Latest / Trojan Talks / Ep. 2: President Beong-Soo Kim with Jonathan Haidt
Transcript
- 0:00And what I'm coming to realize
- 0:01is that if you grew up in a minefield — suppose
- 0:03you were raised literally in a minefield,
- 0:05littered mines all over the place
- 0:06— you'd be pretty careful
- 0:08where you walk.
- 0:13Welcome to Trojan Talks.
- 0:14I'm Beong Kim,
- 0:15Interim President of USC.
- 0:17And this podcast is the space
- 0:19for open conversation
- 0:20with thought leaders both inside
- 0:22and beyond USC
- 0:23as we explore the ideas
- 0:25shaping USC's future.
- 0:26Today, I am absolutely delighted
- 0:28to welcome Jonathan Haidt,
- 0:30the renowned social psychologist
- 0:31and bestselling author
- 0:33of a number of important books
- 0:34that I've learned a lot from,
- 0:36including The Righteous Mind,
- 0:37The Coddling of the American Mind
- 0:39and The Anxious Generation.
- 0:41Jonathan, thank you so much for being here.
- 0:42My pleasure, Beong.
- 0:44In The Anxious Generation,
- 0:46you talk about
- 0:48the way that social media
- 0:49and cellphones
- 0:51have rewired adolescent brains,
- 0:53and there's a chapter in the book
- 0:55about what schools can do about this,
- 0:57in particular K through 12 schools.
- 1:00I wanted to ask you,
- 1:01what can universities
- 1:03do about this problem?
- 1:05And is it too late by the time they reach us?
- 1:07Yeah.
- 1:08Well, first let me just say,
- 1:10I'm here
- 1:10with you, in part, because I'm here for parents
- 1:12weekend, and I love being ...
- 1:13I really feel like I'm now part of the Trojan Family.
- 1:16This is an amazing university that really has just such
- 1:18intense alumni and, and creates such a community.
- 1:21So I'm really grateful to now be part of it.
- 1:23Grateful that my son is here.
- 1:26In terms of what universities can do.
- 1:28Yeah, I'm thinking about that a lot.
- 1:30Each of my four books
- 1:32actually has lessons that I think can be applied.
- 1:34So the first, my first book,
- 1:36The Happiness Hypothesis,
- 1:38the conclusion of the book is that happiness
- 1:40doesn't come from
- 1:41getting what you want.
- 1:42It doesn't come from within entirely.
- 1:44It comes from between.
- 1:45It comes from getting the right kind
- 1:47of embeddedness
- 1:48between yourself and others, yourself
- 1:50and some sort of productive work,
- 1:52and yourself in something
- 1:52larger than yourself.
- 1:54And when students are coming to campus,
- 1:57it used to be, you know,
- 1:58they had more experience.
- 1:59They were more socially skilled.
- 2:01They hadn't been as isolated.
- 2:02And especially we had in COVID
- 2:05affecting so
- 2:06much of their development.
- 2:08So anything that universities
- 2:09can do to ease that trend,
- 2:11to get them embedded in the right way.
- 2:13And it doesn't mean like, you know,
- 2:14go out and do, you know,
- 2:16some volunteer work somewhere else.
- 2:17It's like, what are the ongoing
- 2:19relationships?
- 2:20So embeddedness.
- 2:23My second book, The Righteous Mind,
- 2:25was about moral psychology in the culture war,
- 2:27and this was written in 2011, 2012.
- 2:30And it's so much worse now.
- 2:31And, and the hostilities are ripping apart
- 2:34our country, our universities.
- 2:36So I think universities can do a lot
- 2:38to prepare,
- 2:40to prepare students to be in
- 2:42a politically diverse environment
- 2:43and to profit from it, to thrive in it,
- 2:46rather than getting upset
- 2:47and switching out of, like, learning
- 2:50mode and into activist mode.
- 2:53My third book,
- 2:53The Coddling of the American Mind,
- 2:55was exactly about these changes that happened on campus
- 2:58around 2014 as Gen Z arrived
- 3:01and I hope we’ll come back and revisit,
- 3:02this is a big topic, but,
- 3:03you know, anti-fragility, just,
- 3:06helping students have to do hard ...
- 3:08Young people have to do hard things
- 3:09in order to grow up,
- 3:10in order to get strong.
- 3:12And so there's so much we can do
- 3:13to not continue the overprotection,
- 3:16but instead
- 3:17frame it
- 3:18as a series of challenges where we're there to help them.
- 3:20But the whole point of this is for you
- 3:22to accept these challenges
- 3:23and do hard things and grow.
- 3:26And then my most recent book,
- 3:27The Anxious Generation,
- 3:29what I'm coming to see, I teach a course
- 3:31at NYU called “Flourishing.”
- 3:34And what I'm coming to see is
- 3:36if you don't
- 3:37help them get control
- 3:38of their digital habits,
- 3:40there's not much else you can do.
- 3:42You have to start there.
- 3:43So ...
- 3:45OK, that was maybe too much
- 3:47my first answer for you, but that's ...
- 3:48Those are some of my thoughts.
- 3:49But on the last point,
- 3:50Jonathan, Jon, isn't it too
- 3:52late, by the time
- 3:53they get to universities,
- 3:54to try to change their social media or cellphone habits?
- 3:58Definitely not. No. Definitely not.
- 4:00So a couple of things.
- 4:01First, so in the book, it's true,
- 4:03I do talk about a sensitive period for culture development
- 4:05from around age 8
- 4:07or 9 through about 15, 16.
- 4:09And there's some evidence that
- 4:12the things you do then —
- 4:13that's a period of very, very rapid
- 4:14brain development.
- 4:15You know, neurons are myelinating, finding each other.
- 4:17You sort of locking down at the adult pattern.
- 4:20So it is true that the most important
- 4:21time is, is really,
- 4:23you know, middle school and early high school.
- 4:25That's the real heart of the sensitive period.
- 4:27But the prefrontal cortex doesn't finish
- 4:30myelinating, locking down,
- 4:32until around age 25.
- 4:34So just neurologically
- 4:35speaking, yeah, it would have been better earlier.
- 4:38But there's still a lot we can do.
- 4:40And I can add on to that.
- 4:41Now that I've been teaching this course,
- 4:43I've been teaching a version of it
- 4:44for about 12 years to MBA students.
- 4:47But I developed
- 4:48an undergrad version two or three years ago.
- 4:49I've taught it four times now.
- 4:50And what I can tell you is,
- 4:53you know,
- 4:54every single one of the students, when I ask them, you know,
- 4:56what are your digital habits, what are the hours, what are you on?
- 4:58And then do you endorse your habits,
- 5:01or do you want to change them a little,
- 5:02or you want to change them a lot?
- 5:03Not a single student endorses their habits.
- 5:05Not one.
- 5:06Half of them say
- 5:07they want to change, they recognize things to be better.
- 5:09They want to make it a little better.
- 5:10And then half say, I want to make major changes.
- 5:12So Gen Z, they know what the problems are.
- 5:14They're not in denial.
- 5:14They don't love this stuff.
- 5:15They just feel trapped.
- 5:17And what we do in the class is
- 5:20I help them get control.
- 5:21Simple things like start by just turning off
- 5:24notifications for almost everything, especially Gmail.
- 5:26Don't get a notification every time you get an email.
- 5:30Take,
- 5:30take your social media platforms.
- 5:31Take at least one of them off of your phone.
- 5:33Just check it on your computer.
- 5:34There's all kinds of steps
- 5:35you can take, and as they free up,
- 5:38as they start spending,
- 5:39you know, not five or seven hours a day,
- 5:42but as it gets down to just two or three,
- 5:43they discover, oh,
- 5:44you know, wow, I have more time.
- 5:46I can do my homework.
- 5:46I'm less stressed.
- 5:48So I've seen amazing transformations
- 5:50in these 19-, 20-year-old students.
- 5:52So here's a pedagogical question.
- 5:54Do you allow laptops in your class?
- 5:56No, this is very important.
- 5:57Any, OK, I’m going to look right in the camera.
- 5:59If any professors out there watching this,
- 6:01I strongly, strongly recommend
- 6:03that you do
- 6:04a no-devices policy at all.
- 6:07And here's why: I, you know,
- 6:09I think with my computer,
- 6:11I'm always taking notes.
- 6:12And for years I would say
- 6:14to my students,
- 6:15OK, you know,
- 6:16everyone's distracted, but you can use your computer, take notes,
- 6:18if you solemnly swear
- 6:21that you will only use it for, you know,
- 6:22and I did that for many years.
- 6:23And then the TA would tell me, like,
- 6:25they're all, you know, they're texting,
- 6:27they're on social media, they're day
- 6:28trading due to the MBA students.
- 6:31And so now
- 6:32we have an absolute no-devices policy,
- 6:33and a lot of professors are doing it
- 6:35and the students prefer it.
- 6:36Obviously there's some classes where you can’t,
- 6:38but the default
- 6:39and something that I was urging
- 6:41President Mills to consider,
- 6:43and I think every president should consider, is
- 6:45obviously you can't tell the faculty like you can't, but,
- 6:48but this is all a game of setting norms.
- 6:51That's really the key to,
- 6:52to breaking out of this.
- 6:53And who sets norms?
- 6:54The leadership has responsibility for the culture.
- 6:56So if you, you know, or
- 6:58any university president
- 6:59were to say, you know, here's the problem.
- 7:01We're all wrestling with this.
- 7:03You know, we've, we've had faculty, we convened
- 7:05and we've decided to recommend that
- 7:06all classes be screen free by default.
- 7:10But, you know,
- 7:10if you, if you have a need for it.
- 7:12Of course, of course.
- 7:14I was speaking to a business school
- 7:16professor here who actually goes one step further.
- 7:18Not only does he ban
- 7:20laptops and cellphones,
- 7:22but he actually doesn't even want
- 7:25the students to be taking notes
- 7:27because he wants them
- 7:28in this discussion class
- 7:29that he has,
- 7:30to be able to speak directly to each other,
- 7:32make eye contact,
- 7:34and really engage and listen fully.
- 7:36It's just interesting. Right.
- 7:38Depending on what the class is,
- 7:40I can totally see it because, right,
- 7:41because the issue here is presence.
- 7:44You know, for literally thousands of years,
- 7:46the advice of the ancients
- 7:48was sort of be here now, like, be present.
- 7:49Don't, you know, the mind is always
- 7:51jumping around, you know?
- 7:52Buddhism,
- 7:53you know, teaches ways
- 7:55to control your thinking.
- 7:56So being fully present, what we're doing,
- 7:58has always been an issue.
- 7:59And as soon as students
- 8:01got phones in their pockets, boom.
- 8:03Like it's hard for them to be present anywhere.
- 8:06It's for us, too.
- 8:07So I think that's a really cool idea
- 8:09to try a class
- 8:10where you have to be totally present
- 8:12socially and eye contact.
- 8:14I may try that.
- 8:16Going back to one
- 8:16of the things you talked about, Jon, with respect
- 8:18to embeddedness from your first book.
- 8:21I am particularly proud
- 8:23that at USC, our mission statement
- 8:25actually talks a lot about
- 8:26not just intellectual
- 8:27and academic development,
- 8:29but also development in wisdom
- 8:31and moral discernment.
- 8:33And it talks a lot about community.
- 8:35We call it here at USC,
- 8:36our Trojan Family.
- 8:37And I wanted to just ask you
- 8:40for your thoughts about
- 8:41whether there are opportunities
- 8:42for universities to provide
- 8:44even more of that kind
- 8:45of social connectivity and embeddedness, as you put it.
- 8:48Absolutely.
- 8:49And I'm glad you have both
- 8:50the moral discernment and the family,
- 8:53because they're actually really, really complementary.
- 8:55When you walk around
- 8:56our oldest universities,
- 8:58you see written in stone
- 9:00all kinds of moral advice.
- 9:04You know, over the
- 9:04gates at Harvard, I can't remember
- 9:05the quote, but,
- 9:06you know, you know,
- 9:07at UVA, Jefferson's
- 9:08words were all over.
- 9:10Everybody understood until the 1970s,
- 9:12everybody understood
- 9:14that part of the task
- 9:15of raising a child and educating them ...
- 9:17It's not just teaching them facts and skills.
- 9:20You have to teach them character and,
- 9:21and what is important.
- 9:23I would even go so far
- 9:24as to say what is sacred in this institution.
- 9:27Institutions need something sacred in the middle
- 9:29that they, that they circle around.
- 9:31And for us, I believe it's the pursuit of truth.
- 9:32It's a noble enterprise.
- 9:34It's a hard enterprise.
- 9:35We’re the specialists, we’re the high priests,
- 9:36like we need to treat truth
- 9:38as this sacred value.
- 9:40And,
- 9:42in the ’70s,
- 9:42there was an, a movement to like, get rid of,
- 9:44you know, preaching morality
- 9:46and get morality out of the schools.
- 9:47And how dare you teach my kids your morality.
- 9:49We have a lot of diversity now,
- 9:51and that would have been
- 9:52OK if kids were embedded in thick,
- 9:54rich moral cultures outside of school.
- 9:56But so much of the last 50 years
- 9:59has been the dissolution of social
- 10:00capital, trust, institutions.
- 10:04As more and more of life moves
- 10:06originally into the living room,
- 10:08watching TV
- 10:09with maybe a couple of people,
- 10:10and now alone, consuming content.
- 10:13So anything that embeds us or connects us
- 10:16and puts us in a, in a coherent
- 10:17moral world is just disappearing.
- 10:20And this, I believe, is why
- 10:22we get, I'll tell you the saddest
- 10:23graph in The Anxious Generation.
- 10:24It goes like this.
- 10:26There's a question, survey
- 10:27question asked to American high school
- 10:28students.
- 10:30The statement is,
- 10:31life often feels meaningless.
- 10:33Do you agree or disagree
- 10:34on a five-point scale?
- 10:36And from the ’90s through 2010, 2011,
- 10:38it was about 9% roughly say yes.
- 10:41I agree, my life often feels meaningless.
- 10:43And all of a sudden 2013, it goes shooting up.
- 10:46It doubles over the next eight or so years,
- 10:49our students feel like
- 10:50they're just lost in space.
- 10:52And so I think universities need to be
- 10:54a lot more active
- 10:56in rooting them in a sense of family,
- 10:58because that, we, that's our deepest ability to bond.
- 11:01And in the sense
- 11:02of being part of a moral community
- 11:04that has sacred values
- 11:06and that we are,
- 11:08we are organized around that,
- 11:09and that if you embrace them,
- 11:11you'll come out
- 11:12not just more knowledgeable,
- 11:13but you'll come out with more ...
- 11:15I would use the term moral discernment.
- 11:16It sounds a little old-fashioned, but
- 11:18I think we need to talk about morality
- 11:20in that way more often.
- 11:21I love that, and I love that
- 11:24the subtle distinction
- 11:25that I think you're implicitly drawing
- 11:27when we talk about moral discernment,
- 11:29when we talk about moral solidarity
- 11:31and development, we're talking more
- 11:35in a Durkheimian sense,
- 11:35not in the sense of
- 11:37you shall not do X, Y or Z.
- 11:39It's not about being prescriptive
- 11:40in terms of what to believe.
- 11:42It's about understanding
- 11:44the connectivity that we all have as a community.
- 11:46My concern is that morality ...
- 11:49morality is best understood as,
- 11:51as a, as a moral matrix.
- 11:52Morality is a consensual
- 11:55hallucination.
- 11:56We come together, we imagine this world.
- 11:58It has all kinds of rules and norms
- 11:59and history and stories,
- 12:01and then we can live within it.
- 12:02And we can't live in a vacuum.
- 12:03That's what Durkheim called anomie or normlessness.
- 12:06And that leads to suicide and meaninglessness,
- 12:07which is what is affecting young people
- 12:10all over the world,
- 12:11variations across countries, but
- 12:13it's not just
- 12:14the U.S., it's most of ...
- 12:15most of the world.
- 12:16It would be amazing if Durkheim had this moment
- 12:18coming back today, right?
- 12:20Yeah. Oh my God, we need him badly.
- 12:22Yeah, yeah.
- 12:23So, so I just want to make
- 12:25the point that
- 12:26because we’re, because we're often,
- 12:27we know we're so afraid
- 12:28to impose morality on anyone.
- 12:31So, so, like,
- 12:32you know, you find your purpose.
- 12:34And I would just say,
- 12:36I just say the more you ...
- 12:37OK, we're members of communities at multiple levels.
- 12:40So like, you're human
- 12:41and there are obligations
- 12:42to other humans.
- 12:43OK.
- 12:43You're, you know, you're an American if you're a citizen.
- 12:46And there we’re divided.
- 12:48So there is an issue there of,
- 12:50well, we can't endorse left or right,
- 12:52but that's the main area where we're divided.
- 12:54And then, you know,
- 12:55you're, you're, you know, a member of the USC family.
- 12:57And there now you really can do things
- 12:59that bring us together
- 13:00or, you know, you're in ROTC
- 13:02or on a sports team or whatever.
- 13:04Or in a fraternity.
- 13:05Or a fraternity. That's right.
- 13:06Right. Fraternities.
- 13:07You know, I'm the sort of person who used to always
- 13:08be sort of against frat-,
- 13:10when I was much, much younger,
- 13:11you know, and I was in college
- 13:12and I go, you know, just leads to, you know,
- 13:14drunkenness and stupidity.
- 13:15Like, once I became, I'm sorry.
- 13:17Please, please don't judge me just yet.
- 13:19Wait. Just,
- 13:21once I started
- 13:21studying moral psychology
- 13:23and reading Durkheim and understanding the need,
- 13:25I came to see when I was a professor at UVA,
- 13:27I came to see
- 13:29fraternities really do a job
- 13:31of binding kids together,
- 13:33causing them to feel
- 13:34they found their people.
- 13:36They produce, I think, a lot of social good.
- 13:38Obviously there's toxicity.
- 13:39There have been problems.
- 13:40There have been deaths.
- 13:41I'm not saying great, go.
- 13:42But I’m just saying
- 13:43I think I have a more positive view of fraternities
- 13:45than most faculty members do,
- 13:48because I understand this desperate need to,
- 13:50for our young people, to be part of a group.
- 13:53I agree, and when you talk
- 13:54to a lot of alums,
- 13:56a lot of them didn't join fraternities
- 13:58and weren't members, but a lot of them did.
- 14:01And that's what they talk
- 14:02about in terms of,
- 14:04when they think about their experience at USC and why it was so rich.
- 14:07And, and tell me,
- 14:09tell me how big a role
- 14:10fraternities play in
- 14:11who becomes a donor to USC.
- 14:13Would you, do you think that people
- 14:14who are in frats are, like,
- 14:15more likely to be donors to the university?
- 14:17There definitely seems to be a correlation,
- 14:20and I don't think it has to do
- 14:21with the fraternities per se,
- 14:22but just about the richness of the experience
- 14:25that they had at USC.
- 14:26They feel more rooted.
- 14:27I know because I asked you that question,
- 14:29because I know that that was the case at UVA.
- 14:31So I imagine it's a universal thing.
- 14:33Yeah. Let me,
- 14:36ask you a little bit about
- 14:40encouraging a culture
- 14:41where students feel
- 14:43not only comfortable,
- 14:44but empowered to have difficult conversations
- 14:46around controversial topics,
- 14:49some of what you've described
- 14:50in your books, in terms of fragmentation,
- 14:54it seems to me that your argument
- 14:56is that that also creates
- 14:57a kind of fragility.
- 14:59And while students need support,
- 15:02given all the reasons
- 15:04that you've discussed,
- 15:05it's also really important
- 15:07to create a culture
- 15:08where they feel like
- 15:10they can have arguments and disagree
- 15:13and then go out
- 15:15and have fun with the person and,
- 15:18and not, not take it personally.
- 15:20And so I wanted to ask you
- 15:22a little bit about
- 15:24going beyond rules and,
- 15:26you know, free speech
- 15:30prescriptions.
- 15:31How do we create as universities
- 15:33more of a better culture,
- 15:34both for faculty and for students
- 15:36to encourage
- 15:37that kind of civil disagreement?
- 15:39Yeah, no, thanks for that question, because this has been
- 15:41one of my top priorities since about 2015.
- 15:45So I first began to notice
- 15:46as a social psychologist
- 15:48that everyone of my field is on the left.
- 15:50There are no conservatives,
- 15:51there's only one I could find,
- 15:53and I created an organization
- 15:54called Heterodox Academy to foster
- 15:56a more viewpoint diverse among the faculty.
- 15:58And it was just a faculty project.
- 16:00I wasn't thinking about the students.
- 16:03But then as things got
- 16:04a lot more polarized on campus,
- 16:05there were a lot of protests
- 16:07and conflicts beginning in 2015,
- 16:09and the mood on campus
- 16:11became much more tense.
- 16:12And then, then Donald Trump was, was elected.
- 16:15And that really polarized
- 16:16things on campus.
- 16:17So I co-founded
- 16:18an organization called the Constructive Dialogue Institute
- 16:21with, with Caroline Mehl, who was working for me at the time.
- 16:23She's run it brilliantly since then.
- 16:26And we're now in,
- 16:27you know, I think more than 100 universities,
- 16:29and yeah, much more than 100.
- 16:31Do you know, I should have asked, is USC are you,
- 16:33do you know
- 16:35the Constructive Dialogue Institute?
- 16:36Have you been talking with them?
- 16:37Yes, we have been talking to them.
- 16:39And we have a Heterodox
- 16:41Academy chapter,
- 16:42I believe, that's very active.
- 16:44Now, this right, this is such a ...
- 16:45USC is is so well positioned for this.
- 16:47I know the general sense,
- 16:48but so, so, to be more specific,
- 16:51what we do at CDI
- 16:52is we have a program called Perspectives
- 16:55that goes through,
- 16:57why are people different on their values?
- 16:59What do they come from?
- 17:00Where do your values come in?
- 17:01You know, students learn to, they learn some
- 17:03moral and social psychology.
- 17:04And then they put it in practice having conversations.
- 17:07And they develop skills
- 17:08of asking questions.
- 17:09So we're giving them skills, and it works.
- 17:11We have evidence.
- 17:12It makes them less polarized, more open.
- 17:13But I want to bring it.
- 17:15So I urge anyone watching this
- 17:16go to Constructive Dialogue ...
- 17:19It's wonderful.
- 17:20Yeah.
- 17:20There are a lot of great resources there.
- 17:22Yeah.
- 17:23But what I'm realizing now is that
- 17:24the problem is even bigger
- 17:26than I thought.
- 17:27Beginning,
- 17:28you know, beginning
- 17:29in the mid-2010s, I started hearing professor ...
- 17:31I remember David Brooks, when he was teaching at Yale.
- 17:33He still is, I think.
- 17:34He was saying
- 17:35he can't get his students to debate each other.
- 17:37He can't get them to disagree with each other.
- 17:39And, you know, I've heard that a lot.
- 17:41And I find that in my classes, too.
- 17:43It's just harder to get any kind of disagreement going.
- 17:45And what I'm coming to realize
- 17:46is that if you grew up in a minefield —
- 17:49suppose you were raised literally in a minefield where there's mines
- 17:51all over the place —
- 17:52You'd be pretty careful where you walk,
- 17:54and then you come to college
- 17:55and you would be really careful
- 17:56where you step.
- 17:58But once everyone got on
- 17:59social media around 2012,
- 18:00they all had it, you know, an iPhone
- 18:02with social media in their pocket.
- 18:03And it became super
- 18:04viral a couple years after that.
- 18:06By 2015, it's super viral.
- 18:07It's a minefield.
- 18:08And they know, as one student said,
- 18:11you know, my motto is
- 18:12silence is safer.
- 18:14They know if you just don't say anything,
- 18:15you won't get in trouble.
- 18:16And so we have to understand
- 18:18our students are coming to us
- 18:20having grown up in social media in a minefield.
- 18:22And now we say, oh, just,
- 18:24you know, speak your mind.
- 18:25Say what you think.
- 18:26Oh, you know, you criticize affirmative action or immigration.
- 18:29Oh, you just say so.
- 18:32And they're afraid to.
- 18:33And so it's very hard.
- 18:35We have ...
- 18:36it's very hard to do this,
- 18:37but a lot of this points back ...
- 18:38We have to ...
- 18:40in everything we do, we have to be looking
- 18:42at the digital world.
- 18:44You know,
- 18:44we have to be looking at what
- 18:46the digital world has done to them,
- 18:47and we have to help them overcome it.
- 18:49And I don't think we paid enough attention to that.
- 18:51Like we sort of think like,
- 18:52you know, what they do on social media is their business.
- 18:54And now here we're in class.
- 18:55Like, no,
- 18:56if you grew up on social media,
- 18:57you live in social media.
- 18:58So we have to try to help them
- 18:59get off of it as much as possible,
- 19:01care less about it.
- 19:02And then we have to cultivate
- 19:03the mindset of,
- 19:06there are all these different games
- 19:07you could be playing at any one time.
- 19:08You could be playing the, the competition game.
- 19:12We're in a discussion.
- 19:12I want to beat you.
- 19:13My goal is to win the argument.
- 19:14We could be playing the,
- 19:18you know, speaking to the ...
- 19:19preaching to the choir game, like,
- 19:20I want them to like me.
- 19:22So I'm going to beat up on you in order to get points with them.
- 19:25Or you could be playing the learning game,
- 19:26which is whoever learns the most
- 19:28when they graduate wins.
- 19:30Whoever, whoever grew the most and learned
- 19:32the most on graduation
- 19:34day here at USC, you did it right.
- 19:36And the more like you can speak explicitly about that
- 19:38as they come in,
- 19:40the more you can speak
- 19:41about the different games
- 19:42that you'll be, that
- 19:43you'll be called into.
- 19:45And I want to urge you
- 19:46to consider the most important game
- 19:48you could play is the learning and growth game.
- 19:50And if you come across someone
- 19:51who has ideas that you think are terrible,
- 19:53there are a number of ways you could react.
- 19:55One would be curiosity.
- 19:57That's great.
- 19:58I want to go back
- 19:59to a couple things that you said, Jon.
- 20:01So one of the things that I took from you answer
- 20:04is that it's easy just to say, oh,
- 20:07you should express yourself more,
- 20:09even if you're ...
- 20:11have this kind of viewpoint
- 20:13or that kind of viewpoint.
- 20:14And I think
- 20:15what you're saying is, a lot
- 20:17easier said than done,
- 20:18because what we're dealing with
- 20:21is not just kind of a calculation
- 20:24and a number of incentives that a student is weighing
- 20:27through, but really kind of,
- 20:30a set of habits
- 20:31that have been developed and reinforced through social media.
- 20:34So it's going to be a harder nut to crack.
- 20:36That's right.
- 20:37Habit is the key word. That's great.
- 20:39The ancients, East and West,
- 20:41thought about,
- 20:42thought about moral development
- 20:43as habits.
- 20:45You know,
- 20:46was it Aristotle said,
- 20:47we are what we repeatedly do?
- 20:49You've got similar things from Mencius,
- 20:50and like the ancients knew this.
- 20:53Oh. Oh, right.
- 20:54They compared to, you know,
- 20:57people learn to be,
- 20:58you know, good people
- 20:59as, you know, as a,
- 21:01as a musician learns to play his instrument.
- 21:02So it’s habits,
- 21:05and, you know,
- 21:06when I, when I moved to NYU Stern
- 21:08and I was teaching the ethics course,
- 21:09I thought a lot about this.
- 21:11Can we change the ethics of our students
- 21:12in two years of an MBA program?
- 21:14And my conclusion was,
- 21:16in a single course, no, you really can't.
- 21:18You can teach them some things they need to know, but
- 21:20you can't change their habits.
- 21:22But if you have them for four years
- 21:25and you can have a coherent,
- 21:28you know, moral vision
- 21:29that you lay out before they arrive,
- 21:30and at convocation
- 21:32when they welcome them.
- 21:33And they're in many of their classes.
- 21:36So if you, if you,
- 21:37if you can create a culture of,
- 21:39in four years, and a culture could be
- 21:42we're in a brutal battle between left
- 21:44and right, we've got to crush the right.
- 21:45Like that's the, that's the culture
- 21:47on some university campuses.
- 21:50But if you can have a culture more of,
- 21:53our country is in huge trouble
- 21:54and we are in real danger
- 21:55of collapse over the next
- 21:57five or 10 years.
- 21:58We have a duty.
- 21:59We have an obligation to study this
- 22:02to become citizens.
- 22:03So you can do that on campus.
- 22:06And then if you ...
- 22:07So if you, if you think about it
- 22:09as four years
- 22:10and you have a consistent set
- 22:12of constructs
- 22:13and a moral mission
- 22:14that brings us together,
- 22:16then I think you can have
- 22:18a lasting impact.
- 22:19Beautiful.
- 22:21I want to talk to you about AI.
- 22:23Oh, boy.
- 22:23Yeah, I know it's hard to go 12 hours
- 22:26without someone talking about AI.
- 22:28Yeah, obviously, AI
- 22:32is a challenge with respect
- 22:33to a lot of the moral developmental issues
- 22:36that you've written about and thought about.
- 22:38And it also seems to me to
- 22:41create very significant
- 22:44challenges
- 22:44with respect to cognitive development
- 22:46if people are going to be using it more and more
- 22:48in, in lieu of writing.
- 22:51What are your thoughts, Jonathan?
- 22:53So, you know, at first,
- 22:54you know, look, you and I first met,
- 22:56it was over this it was just like,
- 22:57what, three or four months ago,
- 22:59we had a conversation about AI.
- 23:01And what are we going to, you know, like,
- 23:03because we're all think, like,
- 23:04you know,
- 23:05how do we teach,
- 23:06knowing that the students can just use
- 23:08AI to do all their homework,
- 23:09to write their papers?
- 23:11So there's the threat to learning
- 23:12and what we do in class.
- 23:15And of course, there’s
- 23:15a threat to employment.
- 23:17It's going to be taken with so many entry-level jobs.
- 23:19So it just, since you and I met,
- 23:21now the assault of the chatbots,
- 23:24it's incredible what's happening
- 23:25and how fast it's happening.
- 23:27But to, to get to
- 23:27the heart of your question,
- 23:29the way that I'm thinking about this now
- 23:32is that,
- 23:33you know, technology
- 23:35helps us do things more easily.
- 23:37Tools have always done
- 23:38that from the first spear
- 23:40through, you know, through ChatGPT.
- 23:42If you're an adult,
- 23:43you want to use tools
- 23:44because you have to get jobs done.
- 23:46And so, yeah, of course,
- 23:47you know, I use AI, we all use it.
- 23:50But kids need to do hard things
- 23:53and so like
- 23:54if you think about, you know, if you have a, OK,
- 23:56imagine if you have a six or seven year old ...
- 23:58OK.
- 24:06How many servants do
- 24:07you want to give to that child?
- 24:08Do you want them to have a,
- 24:10you know, maid to clean the room,
- 24:11a cook to do all the cooking,
- 24:12a chauffeur to take her to class, to school?
- 24:14Like, how many servants do
- 24:15you think a seven year old should have?
- 24:17What's your answer?
- 24:18Zero. Good.
- 24:19That's the right answer. So,
- 24:22But then we give them access to AI,
- 24:25and now, you know,
- 24:26we can do almost everything for them.
- 24:28And soon there'll be robots as well.
- 24:29AI in robots.
- 24:31So once you understand that kids have to do
- 24:33hard things over and over again,
- 24:35they have to fail.
- 24:37We realize, you know,
- 24:38we probably should be keeping
- 24:39AI away from children.
- 24:41I think we should get entirely out
- 24:43of elementary school.
- 24:44High school is more, I don't know, there are ...
- 24:45I can see uses in high school, a reason to train them,
- 24:47but elementary school and middle
- 24:49school,
- 24:51there's no evidence this is helping
- 24:52and there's a lot of evidence of harm.
- 24:54So I think we need to get it all.
- 24:56And I'm talking about Chromebooks, iPad, all the technology,
- 24:58get it out of elementary school.
- 25:01The, the people who made this stuff,
- 25:02they send their kids to the Waldorf school
- 25:04because there's no technology there.
- 25:06They know how harmful this stuff is.
- 25:08So,
- 25:09if we give our kids a tool
- 25:11that actually does their thinking for them,
- 25:13they're not going to learn to think.
- 25:15Kids aren't reading anymore.
- 25:17There's
- 25:18the phone is too interesting,
- 25:20and AI is going to mean there's no need to read a book.
- 25:22If I assign a book to my students and I do it myself,
- 25:24sometimes I have to, you know, I'll ask ChatGPT,
- 25:26give me a, you know, give me a summary of the book.
- 25:29So if we lose reading and thinking,
- 25:32it's over for humanity.
- 25:34Yeah. That sounds right to me.
- 25:36And it gets more complicated, though, when you get to college,
- 25:38because then you're trying
- 25:39to teach skills,
- 25:42that they're going to need
- 25:43in the workplace, and the workplace
- 25:44is completely transforming thanks to AI.
- 25:47So they need those skills,
- 25:49but they're also developing cognitively.
- 25:51So how are we going
- 25:53to thread that needle?
- 25:54So given what we now know
- 25:55about how often they're using
- 25:57AI outside of class,
- 25:59outside of school,
- 26:00we don't have to worry.
- 26:01Suppose we were to say in all our classes,
- 26:04you can't use AI at all.
- 26:06They're still using it all over the place.
- 26:08They're still going to learn how to use it.
- 26:09And it's going to be so different
- 26:11in a few years from how it is today.
- 26:13So I think we need to,
- 26:15you know, in K-12,
- 26:16we really need to teach them to read,
- 26:17think, write, all that.
- 26:19I think that continues into college.
- 26:21And so,
- 26:22you know what many people, I'm doing the same thing is,
- 26:24you know, rather than having like
- 26:24a weekly integration paper
- 26:26that they do the readings,
- 26:27you know, they summarize the readings,
- 26:28draw some links.
- 26:30Now that they can do all that with AI,
- 26:32I'm having them do a little bit
- 26:33more writing in class, which is,
- 26:35you know, more difficult to grade, more time consuming.
- 26:37But it, but at least it, it,
- 26:39I think it sort of anchors
- 26:40them and tells them, OK, my ...
- 26:42the professor knows how I write.
- 26:44So now I'm less, I can't
- 26:45just send in ChatGPT
- 26:47because, you know,
- 26:49so we've got to do what we can
- 26:51to encourage them to read,
- 26:53think and write.
- 26:54And I don't think
- 26:55we need to worry about training them to use AI.
- 26:57They’re going to learn that.
- 26:57So the blue books are coming back?
- 27:00They are, yeah. I'm using them.
- 27:02Jon, thank you so much for your time.
- 27:04It's been a pleasure, and Fight On.
- 27:06All right.
- 27:07Thank you, Beong, for welcoming me into the USC
- 27:09family, and Fight On.