
- 28:55The logic behind why the government should have this running
- 28:58property interest made
- 28:59SPEAKER_01: sense in the very,
- 29:00SPEAKER_01: very beginning probably when it was put in place,
- 29:02SPEAKER_01: which was,
- 29:03SPEAKER_01: this is taxpayer money.
- 29:04SPEAKER_01: We want to make sure that you're not, you know, wasting taxpayer money.
- 29:08But the reality is the government is not trying to recover
- 29:10pennies on the dollar
- 29:11SPEAKER_01: for a failed project.
- 29:12SPEAKER_01: That's not really what the government is trying to recover.
- 29:15SPEAKER_01: what the government really probably cares about is what happens to the IP
- 29:19SPEAKER_01: associated with that project,
- 29:21SPEAKER_01: right?
- 29:21SPEAKER_01: You don't want that IP to just be bought up and taken overseas.
- 29:24SPEAKER_01: And that actually had happened for decades and decades prior.
- 29:27SPEAKER_01: There wasn't a good enforcement of the IP rights of the government.
- 29:31And so imagine a world in which the government can essentially
- 29:35reach an agreement
- 29:36SPEAKER_01: with the counterparty.
- 29:37SPEAKER_01: In this case, it'll be
- 29:38the developer of the clean energy technology and their bank
- 29:40perhaps saying,
- 29:41SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 29:42SPEAKER_01: at the end of this project,
- 29:43SPEAKER_01: we will vest title.
- 29:45SPEAKER_01: The only thing we care about is if this project gets sold,
- 29:48we just want to make sure that the IP is not going overseas or
- 29:51to a certain country
- 29:52SPEAKER_01: or whatever it is.
- 29:53SPEAKER_01: It could be as,
- 29:54SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 29:55SPEAKER_01: it's a lot more complicated than that,
- 29:56SPEAKER_01: but really like conceptually,
- 29:58SPEAKER_01: that's how simple it is.
- 29:59SPEAKER_01: But even getting to that place,
- 30:01that thinking of how do you structure award terms to ensure
- 30:06that a private bank
- 30:07SPEAKER_01: feels comfortable giving a loan to one of those projects,
- 30:11SPEAKER_01: that requires very different thinking than what DOE had.
- 30:14And so this is precisely why the Under Secretary for
- 30:17Infrastructure was set up at
- 30:18SPEAKER_01: the Department of Energy.
- 30:20SPEAKER_01: And a bunch of new offices that were created,
- 30:22SPEAKER_01: the Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations,
- 30:24SPEAKER_01: a new Office of Manufacturing and Energy Supply Chains,
- 30:27SPEAKER_01: a new Office of Grid Deployment,
- 30:29SPEAKER_01: Grid Deployment Office,
- 30:30SPEAKER_01: and then the existing Loan Programs Office.
- 30:32SPEAKER_01: These offices,
- 30:33SPEAKER_01: along with a few others,
- 30:34SPEAKER_01: were all consolidated under a new Undersecretary for Infrastructure.
- 30:37SPEAKER_01: And that was led by David Crane, the Undersecretary.
- 30:40SPEAKER_01: And then there was also a woman named Leslie Biddle,
- 30:43SPEAKER_01: who was the Deputy Undersecretary,
- 30:44SPEAKER_01: who came with a very strong finance background.
- 30:47It's funny because I hadn't put this together until you kind of
- 30:50explained this,
- 30:51but when the Biden admin talked a lot about crowding in private investment,
- 30:54SPEAKER_00: the idea,
- 30:55SPEAKER_00: and I'll tell me if I'm paraphrasing correctly,
- 30:56was that you want to find ways of using federal dollars that
- 31:00encourage private
- 31:00SPEAKER_00: actors into the market.
- 31:01And one of the things that you're talking about that was an
- 31:03issue previously is that
- 31:05SPEAKER_00: Turns out there are all kinds of cases where federal dollars,
- 31:07SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 31:08scare off banks from otherwise investing or working with other
- 31:12private actors.
- 31:12And being charitable to DOE didn't have that scale of grant
- 31:18money to put out until
- 31:19SPEAKER_01: the infrastructure bill and the Inflation Reduction Act passed.
- 31:22SPEAKER_00: New things DOE would be asked to do.
- 31:24SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 31:25SPEAKER_00: Generally had not been previously.
- 31:26SPEAKER_01: For example,
- 31:27SPEAKER_01: just for batteries and critical minerals,
- 31:28SPEAKER_01: the Department of Energy was giving out $6 billion of money.
- 31:32SPEAKER_01: That's grant money.
- 31:33SPEAKER_01: That was unprecedented.
- 31:34SPEAKER_00: They had not flexed that muscle before.
- 31:36SPEAKER_00: They didn't flex that.
- 31:37SPEAKER_01: Yeah, at all.
- 31:38And because even during the Recovery Act,
- 31:41it was a very,
- 31:42very different posture.
- 31:42SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 31:43SPEAKER_01: Smaller projects.
- 31:44SPEAKER_01: And it was just, like I said, money out the door yesterday.
- 31:47SPEAKER_01: And it was a lot of money actually given to states directly to then,
- 31:51SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:51set up revolving loan funds for energy retrofits and all that
- 31:54kind of stuff.
- 31:55SPEAKER_00: There's much more kind of classic Keynesian stimulus,
- 31:58SPEAKER_00: just like put money in the economy,
- 31:59SPEAKER_00: period.
- 32:00SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 32:00SPEAKER_01: And so this was not meant to be that, right?
- 32:03This was supposed to be,
- 32:04let's be deliberate about how we re-industrialize parts of the economy.
- 32:09SPEAKER_01: That was very much part of the thinking of the Build Back Better agenda.
- 32:13Also make long-term investments in our infrastructure and set
- 32:16up the United States
- 32:17SPEAKER_01: to succeed in the clean energy race of the future.
- 32:22So let me ask you about a really specific thing that you worked
- 32:24on in service of
- 32:26SPEAKER_00: this kind of big bid and admin priorities.
- 32:28It's funny because I think you're very good at explaining this
- 32:30kind of broad,
- 32:31the admin agenda.
- 32:32And then the thing I want to talk to you about is this
- 32:33incredibly arcane little weird detail.
- 32:36You spent a lot of time rewriting or writing a guide to using
- 32:39other transactions
- 32:40SPEAKER_00: authority or OTA,
- 32:41SPEAKER_00: which we've talked about on here in the past.
- 32:43SPEAKER_00: I was talking to colleagues in the office.
- 32:44SPEAKER_00: I was like, I'm interviewing this guy.
- 32:46SPEAKER_00: He rewrote this guy.
- 32:46SPEAKER_00: And I was like, that sounds like a
- 32:48SPEAKER_00: a nightmare.
- 32:48SPEAKER_00: You write this 100-page document on contracting authorities.
- 32:55So what's the point of doing that,
- 32:57of going into the weeds and fixing that?
- 32:59SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 33:00SPEAKER_01: So like I said,
- 33:01DOE was at an unprecedented moment on the heels of even just
- 33:05the bipartisan
- 33:06SPEAKER_01: infrastructure law being passed.
- 33:07Just that one bill gave DOE about $65 billion of new grant
- 33:11money to put out the door.
- 33:13And so it became so we not only set up the undersecretary for
- 33:17infrastructure and
- 33:18SPEAKER_01: from the general counsel's office,
- 33:19SPEAKER_01: I was involved with writing the memo to do that.
- 33:21SPEAKER_01: So this, once again, kind of goes back to the history.
- 33:24SPEAKER_01: How can DOE reorganize itself and all that?
- 33:26it became pretty clear that we were going to have to think
- 33:30about contracting very differently.
- 33:32And there's been a lot of voices out there over the last many
- 33:35years that have been
- 33:36SPEAKER_01: calling for the Department of Energy to exercise this thing called Other
- 33:40SPEAKER_01: Transactions Authority.
- 33:42SPEAKER_01: So what is that?
- 33:43SPEAKER_01: For people in the government contracting space,
- 33:45SPEAKER_01: it's kind of this mythological,
- 33:47SPEAKER_01: there's truly this mythology about OTs.
- 33:50SPEAKER_01: Other transactions.
- 33:51SPEAKER_01: Other transactions.
- 33:52And to put it simply,
- 33:54other transactions are defined by what they're not.
- 33:56SPEAKER_01: They're not a traditional grant or cooperative agreement.
- 33:59SPEAKER_01: And I know that's not a very fulfilling response,
- 34:02but what I mean by that is when you are executing a grant or a
- 34:07cooperative
- 34:08SPEAKER_01: agreement as the government,
- 34:09There are a lot of clear rules and regulations around what the
- 34:14terms of the
- 34:15SPEAKER_01: contract can be under 2 CFR 200.
- 34:18SPEAKER_01: And then that's the general contracting regulations.
- 34:22SPEAKER_01: And then each agency has its own.
- 34:24SPEAKER_01: There's actually...
- 34:25SPEAKER_01: There's a lot of good that comes out of that.
- 34:27I actually want to take a moment to just recognize that not all
- 34:30government
- 34:31SPEAKER_01: contracting is rickety and inefficient.
- 34:34SPEAKER_01: The reason why a lot of that is good is,
- 34:36SPEAKER_01: one,
- 34:36SPEAKER_01: it lessens the space for negotiation for contracts.
- 34:40SPEAKER_01: You as the government,
- 34:41SPEAKER_01: and especially when you're doing business with the government,
- 34:42you don't want to be spending years and years negotiating a
- 34:45grant contract.
- 34:46SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 34:47Those rules and regulations are in place to prevent waste,
- 34:50fraud and abuse.
- 34:51SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 34:51SPEAKER_01: And as much as people want the government to be big,
- 34:54SPEAKER_01: bold,
- 34:55SPEAKER_01: boisterous,
- 34:55SPEAKER_01: take risks,
- 34:56SPEAKER_01: the government is held to a very,
- 34:57SPEAKER_01: very different standard than the private sector.
- 34:59SPEAKER_01: In fact,
- 35:00I would say the private sector has the luxury to fail and
- 35:03failure is seen as a good
- 35:04SPEAKER_01: thing when the government fails.
- 35:05SPEAKER_01: It very often is, you know.
- 35:07SPEAKER_01: It becomes a political football.
- 35:09SPEAKER_01: You have got oversight hearings, all that kind of stuff.
- 35:11So the contracting structure is very much a response to that to
- 35:15ensure that the
- 35:16SPEAKER_01: opportunities for fraud,
- 35:18SPEAKER_01: waste,
- 35:18SPEAKER_01: and abuse are minimized as much as possible.
- 35:20SPEAKER_01: So there's cost accounting standards that are attached.
- 35:23SPEAKER_01: There is standards attached on if you're paid for potential failure,
- 35:27let's make sure that you still tried just enough and all that
- 35:29kind of stuff.
- 35:30There's very clear rules around the IP rights that the
- 35:33government takes and stuff like that.
- 35:34SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 35:35SPEAKER_01: So these are all very good things.
- 35:36But most,
- 35:38if not all of those regulations were written for with R&D
- 35:41contracts in mind.
- 35:42SPEAKER_01: So typically taking a few steps back,
- 35:44SPEAKER_01: when the government is putting money out the door,
- 35:46SPEAKER_01: you can roughly bucket in two categories.
- 35:49SPEAKER_01: Either the government is procuring or acquiring something.
- 35:53So they're paying someone for anything from chairs for the
- 35:55office to a warfighter.
- 35:57SPEAKER_01: Or the government is providing financial assistance.
- 36:00SPEAKER_01: And that's where grants come into play.
- 36:02SPEAKER_01: Got it.
- 36:02I'm either buying something as a federal government or I'm
- 36:05supporting you in doing
- 36:06SPEAKER_00: some project out there.
- 36:08SPEAKER_01: And then loans are a slightly different flavor.
- 36:10SPEAKER_01: They don't fall under the same regulations, but we'll set that aside.
- 36:13SPEAKER_01: So DOE was very quick to immediately say,
- 36:17SPEAKER_01: well,
- 36:17SPEAKER_01: look,
- 36:18we've done cooperative agreements for big carbon capture and
- 36:21storage projects in
- 36:22SPEAKER_01: the past,
- 36:22SPEAKER_01: for nuclear projects in the past.
- 36:24SPEAKER_01: So we should essentially do that again.
- 36:27And just briefly,
- 36:28a cooperative agreement,
- 36:30it's one of the usual contracting things you do.
- 36:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 36:33SPEAKER_00: And it's what?
- 36:34SPEAKER_01: It has the standard cost accounting standards attached to it.
- 36:39Like I said,
- 36:40the cost performance structure and the IP terms are pretty
- 36:45clearly laid out.
- 36:46SPEAKER_01: Competition is pretty explicitly laid out.
- 36:48But all of these contracts envision having a single
- 36:52counterparty that's just doing one thing.
- 36:54And once you get to the demonstration deployment phase where
- 36:57you're potentially even trying to
- 36:58SPEAKER_01: help seed or create a market.
- 37:01SPEAKER_01: And you have not just one player,
- 37:02but you have a whole team of you've got this developer that's
- 37:08building or scaling
- 37:09SPEAKER_01: up the energy technology.
- 37:10SPEAKER_01: They've got potential offtakers.
- 37:13SPEAKER_01: You've got a whole supply chain around it.
- 37:15So in essence,
- 37:16the government is maybe actually contracting with a consortium
- 37:19or like a hub.
- 37:19SPEAKER_01: Hydrogen hubs is a good example.
- 37:21SPEAKER_01: So it's not just one entity, it's multiple entities.
- 37:24SPEAKER_01: So you've got like subs,
- 37:27SPEAKER_01: under that and all that.
- 37:28Cooperative agreements could still work,
- 37:30but it actually could be quite limiting.
- 37:32SPEAKER_01: And we realized that pretty quickly.
- 37:33SPEAKER_01: And at times,
- 37:35the government is not just purely executing a procurement or a
- 37:39financial assistance function.
- 37:40SPEAKER_01: For example,
- 37:41the Department of Energy recognized through its hydrogen
- 37:45liftoff reports that,
- 37:46SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 37:46SPEAKER_01: we've got a problem setting up a new hydrogen industry where the
- 37:52SPEAKER_01: There's not a clear strike price for clean hydrogen.
- 37:55SPEAKER_01: We're trying to literally seed a new commodity market.
- 37:58SPEAKER_01: There's a whole kind of the supply demand stalemate.
- 38:01SPEAKER_01: No one wants to pay a price premium for this thing just yet.
- 38:06SPEAKER_01: No one knows what price to sell it at just yet.
- 38:08SPEAKER_01: And so there was a real need for the government DOE to come in and say,
- 38:12SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 38:12SPEAKER_01: you're going to try to provide demand side support for a few projects.
- 38:16SPEAKER_01: and try to enable some market transparency.
- 38:18The other thing with these offtake agreements is very often
- 38:20they're not publicized
- 38:22SPEAKER_01: how much someone is paying for something.
- 38:24And so it's very hard to actually have market transparency and
- 38:27build a whole ecosystem.
- 38:28SPEAKER_01: Whereas when the government is involved,
- 38:29SPEAKER_01: they can say,
- 38:30SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 38:30SPEAKER_01: if you're contracting and you're getting government money,
- 38:34one of the conditions the government can put in is you're going
- 38:36to actually publish
- 38:37SPEAKER_01: and publicize how much you're selling this thing for,
- 38:40SPEAKER_01: because we're actually trying to catalyze the market.
- 38:41SPEAKER_01: We're not just trying to get
- 38:42You want to create market signals that other actors can look at
- 38:45and use for their
- 38:46SPEAKER_00: own market decisions.
- 38:47SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 38:48And so it became clear that we needed to look at our
- 38:52contracting apparatus and see,
- 38:55SPEAKER_01: is there a way to invigorate our use of other transactions authority?
- 39:00SPEAKER_00: And just in brief,
- 39:01why was it so important to have another tool to do the
- 39:04contracts that wasn't the
- 39:05SPEAKER_00: existing stuff on the table?
- 39:07SPEAKER_00: What did you want to be able to do that the DOE thought it couldn't do?
- 39:11SPEAKER_01: The way I would put it is you actually don't know what you don't know.
- 39:15You often don't know what kind of challenges that are going to
- 39:18arise when you're
- 39:20SPEAKER_01: negotiating a contract until you're really there.
- 39:22SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 39:22SPEAKER_00: often,
- 39:23SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 39:23SPEAKER_01: a program office like the Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations or any
- 39:27SPEAKER_01: manufacturing energy supply chain office may go in saying,
- 39:29SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 39:30SPEAKER_01: we've got a problem.
- 39:31SPEAKER_01: We're
- 39:32SPEAKER_01: Like I said,
- 39:32SPEAKER_01: we're trying to catalyze this market or industry,
- 39:34SPEAKER_01: or we're trying to contract with multiple players under one award.
- 39:38And in those cases,
- 39:39you want to make sure your contract is fit for a purpose.
- 39:42SPEAKER_01: But genuinely,
- 39:43SPEAKER_01: when we undertook this effort,
- 39:44what I was really getting at is this should be a tool in our
- 39:47toolbox that currently
- 39:49SPEAKER_01: does not exist.
- 39:50SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 39:50SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 39:51SPEAKER_00: And especially if you're correct me if I'm wrong,
- 39:52but if you're contracting with the kinds of entities you
- 39:54haven't contracted with before,
- 39:56SPEAKER_00: you don't know what they what those players want in contract,
- 39:59SPEAKER_00: what they what will work for them.
- 40:00And so you if you don't have the flexibility to think through
- 40:02that contract offer,
- 40:03SPEAKER_00: you won't be able to come to a deal.
- 40:06SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 40:06SPEAKER_01: And at the same time,
- 40:07SPEAKER_01: the flip side of this,
- 40:08SPEAKER_01: and I made it a point to emphasize this all the time,
- 40:11which is OTs can't be a hammer in search of a nail just because
- 40:15you have other
- 40:16SPEAKER_01: transactions and you can rip up.
- 40:18One of the things I should have mentioned is another way people
- 40:20describe an other
- 40:21transaction agreement is you can literally take a blank sheet
- 40:24of paper and write a contract.
- 40:26SPEAKER_01: And that's something that government is not typically used to doing.
- 40:28SPEAKER_01: You have preset contracts.
- 40:30Whereas you and I in the private world can contract basically
- 40:33any way we want.
- 40:34SPEAKER_01: True.
- 40:34SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 40:35SPEAKER_01: And so what we decided to do was,
- 40:38SPEAKER_01: well,
- 40:38SPEAKER_01: one,
- 40:39it became very clear that DOE had definitely had other
- 40:43transactions authority going
- 40:44SPEAKER_01: back to at least 2005.
- 40:45SPEAKER_01: That is in the statute.
- 40:46SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 40:48SPEAKER_00: Congress says, you can do this.
- 40:50SPEAKER_01: So in the Energy Policy Act of 2005,
- 40:53SPEAKER_01: and you can tell if you just read the statute,
- 40:56SPEAKER_01: that Congress was so frustrated with DOE and the way it contracted.
- 41:00Because what Congress did was it cross-referenced DOD's Other
- 41:05Transactions
- 41:06SPEAKER_01: Authority and said,
- 41:07SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 41:07SPEAKER_01: DOE,
- 41:08SPEAKER_01: you now have this Other Transactions Authority.
- 41:11SPEAKER_01: And by the way,
- 41:12you've got 90 days to promulgate regulations to implement this
- 41:15Other Transactions Authority.
- 41:17SPEAKER_01: That is Congress saying, get off.
- 41:19SPEAKER_00: Get your rearing gear.
- 41:20SPEAKER_00: Yeah, like truly.
- 41:22SPEAKER_00: And what was that in response to?
- 41:23Was Congress just seeing the existing contracts that DOE was
- 41:27writing and making and saying,
- 41:28SPEAKER_00: like,
- 41:28SPEAKER_00: these are not fit for purpose?
- 41:30SPEAKER_00: Yeah, essentially.
- 41:31SPEAKER_01: And so...
- 41:32SPEAKER_01: You can tell Congress is impatient.
- 41:34SPEAKER_01: And over the years,
- 41:35Congress had gotten increasingly impatient because he would
- 41:37have new grant programs
- 41:38SPEAKER_01: that were stood up where Congress would explicitly say,
- 41:41SPEAKER_01: this should be a milestone-based other transaction.
- 41:44So the fusion milestone program that the Office of Science at
- 41:47the Department of
- 41:48SPEAKER_01: Energy administers,
- 41:49SPEAKER_01: in the Energy Act of 2020,
- 41:51that program was authorized and it explicitly says DOE should
- 41:54do this as another transaction.
- 41:55SPEAKER_00: And just for the listeners who don't know,
- 41:57a milestone-based contract will pay you as you meet certain
- 42:01technological thresholds.
- 42:02SPEAKER_00: If you are able to build a technology that does this and this,
- 42:05SPEAKER_00: you get the big chunk of money,
- 42:06SPEAKER_00: and then we move on to the next phase.
- 42:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 42:08And the famous example of this is the SpaceX agreement that
- 42:11NASA entered in 2006.
- 42:12SPEAKER_01: It's kind of like the gold standard for milestone-based contracts.
- 42:16SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 42:16SPEAKER_01: And it's different from cost-based reimbursement, right?
- 42:20Because cost-based reimbursement,
- 42:22like I said,
- 42:22you're being paid for trying.
- 42:24SPEAKER_01: A milestone-based payment is if you don't hit this technical thread,
- 42:28SPEAKER_01: technical milestone,
- 42:29SPEAKER_01: you're not going to get paid.
- 42:30SPEAKER_00: If you do, here's the big chunk.
- 42:32SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 42:32SPEAKER_01: And so that's actually a great deal for the taxpayer, right?
- 42:35SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 42:36SPEAKER_00: Pay for success.
- 42:36SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 42:37SPEAKER_01: you're paying for success,
- 42:38SPEAKER_01: but it also helps push private industry to try their best and succeed.
- 42:43SPEAKER_01: Then there's also another contract structure in between,
- 42:46SPEAKER_01: which is a fixed cost agreement,
- 42:48SPEAKER_01: which is like,
- 42:49SPEAKER_01: regardless of how you get to point B,
- 42:52SPEAKER_01: As long as you get there, we'll pay you.
- 42:54So you're incentivized to do it as cheaply as possible so you
- 42:57can pocket the difference,
- 42:58right?
- 42:58That's basically paying a private enterprise to be as efficient
- 43:01as possible.
- 43:02So that's actually another flavor of other transactions that
- 43:05DOD was very used to.
- 43:06SPEAKER_00: So DOD does a fair amount of other transactions.
- 43:09SPEAKER_00: NASA does other transactions.
- 43:11SPEAKER_00: And since 2005, the Department of Energy had this authority.
- 43:15SPEAKER_00: So-
- 43:16What was going on in the 15 years between then and 2020 that it
- 43:18did not have a robust,
- 43:20SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 43:20SPEAKER_00: it hadn't built the muscle of doing other transactions?
- 43:23Yeah,
- 43:23there was a great GAO report from 2016 that did a comparative
- 43:27study of all the agencies.
- 43:29SPEAKER_01: And DOE between 2011 and 2014 did less than 20 OT agreements.
- 43:32SPEAKER_01: NASA had done probably about 10,000.
- 43:41DOD was somewhere in between,
- 43:42but it was...
- 43:43It just wasn't using the tool.
- 43:45SPEAKER_01: Yeah, DOE was not using it.
- 43:47SPEAKER_01: And when we started looking at this,
- 43:49there were only one or two people across the entire Department
- 43:52of Energy Enterprise
- 43:53SPEAKER_01: that were warranted to execute another transaction agreement.
- 43:56That is,
- 43:57DOE has the authority,
- 43:58but within DOE,
- 43:59you need a couple people who have the hat on.
- 44:01SPEAKER_01: Contracts or agreements officer that is actually writing the contract,
- 44:04SPEAKER_01: signing the contract on behalf of DOE,
- 44:06and you need to be warranted in order to execute an other
- 44:09transaction agreement.
- 44:10And there were just a small handful of people and very little
- 44:13institutional
- 44:14SPEAKER_01: knowledge on how to do that.
- 44:16And I got to say,
- 44:17credit to the deep institutional knowledge and the civil
- 44:21servants at DOE,
- 44:22There is a really incredible group of folks that have done
- 44:26almost every flavor of
- 44:27contract you can imagine within the existing structures that
- 44:31have also always
- 44:32SPEAKER_01: wanted to explore the use of OTs.
- 44:34SPEAKER_01: There was a couple of bumps in the road here.
- 44:36SPEAKER_01: So one, 2005, Congress passed the Energy Policy Act in 2005.
- 44:40SPEAKER_01: And DOE,
- 44:41SPEAKER_01: in response to that 90-day shot clock,
- 44:43SPEAKER_01: what DOE does is they pretty much copy-paste DOD's regulations and
- 44:48SPEAKER_01: The DOD regulation,
- 44:49SPEAKER_01: the DOE copy pasted,
- 44:51SPEAKER_01: and I say this just very loosely,
- 44:53SPEAKER_01: it's not exactly a copy paste,
- 44:54SPEAKER_01: but like largely modeled these regulations after.
- 44:57Those regulations enable the use of quote unquote technology
- 45:00investment agreements.
- 45:01SPEAKER_01: So this is what the fixed cost agreement essentially,
- 45:05SPEAKER_01: like technology investment agreements enable that.
- 45:08SPEAKER_01: And what DoD had set up,
- 45:10SPEAKER_01: TIAs as they're known to do,
- 45:11SPEAKER_01: was largely for prototyping and very DoD specific activities.
- 45:16It's not really a good fit when you're trying to commercialize
- 45:18energy technologies
- 45:20SPEAKER_01: and you're trying to seed new markets.
- 45:22SPEAKER_01: There's no, you know, function.
- 45:23You're really trying to take like a widget or a thing and then
- 45:26prototype it and then,
- 45:27SPEAKER_01: you know...
- 45:28SPEAKER_01: You can scale it up within limits,
- 45:29but you don't get the full bang for your authority if you just
- 45:34use the TIA flavor
- 45:36SPEAKER_01: of that authority Congress had cross-referenced.
- 45:38SPEAKER_01: So that was a limitation.
- 45:39SPEAKER_01: And then the prevailing wisdom within the Office of General Counsel was,
- 45:43SPEAKER_01: even so,
- 45:44SPEAKER_01: this authority is not super expansive.
- 45:47What it did do,
- 45:47however,
- 45:48it expanded DOE's ability to offer more IP flexibility.
- 45:52SPEAKER_01: That was actually distinct.
- 45:54And people recognized that,
- 45:55but once again,
- 45:56the regulations were limiting.
- 45:58SPEAKER_01: And so DOE hadn't touched this in nearly 20 years.
- 46:01SPEAKER_01: They hadn't touched this regulation.
- 46:03So you're at the general counsel's office at the Department of Energy,
- 46:06and you do what?
- 46:07SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 46:07SPEAKER_01: so August of 2022,
- 46:10SPEAKER_01: so August 16th,
- 46:11SPEAKER_01: and I remember the exact dates because this was somewhat intentional.
- 46:16August 16th,
- 46:17the Inflation Reduction Act gets signed into law by President Biden.
- 46:20SPEAKER_01: August 15th,
- 46:21our chief of staff at DOE kicks off an innovative funding
- 46:25mechanisms working group,
- 46:27SPEAKER_01: which I co-chaired.
- 46:29SPEAKER_01: along with a career civil servant,
- 46:31SPEAKER_01: our senior procurement executive at the time,
- 46:33SPEAKER_01: who is now retired.
- 46:35SPEAKER_01: But this is someone with decades of contracting,
- 46:38SPEAKER_01: government contracting experience,
- 46:39SPEAKER_01: had done stints at other agencies as well.
- 46:41SPEAKER_01: So I co-chaired this.
- 46:43SPEAKER_01: What's his name?
- 46:44SPEAKER_01: John Basista.
- 46:45SPEAKER_01: Phenomenal public servant, really.
- 46:47SPEAKER_01: I have so much respect for folks like John.
- 46:49And what we did was we pulled together incredible cross-cutting
- 46:53team across the DOE enterprise.
- 46:56So the way DOE is set up,
- 46:57you've got DOE headquarters,
- 46:58but then you've got these field offices
- 47:00SPEAKER_01: all across the country.
- 47:01SPEAKER_01: We've got a field office in Golden, Colorado.
- 47:03SPEAKER_01: We've got a field office in Idaho.
- 47:05SPEAKER_01: Each one is kind of attached to the national laboratory that's there.
- 47:08SPEAKER_01: You've got a field office in Pennsylvania and West Virginia,
- 47:11SPEAKER_01: but a lot of the contracting functions,
- 47:13SPEAKER_01: you've also got a field office in Chicago.
- 47:15A lot of the contracting functions actually happen typically
- 47:17through the field offices.
- 47:19So we pulled in the best of the best,
- 47:20both at headquarters and out in the field.
- 47:22We set up a structure where we had kind of an advisory and
- 47:25steering council of
- 47:27SPEAKER_01: heads of each program office as well.
- 47:30SPEAKER_01: And so at the outset,
- 47:31SPEAKER_01: we pretty much said,
- 47:32we know because of the bipartisan infrastructure law and the
- 47:35Inflation Reduction Act,
- 47:36SPEAKER_01: you all are going to be trying to do creative things contracting wise.
- 47:39So we're going to take a second look at our other transactions
- 47:42authority as DOE.
- 47:44SPEAKER_01: And that wasn't the only thing we looked at.
- 47:45SPEAKER_01: We also looked at the use of partnership intermediary agreements.
- 47:47But for the purpose of this conversation,
- 47:49we'll just focus on the OT side.
- 47:52SPEAKER_01: So you mentioned that other transactions guide.
- 47:54I mean,
- 47:55a lot of this work was done by the best of the best careers,
- 47:58civil servants.
- 47:59And so much credit really has to go to them because a couple of
- 48:04things have to fall
- 48:04SPEAKER_01: in place for an effort like this to happen.
- 48:06SPEAKER_01: One,
- 48:06SPEAKER_01: you need to bring your best institutional experience,
- 48:09SPEAKER_01: people that know how the contracting system works to the department.
- 48:12SPEAKER_01: But then two,
- 48:13one of the amazing things that happened at DOE over the last
- 48:16few years was as a
- 48:17result of setting up the undersecretary for infrastructure and
- 48:21bringing in a lot
- 48:22SPEAKER_01: more commercialization thinking into the department,
- 48:25you had this whole new cadre of folks that came in from the
- 48:28private sector.
- 48:29SPEAKER_01: that were very much trying to think in terms of commercial contracts,
- 48:32SPEAKER_01: that were trying to think outside the box.
- 48:35SPEAKER_01: So you had this kind of perfect tension where people wanted to rip up the
- 48:39SPEAKER_01: contracting structure as they knew it,
- 48:40SPEAKER_01: but knew exactly why they wanted to do it.
- 48:42But then you had people in the general counsel's office and in
- 48:44the contracting
- 48:45SPEAKER_01: apparatus that knew the limits.
- 48:47SPEAKER_01: And so what you got through this effort was essentially kind of like a,
- 48:52SPEAKER_01: I don't want to say a compromise solution,
- 48:54SPEAKER_01: but we got to the end goal of figuring out how to reinvigorate
- 48:58our other transactions authority in a way that could ultimately
- 49:01serve the larger purpose.
- 49:02SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 49:03SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 49:03SPEAKER_00: as I understand it,
- 49:04SPEAKER_00: and I'm painting with a broad brush here,
- 49:05SPEAKER_00: but a lot of the people who came in had Wall Street experience,
- 49:08had experience in the private sector doing the kinds of project
- 49:11finance stuff that
- 49:12SPEAKER_00: now all of a sudden DOE was being asked to do.
- 49:14SPEAKER_00: And so there was like this impression I understand of like, wait, if you,
- 49:19SPEAKER_00: we were doing this in the private sector,
- 49:21SPEAKER_00: we'd structure the contract this way,
- 49:22SPEAKER_00: we'd do all these things.
- 49:23SPEAKER_00: It doesn't look like we have that flexibility here.
- 49:25SPEAKER_00: And so there's a strong impetus to like,
- 49:27SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 49:27SPEAKER_00: well,
- 49:28SPEAKER_00: best practice out there in the world is to contract this.
- 49:31But I literally cannot do this because the cooperative
- 49:34agreement structure doesn't
- 49:35SPEAKER_01: let me do it,
- 49:36SPEAKER_00: right?
- 49:36SPEAKER_00: Even though if I was a Goldman...
- 49:38SPEAKER_00: doing this project finance agreement.
- 49:39SPEAKER_00: We do this in a flash.
- 49:40If I was a project developer,
- 49:41yeah,
- 49:42I would structure this totally differently.
- 49:43SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 49:44Among the things we did is we didn't just settle for looking
- 49:47back at the 2005 Other
- 49:48SPEAKER_01: Transactions Authority.
- 49:50SPEAKER_01: And I actually,
- 49:51SPEAKER_01: I want to give a shout out to one of your previous guests on the show,
- 49:55SPEAKER_01: Rick Dunn.
- 49:55SPEAKER_01: I heard you guys talked.
- 49:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 49:57Rick Dunn and I had talked a couple of times and Rick Dunn has
- 50:00been highly critical
- 50:02SPEAKER_01: of all agencies,
- 50:03but he's had special ire for DOE saying that DOE had never
- 50:08exercised its quote
- 50:09SPEAKER_01: unquote organic other transactions authority.
- 50:12SPEAKER_00: And for context for listeners,
- 50:13Rick Dunn is kind of the godfather of other transactions
- 50:17authority in some ways,
- 50:17SPEAKER_00: just to throw that out there.
- 50:19SPEAKER_01: He was the general counsel for DARPA.
- 50:21SPEAKER_01: He was part of many of the NASA other transactions that were executed.
- 50:26SPEAKER_01: Now he actively is out there providing thought leadership,
- 50:30SPEAKER_01: sharing his institutional knowledge from back in the day.
- 50:33SPEAKER_01: So I had many conversations with Rick Dunn.
- 50:35SPEAKER_01: And one of the things that within DOE,
- 50:38was generally believed was that DOE does not have the same
- 50:42other transactions
- 50:43SPEAKER_01: authority as NASA because there's a one-word difference in our statutes.
- 50:47SPEAKER_01: So the NASA statute read something along the lines of the secretary,
- 50:53SPEAKER_01: the administrator has the authority to enter and to grant leases,
- 50:58SPEAKER_01: cooperative agreements,
- 50:59SPEAKER_01: and other transactions.
- 51:00SPEAKER_01: And the DOE Organization Act in 1977 had language along the lines of,
- 51:05SPEAKER_01: the secretary has the authority to enter into grants,
- 51:08SPEAKER_01: contracts,
- 51:09SPEAKER_01: leases,
- 51:10SPEAKER_01: cooperative agreements,
- 51:11SPEAKER_01: and other similar transactions.
- 51:13SPEAKER_01: So this word similar was different.
- 51:16SPEAKER_01: It's not other transactions, it's other similar transactions.
- 51:19SPEAKER_01: So for years and years,
- 51:21SPEAKER_01: everyone would say,
- 51:23so there is a clear distinction and therefore DOE does not have
- 51:26NASA's authority.
- 51:27SPEAKER_00: Because otherwise, why would it be different?
- 51:29SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 51:29SPEAKER_01: So we agonized over this.
- 51:32SPEAKER_01: And so part of this working group,
- 51:33SPEAKER_01: and I can't emphasize it more,
- 51:35SPEAKER_01: the people were so energized to look at the legislative history.
- 51:41SPEAKER_01: They went deep into the legislative history.
- 51:43SPEAKER_01: And so in the committee hearings.
- 51:45SPEAKER_00: I'm going to pull it up while you're saying it.
- 51:47I'll pull it up myself because there's this incredible quote
- 51:50from John Dingell in
- 51:52SPEAKER_01: one of the committee hearings in April of 1977.
- 51:54SPEAKER_01: So the DOE Organization Act gets passed in October.
- 51:58SPEAKER_01: And John Dingell is who, remind us?
- 52:00SPEAKER_01: He was the chairman of the Energy and Commerce Committee,
- 52:02SPEAKER_01: one of the strongest chairman of the ENC Committee.
- 52:07In many ways,
- 52:07you could call him kind of the father of the Department of Energy.
- 52:10He had envisioned this department to kind of be the solution to
- 52:16the energy crisis.
- 52:17SPEAKER_01: And so in the committee hearing,
- 52:20SPEAKER_01: there's this great quote where John Dingell says,
- 52:23SPEAKER_01: observe,
- 52:24SPEAKER_01: Mr.
- 52:24SPEAKER_01: Chairman,
- 52:25SPEAKER_01: the great breadth of authority that the secretary gets.
- 52:28SPEAKER_01: He may enter into and perform contracts, leases and grants.
- 52:31You have cooperative agreements and other transactions with
- 52:34public agencies and
- 52:35SPEAKER_01: private organizations and persons.
- 52:37He can do literally almost anything he wants to in terms of
- 52:41expending money and
- 52:42SPEAKER_01: making agreements.
- 52:44SPEAKER_01: That is very, very broad authority.
- 52:46So you go back to the legislative debate and you're like,
- 52:50yeah,
- 52:50you got that.
- 52:50And then you've even got a concurrence from the minority in the
- 52:53committee hearing.
- 52:54SPEAKER_01: So everybody agrees.
- 52:55SPEAKER_01: Everybody agrees.
- 52:57SPEAKER_01: And so they very closely modeled this after the Space Act.
- 53:00SPEAKER_01: So and that's also clear in the committee hearings.
- 53:03SPEAKER_01: Mm hmm.
- 53:04SPEAKER_01: And so this leads us to put together a memo,
- 53:07SPEAKER_01: which the general counsel Sam Walsh signs the next summer of 2023,
- 53:12SPEAKER_01: saying,
- 53:13SPEAKER_01: actually,
- 53:14SPEAKER_01: DOE does have this broad other transactions authority from its inception.
- 53:18SPEAKER_01: And
- 53:19SPEAKER_01: It's not just this one quote from the committee hearing,
- 53:23SPEAKER_01: but when you look at the whole historical context of why DOE was set up,
- 53:27SPEAKER_01: DOE was set up to be a wartime agency,
- 53:29SPEAKER_01: essentially.
- 53:29We were considered to be in a wartime footing in the midst of
- 53:33the energy crises.
- 53:34And you look at all these different quotes in the Organization
- 53:38Act that say...
- 53:39SPEAKER_01: There's a grave energy crisis and DOE is meant to help solve this.
- 53:44SPEAKER_01: And when you're setting up a new agency,
- 53:47SPEAKER_01: you don't know what that agency is going to have to undertake one day,
- 53:50SPEAKER_01: which is why you entrust that agency with broad authority like this.
- 53:54SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 53:55So what did you end up doing with that revised other
- 53:57transactions authority guidance?
- 53:59SPEAKER_01: So pretty quickly,
- 54:00SPEAKER_01: you would start seeing,
- 54:02SPEAKER_01: so the first thing you saw is this demand-side support for hydrogen.
- 54:07The Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations put out a
- 54:08solicitation for an independent
- 54:11entity to help potentially provide contract for differences and
- 54:14help seed a new
- 54:16SPEAKER_01: hydrogen market.
- 54:17SPEAKER_01: In their solicitation itself,
- 54:19SPEAKER_01: they explicitly said,
- 54:20SPEAKER_01: we will enter into agreements pursuant to 42 U.S.C.
- 54:25SPEAKER_01: 7256A.
- 54:26SPEAKER_01: That is the line of the original DOE Organization Act.
- 54:28SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 54:29The other transactions authority that I mentioned that's
- 54:32cross-referenced to DODs,
- 54:33SPEAKER_01: that's 7256G.
- 54:36SPEAKER_01: Now you've got both of these authorities together.
- 54:39SPEAKER_01: And actually,
- 54:40they work very well together because the subsection G authority
- 54:44provides broader IP flexibility.
- 54:47The subsection A authority provides broad flexibility for
- 54:50everything else that's
- 54:51SPEAKER_01: not IP,
- 54:51SPEAKER_01: essentially.
- 54:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 54:52SPEAKER_00: You love this stuff.
- 54:53SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I really do.
- 54:56SPEAKER_01: And so in January of this year,
- 54:59SPEAKER_01: of 2025,
- 55:00SPEAKER_01: DOE finally also updated the original OT regulations from 2006.
- 55:06SPEAKER_01: So that was almost 20 years in the making.
- 55:08SPEAKER_01: So that was the technology investment agreement.
- 55:11SPEAKER_01: TIA's authority that came under the regulations from 2006,
- 55:14SPEAKER_01: DOE updated that to pretty much say,
- 55:16SPEAKER_01: actually,
- 55:16SPEAKER_01: we're not limited by what DOD was doing anymore.
- 55:20SPEAKER_01: And our IP flexibility is broader.
- 55:22Also,
- 55:22we have this broader 7256A original OG,
- 55:28Other Transactions Authority.
- 55:29SPEAKER_01: And similarly,
- 55:31SPEAKER_01: in a recent solicitation for Gen 3 Plus nuclear reactors,
- 55:35SPEAKER_01: the Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations put out a solicitation saying,
- 55:38we're going to enter into two contracts at least that are other
- 55:41transactions contracts.
- 55:43And the reason for this is because we're not just contracting
- 55:46with the developer,
- 55:47we're going to contract also with the developer and a potential
- 55:51offtaker or fuel
- 55:52SPEAKER_01: supplier as well.
- 55:53So recognizing that there may be multiple stages of this grant
- 55:57agreement where
- 55:58SPEAKER_01: there may be different entities that join this team,
- 56:02SPEAKER_01: teaming arrangement.
- 56:03And so there's a need for other transactions authority because
- 56:06we're going to have to
- 56:07SPEAKER_01: develop a pretty bespoke contract to do this thing.
- 56:10And just to flush that out for me in that case is because
- 56:12looking for new nuclear
- 56:13SPEAKER_00: reactor models and you want to be able to catalyze that industry.
- 56:16And one of the problems in the nuclear industry is filling out
- 56:20the order book for that reactor.
- 56:22SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 56:23SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 56:24SPEAKER_01: And and make sure making sure they have offtake agreements.
- 56:27And so you have kind of this chicken and egg problem that no
- 56:30one wants to buy the
- 56:31SPEAKER_01: electricity without knowing what the price is going to be.
- 56:33No one wants to build the thing without knowing what people are
- 56:36going to buy,
- 56:37SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 56:38SPEAKER_01: the electricity for.
- 56:38SPEAKER_01: And
- 56:41SPEAKER_01: DOE as an agency can help kind of catalyze that and smooth that.
- 56:47SPEAKER_00: I know we're close to time,
- 56:48SPEAKER_00: but just on your work on OTAs,
- 56:51SPEAKER_00: if you could go back into the Department of Energy,
- 56:54SPEAKER_00: knowing what you know now and you run through that playbook again,
- 56:57SPEAKER_00: what would you have done differently?
- 56:58SPEAKER_00: Would you have tried to start the OTA working group earlier?
- 57:02SPEAKER_00: Would you have written the guidance differently differently?
- 57:05SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I wish we had kicked off.
- 57:06SPEAKER_01: So we called this the Innovative Funding Mechanisms Working Group.
- 57:09SPEAKER_01: I wish we had kicked that off even sooner.
- 57:13But that being said,
- 57:14I mean,
- 57:14institutional change generally also takes time.
- 57:17SPEAKER_01: Among the things that came out of this effort was,
- 57:19so we put this OT guide out publicly because the idea was this
- 57:24is not just to
- 57:25SPEAKER_01: change the zeitgeist within organizations.
- 57:27SPEAKER_01: DOE,
- 57:27but it's also to make sure that everyone outside knows we're
- 57:31open for business now
- 57:32SPEAKER_01: to do other transactions.
- 57:32SPEAKER_00: If you do funky,
- 57:33SPEAKER_00: interesting stuff that you couldn't contract with us before...
- 57:36SPEAKER_01: Talk to us,
- 57:37SPEAKER_01: right?
- 57:38SPEAKER_01: We set up a whole training program within the department.
- 57:40SPEAKER_01: So this comes back to statecraft, state capacity.
- 57:43SPEAKER_01: You have to kind of build that muscle within the department.
- 57:47SPEAKER_01: I do wish we had started...
- 57:49SPEAKER_01: perhaps even a year earlier.
- 57:51SPEAKER_01: But I honestly didn't even know really what OTs could unlock in 2021.
- 57:57There'd been a lot,
- 57:59like I said,
- 58:00a lot of talk about OTs,
- 58:01but it felt very loose.
- 58:03You didn't really know what the use case could be until people
- 58:05were seriously
- 58:06discussing what the bipartisan infrastructure law programs
- 58:09could do or what
- 58:10SPEAKER_01: eventually the Inflation Reduction Act programs could do.
- 58:12SPEAKER_01: Also,
- 58:12we were deep in the throes of negotiations and providing
- 58:15technical assistance to
- 58:17the drafting of the bipartisan infrastructure law and the
- 58:19Inflation Reduction Act.
- 58:20SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 58:20Let's say Dems are back in the presidency in 2029 and they've
- 58:24got these tools
- 58:25SPEAKER_00: available to them at the Department of Energy.
- 58:28SPEAKER_00: What do you want to see?
- 58:29SPEAKER_00: What kinds of contracts do you want to see made then?
- 58:32SPEAKER_01: I would actually say even earlier,
- 58:35SPEAKER_01: it doesn't matter Democrat or Republican,
- 58:36SPEAKER_01: even this administration,
- 58:38SPEAKER_01: Energy Secretary Chris Wright is a supporter of nuclear energy,
- 58:42SPEAKER_01: supporter of geothermal energy.
- 58:43SPEAKER_01: There's so many different,
- 58:45and these are programs that DOE still has significant grant
- 58:47dollars to help
- 58:49SPEAKER_01: catalyze these industries.
- 58:50SPEAKER_01: The Department of Energy today can very much take advantage,
- 58:53SPEAKER_01: continue to take advantage of OT authority.
- 58:56But yeah,
- 58:56looking out to 2029,
- 58:58I think there can be a lot more innovative program design.
- 59:02SPEAKER_01: For the foreseeable future in the clean energy space,
- 59:05SPEAKER_01: you're going to have a lot of market formation challenges,
- 59:08especially in the face of cheap clean energy products coming in
- 59:12from other countries.
- 59:13And there is a need for quote unquote industrial policy to help
- 59:17stand up and
- 59:17SPEAKER_01: catalyze industries.
- 59:19Other transactions authority lets you be more nimble as a
- 59:22government agency.
- 59:23SPEAKER_01: And I do want to actually emphasize one point, which is
- 59:26SPEAKER_01: Just because you have OT authority doesn't mean the cat's out of the bag,
- 59:29SPEAKER_01: there's no guardrails at all.
- 59:31The reason we wrote the guide and the reason we wrote all this
- 59:34internal guidance as
- 59:35SPEAKER_01: well is to ensure that there's still guardrails.
- 59:38SPEAKER_01: In fact,
- 59:39we even briefed the inspector general's office right after this
- 59:44effort ended to
- 59:45SPEAKER_01: make sure that they were fully aware of what we were opening up.
- 59:47And we set up all these processes to make sure that there were
- 59:51checks and balances,
- 59:52SPEAKER_01: even for executing an OT agreement.
- 59:54SPEAKER_01: That being said, there's a fine balance.
- 59:56You don't want OTs to become the new cooperative agreement that
- 59:58eventually there's
- 59:59SPEAKER_01: only three ways of doing an OT.
- 1:00:00SPEAKER_01: That defeats the purpose, as Rick Dunn would say.
- 1:00:02SPEAKER_00: All right.
- 1:00:03SPEAKER_00: Well, Narayan, thank you so much for joining.
- 1:00:05SPEAKER_01: Thank you for having me.