Latest / Hygiene Rising / Dental Hygienists Diagnose. Here's the Proof. (Ep 176)
Transcript
- Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: It was great to be joined by our three co-authors of such a important paper in our profession and really appreciate, as I mentioned, their contributions to this paper, which I think is significant and their time to share this all with you. Hopefully you all listened and enjoyed what they had to say. And if you haven't had a chance to read the white paper, I would strongly encourage you to do so. Hello and welcome to Hygiene Rising. I'm your host, Matt Crispin. It's great to be with you again for another awesome episode, a very important episode, we will be talking about the D word, diagnosis. ⁓ if you're not aware, there is a brand new white paper that was released in February from the ADHD in regards to dental hygiene diagnosis and the critical role that it plays in the dental hygiene. Very excited to be joined by our three guests today on our interview on a very, very important topic that we're sharing with all of you about dental hygiene diagnosis, the big D word as everybody might say, and something that I know some of us are scared of, but really excited to be joined by three experts in this area, authors, co-authors of the recently released white paper from ADHD on this specific topic. So, You can review that on the ADHD website. You just simply go to the website or type in slash white papers and you can read not only this white paper, but several of the others on things like professional autonomy and more, some of which we've covered here ⁓ on rising. So ⁓ make you take some time to check those out and bookmark them because they're a great resource. There are great things to share. process of care and I'm really excited to be joined by three great guests later on in our episode to talk a little bit more about the importance of dental hygiene diagnosis, why we must do it, why we can do it and why we need to be doing it if we are not. We'll get to that in a moment, but first a few updates from the ADHD. Hopefully all of you are doing well as we move into spring. I cannot believe that it's already April. We have some awesome webinars coming up this month and some really great episodes. Really excited to be joined by Krista Beatty, Toni McLaRoy, and Darlene Swigert, who were the co-authors of this paper that hopefully you all have had a chance to read. And if not, hopefully you will be reading soon. So Toni, Krista, Darlene, welcome to Hygiene Rising. Really excited to have this conversation with you all today. thank you for spending some time with our listeners today. Toni McLeroy: Thank you. Darlene Swigart: Thank you. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Questions like this come up all the time on social media in regards to what can dental hygienists do? How can they diagnose? Dental hygienists can't diagnose and they certainly can and should and hopefully after listening to today's podcast, you all better understand that concept. hope you all enjoyed this episode. If you are not planning or haven't yet planned on coming to the Integrated Care Summit in... ⁓ All right, well, let's jump right in. This paper is probably long overdue and was really excited to get a glimpse at it and dive in and really excited to spend some time with you to learn a little bit more from your perspective as the authors. you know, maybe I'd like to start, Tony, with you with a question in regards to, you know, have a great webinar later this month on Wednesday, October 22nd that's focused on the 2026 state of work data that you can data that works for you. And excited to be partnering with our friends at go to for that webinar. And then also on Wednesday, April 29th, ⁓ we hosting a webinar with the one and only Joanne Gorenlyan ⁓ and Spolarich. The paper really opens with this bold statement that there's a misconception that dental hygienists do not diagnose. We often see this on social media message boards and all of this sort of thing. And this is something we really have to dispel. So where did that misconception come from in your opinion? And why is it so persistent in our profession? Colorado in just a couple of weeks. I would strongly encourage you to still consider coming Darlene who one of our guests today mentioned she's gonna be there. I'm gonna be there speaking I'm hopefully you had a chance to listen to our podcast last month in regards to medical dental integration We had two guests that are also speakers at that conference so really to join our colleagues in Denver or just outside of Denver in a couple of weeks at the integrated care summit to learn a lot more about how ⁓ those two are also joining us ⁓ a podcast that will be released ⁓ this month, probably in just a couple of weeks, that's really focused ⁓ redefining periodontal disease management. So we a really great webinar for you later in along with ⁓ a podcast dives a little bit deeper into another white paper that's focused on periodontal management. Toni McLeroy: Well, that misconception didn't come from one place. It's really the result of history, language, and how our roles were originally defined within the dental care model. If you go back to the early development of dental hygiene, our profession was intentionally positioned as preventive and supportive. Diagnosis, by both legal definition and professional culture, was reserved for dentists. But here's where it gets interesting. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Hopefully last night you all had the opportunity to participate in listening to the first ever ADHDs all member meeting. This is a new format as a result of some of the governance change that ADHD continues to move forward with. It was really exciting to participate in that last night. I enjoyed in, hearing some of the updates and really excited about the new strategic plan. If you want to learn a little bit more about that plan. dental care and behavioral health and medical care all can be better integrated together. So those of you that are going to be at the National Oral Health Conference, I hope to see many of you there later this week. I'm heading out Saturday. I'll be speaking a couple of times over the course of the couple days at the conference. So really looking forward to that opportunity. Toni McLeroy: Even as the scope of dental hygiene expanded, the language didn't keep up. In education, our students are trained or were trained to collect data, assess conditions, identify problems, but very deliberately not to use the word diagnosis. Instead, we used a safer, more indirect like assessment collection, clinical findings, things like that. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: And really looking forward to just connecting with many of my dental public health colleagues that will be there. if I haven't seen you in a while, we can connect at the National Oral Health Conference. And if not at the Integrated Care Summit in Colorado, and if not there, then certainly make sure that you're making plans to join us in Fort Worth in the fall for ADHD 2026. you can visit the website and learn a bit more. couple of other important updates, ⁓ few other in-person opportunities ⁓ webinars, Wednesday, May ⁓ with our partners at Cure-A-Dont, there is a non-invasive caries treatment webinar that will be presented by Lisa Mayo. And then also some of you may be heading to the ⁓ diabetes Toni McLeroy: So we created this kind of semantic workaround where dental hygienists were doing the cognitive work of diagnosis, but we stopped short of naming it. And at the same time, state practice acts and regulatory language often avoided the term altogether, not because we weren't thinking critically, but because diagnosis was seen as a protective word tied to dentistry. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: So until next time, continue to think outside the box, be comfortable with being uncomfortable, and continue to imagine what the future of dental hygiene can look like. oral health symposium that ADHD is putting ⁓ in Oklahoma City ⁓ occurs right before the National Oral Health Conference, which is where I'll be heading this coming weekend. Very excited to be speaking at that conference once again. Excited to see some of my public health colleagues in the coming days ⁓ hopefully reconnect with many of you. And hopefully if you're a listener, ⁓ up and say hello. you... Toni McLeroy: And that reinforced the idea both legally and culturally that diagnosis wasn't part of our role. And over time, that message became internalized. We've had generations of dental hygienists who were educated in systems where their clinical judgment was essential, but not explicitly recognized as diagnostic reasoning. So even highly skilled clinicians began to describe their work in more procedural or task-based terms. And that's really where Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Want one of our great new stickers for your water bottle or your laptop? I will have them with me. So come up and say hi. Our new hygiene rising logo is out there and we hope you're enjoying not only the new name and the new face, but also all of the great content that we continue to bring you. So if you have an idea for an episode, please don't hesitate to reach out. Always great to hear from our listeners and make sure that you hit subscribe so that every time a new episode is released. Toni McLeroy: what the key issue is because language shapes our identity. And when we consistently describe what we do as just assessment or just cleaning, it minimizes the level of expertise that's involved and makes complex clinical decision-making sound routine or mechanical. But really in reality, every time a dental hygienist determines why inflammation is present or. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: you get that downloaded right onto your device. So if you're doing some traveling, make sure you download a couple episodes upcoming and we will be having some really great guests coming up. ⁓ other things to look forward to in the coming months. Of the integrated care summit here in May in Denver. We did an episode. Our last episode was focused on this. You can hear from some of the speakers that will be speaking at that meeting. There's still time. Toni McLeroy: identifies risk factors for disease or evaluates barriers to behavioral change. They're making diagnostic decisions. The disconnect isn't in the doing, it's in the naming. And when something isn't named, it's very difficult to teach consistently, to measure effectively, or even to advocate for at a professional level. So this misconception has persisted not because dental hygienists don't diagnose, Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: to plan and register and attend that meeting just outside of Denver, Colorado. It's gonna be a great, great experience. I'm again, really looking forward and excited to be speaking on a topic that is just very, very near and dear and I'm very passionate about, which is medical dental integration. So make sure you carve out some time and join us in May Colorado. Those dates are May ⁓ through the 17th. Toni McLeroy: but because for a long time we were taught not to say that we do. And what the white paper really challenges us to do is close that gap by aligning our language with our actual clinical expertise. Because once we name it, we can strengthen it. And once we strengthen it, we elevate both person-centered care and the profession as a whole. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Also, you're going to want to make sure and mark your calendar for the ADHA's annual conference that's held this year in Fort Worth, Texas. That will be in September, so make sure and mark your calendar and check back in May for registration, which will open soon. ⁓ of really great opportunities and one last one that I will encourage you all to think about, and that is ⁓ International Symposium on Dental Hygiene, which this year is being held. Yeah, you know, it's really interesting and I live in the state of Wisconsin and I often hear hygienists here say, well, it says right in the statutes that dental hygienists can't diagnose. And I say, you're actually right. It does, but you need to keep reading the rest of the sentence because it doesn't say dental hygienists may not diagnose period. says dental hygienists may not diagnose outside the scope of practice of dental hygiene. And it's such held in Milan, Italy this summer. The conference is held on July 9th through the 11th in Milan. There are some activities going on for the International Federation of Dental Hygienists House of Delegates a couple days before that. So our delegates from the United States, Tammy Filippiak and Kelly Jakes will be representing the United States at that meeting. Of course, Darlene Swigart: Yes. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: a critical piece to we do as dental hygienists. And I just recently happened to stumble across a dentist that was talking, he was a social media post and he was talking about the importance of collaboration within an office. And he talked a lot about how much time we as dental hygienists spend with patients as compared to a dentist that is coming in to do that periodic exam for ⁓ five when we might have spent Jill Rethman is the current president of IFDH. So it's great to see the United States representing well there. I also have seen many of you celebrating as well as myself celebrating the fact that we'll be speaking at the IFDH or ISDH meeting in Milan. So I'm really excited. I'm going to have the opportunity to speak at least two times at that meeting. just really excited to be able to once again share some of the work that we're doing internationally. It's been great to see many of you. 40 or 45 minutes with the patient and how much more we're able to see and provide context to as well as potentially even diagnose and treatment plan within our scope of dental hygiene. So interesting to see and hear from your perspective, kind of the evolution and sort of why that exists and maybe why it still exists in ⁓ culture and hopefully something we can continue to sort of redefine. So Darlene, wanna go to you and. across the country and even some of my international colleagues that I've met at ISDH meetings in the past, celebrating their acceptance to speak at that upcoming meeting as well. So make sure you plan accordingly. It's a great meeting. ⁓ I know I have my flights booked. I'm gonna be doing some traveling in Italy, really excited to visit the country for the very first time and do some sightseeing before we get down to work in Milan in July. So. and ask a question, you know, in particular about the paper, you know, you all define dental hygiene diagnosis more than periodontal classification. So can you kind of walk our listeners through how broad the scope of dental hygiene diagnosis really is? And just give us an example that might open people's eyes on this. Check out that on the ISDH website. You can just simply search for International Federation of Dental Hygienists or International Symposium on Dental Hygiene and you can learn a bit more about this really, really great international event that takes place every couple of years. So make sure to check that out. I'm gonna transition and get to our interview. Really, really important interview, as I said on the onset. Dental hygiene diagnosis is something that we need to be doing, we should be doing, and we absolutely must be doing. Darlene Swigart: Sure. Many professions and not just health care require critical thinking to make and make a diagnosis. For example, you have a drain backed up at your home. You call a plumber. They assess the situation. They determine the problem, which is a form of diagnosis, and then they provide the solution. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: You'll hear from our guests who are the co-authors of a very important white paper that if you haven't read, I would highly encourage you to check out and really integrate dental hygiene diagnosis into your day-to-day work. So without further ado, let's get to our interview. Darlene Swigart: As dental hygienists, we practice epically according to the American Dental Hygienists Association Standards for Clinical Practice. These are our guidelines that include our thorough assessment, determination of dental hygiene diagnoses, and the implementation of evidence-based care. We are all trained to determine a patient's periodontal classification. And it's easy to think of that as the patient's only dental hygiene diagnosis. But I'd like your listeners to take a moment to think about the full range of dental hygiene diagnosis we actually encounter every day in patient care. For example, a patient might come into your practice with a blood pressure reading of 149 over 89. They have medication for hypertension, but they state they don't take it consistently. dental hygiene diagnosis in this case could be a risk for emergency due to ⁓ high blood pressure with a care plan that includes a referral to their physician and stress reduction protocols. Other common dental hygiene diagnosis includes xerostomia due to medication, dental anxiety or fear related to a previous difficult or painful dental visit, risk for injury from playing contact sports without a athletic mouth guard. high risk for oral cancer due to smoking, with the inclusion of tobacco sensation in the care plan, high risk for dental caries due to an area of demineralization with preventive protocols included in the care plan. Even attrition related to malocclusion or bruxism. And then we refer to the dentist because they're the one that would be providing treatment for that. Each of these patient encounters involves a diagnostic process that includes analyzing the assessment findings, identifying the needs and risks, and recommending the appropriate intervention. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: And you know, Krista, I'd like to go to you and talk a little bit about the, you know, so what for clinicians. So, you know, the paper makes the case that without a diagnostic framework that patient care risks becoming task oriented rather than outcome driven. So can you maybe just help us paint a picture of what that looks like in a real patient encounter and how dental hygiene diagnosis changes that? Krista Beaty: Yes, absolutely. to the routine nature ⁓ our clinical dental hygiene practice, there's a risk that for time efficiency, hygienists may have a prescriptive list of tasks that are provided to each patient. So an example of that might be an established prophylaxis patient that the hygienist has seen over years maybe. the prophylaxis patient comes in and we give them their four horizontal bite wings, they get their periodic examination and that only happens once a year. ⁓ we do a spot probing or assessment and then we do our scaling and polishing and then we do that over ⁓ each of the prophylaxis patients we see during the course of the day. But are those patients really being evaluated for their individual risk factors each time? Or are we just assuming that their appointment will progress the same way each time we see that patient? So the dental hygiene diagnostic framework requires a more individualized and comprehensive approach. An example might look something like this. A year-long established patient comes in for their six-month adult prophylaxis. The dental hygienist does a thorough review of the medical, dental, and social history and notes that this patient has had a recent major life change, such as the death of a family member. Assessment findings show a slight increase in blood pressure and pulse, a generalized increase in leading on probing. Pocket depths may be increased from a three millimeters to a generalized four millimeters. Pingible margin may show some increases in redness and edema. So should we then just continue with the prophylaxis as in previous appointments or should this appointment look different today for this patient? What outcome should we expect then with a patient like this who presents with these types of changes. So the dental hygiene diagnostic framework takes into account all these oral and life changes and the treatment plan then it should be adjusted accordingly. So respectors may increase for periodontitis due to increased pocket depth and inflammation. Maybe vertical bite wings would be more appropriate this visit versus horizontal bite wings. Perhaps instead of a periodic evaluation, we should do a periodontal evaluation, our DO180 code. local anesthesia or nitrous oxide could be offered. The increased stress that this patient is experiencing may result in diagnostic statements related to stress reduction protocols. The treatment plan should then include possible referral to social services or mental health services. And then the recall or re-care interval may need to be increased to manage this patient's disease state because of all of these different factors. So this is an example perhaps of how an individualized encounter should be based on this framework. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Yeah, you know, it makes me think of an example that I often say to hygienists that say, I can't diagnose, know, dental hygienist can't diagnose. And I like to give the example of, well, this is what it would sound like if a dental hygienist can't diagnose is the dentist would come into the operatory and sit down next to the patient and they would say to the patient, they would say to the dental hygienist, you know, well, what did you see in there? What do you, what's going on? And this is what it would sound like from the dental hygienist. silence, right? what it sounds like if a dentist isn't diagnosing because ⁓ spent, as I said, 30, 40, 45 minutes of the patient assessing all of these different things that now we want to collaborate with that dentist on to, you know, put together a plan to ⁓ appropriately treat that patient. And I ⁓ the examples that you gave, Krista, about, you know, it really needing to be tailored to the patient. We can't just treat every single patient the same way. because we all know if we go to our medical provider or even our dental provider, we don't want to be treated the same way that the patient before us is treated because we have different things going on in our mouth, going on in our health. So great, great examples. I would love our listeners to get to know you all a little bit more. So maybe Tony, you could start and just share a little bit about your background, your journey in dental hygiene, sort of who you are, what you're doing, where you're at. I know you're all educators, so just share with our listeners a little bit more about yourselves. Toni McLeroy: Sure. Well, my name is Toni McElroy and I have known since I was the age six that I wanted to be a dental hygienist. And my childhood dentist saw something in me that I did not know I was going to become and encouraged me through the years to become a dental hygienist. And it really, for me, has been a match made in heaven. have never would like to say I've never really worked a day of my life because I've loved what I've done every day. So I have had the really the joy of clinical practice for 20 years, my first 20 years, and then I entered academia about 15 years ago, and I have loved being an educator for the past 15 years. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: and you're an educator wear. Toni McLeroy: at State College of Florida in the sunny state of Florida. So we are on the West Coast. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Great, great. And let's go to you, Chris, to share with our listeners a little bit about your background. Krista Beaty: Absolutely. My name is Krista Beaty and I've been in dentistry since 1999, first as an expanded functions dental assistant and then as a dental hygienist. I graduated from dental hygiene school in 2004 and I've had, I just loved my dental hygiene career. As I was doing full-time hygiene and my body was starting to feel the strain, I started to look at getting a master's degree. And actually that's where I got to meet Darlene Swigert because she and I were in the same master's program. then we took a job, an educating job at the same university. So I'm currently at Oregon Institute of Technology and I've been here since 2017. And I'm the department chair for dental hygiene ⁓ and taken on a lot more administrative duties. But because of my work with Darlene and teaching together and going to school together, I've been included on this very important work in this white paper. And it's just been my pleasure working with both Tony and Darlene on this. ⁓ Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Great, and Darlene, share with our listeners a little bit about you. Darlene Swigart: Yeah, hello. Thank you for joining us. I've worked in clinical practice versus a dental assistant and then as a dental hygienist for over 30 years and then decided I want to be an educator. My kids were grown and I go, have the opportunity to make a big change. And so I went back and got my master's degree. And like Krista said, working at Oregon Tech. ⁓ And I am their first year clinic lead, so I am in clinic quite a bit. And I teach prevention courses. ⁓ done quite a lot of research since I've been in education on dental hygiene diagnosis and social determinants of health. And so those are my two focuses, and that's why I probably asked to be a part of this white paper. So thank you for having us. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: let's keep moving along. So Darlene, we're gonna come to you and talk about the Gremlin and Swigert model that now includes social determinants of health as a diagnostic domain. And that's a expansion. So how should dental hygienists ⁓ in a traditional practice setting actually start to integrate that into their workflow? Darlene Swigart: I am so glad you asked that question and it's very near and dear to my heart. good news is that it can be incorporated quickly and easily into a busy workflow. The new ADH standards included social determinants of health and assessment, dental hygiene diagnosis and care planning. And so spent many years in clinical. practice, I understand that before adding anything new to a busy day, it's important to understand why, why it's, you know, needed and why I should do it. There's a growing body of research demonstrating how unmet social determinative health needs can negatively impact outcomes for conditions like diabetes, cardiovascular disease, dental caries, periodontal disease, and oral cancer. I teach in the Dental Hygiene Educational Center and we have included social determinants of health assessment into our student clinical practice. that was probably over a year ago. ⁓ found it to be a very quick and easy process that provides much needed help to those patients with those needs. We added the assessment notes ⁓ into clinic chart notes. And so, What we do in education can be done in private practice. So because these are sensitive questions for patients to ask patients, when the student gets to the part of the assessment where they're going to start asking the questions, they state this, I ask everyone about food, housing, and other basic needs, as these can affect dental health. This helps me support you and offer resources if needed. Please let me know if you have any difficulties in the following areas. And then a yes to any of these questions would mean they have need. So they go through establishing safe and stable housing, having money for worries about food will run out, difficulties finding childcare, dependent care, ⁓ unable get medicine or medical care, difficulty understanding health information. difficulty finding a job, difficulty completing education or job training, struggles with transportation, or struggles with feelings of loneliness. We have found this assessment literally takes less than a minute. If the patient says yes to one of the needs, then a social determinant of health diagnosis, dental hygiene diagnosis is determined. In our chart model that Dr. Greenlian and I developed, includes the social determinant of health dental hygiene diagnosis. so we have social determinants, like the diagnostic statement would be social determinant of health needs due to communication barriers, education barriers, financial strain, food insecurity, health literacy barriers, housing or utility barriers, insufficient social support. personal safety concerns, transportation barriers. Here's a few examples of a dental hygiene diagnosis documentation related to these needs. Social determinant of health concerns related to food insecurity or financial strain following a job loss. Another example could be insufficient social support related to bereavement after the loss of a spouse. There are many community resources available to address these needs. our care plans include a referral. And how we do that ⁓ ⁓ patients receive referral card. And on referral card is a QR code to the findhelp.org website. And the ⁓ students ⁓ the scan the code. They go onto the website. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: you Darlene Swigart: The patient enters their zip code, because it's throughout the United States. They can select their preferred language. And then the student just shows them, OK, you can click Housing. Housing's a need for you. They click it. And the resources for that community are there. so it's truly an amazing resource. Patients take the card home. And we've had patients return to our clinic to share how they access the help they desperately needed, making a real difference in their lives. So really the assessment takes one minute and then or less. And then with those patients with needs, the diagnosis and the ⁓ really just is adding a few minutes. ⁓ really is truly life-changing and worth it. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Yeah, and you answered several of the follow up questions that I was formulating as you were describing there, which was, you know, what resources do you then provide to the patients? You know, the Find Help resource that you mentioned is a great one. I'm ⁓ familiar that. And ⁓ even to hear the stories when the patients come back of the success they've had. So that's, that's really great to hear. So ⁓ Darlene Swigart: Yeah, we can I say we also we refer to the website everybody gets that referral, but like the senior with ⁓ a senior citizen who's lonely we refer to the senior citizen center in a local community. We refer to mental health there's other referrals that can be given, but we definitely give find help referral to pretty much everybody with a need. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Yeah, that's great to hear. Krista, let's go to you. Your all's research found a lot of variation in how dental hygiene programs define and teach dental hygiene diagnosis. So what's the risk to patients and to the profession when our own curricula are not speaking the same language? Krista Beaty: This is an excellent question and we were so excited to see this on your list, Matt. this terminology, and I know Tony alluded to this earlier, the idea that we're doing the work, but the terminology is where the problem seems to be. So standardizing this terminology relating to dental hygiene diagnosis is essential to supporting the dental hygiene education process. When we as a profession don't agree ⁓ on these definitions and concepts, then advocating for our profession becomes very difficult. The important critical thinking and diagnostic skills that we employ every day during patient care may not be valued by the public that we serve or by the dentists who may then think that a dental assistant could perform the same tasks. And we see wide variances in the language of state practice acts, which could potentially affect the portability of dental hygiene professionals between states as well. And we really believe that standardizing this language could help alleviate at least some of these problems. lack of standardization and education related to dental hygiene diagnostic terminology can potentially create gaps in the continuity of the process of care. ⁓ for example, perhaps a dentist assumes the dental hygienist will discuss reported changes in the patient's social or dental history. but the hygienist is assuming that the dentist is gonna handle that. So the dental hygiene, pardon me, the dental hygiene diagnostic framework that is consistently applied helps us to ensure better communication between the dental team members and the patients that we serve. And this really is gonna start in the dental hygiene programs. That's where this standardization of terminology begins. So patients are gonna benefit from this. diagnostic model because it guides patient conversations. It improves their understanding and their ability to make decisions regarding their own oral and systemic health. So documentation of individualized findings and the expected outcomes is enhanced and it enables better continuity of care and better health. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Great. I'm to come to you for this next question. So you all are calling on CODA to reinstate dental hygiene diagnosis explicitly into accreditation standard 2-13. So what happened and why does this specific wording in accreditation standards matter so much? Toni McLeroy: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. This is such an important question because on the surface it can sound like we're just talking about semantics or wording, but in reality, accreditation language has a profound impact on how our entire profession is educated and practiced. Commission on Dental Accreditation, or CODA, sets the standards that every dental hygiene program in the country must follow. And these standards don't just guide curriculum, they shape what's taught, how it's assessed, and ultimately, how future clinicians think. At the present time, CODA does define the dental hygiene diagnosis as identification of an existing or potential oral health problem that a dental hygienist is qualified and licensed to treat. And historically, dental hygiene diagnosis was more clearly embedded in accreditation standards, including standard 213, which is the standard that speaks to ⁓ process of care. graduates must be competent in providing the dental hygiene process of care, which includes that comprehensive collection of patient data, analysis of assessment findings, and use of critical thinking in order to address the patient's dental hygiene treatment needs, and goes on to the establishment of a care plan, the provision of comprehensive patient-centered treatment, and so on. And although standard 213 implies teaching to the definition of dental hygiene diagnosis, it stopped clearly defining it or naming it. I should say naming it. And that shift matters more than people might realize because in education, what gets explicitly stated gets emphasized. It gets built into learning objectives, classroom discussions, clinical evaluations, and competency assessments. But when something becomes implied rather than stated, programs are left to interpret it, and that's where variation begins. And that inconsistency can have ripple effects. It affects clinical confidence, communication with other providers, documentation practices, and even how dental hygienists advocate for themselves in the workplace. So when the white paper calls for reinstating dental hygiene diagnosis explicitly, explicitly into standard 213. It's not about adding something new, it's really about naming what already exists and ensuring it is consistently taught across all programs. Accreditation standards are powerful. They are the foundation that curricula are built on. And the reality is this, if we want dental hygiene diagnosis to be universally understood, valued in practice, it has to be universally taught. And if we want it to be taught, it has to be clearly and intentionally written into the standards that guide education. So the wording matters because wording drives teaching, teaching shapes practice, and practice ultimately defines our profession. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: So I want to shift gears and talk a little bit about policy and state practice acts. We know that across the country, our practice acts vary, which doesn't make a lot of sense. We talk a lot about this when it comes to supervision and scope. And no surprise, there's not consistency in the way that dental hygiene diagnosis is or even utilized. so, Krista, three states, Colorado, Oregon, and Maine. explicitly named dental hygiene diagnosis in their practice act. So what does the landscape look like in the other 47 states and what's the most practical path forward for a change? Krista Beaty: Yes, it's true that only those three states actually use that phrase dental hygiene diagnosis, but we did find that many other states actually are using that same definition that COTA was using or that the ADHD is using. They're just not using that same phrase. So we found that 20 other states are still authorizing dental hygienists to perform those same levels of assessment and treatment planning. that are in this definition that we have proposed in the white paper. Additionally, 38 states are allowing Dell hygienists to diagnose the need for and place sealants in community health settings. Another 42 states are allowing independently practicing hygienists to provide prophylaxis without prior dentist approval. So we found that across all of these states, there are quite a few of, you know, there's a lot of applications to this same terminology being done. It's just that the terminology isn't exactly the same and we think that's where that communication is breaking down and it all comes back to that same definition. So you said what is the most practical path for change and that's why you know we're promoting first starting an education getting that established this is what dental hygiene diagnosis is this is the framework we want everybody to use. that's going to then train our workforce to go out and advocate for our profession for dental hygiene diagnosis and that standardization of terminology. So it's going to start in the schools, we hope, and then it's going to go out and we're going to release hygienists that are going to be passionate for advocating for our profession. Educating the public so they know what it is that we do and why what we do is important to their overall health and their treatment outcomes. Educating dentists and other dental team members so that they know what we mean by that. We're not trying to expand our scope. That isn't really our goal. We're just saying this is what we are already doing. This is what dentists expect us to be able to do. So let's call it the same thing. So we see it, and Tony mentioned a ripple effect, this idea that by starting at the educational level and then branching out with advocacy, branching out into the CODA standards, is the way to affect that change, bring about that standardization and then that will help future portability, we hope. And even state practice acts through advocacy, can actually incorporate that standardized wording and then that will bring clarity, we think, to this idea of dental hygiene diagnostics in that framework. Toni McLeroy: You're muted. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: was muted. Your description of the states that allow dental hygienists to determine the need for sealants reminds me of an interesting story that I just want to quickly share. In our state in the state of Wisconsin, dental hygienists can determine the need for sealants in, for example, like in a school setting without the diagnosis of a dentist needing to happen first. And there's oftentimes been Questions raised around this at for example our state dental board State examining board meetings and we're oftentimes there to provide some testimony or insight on that and What we said is that you know, yes dental hygienists are ⁓ you know, diagnosing the need for a sealant and in many ways ⁓ they're diagnosing or not the tooth has decay and at what level because they're determining whether that that tooth is you know, able to be sealed if the decay is, you know, maybe just in the enamel. And I oftentimes chuckle because don't necessarily get agreement from ⁓ dentist colleagues on this board that will say things like, well, you're not determining whether or not there's decay. You're just determining whether or not there isn't decay. And have to take a step back and just go, okay, yep. Darlene Swigart: Thank you. Toni McLeroy: Potato, potato. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Yep, we'll just keep doing these sealants in schools, but if that's the way you want to look at it, then we'll just keep on keeping on. ⁓ is ⁓ interesting concept and it is just this ongoing struggle of us being okay with saying, yes, we do diagnose. ⁓ we have to, if ⁓ didn't do it, we wouldn't be doing our patients any So. Toni McLeroy: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Let's move on and look a little bit into the future now and talk a little bit about kind of looking forward. I want to go to you with a question that ⁓ on a topic that I'm really interested in a lot in regards to artificial intelligence and the use of AI. And this showing up in the paper as a diagnostic adjunct. We know that ⁓ clinicians using AI in a variety of different ways, whether it's Toni McLeroy: Mm-hmm. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: reading radiographs or annotating pathology. So what's your take on how AI fits into the dental hygiene diagnosis process and maybe what concerns you most about how it might be adopted? Toni McLeroy: Well, artificial intelligence, AIs, it's an incredibly promising adjunct in our dental hygiene process of care, and especially when it comes to assessment tasks like reading radiographs, as you said, and maybe flagging potential pathology or identifying patterns that might otherwise be missed. And it does have the potential to improve efficiency and free up time so clinicians can focus more on person-centered care and clinical decision making. But with that said, it's important Also to recognize that they're evolving rapidly and they're not without limitations. So AI should support, not replace, clinical judgment. We still need to critically evaluate what the technology is showing us and consider the full patient context. There are also important concerns to keep in mind. Data privacy and HIPAA compliance are major considerations, especially when patient information's being processed. through those third party platforms. And just as important as defining what constitutes appropriate use, where AI enhances care versus where it may introduce risk or over-reliance. So while it's an exciting tool and being used by many, it requires thoughtful integration. And the goal isn't to hand over diagnosis to technology, it's to use technology to strengthen the diagnostic process. while keeping us, the clinician, firmly at the center. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Yeah, yeah, great assessment. I want to wrap up with you ⁓ you know, dental hygienists going to be listening to this and probably wanting to go to their office tomorrow morning ⁓ and do different. So ⁓ what advice would give to a dental hygienist that listens to this and decides I'm going to go in tomorrow and, you know, bust out the doors and ⁓ tell my dentist I'm going to start diagnosing things? ⁓ You know, what what would you want those things to be and what advice would you maybe give to those dental hygienists that are listening today? Darlene Swigart: Well, to start, if the dental hygiene diagnosis feels new to them or if they've ever thought it's something they aren't allowed to do, we want them to recognize and reassure them that they're actually making these diagnosis every day already in their work. a dental hygiene diagnosis is simply a way of identifying the patient's concerns and needs that we can address. mean providing stress reduction protocol strategies, teaching ways to prevent dental caries or manage dry mouth, offering guidance on dental or diet or smoking sensation, or referring patients to other professionals when the care needed is beyond our scope. We already do these things. And so I really, think all three of us would like people, hygienists to be just thinking, what do I already do? How have I already been doing this without calling it a dental hygiene diagnosis? key really to recognizing that these diagnoses are part of the meaningful everyday impact we have on our patients' oral and overall health. With in mind, we would encourage you, the listener, to start documenting the dental hygiene diagnosis in the patient's chart. They haven't already begun assessing for social determinants of health. We invite you to integrate this valuable step into the workflow. wanna thank everybody for listening to this ⁓ and really for the care and dedication that each one of you bring to your patients every day. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: Well, Krista, Tony, Darlene, thank you so much for both your time today and definitely for the time and commitment that you made in putting together this white paper. think it's, as I mentioned in the onset, kind of a long time coming to really help our ADHD members and really the dental hygiene and dental ⁓ profession at large better understand. what dental hygiene diagnosis is and why it's critical to the work that we do every single day. So thank you very much for that contribution. last words that any of you wanna share as we wrap up and ⁓ things out here and people head on their way to start better understanding dental hygiene diagnosis and read the paper if they haven't? Krista Beaty: would just like to say ⁓ I ⁓ like the listeners to hear that we really want involvement and collaboration across the whole dental team. We of course advocate for dental hygiene in our profession and the things that we are so passionate about doing for our patients, but we value our dentists and ⁓ training and we value our dental assistants and the supports that they provide. So we do We just want to say we value the entire dental team and we're hoping that this white paper and the things that we're hoping to incorporate into dental hygiene education will benefit the whole profession and ultimately our patients. Matt Crespin, MPH, RDH, FADHA: All Well, thank you all very much. I really appreciate your time and thanks for joining us today. Toni McLeroy: Agree? Thank you for having us. Krista Beaty: Thank you, Matt. Darlene Swigart: Thank you for having us.