Latest / Bloomberg Law / Finders Keepers in Citibank's $500 Million Mistake
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brussel from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:17Speaker 1: That's the way you're doing. That's what you're doing. It
- 0:30Speaker 1: wasn't exactly money for nothing, but it certainly was an
- 0:33Speaker 1: unexpected windfall. City Bank accidentally paid nine hundred million dollars
- 0:38Speaker 1: of its own money to a group of lenders, expecting
- 0:41Speaker 1: an interest payment on behalf of Revlon paying off the
- 0:45Speaker 1: loan in full. Some of the lenders returned four hundred
- 0:48Speaker 1: million dollars, and City Bank took the other investment firms
- 0:51Speaker 1: to court, and after a trial, a federal judge ruled
- 0:55Speaker 1: that City Bank is out the five hundred million dollars
- 0:58Speaker 1: because of a thirty year old legal precedent that essentially
- 1:01Speaker 1: says finders keepers joining me is Chris Dolmesh, Bloomberg Legal reporter.
- 1:07Speaker 1: Did this verdict come as a surprise, It did, so,
- 1:10Speaker 1: it was not necessarily complete shock. Some of our own
- 1:14Speaker 1: analysts had seen the way the judge was going and
- 1:17Speaker 1: sort of thought that he was leaning towards saying that
- 1:19Speaker 1: the hedge funds didn't have to give back the money.
- 1:22Speaker 1: But it certainly was not locked in stone, and a
- 1:26Speaker 1: lot of people thought that City Bank was going to
- 1:28Speaker 1: escape by and be able to get some money back
- 1:30Speaker 1: despite some of the problems that they documented during the trial.
- 1:33Speaker 1: But the judge felt otherwise. He felt that the creditors
- 1:36Speaker 1: had established that they didn't know this was a mistake
- 1:39Speaker 1: and that they thought they were actually getting their loans
- 1:42Speaker 1: paid off. Go back and explain how this happened, whose
- 1:46Speaker 1: fault it was. It happened because of the failure of
- 1:50Speaker 1: a system they used as City Bank to send out
- 1:53Speaker 1: loan interest payments on a regular basis, usually scheduled interest
- 1:57Speaker 1: payments on that quarterly interest pay and things like that.
- 2:01Speaker 1: The system is called a six eye system, meaning there's
- 2:03Speaker 1: three people that checked the way that the wires sent out.
- 2:07Speaker 1: But that system failed. There was a mistake made on
- 2:10Speaker 1: a digital form that was being filled out, and they
- 2:12Speaker 1: didn't realize it at the time, and by the time
- 2:16Speaker 1: they realized it the next morning, nine million dollars had
- 2:19Speaker 1: gone out. So it was essentially a failure of a
- 2:21Speaker 1: kind of an antiquated system at the bank that they
- 2:24Speaker 1: were already in the process of replacing. At the time
- 2:27Speaker 1: that had happened, the lenders were locked in a battle
- 2:30Speaker 1: with Revlon over its restructuring. They get this unexpected windfall
- 2:36Speaker 1: out of the blue, and the judge found that they
- 2:39Speaker 1: were correct to conclude that it was money being paid
- 2:43Speaker 1: for what they were owed. Well, it's not necessarily they
- 2:47Speaker 1: corrected that. He established that they had no other knowledge
- 2:51Speaker 1: that would have convinced them otherwise until they got a
- 2:53Speaker 1: notice from City Bank later in the day that the
- 2:56Speaker 1: transfers had been a mistake and asking for the money back.
- 3:00Speaker 1: Their testimony was pretty consistent that they didn't know what
- 3:03Speaker 1: this was, but their best guests was that they were
- 3:06Speaker 1: actually paying off the loans in full. They were engaged
- 3:08Speaker 1: in this big restructuring battle with Revlon. Some of the
- 3:11Speaker 1: people testified that they weren't sure if this was some
- 3:14Speaker 1: sort of move by Revlon to extinguish the debt, to
- 3:17Speaker 1: increase leverage, you know, on other lenders and that sort
- 3:20Speaker 1: of thing. So there was a lot of uncertainty about
- 3:23Speaker 1: what this was, and really what the judge found at
- 3:26Speaker 1: the end was that it kind of would have boggled
- 3:28Speaker 1: the mind to think that this would have been a
- 3:32Speaker 1: mistake of the magnitude that it was by one of
- 3:34Speaker 1: the world's largest financial institutions. Tell me about this, The
- 3:37Speaker 1: judge said. The outcome was surprisingly straightforward, even if it
- 3:42Speaker 1: may not seem the fairest result. I mean, he's saying
- 3:46Speaker 1: in terms of the law and the precedence that he followed,
- 3:49Speaker 1: which is a thirty year old New York State case
- 3:52Speaker 1: in which the money went out the door and it
- 3:55Speaker 1: was spent before even the credits to even get a
- 3:58Speaker 1: notice after them, and that was not the case year.
- 4:00Speaker 1: But in the end he just found that there was
- 4:03Speaker 1: enough uncertainty about it. They certainly could have thought that
- 4:06Speaker 1: this was a legit payoff of the loan, given the
- 4:09Speaker 1: contentious history between the parties. Now that's gonna be a
- 4:12Speaker 1: big issue on appeal I. And there's an interesting footnote
- 4:16Speaker 1: in the decision where the judge says there's not really
- 4:20Speaker 1: a lot of precedent in case law to establish whether
- 4:23Speaker 1: or not the defendants had to show, by her ponderance
- 4:27Speaker 1: of the evidence that they were not unnoticed. In other words,
- 4:30Speaker 1: they would have had to have proven that they didn't
- 4:34Speaker 1: know this was a mistake. But he also said because
- 4:36Speaker 1: he can't prove a negative, that he didn't have to
- 4:38Speaker 1: reach that question. But that might be an area where
- 4:42Speaker 1: the appeals court kind of seeks to see if if
- 4:45Speaker 1: it was the burden of the defendants to prove that
- 4:47Speaker 1: they had no idea that this was a mistake, that
- 4:51Speaker 1: there's testimony that they at least thought maybe there was
- 4:54Speaker 1: something wrong happened here. On appeal, they can appeal based
- 4:58Speaker 1: on the facts or on the lass. Based on the facts.
- 5:01Speaker 1: What's the likelihood of a good outcome for City Bank
- 5:05Speaker 1: pretty slay. I mean the fact that the facts and
- 5:07Speaker 1: they were pretty established a trial at least with the
- 5:09Speaker 1: judge bound. So they'd have to prove that the judge
- 5:12Speaker 1: totally got the law wrong and his interpretation of the
- 5:15Speaker 1: facts is completely wrong, and that's going to be an
- 5:18Speaker 1: uphill battle given the fact that he's pretty much relied
- 5:21Speaker 1: on precedent to make his ruling. Like he said, it's
- 5:24Speaker 1: not the fairest outcome in the world, but it is
- 5:26Speaker 1: pretty straightforward, and there isn't a lot of precedent in
- 5:29Speaker 1: this area. You just don't have large financial institutions stakingly
- 5:32Speaker 1: sending almost a billion dollars to creditors that are involved
- 5:37Speaker 1: in a contentious dispute every day. So that was kind
- 5:41Speaker 1: of the problem with this case. And this case might
- 5:44Speaker 1: help clarify the law in a lot of those areas,
- 5:47Speaker 1: or it just might make it murkier. As experts have
- 5:49Speaker 1: told me, this is a very murky area of the law.
- 5:52Speaker 1: You know, these are kind of black Swan events. When
- 5:54Speaker 1: we see these things happen. It's very interesting and it
- 5:57Speaker 1: raises a lot of questions, but it doesn't necessary really
- 6:00Speaker 1: make it clear what happens when something like this goes wrong.
- 6:04Speaker 1: So I take it that the New York Court of
- 6:07Speaker 1: Appeals could change the law if it wanted to, But
- 6:10Speaker 1: this is going up to the Second Circuit Federal Court Appeals.
- 6:14Speaker 1: The likelihood that they would be able to overturn the
- 6:17Speaker 1: law that way is slim. I mean, certainly the Second
- 6:20Speaker 1: Circuit could ask the Court of Appeals a question to
- 6:23Speaker 1: certify a question involved in the case, but they wouldn't
- 6:26Speaker 1: make the ultimate decision. If City Bank does not win
- 6:29Speaker 1: an appeal, City Bank now holds the five billion dollar
- 6:34Speaker 1: loan of Revlon. That is the nillion dollar question as
- 6:39Speaker 1: it is what happens to that debt. Do they become
- 6:42Speaker 1: the de facto owners of the debt? Do they go
- 6:46Speaker 1: after Revalon in some way? That's there's a lot of
- 6:49Speaker 1: questions as what happens with that next, and it's not
- 6:53Speaker 1: really clear what the road will be on that. I
- 6:55Speaker 1: mean until there's an actual judgment in terms of the
- 6:59Speaker 1: end of the appeal and they get a final judgment.
- 7:01Speaker 1: At this point, I would say it's status quo because
- 7:04Speaker 1: the money is frozen and Revlon is still obligated to
- 7:07Speaker 1: make regular interest payments on that debt. Looking at the future,
- 7:11Speaker 1: if this case remains as it is on the books,
- 7:15Speaker 1: will this expose banks that facilitate wire transfers or serve
- 7:20Speaker 1: as administrators to more liability? Might there be change in
- 7:25Speaker 1: rules because of this? I mean at the very least,
- 7:28Speaker 1: you know, City Group even before the lawsuit and the trial,
- 7:32Speaker 1: it was already revealing its internal controls because of responses
- 7:35Speaker 1: from regulators about these kind of problems with this system
- 7:39Speaker 1: and other things that had happened. So you know, on
- 7:41Speaker 1: that level, there will certainly probably be changes at City
- 7:44Speaker 1: Group that will probably have a full autopsy of what
- 7:47Speaker 1: happened here. As to other transfer agents, administrative agents and
- 7:51Speaker 1: banks that service administrative agents, and it's hard to say.
- 7:54Speaker 1: Experts have said, you know, it certainly could increase the
- 7:57Speaker 1: cost of doing this kind of business, but this is
- 8:00Speaker 1: not a big profit center for banks. These are more
- 8:03Speaker 1: services they provide in order to be close to borrowers
- 8:07Speaker 1: and you know, to get better business and to provide
- 8:09Speaker 1: a service. And so therefore, you know, it might just
- 8:13Speaker 1: lead to some banks you decide they just don't want
- 8:15Speaker 1: to do this anymore for the very little amount of
- 8:17Speaker 1: money they get out of it. It might just need
- 8:19Speaker 1: to lead to another layer of compliance. Um with more
- 8:22Speaker 1: lawyers who have to sign off on these things, are
- 8:25Speaker 1: certainly a more robust and uniform way of making these transfers.
- 8:29Speaker 1: Thanks Chris. That's Crystal Mesh Bloomberg Legal reporter joining me now.
- 8:34Speaker 1: Is one of the attorneys for the winning investment firms,
- 8:38Speaker 1: Adam Abenson, a partner a Quinn Emmanuel. Many people were
- 8:42Speaker 1: surprised by the judges ruling. Were you surprised? We were pleased,
- 8:46Speaker 1: but not surprised. We have been deep in the law
- 8:49Speaker 1: on the case over the course of four months at
- 8:51Speaker 1: that point and understood that, notwithstanding with some other folks
- 8:56Speaker 1: thought we had a really effluent defense under the longest
- 9:00Speaker 1: that wished doctrine in New York. What do you think
- 9:03Speaker 1: the trial turned on? What point in the trial convinced
- 9:07Speaker 1: the judge. It's an interesting question here. I don't know
- 9:10Speaker 1: that I could point to one moment or one witness.
- 9:13Speaker 1: I think it was becoming increasingly clear over the course
- 9:16Speaker 1: of the trial that no one in the position of
- 9:19Speaker 1: our clients would have thought that this was a mistake
- 9:23Speaker 1: by City Bank. They had never made a mistake of
- 9:26Speaker 1: that type or on that scale, and under long established
- 9:29Speaker 1: doctrine in New York. It's all under a case called
- 9:32Speaker 1: bank worms. That that really was a key and I
- 9:36Speaker 1: think ultimately this positive point. So the average person might
- 9:40Speaker 1: look at this and say, if I went to a
- 9:43Speaker 1: bank machine and fifty dollar bills just started flying out,
- 9:47Speaker 1: I would have to return it. So why shouldn't the
- 9:50Speaker 1: hedge funds have to return this windfall? Even the judge
- 9:53Speaker 1: said that it might not seem like the fairest result. Well, look,
- 9:57Speaker 1: I think that the key difference between, you know, the
- 10:00Speaker 1: the money machinery pathetical and what we had here it
- 10:03Speaker 1: was undisputed that the lenders represented by our clients were
- 10:06Speaker 1: actually owed the amounts they received. What they got was
- 10:10Speaker 1: to the penny there as in principle, and a crude interest.
- 10:14Speaker 1: So this wasn't, you know, the kind of windfall the
- 10:17Speaker 1: other side wanted to portray it. What it was was
- 10:21Speaker 1: a group of lenders receiving exactly what they were oute
- 10:24Speaker 1: and that's an important distinction under New York law, and
- 10:27Speaker 1: we think it was a compelling distinction here at trial.
- 10:30Speaker 1: City Bank says it's going to appeal. What do you
- 10:33Speaker 1: think their chances are an appeal? Look, I hesitate to
- 10:36Speaker 1: try and sort of handicapped, you know what arguments City
- 10:39Speaker 1: Bank might make. We certainly think that court did an
- 10:43Speaker 1: excellent job in its opinion. We think it gave a
- 10:46Speaker 1: lot of detail and explanation as to why it was
- 10:48Speaker 1: persuaded as it was. Much of its analysis has to
- 10:51Speaker 1: do with what the court ocurred and saw from the witnesses.
- 10:54Speaker 1: We're confident in our case. We very much think we're
- 10:56Speaker 1: right on the law. And if City think, you know,
- 10:59Speaker 1: follow us through its plans, we certainly like our chances.
- 11:02Speaker 1: There are some legal scholars who are saying that the
- 11:05Speaker 1: New York Court of Appeals should change the law. I
- 11:08Speaker 1: don't expect that it will change, and I don't see
- 11:11Speaker 1: why it should. I think that the decision that we
- 11:13Speaker 1: relied on, which has decided I think over thirty years ago,
- 11:16Speaker 1: has has now stood the test of time. The Court
- 11:18Speaker 1: of Appeals decided that decision as it did in part
- 11:22Speaker 1: because it wanted to incentivize banks and not to make
- 11:25Speaker 1: these kinds of mistakes. And as a lot of the
- 11:27Speaker 1: reports for indicating there haven't been a lot of these
- 11:30Speaker 1: kinds of mistakes. So I think that authority in large
- 11:32Speaker 1: part has worked. Um So, I I don't think there's
- 11:35Speaker 1: a need for a change. I wouldn't anticipate a change,
- 11:39Speaker 1: um And. And we think certainly that the decision here
- 11:42Speaker 1: was very much in keeping with what the President required.
- 11:46Speaker 1: What was the highlight of the trial for you? You You know,
- 11:49Speaker 1: we had we had a really outstanding team working on this,
- 11:53Speaker 1: Kates um I was co counsel of trial with two
- 11:58Speaker 1: partners of mine at Quinnmanuel um Ben Finstone and Bob Lloydman.
- 12:02Speaker 1: Both of them are outstanding and working closely with them,
- 12:06Speaker 1: working in the trenches with them, um And that was
- 12:09Speaker 1: the highlight of it. We also had really an excellent
- 12:11Speaker 1: team of associates involved, um And. And. Look, it's not
- 12:15Speaker 1: it's never easy to be in trial. It's intense, it's
- 12:18Speaker 1: a lot of hours, but it was a really fantastic
- 12:20Speaker 1: group to be doing it with. I was referring to,
- 12:23Speaker 1: for example, if there was a cross examination or a
- 12:27Speaker 1: direct examination that that stood out to you. We divveed
- 12:32Speaker 1: up the witnesses, um, you know among the group that
- 12:34Speaker 1: I mentioned, UM, And so for me, the high heights
- 12:38Speaker 1: were the ones that I handled. UM. You know, I
- 12:40Speaker 1: don't know if that's much the the the answer that
- 12:43Speaker 1: you'd be looking for, but I I did a couple
- 12:45Speaker 1: of the early witnesses who were the city bank folks
- 12:48Speaker 1: who were actually involved in um, uh you know, making
- 12:51Speaker 1: the transfer, UM. And that was very much the start
- 12:55Speaker 1: of the case, sort of getting feet wet um. And
- 12:58Speaker 1: uh you know that that it was, you know, an
- 13:00Speaker 1: exciting opportunity for me to be handling those and again
- 13:05Speaker 1: we we we liked how the evidence was coming in
- 13:09Speaker 1: and uh you know, we felt as if it stayed
- 13:12Speaker 1: on a good track from there on. I want to
- 13:14Speaker 1: emphasize again what a great team effort this was, um.
- 13:17Speaker 1: You know, not only with the partners and associate if
- 13:19Speaker 1: I worked on, but also our firm quin Immanual, which UM,
- 13:22Speaker 1: you know, it takes cases that that others might think unusual, um,
- 13:29Speaker 1: and have we have a great track record of winning them,
- 13:31Speaker 1: and UM, you know we're proud to I knew with
- 13:33Speaker 1: the result here. Thanks Adam. That's Adam Abenson of Queen Emmanuel.
- 13:37Speaker 1: And that's it for the edition of Bloomberg Law. I'm
- 13:40Speaker 1: June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg