Latest / Huckaleros / Charlie Dumo of Dumo Digital
Transcript
- Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Welcome to Huckaleros. I'm Mike Brennan and I'm recording from the world famous Nextcore Studios in downtown Rochester, New York, in the historic Sibley building. And I am joined by Charlie Dumo from Dumo Digital. And he's joining us remotely from Chicago, Illinois. welcome. Thank you for coming on, Charlie, and spending some time talking about your entrepreneurial journey and you know, we met at dot the Shopify dot dev conference and through I approached you 'cause I w you the jacket that you're wearing now is like you know, it was c it was a conversation start 'cause it's like it's it stood out. It had the Shopify brand. It had, you know, your branding on it. I was like, like it it was magnetic that that I was like, I think it was breakfast. I like, hey, you know, what's up with this coat? And that's how we kind of made our acquaintances as you do at these things. So you know, thanks for coming on. But like the I f I have a feeling that it's like the the coat has more of a story than just, you know, a standout thing. It's like how how how does that inform your approach to personal branding and marketing? Charlie Dumo: Yeah, well first of all, Mike, thank you again for having me. I'm very glad to be here. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, for sure. Charlie Dumo: and the coat really does have a way deeper story. It's it's it's less of you know, just to show up, just to show up differently, but it's more of like, how do you build a brand? A brand is the biggest thing that a brand means nothing without a name, right? And so you can have the best product in the world. If you don't have a brand and a name that people stand by, where really are you? and a lot of my background, I came from the brand side. I came from the marketing side. And now running an agency, it's I'm really bringing some of those same tendencies over to the agency side because nobody really, there's really no standout agencies that everybody knows. Right? Like you you can't Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: True, that's true. Charlie Dumo: you can't really name the top plumber in the country because none of none of them really have any branding. It's like all these B2B businesses really have no personality, they have no tone, they have no brand. And coming from the brand background, I was like, I want to change that stigma. I want to show up funky. I want to show up different. I want to have a personality. And I wanna be fun because the clients we work with and the partners we have, they show up like that. And I wanna show up like them because that's what I love to do. And that's how I get to meet great people like Mike and just have great conversation starters based off a cool jacket. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Yeah. No, and and that's like appropriate because it definitely you know, you have like a room of two thousand agencies and like and there and there are those ones and if you know if you're in the know, but as far as like just if i you you may be able you're gonna be able to have th this is the top agency that or that, but as far as like you standing out in that event and in that ecosystem, it was like it did it, right? Like in in the room just by having that it was a standout type of you know s moniker and so y you know I I and you went to OSU so like that w what w what was your major and 'cause you say you come from the brand side, does it did it did that start Charlie Dumo: Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: in college or Charlie Dumo: Yeah, so I'll take a step back. I was actually born and raised in consumer packed goods and marketing. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: My mother has been working on food and beverage brands from Miracle Whip to A1 Steak Sauce to Taco Bell to Starbucks with partnerships with Kraft Heinz, Ellen Jennerish, Donald Trump, I mean you name it, she's been involved in a business. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Cool. Charlie Dumo: And I kind of learned the game from the moment I could really speak. And I've been involved in, you know, the consumer pack of the goods industry and really the food and beverage industry for my whole life. I remember, you know, when I was ten, twelve, those ages, you know, I she would come home from Expo West, which is the biggest food and beverage trade show, C PG trade show in the world. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: with a suitcase full of snacks and it was like Halloween in March and it was awesome. And so I really started, you know, listening in on her meetings. I started working with her on the side. I started helping her with her consulting practice and kind of really understanding the brand side. I actually then went to college to play baseball. I didn't Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: then marketing business was nothing to me. It was all baseball. I was a Kalitch athlete. Yeah. And it was all sports. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Baseball, sports. Yeah, yeah. Well and if you're going at Ohio State, you're playing at a high super high level, then. Yeah. Okay, gotcha. Charlie Dumo: I was playing at a different school. I actually transferred to Ohio State. So I was on scholarship at another school. When I was at that other school, I kinda had a moment where I was like, you know what? I don't think this is for me. I think this CPG, this marketing, like that is who I am. And so I ended up transferring before or actually before I transferred, I my end of my freshman semester, my first semester, I s went to my mother and I was like, I want to start a brand. I don't know what to do. I d I've never started a business before. I've never worked a job before. Like I've never done Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Charlie Dumo: Just some baseball. And she immediately said to me, She's like, Take our grandma's chocolate peanut butter balls and build the business. And I was like I was like, Okay. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. What's what were grandma's chocolate peanut butter balls? Charlie Dumo: They are the best chocolate cover peanut butter balls you'll ever have in your life. The business is called chocolate. Exactly. Exactly. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Sounded like she was waiting for you to ask that. Like y like I like sh it was like, do this. Like she already had kind of that like mapped out for you. Do you think that that was like Charlie Dumo: It well, it's funny because they're a staple, like everybody knows them. And so many Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: people were telling her to quit her consulting practice and build the peanut butter ball business. She's like, no, no, no. So when I came along, she's like, you go do it. And I I didn't even think twice about it. It's like, okay. And I started that day. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Cool. Charlie Dumo: for the first seven months, we were we got into like 20 local mom and pop shops, retail stores across the country, ice cream shops, restaurants, you kind of name it. And throughout that process I was really understanding right in the Chicago area, trying to understand Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Just loud in the Chicago area. Okay. Charlie Dumo: how to really work a business because I really didn't know what was going on. And then Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. And how are you approaching the p like the the creation if y like you had to actually produce the product? Was it like grandma, Charlie Dumo: I was making Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: you're you're like using your gross recipe and like, Grandma we gotta do another order? Charlie Dumo: Yeah, so she she was very she was like, Hey, you you take the business, two things. You can't change the recipe at all. And the business has to be pink. And I was like, Well, pink's my favorite color, so I'm with that, and the recipe because Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right on. Charlie Dumo: they're unbelievable. And so I made a batch of three thousand in my kitchen. And over winter break, I spent every single day walking around in like a fifty mile radius to over like five hundred stores with a box of ten peanut butter balls pitching to the manager. And by the time I was done kind of talking about them, I was like, they would finish all 10 peanut butter balls. And they're like they're like, you Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: You're kidding. Charlie Dumo: have to come back and give me more to my team so I can, you I can I can do this. And I'm like, well I I know I gotta get product. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, like yeah, we still gotta think about it. We still gotta before we gotta shove we gotta we need we need some more samples. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Know I have a good product. I was like, I have the beauty of a good product already. Like I was handed a good product. It's just my turn to build the brand. So we got into all these stores, and and long story short, about seven months after being in these stores, I realized nobody knew who Charlie's Crunch was. They knew the stores and they knew that these stores just sold these peanut butter balls. I had no brand equity. Like, this is a problem. Is I've got this great product and I've got no brand behind it. And I said, if I really want to do something great, I've got to build the brand. So I first started putting a basic website together on Shopify. And you know, learning the the basic founder ins and outs of like how do I throw a basic template together? Just very simple, like founder scrappiness. And then started posting on social media. I started testing different viral hooks. I didn't do I didn't run any ads. I didn't do anything. I just was trying to get super creative. We had very funky branding. I was like, come try my balls. I've got the best balls in town. Right. I mean, people were turning their heads when Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: I was at farmers markets, just like trying to be super funky. Like, who wants my nuts? Like I got the best peanut butter balls in the country. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: It Yeah, yeah. No, that's I mean, hey, Charlie Dumo: It's Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: you gotta stand out. That's that's hilarious. Charlie Dumo: It started really picking up traction and when I got to campus it blew up. And I started doing pop-up events every single game day. I was doing because I mean Ohio State has like Buckeye, it's like another chocolate peanut butter thing. And I said, Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, yeah. Charlie Dumo: I've got the Buckeye reinvented. I've changed the Buckeye. And I branded it kind of OSU. I even started running freshman delivery dorm service, where these dorms have like over 700 to a thousand kids in these long, in these huge, tall buildings. And I would run a delivery service from Thursday night to like Sunday night from 10 p.m. like 3 a.m. when everybody was out in the bars and they were coming back and they wanted peanut butter balls late at night when they were you know drunk from the bars and I had all these Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: No, that's awesome. Charlie Dumo: I had all I had packers I had shippers and I would ship them from our facility in Chicago to Columbus. I had a haggle the foods like the food safety team in Columbus for like a freezer. I was like I need a huge freezer to hold all of these. And finally, when we got through that, I had all this stock in Columbus. We'd pull the stock, we then bag them there in Columbus for these little five packs, and it was like an OSU discount. And you get a five pack for $5. On every single five pack, I would funnel them to our website to get a custom code, like a like an OSU code, like a student code. And then we started generating all these sales on our website. And then they would then send them to their parents. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: That was the Shopify that you built, the Shopify s the storefront you built. Charlie Dumo: That would Shopify, yeah. They would then send them to their parents. And the beauty of a good product is their parents would fall in love with them, they would send them to their friends, and then it just started to rapidly explode. And every Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Wow. Charlie Dumo: single package I would put, I wouldn't tell them, but I would give another discount. 'Cause like I know people our reorder rearate was ridiculous. Like our slogan was one bite totally hooked. Once you try once, you're addicted for life. And Exactly. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Yeah, you need to sense them up this way so we can try Charlie Dumo: So I was willing to give out these like first time discounts and all this stuff just to get people ordering and buying and getting into a habit of like these are the best things ever, like I need these all the time. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: so every first box that I shipped, I tagged within Shopify and I said, enter in this insert card. And in that insert card they would get twenty five percent off their next order on orders fifty dollars and above. And then from there they kept just repeating and it kept expanding and became known on campus. As the peanut butter ball boy. That was my name. Everywhere Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: That was her name. Charlie Dumo: I went, when I went to class, when I went to the gym, when I was walking on the street, going for a run, getting food, going out with my friend. It was the peanut butter ball boy. I was Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: viral on social media and we sold half a million units in the first six months of launching our shop if I store with zero Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Wow. Charlie Dumo: traffic. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Wow. That's amazing. And that's exactly what you set out to do. You're like getting in these stores early and then you're like, okay, well we need to do some brands, Charlie Dumo: Something different. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: some brand, some recognition, and that's exactly what you deliver. And I think if I'm you know, let's exploit like it sounds like doing that is you're not asking for permission, right, d to do a dorm delivery service. You just kinda like did it and maybe like showing Charlie Dumo: You just do it. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: up the showing up and like doing a pop-up event, it's like you're not probably getting the permits and you know, it's like ask y you just just go out and do it. And yeah. Charlie Dumo: No, yeah, I mean it's it's never perfect. You just go on and do it. And then it's funny you even bring that up because after like my fourth event, someone came up to me from the campus like, hey, do you have a permit? And then I tackled that problem there. But if I focused Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, exactly. Charlie Dumo: on getting a permit first, I wouldn't got the product out there. My only Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: No. Charlie Dumo: goal was how much product can I move? How many peanut butter balls can I get in people's hands? And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: so one thing I learned is our conversion rate was almost a hundred percent once somebody tried it. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: So the repeat buyer was was on point. Like that couldn't get any better. Charlie Dumo: So I was I was on point. But even in person, all sampling events, you get one free peanut butter ball. That's it. You get a full they're about this size about they're about the size of like if you put your pointer finger on your thumb, kinda like that size. Yeah. A little small circle. I said, Here, you get one ball. That was it. That's all I needed to sell them. And they're like, How many and how much? And I Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: That's kind of the question. And so it's really about like if you try and tackle every single problem at once, you're never gonna get the product out there and never really build the brand. You kinda just gotta throw stuff at the wall and see what sticks. And so I started doing this and I had the recipe. Yeah. I mean I had a good Yeah, exactly. The beauty of a good product since the seventies. Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: And you had the recipe. And you had the recipe. That's that's that's the core of it. Yeah. Yeah. And the story. This is my grandmother's recipe. You know, it's like yeah, yeah. How long has it been in your family for? How long has she been making? Since the seventies. Okay. Yeah, I think I noticed that when I checked out the website, it was like since nineteen seventy-two or something like that. So Charlie Dumo: Yeah. Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: it has that connotation, is like these have been in production for a very long time. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: forever. Yeah. And you know We we we moved a lot of units and I was learning throughout the way. And what I really fell in love with was the the online shopping piece. I was like, this is ridiculous. I was like, I love this space. And I just started really spending all of my time focusing on direct consumer, consumer psychology online, how to get people to buy online. And then I realized like I can't spend all my time doing this when I've got a million other things to deal with. We were dealing with production issues, fulfillment. There's a bunch of other stuff, like you know, being a founder, ingredient. and sourcing all of this stuff. And then come so Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: It's there's so much that goes into it. Charlie Dumo: much that goes into it. And I was falling in love with like one specific aspect of the business. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: so come January 2025, we outgrew our our space and I needed to move into our own manufacturing plant and like a new copacker. And I needed a lot of capital I needed to raise because we needed to buy some huge equipment to like make these peanut butter balls. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Make these. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And I didn't really know what to do. And I was like, I don't really have enough information on the industry. I need to kind of better myself. So I started calling everyone I knew. And When I started calling everyone I knew, I s people kept like giving me really good advice, but they kept also asking me for help because I talked to a lot of brands. They're like, How did you do on the right-to-consumer side? And I started kind of consulting while I was trying to figure out this Charlie's Crunch thing. And I started consulting on like strategy and marketing strategy and what apps to use and where to put different things on your site. And that pick that picked up instantly. It was an overnight success. We got we Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: It was like Charlie Dumo: got ten clients in the first month. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Wow. Charlie Dumo: And I brought my co-founder actually in the g at the gym in January twenty twenty five because he came up to me and he said, Hey, you're the peanut butter ball boy. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And I was like, What's up? Like, all right, what what's up? Like Yeah, I was like, nice to meet you. And he He's like, Nice Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. you want some balls? You want some of my balls? Charlie Dumo: to meet you. And and then he's like, Hey, I've been in e-commerce since I was fifteen. And then I was like, my interest kind of peaked. I like, maybe we Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Get out. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: can be friends. Like I kind of. And we became friends instantly. I started Dumo Digital. And then about a month later, he joined in as a co-founder. And we've been working on Dumo Digital since. And we sunset and put Charlie's Crunch on pause in April 2025. We've gone all in on Dumo Digital and we are a Shopify partner for specialty food and beverage brands with a deep focus on consumer psychology, on how to get shoppers to buy. Buy more and subscribe. And how do we build a brand online? A lot of brands focus really on the shiny object, which is let's pour a bunch of money on ads, let's get Center IOL, Walmart, and Kroger, and Sprouts, and Costco. But what they really forget first is you have to build a brand. If you want to show up and perform at those high-level retailers, all they care about is volume. The margins there suck. They suck. And so in order to show up as your best self, you need to first of all build brand equity in the space. And you need to be able to have the cash to be able to fulfill these huge POs that these retailers put in. If you don't have that, and then you're cash constraint and you don't have enough volume to market once you're in these stores, they're gonna pull you off and you're never gonna show up again. So our job is to build the direct to consumer platform and that channel for brands to build that brand equity, to build the data, to build a customer base, and to build fans. Who are a brand loyalist and turn your product into a daily habit. And there's so much that goes into that, but it's really, it's like if you're selling a protein bar or like a supplement, it's not it's not a supplement, it's not a protein bar, it's a habit. The supplement's a daily use habit. You're selling a habit. Like, hey, get your best self back in 30 days. You need to have it every third every day for 30 days to even see any benefits. Your protein bar, right? We're all creatures of habit when we're all consumers. I have a dedicated protein bar that I eat and I need that on repeat because I have it every day before the gym or every day after my 3 p.m. crash, kind of whenever it is. And so it's like how do you frame your product around the habit that the consumers use it and then tailor your offer and your funnel towards that habit through subscription? Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Got it, got it. So that's a interesting transition that you know, when you're going from the Charlie's Crunch is having this like rise and understanding one, what you really liked about building that was the the D to C and Shopify component and being able to, you know, have the the will to, you know, take a hiatus and say, no, I this is my lane that I w that I want to to build in and this is what I wanna grow. how did you how did that decision come? 'Cause that it probably wasn't like well or maybe it was. It was like, did it just click or or did you have like some serious consideration? Did you have to go and talk to your grandma to be like, hey, You know, you had to put the balls on hiatus for a little bit here, you know, like how what was that what was that what was that time period like where you flipped the switch? Charlie Dumo: Great question. So from January to April 2025, my sophomore year of college. And at that time I was running both Dumo Digital and Charlie's Crunch. And we were dealing with all these fulfillment and these manufacturing issues. And I was trying to build Dumo Digital. I was like, let me just get home to back to Chicago and then figure out what I want to do from there. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And I kind of got home and I really sat with it for about two weeks. I gave myself two weeks to think about it. And I weighed out the pros and cons. I talked to a lot of my mentors and I said, you know what? I said, I know I've got a killer product here. I know I can do something here, but I need to learn more about the industry and I want to build a name for myself. I was I was twenty years old at the time. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And I was like, I need to figure something. I need to just build an I need to build my own personal brand within this industry and learn and help other people to do you know, do what I did. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And so once I kind of figured that out, I was like, all right, I'm I'm all in on Dumo Digital right now and I'm just gonna build my name in this space. and the one thing too, I fell in love with the e-commerce and the D and the you the D to C channel and like consumer psychology, but I never I never also didn't fall. I fell also in love too with the brand side. And that's the big piece we brought over to Dumo Digital is like let's show up branded, let's show up funky, let's talk weird, Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: let's have a personality, let's wear crazy jackets when we go places so people recognize us. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: For sure. Charlie Dumo: Like let's just do things differently. Because I mean you look at any other B2B service provider walking any trade show or event, they're all kind of wearing the same clothes. They're in business casual, business professional clothes. I'm like, screw that. I'm gonna wear jeans, sneakers, and a varsity jacket with a big Shopify logo and our logo on the back with my name pr printed on. This is what Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, for sure, for sure. Charlie Dumo: I wanna do. Like it's not that it's this is who I am, and I'm gonna show up who I am. and so it was really a tough decision and I really weighed out the pros and cons, but If I could go back, I'd make the same decision again. And it's really taught me a lot about the industry and allowed me to really focus in on what I love. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: think it's a mature o approach to have when I was twenty r when I was twenty years old, I wouldn't probably put myself in that to have a little bit of like wisdom there to say, hey, you know what, I need to learn more about this. And you know, you mentioned mentors in that decision making process. how did you how how did you identify and locate and 'cause as I'm doing this podcast I'm finding that like there's there's definitely Like for entrepreneurs, I'm I'm starting to see some like connections between it. It's like there's definitely a family element. So having your mother be in the space and like having that Charlie Dumo: Yeah, great question. Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: pedigree, but also having mentors and somebody that can help you navigate a difficult situation based on their experience, you know, it is something that even experienced entrepreneurs may not have until like later or they don't know how to approach a mentor. How how did that Charlie Dumo: So the the biggest Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: work? Charlie Dumo: Yeah, so the biggest thing too is stay curious. Make sure you you just always are at like you you're never satisfied with what you know. Like always keep thinking. And then the biggest too, especially for young entrepreneurs starting out, is in order to really find a solid mentor, somebody who's really has done something incredible, you you need to be working on something yourself. You need to have some value that you can provide. And these I mean, and so one of my first mentors I ever met, I was in New York City for an event. I was at a hotel gym in the middle of Manhattan, and it was like six AM. And there was a guy in there, and you know, I could kind of tell he did well for himself. He was well put together, he was in great shape. And I went up to him and I was genuine and I was myself and I said, Man, if I look like you and I'm your age, I'll be a happy camper. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Nice. Charlie Dumo: He's been a contact of mine and somebody I visit almost once or twice a year. We stay in touch every now and then, almost every two weeks for for the last two years. From there, he's Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: connected me to other people. I've been able to connect it to crazy other people. And he's introduced me to other mentors and he's helped expanded my network through who he knows. And we've built a really good relationship. And then another he's he is a lawyer. He's a lawyer. He has Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Is he in consumer packaged goods as well or DC is in he's a lawyer? yeah, yeah. Charlie Dumo: his own law firm. It doesn't matter really who they are in because so the one thing too about mentors is you have to have mentors for different things. So I really Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Sure. Charlie Dumo: go in when I have questions about dealing with people and like business ops. I'm like how do I deal with this type of person? Right. I'm really struggling with this type of persona. I have some mentors that are very CPG focused, they're very marketing focused. I go to them with certain types of questions. But the biggest thing is whenever you interact with your mentors, come to them with a question. Nobody really has time to just kind of talk the talk. Come to them with a question, and then you can talk to talk. Have a specific, yeah, hey, I Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, exactly. Like y you know, have a specific s this is what I'm working through. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: have a specific problem. I need your advice. This is my question. How do we move forward? What do I do? And then the Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Be Charlie Dumo: the biggest thing is take their advice. And if it doesn't work, let them know that you tried and report back to them. And if it does work, let them know you tried and report back to them. Like you need to, the biggest is follow-up. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: That's really good advice. That's really good advice. Charlie Dumo: Nobody, I'm not like I mean I mean people people come to me for you know entrepreneurship help and some mentoring and some guidance and I give them advice I don't hear for them. I never hear back from them. And I'm like, and Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: then they come back to me three months later and I'm like, listen, I'm not gonna spend any time with you because it's a waste of my time if you're not gonna go actually execute. Right? Tell me you Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right. Right. Charlie Dumo: tried it at least. If it didn't work, great, let's try something else. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: I I love that. I love that because I think that's something where you you need to be diligent with your own time and also like respectful of if a mentor's gonna take time, having that respect and you know, for the relationship and say, Hey, you know what, I tried this and it worked or you know what, it it didn't go as I as as planned and you know, I think that Charlie Dumo: That was Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: that sets up it it's it shows respect. It also shows some, you know chops in you're you're constantly working towards solving and solving a problem, taking things to the next step, and that it's a constant refinement. Yeah. I mean that's yeah. Charlie Dumo: It's it shows you pride. It shows you pride. And that's what they want to see. Is because these mentors, they they want to see themselves in you. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Sure. Charlie Dumo: that's really what gets them bought in. And you come back to them in port and say, Hey, John, listen, you told me to do this. I did it. Here's exactly what happened. Here's where I messed up. Maybe I didn't take your advice the right way, but what do we do now? Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And they're like, okay, this kid's invested. Like he's actually going out there and trying and he's listening to me. The biggest thing in I mean in human nature is people want to feel heard. And especially your mentors, you Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: A hundred percent. Charlie Dumo: want to keep them around, make them feel heard. And then it's funny enough because as you continue to build a relationship with them, you start adding value to them. And now some of my mentors, I'm I'm helping them with certain parts of their business with stuff that they're Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: asking me questions on. And you just continue to add value and the relationships get stronger and stronger. But it's all about just being curious. And I mean, I found other mentors too, where I'll be at a coffee shop and I'll overhear a conversation and I'll literally be like, hey, I don't mean to interrupt. But I couldn't agree more with what you just said. I'm sorry for eavesdropping. That's all and then that's all I say. And then they're like, who are you? Right? It's just like it doesn't have to be it. You have nothing Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: I love that. I love that. Yeah. What do you got to lose? What do you got to lose? Charlie Dumo: to lose. You have nothing to lose. And it's the only thing you have to lose if you don't try. And it's Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Exactly. Charlie Dumo: just try and start a conversation, but you have to be genuine. If you are weird about it and if you aren't genuine, like sometimes what I'll do is like I have a mentor that I started a conversation with. I mean, he runs a CPG brand. I had no idea who he was. He wants he runs Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Funny. Charlie Dumo: one of the hottest CPG brands in 2025 and 2026 right now, launched in almost every major retailer across the country. I had no idea who he was. But I I saw him sitting at a table at an event and he was just sitting there and no and there knows nobody else at his table. I don't really have anyone else to sit. And I went up to him And I just said, Hey man, like I really like your shoes. Like, where'd get those? And it was a genuine compliment. Like I was not trying to do anything. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And we just started talking. And next thing you know, he kinda told me what he does. He's like, Yeah, he's actually I'm a I'm a panel speaker here at the Forbes thirty under thirty. Like I'll be speaking tomorrow. And I was like, No way, I just went up to you and I had no idea, Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: right? And so you never know. You just never know. The people he connected Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: never know who you Yeah. Yeah, you never know. Charlie Dumo: me with and and and so on, like you just never know. and that's really kind of how we've built Dumo Digital as a whole is just through getting out in the world and meeting people like Mike at Shopify dot dev and just continuing to expand our network, especially being so young. I'm twenty one now. I actually, you know, dropped out of college my junior year, so November with my co founder. So about ten months into Dumo Digital, we dropped out together. and we have yeah. Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. So so I was curious, like you is so that was Ohio State connection where you where in you're like, okay, it takes a lot of guts to do that. And I think, you know, people who aren't in in the space or have an entrepreneurial sense will be will really question that. Like, why are you you know, y wait a minute, you you need your college degree. and I and I'm like, you know, I I I I tend to sit on the other side of the fence that is that like you if you have something you're getting traction, you know, w you're when you're that young, like you can always go back and finish your degree, may you know? Charlie Dumo: Nothing to lose. What I saw was an opportunity. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: My mindset was take the risk or lose the chance. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And I'm gonna take the risk ten times out of ten. And I'm Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: What did Charlie Dumo: not Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: your mother say, like knowing knowing your journey to that point and that she's in the space, you know, what was her reaction to that decision? Charlie Dumo: You know, the the family didn't take it too well. my mother's an entrepreneur, so it's like but they both I mean, they all I mean, it's Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: it's it's it's uncommon for where from where I grew up for a kid to drop out of college. I mean, almost everyone in my high school went to college. and Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right. Charlie Dumo: it's uncommon for anybody to drop out. And I said, I don't really care. This is my path. This is what I'm doing. I'm passionate, I ha I see an opportunity. I've never seen something more clear in my life. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: That doesn't mean I have my business plan figured out, but I know, like, I n I'm Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: You have a North Star. Charlie Dumo: I'm doing what I'm supposed to be doing. And I and Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: that that's what that's what drove the decision for me. And, you know, they over time have gotten, you know, it's been almost a year now, so they've gotten used to it and they know I'm I'm busting I'm busting Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: around getting it getting stuff done. But it's really it was a really it was really hard and I think the hardest thing too, we don't need to get too deep into this, but It's there i if you are a aspiring entrepreneur, you you need to give it a hundred percent because there are people giving it a hundred and ten percent who are still failing. So Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: how do you expect to give fifty to forty percent and expect to win? If you're not giving it everything you have, how do you expect to succeed? That's fine. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: I agree. I agree. Yeah. It's it's the it's the commitment to the mission, the journey. You have a North Star, you're like, this is where you y maybe you don't the road is winding and you don't know exactly how you know today is gonna d today or this quarter or maybe before the end of the year it's like it's gonna take you in all sorts of dirt different directions, but you're but you're moving and you're progressing. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Just gotta be yeah, you just gotta be in the car driving. Sometimes you don't even know where you're driving, but at least I'm driving somewhere. You're Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, yeah. Charlie Dumo: just moving. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: And I think that aligns well with like the message of Shopify in general is that, you know, you hear Toby and Harley like talk about it like on the stage there and and you know, in relation to message that they're delivering to to the partners, the message they put out on their earnings call, the brand is really focused about being the the technology that enables entrepreneurship. Like where, you know, y And I think you are a good case study of that is that like when there's a there's a lot of things that you need to do when you're doing any e commerce startup but definitely in the consumer packaged goods is like you need beyond getting suppliers, packing facility, you know, shippy you're you're dealing with like chocolate, like it perishable freezer conditions, all those things. But with Shopify, you just unlock it and they've they they built the infrastructure so you don't have to worry about okay, the the im I put my inventory in, I have the storefront. They're they take care of all those things, the payments, the checkout. So it it's funny how it's like I think that's the attraction that like somebody's going into the space is like they they have that in their core philosophy is that like well we're really, you know, yeah, we're like an e-commerce enablement tool and it like it's basically SaaS, right? At the end of the day, it's like it's e commerce SaaS. But the story and the brand that they've built is really the you know, they talk about the merchants, they talk about entrepreneur. They're like the last th yeah. And yeah, yeah. Charlie Dumo: So much for you. I mean, everybody is online nowadays. This is where you build a brand. This is, I mean, everybody's on their phones 24-7. R attention spans are less than five seconds. And if you want to build a brand, you gotta learn how to win online. You want Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: to win the physical world, you gotta learn how to win online first. You want Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right, right. Charlie Dumo: people finding your product on a shelf, not asking what is this, but saying, I've seen this. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: I've seen this before. I need this. You know, and that those times. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Yeah. Yeah. Well my favorite influencer uses this. I can't believe it's finally in my local target. That's what you Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: want. And those retailers, they want to see traction. They want to see data. They want to Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right. Charlie Dumo: see how can you make the pie bigger? I mean one of my mentors, he told me, he said when he was pitching this category to a specific retailer. he said, Listen, this category right now, this aisle for you, does about a million dollars a year. He's like, I'm not gonna come in and add that million dollars, like a percentage of it. I'm gonna come in and make the pie bigger. I'm gonna make that aisle worth five million dollars for you because I've got a whole new demographic of people shopping for this specific product that will come looking for it. I will Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: That will come look that will come looking for this. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: make this pie bigger. That is what you wanna do as a brand, is how can you make the pie bigger in a saturated market? Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: In order to do that, is you build this crazy brand online. You call Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right, right. Charlie Dumo: them. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: And so that's th you've been you've been at this and you s you know, y you're already you know, just some stats here. Y you know, in under two years you already generated fifty million in revenue for your clients and you have you know, if you know, go to Dumo Digital dot com if you want read the playbook. But so but I mean that's indicative of hey, you're off s you're you're off to a really strong start. You said you have the you know right off the bat, in the first couple months, you had a dozen clients. And I'm sure it like some of I I assume, you know, th those those are some of your the people brands you've worked with that are on the shelf behind you. how and also leveraging your network, right? Like you're saying you had you were already talking to these people about your business, but they it in that in almost like that mentorship model you know, there was a reflection of, hey, well I gotta ask you a couple things like, you know, you're doing this online and how are how are you doing this? So how how did those first conversations with those brands and like convert them and saying, hey, I want to work on this with you, what was that like? And and how did you fold that into kind of like a sales motion and acquisition? Yeah, yeah. Charlie Dumo: how you get your first clients. It's hard. It's very hard to kind of get your first clients, especially being a service provider. The biggest thing is show value. Show value. Show Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Mm-hmm. Right. Charlie Dumo: as much value as you can up front. I mean there are still projects, there are clients I'm still chasing that I would really like to work with. Where I will say, listen, give me just access and give me something. I have a plan. I know what I can do. Give me one month to prove myself to you. No strings attached. No dollar amount. I just want to show you what I can do. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: I just want to show you. You Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: just provide value. You teach, you educate. Almost on every call I get on, it's half the time I'm just teaching them about consumer psychology within their category on their storefront. I'm not even selling anything. I'm just teaching. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Show value. And especially for any young entrepreneurs listening to this, if you are struggling to get your first clients, build a referral system. So instead of trying to figure out, stop thinking so much in transactional, like how much money can I get off these sales? Think about, hey, I need to build this business. I need to put in some sweat equity. Right. So maybe I take on five projects in the first five projects. You say, hey, I'm gonna do this completely for free for you. But well, here's what I need to return. I need approval to use this as a case study. I need a written testimonial. Now you do that five times. You've now got five case studies. You've got now five reps under your belt to pressure test your business and your services. You've got five testimonials. Make Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Make sure you deliver. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: sure you deliver and you've got reps and you've got testimonials. Now that sixth person that comes to you, now you know your price, you know your value, and you can start pricing out. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Absolutely. Talk a little bit more when you mentioned, you know, getting on the the call and like delivering the value where you're talking about the consumer buying psychology. Like what is there any anecdotal things or stories you could share that people respond to or just just what you've learned that you know you might share on a share on a call? Charlie Dumo: So there's three pillars your website needs to have selling consumer product goods online. Is the first is education. Your website can either be your best salesman or your worst salesman. So you need to educate your consumer. A lot of brands lead with features of their product, not the benefits. You need to lead, you need to find the pain points of your consumers and pump and pump and pressure those pain points. And lead with the problem saying, hey, here's a problem you have, here's a solution we have to it. How do you educate, right? So us first them, ingredients deep dive, the science behind your product, whatever it is, blogs, whatever. Then the second pillar is trust. So how do you induce trust? Do you have clear reviews? Do you have filterable reviews? Do you have UGC on your website of the same demographic that you're targeting. So if you're targeting millennial moms, if I go on the site and I'm looking on the product page, do I see UGC of millennial moms using this product? So that millennial mom who's debating if they want to buy this product actually sees themselves using that product through those UGC content. And then FAQs, right? You need to make sure it's trust. Like, do they have proper FAQs? There's a difference between product-specific FAQs and brand-wide specific FAQs. On your product page, you need to ask questions about them buying. Think about like questions they ask right before they buy. What does it taste like? How do I use this? What does it taste best with? Does it make me feel bloated? Questions about actually buying signals. A lot of brands put like shipping and policy and return exchange. Like those are those are brand wide FAQs. Those live on a Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: separate FAQ page. And so you really need to make sure you have your structured FAQ content because people read those. They're important. You don't want to skip Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right. Charlie Dumo: them. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right. Charlie Dumo: And then the third most important pillar, so you have education, you have trust, and the third is ease of use. How easy is it to buy a three-pack, a six-pack, subscribe and save, add to cart, reach your free shipping threshold, and check out? When you have Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Sure. Charlie Dumo: all three of those firing, becomes an engine. I don't like to say the word website, it becomes a revenue engine. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And so our goal at Dumo Digital is our North Star metric is revenue per visitor. We are not the team that gets people to the site. We are the team that makes the traffic you have already worth more. So for Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Got it. Charlie Dumo: example, if you're a brand that has a hundred people coming to your site a day, and right now three people buy and they spend an average of ten dollars and none of them subscribe. What we do is we we all bottom of the funnel, right? So we copywriting, offer framing, education, trust, ease of use, clean all that up, whether that be a rebuild, redesign, whatever it is, or optimization. We take the same hundred people that are originally coming to your site, instead of three people buying and spending $10, now 20 people buy and they spend $50 and seven of them subscribe. Completely different business model, same amount of traffic. And so a brand really has to think, do we have the right to turn on ads and start scaling paid traffic? And so many Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right. Charlie Dumo: brands throw a basic template up and then just start pouring money into meta and creatives. And then who do they go blame? They go blame their meta agency or their meta ads for why they're not converting. And I ask them and I say, listen, you're sending people to a store that's not built to convert cold traffic. You're not educating, you're not teaching, you're not, you have no trust. This is impossible to find the products I'm looking for. I have no idea how to get the checkout. What do you expect people to do? Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: It's an online brick and mortar. And it's it's the same. I mean, think about it in the real world, because this really clears it up for a lot of people too, is imagine you're on High Street in on in downtown Columbus, the main street in Columbus. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: And there's a store, a clothing store, for example, and they spend all their money on marketing, billboards, posters, ads, everywhere you go. There's you see this grand opening. They sp they put all the money and all the capital into this opening, into this marketing for their opening. But then when you walk into the store, none of the clothes are hung up, nobody's there to greet you, there's only one changing room, there's only one cashier. The entire process of how the store was built is horrible. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Doesn't match what was out there. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Anybody's gonna walk into the store, take one good look and walk right out. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: that's exactly what these brands are doing is they're pouring all this money on top of funnel. They're pouring all this money Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Great analogy. Yeah, it's great analogy. Charlie Dumo: on top of funnel and completely disregard bottom of the funnel where the purchase is made. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Right. Charlie Dumo: that's the big unlock there. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: That's That's that's a super good way to visualize that and get through. especially, you know, if you're going to be like, Hey, your store n needs this basic work done in order to be able to convert and that's how I'm gonna create value for your brand and move units. And I know when we when we had spoken at at dot dev and and like, you know, it's it's highlighted on your services and is the subscription and the strategy for that. How do you approach that? Because they're difficult. It's like you know, I'm sure it's it's case by like what the category is, what the product is. You know, Charlie Dumo: Course. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: but w can you talk a little bit about how you at Du Won't Digital kind of go through that w with a client that either needs to improve their subscription or enable like they don't have it and you're you're implementing it. Those two use cases. Charlie Dumo: Yeah. It's a great question. So it all it all comes down to what is that core offer? Is how do we frame subscription as the best offer? And within that, a lot of brands are like, I have no idea where to start. And I'm like, perfect. That's okay. We're gonna work through it together. The first thing you need to unlock is, all right, what are your margins? What does it cost to fulfill? What are we actually working with here? How deep of a discount can we get? What what like and how crafty of an offer can we have? Right. So maybe if you have good margins and and it doesn't cost you too much to ship, maybe we offer free shipping on subscription orders only. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right. Charlie Dumo: Right. And then you really entice you really want to intensify people to to subscribe. And you want to lead with subscription. Subscription is the default. Now, if you're a brand that subscription isn't the only way to buy, you always have a one-time purchase right under, but you have subscription on top, auto-toggled on, already clicked so that they can visually see the discount when you're on a product page. That's where the offer lies. So instead of a consumer Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: That's where the offer lies. That's where you're getting. That's where the consumer's gonna see the most value. Charlie Dumo: A a consumer a lot of consumers they don't want to opt out of a discount. So if you just flip it Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: where they have to opt out of a discount, they're not gonna want to do that. And then you frame subscriptions around like cancel anytime, no commitment, right? You know, free shipping on every order, get a free gift on your first subscription, right? XYZ, change flavors anytime. VIP access. And then the more they buy, the deeper the savings they get too, right? And so you really want to make such a compelling offer. So we like to do this like we like to do anchor pricing on the PDVs. Whereas like Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: we'll show instead of just showing one product, One time you show the same product, but instead of a one-pack, two-pack, and a three-pack, let's say you're selling a supplement, reframe it, right? So it's let's say a one pack is 30 days worth of gummies to take every day. It's not a Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Sure, sure. Call me supplement. Charlie Dumo: one-pack, two-pack, a three-pack. It's a one-month, two-month, three-month program. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: And then you can subscribe. And just changing that copy gets it in their minds, like, hey, I need to use this every day. It's a program, Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, yeah. Charlie Dumo: it's a habit former, it's a habit, right? Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: That's exactly what you would said in terms of at the top of this when we're talking about is like creating that habit, making it habitual with the consumer, where and then the product has to be good also is like that you th yeah, like you said, Charlie Dumo: Yeah. The product has to the product has to Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: you know, it's like for your y you know, once you get a taste of whether it's Charlie's crunch or you s you mentioned your protein bar, it's like it has to deliver on the value promised, or else you're gonna have a lot of people canceling subscription. Charlie Dumo: If the product isn't good, like there's nothing really a good storefront can do. Like you have to have a good product. That's Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: the bottom line. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: But then from there, it's like great, how do we craft the compelling offer? So like on, let's say you have three options. So you have the 30-day program, the 60-day program, and the 90-day program. You have the middle tiers, auto-selected, and subscribe and save auto-selected. And on the middle tier, you call out most popular. And then on the 90-day program, you call us best value because you get the deepest discounts. Right. And you Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Charlie Dumo: don't let your consumers do mental math. Show the the cr the strike-through savings on this so they can clearly see the ment they don't have to do any mental math, they can clearly see their saving. Yeah. Yeah. Like hey. Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: what I'm leaving on the table if I if I wanted to do this or this is where I'm comfortable this is like this is where I'm comfortable making a commitment, you know, yeah, it's visually. And we all go through that Charlie Dumo: Exactly. Hey, if you buy a Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: when you're on a checkout or or you're on a product detail page is, you know, the where where where am I going to see the most value? And like where do I see myself fitting? And then you then you you layer on some of the other elements you're saying is that if you're targeting middle aged moms, it's like show that. Show that show show that on the product detail page. Charlie Dumo: And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Sure, sure. Charlie Dumo: leave the benefits above the fold, right? So if you have ten grams of protein, six grams of fiber, zero sugar, that should be above the fold when I'm d when looking at the product images. I Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: sh clearly s it shouldn't be in text. Nobody's reading text nowadays. I mean I'm not sitting around Yeah. Except for the AI. So but but Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Well except for except for the AI. Except for AI. Right. And that's a whole nother conversation. Right. Charlie Dumo: But e i even how you structure the the benefits, make it readable for AEO, but make it so that consumers when they land on a product page they immediately see all right, ten grams of protein with an icon, six grams of fiber, zero grams of sugar, gluten free, right? They see those benefits clearly and then calling out Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. That's me. That's me. That's what I care about. Charlie Dumo: Yeah, exactly. Not the features of the product, the benefits, the benefits. And then two Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: No. Yeah. Well that harkens back to essentially, you know, f core fundamental things that are business is, you know, i it's it's the it's not the features, it's the benefits. If you go back to like the great advertising minds of of like the past century, like OV, you know, that was that was his whole thing is that you know you they write a full page ad and it was just talking about what you could expect the benefits were. It wasn't you know product features, it was benefits, benefits, benefits. So it's it's it's timeless. But I think it's still you know, i i it it's not done well, you know, all over the place. So there is a lot of room for those improvements. And I guess y another thing to say is like who's who is like absolutely killing it right now? Like categories or brands that you're seeing that are that are taking those, implementing it, and just like really crushing it right now. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Gruins, let's talk about Gruins. Thirty-two months into their business, $1.2 billion valuation, not a single retail store until then. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Model of subscription. They have Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: And they're Charlie Dumo: the craziest offer. You land on their on their homepage, you get 52% off your first order on subscriptions. Why would you not subscribe at that point? Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And then you get the subscription, and then from there, you get the product in your hand. You're this is unbelievable. I gotta use all of it. I just bought a 30 pack, I gotta eat one a day. And then you get into a habit of eating one every day, and then they've built out a whole subscription platform with retention, with clavial marketing, with email marketing, cancellation flows. So if people want cancel you build out a whole flow saying hey why are you canceling is it price texture using use it enough based on what they answer you segment it out their entire business model has been subscriptions Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: and they're constantly testing new offers I mean every single month when you go on that website you will see a new offer and then even two they're a b testing different pages you Mike and I can go on the site right now and maybe we'll see different parts of the website that you only see and that I only see they're constantly testing they're constantly learning from the data but they have Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, the segmenting out. Yeah. And they Charlie Dumo: They they're I mean they're doing Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: they took that to a huge acquisition by was it Proctor Gamel? Gamble just bought him. That was Thorin. Okay. Yeah. That's another huge so you see these Charlie Dumo: I th I think so. That was that was Thorm. That was Thorm. Exactly. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: big exits. It's like w like with subscription based businesses. And that's who's like carrying a lot of weight. Yeah. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Exactly. This is this is the model. And this is why food and beverage and anything consumable, it's all subscription because you have to eat it and you have to use it. I mean we've even done this with olive oil brands where people I mean this olive oil Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay, explain that because olive oil is yeah, you know, we go through a lot of it, I guess, but you know, that's that's Charlie Dumo: Exactly. So this is Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: something you wouldn't normally think. I need is I need an olive oil subscription. How did that how does that work? Charlie Dumo: Great question. So this brand came to us and they're like, hey, people are only buying one bottle and they're not subscribing and our AOV is flat. We know what do do? And I said, listen, let's give the consumer three options. They can buy one bottle, three bottles, or six bottles. Within sixty days, their AOV went from like twenty-nine dollars to like forty-five dollars. And people were buying three bottles of olive oil and they were subscribing and keeping it. Because they bought so much olive oil, what do you think they started doing every time they cooked? They used all of it, they loved Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Using it. Charlie Dumo: it, they started dipping it in bread, like they were using in ways they never used it before because they had access to it. And then Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: because they had all this access to it and they were using it, it became part of their habit. And now they love it. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: habitual. Yeah. And then you're you're showing those those benefits on the site. It's like it's it's healthier than alternative. I can see like all all those elements that you Charlie Dumo: Yeah. Yeah. Well they had a exact Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: that you laid out, it's like okay that that fits fits the mold. Charlie Dumo: Like if I buy three bottles of olive oil, I'm gonna use my three bottles of olive oil. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Right, right. Yeah, and I think that's that's a good way to say it because I think w at least in in my personal experience or like when you're when you're thinking about like subscription, it's like, are you buying too much? Am I just buying this for the hell of it? Or am I actually gonna consume this? Right. And it's like so you there is some nuance in that the retention strategy and making sure like you use grooms as an example, which I just saw in like Costco by the way, so it's like they're you know, talk about like Charlie Dumo: Yeah, they're Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: you like go blowing up. But the the nuance of detail is like hey you know like maybe you need this spaced out a little bit more like don't scrap the whole thing but like there's there's ways to manage that flow Charlie Dumo: There's right. So maybe instead of every month for olive oil, it's like every three months. Right. It's a bit Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, yeah, which you know, which could be a thing, but but it you're still getting the retention there. And and it's habits Charlie Dumo: Exactly. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: and it's habit on that brand is like this is this is the best olive oil. I use it when I cook all the time. Whereas opposed to you know, it 'cause it that's something where you're you're retaining like ownership of the brand. It's like I don't you ask me to name an olive oil brand, it's like, I don't know, like buy like again, Costco, like or whatever Charlie Dumo: The biggest brand that comes to my mind is Grazza. I mean they've built a they've built a crazy brand. They've built a crazy brand. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay, Grazie. yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. As soon as you say it, but the recall now I now have the recall of it because it I've definitely been exposed to that. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: But they've built a huge brand. They've built a huge following. And that's why they have all this brand equity within that space because of the following they've built and the brand they've built. I couldn't name any Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: For sure, for sure. Charlie Dumo: other I couldn't name any seasoning brand. Like I don't know any seasoning brands like a major barbecue sauce brand other like Sweet Baby Rays. Right? But it's they've been around Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Sweet baby raise, yeah, yeah. And it's like just everything else. Charlie Dumo: for so long. So if you want to show up in the barbecue sauce aisle, you've got to build a crazy brand. You've got to do something. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. So competitive. So competitive. Charlie Dumo: gotta be funky in your marketing. You gotta, you gotta have different packaging, right? Like everyone's showing up. Like go walk. I do this all the time. With a lot of our partners and our competitor with our partners, I'll go look at their competitors in store and I'll just get ideas and I'll just think about like how can we show up differently? Like everyone Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: else is showing like if everyone else is showing up like this, let's show up completely different. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. No, that's that's a great competitive advantage too. And it's also i if you're in if you're not if the brand isn't afraid to stand out and make those bold decisions and and then like really see the results, it seems yeah, you know. Well Charlie Dumo: Take the risk. Yeah. I mean literally take the risk. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. And that that I you know, I I'm seeing just getting to like know you better in this time is like I I see I see the the the risk taking as obviously as like you you're no stranger to that and how that's infused like how you're looking at business and it's really it's like it really becomes part of your life. It's like t like those those elements of, you know, taking a chance. Just just do it. It's like y y you know, it you you're doing that with your clients as well too. So it's like you're you're not just you know, you're saying it is like you're doing it yourself and then you can i i i if somebody wants to work with you, you'd be like, Hey, you're gonna have you're gonna have to take this risk too because or else it's not gonna work. Charlie Dumo: And the beauty too is you better you'd rather take the risk on a direct to consumer storefront where you have way better margins and you don't have to worry about slotting fees and volume because you can kind of throw stuff at the wall and see what sticks under direct to consumer storefront. You can't really that in retail. So you Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. No, you don't have the margin, right? Charlie Dumo: don't have the margin, you also don't have if it doesn't work, like they're gonna kick you off the shelf. So it's like Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: figure it out first, figure out what works first, and then show up to retail. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. And and create the brand, make like deserve the space. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: Take all those risks before you get there so that when you're there, you're your best self and you Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: sit on the shelf. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: No. Well and like What about so we're we're on the other side is I think, you know, it would be remiss of us not to discuss AI and how that's you know, I I I think obviously it's changing but for for selling like goods, like people are still gonna buy these items and the subscription items. But are you seeing any you know, I guess what's your outlook and w how do you infuse AI into what you're doing and you know what what are brands seeing and like what are they interested in when it comes to like AI and it's you know rolling out quickly here. What's Charlie Dumo: I think it's it's really it's it's really about how much there's so much we can get so much more accessible data with AI that allows us to to to be able to get data faster and then be able to form hypothesis better based on data. Right. Because when you're testing on a storefront, like if you're running ongoing tests, like you need data and then you need to be able to form hypothesis. And so it's like we can now quickly gather data, we can scrape more, we can see different competitors, we can do competitor analysis, and then really come better with a better plan with AI. I also think AI too, like I don't think, and this is my personal opinion, I've heard different sides of the story. I think online shopping is going to start like a kind of how it is right now on Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: an AI model, like an LLM, a chat, GBT, a Claude. But I still think people are going to go to the store because people like to shop. They like to browse. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: People do yeah, yeah. Charlie Dumo: I'm a consumer. I don't want AI to tell me, Yep, I ordered your shoes without even looking at it. Like that's part of the fun. Like part of Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: For sure. For sure. Charlie Dumo: the fun is like being able to browse and look at different colors and like that's part of the fun. But it's like you need to make sure your storefront is structured so that you are recommended when people look for your products. And that comes in with how you write your FAQ copy, how you write your copy. Are you leading with features? You're never gonna show up if somebody types in and saying, Hey, I feel super sluggish. I never have enough energy. I need supplement that I can take that doesn't have any sugar, that's vegan, because I'm vegan, what do you recommend for me that I can easily order that has a bunch of reviews? Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: And if your store doesn't have any of that information, you're never gonna get recommended. It's never gonna show up. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: It's never gonna show up. Yeah. And that was something, you know, s heart like circling back and kind of like bringing it all together. That was something that was covered at dot dev and like that was real alpha in that is that they're getting very granular with the the agenic recommendations. Is that like just that that whole like paragraph is like you could picture somebody putting that into Chat GBT and it's like, well what's showing up? It's like and that's it they're wiring Charlie Dumo: Exactly. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: the Agenic Commerce to like it's not just, you know, give me X variant and this type of category, it's all these situations. Yeah. Yeah. And here's the little nitty-gritty of it. So it's like while Charlie Dumo: Yeah. I have this problem, how can I solve this problem? What are the best ways to solve this problem? Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: search volume might be down, it's like when somebody's showing up from that they've already done all the research in their in their LLM. then you know they're gonna convert higher because they've like already kind of like made the decision, right? I think that's that's that's the real transformation is that like this the the traffic Charlie Dumo: Yeah. They're not asking they're not asking Google, hey, find me a caffeine gummy. They're like, hey, here are problems I have with my day. What do recommend I do? And then Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Where are some where are some options? Charlie Dumo: what are some options? And then Chad GBT or Claude can like, hey, I think a caffeine gummy with zero sugar would be great place to start. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Yeah. No th Charlie, this has been fantastic. I I'm really I'm really happy to like have have learned about what you're building with Dumo agency. Just like w you know, just a couple things as we wrap up here. Where what do you see for the next year building the agency and like we'll just go there. What's what's the next year like? Charlie Dumo: Great question. It's the beauty of entrepreneurship that I don't really even know what tomorrow looks like. But Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: For sure, for sure. Charlie Dumo: really what we see is this whole concept of I mean, everyone knows SaaS, software as a service. Really where we kind of are seeing it is the reverse SaaS, which is service as a software. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: America, businesses on average spend six dollars for every service compared to one dollar they spend on software. And now with all the technology we have available at our hands, we can build our back end as software and have our front end be a service. So 20% of it is service, which is all the front end. So you still get to connect with a real person. They're still interacting with you. But the back end is entirely software. So that's what we're building out. So we can actually move and ship a lot faster, but you still get that service aspect and that connection and that strategy that we have. And so that's Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, that's smart. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: really what we're trying to build too, is build this technical back end because nobody really cares. How sausage is made, they just want it made. And with all this technology, Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Exactly. Exactly. Charlie Dumo: it's like we can start building this reverse SaaS and really start shipping faster, testing faster, and getting results faster for our partners. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah, yeah. So you can scale and it's also where you're talking about subscription is like as a service is like that's that's what you want too is like there's that there's so many like metal meta like things that resonate through your story and that's like one of them is like well this is how we're gonna do well is cause you're subscribing to me as well too and Charlie Dumo: Exact. Exactly. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: and how we're gonna generate it for you is subscriptions as well. So it's Charlie Dumo: Yeah. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: it it's the same thing. yeah. Yeah, that well I I I I I gotta say, I'm definitely I I'm a fan. Like I you know, you don't run across many young entrepreneurs that have the chops or like the real sense of like where you're going and like why you're doing it. So it's it's awesome to like connect at this level. And I'll be I'll be you know keep like you know forming this relationship. I'll definitely be checking in with you, have you on for an update, you know, or if you ever want to come back on, let's let's do it. I gotta end on like college football because this is one thing where we we where we don't agree because you're Ohio State Buckeys, I'm Notre Dame, and I am definitely in the not in any position to say anything, but what what's your outlook for the Buckeyes this year in college football? Charlie Dumo: You're gonna hate my answer. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: W well yeah, but that's why I asked. You know, we gotta do it. Okay. Because you're dorking Charlie Dumo: Honestly, I don't know. I haven't I haven't been keeping up. I love my buckeyes, I'll root for them, but I mean once I stop playing col Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: All right. Respect. Charlie Dumo: once I stop playing college sports, it's kinda been really hard for me to kinda engage with any sports at all. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Okay, interesting, yeah. Charlie Dumo: and so I always root for my buckeyes, they're my team, but I'm I'm focusing on consumer psychology and yeah business and Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: But getting no that you know what? That's a great I I love that answer because it's because it's authentic. And that's and that's something that that's a great great way. And just like, you know, for me it's like go Irish is like we can't get over that's one of the the the hurdles is like Notre Dame can't get through Ohio State or like you know, but it came close a couple of times here and desperate like national championship I you know, the the you know, story for another podcast. But the authenticity that you bring, Charlie, is really something where you can't fake it. I can't take that away from you. And listening to your mentors and you know your gut is I think is gonna serve you well. And it'll it'll transcend beyond whatever the AIR is or you know what what other challenges are thrown your way is you're you seem well positioned for for that for that growth and up for the challenge you know of of solving these problems I I have a feeling like you know in the trenches you're probably throwing a lot of different crap that is comes with running this and and running this for your clients and you know I you know I can I can see you taking that in stride so and Charlie Dumo: Thank you. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: that's that's something you like nobody can take that away those those elements away from you so that's that's good Charlie Dumo: I I think the one thing I wanna end on is it's The most important thing you can do the being a business owner, being involved, being an entrepreneur is be yourself. How Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: I show up today is exactly how I show up with my childhood best friends, with my family. When I meet a new prospect and I'm on a sales call, whatever you name it, I show up the exact same. Because at the end of the day, I'm not in the food and beverage industry. I'm not in the Shopify industry. I'm in the people industry. And Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Yeah. Charlie Dumo: people buy into people. And in order for people to buy into us and kind of what we believe in and who we are and what we stand for, I'm I gotta show up as myself and be my authentic 100% always self, Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: no matter where or what the situation is. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. No, it g otherwise it doesn't come through. And then y you know, when you're talking about infusing that into everything you do and then making sure your clients are doing the same, there's a a a resonance there that you can't you you can't fake that. You can't fake that. It comes through. It it comes through and it's either there and it or it's not. so I really enjoyed the conversation. Where can people find you? Let's say they have a a D to C consumer package good and they need help with With their brand, their subscription strategy, their their retention, where how do they get in touch? Charlie Dumo: Yeah, you can get in touch with us at Dumo Digital dot com. That's D U O Digital dot com. Also post a lot on my LinkedIn on consumer psychology frameworks, kind of what I see winning in the market, kind of what we've been doing for brands. That's Charlie Dumo on LinkedIn, D-U-M-O. I post regularly on my personal Instagram account. That's Charlie.dumo. Other than that, I'm always happy for a conversation. If you're a brand looking just for for ideas and just where to kind of start and to kind of get your brain thinking in one spot, if you feel overwhelmed, always open to chat. I know what it's like to be a brand, a founder of a brand schlepping product in the summer heat to a farmer's market, product melting, manufacturing issues, Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: mislabeling. I've been there, I've done that. If you want to just talk and talk it through and have somebody to vent to, I'm your guy. I always have a great conversation. I always love meeting new people. Mike, thank you again for having me. This has been awesome. And I wish Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Yeah. Charlie Dumo: everybody who's listened the best success on their entrepreneurial journeys. Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Thanks, Charlie. It's been a it's been a real pleasure. Thank you. Charlie Dumo: Thank you.