Latest / The Bitcoin Way Podcast / How Bitcoin Becomes Nothing | Ep. #109
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, Michael here with the Bitcoin Way podcast. Thank you for tuning in. Today on the
- 0:03show, I have Chris Guida. Chris is an outspoken developer and a big proponent of BIP110,
- 0:10NOTS. He lays it all out. I think this was one of the best explanations I've heard
- 0:14in one concise place where we talk about NOTS, the origins of the node debates and everything,
- 0:19all the implementations, and we get into BIP110, what it is, why he thinks everyone should be
- 0:23signaling it. You're going to love this discussion. It does get a little bit technical, but I think
- 0:27it's high level enough that if you've been following Bitcoin for any period of time,
- 0:31you're going to kind of track and hopefully you're convinced one way or the other at the end.
- 0:44Hey, everyone. Like I said in the intro, I've got Chris here with me. Chris,
- 0:48welcome to the Bitcoin Way podcast. Hey, Michael. Thanks for having me.
- 0:52I appreciate you joining, man. This has been too long. We should have been talking about this a
- 0:56while back. I've had a mechanic on, I've had sort of different perspectives. Pierre Richard came on
- 1:02during the heat of the knots versus core debate. But when I get into some of the technical details
- 1:08of BIP 110, I want to keep it high level enough that people can follow if they're not a developer
- 1:13and I'm not. So I'm going to be asking these questions out of genuine curiosity. Let's start
- 1:18just briefly, a quick background on you. You've been a developer for a long time, Bitcoin focused
- 1:24now for several years. What was the moment that made Bitcoin resonate with you where you said,
- 1:31okay, I'm going all in, I'm dedicating my time to this? Oh, man. Yeah. So I've been, as you said,
- 1:37I've been a professional developer for a while, 2010 is when I started. I became a Bitcoin developer
- 1:42in 2020. And the moment that I said, I want to be all in on Bitcoin, I think was much earlier
- 1:51when I first got into Bitcoin, I was kind of always trying to find a way to get into Bitcoin
- 1:55development because I was just so interested in Bitcoin and how, you know, how it can give you
- 2:00freedom in your life. Basically, several years, maybe over a decade ago is when I first got into
- 2:08Bitcoin. And I guess there were lots of things that just kind of pulled me in. But one of the
- 2:16things I realized was that, I mean, so the real killer app for me was actually the Silk Road.
- 2:22When I realized that, oh my God, there's a whole, you know, like Agora marketplace functioning
- 2:31basically like outside the law. The people running it seem to be like these, like basically moral
- 2:36upstanding people, but they just, you know, there's these certain, you know, substances and
- 2:40whatever that are illegal for, in my opinion, not great reasons. But there's this payment system
- 2:48that you can use that nobody can stop. And I was like, that was sort of, I guess,
- 2:56the beginning of the rabbit hole. But I had already sort of started getting into
- 3:00libertarian politics and sort of realizing how the financial system, the monetary system
- 3:06is sort of very oppressive, but in ways that are not obvious. And I realized that Bitcoin can
- 3:14provide freedom both on the individual level, but also on a societal level. And so I think
- 3:20my sort of Bitcoin moment was, yeah, over a decade ago, I would say, when I realized,
- 3:26oh, this is the way forward for humanity. Yeah, absolutely. I couldn't agree more with that.
- 3:32Okay, so let's jump right in, because this could be a long conversation. I'm going to have a lot of
- 3:36dumb questions for you. I've studied this and then forgot it. It's like learning Spanish for me,
- 3:40right? If I don't use it, I lose it kind of thing. So a lot of these things are very fuzzy for me
- 3:45right now. I haven't dug deep lately. So the technical crux of the debate that's been raging,
- 3:52knots versus core, I think BIP 110 is sort of an extension of all of that, has been, as I
- 3:58understand it, to be related to the SegWit witness discount. So data stored in the section,
- 4:03It's cheaper than regular transactions.
- 4:05And critics say that this was designed for signatures, smart contract features.
- 4:08It's not for JPEGs, which is obviously a huge concern for many people.
- 4:13Is that a good way of framing it?
- 4:16How would you reframe that, perhaps?
- 4:18So I agree that the SegWit discount has caused there to be more spam than there would be otherwise.
- 4:26But I disagree that there's sort of an implication there that, oh, well, if we got rid of the
- 4:32discount, then the problem will be fixed. And I don't agree with that. There are always going to
- 4:39be incentives for people to put arbitrary data in the chain because Bitcoin's blockchain is very,
- 4:45very useful for storing arbitrary data. What it's especially useful for is what we call gamified
- 4:51spam, which is effectively shit coins, right? It's these token projects that they're pumping
- 4:57and dumps, right? They're just a way for scammers to do a quick money grab by leveraging Bitcoin's
- 5:04brand, right? It's basically like an, what's it called? Like an affinity scam of Bitcoin. They're
- 5:08saying, oh, we're building on Bitcoin. So this is, we're all Bitcoiners and we're doing Bitcoin stuff,
- 5:12but it's a lie, right? It's a big scam. And so they just, they do these pump and dumps. And
- 5:17what happens is the people, their victims are trying to get rich. And so when they're not very
- 5:27sensitive to fees. So the fees can go up to $50 or $100 per transaction, but these people think
- 5:33they're going to be millionaires. So it doesn't really matter whether the witness discount is
- 5:38there. The witness discount provides a 75% discount, which is significant. And if we lowered it, that
- 5:43could maybe help a little bit. But the thing that keeps spam away, and if you study Bitcoin history,
- 5:51you realize the thing that keeps spam away is an attitude of hostility towards spam.
- 5:55And so we had this exact same battle a little over a decade ago, and it was called the Op-Raturn War. And BitMEX actually wrote a great article about it, which everyone should read, where basically Bitcoin culture was hostile to these spammy shitcoin use cases.
- 6:14and there were people like Luke Dasher, Jeff Garzik,
- 6:20and many other Bitcoin Core devs at the time
- 6:22who were very hostile to these use cases
- 6:24and basically put up a credible front of,
- 6:30well, we're just going to keep fighting against this spam
- 6:33and every time the spammers make a move,
- 6:35we're going to make another move
- 6:36and we're going to keep escalating until they go away.
- 6:40And eventually what happened is there was this sort of compromise,
- 6:43which is Op return, where it's known as like a garbage bin, you know, okay, well, the spammers
- 6:51are going to spam. So, you know, let's just give them a place that's, you know, as harmless as
- 6:55possible. And so that was Op return. And then the spammers went away for about a decade. And then
- 7:02they started coming back with ordinals. So we're just having, you know, part two of that war.
- 7:06So we really need to look to how we won historically and just do the same thing again.
- 7:14Can you explain what's different?
- 7:17Why did the spammers go away for a decade?
- 7:19What was it?
- 7:20And then why did ordinals and some of these other, what I would agree with you, sort of
- 7:26shitcoiny, scammy sort of projects come about?
- 7:29Was it just they figured out that there was a way for them to do these things using the
- 7:34existing tools?
- 7:35Yeah.
- 7:36And so what happened in 2014 is that the spammers decided to go spam on other blockchains.
- 7:43So at first they were like, well, you know, we can leverage Bitcoin security because Bitcoin
- 7:48is so secure because it's the number one cryptocurrency.
- 7:52And so there were people like the counterparty guys, there was Omni, and then there was Vitalik
- 7:59with Ethereum.
- 8:00And you can look back at his tweets.
- 8:02he was thinking about building Ethereum on Bitcoin.
- 8:07And he basically said, he explicitly stated
- 8:10that he noticed that the Bitcoin devs
- 8:13were hostile to use cases like his.
- 8:17And so he knew that the Bitcoin core devs
- 8:18were gonna be at war with him.
- 8:20And so he decided to go build another blockchain.
- 8:23And so what happened is the shitcoiners,
- 8:24in that moment, that's when the shitcoin industry
- 8:28was kind of born.
- 8:29because all of the cryptocurrency activity
- 8:34was going to happen on Bitcoin up until that moment.
- 8:36But then when Ethereum came about,
- 8:38all of the shitcoiners
- 8:39and all these sort of fiat brain people
- 8:41realized, oh, we can just make our own blockchain, right?
- 8:44We don't have to do this on Bitcoin.
- 8:45We can just go to this other blockchain
- 8:47or this long tail of other shitcoins
- 8:50and we can do our shitcoin use cases over there.
- 8:54And basically what happened is the scams dried up.
- 8:57everybody realized, oh, these are scams, you know? And so these pump and dumps have a certain life
- 9:03cycle, right? Like you have to, they keep going as long as there's a, as long as the sort of shared
- 9:09delusion can be maintained. The shared delusion can be maintained as long as there's a sense that
- 9:14something novel is happening. So, you know, there was a big NFT craze on Ethereum in starting with
- 9:21CryptoKitties, like in 2017, which made an Ethereum node impossible to run. But then it really sort of
- 9:26reached its peak in 2021. And then it sort of crashed. And then after that, all of the NFT
- 9:32scammers just kind of went away because the public had wised up to the scam. But then what happened
- 9:38with ordinals is that something that appeared novel happened, which is that, oh, now we can do
- 9:43NFTs, same as before, but now it's on Bitcoin. And so this felt novel again. And so the scam sort of
- 9:50got this renewed energy. So that's really all that happened, right? It's these people who are just
- 9:55these DGens who are like going to the casino and they're trying to gamble and they're trying to get
- 9:59rich quick. Most of them are losing their shirts, but some of them are getting, you know, rich in
- 10:03the short term. In the long term, usually they end up just blowing the money on something else.
- 10:08But yeah, that's I think that hope that answers your question. Yeah. Yeah. So in your view is the
- 10:13incentive, because like what I think of is we're going to have you're putting Bitcoin's future at
- 10:20risk when you do these things. I'm not saying it's over. Like my conviction is still very high.
- 10:25But you're putting Bitcoin's future at risk.
- 10:28Is the incentive for the people promoting these what you refer to as scams?
- 10:33And candidly, I generally agree with that sentiment.
- 10:37When you say putting Bitcoin's future at risk, you're talking about the scammers are putting Bitcoin's future at risk, right?
- 10:42Correct. Correct. Yeah.
- 10:43So they are comfortable doing that, in your view, not because they aren't concerned about Bitcoin's future.
- 10:53Like they, they, they're just, they're just hoping to get rich quick.
- 10:57Like that's really what it amounts to.
- 11:00And if Bitcoin dies because of it, who cares?
- 11:02They made their money.
- 11:03They got out.
- 11:04Is that kind of the.
- 11:05Exactly.
- 11:06Yeah.
- 11:06So there's, there's a kind of, um, you know, and, and, and, uh, this is very deep in, in
- 11:11Bitcoin culture that, um, there's a certain darkness to fiat culture.
- 11:16There's a certain, there's a certain, um, high time preference that, that fiat money
- 11:21being the reserve asset creates in people.
- 11:23It incentivizes short-term thinking.
- 11:28And it incentivizes this exact behavior, right?
- 11:32Like, oh, well, I don't have to plan for the future.
- 11:33And I can't plan for the future.
- 11:35Planning for the future is actually punished under a fiat standard.
- 11:38And so my best path towards prosperity for myself and my descendants is to just try and
- 11:47just keep rolling the dice.
- 11:50That's kind of the best strategy on a fiat standard.
- 11:53So if you're a fiat brain person and you've grown up surrounded by fiat culture and you're used to your money just kind of evaporating away all the time and you're looking for some way to get ahead, it actually is kind of a good strategy if you're sort of spiritually bereft to just kind of go to the casino and see if you can get lucky.
- 12:12Okay. So is your position then that if people seek to allow Bitcoin to do anything because it's valid consensus, it's a valid transaction, it effectively becomes nothing because it's no longer peer-to-peer electronic cash.
- 12:32And it just becomes whatever the hell anyone wants it to be. And in the future, it could be some other iteration of some sort of shitcoin scam on top of Bitcoin as well.
- 12:42Right now, it's money versus arbitrary data.
- 12:45It's a file storage database.
- 12:48Is that?
- 12:48Yeah.
- 12:49Yeah.
- 12:49So it's wonderful, actually, that we drove Vitalik to create his own blockchain because
- 12:56Ethereum shows us all of the things that are going to happen to Bitcoin that wait down
- 13:00this road of just kind of let the money printer have its way with Bitcoin.
- 13:07um that exactly what has happened to ethereum is what is going to happen to bitcoin if we do that
- 13:12and bitcoiners are very sort of libertarian minded they they believe in free markets but
- 13:17what they don't realize is that when you just when you just say all behavior is is is you know
- 13:22morally equivalent you know all and and and um the bitcoin system should not should not bias any
- 13:28particular behavior over any other behavior um as long as you know as long as everything's paying
- 13:34a fee per data. That's the only metric that we need to look at. What libertarians don't realize
- 13:39is that we don't exist in a free market right now. We exist under a fiat standard, which is
- 13:45actually very authoritarian. There's people who pull the levers to print the money. And those are
- 13:50the people that are going to end up in charge of Bitcoin if we allow the free market to have its
- 13:54way with Bitcoin. It's not really the free market, right? What's happening is that the fiat printer
- 13:59comes in and captures Bitcoin. And if you want to see what's going to happen to Bitcoin,
- 14:05all you need to do is look at Ethereum. That is what's waiting for us down that road.
- 14:10Okay. So let me give you an analogy that I've sort of used in my mind. I think other people
- 14:14probably used it too, but I want you to either poke holes in it or tell me if this is right.
- 14:19So a group of people get together in a community and they're like, hey, let's design and build a
- 14:24park for us all to use freely. Right. Um, and the intent of this park is for, you know, our kids to
- 14:30play on the playground, for us to have picnics, to do all these things. And then you've got more
- 14:35people show up and they're using the park for the same purposes as intended. And then more people
- 14:40show up and they want to start putting graffiti on, on the playground and on the, uh, you know,
- 14:46the, the, the pickleball court ground, you know, like whatever it is that they're doing.
- 14:51And you say, look, technically, it's not like any of us own this. However, this was never the design. Take your graffiti and all the other things that you're doing, shooting off fireworks or whatever, take it somewhere else.
- 15:04Like this was growing garbage or letting the dogs poop everywhere, you know, just kind of leaving a mess.
- 15:09Yeah. So is that sort of the justification as an analogy? Is that sort of the justification you would use for saying, no, even though this is a decentralized thing that no one operates independently or centrally, that's effectively what this whole debate amounts to?
- 15:28yeah i mean basically what what our opponents who tend to be core supporters are arguing is that um
- 15:36well the the people who are using the park for for good things are going to price out the people
- 15:41who are using the park for bad things and uh this argument is insane i don't know why anybody would
- 15:46believe it yeah if you just if you just if you have two brain cells to rub together you realize
- 15:51this is a silly argument um no that's not what's going to happen what's going to happen is it's
- 15:55going, the park is going to get ruined and everyone's going to leave. You know, there needs
- 15:59to be a, you know, even though it's decentralized, right? Even though we're all, you know, we're all
- 16:06working together to make the park happen. There needs to be a sense of what the park is for
- 16:12and what sorts of behaviors are acceptable. What sorts of behaviors are not acceptable.
- 16:18The park has a purpose, right? If the park doesn't have a purpose, then yeah, it's fine to just let
- 16:24anybody do whatever they want. But if the point of the park is for people to be able to go to the
- 16:28park and hang out in nature and touch grass and throw a Frisbee and run around with their dogs,
- 16:36then those are the sorts of activities that should be protected. And similarly with Bitcoin,
- 16:42Bitcoin has a purpose. The purpose is to be money. And in my view, I don't think you should really
- 16:50call yourself a Bitcoiner if you don't believe this, if you don't agree with this. But I think
- 16:55Bitcoin's purpose is to be the next world reserve asset, or at least to be a future world reserve
- 17:00asset so that we can replace the fiat standard with something more just. So that's its purpose.
- 17:07So if there's all of this activity that's competing with that purpose, then Bitcoin is sick or dying.
- 17:15So the sticking point to all of this is while Bitcoin is decentralized, and I would say credibly so, it should be more. We need way more nodes, in my opinion, running online. I mean, that's what we're all about the Bitcoin way. Self-custody, run a node, be self-sovereign.
- 17:31we have this we have the reference implementation core and that is when if someone spins up a brand
- 17:41new node and they know very you know they're brand new to bitcoin they've heard they should
- 17:44run a node by default they're probably going to run core all else equal and there are a handful
- 17:51of developers ultimately a very small group of people who centrally manage that you know and
- 17:58And yes, there's area for public comment.
- 18:03And I mean, we've seen some of this.
- 18:06What's the solution to that?
- 18:09Like, you know what I mean?
- 18:10Like, is it just many implementations?
- 18:12Like, would your hope be that Knotts isn't the only primary alternative and that we'd
- 18:16have tons of implementations?
- 18:18Or do you think we just need a few?
- 18:20Is Core just, are they bought and paid for in your view?
- 18:23I know these are a lot of questions I'm throwing at you.
- 18:25Yeah, I mean, so I think that two implementations is much better than one.
- 18:29I don't know why everybody is like, we need a third implementation.
- 18:32I think we should focus on having a second implementation before we should focus on having
- 18:35a third implementation.
- 18:38But one implementation is obviously not good, right?
- 18:40That's a central point of failure, as you've just noted.
- 18:44It's very easy to see.
- 18:46And I think we've seen very strong evidence recently that this has actually been happening,
- 18:50how a single implementation can become corrupted and subverted
- 18:57to serve the ends of moneyed interests, let's just say,
- 19:03and to no longer serve the interests of the users, right?
- 19:08The node runners, the people who are actually running the software.
- 19:13So yeah, I mean, that situation is very bad.
- 19:16How do we solve it?
- 19:17I think that we should focus on making Notts more decentralized.
- 19:24I think that people have this sort of loop derangement syndrome where they don't like
- 19:28Luke for one reason or another.
- 19:30I think those are irrational fears.
- 19:35Bitcoin Notts is open source.
- 19:37I think that it's totally transparent what Luke does.
- 19:41I'm going to start trying to contribute to Notts actually more pretty soon, hopefully.
- 19:47And, you know, a GitHub repo is centralized.
- 19:58There's nothing that anybody can do about that.
- 20:00There's the people who can, there's the maintainers, right?
- 20:02There's the people who can merge the PRs into the code base
- 20:06and make that officially the code.
- 20:08And so, you know, it's not going to work if there's 100 maintainers.
- 20:12And one maintainer is obviously not good either.
- 20:17Five maintainers is what Bitcoin Core has.
- 20:19That's pretty centralized.
- 20:21One maintainer is what Bitcoin Nots has.
- 20:23That's also pretty centralized.
- 20:24That's even more centralized.
- 20:26But what I don't agree with is people saying,
- 20:29well, we shouldn't support Bitcoin Nots
- 20:32because Bitcoin Nots only has one maintainer.
- 20:34And I'm like, okay, well,
- 20:36two centralized repos
- 20:38are better than one centralized repo.
- 20:41That's still a lot better, right?
- 20:43So but yes obviously it would be ideal if there were many many implementations I think that would be the healthiest thing Yeah You have competition at least So okay So here I tell you how I
- 20:56perceived this being rolled out was because I'm on X, right? So like I'm paying attention to the
- 21:01debate there. I'm not a developer, so I'm not going through all the forums. Although I did go
- 21:06back and revisit that and it's hard to follow if you're not a developer. But the way I saw it was
- 21:12there was sort of a debate about this in the background amongst developers uh maybe some
- 21:18censorship i mean we could talk about that too i'd be curious to hear your opinions but
- 21:21in general there there was there was debate going on but then it felt like it more or less came to
- 21:28the broader public and which happens to be kind of x which is a lot of the node runners right the
- 21:34people who are into bitcoin are on x and they said this is what we're doing that was sort of where
- 21:40for me, I got really turned off. Even if I agreed with the change, philosophically, I can't just get
- 21:49on board with the fact that they wanted to make this change. And it was obviously a very contentious
- 21:53topic. In that sort of environment, my default, or what seems to make sense to me is a default to
- 22:00conservatism. Let's not make the change if this is that heated. And they proceeded anyway. Is that
- 22:07a fair analysis of what you think happened. Do they need to pay attention to what people on X
- 22:12are saying? Okay, so you think they do. Absolutely. Okay, so you hit the nail on the head. That is
- 22:17absolutely right. And their disdain for X users is misplaced. So for one thing,
- 22:28so as I said earlier, devs need to take into account the opinions of the people that are
- 22:34running their software. If they don't do that, people will stop running their software.
- 22:39And so that's why we saw after the PR was open to remove the operaturn limit,
- 22:45we saw a big exodus into Bitcoin Noughts. And then once the PR was merged, you saw another
- 22:51exodus after that. And it went up to 20%. I think it's around 25% people running Noughts.
- 22:56this was perfectly predictable.
- 23:02So another thing,
- 23:07Bitcoin developers tend to be either not node runners.
- 23:11They just have a salary.
- 23:13They're just paid by one of these organizations
- 23:15that funds Bitcoin devs.
- 23:17And they don't necessarily own Bitcoin.
- 23:19They don't necessarily run a node.
- 23:20They don't necessarily align with Bitcoin values.
- 23:23They just have a job.
- 23:24And they're usually these sort of engineering types who like to tinker and solve interesting
- 23:30problems and work on cool tech.
- 23:32And that's great and all, but they tend to get lost in the weeds, right?
- 23:35They tend to look at the trees and they don't tend to look at the forest.
- 23:39So, and as I said, they tend to be just people who are getting paid to work on Bitcoin, but
- 23:45who don't necessarily hold the Bitcoin values.
- 23:48And the ones who do run nodes usually are running them for testing purposes, and they usually have very powerful machines.
- 23:57So developers have very high salaries, and they can usually afford very high-powered machines.
- 24:03And so when they have a lot of complaints about people having trouble syncing their nodes, for instance, a lot of times they just kind of dismiss those complaints as not realistic because they're like, well, I have a $2,000 computer and it syncs Bitcoin in half a day.
- 24:25So why are people worried about this?
- 24:27But when you're working, as I did, with actual merchants trying to get people to accept Bitcoin using their own full nodes, and you realize that merchants don't have $2,000 to spend on a point of sale system, you take a different perspective.
- 24:46Um, so, but anyway, all this is to say that, uh, yes, devs absolutely need to listen to
- 24:52people on, on, on Twitter who are, um, who are telling them in no uncertain terms, I am
- 24:58running a node.
- 24:59I am having problems running my node.
- 25:01I have friends who I have, um, tried to onboard to running nodes and they're struggling.
- 25:06Um, you know, uh, Bitcoin devs need to pay attention to that.
- 25:09Um, and if they don't, then they're going to end up, uh, losing market share, which
- 25:13is exactly what we've seen.
- 25:14okay so to what extent these these bitcoin these core devs who are making these changes supporting
- 25:21these changes to what extent do you believe and i'm sure there's some combination of these two i
- 25:26don't think it's 100 one or the other but i could see it being there are paid interests in the
- 25:32background and they are being asked to do operate in a certain way and their funding's dependent on
- 25:38some variation of that. And then I think you've also got, to your point, my dad used to run a
- 25:45software company and he worked with developers. And it's hard to find developers that are easy
- 25:51to work with because they're so smart, so technically. Good ones are very smart, very
- 25:56technical, and they want to engineer the hell out of everything. And sometimes what you need
- 26:02is simplicity and you need someone who understands the business implication in this case. And for
- 26:08you know, for Bitcoin, you didn't understand the monetary, you know, uh, incentives that are put,
- 26:12put forth by the, the changes you make to what degree do you feel like core is influenced by
- 26:19just excitable engineers versus there's money changing hands in the background to incentivize
- 26:27particular changes? Um, yeah, I, I like to, I like to assume good faith whenever I can. Um,
- 26:36You know, there are definitely moneyed interests that are involved with funding Bitcoin core devs that definitely have an interest in raising the opportunity limit, for instance.
- 26:49But I think the devs themselves, as you said, they just tend to be people who are like basically good people who are, in my opinion, misguided.
- 26:58Right. A lot of them came into Bitcoin with this.
- 27:01So I think it's mostly ideological, right?
- 27:07Bitcoin has this kind of, you know, like F the man, you know, we're going to replace the world order with a Bitcoin standard.
- 27:16And we're going to do it without any violence.
- 27:20And, you know, just people writing software and running software.
- 27:24And there's kind of two different flavors of that.
- 27:27There's the, how do I put this? There's the kind of more, less realistic, more utopian version,
- 27:39which actually you can see in certain strains of anarcho-capitalism, which where,
- 27:46basically, it's kind of like communism, right? Where, okay, we all just have to be good people,
- 27:54and we all just kind of have to help each other out.
- 27:56And then society will just like magically work.
- 28:00There's that kind of dominant ideology among Bitcoin devs
- 28:04where, okay, Bitcoin is just going to kind of magically work.
- 28:09And if it becomes under attack,
- 28:11it will just kind of magically do some kind of Tai Chi move
- 28:15and avoid the attack.
- 28:17But it doesn't need to counterattack or do anything defensive.
- 28:20So, you know, nobody needs to like consciously provide for the collective defense. That's
- 28:27basically what I'm trying to what I'm getting at. There's a strain of libertarianism or
- 28:31anarcho-capitalism that just kind of denies the problem of collective defense. And then you have
- 28:36the other side of anarcho-capitalists or libertarians who understand that you need some
- 28:41kind of sheriff, you know, some kind of defense force who takes responsibility for collective
- 28:49defense. And this is not, you know, this is not statism, right? But it's a more realistic view.
- 28:57And you can see this by, I mean, we can, it's a whole nother conversation.
- 29:02But the upshot- It's like the militia, right? It's not a central power having a standing army,
- 29:09it's the people organizing. And in this case, maybe that would be the node runners, for example.
- 29:14The node runners, exactly. Yes. The node runners need to be conscious of what they're doing.
- 29:18They need to be taking active choices.
- 29:23When a certain group of developers gives them the option of running a certain piece of software,
- 29:28they have to consider that piece of software and be like, is this a good idea to run?
- 29:32Or am I going to take this other software?
- 29:35Because I think that's better in the long term.
- 29:37You need to have a group of principled, long-term thinking,
- 29:41you know, based node runners, you know, who are going to stand up and fight for Bitcoin survival
- 29:49and not just roll over when the free market says that Bitcoin is for free is for data storage.
- 29:57Yeah. So so I agree with that. What concerns me long term is that we are still at least best I
- 30:03can tell in sort of the I mean, at the earliest I mean, or I'm sorry, the latest we're in like the
- 30:10early majority phase of Bitcoiners coming online. I think we're probably even pre early majority
- 30:17coming online. We're still very early. And when I think out 20 or 30 years, who are the next batch
- 30:22of node-orders going to be over that period of time, it's going to be a lot harder to muster up
- 30:27a new crop of libertarian minded people. Do you have any long-term concern with what you just
- 30:34described that that's what Bitcoin is going to sort of depend on is the guy who you've been
- 30:39talking to about Bitcoin for 10 years now, trying to get him into it, buy some, hey, learn about
- 30:45self-custody, run a node. And he's just at every turn it's been known, yeah, maybe someday. And
- 30:51then eventually that guy's going to be a node runner, or at least he's going to be a Bitcoiner
- 30:56because I think you're going to have to be. It's the monetary gunpowder of our age, in my view.
- 31:01Is he going to have the ability to discern in the future what type of node, what software he
- 31:07should be running and what changes are hostile toward Bitcoin as a form of money? Yeah, I mean,
- 31:13it's a difficult question. And, you know, we just kind of have to, it's an iterative process,
- 31:21right? We just have to watch as threats develop and we have to be very vigilant. And when
- 31:27stuff starts to get bad, we have to see if we can recruit people to the cause, you know?
- 31:35So, hey, and Bitcoiners tend to do that, right?
- 31:38They tend to rise to the challenge.
- 31:39When Bitcoin is under threat, they tend to understand this and they tend to be agentic
- 31:46people, right?
- 31:46They tend to be people who can get stuff done and who are willing and able to make a real
- 31:55difference in the world.
- 31:57And when duty calls, they are willing to do that.
- 32:01And we've seen Bitcoiners do this again and again.
- 32:03And, you know, as I mentioned in 2013 and 2014, when we were having, you know, spam war part one, we saw a bunch of node runners come up and say, yeah, we're going to run these filters.
- 32:13We don't like this spam, you know, you know, and a bunch of miners back then.
- 32:18There used to be a lot more principled miners back then.
- 32:21That's definitely a problem.
- 32:22Um, um, but yeah, I mean, the, the, the hope is that, you know, as threats develop, the
- 32:28threats develop slowly enough that people can, can catch them developing before they
- 32:32become, uh, fatal.
- 32:34Um, and, and, and Bitcoiners rise to the challenge to, um, to repel the attack.
- 32:40Um, so.
- 32:41Yeah, no, I think that makes sense.
- 32:43And what gives me hope is like, I've got three kids, one on the way, and they're all going
- 32:47to be running their own node in their teens.
- 32:48You know, like I'm going to be teaching them self custody and they're going to, you know, earn in Bitcoin and that as early as possible.
- 32:56And so one guy myself who just tripped into Bitcoin a few years ago is going to, you know, offload into the world for new node runners who are hopefully critical thinkers and principled in their convictions and can make that discernment.
- 33:10And it seems to me like Bitcoiners tend to populate the earth at a higher rate than many other cohorts.
- 33:16So I'm hopeful, but I wanted to hear your perspective on that.
- 33:20Okay, so let's talk about, we're going to get to BIP-110, I promise.
- 33:24I want to hear your take on this distinction between knots and core, because my understanding
- 33:32is some high 90%, they're the same, right?
- 33:37Like it's 90, they're 99% the same.
- 33:39And there are some configurations in each that are different for a very specific purpose
- 33:44and for nots in order to fight what Luke and folks like yourself view to be spam.
- 33:50How would you explain how these two implementations operate differently?
- 33:57Yeah, I mean, it's an interesting question.
- 33:59I think that Luke has a more specific vision for Bitcoin than Bitcoin Core does.
- 34:07Bitcoin Core seems to have this very diffuse vision of Bitcoin that doesn't, in my view,
- 34:14it's very unfocused and incoherent.
- 34:16It's kind of just like, okay, well, whoever contributes is the one who gets to say where
- 34:21it goes.
- 34:22And then as I alluded to before, there's funding that sort of tends to drag developers'
- 34:29interests in a particular way.
- 34:31And when there's a fiat money printer printing the reserve asset, it tends to go in that
- 34:37direction, in a more fiat direction. And so I think Luke's vision for Bitcoin is more
- 34:43Bitcoin centric. It's more node runner centric. Luke's philosophy is the same thing that you just
- 34:56said, which is there should be as many node runners as possible. The number of node runners
- 35:00is pathetically low right now. Everybody needs to be run. I mean, there's no reason why in the
- 35:06future, everybody, every human in the world can't run a node. The only reason is that the limits,
- 35:17really the block size limit, was set too high. I mean, that's basically what it is.
- 35:24And, you know, so, but the good news is that Moore's law increases exponentially.
- 35:30So what that means is that computing power and, you know, and resources are always
- 35:33increasing exponentially with respect to cost. And so what that means is that the cost of running
- 35:39a Bitcoin node should be decreasing exponentially over time. And so basically as long as we keep
- 35:47the UTXO set limited in size, and this is the big problem that happened during the spam attack in
- 35:542023 and 2024, was the UTXO set exploded in size. And that's why we saw node runners struggling to
- 36:00do IBD, and the cost of running a node, the minimum cost of running a node rising instead
- 36:06of falling exponentially as it's supposed to do, as long as we keep that under control,
- 36:12the block size limit takes care of the rest.
- 36:15But Luke has a great talk about this from 2019 or 2021 or so, a few years ago, where
- 36:24he talks about why the blocks need to be small.
- 36:26And it's basically because of this.
- 36:27We want the technology to catch up and surpass the growth of the blockchain.
- 36:36And if it does that, and if and when it does that in 10 or 20 years, you're going to see
- 36:40the cost, the minimum cost of running a node become cheaper and cheaper and cheaper and
- 36:43cheaper.
- 36:44And eventually, any random person is going to be able to sink a node in under an hour
- 36:49for $5.
- 36:50But we have to focus on that as an outcome or it won't happen because there's all of
- 36:56these other forces that are trying to make Bitcoin nodes harder to run.
- 37:03So, yeah, I think that's a long answer.
- 37:07No, no, that's helpful.
- 37:08So is the incentive in your mind for people to run a node who, like, you know, I mean,
- 37:15you've obviously been very deeply involved in Bitcoin.
- 37:18I've only been around for four years, but I, you know, I did my 2000 hours of podcast
- 37:22listening and read all the books, you know, like I've sort of checked those boxes.
- 37:26For me, it's an act of self-sovereignty.
- 37:29Philosophically, I could not run a node, right?
- 37:32But I also have an economic interest to run a node.
- 37:34I mean, there's privacy,
- 37:35I wanna add decentralization to the network
- 37:37that my net worth is highly dependent upon.
- 37:41In your mind, is the incentive going to be
- 37:45for the next cohort of Bitcoiners who come online to say,
- 37:49I have an economic incentive,
- 37:51I need this network to maintain its decentralized nature
- 37:54to grow in its decentralized nature because my life depends on Bitcoin remaining secure and
- 38:02decentralized. Is that going to be enough, do you think, for many, many people? If they just
- 38:07understand that one thing, they don't have to understand all the nuts and bolts and how mining
- 38:10works and all these things, but if they can just grasp that, is that the incentive?
- 38:15Yeah. I mean, I think the key fight that's happening right now, especially with Bit.1.10,
- 38:21is going to be cultural.
- 38:24If we can keep,
- 38:26if we can preserve Bitcoin's culture
- 38:27as a Bitcoin-centric culture
- 38:29and avoid Bitcoin
- 38:31from sliding into fiat culture,
- 38:34which there are strong forces on it
- 38:37to do that because of funding
- 38:38that comes from fiat VCs,
- 38:40if we can keep Bitcoin's culture strong,
- 38:43then it should be fairly easy
- 38:45to beat that drum
- 38:47and keep teaching new Bitcoiners,
- 38:50You know, run your node, make sure you know what's going on. Don't trust anybody that didn't earn your trust. You know, don't, yeah, don't trust Verify. You know, become a Bitcoin dev, learn the technology. It's not as hard as it sounds. You know, it's, especially now with LLMs, you know, you can just go and you can, you know, ask the LLM, like, hey, explain to me this technical concept. And it's really not difficult concepts.
- 39:18The thing about Bitcoin that's hard is it takes a lot of time because there's a lot of concepts.
- 39:24But it's just a lot of simple concepts that build on top of each other.
- 39:28And so all you have to do is just put in the time and eventually you'll get to the point where you don't need to trust anyone.
- 39:34But as I said, I mean, we have to win this cultural battle.
- 39:38And Bit.10 is primarily a cultural battle.
- 39:41I mean, it's primarily a, are we going to let fiat culture invade Bitcoin and displace Bitcoin culture inside of Bitcoin, which obviously would be fatal? Or is Bitcoin culture going to win? And is Bitcoin spirit going to survive? Is Bitcoin survival instinct going to survive? And are Bitcoin maximalists going to win the day?
- 40:04yeah that's a good it's a good question so the core the core side says that filters don't work
- 40:12miners are going to include these transactions anyways you've got things like slipstream uh
- 40:17from mara um and basically you end up playing whack-a-mole is is kind of which to me it sounds
- 40:22like what you've described is the anti-spam camp playing whack-a-mole over the years and just
- 40:27trying to you know the spammers do something you respond they do something else you respond again
- 40:33is that just the game of the game here? Yeah. I mean, the, the, I mean, yes,
- 40:38it's a cat and mouse game. I mean, the,
- 40:40the fight for freedom is a cat and mouse game.
- 40:42The fight against tyranny is a cat and mouse game.
- 40:44The tyranny always comes back and we always have to fight it.
- 40:46This is not something that can just be a one forever. You know,
- 40:50and this is what I mean by the,
- 40:52these core devs who have more sort of communist leanings or utopian leanings.
- 40:58They think that there's,
- 40:59there's going to be some kind of technical solution that's just going to solve the problem
- 41:04forever. And that's, you know, just study history. That's obviously not going to happen.
- 41:10Now, the good news is that, so the will to fight spam is one of the most important
- 41:20one of the most important features or aspects of the battle against spam. If you think that
- 41:30spam is something that can be defeated, it becomes something that you can defeat. If
- 41:34you think that it not something that you can defeat then it becomes a much more difficult problem And this is precisely the strategy of the spammers right They want to kind of demoralize Bitcoiners
- 41:45and make Bitcoiners believe,
- 41:47oh, there's nothing that we can do to stop it,
- 41:48so we might as well just let it happen.
- 41:51And so, but obviously this is voices of darkness,
- 41:55who are tempting Bitcoiners down a dark path.
- 41:57Let's not listen to those voices.
- 41:59In the past, we easily defeated the spammers
- 42:02because the core developers were willing to play
- 42:07that cat and mouse game.
- 42:09And all they needed to do was commit to playing that game,
- 42:13just commit to escalating.
- 42:14Whenever the spammers come back with some new thing,
- 42:17we just escalate even more.
- 42:20And so the last time this happened, the last Spam War
- 42:24Part 1 in 2013 and 2014, we fought them in policy.
- 42:30We fought them with filters because that's all we needed to do.
- 42:35There's a reason why in evolution animals evolve sort of menacing behaviors or growling behaviors.
- 42:49Bitcoin should have the ability to say, hey, we don't like that.
- 42:53Stop doing that.
- 42:54That's hurting us.
- 42:56And that's what filters do.
- 42:57Filters are this kind of voice that says, hey, this behavior is unacceptable.
- 43:03And these words are backed by force, right?
- 43:10Like an animal is not going to have like a threatened disposition if it can't back up
- 43:14the threats with force.
- 43:16And the consensus rules are force.
- 43:20And so back in the day when we were fighting spam, the devs just needed to say, hey, we're going to filter your spam because it was implied.
- 43:32We're going to find some way in consensus to block this stuff if you don't back down.
- 43:37And so the spammers just said, OK, well, we're going to go somewhere else.
- 43:41So usually that's all you need to do.
- 43:43But when core, when the dominant Bitcoin implementation is on the side of the spammers,
- 43:50then that's a much worse situation for Bitcoin node runners.
- 43:54Because now the dominant node implementation is saying there's nothing we can do to fight
- 43:58spam and we absolutely commit to never attempting to fight spam.
- 44:02So what's that going to do?
- 44:03That has the obvious effect of now the spammers are going to be emboldened.
- 44:06Now the spammers are going to redouble their efforts.
- 44:08They're going to like, there's a whole shit coin industry out there that wants to come and spam Bitcoin and turn it into Ethereum. And if we don't do anything about that, that's what they're going to do. So, I mean, it's really unfortunate that that core sort of betrayed us this time around. But, you know, so we're so we have to take the battle to the consensus layer. So that's what we're going to do.
- 44:29Okay. So one last question before we get to the battle at the consensus layer. Some of the core, I guess, the core sympathizers would argue that filters could actually increase mining centralization because they push transactions to out-of-band channels controlled by obviously like the large miners.
- 44:50How do you think about that trade-off?
- 44:52And if you're willing and able, if you could sort of steelman that argument and then dismantle it in sort of whatever way you see fit.
- 45:00Yeah, so the steel man of that is that if we have direct miner APIs like Slipstream,
- 45:09then if node runners are filtering en masse kinds of transactions that are commonly mined,
- 45:24then you could end up creating an advantage for,
- 45:31I mean, it's kind of a long, hairy technical debate,
- 45:35but there's a lot of moving parts.
- 45:38But basically there's these things called compact blocks.
- 45:40And when a new block is found,
- 45:44that block is propagated throughout the network
- 45:46in sort of a summarized form
- 45:48so that the block propagation can happen really fast.
- 45:51And you want block propagation to happen really fast
- 45:53because you want the network to stay in consensus.
- 45:55You don't want, if two blocks come out really, really fast,
- 45:59kind of one after the other, or immediately at the same time,
- 46:02you don't want a situation where one part of the network
- 46:05is building on this block, and the other part of the network
- 46:06is building on this other block, because then you
- 46:09get network partitions, and you get forks,
- 46:10and you start to have double spend risk.
- 46:14Not a big problem, but minor centralization
- 46:18comes in where, OK, so if there's
- 46:21a kind of transaction that's being commonly mined,
- 46:24but most of the nodes are ignoring that transaction,
- 46:27then those blocks become very slow to propagate.
- 46:30And if that happens, then you could have large miners
- 46:34who have 20%, 30%, whatever of the hash power,
- 46:36you could have them, basically they know about the block
- 46:39before the rest of the network.
- 46:40And so they have kind of an advantage
- 46:42and they can start building on that block.
- 46:44And then they have kind of a, yeah,
- 46:48They have a few seconds of head start on the rest of the network.
- 46:55The thing is, there's a bunch of reasons why this doesn't hold water.
- 47:00The first is that the type of transaction that was the rationale for removing the opportune limit does not cause this.
- 47:11Because this was a justice transaction, a fraud-proof transaction from Citria that is never supposed to happen.
- 47:18So I don't know how much you've read about this transaction, but it's basically, it's like a, you know, it's like a, you know, shit went really sideways.
- 47:28And the coordinator that's running the network is trying to screw people out of their money.
- 47:32And so, you know, the watchtowers have to, like, post this fraud proof as fast as possible so that people can get their money out and slash the coordinator.
- 47:43But, yeah, it's never supposed to happen.
- 47:44So the thing is, this particular transaction
- 47:47was the rationale for getting rid of the operaturn limit.
- 47:50But this transaction is never expected to happen.
- 47:54And if it does happen, it only needs 64 bytes.
- 47:58So it needs 144 bytes.
- 48:00So an operaturn that fits this transaction,
- 48:03if we had doubled the operaturn limit from 80 bytes
- 48:06to 160 bytes, that would have been sufficient
- 48:08for this transaction.
- 48:10So I mean, yes, there's these extremely
- 48:14extreme edge cases that are totally not at all relevant to the PR that removes the operaturn
- 48:20limit, where mining centralization could be remotely relevant, but it isn't. And the other
- 48:28reason why it's not relevant is because miners can do selfish mining attacks anyway. So basically,
- 48:33the attack that they're... Well, actually, there's two reasons. The first reason is that
- 48:39miners can already do a selfish mining attack.
- 48:42So this is where a miner mines a block
- 48:45and then doesn't announce the block at all.
- 48:47And then they just keep mining on top of that block.
- 48:49And if they have a high enough hash power,
- 48:50they can kind of attack the network
- 48:53by constantly just messing with the chain
- 48:57and sending these three block reorgs to the rest of the,
- 49:01basically keeping the rest of the network kind of in chaos
- 49:04and messing with smaller miners.
- 49:06But this is an attack that they can already do intentionally.
- 49:10So the worry is that, OK, well, miners
- 49:12would do this attack unintentionally
- 49:14because their blocks are propagating more slowly.
- 49:17And the other thing that makes this argument completely
- 49:20irrelevant is that miners don't do this because they don't
- 49:23want their blocks to propagate slowly.
- 49:25They want the whole network to build on top of their block
- 49:29because it's very, very improbable
- 49:30that they will find that next block.
- 49:33So they don't want their blocks to propagate slowly.
- 49:36And actually, if you look at the compact blocks release, the release of Bitcoin Core that included compact blocks for the first time, it actually said the reverse of what Bitcoin Core developers are saying now.
- 49:46It said, hey, miners, you probably need to adjust.
- 49:49You probably want to adjust your filters to mine only things that are commonly filtered, you know, to mine only standard things.
- 49:56Because if you don't do that, your blocks are going to propagate more slowly.
- 49:59So back in 2016, this was seen as like a, you know, a thing that miners should definitely want to do.
- 50:03And I see no reason why that same argument isn't relevant today.
- 50:10And also, it would seem to me like if you have set up the infrastructure such that you have 20, 30 percent of the hash power on the network, you have a very strong, I mean, unless you're just an arm of like the CIA or something operating with, you know, federally funded dollars in sort of an opaque fashion.
- 50:29And it would seem to me like your incentives align such that you don't make people question
- 50:34the integrity of the network and you try to keep it.
- 50:36You're incentivized to make the network strong and to play by the rules.
- 50:41So that way people don't, there's not an exodus from Bitcoin because there's a bunch of monkey
- 50:46business.
- 50:47That's basically, yeah, yeah.
- 50:50Exactly.
- 50:50And Satoshi wrote this in the white paper.
- 50:52He said, you know, basically my consensus system doesn't work if more than half of the miners
- 50:56are dishonest.
- 50:57And so I would see them as a hostile miner. They are mining things that the network says are abusive. So that's a hostile act. And so we should take action with our miners that are explicitly dishonest. We should take action to boycott them and otherwise make their lives more difficult.
- 51:20Yeah, it all comes back to kind of the theme that's run throughout this conversation is basically as a culture, we need to act in such a way as to disincentivize bad actors from operating on the network and let them go play on Ethereum or some other shit coin rails.
- 51:39Okay, man, let's talk about BIP-110.
- 51:41okay so i'm i'm gonna be honest with you everything that we've talked about
- 51:46up to this point i've i'd sort of done my research forgotten a lot of it but it's coming back to me
- 51:52now bip 110 is not something i have had a lot of time to dive into um could you put into simple
- 51:59terms what bip 110 is and i mean to the extent that it's useful maybe kind of break down like
- 52:04how bips work sort of generally for for anyone who isn't isn't familiar with the concept um yeah
- 52:10You don't need to get into the weeds on that.
- 52:12But if it's helpful at all to kind of describe how BIP-110 came about, feel free.
- 52:17Yeah.
- 52:17So I don't know if we're going to have time to go into the BIP process.
- 52:22And I mean, so just to summarize BIP-110 specifically, and then if you want to like double click on anything and go deeper, then we can do that.
- 52:31But just to kind of summarize where, in my view, where BIP-110 came from is, you know, so basically as we've been talking about,
- 52:40There is this, there was a standard on the network
- 52:45starting in 2014 that transactions that include
- 52:49more than 80 bytes of arbitrary data per transaction
- 52:52were non-standard or abusive.
- 52:56And that the Bitcoin node runner community came together
- 52:59and said, this is the maximum amount of arbitrary data
- 53:03that we want to allow per transaction because Bitcoin
- 53:05is not for arbitrary data storage.
- 53:06And so when the operaturn limit was removed in October, I think is when they released version 30 of Bitcoin Core, when that happened, Bitcoin Core effectively unilaterally hard-working policy.
- 53:29So there's a, like, it's kind of a metaphor and kind of not.
- 53:41And for your listeners, if they don't
- 53:42know what the difference between a hard fork and a soft fork
- 53:44is, a hard fork is where you expand the rules.
- 53:47And a soft fork is where you restrict the rules.
- 53:50And so the great thing about Bitcoin
- 53:52is that it tends towards stability because,
- 53:55or it tends towards conservatism because soft forking
- 53:57is much easier than hard forking.
- 53:59And that makes sense when you think about it.
- 54:01You know, if some of the nodes would like to restrict the rules
- 54:05and they want to be pickier about what types of transactions
- 54:11they're going to accept,
- 54:13then they can simply reject blocks that don't do that.
- 54:15Whereas a hard fork,
- 54:17if some of your listeners were around for the block size wars,
- 54:22you'll remember that the big blockers wanted to hard fork Bitcoin
- 54:26to a larger block size.
- 54:27And this was non-viable because hard-forcing Bitcoin
- 54:32is very, very difficult.
- 54:34Because when you loosen the rules,
- 54:38the old nodes will not accept those new blocks.
- 54:42So the old nodes say there is a limit of one megabyte per block.
- 54:47And if we want to raise the limit to two megabytes per block,
- 54:52all of the old nodes who haven't upgraded
- 54:54are going to reject those new blocks.
- 54:56As soon as somebody mines a block that's two megabytes,
- 54:58they're going to reject that block.
- 55:01And so this is ultimately why Bcash failed,
- 55:04because they were trying to hard fork Bitcoin.
- 55:07And SegWit actually did end up increasing the block size,
- 55:11but they did it in a way that was backwards compatible
- 55:13with the old nodes.
- 55:14And this is why SegWit was victorious,
- 55:17while Bcash was the loser.
- 55:20So going back to the hard forking policy,
- 55:25This is a new thing that I just came up with.
- 55:27So basically, you know, so Node Runners had decided from 2014 that the amount of arbitrary
- 55:32data allowed in a Bitcoin transaction is 80 bytes.
- 55:35And then when Core said, OK, we're going to raise that limit to 100,000 bytes, that was
- 55:39a loosening of the rules.
- 55:41And in consensus, this is a no-no, right?
- 55:44You don't hard fork Bitcoin.
- 55:47I mean, like there's very, very edge case scenarios where you can, but generally speaking, you
- 55:52can't do that.
- 55:53and certainly not unilaterally, and certainly not
- 55:55in just a few months like Bitcoin Core did,
- 56:00with obvious pressure from the shitcoin industry.
- 56:03And so as we were talking about before,
- 56:08if node runners are not able to suppress the bad behavior,
- 56:14the abusive behavior, the spamming, in policy
- 56:18because the dominant node implementation
- 56:20has suddenly become a turncoat, has suddenly betrayed the Bitcoin node runner community,
- 56:25and has decided unilaterally that 100,000 is now the limit instead of 80, when that happens,
- 56:32the only backstop, the only fallback is changing the consensus rules. And so
- 56:37So leading up to bit.1.10, bit.1.10 was originally proposed by Luke, and then was later taken
- 56:50up by another developer called Dathan. And what it says is that we can temporarily invalidate
- 57:02transactions that have more than 80 bytes of arbitrary data.
- 57:09And when I first was participating in these filter battles,
- 57:15I didn't realize that, like it seemed to me
- 57:19that you can't fight spam in consensus
- 57:22because the way that information theory works,
- 57:25and the core devs will tell you this,
- 57:27and there's a great BitMEX research article
- 57:30talking about it, you can't put in the consensus rules,
- 57:35no spamming, right, where Bitcoin is money.
- 57:38You can't do that.
- 57:39But what you can do, BIP 110 is making me realize,
- 57:44is that you can temporarily limit certain transaction
- 57:50formats that are known to be stored on arbitrary data.
- 57:55So that's what BIP 110 does.
- 57:56It basically is the next level of escalation beyond filters.
- 57:58If filtering doesn't work, usually filtering works,
- 58:01because the dominant node implementation
- 58:04is filtering abusive transactions.
- 58:06But when the dominant node implementation betrays
- 58:09the node-runner community and says, well,
- 58:11we're not going to do that anymore,
- 58:12because filters don't work, even though they do, then.
- 58:16And that can, in retrospect, that actually
- 58:21is very likely to happen, because there's
- 58:22this thing called the tolerant minority in policy,
- 58:28where if you just have a few percent Libre Relay, whatever,
- 58:31a few percent of node runners that are very tolerant,
- 58:35and a few miners that are willing to go against the standards
- 58:39on the network, then anybody who wants
- 58:45to send that transaction is going
- 58:47to have a pretty easy time of it.
- 58:49So you really need a strong political will
- 58:54and also a strong technical ability
- 58:55in order to filter that stuff at the policy level.
- 59:00But what core devs did not tell you about
- 59:02is that at the consensus level, there's
- 59:04an intolerant minority.
- 59:07So in policy, there's a tolerant minority that says, oh, well,
- 59:10there's a bunch of people posting JPEGs.
- 59:12Well, we're just going to allow that.
- 59:14And we're 5% of the node runners,
- 59:15so we're basically making the standard from the network.
- 59:21But in consensus, it works the opposite way.
- 59:23In consensus, if you have just a few percentage
- 59:25of the node runners that say, we don't like this,
- 59:27then it's very easy for those node runners
- 59:31to restrict the rules further.
- 59:36And so all this is to say, the more I've looked into BIP 110,
- 59:41the more I've realized that it is kind of the ideal next step.
- 59:46And if it activates, I expect it to be very effective.
- 59:50OK.
- 59:50So describe what it's doing exactly.
- 59:53I think you sort of touched on it, but you gave sort of a narrative, which I think was very helpful, around context for it.
- 1:00:00What exactly does BIP110 do?
- 1:00:03Why is it?
- 1:00:04Something is temporary.
- 1:00:06It doesn't filter out these, or it doesn't, explain that.
- 1:00:10Yeah. So basically what Bit.10 does, if you look at the rules, it takes all of the transaction formats that can be seen as officially supported ways of storing arbitrary data in the Bitcoin blockchain.
- 1:00:27It takes all of these commonly used formats and some additional formats that could become standard if Bitcoin Core continues to loosen policy.
- 1:00:40It takes basically large operaturns and inscriptions, and it says these are consensus invalid for one year.
- 1:00:49And so that communicates that Bitcoin is not for arbitrary data storage.
- 1:00:56And because it's not for arbitrary data storage, it is money.
- 1:01:01It sort of reaffirms that Bitcoin is money.
- 1:01:03so so is the intent then that is the reason it's for one year to sort of minimize the
- 1:01:14i guess the the the blowback from some people who might say who might say hey this is
- 1:01:19does it just give us a runway to use bitcoin as money to weed out the spammers for a period of
- 1:01:26time so that way they go build somewhere else or they stop like what happens after a year i guess
- 1:01:30is maybe my concern.
- 1:01:32Well, so making the fork temporary
- 1:01:36allows us to invalidate things that we wouldn't otherwise
- 1:01:40be able to invalidate.
- 1:01:41So BIP110 turns off a thing called op if inside Tapscript.
- 1:01:51And this is something that is, as far as people can tell,
- 1:01:55is not used anywhere actively except by inscriptions,
- 1:02:01right, inscription spam.
- 1:02:04And so there could be some risk.
- 1:02:07So we've never tried it.
- 1:02:10The last time Bitcoin turned off disabled behavior
- 1:02:14that was previously allowed was back in the days of Satoshi.
- 1:02:18I think there might have been some other force since then
- 1:02:20that I'm forgetting.
- 1:02:21But this is something that rarely happens on Bitcoin And so there could end up being some people who have their funds frozen for up to a year because of that
- 1:02:37And people who are not spammers, right?
- 1:02:39People who are using this very edge case thing.
- 1:02:43Again, there aren't any known examples of people who have their funds frozen.
- 1:02:51Hypothetically.
- 1:02:51Yeah, hypothetically, if those people did exist, then at the end of the year, they could withdraw those funds. And then the other reason is because the way that Bit.1.10 operates is it turns off what's called upgrade hooks.
- 1:03:08So these are things like future SegWit versions and unknown Tapscript versions.
- 1:03:15And these are, they're called hooks.
- 1:03:21They're like places in script that don't have a defined definition right now.
- 1:03:26But in a future soft fork, the software could redefine them as something specific.
- 1:03:31So all of the proposed upgrades to Bitcoin script, so like CheckSig from Stack and like
- 1:03:42OpCat, I think, and GreatScript Restoration and BIP360, and all of these are turning on
- 1:03:50new versions of Bitcoin script, and they're using these upgrade hooks.
- 1:03:54and basically those will become unusable for a year.
- 1:04:01So Bitcoin would not be able to turn on any new functionality
- 1:04:05during when Bit.1.10 is active.
- 1:04:09And so if we were to make those rules permanent,
- 1:04:12and so it does that in order to prevent spam
- 1:04:13because those can be abused, right?
- 1:04:17Those upgrade hooks can be abused to store arbitrary data
- 1:04:19in the blockchain.
- 1:04:21So Bit.1.10 turns them off in order to sort of preempt that.
- 1:04:24But that's not something that we can leave as a permanent situation because then Bitcoin would not be able to have any soft forks that upgrade the protocol.
- 1:04:36Okay.
- 1:04:37So when you think about things like, I know it's sort of a point of FUD at the moment, but you think about like quantum resistance, that sort of stuff.
- 1:04:45You eventually need some malleability to adopt those types of changes.
- 1:04:51Not for engineers just tinkering and having fun, but new threats emerge.
- 1:04:56You need some level of ability to modify and sort of play the new game that's being played,
- 1:05:02I guess, as time goes on.
- 1:05:04Yeah.
- 1:05:04And again, I've read the BIP very closely.
- 1:05:09It explains all this.
- 1:05:12It's very unlikely that there will be some emergency upgrade that Bitcoin needs to do
- 1:05:17in the next year.
- 1:05:18But if magically there is some kind of quantum resistance or whatever that Bitcoin needs in the next year, then that's fine.
- 1:05:30It'll just activate as soon as Bit.1.10 is no longer active.
- 1:05:35And one more thing about the temporary nature.
- 1:05:38This goes back to what I was talking about with information theory, where you can't stop spam with permanent protocol changes, because there's always going to be ways around the spam.
- 1:05:53But what a temporary software allows us to do is it allows us to fight spam and consensus, basically.
- 1:06:00It's not something that we should ever have to do, but it's a very, very, very useful and vital tool, I think, for Bitcoin to have moving forward if we want Bitcoin to stay money.
- 1:06:12Yeah.
- 1:06:13We need to be able to say, hey, arbitrary data storage is not okay, so we're turning off all of the popular methods of arbitrary data storage.
- 1:06:21Okay.
- 1:06:22So BIP-110 has a mandatory activation date sometime this fall.
- 1:06:27um and that that's regardless of minor signaling right so my my understanding is support's growing
- 1:06:35right uh but what happens if it activates we don't have sufficient minor support like how does this
- 1:06:41actually work you know like what do we need to have happen in order for your vision for how this
- 1:06:48should play out to play out and what could go wrong in the midst of that and if it does go wrong
- 1:06:52what does that mean so um were you around for the block size war no man i'm i'm still a noob
- 1:06:58okay so in the block size war so so i read the book okay cool yeah you read the block size war
- 1:07:04book by uh jonathan beer yeah yeah very good book everybody should read that um yeah it
- 1:07:09basically bit.10 does the same thing um uh the difference is that so segwit segwit was given a
- 1:07:18year of signaling.
- 1:07:21And then it was given a deadline at the end of the signaling
- 1:07:24period.
- 1:07:25And at the end of the signaling period,
- 1:07:27if insufficient hash power was signaling for SegWit,
- 1:07:31SegWit would be canceled.
- 1:07:33And so a few months into the signaling period,
- 1:07:39we kind of started realizing that this was a mistake,
- 1:07:42because there were some hostile miners that were blocking the fork
- 1:07:45from activating, namely Bitmain.
- 1:07:48and they're lackeys.
- 1:07:51And so what ended up happening is that a group of developers
- 1:07:59got together and put out a different version of Bitcoin,
- 1:08:05a different activation client for something called BIP148,
- 1:08:08which was the original UASF.
- 1:08:11So this was a soft fork to start rejecting blocks
- 1:08:15that were not signaling for SegWit.
- 1:08:18And long story short, leading up to the activation of BIP-148,
- 1:08:23100% of the miners started signaling for SegWit.
- 1:08:26So if you look into the incentives for miners
- 1:08:33and why this happened, it becomes very obvious
- 1:08:35why they did this.
- 1:08:38Because miners are just trying to get paid.
- 1:08:40They're not trying.
- 1:08:41And we shouldn't be leaving protocol changes up to the miners.
- 1:08:46That doesn't make any sense.
- 1:08:47The node runners, you and me, we should be in charge of the rules.
- 1:08:54And the miners are just employees.
- 1:08:56The miners should just, you know, I mean, like you could see a situation where there's
- 1:09:03some kind of simple attack on the network where, you know, some three-letter agency
- 1:09:07like spins up a bunch of fake nodes and tries to, you know, you know, turn on Ethereum or something
- 1:09:12like that, you know, turn on a bunch of MEV, a bunch of, anyway. But this is clearly not that,
- 1:09:21you know, if you, if you look on, on Twitter, as you were, as you were saying, you know, this,
- 1:09:25this clearly has support among, you know, real actual Bitcoiners who really, really are looking
- 1:09:30out for the long-term interest of Bitcoin. And it's not turning on any, any new functionality,
- 1:09:34It's just a protective measure.
- 1:09:36It's just disabling some things that are abusive.
- 1:09:41But anyway, so the mandatory signaling period
- 1:09:44is basically building .
- 1:09:46It's kind of like if you took SegWit and you built
- 1:09:48BIP 148 in from the beginning.
- 1:09:51So that's all that .10 is.
- 1:09:52It's basically if SegWit had been done in a way
- 1:09:55that it doesn't put the miners in charge
- 1:09:57from the beginning.
- 1:09:58Instead of putting them in charge and then being like,
- 1:10:01whoops, we shouldn't have done that.
- 1:10:02The users are in charge.
- 1:10:03do it uasf and and then the miner start signaling so bit 110 just does that same thing but just all
- 1:10:09in the same package from the start okay so i've heard many people on the core side like the the
- 1:10:17loudest ones and probably the most some of the most notable say that the knots bip 110 crowd
- 1:10:24sounds like the big blockers of the of the block size wars what what exactly are they i know you're
- 1:10:31you're shaking your head. What are they, what, what's their argument? Like what, what are they
- 1:10:35referring to when they say that? Cause like I, I read the book, but again, I'm not a developer.
- 1:10:40So there was a lot of it that was just kind of over my head. I kind of understood conceptually,
- 1:10:44but it's, it's also been a while since I read that. Yeah. I think the steel man of that is that
- 1:10:49we are opposing Bitcoin core and Bitcoin core was seen as kind of the, the victors of the block size
- 1:10:57war. But I think this is a misreading of history. And actually, if you read the Block Size War book,
- 1:11:02it explains that a lot of the core developers were actually against doing the UASF.
- 1:11:05And if it had been up to core, SegWit would have failed. I'm now pretty much convinced of that.
- 1:11:15And basically, it was just a few developers who were willing to be like, no, we are not
- 1:11:19leaving this to chance. We are turning on SegWit. SegWit is the solution. We are not leaving the
- 1:11:26miners in charge. So I think the steel man of the case that the knots people or the BIP110 people
- 1:11:31are the big blockers is that, you know, that we're opposing Bitcoin core, which I think is silly. I
- 1:11:39mean, I think, I mean, I think it's true, right? I think we are opposing Bitcoin core, but I don't
- 1:11:43think that makes us the big blockers. And I think if you look at all of the other ways in which the
- 1:11:47core supporters are like the big blockers, it makes a lot more sense. So like, for instance,
- 1:11:51It's, you know, so as I was saying before, you know, Luke's philosophy and my philosophy
- 1:11:57is very much that we want more node runners.
- 1:12:00And fighting against spam allows there to be more node runners because it increases the
- 1:12:09benefits and lowers the costs of running a node.
- 1:12:12So this much is obvious.
- 1:12:15And the big blockers were saying, oh, it doesn't matter if fewer people run nodes.
- 1:12:19Let's just make the blocks bigger anyway.
- 1:12:20there will always be at least 100 node runners or there will always be at least 1,000 node runners
- 1:12:24or something like that. They had this idea in their head, oh, it doesn't matter because there
- 1:12:27will always be enough, right? But if you just don't care about the costs and you just blow the
- 1:12:34lid off of the costs and at the same time, you cripple Bitcoin's usefulness as money, right? So
- 1:12:43by enabling all these spammy use cases, you're making it harder for merchants to onboard,
- 1:12:48right like if you've ever tried you know onboarding uh anybody to self-custody and the fees are 50
- 1:12:53dollars you can't you kind of look like a scammer they look at you and they're like who's this
- 1:12:57scammer you know this bitcoin thing seems like a scam um so you know so fighting spam is is good
- 1:13:04it it helps bitcoin be better money it helps bitcoin be be healthy it helps it uh fulfill its
- 1:13:08uh its purpose okay so i don't remember if i was answering your question there no no no i think you
- 1:13:14did. So let's start to round this out. So if BIP 110, I guess I would just say broadly,
- 1:13:23what you're hoping for, if it doesn't play out the way that you intend, and I don't know if this
- 1:13:29is maybe the way of saying it, but if Core sort of wins this battle, so to speak, does that
- 1:13:35fundamentally change your conviction in Bitcoin? Does it alter the way that you view its future,
- 1:13:43its likelihood of succeeding in the ways that you and I hope that it does?
- 1:13:47Do we see an exodus of people from Bitcoin
- 1:13:51because they've lost hope in the project?
- 1:13:52What do you think?
- 1:13:56100%.
- 1:13:56If Core is able to unilaterally
- 1:13:59effectively hard fork policy
- 1:14:04against the will of most of the node runners
- 1:14:07and
- 1:14:09Bitcoin loses the will to fight spam
- 1:14:13and through that
- 1:14:16all these Ethereum use cases flood into Bitcoin
- 1:14:20and through that Bitcoin turns into a big casino
- 1:14:25that's no more innovative than Ethereum
- 1:14:28and you know
- 1:14:31Ethereum is a joke
- 1:14:32and people think oh Bitcoin will magically
- 1:14:36no longer, will magically never become Ethereum. And that's not true. Bitcoin will avoid becoming
- 1:14:43Ethereum if Bitcoiners prevent it from becoming Ethereum. We, you know, the buck stops with us,
- 1:14:48you know, the node runners. And if we let Bitcoin turn into Ethereum, it will become
- 1:14:53a plaything of the fiat money printer. And it will not threaten, it will not disrupt anything.
- 1:15:01It will not be capable of disrupting anything. It will just be this mindless, purposeless
- 1:15:04thing that isn't money anymore. Yeah. As an analogy, you hear, fix the money,
- 1:15:11fix the world. And I used to say that very flippantly. And I don't believe that anymore.
- 1:15:15I think human action fixes the world. And our money in Bitcoin in particular is a tool to do so.
- 1:15:21And so I've grown more convinced of the cultural necessity of what you've described here. And
- 1:15:27I think it makes a lot of sense.
- 1:15:30I don't have the technical chops
- 1:15:34to agree or disagree with what you've just described.
- 1:15:37I'm hopeful that you're wrong
- 1:15:38because I don't know which direction we're headed.
- 1:15:41But in the meantime, the way I...
- 1:15:45I mean, this is it, man.
- 1:15:46This is...
- 1:15:47If 5.10 doesn't activate, the future is dark.
- 1:15:52Okay.
- 1:15:52Yeah, because in the meantime,
- 1:15:55I'm the, like, where else am I going to park my wealth, right?
- 1:15:58I mean, like, it's Bitcoin or it's, you know, a Tesla stock.
- 1:16:01I don't know.
- 1:16:02So, I mean, this is our shot and why I wanted to have you on to discuss this.
- 1:16:08Okay, so for someone who's listening to this podcast, maybe just being introduced to all
- 1:16:13these concepts, I'm sure most people who are listening to a Bitcoin podcast of this nature
- 1:16:18are acquainted with the notion of BIP 110 and the NOS versus core thing.
- 1:16:25what should they focus on and care about here?
- 1:16:31What's your guidance for people?
- 1:16:32Is it just run a node, run knots, signal BIP 110, that's it?
- 1:16:38Or is there maybe more to the story?
- 1:16:42I mean, there's all levels of analysis
- 1:16:46from zoomed all the way out to zoomed all the way in.
- 1:16:49And I think our priorities should...
- 1:16:53I think our priorities become straightened out once we realize what the absolute widest,
- 1:17:02the absolute most zoomed out view is, which is Bitcoin becoming the reserve asset.
- 1:17:07And in order for it to do that, and in order for it to, I mean, so
- 1:17:11there are ways that Bitcoin could become the reserve asset and become centralized. And if it
- 1:17:16does that, it still fails. So it has to become the reserve asset, but it also has to stay
- 1:17:21stay decentralized. And so the way that I put this is Bitcoiners have to value decentralization
- 1:17:27and integrity. And they have to value Bitcoin being money because, I mean, that's at the end
- 1:17:32of the day, Bitcoin isn't useful at all if it's not money. It isn't anything if it isn't money.
- 1:17:39So what I would say, so everything, all the more zoomed in levels of analysis should flow from
- 1:17:45that. So that should tell you what you should be doing. So in order for Bitcoin to stay decentralized,
- 1:17:54you have to, as I said, don't trust, verify, run your own node, hold your own keys.
- 1:18:03Don't improperly do too many things for other people, right? Try to onboard as many other people
- 1:18:08to being sovereign Bitcoiners as possible. You know, like Uncle Jimming is great, but, you know,
- 1:18:13don't become JP Morgan. Be the small community, Uncle Jim. Don't do everything for everyone.
- 1:18:25Make sure that other people are onboarding themselves. Other people are becoming sovereign.
- 1:18:29Other people are becoming agentic. We have to get Bitcoin being used in commerce by merchants.
- 1:18:40One of the things that really affects the outcome of consensus changes, consensus battles like Bit.1.10, is merchant adoption. Which side are merchants falling on? Do merchants believe in decentralization and integrity and in Bitcoin being money? Or are merchants kind of don't care and they might as well accept Ethereum or Solana in addition to Bitcoin?
- 1:19:08You know, are they doing, you know, we need, what keeps the miners in line is merchants,
- 1:19:19right?
- 1:19:19Like that's the counterweight to the miners in the consensus process.
- 1:19:23If a bunch of node runners who aren't doing any payments say, we don't like what the miners
- 1:19:27are doing, the miners can just ignore that.
- 1:19:29But if a bunch of nodes being used for commerce are going to be rejecting blocks, then the
- 1:19:36miners have to, they have to think about that, right?
- 1:19:38They have to think twice about mining blocks that are going to be rejected.
- 1:19:43Because a block is like $300,000 to mine.
- 1:19:46That's a lot of money.
- 1:19:47If you mine a block and it gets rejected, you just lost a lot of money.
- 1:19:53So what I would say is, yeah, teach people how to be devs.
- 1:19:58Teach people how to be merchants.
- 1:19:59If you don't know how to be a merchant, become a merchant.
- 1:20:01If you don't know how to, I mean, so I would say hold your own keys.
- 1:20:04Learn how to use Lightning.
- 1:20:05learn how to onboard somebody to self-custody, learn how to be a merchant, learn how to be a
- 1:20:11developer. Generally, people take one of those two paths. They either become a merchant or they
- 1:20:17become a developer. I'm trying to kind of create, I'm working on a project called Ambrosia, which I
- 1:20:21hope to sort of combine those, right? Like I want devs to be merchants because the biggest problem
- 1:20:27with Bitcoin Core is they don't understand why the merchant experience is bad because they're
- 1:20:31and not merchants.
- 1:20:33Devs tend to just kind of look for a job.
- 1:20:34They tend to look for somebody else to give them
- 1:20:36a high-paying salary.
- 1:20:38And then they can sit back and have a cushy existence,
- 1:20:40and they don't understand the people that are actually
- 1:20:42trying to use their software.
- 1:20:44I want developers to use their own dog food.
- 1:20:47So we have to get this loop between devs and merchants going.
- 1:20:50And we have to get this loop between Bitcoiners and merchants.
- 1:20:57If nothing else, get merchants in your local economy
- 1:21:00accepting Bitcoin, at least using a custodial wallet, but pressure them to get into something
- 1:21:06self-custodial. Phoenix wallet works really well for that. Yeah, just learn as much as you can,
- 1:21:14help other people learn as much as they can, and use Bitcoin as money.
- 1:21:20I love it, man. I think that's sage advice. Honestly, that's what we do. All we do is train
- 1:21:25people on self-custody, self-sovereignty, protecting your data, plan B residencies,
- 1:21:31how to run a node. That's all we do all day long. And I couldn't agree more with that
- 1:21:35sentiment. So let's round this out with our final question. You promised me you had some
- 1:21:42unpopular opinions. So what's an unpopular opinion you have? And you get bonus points
- 1:21:46if you offend some Bitcoiners with it. Besides everything you just said.
- 1:21:52Yeah, I know. I think I've already mentioned them, right? I think
- 1:21:55My two biggest unpopular opinions are that most Bitcoiners are actually sovereignty minimalists,
- 1:22:00not sovereignty maximalists. So they're the sort of the more communist version of a libertarian,
- 1:22:08which is, you know, basically I want to have as much freedom as possible, but I don't want to
- 1:22:14take any responsibility. So I know this is going to trigger a lot of people. There's a lot of
- 1:22:19Bitcoin core devs that fall in that camp. Actually, almost all of them basically are just like,
- 1:22:23we don't, what taking responsibility, what's that? We don't want to have to do that. We just want to
- 1:22:26tinker and not have to worry about anything. That's number one. And number two is, I think,
- 1:22:36you know, a lot of like Wall Street Bitcoiners would be offended by this, but Bitcoin is not
- 1:22:40just a store of value. Bitcoin is a store of value and a medium of exchange. If it's just a store of
- 1:22:45value, it becomes gold. And as we know, gold was captured and is literally where the fiat standard
- 1:22:52came from.
- 1:22:53The fiat standard came from gold being captured.
- 1:22:55So if we want to avoid that, we need
- 1:22:59Bitcoin to work as a medium of exchange.
- 1:23:01We need Bitcoin to work in commerce.
- 1:23:02Obviously, store of value is more important.
- 1:23:04This is why in the block size wars,
- 1:23:06we emphasized Bitcoin being stable and conservative.
- 1:23:13But Bitcoin also needs to scale organically.
- 1:23:17And oh, here's another one that'll probably
- 1:23:19fend a lot of people.
- 1:23:19Liquid and Citria and layer twos that don't have unilateral exit.
- 1:23:28So Lightning and Arc have unilateral exit.
- 1:23:30Do you know what unilateral exit is?
- 1:23:32I can imagine what it would mean.
- 1:23:34You can get in and out and you can decide.
- 1:23:38Like you have optionality when you're there.
- 1:23:40You don't need to ask permission to exit the layer two.
- 1:23:42Yeah.
- 1:23:43So this is what Lightning does.
- 1:23:45If you have a Lightning channel, you have a transaction that's pre-signed
- 1:23:49that you can post at any moment, and it will close the channel
- 1:23:51and withdraw all your money.
- 1:23:53So that's why Lightning has unilateral exit.
- 1:23:54Arc has a similar thing, although they're kind of struggling with that.
- 1:23:59They have some workarounds that are not great.
- 1:24:01But we're working towards unilateral exit on all the layer twos.
- 1:24:05But Liquid and Citria and BitVM and all these,
- 1:24:10there are apparently ways to make BitVM have unilateral exit
- 1:24:13with like ZK proofs and stuff.
- 1:24:15But I'm skeptical.
- 1:24:19I'm not ready for shit.
- 1:24:20So my unpopular opinion is that a bunch of things that people say are layer twos are
- 1:24:25not actual layer twos.
- 1:24:26They're just, they're applications, right?
- 1:24:28They're just things that use Bitcoin.
- 1:24:30Okay.
- 1:24:30You're not really a lot better than Coinbase, right?
- 1:24:32Like you just, you put your layer two, you put your, you put your Bitcoin into layer
- 1:24:36two, you trust somebody, and then hopefully you can get your money out.
- 1:24:40That's not layer two.
- 1:24:41That's an app.
- 1:24:42That's a good, that's a good warning to give.
- 1:24:43because I use Lightning often for payments, haven't played around with many of the others.
- 1:24:51So that's something I need to be aware of. And I think many people do. Well, I'll be honest with
- 1:24:55you I think those are good unpopular opinions because there are lots of people who will be offended No offense taken here man I think we on the same page with this stuff So I appreciate that Chris first of all thank you so much for your time man This has been a blast I learned a ton Why don you tell people where they can find you follow you anything
- 1:25:11else you want to point them to? Yep. Yeah. Thanks. Same. Right back at you, Michael. Thanks for
- 1:25:16having me on. It's a fun conversation. I'm Chris Guida. I'm cguida6 on Twitter. My projects right
- 1:25:27now are just working on building a local economy and building a project called Ambrosia, which,
- 1:25:33as I said, is a point of sale system to try and get as many merchants onboarded to self-custodial
- 1:25:38Lightning as possible. And yeah, you'll see me around speaking at conferences and
- 1:25:43doing a podcast circuit and all that. So yeah.
- 1:25:47Love it, man. Thank you so much for your time. Cheers, brother.
- 1:25:50Cheers, man.
- 1:25:51And that's a wrap again. Hope you enjoyed my conversation with Chris. I know I had a blast.
- 1:25:54One of my favorite conversations I've had on the podcast, honestly, just very insightful,
- 1:25:58knowledgeable guy.
- 1:25:59Glad he spent some time with me.
- 1:26:02If you need help, as we discussed, taking your Bitcoin into proper 100% self-custody,
- 1:26:06go to thebitcoinway.com slash podcast.
- 1:26:09We can teach you to run a node, schedule a free 30-minute call with our team where we
- 1:26:13can walk you through our philosophy.
- 1:26:14We can show you what an onboarding option looks like for you.
- 1:26:18And we also help with online privacy, setting up privacy phones.
- 1:26:21We've got a Plan B residency in tropical Panama as well.
- 1:26:24if you're looking to get out of one of these tyrannical jurisdictions that we're seeing pop
- 1:26:28up all over the world. Again, it's thebitcoinway.com slash podcast. Until next time, stay safe,
- 1:26:34stay sovereign, and remember the yield on Bitcoin is freedom.