Latest / The Morning Rundown / Courts, Cash, and Conflict: The Press Ban Fight, Paramount's Big Bill, and Ethiopia on the Brink
Transcript
- 0:00[Maya] Okay, David, don't even sit down because today is a LOT.
- 0:18[David] Already?
- 0:19[David] We haven't even said hi to anybody.
- 0:20[Maya] No time.
- 0:21[Maya] You're Maya.
- 0:22[Maya] I'm-- Wait, I'm Maya.
- 0:24[Maya] You're David.
- 0:25[Maya] This is the Morning Rundown, and we've got three stories that are
- 0:28[Maya] all kind of insane.
- 0:30[David] Courts versus the White House, for one.
- 0:32[Maya] Judges are literally stepping in over who gets to stand in a
- 0:35[Maya] room and ask questions.
- 0:37[David] Which, come on, that's wild on its own.
- 0:39[Maya] Then there's this merger, massive companies, massive deal.
- 0:43[David] And suddenly there's a price tag attached that nobody saw coming.
- 0:47[Maya] Like real money, painful money.
- 0:49[David] And then the tone just drops off a cliff.
- 0:52[Maya] Yeah.
- 0:52[Maya] Ethiopia, Tigray.
- 0:54[Maya] It's looking like round two of something nobody wanted to see again.
- 0:57[David] Heavy stuff.
- 0:58[Maya] Heavy stuff.
- 0:59[Maya] But hey, that's the job.
- 1:02[David] So where do we start?
- 1:03[Maya] Courts.
- 1:04[Maya] Let's start with the courts stepping into this press access fight because
- 1:07[Maya] it's a mess.
- 1:09[Maya] Oh, so a judge just blew up part of that ban.
- 1:14[David] Wait, already?
- 1:15[David] That was fast.
- 1:16[David] A court ordered the government to let CNN, Politico, and MSNOW
- 1:19[David] back in the building.
- 1:20[David] That's the BBC's reporting from Thursday.
- 1:22[Maya] Reinstated.
- 1:24[Maya] Okay, so the ban's dead.
- 1:25[David] Not exactly.
- 1:27[David] The judge is Timothy Kelly, and NBC News reported he only reinstated
- 1:30[David] their access for fourteen days.
- 1:32[Maya] Fourteen days.
- 1:34[Maya] So it's a clock, not a fix.
- 1:36[David] Right.
- 1:36[David] And here's the part that got me.
- 1:38[David] NBC News reported reporters were still locked out Thursday morning because the
- 1:42[David] administration hadn't handed back their hard badges yet, even with a court
- 1:46[David] deadline sitting right there.
- 1:48[Maya] So the judge says let them in, and the White House just
- 1:52[Maya] doesn't?
- 1:53[David] Hold on.
- 1:53[David] The reporting there is specific.
- 1:55[David] It wasn't a policy fight in that moment.
- 1:57[David] It was physical hard badges.
- 1:58[David] No badge, no walking through the door, no matter what the judge
- 2:01[David] signed.
- 2:02[Maya] That's such a bureaucratic way to slow walk a court order.
- 2:05[Maya] Like, technically, we're complying.
- 2:08[Maya] We just haven't found the badge yet.
- 2:10[David] For a stretch, yeah.
- 2:11[David] NBC News reported Trump responded to the whole thing by calling it,
- 2:14[David] quote, "The ban on the free press."
- 2:17[Maya] Which is a hell of a thing to say about your own
- 2:19[Maya] administration's rule.
- 2:21[David] I mean, he's not wrong that it's a ban.
- 2:23[David] He's just framing it like somebody else did it to him.
- 2:26[Maya] Fair.
- 2:27[Maya] But okay, step back a second.
- 2:29[Maya] Even if these three outlets get their badges back next week, does
- 2:33[Maya] that actually settle anything?
- 2:35[David] No.
- 2:35[David] And that's the piece I keep coming back to.
- 2:38[David] A win in court for CNN and Politico doesn't answer the question
- 2:41[David] whether the White House has the authority to set its own credentialing
- 2:44[David] rules in the first place.
- 2:45[Maya] Right.
- 2:46[Maya] Because it's their building, their briefing room.
- 2:49[David] Exactly.
- 2:50[David] And courts have generally been cautious about telling the executive branch who
- 2:53[David] it has to let stand in its own press room.
- 2:56[David] Fourteen days buys time.
- 2:57[David] It doesn't decide the question.
- 2:59[Maya] So what happens after fourteen days, though?
- 3:01[Maya] Does it just expire and we're back to square one?
- 3:05[David] Basically, the order doesn't force a permanent fix.
- 3:07[David] It just holds the line while the bigger legal fight plays out.
- 3:11[David] It could get appealed, extended, or just quietly die once the underlying
- 3:14[David] case moves forward.
- 3:16[Maya] Hmm.
- 3:16[Maya] And I'll say I get why some people aren't losing sleep on
- 3:20[Maya] this one.
- 3:20[David] Yeah?
- 3:21[Maya] A couple of these outlets have a pretty long track record of
- 3:24[Maya] adversarial coverage toward this White House.
- 3:26[Maya] So when the administration says, "We get to decide who's in the
- 3:29[Maya] room," that's not a crazy position to hold, even if the execution
- 3:33[Maya] here was messy.
- 3:34[David] It's the messy execution that's the problem.
- 3:36[David] Lock the door, miss your own court deadline, then complain about a
- 3:39[David] free press ban you just got sued over.
- 3:42[Maya] When you put it that way.
- 3:44[David] I'm just reading it back to you.
- 3:45[Maya] No, no, I hear it.
- 3:47[Maya] Fourteen days, then we find out if this was a blip or
- 3:50[Maya] the start of something longer.
- 3:51[David] And it's worth remembering this isn't the first time an administration has
- 3:54[David] drawn hard lines around who gets a seat in that briefing room.
- 3:58[David] Access to power is always a fight.
- 3:59[David] It's usually just quieter than this.
- 4:01[Maya] Right.
- 4:02[Maya] Normally, it's a phone call, not a lawsuit and a missed badge
- 4:05[Maya] deadline.
- 4:06[David] And it's not just optics for reporters either.
- 4:08[David] Access to daily briefings can shape which stories actually reach people first.
- 4:13[David] So a shutout like this has real downstream effects on what gets
- 4:15[David] covered.
- 4:16[Maya] Which is a fair point, but that cuts both ways.
- 4:19[Maya] If outlets misuse the access to score points rather than report, that's
- 4:23[Maya] part of why administrations get twitchy about who's in the room in
- 4:26[Maya] the first place.
- 4:27[David] Sure, but the remedy for that is public accountability, not just cutting
- 4:30[David] off the mic.
- 4:32[David] Otherwise, you get a White House picking its own audience.
- 4:34[Maya] I hear that.
- 4:35[Maya] Either way, it's a fight we'll be watching past these fourteen days.
- 4:38[David] Yeah.
- 4:39[David] And if there's a silver lining, it's that this is happening in
- 4:41[David] full public view instead of some quiet backroom decision.
- 4:45[Maya] Small mercy, but I'll take transparency over another quiet phone call.
- 4:49[David] Speaking of things with a longer fight ahead and money attached.
- 4:52[Maya] Oh, here we go.
- 4:54[David] Let's get into the Paramount-Warner mess because this one has a
- 4:57[David] number attached that'll make your eyes water.
- 5:00[Maya] So picture this.
- 5:01[Maya] Everybody's set for a hearing where a judge just rubber-stamps the Paramount-Warner Brothers settlement.
- 5:06[Maya] Just a formality, right?
- 5:07[David] That's what everyone assumed.
- 5:09[Maya] Then right before that hearing, critics of the whole deal got a
- 5:11[Maya] motion granted that stopped it cold.
- 5:15[Maya] TheWrap covering this move by move, and their timeline is basically hearing
- 5:18[Maya] scheduled, motion filed, settlement halted, at least for now.
- 5:23[Maya] Wait, so the people who hate the deal actually won something?
- 5:29[David] Wait, so the people who hate the deal actually won something?
- 5:33[Maya] For the moment, yeah.
- 5:34[David] Okay, that's a twist.
- 5:36[Maya] It gets more specific too.
- 5:38[Maya] The Wrap reported the judge handling this, a judge named Martinez-Olguin, is
- 5:42[Maya] the one who held off on approving it.
- 5:45[David] And what's actually in the settlement she's sitting on?
- 5:48[Maya] This is the part that got me.
- 5:50[Maya] There's a thirty million dollar penalty per film if a movie misses
- 5:55[Maya] its theatrical release.
- 5:56[David] Per movie?
- 5:57[Maya] Per movie.
- 5:59[Maya] And on top of that, forced divestitures.
- 6:02[Maya] They'd have to give up Miramax, like the studio.
- 6:05[David] The studio.
- 6:06[Maya] And BET, the network.
- 6:09[David] Okay, so this isn't a slap on the wrist.
- 6:11[David] This is like restructure the whole company.
- 6:13[Maya] And divestitures like that aren't quick either.
- 6:16[Maya] You're talking about untangling decades of catalog deals, library rights, and contracts
- 6:22[Maya] before you can even hand the keys.
- 6:24[David] So even if the settlement goes through eventually, selling Miramax isn't a
- 6:27[David] same-day transaction.
- 6:29[Maya] Right.
- 6:30[Maya] And here's where the money gets scary.
- 6:32[Maya] NBC Los Angeles reported that under the merger terms, Paramount owes Warner
- 6:37[Maya] Bros. Discovery shareholders an extra seven million dollars a day starting October
- 6:44[Maya] first for every day this stays unresolved.
- 6:47[David] Seven million a day.
- 6:48[Maya] A day.
- 6:50[Maya] Think about it like this.
- 6:51[Maya] That's roughly the cost of a small office building every single day
- 6:55[Maya] the lawyers can't get this signed.
- 6:57[David] And this is on top of the actual deal?
- 7:00[Maya] On top of an eighty-one billion dollar deal that's already cleared regulators
- 7:05[Maya] in more than sixty-five countries.
- 7:08[David] Sixty-five countries said yes, and one motion in one courtroom just put
- 7:11[David] a clock on it.
- 7:12[Maya] And think about who actually eats the cost if this drags on.
- 7:16[Maya] It's not just corporate boardrooms.
- 7:18[Maya] Shareholders take the hit, and eventually that trickles into decisions about content
- 7:23[Maya] budgets.
- 7:24[Maya] So maybe fewer shows green-lit while everybody waits on a courtroom?
- 7:29[David] That's the thing that bugs me.
- 7:30[David] Look, I'm not gonna sit here and tell you media consolidation is
- 7:33[David] great.
- 7:34[David] I get why people are nervous about one company owning that much
- 7:37[David] content.
- 7:38[Maya] Sure.
- 7:38[David] But you've got a deal that cleared antitrust review basically everywhere on
- 7:42[David] Earth, and now one motion can turn on a seven million dollar
- 7:45[David] a day meter starting next week.
- 7:47[David] That's not regulators doing their job.
- 7:49[David] That's one court freezing global commerce because somebody filed the right paperwork
- 7:53[David] at the right minute.
- 7:54[Maya] I mean, isn't that kind of the point of the courts, though?
- 7:57[Maya] Somebody gets to challenge it.
- 7:59[David] Challenge it, sure, but there's a difference between a challenge and holding
- 8:02[David] sixty-five countries worth of approval hostage over one filing.
- 8:06[David] If this drags into November, that's hundreds of millions of dollars just
- 8:10[David] bleeding out because of scheduling.
- 8:12[Maya] What's the actual argument the challengers are making?
- 8:14[Maya] Do we know, or is it just we don't like it?
- 8:17[David] The reporting so far is mostly about the mechanics of the settlement
- 8:19[David] itself, not a full breakdown of every objection, but the headline is
- 8:23[David] simple.
- 8:24[David] Whatever their reasoning, it was enough to get a judge to pump
- 8:27[David] the brakes right before the finish line.
- 8:29[Maya] Do we know how long the judge is actually taking?
- 8:32[David] Not from what's out there yet.
- 8:33[David] It's just delayed.
- 8:35[Maya] So nobody knows if this is a two-week thing or a two-month
- 8:39[Maya] thing.
- 8:39[David] Nope.
- 8:40[David] And every day it's undecided, that meter's running.
- 8:43[Maya] What about the people already working on shows tied to this merger?
- 8:46[Maya] Do they just sit in limbo too?
- 8:48[David] Basically, yeah.
- 8:50[David] Greenlights get cautious.
- 8:51[David] Budgets get frozen.
- 8:53[David] Nobody wants to commit real money to a slate when the corporate
- 8:56[David] structure above it might look completely different in a month.
- 8:59[Maya] So even folks who have nothing to do with the courtroom fight
- 9:02[Maya] end up waiting on a judge's calendar.
- 9:04[David] That's the collateral damage nobody puts in the headline.
- 9:07[David] It's not just shareholders.
- 9:08[David] It's every project sitting one signature away from getting made.
- 9:12[Maya] And regulators sixty-five countries deep usually don't reopen their review just because
- 9:17[Maya] one US court hits pause, right?
- 9:19[David] Right.
- 9:20[David] This is a domestic wrinkle, not a global one.
- 9:23[David] But domestic can still mean expensive.
- 9:26[Maya] Man.
- 9:26[Maya] Okay.
- 9:27[Maya] Well, that's a story we'll have to watch play out.
- 9:29[David] Definitely.
- 9:30[Maya] Okay.
- 9:30[Maya] From boardrooms to something a lot heavier.
- 9:33[Maya] Let's talk about Ethiopia, because this one isn't about money, it's about
- 9:37[Maya] people.
- 9:37[David] Yeah.
- 9:38[David] Different kind of stakes entirely.
- 9:40[Maya] So Ethiopia and Tigray are back to trading accusations, and each side
- 9:45[Maya] says the other started shooting first.
- 9:47[David] That's never a good sign.
- 9:49[Maya] And this isn't happening quietly either.
- 9:51[Maya] It's playing out in real time as accusations fly from both capitals.
- 9:55[David] Which makes it harder to know who to believe on any given
- 9:58[David] claim.
- 9:59[Maya] BBC reported that local authorities in Tigray have seized the region's airports,
- 10:04[Maya] and that came right after word of fresh drone strikes.
- 10:07[David] Wait, they took the airports themselves?
- 10:10[Maya] That's what's being reported.
- 10:11[Maya] No civilian flights, no easy way to move anyone out if this
- 10:15[Maya] turns into something bigger.
- 10:16[David] Seizing your own airports is a pretty extreme move for a government
- 10:20[David] to make against its own citizens, even in a crisis.
- 10:23[Maya] It tells you how much they think this could escalate.
- 10:25[Maya] They're not taking chances on people or supplies moving freely.
- 10:29[David] Okay, so who's actually behind the drone strikes?
- 10:32[Maya] A group called ACLED, they track conflicts around the world, says Ethiopian
- 10:37[Maya] forces have been hitting Mekelle and southern Tigray with drones for months
- 10:41[Maya] now.
- 10:42[David] Months, not days.
- 10:44[Maya] Right.
- 10:44[Maya] This isn't a sudden flare-up.
- 10:46[Maya] It's been building.
- 10:47[David] So this has been simmering for months while everyone's attention was elsewhere.
- 10:51[Maya] Exactly.
- 10:52[Maya] It's not like it came out of nowhere.
- 10:53[Maya] The strikes were already happening.
- 10:55[Maya] It's the ground offensive that's new.
- 10:57[David] And people forget there was already a war here.
- 11:00[Maya] Yeah.
- 11:00[Maya] Twenty twenty to twenty twenty-two, and the estimate on that one is
- 11:04[Maya] brutal.
- 11:05[Maya] Something like six hundred thousand people died.
- 11:08[David] That's more than some entire wars in modern history.
- 11:11[Maya] It is.
- 11:11[Maya] So when people say they're scared of round two, that's the math
- 11:14[Maya] they're doing in their heads.
- 11:16[David] And that math is exactly why the airport seizures matter so much.
- 11:19[David] If this turns into a siege situation, there's no way out for
- 11:22[David] civilians.
- 11:23[Maya] Right.
- 11:24[Maya] That's the nightmare scenario everyone's trying to avoid repeating.
- 11:27[David] Who's claiming what on the ground right now?
- 11:29[Maya] The Tigray army is saying the federal government launched a full-scale offensive,
- 11:34[Maya] infantry and drones together.
- 11:36[David] And the other side?
- 11:38[Maya] A senior advisor to Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed is putting it on
- 11:42[Maya] the TPLF, saying they're the ones who started the fighting.
- 11:46[David] It's the same story like last time too, both sides blaming the
- 11:49[David] other and nobody outside really able to verify who's telling the truth
- 11:52[David] first.
- 11:53[David] That ambiguity is basically the norm in conflicts like this.
- 11:57[Maya] Which is part of why these conflicts are so hard to cover
- 12:00[Maya] responsibly.
- 12:01[Maya] You're working off claims from both governments, not confirmed facts on the
- 12:05[Maya] ground, and by the time anyone verifies anything, the situation's already moved
- 12:10[Maya] on.
- 12:10[David] So nobody agrees on who fired first.
- 12:13[Maya] Nobody ever does in these situations.
- 12:15[David] And there's no outside force really pushing to stop it either.
- 12:18[Maya] Not that we're seeing reported anywhere right now.
- 12:21[David] No ceasefire talks, no outside mediator stepping in that we've seen reported,
- 12:26[David] and no clear signal anyone with leverage is even trying yet.
- 12:29[Maya] Which means whatever happens next is probably going to happen fast and
- 12:33[Maya] without much warning based on how quickly this all turned this week.
- 12:37[David] 600,000 dead the last time, and it sounds like the pieces are
- 12:41[David] already moving again.
- 12:42[Maya] That's the part that should worry people more than it seems to.
- 12:45[David] It really is, and it's the kind of story that can get
- 12:47[David] buried under all the entertainment and business news today.
- 12:50[Maya] Which is exactly why it's worth stopping on, even for just a
- 12:54[Maya] minute before we move on.
- 12:55[David] And it's worth saying, most of the people caught in the middle
- 12:58[David] of this didn't choose any of it.
- 13:00[David] They're just trying to get through another day while two governments trade
- 13:03[David] blame.
- 13:04[Maya] That's true of basically every conflict like this.
- 13:07[Maya] The people paying the highest price are rarely the ones making the
- 13:10[Maya] decisions.
- 13:11[David] Which is exactly why outside attention matters, even from a morning podcast
- 13:16[David] a world away.
- 13:17[Maya] Even just naming it clearly so it doesn't slide by unnoticed.
- 13:21[David] And there's no version of this where more waiting helps anyone on
- 13:24[David] the ground.
- 13:25[Maya] No.
- 13:26[Maya] Time is not on their side here.
- 13:28[David] Yeah.
- 13:29[David] That's a heavy note to end on, so let's wrap things up.
- 13:32[Maya] So when you zoom out on today, courts telling the press who
- 13:36[Maya] gets a badge, a judge holding up an $81 billion merger, and
- 13:41[Maya] a government in Addis Ababa trading blame with its own region, it's
- 13:45[Maya] really one story.
- 13:46[David] Yeah.
- 13:47[David] Institutions deciding who holds the power and who pays for it.
- 13:50[Maya] Right.
- 13:51[David] Access, money, territory, different rooms, same fight.
- 13:55[Maya] When you put it that way, it's a lot for one morning.
- 13:58[David] It kinda always is.
- 13:59[Maya] I keep coming back to the reporters stuck outside without their badges,
- 14:03[Maya] honestly.
- 14:03[David] Mhm.
- 14:04[Maya] Like, Somebody somewhere is still deciding who gets in the room, and
- 14:08[Maya] we don't even know who yet.
- 14:10[David] That's the thread, though.
- 14:11[Maya] Yeah.
- 14:11[David] Money, access, territory.
- 14:13[David] Somebodys always deciding.
- 14:15[Maya] Well, on that note, thank you guys so much for hanging out
- 14:18[Maya] with us this morning.
- 14:19[David] Appreciate you.
- 14:20[Maya] We'll catch you next time.
- 14:21[Maya] Same place, same coffee.
- 14:23[David] Same coffee.
- 14:24[Maya] Bye, everybody.