Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Needs to Strengths: Identifying Gaps and Resources for Youth with Learning Differences.
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:04and you're listening to Needs to Strengths, a special four-part podcast series
- 0:08from ELA in collaboration with Education Reimagined.
- 0:11In each episode, we'll explore how learner-centered sites across the country
- 0:15are supporting youth with learning differences, and what we can all learn from
- 0:19their challenges, breakthroughs, and bold ideas.
- 0:22I'm excited to be joined today by Lindsay Ogawa, the Senior Director at Education
- 0:27Reimagined, a national nonprofit whose mission is to make learner-centered education
- 0:31available to every child in the country.
- 0:34Alongside Kim Carter, Executive Director of the QED Foundation and a champion
- 0:38for personalized learner-centered educations.
- 0:41It's great to have both of you here today. Thanks for joining me. Let's dive right in.
- 0:44And can you tell us a little bit about Immersive Inquiries and how that came about?
- 0:49Yeah, so Immersive Inquiries is a practice to research initiative launched by
- 0:54Education Imagined in partnership with the Oak Foundation. to better understand
- 0:58how learner-centered environments across the country work with young people.
- 1:02For this study, we really focused on how they work with youth with learning
- 1:06differences, and the goal is to generate insights that are grounded in practice,
- 1:10shaped by those closest to the work, and are ultimately useful to the entire field.
- 1:15This work came about because we noticed a need in the field for evidence about
- 1:20what's working and what's needed to be able to support young people so that they can thrive,
- 1:24not just academically but also
- 1:26in life and particularly those who've been historically most underserved.
- 1:31For the past decade we've been fostering a national network of education professionals
- 1:36like Kim here who've been leading that kind of work and we just saw an opportunity
- 1:41to connect these powerful insights of some of these educators and their learner-centered
- 1:45environments and then channel them into research.
- 1:48And so the immersive inquiry was a six-month national community of practice
- 1:53with educators as co-researchers and visited three sites.
- 1:57The first was Norris School District in rural Wisconsin.
- 2:01The second was Avalon School, a public charter school in St. Paul, Minnesota.
- 2:06And then finally, we visited Lafayette Big Picture, which is a public school
- 2:11within a school in the Big Picture Learning Network just outside of Syracuse, New York.
- 2:16All of these serve students' populations where at least 50% have IEPs or 504
- 2:23plans, and we really got to engage and learn from young people,
- 2:27parents, staff, and community partners.
- 2:30And so it was just a really good and grounded way, collaborative way,
- 2:34to learn about what's happening and connect practice to research.
- 2:37Kim or Lindsay, can you share a story or an example about how some of your findings looked in practice?
- 2:45Yeah, this is Kim, and I'm happy to take that question. I have to say I've had
- 2:49a couple decades of experience visiting schools around the country,
- 2:53working with different communities.
- 2:55All supporting learners, particularly learners with differences and challenges,
- 3:01but really the range of types of learning that's out there.
- 3:06And what was most exciting to me about the immersive inquiry was the opportunity
- 3:11to see three sites, visit three different sites with a team of practitioners
- 3:17all committed to finding what works and what can we learn.
- 3:21And out of the several stories, many stories that I'm carrying with me from those visits,
- 3:28there are four I wanted to mention, which I think really surface and elevate
- 3:32some of the findings that we learned through this inquiry.
- 3:36The first that comes to mind for me is when I first walked into Avalon in Minnesota,
- 3:42I noticed a wall with a mural that mapped out a process, and the process looked pretty familiar.
- 3:50It's basically a project learning process. It started with, number one, think of an idea.
- 3:56And then it proceeded through to done in big, bold letters, which was kind of fun.
- 4:03But what I then noticed was sitting on the floor in a corner at the base of
- 4:09this wall, under this mural, was a young person who was dressed in black, shredded jeans.
- 4:15Hunched over on their phone, shoulders rolled in, head down.
- 4:21Basically trying to seeming to attract as little notice as possible.
- 4:27We later learned from a host that this learner is very anxious in classrooms,
- 4:32preferred to be in the hallway, was still trying to find where she fit in into
- 4:38the community, and the adults were trying to build trust with this Lerner.
- 4:44She had decided she wanted to make this mural, and one of the school leaders
- 4:49was like, that day before you were coming.
- 4:53But it's always the way. Always the way, yep. And the mural was a deliverable for one of her projects.
- 5:01What really caught my attention was when I went by later in the day,
- 5:05the Lerner was now sitting at a table in front of the mural and had a cabinet
- 5:11sort of as a sidewall for her, and she was sitting there with her laptop,
- 5:16her papers, and her work spread out around her,
- 5:19definitely engaged in learning work, and she readily engaged with the visiting
- 5:25team, answering questions about her mural, her project,
- 5:29her experience at Avalon, her own learning needs.
- 5:32What a change from that head down, hunched over on the phone.
- 5:36So there's one vignette. Let's hold that for a minute.
- 5:40Another learner at Avalon in his first year there, he's a 17-year-old,
- 5:45also very withdrawn, despite having volunteered to talk with a couple of us.
- 5:51He sat hunched over, his hair falling over his face.
- 5:55He was, you know, kind of mumbled into his chest when he would give us short couple of word answers.
- 6:03He did speak up to talk about his previous learning environment.
- 6:07He said, I was getting better, but the staff wouldn't see it.
- 6:10And when he was asked what the difference was at Avalon, he suddenly sat up
- 6:15straight, pulled his hair back from his face, and said with a bit of a smile,
- 6:20people here are a lot kinder.
- 6:23The workspace is more calm. It's easier to get work done. I had less stress.
- 6:30Wow. And that was really lovely. At Lafayette, at the Big Picture School,
- 6:36I just really recall a parent speaking with this strong conviction,
- 6:44saying they tailored learning to each child's individual needs,
- 6:49and they uncover each child's individual passions to engage them in learning
- 6:54and to grow and develop on that.
- 6:56So he went on to say, my son has dyspraxia.
- 7:02He's a normal child, but has this disorder.
- 7:05I don't know if my son would ever be able to work on his own.
- 7:09I'm proud to say this year my son is on his own in his internship without a teaching assistant.
- 7:18There's so much in that statement because he's a normal child.
- 7:23He just has this disorder.
- 7:26And that he is able to work on
- 7:29his own speaks volumes to what that kind of personalized support can give.
- 7:35And the last vignette was really at the first school that we visited,
- 7:40but it seemed to me to encompass the kind of mindset that the adults at all of these schools bring.
- 7:48And they are the primary resources, both for identification and for support for our learners.
- 7:56And at Norris, all of the staff, regardless of their position,
- 8:02are trained to work with learning differences.
- 8:05In fact, they all get certification as special education aides if they're not educators.
- 8:11And then they work together in community to expand their understanding of these
- 8:17learners and how to support them and how to make sure that they're offering
- 8:21interest-based learning opportunities for every learner.
- 8:25The staff, whomever you talk to there, will tell you that they recognize that
- 8:31learning differences and trauma often go hand in hand for their learners.
- 8:36With few, if any, of their learners there by choice,
- 8:40they recognize that kids come in carrying great weight of shame and guilt,
- 8:46and they work hard to convey to each learner, and this is a quote, and I just love it,
- 8:52you are exactly who you're meant to be.
- 8:56And they help them explore the question, What's your next best place?
- 9:03And they work together with this belief that there's no situation you can't learn something from.
- 9:09And that calmness pervades the sensibility of the school, their interactions
- 9:16with their learners, their interactions with parents.
- 9:20It's a beautiful thing to see. What I might add on to Nora is just to underscore,
- 9:27Kim had mentioned that everyone was trained to work with learners with learning differences.
- 9:32But I think just to paint even more of a picture on that, we engage with paraprofessionals
- 9:38who are then teaching courses on music writing, teaching rap,
- 9:44art, doing internships.
- 9:46The custodial staff was doing the same, the chief business officer.
- 9:51And so every single educator, everyone was an educator there and expanding the
- 9:57opportunities for learners with learning differences and those who didn't as well.
- 10:02And other learners as well. Kids had the opportunity to mentor or offer lessons.
- 10:10They didn't call them lessons. They called them like curiosity workshops or something like that.
- 10:15But there was one young woman who was really having a hard time having a place
- 10:19to be, but she really liked doing cosmetology.
- 10:23And an older student who was there, whose mom was an esthetician,
- 10:28was working with her and letting her practice her makeup work on her.
- 10:35So they're just using every resource available to meet the learning needs and
- 10:43inspire that sense of relationship across the community, I think.
- 10:49When we were at these sites, one of the principals said, I would like you to...
- 10:57Try to see who is a special education teacher here?
- 11:00Who is a paraprofessional here? Who is the learners with learning differences?
- 11:04And I bet you can't tell. And she was totally right.
- 11:07And we could see, hear, feel that across all of the sites that we visited.
- 11:12That's what we always want to see. We want to tear down that wall.
- 11:14You reminded me of a quote from Lafayette.
- 11:18And I love the fact that you ask questions of people there and they tell you a story.
- 11:23And it reminded me of this one teacher who told us a story about a student who was school phobic.
- 11:30He said, it took me three days to get that student into the building.
- 11:34He had been in education, special education for years, and that was the biggest challenge.
- 11:40Once the student got comfortable and realized all they had to do was give me
- 11:44a look and they could leave the classroom, that student took off.
- 11:48And he didn't mean out of the classroom. He said, And every barrier,
- 11:52every door was kicked in.
- 11:55The student just crushed it with their success.
- 11:59And it comes from listening, building the relationship, building the trust,
- 12:04and listening to what our learners have to tell us about themselves.
- 12:10It's incredibly powerful, that one seemingly simple action.
- 12:15What are some findings you noticed across the sites regarding how learners'
- 12:19needs are identified? and what resources are available to support our youth
- 12:24with learning differences.
- 12:25I mean, we gave some great examples, some great stories.
- 12:27You know, are there other themes that you kind of want to highlight?
- 12:31I'll jump in again. I feel like the themes from the preliminary research findings
- 12:37from the community of practice are evidenced in each of the vignettes that we've
- 12:41shared. And you can mine them for that.
- 12:44And there are a whole bunch of additional ones. But I would say there are basically
- 12:49six key themes that we have surfaced.
- 12:54And the first is the importance of moving from deficit-based to strength recognition.
- 13:01That shifts the relationship immediately with the learner.
- 13:06The second is the learner's self-identification of their needs.
- 13:11We have to listen to them.
- 13:13They have to have agency and ownership. and they know themselves better than we do.
- 13:18When we talk about giving kids agency, that's really not what it's about.
- 13:24They have agency and the only way they learn to use it in many cases is to say
- 13:29no or to put their heads down or to be mute or to rage, whatever it is.
- 13:36So what learner self-identification needs does is open the door for partnership and collaboration.
- 13:45The third is that relationship-centered identification.
- 13:49When we let learners be in relationship with us, when we're in partnership with them,
- 13:56we come to know who they are more deeply, and we know more about what they're
- 14:00capable of, which helps us support where their challenges are.
- 14:05And they're better able to help us understand those places they need support
- 14:11and help. So identification should be centered in relationship, first and foremost.
- 14:19And then that leads to the fourth theme, which is collaborative teams for comprehensive
- 14:24recognition and support. The more viewpoints, the more perspectives, the better.
- 14:30Parents are critical partners in this.
- 14:34And just that collaboration perspective.
- 14:37At every one of the sites that we visited, people would tell you,
- 14:43they're all my learners.
- 14:44Every learner belongs to everybody, and they would share the different ways
- 14:51they see and engage with the child, so they came to develop a more full and
- 14:55richer picture of every learner.
- 14:57A fifth piece is designing environments for regulation.
- 15:04These three schools were very thoughtful about what kinds of environments were
- 15:10going to support learners to feel safe, to be able to be less stressed,
- 15:16to be able to focus on what they needed so that they could be engaged in their
- 15:22learning and fully move towards success.
- 15:26And then the sixth piece, which is really throughout all of them,
- 15:31I think, but it's family partnership and understanding learner needs.
- 15:35Parents know their kiddos.
- 15:38They know them from a different perspective.
- 15:41And whether they have the formal language or not,
- 15:45they have really rich and important insights that should be triangulated with
- 15:53the learner's insights as well as the collaborative team's insights.
- 15:58So I think those six things, the deficit-to-asset-based, learner's self-identification
- 16:05of needs, relationship-centered identification,
- 16:08collaborative teams for comprehensive recognition, designing environments for
- 16:13regulation, and family partnerships and understanding learners' needs are the
- 16:18main themes that have surfaced from our immersive inquiry.
- 16:22What's a key insight or maybe a big takeaway you have about identifying and
- 16:27supporting young people with learning differences?
- 16:31So one thing we heard repeatedly at all three sites are two deeply held shared beliefs.
- 16:38They may have been worded slightly differently, but I think they're captured across the three sites.
- 16:45And that first, to use the quote from Norris, is you are exactly who you're meant to be.
- 16:52Like I get goosebumps even just saying it. Because there is so little recognition
- 16:57of that across the board in education.
- 17:00We're always pushing you to the next thing you can be, right?
- 17:04Or the goal way up there was that you are exactly who you're meant to be.
- 17:09And relationships lead the way in that. That's so powerful.
- 17:13And the second is every adult in the learning community will do everything possible.
- 17:21To ensure that each learner has the resources and opportunities to thrive.
- 17:26That includes finding others who can help meet needs, whether they're educators,
- 17:31parents, professionals, other learners, community partners, even animals.
- 17:37At one site, their community partner trains dogs to work with veterans.
- 17:44And the kids learning to work with the dogs were able to overcome their own trauma in that process.
- 17:52So that's a powerful thing. As we heard several times at Lafayette from kids,
- 17:58we don't have to fit the school.
- 18:01The school fits us.
- 18:03And I think those two things, if you can keep that true north,
- 18:08that every person is exactly who they're meant to be, and we,
- 18:13I, will do everything I can to support you, then all the rest kind of unfolds from there.
- 18:21Oh man, I love that. We don't have to fit the school. The school fits us.
- 18:25That's really powerful.
- 18:26Grateful for everyone out there who also shares this mission and this commitment.
- 18:31Reach out. We want to learn more from you as well.
- 18:34Awesome. Well, that's it for us today, folks. Thank you to Kim Carter and Lindsay Ogawa.
- 18:40Look out for a series of research briefs coming from this work to be shared in the fall.
- 18:45To learn more, visit educationreimagined.org and qedfoundation.org.
- 18:50I'm Aurora from ELA, and this was Needs to Strengths, an ELA podcast series.