Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / The Accuracy Crisis in Advertising: Scott McKinley on Bad Data and the Hidden Tax on CTV
Transcript
- 0:03This is signal and noise, bringing clarity to data, tech
- 0:07and AI. Hey everybody.
- 0:14Welcome back to Signal and Noise.
- 0:16I'm Brett House, joined by my Co host Real Longacre.
- 0:20And today we have a phenomenal guest, Scott McKinley, the
- 0:25founder of Truth Set and someone that's been 25 plus years.
- 0:30I don't think we're counting up to 30, right, Scott, because I
- 0:32stopped counting at 25. I know that it, digital
- 0:35advertising, identity, data strategy, analytics.
- 0:39You and I crossed paths briefly at Nielsen, although you were
- 0:42there for, I was there for about 5 years.
- 0:44You were there for what, eight years?
- 0:45Yeah, something like that. And then you've been, you've
- 0:48been now on this entrepreneurial, entrepreneurial
- 0:51streak. You founded IDFI, you sold that
- 0:54and exited that business and now you've founded Truth Set.
- 0:58And for, for those that don't know, Truth Set's a really
- 1:01interesting company. Scott is a work one of my old
- 1:05new star executives, Greg Galetta that was behind one ID,
- 1:09which was sort of our identity machine learning based identity
- 1:12resolution solution. And and Scott is a former
- 1:16Olympic cyclist, which I like to say, I know I've mentioned that
- 1:19to you a couple of times because I'm a cyclist, but I'm more of a
- 1:22weakened warrior. You were a professional athlete.
- 1:24So is Greg Galletta. But welcome to the show, Scott.
- 1:27Thrilled to have you trying to connect paths and impossible.
- 1:32But you know, 15 meetings a day is a lot and we ended up
- 1:35connecting. But would love for you to
- 1:37introduce yourself to the to the audience and tell everybody a
- 1:39little bit about you. And if I if I missed anything in
- 1:42your background. Thanks, Brett, and thanks Rio
- 1:45for having me on. Yeah, it should be a fun
- 1:48conversation. I you know, it's funny about the
- 1:5025 years thing. I think everybody just just cuts
- 1:53it off at 25 because anything older than that, like it ages
- 1:56you into into the Methuselah care, you know?
- 2:00Obsolescence. I mean, it's what's scary about
- 2:03that. I, my first toe in the water in
- 2:07digital was in 1997, the year after I retired from, from bike
- 2:12racing. I, I had a partner.
- 2:15We taught ourselves how to code and we were building websites
- 2:19for companies. And during that year I said just
- 2:23big business back then, right? I said, I think like part one
- 2:26time. I said, I think, I think we
- 2:26missed it. I think we're a little too late.
- 2:29We entered that in 1997, but that's how it started.
- 2:33And then I, I, you know, ironically, this is, this is a
- 2:37funny story, but we got time. We'll tell it I needed a job.
- 2:42Like a real job. Because I got married, my wife
- 2:44got pregnant, we realized. That'll force you to get a real
- 2:49job fast. Huh.
- 2:49Yeah, Yeah. It makes you do things.
- 2:51And you you have a. Mortgage.
- 2:53Yeah. And I and I picked up a a
- 2:55freelance gig with Cox Enterprises, which Cox at the
- 3:00time. So Cox Communications like well.
- 3:03Enterprise is a whole, is the overall comedy.
- 3:04Communications is one of them. It was and they had this is,
- 3:08they had done this thing just about 6 months earlier where
- 3:11they said, oh, the Internet's here.
- 3:13So we're going to treat this like another medium.
- 3:15Cox. That's what we do.
- 3:17Cox started in newspapers in the 1800s.
- 3:21Literally way back, yeah. And then they have, they have
- 3:23radio stations. They have.
- 3:24This is what they, from their perspective, this is no big
- 3:29deal. It's another medium.
- 3:30What we do since the 1860s when they bought up a bunch of
- 3:35newspapers in the Midwest, that was great.
- 3:37They built that up. They created the first, you
- 3:39know, big sort of aggregated newspaper empire.
- 3:43And then what was next? Radio came along.
- 3:46What do they do? Cox Radio is still huge, so they
- 3:48dominated radio. They have tons of stations
- 3:50across the country still, and it was television.
- 3:54They spun off the radio stations.
- 3:55I think they're just in like an MVPD cable company.
- 3:58I don't know, I don't follow what they've done yet.
- 4:00But the point is every time a new medium from radio,
- 4:03newspapers, radio, television and cable, they just, this is
- 4:07cool. They would allocate funds very
- 4:09smart. They would try to get as much
- 4:11leverage off their existing properties as they could to
- 4:14support the new, the new media empire that they were going to
- 4:17build, which they invariably did.
- 4:19And so when the Internet came along and they're like, we're
- 4:21just going to allocate $100 million to new media and they
- 4:25Cox, they call it Cox Interactive Media.
- 4:27And again, Peter Winter was hard to run it.
- 4:29He's a really good guy. But you know, this was a
- 4:32different animal. This was the animal that was
- 4:33gonna eat all the other animals, basically.
- 4:36Yeah. So the transformation playbook
- 4:38didn't quite apply to the to the new Internet, right, Because
- 4:40we've heard a similar story from Jessica Hogue, who you know,
- 4:43yeah, is that you get officer at Hearst and she talks about, you
- 4:46know, this continuation of sort of transformation and
- 4:49reinvention based on new media over a couple 100 years.
- 4:53Yeah, but you're suggesting that it doesn't necessarily.
- 4:55It didn't apply quite as easily as they thought.
- 4:58The best example. The best example was you know
- 5:01what supports newspapers Classifieds.
- 5:03Classifieds were the workhorse. Craigslist killed that.
- 5:06Yeah, and. I was.
- 5:08So I was in San Francisco there. I was in San Francisco.
- 5:10They were done in Atlanta and, and Craigslist showed up and
- 5:14they're like, Scott, what's going on with this Craigslist
- 5:16thing? You know, is it a, it's a joke?
- 5:18It's right. What wouldn't worry about this?
- 5:19And I was like, oh, Oh, yeah, you have to worry about.
- 5:22They're coming for your. They're coming for your revenue.
- 5:2440% of your revenue is gone like just your fingers, right,
- 5:27that's. Right.
- 5:28That's what happened and it's when you stand back and look at
- 5:31it, Craigslist and the rest of the online classifieds players
- 5:37like those classifieds.com, there were some other ones, eBay
- 5:39basically we used to look kind of like a classifieds at the
- 5:42start. Yeah, they turned.
- 5:44They turned Craigslist turned a $24 billion industry into a $2
- 5:49billion industry. Like the whole thing depressed.
- 5:52Yeah. And like, you know, overnight,
- 5:54like in terms of the history of Cox, like this was a a drop in
- 5:58their history, sort of ocean, right timeline, you know.
- 6:02Craigslist made it initially it was 0 for them and they slowly
- 6:04built up a small into a small business for the same shitty
- 6:07website. I just thought that was
- 6:08fascinating but it but you're right, it gutted the industry.
- 6:11It shrunk it. It it took the whole pie and
- 6:13shrunk it. It wasn't like they were going
- 6:15to eat the pie and take it away from Cox.
- 6:17They shrunk it. So no matter what you did like
- 6:20that, that opportunity is gone. And they made investments in
- 6:23classifieds.com, cars.com and a bunch of other like sort of new
- 6:27media diversification classified strategies.
- 6:29None of them really. I mean when you shrink a market
- 6:33by the way, we'll get to this probably.
- 6:34But the kind of the same things happening with Nielsen,
- 6:36Nielsen's been running on a $2 billion Tam, which is the linear
- 6:40addressable market, which they major obviously in the linear
- 6:43television market. And that that's just going to
- 6:46kind of go away. I mean that one might not
- 6:48shrink, it might, but it just gets eaten alive by a new a new
- 6:52set of technologies that you can't you can't migrate to at
- 6:56all. Yeah, if you don't realize this
- 6:59about publishing, it's actually half the size.
- 7:01It was like to your point in 2000, you look at today like the
- 7:04whole publishing industry, like the overall revenue is half this
- 7:07quite literally half the size despite the economy like
- 7:09probably more than doubling over that time.
- 7:12So it's, it's remarkable that you know, the precipitous and
- 7:14ongoing drop and how it is. And yeah, it's wild, but it's
- 7:19got to be the reason why we're excited to have you on here is
- 7:21like there's been a lot of talk about CTV.
- 7:23We had some great discussions that are possible about that
- 7:27with your extensive experience in this industry and media.
- 7:31And I think really the key tension that the whole
- 7:33advertising business is built on this enormous confidence that we
- 7:36have, right when you look at precision, precision advertising
- 7:39targeting, to do that you need addressability or you need
- 7:42audience quality, you need. You know.
- 7:45We're in the age of outcomes after all.
- 7:46You need identity graphs last couple years enter clean rooms
- 7:50and now AI, right, AI driven optimization and targeting.
- 7:53But I think under, that's his basic question, right?
- 7:55Like are the signals underneath any good?
- 7:59And I, I guess what you're saying is a lot of times the
- 8:02answer is no. And I, I don't disagree.
- 8:04And like, if that's the case, what is like modern market
- 8:07infrastructure really look like? And what is a, is there a more
- 8:11sophisticated way to, to move, to move bad data through this,
- 8:15you know, or good data through the system faster to get to get
- 8:18to those better targeting and better outcomes we're looking
- 8:20at? I think it's going to be a fun
- 8:21conversation. Totally.
- 8:23Do you want to get into? It yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 8:26And you I mean, you've been, you know, you've been arguing about
- 8:28this data quality problem for quite a few years.
- 8:30I mean, ever since I think I left Nielsen, probably before
- 8:32that. And and I remember a lot of the
- 8:34conversation, especially at New Star, we were preparing for
- 8:37signal loss. There's cookie deprecation.
- 8:40And you know, all of us spent countless cycles trying to solve
- 8:43because our clients are saying what's going to happen to this
- 8:46House of Cards? Is it a House of Cards that
- 8:48we've built? What what did what have you seen
- 8:50across the companies that you've run?
- 8:51And then and then obviously true set that's convinced do that
- 8:54that we're really unreliable data is kind of at the core of
- 8:58the problem and it continues to be a problem.
- 9:01Yeah. So that's the that is the
- 9:02genesis of the company. You know, one of my roles at
- 9:06Nielsen was to do diligence on potential acquisitions.
- 9:10So I had a little team and we would go look at what they're
- 9:13doing and, you know, invariably, you know, probably more often
- 9:17than not, they were obviously massively exaggerating the
- 9:21capabilities and stuff like that.
- 9:22But every time we got into the weeds, we would look at the data
- 9:25sources of the data they're producing with the methods they
- 9:28were using to assemble data for things like targeting or
- 9:30whatever the thing might be. And I, I was just horrified
- 9:34every single time. Like I cannot believe that we've
- 9:38built this, you know, multi billion dollar, you know,
- 9:42technological infrastructure that runs on really low octane
- 9:46fuel. You know, like that's, that's
- 9:48just a great analogy. And I actually, you know, I
- 9:51actually wanted to do this at Nielsen.
- 9:53I felt like the linear TV market was obviously aging out.
- 9:58It's it's going to go away almost completely.
- 10:01It's all going to go to addressable and addressable,
- 10:04kind of like that conversation we had about classifieds,
- 10:07addressable CTV. It's the people who measure the
- 10:10way you measure Addressable CTV is never going to enjoy the same
- 10:13economics that Nielsen enjoyed for measuring linear television.
- 10:17Yeah, because it was the M word. It was the.
- 10:20It was the only place you went. It was the currency.
- 10:22OK. It had some governance with.
- 10:24The accreditation, right? But it was, it's, it's, it was
- 10:27the way that buyers and sellers agreed to size an audience on
- 10:31television. And it was very helpful.
- 10:34The people rag on Nielsen, you know, they, I feel I was there
- 10:38when we tried to make a transformation.
- 10:39We failed for a bunch of reasons that aren't entirely rational.
- 10:43I can explain those to you actually, But where was I going
- 10:48with this? Was was it something I lost my
- 10:52talk with? Well.
- 10:53I guess, yeah, yeah. But we're talking about Nielsen
- 10:56A measurement, but, but yeah, but, but interject really
- 10:58quickly for the audience. So, you know, Nielsen's really
- 11:00providing A measurement currency so we can evaluate like like how
- 11:03many households within that within a specific group are
- 11:06actually seeing a specific ad that's running the program
- 11:09during a specific day part. So maybe I don't.
- 11:12So not everyone who's listening probably understands how how ads
- 11:15are bought, right? So I think that that that'd be a
- 11:16good thing to dig into a little bit and then we can maybe even
- 11:18go into CTV because I, I just agree, I think that's a really
- 11:21cool discussion about how data works there and targeting.
- 11:24Individual so, so picture the 50s right when or whenever it
- 11:28was doing television starts getting mainstream and all these
- 11:31families are crowding around the console TV in the shag living
- 11:35room with the wood panel and they're watching the $64,000
- 11:38question or ABC News and, you know, think about those days.
- 11:41So all the marketers are seeing this happen, the big CPGS and
- 11:45they're thinking, how do I get these audiences?
- 11:49But there's no way to size them. So what happens?
- 11:52They all make primary research. They brag about how big their
- 11:55audiences are and nobody believes them.
- 11:57It's a it's it's a lot like programmatic looks today can't
- 12:02even see too like you just nobody really knows how big
- 12:06these things are. Nobody knows how many humans are
- 12:08seeing all these device IDs that are being bought and sold and
- 12:10traded. Nobody knows big bots It's it's
- 12:13and so when Nielsen came along so there was there was chaos in
- 12:17the 50s because the audiences were clearly watching
- 12:20television. It was an incredible new medium
- 12:22where a brand had an opportunity to to tell a sight sound and
- 12:25story. 32nd vignette of the brand and how this is going to
- 12:29help your lives. It was according and what
- 12:31happened, this is facts. When Nielsen, it took him 15
- 12:35years to build a rating system. They never said it was going to
- 12:38be perfect. It was always an estimate, but
- 12:40it went went when that system got asserted in the market to
- 12:43give buyers and sellers at least a directional view of how big
- 12:46these audiences were, the friction got pulled out of that
- 12:50market and that market started to grow like crazy.
- 12:53And it was literally, you can, you can absolutely credit
- 12:56Nielsen for the linear television market becoming a $70
- 12:59billion market in, you know, very, very quickly.
- 13:01And a really important part about removing that friction
- 13:04point, right, to allow it allow the economics and for people
- 13:07have the confidence to actually make the purchases.
- 13:09Based on. Real, yeah, the buyer would
- 13:12know, would be able to say, we know we're buying, we're buying
- 13:14like an advertisement in front of the specific audience, right?
- 13:16You can, you can understand the value of it.
- 13:18You can. You can think words you want to
- 13:20spend on it. The word we're circling here,
- 13:23the buyer has the confidence in buying that I can trust is
- 13:27trust. The word is trust.
- 13:29When there's trust in markets, when there's trust between
- 13:32buyers and sellers, when there's trust between two humans, life
- 13:36is easier, things go better. You can look at a a bar chart of
- 13:42the top 100 countries in the world and you can map their GDP
- 13:47per GP per person against levels of corruption in the country.
- 13:51And it is exactly linear like India.
- 13:54Huge population, super low GDP per person, highest corruption
- 13:58rates in the world. I mean, it's so you can
- 14:00literally function a legal. System, right?
- 14:02Yeah, everything. You can trust is trust removes
- 14:05friction. Lack of trust, it's all
- 14:08friction. And I would argue that right now
- 14:10in the digital space, we're the lack of trust world, right?
- 14:14Nobody. Yeah.
- 14:15Yeah, we're selling trust, right?
- 14:17I mean, that's really what they're selling with their model
- 14:19that they weren't saying was perfect, but it this is right.
- 14:21Yeah, and. I think with the, with the
- 14:24especially with the open Internet, right, the walled
- 14:26gardens which a lot of brains are flocking to, there is I
- 14:29think a level of trust because they can connect sort of an
- 14:31engagement action with some sort of point of sale and they can
- 14:34show. Attribution they can show.
- 14:36Attribution, whereas the open Internet and then you mentioned
- 14:38it earlier, you sort of alluded to, we've had a ton of
- 14:40conversations with with Doctor Fu and Mark Zagorski at Double
- 14:44Verify around a lot of the slop and unverified reach.
- 14:48There's a big promise for reach, which is what linear television
- 14:51was promising, but but the it's not really proving out where
- 14:55we're realizing that there's actually more inventory being
- 14:58promised than actually exists right in in the ecosystem.
- 15:02You're promising reach, but it's not all real reach.
- 15:04And that's, that's problematic, yeah.
- 15:06I mean, you know, the the reason why measurement is so important
- 15:09is because of that story we just told.
- 15:11I mean, measurement itself was the thing for linear TV that
- 15:15allowed the market to to establish some trust between
- 15:18buyers and sellers and grow, right.
- 15:20And I think if you want, if you want to be, there's two ways to
- 15:22look at the current situation. You can look at it very, very
- 15:25negatively and say how bad that sucks and how much bought some
- 15:28fraud and everything else is flowing through the system.
- 15:30Or you can say that's OK, We're just behind the curve.
- 15:34We're just catching up. Eventually we'll have
- 15:35measurement. Things will run, the market will
- 15:37grow. They'll be trusting buyers and
- 15:38sells. That's what that's what
- 15:39happened. So my assertion just coming back
- 15:41to the Nielsen thing and it's come and truth set.
- 15:43I thought, well, if Nielsen because we kept buying companies
- 15:47and then messing them up. And I realized like, yeah, like
- 15:49this is not the way to to transform because, you know, I
- 15:54was part of 1. Of those companies, Nielsen,
- 15:56yeah. Nielsen, Excellent.
- 15:58That's late Nielsen marketing planet that I had people I had I
- 16:01had one story where Oh my God, I don't even know can I tell this.
- 16:03I guess we're in a bit of podcast, but where I had people
- 16:06because we were trying to launch a business unit with Mark
- 16:08Zagorski and Damien Garage. You knew that whole play right?
- 16:10We brought in some of Matt Krepsix MTA solutions and
- 16:14amendment sort of commercializing those.
- 16:16But but there was a lot of pushback organizationally around
- 16:19launching this very successful high growth post acquisition
- 16:23sort of marketing cloud which was sort of next generation for
- 16:27from Nielsen's perspective. And so they would have people
- 16:29like SPY on our on our organization to ensure that we
- 16:33were, you know, kind of running by the, the, the, the playbook
- 16:37that they interested on it. So they're worried.
- 16:39You were going. To you're somehow going to
- 16:41sabotage, yeah. Like people would shadow you,
- 16:44you know, to make sure that you weren't going out making bold
- 16:46statements about adtech, martech, etcetera that we're
- 16:48going to. And Scott, you probably ran into
- 16:50some of this and you have your own right, because, you know.
- 16:53The truth is I had I wrote the strategy for the acquisition of
- 16:57excellent. I was, I was the part, I was the
- 17:00architect, but I was, it's coming out of a New Mexico,
- 17:02Mexico off site where I was trying to buy 2 MTA companies
- 17:07either OK or a dormitory. And, and we could, and they both
- 17:13got acquired like within 24 hours, AOL bot converted for 107
- 17:17million and then Googled by odometry.
- 17:20And so that I and, and Hasker said to me, what, what, what,
- 17:23what do we do? And I'm like, you know what,
- 17:26fuck it. I'm like, what is, what is, what
- 17:29is MTA? It is a database that can
- 17:31collect or a data infrastructure that can collect exposure and
- 17:34transaction data. And it's a set of analytics on
- 17:37top. And I said, we've already
- 17:39learned. We've already learned at
- 17:40Nielsen, our analytics are probably better than the
- 17:43analytics of these little companies.
- 17:44That's what we do with analytics that we do media analytics that
- 17:46we should be able to do the analytics part that in that case
- 17:49all we really need is ADMP. So that, that was what started
- 17:52that. OK, great.
- 17:52Let's go by the data. Management platform, yeah.
- 17:55ADMP. But my my strategy for the
- 17:57thing, which is what got it done was a plan to essentially use
- 18:02the DMP to platform Nielsen's data, right.
- 18:05Like my vision for the thing was, which I sold up.
- 18:08My vision wasn't let's do, let's let X like keep doing what
- 18:11they're doing. My vision was, holy smokes,
- 18:14Nielsen has global media exposure data global and as
- 18:18global buy data with the RMS retail measurement systems.
- 18:21Let's bring together. We were trying to bring together
- 18:23what we called watch and buy exposures to transactions for a
- 18:28long time, but there was so much friction to me.
- 18:31This was the thing that was going to bring watch and buy
- 18:33data together and then we would move.
- 18:36It was for those who. Don't know ADMP of data
- 18:38management platform and Brett, you've described it as a cookie
- 18:40farm is collecting cookie data, right.
- 18:42So like combining that with the other, the other signals this
- 18:44and that. I mean that makes a lot of
- 18:45sense. We I can see why there'd be a
- 18:47sound strategy. Well, and there was, there was
- 18:49kind of a breakdown with household versus persons level
- 18:51data. Can you talk about that a little
- 18:53bit, right, Just in terms of how do you actually fuse those,
- 18:55right, Because a lot of the Catalina solutions, the buy
- 18:58solutions, we're all at the household level.
- 19:00The the television data and even digital ad ratings was still was
- 19:05still at a household level and you're trying to get down to a
- 19:07person. This is.
- 19:08Even back with Lynn back with when it was with linear, right,
- 19:10But I we're not haven't gotten to CTV yet.
- 19:12So I mean something that was not even back down with the Nielsen
- 19:14data, right? Well, that's, I mean you're
- 19:16sticking with the X late story. You know, the when I we evaluate
- 19:21X late, I said amazing pipes, amazing connectivity, amazing so
- 19:26much bleeding edge technology in the this data management
- 19:30platform, which is exactly what Nielsen need needed.
- 19:34But and I and I really actually dismissed all the cookie data
- 19:37that was in there. They had no sense of identity to
- 19:39your point. They had no sense of person ID
- 19:41or a household ID. They just treated a cookie as
- 19:44this must be a person. How do we classify it and sell
- 19:46it? That was, yeah.
- 19:48You should have seen how they profiled me.
- 19:49I think I was a single female living alone in New York City,
- 19:52right when I ran my profile analysis.
- 19:54I'm like, they've got me completely wrong, but you got
- 19:57to. Write which we we've got to
- 19:59digress for one second here to not not throw all these
- 20:02companies completely into the bus because they you know, the
- 20:05cookies were reliable for a long time like device IDs were very
- 20:09reliable for a long freaking time.
- 20:11Retargeting is still reliable. So, you know, and and then you
- 20:15can't blame them if their buyers are saying I want scale over
- 20:20accuracy, like, hey, hey, Mark and all you guys over there,
- 20:24exhalate. Yep, when you have a chance to
- 20:26give me 100 million. Cookies that might be something
- 20:31versus 20 million that you know, are something I want the 100
- 20:34million, I want the 100 million, I want the 100 million.
- 20:36So you know, it's yeah, when I looked at it, I was like, I
- 20:39don't want any of that data like Nielsen is about truth.
- 20:42We're going to use this to tell the truth about what's
- 20:44happening. We're trying to migrate that
- 20:46into a personal level idea and I also level idea like you said,
- 20:50there was even budget that I argued for.
- 20:52I said I don't want to acquire this company unless there's X
- 20:54$1,000,000 set aside to build an identity graph to put in it.
- 20:58To your point, Brad, there is no sense of person or household,
- 21:01which is was I could see was absolutely going to be needed to
- 21:04be competitive and dominant even just in measurement you're going
- 21:08forward. So that was but that the story
- 21:11here that's that's really relevant is like this starts to
- 21:13explain why the Internet quickly became such a, a mess.
- 21:19I wouldn't even call it signal and noise, I'd call it static.
- 21:21I mean, it's like there's no value to it.
- 21:24Like it just, it's just as you know, like right now there are
- 21:2720 billion hexadecimal values floating around in these buying
- 21:31systems, these representing devices, which is supposed to
- 21:34represent people. Supposedly this is, this is not
- 21:37even signal and noise. This is static.
- 21:40You know what I mean? Noise, I would characterize
- 21:42static is you don't even know if it's real or not.
- 21:44Noise is OK, it represents something, but we have really
- 21:47have no idea what it represents. And signal is it's something
- 21:50that probably likely maybe represents a human being that's
- 21:53going to, you know, have a kid in a wallet in the car or a trip
- 21:55they got to take. So you really want the signal.
- 21:58And it's like if you look at, so look at the 20 years of
- 22:02development, the, the everybody built these either noise
- 22:06machines or noise processing machines, one or the other,
- 22:10right? Like like you just had to like
- 22:12like if you were on the buy side, if you sorry, if you were
- 22:15on like the I need to create audiences to sell.
- 22:18I'm going to create noise. They created this just spat out
- 22:22noise and then the buy side would buy all the noise and it's
- 22:25either just cover their eyes and hold their nose and go on their
- 22:27merry way. No.
- 22:28Noise, yeah, noise can sort of behind the the segmentation
- 22:31scheme and if the. CPMS are low enough to your
- 22:33point, like, like scale is sometimes, you know, just just
- 22:37little precision. But we have scale anyway.
- 22:38This doesn't even matter, right? Yeah, Well, Rio.
- 22:40Rio, you saw a lot of that. Rio, you're tapping into yet
- 22:43another endemic problem with the whole system, which is the
- 22:49biggest buyers, the biggest CPGS.
- 22:51They were and still do use NMMS. Like they tried all these little
- 22:55experiments, they tried NCS with Nielsen, they tried Cercona,
- 22:59they still, but they lost confidence in all of these, you
- 23:03know, very precise measurement systems and they ended up going
- 23:06back to mix. What does mix do?
- 23:07Mix looks at what? Mix just looks at how heavy, how
- 23:11heavy was I here over what period of time and how can I see
- 23:14my sales go up and down relative to that media weight to?
- 23:18Fuel like strategic decisions around budget allocation at the
- 23:22channel level and at a very high sort of aggregate level, right?
- 23:25Totally. So and their system is not
- 23:27sensitive, MMMS are not sensitive.
- 23:29And what they do is they say, oh, we noticed when we did a
- 23:32time series regression, when we look back over the last year, we
- 23:35heavied up in Phoenix and sales went up.
- 23:38So I'm going to credit the sales with that heavy up.
- 23:41And, and that's great, except that what that does is it
- 23:44creates a KPI for efficiency at that point, if that's your, if
- 23:48those are your calculations, all I want to do is drive down the
- 23:51cost of all that media weight, right?
- 23:53And that's what they do. I don't care if it's good or
- 23:55bad. I just want weight right to.
- 23:58Spend my budget too. I mean, that's always part of
- 24:00it, right? It's funny, I work with a couple
- 24:02of clients, a couple of clients now and I've seen the MMM get
- 24:04created right by the strategy team.
- 24:07And then and then it goes over to totally different team who's
- 24:11actually going to buy the media and they work with the agency to
- 24:13create the plan based on that. And then, you know, there's a
- 24:16lag the translation of that into actual like tactics and where
- 24:19the buys happen, which platforms, which I mean, it's
- 24:22just to say it's not a sciences and understatement in my
- 24:26opinion. Well, the.
- 24:26Activation of the of from the insights and that six month
- 24:30window is is maybe less scientific than it needs to be.
- 24:32It's not directly tied to, I'm talking.
- 24:34Just I'm talking just translating the MMM into the
- 24:36actual media buying plan, forget about even like the like looking
- 24:39at the outcomes and tying back the measurement to like how you
- 24:43how you reconfigure and adjust that.
- 24:44I mean, I think that's a whole another thing.
- 24:47The point is that this, if that's the way you're measuring
- 24:51and the resulting outcomes of the resulting action items of
- 24:56what you should do to make it better is push down media cost.
- 25:00This is bad. This literally created a lot of
- 25:02the mess we're in right now because what that does, it
- 25:04motivates all your partners to optimize for scale with no
- 25:07caring about quality whatsoever. It also grinds down the
- 25:10publishers, which actually works against you as a major brand
- 25:14because you need those publishers to survive, to
- 25:16attract people who who you can rent their time and attention
- 25:20for seven seconds. Yeah, they.
- 25:21Need to be able to effectively monetize their properties and if
- 25:23you're if you're going going against that you're really going
- 25:26against the open web and then you're forced into these these
- 25:28walled garden type of ecos systems to do all you're buying
- 25:31right in my. In my first start, my second
- 25:33startup, which was a mixed, sort of a advanced mixed modeling
- 25:36company meant to be digitally oriented, meant to try to solve
- 25:39this problem. We had a client, I, it's a top
- 25:43five CPG, like I shouldn't say who it was, but they, we did a
- 25:48study for them. This is, there was barely even
- 25:51any video inventory. This is probably 2005, maybe
- 25:572006. I mean there was some inventory
- 26:00coming online and bright Roll was there.
- 26:02You know, all the rich media stuff is there.
- 26:04It was some video online. And so we did, they wanted to
- 26:06know how do I compare the, the ROI, the robots, the
- 26:10effectiveness efficiency of, of, of online video versus
- 26:14television versus Pratt. These are the three things that
- 26:17they bought. So we did this very robust, very
- 26:20robust and I would say accurate study.
- 26:23One fault of mine is I always tell the truth even if it's not
- 26:26my own interests. So sometimes that, but we told
- 26:30there's no. Obfuscation.
- 26:31There's no obfuscation with Scott McKinley, right?
- 26:34None, none. Even if it puts me out of a job.
- 26:38And we told them, we told we showed them the online video at
- 26:41that time was very performed. It was, it might be, it was
- 26:44right up there. It might have been better at the
- 26:46time because the CPMS were low and everything else.
- 26:48And they said publicly we're going to allocate 20% of our
- 26:52budget, which was over a billion dollars to online video.
- 26:57They actually did a press release on this bragging about
- 27:00how modern they were. First of all, there was not that
- 27:01much inventory on the whole Internet.
- 27:03They could have bought out the whole Internet for $2 billion,
- 27:05not 20 or $200 million. And they were, they had a set.
- 27:09They had a second stipulation. This is back to the MMM driving
- 27:12efficiencies instead of affecting this they said.
- 27:14But we have a rule for it. And like, what's the rule that
- 27:16like we're telling everybody we're never going to spend more
- 27:18than a $3 CPM for this video. And I was like, so we're going
- 27:23to, we're going. To spend all this money and
- 27:25we're going to be at a super low rate.
- 27:26I mean, he could have bought all the inventory 50 times.
- 27:28That's just but you it's the the point was and then if at the
- 27:31time I talked to Todd Sastrodati, who ran bright roll,
- 27:35it turned out this is the same. We shared this client and he
- 27:38named it. I'm still like a name who it is
- 27:39and he's he said, Scott, he says your story is so right.
- 27:42He said I would tell them, I can't tell you guys that we're
- 27:45delivering a single video to a single actual human being
- 27:48because of this low price point. Like we're like he like hey,
- 27:51you. Kind of you nailed the hit that
- 27:53on that this was how many years ago was this?
- 27:55This is 20, it is 2005, so whatever that is, nothing's
- 27:58changed. Nothing's changed.
- 28:00Did we hear this problem all the time?
- 28:02I said. You're reaching so funny.
- 28:04Audiences on a mobile phone aren't real.
- 28:06What's? Worse than that, it's like, hey,
- 28:08do your kids have Napster? You know, if you scroll, you
- 28:10know if it loads really slowly, you scroll to the bottom.
- 28:12There's a a bunch of stuff down there.
- 28:14Those are pixels, lots of video with thousands of of video
- 28:18calls. That's where your ads are
- 28:20getting delivered, right? That like literally not to be.
- 28:23But the point, the whole point of this whole story, I think
- 28:25it's, it's all relevant. It's that.
- 28:27It's that the industry evolved in a direction to optimize for
- 28:32scale. No sense of accuracy.
- 28:35Everyone assumed that the early performance of cookies was just
- 28:38going to carry through. No one paid attention as this
- 28:41stuff degraded. Nobody, really.
- 28:43Everyone turned a blind eye when all these fraudsters, when they
- 28:46did it deliberately or just through evolution, started
- 28:51selling things that were not humans.
- 28:52They were not humans. They like, these are just not
- 28:55people. And then then a funny thing
- 28:57happened in around 2010. So Facebook showed up, right.
- 29:01Mark Zagorski never sat down and said, I, I, I'm brilliant.
- 29:05I'm going to predict that if I can get somebody to give me
- 29:07their e-mail address, I can build a media empire.
- 29:09He didn't say that. He said, I'm going to build a, a
- 29:12book face thing, Facebook thing so that we can all laugh at each
- 29:15other. But in order to do that, you
- 29:17have to identify yourself. And and that accidental hack is
- 29:21what allowed him to build the most powerful media empire on
- 29:24the planet's ever seen Mark Zucker.
- 29:26Wickerberg Yeah, yeah. Why by?
- 29:27Requiring people to authenticate to say here's my e-mail address,
- 29:30because what that did is it gave Facebook control of the
- 29:35consumer. It gave Facebook a durable
- 29:39person level identity that's owned by the person that's not
- 29:42likely to change or be traded that they can hook data to.
- 29:46And that is that that's the playbook.
- 29:48I mean, the punchline of this whole conversation is why is
- 29:53especially CTV and these big networks, why are they not just
- 29:56looking at the walled gardens and saying that's the playbook
- 30:00that wins, the playbook that wins Google Facebook, you know?
- 30:05Authentication with persistent identifiers, right?
- 30:08Which is. Authentication is the freaking
- 30:11hack. Like get it through your heads
- 30:14if you right right now. And I did a study like I said
- 30:17Nielsen privately the the average CPM at the time for a an
- 30:22unauthenticated cookie based audience was like $1.50 or a
- 30:25buck or something like that. Maybe kind of like?
- 30:27A remnant inventory CPM that that's.
- 30:29The whole open Internet average, the, the average inventory for
- 30:34that same CPM, for that same audience on Facebook or on
- 30:38Google, a place where there was authentication was 8 or $10 and
- 30:42that's. Like it's almost 10X Yeah, the.
- 30:45Difference and so everyone's like I can't believe they ran
- 30:47away with their 70 centers of every media dollar goes to the
- 30:51it's because they have human audiences that actually can see
- 30:54the ads and then you respond like everything else no it's.
- 30:57No wonder why they actually convert right and you can
- 30:59actually prove outcomes and and 100%.
- 31:02But yeah, but Scott, let's turn. To CTCTVI mean this is such you
- 31:06know it's growing it's growing like crazy.
- 31:07I think Brett, we covered this couple episodes 18% this year
- 31:10continues to So like, and so it'd be good for the audience
- 31:13people to hear about like like how to see how is inventory
- 31:16actually bought? Obviously, if you go to the
- 31:18walled gardens, you go to like like Amazon to buy their owned
- 31:20and operated Amazon Prime Video. You're logged to know who you
- 31:23are. But a lot of CTV inventories
- 31:25actually bought through, you know, it's debatable.
- 31:28Is it open web or not, but you can go to the trade desk.
- 31:31You don't even buy like like audience extensions off site
- 31:34inventory in Amazon DSP for for Netflix or other places.
- 31:37Let's talk about like, how is that bought?
- 31:39Because you have, you have the inventory itself, right?
- 31:42Then you have the data, the audience super important.
- 31:45And maybe we can walk through like how is that board?
- 31:47And like how is what is the role of data and how is important to
- 31:50have good data? And how is that data?
- 31:52And a lot of times it's not any good because I think that's part
- 31:54of your thesis, right? Well, when CTV started to become
- 31:59real and everyone could see this is where things were going
- 32:02despite a lot of people, you know, Pooh poohing it, YouTube's
- 32:06net, YouTube's not ATV channel, you know, like I remember we've
- 32:11no one ever watched YouTube on their TV's, right?
- 32:14Like that's almost. Now, yeah, you still hear.
- 32:16Denials around that today I've heard denials with conversations
- 32:19with pretty senior execs and I'm like, it is television.
- 32:21I don't care what you call it. It's still people are watching
- 32:2460% of all television consumptions in YouTube on the
- 32:27big screen. A. 100% And it's, you know, this
- 32:30is one of the problems that the traditional TV networks have is
- 32:35they, they, they, they think their, their content is just
- 32:38extra precious because it costs a lot of money and attracts a
- 32:42lot of viewership. And I've had this argument
- 32:44forever about, you know, the idea of attention and outcomes
- 32:48and the value of media. You can't just because you
- 32:51spent, you know, a billion dollars making land man and a
- 32:55lot of people TuneIn and watch it, it doesn't mean that that I
- 32:59love that show. By the way, you.
- 33:00Put a you put a pharma ad in front of me for a for a put it.
- 33:03Put it in front of me 25 times in two hours for a condition
- 33:07that I will never have. That ad, despite you getting the
- 33:11media right and having great creative is not going to
- 33:14perform. And I could be later that night
- 33:17on freaking Instagram, lazily, boringly doom scrolling and I
- 33:22see whoop a black and white shitty, poorly produced creative
- 33:25for a mountain bike that I happen to be in the market for.
- 33:28I'm going to stop and I might even click like so.
- 33:30You can't, you can't. They had this, this preciousness
- 33:35which you understand they're defending their legacy.
- 33:37Like what we do is make great stories that people like Long.
- 33:41Form Hollywood content. It's a Hollywood economy, right?
- 33:44Yeah. And then and they but the the
- 33:45point is you guys are missing the data piece, right?
- 33:48You're getting crushed by Instagram in a terrible media
- 33:51environment. Because they know who I am every
- 33:53single time I log on with shitty.
- 33:55Ads that you know. But they still going to work
- 33:59because the three legged stool of advertising is the audience.
- 34:02Like I made a product for somebody, it's an audience.
- 34:05Then the next one is the creative.
- 34:07What am I going to say to that audience?
- 34:09And the third one is the media. Where can I rent 7 seconds or 30
- 34:12seconds of attention from the human being that is that person
- 34:16and tell my story to that person.
- 34:17That's the, that's the, you pull out any one of those legs that
- 34:21still doesn't stand up, right? In the old days, in the old
- 34:24days, there was no concept of, of audience.
- 34:26It was all mass targeting, like every product that got
- 34:29advertised on television was to a mom who could walk down the
- 34:33street and buy the Swiffer mop in her corner store or her Sears
- 34:36or her JC Penney and all. All that's changed.
- 34:39Like there was only Asian gender.
- 34:41That's what Nielsen could report on because it was hard to go
- 34:43beyond that. That's how it ran.
- 34:44So all the emphasis went to creative.
- 34:46This is where we got the Mad Men golden out, you know, the golden
- 34:49era of advertising. And it went to the medium, this
- 34:51incredible medium of television, and that's all you needed.
- 34:54And it was amazing. Now it's all different.
- 34:56I think people have forgotten that just how important it is to
- 35:02get audience data, right. There's a ton of audience data,
- 35:05but it's more static than it is signal or noise.
- 35:08Yeah. And you?
- 35:08And you guys have said that 40% of every dollar spent on CTV
- 35:11programmatic is wasted because of bad data.
- 35:15And I think he calculated it, it was over 7 billion, 7.4,
- 35:19something like that in lost CTV dollars.
- 35:21So clearly there's some friction in this ecosystem.
- 35:26Let's go back. How do we?
- 35:27Yeah. Let's get it comes back to Rio's
- 35:28question like how how do people buy, buy a CTV And when CTV
- 35:32started to get maturity and everyone could real, it's sort
- 35:35of treat like a real channel. There was a question in the
- 35:37industry which was well, what kind of a channel is it?
- 35:41Is it its own channel? Is it going to be like linear
- 35:43TV? Are we going to buy it, sell it
- 35:44and measure it like we do linear TV?
- 35:46Are we going to buy a seller and measure it like we do
- 35:48programmatic And it went the programmatic route, which I'm
- 35:53going to say was the dangerous path.
- 35:56It's what, what what percent is? Biddable today Scott of CTV.
- 36:00It's like the is the majority biddable I.
- 36:02Don't know for sure, but I would.
- 36:05I would bet that I think it probably a lot it is is the
- 36:09majority is is is biddable. But here's the problem, OK, when
- 36:14it went to the programmatic route, everyone was like, OK,
- 36:17well, how do we get the the volume that we need?
- 36:19How do we create a transactable thing that we can buy and sell
- 36:22that represents a television that's supposed to be hanging in
- 36:25somebody's home, right? And The thing is, so here's the,
- 36:28here's the here's the supply chain of identity and data for
- 36:33CTV. It starts with a CTV.
- 36:35There is a CTVID. It's set by the OEMs. It sits on
- 36:39the device. You can't see it.
- 36:40You can't guess it's a device. ID it's a device.
- 36:44ID for the CTV, but it's not an. Independent of IP address, this
- 36:47is. This is device specific, the
- 36:48next one. Goes right that it's the, it's
- 36:51hard to get the CTVID. It has to be I think acquired
- 36:54only from the OEMs who said it. Yeah, I don't think you can see
- 36:57it and it's so you won't have the scale ever.
- 37:00Even if you got all the, you got all the OEMs or half the OEMs to
- 37:03give you half the CTVIDS, you would have big gaps in your
- 37:06viable inventory and that's never will they.
- 37:08Share those with the like automatic the ACR aggregators as
- 37:12well or like does it because I know that the a big part of the
- 37:15like the the streams themselves they don't really make money on
- 37:18them or they like I think sometimes they lose money on
- 37:20them right and they're making their money through through
- 37:24selling or syndicating all the data they're collecting right so
- 37:26the device ID that'd be one one of the signals they're
- 37:29collecting they're probably making money off of right the
- 37:31manufacturer yeah, but it's. Not it's not prevalent and
- 37:34scaled enough to be the tradable identity.
- 37:38The tradable identity is IP address.
- 37:40So what you do is you, you connect, you try to connect the
- 37:43CTV with an IP address. Great.
- 37:45Now the both those things are on the device at the same time.
- 37:49If you can get the CTV or whatever, you end up with the IP
- 37:52address. That's the thing that people are
- 37:53buying and selling. The IP address then gets, then
- 37:56gets connected to a cookie or a e-mail address or a postal
- 38:00address through a variety of. And there's connections kind of
- 38:04suck, right, like IP address to postal is super low percentage.
- 38:08So we. Did a.
- 38:09IP is very broad, right? It could be several houses, it
- 38:11could be a blockage, I mean, or if you're through VPN, it could
- 38:14be another state entirely or another country.
- 38:16We did a. Study A Commission study last
- 38:18year by SIM, the industry body, which is doing really good, the
- 38:23Coalition. Of innovation media measurement,
- 38:25right, that's. Coalition, Coalition for
- 38:27innovation in media measurement. Nice job for innovation.
- 38:30Yeah, very. Unwieldy to say all the all the
- 38:33letters that that was meant to to shine a light on this and
- 38:37understand how accurate or inaccurate are the linkages
- 38:42between IP addresses and the other things that you use to
- 38:44build audiences like IP address doesn't have a demographic.
- 38:47You need to understand who's in the home.
- 38:49So you need to link it to something where there is a
- 38:50demographic like an e-mail address or a postal or you could
- 38:54do a cookie or whatever. We found that the average among
- 38:58a whole pile of well known providers of this linkage data,
- 39:03the average was I believe 13% accurate when linking AIP
- 39:07address IP address to. To IT home address right and
- 39:12then. 16% for postal address I believe is what the staff is.
- 39:16And so you guys like stand back, you're trying to support and
- 39:20embrace and leverage this new media channel that promises
- 39:23everything full sight, sound of motion delivery of televisions
- 39:26of of brand stories into somebody's living room.
- 39:29What This is incredible. Much more automated ad.
- 39:31Delivery that's switchable and you can adjust creative you can.
- 39:35You can do all sorts of things. Incredible.
- 39:37Except. You couldn't do in the linear
- 39:39except. That your guess about who those
- 39:42people are behind the screen is 87% wrong to start Like that's
- 39:48it's wrong almost not. Not some of the time.
- 39:50Almost all the time it's. Wrong almost all the time.
- 39:52It's worse than cookies were for sure, probably worse than
- 39:55cookies are today. It's just really like we jumped
- 39:58from the frying pan cookies that didn't work into the fire IP
- 40:02addresses, they're not going to work.
- 40:04You know, I will say I just got to throw in here that averages
- 40:06are always very dangerous because they smooth everything
- 40:08out and the assumption is that everybody has 13%.
- 40:11No, there are extremely accurate pools of IP linkage data.
- 40:16Roku for example, they see. The IP, Comcast, they're the
- 40:20ones who set the IP address, right.
- 40:21So there are pockets of of sources of purely deterministic,
- 40:29no probabilistic guesses about the connection of a given IP
- 40:32address and the devices connected to it, to the home and
- 40:35the people and everything else. But the goal, really, go ahead.
- 40:38Yeah, Yeah. But.
- 40:39That's that and that supports either direct to publisher or
- 40:42direct to Roku type provider purchase, but it doesn't support
- 40:48across ecosystem purchase from a media buying perspective, Yeah.
- 40:52It's like you would do it's. Linear, right?
- 40:55Exactly, it's a mess and there's another problem at the happening
- 40:59at the same time. Like we're always out there
- 41:01advocating just like we talked about earlier.
- 41:04Hey, TV, you know, just use example again, like the ability
- 41:08for, you know, Paramount to monetize 30 seconds of my time
- 41:13and attention during Land Man, which is a show I really, really
- 41:15love. I mean, if they don't, if I, if
- 41:20I'm authenticated and they ignore my authentication, let's
- 41:22come back to that for a second. Instead, instead, just take my
- 41:26IP and put it into another bunch of IPS and sell it off to
- 41:29somebody because it's got the scale.
- 41:31I'm going to see an ad that's not relevant to me.
- 41:33So they are not going to get the yield from that inventory that
- 41:38they should get take that same program and now they've licensed
- 41:41it to Amazon, now they've licensed it to Netflix or now
- 41:45whatever they have my identity the chance they're going to
- 41:48monetize it 20 times or higher better.
- 41:51And so these are all the other. Places where you can buy
- 41:53inventory in other words, and like they may have bought that
- 41:55that IP address to supposedly link to you or like and then so
- 41:59to your point like people are buying these audiences that are
- 42:02supposedly like highly accurate, but they may not be well they.
- 42:06Aren't they? May not.
- 42:10They are not, but like I want to help save linear traditional
- 42:15television. I want, I think it's unhealthy
- 42:18for the walled gardens to to control the narrative and the
- 42:21advertising around wait. You want to save traditional
- 42:24television or you want to save the model that allowed for like
- 42:27broader reach across the entire ecosystem?
- 42:29I want. I want NBC and CBS, all these,
- 42:31all these companies to survive. I think it's really healthy to
- 42:34have diversity. It's good for journalism, it's
- 42:37good for free speech. It's good for democracy.
- 42:40And it really is. Good for democracy.
- 42:41And I you know, that's, that's like a people think really,
- 42:44we're not digging wells here in India, but it is good for
- 42:46democracy. Like you cannot have the the the
- 42:50cultural narrative be controlled by a couple of companies, right?
- 42:54Yeah, we'll have. Like a it's a publisher
- 42:56balkanization and is what it is. And you end up having all of
- 42:58these separate worlds that are that are completely corporatized
- 43:02and behind walled garden, well, even new.
- 43:03York Times, they've been like they struggled so much to
- 43:05monetize any of their inventory. They're now selling like they
- 43:08make more some money in crossword puzzles.
- 43:10I mean they're they everyone talk about how they're doing
- 43:11well and they are like it Congrats to them.
- 43:13But The thing is like they're monetizing all these games.
- 43:15They found, they found different models, right.
- 43:17I think it's almost like they've given up on, you know, on
- 43:19selling on on selling as to an extent, I don't know.
- 43:22Yeah. And and.
- 43:23Then in their in their case, you also have just the tidal wave of
- 43:27of really good user generator content.
- 43:29I mean, just, I'm sorry, very few people are going to sit and
- 43:32read an article on the New York Times.
- 43:34For every person that that's going to sit, how life?
- 43:36Has changed since we started, right for every for every.
- 43:41Human being that that's going to read a physical newspaper or
- 43:44even go online and read a long form news story on New York
- 43:48Times for every one person there there are 1,000,000 people
- 43:51happily scrolling away on TikTok and Instagram right so let's
- 43:55just let's just face it like the consumption the nature of media
- 43:59consumption has changed and will probably never I I sat down and
- 44:02tried to force myself to read a book the other day I I couldn't
- 44:05even read it I know I. Yes, Scott, I was like, but, you
- 44:08know, just. A problem with me.
- 44:09Or is this interesting problem? So I was like dinner with a
- 44:12bunch. How many pages do I have to get
- 44:14through till I get a dopamine hit?
- 44:15Damn it, come on. Stimulating.
- 44:19Enough but people. Will listen those same people
- 44:21who will go to scroll tick tock you're right will not read a
- 44:23long form article. They will listen to a 2 hour
- 44:25podcast. I think that it so.
- 44:27This is almost like the dumbbell effect where people prefer short
- 44:30form. I agree with you.
- 44:31It's harder, but I think there is a place for long for But I
- 44:35just think the way people consume content has changed.
- 44:37And I think a lot of these like I like you're watching lame.
- 44:40I love lame. And there's a lot of shows I
- 44:41watch and I watch them all the time right when they come out
- 44:43right. But but yeah, but I think that I
- 44:46haven't read. I've actually had funny.
- 44:47I haven't used speaking books. I haven't read a physical book
- 44:50in the years I I bet I do read e-books.
- 44:52So yeah, I think, I think those signal.
- 44:53Noises like the Cliff notes for the, the Martech data tech AI,
- 44:58right? We're like the dummy proof.
- 44:59Just listen to us. You don't have to read anything.
- 45:02But no, but so back to your point about saving what you said
- 45:06was sort of traditional television, or at least the
- 45:08model behind traditional television, which is sort of an
- 45:10open model that's supportive of all publishers that are, that
- 45:13are within that medium. How, how do you see that?
- 45:15What are the next steps? How do you see that happening?
- 45:18What? Can't.
- 45:20If we. Keep going down this path of
- 45:23pretending that an IP address represents a certain kind of
- 45:28person or it we will. I'll tell you what happened.
- 45:32Those companies will never get yield off their inventory
- 45:35because it won't perform because of the poorly targeted.
- 45:37OK, so the money is going to they will never get the yield.
- 45:40The next step will be the death knell, which is already starting
- 45:44of of traditional television, which is those companies will
- 45:47realize this and in an effort to to make revenue, they will start
- 45:50licensing their content to their competitors who can monetize it
- 45:5420 times better. They if they take half the take
- 45:57rate off of land man shown on prime with an ad tier, they're
- 46:02going to still make five times more than they would trying to
- 46:04monetize that themselves. That's the nature of so I think
- 46:06we are. And if if we don't, if we
- 46:09continue down this path, we already hit the iceberg.
- 46:12It's just rearranging deck chairs.
- 46:14It's it's not, it's going to all end up in the gardens.
- 46:16And I think that's really, really unhealthy.
- 46:18You're already seeing the consolidation like it's, it's
- 46:20crazy. The alternative is staring us
- 46:23right in the face, which is use that playbook, guys,
- 46:28authenticate your users, authenticate your use.
- 46:31Mandated, mandated. I was told by somebody, it's
- 46:34funny. So we do serve some of these big
- 46:37TV folks. We're trying, we're doing really
- 46:40good things to try to make this transition.
- 46:42And someone senior told me, Scott, you know, you, I ran that
- 46:46up the flagpole. Like, you know, you told me you
- 46:48should have mandatory authentication wherever you can
- 46:50get it For these reasons. And he says, I agree.
- 46:52And he ran up the flagpole. He says we're not going to do
- 46:54it. I said, why in the world?
- 46:56You know what's going to happen? He's like, what'd they say?
- 46:59They said. It's a privacy compliance issue.
- 47:01We don't have the infrastructure to create to to manage, to
- 47:05manage. Consents to OK, yeah, yeah, and
- 47:07they're. Like they're more is it?
- 47:09Yeah, that sounds like a cop out, like a double opt in.
- 47:11I don't this is not it's. Not AI wouldn't say it's a
- 47:14copped out, a cop out. I would say it's it's letting
- 47:18legal liability get in the way of existential survival.
- 47:21Like that's just a legal problem.
- 47:23You just got a technology problem too, Just solve it.
- 47:26You don't just say tools. Are tools are out there right,
- 47:28You can go go one trust if you just want to do cookie consent
- 47:30management or if it's a bigger total management play there
- 47:33there consent management platforms you can I don't know
- 47:35you can collect you could have. Stored in your.
- 47:37CDP, I don't know, there's a ways to do it, Yeah.
- 47:39So maybe. It was a little bit, I'm sure it
- 47:41was a little bit of a cop out. People just don't really want to
- 47:43change and they're bummed out and their careers are going to
- 47:45be over before this really hits. So who?
- 47:47Well, yeah. Well, in the.
- 47:48Legal. Department like they want to
- 47:50prove, like prove that they're show their valuable right.
- 47:52So they like to say no to things a lot.
- 47:54So I don't know. Like the back of the napkin math
- 47:57and, and sort of think, well, hey, how many, what percentage
- 47:59of our total audience reach back to the audience reach topic is
- 48:02willing to authenticate. And if it's a sub segment that's
- 48:05a 10/20/30 percent, we're going to lose all of this extensible
- 48:09reach that we are promising our advertisers.
- 48:11So you know, so then it's this downward spiral of like, well,
- 48:14then there's less revenue because we have less reach,
- 48:16right? So we're not going to go down
- 48:17that path. Is that part of the calculus?
- 48:19Yes, yes, so, so let's go back from one second to newspapers
- 48:24and run this. We're going way.
- 48:26Back No, no. So I was the only 10 years ago I
- 48:28was at, I was at idfy that that company under ALC, which is it
- 48:32was a sub and and I went down and talked to about 1000
- 48:39conglomerate that operates date runs data for like 1000
- 48:42publishers, some very, very big ones that you definitely have
- 48:47heard of. And I made this authentication
- 48:49speech and they, and I basically said, I trotted out that stat
- 48:53that the monetization rate for the same audience in a cookie
- 48:57world versus an authenticated world is like 10X, you know, And
- 49:03they, they said to me, Scott, we hear what you're saying, but if
- 49:09we forced, if we put an auth wall up, not even, I said, don't
- 49:12put a pay wall. You just want, you just want
- 49:14them to authenticate. That's the beginning to ask them
- 49:15to give their e-mail. That's the beginning of success,
- 49:18you know, and they said if we put an auth wall up, we've
- 49:22calculated that we're going to lose 15% of our Get ready for
- 49:26this page views. Oh my God.
- 49:29This is like. Page use what a solid metric
- 49:32that is but. Think about it, they were word
- 49:35of 15% not knowing this AI tsunami is going to hit them
- 49:38where they're going to lose 40 like talking.
- 49:40To pubs and it. Lost 25 Thirty 40% of all of all
- 49:43referral traffic is already gone.
- 49:45Also, I'm like, that's great because you're going to monetize
- 49:49the remaining 85% ten times better than 10.
- 49:52Times the outcome. Is still or an order of
- 49:55magnitude higher than you're earning today and you're going
- 49:57out of business guys like so that that's that mentality now
- 50:00coming back to see to think about that come back to CTV.
- 50:03Their pushback was privacy. Maybe it was a cop out, maybe
- 50:05not even since then. This is about a year and a half
- 50:07ago when I had this conversation.
- 50:09They've started realizing this like I set my father-in-law up
- 50:12on Pluto the other day and it was, they were very aggressive
- 50:15and made it very easy to authenticate right.
- 50:17There was a good value proposition.
- 50:19So they're trying, but here's the other problem.
- 50:21The other problem is if I'm a seat, a streamer, a big, big
- 50:26program, a big TV network and I've got my linear we, I know
- 50:29that's dying out, that's bothering me out.
- 50:30I've got my streaming and a lot of it's authenticated.
- 50:32Most of it's authenticated. Maybe I have a fast property
- 50:35where I don't, I don't know if I want to they should
- 50:37authenticate, but they're for some reason they're not.
- 50:40But the point is that like Paramount Plus or NBC Peacock,
- 50:44right? You are giving them your billing
- 50:46address, your e-mail address, all these things, right?
- 50:49So there's a portion of that entire audience at a Paramount
- 50:53or NBC or WBD that is authenticated, right?
- 50:57You know what, they don't sell that as authenticated inventory
- 51:00because the buyers come along and they say, I want 100 of the
- 51:04things and they're like, we have 20 of the things that are
- 51:06really, really accurate because we have authentication.
- 51:09Do you want those? They're like they literally the
- 51:11buyers saying, I don't even care if 20% are authenticated.
- 51:15I just want IP addresses for the whole 100 things that I want to
- 51:18buy. So that's.
- 51:19A buyer? That's a buyer issue, right?
- 51:21It is a buyer. Issue it's that's right.
- 51:22So it's you can't blame like you to be careful about blaming
- 51:27people who are doing things that look irrational or not in their
- 51:30best interest because it's it's coming down.
- 51:32It's the pyramid, it's the brands, the agencies and the
- 51:35KPI's were still running on these stupid reach KPI's.
- 51:38Look, I was one or we have several CPG clients.
- 51:41I was at one of them the other day and they told me that
- 51:49they've decided this is 100 year old company.
- 51:52They've decided they realized actually that they they have to
- 51:55stop applying the old calculus everything the economics of
- 52:02linear. What they didn't linear, which
- 52:03they leveraged as a competitive advantage.
- 52:05They're so good at it. They, they were kept trying to
- 52:07use linear tools and tricks to move into addressable and they
- 52:12finally realized these things don't play these do they do
- 52:15nothing is the same. We need to break our literally
- 52:18break our models and create a whole new approach to use
- 52:22addressable, you know, in for a competitive advantage for
- 52:25marketing. And they, and they said we
- 52:26don't, we don't know how to do it.
- 52:27It doesn't work for us. We want scale and it's really
- 52:30hard to get in CTV. It's the measurement.
- 52:32Everything's messier. So that tells you how different
- 52:36linear and CTV are and just come.
- 52:38I want to close out this little topic with what streamers need
- 52:43to do is look at what the walled gardens are doing and say it's
- 52:47that's the playbook. Authenticate your users, own
- 52:50your users. Stop.
- 52:52Stop outsourcing everything to part to third parties.
- 52:55Stop. Yeah, you're.
- 52:56Disintermediating yourselves totally right by doing that, but
- 53:00but let's. Say this happens like so like
- 53:02open web versus like logged in web.
- 53:04I think that's the term I heard throwing around a lot.
- 53:06So does open web just become a, a place for like not only
- 53:10unauthenticated, but low quality undifferentiated traffic, right,
- 53:15Versus this like if publishers did this, right, if they, they
- 53:18had some kind of authentication, you're right, they could have up
- 53:21to up to 1010 times higher CPM. That's a huge difference, right?
- 53:25But if they all leave, what happens to the open web then?
- 53:27I mean, like, does does it, you know, does it, does it still
- 53:29exist because you have the walled gardens, the logged in
- 53:32web? I mean sounds like open web just
- 53:34become it's a race to the bottom then right It already.
- 53:37Is a race to the bottom. If you do the.
- 53:39If you do the the overlapping articles of where it's it's it's
- 53:42less, I think it's about 17. OK.
- 53:44I think last time I checked, which was I think Jones who's
- 53:47cane at Jones Media puts out a thing that that kind of maps the
- 53:50different channels and stuff like that.
- 53:51But if last time I checked, I think the unauthenticated open
- 53:54web was 17% and and losing a couple points every single.
- 53:59There's no where that's going except down, right?
- 54:01Yeah, if you look at it, somebody just put out a a stack
- 54:04rank of where the money is going into the big media properties
- 54:09and there's a couple. So it's always, it's a big guys,
- 54:11right to see. Obviously the, you know,
- 54:13Google's met what all those guys are at the top.
- 54:15The only like open web things on there are like Pinterest snap
- 54:20because these are little gardens.
- 54:22These are little gardens. They're heavily authenticated,
- 54:23mostly authenticated, you know, they're, they're building
- 54:26audiences that are sustainable and durable and they're actually
- 54:29represent people. They're doing a much better job
- 54:31of, of acting like a walled garden than the open web is.
- 54:34If you, if you're a site that's just running on cookies or IPS,
- 54:37I mean, I don't what are you doing?
- 54:39I mean, it's a race to the bottom.
- 54:42Yeah. And, and there's a, there's a
- 54:43big push towards, towards, and we talked about this with the
- 54:45primitive, right, with, with, with Joe Root, right.
- 54:49And, and they're pushing towards just premium inventory.
- 54:52And and to be premium, you need to have authenticated audiences,
- 54:55even if they're smaller volumes of audiences, they're
- 54:58directional. Deals like they're really sour
- 55:00and open exchange right completely just if you if you
- 55:03have that's the robust sell side signals right which include
- 55:06Brett all the things you just mentioned the audience details
- 55:08the the contextual signals all of that right I mean you can you
- 55:13can command a premium and you should be supporting these
- 55:16publishers as they work directly friends that was their thesis
- 55:19anyway yeah and how. Underutilized.
- 55:21The data that they have, the publishers have is in the
- 55:24advertising sort of bid streaming ecosystem.
- 55:27Once they push it through the DSP pipes, there's a narrowing
- 55:29of the pipes. All that rich consumer they own
- 55:32the audience is not being utilized.
- 55:34And so it affects yields to your point earlier about Scott
- 55:37because it's not going to perform because you're taking a
- 55:39sub segment of the data that that publishers already have and
- 55:42yet they're you know some of them are still hesitating going.
- 55:45Scott, where do you see? Things going though, just quick
- 55:47questions like, so where do you do just like with if, if this
- 55:49happens, if let's say, you know, publishers are OK, we have to
- 55:52get authenticated audiences. We're going to just force
- 55:55everyone to go through this path.
- 55:56Even if we lose 2/3 doesn't matter.
- 55:58We're going to be 10X on that that one third.
- 56:00If that starts happening, like just the way inventories bought
- 56:04and sold may be changed. I mean, because again, permutive
- 56:08thesis was it'll be more direct sold instead of majority being
- 56:12programmatic and like say most of that being biddable.
- 56:15You know, you could have more more direct sold these.
- 56:17I mean, I rented PMPS are still you're still in auction, but
- 56:20like just there's the format of these media like the.
- 56:23Way. Media's bought and sold change
- 56:24and like does does this impact the way that you mentioned
- 56:27buyers? Does this change their behaviors
- 56:29do you think? I think that that the trend for
- 56:32buyers who actually pay attention to what's happening
- 56:36and doing their best to assess value to different ways of
- 56:39buying in different channels, I think they will absolutely
- 56:42gravitate to where the inventory is trustworthy and credible.
- 56:46OK, that's the first thing. And then, and then that's that
- 56:48that usually correlates with there's some kind of the chances
- 56:53of me reaching humans on that particular channel are much
- 56:55higher because they're authenticated.
- 56:57Like, I think that's what, because it's, you know, it's,
- 57:00it's just abundantly clear that throwing a dollar into a plot
- 57:03and their DSP who tells you they're going to buy a bunch of
- 57:06CTV is you might get 3-5 cents of, of value out of that.
- 57:11Really it's, it's, it's kind of that bad.
- 57:13I mean, on average. So I think that's what's going
- 57:15to happen. I think, I think the
- 57:17authentication story is inevitable.
- 57:20I think either like even these publishers you're talking about,
- 57:23like the the sort of race to the bottom, like if you're a
- 57:27publisher that produces actually good, you're not, you're not an
- 57:31MFA, you're not a made for advertising site.
- 57:33You're not a bullshit, you know, recipe site that you've got an.
- 57:37AIAI generated recipe site, Yeah.
- 57:39Lady, I don't want to hear where you were born.
- 57:41I want to see the recipe for the, you know, excuse to put in
- 57:44more ads. But I think that the website
- 57:49programmers, content producers who produce good content can
- 57:54easily earn authentication and they don't realize it, you know,
- 57:59like they can earn it. And if they can't, you, your
- 58:01stuff is so garbage. Sorry, you're you're going to
- 58:04float around on the bottom and not, you know, I don't know what
- 58:06why people ever buy your inventory, but I think that
- 58:08everybody should try harder to create that value exchange with
- 58:12the user that earns the right to authenticate and delivers a good
- 58:15quality experience. You know, I'm a cyclist.
- 58:17I used to, I always watched the old cycling races and there's
- 58:21one company out of Australia called Cycling News, which is
- 58:23the global source for everything Pro Cycling.
- 58:27And to me that was like a litmus test.
- 58:29I was like, during all this time when I'm realizing that
- 58:32authentication is the path forward for, for, for, for
- 58:34media. I was like, I cannot believe all
- 58:39if they put an off wall up and say, hey, just we want to, you
- 58:42know, collect your e-mail address to serve you better and
- 58:43give you personal whatever it is, I would 100% do it.
- 58:47Years. It took them years and years and
- 58:49years to do it. And finally they did it.
- 58:51So that's what yeah. For for things looking forward
- 58:54for the open Internet and even television, anything that's not
- 58:59in a walled garden already for it to for those for those
- 59:02enterprises hope to compete in the new media world, they must
- 59:07authenticate their users. There is no other path forward.
- 59:11That's it. That's, that's it.
- 59:13And I think once, I think once as that increases as and I will
- 59:20say that again, the traditional TV networks are and they've
- 59:22learned this and they're trying really hard to authenticate the
- 59:24minute we get authenticated inventory in the non walled
- 59:28garden media world. Now I can buy scale now.
- 59:31And it doesn't really matter if you buy direct.
- 59:33The direct or intermediary buying strategies are really
- 59:36about like how much scale do you want?
- 59:38Do you want to do I really want to do 14 contracts for iOS and
- 59:41two with 14. Sometimes you just want to buy
- 59:43it all that's available. That will work if what I can buy
- 59:47is authenticated and it acts. And that's, and that's one thing
- 59:49that we're doing at Truth Set. We, we're, we're literally
- 59:53walking the walk around this all this whole subject.
- 59:55We're saying the Internet is a mess.
- 59:57It's not good for anybody. There's no one knows what
- 1:00:00they're getting. No one knows how many people are
- 1:00:02behind these IDs. No one knows how much fraud or
- 1:00:04so we want a true set saying. Our approach to this is instead
- 1:00:09of starting with all this static, which might be some
- 1:00:12noise, which might, you might be able to squeeze some signal out
- 1:00:15of which is the state of things, Let's start with all the people.
- 1:00:19Let's, let's recognize that there are 300 million adults or
- 1:00:22whatever the number is. Let's do our best to understand
- 1:00:25those people. Let's build up from them.
- 1:00:27Let's build audiences of the 12 million women today who might be
- 1:00:31who are actually pregnant. Let's, let's let's try to start
- 1:00:35from certainty. Like what does census say this
- 1:00:38audience is? You know, instead of like, hey,
- 1:00:40I'll sell you 6,000,000, you know, left-handed soccer moms in
- 1:00:43Kansas City, Adna that has 1.2 million people in it.
- 1:00:46Like that was the world. That's still the world that
- 1:00:48that's the. Probabilistic world, right?
- 1:00:50It's kind of a it's like a model based guesswork, right?
- 1:00:54So what we're saying is, look, do that if you want, but if you
- 1:00:57want people you want. It's like marketing works when a
- 1:01:01message reaches a human being who's got kids, a wallet, a car,
- 1:01:05a commute, a trip they want to take, not a device, an actual
- 1:01:09human being, right? So let's start there.
- 1:01:12Let's, let's, let's allow a brand to build an audience with
- 1:01:14the certainty that this is the, these are the humans that I want
- 1:01:17to reach. And now let's push that out in
- 1:01:20the ecosystem, ideally doing 1 to 1 API matches with different
- 1:01:24destinations to pull out that 20% of authenticated inventory,
- 1:01:28pull out another 18% here, 12% here, and slowly amass audiences
- 1:01:32that are big enough to justify a decent buy.
- 1:01:35That's what we're trying to do. We're trying to make a person
- 1:01:36based, truly person based. I think that digital and CTV
- 1:01:41should look like direct mail eventually, like eminently
- 1:01:43targetable, eminently measurable, like really, really
- 1:01:47certain. And also prices are going to go
- 1:01:49up. This is a world of, we're moving
- 1:01:51to a world of scarcity. The 20 billion viable IDs
- 1:01:54floating around very which very few, which are actually humans,
- 1:01:57much less the right humans is going to shrink.
- 1:01:59It's and it's going to be a really, really good thing,
- 1:02:01except everyone's going to struggle about prices going up
- 1:02:05because prices will go well. It's interesting.
- 1:02:07To say, because that's been to Doctor Fu, we have had him on
- 1:02:09this podcast a couple times. That's always been his argument
- 1:02:12is that so like you look at the amount of ads spent that's gone
- 1:02:15into digital, it's gone up by, you know, X or something like
- 1:02:18that, right. Over time and the inventory
- 1:02:22hasn't grown that much yet, the CPM continue to collapse, right.
- 1:02:25So there's just a lot of garbage inventory out there.
- 1:02:29If, if, if really it's really because it is a marketplace.
- 1:02:32If anything, CPM should have gone way up because you have
- 1:02:35more money chasing not that much more inventory.
- 1:02:37So that's a good point you make there.
- 1:02:39Yeah. Well, and I and I love your
- 1:02:40point about that direct mail and you know that the digital is
- 1:02:44going to go the way of direct mail.
- 1:02:45I'm in a sense of like the the authentication and the one to
- 1:02:48one reach that you're getting with direct mail.
- 1:02:50Do we still have Scott on the on the line?
- 1:02:54I think we may have lost him well.
- 1:02:55Hey, for everybody that oh, there we are.
- 1:02:57He's back. A little bit of a delay.
- 1:02:59Well, I and I think we were just, we were just did you hear
- 1:03:01us? You you heard us, I'm assuming.
- 1:03:03Yeah, but no, we we're yeah, yeah.
- 1:03:05So, Scott, this has been a great conversation.
- 1:03:07We're all a little bit over our next join.
- 1:03:09Do quick. Hits or we?
- 1:03:10Yeah, we should. Do quick hits or should we?
- 1:03:12Yeah, we'll do some quick hits and then we'll we'll wrap up.
- 1:03:15So this is what we'll just ask you a couple a couple of quick
- 1:03:18questions. I got the first one.
- 1:03:20So what part of the identity ecosystem is most overdue for A
- 1:03:25reckoning? A focus on the quality of these
- 1:03:31linkages, which is the connection of one ID to another.
- 1:03:36People completely misunderstand that.
- 1:03:40Even if I have a quote deterministic ID, someone gave
- 1:03:43me an e-mail address, that's great.
- 1:03:46You can't do anything with that until you connect that e-mail
- 1:03:48address to something else, to whatever it might be, to an IP
- 1:03:52address, right? And, and those linkages,
- 1:03:55everybody for some reason just assumes that those linkages are
- 1:03:59good. They're, they're not good.
- 1:04:00Like the IP address linkage, we talked about 13 to 60% average
- 1:04:05accuracy. I mean, just thrown away
- 1:04:07potentially 8382% of your, your, your, your dollar.
- 1:04:11So I think it's, it's 2 answers. One is it's the linkages that
- 1:04:15people don't understand, that data moves through these hops
- 1:04:19between identity spaces. And each time you lose a lot of
- 1:04:24fidelity, you lose records, and nobody really pays attention to
- 1:04:27how important that is. The other part of the identity
- 1:04:30thing that I would highlight is what we've talked about this
- 1:04:32whole time, which is you need to authenticate your users.
- 1:04:35It's, you know, we're not. We're not 20 years ago, we were
- 1:04:37scared to handle PII. Like you should do that because
- 1:04:40look at the market caps of the other media companies who are
- 1:04:43doing that. It they're worth hundreds of
- 1:04:45billions of dollars. Yeah.
- 1:04:46And they're not. Running into any legal issues,
- 1:04:48right? Usually.
- 1:04:52If they are. It's like a small potatoes
- 1:04:53relative to the, you know, the revenue they're generating from
- 1:04:56it, right? Like, yeah, we still have fines
- 1:04:58for privacy, but like, you look at how much money they're
- 1:05:00making. It's nothing, Yeah.
- 1:05:02It's back to that conversation about that TV network, like
- 1:05:05would you rather just, you know, I don't want to do it and then
- 1:05:08go out of business or like figure out how to do it, figure
- 1:05:10out how to handle the legal liability, the technical
- 1:05:12challenge, which to your point, Rio, there are tons of tools
- 1:05:16that are built to do this. So that's what I'd say about
- 1:05:18identity, Scott. What's a bigger problem in
- 1:05:21what's more corrosive to the system?
- 1:05:24Bad source data, bad modelling, or just perverse bad incentives?
- 1:05:30I mean, all three of those are kind of the same thing.
- 1:05:34I mean, it's they all work together.
- 1:05:36You have perverse incentives which cause you to stretch your
- 1:05:41model to produce an outcome or a audience that you want.
- 1:05:45And then that turns into a, that turns into the first thing,
- 1:05:47which is bad audience data. So literally what you said and
- 1:05:51intentionally, it's a Daisy chain.
- 1:05:53It's the, it's the perverse incentives that drive the misuse
- 1:05:57of technological tools, the modeling and etcetera, which
- 1:06:01produce data that's not actually accurate and reliable and will
- 1:06:03produce a result that you expect.
- 1:06:06So who's got the power to change, to enforce standards, to
- 1:06:09change this is it is it? Does it start with the brands
- 1:06:11that are actually doing the media buying?
- 1:06:13Well, you. Said two words that modify the
- 1:06:16answer a little bit. Yes, the brands are responsible,
- 1:06:20demanding transparency, you know, clarity, all this.
- 1:06:25And they're starting to do it right.
- 1:06:26And it used to be that their agencies weren't so hot on that
- 1:06:30because once they dialed in a model, finally they can survive.
- 1:06:32They don't want to change anything at all.
- 1:06:33They don't want to do that. So, but all that's changing.
- 1:06:35I think the agencies are stepping up.
- 1:06:38I think everybody is realizing that past things have to change.
- 1:06:40And to your point, yes, it has to come from the top.
- 1:06:43You can't blame the data providers.
- 1:06:44You can't blame these intermediaries really, because
- 1:06:46they're just doing what they're what they're asked to do.
- 1:06:48OK. The other words you said, though
- 1:06:51were enforced standards, which is quite interesting.
- 1:06:55I really do believe like I was a Nielsen, I came into Nielsen as
- 1:06:58a, as a skeptic of their business.
- 1:07:00Like, how are you even, how are you making all this money off
- 1:07:03this panel? What the hell?
- 1:07:05And then I I slowly did a 180 and realized how important
- 1:07:10independent measurement is and independent governance and these
- 1:07:15things kind of go together and what what this new world needs.
- 1:07:19We talked about this at the beginning of the of the pod
- 1:07:22here. You really this new world, this
- 1:07:25new messy, crazy, heavily obfuscated, very valuable world
- 1:07:30of CTV and addressable CT addressable television.
- 1:07:33It needs in, it needs independent bodies, whether it's
- 1:07:38governing bodies like a new version of the MRC or or another
- 1:07:44Nielsen that maybe doesn't have the maybe operates differently.
- 1:07:48It has to be, it can't be Nielsen because that would mean
- 1:07:50they have to change their economic model because that that
- 1:07:52will just not work. Maybe it would, I don't know.
- 1:07:54But we need independent. We, it's like when you go to a,
- 1:07:57we drive a car to a gas pump to fill it up.
- 1:08:00If there's no octane rating on that pump, a sticker, you're not
- 1:08:04going to put gas in your car because it might be watered
- 1:08:06down. Because that week the owner
- 1:08:09wanted to buy a boat and he watered down all his gas for,
- 1:08:11you know, he like what that octane rating does is it gives
- 1:08:14the consumer confidence that an independent entity has said
- 1:08:18this, this gas is not going to break your car and it's going to
- 1:08:21give you choice about what grade of gas you want to buy depending
- 1:08:25on your use case. Yeah, BMW or rent a car, rent a
- 1:08:28rental car. So that same thing thing needs
- 1:08:31to exist in the new this new data ecosystem where buyers and
- 1:08:36sellers can agree, if I'm going to buy a identity, if we're
- 1:08:40bretthouse@gmail.com, I need the confidence that he's actually
- 1:08:44male, he's actually married or not, he actually has a cat, all
- 1:08:46these different things about it. So there needs to be some
- 1:08:48independent entity that helps bring trust into this
- 1:08:53data-driven ecosystem, much like Nielsen brought trust into the
- 1:08:57linear television market. I think that's a great way to
- 1:09:00end it. Trust has carried carried
- 1:09:02through this entire episode. And Scott, hey, thanks for the
- 1:09:05time. It was awesome to connect.
- 1:09:06It's a great conversation. Yeah.
- 1:09:08I'm glad we could view this versus a 20 minute at possible
- 1:09:11because, you know, it allows you just to really unpack a lot of
- 1:09:13these pretty heady topics. Yeah.
- 1:09:15This was this was a ton of fun. And thanks for thanks for
- 1:09:17joining us. Yeah, I appreciate.
- 1:09:18You guys really fun and. Everybody that made it this far,
- 1:09:21Deb Deb Deb dot signaling, noise dot AI and you can find us on
- 1:09:24YouTube, Spotify and Apple Podcast, as well as our
- 1:09:28newsletter, which is going far and wide now and we will see you
- 1:09:32next time. Looking forward.
- 1:09:33To it. Thanks everyone.