Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: Bump Stocks, Social Media & Trump's Sneakers
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: It was a busy week at the Supreme Court. The
- 0:13Speaker 2: Justice has heard oral arguments in two high profile cases
- 0:17Speaker 2: over guns and the Internet, and they decided to take
- 0:20Speaker 2: up Donald Trump's bid for immunity from criminal prosecution, putting
- 0:24Speaker 2: his election interference trial on hold until the Court makes
- 0:28Speaker 2: a decision, perhaps as late as June. Trump's litigation strategy
- 0:33Speaker 2: of delay, delay, delay essentially gave him a victory. Here's
- 0:38Speaker 2: former federal prosecutor Robert Mintz.
- 0:40Speaker 3: One pactick in any defense team's playbook is to try
- 0:45Speaker 3: to delay. Here We've seen that done again and again
- 0:48Speaker 3: by former President Trump's lawyers, and it has special significance
- 0:52Speaker 3: here given the fact that there is an upcoming election,
- 0:54Speaker 3: and so the decision here as to whether and how
- 0:58Speaker 3: quickly Trump could god a trial is especially critical because
- 1:03Speaker 3: it could not only affect his election prospect, but should
- 1:06Speaker 3: he be reelected, it would actually affect the Department of
- 1:09Speaker 3: Justice ability to bring this case at all, since once
- 1:12Speaker 3: he's president, he could simply direct his attorney general to
- 1:15Speaker 3: dismiss the case that was penning against him. So it
- 1:18Speaker 3: has particular significance.
- 1:20Speaker 2: And like everything related to Trump, that decision seemed to
- 1:23Speaker 2: overshadow the cases the Court heard this week. On Monday,
- 1:28Speaker 2: during almost four hours of arguments, the justices grappled with
- 1:32Speaker 2: the new Republican backed laws in Texas and Florida that
- 1:36Speaker 2: bans social media platforms from removing content based on the
- 1:40Speaker 2: views expressed.
- 1:41Speaker 4: This is such an odd case for our usual jurisprudence.
- 1:49Speaker 4: It seems like your law is covering just about every
- 1:54Speaker 4: social media platform on the Internet. And we have a
- 1:58Speaker 4: meek guy who are not additional social media platforms like
- 2:04Speaker 4: smartphones and others who have submitted ANKI brief telling them
- 2:09Speaker 4: that readings of this law could cover them.
- 2:12Speaker 2: And several Justices echoed the concerns of Justice Sonya Sotomayor
- 2:17Speaker 2: about how the very broad laws might affect other sites
- 2:21Speaker 2: like Uber, Etsy, and Venmo. Here's Justice Amy Cony Barrett.
- 2:26Speaker 5: So Florida's law, so far as I can understand, it
- 2:28Speaker 5: is very broad, and we're talking about the classic social
- 2:31Speaker 5: media platforms, But it looks to me like it could
- 2:33Speaker 5: cover Uber. It looks to me like it could cover
- 2:36Speaker 5: just Google search engines, Amazon Web Service, and all of
- 2:39Speaker 5: those things would look very different, and Justice Sotomayor brought
- 2:43Speaker 5: up etsy.
- 2:45Speaker 2: Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas appeared most ready to
- 2:49Speaker 2: embrace arguments made by lawyers for the States characterizing social
- 2:54Speaker 2: media's content moderation as censorship.
- 2:57Speaker 6: Is it anything more than a euphemism for censorship?
- 3:00Speaker 7: I want to just ask you this, If somebody in
- 3:02Speaker 7: nineteen seventeen.
- 3:04Speaker 8: Was prosecuted and thrown in jail for opposing US participation
- 3:09Speaker 8: in World War One?
- 3:10Speaker 1: Was that content moderation?
- 3:12Speaker 2: Joining me is Eric Goleman, co director of the High
- 3:15Speaker 2: Tech Law Institute at Santa Clara University Law School. Eric
- 3:20Speaker 2: justice is on both sides of the ideological spectrum. We're
- 3:24Speaker 2: concerned about how broad these laws are and how they
- 3:28Speaker 2: could cover sites from et seed to Gmail.
- 3:31Speaker 8: Essentially, what Florida and Texas did is that they passed
- 3:34Speaker 8: laws that were tacked with over a dozen different ideas
- 3:39Speaker 8: in each and because of that complexity, it makes it
- 3:43Speaker 8: very hard to determine who's actually covered by the law
- 3:46Speaker 8: and what they're expected to do. And based on the
- 3:49Speaker 8: way that the cases got to the Supreme Court, some
- 3:52Speaker 8: of that wasn't fully clarified at the lower levels, and
- 3:56Speaker 8: so the justices were just wrestling with the pay of
- 4:00Speaker 8: the law that they couldn't figure out who's covered, what
- 4:04Speaker 8: it would actually require them to do, and therefore they
- 4:07Speaker 8: didn't even know how to evaluate the constitutionality of those provisions.
- 4:11Speaker 2: There were also a lot of questions about whether social
- 4:14Speaker 2: media platforms should be treated like common carriers such as
- 4:18Speaker 2: telephone companies. So are tech companies more like publishers or
- 4:23Speaker 2: public utilities.
- 4:25Speaker 8: I think that the real struggle was in how to
- 4:28Speaker 8: interplay a speech restriction, of which the laws contained several
- 4:33Speaker 8: with other legal principles like public accommodations, the idea that
- 4:38Speaker 8: companies should not discriminate against their customers based on certain
- 4:42Speaker 8: protected attributes, so other concepts like common carriage or public
- 4:48Speaker 8: utility doctrines. Those concept doctrines could be in play. But
- 4:52Speaker 8: the real struggle is that the court doesn't really know
- 4:55Speaker 8: how to think about how social media services differ from say,
- 4:58Speaker 8: a restaurant. Until they get to that basic understanding of
- 5:02Speaker 8: the different functions of social media services, they don't even
- 5:06Speaker 8: know how to categorize them.
- 5:08Speaker 2: And early in the arguments, Justice Cavanaugh emphasized to Florida
- 5:12Speaker 2: Solicitor General that the First Amendment only prevents governments from
- 5:17Speaker 2: restricting speech, not private businesses.
- 5:20Speaker 9: In your opening remarks, you said, the design of the
- 5:23Speaker 9: First Amendment is to prevent suppression of speech end quote,
- 5:28Speaker 9: and you left out what I understand to be three
- 5:30Speaker 9: key words in the First Amendment or to describe the
- 5:34Speaker 9: First Amendment by the government.
- 5:37Speaker 2: That seemed to be such a strong point, but then
- 5:39Speaker 2: it just disappeared from the arguments.
- 5:42Speaker 8: Justine Covanaugh really hammered that the First Amendment restricts how
- 5:47Speaker 8: governments act, not how private actors act. And when the
- 5:51Speaker 8: government tries to tell publishers how to act, that's a facial,
- 5:55Speaker 8: unambiguous First Amendment violation, no questions about it. For some reason,
- 6:01Speaker 8: he was pretty much the only voice making that point,
- 6:04Speaker 8: even though it seems so screamingly obvious. All the other
- 6:07Speaker 8: justices were struggling to get back to that basic point.
- 6:11Speaker 8: And so that makes me nervous because Justice Kavanaugh was
- 6:15Speaker 8: one hundred percent correct in that observation, and here was
- 6:18Speaker 8: almost like a lone voice on it.
- 6:20Speaker 2: I thought, coming into these arguments that there was no
- 6:24Speaker 2: way they would uphold either of these laws. Now I'm
- 6:28Speaker 2: not so sure.
- 6:30Speaker 8: Well, it's not a binary question, it's not do the
- 6:33Speaker 8: law survive or the laws fail. It could be the
- 6:35Speaker 8: parts of the law survive and parts of the law fail,
- 6:37Speaker 8: like in the Eleventh Circuit, some of the laws did
- 6:40Speaker 8: survive and other parts did not. So the Supreme Court
- 6:44Speaker 8: is quite likely to try to make some distinctions about
- 6:47Speaker 8: the different provisions and will be careful to try and
- 6:51Speaker 8: make sure that whatever they say on any of those
- 6:53Speaker 8: visions wouldn't affect some future legislature's freedom on different topic.
- 6:57Speaker 8: So then that effect is that it's possible that some
- 7:01Speaker 8: parts of the law will survive. And that's scary to
- 7:04Speaker 8: me because there was really no salagy in the law
- 7:06Speaker 8: at all either law. Both of them were so misguided
- 7:11Speaker 8: at their core that the idea that any peace in
- 7:13Speaker 8: the law might be okay is really just horrifying to me.
- 7:17Speaker 2: Well, if parts of the laws are allowed to go
- 7:19Speaker 2: into effect, that means we could have a landscape across
- 7:23Speaker 2: the country where different states have different rules about social media.
- 7:27Speaker 8: That's inevitable, that's already happening today. And that's a different
- 7:31Speaker 8: question for the Court that they acknowledged occasionally but weren't
- 7:35Speaker 8: prepared to deal with. It wasn't within the scope of
- 7:37Speaker 8: their review. But the entire idea of individual states coming
- 7:42Speaker 8: up with their own version of a social media service
- 7:46Speaker 8: and how they regulated just completely touch or diicts how
- 7:51Speaker 8: we think about the Internet and really how Internet law
- 7:55Speaker 8: can function in a meaningful way. So, you know, just
- 7:59Speaker 8: to be clear, there are provisions of both the Floor
- 8:02Speaker 8: and Texas laws that were not challenged, that are in
- 8:04Speaker 8: effect today that the states have chosen not yet to enforce.
- 8:08Speaker 8: So we are already living in a world where parts
- 8:11Speaker 8: of these laws are in effect, and whenever they're enforced,
- 8:16Speaker 8: if ever, we could see a radically different Internet. The
- 8:19Speaker 8: states are not likely to deploy those laws to advance
- 8:22Speaker 8: the interests of the Internet at large. They will do
- 8:25Speaker 8: so to advance the voters they're trying to impress.
- 8:29Speaker 2: Yeah, at one point there was a discussion about whether
- 8:32Speaker 2: Texas could be GEO fenced out.
- 8:35Speaker 8: Yeah, it's the weirdest message. The Texas lawyer basically said,
- 8:39Speaker 8: to get the f out of Texas. You don't want
- 8:42Speaker 8: to follow their rules. And if I'm a Texas social
- 8:46Speaker 8: media user, I'm going to be quite concerned about that position.
- 8:50Speaker 8: They're basically begging the social media service to change the
- 8:53Speaker 8: Internet for Texas, and I'm pretty sure that's not actually
- 8:56Speaker 8: what Texas voters want.
- 8:58Speaker 2: These cases are just at the ordinary injunction stage, So
- 9:02Speaker 2: could the justices just send this back, you know, for
- 9:06Speaker 2: trial and for more findings of fact.
- 9:09Speaker 8: That's the best case scenario for the social media services
- 9:13Speaker 8: is that the Supreme Court keeps the injunction in place,
- 9:17Speaker 8: or in the Texas case, restores the injunction that was
- 9:19Speaker 8: initially issued and then sends it back to the trial
- 9:23Speaker 8: courts to determine whether or not a permanent injunction is appropriate.
- 9:28Speaker 8: That's the best case scenario. That step would have to
- 9:31Speaker 8: happen no matter what if the law is going to
- 9:33Speaker 8: be struck down. But if the courts decide to affirm
- 9:37Speaker 8: some or all of the existing laws, they could simply
- 9:40Speaker 8: say injunction. Dissolved laws go into effect, and either the
- 9:45Speaker 8: social media services can never challenge it because they'll have
- 9:48Speaker 8: no merit, or at best, the social media services will
- 9:52Speaker 8: have to challenge only after they've been sued under the law.
- 9:57Speaker 8: And it's clearly social media services don't like that answer
- 10:00Speaker 8: because of the fact that they would then have to
- 10:02Speaker 8: build a compliance function and hope that they got it right,
- 10:06Speaker 8: or risk really quite devastating remedies. So the best scenario
- 10:11Speaker 8: is that we have further proceeds in this case at
- 10:13Speaker 8: the lower court to determine the permanent injunction. And the
- 10:16Speaker 8: worst case scenario is that the laws go into effect
- 10:19Speaker 8: as they're currently written, with the possibility of limited further challenges.
- 10:23Speaker 2: And how do you think the justices are going to
- 10:25Speaker 2: line up?
- 10:26Speaker 8: It wouldn't surprise me if three justices would vote to
- 10:30Speaker 8: support the Texas and Florida laws. That could be done
- 10:33Speaker 8: substantly or more likely on a procedural basis, simply saying
- 10:38Speaker 8: that they reject the facial challenge. That was Justice Thomas,
- 10:41Speaker 8: Justice Tolito, and Justice or such. After that, the other
- 10:45Speaker 8: six justices were kind of all over the map. I
- 10:49Speaker 8: heard some reservations about the laws and the likelihood that
- 10:54Speaker 8: some aspects were in constitutional, but I couldn't tell then
- 10:58Speaker 8: if that would support a procedural ruling on the legitimacy
- 11:03Speaker 8: of the facial challenge, or if there were a substance
- 11:07Speaker 8: of agreement about which of the pieces were going to
- 11:10Speaker 8: be unconstitutional. So I come away from the oral argument
- 11:14Speaker 8: really uncertain about the future of the cases, and also
- 11:18Speaker 8: frankly uncertain about the future of the Internet.
- 11:21Speaker 2: There's certainly a lot at stake here. Thanks so much, Eric.
- 11:24Speaker 2: That's Professor Eric Goldman, co director of the High Tech
- 11:27Speaker 2: Law Institute at Santa Clara University Law School. Coming up
- 11:31Speaker 2: next on the Bloomberg Law Show. The Justice is a
- 11:34Speaker 2: peer split over whether to uphold the federal ban on
- 11:37Speaker 2: bump stocks, and two justices from opposite ends of the
- 11:42Speaker 2: ideological divide make a public appearance together. We'll tell you why.
- 11:47Speaker 2: I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:49Speaker 7: The Aichens accelerator at the original bumpstock shot at six
- 11:52Speaker 7: hundred and fifty rounds a minute, and the devices at
- 11:54Speaker 7: issue here are represented to shoot between four hundred and
- 11:57Speaker 7: eight hundred round a minute, so right in that range
- 12:00Speaker 7: with the sixteen the M fourteen.
- 12:01Speaker 2: Brian Fletcher, representing the Biden administration, explained to the Supreme
- 12:06Speaker 2: Court Justices on Wednesday that bump stocks turned semi automatic
- 12:10Speaker 2: rifles into weapons that fire at speeds comparable to machine
- 12:15Speaker 2: guns like the M sixteen and M fourteens used by
- 12:18Speaker 2: the military. The question is whether the justices will strike
- 12:22Speaker 2: down a ban on bump stocks that was imposed by
- 12:25Speaker 2: the Trump administration after the deadliest mass shooting in US
- 12:29Speaker 2: history in Las Vegas in twenty seventeen. The liberal justice is,
- 12:34Speaker 2: like Elena Kagan, seemed to think that the one hundred
- 12:37Speaker 2: year old law banning machine guns could also cover bump stocks.
- 12:41Speaker 10: The entire point of this device is that you exert
- 12:45Speaker 10: forward pressure and you have your finger on the trigger,
- 12:49Speaker 10: and then a torrent of bullets shoots out. So I
- 12:52Speaker 10: don't understand why it's any different different from pushing a
- 12:54Speaker 10: button and holding the trigger, pushing the barrel and holding
- 12:57Speaker 10: the trigger.
- 12:58Speaker 2: But conservative justice is like Amy Cony Barrett and Neil Gorsuch,
- 13:02Speaker 2: while seeming to acknowledge the danger of bomb stocks, question
- 13:06Speaker 2: whether banning the device is was up to the court.
- 13:09Speaker 5: It seems like, yes, this is functioning like a machine
- 13:11Speaker 5: gun would. But you know, looking at that definition, I
- 13:15Speaker 5: think the question is why didn't Congress pass that litigation,
- 13:18Speaker 5: I mean, that legislation to make this coverment more clearly.
- 13:22Speaker 6: I can certainly understand why these items should be made illegal,
- 13:27Speaker 6: but we're dealing with the statute as enacted in the
- 13:30Speaker 6: nineteen thirties, and through many administrations, the government took the
- 13:37Speaker 6: position that these bump stocks are not machine.
- 13:41Speaker 2: Guns, joining me is Andrew Willinger, executive director of the
- 13:44Speaker 2: Duke Center for Firearms Law. Andrews start by giving us
- 13:48Speaker 2: a little bit of the history of the federal ban
- 13:50Speaker 2: on bomb stocks.
- 13:52Speaker 11: So, this is.
- 13:53Speaker 12: An ATF regulation that categorizes bombstock devices as machine guns
- 14:00Speaker 12: under the National Firearms Act, and so therefore those devices
- 14:04Speaker 12: are banned. This regulation was promulgated after the twenty seventeen
- 14:09Speaker 12: Las Vegas shooting, the deadliest mass shooting in US history,
- 14:13Speaker 12: where the shooter used bump stocks. And after that shooting,
- 14:17Speaker 12: there was some discussion about whether Congress might act through
- 14:22Speaker 12: legislation to specifically say that, you know, bump stocks are
- 14:26Speaker 12: prohibited or bump stocks are machine guns, and ultimately that
- 14:29Speaker 12: did not happen. Instead, the ATF under the Trump administration
- 14:34Speaker 12: promulgated this regulation. And you know, it's I guess worth
- 14:38Speaker 12: noting here that the ATF has sort of had, in
- 14:42Speaker 12: the previous decade or so gone back and forth on
- 14:46Speaker 12: how it categorized them in informal guidance to the industry.
- 14:50Speaker 12: These sort of letters that the ATF would send to
- 14:52Speaker 12: companies that were making bump stocks, occasionally saying that some
- 14:55Speaker 12: of these devices were not machine guns and could be
- 14:58Speaker 12: produced and sold, and so this regulation in twenty eighteen
- 15:02Speaker 12: kind of settled that matter. But again it's the culmination
- 15:04Speaker 12: of a little bit of a back and forth from
- 15:06Speaker 12: the ATF.
- 15:07Speaker 2: So this isn't about the Second Amendment. Then, it's about
- 15:10Speaker 2: the reach of this federal statute and how the ATF
- 15:15Speaker 2: interpreted it.
- 15:16Speaker 12: Yeah, exactly, it's a little bit complicated. It's not, I
- 15:19Speaker 12: guess to start.
- 15:20Speaker 2: It's a lot complicated.
- 15:21Speaker 11: Yeah, the justices certainly, I think you're struggling with this
- 15:24Speaker 11: one as well. So to start, you know, you're right,
- 15:27Speaker 11: it's not a Second Amendment case. That's been pretty clear
- 15:29Speaker 11: from the get go. This is really, as I see
- 15:32Speaker 11: it at this.
- 15:33Speaker 12: Point, really a pure statutory interpretation question. And then the
- 15:37Speaker 12: question is whether the ATFS interpretation of machine gun to
- 15:40Speaker 12: include bump stocks was in accord with the statute, with
- 15:45Speaker 12: what the statute mean, what the intent was when the
- 15:47Speaker 12: statute was written. So for that reason, the arguments that
- 15:50Speaker 12: we heard are really focused on just this question of
- 15:53Speaker 12: what does the relevant statutory language single function of the
- 15:56Speaker 12: trigger automatically, what do those words mean?
- 15:59Speaker 2: I have to say I found these arguments so confusing,
- 16:04Speaker 2: with the justices seeming to struggle over the technical aspects
- 16:08Speaker 2: of bump stocks over you know, are you're pushing a button,
- 16:11Speaker 2: are you pulling? Are you exerting pressure on it? Why
- 16:14Speaker 2: was that important?
- 16:16Speaker 11: Yeah?
- 16:16Speaker 12: I mean yeah, there was a lot of confusion and
- 16:18Speaker 12: a lot of hypothetical you know, revolving around buttons and
- 16:21Speaker 12: trip wires and those types of things. But I think
- 16:25Speaker 12: ultimately the issue sort of reduces to the perspective from
- 16:29Speaker 12: which you view this phrase single function of the trigger.
- 16:33Speaker 12: So the government's argument really just boiled down, is that
- 16:37Speaker 12: single function of the trigger really means single pull of
- 16:40Speaker 12: the trigger. So you're focused on the act of the
- 16:43Speaker 12: shooter and what the shooter does in pulling the trigger,
- 16:47Speaker 12: and that because that pull of the trigger initiates the
- 16:50Speaker 12: bump firing sequence when you're using a bump stock, that
- 16:54Speaker 12: therefore the gun is firing multiple rounds with a single
- 16:58Speaker 12: function of the trigger. Cargill, on the other hand, says,
- 17:02Speaker 12: you don't look at this from the perspective of the shooter. Instead,
- 17:06Speaker 12: you're looking at the actual mechanical function of the trigger.
- 17:09Speaker 12: What does the trigger of the gun do? And the
- 17:13Speaker 12: way again, according to Cargo's argument and the way that
- 17:15Speaker 12: that works is that when you are bump firing a
- 17:18Speaker 12: STEMI automatic weapon, the trigger still has to go back
- 17:22Speaker 12: and forth, and only one round is expelled each time
- 17:26Speaker 12: the trigger goes back and forth. It just happens very quickly.
- 17:29Speaker 2: The court's liberals seem to suggest that bump stocks fell
- 17:33Speaker 2: within what Congress intended when it banned machine guns, and
- 17:38Speaker 2: particularly Justice Elena Kagan went at this over and over
- 17:42Speaker 2: again with Cargo's attorney, and you know, appeared incredulous that
- 17:47Speaker 2: a weapon that can fire a torrent of bullets could
- 17:50Speaker 2: not be defined as a machine gun.
- 17:52Speaker 12: That's what I detected from Justice Kagan, probably Justice Jackson,
- 17:56Speaker 12: maybe Justice Soda Mayor, with sort of this maybe consequentialist
- 18:01Speaker 12: approach to this statute, which is, well, how does it
- 18:04Speaker 12: make any sense to read the statue to exclude from
- 18:09Speaker 12: its scope devices that would allow you to achieve the
- 18:13Speaker 12: same high rate of fire as you know, a machine
- 18:16Speaker 12: gun like the sixteen for example, Right in their view,
- 18:19Speaker 12: I think that seems that something of an absurd result
- 18:22Speaker 12: given the evidence about the National Firearms Act and what
- 18:25Speaker 12: the congressional intent was there.
- 18:28Speaker 2: So it seemed like several conservatives were acknowledging that it's
- 18:33Speaker 2: functioning like a machine gun. So Justice is Barrett and
- 18:36Speaker 2: Gorsich said words to that effect. Then the buts came
- 18:40Speaker 2: and they both thought that this is something that Congress
- 18:43Speaker 2: should do.
- 18:43Speaker 12: Yeah, I think that's right. I think they thought that
- 18:45Speaker 12: this is something Congress should do that cannot be accomplished
- 18:49Speaker 12: through regulation. And I also think there was a strong view,
- 18:54Speaker 12: you know, among some of the conservative justices, Justice Gorsas,
- 18:57Speaker 12: just as Kavanaugh, maybe Justice Alito, that they were very
- 19:00Speaker 12: concerned about the potential confusion and the potential for sort
- 19:06Speaker 12: of people who own these devices to be kind of
- 19:08Speaker 12: almost trapped, right and be like, well that they're not
- 19:10Speaker 12: sure what the legal status is and yet that they
- 19:13Speaker 12: could be prosecuted criminally for having these devices. And so
- 19:16Speaker 12: a lot of concern about sort of what the practical
- 19:19Speaker 12: impact of this rule would be on people who have
- 19:22Speaker 12: owned bump stock devices at various points in time.
- 19:25Speaker 2: I thought that was a ridiculous concern. Would people be
- 19:28Speaker 2: so confused if the ATF said bump stocks are now illegal?
- 19:34Speaker 2: I mean, laws change. Ask the Supreme Court about abortion.
- 19:38Speaker 12: Maybe the key point here is that, actually, I don't
- 19:41Speaker 12: know how much this matters. And there were a few
- 19:43Speaker 12: justices who pressed the government attorney on this issue. The
- 19:47Speaker 12: government is not really bringing criminal prosecutions as far as
- 19:50Speaker 12: I know of those who have possessed bump stock devices, right,
- 19:54Speaker 12: And I would suspect that they wouldn't do that until
- 19:57Speaker 12: this litigation sort of resolved. And cerly, this issue is
- 20:01Speaker 12: not unique to bump stocks. Right. Frequently circuits disagree on
- 20:05Speaker 12: various issues of criminal law. Right, that doesn't mean that
- 20:08Speaker 12: criminal penalties can't be invoked.
- 20:10Speaker 2: So what's your best guess as to how this will
- 20:13Speaker 2: come out?
- 20:14Speaker 12: Again, this is not a Second Amendment case. It of
- 20:16Speaker 12: course involves firearms and firearm accessories, but it's not a
- 20:20Speaker 12: Second Amendment case. And that might initially lead one to think, well,
- 20:24Speaker 12: maybe the justices will break down differently right than they
- 20:28Speaker 12: have in their most recent Second Amendment decisions. After listening
- 20:31Speaker 12: to the argument, I'm not so sure that's true. I
- 20:34Speaker 12: think you can pretty confidently say that you know Justices Soda, Mayor, Kagan,
- 20:39Speaker 12: and Jackson, they're probably on the side of the government here.
- 20:43Speaker 12: Justice Alito, Justice Kavanaugh, Justice Gorsuch, and probably Justice Thomas.
- 20:47Speaker 12: I would guess it seems a little bit more sympathetic
- 20:49Speaker 12: to Cargill's position. So then you have, of course, Justice
- 20:52Speaker 12: Barrett and Chief Justice who are sort of up in
- 20:55Speaker 12: the air, and the Chief Justice didn't say a whole
- 20:57Speaker 12: lot during oral arguments. Putting all that together, I expect
- 21:00Speaker 12: this to be a very close case. It's potentially a
- 21:03Speaker 12: five four decision. I'm not really sure which way it
- 21:05Speaker 12: will go. You have those same justices Barrett and Roberts
- 21:09Speaker 12: that are kind of the key votes in the second
- 21:11Speaker 12: Amendment area, also being the key votes here.
- 21:14Speaker 2: Such an important case. Thanks Andrew. That's Andrew Willinger, Executive
- 21:18Speaker 2: director of the Duke Center for Firearms Law. A note.
- 21:22Speaker 2: Michael Bloomberg, the founder majority owner of Bloomberg LP, the
- 21:25Speaker 2: parent company of Bloomberg Radio, is a donor to groups
- 21:29Speaker 2: that support gun control, including every Town for Gun Safety Now.
- 21:33Speaker 2: While the justices were exhibiting division on the bench during
- 21:37Speaker 2: oral arguments this week, two justices from opposite ends of
- 21:41Speaker 2: the ideological spectrum appeared on stage side by side at
- 21:45Speaker 2: the National Governors Association in DC last Friday to talk
- 21:49Speaker 2: about how well the justices get along. But the main
- 21:53Speaker 2: message from liberal Justice Sonya Sotomayor and conservative Justice Amy
- 21:57Speaker 2: Cony Barrett seemed to be that the justices are not
- 22:01Speaker 2: beholden to the presidents who appointed them.
- 22:04Speaker 4: And remember, thankfully, for us, presidents don't last that long, right,
- 22:09Speaker 4: there's eight years, So for us to be behold into
- 22:13Speaker 4: one of them is a little crazy.
- 22:14Speaker 10: Right.
- 22:16Speaker 5: It's not just that we're not Obama judges and Trump judges,
- 22:19Speaker 5: but we're also not Democratic judges or Republican judges. We
- 22:22Speaker 5: don't sit on opposite sides of an aisle. We all
- 22:24Speaker 5: wear the same color black robe. We don't have red,
- 22:27Speaker 5: red robes and blue robes.
- 22:29Speaker 2: Joining me is constitutional law expert David super, a professor
- 22:33Speaker 2: at Georgetown Law School. So was the point to tell
- 22:36Speaker 2: the country that they get along and play well together
- 22:39Speaker 2: or something else.
- 22:41Speaker 1: The point is to salvage the Supreme Court as a
- 22:46Speaker 1: unifying institution, an institution relevant to all of us. And
- 22:50Speaker 1: participating in that effort was one of the few things
- 22:54Speaker 1: that Justice Soda Mayor can do to make herself relevant,
- 22:58Speaker 1: given how heavily outvoted.
- 23:00Speaker 2: The biggest message to me was that they're not beholden
- 23:03Speaker 2: to the presidents that appointed them or to the president's party.
- 23:07Speaker 2: Barrett said, we're not Obama judges or Trump judges. We're
- 23:11Speaker 2: not Democratic judges or Republican judges, but she left out
- 23:16Speaker 2: we are liberal judges and conservative judges.
- 23:20Speaker 1: This is damage control for a court whose image has
- 23:23Speaker 1: been badly harmed. You saw the same sort of thing
- 23:26Speaker 1: in the early two thousands after Bush vy Gore and
- 23:30Speaker 1: some of the Democratic justices then after several months had passed,
- 23:35Speaker 1: started giving speeches that the court works well together and
- 23:39Speaker 1: people should still respect the court. And I think after
- 23:42Speaker 1: the damage that Dobbs and grun and some of these
- 23:45Speaker 1: other high profile cases, the Affervative Action case have done
- 23:49Speaker 1: to the image of a court as an impartial finder
- 23:53Speaker 1: of legal truths, that they feel some need to do this.
- 23:57Speaker 1: Chief Justice Roberts has been doing it for a long time,
- 24:00Speaker 1: and I suspect he's encouraged other justices to join in.
- 24:03Speaker 2: We'll see if the public's opinion of the Court plummets
- 24:07Speaker 2: any lower after this term's decisions on guns, the abortion pill,
- 24:12Speaker 2: social media, and the like. Thanks so much, David. That's
- 24:15Speaker 2: Professor David super of Georgetown Law School. Coming up next.
- 24:19Speaker 2: Might Donald Trump be facing another lawsuit, this time over
- 24:23Speaker 2: his new sneakers with those bright red souls. I'm June Gross.
- 24:28Speaker 2: When you're listening to Bloomberg, that's.
- 24:30Speaker 12: The real deal. That's the real deal.
- 24:34Speaker 2: Donald Trump launched his Never Surrender high Top sneakers at
- 24:39Speaker 2: sneaker Con last week, a limited edition selling for three
- 24:42Speaker 2: hundred and ninety nine dollars.
- 24:44Speaker 4: You know, I've wanted to do this for a long time.
- 24:46Speaker 1: I have some incredible people that work with me on things,
- 24:49Speaker 1: and they came up with this, And this is something.
- 24:52Speaker 10: I've been talking about for twelve.
- 24:54Speaker 9: Years, thirteen years, and I think it's going.
- 24:57Speaker 4: To be a big success.
- 24:58Speaker 2: It didn't take long for the garish goal sneakers were
- 25:01Speaker 2: the stars and stripes designed around the ankle and a
- 25:05Speaker 2: huge letter T on the side to be mocked, including
- 25:08Speaker 2: a skit on Saturday Night Live.
- 25:10Speaker 12: In terms of basketball movie vestiche and with regard to shoes,
- 25:15Speaker 12: I think we've done a wonderful boittmn Karen.
- 25:18Speaker 2: But it's the bright red souls on the sneakers that
- 25:21Speaker 2: have lawyers talking. Is luxury brand Christian le Bouton, known
- 25:26Speaker 2: for its iconic red souls, going to sue for trademark infringement.
- 25:30Speaker 2: Joining me is Susan Scaffiti, director of the Fashion Law
- 25:33Speaker 2: Institute at Fordham Law School. So these Never Surrender high
- 25:38Speaker 2: Top sneakers, which are gold Trump's favorite color apparently, but
- 25:42Speaker 2: with those bright red souls screams I'm a Christian leu
- 25:47Speaker 2: button sneaker.
- 25:49Speaker 13: Yes it does. And I have a feeling that maybe
- 25:54Speaker 13: there were a few trademark layers who had a hand
- 25:56Speaker 13: in this shoe because it screams Lobotomata pulls back a
- 26:00Speaker 13: little bit, says, yes, I'm Libaton, but not quite in
- 26:04Speaker 13: part because the Lebaton trademark, as registered is actually for
- 26:09Speaker 13: women's shoes only. Also, you see the way on the
- 26:12Speaker 13: side of the Trump shoe the red outsole bleeds up
- 26:17Speaker 13: a little bit onto the white foxing along the side
- 26:20Speaker 13: of the shoe, And I think that's because in the
- 26:24Speaker 13: landmark lawsuit, when La and Libata were in court together
- 26:28Speaker 13: here in New York, if the trademark ultimately ended up
- 26:30Speaker 13: being modified, Now that trademark was about an all red
- 26:34Speaker 13: shoe with a red upper and a red outsole, that
- 26:37Speaker 13: the law had done. But the ultimate result of that
- 26:40Speaker 13: lawsuit was that the Loboton trademark was modified so that
- 26:45Speaker 13: there must be a contrast between the outsole and the upper.
- 26:48Speaker 13: So maybe some clever trademark lawyers thought, well, if the
- 26:51Speaker 13: red bleeds over a little bit, we could at least
- 26:53Speaker 13: argue that there's not contrast, and we could argue that
- 26:57Speaker 13: the registration is technically for women's although that's not really
- 27:01Speaker 13: smart thinking, because of course there's a common law trademark
- 27:05Speaker 13: in the US, and since Blebaton is so associated with
- 27:08Speaker 13: red soles on shoes, including now for mens, including his own,
- 27:13Speaker 13: even though at the time he originally registered in the
- 27:15Speaker 13: US he did very few mens. I think that Libertont,
- 27:18Speaker 13: if it cared to take action, would in fact have
- 27:21Speaker 13: a pretty good case.
- 27:22Speaker 2: And Nike might also be looking at these Trump sneakers.
- 27:25Speaker 13: Well, you know, lo Baton is the first glaring trademark reference,
- 27:30Speaker 13: shall we say, kind of reference to luxury in those shoes.
- 27:33Speaker 13: But you know, the silhouette is an awful lot like
- 27:36Speaker 13: the Nike Air Force one Nudgwink Air Force one. So
- 27:40Speaker 13: there's a lot going on here. And while Nike does
- 27:43Speaker 13: have trade dress registration on some elements of the Air
- 27:47Speaker 13: Force one, including the Air Force one high tops that
- 27:49Speaker 13: these resemble, I again think there might have been a
- 27:52Speaker 13: trademark lawyer in the design room saying, you know, maybe
- 27:55Speaker 13: move those panels just a little bit, maybe don't do
- 27:58Speaker 13: too many vertical line down along the base of the
- 28:02Speaker 13: foxing at the bottom of the shoe, just before it
- 28:04Speaker 13: touches the ground. Maybe make sure you don't use the
- 28:07Speaker 13: wavy leather brackets that hold the islets for the shoelaces
- 28:11Speaker 13: that are so classic and associated with the Nike Air
- 28:14Speaker 13: Force One. And yet for a sneaker officionado looking at
- 28:17Speaker 13: that silhouette, it does have that reference, especially because the
- 28:22Speaker 13: flaglike imagery around the top, it also feels like a
- 28:26Speaker 13: reference to the band around the top of an air
- 28:28Speaker 13: Force one. So overall, I can't imagine that Nike would
- 28:31Speaker 13: be happy. They wouldn't necessarily have quite a strong trademark
- 28:34Speaker 13: claim as Lobaton, but I think that certainly it crossed
- 28:39Speaker 13: a desk at Nike, the desk in the legal department.
- 28:42Speaker 2: The little difference is, let's say, the way the red
- 28:44Speaker 2: goes up the side. Do those make that much of
- 28:47Speaker 2: a difference in a lawsuit because most people just look, oh,
- 28:51Speaker 2: it's got a red soule.
- 28:52Speaker 13: Well, it moves us from the realm of a straight
- 28:54Speaker 13: up counterfeit, where we have something that is nearly orbidentially
- 28:58Speaker 13: identical to the realm of potential infringement. But because there
- 29:02Speaker 13: is that generalized test in trademark? Is there a likelihood
- 29:06Speaker 13: of consumer confusion? Might some consumers think that this was
- 29:10Speaker 13: a deal between Donald Trump and Lobaton? That test to
- 29:14Speaker 13: consumer confusion is what we'll control. And I think a
- 29:17Speaker 13: consumer could absolutely be confused as to whether or not
- 29:19Speaker 13: this was a licensed product, or whether or not perhaps
- 29:22Speaker 13: even Lobaton was endorsing Trump, which of course could be
- 29:26Speaker 13: very controversial, both for the company itself and for the
- 29:29Speaker 13: designer himself, but also for consumers who love their movies.
- 29:33Speaker 2: And apparently some social media users were commenting on Instagram.
- 29:39Speaker 2: One said, please, please please sue Donald Trump for infringing
- 29:42Speaker 2: on your Red Soul trademark. Another said, you licensed your
- 29:46Speaker 2: trademark Red Soul? Do that want to be blank?
- 29:49Speaker 13: It's the comment about licensing that is of more concern. Right,
- 29:53Speaker 13: sue him? Does not show consumer confusion? Hey, how dare
- 29:57Speaker 13: you license to him? Is of more concern from a
- 30:00Speaker 13: legal perspective. And you know, there is an instance in
- 30:03Speaker 13: the past when Cristan Lebotant went after a right wing
- 30:06Speaker 13: Belgian politician, a woman who was wearing his Red Soul regularly,
- 30:10Speaker 13: but most importantly for purposes of his complaint on posters
- 30:15Speaker 13: and ads that were targeting Muslim immigrants to Belgium. In
- 30:19Speaker 13: that case, it was the actual Lobatont product showing up
- 30:23Speaker 13: in her political ads and in her political statements, and
- 30:26Speaker 13: so it was an even closer connection. Still, he seems
- 30:29Speaker 13: to have been willing to wade into a fight before
- 30:34Speaker 13: in occasion which a politician tried to associate with the
- 30:37Speaker 13: Red Souls without his permission.
- 30:39Speaker 2: So that would be a business decision whether or not
- 30:42Speaker 2: you want to go after Trump and possibly get the
- 30:47Speaker 2: backlash that people who go after Trump often do. But
- 30:50Speaker 2: on the other hand, do you want your shoes associated
- 30:54Speaker 2: with Trump?
- 30:55Speaker 13: Absolutely, at one level it's a trademark decision. You don't
- 30:58Speaker 13: want your Red Soul to just be a generic indicator
- 31:02Speaker 13: of luxury, a shorthand for a minor product, and so
- 31:05Speaker 13: from a trademark perspective, to avoid becoming generic, you do
- 31:08Speaker 13: have to engage in a certain amount of policing. But yes,
- 31:11Speaker 13: at the level of a business decision, you have to
- 31:14Speaker 13: decide do you dare offend Trump supporters or are you
- 31:17Speaker 13: more concerned about Trump opponents starting to boycott your shoe
- 31:21Speaker 13: if they believe that there's a connection. And there's these
- 31:24Speaker 13: additional concern in terms of a business decision of how
- 31:27Speaker 13: much attention do you want to draw to these sneakers
- 31:30Speaker 13: that were apparently a limited edition, one undone. If you
- 31:34Speaker 13: think he might do it again, maybe you're more likely
- 31:37Speaker 13: to file a lawsuit or at least send a season
- 31:39Speaker 13: to this letter. But if you think it might just
- 31:42Speaker 13: be a quick hit in the media and something that
- 31:45Speaker 13: disappears in the public consciousness, do you want to be
- 31:48Speaker 13: the entity keeping those red souls in the public consciousness,
- 31:52Speaker 13: therefore underscoring the association between your brand and the politician.
- 31:58Speaker 2: What does lou Baiton lose if they don't sue over
- 32:02Speaker 2: the sneakers? Does their mark get watered down?
- 32:05Speaker 13: Sure, there's a potential for a dilution of the mark.
- 32:07Speaker 13: That is to say, now when we see a red soul,
- 32:10Speaker 13: we automatically think leubatont or do we think what it
- 32:13Speaker 13: could be libtont or it could be Trump. And that's
- 32:16Speaker 13: the key to dilutions. So they worry about dilution of
- 32:19Speaker 13: the strength of that mark, and they worry about ultimately
- 32:22Speaker 13: if they allow this one, then the next one and
- 32:24Speaker 13: the next one that happen the red Soul mark actually
- 32:27Speaker 13: becoming generic and the mark actually dying. We refer to
- 32:31Speaker 13: the concept of genericide right. Becoming generic can kill a
- 32:35Speaker 13: mark because it's no longer serving as a source indicator
- 32:38Speaker 13: to consumers. It's no longer a red flag telling consumers, hey,
- 32:42Speaker 13: this is in the best possible way, a red flag.
- 32:45Speaker 13: This is definitely a libtant because you see the red soul.
- 32:48Speaker 2: Let's say Lebton does sue. Would it be for trademark
- 32:51Speaker 2: infringement or trademark dilution?
- 32:54Speaker 13: It could be for both trademark infringement and trademark dilution.
- 32:58Speaker 2: And who do you think would have the better case
- 33:00Speaker 2: in court? I mean, is there a chance that Lewton
- 33:03Speaker 2: could lose.
- 33:04Speaker 13: There's always a chance. You never know what you're going
- 33:06Speaker 13: to get going into court. On the other hand, Lebton
- 33:09Speaker 13: has a very solid footprint with this trademark, and so
- 33:12Speaker 13: I think that in a kickboxing match with these shoes,
- 33:15Speaker 13: I would think that Lebton may very well come out
- 33:17Speaker 13: on top.
- 33:18Speaker 2: I assume it also just does it want to be
- 33:20Speaker 2: associated with that garish, clunky gold sneaker in terms.
- 33:25Speaker 13: Of reputational concern, Yes, you absolutely don't want to be
- 33:28Speaker 13: associated with something that you find distasteful, not only because
- 33:32Speaker 13: of the individual it might be associated with, but because
- 33:35Speaker 13: of the style itself or lack thereof, they are indeed
- 33:38Speaker 13: quite dramatic.
- 33:39Speaker 2: You're so nice to put it that way, Susan.
- 33:43Speaker 13: Well, then there's a question of the quasi flag iconography
- 33:46Speaker 13: as well, which actually is an interesting problem because the
- 33:50Speaker 13: US has law on the books about disrespect or disparagement
- 33:54Speaker 13: of the flag. Technically, you're not supposed to use the
- 33:57Speaker 13: flag in advertising. In fact, the Trademark Office won't register
- 34:00Speaker 13: a trademark that include the flag. Now, obviously there's not
- 34:04Speaker 13: actually a flag on the shoes, just a nod to
- 34:07Speaker 13: the flag with a handful of stars and stripes. But
- 34:10Speaker 13: even though First Amendment law has, oh my goodness, in
- 34:14Speaker 13: the last fifty years, prevented enforcement of any kind of
- 34:19Speaker 13: law that would hemalize anyone for putting a flag on clothing,
- 34:22Speaker 13: or putting a flag on shoes where it might be
- 34:25Speaker 13: dirtied or damaged or otherwise disparage. Nevertheless, you're walking a
- 34:29Speaker 13: fine line when you decide to put a flag or
- 34:32Speaker 13: something that looks like a flag somewhere that might be
- 34:35Speaker 13: considered disrespectful.
- 34:37Speaker 2: So do you think that Leubaton will at least send
- 34:40Speaker 2: a season assist letter, I.
- 34:42Speaker 13: Would hope so. Unfortunately, one of the concerns for Lebaton
- 34:46Speaker 13: is if Lebaton send a season to this letter, it
- 34:49Speaker 13: will immediately be posted. And so it comes back to
- 34:51Speaker 13: the question of do we think Trump will do this
- 34:54Speaker 13: again or do we think Trump's licensee will do this again?
- 34:57Speaker 13: And how much attention do we want to draw to
- 34:59Speaker 13: this If it was indeed a one and done At
- 35:01Speaker 13: Sneaker con.
- 35:02Speaker 2: The company has left itself an out because purchasers of
- 35:07Speaker 2: the sneakers may not actually get red Soul sneakers when
- 35:11Speaker 2: their order arrives in July. On the website it says
- 35:14Speaker 2: the images shown are for illustration purposes only and may
- 35:18Speaker 2: not be an exact representation of the product. So that
- 35:21Speaker 2: leaves them room to get rid of the red Souls.
- 35:24Speaker 13: It does now if they were to do that, and
- 35:27Speaker 13: particularly they were forced to do that to be a
- 35:29Speaker 13: legal action, I think some consumers would be upset because
- 35:33Speaker 13: they're not getting what was pictured and what was promised.
- 35:36Speaker 13: That's not a minor change, that's a significance stylistic change.
- 35:40Speaker 13: But nevertheless, they have indeed left themselves technically a legal out.
- 35:44Speaker 13: But of course if the purpose of these sneakers is
- 35:47Speaker 13: in part to court your audience, and to court the
- 35:50Speaker 13: audience of sneakerheads, a young, male, more urban audience. Then
- 35:56Speaker 13: you absolutely don't want to undermine that, essentially at advertising
- 36:00Speaker 13: or campaign effort, by making your customer to angry when
- 36:03Speaker 13: they receive issues. You don't want lots of negative publicity
- 36:06Speaker 13: following on the initial release of issue.
- 36:09Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Susan. It's always an informative and fun conversation.
- 36:14Speaker 2: That's Susan Scaffiti, a professor at Fordham Law School and
- 36:17Speaker 2: director of the Fashion Law Institute. And that's it for
- 36:20Speaker 2: this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you've can
- 36:23Speaker 2: always get the latest legal news by subscribing and listening
- 36:26Speaker 2: to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and at Bloomberg
- 36:30Speaker 2: dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June Grosso and
- 36:34Speaker 2: this is Bloomberg