Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP214 - The Terrifying Duvall Brothers
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi everyone, welcome to Crimes and Consequences.
- 0:40My name is Talia and this is my lovely co host, Tanya.
- 0:45Welcome back, everyone, Welcome back. We have a great story and we're
- 0:49thrilled to be on True Crime Daily. Thank you for everybody that has supported
- 0:54us. This story that we're getting into is a Michigan story. It's one
- 1:03that I dealt with actually, kind of on the peripheral of when I was
- 1:07working at the Attorney General's office a long time ago, ages ago, not
- 1:12that long. If you haven't done so already, subscribe, follow like us,
- 1:21join our patreonpatreon, dot com, slash tnt Crimes and can get many
- 1:26more episodes just like this. But with that said, are you ready for
- 1:32some true crime? I am. Let's get into it. This one.
- 1:36This one's bad, this one's rough, it's it's got some some nasty things.
- 1:44And it was a cold case, which I love cold cases. I
- 1:48love the cold cases are salt and it's solved. Yes, So let's get
- 1:52a spoiler alert. It's solved. This is about the terrifying Duval brothers,
- 2:00and I'm going to go through the whole family because it's pretty scary. There's
- 2:04seven of them. It's but the point, the focus of the story is
- 2:08about the victims. And I want to be clear. There were two David
- 2:14Till and Brian Adgen. These were two best friends. They met each other
- 2:22in fourth grade and they were close ever since. They lived in the Detroit
- 2:29area of Michigan. And so you have in Michigan. I don't know if
- 2:36a lot of people know this, but we have what's called deer hunting season.
- 2:40Oh yeah, it's very popular, very very popular. I mean people
- 2:46on average we get eight hundred thousand people coming over for deer hunting season.
- 2:53So in this case, it went cold for eighteen years as to what happened
- 3:00to David and Brian during the hunting season. And I'm gonna explain to you
- 3:07what happened, but I want to give you some background on them. So
- 3:15it takes place in November nineteen eighty five, and as I said, they
- 3:20met in fourth grade, they had this trip that they would do yearly with
- 3:27some family members and they would go up north because everybody goes up north.
- 3:30Michigan's a mitten and they would go like up north hunting, and up north
- 3:37is pretty much to me, anything north of Detroit, anything, yes,
- 3:40and they yeah. So David till he was a machinist, and he lived
- 3:46in Troy, Michigan, which is not far from where we are right now.
- 3:52And Brian Ogden Ogen, Brian Ogen, forgive me, I'm so horrible
- 4:00with names. I apologize. Agen. He lived in Saint Clair Shores,
- 4:05which isn't It's not that they're not that far from each other. And he
- 4:11was a mechanic. David got married when he was nineteen, and Brian was
- 4:16single, but he was dating a woman named Janice. And originally these two
- 4:23friends were going to go to a place called White Cloud, Michigan. They
- 4:28were going to go there. And for those that aren't familiar with Michigan,
- 4:36it's here, white Cloud's here. Let's go with it, okay, yeap
- 4:42wit. And that's a very touristy area. The western part of Michigan is
- 4:48very touristy because you have like Michigan and will love to go, you know,
- 4:53to the lakes and everything. And that's where David tills. He had
- 4:57a cabin and his family they had a cabin there too. He had a
- 5:00brother named Matt. They were going to meet up with Matt and David's dad
- 5:05and some friends. And what guys do is they just have a lot of
- 5:10drinks, a lot of haunting, and it's just like probably a lot of
- 5:15good food. I would think, guys time, I've never done. It's
- 5:18guy's time. It's guys time. So we're on the weekend of November twenty
- 5:24second, nineteen eighty five, David went to Brian's house to pick up Brian
- 5:32and they were going to drive together in David's Bronco. He got there around
- 5:38two o'clock and Brian was sleeping because Brian often worked nights, worked late,
- 5:46and so Brian wasn't awake. It took them a little bit of time to
- 5:50get ready and they were getting ready to go to White Cloud. But they
- 5:57had this mutual friend named Dennis, and Dennis he lived if you're looking at
- 6:02the Minten Okay, he lived on the other side of where white Cloud would
- 6:08be. And they decided they would meet up with Matt at David Hill's cabin,
- 6:15family cabin maybe the next day in White Cloud, but they were going
- 6:19to go to a place called Mile and meet their friend Dennis. And Dennis
- 6:27this is back in the day when there were no Google right anything. Yeah,
- 6:33and Dennis had written a map to get there and to give you a
- 6:40little idea of Mile. Mile has a population of two thousand people. Oh,
- 6:46very small, very very tiny. It's in Ascota County. It's got
- 6:51one stop light in the whole county and the whole county city. No,
- 6:56the whole county, county, entire county. Yes, it might know because
- 7:00I did this case. One stop like the whole county, so that tells
- 7:03you. And it's very beautiful, but it's not a touristy area. It's
- 7:11more it has more poverty because it's not the touristy area. I've never been
- 7:15there, but I've driven through it like past. It's it's very beautiful,
- 7:20but for some reason, the west side is where people end up going in
- 7:24Michigan. They actually leave about five o'clock. Right before they leave, David
- 7:30calls his brother and they don't have cell phones, keep in mind, and
- 7:36so he calls from Brian's house and he says, you know what, we
- 7:40might not make it there till Saturday, okay, And they decide to go
- 7:45see their friend Dennis. And when they went to do that, I should
- 7:51say this, Dennis didn't actually draw the map. A guy named David Jacob
- 7:57did. He made the map and he out a major highway. Oh no,
- 8:03he forgot to put in M thirty three. But somehow they made it
- 8:07to Mio and they found a bar called Walker's Bar and Bowling Alley, and
- 8:15they went and they had some drinks at Walker's Bowling Alley. They met somebody
- 8:20and there's a lot of David's So they met a guy named David Welch and
- 8:24we'll just call him Welch. And they asked David basically, hey, where
- 8:31is a place to have a good time around here? But they're in Mio.
- 8:37I mean it's like, yeah, that is probably the place the bowling
- 8:41at the bowling Alley. They wanted to maybe just hang out, party,
- 8:48flirt with women, you know, and mister Welch told him the bowling Alley
- 8:54is not the place to be. Oh no, there was a place down
- 8:58the road. And Brian went to the place down the road where David stayed
- 9:05and the place was called Northwood Gardens. And while Brian was there, he
- 9:09saw some ladies and he was flirting with them. This is according to the
- 9:15people that worked there. And he wrote something down on a piece of paper
- 9:20and handed it to a woman. We don't know what he wrote down,
- 9:24but she didn't like it. Oh no, yeah, and they got up
- 9:30and laughed, and Brian felt pretty jaded. So he went back to see
- 9:33David and mister Welch at the Walker's Bar and Bowling Alley. By that time,
- 9:41David Till was intoxicated. And that's okay, of course, I mean
- 9:48that's what they're up there for. That's okay, Yes, good guy,
- 9:52I am not judging him. And they're still trying to find their friend Dennis,
- 9:58like where does Dennis live? And they stopped someone they saw and they
- 10:07asked him, do you know Dennis because it's a small town. And the
- 10:11guy was like no, but he said, you'd have a better chance of
- 10:15finding him if your map wasn't upside down. Oh oh no, whoops,
- 10:20I've been there. Yeah. I'm horrible with directions. Actually, I mean
- 10:26terrible. I think that GPS was invented and now and I still get lost
- 10:31night occasionally. I mean, I'm bad. And he this guy did notice
- 10:35that they had an empty twelve pack of beer in the bronco, so they
- 10:41were drinking on the way and they're in mile, they're hanging out. No
- 10:48one knows what's on the note. They ended up being I mean, honestly,
- 10:52they end up getting ship faced. They laughed about the fact that the
- 10:56map was upside down. I mean, they are the boondocks. They ended
- 11:03up crashing somewhere I don't nowhere, But when it came Saturday morning, they
- 11:07were really hungover. Oh, really hungover. So they went back to the
- 11:13Bowling Alley and they kind of nursed their hangover at the bowling Alley and they
- 11:20made some jokes about how they felt like grab That was pretty close to the
- 11:26last sighting of them, but not completely. But that's one of the last
- 11:35times they interacted with people. They're nursing their hangover, and I think they're
- 11:41doing it. What's the name where you what is it hair of the dog
- 11:45or hair the hair of the dog. They ended up going to a place
- 11:50called Linkers, and they were at Linkers and some people accused them of grabbing
- 11:58girls, but her name was Barb. It was actually Brian that allegedly grabbed
- 12:05Barbes. But and then there was accusations that David Till while Barb was playing
- 12:13pool, rubbed up against her. I don't know if any of that is
- 12:18true, but I mean, she claimed she was leaning over the pool table
- 12:22playing pool and she didn't like how he was being so flirty. One of
- 12:28the workers at Linkers, it's called Linkers lost lap Lah, Linkers lost Ladge,
- 12:37And that's why we haven't said the whole the whole name. Her name
- 12:41was Cindy, and Cindy said they came in and that they were kind of
- 12:46being a bit obnoxious because they were intoxicated. At one point, David Till
- 12:54tried to pay the bill and Brian said to Cindy, if you let him
- 12:58pay the bill, I'm gonna smack you. But I'm sure he was just
- 13:03joking around. And that's pretty much one of the last recorded times they were
- 13:11seen. David Till's wife, Sunday Night, became really worried because they were
- 13:18supposed to be back. He had work on Monday, and he was always
- 13:24very punctional, punctual, and he didn't come back, and so she contacted
- 13:30the police the next morning on Monday. I mean, she was concerned and
- 13:33then she called the family and the family said, you know, they never
- 13:37made it Toy Cloud. Then I would be like, oh, oh right,
- 13:41oh something happened. Oh shit. And so they started searching for these
- 13:48guys. And when I say searching, they hired helicopters to look for them.
- 13:52They were concerned that maybe they never made it, maybe they had a
- 13:58car accident on the way, because they don't even know that they made it
- 14:01to Mile because they never found Dunnis. Oh that's right. They have no
- 14:05idea, you know, where they're at. And like I said, Matt's
- 14:13like, they never made it to White Cloud. Then their first assumption was
- 14:16a car accident. It's got to be a car accident because it's a lot
- 14:20of backroads, it's winter, it's November, and so that's what they thought.
- 14:31Eventually, with the help of friends and they contacted the police, they
- 14:39realized that they did make it to Mile. But you have to remember Mile
- 14:45and this whole area goes from having like two thousand people population to eight hundred
- 14:52thousand people coming in. So there's this influx of men. I mean,
- 14:58let's be honest, they're mostly men, and it was really hard to pinpoint
- 15:01exactly where Brian and David were. And there were a couple of people that
- 15:09thought they saw in there, but this case ended up being cold for eighteen
- 15:18years. They just vanished, disappeared. The bronco that David drove never was
- 15:26found. Let me tell you something I failed to mention to you about the
- 15:33town of Mile That is where the Devale brothers live. Scary scary Dvall brothers,
- 15:45and there's a lot of them. There's seven. So I'm going to
- 15:48go from what I described as the least offensive and kind of work our way
- 15:54up into the more interesting characters in the family. The Devall brothers were the
- 16:02proud offspring of Raymond Duvall and his wife Shirley. She went by Whorli.
- 16:10So there were seven Devall brothers and one daughter named Sissy. The youngest of
- 16:15the Dvall brothers, his name was Kenny. And let me give you a
- 16:19little insight into Kenny, because he's a baby of the family, right,
- 16:25you don't want to be the baby of the brother No. When Kenny was
- 16:29little, for fun, the Devall brothers tied him up with rope and hoisted
- 16:33him onto a tree and left him there just for shits and giggles, you
- 16:38know, Yeah, torture your younger brother, I guess is hilarious. He
- 16:42was arrested in nineteen eighty three for spousal abuse, stocking his wife, breaking
- 16:49and entering, and at the time he was smoking crack. Oh boy,
- 16:53Okay. He ended up getting clean in his defense, and he started a
- 17:00company called you call we Haul. Oh that's a great name, right,
- 17:07Yeah, and he enjoyed taking a power cars. Then there was Tommy.
- 17:12He also went by Worm. Do they all have nicknames? Pretty much?
- 17:18A lot of them? A lot of them do worm? And I don't
- 17:19want you to be confused later because there's another person with a nickname worm.
- 17:23Are you kidding me? Swarm the worm? Hey, it's popular nickname.
- 17:30Apparently. I don't have a lot of information on Tommy, and I don't
- 17:34really need a lot. It's fine. Next we have Frank. Frank was
- 17:40arrested and convicted for criminal sexual conduct. Oh no, in an incident with
- 17:45his friend's fifteen year old daughter. Yeah, criminal sexual conduct is underaged victims.
- 17:52Yeah, he was thirty two and he was an habitual offender. I
- 17:57don't know exactly where all his a enes were, but he had warns all
- 18:03over the place for him, and he once yelled out, all I did
- 18:07was transport the bodies. Oh that's all just you know. So that's Frank.
- 18:15Okay, Now we have Randy. Randy was able to scrap this is
- 18:22what he's known for six and a half cars from January first to May twenty
- 18:27third, like quickly. I don't know if it's scrap competition, I don't
- 18:33know. I just I don't know. If it's bragging rights, I don't
- 18:37know. But that was one of the things he was known for, being
- 18:41able to scrap a car really fast. Okay, Well, and he was
- 18:45seen driving a Bronco. Uh. Oh. He helped Kenny start a legitimate
- 18:52business, and so some of the Duval brothers moved to Monroe County. Oh
- 18:57that's Southlake Toledo border in Ohio border. Yeah. Yeah, yes, So
- 19:04you have some up here and then some down here trying to make legitimate life.
- 19:12I guess you got to get away from my Oh probably, I'm guessing
- 19:18Randy and Kenny ended up putting missing flyers for the hunters at their business.
- 19:25Okay, Okay, now we have Rex also known as Rexy. Oh Sexy,
- 19:30Rexy. No, no, no, no, Rexy had lots of
- 19:37pigs. Oh no, he had a favorite pig. He had a favorite
- 19:41pig, and he let that favorite pig stay in their house. Are we
- 19:47talking like little tiny pigs? Are we talking about talking about a pig?
- 19:52A pig. He had a a big, old farm pig. Okay,
- 19:56those pigs, they're they're huge. I don't know if you have you seen
- 19:57one in real life? Yes, a pig, A pig in real life.
- 20:03Girl. You know, some people don't get out to the country and
- 20:07they're huge. Okay, Okay, I had a favorite pig, and that
- 20:11pig was able to stay in his house and pretty much run things. Okay,
- 20:17I'm sorry, I'm sorry. Okay, he had the run of the
- 20:19house. It wasn't a little pig like on Green Acres, right, No,
- 20:26little little Arnold. I remember that show. So anyway, okay,
- 20:30we are digressing. Yeah, I'm sorry. Rex had a daughter and she
- 20:34shared some stories later about when her uncles would come over, they would go
- 20:42to the basement and she would hear chainsaws, and they would come back from
- 20:47the basement with five gallon buckets filled with red raw meat, and they would
- 20:52go feed their pigs because there were more pigs. Okay. Rex had a
- 20:57wife named Sharon, and they had an abandoned bus in their backyard. And
- 21:06do you know what they kept in the bus? No, thirteen pigs the
- 21:10bus. The pigs lived in the bus, yes, thirteen of them.
- 21:15Yes, Okay, buses aren't that big. Okay, Well, I don't
- 21:18know. I don't know. You can have how many kids? Yeah?
- 21:22But kids? Okay, you're right, I don't know. Maybe they cleared
- 21:26out. I am just reporting. Okay, you're allowing bus. Well,
- 21:30they got it. I don't know what they're living. Okay, we just
- 21:33moved on. That was a rhetorical question. I'm sorry, I'm really I'm
- 21:37really like stuck on these pigs. Okay, anyway, back to the story.
- 21:41We're pretty sure Rex had something to do with the disappearance of the Hunters,
- 21:48just so you know. But Rex died when he passed away in twenty
- 21:55twelve. Okay, I have his obituary. Oh all right, let's hear
- 21:59it. He was an avid outdoorsman who appreciated his vacation time. Who doesn't,
- 22:04girl, I love my vacation time. I think he was unemployed,
- 22:08I'm not trying to be rude, but his whole vacation a perpetrator in this
- 22:15case. And yes, he liked horseshoes, fishing, boating, hunting,
- 22:19turtle trapping, and NASCAR. That's it. And then in their obituary they
- 22:30wrote that he was a bit bullheaded at times. He must have been real
- 22:37stubborn. Please don't write that on my obituary. Just say nice things.
- 22:41You don't have to be honest. I think obituary should be honest. Really,
- 22:48yes, she was a bit sometimes she was a real pain in the
- 22:51ass. Well, you know, if they're writing he was a bit bullheaded,
- 22:53he was a lot. He was very bullheaded. Right, So who
- 23:00raised these wonderful boys? Well we'll get to that, but I do have
- 23:06to mention another particular boy, Jr. When Jr. Was thirteen, you
- 23:14know, he's his dad's namesake, Raymond Raymond. Oh, I get it,
- 23:18JR. It's kind of sad. He saw his dad beating early oh,
- 23:29and he was beating the shit out of Whirly. So he grabbed a
- 23:33gun twenty two and he shot his dad at thirteen. Wow. Both his
- 23:40dad and mom had to go to the hospital and they both survived and then
- 23:44he didn't get in trouble because the police said it was its self defense.
- 23:48And it kind of was a joke in the family about Raymond Senior beating Worly.
- 23:55In fact, one of the jokes made was that two of her boys
- 23:59were born with black eyes. Oh, that's hilarious. That's horrible. Yes,
- 24:03it's horrible. It's horrible. That just gives you like an idea of
- 24:08what this family is like, right, And that was kind of a trend
- 24:11with all the brothers. They enjoyed beating up women. So I'm gonna talk
- 24:18to you a little bit, a little bit about j R. Raymond Junior.
- 24:22He was born November eleventh, nineteen fifty. He got married as a
- 24:26teenager and he went to Vietnam and he served our country. He was part
- 24:32of the military police. He had a string of failed marriages and need a
- 24:38bunch of different kids. One he named Doobie. No, No, I
- 24:47love Saint Doobey. You know, I do like St. Doobey. Yeah,
- 24:51Doobie, Okay, And then he had Tom. Doobey was later interviewed
- 25:00an investigation to see what he might know and you know, any involvement with
- 25:06what happened with the Hunters. He was only seventeen when he was interviewed,
- 25:12and he was in the County Youth Home being held for criminal sexual assault along
- 25:18with other ties. Wonderful. And in nineteen ninety eight he became a homicide
- 25:26suspect. There was a body found on the railroad tracks in Monroe. And
- 25:33as I told you, the Duval brothers, they hang out in Monroe County
- 25:38and then they're in Mio. A man was put on his body was put
- 25:45on the railroad tracks and they tried first thought it was suicide, but then
- 25:53it appeared to be murder linked to do be. Doobie talked about his violent
- 26:02childhood and how he was raped by some male relatives. No, which is
- 26:07sad. Yeah, that's terrible. When he was eleven, he started doing
- 26:11drugs probably yeah, to deal with the trauma, right, And he said,
- 26:19basically, my family is straight out of a movie. And do you
- 26:26know what movie? He described? I have a guess what deliverance? Yes?
- 26:33Yes, yeah? Did yikes? He did. That's very scary.
- 26:37So Doobie was jr. Son and I haven't completely gotten into JR. And
- 26:44then he has a son, Tom. Tom would strangle and beat his girlfriend
- 26:51and one time Tom he went by. Tommy thought his girlfriend was getting out
- 26:56of control. In nineteen ninety seven, and now remember this already took place
- 27:00in nineteen eighty five. He told his dad, you know, go ahead
- 27:06and tell my girlfriend what we do to women. And his dad said,
- 27:11we've killed before and we'll kill again. Oh wow, terrifying. Yeah.
- 27:18Jr. Had a girlfriend, her name was Eileen, for ten years and
- 27:23they had two children. They lived on a dirt road in a shack with
- 27:29a dirt floor. Wow, in nineteen eighty five. And it's it's sad
- 27:37because it was basically a hut and it got really cold and they would talk
- 27:41about how cold it was. I mean, in all the information, and
- 27:45I got a lot of my information from this book called Darker That Darker than
- 27:49Night by Tom Henderson. He is a local writer and he wrote a great
- 27:55book on this. Jr's girl friend, Eileen and him were together for like
- 28:02I said, almost ten years, and he would beat her all the time.
- 28:07Eileen was with him when the Hunters died and she moved out on her
- 28:15own. Eventually she's like, I'm out and she married a guy named Nelson
- 28:22Boltzman. Okay, Eileen didn't do much better with Nelson. Nelson ended up
- 28:34being charged with her murder. Oh. No, in nineteen eighty five.
- 28:40Wow, he was charged in Mcomb County, oh which is where we lived.
- 28:45Yes, And he wrote a letter to the Macomb County prosecutor. And
- 28:48in his letter he stated that he was wrongly convicted and that she was murdered
- 28:56by the Deval brothers because she knew too much about the unsolved disappearance of David
- 29:02and Brian. Oh, and that she was murdered because of that information.
- 29:07And everybody agrees that Eileen probably had a lot of information, but they don't
- 29:15agree that the Duval brothers killed her. And let me tell you why.
- 29:21Well, they were probably people you could easily pin a murder on, right.
- 29:26I mean, they don't sound like they're angels by any means, and
- 29:30so it was probably easy for him to be like, it wasn't me.
- 29:33Well, I got the court case for Nelson, his murder case, and
- 29:38here's some evidence to show you kind of why he he did it. They
- 29:47were on a canoe trip, Nelson was with Eileen. Witnesses saw them arguing
- 29:53in the pickup truck. The next morning, her body was found on the
- 29:59road one block from the home that they'd been staying at. They were staying
- 30:03at like a friend's house. She was beaten to strangled with Nelson's shirt wrapped
- 30:11around her neck, and he was found sleeping passed out drunk one hundred yards
- 30:17away in his truck from her body. So they were not at their house
- 30:22usually right, they were off on a canoe trip. So the Deval brothers
- 30:26supposedly tracked her down on this canoe trip, yes, and strangled and somehow
- 30:30got Shelson's yes okay. And he had threatened earlier that day to kill her,
- 30:37and he had a history of choking and beating her, and only a
- 30:41few hours before her death, in front of other people, he said he
- 30:45was going to kill her. I mean, you can judge for yourself.
- 30:49Yeah, but he's in jail prison. So let's go back to when Jr.
- 30:56Was with Eileen. They had some between six and thirteen pigs. Okay,
- 31:03I don't get hung up on them. I'm not. I'm past it.
- 31:06Ti is an alcoholic. He had lots of outstanding warns for his arrest,
- 31:11and he didn't have a page child sport. He had some DUIs.
- 31:17There's this very interesting story about JR. He was part of a motorcycle gang.
- 31:22Interesting. I don't only know how I'm gonna say it all and be
- 31:29great, but be YouTube friendly, okay, okay, Yes, So he
- 31:33hung out with these motorcycle buddies and on a dare he ate pig shit okay,
- 31:44And he never denied that, just kind of dare, like not even
- 31:47for money. I mean, not that I would do it, but I'm
- 31:49just saying, okay, go ahead. It's also believed that he kissed pigs
- 31:55genitals for five dollars. Oh well, at least he made money there,
- 32:00stop it, sorry, and eventually not to go to forward. But there's
- 32:06testimony from another brother who said, my brother had a pet pig and it
- 32:13came in and now and did whatever it wanted to do, more or less,
- 32:17and it backed its ass up against a wood stove and it burned its
- 32:24privates. That's not the word he used, and that was a direct quote
- 32:30from court testimony. JR. Spoke about it in court and he said he
- 32:38passed out near the pig pen and when he woke up, the pig's private
- 32:44parts were in his face. But others have said that for five dollars he
- 32:51kissed the pig's private parts, and he was teased about it all the time.
- 32:59Yeah, sounds it's a gatty great story. So I've left out one
- 33:04brother, Coco. Coco. His name was Donald. You want to say
- 33:08what's but he went by Coco. Okay. Nineteen fifty two he was born.
- 33:13He got married to a woman named Georgia. The first year they were
- 33:16married, he broke her jaw, wow, and he broke her nose.
- 33:22And when he was asked later on how he made a living, he said,
- 33:27firewood and welfare. Oh. Perfect. He got divorced in nineteen seventy
- 33:31six, and he got to keep the dogs, the pigs, and the
- 33:35chickens, and he had cows running around in his backyard. He was an
- 33:40alcoholic, but he did not do drugs. Uh. There's a story of
- 33:46Coco and Jr. Oh, I can't wait for this. One time they
- 33:52went to a party and they decided at the party to fight each other for
- 33:59fun. Okay, I'm gonna beat the shit out of my brother for fun,
- 34:02for fun. During the fight, Coco breaks Jr's nose and blood squirts
- 34:10everywhere. JR. Says, time out, time out, time out.
- 34:14We need to reschedule this for tomorrow. Reschedule My nose is all fucked up.
- 34:21Sure, that's how the events were described. Coco says, okay,
- 34:24tomorrow at noon, high noon. They've got it. So they get there
- 34:30and j R. Says, okay, there's just one rule. You can't
- 34:35punch me in the nose, okay, because you just broke it. So
- 34:39where's the first place he punches him? Go punches him, of course and
- 34:45none. No, of course, you want to win the fight, don't
- 34:46you. You got to take out your opponent's weakness. I mean, you
- 34:52should have just never said anything. So every fourth of July, the the
- 34:57balls would have a Fourth of July pig ro You know, they have beer
- 35:02and guns and they kill a pig and there'd be lots of fireworks. In
- 35:08fact, some people blew off fingers. Oh are you surprised? But at
- 35:15one time it ended up there wasn't going to be enough meat. And this
- 35:19is a true story. The whole ass pig and there's not enough meat.
- 35:22I don't know. But they get a lot of friends. I don't know,
- 35:24So Rex Jr. And Rex's mom worly they get into a jeep and
- 35:31they're driving around and they spot a neighbor's cow. Don't tell me. They
- 35:38stopped the truck. They shoot the cow in the head, and then Jr.
- 35:44Took a chainsaw what right then and there and cut the cow in half
- 35:50on the field, and then they loaded it up and brought it back to
- 35:53the party. Wow. If I was the neighbor, that's a true story.
- 36:00Damn. The Devals had a really close friend named Schwarm. Sherm,
- 36:06Oh, this is sher the Worm. Sure the worm, Yes, and
- 36:08he was a very scary guy too. A man named David Henry Johnson told
- 36:15investigators that one time Schwarm the Worm was in a store and David Henry Johnson's
- 36:22wife was there. Her name was Kimberly, and he pushed her up against
- 36:27the wall and started mumbling something about killing pigs at it's just at a grocery
- 36:34store. Yeah, and then he put his hands on her and said he
- 36:37could rape her whenever he wanted, and there was nothing she could do about
- 36:40it. David Henry Johnson confront and Shehrmed the worm and that's when Sherm the
- 36:49Worm said, you know I can feed you to the pigs. Oh no.
- 36:53So a woman named Connie Sandberg dated Cocoa for nine years, madam,
- 37:00when she's sixteen, he's twenty seven. She told the story about how they
- 37:06had broken up once and she was on a date with a local sheriff,
- 37:09the a deputy's son, and when the deputy's son went to pick her up,
- 37:15the Deval brothers showed up and kicked his ass with metal pipes. Oh
- 37:21oh damn. These guys do not mess around. And nobody did anything about
- 37:24it because everybody, everybody was afraid of the Dwal brothers. Well they sound
- 37:30crazy. In Monroe, they silent. They were considered the Monroe mafia.
- 37:36What okay that means? I get it. Connie once told the story of
- 37:42a time when Coco got really shit faced, which short sh shirm the worm
- 37:49and Jr. They threw him out of the door of the truck and he
- 37:52landed in the dirt and he passed out in the dirt, and when he
- 37:55woke up, she was there and he mumbled something about out how he killed
- 38:00someone, and she said what, And then he said the next day.
- 38:07The next day she asked him about it and he strangled her. So and
- 38:12Mourner, don't ever fucking ask me about it again. And she didn't can't
- 38:20blame her j R. He'd been with lots of different women. He was
- 38:24with a woman named Donna and she was pregnant with his baby. He would
- 38:30later beat her and then on labor day he dragged her around her mobile home
- 38:35by her hair. So she left him. Good for her, Yeah,
- 38:40but before she left it, she heard him talking to somebody about pigs and
- 38:46people and hunters being missing, and she made a joke about how could you
- 38:53feed someone to a pig. Pigs don't eat skulls, they don't. Well,
- 39:01I mean, I looked it up. I'll tell you. Okay.
- 39:05He beat her up, punched her, and said he was going to feed
- 39:07hurt to the pigs. So a lot of people are scared. These Duval
- 39:14brothers are talking about pigs. Blah blah blah. One of the investigators actually
- 39:20reached out in this case to Michigan State University swine expert to find out if
- 39:24it's possible for pigs to actually eat humans. The expert said that you would
- 39:32need five or six pigs to be hungry for a few days, and then
- 39:37they would probably eat a person in about three or four days. Oh wow,
- 39:44unlike what we think about pigs and how they'll just need anything NonStop.
- 39:49They actually do stop. And he said eventually about seventy two hours after eating
- 39:55a human, they would excrete everything that they eight. This investigator his name
- 40:02was Bronco Leneski. So we have a Bronco vehicle and we have Bronco Leneski
- 40:09and he is actually the hero of this story. He worked for the state
- 40:15police and on his spare time, because this is a cold case, very
- 40:20cold case, on a spare time, he would investigate the case, asking
- 40:24questions, stirring things up. He would knock go door to door and finally
- 40:31he got a tip from someone who called in and said he needed to talk
- 40:37to a woman named Barb. But he didn't Barbe's address, so he went
- 40:44door to door. Well, I mean, there's two thousand people door to
- 40:49door knocking trying to find Barb. It took some time, but eventually he
- 40:53knocked on a door and said are you Barb? And the woman cracked it
- 40:58open and said, you're going to get me killed. And she tried to
- 41:04shut the door, but he kind of put its foot in and so he
- 41:09came inside and eventually she bean talking to him about what she knew about the
- 41:15hunters. She described. What she described ended up later out later on matching
- 41:25what the Duval brothers shared in nineteen eighty six in Wickham, Michigan, at
- 41:32a dinner with the Duval family find dinner conversation and friends. It took fifteen
- 41:39years for Barb to come forward officially and discuss what happened. She was too
- 41:51afraid to go on the record. I mean during that fifteen years, one
- 41:55of her dogs got ran over by the a Duval brother another one was shot
- 42:00in her front yard by Devall brother. She ran into the Devall brothers once
- 42:07and they said, we know your granddaughters and they're real pretty oh, in
- 42:13a threatening manner. Yeah. There was one hundred thousand dollars reward out there
- 42:19for information leading to the you know, finding Brian and David, and Bronco
- 42:29said Barb, now there's a one hundred thousand because she's telling him things off
- 42:32the record. And she said the money is no good if I'm dead.
- 42:37Good point, mm hmm. But eventually, after seventeen years, she agreed
- 42:44to testify against the Daval brothers. She was probably scared shitless, right,
- 42:50and this is what she said in court happened she was at Linker's Bar.
- 42:55She was there with her friend, Ronnie Emery, who was celebrating his first
- 43:00legal kill of a buck deer. Okay, and just so you know,
- 43:07Ronnie is now dead. He was an alcoholic and he died by getting so
- 43:10drunk he passed out on the road and someone ran over his head. Oh
- 43:15no, Barr believes he was murdered, but we'll never know. We'll never
- 43:21know. So on the night of the murders, Connie, who is Coco's
- 43:25girlfriend, was dancing at the bar Linkers, and a tiff began between the
- 43:31Deval brothers and Brian and David. Now Ronnie, Barb's friend knew when the
- 43:39Devall brothers are angry, shots back, so he called the police. And
- 43:47coincidentally, Barb was dating the police officer. And there's probably two a mile
- 43:53I'm guessing, yeah, And he never showed up. He said he didn't
- 44:00want to get involved with the bar fight that night, the police officer,
- 44:05so he didn't show up. Okay, No, it'll sort itself out,
- 44:08right. I guess Barb had been drinking a lot that night. She had
- 44:14at least nine salty dogs. I don't know what that is, but Okay,
- 44:19I don't know. It doesn't sound good and bloody Mary's Oh. While
- 44:23she was at Linkers, she was sitting on a chair and there's a payphone
- 44:28next to her and she overhears Jr. On the phone speaking with someone saying,
- 44:34I'm gonna need your help. About forty five minutes later, Schworm Firm
- 44:40Firm. The Worm showed up with someone else. I think it was Rex,
- 44:46but I'm not for sure. They gave Bob. They gave Barb a
- 44:52six pack of beer and told her she'd better get the hell out of there.
- 44:57Bob, Barb, and Ronnie left. They went back to Barb's house
- 45:00and it was about a mile away. They sat in Barb's living room and
- 45:06they drank the beer and they watched Scarface. On a side note, Barb
- 45:12has watched Scarface over two hundred times. Wow, it's a side note about
- 45:15Barb. Wow. So they're watching this and they hear some sounds and Barb
- 45:22opens the kids her kitchen window and the sounds you can hear more, And
- 45:28Ronnie says, oh, I bet the hunters are getting their ass beat.
- 45:32So the two go out the front door. They want to oh, yeah,
- 45:37check it out. There has nothing to do in this town, so
- 45:38I'm sure watching a fight is interesting. When they go out the front door,
- 45:44there's a strange car there, and I believe it's one of the brother's
- 45:51cars. It's a car there, and so they go back inside. They
- 45:54go out the back door and they walk down about a quarter mile down this
- 45:59path and there's a clearing. When they get to the clearing, they see
- 46:04the Bronco and its lights are on and David Till is on his knees being
- 46:12hit with a baseball bat. Oh no, he's trying to stand. He's
- 46:17urinated himself and he's crying, please someone help, please stop. At the
- 46:27same time, you have Brian being held by some men. The next thing
- 46:35Barb sees is Coco swing a bat to David's head, and she described it
- 46:43as exploding or disappearing. Oh no, oh, that's brutal. And the
- 46:51Devale brothers told many people that they hit a man on the head and his
- 46:57head split like a water moon. I'm sorry, this is really gruesome and
- 47:01it's very upsetting. All this time, Brian is, Oh, he's watching
- 47:07his friends best friend, childhood best friend. They've known each other forever,
- 47:13fourth grade. Brian manages to escape. He does, but the Ball Brothers
- 47:19caught up with him, dragged him back. They beat him. They beat
- 47:23him even when he wasn't moving anymore. Barb and Ronnie take off down the
- 47:30path and they go back to Barb's house. About five minutes later, there's
- 47:35a knock on their door. Oh, it was the Ball brothers and they
- 47:38said, quote, we know, we know you, we know where you
- 47:43live. And pigs got to eat too. That is terrifying, terrifying.
- 47:50Is this fucking horrible? Yeah, this is so. The Attorney General's office
- 47:57in two thousand and two had taken on this case and I worked there at
- 48:01the time. It was a huge breakthrough and they decided to go ahead and
- 48:09prosecute. Even though they had nobody, no DNA, never found the Bronco,
- 48:19they still went ahead and did it. It just had circumstantial evidence right
- 48:23based on mostly yeah testy, basically good Barb. Donna Panograss was the one
- 48:31that actually prosecuted it, and she's an amazing She was an amazing assistant in
- 48:37Attorney General. It took the jury only thirty minutes to find them guilty and
- 48:44sentence them to life. So what Donna Penograss believes happened is after the murder,
- 48:52the men were put in the bronco and then they were put through a
- 48:58wood chipper, Oh my god, and then they were fed to the pigs.
- 49:07And you know, I did tell you that the brothers are really good
- 49:12at taking apart cars and had scrap bats, right scrapyards. That makes sense
- 49:20that it that the bronco disappeared. And so that is the sad story of
- 49:29David Till and Brian ogin Ougen. That is terrible. A wood chipper.
- 49:38Oh, you know, we do these stories. I mean we're an episode
- 49:44like two hundred and one billion, yeah something, and we have just almost
- 49:49just as money in our Patreon And I'm not like, I'm still amazed and
- 49:55shocked and horrified. I just or what for flirting? M A little obnoxious
- 50:05flirting maybe, I mean. The prosecutors believe that the Duval brothers were very
- 50:12aggressive at first with David and Brian, but then lured them out with marijuana.
- 50:20Okay, because David and Brian had been asking people if you know where
- 50:23any marijuana is, and then the Daval brothers were heard trying to get some
- 50:30marijuana. So they believe that they probably faked being nice and lured them smoke
- 50:36weed and that's how they got them there. I see that. That makes
- 50:39a lot of sense. It's a really sad case. They're still alive and
- 50:45in prison, and a lot of the Deval family is in prison and even
- 50:52for other crimes, for other crimes, and even one of the females was
- 50:58in is imprisoned for murder. Oh wow, crazy. The story is just
- 51:07awful. I'm glad it was solved. I mean for the family, right,
- 51:12Like, yeah, I'm sure my heart goes out to the families because
- 51:16this is just a horrible yeah story and have your loved ones die that way
- 51:22for nothing but to just be with a rumman. And these men got away
- 51:28with telling everybody. Hey, you're telling everybody for eighteen years and people to
- 51:31the pigs. Yeah, well that was horrible. Thanks to Leah. I
- 51:37want to thank everybody for taking the time to listen to us, listen to
- 51:43the story. If you haven't done so already, please hit the subscribes follow
- 51:47like Latin. You can go to our website Crimes and Consequences dot com.
- 51:53We have merchandise there. You can join us and Patreon at Patreon dot com.
- 51:59Slash t and T Crimes or on Apple podcasts and become members where we
- 52:04release episodes that aren't on True Crime Daily and they're ad free and what else.
- 52:15That's it. I think that's it. So I think you covered most
- 52:16everything, and I'm sorry for the family. Yeah, my heart goes out
- 52:22to them. So until our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye bye,