Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Direct Listings to Go Public
Transcript
- Lucas: So it's July 23, 2026, and Coinbase is trading around 166 bucks — up about three and a half percent over the past five days. Not a bad run, but it's a far cry from its opening trade of 381 dollars back in 2021. And that opening trade happened not through a traditional IPO, but through a direct listing. Luna: Right, and direct listings have been this sort of alternative path that a small but notable group of companies have taken. Coinbase being the highest-profile example. Lucas: Exactly. So let's unpack what a direct listing actually is. In a traditional IPO, a company hires underwriters — investment banks — who buy the shares from the company at a discount and then sell them to the public. The company raises capital, the banks get fees, and there's typically a lockup period of 90 to 180 days before insiders can sell. Luna: And in a direct listing, no underwriters, no new shares issued, no lockup. The existing shareholders — founders, employees, early investors — just sell their shares directly on the exchange. Lucas: Right. The company itself doesn't raise new money. It's purely a liquidity event for existing shareholders. That's the key distinction. And it's a big reason why companies like Spotify, Slack, and Coinbase chose this route. They didn't need the capital — they were already well-funded — but their employees and early backers wanted to cash out. Luna: And it saves on those hefty underwriting fees. Investment banks typically charge four to seven percent of the proceeds in an IPO. For a company like Coinbase, that could have been hundreds of millions. Lucas: Yeah. But there's a trade-off. Without underwriters, there's no price stabilization. In an IPO, the banks can step in and buy shares if the stock starts falling, to support the price. In a direct listing, it's just supply and demand from the opening bell. The opening price is set by a designated market maker based on buy and sell orders, not by bankers negotiating a price. Luna: And that can lead to some volatility. Coinbase opened at 381 dollars, but within days it was in the 300s. It's been a rollercoaster ever since. Lucas: And that's actually one of the things the SEC has been looking at. Back in 2020, they allowed direct listings on the New York Stock Exchange, but with restrictions. Then in 2021, they approved a rule change that allowed companies to also raise capital in a direct listing — a primary direct listing — not just a secondary one. So a company could issue new shares and sell them directly to the public, without underwriters. Luna: But that hasn't really taken off. Most direct listings are still the old-school kind, like Coinbase's, where no new capital is raised. Why do you think that is? Lucas: I think it's a combination of factors. One, the companies that are candidates for direct listings are typically well-known brands with strong balance sheets. They don't need the capital. Two, the lack of underwriter support means the company has to do a lot of the investor education itself. And three, there's still this cultural inertia around IPOs. The roadshow, the bell-ringing, the pop on the first day — it's a rite of passage. Luna: Yeah, and there's also the question of pricing. In an IPO, the banks often underprice the shares intentionally, so they pop on day one. That leaves money on the table for the company, but it rewards early investors. In a direct listing, the market sets the price, so you don't get that pop. But you also don't leave money on the table. Lucas: It's a philosophical difference. Some companies want to maximize the price for existing shareholders, not court new ones. And the direct listing does that. It's also more transparent — the price is set by actual orders, not by a few bankers in a room. Luna: But it's not for everyone. If you're a smaller company without a recognizable brand, you might need the banks to drum up demand. And if you need to raise capital, a primary direct listing is still untested. Lucas: So who is it for? Typically, companies with a large, liquid secondary market already — think Spotify, which had shares trading on private markets for years. Or Coinbase, which had a huge user base and a well-known name. The idea is that the market knows enough about the company to price it efficiently. Luna: And one often overlooked benefit: no lockup period. In an IPO, insiders are locked up for months. In a direct listing, they can sell on day one. That's huge for employees who have been holding illiquid stock for years. Lucas: Huge, but also risky. If a lot of employees sell at once, it can depress the price. And without a lockup, there's no forced holding period. So you could see a flood of supply on day one. That's part of why Coinbase opened at 381 and then dipped — there was a lot of selling pressure from early investors and employees. Luna: Right, but the flip side is that by day two, the market has already absorbed that supply. In an IPO, the lockup expiration often causes a second wave of selling months later. Lucas: Exactly. So the direct listing compresses that selling into the first few days. Some argue that's more efficient. Others say it's more chaotic. But it's definitely a different risk profile. Luna: And since we're recording this for a business and technology podcast — if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, we'd love your support. Listener contributions are what keep this show ad-free and independent. If you're able, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, we really appreciate it. It helps us keep digging into topics like this one. So back to direct listings — one interesting development is that the SEC has been considering expanding the rules to make it easier for companies to do primary direct listings, where they issue new shares. Luna: That could be a game-changer. If a company can raise capital without paying underwriting fees, and without a lockup, it might become the default for a certain class of companies. Lucas: Right. But there are still hurdles. For example, in a direct listing, the company doesn't have the same liability protections. In an IPO, the underwriters do due diligence and the company can rely on their work. In a direct listing, the company alone is responsible for the accuracy of its disclosures. Luna: That's a big legal risk. Especially for tech companies with complex revenue models. Lucas: Exactly. So it's not a free lunch. But for the right company, it can be a much more efficient way to go public. And we're seeing more companies consider it. In 2021, we had a wave — but since then, the IPO market has been quieter. As it revives, I think we'll see more direct listings. Luna: Well, and with the current market, the VIX has been elevated, and IPOs have been slow. But the pipeline is building. When it opens up, direct listings will be a topic again. Lucas: One thing to watch is how institutional investors react. In an IPO, they get allocations at the IPO price. In a direct listing, they have to buy on the open market, like everyone else. That reduces their incentive to participate in the roadshow. Luna: But some institutions prefer that. They don't want to be locked up, and they don't want to play the allocation game. They'd rather just buy in the open market. Lucas: True. So it's not a one-size-fits-all. But for a company like Coinbase, it worked. They saved tens of millions in fees, gave their employees immediate liquidity, and got a fair market price. Luna: And they still have a public listing. Their stock is actively traded, they're in the Nasdaq, they have analyst coverage. So it's not like they're missing something by not having an IPO. Lucas: Right. The institutional machinery is the same after the listing. The difference is really just the process of getting there. And that process is becoming more standardized. The NYSE and Nasdaq have both filed rule changes to accommodate direct listings. Luna: So it's a real option. Not just a niche. Lucas: Exactly. And as more companies choose it, the ecosystem around it will mature. There'll be more research, more templates, more legal precedents. That will lower the barriers for smaller companies. Luna: Well, and speaking of smaller companies, what about SPACs? They were huge in 2020 and 2021, but they've faded. Do you think direct listings will replace SPACs as the alternative to IPOs? Lucas: I think there's room for both. SPACs offer a different set of trade-offs — they're faster, they allow for forward-looking projections, but they've had a lot of regulatory and reputational issues. Direct listings are cleaner, but they require the company to already be well-known and well-capitalized. Luna: So for the next high-profile tech unicorn, which path would you recommend? Lucas: It depends. If they need capital and have a strong brand, I'd consider a primary direct listing if the rules allow. If they don't need capital, a secondary direct listing is great for liquidity. But if they're less established, a traditional IPO with strong underwriters might still be the safer bet. Luna: So it's back to that classic line: it depends. Lucas: It always does. But the point is that companies now have more options than they did ten years ago. And that's good for everyone. Luna: Agreed. So we'll be watching to see who goes next. Lucas: And we'll be here to break it down. For Fexingo Business, I'm Lucas. Luna: And I'm Luna. Thanks for listening.