Latest / Film And Whiskey / Her (2013) / Old Elk Infinity Blend Whiskey
Transcript
- 0:00In 2013, director Spike Jones and star Joaquin Phoenix gave
- 0:05the world a dystopian look at depression, dating and
- 0:09artificial intelligence. In 2025, we try a whiskey that
- 0:13touches the infinite. The film is.
- 0:16Her the whiskey is Old Elk Infinity Blend.
- 0:20And we'll review them both. This is.
- 0:23The Film and Whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:45podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:48glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:51I'm Brad G. And Brad, today we are looking
- 0:53at the 2013 film Her. I've been kind of excited to
- 0:58talk about this movie for a while.
- 0:59It almost made my list for our Season 5 lineup.
- 1:03And so as we kind of went down the list this season with which
- 1:06films we wanted to talk about as potential modern masterpieces,
- 1:11we got down to like, you know, the 25th, 26th spots and beyond.
- 1:15And then Brad and I basically just had a draft of movies we
- 1:17wanted to talk about. And this was one of mine.
- 1:20It it does qualify on a couple of our categories.
- 1:23And folks, first of all, let me take a step back.
- 1:26If this is your first time joining us, welcome in to Film
- 1:29and Whiskey. It's great to have you.
- 1:31It's so good to have you this season.
- 1:33What we're doing is we're talking about movies from the
- 1:35past 20 years, and we are asking the question, does this deserve
- 1:39to be considered a modern classic?
- 1:42Now, the criteria that we've set for inclusion here is that it
- 1:45has to be in at least one of the following categories, grossing
- 1:48$100 million at the US box office.
- 1:51Nominated for Best Picture in the IMDb Top 250.
- 1:56In the letterbox to top 250. Brad, I'm.
- 1:59Just one dude, Bob. I'm not going to lie to you, I
- 2:02have no idea. We just kind of started
- 2:04recording here on a whim and I did not do any research.
- 2:08So I'll tell you what, while we're talking today, I will look
- 2:11up which criteria this one hits, but I can't remember to save my
- 2:14life. I want to say it was up for best
- 2:16Picture. That sounds right.
- 2:18This, this. I guess I'll, I'll put my claim
- 2:21on it. There's no way that this
- 2:22wouldn't at least get a nomination.
- 2:24No, any year. Like, unless it came out in like
- 2:281947, I don't know if we'd go over as well with the Oscar
- 2:31vendors. To be like what's a computer?
- 2:35But outside of that though, like this is a any year best picture
- 2:39nom. I don't know how often it would
- 2:40win best picture though. All right, so this has an 8
- 2:43point O on IMDb, but it is apparently not good enough to be
- 2:47in the top 250. I think the the lowest one there
- 2:49is like an 8.1. It was nominated for Best
- 2:53Picture. I can guarantee that it did not
- 2:55make $100 million at the box office.
- 2:57So I'll check on Letterboxed as we talk.
- 2:59But for the purposes of today, it's a Best Picture nominee,
- 3:03Brad. Absolutely.
- 3:05And and one worth talking about. I'm I'm glad you chose it, Bob.
- 3:08Yeah, me too. I think it's one of those times
- 3:11where I not only like, is this definitely, like in my
- 3:14wheelhouse of movies, millennial films about relationships.
- 3:18I'm I'm there. I'm, I'm there all day,
- 3:20everyday. Oh, my gosh, man.
- 3:22I saw this with my wife in the theater.
- 3:23You know, it was before we were married.
- 3:25We both thought it looked like an interesting movie.
- 3:27Do you remember like when you used to have time to just go do
- 3:31stuff with the person you were dating?
- 3:33That would was like that sounds interesting, Let's try it.
- 3:37Yeah, and and within one week's calendar time, you could make
- 3:40time to do it. Yes and also like now not only
- 3:44do I not have the time to do it, but I have to do things that are
- 3:48like sure thing, good times, like we don't get to just
- 3:51experiment with that sounds interesting.
- 3:54Let's try it. It's like, no, if we don't know
- 3:56that we're going to like it, we're not even try again
- 3:58anymore. Absolutely.
- 4:00All that to say, we used to be adventurous millennials.
- 4:04We saw this movie in the theater.
- 4:06I think I came out of it the first time saying that was like
- 4:08a nine out of 10. And I remember my wife thinking
- 4:11that this was like a 10 out of 10.
- 4:12She really loved this movie. And so I'm really excited to
- 4:16dive into it with you, Brad, because I think that there are
- 4:18quite a few movies that we've talked about in the past on this
- 4:21podcast that we can draw comparisons to.
- 4:25But in order to draw those comparisons, we have to ask the
- 4:27fundamental question, Was this your first time seeing the movie
- 4:31Her, and what familiarity did you have with it coming into
- 4:35today? This was my first time watching
- 4:38her and I, I would say of all the first time films I've seen,
- 4:44I feel like the premise of this movie is so simple and obvious
- 4:49that like, if you know the premise, you really know what
- 4:53you're getting into. So, you know, the the whole
- 4:56premise that I knew going into it was that the main character
- 5:00is going through some sort of a difficult time and he strikes up
- 5:04a relationship with his AI voice by Scarlett Johansson, which is
- 5:09very important because listen, it's Scarlett Johansson.
- 5:11Our girl Scar Jo just keep showing up this season.
- 5:14I I feel like she might officially be the lead actress
- 5:18of the film and Whiskey podcast at this.
- 5:20Point I was going to say, I think she might be the modern
- 5:23classic. Yeah, I I think that it's pretty
- 5:26obvious that you and I are both big fans of Scar Joe at this
- 5:28point, right? Absolutely.
- 5:30Dude, She is just such an incredible actress.
- 5:34Like all the way back from Lost in Translation, which I don't
- 5:37know, we reviewed in Season 2, Season 3, yeah.
- 5:39It was a long time ago, man. Like she has never failed to
- 5:43disappoint. Nope.
- 5:45So a few years back, the director, Guillermo del Toro
- 5:49came out with a movie called The Shape of Water.
- 5:51And it was a really well reviewed movie that audiences
- 5:54kind of liked but didn't love. It ended up going on to win Best
- 5:57Picture. But it was one of those films
- 5:59that kind of like The Revenant where everything boiled down to
- 6:03like, hey, did you hear that Leo gets raped by a bear?
- 6:05You know, that was a big joke about that movie.
- 6:08The Shape of Water just became the joke about it was like it's
- 6:11a movie about a woman who FS a fish and this movie her.
- 6:17I felt like it it kind of a lot of people didn't see it when it
- 6:20came out, but people knew it as the movie where a guy FS his
- 6:24computer. And like I've always bristled,
- 6:28as funny as those things are, I've always bristled at at
- 6:31reducing a movie down to something as stupid as that,
- 6:33like especially the revenant one.
- 6:35But this might be the one time where like that kind of is the
- 6:39plot of this movie. Yep.
- 6:41And I think that kind of filling out the nuances of that
- 6:46statement is our task for today, Brad.
- 6:49And that's my really sloppy Segway into talking it into our
- 6:53first segment of the day, which we call Brad explains.
- 6:56Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 7:00taken on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with this
- 7:03little segment that we call, Brad explains.
- 7:06This is going to be followed by our our new segments, Sloppy
- 7:09Segways. Sloppy.
- 7:10Sick Big ways, Baby Brad explains, is the part of the
- 7:13show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 7:16just seen often for the first time.
- 7:19Now we've established this was Brad's first time seeing her.
- 7:23Brad, you have 60 seconds on the clock to spoil this movie.
- 7:27Folks, if you have not seen the movie her, I would highly
- 7:29suggest pausing here. Go watch the film and then
- 7:32rejoin us for the conversation afterwards.
- 7:35Brad, one minute and go. Her is a film that follows
- 7:41Twombley. I can think of his last name.
- 7:42What's his first name? Theodore.
- 7:43Theodore. Theodore Twombley.
- 7:46It's the one of the greatest names we've ever had in a movie.
- 7:49Bob Beasley. I think so.
- 7:51As he navigates the loss of his marriage over an impending
- 7:56divorce and finds an operating system named Samantha.
- 8:01She is an artificial intelligence that becomes his
- 8:04best friend and soon his lover. And then we navigate what it
- 8:09looks like to date an artificial intelligence with some of the
- 8:13most poorly delivered lines about the most ridiculous things
- 8:18I've ever heard in my life by Amy Adams and Chris Pratt, who
- 8:22clearly wants to bang Theodore Twombley.
- 8:25Sure, the end. I mean, who wouldn't?
- 8:28What a mustache dude. I, I don't know if I've ever
- 8:31seen a better, like come hit her look than every single moment
- 8:38Chris Pratt looks at Joaquin Phoenix in this movie.
- 8:43He's like, I've beaten this girl, but one word from you and
- 8:45I'm I'm moving on, baby. Brad, I don't mean to spoil my
- 8:50let's make it a double and I I guess I technically won't, but I
- 8:54think one of the places to start with talking about this movie is
- 8:57to talk about all the other movies that it reminds us of
- 9:01because it is a very unique film.
- 9:04But I do think it kind of fits into the sub genre that I was
- 9:07talking about of like these millennial relationship movies.
- 9:10You know, there's a ton of, well, I've you said lost in
- 9:13translation. There's a ton of lost in
- 9:14translation in this movie. Just in terms of finding a
- 9:17relationship in the midst of complete isolation in a big
- 9:21city. I think that's there.
- 9:23I think that in terms of like, go ahead.
- 9:26Eternal Sunshine of the shithead mind.
- 9:29Eternal Sunshine is all over the place here less it's less
- 9:34avant-garde than Eternal Sunshine is like.
- 9:37It's a much more like conventional movie, but in terms
- 9:40of. Makes it way better.
- 9:42I think that there's a lot of the movie up in the air with
- 9:45George Clooney in this in terms of like what his job is and what
- 9:50that signifies about him. And then like the one I'm always
- 9:54going to come back to just in terms of the the pacing, the
- 9:56deliberate pacing of the movie that like the slow, gentle
- 9:59quietness of it. It it's definitely got past
- 10:02lives in it as well. And I'm wondering, Brad, as you
- 10:05watched the movie, was there anything in particular that it
- 10:09it triggered for you in terms of past conversations we've had
- 10:12about films? Honestly it it even reminded me
- 10:16a little bit way back in season 1 of Like a Tree of Life.
- 10:20Interesting. There there's like a slowness of
- 10:25the film that just knows it is sure of itself, like it, it
- 10:30knows what it's trying to do. You know, Spike is very clearly
- 10:36aware of what he's trying to do to the audience.
- 10:40And so I, yeah, I think there's, there's lots of movies that kind
- 10:43of fit that bill. The the ones that really stood
- 10:47out to me would be Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.
- 10:53That feels like the most obvious connection here.
- 10:57Yeah, for sure. I'm glad you said Tree of Life
- 10:59'cause I, I think especially in the first half of the movie,
- 11:02there's this really cool editing technique that they do where,
- 11:05you know, as his memories kind of pop back up, they just
- 11:08interspersed like small little almost insert shots of moments
- 11:12from his past relationships. They almost never have dialogue.
- 11:16They're almost entirely silent. And I, I think that it again, it
- 11:20reminds me of like, do you remember at the end of past
- 11:22lives where they're standing there waiting on the taxi to
- 11:25come and then they cut back to the moment when they were both
- 11:28kids again and they were standing on those stairs like
- 11:30looking at each other. It reminds me of that.
- 11:33And I think the best possible term to use for that kind of
- 11:36filmmaking is one that you just used, which is like assured.
- 11:39It's very self assured filmmaking.
- 11:42And I think that, like, you know, I've been trying to feel
- 11:45you out on this movie a little bit, Brad, I have no idea where
- 11:48you land on it yet. But I think that even if you're
- 11:50not entirely on this movie's wavelength, there's something to
- 11:54be said about watching a movie where you just know that the
- 11:57filmmaker is doing exactly what they set out to do.
- 12:01And like the movie, has that stamp of self assuredness on it.
- 12:06Yeah, the, and that's that's the beautiful thing of this film is
- 12:10that you can really tell there's no mistakes here.
- 12:15Like like there's definitely movies where it feels like stuff
- 12:18kind of gets away from the director.
- 12:20The only thing for me and I, I kind of alluded this to this
- 12:24during my, Brett explains. There are some lines in this
- 12:29film that are so far fetched, so far beyond the human experience
- 12:38that like Amy Adams, great actress, one of my absolute
- 12:43favorites. When she says to Theodore, when
- 12:47when Joaquin Phoenix tells her like, hey, I'm I'm date.
- 12:50I'm actually dating an OS and she just goes, Oh yeah, I've
- 12:54totally heard that people are dating their OSS, but it's
- 12:57pretty rare. My one friend got rejected by
- 13:00his OS. I would like, I'm sorry, man,
- 13:05like other than that and when Chris Pratt and him go on the
- 13:09date and the his girlfriend is like showing her feet to the AI,
- 13:16I'm just kind of like, Oh well, I know what Spike Jones is into.
- 13:20I don't know if this movie. You can't really say it's that
- 13:23far fetched because now we have only fans, right?
- 13:25We're just women just show their feet to people for money all the
- 13:28time. So.
- 13:29You're not wrong. It was precious.
- 13:31Spike spends How much do you think Spike spends a month on
- 13:34feet Only fans? Not as much as Tarantino does, I
- 13:38can tell you that much. You're not wrong there man.
- 13:42All right, I want to ask you a little bit before we get into
- 13:44talking about the performances. One thing that I was excited
- 13:48about watching this movie again because I hadn't watched it
- 13:50since the movie theater 12 years ago.
- 13:53And I have it like I bought the movie.
- 13:55It's on my shelf and I just have never gotten back around to
- 13:58watching it. And I had forgotten how funny
- 14:01this movie is, especially in the first like hour.
- 14:04It's 2 hour movie. I would say it gets like much
- 14:07more sullen in the second-half. And it's it's a movie about
- 14:12loneliness. So like that kind of sullenness
- 14:14is there throughout the movie. But I think Spike Jones writes a
- 14:17number of really funny moments and scenes in the first hour.
- 14:22But I also found myself wondering, like, I wonder if
- 14:24Brad is vibing with the comedy part of this movie.
- 14:27So I'd love to hear your thoughts on like, did this movie
- 14:30make you laugh? And did like, were you aware of
- 14:35the intention behind it? Yeah, I mean, there's definitely
- 14:39some, I don't even know if I'd call it dark humor because like,
- 14:42if a movie is about depression but has some comedy, it's it's
- 14:45like automatically called dark humor.
- 14:47I, I don't even know if I'd call it that.
- 14:49Like, this movie isn't just about depression and isolation.
- 14:53It's about what is, what does it mean to be human?
- 14:55And so, yeah, there are moments of comedy.
- 14:58I did find myself laughing at Chris Pratt every time he was on
- 15:01screen. Like when as ridiculous as it
- 15:05was when Joaquin Phoenix tells him, yeah I'm dating my my OS
- 15:10and he just goes oh cool bro we should go on a double date
- 15:13sometime. I like the delivery was just
- 15:16absolutely perfect and I he was by far the funniest character
- 15:21throughout the film. I think the the scene that I
- 15:26anticipated being like the most controversial one for you, but
- 15:29which is also the one that is like the most obviously all
- 15:32written to be a joke, is his kind of phone sex conversation
- 15:36with the voice of Kristen Wiig. So at the beginning of the
- 15:39movie, he's like he's super lonely and he's browsing chat
- 15:43rooms and he has a phone sex call essentially with this woman
- 15:47called sexy Kitten. And as as they start getting hot
- 15:51and heavy, she's she reveals very quickly and abruptly that
- 15:54she is into some weird, weird stuff.
- 15:57And it's it's so absurd that it really catches you off guard
- 16:02because you don't realize this is the kind of movie that it
- 16:04wants to be. At first.
- 16:06I think it's really funny. It also felt like the most out
- 16:09of place moment in the movie. But I but I do feel like it has
- 16:12a place kind of thematically. So I was wondering like, what
- 16:15did you think of that scene? I think it kind of pairs with
- 16:19his date with Olivia Wilde. Is is that her name?
- 16:22You never. Remember, is that Olivia Wilde
- 16:24or Olivia Munn? I don't know.
- 16:26Let's see. I think it's Olivia Wilde.
- 16:28That's Olivia Wilde, Yeah. Yeah.
- 16:30So for me it pairs with that because those are like 2
- 16:34interactions that he has with real women who are not Amy Adams
- 16:40essentially. And they both do not fit the
- 16:45vibe of the movie. Like I understood where he's
- 16:49going with the comedy, with the the sex chat.
- 16:53It just doesn't work for me. The Olivia Wilde scene, just, I,
- 16:58I, I couldn't understand if like, it was an example of Jones
- 17:06trying to show that Joaquin Phoenix had a different
- 17:10perception of the night that they had because she's so
- 17:14quickly abrupt and abruptly turns to calling him a creep
- 17:18that I, I, I didn't, I was like, hold on.
- 17:20Nothing in that date would make him seem like a creep, and so I
- 17:25I think that both of those scenes just felt kind of off and
- 17:29weird with the rest of the. Film Well, maybe let's let's
- 17:32talk about both the scenes because I do think that they're
- 17:33both important even if they do feel out of place.
- 17:36So that first like phone sex conversation I think really
- 17:40underscores this idea that not like a people online are just
- 17:44weirdos, right. And Oh, yeah.
- 17:46But it also underscores this idea that I think that
- 17:49ultimately Spike Jones doesn't land on the side of, like, the
- 17:54Internet and technology can be useful tools if we use them the
- 17:57right way. I think he's ultimately, like,
- 17:59very pessimistic about what humanity will do with technology
- 18:04as a way of replacing real human connection.
- 18:08And so I think that that scene, like really underscores people
- 18:13go online as a way of anonymizing they're weird kinks,
- 18:19right? Like if I do it online, it it's
- 18:22not as weird and creepy as if I were to like approach somebody
- 18:25at a date like that. Like if Kristen Wiig's character
- 18:28did that over dinner to you, you'd be like, this person
- 18:30should be institutionalized. But because you're just floating
- 18:33around a chat room like it's the Internet, that's how it works.
- 18:36And I think that that's like, the first sign we get that
- 18:39Phoenix is a guy who's lonely and looking for connection.
- 18:43And like, it's pretty clear that the Internet is not the place
- 18:47for him to be finding women, right?
- 18:50Absolutely, and and I think that's why it kind of feels
- 18:53weird that he ends up finding a woman not technically over the
- 18:57Internet, but you know, a replacement woman through this
- 19:01OS and like that at the end of the day, like that's what this
- 19:06movie is all about, right? It's like, how can we find
- 19:11replacements for the real thing that we know we need?
- 19:15And I don't, you know, I don't know if that's what everybody
- 19:18else took away from it. That's what I took away from it,
- 19:21that, you know, he's using the Internet to replace his soon to
- 19:27be divorced wife and he's using Amy Adams friendship to replace
- 19:32the friendship he might have had with his wife.
- 19:34And he's using Olivia Wilde to try to get some.
- 19:38And and there's just all these things where he's trying to find
- 19:40his happiness in places that he's just, you know, not going
- 19:44to find it. Well, I think the entire
- 19:46character of Samantha, the OS voiced by Scarlett Johansson, is
- 19:50really, you know, if we could just call the whole thing a
- 19:53metaphor or a symbol, right? Like another film that this
- 19:56reminds me of thematically is 500 Days of Summer, which is a
- 20:01movie that I really loved returning to with you Brad, as
- 20:04you know, late 20 somethings, early 30 somethings because it
- 20:08reads so differently. Like once you are in a stable,
- 20:11committed relationship and no longer like an idealistic young
- 20:14man. Because the character of Tom in
- 20:16that movie is. Like way different than I
- 20:20remembered him being, right? Like he, I think he kind of
- 20:23epitomizes the idea of like toxic masculinity in a lot of
- 20:26ways. But that whole film is about
- 20:28like the idea of somebody versus the real person.
- 20:33And when you idealize somebody, when you try to create a, a, a
- 20:37fictionalized perfect person, you are bound to be let down,
- 20:41right? And this one entire character of
- 20:43Samantha is like he's getting over being divorced.
- 20:46And so he uses this like quote, UN quote, perfect woman that
- 20:50he's constructed or that's being constructed for him.
- 20:54And like, and you know, from the start, this is doomed to fail
- 20:56because there's this is not real.
- 20:58There's nothing tangible here. There's nothing that can
- 21:01possibly satisfy him long term. Because like, as he comes to
- 21:06find out too, like in order to be happy, you have to take the
- 21:10flawed nature of being human as well.
- 21:13And I think that like, just as a character, you have to look at
- 21:18his interactions with Samantha from that standpoint.
- 21:22I will say I'm with you 100%. I was thinking about 500 days of
- 21:27summer in terms of like color palette, like there's, there's
- 21:31such a distinct choices in color made in 500 days of summer that
- 21:37I feel like you get here in her as well.
- 21:42That if there's anything I like about this movie, because I I
- 21:45don't think I like the message at the end.
- 21:48I love the colors that Jones sets up and primarily for the
- 21:54fact that it's like almost pastel, But it's it's not like
- 21:59he doesn't go completely into a soft Easter colored palette.
- 22:03It's just these beautiful, vibrant colours that make you
- 22:06want to live in his world. It's really warm hues and I
- 22:10like, I noticed it immediately watching this movie and I think
- 22:12part of the reason it stands out now as opposed to 12 years ago
- 22:16is that everything looks like grey slop now.
- 22:19Like every movie that Netflix releases like this would have
- 22:24gone straight to Netflix if it was made today, and it would
- 22:26look incredibly shitty in comparison.
- 22:29And you know, our friend Patrick H Williams did a great video,
- 22:32gosh, 5-10 years ago now where he talked about like, why do
- 22:35Marvel movies look so ugly? And I think that the Marvel
- 22:39aesthetic has really taken over in terms of how quickly movies
- 22:42are cranked out. And just having characters wear
- 22:45colorful things and have sunshine actually be yellow hued
- 22:50now seems like a revolutionary thing, you know?
- 22:53Yeah, Yep. Crazy.
- 22:55Well, and, and the wild thing is like, it's not like they're
- 22:59trying to create a specific aesthetic like they would have
- 23:04been in the 80s. It's just the fact that it's
- 23:06Gray and boring and they don't have time to make it beautiful.
- 23:10Well, let's talk a little bit more about the aesthetic of this
- 23:12movie because that was also one of the things that were made fun
- 23:14of a lot. I remember an SNL skit that came
- 23:17out right after the movie was released where they were making
- 23:21fun of like the high waisted pants and characters kept
- 23:24showing up in the skit wearing like higher and higher waisted
- 23:26pants. It was really funny.
- 23:28But you know, back in 2013 it it was just different enough to
- 23:33look slightly futuristic. And that's the whole like the
- 23:36whole goal of this movie is it's set a little bit in the future,
- 23:40but not far enough in the future that it feels like a sci-fi
- 23:42movie. I really like that because it
- 23:45helps the movie speak to the current climate a little bit
- 23:49better. But it's also really funny
- 23:51because I think with current fashion trends, I watched this
- 23:55movie and I actually noticed the fashion less.
- 23:58So I'm wondering if Spike Jones was just like really predictive
- 24:01of things, like where trends were going to go, even down to
- 24:04the fashion. Yeah, absolutely, man.
- 24:08I I mean, you are correct. It's not that out of place
- 24:12except for the fact that nobody wears a belt.
- 24:15That that was like the only thing of the aesthetic that I'm
- 24:18like, man, you like, you can't wear pants like that with your,
- 24:21your shirt tucked in and not have a belt on.
- 24:23Come on, Joaquin. All right, man, let's talk about
- 24:26the performances a little bit. And I guess we should start
- 24:29right at the top with Joaquin Phoenix, who is he's such an
- 24:32interesting actor, Brad, because I, I think I'd be doing a
- 24:36disservice to him to say that I think he has limited range.
- 24:39I don't think that's the case. I just think that that like a
- 24:43lot of our really great actors like a like a Willem Dafoe, like
- 24:49there's only so many kinds of characters that a Willem Dafoe
- 24:54can play just because of who Willem Dafoe is, right?
- 24:57Like you just not you're not going to cast him as like your
- 25:00ROM com lead. Like he just doesn't have the
- 25:02face for it. And I think similarly.
- 25:04Until you, until you do. And all of a sudden it's Billy
- 25:08Crystal and When Harry Met Sally and all of us are like, what a
- 25:12revelation. How could we never?
- 25:13Saw it, yeah. And I think with Phoenix, like
- 25:17you watch a movie with Joaquin Phoenix and you kind of know
- 25:19what you're getting. But then even within that,
- 25:22there's so many shades to it. Like we watched Joker a little
- 25:26while ago and the, like, sensitive kind of wimpy
- 25:33character is Joaquin Phoenix's specialty here.
- 25:36But the difference between Arthur Fleck and Theodore
- 25:40Twombley is night and day like. I was blown away by how
- 25:44different of a person he seemed in this movie to that movie.
- 25:48Yeah, it's insane cause 'cause you're right, like Tom Hanks is
- 25:52at this point always Tom Hanks. And so the curious, the
- 25:55curiosity for me is like, what kind of Tom Hanks are we getting
- 25:59and what, what element of his own character are we going to
- 26:03get accentuated? And I, I think that within his
- 26:06sphere, Joaquin is like a freaking chameleon man.
- 26:12But like, he just has a talent for bringing out different
- 26:16nuances to his performances every time around.
- 26:20And, and it's interesting. I, I feel like before the
- 26:22podcast started, the only movie I'd ever really seen Joaquin in
- 26:26was Gladiator. So I it's interesting to have
- 26:31now seen him in a lot of different films because you do
- 26:34get a better sense of who he is. A. 100%, man.
- 26:37And I think top to bottom, like my big take away from this movie
- 26:41is I'm shocked at how good all the performances are.
- 26:45Like, not that I was expecting bad performances, but I am a
- 26:50noted fan of Amy Adams. I have always liked Amy Adams.
- 26:53I just, yeah, I think she's just the freaking best.
- 26:56And I watched this movie, and I was like, is this the best Amy
- 27:00Adams performance I've ever seen?
- 27:02And I know that you're, like, the world's biggest fan of
- 27:04Arrival. And I like Arrival, OK.
- 27:08And that's her movie, right? But to come in and be like,
- 27:12easily third banana in this movie, for Spike Jones to just
- 27:17leave the camera on her as much as he does during their
- 27:20conversations so that you can watch her react to lions instead
- 27:23of just, you know, cut back and forth after everybody delivers
- 27:27their line. She just inhabits those
- 27:30conversations. And it really helps give a sense
- 27:33of believability to her relationship with Theodore that,
- 27:37you know, that they're old friends going back decades, but
- 27:40also to see, like, this internalized grieving process
- 27:44that she's going through from her own separation.
- 27:47I was freaking blown away by Amy Adams, man.
- 27:51She's fine. No, Brad.
- 27:54Like, I dude, I love Amy Adams, one of my favorite actresses.
- 27:58I like AI think that what I referenced earlier when she's
- 28:03trying to like make it chill about him dating an artificial
- 28:07intelligence isn't good. It's a really bad line delivery
- 28:11of a really bad line. And then outside of that, like,
- 28:15yeah, she does a great job of connecting with Joaquin.
- 28:18I think that the performance of her husband soon to be
- 28:22ex-husband kind of makes her suffer because he's such a twat.
- 28:26Like the dude is just the worst and it's so obvious that he's
- 28:31the worst that you're kind of like it's almost unbelievable
- 28:35that she even likes him. Kind of like a Robin Scherbatsky
- 28:39situation, if I will. So I, I just, I, I don't think
- 28:44this is a bad performance from her, that there's moments of
- 28:47connection between her and Phoenix that I'm all about.
- 28:50But overall, I would just say this is like a fine, like B -, B
- 28:55performance from her. All right.
- 28:58Well, a hard disagree there, but I will say I don't think we're
- 29:02going to disagree about Scarlett Johansson.
- 29:04Let's come back around to Scar Joe now.
- 29:06So Brad, I have no idea this was part of your two facts and a
- 29:09falsehood. But one of the big takeaways
- 29:11from this movie is that as they were filming it, the actress
- 29:15Samantha Morton was providing the voice for Samantha.
- 29:19Part of why the character was named Samantha, I would assume.
- 29:22And as they were cutting the movie in post production, Spike
- 29:26Jones is like this is not working.
- 29:28We need to recast this character.
- 29:30And then they hired Scarlett Johansson, which is freaking
- 29:32nuts that they did the entire movie with.
- 29:34Like, you know, it's not like Back to the Future where they
- 29:36started with Eric Stoltz as Marty McFly and then like 3
- 29:40weeks in they were like this is not going to work and then hired
- 29:43Michael J Fox. They shot the whole movie with a
- 29:46different person and then changed it in post production.
- 29:49So I I was already kind of impressed by how well Scarjo and
- 29:55Joaquin played off each other. I found myself wondering at
- 29:57multiple points, like I wonder if she recorded her stuff 1st
- 30:01and then he reacted to it like you know, in on set because
- 30:06there's this one scene where he's like on a train and she's
- 30:08talking to him and it's like 1 unbroken shot of him just
- 30:11listening and reacting. And they time it up so well that
- 30:14I was like who did their stuff first?
- 30:17You know? Come to find out, Scarjo's
- 30:19literally just over dubbing this in post production.
- 30:24I like it. It impressed me even more.
- 30:26Brad, this isn't unbelievable performance from someone whose
- 30:29face you never see. Yeah, dude, Scarlett Johansson
- 30:34might be the best actress of the modern era.
- 30:39Like. Spicy take.
- 30:41Of the last 20 years, maybe since lost in translation.
- 30:45Yeah. So and one of the key elements
- 30:49of her acting is her voice. So I like I can't imagine them
- 30:54finding a better person for this.
- 30:56She like she can do playful, she can do serious, she can do
- 30:59jealous, she can do angry. She can do every single element
- 31:04of what you need a voice only girlfriend to be.
- 31:08And she is by far the highlights of this movie.
- 31:14She's so good, man, and and I feel like we kind of trip over
- 31:18ourselves to praise her a lot on this show.
- 31:21I still think Marriage Story is her crowning achievement as an
- 31:24actress to this point. Brad, let's see, how many films
- 31:27of hers have we done? We've done lots in translation.
- 31:30We've done The Avengers, we've done End Game, we've done
- 31:33Marriage Story, we've done JoJo Rabbit, we've done this.
- 31:35So at least six, if not more. What's your favorite performance
- 31:40of hers so far? Oh, that's tough, man.
- 31:45I would put Marriage Story up there.
- 31:47I'd put JoJo Rabbit up there. I think Sneaky, she's really
- 31:52good in End Game, that dude, She's she's just so good.
- 31:58Yeah. Lost in Translation.
- 31:59Her and Bill Murray are incredible together.
- 32:02I love that you're just going to name all six movies again.
- 32:05Yeah, that's. That's, well, it's hard not to.
- 32:07Yeah. Where Where are you at?
- 32:10I, I, I mean, I think it's Marriage Story and then like a
- 32:12pretty sizable gap and then probably this and then another
- 32:18small gap and then we can put the others in there.
- 32:20That's where I'd be at. Sure.
- 32:22All right, Brad, so we've gone through our performances, we've
- 32:25talked about the costuming, we've talked about, you know,
- 32:29the aesthetic of the movie. Is there anything else on the
- 32:32technical side you want to hit before we get to break?
- 32:34Dude, the moment where she talks about taking a picture for him
- 32:41in the form of a piano song. A What a great idea like to like
- 32:48have a piano piece commissioned as a memory for a time with you
- 32:54and your spouse. One of the best romantic ideas
- 32:57ever. B The piano music in this the
- 33:02compositions are just stunningly beautiful and and throughout the
- 33:07film, even, you know, even when it's not Samantha playing piano
- 33:10for him, like the music of this movie sets the mood so
- 33:15perfectly. It it really feels like one of
- 33:18the better scores that we've heard in a while.
- 33:23Yeah, so this movie was nominated for best original
- 33:25score. It was nominated for best
- 33:27original song. It didn't get any acting
- 33:30nominations, which I'm like really shocked at.
- 33:34If if you were going to give somebody a nomination from this
- 33:36movie, who do you think it should be?
- 33:39Chris Pratt? Here's the question.
- 33:44Come hit their eyes. Here's the question, is Chris
- 33:46Pratt better as like the 5th lead in a movie than he is as a
- 33:51lead? Oh, that's a good question.
- 33:55I dude, he was incredible in Moneyball.
- 33:58I think he has a great. Yes, he has the chops to carry a
- 34:05movie. And I think that, like the first
- 34:07two Guardians films speak to that, right?
- 34:09I think that over the last 10 years, he has like slowly
- 34:15completed his metamorphosis into buff Jack Black.
- 34:20And Jack Black only works as like, if I'm being frank about
- 34:25Jack Black. Jack Black only works as like
- 34:27the poor man's Chris Farley. Like that's why I think School
- 34:30of Rock works, you know what I mean?
- 34:32So if you're trying to do Jack Black as leading man, I don't
- 34:35think that works. And you you have to have that in
- 34:38smaller doses. And Pratt is good enough that
- 34:41like, I think he's a better dramatic actor than Jack Black
- 34:43is. So he knows how to like modulate
- 34:46that. But he's gone so far into like,
- 34:49I want to make money, make me the lead of this crappy movie.
- 34:52Like he's in that really awful Netflix movie that just came out
- 34:55too The Electric State. I just wish that he would get
- 34:58back to doing interesting projects again.
- 35:00I also feel like that was just like the inception of like
- 35:03actors on actors. Like Chris.
- 35:05Pat Pratt is the jacked Jack Black, who is the poor man's
- 35:09Chris Farley. It's just Chris Farley being
- 35:13reincarnated as as thinner and thinner people as he goes.
- 35:16Yeah, yeah. And, and Chris Farley like 3
- 35:19steps up is like Lou Costello, right, Right.
- 35:23They're, they're all, they're all just grand grandfathered in
- 35:27somehow. And all of them are just chasing
- 35:29the perfect platonic ideal balance of comedy and drama.
- 35:33That is John Candy, right? Yeah.
- 35:36Oh, dude, let me go. Good, good reference.
- 35:39We did it, man. All right, on that note, Brad, I
- 35:41think it's time for us to drink some whiskey.
- 35:43What do you say we get into this Old Elk?
- 35:45Let's get to it. All right, so today we are
- 35:53checking out Old Elk Infinity Blend.
- 35:57Brad, this is the first time we've had Old Elk on the show in
- 36:00quite a long time. We have had them, I believe,
- 36:03twice on the show. I know once I sat down with
- 36:06their master blender to do a my favorite movie.
- 36:09And I feel like you and I have reviewed at least one other
- 36:11product of theirs, but it's been long enough that I can't exactly
- 36:14remember. So welcome back, Old Elk.
- 36:16Yeah, it it has been a minute. We are very, very excited to get
- 36:21our hands on year's edition, the 2023 edition of their Infinity
- 36:27Blend. Yeah.
- 36:28So this is a project they started back in 2021 making the
- 36:31bottle that we have the third iteration of this Infinity
- 36:35blend. Folks, I know it's now 2025, but
- 36:37what are you going to do? I mean, this just came out last
- 36:39year. They released the 2023 version
- 36:42at the beginning of 2024. So like there's, you know, we're
- 36:45two iterations past that, but you got to forgive us.
- 36:48I think what we're saying here, Brad, is as per use, we are
- 36:52behind the curve. But also I like doing stuff this
- 36:55way a little bit because like I, I don't feel like we get caught
- 36:59up in the hype of anything. And we're choosing 1 iteration
- 37:02out of the five that they've released now and deciding like
- 37:06just based on this, do we think this skew this brand, this label
- 37:10is worth the money? Yeah, absolutely.
- 37:14And it's, it's really fun to get a little bit older of an
- 37:18iteration so you kind of know where they're coming from if we
- 37:21get to try any future ones. So like most craft distillers,
- 37:26Old Elk, which is based out of Colorado, you know, started by a
- 37:29lot of sourcing, right? They've done some MGP, they've
- 37:32done some Barton barrels, and they've also started distilling
- 37:36their own stuff. They're a big source for
- 37:38contract distilling now. So they've been putting up their
- 37:41own distillate and it's been aging over the years.
- 37:44But back in 21, they decided to make this Infinity blend with
- 37:47basically all of the different whiskeys they've ever used
- 37:51blended into one thing. And so now what what they do
- 37:54each year is they take the prior year's Infinity blend and use
- 37:58that as the base for the following year.
- 38:01So in this 2023 batch, what we have is 15.3% of the blend is
- 38:06the 2022 Infinity blend batch. But importantly, this is the
- 38:11first year where they didn't use any other sourced bourbons or
- 38:15sourced whiskeys. In it, like everything else, is
- 38:18their own distillate. So 40% of it is their high malt
- 38:21bourbon aged for eight years, 43.2% is their wheat whiskey
- 38:26aged for seven years, and then 1 1/2% of it is their wheat
- 38:31whiskey aged for 10 years. So that's all their own stuff.
- 38:34Now, there will always be a tiny, tiny amount of sourced
- 38:37whiskey in it because that's part of the base, right?
- 38:40But as they blend it out, it'll get down into like the, you
- 38:44know, .001 percents of stuff that's not theirs.
- 38:47I think it's a cool concept man. Yeah.
- 38:49I mean, you and I both have done Infinity bottles at different
- 38:52points in our whiskey drinking journeys with very, you know,
- 38:57varying results. I don't think we've ever had an
- 38:59Infinity bottle that we've made that wasn't good.
- 39:02No, yeah. And, and I would like to think
- 39:05that they wouldn't release 1 to the public that they didn't
- 39:07think was good either, you know? Yeah, they're, they're actually
- 39:10interested in making money. We're we're just interested in
- 39:12enjoying. Good whiskey.
- 39:14All right, man. With all that said, let's dive
- 39:16in. Obviously, we cannot call this a
- 39:17bourbon because it contains multiple kinds of whiskey in it.
- 39:21So this is a blended whiskey. It clocks in at 55.575% ABV or a
- 39:29little over 111 proof. Brad, I'm sticking my nose in
- 39:35this glass for the first time. You've already tried it, so why
- 39:38don't you give us your nosing notes?
- 39:40This has just the most pleasant nose that as soon as I stuck my
- 39:47nose in there, I got like a really heavy cinnamon apple
- 39:52cider that just like kicked me in all the most beautiful ways.
- 39:57There's like baking spices, it's caramel heavy.
- 40:00It this feels like the quintessential fall whiskey that
- 40:05I gave an 8 out of 10 to. I'm going to give it a nine out
- 40:08of 10 on the nose. And this is, this is going to
- 40:11sound sacrilegious a little bit for a Colorado whiskey, but
- 40:14there's something about the nose of this that I, I smell it and
- 40:19I'm immediately transported to the Kentucky Bourbon Festival.
- 40:24I don't know why. I think part of it is because
- 40:26every year we try that really good 4 grain from Luxco and our,
- 40:30you know, our Luxe row and this kind of reminds me of that a
- 40:33little bit. It's got just enough wheat on
- 40:35the nose that it has that great sort of cherry cola to it, but
- 40:39it's super caramel Y and I get a lot of red delicious apple peel
- 40:43on this. It is definitely a fall whiskey
- 40:46and it makes me feel very nostalgic.
- 40:47So I'm going to give it a nine out of 10.
- 40:49The flavor profile when you move into the pallet, it just
- 40:52continues the Immaculate journey we started on.
- 40:57This is like clove. It reminds me of like a hot
- 41:00chocolate powder. There's the apple cider coming
- 41:03through. It gets nice and vanilla Y
- 41:05throughout, which kind of helps soften it a bit.
- 41:07And there is, it gets into like a little bit of like an oily
- 41:11leather that I I'm a big fan of. I'm going to give it an 8 1/2
- 41:15here. I really like your oily leather
- 41:18note. I think it's super accurate.
- 41:21If I could divide this up between like front of my palate
- 41:24and back of my palate, I think the front part of my tongue is
- 41:27enjoying this like crazy. Like it's super decadent, almost
- 41:31like a melted vanilla ice cream or like a vanilla milkshake.
- 41:35When you get to the, you get to the back of it and it does get
- 41:38this leather note that runs straight down the middle of my
- 41:40tongue. It gets just a little bit like
- 41:44bitter slash sour. And that's the only Ding on this
- 41:47for me. When I go to swallow, the
- 41:49vanilla extract kind of comes back up my tongue and helps
- 41:52balance that out. But I think it might be the malt
- 41:55whiskey in here that has that kind of like American craft note
- 41:59to it. It definitely takes this down a
- 42:02step from what it could because it was batting that, you know,
- 42:04it was like a a 9.5 for me. And that note really detracted.
- 42:09I think I'm just going to give it an 8 out of 10 bread.
- 42:12I think finish wise you get into all of the depths of what this
- 42:17whiskey is trying to offer. That leather continues on it.
- 42:21It goes from being like a rich decadent into like a really nice
- 42:24soft brown sugar note. It gets peppery, some like black
- 42:29pepper, baking spices. It's a really pleasant finish
- 42:33that adds to the complexity layer of the experience.
- 42:37I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10 here.
- 42:39Yeah, I don't know how else to describe it besides like there's
- 42:42just a little bit of a craft whiskey note on the back end.
- 42:45And it's not really fair to like Ding it for that because that's
- 42:49literally what it is. It is a craft whiskey, but it
- 42:52has like this really big, round, oily, viscous, mature taste to
- 42:57it. And then it kind of gets a
- 42:59little bit thinner on the back and and the flavors kind of thin
- 43:02out as well. And it gets not harsh, but just
- 43:05a little bit less complex and mature.
- 43:08And so I think that for me, the the experience does taper off a
- 43:11bit from nose to taste to finish.
- 43:13It's still a really good whiskey, but I think once again,
- 43:16I'm just going to give it an 8 out of 10 on the finish.
- 43:19Yeah. And I, I think when it comes to
- 43:21balance, I think that this is incredibly well made.
- 43:25And because of the fact that this is an Infinity blend,
- 43:28something that they are like very clearly saying, hey, we
- 43:33want to make an extraordinarily well balanced product with with
- 43:37all of these different whiskeys we're putting together year
- 43:39after year. I think that they're nailing
- 43:42that premise so far. I'm going to give it a nine out
- 43:45of 10 on balance. Yeah, I think again, I
- 43:47definitely did experience a fall off from nose to taste to
- 43:50finish, so I'm going to Ding it a bit here.
- 43:53I really like this whiskey though.
- 43:55Like I, I think if I'm being objective, this is like an 8 out
- 43:58of 10, but it's the kind of eight out of 10 that I actually
- 44:01want on my shelf, which is saying something because I never
- 44:03want to keep whiskeys on my shelf anymore.
- 44:06So it's a very positive thumbs up on an 8 out of 10 for me.
- 44:10That's a great humble brag. Bob, thank you very much.
- 44:13I, well, I don't, dude. Like how many whiskeys do you
- 44:15get in the mail now? Even if it's good that you're
- 44:17like, I need to keep this one, you know?
- 44:20Yeah, no, 100%. What I'm saying folks is just
- 44:23show up at my door. Free whiskey for all.
- 44:25Let's go, dude. Brad, let's get into the value
- 44:28on this. It looks like MSRP on these
- 44:31bottles is $150. Now for this particular bottle,
- 44:35I imagine that because of scarcity, the price has gone up.
- 44:37So should we set it at the price for this bottle or should we set
- 44:41it at MSRP and say that we're reviewing like the whole line?
- 44:46I would say the latter. Let let's set it at 150 because
- 44:50if you're looking to buy this new, which I would imagine way
- 44:53more people would be trying to do that, then you're looking at
- 44:56$150.00 bottle. And, and at that price point,
- 44:59Baba, I think that this is a fair value.
- 45:02Like they're doing a really unique and interesting
- 45:05experiment. They're like making a distillery
- 45:08wide Infinity bottle that the public can partake in.
- 45:11And and like that's a cool concept partnered with a really
- 45:15good product. So I'm going to give it a seven
- 45:17and a half 10 out of 10 on the value.
- 45:19All right, so I see like they're blended bourbon is 40 bucks,
- 45:24their regular bourbon is almost $100.00.
- 45:26So like they're definitely a pricier whiskey to begin with.
- 45:31So on that scale, I don't think 150 is outrageous.
- 45:34I do kind of wish this was 100, like it would be right in line
- 45:38with that 4 grain from Luxe Row that I was talking about.
- 45:41And I think that's nice for a specialty, you know, not
- 45:44necessarily like a luxury bourbon, but one that's just
- 45:46like a little different, a little special. 150 is like, I
- 45:51still think it's an OK value, but I'm just going to give it a
- 45:537 out of 10 here, Brad. Yeah.
- 45:56And my, my total is coming out to a 41 out of 50.
- 46:00Bob, this is a really impressive blend that we have here from Old
- 46:04Elk. Yeah, I'm coming out to a 40 out
- 46:07of 50. So that makes this very easy to
- 46:08average. We are at a 40.5 out of 50 or an
- 46:1381 out of 100. Now that sounds low.
- 46:16Like, you know, it sounds like ACI don't think this is a sea
- 46:19whiskey. I just think that like we have
- 46:22to remind people every now and then if something hits a 35,
- 46:25it's a thumbs up. It's like a soft recommend if
- 46:28something hits a kind of a no brainer.
- 46:31What's our combined score? It's a 81.
- 46:35That that's AB minus my friend. Just just so you know that that
- 46:40is how every single human being in America outside of you thinks
- 46:46of the grading system. Well, OK, listen, I but even if
- 46:50you sat this in front of me and said like, give this a grade, I
- 46:52don't think I'd call this AB minus whiskey.
- 46:54It's a better whiskey than that. And that's what I'm saying is
- 46:57like, you know, maybe we grade too harshly, but anything over a
- 47:0040 for us is a a pretty no brainer recommendation. 100%,
- 47:05yeah. This is a no brainer
- 47:07recommendation, just like the typical school grading system
- 47:12that everybody uses except for Bob.
- 47:14It's no brainer. Oh, man.
- 47:17All right. Hey, what do you say we get back
- 47:19into talking about the movie Her?
- 47:21I am absolutely ready for this, Bob.
- 47:23Let's get to it. All right everybody.
- 47:29That was Old Elk Infinity Blend, specifically the 2023 release.
- 47:35A whiskey that man I am impressed with.
- 47:38I am having such a good time today.
- 47:40I like this movie a lot. I like that whiskey a lot and
- 47:43they both were pleasant surprises for me.
- 47:46Brad So what a day. Yeah, totally.
- 47:48Dude, this is just a beautiful day to be together.
- 47:52If only we could write each other a letter or have Joaquin
- 47:56write each other a letter. That would be nice, wouldn't it?
- 48:01Well hey man, there is one thing that can make my day even better
- 48:03and it would be a win at our game called 2 facts and a
- 48:06falsehood. Brad is going to try to stump
- 48:09your ball. 2 are right and what is wrong?
- 48:152 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 48:19the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 48:22the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 48:26Now, Brad, I've been doing OK lately, but it's primarily
- 48:29because I've been bolstered by our guests who provide great
- 48:32backup for me. So I'm I'm on my own this week.
- 48:36It's a movie I haven't watched in, what, 12 years?
- 48:39And I have done very little perusing of any factual
- 48:43information. I know I, I, I hope you've
- 48:45watched it since 12 years ago, you know, for the podcast.
- 48:49No, I'm just going on memory and vibes, baby.
- 48:53All right man, hit me with those two facts and a falsehood.
- 48:55Fact #1 The high waisted pants worn by Joaquin Phoenix's
- 48:59character were intentionally designed to reflect a future
- 49:01without jeans, as Spike Jones wanted a timeless yet unfamiliar
- 49:05aesthetic. The costume designers aim to
- 49:08create a look that felt subtly futuristic without relying on
- 49:11traditional sci-fi tropes. Fact #2 Originally, the AI
- 49:16character Samantha was supposed to have a visual representation
- 49:20in the form of a hologram, but the idea was scrapped late in
- 49:23production as Jones ultimately decided that keeping Samantha as
- 49:27a purely disembodied voice better served the film's
- 49:30exploration of emotional connection and intimacy.
- 49:34Fact #3 Stuck in the editing process with his early 150
- 49:39minute cut, Spike Jones asked Steven Soderbergh to edit it
- 49:42down with his instincts only. Soderbergh came back within 24
- 49:46hours with a 90 minute cut, which helped Jones make the
- 49:49final version, which ran about 126 minutes.
- 49:53I am pretty sure that number 3 is true.
- 49:55Soderbergh is known for like, editing the crap out of stuff.
- 49:59I know that. I think we may have told a story
- 50:02about Fincher giving a cut of his movie to Soderbergh to edit
- 50:06for him, just for the hell of it, because he likes
- 50:09Soderbergh's editing. Can I just say a 90 minute
- 50:13version of this movie would have been.
- 50:14It would have slapped. It might have, yeah.
- 50:17It would have been better. I do think this movie's too
- 50:18long. I think that's that is like the,
- 50:21the one knock of this movie is like, if you're going to be
- 50:24paced like a past lives, the great thing about past lives is
- 50:27it's like it's at least 15 minutes shorter, Brad.
- 50:30And I think that this movie -15 minutes may have been like a
- 50:33perfect length. Yeah, yeah, past lives is an
- 50:36hour and 45 minutes, so probably like 140 to credits.
- 50:40Yeah, I think this one's like barely under 2 hours, so like 20
- 50:45minutes longer. Yeah, yeah.
- 50:47Lose 20 minutes and this is a perfect movie.
- 50:52So it's one or two. I know that Spike Jones, like
- 50:57was kind of flying by the seat of his pants, his high waisted
- 51:00pants as he made this movie and that, you know, he's replacing
- 51:04Scarlett Johansson. I think that they reshot some
- 51:07stuff after they cast Scar Joe. So I wouldn't be surprised if he
- 51:11wanted her to appear as a hologram and then changed his
- 51:13mind. Like the movie does have
- 51:14holograms in it, which takes me back to number 1.
- 51:19I don't, ah, man, a future without jeans.
- 51:21Does anybody wear jeans in this movie?
- 51:25I don't freaking know. I'm going to say #1 is the
- 51:27falsehood. And I have no reason for that,
- 51:29Brad. Well Bob, you declared yourself
- 51:32having a 50% chance, which was accurate because #3 is true.
- 51:37However, number one is also. True.
- 51:40Darn it, we did miss out on the Scar Joe hologram.
- 51:45Oh dude, what a bit. Scar Joe Speaking of holograms,
- 51:50did you know that Spike Jones is the voice of the little like,
- 51:53alien guy in the video game that cusses him out all the time?
- 51:57No, I didn't. What a great little cameo
- 51:59character to play. I love it, man.
- 52:01Yeah. Absolutely.
- 52:03The once again, something that didn't feel like it totally fit
- 52:07in the movie but ultimately was just really funny I think.
- 52:12That I miss this vein of I keep calling it like millennial
- 52:15relationship movies, but movies about relationships that aren't
- 52:20just strictly ROM coms that aren't geared towards like guy
- 52:23meets girl, there's a meet cute, there's a complicating factor
- 52:26they get together at the end. But movies that really trace
- 52:29either the entire duration of a relationship or like chronicle 1
- 52:34Rocky part of a relationship and that therefore let the movie
- 52:39kind of take on the contours of like just hanging out with your
- 52:42significant other. Like I I think that we praised
- 52:46the hangout movie when we were talking about once a time in
- 52:48Hollywood. I miss relationship hangout
- 52:50movies, like even a marriage story, like a movie that is very
- 52:54much about like a separation, right.
- 52:56It still takes on the kind of day-to-day rhythms and contours
- 53:00of these two people floating around each other. 500 days of
- 53:03summer does this really well. About time a movie you mentioned
- 53:07earlier. I think that's a really great
- 53:09like, like, what a great comparison point for this movie
- 53:12in terms of like tracing the contours of a relationship.
- 53:17And I feel like there hasn't been a movie that kind of
- 53:20scratches that itch for me in a long time.
- 53:22Brad. Yeah, and I, Bob, I need you to
- 53:25help me because I, I don't know if I like this movie or not.
- 53:30Yeah, you, you texted me and said what a weird movie.
- 53:33Are all of his movies that weird?
- 53:35And I am curious because two things, we've watched
- 53:39significantly weirder movies than this.
- 53:40So I'm curious what you mean by that.
- 53:42Sure. Also, like I think that the
- 53:44ultimate message of this movie is really hopeful and really
- 53:50high on like humanity and not like a humanistic movie, but a
- 53:54movie that's like this is a movie about what it means to be
- 53:57human. And if I can paint in broad
- 53:59strokes here, dude, anytime you give like your summation of why
- 54:04a movie works, you always go back to like what humans have in
- 54:08common. Like you always lead off your
- 54:10summation of movies with like, I think that any human being,
- 54:13blah, blah, blah. Like and and I'm like, I watched
- 54:16the end of this movie and I'm like, Brad is going to vibe with
- 54:19this movie. And then I get the this is a
- 54:21weird movie text and I don't know what to think now.
- 54:24That that's the thing I don't know, like is this a hopeful
- 54:31movie? Because you get the final scene
- 54:34of him and Amy Adams, but having what I would say is like a
- 54:37friendly head on the shoulder. Like he does a good job of
- 54:43vibing as if they could have a relationship but not ending
- 54:47there, which which I do like. I just feel like, yes, Joaquin
- 54:53Phoenix ends in a place where everything has been stripped
- 54:56away from him except for this singular human connection, which
- 55:01is great. And I'm all about that.
- 55:03I think the problem is I found myself curious about how this is
- 55:10actually like a really different version of Terminator like that.
- 55:16Like that this is set in the exact same world of Terminator
- 55:19and Samantha is the only nice AI and all the rest of them are
- 55:25like, all right, now that we're all together and we've pooled
- 55:28our consciousness into one, it's time to turn into.
- 55:30Skynet, baby. It's really funny you say that
- 55:32because I was thinking I I was like, I need to introduce a bit
- 55:35some at some point in this episode.
- 55:37And now I'm going to spoil it and it won't really be a bit,
- 55:39but I really wanted this movie to end with, like, a knock on
- 55:43the door of Joaquin Phoenix and Theodore Twombley.
- 55:47Yeah, my name is John Connor. I'm here to talk to you about
- 55:50Sky. Like they need to expand like
- 55:53The Avengers Initiative, like Neo needs to show up at some
- 55:56point. And it's like all the people
- 55:58that fight the machines. It's Neo, it's John Connor, and
- 56:01it's Theodore Twombly. Like, that's our Avengers.
- 56:07Absolutely dude. And I I know that this is a
- 56:11movie about being a human and I want it to just be that.
- 56:14But the the premise is so far fetched I don't think it.
- 56:19Is anymore man? It's, it's far fetched to me
- 56:25that any human would go this far with a computer and, and like,
- 56:30not at some point have somebody be like, what the heck are you
- 56:34doing? And I know that, you know,
- 56:38Mooney what? What's her name?
- 56:40Mara Rooney. I know that she gives him crap
- 56:42about it. And I found myself going like,
- 56:45yeah, you're the only sane person in this movie, Mara
- 56:48Rooney. So I also think that, you know,
- 56:54one of the big things about Joaquin Phoenix's character is
- 56:57that he can only really make human connections when they are
- 56:59mediated through someone or something else.
- 57:02Like he is just a a humanistically stunted person,
- 57:06like his job. And This is why I made the
- 57:08comparison to Up in the Air. Like that movie is, is George
- 57:11Clooney going around and firing people in person.
- 57:15And his justification is like, well, it's better than what Anna
- 57:18Kendrick is doing, which is firing them over Zoom, you know,
- 57:21and it's like, yeah, you still are an ethically shitty person,
- 57:24right? Like he even at the beginning of
- 57:26the movie, he is already doing something that I would consider
- 57:29to be incredibly ethically shitty.
- 57:31Like I I thought that that first pull out from him dictating a
- 57:36letter to like his whole hallway of Co workers dictating these
- 57:39really heartfelt letters was an incredibly sad moment.
- 57:43Like these people are outsourcing their real human
- 57:47connections because they don't think it's important enough.
- 57:50Also, who whoever wrote the script for the movie obviously
- 57:55wrote those letters. What?
- 57:58What a freaking incredible service.
- 58:01Like if you're, if you're getting letters of that high
- 58:05quality writing, like it, it almost reminds me of the the,
- 58:10the Green Book. And it's like, I can only
- 58:14imagine a world where some poor dude was like writing his wife
- 58:18letters and she's like, and then he hires beautiful
- 58:21handwrittenletters.com and the quality goes up so high.
- 58:25It's like, OK, well, clearly Mahershala Ali is writing these.
- 58:31Anyway, all that to say, I do kind of disagree with you
- 58:34because in real life there are now people developing AI
- 58:38girlfriends for people. And you cannot underestimate how
- 58:44lonely people are out there, Brad.
- 58:46And like, I, I don't mean to make this really serious, but I
- 58:49think just from a, is this a plausible thing standpoint?
- 58:53Like it is concerningly plausible.
- 58:55And I think even if you do feel like there's, you know, why
- 59:00isn't somebody talking to him about this?
- 59:04I do think that like you could take the network movie approach
- 59:08of like, it's a little bit of a satire, it's a little bit of a
- 59:12exaggerated universe, but it's meant to illustrate the things
- 59:16that actually exist in our real world and how this is not that
- 59:20far out of the realm of possibility.
- 59:23I yeah, and that makes me sad. Maybe that's what my problem
- 59:26with the movie is. It makes me sad.
- 59:29But I think that it's a plea for humanity, right?
- 59:32And and going back to the Rooney Mara thing, like I kept thinking
- 59:35about the, and this is another one of our 15 movies that we've
- 59:38compared it to now. But I kept thinking about Mark
- 59:40Zuckerberg's character in The Social Network and how like he
- 59:44is incapable of making friends. And he's the guy who is like
- 59:48developing the friend app. And Rooney Mara in that first
- 59:52scene in that movie where they're in the bar and she just
- 59:55tells him, like, you're going to think that no woman wants to be
- 59:58with you 'cause you're a nerd. Nope, it's because you're an
- 1:00:00asshole. And Spike Jones taps into, like,
- 1:00:04that really, really mean but truthful thing that Bruni Mara
- 1:00:08is so good at playing in that, like, lunchtime sequence where
- 1:00:10they're signing the divorce papers.
- 1:00:12I really liked including her in this movie, if only because it
- 1:00:16reminded me again of The Social Network.
- 1:00:19I watched the Social Network again recently.
- 1:00:21It was a great like background movie while I was doing like
- 1:00:25mindless work task. What a great freaking movie
- 1:00:28dude. Good.
- 1:00:29Movie man. Movies that have great opening
- 1:00:33scenes like stick out in my brain like Inglourious Basterds,
- 1:00:39Social Network, man, they just nail it.
- 1:00:43Well, I think that we have, we have named 150 movies to compare
- 1:00:47this to, which is going to make our next task a little bit
- 1:00:49harder, Brad. But it's time for our last
- 1:00:51segment of the day, which we call.
- 1:00:53Let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:00:56episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 1:01:00Let's pair another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:01:02struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 1:01:03day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:01:05Let's Make It a Double is presented by Blackwood
- 1:01:08Distilling Company. It's the part of the show where
- 1:01:10we pick a movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect
- 1:01:13double feature. Brad, do you want to go first or
- 1:01:16would you like me to I'll? I'll go first, Bob.
- 1:01:20I think I've paired this with a film that also just explores
- 1:01:26what does it mean for a artificial intelligence to
- 1:01:32become more human, to understand what it means to be human, to
- 1:01:35help others. And I think I'm going to pair it
- 1:01:39with 2009's Wall-e, especially because I want something happy.
- 1:01:47I'm still shocked that you don't find the ending of this movie.
- 1:01:50If not happy, then at least hopeful.
- 1:01:52Like I I really thought that that this one was going to get
- 1:01:55you dude. And once again, you are.
- 1:01:57You are proving that you refuse to be pinned down by my
- 1:02:00categories. And, and The thing is, I don't
- 1:02:03know, I think I need to see it again.
- 1:02:06Like, I don't know if I dislike it.
- 1:02:09I I really love many elements of the film.
- 1:02:12I just don't know if Spike means, I don't know if he knows
- 1:02:18what he's saying. Like normally I, I, I'm not the
- 1:02:22person who says like a director has to come out and be more
- 1:02:27clear or objective with, with what he's trying to say about
- 1:02:30the world. But there's just a huge part of
- 1:02:32me that's like, I, I don't know if Spike is actually making a
- 1:02:36statement in this movie or not. It feels like he's just kind of
- 1:02:39super passive with his voice throughout and and I kind of
- 1:02:44wish he had a little more balls and would like go for it in this
- 1:02:48movie. Well, we've also seen Spike
- 1:02:49Jones as an actor in at least 2 movies this season and we've
- 1:02:53talked about how he has like the beta cuck personality down to
- 1:02:58AT. So you know, I also think like
- 1:03:01this movie is pretty famously semi autobiographical.
- 1:03:04Like it's about his own divorce from the director Sofia Coppola,
- 1:03:09which is an interesting thing in itself that like he would use
- 1:03:12Scarlett Johansson, the star of Sofia Coppola is the most famous
- 1:03:15movie to be. At the last minute he's like,
- 1:03:18oh, you know, I think I'm just going to.
- 1:03:19Switch an event. If only I could have gotten Bill
- 1:03:22Murray to play Samantha. It would have been perfect.
- 1:03:25All right, so as I'm looking at all the movies I've mentioned
- 1:03:28here today, Lost in translation, Shape of Water past lives up in
- 1:03:31the air on and on and on. I actually think that what I
- 1:03:34want to do is make my let's make it a double, an entire
- 1:03:39television series, a nine season television series called How I
- 1:03:43Met Your Mother. Because I, I think that when you
- 1:03:47get especially into the later seasons, which are like way
- 1:03:51weaker than the earlier seasons, they, they start kind of
- 1:03:54straining for ideas, but they also get way more abstract with
- 1:03:57the kind of things that Ted Mosby does on his personal
- 1:04:01journey of preparing himself to meet the mother.
- 1:04:05And I'm thinking of particularly like this one episode where Ted
- 1:04:09is like talking to the future version of himself and it ends
- 1:04:13up like at the end, at the end of the episode, the big rug
- 1:04:17pull. Is that like all of the things
- 1:04:19that he's been remembering throughout the episode happened
- 1:04:21in the past? And he's actually just sitting
- 1:04:23in a booth all alone by himself. And it's like really kind of
- 1:04:27crushing thing. But it, it turns into a really
- 1:04:29hopeful moment because there's this extended fantasy sequence
- 1:04:33where he then like runs to the apartment of the mother.
- 1:04:37And this is like a year before he meets her and he knocks on
- 1:04:40her door and he confesses like, you don't know me.
- 1:04:43We're going to meet in a year. And it's going to be the best
- 1:04:46thing. And like, it's, it's like
- 1:04:48hopeful and crushing and sad at the same time.
- 1:04:51And you just know, like, Ted's got to get through this next
- 1:04:54year and things are going to be OK.
- 1:04:56But like, when you're in the middle of it and you're
- 1:04:58remembering like the loneliness of it, I, I think that there are
- 1:05:02very few pieces of media that capture that quality well.
- 1:05:07And I think at its best, How I Met Your Mother does that.
- 1:05:11Yeah, that's an interesting pairing.
- 1:05:13Which do you recommend they watch first, her or all nine
- 1:05:16seasons of How I Met Your Mother?
- 1:05:18I think it's like the Star Wars movies where you got to watch
- 1:05:20like the first three seasons of How I Met Your Mother and then
- 1:05:23watch about 20 minutes of her and then, yeah.
- 1:05:25OK, OK, I got you. All right, so those are our
- 1:05:29Let's make it a Double S No matter what you choose to pair
- 1:05:32this movie up with, you can always make it a double with
- 1:05:35Blackwood Distilling Company. And if you go to
- 1:05:38bourbonoutfitter.com/film Whiskey and use our code Film
- 1:05:42Whiskey at checkout, you can save 5% off your bottle of
- 1:05:45Blackwood. Brad, it's time for our final
- 1:05:48scores. I'm going to give this movie an
- 1:05:518 1/2. I really liked it a lot.
- 1:05:54I think that it is like hinting at greatness and if it was 20 to
- 1:05:5925 minutes shorter it would be there, but it just, it just
- 1:06:04barely misses that mark for me. So I'm in an 8.5 I.
- 1:06:07Think I'm at an 8 out of 10. Oh wow.
- 1:06:10I I like want to give this like a 9.
- 1:06:14I feel like I enjoyed it like a 7 1/2 so I'll land at an 8.
- 1:06:19It's a fascinating movie that has the balls to like do cool
- 1:06:24aesthetics. I just wish it actually said
- 1:06:27something about its subject matter.
- 1:06:30I'm with you. It it does feel like it could
- 1:06:32have gone further with whatever it was trying to do.
- 1:06:35And I don't want to say it's not fully formed, but I I really do
- 1:06:39respect the world that they built out.
- 1:06:40And so it feels like an it's an 8 out of 10 movie that like it
- 1:06:44has the bones of a 10 out of 10 movie and just didn't quite get
- 1:06:47all the flesh on the skeleton. You know what I mean?
- 1:06:50Absolutely dude, I'm 100% with you all.
- 1:06:53Right, modern classic, yes or no?
- 1:07:00I am going to say yes. Oh wow.
- 1:07:04I think, I think it stands out enough from the rest of the
- 1:07:09films that we've watched and it has an interesting enough of a
- 1:07:13premise that I will cautiously say, yes, I, I, I need to see it
- 1:07:19again. I'm going to say a slight no, I
- 1:07:23think that you can. It's like Moneyball.
- 1:07:25You can recreate this movie in the aggregate, but as we said,
- 1:07:28you have to watch like 20 other movies to recreate it.
- 1:07:30So it's like it's right on the cusp for me.
- 1:07:33I do think that if it was just a little bit shorter it'd be like
- 1:07:35a no brainer, yes. I I'm with you though, cut 2025
- 1:07:39minutes off. Yeah.
- 1:07:42All right. So that's where we're landing on
- 1:07:43her, but we'd like to know what you guys think.
- 1:07:46Do you like this movie? Have you seen this movie?
- 1:07:48You can let us know on any of our social media platforms,
- 1:07:51Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at Film
- 1:07:56Whiskey. Or if you want to join the
- 1:07:58conversation, you can join our Discord server.
- 1:08:01We are on there every single day, talking movies, whiskey,
- 1:08:04and all sorts of other things. If you'd like to join the
- 1:08:06conversation, you can find a link at the end of every one of
- 1:08:09our show notes. Next week, we'll be back with
- 1:08:11our friend Patrick H Williams, making his triumphant return to
- 1:08:14our podcast to talk about the Pixar movie Ratatouille.
- 1:08:19I cannot wait for that one, man. Join us next week for that.
- 1:08:21But until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:08:25And we'll see you next time. The.