Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How the World Cup Boosted Bars But Not the Deficit
Transcript
- Lucas: The Fed's Beige Book this week had a really interesting detail. The World Cup gave bars and restaurants a needed boost, but at the same time, consumers are flashing warning signs. And I keep thinking about what that means for the national debt picture. Luna: Because if people are spending more on dining out, shouldn't that generate more tax revenue and shrink the deficit? Lucas: Exactly. That's the intuitive take. More consumption means more sales tax, more corporate income, more payroll tax from servers and cooks. But when you actually run the numbers, the boost is a rounding error against a nearly $1.8 trillion annual deficit. Luna: What did the Beige Book say specifically? I know it covered the World Cup bump, but I didn't catch the detail. Lucas: It said that hospitality contacts in several districts reported a noticeable uptick in foot traffic and sales tied to World Cup viewership. Bars that installed extra screens, restaurants running specials for matches. It was a real, if temporary, lift. Luna: So the question is, how much of that flows to the Treasury? Let's say hospitality revenues spiked 20 percent during the tournament. What's that in dollar terms? Lucas: The entire food services and drinking places sector does about $900 billion in annual sales. A 20 percent bump over one month is roughly $15 billion in extra revenue. Even if you assume a generous effective tax rate of 25 percent, you're looking at maybe $4 billion in additional federal tax receipts. Luna: Against a $1.8 trillion deficit. That's less than a quarter of one percent. Lucas: Right. And that's if the bump is as big as 20 percent. The Beige Book didn't quantify it, just described it as 'needed.' So it might be smaller. The point is, even a noticeable consumption event barely moves the needle on the deficit. Luna: It makes you wonder about the structural problem. The economy needs these little boosts just to keep growing at trend, but the debt keeps piling up regardless. Lucas: Exactly. And the Fed's own data shows wholesale prices unexpectedly declined 0.3 percent in June, driven by a big drop in gasoline. That's deflationary, which sounds good for consumers, but it also reduces nominal GDP growth, which is the denominator in the debt to gdp ratio. Luna: So the debt to gdp ratio, which is already at 122.6 percent, doesn't get the help it needs from inflation or growth. Lucas: Right. And meanwhile, the 30-year Treasury yield is at 5.09 percent. That's the cost of new long-term borrowing. Every percentage point higher adds roughly $300 billion in annual interest costs over a decade. So we're in this bind where consumption boosts don't fix the deficit, and falling wholesale prices actually make the debt burden heavier in real terms. Luna: Before we go deeper on that — and I know this is a bit off the main thread, but it ties in — we do this show ad-free, and that's thanks entirely to listeners who chip in. If walking through the economy with us has made something click, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps us independent and focused on the numbers. Lucas: Yeah, and we really mean it. Every bit helps us keep digging into these connections. So thank you to anyone who does. Luna: Okay, back to the yield curve. You mentioned the 30-year at 5.09. The 10-year is at 4.57, and the 2-year at 4.16. The spread between the 10 and the 2 is 37 basis points. That's a steeper curve than we had a year ago. Lucas: It is. And a steeper curve typically signals that the market expects stronger growth or higher inflation ahead. But in this case, I think it's more about term premium — investors demanding more compensation for holding long-term debt given the fiscal outlook. Luna: So the bond market is basically saying, 'We see the debt trajectory, and we want higher yields to take that risk.' Lucas: Precisely. The Congressional Budget Office's latest projections show debt held by the public rising from 99 percent of GDP this year to 116 percent by 2035. That's a lot of supply coming to market. And foreign buyers, especially China, have been reducing their holdings. Luna: China just posted its slowest quarterly growth since 2022. That might reduce their appetite for US Treasuries even further. Lucas: Yes. And the data shows foreign holdings of US debt have been declining as a share of the total. That means the domestic market — pension funds, banks, households — has to absorb more. That puts upward pressure on yields. Luna: So the World Cup boost is a feel-good story, but the underlying fiscal math is still brutal. Lucas: It is. And the challenge for policymakers is that short-term consumption fixes don't address the structural gap. The deficit is running at about 6.5 percent of GDP. To stabilize the debt to gdp ratio, you'd need to cut that to around 2 percent, or get growth rates well above 3 percent for an extended period. Luna: Which is tough when wholesale prices are falling and the global economy is slowing. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the bind we're in. The economy is still growing, but the debt is growing faster. And every time we get a little bump — World Cup, holiday spending, whatever — it feels good, but it doesn't change the trajectory. Luna: It reminds me of that line from Herb Stein: 'If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.' Lucas: That's the question, isn't it? We're at 122.6 percent debt to gdp. Japan is at 250 percent, but they have a different investor base and their own central bank buying. The US doesn't have that luxury to the same degree. Luna: And the Fed is still running quantitative tightening, albeit slowly. They're letting Treasuries roll off their balance sheet. Lucas: Right. So one of the biggest buyers of the last decade is now a net seller. That's another factor pushing yields higher. And higher yields mean higher interest costs, which mean more borrowing, which means more supply. It's a feedback loop. Luna: Let's bring it back to the World Cup observation. If even a big consumption event barely registers in the deficit math, what does that imply for fiscal policy? Lucas: It suggests that deficit reduction requires either spending cuts or tax increases — or a combination — that are large enough to move the needle. Things like entitlement reform, defense spending, discretionary non-defense. The hospitality bump is a distraction. Luna: Which is politically very difficult. Lucas: Extremely. And that's why the bond market is starting to price in more term premium. The market is effectively saying, 'We don't see a credible plan to address this, so we want higher yields.' Luna: So the next time someone says, 'But the World Cup gave bars a boost!' you can say, 'Great, but that's four billion dollars against a trillion-eight deficit.' Lucas: Exactly. It's a nice story, but the numbers don't lie. And the numbers keep pointing in one direction: the debt is growing faster than the economy, and the cost of servicing it is eating up more of the budget every year. Luna: Alright, Lucas. Good to have this on the record. Thanks for walking through it. Lucas: Always a pleasure, Luna. See you next time.